Normalized to: Lugaz, N.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.04811 [pdf] - 1994301
Evolution of CME Properties in the Inner Heliosphere: Prediction for
Solar Orbiter and Parker Solar Probe
Submitted: 2019-10-10
The evolution of the magnetic field and plasma quantities inside a coronal
mass ejection (CME) with distance are known from statistical studies using data
from 1 au monitors, planetary missions, Helios, and Ulysses. This does not
cover the innermost heliosphere, below 0.29 au, where no data are yet publicly
available. Here, we describe the evolution of the properties of simulated CMEs
in the inner heliosphere using two different initiation mechanisms. We compare
the radial evolution of these properties with that found from statistical
studies based on observations in the inner heliosphere by Helios and MESSENGER.
We find that the evolution of the radial size and magnetic field strength is
nearly indistinguishable for twisted flux rope from that of writhed CMEs. The
evolution of these properties is also consistent with past studies, primarily
with recent statistical studies using in situ measurements and with studies
using remote observations of CMEs.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.10161 [pdf] - 1967014
CME -- HSS interaction and characteristics tracked from Sun to Earth
Heinemann, Stephan G.;
Temmer, Manuela;
Farrugia, Charles J.;
Dissauer, Karin;
Kay, Christina;
Wiegelmann, Thomas;
Dumbović, Mateja;
Veronig, Astrid M.;
Podladchikova, Tatiana;
Hofmeister, Stefan J.;
Lugaz, Noé;
Carcaboso, Fernando
Submitted: 2019-08-27
In a thorough study, we investigate the origin of a remarkable plasma and
magnetic field configuration observed in situ on June 22, 2011 near L1, which
appears to be a magnetic ejecta (ME) and a shock signature engulfed by a solar
wind high-speed stream (HSS). We identify the signatures as an Earth-directed
coronal mass ejection (CME), associated with a C7.7 flare on June 21, 2011, and
its interaction with a HSS, which emanates from a coronal hole (CH) close to
the launch site of the CME. The results indicate that the major interaction
between the CME and the HSS starts at a height of 1.3 Rsun up to 3 Rsun. Over
that distance range, the CME undergoes a strong north-eastward deflection of at
least 30 degrees due to the open magnetic field configuration of the CH. We
perform a comprehensive analysis for the CME-HSS event using multi-viewpoint
data (from the Solar TErrestrial RElations Observatories, the Solar and
Heliospheric Observatory and the Solar Dynamics Observatory), and combined
modeling efforts (nonlinear force-free field modeling, Graduated Cylindrical
Shell CME modeling, and the Forecasting a CMEs Altered Trajectory ForeCAT
model). We aim at better understanding its early evolution and interaction
process as well as its interplanetary propagation and related in situ
signatures, and finally the resulting impact on the Earth's magnetosphere.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.09921 [pdf] - 1868071
Generic magnetic field intensity profiles of interplanetary coronal mass
ejections at Mercury, Venus and Earth from superposed epoch analyses
Janvier, Miho;
Winslow, Reka;
Good, Simon;
Bonhomme, Elise;
Démoulin, Pascal;
Dasso, Sergio;
Möstl, Christian;
Lugaz, Noé;
Amerstorfer, Tanja;
Soubrié, Elie;
Boakes, Peter D.
Submitted: 2019-01-28
We study interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICMEs) measured by probes at
different heliocentric distances (0.3-1AU) to investigate the propagation of
ICMEs in the inner heliosphere and determine how the generic features of ICMEs
change with heliospheric distance. Using data from the MESSENGER, Venus Express
and ACE spacecraft, we analyze with the superposed epoch technique the profiles
of ICME substructures, namely the sheath and the magnetic ejecta. We determine
that the median magnetic field magnitude in the sheath correlates well with
ICME speeds at 1 AU and we use this proxy to order the ICMEs at all spacecraft.
We then investigate the typical ICME profiles for three categories equivalent
to slow, intermediate and fast ICMEs. Contrary to fast ICMEs, slow ICMEs have a
weaker solar wind field at the front and a more symmetric magnetic field
profile. We find the asymmetry to be less pronounced at Earth than at Mercury,
indicating a relaxation taking place as ICMEs propagate. We also find that the
magnetic field intensities in the wake region of the ICMEs do not go back to
the pre-ICME solar wind intensities, suggesting that the effects of ICMEs on
the ambient solar wind last longer than the duration of the transient event.
Such results provide an indication of physical processes that need to be
reproduced by numerical simulations of ICME propagation. The samples studied
here will be greatly improved by future missions dedicated to the exploration
of the inner heliosphere, such as Parker Solar Probe and Solar Orbiter.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.08728 [pdf] - 1774812
Roadmap for Reliable Ensemble Forecasting of the Sun-Earth System
Nita, Gelu;
Angryk, Rafal;
Aydin, Berkay;
Banda, Juan;
Bastian, Tim;
Berger, Tom;
Bindi, Veronica;
Boucheron, Laura;
Cao, Wenda;
Christian, Eric;
de Nolfo, Georgia;
DeLuca, Edward;
DeRosa, Marc;
Downs, Cooper;
Fleishman, Gregory;
Fuentes, Olac;
Gary, Dale;
Hill, Frank;
Hoeksema, Todd;
Hu, Qiang;
Ilie, Raluca;
Ireland, Jack;
Kamalabadi, Farzad;
Korreck, Kelly;
Kosovichev, Alexander;
Lin, Jessica;
Lugaz, Noe;
Mannucci, Anthony;
Mansour, Nagi;
Martens, Petrus;
Mays, Leila;
McAteer, James;
McIntosh, Scott W.;
Oria, Vincent;
Pan, David;
Panesi, Marco;
Pesnell, W. Dean;
Pevtsov, Alexei;
Pillet, Valentin;
Rachmeler, Laurel;
Ridley, Aaron;
Scherliess, Ludger;
Toth, Gabor;
Velli, Marco;
White, Stephen;
Zhang, Jie;
Zou, Shasha
Submitted: 2018-10-19, last modified: 2018-10-29
The authors of this report met on 28-30 March 2018 at the New Jersey
Institute of Technology, Newark, New Jersey, for a 3-day workshop that brought
together a group of data providers, expert modelers, and computer and data
scientists, in the solar discipline. Their objective was to identify challenges
in the path towards building an effective framework to achieve transformative
advances in the understanding and forecasting of the Sun-Earth system from the
upper convection zone of the Sun to the Earth's magnetosphere. The workshop
aimed to develop a research roadmap that targets the scientific challenge of
coupling observations and modeling with emerging data-science research to
extract knowledge from the large volumes of data (observed and simulated) while
stimulating computer science with new research applications. The desire among
the attendees was to promote future trans-disciplinary collaborations and
identify areas of convergence across disciplines. The workshop combined a set
of plenary sessions featuring invited introductory talks and workshop progress
reports, interleaved with a set of breakout sessions focused on specific topics
of interest. Each breakout group generated short documents, listing the
challenges identified during their discussions in addition to possible ways of
attacking them collectively. These documents were combined into this
report-wherein a list of prioritized activities have been collated, shared and
endorsed.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.02359 [pdf] - 1661883
Fitting and Reconstruction of Thirteen Simple Coronal Mass Ejections
Submitted: 2018-04-06
Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are the main drivers of geomagnetic
disturbances, but the effects of their interaction with Earth's magnetic field
depend on their magnetic configuration and orientation. Fitting and
reconstruction techniques have been developed to determine the important
geometrical and physical CME properties. In many instances, there is
disagreement between such different methods but also between fitting from in
situ measurements and reconstruction based on remote imaging. Here, we compare
three methods based on different assumptions for measurements of thirteen CMEs
by the Wind spacecraft from 1997 to 2015. These CMEs are selected from the
interplanetary coronal mass ejections catalog on
https://wind.nasa.gov/ICMEindex.php due to their simplicity in terms of 1)
small expansion speed throughout the CME and 2) little asymmetry in the
magnetic field profile. This makes these thirteen events ideal candidates to
compare codes that do not include expansion nor distortion. We find that, for
these simple events, the codes are in relatively good agreement in terms of the
CME axis orientation for six out of the 13 events. Using the Grad-Shafranov
technique, we can determine the shape of the cross-section, which is assumed to
be circular for the other two models, a force-free fitting and a
circular-cylindrical non-force-free fitting. Five of the events are found to
have a clear circular cross-section, even when this is not a pre-condition of
the reconstruction. We make an initial attempt at evaluating the adequacy of
the different assumptions for these simple CMEs. The conclusion of this work
strongly suggests that attempts at reconciling in situ and remote-sensing views
of CMEs must take in consideration the compatibility of the different models
with specific CME structures to better reproduce flux ropes.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.06128 [pdf] - 969032
Comparing generic models for interplanetary shocks and magnetic clouds
axis configurations at 1 AU
Submitted: 2015-03-20
Interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejections are the manifestation of solar
transient eruptions, which can significantly modify the plasma and magnetic
conditions in the heliosphere. They are often preceded by a shock, and a
magnetic flux rope is detected in situ in a third to half of them. The main aim
of this study is to obtain the best quantitative shape for the flux rope axis
and for the shock surface from in situ data obtained during spacecraft
crossings of these structures. We first compare the orientation of the flux
ropes axes and shock normals obtained from independent data analyses of the
same events, observed in situ at 1AU from the Sun. Then, we carry out an
original statistical analysis of axes/shock normals by deriving the statistical
distributions of their orientations. We fit the observed distributions using
the distributions derived from several synthetic models describing these
shapes. We show that the distributions of axis/shock orientations are very
sensitive to their respective shape. One classical model, used to analyze
interplanetary imager data, is incompatible with the in situ data. Two other
models are introduced, for which the results for axis and shock normals lead to
very similar shapes; the fact that the data for MCs and shocks are independent
strengthen this result. The model which best fit all the data sets has an
ellipsoidal shape with similar aspect ratio values for all the data sets. These
derived shapes for the flux rope axis and shock surface have several potential
applications. First, these shapes can be used to construct a consistent ICME
model. Second, these generic shapes can be used to develop a quantitative model
to analyze imager data, as well as constraining the output of numerical
simulations of ICMEs. Finally, they will have implications for space weather
forecasting, in particular for forecasting the time arrival of ICMEs at the
Earth.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.2954 [pdf] - 1451800
Sun-to-Earth Characteristics of Two Coronal Mass Ejections Interacting
near 1 AU: Formation of a Complex Ejecta and Generation of a Two-Step
Geomagnetic Storm
Submitted: 2014-09-10
On 2012 September 30 - October 1 the Earth underwent a two-step geomagnetic
storm. We examine the Sun-to-Earth characteristics of the coronal mass
ejections (CMEs) responsible for the geomagnetic storm with combined
heliospheric imaging and in situ observations. The first CME, which occurred on
2012 September 25, is a slow event and shows an acceleration followed by a
nearly invariant speed in the whole Sun-Earth space. The second event, launched
from the Sun on 2012 September 27, exhibits a quick acceleration, then a rapid
deceleration and finally a nearly constant speed, a typical Sun-to-Earth
propagation profile for fast CMEs \citep{liu13}. These two CMEs interacted near
1 AU as predicted by the heliospheric imaging observations and formed a complex
ejecta observed at Wind, with a shock inside that enhanced the pre-existing
southward magnetic field. Reconstruction of the complex ejecta with the in situ
data indicates an overall left-handed flux rope-like configuration, with an
embedded concave-outward shock front, a maximum magnetic field strength
deviating from the flux rope axis and convex-outward field lines ahead of the
shock. While the reconstruction results are consistent with the picture of
CME-CME interactions, a magnetic cloud-like structure without clear signs of
CME interactions \citep{lugaz14} is anticipated when the merging process is
finished.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.4684 [pdf] - 913072
Deflected propagation of a coronal mass ejection from the corona to
interplanetary space
Submitted: 2014-06-18
Among various factors affecting the space weather effects of a coronal mass
ejection (CME), its propagation trajectory in the interplanetary space is an
important one determining whether and when the CME will hit the Earth. Many
direct observations have revealed that a CME may not propagate along a straight
trajectory in the corona, but whether or not a CME also experiences a deflected
propagation in the interplanetary space is a question, which has never been
fully answered. Here by investigating the propagation process of an isolated
CME from the corona to interplanetary space during 2008 September 12 -- 19, we
present solid evidence that the CME was deflected not only in the corona but
also in the interplanetary space. The deflection angle in the interplanetary
space is more than 20 degrees toward the west, resulting a significant change
in the probability the CME encounters the Earth. A further modeling and
simulation-based analysis suggest that the cause of the deflection in the
interplanetary space is the interaction between the CME and the solar wind,
which is different from that happening in the corona.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.6088 [pdf] - 826847
Observations of an extreme storm in interplanetary space caused by
successive coronal mass ejections
Liu, Ying D.;
Luhmann, Janet G.;
Kajdič, Primož;
Kilpua, Emilia K. J.;
Lugaz, Noé;
Nitta, Nariaki V.;
Möstl, Christian;
Lavraud, Benoit;
Bale, Stuart D.;
Farrugia, Charles J.;
Galvin, Antoinette B.
Submitted: 2014-05-23
Space weather refers to dynamic conditions on the Sun and in the space
environment of the Earth, which are often driven by solar eruptions and their
subsequent interplanetary disturbances. It has been unclear how an extreme
space weather storm forms and how severe it can be. Here we report and
investigate an extreme event with multi-point remote-sensing and in-situ
observations. The formation of the extreme storm showed striking novel
features. We suggest that the in-transit interaction between two closely
launched coronal mass ejections resulted in the extreme enhancement of the
ejecta magnetic field observed near 1 AU at STEREO A. The fast transit to
STEREO A (in only 18.6 hours), or the unusually weak deceleration of the event,
was caused by the preconditioning of the upstream solar wind by an earlier
solar eruption. These results provide a new view crucial to solar physics and
space weather as to how an extreme space weather event can arise from a
combination of solar eruptions.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.3579 [pdf] - 1208965
Connecting speeds, directions and arrival times of 22 coronal mass
ejections from the Sun to 1 AU
Möstl, C.;
Amla, K.;
Hall, J. R.;
Liewer, P. C.;
De Jong, E. M.;
Colaninno, R. C.;
Veronig, A. M.;
Rollett, T.;
Temmer, M.;
Peinhart, V.;
Davies, J. A.;
Lugaz, N.;
Liu, Y. D.;
Farrugia, C. J.;
Luhmann, J. G.;
Vršnak, B.;
Harrison, R. A.;
Galvin, A. B.
Submitted: 2014-04-14
Forecasting the in situ properties of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from
remote images is expected to strongly enhance predictions of space weather, and
is of general interest for studying the interaction of CMEs with planetary
environments. We study the feasibility of using a single heliospheric imager
(HI) instrument, imaging the solar wind density from the Sun to 1 AU, for
connecting remote images to in situ observations of CMEs. We compare the
predictions of speed and arrival time for 22 CMEs (in 2008-2012) to the
corresponding interplanetary coronal mass ejection (ICME) parameters at in situ
observatories (STEREO PLASTIC/IMPACT, Wind SWE/MFI). The list consists of
front- and backsided, slow and fast CMEs (up to $2700 \: km \: s^{-1}$). We
track the CMEs to $34.9 \pm 7.1$ degrees elongation from the Sun with J-maps
constructed using the SATPLOT tool, resulting in prediction lead times of
$-26.4 \pm 15.3$ hours. The geometrical models we use assume different CME
front shapes (Fixed-$\Phi$, Harmonic Mean, Self-Similar Expansion), and
constant CME speed and direction. We find no significant superiority in the
predictive capability of any of the three methods. The absolute difference
between predicted and observed ICME arrival times is $8.1 \pm 6.3$ hours ($rms$
value of 10.9h). Speeds are consistent to within $284 \pm 288 \: km \: s^{-1}$.
Empirical corrections to the predictions enhance their performance for the
arrival times to $6.1 \pm 5.0$ hours ($rms$ value of 7.9h), and for the speeds
to $53 \pm 50 \: km \: s^{-1}$. These results are important for Solar Orbiter
and a space weather mission positioned away from the Sun-Earth line.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.1075 [pdf] - 803058
A New Class of Complex Ejecta Resulting from the Interaction of two CMEs
and its Expected Geoeffectiveness
Submitted: 2014-02-05, last modified: 2014-03-27
A significant portion of transients measured by spacecraft at 1 AU does not
show the well-defined properties of magnetic clouds (MCs). Here, we propose a
new class of complex, non-MC ejecta resulting from the interaction of two CMEs
with different orientation, which differ from the previously studied
multiple-MC event. At 1 AU, they are associated with a smooth rotation of the
magnetic field vector over an extended duration and do not show clear signs of
interaction. We determine the characteristics of such events based on a
numerical simulation and identify and analyze a potential case in the
long-duration CME measured in situ in 2001 March 19-22. Such events may result
in intense, long-duration geo-magnetic storms, with sawtooth events, and may
sometimes be misidentified as isolated CMEs.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.4747 [pdf] - 1180022
A Plasma {\beta} Transition Within a Propagating Flux Rope
Submitted: 2013-10-17, last modified: 2013-11-27
We present a 2.5D MHD simulation of a magnetic flux rope (FR) propagating in
the heliosphere and investigate the cause of the observed sharp plasma beta
transition. Specifically, we consider a strong internal magnetic field and an
explosive fast start, such that the plasma beta is significantly lower in the
FR than the sheath region that is formed ahead. This leads to an unusual FR
morphology in the first stage of propagation, while the more traditional view
(e.g. from space weather simulations like Enlil) of a `pancake' shaped FR is
observed as it approaches 1 AU. We investigate how an equipartition line,
defined by a magnetic Weber number, surrounding a core region of a propagating
FR can demarcate a boundary layer where there is a sharp transition in the
plasma beta. The substructure affects the distribution of toroidal flux, with
the majority of the flux remaining in a small core region which maintains a
quasi-cylindrical structure. Quantitatively, we investigate a locus of points
where the kinetic energy density of the relative inflow field is equal to the
energy density of the transverse magnetic field (i.e. effective tension force).
The simulation provides compelling evidence that at all heliocentric distances
the distribution of toroidal magnetic flux away from the FR axis is not linear;
with 80% of the toroidal flux occurring within 40% of the distance from the FR
axis. Thus our simulation displays evidence that the competing ideas of a
pancaking structure observed remotely can coexist with a quasi-cylindrical
magnetic structure seen in situ.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.2210 [pdf] - 1179105
The Interaction of Two Coronal Mass Ejections: Influence of Relative
Orientation
Submitted: 2013-09-09
We report on a numerical investigation of two coronal mass ejections (CMEs)
which interact as they propagate in the inner heliosphere. We focus on the
effect of the orientation of the CMEs relative to each other by performing four
different simulations with the axis of the second CME rotated by 90 degrees
from one simulation to the next. Each magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulation is
performed in three dimensions (3-D) with the Space Weather Modeling Framework
(SWMF) in an idealized setting reminiscent of solar minimum conditions. We
extract synthetic satellite measurements during and after the interaction and
compare the different cases. We also analyze the kinematics of the two CMEs,
including the evolution of their widths and aspect ratios. We find that the
first CME contracts radially as a result of the interaction in all cases, but
the amount of subsequent radial expansion depends on the relative orientation
of the two CMEs. Reconnection between the two ejecta and between the ejecta and
the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) determines the type of structure
resulting from the interaction. When a CME with a high inclination with respect
to the ecliptic overtakes one with a low inclination, it is possible to create
a compound event with a smooth rotation in the magnetic field vector over more
than 180 degrees. Due to reconnection, the second CME only appears as an
extended "tail", and the event may be mistaken for a glancing encounter with an
isolated CME. This configuration differs significantly from the one usually
studied of a multiple-magnetic cloud event, which we found to be associated
with the interaction of two CMEs with the same orientation.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.3777 [pdf] - 1165946
On Sun-to-Earth Propagation of Coronal Mass Ejections
Submitted: 2013-04-13
We investigate how coronal mass ejections (CMEs) propagate through, and
interact with, the inner heliosphere between the Sun and Earth, a key question
in CME research and space weather forecasting. CME Sun-to-Earth kinematics are
constrained by combining wide-angle heliospheric imaging observations,
interplanetary radio type II bursts and in situ measurements from multiple
vantage points. We select three events for this study, the 2012 January 19, 23,
and March 7 CMEs. Different from previous event studies, this work attempts to
create a general picture for CME Sun-to-Earth propagation and compare different
techniques for determining CME interplanetary kinematics. Key results are
obtained concerning CME Sun-to-Earth propagation. Our comparison between
different techniques (and data sets) also has important implications for CME
observations and their interpretations. Future CME observations and space
weather forecasting are discussed based on these results. See detail in the
PDF.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.6945 [pdf] - 621029
Assessing the Constrained Harmonic Mean Method for Deriving the
Kinematics of ICMEs with a Numerical Simulation
Submitted: 2013-01-29, last modified: 2013-01-30
In this study we use a numerical simulation of an artificial coronal mass
ejection (CME) to validate a method for calculating propagation directions and
kinematical profiles of interplanetary CMEs (ICMEs). In this method
observations from heliospheric images are constrained with in-situ plasma and
field data at 1 AU. These data are used to convert measured ICME elongations
into distance by applying the Harmonic Mean approach that assumes a spherical
shape of the ICME front. We use synthetic white-light images, similar as
observed by STEREO-A/HI, for three different separation angles between remote
and in-situ spacecraft, of 30{\deg}, 60{\deg}, and 90{\deg}. To validate the
results of the method they are compared to the apex speed profile of the
modeled ICME, as obtained from a top view. This profile reflects the "true"
apex kinematics since it is not affected by scattering or projection effects.
In this way it is possible to determine the accuracy of the method for
revealing ICME propagation directions and kinematics. We found that the
direction obtained by the constrained Harmonic Mean method is not very
sensitive to the separation angle (30{\deg} sep: \phi = W7; 60{\deg} sep: \phi
= W12; 90{\deg} sep: \phi = W15; true dir.: E0/W0). For all three cases the
derived kinematics are in a relatively good agreement with the real kinematics.
The best consistency is obtained for the 30{\deg} case, while with growing
separation angle the ICME speed at 1 AU is increasingly overestimated (30{\deg}
sep: \Delta V_arr ~-50 km/s, 60{\deg} sep: \Delta V_arr ~+75 km/s, 90{\deg}
sep: \Delta V_arr ~+125 km/s). Especially for future L4/L5 missions the
60{\deg} separation case is highly interesting in order to improve space
weather forecasts.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.2359 [pdf] - 1151316
The Deflection of the Two Interacting Coronal Mass Ejections of 2010 May
23-24 as Revealed by Combined In situ Measurements and Heliospheric Imaging
Submitted: 2012-09-11
In 2010 May 23-24, SDO observed the launch of two successive coronal mass
ejections (CMEs), which were subsequently tracked by the SECCHI suite onboard
STEREO. Using the COR2 coronagraphs and the heliospheric imagers (HIs), the
initial direction of both CMEs is determined to be slightly west of the
Sun-Earth line. We derive the CME kinematics, including the evolution of the
CME expansion until 0.4 AU. We find that, during the interaction, the second
CME decelerates from a speed above 500 km/s to 380 km/s the speed of the
leading edge of the first CME. STEREO observes a complex structure composed of
two different bright tracks in HI2-A but only one bright track in HI2-B. In
situ measurements from Wind show an "isolated" ICME, with the geometry of a
flux rope preceded by a shock. Measurements in the sheath are consistent with
draping around the transient. By combining remote-sensing and in situ
measurements, we determine that this event shows a clear instance of deflection
of two CMEs after their collision, and we estimate the deflection of the first
CME to be about 10 degrees towards the Sun-Earth line. The arrival time,
arrival speed and radius at Earth of the first CME are best predicted from
remote-sensing observations taken before the collision of the CMEs. Due to the
over-expansion of the CME after the collision, there are few, if any, signs of
interaction in in situ measurements. This study illustrates that complex
interactions during the Sun-to-Earth propagation may not be revealed by in situ
measurements alone.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.1990 [pdf] - 581982
A study of the Heliocentric dependence of Shock Standoff Distance and
Geometry using 2.5D MHD Simulations of CME-driven shocks
Submitted: 2012-09-10
We perform four numerical magnetohydrodynamic simulations in 2.5 dimensions
(2.5D) of fast Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) and their associated shock fronts
between 10Rs and 300Rs. We investigate the relative change in the shock
standoff distance, Sd, as a fraction of the CME radial half-width, Dob (i.e.
Sd/Dob). Previous hydrodynamic studies have related the shock standoff distance
for Earths magnetosphere to the density compression ratio (DR,Ru/Rd) measured
across the bow shock (Spreiter, Summers and Alksne 1966). The DR coefficient,
kdr, which is the proportionality constant between the relative standoff
distance (Sd/Dob) and the compression ratio, was semi-empirically estimated as
1.1. For CMEs, we show that this value varies linearly as a function of
heliocentric distance and changes significantly for different radii of
curvature of the CMEs leading edge. We find that a value of 0.8+-0.1 is more
appropriate for small heliocentric distances (<30Rs) which corresponds to the
spherical geometry of a magnetosphere presented by Seiff (1962). As the CME
propagates its cross section becomes more oblate and the kdr value increases
linearly with heliocentric distance, such that kdr= 1.1 is most appropriate at
a heliocentric distance of about 80Rs. For terrestrial distances (215Rs) we
estimate kdr= 1.8+-0.3, which also indicates that the CME cross-sectional
structure is generally more oblate than that of Earths magnetosphere. These
alterations to the proportionality coefficients may serve to improve
investigations into the estimates of the magnetic field in the corona upstream
of a CME as well as the aspect ratio of CMEs as measured in situ.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.2526 [pdf] - 561321
Heliospheric Observations of STEREO-Directed Coronal Mass Ejections in
2008--2010: Lessons for Future Observations of Earth-Directed CMEs
Submitted: 2012-05-11
We present a study of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) which impacted one of the
STEREO spacecraft between January 2008 and early 2010. We focus our study on 20
CMEs which were observed remotely by the Heliospheric Imagers (HIs) onboard the
other STEREO spacecraft up to large heliocentric distances. We compare the
predictions of the Fixed-Phi and Harmonic Mean (HM) fitting methods, which only
differ by the assumed geometry of the CME. It is possible to use these
techniques to determine from remote-sensing observations the CME direction of
propagation, arrival time and final speed which are compared to in situ
measurements. We find evidence that for large viewing angles, the HM fitting
method predicts the CME direction better. However, this may be due to the fact
that only wide CMEs can be successfully observed when the CME propagates more
than 100 deg from the observing spacecraft. Overall eight CMEs, originating
from behind the limb as seen by one of the STEREO spacecraft can be tracked and
their arrival time at the other STEREO spacecraft can be successfully
predicted. This includes CMEs, such as the events on 4 December 2009 and 9
April 2010, which were viewed 130 deg away from their direction of propagation.
Therefore, we predict that some Earth-directed CMEs will be observed by the HIs
until early 2013, when the separation between Earth and one of the STEREO
spacecraft will be similar to the separation of the two STEREO spacecraft in
2009--2010.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.3813 [pdf] - 500905
Effect of Solar Wind Drag on the Determination of the Properties of
Coronal Mass Ejections from Heliospheric Images
Submitted: 2012-04-17
The Fixed-\Phi (F\Phi) and Harmonic Mean (HM) fitting methods are two methods
to determine the average direction and velocity of coronal mass ejections
(CMEs) from time-elongation tracks produced by Heliospheric Imagers (HIs), such
as the HIs onboard the STEREO spacecraft. Both methods assume a constant
velocity in their descriptions of the time-elongation profiles of CMEs, which
are used to fit the observed time-elongation data. Here, we analyze the effect
of aerodynamic drag on CMEs propagating through interplanetary space, and how
this drag affects the result of the F\Phi and HM fitting methods. A simple drag
model is used to analytically construct time-elongation profiles which are then
fitted with the two methods. It is found that higher angles and velocities give
rise to greater error in both methods, reaching errors in the direction of
propagation of up to 15 deg and 30 deg for the F\Phi and HM fitting methods,
respectively. This is due to the physical accelerations of the CMEs being
interpreted as geometrical accelerations by the fitting methods. Because of the
geometrical definition of the HM fitting method, it is affected by the
acceleration more greatly than the F\Phi fitting method. Overall, we find that
both techniques overestimate the initial (and final) velocity and direction for
fast CMEs propagating beyond 90 deg from the Sun-spacecraft line, meaning that
arrival times at 1 AU would be predicted early (by up to 12 hours). We also
find that the direction and arrival time of a wide and decelerating CME can be
better reproduced by the F\Phi due to the cancellation of two errors:
neglecting the CME width and neglecting the CME deceleration. Overall, the
inaccuracies of the two fitting methods are expected to play an important role
in the prediction of CME hit and arrival times as we head towards solar maximum
and the STEREO spacecraft further move behind the Sun.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.0515 [pdf] - 473009
Arrival time calculation for interplanetary coronal mass ejections with
circular fronts and application to STEREO observations of the 2009 February
13 eruption
Möstl, C.;
Rollett, T.;
Lugaz, N.;
Farrugia, C. J.;
Davies, J. A.;
Temmer, M.;
Veronig, A. M.;
Harrison, R.;
Crothers, S.;
Luhmann, J. G.;
Galvin, A. B.;
Zhang, T. L.;
Baumjohann, W.;
Biernat, H. K.
Submitted: 2011-08-02
A goal of the NASA STEREO mission is to study the feasibility of forecasting
the direction, arrival time and internal structure of solar coronal mass
ejections (CMEs) from a vantage point outside the Sun-Earth line. Through a
case study, we discuss the arrival time calculation of interplanetary CMEs
(ICMEs) in the ecliptic plane using data from STEREO/SECCHI at large
elongations from the Sun in combination with different geometric assumptions
about the ICME front shape (Fixed-\Phi (FP): a point and harmonic Mean (HM): a
circle). These forecasting techniques use single-spacecraft imaging data and
are based on the assumptions of constant velocity and direction. We show that
for the slow (350 km/s) ICME on 2009 February 13-18, observed at quadrature by
the two STEREO spacecraft, the results for the arrival time given by the HM
approximation are more accurate by 12 hours than those for FP in comparison to
in situ observations of solar wind plasma and magnetic field parameters by
STEREO/IMPACT/PLASTIC, and by 6 hours for the arrival time at Venus Express
(MAG). We propose that the improvement is directly related to the ICME front
shape being more accurately described by HM for an ICME with a low inclination
of its symmetry axis to the ecliptic. In this case the ICME has to be tracked
to > 30{\deg} elongation to get arrival time errors < 5 hours. A newly derived
formula for calculating arrival times with the HM method is also useful for a
triangulation technique assuming the same geometry.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.5284 [pdf] - 561284
Numerical Investigation of a Coronal Mass Ejection from an Anemone
Active Region: Reconnection and Deflection of the 2005 August 22 Eruption
Submitted: 2011-06-26
We present a numerical investigation of the coronal evolution of a coronal
mass ejection (CME) on 2005 August 22 using a 3-D thermodynamics
magnetohydrodynamic model, the SWMF. The source region of the eruption was
anemone active region (AR) 10798, which emerged inside a coronal hole. We
validate our modeled corona by producing synthetic extreme ultraviolet (EUV)
images, which we compare to EIT images. We initiate the CME with an
out-of-equilibrium flux rope with an orientation and chirality chosen in
agreement with observations of a H-alpha filament. During the eruption, one
footpoint of the flux rope reconnects with streamer magnetic field lines and
with open field lines from the adjacent coronal hole. It yields an eruption
which has a mix of closed and open twisted field lines due to interchange
reconnection and only one footpoint line-tied to the source region. Even with
the large-scale reconnection, we find no evidence of strong rotation of the CME
as it propagates. We study the CME deflection and find that the effect of the
Lorentz force is a deflection of the CME by about 3 deg/Rsun towards the East
during the first 30 minutes of the propagation. We also produce coronagraphic
and EUV images of the CME, which we compare with real images, identifying a
dimming region associated with the reconnection process. We discuss the
implication of our results for the arrival at Earth of CMEs originating from
the limb and for models to explain the presence of open field lines in magnetic
clouds.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1010.1949 [pdf] - 377708
Accuracy and Limitations of Fitting and Stereoscopic Methods to
Determine the Direction of Coronal Mass Ejections from Heliospheric Imagers
Observations
Submitted: 2010-10-06
Using data from the Heliospheric Imagers (HIs) onboard STEREO, it is possible
to derive the direction of propagation of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) in
addition to their speed with a variety of methods. For CMEs observed by both
STEREO spacecraft, it is possible to derive their direction using simultaneous
observations from the twin spacecraft and also, using observations from only
one spacecraft with fitting methods. This makes it possible to test and compare
different analyses techniques. In this article, we propose a new fitting method
based on observations from one spacecraft, which we compare to the commonly
used fitting method of Sheeley et al. (1999). We also compare the results from
these two fitting methods with those from two stereoscopic methods, focusing on
12 CMEs observed simultaneously by the two STEREO spacecraft in 2008 and 2009.
We find evidence that the fitting method of Sheeley et al. (1999) can result in
significant errors in the determination of the CME direction when the CME
propagates outside of 60deg \pm 20 deg from the Sun-spacecraft line. We expect
our new fitting method to be better adapted to the analysis of halo or limb
CMEs with respect to the observing spacecraft. We also find some evidence that
direct triangulation in the HI fields-of-view should only be applied to CMEs
propagating approximatively towards Earth (\pm 20deg from the Sun-Earth line).
Last, we address one of the possible sources of errors of fitting methods: the
assumption of radial propagation. Using stereoscopic methods, we find that at
least seven of the 12 studied CMEs had an heliospheric deflection of less than
20deg as they propagated in the HI fields-of-view, which, we believe, validates
this approximation.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.5394 [pdf] - 368514
Numerical Modeling of Interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejections and
Comparison with Heliospheric Images
Submitted: 2010-08-31
Interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICMEs) have complex magnetic and
density structures, which is the result of their interaction with the
structured solar wind and with previous eruptions. ICMEs are revealed by in
situ measurements and in the past five years, through remote-sensing
observations by heliospheric imagers. However, to understand and analyze these
observations often requires the use of numerical modeling. It is because no
instruments can yet provide a simple view of ICMEs in two or three dimensions.
Numerical simulations can be used to determine the origin of a complex ejecta
observed near Earth, or to analyze the origin, speed and extent of density
structures observed remotely. Here, we review and discuss recent efforts to use
numerical simulations of ICMEs to investigate the magnetic topology, density
structure, energetics and kinematics of ICMEs in the interplanetary space.
After reviewing existing numerical models of ICMEs, we first focus on
numerical modeling in support of the SMEI and STEREO observations. 3-D
simulations can help determining the origins of the fronts observed by SECCHI
and SMEI, especially for complex events such as the January 24-25, 2007 CMEs.
They can also be used to test different methods to derive ICME properties from
remote observations, to predict and explain observational effects, and to
understand the deceleration and deformation of ICMEs. In the last part, we
focus on the numerical investigation of non-magnetic cloud ejecta. We discuss
how simulations are crucial to understand the formation of non-twisted ejecta
and the formation of complex ejecta due to the interaction of multiple ICMEs.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.0945 [pdf] - 158360
Determining the azimuthal properties of coronal mass ejections from
multi-spacecraft remote-sensing observations with stereo secchi
Submitted: 2010-04-06
We discuss how simultaneous observations by multiple heliospheric imagers can
provide some important information about the azimuthal properties of Coronal
Mass Ejections (CMEs) in the heliosphere. We propose two simple models of CME
geometry that can be used to derive information about the azimuthal deflection
and the azimuthal expansion of CMEs from SECCHI/HI observations. We apply these
two models to four CMEs well-observed by both STEREO spacecraft during the year
2008. We find that in three cases, the joint STEREO-A and B observations are
consistent with CMEs moving radially outward. In some cases, we are able to
derive the azimuthal cross-section of the CME fronts, and we are able to
measure the deviation from self-similar evolution. The results from this
analysis show the importance of having multiple satellites dedicated to space
weather forecasting, for example in orbits at the Lagrangian L4 and L5 points.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.2647 [pdf] - 902741
Towards a Realistic, Data-Driven Thermodynamic MHD Model of the Global
Solar Corona
Submitted: 2009-12-11
In this work we describe our implementation of a thermodynamic energy
equation into the global corona model of the Space Weather Modeling Framework
(SWMF), and its development into the new Lower Corona (LC) model. This work
includes the integration of the additional energy transport terms of coronal
heating, electron heat conduction, and optically thin radiative cooling into
the governing magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) energy equation. We examine two
different boundary conditions using this model; one set in the upper transition
region (the Radiative Energy Balance model), as well as a uniform chromospheric
condition where the transition region can be modeled in its entirety. Via
observation synthesis from model results and the subsequent comparison to full
sun extreme ultraviolet (EUV) and soft X-Ray observations of Carrington
Rotation (CR) 1913 centered on Aug 27, 1996, we demonstrate the need for these
additional considerations when using global MHD models to describe the unique
conditions in the low corona. Through multiple simulations we examine ability
of the LC model to asses and discriminate between coronal heating models, and
find that a relative simple empirical heating model is adequate in reproducing
structures observed in the low corona. We show that the interplay between
coronal heating and electron heat conduction provides significant feedback onto
the 3D magnetic topology in the low corona as compared to a potential field
extrapolation, and that this feedback is largely dependent on the amount of
mechanical energy introduced into the corona.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.1895 [pdf] - 902365
Solar-Terrestrial Simulations of CMEs with a Realistic Initiation
Mechanism: Case Study for Active Region 10069
Submitted: 2009-11-10
Most simulations of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) to date either focus on the
interplanetary propagation of a giant plasma "blob" without paying too much
attention to its origin and to the formation process or they focus on the
complex evolution of the coronal magnetic field due to (sub-)photospheric
motions which result in an eruption. Here, we present global simulations of
CMEs where coronal motions are used to produce a realistic evolution of the
coronal magnetic field and cause an eruption. We focus on active region 10069,
which produced a number of eruptions in late August 2002, including the August
24, 2002 CME - a fast (~2000 km/s) eruption originating from W81-, as well as a
slower eruption on August 22, 2002 (originating from W62). Using a
three-dimensional magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulation of these ejections with
the Space Weather Modeling Framework (SWMF), we show how a realistic initiation
mechanism enables us to study the deflection of the CME in the corona and in
the heliosphere. Reconnection of the erupting magnetic field with that of
neighboring streamers and active regions modify the solar connectivity of the
field lines connecting to Earth and change the expected solar energetic
particle fluxes. Comparing the results at 1 AU of our simulations with in situ
observations by the ACE spacecraft, we propose an alternate solar origin for
the shock wave observed at L1 on August 26.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.0534 [pdf] - 1017353
Deriving the radial distances of wide coronal mass ejections from
elongation measurements in the heliosphere - Application to CME-CME
interaction
Submitted: 2009-09-02
We present general considerations regarding the derivation of the radial
distances of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from elongation angle measurements
such as those provided by SECCHI and SMEI, focusing on measurements in the
Heliospheric Imager 2 (HI-2) field of view (i.e. past 0.3 AU). This study is
based on a three-dimensional (3-D) magneto-hydrodynamics (MHD) simulation of
two CMEs observed by SECCHI on January 24-27, 2007. Having a 3-D simulation
with synthetic HI images, we are able to compare the two basic methods used to
derive CME positions from elongation angles, the so-called "Point-P" and
"Fixed-Phi" approximations.
We confirm, following similar works, that both methods, while valid in the
most inner heliosphere, yield increasingly large errors in HI-2 field of view
for fast and wide CMEs. Using a simple model of a CME as an expanding
self-similar sphere, we derive an analytical relationship between elongation
angles and radial distances for wide CMEs. This relationship is simply the
harmonic mean of the "Point-P" and "Fixed-Phi'' approximations and it is aimed
at complementing 3-D fitting of CMEs by cone models or flux rope shapes. It
proves better at getting the kinematics of the simulated CME right when we
compare the results of our line-of-sights to the MHD simulation. Based on this
approximation, we re-analyze the J-maps (time-elongation maps) in January
26-27, 2007 and present the first observational evidence that the merging of
CMEs is associated with a momentum exchange from the faster ejection to the
slower one due to the propagation of the shock wave associated with the fast
eruption through the slow eruption.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:0810.1330 [pdf] - 17202
The August 24, 2002 Coronal Mass Ejection: When a Western Limb Event
Connects to Earth
Submitted: 2008-10-07
We discuss how some coronal mass ejections (CMEs) originating from the
western limb of the Sun are associated with space weather effects such as solar
energetic particles (SEPs), shock or geo-effective ejecta at Earth. We focus on
the August 24, 2002 coronal mass ejection, a fast (~ 2000 km/s) eruption
originating from W81. Using a three-dimensional magneto-hydrodynamic simulation
of this ejection with the Space Weather Modeling Framework (SWMF), we show how
a realistic initiation mechanism enables us to study the deflection of the CME
in the corona and the heliosphere. Reconnection of the erupting magnetic field
with that of neighboring streamers and active regions modify the solar
connectivity of the field lines connecting to Earth and can also partly explain
the deflection of the eruption during the first tens of minutes. Comparing the
results at 1 AU of our simulation with observations by the ACE spacecraft, we
find that the simulated shock does not reach Earth, but has a maximum angular
span of about 120$^\circ$, and reaches 35$^\circ$ West of Earth in 58 hours. We
find no significant deflection of the CME and its associated shock wave in the
heliosphere, and we discuss the consequences for the shock angular span.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:0805.3707 [pdf] - 12912
Three-Dimensional MHD Simulation of the 2003 October 28 Coronal Mass
Ejection: Comparison with LASCO Coronagraph Observations
Submitted: 2008-05-23
We numerically model the coronal mass ejection (CME) event of October 28,
2003 that erupted from active region 10486 and propagated to Earth in less than
20 hours causing severe geomagnetic storms. The magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model
is formulated by first arriving at a steady state corona and solar wind
employing synoptic magnetograms. We initiate two CMEs from the same active
region, one approximately a day earlier that preconditions the solar wind for
the much faster CME on the 28th. This second CME travels through the corona at
a rate of over 2500 km s$^{-1}$ driving a strong forward shock. We clearly
identify this shock in an image produced by the Large Angle Spectrometric
Coronagraph (LASCO) C3, and reproduce the shock and its appearance in synthetic
white light images from the simulation. We find excellent agreement with both
the general morphology and the quantitative brightness of the model CME with
LASCO observations. These results demonstrate that the CME shape is largely
determined by its interaction with the ambient solar wind and may not be
sensitive to the initiation process. We then show how the CME would appear as
observed by wide-angle coronagraphs onboard the Solar Terrestrial Relations
Observatory (STEREO) spacecraft. We find complex time evolution of the
white-light images as a result of the way in which the density structures pass
through the Thomson sphere. The simulation is performed with the Space Weather
Modeling Framework (SWMF).