We present a generalization of Rastall's gravity in which the conservation law of the energy-moment tensor is altered, and as a result, the trace of the energy-moment tensor is taken into account together with the Ricci scalar in the expression for the covariant derivative. Afterwards, we obtain the field equation in this theory and solve it by considering a spherically symmetric space-time. We show that the external solution has two possible classes of solutions with spherical symmetry in the vacuum in generalized Rastall's gravity. The first class of solutions is completely equivalent to the Schwarzschild solution, while the second class of solutions has the same structure as the Schwarzschild--de Sitter solution in general relativity. The generalization, in contrast to constant value $k=8\pi G$ in general relativity, has a gravitational parameter $k$ that depends on the energy density $\rho$. As an application, we perform a careful analysis of the effects of the theory on neutron stars using realistic equations of state (EoS) as inputs. Our results show that important differences on the profile of neutron stars are obtained within two representatives EoS.