Normalized to: Line, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.10292 [pdf] - 2119122
The TESS Phase Curve of KELT-1b Suggests a High Dayside Albedo
Beatty, Thomas G.;
Wong, Ian;
Fetherolf, Tara;
Line, Michael R.;
Shporer, Avi;
Stassun, Keivan G.;
Ricker, George R.;
Seager, Sara;
Winn, Joshua N.;
Jenkins, Jon M.;
Louie, Dana R.;
Schlieder, Joshua E.;
Sha, Lizhou;
Tenenbaum, Peter;
Yahalomi, Daniel A.
Submitted: 2020-06-18, last modified: 2020-06-21
We measured the optical phase curve of the transiting brown dwarf KELT-1b
(TOI 1476, Siverd et al. 2012) using data from the TESS spacecraft. We found
that KELT-1b shows significant phase variation in the TESS bandpass, with a
relatively large phase amplitude of $234^{+43}_{-44}$ ppm and a secondary
eclipse depth of $371^{+47}_{-49}$ ppm. We also measured a marginal eastward
offset in the dayside hotspot of $18.3^\circ\pm7.4^\circ$ relative to the
substellar point. We detected a strong phase curve signal attributed to
ellipsoidal distortion of the host star, with an amplitude of $399\pm19$ ppm.
Our results are roughly consistent with the Spitzer phase curves of KELT-1b
(Beatty et al. 2019), but the TESS eclipse depth is deeper than expected. Our
cloud-free 1D models of KELT-1b's dayside emission are unable to fit the full
combined eclipse spectrum. Instead, the large TESS eclipse depth suggests that
KELT-1b may have a significant dayside geometric albedo of
$\mathrm{A}_\mathrm{g}\sim0.5$ in the TESS bandpass, which would agree with the
tentative trend between equilibrium temperature and geometric albedo recently
suggested by Wong et al. 2020. We posit that if KELT-1b has a high dayside
albedo, it is likely due to silicate clouds (Gao et al. 2020) that form on
KELT-1b's nightside (Beatty et al. 2019, Keating et al. 2019) and are
subsequently transported onto the western side of KELT-1b's dayside hemisphere
before breaking up.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.11442 [pdf] - 2119151
2D Retrieval Frameworks for Hot Jupiter Phase Curves
Submitted: 2020-06-19
Spectroscopic phase curves provide unique access to the three-dimensional
properties of transiting exoplanet atmospheres. However, a modeling framework
must be developed to deliver accurate inferences of atmospheric properties for
these complex data sets. Here, we develop an approach to retrieve temperature
structures and molecular abundances from phase curve spectra at any orbital
phase. In the context of a representative hot Jupiter with a large day-night
temperature contrast, we examine the biases in typical one-dimensional (1D)
retrievals as a function of orbital phase/geometry, compared to two-dimensional
(2D) models that appropriately capture the disk-integrated phase geometry. We
guide our intuition by applying our new framework on a simulated HST+Spitzer
phase curve data set in which the ``truth'' is known, followed by an
application to the spectroscopic phase curve of the canonical hot Jupiter,
WASP-43b. We also demonstrate the retrieval framework on simulated JWST phase
curve observations. We apply our new geometric framework to a joint-fit of all
spectroscopic phases, assuming longitudinal molecular abundance homogeneity,
resulting in an a factor of 2 improvement in abundances precision when compared
to individual phase constraints. With a 1D retrieval model on simulated
HST+Spitzer data, we find strongly biased molecular abundances for CH$_4$ and
CO$_2$ at most orbital phases. With 2D, the day and night profiles retrieved
from WASP-43b remain consistent throughout the orbit. JWST retrievals show that
a 2D model is strongly favored at all orbital phases. Based on our new 2D
retrieval implementation, we provide recommendations on when 1D models are
appropriate and when more complex phase geometries involving multiple TP
profiles are required to obtain an unbiased view of tidally locked planetary
atmospheres.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.05153 [pdf] - 2092559
An Unusual Transmission Spectrum for the Sub-Saturn KELT-11b Suggestive
of a Sub-Solar Water Abundance
Colón, Knicole D.;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Line, Michael;
Welbanks, Luis;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Beatty, Thomas;
Tamburo, Patrick;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Mandell, Avi;
Rodriguez, Joseph E.;
Barclay, Thomas;
Lopez, Eric D.;
Stassun, Keivan G.;
Angerhausen, Daniel;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
James, David J.;
Pepper, Joshua;
Ahlers, John P.;
Plavchan, Peter;
Awiphan, Supachai;
Kotnik, Cliff;
McLeod, Kim K.;
Murawski, Gabriel;
Chotani, Heena;
LeBrun, Danny;
Matzko, William;
Rea, David;
Vidaurri, Monica;
Webster, Scott;
Williams, James K.;
Cox, Leafia Sheraden;
Tan, Nicole;
Gilbert, Emily A.
Submitted: 2020-05-11
We present an optical-to-infrared transmission spectrum of the inflated
sub-Saturn-mass exoplanet KELT-11b measured with the Transiting Exoplanet
Survey Satellite (TESS), the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Wide Field Camera 3
(WFC3) G141 spectroscopic grism, and the Spitzer Space Telescope (Spitzer) at
3.6 $\mu$m, in addition to a Spitzer 4.5 $\mu$m secondary eclipse. The precise
HST transmission spectrum notably reveals a low-amplitude water feature with an
unusual shape. We apply a suite of modeling tools to the transmission spectrum
to investigate the planet's properties. Based on a retrieval analysis with
varying molecular abundances, we find strong evidence for water absorption in
the spectrum and tentative evidence for other absorbers (HCN, TiO, and AlO)
depending on model assumptions. The retrieved water abundance is generally
$\lesssim 0.1\times$ solar (0.001--0.7$\times$ solar over a range of model
assumptions), which is several orders of magnitude lower than expected from
planet formation models based on the solar system metallicity trend. We also
consider chemical equilibrium and self-consistent 1D radiative-convective
equilibrium model fits and find that they too prefer low metallicities ($[M/H]
\lesssim -2$, consistent with the free retrieval results); however, the
equilibrium models fit poorly and should be interpreted with caution. Finally,
we find that the dayside flux measured from the Spitzer secondary eclipse is
indicative of full heat redistribution from KELT-11b's dayside to nightside,
assuming the dayside is not cloudy. Altogether, the unusual results for
KELT-11b's composition are suggestive of new challenges on the horizon for
atmosphere and formation models in the face of increasingly precise
measurements of exoplanet spectra.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.11335 [pdf] - 2097424
Neutral Iron Emission Lines From The Day-side Of KELT-9b -- The GAPS
Programme With HARPS-N At TNG XX
Pino, L.;
Désert, J. M.;
Brogi, M.;
Malavolta, L.;
Wyttenbach, A.;
Line, M.;
Hoeijmakers, J.;
Fossati, L.;
Bonomo, A. S.;
Nascimbeni, V.;
Panwar, V.;
Affer, L.;
Benatti, S.;
Biazzo, K.;
Bignamini, A.;
Borsa, F.;
Carleo, I.;
Claudi, R.;
Cosentino, R.;
Covino, E.;
Damasso, M.;
Desidera, S.;
Giacobbe, P.;
Harutyunyan, A.;
Lanza, A. F.;
Leto, G.;
Maggio, A.;
Maldonado, J.;
Mancini, L.;
Micela, G.;
Molinari, E.;
Pagano, I.;
Piotto, G.;
Poretti, E.;
Rainer, M.;
Scandariato, G.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Allart, R.;
Borsato, L.;
Bruno, G.;
Di Fabrizio, L.;
Ehrenreich, D.;
Fiorenzano, A.;
Frustagli, G.;
Lavie, B.;
Lovis, C.;
Magazzù, A.;
Nardiello, D.;
Pedani, M.;
Smareglia, R.
Submitted: 2020-04-23
We present the first detection of atomic emission lines from the atmosphere
of an exoplanet. We detect neutral iron lines from the day-side of KELT-9b (Teq
$\sim$ 4, 000 K). We combined thousands of spectrally resolved lines observed
during one night with the HARPS-N spectrograph (R $\sim$ 115, 000), mounted at
the Telescopio Nazionale Galileo. We introduce a novel statistical approach to
extract the planetary parameters from the binary mask cross-correlation
analysis. We also adapt the concept of contribution function to the context of
high spectral resolution observations, to identify the location in the
planetary atmosphere where the detected emission originates. The average
planetary line profile intersected by a stellar G2 binary mask was found in
emission with a contrast of 84 $\pm$ 14 ppm relative to the planetary plus
stellar continuum (40 $\pm$ 5$\%$ relative to the planetary continuum only).
This result unambiguously indicates the presence of an atmospheric thermal
inversion. Finally, assuming a modelled temperature profile previously
published (Lothringer et al. 2018), we show that an iron abundance consistent
with a few times the stellar value explains the data well. In this scenario,
the iron emission originates at the $10^{-3}$-$10^{-5}$ bar level.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.00014 [pdf] - 2089187
Smaller than expected bright-spot offsets in Spitzer phase curves of the
hot Jupiter Qatar-1b
Keating, Dylan;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Rauscher, Emily;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Bell, Taylor;
Dang, Lisa;
Deming, Drake;
Désert, Jean-Michel;
Feng, Y. Katherina;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Kempton, Eliza M. -R.;
Lewis, Nikole;
Line, Michael R.;
Mansfield, Megan;
May, Erin;
Morley, Caroline;
Showman, Adam P.
Submitted: 2020-03-31
We present \textit{Spitzer} full-orbit thermal phase curves of the hot
Jupiter Qatar-1b, a planet with the same equilibrium temperature---and
intermediate surface gravity and orbital period---as the well-studied planets
HD 209458b and WASP-43b. We measure secondary eclipse of $0.21 \pm 0.02 \%$ at
$3.6~\mu$m and $0.30 \pm 0.02 \%$ at $4.5~\mu$m, corresponding to dayside
brightness temperatures of $1542^{+32}_{-31}$~K and $1557^{+35}_{-36}$~K,
respectively, consistent with a vertically isothermal dayside. The respective
nightside brightness temperatures are $1117^{+76}_{-71}$~K and
$1167^{+69}_{-74}$~K, in line with a trend that hot Jupiters all have similar
nightside temperatures. We infer a Bond albedo of $0.12_{-0.16}^{+0.14}$ and a
moderate day-night heat recirculation efficiency, similar to HD 209458b.
General circulation models for HD 209458b and WASP-43b predict that their
bright-spots should be shifted east of the substellar point by tens of degrees,
and these predictions were previously confirmed with \textit{Spitzer}
full-orbit phase curve observations. The phase curves of Qatar-1b are likewise
expected to exhibit eastward offsets. Instead, the observed phase curves are
consistent with no offset: $11^{\circ}\pm 7^{\circ}$ at $3.6~\mu$m and
$-4^{\circ}\pm 7^{\circ}$ at $4.5~\mu$m. The discrepancy in circulation
patterns between these three otherwise similar planets points to the importance
of secondary parameters like rotation rate and surface gravity, and the
presence or absence of clouds, in determining atmospheric conditions on hot
Jupiters.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.05397 [pdf] - 2069114
A weak spectral signature of water vapour in the atmosphere of HD 179949
b at high spectral resolution in the L-band
Submitted: 2020-03-11
High resolution spectroscopy (R > 20,000) is currently the only known method
to constrain the orbital solution and atmospheric properties of non-transiting
hot Jupiters. It does so by resolving the spectral features of the planet into
a forest of spectral lines and directly observing its Doppler shift while
orbiting the host star. In this study, we analyse VLT/CRIRES (R = 100,000)
L-band observations of the non-transiting giant planet HD 179949 b centred
around 3.5 microns. We observe a weak (3.0 sigma, or S/N = 4.8) spectral
signature of H2O in absorption contained within the radial velocity of the
planet at superior-conjunction, with a mild dependence on the choice of line
list used for the modelling. Combining this data with previous observations in
the K-band, we measure a detection significance of 8.4 sigma for an atmosphere
that is most consistent with a shallow lapse-rate, solar C/O ratio, and with CO
and H2O being the only major sources of opacity in this wavelength range. As
the two sets of data were taken three years apart, this points to the absence
of strong radial-velocity anomalies due, e.g., to variability in atmospheric
circulation. We measure a projected orbital velocity for the planet of KP =
(145.2 +- 2.0)kms^{-1} (1 sigma) and improve the error bars on this parameter
by ~70%. However, we only marginally tighten constraints on orbital inclination
(66.2 +3.7 -3.1 degrees) and planet mass (0.963 +0.036 -0.031 Jupiter masses),
due to the dominant uncertainties of stellar mass and semi-major axis. Follow
ups of radial-velocity planets are thus crucial to fully enable their accurate
characterisation via high resolution spectroscopy.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.01063 [pdf] - 2060825
A comparison of exoplanet spectroscopic retrieval tools
Submitted: 2020-02-03, last modified: 2020-03-09
Over the last several years, spectroscopic observations of transiting
exoplanets have begun to uncover information about their atmospheres, including
atmospheric composition and indications of the presence of clouds and hazes.
Spectral retrieval is the leading technique for interpretation of transmission
spectra and is employed by several teams using a variety of forward models and
parameter estimation algorithms. However, different model suites have mostly
been used in isolation and so it is unknown whether the results from each are
comparable. As we approach the launch of the James Webb Space Telescope we
anticipate advances in wavelength coverage, precision, and resolution of
transit spectroscopic data, so it is important that the tools that will be used
to interpret these information rich spectra are validated. To this end, we
present an inter-model comparison of three retrieval suites: TauREx, NEMESIS
and CHIMERA. We demonstrate that the forward model spectra are in good
agreement (residual deviations on the order of 20 - 40 ppm), and discuss the
results of cross retrievals between the three tools. Generally, the constraints
from the cross retrievals are consistent with each other and with input values
to within 1 sigma However, for high precision scenarios with error envelopes of
order 30 ppm, subtle differences in the simulated spectra result in
discrepancies between the different retrieval suites, and inaccuracies in
retrieved values of several sigma. This can be considered analogous to
substantial systematic/astrophysical noise in a real observation, or
errors/omissions in a forward model such as molecular linelist incompleteness
or missing absorbers.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.01567 [pdf] - 2027894
Evidence for H$_{2}$ Dissociation and Recombination Heat Transport in
the Atmosphere of KELT-9b
Mansfield, Megan;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Komacek, Thaddeus D.;
Bell, Taylor J.;
Tan, Xianyu;
Malik, Matej;
Beatty, Thomas G.;
Wong, Ian;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Dang, Lisa;
Désert, Jean-Michel;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Gaudi, B. Scott;
Keating, Dylan;
Kempton, Eliza M. -R.;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Line, Michael R.;
Parmentier, Vivien;
Stassun, Keivan G.;
Swain, Mark R.;
Zellem, Robert T.
Submitted: 2019-10-03, last modified: 2020-01-07
Phase curve observations provide an opportunity to study the full energy
budgets of exoplanets by quantifying the amount of heat redistributed from
their daysides to their nightsides. Theories explaining the properties of phase
curves for hot Jupiters have focused on the balance between radiation and
dynamics as the primary parameter controlling heat redistribution. However,
recent phase curves have shown deviations from the trends that emerge from this
theory, which has led to work on additional processes that may affect hot
Jupiter energy budgets. One such process, molecular hydrogen dissociation and
recombination, can enhance energy redistribution on ultra-hot Jupiters with
temperatures above $\sim2000$ K. In order to study the impact of H$_{2}$
dissociation on ultra-hot Jupiters, we present a phase curve of KELT-9b
observed with the Spitzer Space Telescope at 4.5 $\mu$m. KELT-9b is the hottest
known transiting planet, with a 4.5-$\mu$m dayside brightness temperature of
$4566^{+140}_{-136}$ K and a nightside temperature of $2556^{+101}_{-97}$ K. We
observe a phase curve amplitude of $0.609 \pm 0.020$ and a hot spot offset of
$18.7^{+2.1}_{-2.3}$ degrees. The observed amplitude is too small to be
explained by a simple balance between radiation and advection. General
circulation models (GCMs) and an energy balance model that include the effects
of H$_{2}$ dissociation and recombination provide a better match to the data.
The GCMs, however, predict a maximum hot spot offset of $5$ degrees, which
disagrees with our observations at $>5\sigma$ confidence. This discrepancy may
be due to magnetic effects in the planet's highly ionized atmosphere.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.10939 [pdf] - 2057833
The Detectability and Constraints of Biosignature Gases in the Near &
Mid-Infrared from Transit Transmission Spectroscopy
Submitted: 2019-12-23
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) is expected to revolutionize our
understanding of Jovian worlds over the coming decade. However, as we push
towards characterizing cooler, smaller, "terrestrial-like" planets, dedicated
next-generation facilities will be required to tease out the small spectral
signatures indicative of biological activity. Here, we evaluate the feasibility
of determining atmospheric properties, from near-to-mid-infrared transmission
spectra, of transiting temperate terrestrial M-dwarf companions. Specifically,
we utilize atmospheric retrievals to explore the trade space between spectral
resolution, wavelength coverage, and signal-to-noise on our ability to both
detect molecular species and constrain their abundances. We find that
increasing spectral resolution beyond R=100 for near-infrared wavelengths,
shorter than 5$\mu$m, proves to reduce the degeneracy between spectral features
of different molecules and thus greatly benefits the abundance constraints.
However, this benefit is greatly diminished beyond 5$\mu$m as any overlap
between broad features in the mid-infrared does not deconvolve with higher
resolutions. Additionally, our findings revealed that the inclusion of features
beyond 11$\mu$m did not meaningfully improve the detection significance nor
abundance constraints results. We conclude that an instrument with continuous
wavelength coverage from $\sim$2-11$\mu$m, spectral resolution of
R$\simeq$50-300, and a 25m$^2$ collecting area, would be capable of detecting
H$_2$O, CO$_2$, CH$_4$, O$_3$, and N$_2$O in the atmosphere of an Earth-analog
transiting a M-dwarf (mag$_{K}=8.0$) within 50 transits, and obtain better than
an order-of-magnitude constraint on each of their abundances.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.04389 [pdf] - 2046388
The Influence of Stellar Contamination on the Interpretation of Near
Infrared Transmission Spectra of Sub-Neptune Worlds around M-Dwarfs
Submitted: 2019-12-09
The impact of unocculted stellar surface heterogeneities in the form of cool
spots and hot faculae on the spectrum of a transiting planet has been a
daunting problem for the characterization of exoplanet atmospheres. The
wavelength-dependent nature of stellar surface heterogeneities imprinting their
signatures on planetary transmission spectra are of concern particularly for
systems of sub-Neptunes orbiting M-dwarfs. Here we present a systematic
exploration of the impact of this spot-contamination on simulated near infrared
transmission spectra of sub-Neptune planets. From our analysis, we find that
improper correction of stellar surface heterogeneities on transmission spectra
can lead to significant bias when inferring planetary atmospheric properties.
However, this bias is negligible for lower fractions of heterogeneities (<1%).
Additionally, we find that acquiring a priori knowledge of stellar
heterogeneities does not improve precision in constraining planetary parameters
if the heterogeneities are appropriately marginalized within a
retrieval---however these are conditional on our confidence of stellar
atmospheric models being accurate representations of the true photosphere. In
sum, to acquire unbiased constraints when characterizing planetary atmospheres
with the James Webb Space Telescope, we recommend performing joint retrievals
of both the disk-integrated spectrum of the star and the stellar contamination
corrected transmission spectrum.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.12988 [pdf] - 2038311
The Featureless Transmission Spectra of Two Super-Puff Planets
Libby-Roberts, Jessica E.;
Berta-Thompson, Zachory K.;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Masuda, Kento;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Lopez, Eric D.;
Deck, Katherine M.;
Fabrycky, Daniel;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Line, Michael R.;
Sanchis-Ojeda, Roberto;
Winn, Joshua N.
Submitted: 2019-10-28
The Kepler mission revealed a class of planets known as ''super-puffs,'' with
masses only a few times larger than Earth's but radii larger than Neptune,
giving them very low mean densities. All three of the known planets orbiting
the young solar-type star Kepler 51 are super-puffs. The Kepler 51 system
thereby provides an opportunity for a comparative study of the structures and
atmospheres of this mysterious class of planets, which may provide clues about
their formation and evolution. We observed two transits each of Kepler 51b and
51d with the Wide Field Camera 3 (WFC3) on the Hubble Space Telescope.
Combining new WFC3 transit times with re-analyzed Kepler data and updated
stellar parameters, we confirmed that all three planets have densities lower
than 0.1 g/cm$^{3}$. We measured the WFC3 transmission spectra to be
featureless between 1.15 and 1.63 $\mu$m, ruling out any variations greater
than 0.6 scale heights (assuming a H/He dominated atmosphere), thus showing no
significant water absorption features. We interpreted the flat spectra as the
result of a high-altitude aerosol layer (pressure $<$3 mbar) on each planet.
Adding this new result to the collection of flat spectra that have been
observed for other sub-Neptune planets, we find support for one of the two
hypotheses introduced by Crossfield and Kreidberg (2017), that planets with
cooler equilibrium temperatures have more high-altitude aerosols. We strongly
disfavor their other hypothesis that the H/He mass fraction drives the
appearance of large amplitude transmission features.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.04241 [pdf] - 1978537
Measuring the D/H Ratios of Exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs
Submitted: 2018-10-09, last modified: 2019-10-11
The relative abundance of deuterium and hydrogen is a potent tracer of planet
formation and evolution. Jupiter and Saturn have protosolar atmospheric D/H
ratios, a relic of substantial gas accretion from the nebula, while the
atmospheres of Neptune and Uranus are enhanced in D by accretion of ices into
their envelopes. For terrestrial planets, D/H ratios are used to determine the
mechanisms of volatile delivery and subsequent atmosphere loss over the
lifetime of the planet. Planets and brown dwarfs more massive than 13 M_J
quickly fuse their initial D reservoir. Here, we simulate spectra for giant
exoplanets and brown dwarfs (2 M_Neptune to ~10 M_Jupiter) from Teff=200--1800
K including both CH3D and HDO to determine the observability of these dominant
deuterium isotopologues in mid-infrared thermal emission spectra. Colder
objects have stronger molecular features in their spectra, due to the
temperature-dependence of molecular cross sections. CH3D is easier to observe
than HDO at all temperatures considered, due to the strength of its absorption
bands and locations of features at wavelengths with few other strong absorption
features. We predict that for nearby cool brown dwarfs, the CH3D abundance can
be measured at high signal-to-noise with the James Webb Space Telescope; for
objects from 200--800 K closer than 10 pc, a protosolar D/H ratio would be
readily observable in 2.5 hours. Moderately young Jupiter-mass planets
(100--300 Myr) and young Neptunes (10 Myr) may be discovered with JWST and
provide the best targets for detecting deuterium on an exoplanet in the coming
decade. Future telescope designs should consider the importance of isotopes for
understanding the formation and evolution of planetary atmospheres.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.00076 [pdf] - 2025910
The Precision of Mass Measurements Required for Robust Atmospheric
Characterization of Transiting Exoplanets
Submitted: 2019-09-30
Two of TESS's major science goals are to measure masses for 50 planets
smaller than 4 Earth radii and to discover high-quality targets for atmospheric
characterization efforts. It is important that these two goals are linked by
quantifying what precision of mass constraint is required to yield robust
atmospheric properties of planets. Here, we address this by conducting
retrievals on simulated JWST transmission spectra under various assumptions for
the degree of uncertainty in the planet's mass for a representative population
of seven planets ranging from terrestrials to warm Neptunes to hot Jupiters.
Only for the cloud-free, low metallicity gas giants are we able to infer
exoplanet mass from transmission spectroscopy alone, to ~10% accuracy. For low
metallicity cases (<4xSolar) we are able to accurately constrain atmospheric
properties without prior knowledge of the planet's mass. For all other cases
(including terrestrial-like planets), atmospheric properties can only be
inferred with a mass precision of better than ~50%. At this level, though, the
widths of the posterior distributions of the atmospheric properties are
dominated by the uncertainties in mass. With a precision of ~20%, the widths of
the posterior distributions are dominated by the spectroscopic data quality.
Therefore, as a rule-of-thumb, we recommend: a ~50% mass precision for initial
atmospheric characterization and a ~20% mass precision for more detailed
atmospheric analyses.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.04742 [pdf] - 1961603
Mass Loss from the Exoplanet WASP-12b Inferred from $\textit{Spitzer}$
Phase Curves
Bell, Taylor J.;
Zhang, Michael;
Cubillos, Patricio E.;
Dang, Lisa;
Fossati, Luca;
Todorov, Kamen O.;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Deming, Drake;
Zellem, Robert T.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Crossfield, Ian J. M.;
Dobbs-Dixon, Ian;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Line, Michael R.
Submitted: 2019-06-11, last modified: 2019-09-14
The exoplanet WASP-12b is the prototype for the emerging class of ultra-hot,
Jupiter-mass exoplanets. Past models have predicted---and near ultra-violet
observations have shown---that this planet is losing mass. We present an
analysis of two sets of 3.6 $\mu$m and 4.5 $\mu$m $\textit{Spitzer}$ phase
curve observations of the system which show clear evidence of infrared
radiation from gas stripped from the planet, and the gas appears to be flowing
directly toward or away from the host star. This accretion signature is only
seen at 4.5 $\mu$m, not at 3.6 $\mu$m, which is indicative either of CO
emission at the longer wavelength or blackbody emission from cool, $\lesssim$
600 K gas. It is unclear why WASP-12b is the only ultra-hot Jupiter to exhibit
this mass loss signature, but perhaps WASP-12b's orbit is decaying as some have
claimed, while the orbits of other exoplanets may be more stable;
alternatively, the high energy irradiation from WASP-12A may be stronger than
the other host stars. We also find evidence for phase offset variability at the
level of $6.4\sigma$ ($46.2^{\circ}$) at 3.6 $\mu$m.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.10904 [pdf] - 1975420
Exploring Exoplanet Cloud Assumptions in \textit{JWST} Transmission
Spectra
Submitted: 2019-08-28
Clouds are ubiquitous in extrasolar planet atmospheres and are critical to
our understanding of planetary climate and chemistry. They also represent one
of the greater challenges to overcome when trying to interpret transit
transmission spectra of exoplanet atmospheres as their presence can inhibit
precise constraints on atmospheric composition and thermal properties. In this
work we take a phenomenological approach towards understanding 1) our ability
to constrain bulk cloud properties, and 2) the impact of clouds on constraining
various atmospheric properties as obtained through transmission spectroscopy
with the \textit{James Webb Space Telescope (JWST)}. We do this by exploring
retrievals of atmospheric and cloud properties for a generic "hot-Jupiter" as a
function of signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), \textit{JWST} observing modes and four
different cloud parameterizations. We find that most key atmospheric and cloud
inferences can be well constrained in the wavelength range ($\lambda = $ 0.6 -
11 $\mu$m), with NIRCam ($\lambda =$ 2.5 - 5 $\mu$m) being critical in
inferring atmospheric properties and NIRISS + MIRI ($\lambda =$ 0.6 - 2.5, 5 -
11 $\mu$m) being necessary for good constraints on cloud parameters. However,
constraining the cloud abundance and therefore the total cloud mass requires an
observable cloud base in the transit geometry. While higher SNR observations
can place tighter constraints on major parameters such as temperature,
metallicity and cloud sedimentation, they are unable to eliminate strong
degeneracies among cloud parameters. Our investigation of a generic
"warm-Neptune" with photochemical haze parameterization also shows promising
results in constraining atmospheric and haze properties in the cooler
temperature regime.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.01316 [pdf] - 1931506
Atmospheric characterization of terrestrial exoplanets in the
mid-infrared: biosignatures, habitability & diversity
Quanz, Sascha P.;
Absil, Olivier;
Angerhausen, Daniel;
Benz, Willy;
Bonfils, Xavier;
Berger, Jean-Philippe;
Brogi, Matteo;
Cabrera, Juan;
Danchi, William C.;
Defrère, Denis;
van Dishoeck, Ewine;
Ehrenreich, David;
Ertel, Steve;
Fortney, Jonathan;
Gaudi, Scott;
Girard, Julien;
Glauser, Adrian;
Grenfell, John Lee;
Ireland, Michael;
Janson, Markus;
Kammerer, Jens;
Kitzmann, Daniel;
Kraus, Stefan;
Krause, Oliver;
Labadie, Lucas;
Lacour, Sylvestre;
Lichtenberg, Tim;
Line, Michael;
Linz, Hendrik;
Loicq, Jérôme;
Mennesson, Bertrand;
Meyer, Michael R.;
Miguel, Yamila;
Monnier, John;
N'Diaye, Mamadou;
Pallé, Enric;
Queloz, Didier;
Rauer, Heike;
Ribas, Ignasi;
Rugheimer, Sarah;
Selsis, Franck;
Serabyn, Gene;
Snellen, Ignas;
Sozzetti, Alessandro;
Stapelfeldt, Karl R.;
Triaud, Amaury;
Udry, Stéphane;
Wyatt, Mark
Submitted: 2019-08-04, last modified: 2019-08-07
Exoplanet science is one of the most thriving fields of modern astrophysics.
A major goal is the atmospheric characterization of dozens of small,
terrestrial exoplanets in order to search for signatures in their atmospheres
that indicate biological activity, assess their ability to provide conditions
for life as we know it, and investigate their expected atmospheric diversity.
None of the currently adopted projects or missions, from ground or in space,
can address these goals. In this White Paper we argue that a large space-based
mission designed to detect and investigate thermal emission spectra of
terrestrial exoplanets in the MIR wavelength range provides unique scientific
potential to address these goals and surpasses the capabilities of other
approaches. While NASA might be focusing on large missions that aim to detect
terrestrial planets in reflected light, ESA has the opportunity to take
leadership and spearhead the development of a large MIR exoplanet mission
within the scope of the "Voyage 2050" long-term plan establishing Europe at the
forefront of exoplanet science for decades to come. Given the ambitious science
goals of such a mission, additional international partners might be interested
in participating and contributing to a roadmap that, in the long run, leads to
a successful implementation. A new, dedicated development program funded by ESA
to help reduce development and implementation cost and further push some of the
required key technologies would be a first important step in this direction.
Ultimately, a large MIR exoplanet imaging mission will be needed to help answer
one of mankind's most fundamental questions: "How unique is our Earth?"
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.02820 [pdf] - 1953553
Constraining Exoplanet Metallicities and Aerosols with ARIEL: An
Independent Study by the Contribution to ARIEL Spectroscopy of Exoplanets
(CASE) Team
Zellem, Robert T.;
Swain, Mark R.;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Bryden, Geoffrey;
Komacek, Thaddeus D.;
Colavita, Mark;
Ardila, David;
Roudier, Gael M.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Bean, Jacob;
Line, Michael R.;
Griffith, Caitlin A.;
Shkolnik, Evgenya L.;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Showman, Adam P.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Wong, Andre;
Chapman, John W.;
Ciardi, David R.;
Howard, Andrew W.;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Kempton, Eliza M. -R.;
Latham, David;
Mahadevan, Suvrath;
Melendez, Jorge;
Parmentier, Vivien
Submitted: 2019-06-06
Launching in 2028, ESA's Atmospheric Remote-sensing Exoplanet Large-survey
(ARIEL) survey of $\sim$1000 transiting exoplanets will build on the legacies
of Kepler and TESS and complement JWST by placing its high precision exoplanet
observations into a large, statistically-significant planetary population
context. With continuous 0.5--7.8~$\mu$m coverage from both FGS (0.50--0.55,
0.8--1.0, and 1.0--1.2~$\mu$m photometry; 1.25--1.95~$\mu$m spectroscopy) and
AIRS (1.95--7.80~$\mu$m spectroscopy), ARIEL will determine atmospheric
compositions and probe planetary formation histories during its 3.5-year
mission. NASA's proposed Contribution to ARIEL Spectroscopy of Exoplanets
(CASE) would be a subsystem of ARIEL's FGS instrument consisting of two
visible-to-infrared detectors, associated readout electronics, and thermal
control hardware. FGS, to be built by the Polish Academy of Sciences' Space
Research Centre, will provide both fine guiding and visible to near-infrared
photometry and spectroscopy, providing powerful diagnostics of atmospheric
aerosol contribution and planetary albedo, which play a crucial role in
establishing planetary energy balance. The CASE team presents here an
independent study of the capabilities of ARIEL to measure exoplanetary
metallicities, which probe the conditions of planet formation, and FGS to
measure scattering spectral slopes, which indicate if an exoplanet has
atmospheric aerosols (clouds and hazes), and geometric albedos, which help
establish planetary climate. Our design reference mission simulations show that
ARIEL could measure the mass-metallicity relationship of its 1000-planet
single-visit sample to $>7.5\sigma$ and that FGS could distinguish between
clear, cloudy, and hazy skies and constrain an exoplanet's atmospheric aerosol
composition to $>5\sigma$ for hundreds of targets, providing
statistically-transformative science for exoplanet atmospheres.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.07064 [pdf] - 1884966
The Need for Laboratory Measurements and Ab Initio Studies to Aid
Understanding of Exoplanetary Atmospheres
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Robinson, Tyler D.;
Domagal-Goldman, Shawn;
Del Genio, Anthony D.;
Gordon, Iouli E.;
Gharib-Nezhad, Ehsan;
Lewis, Nikole;
Sousa-Silva, Clara;
Airapetian, Vladimir;
Drouin, Brian;
Hargreaves, Robert J.;
Huang, Xinchuan;
Karman, Tijs;
Ramirez, Ramses M.;
Rieker, Gregory B.;
Tennyson, Jonathan;
Wordsworth, Robin;
Yurchenko, Sergei N;
Johnson, Alexandria V;
Lee, Timothy J.;
Dong, Chuanfei;
Kane, Stephen;
Lopez-Morales, Mercedes;
Fauchez, Thomas;
Lee, Timothy;
Marley, Mark S.;
Sung, Keeyoon;
Haghighipour, Nader;
Robinson, Tyler;
Horst, Sarah;
Gao, Peter;
Kao, Der-you;
Dressing, Courtney;
Lupu, Roxana;
Savin, Daniel Wolf;
Fleury, Benjamin;
Venot, Olivia;
Ascenzi, Daniela;
Milam, Stefanie;
Linnartz, Harold;
Gudipati, Murthy;
Gronoff, Guillaume;
Salama, Farid;
Gavilan, Lisseth;
Bouwman, Jordy;
Turbet, Martin;
Benilan, Yves;
Henderson, Bryana;
Batalha, Natalie;
Jensen-Clem, Rebecca;
Lyons, Timothy;
Freedman, Richard;
Schwieterman, Edward;
Goyal, Jayesh;
Mancini, Luigi;
Irwin, Patrick;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Molaverdikhani, Karan;
Gizis, John;
Taylor, Jake;
Lothringer, Joshua;
Pierrehumbert, Raymond;
Zellem, Robert;
Batalha, Natasha;
Rugheimer, Sarah;
Lustig-Yaeger, Jacob;
Hu, Renyu;
Kempton, Eliza;
Arney, Giada;
Line, Mike;
Alam, Munazza;
Moses, Julianne;
Iro, Nicolas;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Blecic, Jasmina;
Louden, Tom;
Molliere, Paul;
Stevenson, Kevin;
Swain, Mark;
Bott, Kimberly;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Krissansen-Totton, Joshua;
Deming, Drake;
Kitiashvili, Irina;
Shkolnik, Evgenya;
Rustamkulov, Zafar;
Rogers, Leslie;
Close, Laird
Submitted: 2019-05-16
We are now on a clear trajectory for improvements in exoplanet observations
that will revolutionize our ability to characterize their atmospheric
structure, composition, and circulation, from gas giants to rocky planets.
However, exoplanet atmospheric models capable of interpreting the upcoming
observations are often limited by insufficiencies in the laboratory and
theoretical data that serve as critical inputs to atmospheric physical and
chemical tools. Here we provide an up-to-date and condensed description of
areas where laboratory and/or ab initio investigations could fill critical gaps
in our ability to model exoplanet atmospheric opacities, clouds, and chemistry,
building off a larger 2016 white paper, and endorsed by the NAS Exoplanet
Science Strategy report. Now is the ideal time for progress in these areas, but
this progress requires better access to, understanding of, and training in the
production of spectroscopic data as well as a better insight into chemical
reaction kinetics both thermal and radiation-induced at a broad range of
temperatures. Given that most published efforts have emphasized relatively
Earth-like conditions, we can expect significant and enlightening discoveries
as emphasis moves to the exotic atmospheres of exoplanets.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.02069 [pdf] - 1890421
Climate of an Ultra hot Jupiter: Spectroscopic phase curve of WASP-18b
with HST/WFC3
Submitted: 2019-04-03
We present the analysis of a full-orbit, spectroscopic phase curve of the
ultra hot Jupiter WASP-18b, obtained with the Wide Field Camera 3 aboard the
Hubble Space Telescope. We measure the planet's normalized day-night contrast
as >0.96 in luminosity: the disk-integrated dayside emission from the planet is
at 964+-25 ppm, corresponding to 2894+-30 K, and we place an upper limit on the
nightside emission of <32ppm or 1430K at the 3-sigma level. We also find that
the peak of the phase curve exhibits a small, but significant offset in
brightness of 4.5+-0.5 degrees eastward.
We compare the extracted phase curve and phase resolved spectra to 3D Global
Circulation Models and find that broadly the data can be well reproduced by
some of these models. We find from this comparison several constraints on the
atmospheric properties of the planet. Firstly we find that we need efficient
drag to explain the very inefficient day-night re-circulation observed. We
demonstrate that this drag could be due to Lorentz-force drag by a magnetic
field as weak as 10 Gauss. Secondly, we show that a high metallicity is not
required to match the large day-night temperature contrast. In fact, the effect
of metallicity on the phase curve is different from cooler gas-giant
counterparts, due to the high-temperature chemistry in WASP-18b's atmosphere.
Additionally, we compare the current UHJ spectroscopic phase curves, WASP-18b
and WASP-103b, and show that these two planets provide a consistent picture
with remarkable similarities in their measured and inferred properties.
However, key differences in these properties, such as their brightness offsets
and radius anomalies, suggest that UHJ could be used to separate between
competing theories for the inflation of gas-giant planets.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.11658 [pdf] - 1890411
A Uniform Retrieval Analysis of Ultracool Dwarfs. III. Properties of
Y-Dwarfs
Submitted: 2019-03-27
Ultra-cool brown dwarfs offer a unique window into understanding substellar
atmospheric physics and chemistry. Their strong molecular absorption bands at
infrared wavelengths, Jupiter-like radii, cool temperatures, and lack of
complicating stellar irradiation, make them ideal test-beds for understanding
Jovian-like atmospheres. Here we report the findings of a uniform atmospheric
retrieval analysis on a set of 14 Y and T-dwarfs observed with the Hubble Space
Telescope Wide Field Camera 3 instrument. From our retrieval analysis, we find
the temperature-structures to be largely consistent with radiative-convective
equilibrium in most objects. We also determine the abundances of water,
methane, and ammonia and upper limits on the alkali metals sodium and
potassium. The constraints on water and methane are consistent with predictions
from chemical equilibrium models, while those of ammonia may be affected by
vertical disequilibrium mixing, consistent with previous works. Our key result
stems from the constraints on the alkali metal abundances where we find their
continued depletion with decreasing effective temperature, consistent with the
trend identified in a previous retrieval analysis on a sample of slightly
warmer late T-dwarfs in Line et al. (2017). These constraints show that the
previously observed Y-J color trend across the T/Y transition is most likely
due to the depletion of these metals in accordance with predictions from
equilibrium condensate rainout chemistry. Finally, we simulate future James
Webb Space Telescope observations of ultra-cool dwarfs and find that the
NIRSpec PRISM offers the best chance at developing high-precision constraints
on fundamental atmospheric characteristics.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.09173 [pdf] - 1854194
Characterizing the Atmospheres of Irradiated Exoplanets at High Spectral
Resolution
Submitted: 2019-03-21
The best-characterized exoplanets to date are planets on close-in transiting
orbits around their host stars. The high level of irradiation and transiting
geometry of these objects make them ideal targets for atmospheric
investigations. However, the modest apertures of many current telescopes allow
mostly low resolution spectra to be observed for transiting planets, failing to
extract key physical and chemical properties of their atmospheres. Ground-based
30-meter class telescopes will set the stage for a substantial leap in our
understanding of exoplanet atmospheres. We outline a two-pronged survey,
recently submitted as a Key Science Project (KSP) for the US ELTs, which would
yield unprecedented insight into the atmospheres of close-in exoplanets via
combined observations with the GMT and TMT. (1) The first opportunity involves
measuring the global-scale atmospheric circulation and planetary rotation for a
sample of 40 hot Jupiters to glean insight into the unique radiative forcing
regime governing highly-irradiated, tidally-locked giant planets. (2) The
second opportunity involves measuring atmospheric mass-loss and extracting
atmospheric composition and abundance ratio information for $\sim60$
sub-Neptunes and super-Earths (including candidate disintegrating planets) to
constrain their formation and evolution histories. These efforts would be made
possible by the unparalleled combination of high spectral resolution
instrumentation and large aperture size of the ELTs. This survey would enable
the first statistical study of atmospheric circulation in extrasolar giant
planets, and would provide detections of trace gases and measurements of
atmospheric escape in small-planet atmospheres, far exceeding the reach of
\textit{JWST}.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.06020 [pdf] - 1871429
TESS full orbital phase curve of the WASP-18b system
Shporer, Avi;
Wong, Ian;
Huang, Chelsea X.;
Line, Michael R.;
Stassun, Keivan G.;
Fetherolf, Tara;
Kane, Stephen R.;
Bouma, Luke G.;
Daylan, Tansu;
Guenther, Maximilian N.;
Ricker, George R.;
Latham, David W.;
Vanderspek, Roland;
Seager, Sara;
Winn, Joshua N.;
Jenkins, Jon M.;
Glidden, Ana;
Berta-Thompson, Zach;
Ting, Eric B.;
Li, Jie;
Haworth, Kari
Submitted: 2018-11-14, last modified: 2019-03-14
We present a visible-light full orbital phase curve of the transiting planet
WASP-18b measured by the TESS Mission. The phase curve includes the transit,
secondary eclipse, and sinusoidal modulations across the orbital phase shaped
by the planet's atmospheric characteristics and the star-planet gravitational
interaction. We measure the beaming (Doppler boosting) and tidal ellipsoidal
distortion phase modulations and show that the amplitudes of both agree with
theoretical expectations. We find that the light from the planet's day-side
hemisphere occulted during secondary eclipse, with a relative brightness of
$341_{-18}^{+17}$ ppm, is dominated by thermal emission, leading to an upper
limit on the geometric albedo in the TESS band of 0.048 (2$\sigma$). We also
detect the phase modulation due to the planet's atmosphere longitudinal
brightness distribution. We find that its maximum is well-aligned with the
sub-stellar point, to within 2.9 deg (2$\sigma$). We do not detect light from
the planet's night-side hemisphere, with an upper limit of 43 ppm (2$\sigma$),
which is 13 % of the day-side brightness. The low albedo, lack of atmospheric
phase shift, and inefficient heat distribution from the day to night
hemispheres that we deduce from our analysis are consistent with theoretical
expectations and similar findings for other strongly irradiated gas giant
planets. This work demonstrates the potential of TESS data for studying full
orbital phase curves of transiting systems. Finally, we complement our study by
looking for transit timing variations (TTVs) in the TESS data and combined with
previously published transit times, although we do not find a statistically
significant TTV signal.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.02548 [pdf] - 1830457
The Influence of H2O Pressure Broadening in High Metallicity Exoplanet
Atmospheres
Submitted: 2018-09-07, last modified: 2019-02-09
Planet formation models suggest broad compositional diversity in the
sub-Neptune/super-Earth regime, with a high likelihood for large atmospheric
metal content (> 100 x Solar). With this comes the prevalence of numerous
plausible bulk atmospheric constituents including N2, CO2, H2O, CO, and CH4.
Given this compositional diversity there is a critical need to investigate the
influence of the background gas on the broadening of the molecular absorption
cross-sections and the subsequent influence on observed spectra. This
broadening can become significant and the common H2/He or "air" broadening
assumptions are no longer appropriate. In this work we investigate the role of
water self-broadening on the emission and transmission spectra as well as on
the vertical energy balance in representative sub-Neptune/super-Earth
atmospheres. We find that the choice of the broadener species can result in a
10 -- 100 parts-per-million difference in the observed transmission and
emission spectra and can significantly alter the 1-dimensional vertical
temperature structure of the atmosphere. Choosing the correct background
broadener is critical to the proper modeling and interpretation of transit
spectra observations in high metallicity regimes, especially in the era of
higher precision telescopes such as JWST.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.01681 [pdf] - 1834103
Retrieving Temperatures and Abundances of Exoplanet Atmospheres with
High-Resolution Cross-Correlation Spectroscopy
Submitted: 2018-11-05, last modified: 2019-02-09
Hi-resolution spectroscopy (R > 25,000) has recently emerged as one of the
leading methods to detect atomic and molecular species in the atmospheres of
exoplanets. However, it has so far been lacking in a robust method to extract
quantitative constraints on temperature structure and molecular/atomic
abundances. In this work we present a novel Bayesian atmospheric retrieval
framework applicable to high resolution cross-correlation spectroscopy (HRCCS)
that relies upon the cross-correlation between data and models to extract the
planetary spectral signal. We successfully test the framework on simulated data
and show that it can correctly determine Bayesian credibility intervals on
atmospheric temperatures and abundances allowing for a quantitative exploration
of the inherent degeneracies. Furthermore, our new framework permits us to
trivially combine and explore the synergies between HRCCS and low-resolution
spectroscopy (LRS) to provide maximal leverage on the information contained
within each. This framework also allows us to quantitatively assess the impact
of molecular line opacities at high resolution. We apply the framework to VLT
CRIRES K-band spectra of HD 209458 b and HD 189733 b and retrieve abundant
carbon monoxide but sub-solar abundances for water, largely invariant under
different model assumptions. This confirms previous analysis of these datasets,
but is possibly at odds with detections of water at different wavelengths and
spectral resolutions. The framework presented here is the first step towards a
true synergy between space observatories and ground-based hi-resolution
observations.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.02214 [pdf] - 1793636
Detection of Helium in the Atmosphere of the Exo-Neptune HAT-P-11b
Mansfield, Megan;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Oklopčić, Antonija;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Désert, Jean-Michel;
Kempton, Eliza M. -R.;
Line, Michael R.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Henry, Gregory W.;
Mallonn, Matthias;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Dragomir, Diana;
Allart, Romain;
Bourrier, Vincent
Submitted: 2018-12-05
The helium absorption triplet at a wavelength of 10,833 \AA\ has been
proposed as a way to probe the escaping atmospheres of exoplanets. Recently
this feature was detected for the first time using Hubble Space Telescope (HST)
WFC3 observations of the hot Jupiter WASP-107b. We use similar HST/WFC3
observations to detect helium in the atmosphere of the hot Neptune HAT-P-11b at
the $4\sigma$ confidence level. We compare our observations to a grid of 1D
models of hydrodynamic escape to constrain the thermospheric temperatures and
mass loss rate. We find that our data are best fit by models with high mass
loss rates of $\dot{M} \approx 10^{9}$ - $10^{11}$ g s$^{-1}$. Although we do
not detect the planetary wind directly, our data are consistent with the
prediction that HAT-P-11b is experiencing hydrodynamic atmospheric escape.
Nevertheless, the mass loss rate is low enough that the planet has only lost up
to a few percent of its mass over its history, leaving its bulk composition
largely unaffected. This matches the expectation from population statistics,
which indicate that close-in planets with radii greater than 2 R$_{\oplus}$
form and retain H/He-dominated atmospheres. We also confirm the independent
detection of helium in HAT-P-11b obtained with the CARMENES instrument, making
this the first exoplanet with the detection of the same signature of
photoevaporation from both ground- and space-based facilities.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.05615 [pdf] - 1751097
Ground- and Space-based Detection of the Thermal Emission Spectrum of
the Transiting Hot Jupiter KELT-2Ab
Piskorz, Danielle;
Buzard, Cam;
Line, Michael R.;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Benneke, Björn;
Crockett, Nathan R.;
Lockwood, Alexandra C.;
Blake, Geoffrey A.;
Barman, Travis S.;
Bender, Chad F.;
Deming, Drake;
Johnson, John A.
Submitted: 2018-09-14
We describe the detection of water vapor in the atmosphere of the transiting
hot Jupiter KELT-2Ab by treating the star-planet system as a spectroscopic
binary with high-resolution, ground-based spectroscopy. We resolve the signal
of the planet's motion with deep combined flux observations of the star and the
planet. In total, six epochs of Keck NIRSPEC $L$-band observations were
obtained, and the full data set was subjected to a cross correlation analysis
with a grid of self-consistent atmospheric models. We measure a radial
projection of the Keplerian velocity, $K_P$, of 148 $\pm$ 7 km s$^{-1}$,
consistent with transit measurements, and detect water vapor at 3.8$\sigma$. We
combine NIRSPEC $L$-band data with $Spitzer$ IRAC secondary eclipse data to
further probe the metallicity and carbon-to-oxygen ratio of KELT-2Ab's
atmosphere. While the NIRSPEC analysis provides few extra constraints on the
$Spitzer$ data, it does provide roughly the same constraints on metallicity and
carbon-to-oxygen ratio. This bodes well for future investigations of the
atmospheres of non-transiting hot Jupiters.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.04985 [pdf] - 1767381
The Transiting Exoplanet Community Early Release Science Program for
JWST
Bean, Jacob L.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Batalha, Natalie M.;
Berta-Thompson, Zachory;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Crouzet, Nicolas;
Benneke, Björn;
Line, Michael R.;
Sing, David K.;
Wakeford, Hannah R.;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Kempton, Eliza M. -R.;
Désert, Jean-Michel;
Crossfield, Ian;
Batalha, Natasha E.;
de Wit, Julien;
Parmentier, Vivien;
Harrington, Joseph;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Lopez-Morales, Mercedes;
Alam, Munazza K.;
Blecic, Jasmina;
Bruno, Giovanni;
Carter, Aarynn L.;
Chapman, John W.;
Decin, Leen;
Dragomir, Diana;
Evans, Thomas M.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Fraine, Jonathan D.;
Gao, Peter;
Muñoz, Antonio García;
Gibson, Neale P.;
Goyal, Jayesh M.;
Heng, Kevin;
Hu, Renyu;
Kendrew, Sarah;
Kilpatrick, Brian M.;
Krick, Jessica;
Lagage, Pierre-Olivier;
Lendl, Monika;
Louden, Tom;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Mandell, Avi M.;
Mansfield, Megan;
May, Erin M.;
Morello, Giuseppe;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Nikolov, Nikolay;
Redfield, Seth;
Roberts, Jessica E.;
Schlawin, Everett;
Spake, Jessica J.;
Todorov, Kamen O.;
Tsiaras, Angelos;
Venot, Olivia;
Waalkes, William C.;
Wheatley, Peter J.;
Zellem, Robert T.;
Angerhausen, Daniel;
Barrado, David;
Carone, Ludmila;
Casewell, Sarah L.;
Cubillos, Patricio E.;
Damiano, Mario;
de Val-Borro, Miguel;
Drummond, Benjamin;
Edwards, Billy;
Endl, Michael;
Espinoza, Nestor;
France, Kevin;
Gizis, John E.;
Greene, Thomas P.;
Henning, Thomas K.;
Hong, Yucian;
Ingalls, James G.;
Iro, Nicolas;
Irwin, Patrick G. J.;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Lahuis, Fred;
Leconte, Jérémy;
Lillo-Box, Jorge;
Lines, Stefan;
Lothringer, Joshua D.;
Mancini, Luigi;
Marchis, Franck;
Mayne, Nathan;
Palle, Enric;
Rauscher, Emily;
Roudier, Gaël;
Shkolnik, Evgenya L.;
Southworth, John;
Swain, Mark R.;
Taylor, Jake;
Teske, Johanna;
Tinetti, Giovanna;
Tremblin, Pascal;
Tucker, Gregory S.;
van Boekel, Roy;
Waldmann, Ingo P.;
Weaver, Ian C.;
Zingales, Tiziano
Submitted: 2018-03-13, last modified: 2018-09-03
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) presents the opportunity to transform
our understanding of planets and the origins of life by revealing the
atmospheric compositions, structures, and dynamics of transiting exoplanets in
unprecedented detail. However, the high-precision, time-series observations
required for such investigations have unique technical challenges, and prior
experience with other facilities indicates that there will be a steep learning
curve when JWST becomes operational. In this paper we describe the science
objectives and detailed plans of the Transiting Exoplanet Community Early
Release Science (ERS) Program, which is a recently approved program for JWST
observations early in Cycle 1. The goal of this project, for which the obtained
data will have no exclusive access period, is to accelerate the acquisition and
diffusion of technical expertise for transiting exoplanet observations with
JWST, while also providing a compelling set of representative datasets that
will enable immediate scientific breakthroughs. The Transiting Exoplanet
Community ERS Program will exercise the time-series modes of all four JWST
instruments that have been identified as the consensus highest priorities,
observe the full suite of transiting planet characterization geometries
(transits, eclipses, and phase curves), and target planets with host stars that
span an illustrative range of brightnesses. The observations in this program
were defined through an inclusive and transparent process that had
participation from JWST instrument experts and international leaders in
transiting exoplanet studies. Community engagement in the project will be
centered on a two-phase Data Challenge that culminates with the delivery of
planetary spectra, time-series instrument performance reports, and open-source
data analysis toolkits in time to inform the agenda for Cycle 2 of the JWST
mission.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.07421 [pdf] - 1741983
Community targets for JWST's early release science program: evaluation
of WASP-63b
Kilpatrick, Brian M.;
Cubillos, Patricio E.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Lewis, Nikole K.;
Wakeford, Hannah;
Macdonald, Ryan J.;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Blecic, Jasmina;
Bruno, Giovanni;
Burrows, Adam;
Deming, Drake;
Heng, Kevin;
Line, Michael R.;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Parmentier, Vivien;
Tucker, Gregory S.;
Valenti, Jeff A.;
Waldmann, Ingo P.;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Beichman, Charles;
Fraine, Jonathan;
Krick, J. E.;
Lothringer, Joshua D.;
Mandell, Avi M.
Submitted: 2017-04-24, last modified: 2018-08-30
We present observations of WASP-63b by the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) as
part of "A Preparatory Program to Identify the Single Best Transiting Exoplanet
for JWST Early Release Science". WASP-63b is one of the community targets under
consideration for the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) Early Release Science
(ERS) program. We present a spectrum derived from a single observation by HST
Wide Field Camera 3 in the near infrared. We engaged groups across the
transiting exoplanet community to participate in the analysis of the data and
present results from each. There is general agreement amongst all results that
we find an H2O absorption feature with 3.5-4.0 sigma significance. However, the
feature is muted in comparison to a clear atmosphere at solar composition.
Although the detection of the water feature is robust, the reasons for the
muting of this feature are ambiguous due to a degeneracy between clouds and
composition. The data does not yield robust detections of any molecular species
other than H2O. The group was motivated to perform an additional set of
retrieval exercises to investigate an apparent bump in the spectrum at ~ 1.55
um. We explore possible disequilibrium chemistry and find this feature is
consistent with super-solar HCN abundance but it is questionable if the
required mixing ratio of HCN is chemically and physically plausible. The
ultimate goal of this study is to vet WASP-63b as a potential community target
to best demonstrate the capabilities and systematics of JWST instruments for
transiting exoplanet science. In the case of WASP-63b, the presence of a
detectable water feature indicates that WASP-63b remains a plausible target for
ERS observations.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.00096 [pdf] - 1755905
From thermal dissociation to condensation in the atmospheres of ultra
hot Jupiters: WASP-121b in context
Parmentier, Vivien;
Line, Mike R.;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Mansfield, Megan;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Lupu, Roxana;
Visscher, Channon;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Deleuil, Magalie;
Arcangeli, Jacob;
Showman, Adam P.;
Marley, Mark S.
Submitted: 2018-04-30, last modified: 2018-08-06
A new class of exoplanets has emerged: the ultra hot Jupiters, the hottest
close-in gas giants. Most of them have weaker than expected spectral features
in the $1.1-1.7\mu m$ bandpass probed by HST/WFC3 but stronger spectral
features at longer wavelengths probed by Spitzer. This led previous authors to
puzzling conclusions about the thermal structures and chemical abundances of
these planets. Using the SPARC/MITgcm, we investigate how thermal dissociation,
ionization, H$^-$ opacity and clouds shape the thermal structures and spectral
properties of ultra hot Jupiters with a special focus on WASP-121b. We expand
our findings to the whole population of ultra hot Jupiters through analytical
quantification of the thermal dissociation and its influence on the strength of
spectral features.
We predict that most molecules are thermally dissociated and alkalies are
ionized in the dayside photospheres of ultra hot Jupiters. This includes
H$_{\rm 2}$O, TiO, VO, and H$_{\rm 2}$ but not CO, which has a stronger
molecular bond. The vertical molecular gradient created by the dissociation
significantly weakens the spectral features from water while the $4.5\mu m$ CO
feature remain unchanged. The water band in the HST/WFC3 bandpass is further
weakened by H$^-$ continuum opacity. Molecules are expected to recombine before
reaching the limb, leading to order of magnitude variations of the chemical
composition and cloud coverage between the limb and the dayside. Overall,
molecular dissociation provides a qualitative understanding of the lack of
strong spectral feature of water in the $1-2\mu m$ bandpass observed in most
ultra hot Jupiters. Quantitatively, however, our model does not provide a
satisfactory match to the WASP-121b emission spectrum. Together with WASP-33b
and Kepler-33Ab, they seem the outliers among the population of ultra hot
Jupiters in need of a more thorough understanding.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.00657 [pdf] - 1767495
The GJ 504 system revisited. Combining interferometric, radial velocity,
and high contrast imaging data
Bonnefoy, M.;
Perraut, K.;
Lagrange, A. -M.;
Delorme, P.;
Vigan, A.;
Line, M.;
Rodet, L.;
Ginski, C.;
Mourard, D.;
Marleau, G. -D.;
Samland, M.;
Tremblin, P.;
Ligi, R.;
Cantalloube, F.;
Mollière, P.;
Charnay, B.;
Kuzuhara, M.;
Janson, M.;
Morley, C.;
Homeier, D. D.;
Orazi, V. D;
Klahr, H.;
Mordasini, C.;
Lavie, B.;
Baudino, J. -L.;
Beust, H.;
Peretti, S.;
Bartucci, A. Musso;
Mesa, D.;
Bézard, B.;
Boccaletti, A.;
Galicher, R.;
Hagelberg, J.;
Desidera, S.;
Biller, B.;
Maire, A. -L.;
Allard, F.;
Borgniet, S.;
Lannier, J.;
Meunier, N.;
Desort, M.;
Alecian, E.;
Chauvin, G.;
Langlois, M.;
Henning, T.;
Mugnier, L.;
Mouillet, D.;
Gratton, R.;
Brandt, T.;
Elwain, M. Mc;
Beuzit, J. -L.;
Tamura, M.;
Hori, Y.;
Brandner, W.;
Buenzli, E.;
Cheetham, A;
Cudel, M.;
Feldt, M.;
Kasper, M.;
Keppler, M.;
Kopytova, T.;
Meyer, M.;
Perrot, C.;
Rouan, D.;
Salter, G;
Schmidt, T.;
Sissa, E.;
Zurlo, A.;
Wildi, F.;
Blanchard, P.;
De Caprio, V.;
Delboulbé, A.;
Maurel, D.;
Moulin, T.;
Pavlov, A.;
Rabou, P.;
Ramos, J.;
Roelfsema, R.;
Rousset, G.;
Stadler, E.;
Rigal, F.;
Weber, L.
Submitted: 2018-07-02, last modified: 2018-07-10
The G-type star GJ504A is known to host a 3 to 35 MJup companion whose
temperature, mass, and projected separation all contribute to make it a test
case for the planet formation theories and for atmospheric models of giant
planets and light brown dwarfs. We collected data from the CHARA
interferometer, SOPHIE spectrograph, and VLT/SPHERE high contrast imager to
revisit the properties of the system. We measure a radius of 1.35+/- 0.04Rsun
for GJ504A which yields isochronal ages of 21+/-2Myr or 4.0+/-1.8Gyr for the
system and line-of-sight stellar rotation axis inclination of
$162.4_{-4.3}^{+3.8}$ degrees or $18.6_{-3.8}^{+4.3}$ degrees. We re-detect the
companion in the Y2, Y3, J3, H2, and K1 dual band SPHERE images. The complete
1-4 $\mu$m SED shape of GJ504b is best reproduced by T8-T9.5 objects with
intermediate ages ($\leq1.5$Gyr), and/or unusual dusty atmospheres and/or
super-solar metallicities. All six atmospheric models used yield
$\mathrm{T_{eff}=550 \pm 50}$K for GJ504b and point toward a low surface
gravity (3.5-4.0 dex). The accuracy on the metallicity value is limited by
model-to-model systematics. It is not degenerate with the C/O ratio. We derive
$\mathrm{log\:L/L_{\odot}=-6.15\pm0.15}$ dex for the companion compatible with
masses of $\mathrm{M=1.3^{+0.6}_{-0.3}M_{Jup}}$ and $\mathrm{M=23^{+10}_{-9}
M_{Jup}}$ for the young and old age ranges, respectively. The semi-major axis
(sma) is above 27.8 au and the eccentricity lower than 0.55. The posterior on
GJ~504b's orbital inclination suggests a misalignment with GJ~504A rotation
axis. We combine the radial velocity and multi-epoch imaging data to exclude
additional objects (90\% prob.) more massive than 2.5 and 30 $\mathrm{M_{Jup}}$
with sma in the range 0.01-80 au for the young and old system ages,
respectively. The companion is in the envelope of the population of planets
synthetized with our core-accretion model.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.00029 [pdf] - 1709444
Global Climate and Atmospheric Composition of the Ultra-Hot Jupiter
WASP-103b from HST and Spitzer Phase Curve Observations
Kreidberg, Laura;
Line, Michael R.;
Parmentier, Vivien;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Louden, Tom;
Bonnefoy, Mickäel;
Faherty, Jacqueline K.;
Henry, Gregory W.;
Williamson, Michael H.;
Stassun, Keivan;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Showman, Adam P.;
Désert, Jean-Michel;
Arcangeli, Jacob
Submitted: 2018-04-30, last modified: 2018-06-06
We present thermal phase curve measurements for the hot Jupiter WASP-103b
observed with Hubble/WFC3 and Spitzer/IRAC. The phase curves have large
amplitudes and negligible hotspot offsets, indicative of poor heat
redistribution to the nightside. We fit the phase variation with a range of
climate maps and find that a spherical harmonics model generally provides the
best fit. The phase-resolved spectra are consistent with blackbodies in the
WFC3 bandpass, with brightness temperatures ranging from $1880\pm40$ K on the
nightside to $2930 \pm 40$ K on the dayside. The dayside spectrum has a
significantly higher brightness temperature in the Spitzer bands, likely due to
CO emission and a thermal inversion. The inversion is not present on the
nightside. We retrieved the atmospheric composition and found the composition
is moderately metal-enriched ($\mathrm{[M/H]} = 23^{+29}_{-13}\times$ solar)
and the carbon-to-oxygen ratio is below 0.9 at $3\,\sigma$ confidence. In
contrast to cooler hot Jupiters, we do not detect spectral features from water,
which we attribute to partial H$_2$O dissociation. We compare the phase curves
to 3D general circulation models and find magnetic drag effects are needed to
match the data. We also compare the WASP-103b spectra to brown dwarfs and young
directly imaged companions and find these objects have significantly larger
water features, indicating that surface gravity and irradiation environment
play an important role in shaping the spectra of hot Jupiters. These results
highlight the 3D structure of exoplanet atmospheres and illustrate the
importance of phase curve observations for understanding their complex
chemistry and physics.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.08173 [pdf] - 1717052
Clear and Cloudy Exoplanet Forecasts for JWST: Maps, Retrieved
Composition and Constraints on Formation with MIRI and NIRCam
Submitted: 2018-03-21, last modified: 2018-05-21
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) will measure exoplanet transmission and
eclipse spectroscopy at un-precedented precisions to better understand planet
structure, dynamics, chemistry and formation. These are essential tools on the
march towards biosignature searches on potentially habitable planets. We
explore a range of exoplanet atmospheric conditions and forecast the expected
results with JWST. We take realistic CHIMERA models that match existing Spitzer
and HST results and simulate the spectra achievable with the JWST MIRI + NIRCam
Guaranteed Time Observations (GTO) survey. We then retrieve atmospheric
parameters from these spectra to estimate the precision to which the planets'
atmospheric compositions can be measured. We find that emission spectra have
well-constrained unimodal solutions but transmission spectra near 10X solar
abundance and solar C/O ratios can suffer from bimodal solutions. Broad
wavelength coverage as well as higher precision data can resolve bimodal
solutions and provide dramatically better atmospheric parameter constraints. We
find that metallicities can be measured to within 20% to 170%, which approaches
the precisions on Solar System planets, and C/O ratios can be constrained to
~10% to 60%, assuming that observers can leverage short wavelength data to
select the correct solution from the bimodal posteriors. These compositional
precisions are sufficient to validate or refute predictions from disk formation
models on final atmospheric abundances as long as their history is not erased
by planet evolution processes. We also show the extent to which eclipse mapping
with JWST is possible on our brightest system HD 189733 b.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.00424 [pdf] - 1705290
A HST/WFC3 Thermal Emission Spectrum of the Hot Jupiter HAT-P-7b
Mansfield, Megan;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Line, Michael R.;
Parmentier, Vivien;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Arcangeli, Jacob;
Dragomir, Diana
Submitted: 2018-05-01
Secondary eclipse observations of several of the hottest hot Jupiters show
featureless, blackbody-like spectra or molecular emission features, which are
consistent with thermal inversions being present in those atmospheres. Theory
predicts a transition between warmer atmospheres with thermal inversions and
cooler atmospheres without inversions, but the exact transition point is
unknown. In order to further investigate this issue, we observed two secondary
eclipses of the hot Jupiter HAT-P-7b with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) WFC3
instrument and combined these data with previous Spitzer and Kepler secondary
eclipse observations. The HST and Spitzer data can be well fit by a blackbody
with $T=2692 \pm 14$ K, and the Kepler data point constrains the geometric
albedo to $A_{g}=0.077 \pm 0.006$. We modeled these data with a 3D GCM and 1D
self-consistent forward models. The 1D models indicate that the atmosphere has
a thermal inversion, weak heat redistribution, and water dissociation that
limits the range of pressures probed. This result suggests that WFC3
observations of HAT-P-7b and possibly some other ultra-hot Jupiters appear
blackbody-like because they probe a region near the tropopause where the
atmospheric temperature changes slowly with pressure. Additionally, the 1D
models constrain the atmospheric metallicity
($[\text{M/H}]=-0.87^{+0.38}_{-0.34}$) and the carbon-to-oxygen ratio (C/O $<1$
at 99 % confidence). The solar composition 3D GCM matches the Spitzer data but
generally underpredicts the flux in the WFC3 bandpass and cannot reproduce its
featureless shape. This discrepancy could be explained by high atmospheric drag
or nightside clouds, and may be better understood through further observation
with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST).
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.08635 [pdf] - 1682469
Water, High-Altitude Condensates, and Possible Methane Depletion in the
Atmosphere of the Warm Super-Neptune WASP-107b
Submitted: 2017-09-25, last modified: 2018-04-30
The super-Neptune exoplanet WASP-107b is an exciting target for atmosphere
characterization. It has an unusually large atmospheric scale height and a
small, bright host star, raising the possibility of precise constraints on its
current nature and formation history. We report the first atmospheric study of
WASP-107b, a Hubble Space Telescope measurement of its near-infrared
transmission spectrum. We determined the planet's composition with two
techniques: atmospheric retrieval based on the transmission spectrum and
interior structure modeling based on the observed mass and radius. The interior
structure models set a $3\,\sigma$ upper limit on the atmospheric metallicity
of $30\times$ solar. The transmission spectrum shows strong evidence for water
absorption ($6.5\,\sigma$ confidence), and the retrieved water abundance is
consistent with expectations for a solar abundance pattern. The inferred
carbon-to-oxygen ratio is subsolar at $2.7\,\sigma$ confidence, which we
attribute to possible methane depletion in the atmosphere. The spectral
features are smaller than predicted for a cloud-free composition, crossing less
than one scale height. A thick condensate layer at high altitudes (0.1 - 3
mbar) is needed to match the observations. We find that physically motivated
cloud models with moderate sedimentation efficiency ($f_\mathrm{sed} = 0.3$) or
hazes with a particle size of 0.3 $\mu$m reproduce the observed spectral
feature amplitude. Taken together, these findings serve as an illustration of
the diversity and complexity of exoplanet atmospheres. The community can look
forward to more such results with the high precision and wide spectral coverage
afforded by future observing facilities.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.02489 [pdf] - 1672003
H- Opacity and Water Dissociation in the Dayside Atmosphere of the Very
Hot Gas Giant WASP-18 b
Arcangeli, Jacob;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Line, Michael R.;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Parmentier, Vivien;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Mansfield, Megan;
Showman, Adam P.
Submitted: 2018-01-08, last modified: 2018-04-25
We present one of the most precise emission spectra of an exoplanet observed
so far. We combine five secondary eclipses of the hot Jupiter WASP-18 b
(Tday=2900K) that we secured between 1.1 and 1.7 micron with the WFC3
instrument aboard the Hubble Space Telescope. Our extracted spectrum (S/N=50,
R=40) does not exhibit clearly identifiable molecular features but is poorly
matched by a blackbody spectrum. We complement this data with previously
published Spitzer/IRAC observations of this target and interpret the combined
spectrum by computing a grid of self-consistent, 1D forward models, varying the
composition and energy budget. At these high temperatures, we find there are
important contributions to the overall opacity from H- ions, as well as the
removal of major molecules by thermal dissociation (including water), and
thermal ionization of metals. These effects were omitted in previous spectral
retrievals for very hot gas giants, and we argue that they must be included to
properly interpret the spectra of these objects. We infer a new metallicity and
C/O ratio for WASP-18 b, and find them well constrained to be solar
([M/H]=-0.01 (0.35), C/O<0.85 at 3 sigma confidence level), unlike previous
work but in line with expectations for giant planets. The best fitting
self-consistent temperature-pressure profiles are inverted, resulting in an
emission feature at 4.5 micron seen in the Spitzer photometry. These results
further strengthen the evidence that the family of very hot gas giant
exoplanets commonly exhibit thermal inversions.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.08708 [pdf] - 1654591
Understanding Stellar Contamination in Exoplanet Transmission Spectra as
an Essential Step in Small Planet Characterization
Apai, Dániel;
Rackham, Benjamin V.;
Giampapa, Mark S.;
Angerhausen, Daniel;
Teske, Johanna;
Barstow, Joanna;
Carone, Ludmila;
Cegla, Heather;
Domagal-Goldman, Shawn D.;
Espinoza, Néstor;
Giles, Helen;
Gully-Santiago, Michael;
Haywood, Raphaelle;
Hu, Renyu;
Jordan, Andres;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Line, Michael;
Llama, Joe;
López-Morales, Mercedes;
Marley, Mark S.;
de Wit, Julien
Submitted: 2018-03-23
Transmission spectroscopy during planetary transits is expected to be a major
source of information on the atmospheres of small (approximately Earth-sized)
exoplanets in the next two decades. This technique, however, is intrinsically
affected by stellar spectral contamination caused by the fact that stellar
photo- and chromospheres are not perfectly homogeneous. Such stellar
contamination will often reach or exceed the signal introduced by the planetary
spectral features. Finding effective methods to correct stellar contamination
-- or at least to quantify its possible range -- for the most important
exoplanets is a necessary step for our understanding of exoplanet atmospheres.
This will require significantly deepening our understanding of stellar
heterogeneity, which is currently limited by the available data.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.07983 [pdf] - 1666875
Strategies for Constraining the Atmospheres of Temperate Terrestrial
Planets with JWST
Submitted: 2018-03-21
TESS is expected to discover dozens of temperate terrestrial planets orbiting
M dwarfs whose atmospheres could be followed up with the James Webb Space
Telescope (JWST). Currently, the TRAPPIST-1 system serves as a benchmark to
determine the feasibility and resources required to yield atmospheric
constraints. We assess these questions and leverage an information content
analysis to determine observing strategies for yielding high precision
spectroscopy in transmission and emission. Our goal is to guide observing
strategies of temperate terrestrial planets in preparation for the early JWST
cycles. First, we explore JWST's current capabilities and expected spectral
precision for targets near the saturation limits of specific modes. In doing
so, we highlight the enhanced capabilities of high efficiency readout patterns
that are being considered for implementation in Cycle 2. We propose a partial
saturation strategy to increase the achievable precision of JWST's NIRSpec
Prism. We show that JWST has the potential to detect the dominant absorbing gas
in the atmospheres of temperate terrestrial planets by the 10th transit using
transmission spectroscopy techniques in the near-IR. We also show that stacking
$\gtrapprox$10 transmission spectroscopy observations is unlikely to yield
significant improvements in determining atmospheric composition. For emission
spectroscopy, we show that the MIRI LRS is unlikely to provide robust
constraints on the atmospheric composition of temperate terrestrial planets.
Higher precision emission spectroscopy at wavelengths longward of those
accessible to MIRI LRS, as proposed in the Origins Space Telescope concept,
could help improve the constraints on molecular abundances of temperate
terrestrial planets orbiting M-dwarfs.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.07163 [pdf] - 1652576
Additional Exoplanet Science Enabled by FINESSE
Zellem, Robert T.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Swain, Mark R.;
Bryden, Geoffrey;
Chapman, John W.;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Line, Michael R.;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Parmentier, Vivien;
Roudier, Gael M.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.
Submitted: 2018-03-19
FINESSE, a NASA MIDEX mission in Step 2, would conduct a large, uniform
survey of exoplanet atmospheres and create a statistically significant sample
for comparative planetology. FINESSE's technical capabilities, driven by a
scientific program to study planetary formation and climate mechanisms, enable
additional exoplanet science presented here.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.06403 [pdf] - 1674957
Characterizing Earth Analogs in Reflected Light: Atmospheric Retrieval
Studies for Future Space Telescopes
Submitted: 2018-03-16
Space-based high contrast imaging mission concepts for studying rocky
exoplanets in reflected light are currently under community study. We develop
an inverse modeling framework to estimate the science return of such missions
given different instrument design considerations. By combining an exoplanet
albedo model, an instrument noise model, and an ensemble Markov chain Monte
Carlo sampler, we explore retrievals of atmospheric and planetary properties
for Earth twins as a function of signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and resolution
($R$). Our forward model includes Rayleigh scattering, single-layer water
clouds with patchy coverage, and pressure-dependent absorption due to water
vapor, oxygen, and ozone. We simulate data at $R = 70$ and $R = 140$ from
0.4-1.0 $\mu$m with SNR $ = 5, 10, 15, 20$ at 550 nm (i.e., for
HabEx/LUVOIR-type instruments). At these same SNR, we simulate data for WFIRST
paired with a starshade, which includes two photometric points between 0.48-0.6
$\mu$m and $R = 50$ spectroscopy from 0.6-0.97 $\mu$m. Given our noise model
for WFIRST-type detectors, we find that weak detections of water vapor, ozone,
and oxygen can be achieved with observations with at least $R = 70$ / SNR$\ =
15$, or $R = 140$ / SNR$\ = 10$ for improved detections. Meaningful constraints
are only achieved with $R = 140$ / SNR$\ = 20$ data. The WFIRST data offer
limited diagnostic information, needing at least SNR = 20 to weakly detect
gases. Most scenarios place limits on planetary radius, but cannot constrain
surface gravity and, thus, planetary mass.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.06548 [pdf] - 1622463
Detection of a Westward Hotspot Offset in the Atmosphere of a Hot Gas
Giant CoRoT-2b
Dang, Lisa;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Schwartz, Joel C.;
Rauscher, Emily;
Zhang, Michael;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Line, Michael;
Dobbs-Dixon, Ian;
Deming, Drake;
Sundararajan, Sudarsan;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Zhao, Ming
Submitted: 2018-01-19
Short-period planets exhibit day-night temperature contrasts of hundreds to
thousands of degrees K. They also exhibit eastward hotspot offsets whereby the
hottest region on the planet is east of the substellar point; this has been
widely interpreted as advection of heat due to eastward winds. We present
thermal phase observations of the hot Jupiter CoRoT-2b obtained with the IRAC
instrument on the Spitzer Space Telescope. These measurements show the most
robust detection to date of a westward hotspot offset of 23 $\pm$ 4 degrees, in
contrast with the nine other planets with equivalent measurements. The peculiar
infrared flux map of CoRoT-2b may result from westward winds due to
non-synchronous rotation magnetic effects, or partial cloud coverage, that
obscures the emergent flux from the planet's eastern hemisphere.
Non-synchronous rotation and magnetic effects may also explain the planet's
anomalously large radius. On the other hand, partial cloud coverage could
explain the featureless dayside emission spectrum of the planet. If CoRoT-2b is
not tidally locked, then it means that our understanding of star-planet tidal
interaction is incomplete. If the westward offset is due to magnetic effects,
our result represents an opportunity to study an exoplanet's magnetic field. If
it has Eastern clouds, then it means that our understanding of large-scale
circulation on tidally locked planets is incomplete.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1712.03384 [pdf] - 1622385
A comparative study of WASP-67b and HAT-P-38b from WFC3 data
Bruno, Giovanni;
Lewis, Nikole K.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Filippazzo, Joseph;
Hill, Matthew;
Fraine, Jonathan D.;
Wakeford, Hannah R.;
Deming, Drake;
Kilpatrick, Brian;
Line, Michael R.;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Collins, Karen A.;
Conti, Dennis M.;
Garlitz, Joseph;
Rodriguez, Joseph E.
Submitted: 2017-12-09
Atmospheric temperature and planetary gravity are thought to be the main
parameters affecting cloud formation in giant exoplanet atmospheres. Recent
attempts to understand cloud formation have explored wide regions of the
equilibrium temperature-gravity parameter space. In this study, we instead
compare the case of two giant planets with nearly identical equilibrium
temperature ($T_\mathrm{eq}$ $\sim 1050 \, \mathrm{K}$) and gravity ($g \sim 10
\, \mathrm{m \, s}^{-1})$. During $HST$ Cycle 23, we collected WFC3/G141
observations of the two planets, WASP-67 b and HAT-P-38 b. HAT-P-38 b, with
mass 0.42 M$_\mathrm{J}$ and radius 1.4 $R_\mathrm{J}$, exhibits a relatively
clear atmosphere with a clear detection of water. We refine the orbital period
of this planet with new observations, obtaining $P = 4.6403294 \pm 0.0000055 \,
\mathrm{d}$. WASP-67 b, with mass 0.27 M$_\mathrm{J}$ and radius 0.83
$R_\mathrm{J}$, shows a more muted water absorption feature than that of
HAT-P-38 b, indicating either a higher cloud deck in the atmosphere or a more
metal-rich composition. The difference in the spectra supports the hypothesis
that giant exoplanet atmospheres carry traces of their formation history.
Future observations in the visible and mid-infrared are needed to probe the
aerosol properties and constrain the evolutionary scenario of these planets.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.05468 [pdf] - 1583450
Quantifying the Impact of Spectral Coverage on the Retrieval of
Molecular Abundances from Exoplanet Transmission Spectra
Chapman, John W.;
Zellem, Robert T.;
Line, Michael R.;
Bryden, Geoff;
Willacy, Karen;
Iyer, Aishwarya R.;
Vasisht, Gautam;
Bean, Jacob;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Griffith, Caitlin A.;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Kempton, Eliza M. -R.;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Swain, Mark R.
Submitted: 2017-05-15, last modified: 2017-08-15
Using forward models for representative exoplanet atmospheres and a
radiometric instrument model, we have generated synthetic observational data to
explore how well the major C- and O-bearing chemical species (CO, CO2, CH4, and
H2O), important for determining atmospheric opacity and radiation balance, can
be constrained by transit measurements as a function of spectral wavelength
coverage. This work features simulations for a notional transit spectroscopy
mission and compares two cases for instrument spectral coverage (wavelength
coverage from 0.5-2.5 ${\mu}$m and 0.5-5 ${\mu}$m. The simulation is conducted
on a grid with a range of stellar magnitudes and incorporates a full retrieval
of atmospheric model parameters. We consider a range of planets from
sub-Neptunes to hot Jupiters and include both low and high mean molecular
weight atmospheres. We find that including the 2.5-5 ${\mu}$m wavelength range
provides a significant improvement in the degree of constraint on the retrieved
molecular abundances: up to ~3 orders of magnitude for a low mean molecular
weight atmosphere (${\mu}$=2.3) and up to a factor of ~6 for a high mean
molecular weight atmosphere (${\mu}$=28). These decreased uncertainties imply
that broad spectral coverage between the visible and the mid-infrared is an
important tool for understanding the chemistry and composition of exoplanet
atmospheres. This analysis suggests that the JWST/NIRSpec 0.6-5 ${\mu}$m prism
spectroscopy mode, or similar wavelength coverage with possible future
missions, will be an important resource for exoplanet atmospheric
characterization.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.02809 [pdf] - 1580845
Uniform Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of Ultracool Dwarfs II:
Properties of 11 T-dwarfs
Line, Michael R.;
Marley, Mark S.;
Liu, Michael C.;
Burningham, Ben;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Hinkel, Natalie R.;
Teske, Johanna;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Lupu, Roxana;
Freedman, Richard
Submitted: 2016-12-08, last modified: 2017-07-24
Brown dwarf spectra are rich in information revealing of the chemical and
physical processes operating in their atmospheres. We apply a recently
developed atmospheric retrieval tool to an ensemble of late T-dwarf (600-800K)
near infrared spectra. With these spectra we are able to place direct
constraints the molecular abundances of H$_2$O, CH$_4$, CO, CO$_2$, NH$_3$,
H$_2$S, and Na+K, gravity, thermal structure (and effective temperature),
photometric radius, and cloud optical depths. We find that ammonia, water,
methane, and the alkali metals are present and well constrained in all 11
objects. From the abundance constraints we find no significant trend in the
water, methane, or ammonia abundances with temperature, but find a very strong
($>$25$\sigma$) increasing trend in the alkali metal abundances with effective
temperature, indicative of alkali rainout. We also find little evidence for
optically thick clouds. With the methane and water abundances, we derive the
intrinsic atmospheric metallicity and carbon-to-oxygen ratios. We find in our
sample, that metallicities are typically sub solar and carbon-to-oxygen ratios
are somewhat super solar, different than expectations from the local stellar
population. We also find that the retrieved vertical thermal profiles are
consistent with radiative equilibrium over the photospheric regions. Finally,
we find that our retrieved effective temperatures are lower than previous
inferences for some objects and that our radii are larger than expectations
from evolutionary models, possibly indicative of un-resolved binaries. This
investigation and methodology represents a paradigm in linking spectra to the
determination of the fundamental chemical and physical processes governing cool
brown dwarf atmospheres.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.04708 [pdf] - 1583393
Forecasting the Impact of Stellar Activity on Transiting Exoplanet
Spectra
Zellem, Robert T.;
Swain, Mark R.;
Roudier, Gael;
Shkolnik, Evgenya L.;
Creech-Eakman, Michelle J.;
Ciardi, David R.;
Line, Michael R.;
Iyer, Aishwarya R.;
Bryden, Geoffrey;
Llama, Joe;
Fahy, Kristen A.
Submitted: 2017-05-12, last modified: 2017-06-15
Exoplanet host star activity, in the form of unocculted star spots or
faculae, alters the observed transmission and emission spectra of the
exoplanet. This effect can be exacerbated when combining data from different
epochs if the stellar photosphere varies between observations due to activity.
redHere we present a method to characterize and correct for relative changes
due to stellar activity by exploiting multi-epoch ($\ge$2 visits/transits)
observations to place them in a consistent reference frame. Using measurements
from portions of the planet's orbit where negligible planet transmission or
emission can be assumed, we determine changes to the stellar spectral
amplitude. With the analytical methods described here, we predict the impact of
stellar variability on transit observations. Supplementing these forecasts with
Kepler-measured stellar variabilities for F-, G-, K-, and M-dwarfs, and
predicted transit precisions by JWST's NIRISS, NIRCam, and MIRI, we conclude
that stellar activity does not impact infrared transiting exoplanet
observations of most presently-known or predicted TESS targets by current or
near-future platforms, such as JWST.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.01257 [pdf] - 1581073
Retrieval of atmospheric properties of cloudy L dwarfs
Submitted: 2017-01-05, last modified: 2017-05-18
We present the first results from applying the spectral inversion technique
in the cloudy L dwarf regime. Our new framework provides a flexible approach to
modelling cloud opacity which can be built incrementally as the data requires,
and improves upon previous retrieval experiments in the brown dwarf regime by
allowing for scattering in two stream radiative transfer. Our first application
of the tool to two mid-L dwarfs is able to reproduce their near-infrared
spectra far more closely than grid models. Our retrieved thermal, chemical, and
cloud profiles allow us to estimate $T_{\rm eff} = 1796^{+23}_{-25}$ K and
$\log g = 5.21^{+0.05}_{-0.08}$ for 2MASS J05002100+0330501 and for 2MASSW
J2224438-015852 we find $T_{\rm eff} = 1723^{+18}_{-19}$ K and $\log g =
5.31^{+0.04}_{-0.08}$, in close agreement with previous empirical estimates.
Our best model for both objects includes an optically thick cloud deck which
passes $\tau_{cloud} \geq 1$ (looking down) at a pressure of around 5 bar. The
temperature at this pressure is too high for silicate species to condense, and
we argue that corundum and/or iron clouds are responsible for this cloud
opacity. Our retrieved profiles are cooler at depth, and warmer at altitude
than the forward grid models that we compare, and we argue that some form of
heating mechanism may be at work in the upper atmospheres of these L dwarfs. We
also identify anomalously high CO abundance in both targets, which does not
correlate with the warmth of our upper atmospheres or our choice of cloud
model, and find similarly anomalous alkali abundance for one of our targets.
These anomalies may reflect unrecognised shortcomings in our retrieval model,
or inaccuracies in our gas phase opacities.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.07008 [pdf] - 1561084
A framework to combine low- and high-resolution spectroscopy for the
atmospheres of transiting exoplanets
Submitted: 2016-12-21, last modified: 2017-03-24
Current observations of the atmospheres of close-in exoplanets are
predominantly obtained with two techniques: low-resolution spectroscopy with
space telescopes and high-resolution spectroscopy from the ground. Although the
observables delivered by the two methods are in principle highly complementary,
no attempt has ever been made to combine them, perhaps due to the different
modeling approaches that are typically used in their interpretation. Here we
present the first combined analysis of previously-published dayside spectra of
the exoplanet HD 209458b obtained at low resolution with HST/WFC3 and
Spitzer/IRAC, and at high resolution with VLT/CRIRES. By utilizing a novel
retrieval algorithm capable of computing the joint probability distribution of
low- and high-resolution spectra, we obtain tight constraints on the chemical
composition of the planet's atmosphere. In contrast to the WFC3 data, we do not
confidently detect H2O at high spectral resolution. The retrieved water
abundance from the combined analysis deviates by 1.9 sigma from the
expectations for a solar-composition atmosphere in chemical equilibrium.
Measured relative molecular abundances of CO and H2O strongly favor an
oxygen-rich atmosphere (C/O<1 at 3.5 sigma) for the planet when compared to
equilibrium calculations including O rainout. From the abundances of the seven
molecular species included in this study we constrain the planet metallicity to
0.1-1.0x the stellar value (1 sigma). This study opens the way to coordinated
exoplanet surveys between the flagship ground- and space-based facilities,
which ultimately will be crucial for characterizing potentially-habitable
planets.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.02085 [pdf] - 1546315
Information Content Analysis for Selection of Optimal JWST Observing
Modes for Transiting Exoplanet Atmospheres
Submitted: 2016-12-06, last modified: 2017-03-08
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) is nearing its launch date of 2018, and
will undoubtedly revolutionize our knowledge of exoplanet atmospheres. While
several studies have explored what the limits of the telescope will be in terms
of exoplanet characterization, less has been done to specifically identify
which observing modes will be most useful for characterizing a diverse range of
exoplanetary atmospheres. We use an information content based approach commonly
used in the studies of Solar System atmospheres. We develop a system based upon
these information content methods to trace the instrumental and atmospheric
model phase space in order to identify which observing modes are best suited
for particular classes of planets, focusing on transmission spectra.
Specifically, the atmospheric parameter space we cover is T=600-1800 K,
C/O=0.55-1, [M/H]=1-100$\times$Solar for a R=1.39 R$_J$, M=0.59 M$_J$ planet
orbiting WASP-62-like star. We find that obtaining broader wavelength coverage
over multiple modes is preferred over higher precision in a single mode given
the same amount of observing time. Regardless of the planet temperature and
composition, the best modes for constraining terminator temperatures, C/O
ratios, and metalicity are NIRISS SOSS+NIRSpec G395. If the target's host star
is dim enough such that the NIRSpec prism can be used, then it cam be used
instead of NIRISS SOSS+NIRSpec G395. Lastly, observations that use more than
two modes, should be carefully analyzed because sometimes the addition of a
third mode results in no gain of information. In these cases, higher precision
in the original two modes is favorable.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.09272 [pdf] - 1532854
Near-Infrared Emission Spectrum of WASP-103b using Hubble Space
Telescope/Wide Field Camera 3
Cartier, Kimberly M. S.;
Beatty, Thomas G.;
Zhao, Ming;
Line, Michael;
Ngo, Henry;
Mawet, Dimitri;
Stassun, Keivan G.;
Wright, Jason T.;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Fortney, Jonathan;
Knutson, Heather
Submitted: 2016-11-28, last modified: 2017-01-10
We present here our observations and analysis of the dayside emission
spectrum of the hot Jupiter WASP-103b. We observed WASP-103b during secondary
eclipse using two visits of the Hubble Space Telescope with the G141 grism on
Wide Field Camera 3 in spatial scan mode. We generated secondary eclipse light
curves of the planet in both blended white-light and spectrally binned
wavechannels from 1.1-1.7 micron and corrected the light curves for flux
contamination from a nearby companion star. We modeled the detector systematics
and secondary eclipse spectrum using Gaussian process regression and found that
the near-IR emission spectrum of WASP-103b is featureless across the observed
near-IR region to down to a sensitivity of 175 ppm, and shows a shallow slope
towards the red. The atmosphere has a single brightness temperature of T_B =
2890 K across this wavelength range. This region of the spectrum is
indistinguishable from isothermal, but may not manifest from a physically
isothermal system, i.e. pseudo-isothermal. A Solar-metallicity profile with a
thermal inversion layer at 10^-2 bar fits WASP-103b's spectrum with high
confidence, as do an isothermal profile with Solar metallicity and a
monotonically decreasing atmosphere with C/O>1. The data rule out a
monotonically decreasing atmospheric profile with Solar composition, and we
rule out a low-metallicity decreasing profile as non-physical for this system.
The pseudo-isothermal profile could be explained by a thermal inversion layer
just above the layer probed by our observations, or by clouds or haze in the
upper atmosphere. Transmission spectra at optical wavelengths would allow us to
better differentiate between potential atmospheric models.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.00056 [pdf] - 1531156
Spitzer Phase Curve Constraints for WASP-43b at 3.6 and 4.5 microns
Submitted: 2016-07-29, last modified: 2016-12-30
Previous measurements of heat redistribution efficiency (the ability to
transport energy from a planet's highly irradiated dayside to its eternally
dark nightside) show considerable variation between exoplanets. Theoretical
models predict a positive correlation between heat redistribution efficiency
and temperature for tidally locked planets; however, recent HST WASP-43b
spectroscopic phase curve results are inconsistent with current predictions.
Using the Spitzer Space Telescope, we obtained a total of three phase curve
observations of WASP-43b (P=0.813 days) at 3.6 and 4.5 microns. The first 3.6
micron visit exhibits spurious nightside emission that requires invoking
unphysical conditions in our cloud-free atmospheric retrievals. The two other
visits exhibit strong day-night contrasts that are consistent with the HST
data. To reconcile the departure from theoretical predictions, WASP-43b would
need to have a high-altitude, nightside cloud/haze layer blocking its thermal
emission. Clouds/hazes could be produced within the planet's cool, nearly
retrograde mid-latitude flows before dispersing across its nightside at high
altitudes. Since mid-latitude flows only materialize in fast-rotating
($\lesssim1$ day) planets, this may explain an observed trend connecting
measured day-night contrast with planet rotation rate that matches all current
Spitzer phase curve results. Combining independent planetary emission
measurements from multiple phases, we obtain a precise dayside hemisphere H2O
abundance ($2.5\times 10^{-5} - 1.1\times 10^{-4}$ at 1$\sigma$ confidence)
and, assuming chemical equilibrium and a scaled solar abundance pattern, we
derive a corresponding metallicity estimate that is consistent with being solar
(0.4 -- 1.7). Using the retrieved global CO+CO2 abundance under the same
assumptions, we estimate a comparable metallicity of 0.3 - 1.7$\times$ solar.
(Abridged)
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.07632 [pdf] - 1532217
Forward and Inverse Modeling of the Emission and Transmission Spectrum
of GJ 436b: Investigating Metal Enrichment, Tidal Heating, and Clouds
Submitted: 2016-10-24
The Neptune-mass GJ 436b is one of the most-studied transiting exoplanets
with repeated measurements of both its thermal emission and transmission
spectra. We build on previous studies to answer outstanding questions about
this planet, including its potentially high metallicity and tidal heating of
its interior. We present new observations of GJ 436b's thermal emission at 3.6
and 4.5 micron, which reduce uncertainties in estimates of GJ 436b's flux at
those wavelengths and demonstrate consistency between Spitzer observations
spanning more than 7 years. We analyze the Spitzer thermal emission photometry
and Hubble WFC3 transmission spectrum in tandem. We use a powerful dual-pronged
modeling approach, comparing these data to both self-consistent and retrieval
models. We vary the metallicity, intrinsic luminosity from tidal heating,
disequilibrium chemistry, and heat redistribution. We also study the effect of
clouds and photochemical hazes on the spectra, but do not find strong evidence
for either. The self-consistent and retrieval modeling combine to suggest that
GJ 436b has a high atmospheric metallicity, with best fits at or above several
hundred times solar metallicity, tidal heating warming its interior with
best-fit intrinsic effective effective temperatures around 300--350 K, and
disequilibrium chemistry. High metal-enrichments (>600x solar) can only occur
from the accretion of rocky, rather than icy, material. Assuming Tint~300--350
K, we find that Q'~2x10^5--10^6, larger than Neptune's Q', and implying a long
tidal circularization timescale for the planet's orbit. We suggest that
Neptune-mass planets may be a more diverse class than previously imagined, with
metal-enhancements potentially spanning several orders of magnitude, to perhaps
over 1000x solar metallicity. High fidelity observations with instruments like
JWST will be critical for characterizing this diversity.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.02026 [pdf] - 1528276
Two NIRCam channels are Better than One: How JWST Can Do More Science
with NIRCam's Short-Wavelength Dispersed Hartmann Sensor
Schlawin, Everett;
Rieke, Marcia;
Leisenring, Jarron;
Greene, Tom;
Walker, Lisa May;
Fraine, Jonathan;
Kelly, Doug;
Misselt, Karl;
Line, Michael;
Stansberry, John;
Lewis, Nikole
Submitted: 2016-10-06
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) offers unprecedented sensitivity,
stability, and wavelength coverage for transiting exoplanet studies, opening up
new avenues for measuring atmospheric abundances, structure, and temperature
profiles. Taking full advantage of JWST spectroscopy of planets from 0.6um to
28um, however, will require many observations with a combination of the NIRISS,
NIRCam, NIRSpec, and MIRI instruments. In this white paper, we discuss a new
NIRCam mode (not yet approved or implemented) that can reduce the number of
necessary observations to cover the 1.0um to 5.0um wavelength range. Even
though NIRCam was designed primarily as an imager, it also includes several
grisms for phasing and aligning JWST's 18 hexagonal mirror segments. NIRCam's
long-wavelength channel includes grisms that cover 2.4um to 5.0um with a
resolving power of R = 1200 - 1550 using two separate configurations. The
long-wavelength grisms have already been approved for science operations,
including wide field and single object (time series) slitless spectroscopy. We
propose a new mode that will simultaneously measure spectra for science targets
in the 1.0um to 2.0um range using NIRCam's short-wavelength channel. This mode,
if approved, would take advantage of NIRCam's Dispersed Hartmann Sensor (DHS),
which produces 10 spatially separated spectra per source at R ~ 300. We discuss
the added benefit of the DHS in constraining abundances in exoplanet
atmospheres as well as its ability to observe the brightest systems. The DHS
essentially comes for free (at no time cost) with any NIRCam long-wavelength
grism observation, but the detector integration parameters have to be selected
to ensure that the long-wavelength grism observations do not saturate and that
JWST data volume downlink constraints are not violated.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.05370 [pdf] - 1530610
Developing Atmospheric Retrieval Methods for Direct Imaging Spectroscopy
of Gas Giants in Reflected Light I: Methane Abundances and Basic Cloud
Properties
Submitted: 2016-04-18, last modified: 2016-09-16
Upcoming space-based coronagraphic instruments in the next decade will
perform reflected light spectroscopy and photometry of cool, directly imaged
extrasolar giant planets. We are developing a new atmospheric retrieval
methodology to help assess the science return and inform the instrument design
for such future missions, and ultimately interpret the resulting observations.
Our retrieval technique employs a geometric albedo model coupled with both a
Markov chain Monte Carlo Ensemble Sampler (emcee) and a multimodal nested
sampling algorithm (MultiNest) to map the posterior distribution. This
combination makes the global evidence calculation more robust for any given
model, and highlights possible discrepancies in the likelihood maps. As a
proof-of-concept, our current atmospheric model contains 1 or 2 cloud layers,
methane as a major absorber, and a H$_2$-He background gas. This 6-to-9
parameter model is appropriate for Jupiter-like planets and can be easily
expanded in the future. In addition to deriving the marginal likelihood
distribution and confidence intervals for the model parameters, we perform
model selection to determine the significance of methane and cloud detection as
a function of expected signal-to-noise in the presence of spectral noise
correlations. After internal validation, the method is applied to realistic
spectra of Jupiter, Saturn, and HD 99492 c, a model observing target. We find
that the presence or absence of clouds and methane can be determined with high
confidence, while parameter uncertainties are model-dependent and correlated.
Such general methods will also be applicable to the interpretation of direct
imaging spectra of cloudy terrestrial planets.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.08643 [pdf] - 1490863
On the Composition of Young, Directly Imaged Giant Planets
Submitted: 2016-08-30
The past decade has seen significant progress on the direct detection and
characterization of young, self-luminous giant planets at wide orbital
separations from their host stars. Some of these planets show evidence for
disequilibrium processes like transport-induced quenching in their atmospheres;
photochemistry may also be important, despite the large orbital distances.
These disequilibrium chemical processes can alter the expected composition,
spectral behavior, thermal structure, and cooling history of the planets, and
can potentially confuse determinations of bulk elemental ratios, which provide
important insights into planet-formation mechanisms. Using a
thermo/photochemical kinetics and transport model, we investigate the extent to
which disequilibrium chemistry affects the composition and spectra of directly
imaged giant exoplanets. Results for specific "young Jupiters" such as HR 8799
b and 51 Eri b are presented, as are general trends as a function of planetary
effective temperature, surface gravity, incident ultraviolet flux, and strength
of deep atmospheric convection. We find that quenching is very important on
young Jupiters, leading to CO/CH4 and N2/NH3 ratios much greater than, and H2O
mixing ratios a factor of a few less than, chemical-equilibrium predictions.
Photochemistry can also be important on such planets, with CO2 and HCN being
key photochemical products. Carbon dioxide becomes a major constituent when
stratospheric temperatures are low and recycling of water via the H2 + OH
reaction becomes kinetically stifled. Young Jupiters with effective
temperatures <~ 700 K are in a particularly interesting photochemical regime
that differs from both transiting hot Jupiters and our own solar-system giant
planets.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.03230 [pdf] - 1486915
The Impact of Non-Uniform Thermal Structure on the Interpretation of
Exoplanet Emission Spectra
Submitted: 2016-07-12
The determination of atmospheric structure and molecular abundances of
planetary atmospheres via spectroscopy involves direct comparisons between
models and data. While varying in sophistication, most model-spectra
comparisons fundamentally assume "1D" model physics. However, knowledge from
general circulation models and of solar system planets suggests that planetary
atmospheres are inherently "3D" in their structure and composition. We explore
the potential biases resulting from standard "1D" assumptions within a Bayesian
atmospheric retrieval framework. Specifically, we show how the assumption of a
single 1-dimensional thermal profile can bias our interpretation of the thermal
emission spectrum of a hot Jupiter atmosphere that is composed of two thermal
profiles. We retrieve upon spectra of unresolved model planets as observed with
a combination of $HST$ WFC3+$Spitzer$ IRAC as well as $JWST$ under varying
differences in the two thermal profiles. For WFC3+IRAC, there is a
significantly biased estimate of CH$_4$ abundance using a 1D model when the
contrast is 80%. For $JWST$, two thermal profiles are required to adequately
interpret the data and estimate the abundances when contrast is greater than
40%. We also apply this preliminary concept to the recent WFC3+IRAC phase curve
data of the hot Jupiter WASP-43b. We see similar behavior as present in our
simulated data: while the H$_2$O abundance determination is robust, CH$_4$ is
artificially well-constrained to incorrect values under the 1D assumption. Our
work demonstrates the need to evaluate model assumptions in order to extract
meaningful constraints from atmospheric spectra and motivates exploration of
optimal observational setups.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.08810 [pdf] - 1530753
No Thermal Inversion and a Solar Water Abundance for the Hot Jupiter
HD209458b from HST WFC3 Emission Spectroscopy
Submitted: 2016-05-27
The nature of the vertical thermal structure of hot Jupiter atmospheres is
one of the key questions raised by the characterization of transiting
exoplanets over the last decade. There have been claims that many hot Jupiter's
exhibit vertical profiles with increasing temperature with decreasing pressure
in the infrared photosphere that leads to the reversal of molecular absorption
bands into emission features (an inversion). However, these claims have been
based on broadband photometry rather than the unambiguous identification of
emission features with spectroscopy, and the chemical species that could cause
the thermal inversions by absorbing stellar irradiation at high altitudes have
not been identified despite extensive theoretical and observational effort.
Here we present high precision HST WFC3 observations of the dayside emission
spectrum of the hot Jupiter HD209458b; the first exoplanet suggested to have a
thermal inversion. Our observations resolve a water band in absorption at 6.2
sigma confidence. When combined with Spitzer photometry the data are indicative
of a monotonically decreasing temperature with pressure over the range 1-0.001
bar at 7.7 sigma confidence. We test the robustness of our results by exploring
a variety of model assumptions including the temperature profile
parameterization, presence of a cloud, and choice of Spitzer data reduction. We
also introduce a new analysis method, "chemical retrieval-on-retrieval", to
determine the elemental abundances from the spectrally retrieved mixing ratios
with thermochemical self-consistency and find plausible abundances consistent
with solar metallicity (0.06 - 10 x solar) and carbon-to-oxygen ratios less
than unity. This work suggests that high-precision spectrophotometric results
are required to robustly infer thermal structures and compositions of
extra-solar planet atmospheres.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.08389 [pdf] - 1428233
Transiting Exoplanet Studies and Community Targets for JWST's Early
Release Science Program
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Lewis, Nikole K.;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Beichman, Charles;
Fraine, Jonathan;
Kilpatrick, Brian M.;
Krick, J. E.;
Lothringer, Joshua D.;
Mandell, Avi M.;
Valenti, Jeff A.;
Agol, Eric;
Angerhausen, Daniel;
Barstow, Joanna K.;
Birkmann, Stephan M.;
Burrows, Adam;
Charbonneau, David;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Crouzet, Nicolas;
Cubillos, Patricio E.;
Curry, S. M.;
Dalba, Paul A.;
de Wit, Julien;
Deming, Drake;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Doyon, Rene;
Dragomir, Diana;
Ehrenreich, David;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Munoz, Antonio Garcia;
Gibson, Neale P.;
Gizis, John E.;
Greene, Thomas P.;
Harrington, Joseph;
Heng, Kevin;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Kempton, Eliza M. -R.;
Knutson, Heather;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Lafreniere, David;
Lagage, Pierre-Olivier;
Line, Michael R.;
Lopez-Morales, Mercedes;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Rocchetto, Marco;
Schlawin, Everett;
Shkolnik, Evgenya L.;
Shporer, Avi;
Sing, David K.;
Todorov, Kamen O.;
Tucker, Gregory S.;
Wakeford, Hannah R.
Submitted: 2016-02-26, last modified: 2016-04-21
The James Webb Space Telescope will revolutionize transiting exoplanet
atmospheric science due to its capability for continuous, long-duration
observations and its larger collecting area, spectral coverage, and spectral
resolution compared to existing space-based facilities. However, it is unclear
precisely how well JWST will perform and which of its myriad instruments and
observing modes will be best suited for transiting exoplanet studies. In this
article, we describe a prefatory JWST Early Release Science (ERS) program that
focuses on testing specific observing modes to quickly give the community the
data and experience it needs to plan more efficient and successful future
transiting exoplanet characterization programs. We propose a multi-pronged
approach wherein one aspect of the program focuses on observing transits of a
single target with all of the recommended observing modes to identify and
understand potential systematics, compare transmission spectra at overlapping
and neighboring wavelength regions, confirm throughputs, and determine overall
performances. In our search for transiting exoplanets that are well suited to
achieving these goals, we identify 12 objects (dubbed "community targets") that
meet our defined criteria. Currently, the most favorable target is WASP-62b
because of its large predicted signal size, relatively bright host star, and
location in JWST's continuous viewing zone. Since most of the community targets
do not have well-characterized atmospheres, we recommend initiating preparatory
observing programs to determine the presence of obscuring clouds/hazes within
their atmospheres. Measurable spectroscopic features are needed to establish
the optimal resolution and wavelength regions for exoplanet characterization.
Other initiatives from our proposed ERS program include testing the instrument
brightness limits and performing phase-curve observations.(Abridged)
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.00151 [pdf] - 1418742
A Characteristic Transmission Spectrum dominated by H$_{2}$O applies to
the majority of HST/WFC3 exoplanet observations
Submitted: 2015-12-01, last modified: 2016-04-01
Currently, 19 transiting exoplanets have published transmission spectra
obtained with the Hubble/WFC3 G141 near-IR grism. Using this sample, we have
undertaken a uniform analysis incorporating measurement-error debiasing of the
spectral modulation due to H$_{2}$O, measured in terms of the estimated
atmospheric scale height, ${H_s}$. For those planets with a reported H$_{2}$O
detection (10 out of 19), the spectral modulation due to H$_{2}$O ranges from
0.9 to 2.9~${H_s}$ with a mean value of 1.8~$\pm$~0.5~${H_s}$. This spectral
modulation is significantly less than predicted for clear atmospheres. For the
group of planets in which H$_{2}$O has been detected, we find the individual
spectra can be coherently averaged to produce a characteristic spectrum in
which the shape, together with the spectral modulation of the sample, are
consistent with a range of H$_{2}$O mixing ratios and cloud-top pressures, with
a minimum H$_{2}$O mixing ratio of 17~$^{+12}_{-6}$~ppm corresponding to the
cloud-free case. Using this lower limit, we show that clouds or aerosols must
block at least half of the atmospheric column that would otherwise be sampled
by transmission spectroscopy in the case of a cloud-free atmosphere. We
conclude that terminator-region clouds, with sufficient opacity to be opaque in
slant-viewing geometry, are common in hot Jupiters.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.00217 [pdf] - 1411131
The Water Abundance of the Directly Imaged Substellar Companion {\kappa}
And b Retrieved from a Near Infrared Spectrum
Submitted: 2015-04-01, last modified: 2016-03-10
Spectral retrieval has proven to be a powerful tool for constraining the
physical properties and atmospheric compositions of extrasolar planet
atmospheres from observed spectra, primarily for transiting objects but also
for directly imaged planets and brown dwarfs. Despite its strengths, this
approach has been applied to only about a dozen targets. Determining the
abundances of the main carbon and oxygen-bearing compounds in a planetary
atmosphere can lead to the C/O ratio of the object, which is crucial in
understanding its formation and migration history. We present a retrieval
analysis on the published near-infrared spectrum of {\kappa} And b, a directly
imaged substellar companion to a young B9 star. We fit the emission spectrum
model utilizing a Markov Chain Monte Carlo algorithm. We estimate the abundance
of water vapor, and its uncertainty, in the atmosphere of the object. In
addition, we place an upper limit on the abundance of CH$_4$. We compare
qualitatively our results to studies that have applied model retrieval on
multiband photometry and emission spectroscopy of hot Jupiters (extrasolar
giant planets with orbital periods of several days) and the directly imaged
giant planet HR 8799b.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.01934 [pdf] - 1411373
Spitzer Observations of Exoplanets Discovered with The Kepler K2 Mission
Beichman, Charles;
Livingston, John;
Werner, Michael;
Gorjian, Varoujan;
Krick, Jessica;
Deck, Katherine;
Knutson, Heather;
Wong, Ian;
Petigura, Erik A.;
Christiansen, Jessie;
Ciardi, David;
Greene, Thomas P.;
Schlieder, Joshua E.;
Line, Mike;
Crossfield, Ian;
Howard, Andrew;
Sinukoff, Evan
Submitted: 2016-03-06
We have used the {\it Spitzer Space Telescope} to observe two transiting
planetary systems orbiting low mass stars discovered in the \Kepler \Ktwo
mission. The system K2-3 (EPIC 201367065) hosts three planets while EPIC
202083828 (K2-26) hosts a single planet. Observations of all four objects in
these two systems confirm and refine the orbital and physical parameters of the
planets. The refined orbital information and more precise planet radii possible
with \Spitzer will be critical for future observations of these and other \Ktwo
targets. For K2-3b we find marginally significant evidence for a Transit Timing
Variation between the \Ktwo and \Spitzer\ epochs.
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.09443 [pdf] - 1385423
The Influence of Non-Uniform Cloud Cover on Transit Transmission Spectra
Submitted: 2015-11-30, last modified: 2016-02-15
We model the impact of non-uniform cloud cover on transit transmission
spectra. Patchy clouds exist in nearly every solar system atmosphere, brown
dwarfs, and transiting exoplanets. Our major findings suggest that fractional
cloud coverage can exactly mimic high mean molecular weight atmospheres and
vice-versa over certain wavelength regions, in particular, over the Hubble
Space Telescope (HST) Wide Field Camera 3 (WFC3) bandpass (1.1-1.7 $\mu$m). We
also find that patchy cloud coverage exhibits a signature that is different
from uniform global clouds. Furthermore, we explain analytically why the
"patchy cloud-high mean molecular weight" degeneracy exists. We also explore
the degeneracy of non-uniform cloud coverage in atmospheric retrievals on both
synthetic and real planets. We find from retrievals on a synthetic solar
composition hot Jupiter with patchy clouds and a cloud free high mean molecular
weight warm Neptune, that both cloud free high mean molecular weight
atmospheres and partially cloudy atmospheres can explain the data equally well.
Another key find is that the HST WFC3 transit transmission spectra of two well
observed objects, the hot Jupiter HD189733b and the warm Neptune HAT-P-11b, can
be explained well by solar composition atmospheres with patchy clouds without
the need to invoke high mean molecular weight or global clouds. The degeneracy
between high molecular weight and solar composition partially cloudy
atmospheres can be broken by observing the molecular Rayleigh scattering
differences between the two. Furthermore, the signature of partially cloudy
limbs also appears as a $\sim$100 ppm residual in the ingress and egress of the
transit light curves, provided the transit timing is known to seconds.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.08226 [pdf] - 1349543
A Search for Water in the Atmosphere of HAT-P-26b Using LDSS-3C
Submitted: 2015-11-25, last modified: 2015-12-23
The characterization of a physically-diverse set of transiting exoplanets is
an important and necessary step towards establishing the physical properties
linked to the production of obscuring clouds or hazes. It is those planets with
identifiable spectroscopic features that can most effectively enhance our
understanding of atmospheric chemistry and metallicity. The newly-commissioned
LDSS-3C instrument on Magellan provides enhanced sensitivity and suppressed
fringing in the red optical, thus advancing the search for the spectroscopic
signature of water in exoplanetary atmospheres from the ground. Using data
acquired by LDSS-3C and the Spitzer Space Telescope, we search for evidence of
water vapor in the transmission spectrum of the Neptune-mass planet HAT-P-26b.
Our measured spectrum is best explained by the presence of water vapor, a lack
of potassium, and either a high-metallicity, cloud-free atmosphere or a
solar-metallicity atmosphere with a cloud deck at ~10 mbar. The emergence of
multi-scale-height spectral features in our data suggests that future
observations at higher precision could break this degeneracy and reveal the
planet's atmospheric chemical abundances. We also update HAT-P-26b's transit
ephemeris, t_0 = 2455304.65218(25) BJD_TDB, and orbital period, p =
4.2345023(7) days.
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.05528 [pdf] - 1347638
Characterizing transiting exoplanet atmospheres with JWST
Submitted: 2015-11-17
We explore how well James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) spectra will likely
constrain bulk atmospheric properties of transiting exoplanets. We start by
modeling the atmospheres of archetypal hot Jupiter, warm Neptune, warm
sub-Neptune, and cool super-Earth planets with clear, cloudy, or high mean
molecular weight atmospheres. Next we simulate the $\lambda = 1 - 11$ $\mu$m
transmission and emission spectra of these systems for several JWST instrument
modes for single transit and eclipse events. We then perform retrievals to
determine how well temperatures and molecular mixing ratios (CH$_4$, CO,
CO$_2$, H$_2$O, NH$_3$) can be constrained. We find that $\lambda = 1 - 2.5$
$\mu$m transmission spectra will often constrain the major molecular
constituents of clear solar composition atmospheres well. Cloudy or high mean
molecular weight atmospheres will often require full $1 - 11$ $\mu$m spectra
for good constraints, and emission data may be more useful in cases of
sufficiently high $F_p$ and high $F_p/F_*$. Strong temperature inversions in
the solar composition hot Jupiter atmosphere should be detectable with $1 -
2.5+$ $\mu$m emission spectra, and $1 - 5+$ $\mu$m emission spectra will
constrain the temperature-pressure profiles of warm planets. Transmission
spectra over $1 - 5+$ $\mu$m will constrain [Fe/H] values to better than 0.5
dex for the clear atmospheres of the hot and warm planets studied.
Carbon-to-oxygen ratios can be constrained to better than a factor of 2 in some
systems. We expect that these results will provide useful predictions of the
scientific value of single event JWST spectra until its on-orbit performance is
known.
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.01492 [pdf] - 1331082
Thermal Emission and Albedo Spectra of Super Earths with Flat
Transmission Spectra
Submitted: 2015-11-04
Planets larger than Earth and smaller than Neptune are some of the most
numerous in the galaxy, but observational efforts to understand this population
have proved challenging because optically thick clouds or hazes at high
altitudes obscure molecular features (Kreidberg et al. 2014b). We present
models of super Earths that include thick clouds and hazes and predict their
transmission, thermal emission, and reflected light spectra. Very thick, lofted
clouds of salts or sulfides in high metallicity (1000x solar) atmospheres
create featureless transmission spectra in the near-infrared. Photochemical
hazes with a range of particle sizes also create featureless transmission
spectra at lower metallicities. Cloudy thermal emission spectra have muted
features more like blackbodies, and hazy thermal emission spectra have emission
features caused by an inversion layer at altitudes where the haze forms. Close
analysis of reflected light from warm (~400-800 K) planets can distinguish
cloudy spectra, which have moderate albedos (0.05-0.20), from hazy models,
which are very dark (0.0-0.03). Reflected light spectra of cold planets (~200
K) accessible to a space-based visible light coronagraph will have high albedos
and large molecular features that will allow them to be more easily
characterized than the warmer transiting planets. We suggest a number of
complementary observations to characterize this population of planets,
including transmission spectra of hot (>1000 K) targets, thermal emission
spectra of warm targets using the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), high
spectral resolution (R~10^5) observations of cloudy targets, and reflected
light spectral observations of directly-imaged cold targets. Despite the dearth
of features observed in super Earth transmission spectra to date, different
observations will provide rich diagnostics of their atmospheres.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.05586 [pdf] - 1295158
A Detection of Water in the Transmission Spectrum of the Hot Jupiter
WASP-12b and Implications for its Atmospheric Composition
Kreidberg, Laura;
Line, Michael R.;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Barstow, Joanna K.;
Henry, Gregory W.;
Williamson, Michael;
Showman, Adam P.
Submitted: 2015-04-21, last modified: 2015-10-16
Detailed characterization of exoplanets has begun to yield measurements of
their atmospheric properties that constrain the planets' origins and evolution.
For example, past observations of the dayside emission spectrum of the hot
Jupiter WASP-12b indicated that its atmosphere has a high carbon-to-oxygen
ratio (C/O $>$ 1), suggesting it had a different formation pathway than is
commonly assumed for giant planets. Here we report a precise near-infrared
transmission spectrum for WASP-12b based on six transit observations with the
Hubble Space Telescope/Wide Field Camera 3. We bin the data in 13
spectrophotometric light curves from 0.84 - 1.67 $\mu$m and measure the transit
depths to a median precision of 51 ppm. We retrieve the atmospheric properties
using the transmission spectrum and find strong evidence for water absorption
(7$\sigma$ confidence). This detection marks the first high-confidence,
spectroscopic identification of a molecule in the atmosphere of WASP-12b. The
retrieved 1$\sigma$ water volume mixing ratio is between $10^{-5}-10^{-2}$,
which is consistent with C/O $>$ 1 to within 2$\sigma$. However, we also
introduce a new retrieval parameterization that fits for C/O and metallicity
under the assumption of chemical equilibrium. With this approach, we constrain
C/O to $0.5^{+0.2}_{-0.3}$ at $1\,\sigma$ and rule out a carbon-rich atmosphere
composition (C/O$>1$) at $>3\sigma$ confidence. Further observations and
modeling of the planet's global thermal structure and dynamics would aid in
resolving the tension between our inferred C/O and previous constraints. Our
findings highlight the importance of obtaining high-precision data with
multiple observing techniques in order to obtain robust constraints on the
chemistry and physics of exoplanet atmospheres.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.03084 [pdf] - 1290800
Discovery and spectroscopy of the young Jovian planet 51 Eri b with the
Gemini Planet Imager
Macintosh, B.;
Graham, J. R.;
Barman, T.;
De Rosa, R. J.;
Konopacky, Q.;
Marley, M. S.;
Marois, C.;
Nielsen, E. L.;
Pueyo, L.;
Rajan, A.;
Rameau, J.;
Saumon, D.;
Wang, J. J.;
Patience, J.;
Ammons, M.;
Arriaga, P.;
Artigau, E.;
Beckwith, S.;
Brewster, J.;
Bruzzone, S.;
Bulger, J.;
Burningham, B.;
Burrows, A. S.;
Chen, C.;
Chiang, E.;
Chilcote, J. K.;
Dawson, R. I.;
Dong, R.;
Doyon, R.;
Draper, Z. H.;
Duchêne, G.;
Esposito, T. M.;
Fabrycky, D.;
Fitzgerald, M. P.;
Follette, K. B.;
Fortney, J. J.;
Gerard, B.;
Goodsell, S.;
Greenbaum, A. Z.;
Hibon, P.;
Hinkley, S.;
Cotten, T. H.;
Hung, L. -W.;
Ingraham, P.;
Johnson-Groh, M.;
Kalas, P.;
Lafreniere, D.;
Larkin, J. E.;
Lee, J.;
Line, M.;
Long, D.;
Maire, J.;
Marchis, F.;
Matthews, B. C.;
Max, C. E.;
Metchev, S.;
Millar-Blanchaer, M. A.;
Mittal, T.;
Morley, C. V.;
Morzinski, K. M.;
Murray-Clay, R.;
Oppenheimer, R.;
Palmer, D. W.;
Patel, R.;
Perrin, M. D.;
Poyneer, L. A.;
Rafikov, R. R.;
Rantakyrö, F. T.;
Rice, E. L.;
Rojo, P.;
Rudy, A. R.;
Ruffio, J. -B.;
Ruiz, M. T.;
Sadakuni, N.;
Saddlemyer, L.;
Salama, M.;
Savransky, D.;
Schneider, A. C.;
Sivaramakrishnan, A.;
Song, I.;
Soummer, R.;
Thomas, S.;
Vasisht, G.;
Wallace, J. K.;
Ward-Duong, K.;
Wiktorowicz, S. J.;
Wolff, S. G.;
Zuckerman, B.
Submitted: 2015-08-12, last modified: 2015-10-09
Directly detecting thermal emission from young extrasolar planets allows
measurement of their atmospheric composition and luminosity, which is
influenced by their formation mechanism. Using the Gemini Planet Imager, we
discovered a planet orbiting the \$sim$20 Myr-old star 51 Eridani at a
projected separation of 13 astronomical units. Near-infrared observations show
a spectrum with strong methane and water vapor absorption. Modeling of the
spectra and photometry yields a luminosity of L/LS=1.6-4.0 x 10-6 and an
effective temperature of 600-750 K. For this age and luminosity, "hot-start"
formation models indicate a mass twice that of Jupiter. This planet also has a
sufficiently low luminosity to be consistent with the "cold- start" core
accretion process that may have formed Jupiter.
[66]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.00902 [pdf] - 1280962
Spitzer Secondary Eclipse Observations of Five Cool Gas Giant Planets
and Empirical Trends in Cool Planet Emission Spectra
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Line, Michael R.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Deming, Drake;
Burrows, Adam;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Triaud, Amaury H. M. J.;
Agol, Eric;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Fulton, Benjamin J.;
Howard, Andrew W.;
Laughlin, Gregory P.;
Lewis, Nikole K.;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Showman, Adam P.;
Todorov, Kamen O.
Submitted: 2015-08-04
In this work we present Spitzer 3.6 and 4.5 micron secondary eclipse
observations of five new cool (<1200 K) transiting gas giant planets:
HAT-P-19b, WASP-6b, WASP-10b, WASP-39b, and WASP-67b. We compare our measured
eclipse depths to the predictions of a suite of atmosphere models and to
eclipse depths for planets with previously published observations in order to
constrain the temperature- and mass-dependent properties of gas giant planet
atmospheres. We find that the dayside emission spectra of planets less massive
than Jupiter require models with efficient circulation of energy to the night
side and/or increased albedos, while those with masses greater than that of
Jupiter are consistently best-matched by models with inefficient circulation
and low albedos. At these relatively low temperatures we expect the atmospheric
methane to CO ratio to vary as a function of metallicity, and we therefore use
our observations of these planets to constrain their atmospheric metallicities.
We find that the most massive planets have dayside emission spectra that are
best-matched by solar metallicity atmosphere models, but we are not able to
place strong constraints on metallicities of the smaller planets in our sample.
Interestingly, we find that the ratio of the 3.6 and 4.5 micron brightness
temperatures for these cool transiting planets is independent of planet
temperature, and instead exhibits a tentative correlation with planet mass. If
this trend can be confirmed, it would suggest that the shape of these planets'
emission spectra depends primarily on their masses, consistent with the
hypothesis that lower-mass planets are more likely to have metal-rich
atmospheres.
[67]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.06670 [pdf] - 1245753
Uniform Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of Ultracool Dwarfs I:
Characterizing Benchmarks, Gl570D and HD3651B
Submitted: 2015-04-24, last modified: 2015-05-28
Interpreting the spectra of brown dwarfs is key to determining the
fundamental physical and chemical processes occurring in their atmospheres.
Powerful Bayesian atmospheric retrieval tools have recently been applied to
both exoplanet and brown dwarf spectra to tease out the thermal structures and
molecular abundances to understand those processes. In this manuscript we
develop a significantly upgraded retrieval method and apply it to the SpeX
spectral library data of two benchmark late T-dwarfs, Gl570D and HD3651B, to
establish the validity of our upgraded forward model parameterization and
Bayesian estimator. Our retrieved metallicities, gravities, and effective
temperature are consistent with the metallicity and presumed ages of the
systems. We add the carbon-to-oxygen ratio as a new dimension to benchmark
systems and find good agreement between carbon-to-oxygens ratio derived in the
brown dwarfs and the host stars. Furthermore, we have for the first time
unambiguously determined the presence of ammonia in the low-resolution spectra
of these two late T-dwarfs. We also show that the retrieved results are not
significantly impacted by the possible presence of clouds, though some
quantities are significantly impacted by uncertainties in photometry. This
investigation represents a watershed study in establishing the utility of
atmospheric retrieval approaches on brown dwarf spectra.
[68]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.2382 [pdf] - 1222485
The Atmospheric Circulation of the Hot Jupiter WASP-43b: Comparing
Three-Dimensional Models to Spectrophotometric Data
Submitted: 2014-10-09, last modified: 2015-01-12
The hot Jupiter WASP-43b has now joined the ranks of transiting hot Jupiters
HD 189733b and HD 209458b as an exoplanet with a large array of observational
constraints on its atmospheric properties. Because WASP-43b receives a similar
stellar flux as HD 209458b but has a rotation rate 4 times faster and a much
higher gravity, studying WASP-43b serves as a test of the effect of rotation
rate and gravity on the circulation when stellar irradiation is held
approximately constant. Here we present 3D atmospheric circulation models of
WASP-43b using the SPARC/MITgcm, a coupled radiation and circulation model,
exploring the effects of composition, metallicity, and frictional drag. We find
that the circulation regime of WASP-43b is not unlike other hot Jupiters, with
equatorial superrotation that yields an eastward-shifted hotspot and large
day-night temperature variations (~600 K at photospheric pressures). We then
compare our model results to observations from Stevenson et al. which utilize
HST/WFC3 to collect spectrophotometric phase curve measurements of WASP-43b
from 1.12-1.65 microns. Our results show the 5x solar model lightcurve provides
a good match to the data, with a phase offset of peak flux and planet/star flux
ratio that is similar to observations; however, the model nightside appears to
be brighter. Nevertheless, our 5x solar model provides an excellent match to
the WFC3 dayside emission spectrum. This is a major success, as the result is a
natural outcome of the 3D dynamics with no model tuning, and differs
significantly from 1D models that can generally only match observations when
appropriately tuned. In sum, these results demonstrate that 3D circulation
models can provide important insights in interpreting exoplanet atmospheric
observations, even at high spectral resolution, and highlight the potential for
future observations with HST, JWST and other next-generation telescopes.
[69]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.8440 [pdf] - 915612
A Quick Study of the Characterization of Radial Velocity Giant Planets
in Reflected Light by Forward and Inverse Modeling
Submitted: 2014-12-29
We explored two aspects of the problem of characterizing cool extrasolar
giant planets in scattered optical light with a space based coronagraph. First,
for a number of the known radial velocity (RV) giants we computed traditional
forward models of their atmospheric structure and clouds, given various input
assumptions, and computed model albedo spectra. Such models have been computed
before, but mostly for generic planets. Our new models demonstrate that there
is likely interesting spectral diversity among those planets that are most
favorable for direct detection. Second, we applied a powerful Markov Chain
Monte Carlo (MCMC) retrieval technique to synthetic noisy data of cool giants
to better understand how well various atmospheric parameters--particularly
molecular abundances and cloud properties--could be constrained. This is the
first time such techniques have been applied to this problem. The process is
time consuming, so only a dozen or so cases could be completed in the limited
time available. Nevertheless the results clearly show that even at S/N ~ 5,
scientifically interesting and valuable conclusions can be drawn about the
properties of giant planet atmospheres from noisy spectra. We find that
atmospheric abundances are best constrained when the planet gravity is bounded.
Thus direct imaging observations of known radial velocity planets are extremely
valuable as limits on a target planet's gravity can be obtained from
astrometric imaging and reflectivity and mass-radius relationship arguments
(for mass and radius, respectively). Further retrieval studies are clearly
warranted and would be valuable to help guide instrument design decisions.
[70]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.2255 [pdf] - 878510
A Precise Water Abundance Measurement for the Hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Kreidberg, Laura;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Désert, Jean-Michel;
Line, Michael R.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Showman, Adam P.;
Charbonneau, David;
McCullough, Peter R.;
Seager, Sara;
Burrows, Adam;
Henry, Gregory W.;
Williamson, Michael;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Homeier, Derek
Submitted: 2014-10-08
The water abundance in a planetary atmosphere provides a key constraint on
the planet's primordial origins because water ice is expected to play an
important role in the core accretion model of planet formation. However, the
water content of the Solar System giant planets is not well known because water
is sequestered in clouds deep in their atmospheres. By contrast, short-period
exoplanets have such high temperatures that their atmospheres have water in the
gas phase, making it possible to measure the water abundance for these objects.
We present a precise determination of the water abundance in the atmosphere of
the 2 $M_\mathrm{Jup}$ short-period exoplanet WASP-43b based on thermal
emission and transmission spectroscopy measurements obtained with the Hubble
Space Telescope. We find the water content is consistent with the value
expected in a solar composition gas at planetary temperatures (0.4-3.5x solar
at 1 $\sigma$ confidence). The metallicity of WASP-43b's atmosphere suggested
by this result extends the trend observed in the Solar System of lower metal
enrichment for higher planet masses.
[71]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.2241 [pdf] - 900868
Thermal structure of an exoplanet atmosphere from phase-resolved
emission spectroscopy
Stevenson, Kevin B.;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Line, Michael R.;
Bean, Jacob L.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Showman, Adam P.;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Kreidberg, Laura;
McCullough, Peter R.;
Henry, Gregory W.;
Charbonneau, David;
Burrows, Adam;
Seager, Sara;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Williamson, Michael H.;
Homeier, Derek
Submitted: 2014-10-08
Exoplanets that orbit close to their host stars are much more highly
irradiated than their Solar System counterparts. Understanding the thermal
structures and appearances of these planets requires investigating how their
atmospheres respond to such extreme stellar forcing. We present spectroscopic
thermal emission measurements as a function of orbital phase ("phase-curve
observations") for the highly-irradiated exoplanet WASP-43b spanning three full
planet rotations using the Hubble Space Telescope. With these data, we
construct a map of the planet's atmospheric thermal structure, from which we
find large day-night temperature variations at all measured altitudes and a
monotonically decreasing temperature with pressure at all longitudes. We also
derive a Bond albedo of 0.18 +0.07,-0.12 and an altitude dependence in the
hot-spot offset relative to the substellar point.
[72]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.5336 [pdf] - 894759
New Analysis Indicates No Thermal Inversion in the Atmosphere of HD
209458b
Submitted: 2014-09-18
An important focus of exoplanet research is the determination of the
atmospheric temperature structure of strongly irradiated gas giant planets, or
hot Jupiters. HD 209458b is the prototypical exoplanet for atmospheric thermal
inversions, but this assertion does not take into account recently obtained
data or newer data reduction techniques. We re-examine this claim by
investigating all publicly available Spitzer Space Telescope secondary-eclipse
photometric data of HD 209458b and performing a self-consistent analysis. We
employ data reduction techniques that minimize stellar centroid variations,
apply sophisticated models to known Spitzer systematics, and account for
time-correlated noise in the data. We derive new secondary-eclipse depths of
0.119 +/- 0.007%, 0.123 +/- 0.006%, 0.134 +/- 0.035%, and 0.215 +/- 0.008% in
the 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 micron bandpasses, respectively. We feed these
results into a Bayesian atmospheric retrieval analysis and determine that it is
unnecessary to invoke a thermal inversion to explain our secondary-eclipse
depths. The data are well-fitted by a temperature model that decreases
monotonically between pressure levels of 1 and 0.01 bars. We conclude that
there is no evidence for a thermal inversion in the atmosphere of HD 209458b.
[73]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.6412 [pdf] - 1208579
An Approach for Retrieving Temperatures and Abundances in Brown Dwarf
Atmospheres
Submitted: 2014-03-25, last modified: 2014-07-31
Brown dwarf spectra contain a wealth of information about their molecular
abundances, temperature structure, and gravity. We present a new data driven
retrieval approach, previously used in planetary atmosphere studies, to extract
the molecular abundances and temperature structure from brown dwarf spectra.
The feasibility of the approach is first demonstrated on a synthetic brown
dwarf spectrum. Given typical spectral resolutions, wavelength coverage, and
noise properties precisions of tens of percent can be obtained for the
molecular abundances and 10s-100s K on the temperature profile. The technique
is then applied to the well studied brown dwarf, Gl 570D. From this spectral
retrieval the spectroscopic radius is constrained to be 0.75 - 0.83
$R_{\mathrm{J}}$, $\log(g)$ to be 5.13 - 5.46 and $T_{\mathrm{eff}}$ to be
between 804 and 849 K. Estimates for the range of abundances and allowed
temperature profiles are also derived. The results from our retrieval approach
are in agreement with the self-consistent grid modeling results of Saumon et al
(2006). This new approach will allow us to address issues of compositional
differences between brown dwarfs and possibly their formation environments,
disequilibrium chemistry, missing physics in current grid modeling approaches
as well as a many other issues.
[74]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.2118 [pdf] - 1215488
Mid-Infrared Spectroscopy of Uranus from the Spitzer Infrared
Spectrometer: 2. Determination of the Mean Composition of the Upper
Troposphere and Stratosphere
Orton, Glenn S.;
Moses, J. I.;
Fletcher, Leigh N.;
Mainzer, Amy K.;
Hines, Dean;
Hammel, Heidi B.;
Martin-Torres, Javier;
Burgdorf, Martin;
Merlet, Cecile;
Line, Michael R.
Submitted: 2014-07-08
Mid-infrared spectral observations Uranus acquired with the Infrared
Spectrometer (IRS) on the Spitzer Space Telescope are used to determine the
abundances of C2H2, C2H6, CH3C2H, C4H2, CO2, and tentatively CH3 on Uranus at
the time of the 2007 equinox. For vertically uniform eddy diffusion
coefficients in the range 2200-2600 cm2 s-1, photochemical models that
reproduce the observed methane emission also predict C2H6 profiles that compare
well with emission in the 11.6-12.5 micron wavelength region, where the nu9
band of C2H6 is prominent. Our nominal model with a uniform eddy diffusion
coefficient Kzz = 2430 cm2 sec-1 and a CH4 tropopause mole fraction of 1.6x10-5
provides a good fit to other hydrocarbon emission features, such as those of
C2H2 and C4H2, but the model profile for CH3C2H must be scaled by a factor of
0.43, suggesting that improvements are needed in the chemical reaction
mechanism for C3Hx species. The nominal model is consistent with a CH3D/CH4
ratio of 3.0+-0.2x10-4. From the best-fit scaling of these photochemical-model
profiles, we derive column abundances above the 10-mbar level of 4.5+01.1/-0.8
x 10+19 molecule-cm-2 for CH4, 6.2 +- 1.0 x 10+16 molecule-cm-2 for C2H2 (with
a value 24% higher from a different longitudinal sampling), 3.1 +- 0.3 x 10+16
molecule-cm-2 for C2H6, 8.6 +- 2.6 x 10+13 molecule-cm-2 for CH3C2H, 1.8 +- 0.3
x 10+13 molecule-cm-2 for C4H2, and 1.7 +- 0.4 x 10+13 molecule-cm-2 for CO2 on
Uranus. Our results have implications with respect to the influx rate of
exogenic oxygen species and the production rate of stratospheric hazes on
Uranus, as well as the C4H2 vapor pressure over C4H2 ice at low temperatures.
[75]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.2120 [pdf] - 1215489
Mid-Infrared Spectroscopy of Uranus from the Spitzer Infrared
Spectrometer: 1. Determination of the Mean Temperature Structure of the Upper
Troposphere and Stratosphere
Orton, Glenn S.;
Fletcher, Leigh N.;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Mainzer, Amy K.;
Hines, Dean;
Hammel, Heidi B.;
Martin-Torres, F. Javier;
Burgdorf, Martin;
Merlet, Cecile;
Line, Michael R.
Submitted: 2014-07-08
On 2007 December 16-17, spectra were acquired of the disk of Uranus by the
Spitzer Infrared Spectrometer (IRS) when its equator was close to the sub-earth
point. This spectrum provides the highest-resolution broad-band spectrum ever
obtained for Uranus from space, allowing a determination of the disk-averaged
temperature and molecule composition to a greater degree of accuracy than ever
before. The temperature profiles derived from the Voyager radio occultation
experiments that match these data best are those that assume a high abundance
of methane in the deep atmosphere, but none of these models provides a
satisfactory fit over the full spectral range. This be the result of spatial
differences between global and low-latitudinal regions, changes in time,
missing continuum opacity sources such as stratospheric hazes or unknown
tropospheric constituents, or undiagnosed systematic problems with either the
radio-occultation or the Spitzer IRS data sets. The spectrum is compatible with
the stratospheric temperatures derived from the Voyager ultraviolet
occultations measurements. Thermospheric temperatures determined from the
analysis of the observed H2 quadrupole emission features are colder than those
derived by Herbert et al. at pressures less than ~1 microbar. Extrapolation of
the nominal model spectrum to far-infrared through millimeter wavelengths shows
that the spectrum arising solely from H2 collision-induced absorption is too
warm to reproduce observations between wavelengths of 0.8 and 3.3 mm. Adding an
additional absorber such as H2S provides a reasonable match to the spectrum,
although a unique identification of the responsible absorber is not yet
possible with available data. An immediate practical use for the spectrum
resulting from this model is to establish a high-precision continuum flux model
for use as an absolute radiometric standard for future astronomical
observations.
[76]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.6663 [pdf] - 1179499
A Systematic Retrieval Analysis of Secondary Eclipse Spectra II: A
Uniform Analysis of Eight Planets and Their C to O Ratios
Submitted: 2013-09-25, last modified: 2014-01-29
Secondary eclipse spectroscopy provides invaluable insights into the
temperatures and compositions of exoplanetary atmospheres. We carry out a
systematic temperature and abundance retrieval analysis of nine exoplanets
(HD189733b, HD209458b, HD149026b, GJ436b, WASP-12b, WASP-19b, WASP-43b,
TrES-2b, and TrES-3b) observed in secondary eclipse using a combination of
space- and ground-based facilities. Our goal with this analysis is to provide a
consistent set of temperatures and compositions from which self-consistent
models can be compared and to probe the underlying processes that shape these
atmospheres. This paper is the second in a three part series of papers
exploring the retrievability of temperatures and abundances from secondary
eclipse spectra and the implications of these results for the chemistry of
exoplanet atmospheres. In this investigation we present a catalogue of
temperatures and abundances for H$_2$O, CH$_4$, CO, and CO$_2$. We find that
our temperatures and abundances are generally consistent with those of previous
studies, although we do not find any statistically convincing evidence for
super-solar C to O ratios (e.g., solar C/O falls in the 1-sigma confidence
intervals in eight of the nine planets in our sample). Furthermore, within our
sample we find little evidence for thermal inversions over a wide range of
effective temperatures (with the exception of HD209458b), consistent with
previous investigations. The lack of evidence for inversions for most planets
in our sample over such a wide range of effective temperatures provides
additional support for the hypothesis that TiO is unlikely to be the absorber
responsible for the formation of these inversions.
[77]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.7601 [pdf] - 1203056
On the Detection of Molecules in the Atmosphere of HD189733b using HST
NICMOS Transmission Spectroscopy
Submitted: 2014-01-29
The HST/NICMOS transmission spectrum measurements of HD 189733b that suggest
the detection of methane (CH$_{4}$) in an exoplanet atmosphere have been a
source of significant controversy. With what is probably the best analyzed
exoplanet spectroscopy data set to date, different teams, using different
methods, have claimed evidence both contradicting and supporting the original
findings. Here, we report results from a uniform spectral retrieval analysis of
the three, independent, published spectra together with null hypothesis
testing. Based on Bayesian model comparison, we find that two of the three
spectra show strong evidence ($\geq$ 3.6$\sigma$) for the detection of
molecular features mainly due to water and methane while the third is
consistent with a weak molecular detection at the 2.2$\sigma$ level. We
interpret the agreement in the spectral modulation established by previous
authors and the atmospheric retrieval results presented here, as a confirmation
of the original detection of molecular absorbers in the atmosphere of HD
189733b.
[78]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.4796 [pdf] - 1180028
A Near-Infrared Transmission Spectrum for the Warm Saturn HAT-P-12b
Submitted: 2013-10-17
We present a HST WFC3 transmission spectrum for the transiting exoplanet
HAT-P-12b. This warm (1000 K) sub-Saturn-mass planet has a smaller mass and a
lower temperature than the hot-Jupiters that have been studied so far. We find
that the planet's measured transmission spectrum lacks the expected water
absorption feature for a hydrogen-dominated atmosphere, and is instead
best-described by a model with high-altitude clouds. Using a frequentist
hypothesis testing procedure, we can rule out a hydrogen-dominated cloud free
atmosphere to 4.9$\sigma$. When combined with other recent WFC3 studies, our
observations suggest that clouds may be common in exo-planetary atmospheres.
[79]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.6679 [pdf] - 1179500
A Systematic Retrieval Analysis of Secondary Eclipse Spectra III:
Diagnosing Chemical Disequilibrium in Planetary Atmospheres
Submitted: 2013-09-25
Chemical disequilibrium has recently become a relevant topic in the study of
the atmospheres of of transiting extrasolar planets, brown dwarfs, and directly
imaged exoplanets. We present a new way of assessing whether or not a
Jovian-like atmosphere is in chemical disequilibrium from observations of
detectable or inferred gases such as H$_2$O, CH$_4$, CO, and H$_2$. Our
hypothesis, based on previous kinetic modeling studies, is that cooler
atmospheres will show stronger signs of disequilibrium than hotter atmospheres.
We verify this with chemistry-transport models and show that planets with
temperatures less than $\sim$1200 K are likely to show the strongest signs of
disequilibrium due to the vertical quenching of CO, and that our new approach
is able to capture this process. We also find that in certain instances a
planetary composition may appear in equilibrium when it actually is not due to
the degeneracy in the shape of the vertical mixing ratio profiles. We determine
the state of disequilibrium in eight exoplanets using the results from
secondary eclipse temperature and abundance retrievals. We find that all of the
planets in our sample are consistent with thermochemical equilibrium to within
3-sigma. Future observations are needed to further constrain the abundances in
order to definitively identify disequilibrium in exoplanet atmospheres.
[80]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.5561 [pdf] - 1166123
A Systematic Retrieval Analysis of Secondary Eclipse Spectra I: A
Comparison of Atmospheric Retrieval Techniques
Submitted: 2013-04-19, last modified: 2013-08-22
Spectra of exoplanet atmospheres provide us the opportunity to improve our
understanding of these objects just as remote sensing in our own solar system
has increased our understanding of the solar system bodies. The challenge is to
quantitatively determine the range of temperatures and species abundances
allowed by the data. This challenge is often difficult given the low
information content of most exoplanet spectra which commonly leads to
degeneracies in the interpretation. A variety of temperature and abundance
retrieval approaches have been applied to exoplanet spectra, but no previous
investigations have sought to compare these approaches. In this investigation
we compare three different retrieval methods: Optimal Estimation, Differential
Evolution Markov Chain Monte Carlo, and Bootstrap Monte Carlo. We call our
suite of retrieval algorithms the Caltech Inverse Modeling and Retrieval
Algorithms (CHIMERA). We discuss what we can expect in terms of uncertainties
in abundances and temperatures given current observations as well as potential
future observations and what conclusions can be drawn given those
uncertainties. In general we find that the three approaches agree for high
quality spectra expected to come from potential future spaceborne missions, but
disagree for low quality spectra representative of current observations. We
also show that the Gaussian posterior probability distribution assumption made
in the Optimal Estimation approach is valid for high quality spectral data. We
also discuss the implications of our models for the inferred C to O ratios of
exoplanetary atmospheres, which of course are important for understanding
formation environments. More specifically we show that in the observational
limit of a few photometric points, the retrieved C/O is biased towards values
near solar and near one simply due to the assumption of uninformative priors.
[81]
oai:arXiv.org:1302.1141 [pdf] - 1159520
Infrared Transmission Spectroscopy of the Exoplanets HD209458b and XO-1b
Using the Wide Field Camera-3 on the Hubble Space Telescope
Deming, Drake;
Wilkins, Ashlee;
McCullough, Peter;
Burrows, Adam;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Agol, Eric;
Dobbs-Dixon, Ian;
Madhusudhan, Nikku;
Crouzet, Nicolas;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Gilliland, Ronald L.;
Haynes, Korey;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Line, Michael;
Magic, Zazralt;
Mandell, Avi M.;
Ranjan, Sukrit;
Charbonneau, David;
Clampin, Mark;
Seager, Sara;
Showman, Adam P.
Submitted: 2013-02-05, last modified: 2013-07-12
Exoplanetary transmission spectroscopy in the near-infrared using
Hubble/NICMOS is currently ambiguous because different observational groups
claim different results from the same data, depending on their analysis
methodologies. Spatial scanning with Hubble/WFC3 provides an opportunity to
resolve this ambiguity. We here report WFC3 spectroscopy of the giant planets
HD209458b and XO-1b in transit, using spatial scanning mode for maximum
photon-collecting efficiency. We introduce an analysis technique that derives
the exoplanetary transmission spectrum without the necessity of explicitly
decorrelating instrumental effects, and achieves nearly photon-limited
precision even at the high flux levels collected in spatial scan mode. Our
errors are within 6-percent (XO-1) and 26-percent (HD209458b) of the
photon-limit at a spectral resolving power of 70, and are better than
0.01-percent per spectral channel. Both planets exhibit water absorption of
approximately 200 ppm at the water peak near 1.38 microns. Our result for XO-1b
contradicts the much larger absorption derived from NICMOS spectroscopy. The
weak water absorption we measure for HD209458b is reminiscent of the weakness
of sodium absorption in the first transmission spectroscopy of an exoplanet
atmosphere by Charbonneau et al. (2002). Model atmospheres having
uniformly-distributed extra opacity of 0.012 cm^2 per gram account
approximately for both our water measurement and the sodium absorption in this
planet. Our results for HD209458b support the picture advocated by Pont et al.
(2013) in which weak molecular absorptions are superposed on a transmission
spectrum that is dominated by continuous opacity due to haze and/or dust.
However, the extra opacity needed for HD209458b is grayer than for HD189733b,
with a weaker Rayleigh component.
[82]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.5178 [pdf] - 1172201
Compositional diversity in the atmospheres of hot Neptunes, with
application to GJ 436b
Submitted: 2013-06-21
Neptune-sized extrasolar planets that orbit relatively close to their host
stars -- often called "hot Neptunes" -- are common within the known population
of exoplanets and planetary candidates. Similar to our own Uranus and Neptune,
inefficient accretion of nebular gas is expected produce hot Neptunes whose
masses are dominated by elements heavier than hydrogen and helium. At high
atmospheric metallicities of 10-10,000x solar, hot Neptunes will exhibit an
interesting continuum of atmospheric compositions, ranging from more
Neptune-like, H2-dominated atmospheres to more Venus-like, CO2-dominated
atmospheres. We explore the predicted equilibrium and disequilibrium chemistry
of generic hot Neptunes and find that the atmospheric composition varies
strongly as a function of temperature and bulk atmospheric properties such as
metallicity and the C/O ratio. Relatively exotic H2O, CO, CO2, and even
O2-dominated atmospheres are possible for hot Neptunes. We apply our models to
the case of GJ 436b, where we find that a CO-rich, CH4-poor atmosphere can be a
natural consequence of a very high atmospheric metallicity. From comparisons of
our results with Spitzer eclipse data for GJ 436b, we conclude that although
the spectral fit from the high-metallicity forward models is not quite as good
as the fit obtained from pure retrieval methods, the atmospheric composition
predicted by these forward models is more physically and chemically plausible.
High-metallicity atmospheres (orders of magnitude in excess of solar) should
therefore be considered as a possibility for GJ 436b and other hot Neptunes.
[83]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.4736 [pdf] - 1123554
Probing the extreme planetary atmosphere of WASP-12b
Swain, Mark;
Deroo, Pieter;
Tinetti, Giovanna;
Hollis, Morgan;
Tessenyi, Marcell;
Line, Michael;
Kawahara, Hajime;
Fujii, Yuka;
Showman, Adam;
Yurchenko, Sergey
Submitted: 2012-05-21, last modified: 2013-05-22
We report near-infrared measurements of the terminator region transmission
spectrum and dayside emission spectrum of the exoplanet WASP-12b obtained using
the HST WFC3 instrument. The disk-average dayside brightness temperature
averages about 2900 K, peaking to 3200 K around 1.46 microns. We modeled a
range of atmospheric cases for both the emission and transmission spectrum and
confirm the recent finding by Crossfield et al. (2012b) that there is no
evidence for C/O >1 in the atmosphere of WASP-12b. Assuming a physically
plausible atmosphere, we find evidence that the presence of a number of
molecules is consistent with the data, but the justification for inclusion of
these opacity sources based on the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) is
marginal. We also find the near-infrared primary eclipse light curve is
consistent with small amounts of prolate distortion. As part of the calibration
effort for these data, we conducted a detailed study of instrument systematics
using 65 orbits of WFC3-IR grims observations. The instrument systematics are
dominated by detector-related affects, which vary significantly depending on
the detector readout mode. The 256x256 subarray observations of WASP 12
produced spectral measurements within 15% of the photon-noise limit using a
simple calibration approach. Residual systematics are estimated to be less than
70 parts per million.
[84]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.0762 [pdf] - 1117741
Sodium Atoms in the Lunar Exotail: Observed Velocity and Spatial
Distributions
Submitted: 2012-04-03
The lunar sodium tail extends long distances due to radiation pressure on
sodium atoms in the lunar exosphere. Our earlier observations measured the
average radial velocity of sodium atoms moving down the lunar tail beyond Earth
(i.e., near the anti-lunar point) to be $\sim 12.5$ km/s. Here we use the
Wisconsin H-alpha Mapper to obtain the first kinematically resolved maps of the
intensity and velocity distribution of this emission over a $15 \times 15 \deg$
region on the sky near the anti-lunar point. We present both spatially and
spectrally resolved observations obtained over four nights bracketing new Moon
in October 2007. The spatial distribution of the sodium atoms is elongated
along the ecliptic with the location of the peak intensity drifting $3 \deg$
east along the ecliptic per night. Preliminary modeling results suggest the
spatial and velocity distributions in the sodium exotail are sensitive to the
near surface lunar sodium velocity distribution. Future observations of this
sort along with detailed modeling offer new opportunities to describe the time
history of lunar surface sputtering over several days.
[85]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.2612 [pdf] - 1091572
Information Content of Exoplanetary Transit Spectra: An Initial Look
Submitted: 2011-11-10
It has been shown that spectroscopy of transiting extrasolar planets can
potentially provide a wealth of information about their atmospheres. Herein, we
set up the inverse problem in spectroscopic retrieval. We use non-linear
optimal estimation to retrieve the atmospheric state (pioneered for Earth
sounding by Rodgers 1976, 2000). The formulation quantifies the the
degrees-of-freedom and information content of the spectrum with respect to
geophysical parameters; herein, we focus specifically on temperature and
composition. First, we apply the technique to synthetic near infrared spectra,
and explore the influence of spectral signal-to-noise ratio and resolution (the
two important parameters when designing a future instrument) on the information
content of the data. As expected, we find that the number of retrievable
parameters increase with increasing signal-to-noise and resolution, although
the gains quickly asymptote for large values. Second, we apply the methods to
the previously studied atmosphere of HD198733b, and compare the results of our
retrieval with those obtained by others.
[86]
oai:arXiv.org:1104.3183 [pdf] - 1053418
Thermochemistry and Photochemistry in Cooler Hydrogen Dominated
Extrasolar Planets: The Case of GJ436b
Submitted: 2011-04-15, last modified: 2011-08-03
We introduce a new thermochemical kinetics and photochemical model. We use
high-temperature bidirectional reaction rates for important H, C, O and N
reactions (most importantly for CH$_4$ to CO interconversion), allowing us to
attain thermochemical equilibrium, deep in an atmosphere, purely kinetically.
This allows ab initio chemical modeling of an entire atmosphere, from
deep-atmosphere thermochemical equilibrium to the photochemically dominated
regime. We use our model to explore the atmospheric chemistry of cooler
($T_{eff} < 10^3$ K) extrasolar giant planets. In particular, we choose to
model the nearby hot Neptune GJ436b, the only planet in this temperature regime
for which spectroscopic measurements and estimates of chemical abundances now
exist. Recent {\it Spitzer} measurements with retrieval have shown that methane
is driven strongly out of equilibrium and is deeply depleted on the dayside of
GJ 436b, whereas quenched carbon monoxide is abundant. This is surprising
because GJ 436b is cooler than many of the heavily irradiated hot Jovians and
thermally favorable for CH$_4$, and thus requires an efficient mechanism for
destroying it. We include realistic estimates of ultraviolet flux from the
parent dM star GJ 436, to bound the direct photolysis and photosensitized
depletion of CH$_4$. While our models indicate fairly rich disequilibrium
conditions are likely in cooler exoplanets over a range of planetary
metallicities, we are unable to generate the conditions for substantial CH$_4$
destruction. One possibility is an anomalous source of abundant H atoms between
0.01-1 bars (which attack CH$_4$), but we cannot as yet identify an efficient
means to produce these hot atoms.
[87]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.4029 [pdf] - 1026484
High Temperature Photochemistry in the Atmosphere of HD189733b
Submitted: 2010-04-22
Recent infrared spectroscopy of hot exoplanets is beginning to reveal their
atmospheric composition. Deep with in the planetary atmosphere, the composition
is controlled by thermochemical equilibrium. Photochemistry becomes important
higher in the atmosphere, at levels above ~1 bar. These two chemistries compete
between ~1-10 bars in hot Jupiter-like atmospheres, depending on the strength
of the eddy mixing and temperature. HD189733b provides an excellent laboratory
in which to study the consequences of chemistry of hot atmospheres. The recent
spectra of HD189733b and HD209458b contain signatures of CH4, CO2, CO and H2O.
Here we identify the primary chemical pathways that govern the abundances of
CH4, CO2, CO and H2O in the cases of thermochemical equilibrium chemistry,
photochemistry, and their combination. Our results suggest that the abundance
of these species can be photochemically enhanced above or below the
thermochemical equilibrium value, so some caution must be taken when assuming
that an atmosphere is in strict thermochemical equilibrium.