Normalized to: Lawler, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.10674 [pdf] - 2117757
OSSOS: The Bimodal Eccentricity and Inclination Distributions of the
Stable Neptunian Trojans
Lin, Hsing Wen;
Chen, Ying-Tung;
Volk, Kathryn;
Gladman, Brett;
Murray-Clay, Ruth;
Alexandersen, Mike;
Bannister, Michele T.;
Lawler, Samantha M.;
Ip, Wing-Huen;
Lykawka, Patryk Sofia;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Gwyn, Stephen D. J.;
Petit, Jean-Marc
Submitted: 2020-06-18
The minor planets on orbits that are dynamically stable in Neptune's 1:1
resonance on Gyr timescales were likely emplaced by Neptune's outward
migration. We explore the intrinsic libration amplitude, eccentricity, and
inclination distribution of Neptune's stable Trojans, using the detections and
survey efficiency of the Outer Solar System Origins Survey (OSSOS) and
Pan-STARRS1. We find that the libration amplitude of the stable Neptunian
Trojan population can be well modeled as a Rayleigh distribution with a
libration amplitude width $\sigma_{A_phi}$ of 15$^\circ$. When taken as a
whole, the Neptune Trojan population can be acceptably modeled with a Rayleigh
eccentricity distribution of width $\sigma_e$ of 0.045 and a typical sin(i) x
gaussian inclination distribution with a width $\sigma_i$ of 14 +/- 2 degrees.
However, these distributions are only marginally acceptable. This is likely
because, even after accounting for survey detection biases, the known large Hr
< 8 and small Hr >= 8 Neptune Trojans appear to have markedly different
eccentricities and inclinations. We propose that like the classical Kuiper
belt, the stable intrinsic Neptunian Trojan population have dynamically `hot'
and dynamically `cold' components to its eccentricity/inclination distribution,
with $\sigma_{e-cold}$ ~ 0.02 / $\sigma_{i-cold}$ ~ 6$^\circ$ and
$\sigma_{e-hot}$~ 0.05 / $\sigma_{i-hot}$ ~ 18$^\circ$. In this scenario, the
`cold' L4 Neptunian Trojan population lacks the Hr >= 8 member and has 13
+11/-6 `cold' Trojans with Hr < 8. On the other hand, the `hot' L4 Neptunian
Trojan population has 136 +57/-48 Trojans with Hr < 10 -- a population 2.4
times greater than that of the L4 Jovian Trojans in the same luminosity range.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.11174 [pdf] - 2034553
A study of the high-inclination population in the Kuiper belt -- III.
The 4:7 mean motion resonance
Submitted: 2019-12-23
The high-inclination population in the 4:7 mean motion resonance (MMR) with
Neptune has also substantial eccentricities ($e\gtrsim0.1$), with more inclined
objects tending to occupy more eccentric orbits. For this high-order resonance,
there are two different resonant modes. The principal one is the
eccentricity-type mode, and we find that libration is permissible for orbits
with $e\ge e_c^0$, where the critical eccentricity $e_c^0$ increases as a
function of increasing inclination $i$. Correspondingly, we introduce a
limiting curve $e_c^0(i)$, which puts constraints on the $(e, i)$ distribution
of possible 4:7 resonators. We then perform numerical simulations on the
sweep-up capture and long-term stability of the 4:7 MMR, and the results show
that the simulated resonators are well-constrained by this theoretical limiting
curve. The other 4:7 resonant mode is the mixed-$(e, i)$-type, and we show that
stable resonators should exist at $i\gtrsim20^{\circ}$. We predict that the
intrinsic number of these mixed-$(e, i)$-type resonators may provide a new clue
into the Solar system's evolution, but, so far, only one real object has been
observed resonating in this mode.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.10320 [pdf] - 2097269
Opportunities and Outcomes for Postdocs in Canada
Submitted: 2019-11-23
Currently, postdoctoral fellow (PDF) researchers in Canada face challenges
due to the precarious nature of their employment and their overall low
compensation and benefits coverage. This report presents three themes, written
as statements of need, to support an inclusive and thriving PDF community.
These themes are the need for better terms of employment and conditions, the
need for access to grants by non-permanent research staff, and the need for a
sustainable PDF hiring model that considers the outcomes for the PDFs.
We make six recommendations:
R1. PDFs should be hired and compensated as skilled experts in their areas,
not as trainees.
R2. Standard PDF hiring practices should be revised to be more inclusive of
different life circumstances.
- R2.1 Allow PDFs the option of part-time employment.
- R2.2 Remove years-since-PhD time limits from PDF jobs.
- R2.3 Financially support PDF hires for relocation and visa expenses.
R3. CASCA should form a committee to advocate for and provide support to
astronomy PDFs in Canada.
R4. CASCA should encourage universities to create offices dedicated to their
PDFs.
R5. PDFs and other PhD-holding term researchers with a host institution
should be able to compete for and win grants to self-fund their own research.
R6. Astronomy in Canada should hire general-purpose continuing support
scientist positions instead of term PDFs to fill project or mission-specific
requirements.
In short, we ask for prioritization of people over production of papers.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.12985 [pdf] - 2026175
OSSOS XVIII: Constraining migration models with the 2:1 resonance using
the Outer Solar System Origins Survey
Chen, Ying-Tung;
Gladman, Brett;
Volk, Kathryn;
Murray-Clay, Ruth;
Lehner, Matthew J.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Wang, Shiang-Yu;
Lin, Hsing-Wen;
Lykawka, Patryk Sofia;
Alexandersen, Mike;
Bannister, Michele T.;
Lawler, Samantha M.;
Dawson, Rebekah I.;
Greenstreet, Sarah;
Gwyn, Stephen D. J.;
Petit, Jean-Marc
Submitted: 2019-10-28, last modified: 2019-10-31
Resonant dynamics plays a significant role in the past evolution and current
state of our outer Solar System. The population ratios and spatial distribution
of Neptune's resonant populations are direct clues to understanding the history
of our planetary system. The orbital structure of the objects in Neptune's 2:1
mean-motion resonance (\emph{twotinos}) has the potential to be a tracer of
planetary migration processes. Different migration processes produce distinct
architectures, recognizable by well-characterized surveys. However, previous
characterized surveys only discovered a few twotinos, making it impossible to
model the intrinsic twotino population. With a well-designed cadence and nearly
100\% tracking success, the Outer Solar System Origins Survey (OSSOS)
discovered 838 trans-Neptunian objects, of which 34 are securely twotinos with
well-constrained libration angles and amplitudes. We use the OSSOS twotinos and
the survey characterization parameters via the OSSOS Survey Simulator to
inspect the intrinsic population and orbital distributions of twotino. The
estimated twotino population, 4400$^{+1500}_{-1100}$ with $H_r<8.66$
(diameter$\sim$100km) at 95\% confidence, is consistent with the previous
low-precision estimate. We also constrain the width of the inclination
distribution to a relatively narrow value of $\sigma_i$=6$^\circ$$^{+1}_{-1}$,
and find the eccentricity distribution is consistent with a Gaussian centered
on $e_\mathrm{c}=0.275$ with a width $e_\mathrm{w}=0.06$. We find a
single-slope exponential luminosity function with $\alpha=0.6$ for the
twotinos. Finally, we for the first time meaningfully constrain the fraction of
symmetric twotinos, and the ratio of the leading asymmetric islands; both
fractions are in a range of 0.2--0.6. These measurements rule out certain
theoretical models of Neptune's migration history.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.13480 [pdf] - 2097244
Planetary Astronomy-Understanding the Origin of the Solar System
Lawler, S. M.;
Boley, A. C.;
Connors, M.;
Fraser, W.;
Gladman, B.;
Johnson, C. L.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Osinski, G.;
Philpott, L.;
Rowe, J.;
Wiegert, P.;
Winslow, R.
Submitted: 2019-10-29
There is a vibrant and effective planetary science community in Canada. We do
research in the areas of meteoritics, asteroid and trans-Neptunian object
orbits and compositions, and space weather, and are involved in space probe
missions to study planetary surfaces and interiors. For Canadian planetary
scientists to deliver the highest scientific impact possible, we have several
recommendations. Our top recommendation is to join LSST and gain access to the
full data releases by hosting a data centre, which could be done by adding to
the CADC, which is already highly involved in hosting planetary data and
supporting computational modelling for orbital studies. We also support MSE,
which can provide spectroscopy and thus compositional information for thousands
of small bodies. We support a Canadian-led microsatellite, POEP, which will
provide small body sizes by measuring occultations. We support the idea of
piggybacking space weather instruments on other astronomical space probes to
provide data for the space weather community. Many Canadian planetary
scientists are involved in space probe missions, but through haphazard and
temporary arrangements like co-appointments at US institutions, so we would
like the community to support Canadian researchers to participate in these
large, international missions.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.08857 [pdf] - 2097234
LRP2020: Astrostatistics in Canada
Eadie, Gwendolyn;
Bahramian, Arash;
Barmby, Pauline;
Craiu, Radu;
Bingham, Derek;
Hložek, Renée;
Kavelaars, JJ;
Stenning, David;
Benincasa, Samantha;
Thomas, Guillaume;
Thanjavur, Karun;
Bovy, Jo;
Cami, Jan;
Carlberg, Ray;
Lawler, Sam;
Liu, Adrian;
Ngo, Henry;
Rahman, Mubdi;
Rupen, Michael
Submitted: 2019-10-19
(Abridged from Executive Summary) This white paper focuses on the
interdisciplinary fields of astrostatistics and astroinformatics, in which
modern statistical and computational methods are applied to and developed for
astronomical data. Astrostatistics and astroinformatics have grown dramatically
in the past ten years, with international organizations, societies,
conferences, workshops, and summer schools becoming the norm. Canada's formal
role in astrostatistics and astroinformatics has been relatively limited, but
there is a great opportunity and necessity for growth in this area. We
conducted a survey of astronomers in Canada to gain information on the training
mechanisms through which we learn statistical methods and to identify areas for
improvement. In general, the results of our survey indicate that while
astronomers see statistical methods as critically important for their research,
they lack focused training in this area and wish they had received more formal
training during all stages of education and professional development. These
findings inform our recommendations for the LRP2020 on how to increase
interdisciplinary connections between astronomy and statistics at the
institutional, national, and international levels over the next ten years. We
recommend specific, actionable ways to increase these connections, and discuss
how interdisciplinary work can benefit not only research but also astronomy's
role in training Highly Qualified Personnel (HQP) in Canada.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.03665 [pdf] - 2097223
Canadian Astronomy on Maunakea: On Respecting Indigenous Rights
Submitted: 2019-10-08, last modified: 2019-10-14
(Abridged) Canadian astronomy has, for decades, benefited from access to
observatories and participating in international consortia on one of the best
astronomical sites in the world: Maunakea. However, Maunakea is part of the
unceded territory of the Native Hawaiian peoples and has always been of special
significance to Hawaiian culture. The use of the summit and its science reserve
has created tensions in the past decade, particularly with the development of
the Thirty Meter Telescope. A meaningful and respectful response from the
International astronomy community is still lacking. It is expected that the LRP
2020 will continue to support Canadian astronomy on Maunakea so a better
official statement on the position and involvement of CASCA should be prepared.
In this paper we present recommendations, based on the United Nation
Declaration for the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, for the Canadian astronomical
community to better support Indigenous rights on Maunakea and Hawaii while
providing clear guidelines for the astronomical community to participate in
activities conducted on Indigenous land. This framework is designed to motivate
conversations with Indigenous communities regarding our place on Indigenous
lands and our roles, and responsibilities toward the communities we are working
with. Furthermore, we propose this framework as a basis for engaging with
communities around the world regarding consent for astronomical facilities.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.02976 [pdf] - 1975514
Indigenizing the next decade of astronomy in Canada
Submitted: 2019-10-07
(Abridged) The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada published its
calls to action in 2015 with 94 recommendations. Many of these 94
recommendations are directly related to education, language, and culture, some
of which the Canadian Astronomy community can address and contribute to as part
of reconciliation. The Canadian Astronomy community has an additional
obligation since it benefits from facilities on Indigenous territories across
Canada and the world. Furthermore, Indigenous people are still underrepresented
at all levels in Canadian astronomy. The purpose of this Community Paper is to
develop recommendations for the Canadian astronomy community to support
Indigenous inclusion in the science community, support Indigenous learning by
developing Indigenous-based learning materials and facilitate access to
professionals and science activities, and to recognize and acknowledge the
great contributions of Indigenous communities to our science activities. As
part of this work we propose the ten following recommendations for CASCA as an
organization and throughout this Community Paper we will include additional
recommendations for individuals: astronomers, students and academics.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.09673 [pdf] - 2034423
Perspectives on the distribution of orbits of distant Trans-Neptunian
Objects
Submitted: 2019-09-20
Looking at the orbits of small bodies with large semimajor axes, we are
compelled to see patterns. Some of these patterns are noted as strong
indicators of new or hidden processes in the outer Solar System, others are
substantially generated by observational biases, and still others may be
completely overlooked. We can gain insight into the current and past structure
of the outer Solar System through a careful examination of these orbit
patterns. In this chapter, we discuss the implications of the observed orbital
distribution of distant trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs). We start with some
cautions on how observational biases must affect the known set of TNO orbits.
Some of these biases are intrinsic to the process of discovering TNOs, while
others can be reduced or eliminated through careful observational survey
design. We discuss some orbital element correlations that have received
considerable attention in the recent literature. We examine the known TNOs in
the context of the gravitational processes that the known Solar System induces
in orbital distributions. We discuss proposed new elements of the outer Solar
System, posited ancient processes, and the types of TNO orbital element
distributions that they predict to exist. We conclude with speculation.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.09286 [pdf] - 1912868
OSSOS XV: Probing the Distant Solar System with Observed Scattering TNOs
Submitted: 2019-05-22, last modified: 2019-05-28
Most known trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs) gravitationally scattering off the
giant planets have orbital inclinations consistent with an origin from the
classical Kuiper belt, but a small fraction of these "scattering TNOs" have
inclinations that are far too large (i > 45 deg) for this origin. These
scattering outliers have previously been proposed to be interlopers from the
Oort cloud or evidence of an undiscovered planet. Here we test these hypotheses
using N-body simulations and the 69 centaurs and scattering TNOs detected in
the Outer Solar Systems Origins Survey and its predecessors. We confirm that
observed scattering objects cannot solely originate from the classical Kuiper
belt, and we show that both the Oort cloud and a distant planet generate
observable highly inclined scatterers. Although the number of highly inclined
scatterers from the Oort Cloud is ~3 times less than observed, Oort cloud
enrichment from the Sun's galactic migration or birth cluster could resolve
this. Meanwhile, a distant, low-eccentricity 5 Earth-mass planet replicates the
observed fraction of highly inclined scatterers, but the overall inclination
distribution is more excited than observed. Furthermore, the distant planet
generates a longitudinal asymmetry among detached TNOs that is less extreme
than often presumed, and its direction reverses across the perihelion range
spanned by known TNOs. More complete models that explore the dynamical origins
of the planet are necessary to further study these features. With observational
biases well-characterized, our work shows that the orbital distribution of
detected scattering bodies is a powerful constraint on the unobserved distant
solar system.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.02618 [pdf] - 1916744
OSSOS: XIII. Fossilized Resonant Dropouts Tentatively Confirm Neptune's
Migration was Grainy and Slow
Lawler, S. M.;
Pike, R. E.;
Kaib, N.;
Alexandersen, M.;
Bannister, M. T.;
Chen, Y. -T.;
Gladman, B.;
Gwyn, S.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Petit, J. -M.;
Volk, K.
Submitted: 2018-08-08, last modified: 2019-04-24
The migration of Neptune's resonances through the proto-Kuiper belt has been
imprinted in the distribution of small bodies in the outer Solar System. Here
we analyze five published Neptune migration models in detail, focusing on the
high pericenter distance (high-q) trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) near Neptune's
5:2 and 3:1 mean-motion resonances, because they have large resonant
populations, are outside the main classical belt, and are relatively isolated
from other strong resonances. We compare the observationally biased output from
these dynamical models with the detected TNOs from the Outer Solar System
Origins Survey, via its Survey Simulator. All of the four new OSSOS detections
of high-q non-resonant TNOs are on the Sunward side of the 5:2 and 3:1
resonances. We show that even after accounting for observation biases, this
asymmetric distribution cannot be drawn from a uniform distribution of TNOs at
2sigma confidence. As shown by previous work, our analysis here tentatively
confirms that the dynamical model that uses grainy slow Neptune migration
provides the best match to the real high-q TNO orbital data. However, due to
extreme observational biases, we have very few high-q TNO discoveries with
which to statistically constrain the models. Thus, this analysis provides a
framework for future comparison between the output from detailed, dynamically
classified Neptune migration simulations and the TNO discoveries from future
well-characterized surveys. We show that a deeper survey (to a limiting
r-magnitude of 26.0) with a similar survey area to OSSOS could statistically
distinguish between these five Neptune migration models.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.11740 [pdf] - 1691625
OSSOS. VII. 800+ trans-Neptunian objects - the complete data release
Bannister, Michele T.;
Gladman, Brett J.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Petit, Jean-Marc;
Volk, Kathryn;
Chen, Ying-Tung;
Alexandersen, Mike;
Gwyn, Stephen D. J.;
Schwamb, Megan E.;
Ashton, Edward;
Benecchi, Susan D.;
Cabral, Nahuel;
Dawson, Rebekah I.;
Delsanti, Audrey;
Fraser, Wesley C.;
Granvik, Mikael;
Greenstreet, Sarah;
Guilbert-Lepoutre, Aurélie;
Ip, Wing-Huen;
Jakubik, Marian;
Jones, R. Lynne;
Kaib, Nathan A.;
Lacerda, Pedro;
Van Laerhoven, Christa;
Lawler, Samantha;
Lehner, Matthew J.;
Lin, Hsing Wen;
Lykawka, Patryk Sofia;
Marsset, Michaël;
Murray-Clay, Ruth;
Pike, Rosemary E.;
Rousselot, Philippe;
Shankman, Cory;
Thirouin, Audrey;
Vernazza, Pierre;
Wang, Shiang-Yu
Submitted: 2018-05-29
The Outer Solar System Origins Survey (OSSOS), a wide-field imaging program
in 2013-2017 with the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope, surveyed 155 deg$^{2}$ of
sky to depths of $m_r = 24.1$-25.2. We present 838 outer Solar System
discoveries that are entirely free of ephemeris bias. This increases the
inventory of trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs) with accurately known orbits by
nearly 50%. Each minor planet has 20-60 Gaia/Pan-STARRS-calibrated astrometric
measurements made over 2-5 oppositions, which allows accurate classification of
their orbits within the trans-Neptunian dynamical populations. The populations
orbiting in mean-motion resonance with Neptune are key to understanding
Neptune's early migration. Our 313 resonant TNOs, including 132 plutinos,
triple the available characterized sample and include new occupancy of distant
resonances out to semi-major axis $a \sim 130$ au. OSSOS doubles the known
population of the non-resonant Kuiper belt, providing 436 TNOs in this region,
all with exceptionally high-quality orbits of $a$ uncertainty $\sigma_{a} \leq
0.1\%$; they show the belt exists from $a \gtrsim 37$ au, with a lower
perihelion bound of $35$ au. We confirm the presence of a concentrated
low-inclination $a\simeq 44$ au "kernel" population and a dynamically cold
population extending beyond the 2:1 resonance. We finely quantify the survey's
observational biases. Our survey simulator provides a straightforward way to
impose these biases on models of the trans-Neptunian orbit distributions,
allowing statistical comparison to the discoveries. The OSSOS TNOs,
unprecedented in their orbital precision for the size of the sample, are ideal
for testing concepts of the history of giant planet migration in the Solar
System.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.05805 [pdf] - 1692470
OSSOS IX: two objects in Neptune's 9:1 resonance -- implications for
resonance sticking in the scattering population
Volk, Kathryn;
Murray-Clay, Ruth A.;
Gladman, Brett J.;
Lawler, Samantha M.;
Yu, Tze Yeung Mathew;
Alexandersen, Mike;
Bannister, Michele T.;
Chen, Ying-Tung;
Dawson, Rebekah I.;
Greenstreet, Sarah;
Gwyn, Stephen D. J.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Lin, Hsing Wen;
Lykawka, Patryk Sofia;
Petit, Jean-Marc
Submitted: 2018-02-15, last modified: 2018-05-24
We discuss the detection in the Outer Solar System Origins Survey (OSSOS) of
two objects in Neptune's distant 9:1 mean motion resonance at semimajor axis
$a\approx~130$~au. Both objects are securely resonant on 10~Myr timescales,
with one securely in the 9:1 resonance's leading asymmetric libration island
and the other in either the symmetric or trailing asymmetric island. These
objects are the largest semimajor axis objects with secure resonant
classifications, and their detection in a carefully characterized survey allows
for the first robust resonance population estimate beyond 100~au. The detection
of these objects implies a 9:1 resonance population of $1.1\times10^4$ objects
with $H_r<8.66$ ($D~\gtrsim~100$~km) on similar orbits (95\% confidence range
of $\sim0.4-3\times10^4$). Integrations over 4~Gyr of an ensemble of clones
spanning these objects' orbit fit uncertainties reveal that they both have
median resonance occupation timescales of $\sim1$~Gyr. These timescales are
consistent with the hypothesis that these objects originate in the scattering
population but became transiently stuck to Neptune's 9:1 resonance within the
last $\sim1$~Gyr of solar system evolution. Based on simulations of a model of
the current scattering population, we estimate the expected resonance sticking
population in the 9:1 resonance to be 1000-4500 objects with $H_r<8.66$; this
is marginally consistent with the OSSOS 9:1 population estimate. We conclude
that resonance sticking is a plausible explanation for the observed 9:1
population, but we also discuss the possibility of a primordial 9:1 population,
which would have interesting implications for the Kuiper belt's dynamical
history.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.00460 [pdf] - 1674860
OSSOS: X. How to use a Survey Simulator: Statistical Testing of
Dynamical Models Against the Real Kuiper Belt
Submitted: 2018-02-01, last modified: 2018-04-30
All surveys include observational biases, which makes it impossible to
directly compare properties of discovered trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) with
dynamical models. However, by carefully keeping track of survey pointings on
the sky, detection limits, tracking fractions, and rate cuts, the biases from a
survey can be modelled in Survey Simulator software. A Survey Simulator takes
an intrinsic orbital model (from, for example, the output of a dynamical Kuiper
belt emplacement simulation) and applies the survey biases, so that the biased
simulated objects can be directly compared with real discoveries. This
methodology has been used with great success in the Outer Solar System Origins
Survey (OSSOS) and its predecessor surveys. In this chapter, we give four
examples of ways to use the OSSOS Survey Simulator to gain knowledge about the
true structure of the Kuiper Belt. We demonstrate how to statistically compare
different dynamical model outputs with real TNO discoveries, how to quantify
detection biases within a TNO population, how to measure intrinsic population
sizes, and how to use upper limits from non-detections. We hope this will
provide a framework for dynamical modellers to statistically test the validity
of their models.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.07521 [pdf] - 1674968
OSSOS. VIII. The Transition Between Two Size Distribution Slopes in the
Scattering Disk
Lawler, S. M.;
Shankman, C.;
Kavelaars, JJ.;
Alexandersen, M.;
Bannister, M. T.;
Chen, Y. -T.;
Gladman, B.;
Fraser, W. C.;
Gwyn, S.;
Kaib, N.;
Petit, J. -M.;
Volk, K.
Submitted: 2018-03-20
The scattering trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) can be measured to smaller
sizes than any other distant small-body population. We use the largest sample
yet obtained, 68 discoveries, primarily by the Outer Solar System Origins
Survey (OSSOS), to constrain the slope of its luminosity distribution, with
sensitivity to much fainter absolute $H$ magnitudes than previous work. Using
the analysis technique in Shankman et al. (2016), we confirm that a single
slope for the $H$-distribution is not an accurate representation of the
scattering TNOs and Centaurs, and that a break in the distribution is required,
in support of previous conclusions. A bright-end slope of $\alpha_b=0.9$
transitioning to a faint-end slope $\alpha_f$ of 0.4-0.5 with a differential
number contrast $c$ from 1 (a knee) to 10 (a divot) provides an acceptable
match to our data. We find that break magnitudes $H_b$ of 7.7 and 8.3, values
both previously suggested for dynamically hot Kuiper belt populations, are
equally non-rejectable for a range of $\alpha_f$ and $c$ in our statistical
analysis. Our preferred divot $H$-distribution transitions to $\alpha_f=0.5$
with a divot of contrast $c=3$ at $H_b=8.3$, while our preferred knee
$H$-distribution transitions to $\alpha_f=0.4$ at $H_b=7.7$. The intrinsic
population of scattering TNOs required to match the OSSOS detections is
$3\times10^6$ for $H_r<12$, and $9\times10^4$ for $H_r<8.66$
($D\gtrsim100$~km), with Centaurs having an intrinsic population two orders of
magnitude smaller.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.03699 [pdf] - 1588248
Details of Resonant Structures Within a Nice Model Kuiper Belt:
Predictions for High-Perihelion TNO Detections
Submitted: 2017-09-12
We analyze a detailed Nice model simulation of Kuiper Belt emplacement from
Brasser & Morbidelli (2013), where Neptune undergoes a high eccentricity phase
and migrates outward. In this work, which follows from Pike et al. (2017), we
specifically focus on the details of structures within Neptune's mean motion
resonances and in the high pericenter population of simulated trans-Neptunian
Objects (TNOs). We find several characteristics of these populations which
should be observable in the distant Solar System in future large-scale TNO
surveys as a diagnostic of whether or not this mode of Neptune migration
occurred in the early Solar System. We find that the leading asymmetric
libration islands of the $n$:1 resonances are generally much more populated
than the trailing islands. We also find the non-resonant high-$q$ population of
TNOs should have higher inclinations than the low-$q$ population due to the
importance of Kozai cycling during their emplacement histories. Finally,
high-$q$ TNOs should be present in roughly equal numbers on either side of
distant mean-motion resonances. These predictions contrast with predictions
from other Kuiper Belt emplacement simulations, and will be testable by
upcoming surveys.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.05348 [pdf] - 1584797
OSSOS VI. Striking Biases in the detection of large semimajor axis
Trans-Neptunian Objects
Shankman, Cory;
Kavelaars, JJ;
Bannister, Michele;
Gladman, Brett;
Lawler, Samantha;
Chen, Ying-Tung;
Jakubik, Marian;
Kaib, Nathan;
Alexandersen, Mike;
Gwyn, Stephen;
Petit, Jean-Marc;
Volk, Kathryn
Submitted: 2017-06-16, last modified: 2017-06-19
The accumulating, but small, set of large semi-major axis trans-Neptunian
objects (TNOs) shows an apparent clustering in the orientations of their
orbits. This clustering must either be representative of the intrinsic
distribution of these TNOs, or else arise as a result of observation biases
and/or statistically expected variations for such a small set of detected
objects. The clustered TNOs were detected across different and independent
surveys, which has led to claims that the detections are therefore free of
observational bias. This apparent clustering has led to the so-called "Planet
9" hypothesis that a super-Earth currently resides in the distant solar system
and causes this clustering. The Outer Solar System Origins Survey (OSSOS) is a
large program that ran on the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope from 2013--2017,
discovering more than 800 new TNOs. One of the primary design goals of OSSOS
was the careful determination of observational biases that would manifest
within the detected sample. We demonstrate the striking and non-intuitive
biases that exist for the detection of TNOs with large semi-major axes. The
eight large semi-major axis OSSOS detections are an independent dataset, of
comparable size to the conglomerate samples used in previous studies. We
conclude that the orbital distribution of the OSSOS sample is consistent with
being detected from a uniform underlying angular distribution.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.01218 [pdf] - 1584237
SONS: The JCMT legacy survey of debris discs in the submillimetre
Holland, Wayne S.;
Matthews, Brenda C.;
Kennedy, Grant M.;
Greaves, Jane S.;
Wyatt, Mark C.;
Booth, Mark;
Bastien, Pierre;
Bryden, Geoff;
Butner, Harold;
Chen, Christine H.;
Chrysostomou, Antonio;
Davies, Claire L.;
Dent, William R. F.;
Di Francesco, James;
Duchene, Gaspard;
Gibb, Andy G.;
Friberg, Per;
Ivison, Rob J.;
Jenness, Tim;
Kavelaars, JJ;
Lawler, Samantha;
Lestrade, Jean-Francois;
Marshall, Jonathan P.;
Moro-Martin, Amaya;
Panic, Olja;
Phillips, Neil;
Serjeant, Stephen;
Schieven, Gerald H.;
Sibthorpe, Bruce;
Vican, Laura;
Ward-Thompson, Derek;
van der Werf, Paul;
White, Glenn J.;
Wilner, David;
Zuckerman, Ben
Submitted: 2017-06-05
Debris discs are evidence of the ongoing destructive collisions between
planetesimals, and their presence around stars also suggests that planets exist
in these systems. In this paper, we present submillimetre images of the thermal
emission from debris discs that formed the SCUBA-2 Observations of Nearby Stars
(SONS) survey, one of seven legacy surveys undertaken on the James Clerk
Maxwell telescope between 2012 and 2015. The overall results of the survey are
presented in the form of 850 microns (and 450 microns, where possible) images
and fluxes for the observed fields. Excess thermal emission, over that expected
from the stellar photosphere, is detected around 49 stars out of the 100
observed fields. The discs are characterised in terms of their flux density,
size (radial distribution of the dust) and derived dust properties from their
spectral energy distributions. The results show discs over a range of sizes,
typically 1-10 times the diameter of the Edgeworth-Kuiper Belt in our Solar
System. The mass of a disc, for particles up to a few millimetres in size, is
uniquely obtainable with submillimetre observations and this quantity is
presented as a function of the host stars' age, showing a tentative decline in
mass with age. Having doubled the number of imaged discs at submillimetre
wavelengths from ground-based, single dish telescope observations, one of the
key legacy products from the SONS survey is to provide a comprehensive target
list to observe at high angular resolution using submillimetre/millimetre
interferometers (e.g., ALMA, SMA).
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.07041 [pdf] - 1542923
The Structure of the Distant Kuiper Belt in a Nice Model Scenario
Submitted: 2017-01-24
This work explores the orbital distribution of minor bodies in the outer
Solar System emplaced as a result of a Nice model migration from the
simulations of Brasser & Morbidelli (2013). This planetary migration scatters a
planetesimal disk from between 29-34 AU and emplaces a population of objects
into the Kuiper belt region. From the 2:1 Neptune resonance and outward, the
test particles analyzed populate the outer resonances with orbital
distributions consistent with trans-Neptunian object (TNO) detections in
semi-major axis, inclination, and eccentricity, while capture into the closest
resonances is too efficient. The relative populations of the simulated
scattering objects and resonant objects in the 3:1 and 4:1 resonances are also
consistent with observed populations based on debiased TNO surveys, but the 5:1
resonance is severely underpopulated compared to population estimates from
survey results. Scattering emplacement results in the expected orbital
distribution for the majority of the TNO populations, however the origin of the
large observed population in the 5:1 resonance remains unexplained.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.06575 [pdf] - 1530730
Observational Signatures of a Massive Distant Planet on the Scattering
Disk
Submitted: 2016-05-20, last modified: 2016-11-21
The orbital element distribution of trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs) with large
pericenters has been suggested to be influenced by the presence of an
undetected, large planet at >200 AU from the Sun. To find additional
observables caused by this scenario, we here present the first detailed
emplacement simulation in the presence of a massive ninth planet on the distant
Kuiper Belt. We perform 4 Gyr N-body simulations with the currently known Solar
System planetary architecture, plus a 10 Earth mass planet with similar orbital
parameters to those suggested by Trujillo & Sheppard (2014) or Batygin & Brown
(2016), and 10^5 test particles in an initial planetesimal disk. We find that
including a distant superearth-mass planet produces a substantially different
orbital distribution for the scattering and detached TNOs, raising the
pericenters and inclinations of moderate semimajor axis (50<a<500 AU) objects.
We test whether this signature is detectable via a simulator with the
observational characteristics of four precisely characterized TNO surveys. We
find that the qualitatively very distinct Solar System models that include a
ninth planet are essentially observationally indistinguishable from an outer
Solar System produced solely by the four giant planets. We also find that the
mass of the Kuiper Belt's current scattering and detached populations is
required to be 3-10 times larger in the presence of an additional planet. We do
not find any evidence for clustering of orbital angles in our simulated TNO
population. Wide-field, deep surveys targeting inclined high-pericenter objects
will be required to distinguish between these different scenarios.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.04251 [pdf] - 1532044
Consequences of a Distant Massive Planet on the Large Semi-major Axis
Trans-Neptunian Objects
Submitted: 2016-10-13
We explore the distant giant planet hypothesis by integrating the large
semi-major axis, large pericenter Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) in the
presence of the giant planets and an external perturber whose orbit is
consistent with the proposed distant, eccentric, and inclined giant planet, so
called planet 9. We find that TNOs with semi-major axes greater than 250 au
experience some longitude of perihelion shepherding, but that a generic outcome
of such evolutions is that the TNOs evolve to larger pericenter orbits, and
commonly get raised to retrograde inclinations. This pericenter and inclination
evolution requires a massive disk of TNOs (tens of M$_\Earth$) in order to
explain the detection of the known sample today. Some of the highly inclined
orbits produced by the examined perturbers will be inside of the orbital
parameter space probed by prior surveys, implying a missing signature of the
9th planet scenario. The distant giant planet scenarios explored in this work
do not reproduce the observed signal of simultaneous clustering in argument of
pericenter, longitude of the ascending node, and longitude of perihelion in the
region of the known TNOs.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.06970 [pdf] - 1531102
OSSOS: IV. Discovery of a dwarf planet candidate in the 9:2 resonance
with Neptune
Bannister, Michele T.;
Alexandersen, Mike;
Benecchi, Susan D.;
Chen, Ying-Tung;
Delsanti, Audrey;
Fraser, Wesley C.;
Gladman, Brett J.;
Granvik, Mikael;
Grundy, Will M.;
Guilbert-Lepoutre, Aurelie;
Gwyn, Stephen D. J.;
Ip, Wing-Huen;
Jakubik, Marian;
Jones, R. Lynne;
Kaib, Nathan;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Lacerda, Pedro;
Lawler, Samantha;
Lehner, Matthew J.;
Lin, Hsing Wen;
Lykawka, Patryk Sofia;
Marsset, Michael;
Murray-Clay, Ruth;
Noll, Keith S.;
Parker, Alex;
Petit, Jean-Marc;
Pike, Rosemary E.;
Rousselot, Philippe;
Schwamb, Megan E.;
Shankman, Cory;
Veres, Peter;
Vernazza, Pierre;
Volk, Kathryn;
Wang, Shiang-Yu;
Weryk, Robert
Submitted: 2016-07-23, last modified: 2016-10-05
We report the discovery and orbit of a new dwarf planet candidate, 2015
RR$_{245}$, by the Outer Solar System Origins Survey (OSSOS). 2015 RR$_{245}$'s
orbit is eccentric ($e=0.586$), with a semi-major axis near 82 au, yielding a
perihelion distance of 34 au. 2015 RR$_{245}$ has $g-r = 0.59 \pm 0.11$ and
absolute magnitude $H_{r} = 3.6 \pm 0.1$; for an assumed albedo of $p_V = 12$%
the object has a diameter of $\sim670$ km. Based on astrometric measurements
from OSSOS and Pan-STARRS1, we find that 2015 RR$_{245}$ is securely trapped on
ten-Myr timescales in the 9:2 mean-motion resonance with Neptune. It is the
first TNO identified in this resonance. On hundred-Myr timescales, particles in
2015 RR$_{245}$-like orbits depart and sometimes return to the resonance,
indicating that 2015 RR$_{245}$ likely forms part of the long-lived metastable
population of distant TNOs that drift between resonance sticking and actively
scattering via gravitational encounters with Neptune. The discovery of a 9:2
TNO stresses the role of resonances in the long-term evolution of objects in
the scattering disk, and reinforces the view that distant resonances are
heavily populated in the current Solar System. This object further motivates
detailed modelling of the transient sticking population.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.02873 [pdf] - 1574538
The Canada-France Ecliptic Plane Survey (CFEPS) - High Latitude
Component
Petit, J-M.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Gladman, B. J.;
Jones, R. L.;
Parker, J. Wm.;
Van Laerhoven, C.;
Pike, R.;
Nicholson, P.;
Bieryla, A.;
Ashby, M. L. N.;
Lawler, S. M.
Submitted: 2016-08-09
We report the orbital distribution of the Trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs)
discovered during the High Ecliptic Latitude (HiLat) extension of the
Canada-France Ecliptic Plane Survey (CFEPS), conducted from June 2006 to July
2009. The HiLat component was designed to address one of the shortcomings of
ecliptic surveys (like CFEPS), their lack of sensitivity to high-inclination
objects. We searched 701~deg$^2$ of sky ranging from 12$^\circ$ to 85$^\circ$
ecliptic latitude and discovered \lKBO TNOs, with inclinations between
15$^\circ$ to 104$^\circ$. This survey places a very strong constraint on the
inclination distribution of the hot component of the classical Kuiper Belt,
ruling out any possibility of a large intrinsic fraction of highly inclined
orbits. Using the parameterization of \citet{2001AJ....121.2804B}, the HiLat
sample combined with CFEPS imposes a width $14^\circ \le \sigma \le
15.5^\circ$, with a best match for $\sigma = 14.5^\circ$. HiLat discovered the
first retrograde TNO, 2008~KV$_{42}$, with an almost polar orbit with
inclination 104$^\circ$, and (418993), a scattering object with perihelion in
the region of Saturn's influence, with $a \sim 400$~AU and $i = 68^\circ$.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.02513 [pdf] - 1483432
ALMA Observations of the Debris Disk of Solar Analogue Tau Ceti
Submitted: 2016-07-08
We present 1.3 mm observations of the Sun-like star $\tau$ Ceti with the
Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) that probe angular scales
of $\sim1$'' (4 AU). This first interferometric image of the $\tau$ Ceti
system, which hosts both a debris disk and possible multiplanet system, shows
emission from a nearly face-on belt of cold dust with a position angle of
$90^\circ$ surrounding an unresolved central source at the stellar position. To
characterize this emission structure, we fit parametric models to the
millimeter visibilities. The resulting best-fit model yields an inner belt edge
of $6.2^{+9.8}_{-4.6}$ AU, consistent with inferences from lower resolution,
far-infrared Herschel observations. While the limited data at sufficiently
short baselines preclude us from placing stronger constraints on the belt
properties and its relation to the proposed five planet system, the
observations do provide a strong lower limit on the fractional width of the
belt, $\Delta R/R > 0.75$ with $99\%$ confidence. This fractional width is more
similar to broad disks such as HD 107146 than narrow belts such as the Kuiper
Belt and Fomalhaut. The unresolved central source has a higher flux density
than the predicted flux of the stellar photosphere at 1.3 mm. Given previous
measurements of an excess by a factor of $\sim2$ at 8.7 mm, this emission is
likely due to a hot stellar chromosphere.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.02895 [pdf] - 1483231
The Outer Solar System Origins Survey: I. Design and First-Quarter
Discoveries
Bannister, Michele T.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Petit, Jean-Marc;
Gladman, Brett J.;
Gwyn, Stephen D. J.;
Chen, Ying-Tung;
Volk, Kathryn;
Alexandersen, Mike;
Benecchi, Susan;
Delsanti, Audrey;
Fraser, Wesley;
Granvik, Mikael;
Grundy, Will M.;
Guilbert-Lepoutre, Aurelie;
Hestroffer, Daniel;
Ip, Wing-Huen;
Jakubik, Marian;
Jones, Lynne;
Kaib, Nathan;
Kavelaars, Catherine F.;
Lacerda, Pedro;
Lawler, Samantha;
Lehner, Matthew J.;
Lin, Hsing Wen;
Lister, Tim;
Lykawka, Patryk Sofia;
Monty, Stephanie;
Marsset, Michael;
Murray-Clay, Ruth;
Noll, Keith;
Parker, Alex;
Pike, Rosemary E.;
Rousselot, Philippe;
Rusk, David;
Schwamb, Megan E.;
Shankman, Cory;
Sicardy, Bruno;
Vernazza, Pierre;
Wang, Shiang-Yu
Submitted: 2015-11-09, last modified: 2016-05-10
We report the discovery, tracking and detection circumstances for 85
trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs) from the first 42 deg$^{2}$ of the Outer Solar
System Origins Survey (OSSOS). This ongoing $r$-band Solar System survey uses
the 0.9 deg$^{2}$ field-of-view MegaPrime camera on the 3.6 m
Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope. Our orbital elements for these TNOs are precise
to a fractional semi-major axis uncertainty $<0.1\%$. We achieve this precision
in just two oppositions, as compared to the normal 3-5 oppositions, via a dense
observing cadence and innovative astrometric technique. These discoveries are
free of ephemeris bias, a first for large trans-Neptunian surveys. We also
provide the necessary information to enable models of TNO orbital distributions
to be tested against our TNO sample. We confirm the existence of a cold
"kernel" of objects within the main cold classical Kuiper belt, and infer the
existence of an extension of the "stirred" cold classical Kuiper belt to at
least several AU beyond the 2:1 mean motion resonance with Neptune. We find
that the population model of Petit et al. (2011) remains a plausible
representation of the Kuiper belt. The full survey, to be completed in 2017,
will provide an exquisitely characterized sample of important resonant TNO
populations, ideal for testing models of giant planet migration during the
early history of the Solar System.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.08177 [pdf] - 1433043
OSSOS III - Resonant Trans-Neptunian Populations: Constraints from the
first quarter of the Outer Solar System Origins Survey
Volk, Kathryn;
Murray-Clay, Ruth;
Gladman, Brett;
Lawler, Samantha;
Bannister, Michele T.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Petit, Jean-Marc;
Gwyn, Stephen;
Alexandersen, Mike;
Chen, Ying-Tung;
Lykawka, Patryk Sofia;
Ip, Wing;
Lin, Hsing Wen
Submitted: 2016-04-27
The first two observational sky "blocks" of the Outer Solar System Origins
Survey (OSSOS) have significantly increased the number of well-characterized
observed trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs) in Neptune's mean motion resonances. We
describe the 31 securely resonant TNOs detected by OSSOS so far, and we use
them to independently verify the resonant population models from the
Canada-France Ecliptic Plane Survey (CFEPS; Gladman et al. 2012), with which we
find broad agreement. We confirm that the 5:2 resonance is more populated than
models of the outer Solar System's dynamical history predict; our minimum
population estimate shows that the high eccentricity (e>0.35) portion of the
resonance is at least as populous as the 2:1 and possibly as populated as the
3:2 resonance. One OSSOS block was well-suited to detecting objects trapped at
low libration amplitudes in Neptune's 3:2 resonance, a population of interest
in testing the origins of resonant TNOs. We detected three 3:2 objects with
libration amplitudes below the cutoff modeled by CFEPS; OSSOS thus offers new
constraints on this distribution. The OSSOS detections confirm that the 2:1
resonance has a dynamically colder inclination distribution than either the 3:2
or 5:2 resonances. Using the combined OSSOS and CFEPS 2:1 detections, we
constrain the fraction of 2:1 objects in the symmetric mode of libration to be
0.2-0.85; we also constrain the fraction of leading vs. trailing asymmetric
librators, which has been theoretically predicted to vary depending on
Neptune's migration history, to be 0.05-0.8. Future OSSOS blocks will improve
these constraints.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.02076 [pdf] - 1418844
Searching for the HR 8799 Debris Disk with HST/STIS
Submitted: 2016-04-07
We present a new algorithm for space telescope high contrast imaging of
close-to-face-on planetary disks called Optimized Spatially Filtered (OSFi)
normalization. This algorithm is used on HR 8799 Hubble Space Telescope (HST)
coronagraphic archival data, showing an over-luminosity after reference star
point spread function (PSF) subtraction that may be from the inner disk and/or
planetesimal belt components of this system. The PSF-subtracted radial profiles
in two separate epochs from 2011 and 2012 are consistent with one another, and
self-subtraction shows no residual in both epochs. We explore a number of
possible false-positive scenarios that could explain this residual flux,
including telescope breathing, spectral differences between HR 8799 and the
reference star, imaging of the known warm inner disk component, OSFi algorithm
throughput and consistency with the standard spider normalization HST PSF
subtraction technique, and coronagraph misalignment from pointing accuracy. In
comparison to another similar STIS dataset, we find that the over-luminosity is
likely a result of telescope breathing and spectral difference between HR 8799
and the reference star. Thus, assuming a non-detection, we derive upper limits
on the HR 8799 dust belt mass in small grains. In this scenario, we find that
the flux of these micron-sized dust grains leaving the system due to radiation
pressure is small enough to be consistent with measurements of other debris
disk halos.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.02747 [pdf] - 1290878
Direct imaging of an asymmetric debris disk in the HD 106906 planetary
system
Kalas, Paul G.;
Rajan, Abhijith;
Wang, Jason J.;
Millar-Blanchaer, Maxwell A.;
Duchene, Gaspard;
Chen, Christine;
Fitzgerald, Michael P.;
Dong, Ruobing;
Graham, James R.;
Patience, Jennifer;
Macintosh, Bruce;
Murray-Clay, Ruth;
Matthews, Brenda;
Rameau, Julien;
Marois, Christian;
Chilcote, Jeffrey;
De Rosa, Robert J.;
Doyon, René;
Draper, Zachary H.;
Lawler, Samantha;
Ammons, S. Mark;
Arriaga, Pauline;
Bulger, Joanna;
Cotten, Tara;
Follette, Katherine B.;
Goodsell, Stephen;
Greenbaum, Alexandra;
Hibon, Pascale;
Hinkley, Sasha;
Hung, Li-Wei;
Ingraham, Patrick;
Konapacky, Quinn;
Lafreniere, David;
Larkin, James E.;
Long, Douglas;
Maire, Jérôme;
Marchis, Franck;
Metchev, Stan;
Morzinski, Katie M.;
Nielsen, Eric L.;
Oppenheimer, Rebecca;
Perrin, Marshall D.;
Pueyo, Laurent;
Rantakyrö, Fredrik T.;
Ruffio, Jean-Baptiste;
Saddlemyer, Leslie;
Savransky, Dmitry;
Schneider, Adam C.;
Sivaramakrishnan, Anand;
Soummer, Rémi;
Song, Inseok;
Thomas, Sandrine;
Vasisht, Gautam;
Ward-Duong, Kimberly;
Wiktorowicz, Sloane J.;
Wolff, Schuyler G.
Submitted: 2015-10-09
We present the first scattered light detections of the HD 106906 debris disk
using Gemini/GPI in the infrared and HST/ACS in the optical. HD 106906 is a 13
Myr old F5V star in the Sco-Cen association, with a previously detected
planet-mass candidate HD 106906b projected 650 AU from the host star. Our
observations reveal a near edge-on debris disk that has a central cleared
region with radius $\sim$50 AU, and an outer extent $>$500 AU. The HST data
show the outer regions are highly asymmetric, resembling the ''needle''
morphology seen for the HD 15115 debris disk. The planet candidate is oriented
$\sim$21$\deg$ away from the position angle of the primary's debris disk,
strongly suggesting non-coplanarity with the system. We hypothesize that HD
106906b could be dynamically involved in the perturbation of the primary's
disk, and investigate whether or not there is evidence for a circumplanetary
dust disk or cloud that is either primordial or captured from the primary. We
show that both the existing optical properties and near-infrared colors of HD
106906b are weakly consistent with this possibility, motivating future work to
test for the observational signatures of dust surrounding the planet.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.1129 [pdf] - 1223449
Fomalhaut b as a Dust Cloud: Frequent Collisions within the Fomalhaut
Disk
Submitted: 2014-12-02, last modified: 2015-02-26
The planet candidate Fomalhaut b is bright in optical light but undetected in
longer wavelengths, requiring a large, reflective dust cloud. The most recent
observations find an extremely eccentric orbit (e ~ 0.8), indicating that
Fomalhaut b cannot be the planet that is constraining the system's eccentric
debris ring. An irregular satellite swarm around a super-Earth has been
proposed, however, explaining the well-constrained debris ring requires an
additional planet on an orbit that crosses that of the putative super-Earth.
This paper expands upon a second theory: Fomalhaut b is a transient dust cloud
produced by a catastrophic collision between planetesimals in the disk. We
perform collisional probability simulations of the Fomalhaut debris disk based
on the structure of our Kuiper belt, finding that the catastrophic disruption
rate of d ~ 100 km bodies in the high-eccentricity scattering component is
several per decade. This model paints a picture of the Fomalhaut system as
having recently (within ~10-100 Myr) experienced a dynamical instability within
its planetary system, which scattered a massive number of planetesimals onto
large, high eccentricity orbits similar to that of Fom b. If Fomalhaut b is
indeed a dust cloud produced by such a collision, we should soon see another
appear, while Fomalhaut b will expand until it is either resolved or becomes
too faint to be seen.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.2791 [pdf] - 1216256
The Debris Disk of Solar Analogue $\tau$ Ceti: Herschel Observations and
Dynamical Simulations of the Proposed Multiplanet System
Lawler, S. M.;
Di Francesco, J.;
Kennedy, G. M.;
Sibthorpe, B.;
Booth, M.;
Vandenbussche, B.;
Matthews, B. C.;
Holland, W. S.;
Greaves, J.;
Wilner, D. J.;
Tuomi, M.;
Blommaert, J. A. D. L.;
de Vries, B. L.;
Dominik, C.;
Fridlund, M.;
Gear, W.;
Heras, A. M.;
Ivison, R.;
Olofsson, G.
Submitted: 2014-08-12
$\tau$ Ceti is a nearby, mature G-type star very similar to our Sun, with a
massive Kuiper Belt analogue (Greaves et al. 2004) and possible multiplanet
system (Tuomi et al. 2013) that has been compared to our Solar System. We
present Herschel Space Observatory images of the debris disk, finding the disk
is resolved at 70 and 160 microns, and marginally resolved at 250 microns. The
Herschel images and infrared photometry from the literature are best modelled
using a wide dust annulus with an inner edge between 1-10 AU and an outer edge
at ~55 AU, inclined from face-on by 35$\pm$10 degrees, and with no significant
azimuthal structure. We model the proposed tightly-packed planetary system of
five super-Earths and find that the innermost dynamically stable disk orbits
are consistent with the inner edge found by the observations. The photometric
modelling, however, cannot rule out a disk inner edge as close to the star as 1
AU, though larger distances produce a better fit to the data. Dynamical
modelling shows that the 5 planet system is stable with the addition of a
Neptune or smaller mass planet on an orbit outside 5 AU, where the Tuomi et al.
analysis would not have detected a planet of this mass.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.3242 [pdf] - 822705
The Debiased Kuiper Belt: Our Solar System as a Debris Disk
Submitted: 2014-05-13
The dust measured in debris disks traces the position of planetesimal belts.
In our Solar System, we are also able to measure the largest planetesimals
directly and can extrapolate down to make an estimate of the dust. The zodiacal
dust from the asteroid belt is better constrained than the only rudimentary
measurements of Kuiper belt dust. Dust models will thus be based on the current
orbital distribution of the larger bodies which provide the collisional source.
The orbital distribution of many Kuiper belt objects is strongly affected by
dynamical interactions with Neptune, and the structure cannot be understood
without taking this into account. We present the debiased Kuiper belt as
measured by the Canada-France Ecliptic Plane Survey (CFEPS). This model
includes the absolute populations for objects with diameters >100 km, measured
orbital distributions, and size distributions of the components of the Kuiper
belt: the classical belt (hot, stirred, and kernel components), the scattering
disk, the detached objects, and the resonant objects (1:1, 5:4, 4:3, 3:2
including Kozai subcomponent, 5:3, 7:4, 2:1, 7:3, 5:2, 3:1, and 5:1). Because a
large fraction of known debris disks are consistent with dust at Kuiper belt
distances from the host stars, the CFEPS Kuiper belt model provides an
excellent starting point for a debris disk model, as the dynamical interactions
with planets interior to the disk are well-understood and can be precisely
modelled using orbital integrations.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.1662 [pdf] - 1166473
Plutino Detection Biases, Including the Kozai Resonance
Submitted: 2013-05-07
Because of their proximity within the transneptunian region, the plutinos
(objects in the 3:2 mean-motion resonance with Neptune) are numerous in
flux-limited catalogs, and well-studied theoretically. We perform detailed
modelling of the on-sky detection biases for plutinos, with special attention
to those that are simultaneously in the Kozai resonance. In addition to the
normal 3:2 resonant argument libration, Kozai plutinos also show periodic
oscillations in eccentricity and inclination, coupled to the argument of
perihelion (omega) oscillation. Due to the mean-motion resonance, plutinos
avoid coming to pericenter near Neptune's current position in the ecliptic
plane. Because Kozai plutinos are restricted to certain values of omega,
perihelion always occurs out of the ecliptic plane, biasing ecliptic surveys
against finding these objects. The observed Kozai plutino fraction (fkoz) has
been measured by several surveys, finding values between 8% and 25%, while the
true fkoz has been predicted to be between 10% and 30% by different giant
planet migration simulations. We show that the observed fkoz varies widely
depending on the ecliptic latitude and longitude of the survey, so debiasing to
find the true ratio is complex. Even a survey that covers most or all of the
sky will detect an apparent Kozai fraction that is different from the true
fkoz. We present a map of the on-sky plutino Kozai fraction that would be
detected by all-sky flux-limited surveys. This will be especially important for
the Panoramic Survey Telescope & Rapid Response System (Pan-STARRS) and Large
Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) projects, which may detect large numbers of
plutinos as they sweep the sky. The Kozai fraction and the distribution of the
orbital elements of Kozai plutinos may be a diagnostic of giant planet
migration; future migration simulations should provide details on their
resonant Kozai populations.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.1450 [pdf] - 1934835
The debris disk around gamma Doradus resolved with Herschel
Broekhoven-Fiene, Hannah;
Matthews, Brenda C.;
Kennedy, Grant M.;
Booth, Mark;
Sibthorpe, Bruce;
Lawler, Samantha M.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Wyatt, Mark C.;
Qi, Chenruo;
Koning, Alice;
Su, Kate Y. L.;
Rieke, George H.;
Wilner, David J.;
Greaves, Jane S.
Submitted: 2012-12-06
We present observations of the debris disk around gamma Doradus, an F1V star,
from the Herschel Key Programme DEBRIS (Disc Emission via Bias-free
Reconnaissance in the Infrared/Submillimetre). The disk is well-resolved at 70,
100 and 160 micron, resolved along its major axis at 250 micron, detected but
not resolved at 350 micron, and confused with a background source at 500
micron. It is one of our best resolved targets and we find it to have a
radially broad dust distribution. The modelling of the resolved images cannot
distinguish between two configurations: an arrangement of a warm inner ring at
several AU (best-fit 4 AU) and a cool outer belt extending from ~55 to 400 AU
or an arrangement of two cool, narrow rings at ~70 AU and ~190 AU. This
suggests that any configuration between these two is also possible. Both models
have a total fractional luminosity of ~10^{-5} and are consistent with the disk
being aligned with the stellar equator. The inner edge of either possible
configuration suggests that the most likely region to find planets in this
system would be within ~55 AU of the star. A transient event is not needed to
explain the warm dust's fractional luminosity.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.2370 [pdf] - 1124043
Herschel imaging of 61 Vir: implications for the prevalence of debris in
low-mass planetary systems
Wyatt, M. C.;
Kennedy, G.;
Sibthorpe, B.;
Moro-Martin, A.;
Lestrade, J. -F.;
Ivison, R. J.;
Matthews, B.;
Udry, S.;
Greaves, J. S.;
Kalas, P.;
Lawler, S.;
Su, K. Y. L.;
Rieke, G. H.;
Booth, M.;
Bryden, G.;
Horner, J.;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Wilner, D.
Submitted: 2012-06-11, last modified: 2012-06-18
This paper describes Herschel observations of the nearby (8.5pc) G5V
multi-exoplanet host star 61 Vir at 70-500micron carried out by the DEBRIS
survey. These reveal emission that is extended out to >15arcsec with a
morphology that can be fitted by a nearly edge-on (77deg inclination) radially
broad (from 30AU to >100AU) debris disk of fractional luminosity 2.7x10^-5,
with two unrelated sources nearby that are more prominent at longer
wavelengths. Chance alignment with a background object seen at 1.4GHz provides
potential for confusion, but the star's 1.4"/yr proper motion allows Spitzer
70micron images to confirm that what we are interpreting as disk emission
really is circumstellar. Although the exact shape of the disk's inner edge is
not well constrained, the region inside 30AU must be significantly depleted in
planetesimals. This is readily explained if there are additional planets in the
0.5-30AU region, but is also consistent with collisional erosion. We also find
tentative evidence that the presence of detectable debris around nearby stars
correlates with the presence of the lowest mass planets that are detectable in
current radial velocity surveys. Out of an unbiased sample of the nearest 60 G
stars, 11 are known to have planets, of which 6 (including 61 Vir) have planets
that are all less massive than Saturn, and 4 of these have evidence for debris.
The debris toward one of these planet-hosts (HD20794) is reported here for the
first time. This fraction (4/6) is higher than that expected for nearby field
stars (15%), and implies that systems that form low-mass planets are also able
to retain bright debris disks. We suggest that this correlation could arise
because such planetary systems are dynamically stable and include regions that
are populated with planetesimals in the formation process where the
planetesimals can remain unperturbed over Gyr timescales.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.7065 [pdf] - 1123809
The Resonant Transneptunian Populations
Gladman, B.;
Lawler, S. M.;
Petit, J-M.;
Kavelaars, J.;
Jones, R. L.;
Parker, J. Wm.;
Van Laerhoven, C.;
Nicholson, P.;
Rousselot, P.;
Bieryla, A.;
Ashby, M. L. N.
Submitted: 2012-05-31
The transneptunian objects (TNOs) trapped in mean-motion resonances with
Neptune were likely emplaced there during planet migration late in the
giant-planet formation process. We perform detailed modelling of the resonant
objects detected in the Canada-France Ecliptic Plane Survey (CFEPS) in order to
provide population estimates and, for some resonances, constrain the complex
internal orbital element distribution. Detection biases play a critical role
because phase relationships with Neptune make object discovery more likely at
certain longitudes. This paper discusses the 3:2, 5:2, 2:1, 3:1, 5:1, 4:3, 5:3,
7:3, 5:4, and 7:4 mean-motion resonances, all of which had CFEPS detections,
along with our upper limit on 1:1 Neptune Trojans (which is consistent with
their small population estimated elsewhere). For the plutinos (TNOs in the 3:2
resonance) we refine the orbital element distribution given in Kavelaars et al.
(2009) and show that steep H-magnitude distributions (N(H) proportional to
10aH, with a=0.8-0.9) are favoured in the range Hg=8-9, and confirm that this
resonance does not share the inclination distribution of the classical Kuiper
Belt. We give the first population estimate for the 5:2 resonance and find
that, to within the uncertainties, the population is equal to that of the 3:2
(13,000 TNOs with Hg < 9.16), whereas the 2:1 population is smaller by a factor
of 3-4 compared to the other two resonances. We also measure significant
populations inhabiting the 4:3, 5:3, 7:3, 5:4, 7:4, 3:1, and 5:1 resonances,
with Hg < 9.16 (D >100 km) populations in the thousands. We compare our
intrinsic population and orbital-element distributions with several published
models of resonant-TNO production; the most striking discrepancy is that
resonances beyond the 2:1 are in reality more heavily populated than in
published models.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.0368 [pdf] - 1092105
Debris Disks in Kepler Exoplanet Systems
Submitted: 2011-12-01, last modified: 2012-05-01
The Kepler Mission recently identified 997 systems hosting candidate
extrasolar planets, many of which are super-Earths. Realizing these planetary
systems are candidates to host extrasolar asteroid belts, we use mid-infrared
data from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) to search for emission
from dust in these systems. We find excesses around eight stars, indicating the
presence of warm to hot dust (~100-500 K), corresponding to orbital distances
of 0.1-10 AU for these solar-type stars. The strongest detection, KOI 1099,
demands ~500 K dust interior to the orbit of its exoplanet candidate. One star,
KOI 904, may host very hot dust (~1200 K, corresponding to 0.02 AU). Although
the fraction of these exoplanet-bearing stars with detectable warm excesses
(~3%) is similar to that found by Spitzer surveys of solar-type field stars,
the excesses detectable in the WISE data have much higher fractional
luminosities (Ldust/L*) than most known debris disks, implying that the
fraction with debris disks of comparable luminosity may actually be
significantly higher. It is difficult to explain the presence of dust so close
to the host stars, generally corresponding to dust rings at radii <0.3 AU; both
the collisional and Poynting-Robertson drag timescales to remove dust from the
system are hundreds of years or less at these distances. Assuming a
steady-state for these systems implies large mass consumption rates with these
short removal timescales, meaning that the dust production mechanism in these
systems must almost certainly be episodic in nature.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.2971 [pdf] - 1032525
Locating the planetesimals belts in the multiple-planet systems HD
128311, HD 202206, HD 82943 and HR 8799
Submitted: 2010-05-17, last modified: 2010-06-21
In addition to the Sun, six other stars are known to harbor multiple planets
and debris disks: HD 69830, HD 38529, HD 128311, HD 202206, HD 82943 and HR
8799. In this paper we set constraints on the location of the dust-producing
planetesimals around the latter four systems. We use a radiative transfer model
to analyze the spectral energy distributions of the dust disks (including two
new Spitzer IRS spectra presented in this paper), and a dynamical model to
assess the long-term stability of the planetesimals' orbits. As members of a
small group of stars that show evidence of harboring a multiple planets and
planetesimals, their study can help us learn about the diversity of planetary
systems.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.0302 [pdf] - 1024926
Gas Absorption in the KH 15D System: Further Evidence for Dust Settling
in the Circumbinary Disk
Submitted: 2010-02-01
Na I D lines in the spectrum of the young binary KH 15D have been analyzed in
detail. We find an excess absorption component that may be attributed to
foreground interstellar absorption, and to gas possibly associated with the
solids in the circumbinary disk. The derived column density is log N_NaI = 12.5
cm^-2, centered on a radial velocity that is consistent with the systemic
velocity. Subtracting the likely contribution of the ISM leaves log N_NaI ~
12.3 cm^-2. There is no detectable change in the gas column density across the
"knife edge" formed by the opaque grain disk, indicating that the gas and
solids have very different scale heights, with the solids being highly settled.
Our data support a picture of this circumbinary disk as being composed of a
very thin particulate grain layer composed of millimeter-sized or larger
objects that are settled within whatever remaining gas may be present. This
phase of disk evolution has been hypothesized to exist as a prelude to the
formation of planetesimals through gravitational fragmentation, and is expected
to be short-lived if much gas were still present in such a disk. Our analysis
also reveals the presence of excess Na I emission relative to the comparison
spectrum at the radial velocity of the currently visible star that plausibly
arises within the magnetosphere of this still-accreting young star.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.0058 [pdf] - 901561
Explorations Beyond the Snow Line: Spitzer/IRS Spectra of Debris Disks
Around Solar-Type Stars
Submitted: 2009-08-31
We have observed 152 nearby solar-type stars with the Infrared Spectrometer
(IRS) on the Spitzer Space Telescope. Including stars that met our criteria but
were observed in other surveys, we get an overall success rate for finding
excesses in the long wavelength IRS band (30-34 micron) of 11.8% +/- 2.4%. The
success rate for excesses in the short wavelength band (8.5-12 micron) is ~1%
including sources from other surveys. For stars with no excess at 8.5-12
microns, the IRS data set 3 sigma limits of around 1,000 times the level of
zodiacal emission present in our solar system, while at 30-34 microns set
limits of around 100 times the level of our solar system. Two stars (HD 40136
and HD 10647) show weak evidence for spectral features; the excess emission in
the other systems is featureless. If the emitting material consists of large
(10 micron) grains as implied by the lack of spectral features, we find that
these grains are typically located at or beyond the snow line, ~1-35 AU from
the host stars, with an average distance of 14 +/- 6 AU; however smaller grains
could be located at significantly greater distances from the host stars. These
distances correspond to dust temperatures in the range ~50-450 K. Several of
the disks are well modeled by a single dust temperature, possibly indicative of
a ring-like structure. However, a single dust temperature does not match the
data for other disks in the sample, implying a distribution of temperatures
within these disks. For most stars with excesses, we detect an excess at both
IRS and MIPS wavelengths. Only three stars in this sample show a MIPS 70 micron
excess with no IRS excess, implying that very cold dust is rare around
solar-type stars.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:0908.0049 [pdf] - 1003225
Survey of Nearby FGK Stars at 160 microns with Spitzer
Submitted: 2009-08-01
The Spitzer Space Telescope has advanced debris disk science tremendously
with a wealth of information on debris disks around nearby A, F, G, K and M
stars at 24 and 70 microns with the MIPS photometer and at 8-34 microns with
IRS. Here we present 160 micron observations of a small sub-set of these stars.
At this wavelength, the stellar photospheric emission is negligible and any
detected emission corresponds to cold dust in extended Kuiper belt analogs.
However, the Spitzer 160 micron observations are limited in sensitivity by the
large beam size which results in significant ''noise'' due to cirrus and
extragalactic confusion. In addition, the 160 micron measurements suffer from
the added complication of a light leak next to the star's position whose flux
is proportional to the near-infrared flux of the star. We are able to remove
the contamination from the leak and report 160 micron measurements or upper
limits for 24 stars. Three stars (HD 10647, HD 207129, and HD 115617) have
excesses at 160 micron that we use to constrain the properties of the debris
disks around them. A more detailed model of the spectral energy distribution of
HD 10647 reveals that the 70 and 160 micron emission could be due to small
water ice particles at a distance of 100 AU consistent with Hubble Space
Telescope optical imaging of circumstellar material in the system.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702593 [pdf] - 89647
The mid-infrared spectrum of the transiting exoplanet HD 209458b
Submitted: 2007-02-21, last modified: 2007-09-20
We report the spectroscopic detection of mid-infrared emission from the
transiting exoplanet HD 209458b. Using archive data taken with the Spitzer/IRS
instrument, we have determined the spectrum of HD 209458b between 7.46 and
15.25 microns. We have used two independent methods to determine the planet
spectrum, one differential in wavelength and one absolute, and find the results
are in good agreement. Over much of this spectral range, the planet spectrum is
consistent with featureless thermal emission. Between 7.5 and 8.5 microns, we
find evidence for an unidentified spectral feature. If this spectral modulation
is due to absorption, it implies that the dayside vertical temperature profile
of the planetary atmosphere is not entirely isothermal. Using the IRS data, we
have determined the broad-band eclipse depth to be 0.00315 +/- 0.000315,
implying significant redistribution of heat from the dayside to the nightside.
This work required development of improved methods for Spitzer/IRS data
calibration that increase the achievable absolute calibration precision and
dynamic range for observations of bright point sources.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0601468 [pdf] - 79326
IRS Spectra of Solar-Type Stars: A Search for Asteroid Belt Analogs
Submitted: 2006-01-19
We report the results of a spectroscopic search for debris disks surrounding
41 nearby solar type stars, including 8 planet-bearing stars, using the {\it
Spitzer Space Telescope}. With accurate relative photometry using the Infrared
Spectrometer (IRS) between 7-34 $\micron$ we are able to look for excesses as
small as $\sim$2% of photospheric levels with particular sensitivity to weak
spectral features. For stars with no excess, the $3\sigma$ upper limit in a
band at 30-34 $\mu$m corresponds to $\sim$ 75 times the brightness of our
zodiacal dust cloud. Comparable limits at 8.5-13 $\mu$m correspond to $\sim$
1,400 times the brightness of our zodiacal dust cloud. These limits correspond
to material located within the $<$1 to $\sim$5 AU region that, in our solar
system, originates from debris associated with the asteroid belt. We find
excess emission longward of $\sim$25 $\mu$m from five stars of which four also
show excess emission at 70 $\mu$m. This emitting dust must be located around
5-10 AU. One star has 70 micron emission but no IRS excess. In this case, the
emitting region must begin outside 10 AU; this star has a known radial velocity
planet. Only two stars of the five show emission shortward of 25 $\micron$
where spectral features reveal the presence of a population of small, hot dust
grains emitting in the 7-20 $\mu$m band. The data presented here strengthen the
results of previous studies to show that excesses at 25 $\micron$ and shorter
are rare: only 1 star out of 40 stars older than 1 Gyr or $\sim 2.5$% shows an
excess. Asteroid belts 10-30 times more massive than our own appear are rare
among mature, solar-type stars.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0601467 [pdf] - 79325
IRS Spectra of Solar-Type Stars: \break A Search for Asteroid Belt
Analogs
Submitted: 2006-01-19
We report the results of a spectroscopic search for debris disks surrounding
41 nearby solar type stars, including 8 planet-bearing stars, using the {\it
Spitzer Space Telescope}. With accurate relative photometry using the Infrared
Spectrometer (IRS) between 7-34 $\micron$ we are able to look for excesses as
small as $\sim$2% of photospheric levels with particular sensitivity to weak
spectral features. For stars with no excess, the $3\sigma$ upper limit in a
band at 30-34 $\mu$m corresponds to $\sim$ 75 times the brightness of our
zodiacal dust cloud. Comparable limits at 8.5-13 $\mu$m correspond to $\sim$
1,400 times the brightness of our zodiacal dust cloud. These limits correspond
to material located within the $<$1 to $\sim$5 AU region that, in our solar
system, originates from debris associated with the asteroid belt. We find
excess emission longward of $\sim$25 $\mu$m from five stars of which four also
show excess emission at 70 $\mu$m. This emitting dust must be located around
5-10 AU. One star has 70 micron emission but no IRS excess. In this case, the
emitting region must begin outside 10 AU; this star has a known radial velocity
planet. Only two stars of the five show emission shortward of 25 $\micron$
where spectral features reveal the presence of a population of small, hot dust
grains emitting in the 7-20 $\mu$m band. The data presented here strengthen the
results of previous studies to show that excesses at 25 $\micron$ and shorter
are rare: only 1 star out of 40 stars older than 1 Gyr or $\sim 2.5$% shows an
excess. Asteroid belts 10-30 times more massive than our own appear are rare
among mature, solar-type stars.