Normalized to: Lascaux, F.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.00711 [pdf] - 1526404
Optical turbulence forecast: ready for an operational application
Submitted: 2016-12-02
One of the main goals of the feasibility study MOSE (MOdellig ESO Sites) is
to evaluate the performances of a method conceived to forecast the optical
turbulence above the ESO sites of the Very Large Telescope and the
European-Extremely Large Telescope in Chile. The method implied the use of a
dedicated code conceived for the optical turbulence (OT) called Astro-Meso-Nh.
In this paper we present results we obtained at conclusion of this project
concerning the performances of this method in forecasting the most relevant
parameters related to the optical turbulence (CN2, seeing , isoplanatic angle
theta_0 and wavefront coherence time tau_0). Numerical predictions related to a
very rich statistical sample of nights uniformly distributed along a solar year
and belonging to different years have been compared to observations and
different statistical operators have been analyzed such as classical bias, RMSE
and and more sophisticated statistical operators derived by the contingency
tables that are able to quantify the score of success of a predictive method
such as the percentage of correct detection (PC) and the probability to detect
a parameter within a specific range of values (POD). The main conclusions of
the study tell us that the Astro-Meso-Nh model provides performances that are
already very good to definitely guarantee a not negligible positive impact on
the Service Mode of top-class telescopes and ELTs. A demonstrator for an
automatic and operational version of the Astro-Meso-Nh model will be soon
implemented on the sites of VLT and E-ELT.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.06506 [pdf] - 1461045
Operational optical turbulence forecast for the Service Mode of
top-class ground based telescopes
Submitted: 2016-08-23
In this contribution we present the most relevant results obtained in the
context of a feasibility study (MOSE) undertaken for ESO. The principal aim of
the project was to quantify the performances of a mesoscale model
(Astro-Meso-NH code) in forecasting all the main atmospherical parameters
relevant for the ground-based astronomical observations and the optical
turbulence (CN2 and associated integrated astroclimatic parameters) above Cerro
Paranal (site of the VLT) and Cerro Armazones (site of the E-ELT). A detailed
analysis on the score of success of the predictive capacities of the system
have been carried out for all the astroclimatic as well as for the
atmospherical parameters. Considering the excellent results that we obtained,
this study proved the opportunity to implement on these two sites an automatic
system to be run nightly in an operational configuration to support the
scheduling of scientific programs as well as of astronomical facilities
(particularly those supported by AO systems) of the VLT and the E-ELT. At the
end of 2016 a new project for the implementation of a demonstrator of an
operational system to be run on the two ESO's sites will start. Our team is
also responsible for the implementation of a similar automatic system at
Mt.Graham, site of the LBT (ALTA Project). Our system/method will permit
therefore to make a step ahead in the framework of the Service Mode for new
generation telescopes. Among the most exciting achieved results we cite the
fact that we proved to be able to forecast CN2 profiles with a vertical
resolution as high as 150 m. Such a feature is particularly crucial for all
WFAO systems that require such detailed information on the OT vertical
stratification on the whole 20 km above the ground. This important achievement
tells us that all the WFAO systems can rely on automatic systems that are able
to support their optimized use.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.01525 [pdf] - 975707
Forecast of surface layer meteorological parameters at Cerro Paranal
with a mesoscale atmospherical model
Submitted: 2015-04-07
This article aims at proving the feasibility of the forecast of all the most
relevant classical atmospherical parameters for astronomical applications (wind
speed and direction, temperature) above the ESO ground-base site of Cerro
Paranal with a mesoscale atmospherical model called Meso-Nh. In a precedent
paper we have preliminarily treated the model performances obtained in
reconstructing some key atmospherical parameters in the surface layer 0-30~m
studying the bias and the RMSE on a statistical sample of 20 nights. Results
were very encouraging and it appeared therefore mandatory to confirm such a
good result on a much richer statistical sample. In this paper, the study was
extended to a total sample of 129 nights between 2007 and 2011 distributed in
different parts of the solar year. This large sample made our analysis more
robust and definitive in terms of the model performances and permitted us to
confirm the excellent performances of the model. Besides, we present an
independent analysis of the model performances using the method of the
contingency tables. Such a method permitted us to provide complementary key
informations with respect to the bias and the RMSE particularly useful for an
operational implementation of a forecast system.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.3976 [pdf] - 1215678
Towards a reliability assessment of the Cn2 and wind speed vertical
profiles retrieved from GeMS
Submitted: 2014-07-15
The advent of a new generation of Adaptive Optics systems called Wide Field
AO (WFAO) mark the beginning of a new era. By using multiple Guide Stars (GSs),
either Laser Guide Stars (LGSs) or Natural Guide Stars (NGSs), WFAO
significantly increases the field of view of the AO-corrected images, and the
fraction of the sky that can benefit from such correction. Different typologies
of WFAO have been studied over the past years. They all require multiple GSs to
perform a tomographic analysis of the atmospheric turbulence. One of the
fundamental aspects of the new WFAO systems is the knowledge of the
spatio-temporal distribution of the turbulence above the telescope. One way to
get to this information is to use the telemetry data provided by the WFAO
system itself. Indeed, it has been demonstrated that WFAO systems allows one to
derive the Cn2 and wind profile in the main turbulence layers (see e.g. Cortes
et al. 2012). This method has the evident advantage to provide information on
the turbulence stratification that effectively affects the AO system, property
more difficultly respected by independently vertical profilers. In this paper,
we compare the wind speeds profiles of GeMS with those predicted by a
non-hydrostatical mesoscale atmospherical model (Meso-NH). It has been proved
(Masciadri et al., 2013), indeed, that this model is able to provide reliable
wind speed profiles on the whole troposphere and stratosphere (up to 20-25 km)
above top-level astronomical sites. Correlation with measurements revealed to
be very satisfactory when the model performances are analyzed from a
statistical point of view as well on individual nights. Such a system appears
therefore as an interesting reference to be used to quantify the GeMS wind
speed profiles reliability.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.2441 [pdf] - 744613
On the comparison between MASS and G-SCIDAR techniques
Submitted: 2013-11-11
The Multi Aperture Scintillation Sensor (MASS) and the
Generalized-Scintillation Detection and Ranging (Generalized SCIDAR) are two
instruments conceived to measure the optical turbulence (OT) vertical
distribution on the whole troposphere and low stratosphere (~ 20 km) widely
used in the astronomical context. In this paper we perform a detailed
analysis/comparison of measurements provided by the two instruments and taken
during the extended site testing campaign carried out on 2007 at Cerro Paranal
and promoted by the European Southern Observatory (ESO). The main and final
goal of the study is to provide a detailed estimation of the measurements
reliability i.e dispersion of turbulence measurements done by the two
instruments at different heights above the ground. This information is directly
related to our ability in estimating the absolute value of the turbulence
stratification. To better analyse the uncertainties between the MASS and the GS
we took advantage of the availability of measurements taken during the same
campaign by a third independent instrument (DIMM - Differential Imaging Motion
Monitor) measuring the integrated turbulence extended on the whole 20 km. Such
a cross-check comparison permitted us to define the reliability of the
instruments and their measurements, their limits and the contexts in which
their use can present some risk.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.6774 [pdf] - 724678
MOSE: optical turbulence and atmospherical parameters operational
forecast at ESO ground-based sites. II: atmospherical parameters in the
surface layer [0-30] m
Submitted: 2013-09-26
This article is the second of a series of articles aiming at proving the
feasibility of the forecast of all the most relevant classical atmospherical
parameters for astronomical applications (wind speed and direction,
temperature, relative humidity) and the optical turbulence (Cn2 and the derived
astro-climatic parameters like seeing, isoplanatic angle, wavefront coherence
time...). This study is done in the framework of the MOSE project, and focused
above the two ESO ground-bases sites of Cerro Paranal and Cerro Armazones. In
this paper we present the results related to the Meso-Nh model ability in
reconstructing the surface layer atmospherical parameters (wind speed
intensity, wind direction and absolute temperature, [0-30] m a.g.l.). The model
reconstruction of all the atmospherical parameters in the surface layer is very
satisfactory. For the temperature, at all levels, the RMSE (Root Mean Square
Error) is inferior to 1{\deg}C. For the wind speed, it is ~2 m/s, and for the
wind direction, it is in the range [38-46{\deg}], at all levels, that
corresponds to a RMSE_relative in a range [21-26{\deg}]. If a filter is applied
for the wind direction (the winds inferior to 3 m/s are discarded from the
computations), the wind direction RMSE is in the range [30-41{\deg}], i.e. a
RMSE_relative in the range [17-23{\deg}]. The model operational forecast of the
surface layer atmospherical parameters is suitable for different applications,
among others: thermalization of the dome using the reconstructed temperature,
hours in advance, of the beginning the night; knowing in advance the main
direction which the strong winds will come from during the night could allow
the astronomer to anticipate the occurrence of a good/bad seeing night, and
plan the observations accordingly; preventing adaptive secondary mirrors shake
generated by the wind speed.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.6775 [pdf] - 724679
MOSE: optical turbulence and atmospherical parameters operational
forecast at ESO ground-based sites. I: Overview and atmospherical parameters
vertical stratification on [0-20] km
Submitted: 2013-09-26
We present the overview of the MOSE project (MOdeling ESO Sites) aiming at
proving the feasibility of the forecast of the classical atmospherical
parameters (wind speed intensity and direction, temperature, relative humidity)
and the optical turbulence OT (CN2 profiles and the most relevant integrated
astro-climatic parameters derived from the CN2: the seeing, the isoplanatic
angle, the wavefront coherence time) above the two ESO ground-based sites of
Cerro Paranal and Cerro Armazones. The final outcome of the study is to
investigate the opportunity to implement an automatic system for the forecast
of these parameters at these sites. In this paper we present results related to
the Meso-Nh model ability in reconstructing the vertical stratification of the
atmospherical parameters along the 20 km above the ground. The very
satisfactory performances shown by the model in reconstructing most of these
parameters (and in particular the wind speed) put this tool of investigation as
the most suitable to be used in astronomical observatories to support AO
facilities and to calculate the temporal evolution of the wind speed and the
wavefront coherence time at whatever temporal sampling. The further great
advantage of this solution is that such estimates can be available in advance
(order of some hours) with respect to the time of interest
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.5445 [pdf] - 606443
MOSE: a feasibility study for optical turbulence forecasts with the
Meso-Nh mesoscale model to support AO facilities at ESO sites (Paranal and
Armazones)
Submitted: 2012-12-21
We present very encouraging preliminary results obtained in the context of
the MOSE project, an on-going study aiming at investigating the feasibility of
the forecast of the optical turbulence and meteorological parameters (in the
free atmosphere as well as in the boundary and surface layer) at Cerro Paranal
(site of the Very Large Telescope - VLT) and Cerro Armazones (site of the
European Extremely Large Telescope - E-ELT), both in Chile. The study employs
the Meso-Nh atmospheric mesoscale model and aims at supplying a tool for
optical turbulence forecasts to support the scheduling of the scientific
programs and the use of AO facilities at the VLT and the E-ELT. In this study
we take advantage of the huge amount of measurements performed so far at
Paranal and Armazones by ESO and the TMT consortium in the context of the site
selection for the E-ELT and the TMT to constraint/validate the model. A
detailed analysis of the model performances in reproducing the atmospheric
parameters (T, V, p, H, ...) near the ground as well as in the free atmosphere,
is critical and fundamental because the optical turbulence depends on most of
these parameters. This approach permits us to provide an exhaustive and
complete analysis of the model performances and to better define the model
operational application. This also helps us to identify the sources of
discrepancies with optical turbulence measurements (when they appear) and to
discriminate between different origins of the problem: model parameterization,
initial conditions, ... Preliminary results indicate a great accuracy of the
model in reproducing most of the main meteorological parameters in statistical
terms as well as in each individual night in the free atmosphere and in
proximity of the surface. The study is co-funded by ESO and INAF-Arcetri
(Italy).
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.5060 [pdf] - 606401
MOSE: zooming on the Meso-NH mesoscale model performances at the surface
layer at ESO sites (Paranal and Armazones)
Submitted: 2012-12-20
In the context of the MOSE project, in this contribution we present a
detailed analysis of the Meso-NH mesoscale model performances and their
dependency on the model and orography horizontal resolutions in proximity of
the ground. The investigated sites are Cerro Paranal (site of the ESO Very
Large Telescope - VLT) and Cerro Armazones (site of the ESO European Extremely
Large Telescope - E-ELT), in Chile. At both sites, data from a rich statistical
sample of different nights are available - from AWS (Automated Weather
Stations) and masts - giving access to wind speed, wind direction and
temperature at different levels near the ground (from 2 m to 30 m above the
ground). In this study we discuss the use of a very high horizontal resolution
(dX=0.1 km) numerical configuration that overcomes some specific limitations
put in evidence with a standard configuration with dX=0.5 km. In both sites
results are very promising. The study is co-funded by ESO and INAF.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.4861 [pdf] - 1091805
Re-calibrated Generalized-Scidar measurements at Cerro Paranal (VLT's
site)
Submitted: 2011-11-21, last modified: 2012-01-27
Generalized Scidar (GS) measurements taken at the Paranal Observatory in
November/December 2007 in the context of a site qualification for the future
European Extremely Large Telescope E-ELT are re-calibrated to overcome the bias
induced on the CN2 profiles by a not correct normalization of the
autocorrelation of the scintillation maps that has been recently identified in
the GS technique. A complete analysis of the GS corrected measurements as well
as of the corrected errors is performed statistically as well as on individual
nights and for each time during all nights. The relative errors of the CN2
profiles can reach up to 60% in some narrow temporal windows and some vertical
slabs, the total seeing up to 12% and the total integrated turbulence J up to
21%. However, the statistic analysis tells us that the absolute errors of the
median values of the total seeing is 0.06 arcsec (relative error 5.6%), for the
boundary seeing 0.05 arcsec (relative error 5.6%) and for the seeing in the
free atmosphere 0.04 arcsec (relative error 9%). We find that, in spite of the
fact that the relative error increases with the height, the boundary and the
free atmosphere seeing contribute in an equivalent way to the error on the
total seeing in absolute terms. Besides, we find that there are no correlations
between the relative errors and the value of the correspondent seeing. The
absolute error of the median value of the isoplanatic angle is 0.13 arcsec
(relative error 6.9%).
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.2667 [pdf] - 359127
Optical turbulence simulations at Mt Graham using the Meso-NH mode
Submitted: 2011-05-13
The mesoscale model Meso-NH is used to simulate the optical turbulence at Mt
Graham (Arizona, USA), site of the Large Binocular Telescope. Measurements of
the CN2-profiles obtained with a generalized scidar from 41 nights are used to
calibrate and quantify the model's ability to reconstruct the optical
turbulence. The measurements are distributed over different periods of the
year, permitting us to study the model's performance in different seasons. A
statistical analysis of the simulations is performed for all the most important
astroclimatic parameters: the CN2-profiles, the seeing {\epsilon}, the
isoplanatic angle {\theta}0 and the wavefront coherence time {\tau}0. The model
shows a general good ability in reconstructing the morphology of the optical
turbulence (the shape of the vertical distribution of CN2) as well as the
strength of all the integrated astroclimatic parameters. The relative error
(with respect to measurements) of the averaged seeing on the whole atmosphere
for the whole sample of 41 nights is within 9.0 %. The median value of the
relative error night by night is equal to 18.7 %, so that the model still
maintains very good performances. Comparable percentages are observed in
partial vertical slabs (free atmosphere and boundary layer) and in different
seasons (summer and winter). We prove that the most urgent problem, at present,
is to increase the ability of the model in reconstructing very weak and very
strong turbulence conditions in the high atmosphere. This mainly affects the
model's performances for the isoplanatic angle predictions, for which the
median value of the relative error night by night is equal to 35.1 %. No major
problems are observed for the other astroclimatic parameters. A variant to the
standard calibration method is tested but we find that it does not provide
better results, confirming the solid base of the standard method.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.5592 [pdf] - 394310
Optical turbulence: site selection above the internal Antarctic plateau
with a mesoscale model
Submitted: 2010-11-25
Atmospherical mesoscale models can offer unique potentialities to
characterize and discriminate potential astronomical sites. Our team has
recently completely validated the Meso-Nh model above Dome C (Lascaux et al.
2009, 2010). Using all the measurements of CN2 profiles (15 nights) performed
so far at Dome C during the winter time (Trinquet et al. 2008) we proved that
the model can reconstruct, on rich statistical samples, reliable values of all
the three most important parameters characterizing the turbulence features of
an antarctic site: the surface layer thickness, the seeing in the free
atmosphere and in the surface layer. Using the same Meso-Nh model configuration
validated above Dome C, an extended study is now on-going for other sites above
the antarctic plateau, more precisely South Pole and Dome A. In this
contribution we present the most important results obtained in the model
validation process and the results obtained in the comparison between different
astronomical sites above the internal plateau. The Meso-Nh model confirms its
ability in discriminating between different optical turbulence behaviors, and
there is evidence that the three sites have different characteristics regarding
the seeing and the surface layer thickness. We highlight that this study
provides the first homogeneous estimate, done with comparable statistics, of
the optical turbulence developed in the whole 20-22 km above the ground at Dome
C, South Pole and Dome A.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.5577 [pdf] - 269367
A dedicated tool for a full 3D Cn2 investigation
Submitted: 2010-11-25
We present in this study a mapping of the optical turbulence (OT) above
different astronomical sites. The mesoscale model Meso-NH was used together
with the Astro-Meso-Nh package and a set of diagnostic tools allowing for a
full 3D investigation of the Cn2. The diagnostics implemented in the
Astro-Meso-Nh, allowing for a full 3D investigation of the OT structure in a
volumetric space above different sites, are presented. To illustrate the
different diagnostics and their potentialities, we investigated one night and
looked at instantaneous fields of meteorologic and astroclimatic parameters. To
show the potentialities of this tool for applications in an Observatory we ran
the model above sites with very different OT distributions: the antarctic
plateau (Dome C, Dome A, South Pole) and a mid-latitude site (Mt. Graham,
Arizona). We put particular emphasis on the 2D maps of integrated astroclimatic
parameters (seeing, isoplanatic angles) calculated in different slices at
different heights in the troposhere. This is an useful tool of prediction and
investigation of the turbulence structure. It can support the optimization of
the AO, GLAO and MCAO systems running at the focus of the ground-based
telescopes.From this studies it emerges that the astronomical sites clearly
present different OT behaviors. Besides, our tool allowed us for discriminating
these sites.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.5583 [pdf] - 269370
Mt. Graham: Optical turbulence vertical distribution at standard and
high vertical resolution
Submitted: 2010-11-25
A characterization of the optical turbulence vertical distribution and all
the main integrated astroclimatic parameters derived from the CN2 and the wind
speed profiles above Mt. Graham is presented. The statistic includes
measurements related to 43 nights done with a Generalized Scidar (GS) used in
standard configuration with a vertical resolution of ~1 km on the whole 20-22
km and with the new technique (HVR-GS) in the first kilometer. The latter
achieves a resolution of ~ 20-30 m in this region of the atmosphere.
Measurements done in different periods of the year permit us to provide a
seasonal variation analysis of the CN2. A discretized distribution of the
typical CN2 profiles useful for the Ground Layer Adaptive Optics (GLAO)
simulations is provided and a specific analysis for the LBT Laser Guide Star
system ARGOS case is done including the calculation of the 'gray zones' for J,
H and K bands. Mt. Graham confirms to be an excellent site with median values
of the seeing without dome contribution equal to 0.72", the isoplanatic angle
equal to 2.5" and the wavefront coherence time equal to 4.8 msec. We provide a
cumulative distribution of the percentage of turbulence developed below H*
where H* is included in the (0,1 km) range. We find that 50% of the whole
turbulence develops in the first 80 m from the ground. The turbulence
decreasing rate is very similar to what has been observed above Mauna Kea.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.1413 [pdf] - 255002
Mesoscale optical turbulence simulations above Dome C, Dome A and South
Pole
Submitted: 2010-11-05, last modified: 2010-11-08
In two recent papers the mesoscale model Meso-NH, joint with the
Astro-Meso-NH package, has been validated at Dome C, Antarctica, for the
characterization of the optical turbulence. It has been shown that the
meteorological parameters (temperature and wind speed, from which the optical
turbulence depends on) as well as the Cn2 profiles above Dome C were correctly
statistically reproduced. The three most important derived parameters that
characterize the optical turbulence above the internal antarctic plateau: the
surface layer thickness, the seeing in the free-atmosphere and in the total
atmosphere showed to be in a very good agreement with observations. Validation
of Cn2 has been performed using all the measurements of the optical turbulence
vertical distribution obtained in winter so far. In this paper, in order to
investigate the ability of the model to discriminate between different
turbulence conditions for site testing, we extend the study to two other
potential astronomical sites in Antarctica: Dome A and South Pole, which we
expect to be characterized by different turbulence conditions. The optical
turbulence has been calculated above these two sites for the same 15 nights
studied for Dome C and a comparison between the three sites has been performed.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.5250 [pdf] - 229036
Wind speed vertical distribution at Mt. Graham
Submitted: 2010-05-28
The characterization of the wind speed vertical distribution V(h) is
fundamental for an astronomical site for many different reasons: (1) the wind
speed shear contributes to trigger optical turbulence in the whole troposphere,
(2) a few of the astroclimatic parameters such as the wavefront coherence time
(tau_0) depends directly on V(h), (3) the equivalent velocity V_0, controlling
the frequency at which the adaptive optics systems have to run to work
properly, depends on the vertical distribution of the wind speed and optical
turbulence. Also, a too strong wind speed near the ground can introduce
vibrations in the telescope structures. The wind speed at a precise pressure
(200 hPa) has frequently been used to retrieve indications concerning the tau_0
and the frequency limits imposed to all instrumentation based on adaptive
optics systems, but more recently it has been proved that V_200 (wind speed at
200 hPa) alone is not sufficient to provide exhaustive elements concerning this
topic and that the vertical distribution of the wind speed is necessary. In
this paper a complete characterization of the vertical distribution of wind
speed strength is done above Mt.Graham (Arizona, US), site of the Large
Binocular Telescope. We provide a climatological study extended over 10 years
using the operational analyses from the European Centre for Medium-Range
Weather Forecasts (ECMWF), we prove that this is representative of the wind
speed vertical distribution at Mt. Graham with exception of the boundary layer
and we prove that a mesoscale model can provide reliable nightly estimates of
V(h) above this astronomical site from the ground up to the top of the
atmosphere (~ 20 km).
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.3244 [pdf] - 122302
Comparison of the atmosphere above the South Pole, Dome C and Dome A:
first attempt
Submitted: 2010-02-17
The atmospheric properties above three sites (Dome A, Dome C and the South
Pole) are investigated for astronomical applications using the monthly median
of the analyses from the ECMWF (European Centre for Medium-Range Weather
Forecasts). Radiosoundings extended on a yearly time-scale at the South Pole
and Dome C are used to quantify the reliability of the ECMWF analyses in the
free atmosphere as well as in the boundary and surface layers, and to
characterize the median wind speed in the first 100 m above the two sites.
Thermodynamic instabilities in the free atmosphere above the three sites are
quantified with monthly median values of the Richardson number. We will present
a ranking of the sites with respect to the thermodynamic stability, using the
Richardson number, and with respect to the wind speed, in the free atmosphere
(using ECMWF analyses) as well as in the surface layer (using radiosoundings).
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.0264 [pdf] - 33375
Study of the winter 2005 Antarctica polar vortex
Submitted: 2010-02-01
During winter and springtime, the flow above Antarctica at high altitude
(upper troposphere and stratosphere) is dominated by the presence of a vortex
centered above the continent. It lasts typically from August to November. This
vortex is characterized by a strong cyclonic jet centered above the polar high.
In a recent study of our group (Hagelin et al., 2008) of four different sites
in the Antarctic internal plateau (South Pole, Dome C, Dome A and Dome F), it
was made the hypothesis that the wind speed strength in the upper atmosphere
should be related to the distance of the site to the center of the Antarctic
polar vortex. This high altitude wind is very important from an astronomical
point of view since it might trigger the onset of the optical turbulence and
strongly affect other optical turbulence parameters. What we are interested in
here is to localize the position of the minimum value of the wind speed at high
altitude in order to confirm the hypothesis of Hagelin et al. (2008).
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.0245 [pdf] - 33374
Numerical simulations of Optical Turbulence at low and high horizontal
resolution in Antarctica with a mesoscale meteorological model
Submitted: 2010-02-01
It has already been demonstrated that a mesoscale meteorological model such
as Meso-NH is highly reliable in reproducing 3D maps of optical turbulence.
Preliminary measurements above the Antarctic Plateau have so far indicated a
pretty good value for the seeing: around 0.3" at Dome C. However some
uncertainties remain. That's why our group is focusing on a detailed study of
the atmospheric flow and turbulence in the internal Antarctic Plateau. Our
intention is to use the Meso-NH model to do predictions of the atmospheric flow
and the corresponding optical turbulence in the internal plateau. The use of
this model has another huge advantage: we have access to informations inside an
entire 3D volume which is not the case with observations only. Two different
configurations have been used: a low horizontal resolution (with a mesh-size of
100 km) and a high horizontal resolution with the grid-nesting interactive
technique (with a mesh-size of 1 km in the innermost domain centered above the
area of interest). We present here the turbulence distribution reconstructed by
Meso-NH for 16 nights monitored in winter time 2005, looking at the the seeing
and the surface layer thickness.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.3772 [pdf] - 33008
Comparison of the atmospheric properties above Dome A, Dome C, and the
South Pole
Submitted: 2010-01-21
The atmospheric properties above three sites on the Internal Antarctic
Plateau are investigated for astronomical applications calculating the monthly
median of the analysis-data from ECMWF (European Centre for Medium-Range
Weather Forecasts) for an entire year (2005) thus covering all seasons.
Radiosoundings extended on a yearly time scale from Dome C and the South Pole
are used to verify the reliability of the analyses in the free atmosphere and
to study the wind speed in the first 100 m as the analysis-data are not
optimized for this altitude-range. The wind speed in the free atmosphere is
obtained from the ECMWF analyses from all three sites. It appears that the
strength of the wind speed in the upper atmosphere in winter is correlated to
the distance of the site from the centre of the polar high. The Richardson
number is employed to investigate the stability of the free atmosphere and,
consequently, the probability to trigger thermodynamic instabilities above the
three sites. We find that, in a large majority of the cases, the free
atmosphere over the Internal Antarctic Plateau is more stable than at
mid-latitude sites. Given these data we can obtain a ranking of the three sites
with respect to wind speed, in the free atmosphere as well as in the surface
layer, and with respect to the stability of the atmosphere, using the
Richardson number.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.1304 [pdf] - 269218
Optical turbulence vertical distribution with standard and high
resolution at Mt. Graham
Submitted: 2010-01-08, last modified: 2010-01-11
A characterization of the optical turbulence vertical distribution (Cn2
profiles) and all the main integrated astroclimatic parameters derived from the
Cn2 and the wind speed profiles above the site of the Large Binocular Telescope
(Mt. Graham, Arizona, US) is presented. The statistic includes measurements
related to 43 nights done with a Generalized Scidar (GS) used in standard
configuration with a vertical resolution Delta(H)~1 km on the whole 20 km and
with the new technique (HVR-GS) in the first kilometer. The latter achieves a
resolution Delta(H)~20-30 m in this region of the atmosphere. Measurements done
in different periods of the year permit us to provide a seasonal variation
analysis of the Cn2. A discretized distribution of Cn2 useful for the Ground
Layer Adaptive Optics (GLAO) simulations is provided and a specific analysis
for the LBT Laser Guide Star system ARGOS (running in GLAO configuration) case
is done including the calculation of the 'gray zones' for J, H and K bands. Mt.
Graham confirms to be an excellent site with median values of the seeing
without dome contribution epsilon = 0.72", the isoplanatic angle theta0 = 2.5"
and the wavefront coherence time tau0= 4.8 msec. We find that the optical
turbulence vertical distribution decreases in a much sharper way than what has
been believed so far in proximity of the ground above astronomical sites. We
find that 50% of the whole turbulence develops in the first 80+/-15 m from the
ground. We finally prove that the error in the normalization of the
scintillation that has been recently put in evidence in the principle of the GS
technique, affects these measurements with an absolutely negligible quantity
(0.04").
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.1430 [pdf] - 1019079
Optical Turbulence above the Internal Antarctic Plateau
Submitted: 2010-01-09
The internal antarctic plateau revealed in the last years to be a site with
interesting potentialities for the astronomical applications due to the extreme
dryness and low temperatures, the typical high altitude of the plateau, the
weak level of turbulence in the free atmosphere down to a just few tens of
meters from the ground and the thin optical turbulence layer developed at the
ground. The main goal of a site testing assessment above the internal antarctic
plateau is to characterize the site (optical turbulence and classical
meteorological parameters) and to quantify which is the gain we might obtain
with respect to equivalent astronomical observations done above mid-latitude
sites to support plans for future astronomical facilities. Our group is
involved, since a few years, in studies related to the assessment of this site
for astronomical applications that include the characterization of the
meteorological parameters and optical turbulence provided by general
circulation models as well as mesoscale atmospherical models and the
quantification of the performances of Adaptive Optics (AO) systems. In this
talk I will draw the status of art of this site assessment putting our studies
in the context of the wide international site testing activity that has been
done in Antarctica. I will focus on the site assessment relevant for
astronomical applications to be done in the visible up to the near infrared
ranges, i.e. those ranges for which the optical turbulence represents a
perturbing element for the quality of the images and the AO techniques an
efficient tool to correct these wavefront perturbations.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.1288 [pdf] - 269217
Mesoscale optical turbulence simulations at Dome C: refinements
Submitted: 2010-01-08
In a recent paper the authors presented an extended study aiming at
simulating the classical meteorological parameters and the optical turbulence
at Dome C during the winter with the atmospherical mesoscale model Meso-NH. A
statistical analysis has been presented and the conclusions of that paper have
been very promising. Wind speed and temperature fields revealed to be very well
reconstructed by the Meso-NH model with better performances than what has been
achieved with the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecast (ECMWF)
global model, especially near the surface. All results revealed to be
resolution-dependent and it has been proved that a grid-nesting configuration
(3 domains) with a high horizontal resolution (1km) for the innermost domain is
necessary to reconstruct all the optical turbulence features with a good
correlation to measurements. High resolution simulations provided an averaged
surface layer thickness just ~14 m higher than what is estimated by
measurements, the seeing in the free atmosphere showed a dispersion from the
observed one of just a few hundredths of an arcsecond (~0.05"). The unique
limitation of the previous study was that the optical turbulence in the surface
layer appeared overestimated by the model in both low and high resolution
modes. In this study we present the results obtained with an improved numerical
configuration. The same 15 nights have been simulated, and we show that the
model results now match almost perfectly the observations in all their
features: the surface thickness, the seeing in the free atmosphere as well as
in the surface layer. This result permits us to investigate now other antarctic
sites using a robust numerical model well adapted to the extreme polar
conditions (Meso-NH).
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.0484 [pdf] - 32399
Meso-Nh simulations of the atmospheric flow above the Internal Antarctic
Plateau
Submitted: 2010-01-04
Mesoscale model such as Meso-Nh have proven to be highly reliable in
reproducing 3D maps of optical turbulence (see Refs. 1, 2, 3, 4) above
mid-latitude astronomical sites. These last years ground-based astronomy has
been looking towards Antarctica. Especially its summits and the Internal
Continental Plateau where the optical turbulence appears to be confined in a
shallow layer close to the icy surface. Preliminary measurements have so far
indicated pretty good value for the seeing above 30-35 m: 0.36" (see Ref. 5)
and 0.27" (see Refs. 6, 7) at Dome C. Site testing campaigns are however
extremely expensive, instruments provide only local measurements and
atmospheric modelling might represent a step ahead towards the search and
selection of astronomical sites thanks to the possibility to reconstruct 3D Cn2
maps over a surface of several kilometers. The Antarctic Plateau represents
therefore an important benchmark test to evaluate the possibility to
discriminate sites on the same plateau. Our group8 has proven that the analyses
from the ECMWF global model do not describe with the required accuracy the
antarctic boundary and surface layer in the plateau. A better description could
be obtained with a mesoscale meteorological model. In this contribution we
present the progress status report of numerical simulations (including the
optical turbulence - Cn2) obtained with Meso-Nh above the internal Antarctic
Plateau. Among the topic attacked: the influence of different configurations of
the model (low and high horizontal resolution), use of the grid-nesting
interactive technique, forecasting of the optical turbulence during some winter
nights.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.0564 [pdf] - 32415
A different glance to the site testing above Dome C
Submitted: 2010-01-04
Due to the recent interest shown by astronomers towards the Antarctic Plateau
as a potential site for large astronomical facilities, we assisted in the last
years to a strengthening of site testing activities in this region,
particularly at Dome C. Most of the results collected so far concern
meteorologic parameters and optical turbulence measurements based on different
principles using different instruments. At present we have several elements
indicating that, above the first 20-30 meters, the quality of the optical
turbulence above Dome C is better than above whatever other site in the world.
The challenging question, crucial to know which kind of facilities to build on,
is to establish how much better the Dome C is than a mid-latitude site. In this
contribution we will provide some complementary elements and strategies of
analysis aiming to answer to this question. We will try to concentrate the
attention on critical points, i.e. open questions that still require
explanation/attention.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.4303 [pdf] - 32121
The widest contiguous field of view at Dome C and Mount Graham
Submitted: 2009-12-22
The image quality from Ground-Layer Adaptive Optics (GLAO) can be gradually
increased with decreased contiguous field of view. This trade-off is dependent
on the vertical profile of the optical turbulence (Cn2 profiles). It is known
that the accuracy of the vertical distribution measured by existing Cn2
profiling techniques is currently quite uncertain for wide field performance
predictions 4 to 20 arcminutes. With assumed uncertainties in measurements from
Generalized-SCIDAR (GS), SODAR plus MASS we quantify the impact of this
uncertainty on the trade-off between field of view and image quality for
photometry of science targets at the resolution limit. We use a point spread
function (PSF) model defined analytically in the spatial frequency domain to
compute the relevant photometry figure of merit at infrared wavelengths.
Statistics of this PSF analysis on a database of Cn2 measurements are presented
for Mt. Graham, Arizona and Dome C, Antarctica. This research is part of the
activities of ForOT (3D Forecasting of Optical Turbulence above astronomical
sites).
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.0129 [pdf] - 24784
Mesoscale Optical Turbulence simulations at Dome C
Submitted: 2009-06-01
These last years ground-based astronomy has been looking towards Antarctica,
especially its summits and the internal continental plateau where the optical
turbulence (OT) appears to be confined in a shallow layer close to the surface.
Preliminary measurements have so far indicated pretty good value for the seeing
above 30-35 m: 0.36" (Agabi et al. 2006), 0.27" (Lawrence et al. 2004) and 0.3"
(Trinquet et al. 2008) at Dome C. Site testing campaigns are however extremely
expensive, instruments provide only local measurements and atmospheric modeling
might represent a step ahead towards the search and selection of astronomical
sites thanks to the possibility to reconstruct 3D Cn2 maps over a surface of
several kilometers. The Antarctic Plateau represents therefore an important
benchmark test to evaluate the possibility to discriminate sites on the same
plateau. Our group (Hagelin et al. 2008) has proven that the analyses from the
ECMWF global model do not describe with the required accuracy the antarctic
boundary and surface layers in the plateau. A better description could be
obtained with a mesoscale model. The Meso-Nh model has proven to be reliable in
reproducing 3D maps of OT above mid-latitude astronomical sites (Masciadri et
al. 1999ab, 2004, Masciadri and Jabouille 2005). In this paper we study the
ability of the Meso-Nh model in reconstructing the meteorological parameters as
well as the OT above Dome C with different model configurations. We concentrate
our attention on the model abilities in reproducing the OT surface layer
thickness Hsl and the integral of the Cn2 in the free atmosphere and in the
surface layer. It is worth to highlight that these are the first estimates ever
done so far with a mesoscale model of the optical turbulence above the internal
Antarctic Plateau.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:0806.3388 [pdf] - 900328
Comparison of the atmosphere above the South Pole, Dome C and Dome A:
first attempt
Submitted: 2008-06-20
The atmospheric properties above three sites (Dome C, Dome A and the South
Pole) on the Internal Antarctic Plateau are investigated for astronomical
applications using the monthly median of the analyses from ECMWF (the European
Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts). Radiosoundings extended on a yearly
time scale at the South Pole and Dome C are used to quantify the reliability of
the ECMWF analyses in the free atmosphere as well as in the boundary and
surface layers, and to characterize the median wind speed in the first 100 m
above the two sites. Thermodynamic instability properties in the free
atmosphere above the three sites are quantified with monthly median values of
the Richardson number. We find that the probability to trigger thermodynamic
instabilities above 100 m is smaller on the Internal Antarctic Plateau than on
mid-latitude sites. In spite of the generally more stable atmospheric
conditions of the Antarctic sites compared to mid-latitude sites, Dome C shows
worse thermodynamic instability conditions than those predicted above the South
Pole and Dome A above 100 m. A rank of the Antarctic sites done with respect to
the strength of the wind speed in the free atmosphere (ECMWF analyses) as well
as the wind shear in the surface layer (radiosoundings) is presented.