Normalized to: Laibe, G.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.06050 [pdf] - 2132050
Protostellar collapse: the conditions to form dust rich protoplanetary
disks
Submitted: 2020-07-12
Dust plays a key role during star, disk and planet formation. Yet, its
dynamics during the protostellar collapse remains a poorly investigated field.
Recent studies seem to indicate that dust may decouple efficiently from the gas
during these early stages. We aim to understand how much and in which regions
dust grains concentrate during the early phases of the protostellar collapse,
and see how it depends on the properties of the initial cloud and of the solid
particles. We use the multiple species dust dynamics solver of the grid-based
code RAMSES to perform various simulations of dusty collapses. We perform
hydrodynamical and MHD simulations where we vary the maximum grain size, the
thermal-to-gravitational energy ratio and the magnetic properties of the cloud.
We simulate the simultaneous evolution of ten neutral dust grains species with
grain sizes varying from a few nm to a few hundredth of microns. We obtain a
significant decoupling between the gas and the dust for grains of typical sizes
a few 10 microns. This decoupling strongly depends on the
thermal-to-gravitational energy ratio, the grain sizes or the inclusion of a
magnetic field. With a semi-analytic model calibrated on our results, we show
that the dust ratio mostly varies exponentially with the initial Stokes number
at a rate that depends on the local cloud properties. We find that larger
grains tend to settle and drift efficiently in the first-core and in the newly
formed disk. This can produce dust-to-gas ratios of several times the initial
value. Dust concentrates in high density regions and is depleted in low density
regions. The size at which grains decouple from the gas depends on the initial
properties of the clouds. Since dust can not necessarily be used as a proxy for
gas during the collapse, we emphasize on the necessity of including the
treatment of its dynamics in collapse simulations.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.08850 [pdf] - 2129358
VLT/SPHERE survey for exoplanets around young, early-type stars
including systems with multi-belt architectures
Lombart, M.;
Chauvin, G.;
Rojo, P.;
Lagadec, E.;
Delorme, P.;
Beust, H.;
Bonnefoy, M.;
Galicher, R.;
Gratton, R.;
Mesa, D.;
Bonavita, M.;
Allard, F.;
Bayo, A.;
Boccaletti, A.;
Desidera, S.;
Girard, J.;
Jenkins, J. S.;
Klahr, H.;
Laibe, G.;
Lagrange, A. -M.;
Lazzoni, C.;
Marleau, G. -D.;
Minniti, D.;
Mordasini, C.
Submitted: 2020-05-18, last modified: 2020-06-05
Dusty debris disks around pre- and main-sequence stars are potential
signposts for the existence of planetesimals and exoplanets. Giant planet
formation is therefore expected to play a key role in the evolution of the
disk. This is indirectly confirmed by extant sub-millimeter near-infrared
images of young protoplanetary and cool dusty debris disks around main sequence
stars usually showing substantial spatial structures. A majority of recent
discoveries of imaged giant planets have been obtained around young, early-type
stars hosting a circumstellar disk. In this context, we have carried out a
direct imaging program designed to maximize our chances of giant planet
discovery and targeting twenty-two young, early-type stars. About half of them
show indication of multi-belt architectures. Using the IRDIS dual-band imager
and the IFS integral field spectrograph of SPHERE to acquire high-constrast
coronagraphic differential near-infrared images, we have conducted a systematic
search in the close environment of these young, dusty and early-type stars. We
confirmed that companions detected around HIP 34276, HIP 101800 and HIP 117452
are stationary background sources and binary companions. The companion
candidates around HIP 8832, HIP 16095 and HIP 95619 are determined as
background contamination. For stars for which we infer the presence of debris
belts, a theoretical minimum mass for planets required to clear the debris gaps
can be calculated . The dynamical mass limit is at least $0.1 M_J$ and can
exceed $1 M_J$. Direct imaging data is typically sensitive to planets down to
$\sim 3.6 M_J$ at 1 $''$, and $1.7 M_J$ in the best case. These two limits
tightly constrain the possible planetary systems present around each target.
These systems will be probably detectable with the next generation of planet
imagers.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.06562 [pdf] - 2101543
A solution to the overdamping problem when simulating dust-gas mixtures
with smoothed particle hydrodynamics
Submitted: 2020-05-13
We present a fix to the overdamping problem found by Laibe & Price (2012)
when simulating strongly coupled dust-gas mixtures using two different sets of
particles using smoothed particle hydrodynamics. Our solution is to compute the
drag at the barycentre between gas and dust particle pairs when computing the
drag force by reconstructing the velocity field, similar to the procedure in
Godunov-type solvers. This fixes the overdamping problem at negligible
computational cost, but with additional memory required to store velocity
derivatives. We employ slope limiters to avoid spurious oscillations at shocks,
finding the van Leer Monotonized Central limiter most effective.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.03689 [pdf] - 2093284
On the settling of small grains in dusty discs: analysis and formulas
Submitted: 2020-04-07
Instruments achieve sharper and finer observations of micron-in-size dust
grains in the top layers of young stellar discs. To provide accurate models, we
revisit the theory of dust settling for small grains, when gas stratification,
dust inertia and finite correlation times for the turbulence should be handled
simultaneously. We start from a balance of forces and derive distributions at
steady-state. Asymptotic expansions require caution since limits do not
commute. In particular, non-physical bumpy distributions appear when turbulence
is purely diffusive. This excludes very short correlation times for real discs,
as predicted by numerical simulations.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.05714 [pdf] - 2063822
SPHERE+: Imaging young Jupiters down to the snowline
Boccaletti, A.;
Chauvin, G.;
Mouillet, D.;
Absil, O.;
Allard, F.;
Antoniucci, S.;
Augereau, J. -C.;
Barge, P.;
Baruffolo, A.;
Baudino, J. -L.;
Baudoz, P.;
Beaulieu, M.;
Benisty, M.;
Beuzit, J. -L.;
Bianco, A.;
Biller, B.;
Bonavita, B.;
Bonnefoy, M.;
Bos, S.;
Bouret, J. -C.;
Brandner, W.;
Buchschache, N.;
Carry, B.;
Cantalloube, F.;
Cascone, E.;
Carlotti, A.;
Charnay, B.;
Chiavassa, A.;
Choquet, E.;
Clenet, Y.;
Crida, A.;
De Boer, J.;
De Caprio, V.;
Desidera, S.;
Desert, J. -M.;
Delisle, J. -B.;
Delorme, P.;
Dohlen, K.;
Doelman, D.;
Dominik, C.;
Orazi, V. D;
Dougados, C.;
Doute, S.;
Fedele, D.;
Feldt, M.;
Ferreira, F.;
Fontanive, C.;
Fusco, T.;
Galicher, R.;
Garufi, A.;
Gendron, E.;
Ghedina, A.;
Ginski, C.;
Gonzalez, J. -F.;
Gratadour, D.;
Gratton, R.;
Guillot, T.;
Haffert, S.;
Hagelberg, J.;
Henning, T.;
Huby, E.;
Janson, M.;
Kamp, I.;
Keller, C.;
Kenworthy, M.;
Kervella, P.;
Kral, Q.;
Kuhn, J.;
Lagadec, E.;
Laibe, G.;
Langlois, M.;
Lagrange, A. -M.;
Launhardt, R.;
Leboulleux, L.;
Coroller, H. Le;
Causi, G. Li;
Loupias, M.;
Maire, A. L.;
Marleau, G.;
Martinache, F.;
Martinez, P.;
Mary, D.;
Mattioli, M.;
Mazoyer, J.;
Meheut, H.;
Menard, F.;
Mesa, D.;
Meunier, N.;
Miguel, Y.;
Milli, J.;
Min, M.;
Molliere, P.;
Mordasini, C.;
Moretto, G.;
Mugnier, L.;
Arena, G. Muro;
Nardetto, N.;
Diaye, M. N;
Nesvadba, N.;
Pedichini, F.;
Pinilla, P.;
Por, E.;
Potier, A.;
Quanz, S.;
Rameau, J.;
Roelfsema, R.;
Rouan, D.;
Rigliaco, E.;
Salasnich, B.;
Samland, M.;
Sauvage, J. -F.;
Schmid, H. -M.;
Segransan, D.;
Snellen, I.;
Snik, F.;
Soulez, F.;
Stadler, E.;
Stam, D.;
Tallon, M.;
Thebault, P.;
Thiebaut, E.;
Tschudi, C.;
Udry, S.;
van Holstein, R.;
Vernazza, P.;
Vidal, F.;
Vigan, A.;
Waters, R.;
Wildi, F.;
Willson, M.;
Zanutta, A.;
Zavagno, A.;
Zurlo, A.
Submitted: 2020-03-12, last modified: 2020-03-13
SPHERE (Beuzit et al,. 2019) has now been in operation at the VLT for more
than 5 years, demonstrating a high level of performance. SPHERE has produced
outstanding results using a variety of operating modes, primarily in the field
of direct imaging of exoplanetary systems, focusing on exoplanets as point
sources and circumstellar disks as extended objects. The achievements obtained
thus far with SPHERE (~200 refereed publications) in different areas
(exoplanets, disks, solar system, stellar physics...) have motivated a large
consortium to propose an even more ambitious set of science cases, and its
corresponding technical implementation in the form of an upgrade. The SPHERE+
project capitalizes on the expertise and lessons learned from SPHERE to push
high contrast imaging performance to its limits on the VLT 8m-telescope. The
scientific program of SPHERE+ described in this document will open a new and
compelling scientific window for the upcoming decade in strong synergy with
ground-based facilities (VLT/I, ELT, ALMA, and SKA) and space missions (Gaia,
JWST, PLATO and WFIRST). While SPHERE has sampled the outer parts of planetary
systems beyond a few tens of AU, SPHERE+ will dig into the inner regions around
stars to reveal and characterize by mean of spectroscopy the giant planet
population down to the snow line. Building on SPHERE's scientific heritage and
resounding success, SPHERE+ will be a dedicated survey instrument which will
strengthen the leadership of ESO and the European community in the very
competitive field of direct imaging of exoplanetary systems. With enhanced
capabilities, it will enable an even broader diversity of science cases
including the study of the solar system, the birth and death of stars and the
exploration of the inner regions of active galactic nuclei.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.02692 [pdf] - 2030735
Channels for streaming instability in dusty discs
Submitted: 2020-01-08
Streaming instability is a privileged channel to bridge the gap between
collisional growth of dust grains and planetesimal formation triggered by
gravity. This instability is thought to develop through its secular mode, which
is long-time growing and may not develop easily in real discs. We address this
point by revisiting its perturbation analysis. A third-order expansion with
respect to the Stokes number reveals important features over-looked so far. The
secular mode can be stable. Epicycles can be unstable, more resistant to
viscosity and are identified by Green's function analysis as promising channels
for planetesimals formation.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.03182 [pdf] - 2026281
The Acceleration of Superrotation in Simulated Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
Submitted: 2019-11-08
Context. Atmospheric superrotating flows at the equator are an almost
ubiquitous result of simulations of hot Jupiters, and a theory explaining how
this zonally coherent flow reaches an equilibrium has been developed in the
literature. However, this understanding relies on the existence of either an
initial superrotating or a sheared flow, coupled with a slow evolution such
that a linear steady state can be reached. Aims. A consistent physical
understanding of superrotation is needed for arbitrary drag and radiative
timescales, and the relevance of considering linear steady states needs to be
assessed. Methods. We obtain an analytical expression for the structure,
frequency and decay rate of propagating waves in hot Jupiter atmospheres around
a state at rest in the 2D shallow water beta plane limit. We solve this
expression numerically and confirm the robustness of our results with a 3D
linear wave algorithm. We then compare with 3D simulations of hot Jupiter
atmospheres and study the non linear momentum fluxes. Results. We show that
under strong day night heating the dynamics does not transit through a linear
steady state when starting from an initial atmosphere in solid body rotation.
We further show that non linear effects favour the initial spin up of
superrotation and that the acceleration due to the vertical component of the
eddy momentum flux is critical to the initial development of superrotation.
Conclusions. Overall, we describe the initial phases of the acceleration of
superrotation, including consideration of differing radiative and drag
timescales, and conclude that eddy-momentum driven superrotating equatorial
jets are robust, physical phenomena in simulations of hot Jupiter atmospheres.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.06822 [pdf] - 1994321
Flybys in protoplanetary discs: II. Observational signatures
Cuello, Nicolás;
Louvet, Fabien;
Mentiplay, Daniel;
Pinte, Christophe;
Price, Daniel J.;
Winter, Andrew J.;
Nealon, Rebecca;
Ménard, François;
Lodato, Giuseppe;
Dipierro, Giovanni;
Christiaens, Valentin;
Montesinos, Matías;
Cuadra, Jorge;
Laibe, Guillaume;
Cieza, Lucas;
Dong, Ruobing;
Alexander, Richard
Submitted: 2019-10-15
Tidal encounters in star clusters perturb discs around young protostars. In
Cuello et al. (2019a, Paper I) we detailed the dynamical signatures of a
stellar flyby in both gas and dust. Flybys produce warped discs, spirals with
evolving pitch angles, increasing accretion rates, and disc truncation. Here we
present the corresponding observational signatures of these features in
optical/near-infrared scattered light and (sub-) millimeter continuum and CO
line emission. Using representative prograde and retrograde encounters for
direct comparison, we post-process hydrodynamical simulations with radiative
transfer methods to generate a catalogue of multi-wavelength observations. This
provides a reference to identify flybys in recent near-infrared and
sub-millimetre observations (e.g., RW Aur, AS 205, HV Tau & DO Tau, FU Ori,
V2775 Ori, and Z CMa).
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.01948 [pdf] - 1901926
Small dust grain dynamics on adaptive mesh-refinement grids. I. Methods
Submitted: 2019-05-06, last modified: 2019-05-29
Small dust grains are essential ingredients of star, disk and planet
formation. We present an Eulerian numerical approach to study small dust grains
dynamics in the context of star and protoplanetary disk formation. It is
designed for finite volume codes. We use it to investigate dust dynamics during
the protostellar collapse. We present a method to solve the monofluid equations
of gas and dust mixtures with several dust species in the diffusion
approximation implemented in the adaptive-mesh-refinement code RAMSES. It uses
a finite volume second-order Godunov method with a predictor-corrector MUSCL
scheme to estimate the fluxes between the grid cells. We benchmark our method
against six distinct tests, dustyadvect, dustydiffuse, dustyshock, dustywave,
settling and dustycollapse. We show that the scheme is second-order accurate in
space on uniform grids and intermediate between second and first-order on
non-uniform grids. We apply our method on various dustycollapse simulations of
1 solar mass cores composed of gas and dust. We developed an efficient approach
to treat gas and dust dynamics in the diffusion regime on grid based codes. The
canonical tests have been successfully passed. In the context of protostellar
collapse, we show that dust is less coupled to the gas in the outer regions of
the collapse where grains larger than approximately 100 micrometers fall
significantly faster than the gas.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.00961 [pdf] - 1795954
Flybys in protoplanetary discs: I. Gas and dust dynamics
Cuello, Nicolás;
Dipierro, Giovanni;
Mentiplay, Daniel;
Price, Daniel J.;
Pinte, Christophe;
Cuadra, Jorge;
Laibe, Guillaume;
Ménard, François;
Poblete, Pedro P.;
Montesinos, Matías
Submitted: 2018-12-03
We present 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of protoplanetary
discs undergoing a flyby by a stellar perturber on a parabolic orbit lying in a
plane inclined relative to the disc mid-plane. We model the disc as a mixture
of gas and dust, with grains ranging from 1 {\mu}m to 10 cm in size. Exploring
different orbital inclinations, periastron distances and mass ratios, we
investigate the disc dynamical response during and after the flyby. We find
that flybys induce evolving spiral structure in both gas and dust which can
persist for thousands of years after periastron. Gas and dust structures
induced by the flyby differ because of drag-induced effects on the dust grains.
Variations in the accretion rate by up to an order of magnitude occur over a
time-scale of order 10 years or less, inducing FU Orionis-like outbursts. The
remnant discs are truncated and warped. The dust disc is left more compact than
the gas disc, both because of disc truncation and accelerated radial drift of
grains induced by the flyby.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.10148 [pdf] - 1790793
Gas and multi-species dust dynamics in viscous protoplanetary discs: the
importance of the dust back-reaction
Submitted: 2018-06-26, last modified: 2018-11-21
We study the dynamics of a viscous protoplanetary disc hosting a population
of dust grains with a range of sizes. We compute steady-state solutions, and
show that the radial motion of both the gas and the dust can deviate
substantially from those for a single-size dust population. Although the
aerodynamic drag from the dust on the gas is weaker than in the case where all
grains are optimally coupled to the gas, the cumulative "back-reaction" of the
dust particles can still alter the gas dynamics significantly. In typical
protoplanetary discs, the net effect of the dust back-reaction decreases the
gas accretion flow compared to the dust-free (viscous) case, even for
dust-to-gas ratios of order $1\%$. In the outer disc, where dust grains are
typically less strongly coupled to the gas and settle towards the midplane, the
dust back-reaction can even drive outward gas flow. Moreover, the radial inward
drift of large grains is reduced below the gas motion in the inner disc
regions, while small dust grains follow the gas dynamics over all the disc
extent. The resulting dust and gas dynamics can give rise to observable
structures, such as gas and dust cavities. Our results show that the dust
back-reaction can play a major role in both the dynamics and observational
appearance of protoplanetary discs, and cannot be ignored in models of
protoplanetary disc evolution.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.10186 [pdf] - 1773143
F.S.I.: Flyby Scene Investigation
Cuello, Nicolás;
Dipierro, Giovanni;
Mentiplay, Daniel;
Price, Daniel J.;
Pinte, Christophe;
Cuadra, Jorge;
Laibe, Guillaume;
Ménard, François;
Poblete, Pedro P.;
Montesinos, Matías
Submitted: 2018-10-24
We present a methodology to interpret observations of protoplanetary discs
where a flyby, also called a tidal encounter, is suspected. In case of a flyby,
protoplanetary discs can be significantly disturbed. The resulting dynamical
and kinematical signatures can last for several thousands of years after the
flyby and hence deeply affect the evolution of the disc. These effects are
stronger for closer encounters and more massive perturbers. For the very same
flyby parameters, varying the inclination of the perturber's orbit produces a
broad range of disc structures: spirals, bridges, warps and cavities. We study
this kind of features both in the gas and in the dust for grains ranging from 1
{\mu}m to 10 cm in size. Interestingly, the dust exhibits a different dynamical
behaviour compared to the gas because of gas-drag effects. Finally, flybys can
also trigger high accretion events in the disc-hosting star, readily similar to
FU Orionis-type outbursts. All this information can be used to infer the flyby
parameters from an incomplete set of observations at different wavelengths.
Therefore, the main scope of our flyby scene investigation (FSI) methodology is
to help to interpret recent "puzzling" disc observations.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.03930 [pdf] - 1767316
Phantom: A smoothed particle hydrodynamics and magnetohydrodynamics code
for astrophysics
Price, Daniel J.;
Wurster, James;
Tricco, Terrence S.;
Nixon, Chris;
Toupin, Stéven;
Pettitt, Alex;
Chan, Conrad;
Mentiplay, Daniel;
Laibe, Guillaume;
Glover, Simon;
Dobbs, Clare;
Nealon, Rebecca;
Liptai, David;
Worpel, Hauke;
Bonnerot, Clément;
Dipierro, Giovanni;
Ballabio, Giulia;
Ragusa, Enrico;
Federrath, Christoph;
Iaconi, Roberto;
Reichardt, Thomas;
Forgan, Duncan;
Hutchison, Mark;
Constantino, Thomas;
Ayliffe, Ben;
Hirsh, Kieran;
Lodato, Giuseppe
Submitted: 2017-02-13, last modified: 2018-06-15
We present Phantom, a fast, parallel, modular and low-memory smoothed
particle hydrodynamics and magnetohydrodynamics code developed over the last
decade for astrophysical applications in three dimensions. The code has been
developed with a focus on stellar, galactic, planetary and high energy
astrophysics and has already been used widely for studies of accretion discs
and turbulence, from the birth of planets to how black holes accrete. Here we
describe and test the core algorithms as well as modules for
magnetohydrodynamics, self-gravity, sink particles, H_2 chemistry, dust-gas
mixtures, physical viscosity, external forces including numerous galactic
potentials as well as implementations of Lense-Thirring precession,
Poynting-Robertson drag and stochastic turbulent driving. Phantom is hereby
made publicly available.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.00037 [pdf] - 1692538
MULTIGRAIN: Simulating mixtures of multiple dust grains and gas with SPH
Submitted: 2018-05-31
We present MULTIGRAIN, an algorithm for simulating multiple phases of small
dust grains embedded in a gas, building on our earlier work in simulating
two-phase mixtures of gas and dust in SPH (Laibe & Price 2012a,b; Price & Laibe
2015). The MULTIGRAIN method (Hutchison, Price & Laibe 2018) is more accurate
than single-phase simulations because the gas experiences a backreaction from
each dust phase and communicates this change to the other phases, thereby
indirectly coupling the dust phases together. The MULTIGRAIN method is fast,
explicit and low storage, requiring only an array of dust fractions and their
derivatives defined for each resolution element. We demonstrate the MULTIGRAIN
algorithm on test problems related to the settling of dust in the discs of gas
around young stars, where solar systems are born. Finally I will discuss
possible extensions of the method to incorporate both large and small grains,
together with recent improvements in our numerical techniques for gas and dust
mixtures. In particular, I will show how the 'overdamping' problem identified
by Laibe & Price (2012a) can be solved.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.03279 [pdf] - 1656374
Enforcing dust mass conservation in 3D simulations of tightly-coupled
grains with the Phantom SPH code
Submitted: 2018-03-08
We describe a new implementation of the one-fluid method in the SPH code
Phantom to simulate the dynamics of dust grains in gas protoplanetary discs. We
revise and extend previously developed algorithms by computing the evolution of
a new fluid quantity that produces a more accurate and numerically controlled
evolution of the dust dynamics. Moreover, by limiting the stopping time of
uncoupled grains that violate the assumptions of the terminal velocity
approximation, we avoid fatal numerical errors in mass conservation. We test
and validate our new algorithm by running 3D SPH simulations of a large range
of disc models with tightly- and marginally-coupled grains.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.02484 [pdf] - 1656365
Circumbinary, not transitional: On the spiral arms, cavity, shadows,
fast radial flows, streamers and horseshoe in the HD142527 disc
Price, Daniel J.;
Cuello, Nicolas;
Pinte, Christophe;
Mentiplay, Daniel;
Casassus, Simon;
Christiaens, Valentin;
Kennedy, Grant M.;
Cuadra, Jorge;
M., Sebastian Perez;
Marino, Sebastian;
Armitage, Philip J.;
Zurlo, Alice;
Juhasz, Attila;
Ragusa, Enrico;
Laibe, Guillaume;
Lodato, Giuseppe
Submitted: 2018-03-06
We present 3D hydrodynamical models of the HD142527 protoplanetary disc, a
bright and well studied disc that shows spirals and shadows in scattered light
around a 100 au gas cavity, a large horseshoe dust structure in mm continuum
emission, together with mysterious fast radial flows and streamers seen in gas
kinematics. By considering several possible orbits consistent with the observed
arc, we show that all of the main observational features can be explained by
one mechanism - the interaction between the disc and the observed binary
companion. We find that the spirals, shadows and horseshoe are only produced in
the correct position angles by a companion on an inclined and eccentric orbit
approaching periastron - the 'red' family from Lacour et al. (2016). Dust-gas
simulations show radial and azimuthal concentration of dust around the cavity,
consistent with the observed horseshoe. The success of this model in the
HD142527 disc suggests other mm-bright transition discs showing cavities,
spirals and dust asymmetries may also be explained by the interaction with
central companions.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.03213 [pdf] - 1641512
MULTIGRAIN: A smoothed particle hydrodynamics algorithm for multiple
small dust grains and gas
Submitted: 2018-02-09
We present a new algorithm, MULTIGRAIN, for modelling the dynamics of an
entire population of small dust grains immersed in gas, typical of conditions
that are found in molecular clouds and protoplanetary discs. The MULTIGRAIN
method is more accurate than single-phase simulations because the gas
experiences a backreaction from each dust phase and communicates this change to
the other phases, thereby indirectly coupling the dust phases together. The
MULTIGRAIN method is fast, explicit and low storage, requiring only an array of
dust fractions and their derivatives defined for each resolution element.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.05812 [pdf] - 1630364
Rings and gaps in the disc around Elias 24 revealed by ALMA
Dipierro, G.;
Ricci, L.;
Pérez, L.;
Lodato, G.;
Alexander, R. D.;
Laibe, G.;
Andrews, S.;
Carpenter, J. M.;
Chandler, C. J.;
Greaves, J. A.;
Hall, C.;
Henning, T.;
Kwon, W.;
Linz, H.;
Mundy, L.;
Sargent, A.;
Tazzari, M.;
Testi, L.;
Wilner, D.
Submitted: 2018-01-17
We present Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA) Cycle 2
observations of the 1.3 mm dust continuum emission of the protoplanetary disc
surrounding the T Tauri star Elias 24 with an angular resolution of $\sim 0.2"$
($\sim 28$ au). The dust continuum emission map reveals a dark ring at a radial
distance of $0.47"$ ($\sim 65$ au) from the central star, surrounded by a
bright ring at $0.58"$ ($\sim 81$ au). In the outer disc, the radial intensity
profile shows two inflection points at $0.71"$ and $0.87"$ ($\sim 99$ and $121$
au respectively). We perform global three-dimensional smoothed particle
hydrodynamic gas/dust simulations of discs hosting a migrating and accreting
planet. Combining the dust density maps of small and large grains with three
dimensional radiative transfer calculations, we produce synthetic ALMA
observations of a variety of disc models in order to reproduce the gap- and
ring-like features observed in Elias 24. We find that the dust emission across
the disc is consistent with the presence of an embedded planet with a mass of
$\sim 0.7\, \mathrm{M_{\mathrm{J}}}$ at an orbital radius of $\sim$ 60 au. Our
model suggests that the two inflection points in the radial intensity profile
are due to the inward radial motion of large dust grains from the outer disc.
The surface brightness map of our disc model provides a reasonable match to the
gap- and ring-like structures observed in Elias 24, with an average discrepancy
of $\sim$ 5% of the observed fluxes around the gap region.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.07108 [pdf] - 1590020
Fast and accurate Voronoi density gridding from Lagrangian hydrodynamics
data
Submitted: 2017-10-19, last modified: 2017-10-20
Voronoi grids have been successfully used to represent density structures of
gas in astronomical hydrodynamics simulations. While some codes are explicitly
built around using a Voronoi grid, others, such as Smoothed Particle
Hydrodynamics (SPH), use particle-based representations and can benefit from
constructing a Voronoi grid for post-processing their output. So far,
calculating the density of each Voronoi cell from SPH data has been done
numerically, which is both slow and potentially inaccurate. This paper proposes
an alternative analytic method, which is fast and accurate. We derive an
expression for the integral of a cubic spline kernel over the volume of a
Voronoi cell and link it to the density of the cell. Mass conservation is
ensured rigorously by the procedure. The method can be applied more broadly to
integrate a spherically symmetric polynomial function over the volume of a
random polyhedron.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.08660 [pdf] - 1588848
Linear growth of streaming instability in pressure bumps
Submitted: 2017-09-25
Streaming instability is a powerful mechanism which concentrates dust grains
in pro- toplanetary discs, eventually up to the stage where they collapse
gravitationally and form planetesimals. Previous studies inferred that it
should be ineffective in viscous discs, too efficient in inviscid discs, and
may not operate in local pressure maxima where solids accumulate. From a linear
analysis of stability, we show that streaming instability behaves differently
inside local pressure maxima. Under the action of the strong differential
advection imposed by the bump, a novel unstable mode develops and grows even
when gas viscosity is large. Hence, pressure bumps are found to be the only
places where streaming instability occurs in viscous discs. This offers a
promising way to conciliate models of planet formation with recent observations
of young discs.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.01115 [pdf] - 1581067
Self-induced dust traps: overcoming planet formation barriers
Submitted: 2017-01-04, last modified: 2017-08-31
Planet formation is thought to occur in discs around young stars by the
aggregation of small dust grains into much larger objects. The growth from
grains to pebbles and from planetesimals to planets is now fairly well
understood. The intermediate stage has however been found to be hindered by the
radial-drift and fragmentation barriers. We identify a powerful mechanism in
which dust overcomes both barriers. Its key ingredients are i) backreaction
from the dust onto the gas, ii) grain growth and fragmentation, and iii)
large-scale gradients. The pile-up of growing and fragmenting grains modifies
the gas structure on large scales and triggers the formation of pressure
maxima, in which particles are trapped. We show that these self-induced dust
traps are robust: they develop for a wide range of disc structures,
fragmentation thresholds and initial dust-to-gas ratios. They are favored
locations for pebbles to grow into planetesimals, thus opening new paths
towards the formation of planets.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.05107 [pdf] - 1584778
Is the dust-to-gas ratio constant in molecular clouds?
Submitted: 2017-06-15
We perform numerical simulations of dusty, supersonic turbulence in molecular
clouds. We model 0.1, 1 and 10 {\mu}m sized dust grains at an initial
dust-to-gas mass ratio of 1:100, solving the equations of combined gas and dust
dynamics where the dust is coupled to the gas through a drag term. We show
that, for 0.1 and 1 {\mu}m grains, the dust-to-gas ratio deviates by typically
10-20% from the mean, since the stopping time of the dust due to gas drag is
short compared to the dynamical time. Contrary to previous findings, we find no
evidence for orders of magnitude fluctuation in the dust-to-gas ratio for 0.1
{\mu}m grains. Larger, 10 {\mu}m dust grains may have dust-to-gas ratios
increased by up to an order of magnitude locally. Both small (0.1 {\mu}m) and
large ($\gtrsim$ 1 {\mu}m) grains trace the large-scale morphology of the gas,
however we find evidence for 'size-sorting' of grains, where turbulence
preferentially concentrates larger grains into dense regions. Size-sorting may
help to explain observations of 'coreshine' from dark clouds, and why
extinction laws differ along lines of sight through molecular clouds in the
Milky Way compared to the diffuse interstellar medium.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.06664 [pdf] - 1582770
An opening criterion for dust gaps in protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2017-04-21, last modified: 2017-05-19
We aim to understand under which conditions a low mass planet can open a gap
in viscous dusty protoplanetary discs. For this purpose, we extend the theory
of dust radial drift to include the contribution from the tides of an embedded
planet and from the gas viscous forces. From this formalism, we derive i) a
grain size-dependent criterion for dust gap opening in discs, ii) an estimate
of the location of the outer edge of the dust gap and iii) an estimate of the
minimum Stokes number above which low-mass planets are able to carve gaps which
appear only in the dust disc. These analytical estimates are particularly
helpful to appraise the minimum mass of an hypothetical planet carving gaps in
discs observed at long wavelengths and high resolution. We validate the theory
against 3D SPH simulations of planet-disc interaction in a broad range of dusty
protoplanetary discs. We find a remarkable agreement between the theoretical
model and the numerical experiments.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.08159 [pdf] - 1513713
On the origin of horseshoes in transitional discs
Submitted: 2016-09-26
We investigate whether the rings, lopsided features and horseshoes observed
at millimetre wavelengths in transitional discs can be explained by the
dynamics of gas and dust at the edge of the cavity in circumbinary discs. We
use 3D dusty smoothed particle hydrodynamics calculations to show that binaries
with mass ratio $q \gtrsim 0.04$ drive eccentricity in the central cavity,
naturally leading to a crescent-like feature in the gas density, which is
accentuated in the mm dust grain population with intensity contrasts in
mm-continuum emission of 10 or higher. We perform mock observations to
demonstrate that these features closely match those observed by ALMA,
suggesting that the origin of rings, dust horseshoes and other non-axisymmetric
structures in transition discs can be explained by the presence of massive
companions.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.01315 [pdf] - 1502043
Grand challenges in protoplanetary disc modelling
Haworth, Thomas J.;
Ilee, John D.;
Forgan, Duncan H.;
Facchini, Stefano;
Price, Daniel J.;
authors, Community;
Boneberg, Dominika M.;
Booth, Richard A.;
Clarke, Cathie J.;
Gonzalez, Jean-François;
Hutchison, Mark A.;
Kamp, Inga;
Laibe, Guillaume;
Lyra, Wladimir;
Meru, Farzana;
Mohanty, Subhanjoy;
Panić, Olja;
Rice, Ken;
Suzuki, Takeru;
Walsh, Catherine;
Woitke, Peter
Submitted: 2016-08-03, last modified: 2016-09-20
The Protoplanetary Discussions conference --- held in Edinburgh, UK, from 7th
--11th March 2016 --- included several open sessions led by participants. This
paper reports on the discussions collectively concerned with the multiphysics
modelling of protoplanetary discs, including the self-consistent calculation of
gas and dust dynamics, radiative transfer and chemistry. After a short
introduction to each of these disciplines in isolation, we identify a series of
burning questions and grand challenges associated with their continuing
development and integration. We then discuss potential pathways towards solving
these challenges, grouped by strategical, technical and collaborative
developments. This paper is not intended to be a review, but rather to motivate
and direct future research and collaboration across typically distinct fields
based on \textit{community driven input}, to encourage further progress in our
understanding of circumstellar and protoplanetary discs.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.08034 [pdf] - 1475517
On the maximum grain size entrained by photoevaporative winds
Submitted: 2016-08-29
We model the behaviour of dust grains entrained by photoevaporation-driven
winds from protoplanetary discs assuming a non-rotating, plane-parallel disc.
We obtain an analytic expression for the maximum entrainable grain size in
extreme-UV radiation-driven winds, which we demonstrate to be proportional to
the mass loss rate of the disc. When compared with our hydrodynamic
simulations, the model reproduces almost all of the wind properties for the gas
and dust. In typical turbulent discs, the entrained grain sizes in the wind are
smaller than the theoretical maximum everywhere but the inner disc due to dust
settling.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.02899 [pdf] - 1437578
On dust entrainment in photoevaporative winds
Submitted: 2016-03-09, last modified: 2016-05-10
We investigate dust entrainment by photoevaporative winds in protoplanetary
discs using dusty smoothed particle hydrodrodynamics (SPH). We use unequal-mass
particles to resolve more than five orders of magnitude in disc/outflow density
and a one-fluid formulation to efficiently simulate an equivalent magnitude
range in drag stopping time. We find that only micron sized dust grains and
smaller can be entrained in EUV driven winds. The maximum grain size is set by
dust settling in the disc rather than aerodynamic drag in the wind. More
generally, there is a linear relationship between the base flow density and the
maximum entrainable grain size in the wind. A pileup of micron sized dust
grains can occur in the upper atmosphere at critical radii in the disc as
grains decouple from the low-density wind. Entrainment is a strong function of
location in the disc, resulting in a size sorting of grains in the
outflow---the largest grain being carried out between $10$--$20\,$AU. The peak
dust density for each grain size occurs at the inner edge of its own
entrainment region.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.06044 [pdf] - 1392858
A Plane-Parallel Wind Solution For Testing Numerical Simulations of
Photoevaporation
Submitted: 2016-02-18, last modified: 2016-03-18
Here we derive a Parker-wind like solution for a stratified, plane-parallel
atmosphere undergoing photoionisation. The difference compared to the standard
Parker solar wind is that the sonic point is crossed only at infinity. The
simplicity of the analytic solution makes it a convenient test problem for
numerical simulations of photoevaporation in protoplanetary discs.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.07457 [pdf] - 1374368
Two mechanisms for dust gap opening in protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2016-02-24
We identify two distinct physical mechanisms for dust gap opening by embedded
planets in protoplanetary discs based on the symmetry of the drag-induced
motion around the planet: I) A mechanism where low mass planets, that do not
disturb the gas, open gaps in dust by tidal torques assisted by drag in the
inner disc, but resisted by drag in the outer disc; and II) The usual, drag
assisted, mechanism where higher mass planets create pressure maxima in the gas
disc which the drag torque then acts to evacuate further in the dust. The first
mechanism produces gaps in dust but not gas, while the second produces partial
or total gas gaps which are deeper in the dust phase. Dust gaps do not
necessarily indicate gas gaps.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.00969 [pdf] - 1274937
A fast and explicit algorithm for simulating the dynamics of small dust
grains with smoothed particle hydrodynamics
Submitted: 2015-05-05, last modified: 2015-09-09
We describe a simple method for simulating the dynamics of small grains in a
dusty gas, relevant to micron-sized grains in the interstellar medium and
grains of centimetre size and smaller in protoplanetary discs. The method
involves solving one extra diffusion equation for the dust fraction in addition
to the usual equations of hydrodynamics. This "diffusion approximation for
dust" is valid when the dust stopping time is smaller than the computational
timestep. We present a numerical implementation using Smoothed Particle
Hydrodynamics (SPH) that is conservative, accurate and fast. It does not
require any implicit timestepping and can be straightforwardly ported into
existing 3D codes.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.00691 [pdf] - 1285000
ALMA images of discs: are all gaps carved by planets?
Submitted: 2015-09-02
Protoplanetary discs are now routinely observed and exoplanets, after the
numerous indirect discoveries, are starting to be directly imaged. To better
understand the planet formation process, the next step is the detection of
forming planets or of signposts of young planets still in their disc, such as
gaps. A spectacular example is the ALMA science verification image of HL Tau
showing numerous gaps and rings in its disc. To study the observability of
planet gaps, we ran 3D hydrodynamical simulations of a gas and dust disc
containing a 5 M J gap-opening planet and characterised the spatial
distribution of migrating, growing and fragmenting dust grains. We then
computed the corresponding synthetic images for ALMA. For a value of the dust
fragmentation threshold of 15 m s --1 for the collisional velocity, we identify
for the first time a self-induced dust pile up in simulations taking
fragmentation into account. This feature, in addition to the easily detected
planet gap, causes a second apparent gap that could be mistaken for the
signature of a second planet. It is therefore essential to be cautious in the
interpretation of gap detections.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.06719 [pdf] - 1273248
On planet formation in HL Tau
Submitted: 2015-07-23
We explain the axisymmetric gaps seen in recent long-baseline observations of
the HL Tau protoplanetary disc with the Atacama Large Millimetre/Submillimetre
Array (ALMA) as being due to the different response of gas and dust to embedded
planets in protoplanetary discs. We perform global, three dimensional dusty
smoothed particle hydrodynamics calculations of multiple planets embedded in
dust/gas discs which successfully reproduce most of the structures seen in the
ALMA image. We find a best match to the observations using three embedded
planets with masses of 0.2, 0.27 and 0.55 $M_{\rm J}$ in the three main gaps
observed by ALMA, though there remain uncertainties in the exact planet masses
from the disc model.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.00430 [pdf] - 1292197
The accumulation and trapping of grains at planet gaps: effects of grain
growth and fragmentation
Submitted: 2015-06-01
We model the dust evolution in protoplanetary disks with full 3D, Smoothed
Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH), two-phase (gas+dust) hydrodynamical simulations.
The gas+dust dynamics, where aerodynamic drag leads to the vertical settling
and radial migration of grains, is consistently treated. In a previous work, we
characterized the spatial distribution of non-growing dust grains of different
sizes in a disk containing a gap-opening planet and investigated the gap's
detectability with the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA).
Here we take into account the effects of grain growth and fragmentation and
study their impact on the distribution of solids in the disk. We show that
rapid grain growth in the two accumulation zones around planet gaps is strongly
affected by fragmentation. We discuss the consequences for ALMA observations.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.00973 [pdf] - 988457
Two phase mixtures in SPH - A new approach
Submitted: 2015-05-05
We present a new approach to simulating mixtures of gas and dust in smoothed
particle hydrodynamics (SPH). We show how the two-fluid equations can be
rewritten to describe a single-fluid 'mixture' moving with the barycentric
velocity, with each particle carrying a dust fraction. We show how this
formulation can be implemented in SPH while preserving the conservation
properties (i.e. conservation of mass of each phase, momentum and energy). We
also show that the method solves two key issues with the two fluid approach: it
avoids over-damping of the mixture when the drag is strong and prevents a
problem with dust particles becoming trapped below the resolution of the gas.
We also show how the general one-fluid formulation can be simplified in the
limit of strong drag (i.e. small grains) to the usual SPH equations plus a
diffusion equation for the evolution of the dust fraction that can be evolved
explicitly and does not require any implicit timestepping. We present tests of
the simplified formulation showing that it is accurate in the small
grain/strong drag limit. We discuss some of the issues we have had to solve
while developing this method and finally present a preliminary application to
dust settling in protoplanetary discs.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.1097 [pdf] - 918845
The marriage of gas and dust
Submitted: 2014-11-04, last modified: 2015-01-07
Dust-gas mixtures are the simplest example of a two fluid mixture. We show
that when simulating such mixtures with particles or with particles coupled to
grids a problem arises due to the need to resolve a very small length scale
when the coupling is strong. Since this is occurs in the limit when the fluids
are well coupled, we show how the dust-gas equations can be reformulated to
describe a single fluid mixture. The equations are similar to the usual fluid
equations supplemented by a diffusion equation for the dust-to-gas ratio or
alternatively the dust fraction. This solves a number of numerical problems as
well as making the physics clear.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.3569 [pdf] - 1215646
Dust and gas mixtures with multiple grain species - a one-fluid approach
Submitted: 2014-07-14
We derive the single-fluid evolution equations describing a mixture made of a
gas phase and an arbitrary number of dust phases, generalising the approach
developed in Laibe & Price (2014a). A generalisation for continuous dust
distributions as well as analytic approximations for strong drag regimes are
also provided. This formalism lays the foundation for numeri- cal simulations
of dust populations in a wide range of astrophysical systems while avoiding
limitations associated with a multiple-fluid treatment. The usefulness of the
formalism is illustrated on a series of analytical problems, namely the
dustybox, dustyshock and dustywave problems as well as the radial drift of
grains and the streaming instability in protoplanetary discs. We find physical
effects specific to the presence of several dust phases and multiple drag
timescales, including non-monotonic evolution of the differential velocity
between phases and increased efficiency of the linear growth of the streaming
instability. Interestingly, it is found that under certain conditions, large
grains can migrate outwards in protoplanetary discs. This may explain the
presence of small pebbles at several hundreds of astronomical units from their
central star.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.1587 [pdf] - 830495
Diversity in the outcome of dust radial drift in protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2014-03-06, last modified: 2014-03-17
The growth of dust particles into planet embryos needs to circumvent the
radial-drift barrier, i.e. the accretion of dust particles onto the central
star by radial migration. The outcome of the dust radial migration is governed
by simple criteria between the dust-to-gas ratio and the exponents p and q of
the surface density and temperature power laws. The transfer of radiation
provides an additional constraint between these quantities because the disc
thermal structure is fixed by the dust spatial distribution. To assess which
discs are primarily affected by the radial-drift barrier, we used the radiative
transfer code MCFOST to compute the temperature structure of a wide range of
disc models, stressing the particular effects of grain size distributions and
vertical settling.
We find that the outcome of the dust migration process is very sensitive to
the physical conditions within the disc. For high dust-to-gas ratios (> 0.01)
or flattened disc structures (H/R < 0.05), growing dust grains can efficiently
decouple from the gas, leading to a high concentration of grains at a critical
radius of a few AU. Decoupling of grains can occur at a large fraction (> 0.1)
of the initial radius, for a dust-to-gas ratio greater than ~ 0.05. The exact
value of the required dust-to-gas ratio for dust to stop its migration is
strongly dependent on the disc temperature structure. Non growing dust grains
are accreted for discs with flat surface density profiles (p<0.7) while they
always remain in the disc if the surface density is steep enough (p>1.2). Both
the presence of large grains and vertical settling tend to favour the accretion
of non growing dust grains onto the central object, but it slows down the
migration of growing dust grains. All the disc configurations are found to have
favourable temperature profiles over most of the disc to retain their
planetesimals.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.5248 [pdf] - 1203487
Dusty gas with one fluid
Submitted: 2014-02-21
In this paper, we show how the two-fluid equations describing the evolution
of a dust and gas mixture can be reformulated to describe a single fluid moving
with the barycentric velocity of the mixture. This leads to evolution equations
for the total density, momentum, the differential velocity between the dust and
the gas phases and either the dust-to-gas ratio or the dust fraction. The
equations are similar to the usual equations of gas dynamics, providing a
convenient way to extend existing codes to simulate two-fluid mixtures without
modifying the code architecture. Our approach avoids the inherent difficulties
related to the standard approach where the two phases are separate and coupled
via a drag term. In particular, the requirements of infinite spatial and
temporal resolution as the stopping time tends to zero are no longer necessary.
This means that both small and large grains can be straightforwardly treated
with the same method, with no need for complicated implicit schemes. Since
there is only one resolution scale the method also avoids the problem of
unphysical trapping of one fluid (e.g. dust) below the resolution of the other.
We also derive a simplified set of equations applicable to the case of strong
drag/small grains, consisting of the standard fluid equations with a modified
sound speed, plus an advection-diffusion equation for the dust-to-gas ratio.
This provides a simple and fast way to evolve the mixture when the stopping
time is smaller than the Courant timestep. We present a Smoothed Particle
Hydrodynamics implementation in a companion paper.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.5249 [pdf] - 1203488
Dusty gas with one fluid in smoothed particle hydrodynamics
Submitted: 2014-02-21
In a companion paper we have shown how the equations describing gas and dust
as two fluids coupled by a drag term can be reformulated to describe the system
as a single fluid mixture. Here we present a numerical implementation of the
one-fluid dusty gas algorithm using Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH). The
algorithm preserves the conservation properties of the SPH formalism. In
particular, the total gas and dust mass, momentum, angular momentum and energy
are all exactly conserved. Shock viscosity and conductivity terms are
generalised to handle the two-phase mixture accordingly. The algorithm is
benchmarked against a comprehensive suit of problems: dustybox, dustywave,
dustyshock and dustyoscill, each of them addressing different properties of the
method. We compare the performance of the one-fluid algorithm to the standard
two-fluid approach. The one-fluid algorithm is found to solve both of the
fundamental limitations of the two- fluid algorithm: it is no longer possible
to concentrate dust below the resolution of the gas (they have the same
resolution by definition), and the spatial resolution criterion h < csts,
required in two-fluid codes to avoid over-damping of kinetic energy, is
unnecessary. Implicit time stepping is straightforward. As a result, the
algorithm is up to ten billion times more efficient for 3D simulations of small
grains. Additional benefits include the use of half as many particles, a single
kernel and fewer SPH interpolations. The only limitation is that it does not
capture multi-streaming of dust in the limit of zero coupling, suggesting that
in this case a hybrid approach may be required.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.2638 [pdf] - 1179844
Growing dust grains in protoplanetary discs - III. Vertical settling
Submitted: 2013-10-09, last modified: 2013-11-06
We aim to derive a simple analytic model to understand the essential
properties of vertically settling growing dust grains in laminar protoplanetary
discs. Separating the vertical dynamics from the motion in the disc midplane,
we integrate the equations of motion for both a linear and an exponential grain
growth rate. Numerical integrations are performed for more complex growth
models.
We find that the settling efficiency depends on the value of the
dimensionless parameter gamma, which characterises the relative efficiency of
grain growth with respect to the gas drag. Since gamma is expected to be of
order as the initial dust-to-gas ratio in the disc (of order 10^-2), grain
growth enhances the energy dissipation of the dust particles and improve the
settling efficiency in protoplanetary discs. This behaviour is mostly
independent of the growth model considered as well as of the radial drift of
the particles.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.2637 [pdf] - 1179843
Growing dust grains in protoplanetary discs - II. The Radial drift
barrier problem
Submitted: 2013-10-09, last modified: 2013-11-06
We aim to study the migration of growing dust grains in protoplanetary discs,
where growth and migration are tightly coupled. This includes the crucial issue
of the radial-drift barrier for growing dust grains. We therefore extend the
study performed in Paper I, considering models for grain growth and grain
dynamics where both the migration and growth rate depend on the grain size and
the location in the disc. The parameter space of disc profiles and growth
models is exhaustively explored. In doing so, interpretations for the grain
motion found in numerical simulations are also provided.
We find that a large number of cases is required to characterise entirely the
grains radial motion, providing a large number of possible outcomes. Some of
them lead dust particles to be accreted onto the central star and some of them
don't.
We find then that q<1 is required for discs to retain their growing
particles, where q is the exponent of the radial temperature profile T(R)
proportional to R^-q. Additionally, the initial dust-to gas ratio has to exceed
a critical value for grains to pile up efficiently, thus avoiding being
accreted onto the central star. Discs are also found to retain efficiently
small dust grains regenerated by fragmentation. We show how those results are
sensitive to the turbulent model considered.
Even though some physical processes have been neglected, this study allows to
sketch a scenario in which grains can survive the radial-drift barrier in
protoplanetary discs as they grow.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.2634 [pdf] - 1179842
Growing dust grains in protoplanetary discs - I. Radial drift with toy
growth models
Submitted: 2013-10-09, last modified: 2013-11-06
In a series of papers, we present a comprehensive analytic study of the
global motion of growing dust grains in protoplanetary discs, addressing both
the radial drift and the vertical settling of the particles. Here we study how
the radial drift of dust particles is affected by grain growth. In a first
step, toy models in which grain growth can either be constant, accelerate or
decelerate are introduced. The equations of motion are analytically integrable
and therefore the grains dynamics is easy to understand.
The radial motion of growing grains is governed by the relative efficiency of
the growth and migration processes which is expressed by the dimensionless
parameter Lambda, as well as the exponents for the gas surface density and
temperature profiles, denoted p and q respectively. When Lambda is of order
unity, growth and migration are strongly coupled, providing the most efficient
radial drift. For the toy models considered, grains pile up when -p+q+1/2<0.
Importantly, we show the existence of a second process which can help discs to
retain their solid materials. For accelerating growth, grains end up their
migration at a finite radius, thus avoiding being accreted onto the central
star.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.4953 [pdf] - 1117472
On the accumulation of planetesimals near disc gaps created by
protoplanets
Submitted: 2012-03-22
We have performed three-dimensional two-fluid (gas-dust) hydrodynamical
models of circumstellar discs with embedded protoplanets (3 - 333 M\oplu) and
small solid bodies (radii 10cm to 10m). We find that high mass planets (\gtrsim
Saturn mass) open sufficiently deep gaps in the gas disc such that the density
maximum at the outer edge of the gap can very efficiently trap metre-sized
solid bodies. This allows the accumulation of solids at the outer edge of the
gap as solids from large radii spiral inwards to the trapping region. This
process of accumulation occurs fastest for those bodies that spiral inwards
most rapidly, typically metre-sized boulders, whilst smaller and larger objects
will not migrate sufficiently rapidly in the discs lifetime to benefit from the
process. Around a Jupiter mass planet we find that bound clumps of solid
material, as large as several Earth masses, may form, potentially collapsing
under self-gravity to form planets or planetesimals. These results are in
agreement with Lyra et al. (2009), supporting their finding that the formation
of a second generation of planetesimals or of terrestrial mass planets may be
triggered by the presence of a high mass planet.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.3090 [pdf] - 1091618
Dusty gas with SPH - I. Algorithm and test suite
Submitted: 2011-11-13
We present a new algorithm for simulating two-fluid gas and dust mixtures in
Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH), systematically addressing a number of
key issues including the generalised SPH density estimate in multi-fluid
systems, the consistent treatment of variable smoothing length terms, finite
particle size, time step stability, thermal coupling terms and the choice of
kernel and smoothing length used in the drag operator. We find that using
double-hump shaped kernels improves the accuracy of the drag interpolation by a
factor of several hundred compared to the use of standard SPH bell-shaped
kernels, at no additional computational expense. In order to benchmark our
algorithm, we have developed a comprehensive suite of standardised, simple test
problems for gas and dust mixtures: dustybox, dustywave, dustyshock, dustysedov
and dustydisc, the first three of which have known analytic solutions. We
present the validation of our algorithm against all of these tests. In doing
so, we show that the spatial resolution criterion \Delta < cs ts is a necessary
condition in all gas+dust codes that becomes critical at high drag (i.e. small
stopping time ts) in order to correctly predict the dynamics. Implicit
timestepping and the implementation of realistic astrophysical drag regimes are
addressed in a companion paper.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.3083 [pdf] - 1091614
Revisiting the "radial-drift barrier" of planet formation and its
relevance in observed protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2011-11-13
Context. To form metre-sized pre-planetesimals in protoplanetary discs,
growing grains have to decouple from the gas before they are accreted onto the
central star during their phase of fast radial migration and thus overcome the
so-called "radial-drift barrier" (often inaccurately referred to as the
"metre-size barrier"). Aims. To predict the outcome of the radial motion of
dust grains in protoplanetary discs whose surface density and temperature
follow power-law profiles, with exponent p and q respectively. We investigate
both the Epstein and the Stokes drag regimes which govern the motion of the
dust. Methods. We analytically integrate the equations of motion obtained from
perturbation analysis. We compare these results with those from direct
numerical integration of the equations of motion. Then, using data from
observed discs, we predict the fate of dust grains in real discs. Results. When
a dust grain reaches the inner regions of the disc, the acceleration due to the
increase of the pressure gradient is counterbalanced by the increase of the gas
drag. We find that most grains in the Epstein (resp. the Stokes) regime survive
their radial migration if-p+q+1/2 \leq0 (resp. if q\leq 2/3). The majority of
observed discs satisfies both-p+q+ 1/2 \leq0 and q\leq 2/3: a large fraction of
both their small and large grains remain in the disc, for them the radial drift
barrier does not exist.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.3089 [pdf] - 1091617
Dusty gas with SPH - II. Implicit timestepping and astrophysical drag
regimes
Submitted: 2011-11-13
In a companion paper (Laibe & Price 2011b), we have presented an algorithm
for simulating two-fluid gas and dust mixtures in Smoothed Particle
Hydrodynamics (SPH). In this paper, we develop an implicit timestepping method
that preserves the exact conservation of the both linear and angular momentum
in the underlying SPH algorithm, but unlike previous schemes, allows the
iterations to converge to arbitrary accuracy and is suited to the treatment of
non- linear drag regimes. The algorithm presented in Paper I is also extended
to deal with realistic astrophysical drag regimes, including both linear and
non-linear Epstein and Stokes drag. The scheme is benchmarked against the test
suite presented in Paper I, including i) the analytic solutions of the dustybox
problem and ii) solutions of the dustywave, dustyshock, dustysedov and
dustydisc obtained with explicit timestepping. We find that the implicit method
is 1- 10 times faster than the explicit temporal integration when the ratio r
between the the timestep and the drag stopping time is 1 < r < 1000.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.1736 [pdf] - 1077173
DUSTYBOX and DUSTYWAVE: Two test problems for numerical simulations of
two fluid astrophysical dust-gas mixtures
Submitted: 2011-06-09
In this paper we present the analytic solutions for two test problems
involving two-fluid mixtures of dust and gas in an astrophysical context. The
solutions provide a means of benchmarking numerical codes designed to simulate
the non-linear dynamics of dusty gas. The first problem, dustybox, consists of
two interpenetrating homogeneous fluids moving with relative velocity
difference. We provide exact solutions to the full non-linear problem for a
range of drag formulations appropriate to astrophysical fluids (i.e., various
prescriptions for Epstein and Stokes drag in different regimes). The second
problem, dustywave consists of the propagation of linear acoustic waves in a
two-fluid gas-dust mixture. We provide the analytic solution for the case when
the two fluids are interacting via a linear drag term. Both test problems are
simple to set up in any numerical code and can be run with periodic boundary
conditions. The solutions we derive are completely general with respect to both
the dust-to-gas ratio and the amplitude of the drag coefficient. A stability
analysis of waves in a gas-dust system is also presented, showing that sound
waves in an astrophysical dust-gas mixture are linearly stable.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:0806.1427 [pdf] - 13364
SPH simulations of grain growth in protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2008-06-09
Aims: In order to understand the first stages of planet formation, when tiny
grains aggregate to form planetesimals, one needs to simultaneously model grain
growth, vertical settling and radial migration of dust in protoplanetary disks.
In this study, we implement an analytical prescription for grain growth into a
3D two-phase hydrodynamics code to understand its effects on the dust
distribution in disks. Methods: Following the analytic derivation of Stepinski
& Valageas (1997), which assumes that grains stick perfectly upon collision, we
implement a convenient and fast method of following grain growth in our 3D,
two-phase (gas+dust) SPH code. We then follow the evolution of the size and
spatial distribution of a dust population in a classical T Tauri star disk.
Results: We find that the grains go through various stages of growth due to the
complex interplay between gas drag, dust dynamics, and growth. Grains initially
grow rapidly as they settle to the mid-plane, then experience a fast radial
migration with little growth through the bulk of the disk, and finally pile-up
in the inner disk where they grow more efficiently. This results in a bimodal
distribution of grain sizes. Using this simple prescription of grain growth, we
find that grains reach decimetric sizes in 10^5 years in the inner disk and
survive the fast migration phase.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.0766 [pdf] - 7770
Dust evolution in protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2007-12-05, last modified: 2008-01-10
We investigate the behaviour of dust in protoplanetary disks under the action
of gas drag using our 3D, two-fluid (gas+dust) SPH code. We present the
evolution of the dust spatial distribution in global simulations of planetless
disks as well as of disks containing an already formed planet. The resulting
dust structures vary strongly with particle size and planetary gaps are much
sharper than in the gas phase, making them easier to detect with ALMA than
anticipated. We also find that there is a range of masses where a planet can
open a gap in the dust layer whereas it doesn't in the gas disk. Our dust
distributions are fed to the radiative transfer code MCFOST to compute
synthetic images, in order to derive constraints on the settling and growth of
dust grains in observed disks.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.0772 [pdf] - 7772
3D SPH simulations of grain growth in protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2007-12-05, last modified: 2008-01-10
We present the first results of the treatment of grain growth in our 3D,
two-fluid (gas+dust) SPH code describing protoplanetary disks. We implement a
scheme able to reproduce the variation of grain sizes caused by a variety of
physical processes and test it with the analytical expression of grain growth
given by Stepinski & Valageas (1997) in simulations of a typical T Tauri disk
around a one solar mass star. The results are in agreement with a turbulent
growing process and validate the method. We are now able to simulate the grain
growth process in a protoplanetary disk given by a more realistic physical
description, currently under development. We discuss the implications of the
combined effect of grain growth and dust vertical settling and radial migration
on subsequent planetesimal formation.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.3070 [pdf] - 5124
3D SPH simulations of grain growth in protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2007-09-19
We present the first results of the treatment of grain growth in our 3D,
two-fluid (gas+dust) SPH code describing protoplanetary disks. We implement a
scheme able to reproduce the variation of grain sizes caused by a variety of
physical processes and test it with the analytical expression of grain growth
given by Stepinski & Valageas (1997) in simulations of a typical T Tauri disk
around a one solar mass star. The results are in agreement with a turbulent
growing process and validate the method. We are now able to simulate the grain
growth process in a protoplanetary disk given by a more realistic physical
description, currently under development. We discuss the implications of the
combined effect of grain growth and dust vertical settling and radial migration
on subsequent planetesimal formation.