Normalized to: Kozyreva, A.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.15028 [pdf] - 2122778
The low-luminosity type II SN\,2016aqf: A well-monitored spectral
evolution of the Ni/Fe abundance ratio
Müller-Bravo, Tomás E.;
Gutiérrez, Claudia P.;
Sullivan, Mark;
Jerkstrand, Anders;
Anderson, Joseph P.;
González-Gaitán, Santiago;
Sollerman, Jesper;
Arcavi, Iair;
Burke, Jamison;
Galbany, Lluís;
Gal-Yam, Avishay;
Gromadzki, Mariusz;
Hiramatsu, Daichi;
Hosseinzadeh, Griffin;
Howell, D. Andrew;
Inserra, Cosimo;
Kankare, Erki;
Kozyreva, Alexandra;
McCully, Curtis;
Nicholl, Matt;
Smartt, Stephen;
Valenti, Stefano;
Young, Dave R.
Submitted: 2020-06-26
Low-luminosity type II supernovae (LL SNe~II) make up the low explosion
energy end of core-collapse SNe, but their study and physical understanding
remain limited. We present SN\,2016aqf, a LL SN~II with extensive spectral and
photometric coverage. We measure a $V$-band peak magnitude of $-14.58$\,mag, a
plateau duration of $\sim$100\,days, and an inferred $^{56}$Ni mass of $0.008
\pm 0.002$\,\msun. The peak bolometric luminosity, L$_{\rm bol} \approx
10^{41.4}$\,erg\,s$^{-1}$, and its spectral evolution is typical of other SNe
in the class. Using our late-time spectra, we measure the [\ion{O}{i}]
$\lambda\lambda6300, 6364$ lines, which we compare against SN II spectral
synthesis models to constrain the progenitor zero-age main-sequence mass. We
find this to be 12 $\pm$ 3\,\msun. Our extensive late-time spectral coverage of
the [\ion{Fe}{ii}] $\lambda7155$ and [\ion{Ni}{ii}] $\lambda7378$ lines permits
a measurement of the Ni/Fe abundance ratio, a parameter sensitive to the inner
progenitor structure and explosion mechanism dynamics. We measure a constant
abundance ratio evolution of $0.081^{+0.009}_{-0.010}$, and argue that the best
epochs to measure the ratio are at $\sim$200 -- 300\,days after explosion. We
place this measurement in the context of a large sample of SNe II and compare
against various physical, light-curve and spectral parameters, in search of
trends which might allow indirect ways of constraining this ratio. We do not
find correlations predicted by theoretical models; however, this may be the
result of the exact choice of parameters and explosion mechanism in the models,
the simplicity of them and/or primordial contamination in the measured
abundance ratio.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.14097 [pdf] - 2089185
Shock breakouts from red supergiants: analytical and numerical
predictions
Submitted: 2020-03-31
Shock breakout (SBO) signal is the first signature of the supernova explosion
apart from gravitational waves and neutrinos. Observational properties of SBO,
such as bolometric luminosity and colour temperature, connect to the supernova
progenitor and explosion parameters. Detecting SBO or SBO-cooling will
constrain the progenitor and explosion models of collapsing stars. In the light
of recently launched eROSITA telescope, the rate for detection of SBO is a few
events during a year. In the current study, we examine the analytic formulae
derived by Shussman et al. (2016). We use four red supergiant models from their
study, while running explosions with the radiation hydrodynamics code STELLA.
We conclude that there is a good agreement between analytic and numerical
approaches for bolometric luminosity and colour temperature during SBO. The
analytic formulae for the SBO signal based on the global supernova parameters
can be used instead of running time-consuming numerical simulations. We define
spectral range where analytic formulae for the SBO spectra are valid. We
provide improved analytical expression for the SBO spectral energy
distribution. We confirm dependence of colour temperature on radius derived by
analytical studies and suggest to use early time observations to confine the
progenitor radius. Additionally we show the prediction for the SBO signal from
red supergiants as seen by eROSITA instrument.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.08713 [pdf] - 1799998
The role of radioactive nickel in shaping the plateau phase of Type II
supernovae
Submitted: 2018-11-21
In the present study, we systematically explore the effect of the radioactive
56Ni and its mixing properties in the ejecta on the plateau of Type IIP
supernovae (SNe). We evaluate the importance of 56Ni in shaping light curves of
SNe IIP by simulating light curves for two red supergiant models using
different amounts of 56Ni and with different types of mixing: uniform
distribution of 56Ni out to different fractions of the envelope and "boxcar"
distribution of 56Ni. We find, similarly to previous studies, that 56Ni extends
duration of the plateau. We find a formula to estimate the extension based on
the observed bolometric light curves and show that for most SNe IIP 56Ni
extends the plateau by about 20%. Another effect of 56Ni consists in reduction
of the plateau decline rate, i.e. 56Ni presented in the ejecta flattens the
plateau. Our simulations suggest that for typical SNe IIP it can reduce the
decline rate by about 1 mag/100 day. We find that for the contribution of 56Ni
seen in most SNe our simulated bolometric light curves resemble observed ones
for various types of 56Ni mixing. We thereby cannot determine the level of 56Ni
mixing in these SNe based on the light curve alone. However, for SN2009ib we
find that only a model where 56Ni is mixed significantly throughout most of the
hydrogen envelope is consistent with the observed light curve. Our light curves
are available via link
https://wwwmpa.mpa-garching.mpg.de/ccsnarchive/data/Kozyreva2018/.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.05791 [pdf] - 1686849
OGLE14-073 - a promising pair-instability supernova candidate
Submitted: 2018-04-16
The recently discovered bright type II supernova OGLE14-073 evolved very
slowly. The light curve rose to maximum for 90 days from discovery and then
declined at a rate compatible with the radioactive decay of 56Co. In this
study, we show that a pair-instability supernova is a plausible mechanism for
this event. We calculate explosion models and light curves with the radiation
hydrodynamics code STELLA starting from two M(ZAMS) = 150 solar masses, Z=0.001
progenitors. We obtain satisfactory fits to OGLE14-073 broadband light curves
by including additional 56Ni in the centre of the models and mixing hydrogen
down into the inner layers of the ejecta to a radial mass coordinate of 10
solar masses. The extra 56Ni required points to a slightly more massive
progenitor star. The mixing of hydrogen could be due to large scale mixing
during the explosion. We also present synthetic spectra for our models
simulated with the Monte Carlo radiative transfer code ARTIS. The synthetic
spectra reproduce the main features of the observed spectra of OGLE14-073. We
conclude that OGLE14-073 is one of the most promising candidates for a
pair-instability explosion.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.07454 [pdf] - 1585060
Pair-Instability Supernova Simulations: Progenitor Evolution, Explosion,
and Light Curves
Submitted: 2017-06-22, last modified: 2017-08-07
In recent years, the viability of the pair-instability supernova (PISN)
scenario for explaining superluminous supernovae has all but disappeared except
for a few slowly-evolving examples. However, PISN are not predicted to be
superluminous throughout the bulk of their mass range. In fact, it is more
likely that the first PISN we see (if we have not seen one already) will not be
superluminous. Here, we present hydrodynamic simulations of PISNe for four
stellar models with unique envelope properties spanning the PISN mass range. In
addition, we compute synthetic light curves for comparison with current and
future observations. We also investigate, in the context of our most massive
model, the prospect of mixing in the supernova ejecta alleviating discrepancies
between current PISN models and the remaining superluminous candidate events.
To this end, we present the first published 3D hydrodynamic simulations of
PISNe. After achieving convergence between 1D, 2D, and 3D simulations we
examine mixing in the supernova ejecta and its affect on the bolometric light
curve. We observe slight deviations from spherical symmetry which increase with
the number of dimensions. We find no significant effects on the bolometric
light curve, however we conclude that mixing between the silicon and oxygen
rich layers caused by the Rayleigh-Taylor instability may affect spectra.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.05746 [pdf] - 1586075
Ultraviolet light curves of Gaia16apd in superluminous supernova models
Submitted: 2017-07-18
Observations of Gaia16apd revealed extremely luminous ultraviolet emission
among superluminous supernovae (SLSNe). Using radiation hydrodynamics
simulations we perform a comparison of UV light curves, color temperatures and
photospheric velocities between the most popular SLSN models: pair-instability
supernova, magnetar and interaction with circumstellar medium. We find that the
interaction model is the most promising to explain the extreme UV luminosity of
Gaia16apd. The differences in late-time UV emission and in color evolution
found between the models can be used to link an observed SLSN event to the most
appropriate model. Observations at UV wavelengths can be used to clarify the
nature of SLSNe and more attention should be paid to them in future follow-up
observations.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.01086 [pdf] - 1494872
Fast evolving pair-instability supernova models: evolution, explosion,
light curves
Kozyreva, Alexandra;
Gilmer, Matthew;
Hirschi, Raphael;
Frohlich, Carla;
Blinnikov, Sergey;
Wollaeger, Ryan T.;
Noebauer, Ulrich M.;
van Rossum, Daniel R.;
Heger, Alexander;
Even, Wesley P.;
Waldman, Roni;
Tolstov, Alexey;
Chatzopoulos, Emmanouil;
Sorokina, Elena
Submitted: 2016-10-04
With an increasing number of superluminous supernovae (SLSNe) discovered the
question of their origin remains open and causes heated debates in the
supernova community. Currently, there are three proposed mechanisms for SLSNe:
(1) pair-instability supernovae (PISN), (2) magnetar-driven supernovae, and (3)
models in which the supernova ejecta interacts with a circumstellar material
ejected before the explosion. Based on current observations of SLSNe, the PISN
origin has been disfavoured for a number of reasons. Many PISN models provide
overly broad light curves and too reddened spectra, because of massive ejecta
and a high amount of nickel. In the current study we re-examine PISN properties
using progenitor models computed with the GENEC code. We calculate supernova
explosions with FLASH and light curve evolution with the radiation
hydrodynamics code STELLA. We find that high-mass models (200 and 250 solar
masses) at relatively high metallicity (Z=0.001) do not retain hydrogen in the
outer layers and produce relatively fast evolving PISNe Type I and might be
suitable to explain some SLSNe. We also investigate uncertainties in light
curve modelling due to codes, opacities, the nickel-bubble effect and
progenitor structure and composition.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.00016 [pdf] - 1553891
Effects of Dimensionality on Pair-Instability Supernova Explosions
Submitted: 2016-09-30
Since the emergence of the new class of extremely bright transients,
super-luminous supernovae (SLSNe), three main mechanisms to power their light
curves (LCs) have been discussed. They are the spin-down of a magnetar,
interaction with circumstellar material, and the decay of large amounts of
radioactive nickel in pair-instability supernovae (PISNe). Given the high
degree of diversity seen within the class, it is possible that all three
mechanisms are at work. PISN models can be self- consistently simulated from
the main sequence phase of very massive stars (VMS) through to their explosion.
These models robustly predict large amounts of radioactive nickel and thus very
luminous SN events. However, PISN model LCs evolve more slowly than even the
slowest evolving SLSNe. Multidimensional effects on the ejecta structure,
specifically the mixing of radioactive nickel out to large radii, could
alleviate this discrepancy with observation. Here we explore the
multidimensional effects on the LC evolution by simulating the explosion phase
in 1D, 2D, and 3D. We find that the ejecta from the multidimensional
simulations have slightly shallower abundance gradients due to mixing at shell
boundaries. We compute synthetic LCs whose shapes show no discernible
differences due to the multidimensional effects.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.00335 [pdf] - 1378998
How much radioactive nickel does ASASSN-15lh require?
Submitted: 2016-03-01
The discovery of the most luminous supernova ASASSN-15lh triggered a
shock-wave in the supernova community. The three possible mechanisms proposed
for the majority of other superluminous supernovae do not produce a realistic
physical model for this particular supernova. In the present study we show the
limiting luminosity available from a nickel-powered pair-instability supernova.
We computed a few exotic nickel-powered explosions with a total mass of nickel
up to 1500 solar masses. We used the hydrostatic configurations prepared with
the GENEVA and MESA codes, and the STELLA radiative-transfer code for following
the explosion of these models. We show that 1500 solar masses of radioactive
nickel is needed to power a luminosity of 2x10^45 erg/s. The resulting light
curve is very broad and incompatible with the shorter ASASSN-15lh time-scale.
This rules out a nickel-powered origin of ASASSN-15lh. In addition, we derive a
simple peak luminosity - nickel mass relation from our data, which may serve to
estimate of nickel mass from observed peak luminosities.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.00439 [pdf] - 1287026
Can pair-instability supernova models match the observations of
superluminous supernovae?
Submitted: 2015-10-01
An increasing number of so-called superluminous supernovae (SLSNe) are
discovered. It is believed that at least some of them with slowly fading light
curves originate in stellar explosions induced by the pair instability
mechanism. Recent stellar evolution models naturally predict pair instability
supernovae (PISNe) from very massive stars at wide range of metallicities (up
to Z=0.006, Yusof et al. 2013). In the scope of this study we analyse whether
PISN models can match the observational properties of SLSNe with various light
curve shapes. Specifically, we explore the influence of different degrees of
macroscopic chemical mixing in PISN explosive products on the resulting
observational properties. We artificially apply mixing to the 250 Msun PISN
evolutionary model from Kozyreva et al. (2014) and explore its supernova
evolution with the one-dimensional radiation hydrodynamics code STELLA. The
greatest success in matching SLSN observations is achieved in the case of an
extreme macroscopic mixing, where all radioactive material is ejected into the
hydrogen-helium outer layer. Such an extreme macroscopic redistribution of
chemicals produces events with faster light curves with high photospheric
temperatures and high photospheric velocities. These properties fit a wider
range of SLSNe than non-mixed PISN model. Our mixed models match the light
curves, colour temperature and photospheric velocity evolution of two
well-observed SLSNe PTF12dam and LSQ12dlf. However, these models' extreme
chemical redistribution may be hard to realise in massive PISNe. Therefore,
alternative models such as the magnetar mechanism or wind-interaction may still
to be favourable to interpret rapidly rising SLSNe.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.01202 [pdf] - 1232167
Can very massive Population III stars produce a super-collapsar?
Submitted: 2015-04-06
A fraction of the first generation of stars in the early Universe may be very
massive ($\gtrsim 300~\mathrm{M_\odot}$) as they form in metal-free
environments. Formation of black holes from these stars can be accompanied by
supermassive collapsars to produce long gamma-ray bursts of a unique type
having a very high total energy ($\sim 10^{54}~\mathrm{erg}$) as recently
suggested by several authors. We present new stellar evolution models of very
massive Population III stars including the effect of rotation to provide
theoretical constraints on super-collapsar progenitors. We find that the
angular momentum condition for super-collapsar can be fulfilled if magnetic
torques are ignored, in which case Eddington-Sweet circulations play the
dominant role for the transport of angular momentum. We further find that the
initial mass range for super-collapsar progenitors would be limited to
$300~\mathrm{M_\odot} \lesssim M \lesssim 700~\mathrm{M_\odot}$. However, all
of our very massive star models of this mass range end their lives as red
supergiants rather than blue supergiants, in good agreement with most of the
previous studies. The predicted final fate of these stars is either a
jet-powered type IIP supernova or an ultra-long, relatively faint gamma-ray
transient, depending on the initial amount of angular momentum.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.5377 [pdf] - 1055720
Finding the First Cosmic Explosions. IV. 90 - 140 M$_{\odot}$
Pair-Instability Supernovae
Submitted: 2014-11-19
Population III stars that die as pair-instability supernovae are usually
thought to fall in the mass range of 140 - 260 M$_{\odot}$. But several lines
of work have now shown that rotation can build up the He cores needed to
encounter the pair instability at stellar masses as low as 90 $_{\odot}$.
Depending on the slope of the initial mass function of Population III stars,
there could be 4 - 5 times as many stars from 90 - 140 $_{\odot}$ in the
primordial universe than in the usually accepted range. We present numerical
simulations of the pair-instability explosions of such stars performed with the
MESA, FLASH and RAGE codes. We find that they will be visible to supernova
factories such as Pan-STARRS and LSST in the optical out to z $\sim$ 1 - 2 and
to JWST and the 30 m-class telescopes in the NIR out to $z \sim$ 7 - 10. Such
explosions will thus probe the stellar populations of the first galaxies and
cosmic star formation rates in the era of cosmological reionization. These
supernovae are also easily distinguished from more massive pair-instability
explosions, underscoring the fact that there is far greater variety to the
light curves of these events than previously understood.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.6340 [pdf] - 844901
Explosion and nucleosynthesis of low redshift pair instability
supernovae
Submitted: 2014-05-24
Both recent observations and stellar evolution models suggest that
pair-instability supernovae (PISNe) could occur in the local Universe, at
metallicities below Z_Sun/3. Previous PISN models were mostly produced at very
low metallicities in the context of the early Universe. We present new PISNe
models at a metallicity of Z=0.001, which are relevant for the local Universe.
We take the self-consistent stellar evolutionary models of pair-instability
progenitors with initial masses of 150 and 250 solar masses at metallicity of
Z=0.001 by Langer et al. (2007) and follow the evolution of these models
through the supernova explosions, using a hydrodynamics stellar evolution code
with an extensive nuclear network including 200 isotopes. Both models explode
as PISNe without leaving a compact stellar remnant. Our models produce a
nucleosynthetic pattern that is generally similar to that of Population III
PISN models, which is mainly characterized by the production of large amounts
of alpha-elements and a strong deficiency of the odd-charged elements. However,
the odd-even effect in our models is significantly weaker than that found in
Population III models. The comparison with the nucleosynthetic yields from
core-collapse supernovae at a similar metallicity (Z=0.002) indicates that
PISNe could have strongly influenced the chemical evolution below Z=0.002,
assuming a standard initial mass function. The odd-even effect is predicted to
be most prominent for the intermediate mass elements between silicon and
calcium. With future observations of chemical abundances in Population II
stars, our result can be used to constrain the number of PISNe that occurred
during the past evolution of our Galaxy.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.5212 [pdf] - 826651
Observational properties of low redshift pair instability supernovae
Submitted: 2014-03-20
So called superluminous supernovae have been recently discovered in the local
Universe. It appears possible that some of them originate from stellar
explosions induced by the pair instability mechanism. Recent stellar evolution
models also predict pair instability supernovae (PISNe) from very massive stars
at fairly high metallicities (i.e. Z~0.004). We provide supernova (SN) models
and synthetic light curves for two progenitor models, a 150 Msun red-supergiant
and a 250 Msun yellow-supergiant at a metallicity of Z=0.001, for which the
evolution from the main sequence to collapse, and the initiation of the PISN
itself, has been previously computed in a realistic and self-consistent way. We
are using the radiation hydrodynamics code STELLA to describe the SN evolution
of both models over a time frame of about 500 days. We describe the
shock-breakout phases of both SNe which are characterized by a higher
luminosity, a longer duration and a lower effective temperature than those of
ordinary SNeIIP. We derive the bolometric as well as the U, B, V, R and I light
curves of our PISN models, which show a long-lasting plateau phase with maxima
at Mbol=-19.3 mag and -21.3 mag for our lower and higher mass model,
respectively. We also describe the photospheric composition and velocity as
function of time. We conclude that the light curve of the explosion of our
initially 150 Msun star resembles those of relatively bright SNeIIP, whereas
its photospheric velocity at early times is smaller. Its 56Ni mass of 0.04 Msun
also falls well into the range found in ordinary core collapse SNe. The light
curve and photospheric velocity of our 250 Msun models has a striking
resemblance with that of the superluminous SN2007bi, strengthening its
interpretation as PISN. We conclude that PISNe may occur more frequently in the
local universe than previously assumed.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.3683 [pdf] - 1124850
On the nature and detectability of Type Ib/c supernova progenitors
Submitted: 2012-07-16
The progenitors of many Type II supernovae have been observationally
identified but the search for Type Ibc supernova (SN Ibc) progenitors has thus
far been unsuccessful, despite the expectation that they are luminous
Wolf-Rayet (WR) stars. We investigate how the evolution of massive helium stars
affects their visual appearances, and discuss the implications for the
detectability of SN Ibc progenitors. Massive WR stars that rapidly lose their
helium envelopes through stellar-wind mass-loss end their lives when their
effective temperatures -- related to their hydrostatic surfaces -- exceed about
150kK.At their pre-supernova stage, their surface properties resemble those of
hot Galactic WR stars of WO sub-type. These are visually faint with narrow-band
visual magnitudes Mv = -1.5 ~ -2.5, despite their high bolometric luminosities
(log L/Lsun = 5.6 ~ 5.7), compared to the bulk of Galactic WR stars (Mv < -4).
In contrast, relatively low-mass helium stars that retain a thick helium
envelope appear fairly bright in optical bands, depending on the final masses
and the history of the envelope expansion during the late evolutionary stages.
We conclude that SNe Ibc observations have so far not provided strong
constraints on progenitor bolometric luminosities and masses, even with the
deepest searches. We also argue that Ic progenitors are more challenging to
identify than Ib progenitors in any optical images.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0510213 [pdf] - 76709
New soft gamma-ray bursts in the BATSE records and spectral properties
of X-ray rich bursts
Submitted: 2005-10-07
A population of X-ray dominated gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) observed by Ginga,
BeppoSax and Hete-2 should be represented in the BATSE data as presumably soft
bursts. We have performed a search for soft GRBs in the BATSE records in the
25--100 keV energy band. A softness of a burst spectrum can be a reason why it
has been missed by the on-board procedure and previous searches for untriggered
GRBs tuned to 50--300 keV range. We have found a surprisingly small number
(~20/yr down to 0.1 ph cm$^{-2}$ s$^{-1}$) of soft GRBs where the count rate is
dominated by 25--50 keV energy channel. This fact as well as the analysis of
HETE-2 and common BeppoSAX/BATSE GRBs indicates that the majority of GRBs with
a low Epeak has a relatively hard tail with the high-energy power-law photon
index >-3. An exponential cutoff in GRB spectra below 20 keV may be a
distinguishing feature separating non-GRB events.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0505490 [pdf] - 73260
Soft Gamma-Ray Bursts in the BATSE data
Submitted: 2005-05-24
We performed the scan of the BATSE DISCLA records inspecting 25-50 keV range
to pick up soft GRBs. We applied the same technique as in our previous (Stern
et al. 2001) scan in the 50-300 keV range. We scanned about 1.8 year of the
data and found 30 new gamma-ray burst (GRB)s. The total number of soft GRBs in
the BATSE data, with the count rate in the 25-50 keV range higher than in the
50-300 keV range, is only 4%. There are about two extremely soft events per
year which are invisible about 50 keV and which could constitute a new class of
events separate from the GRB phenomenon. We also show that X-ray flashes (XRFs)
detected by BeppoSAX have a hardness ratio very similar to that of normal GRBs,
supporting a view that XRFs and GRBs are a single phenomenon with a wide
spectral variety.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409396 [pdf] - 67477
Light Curve Models of Supernovae and X-ray spectra of Supernova Remnants
Submitted: 2004-09-16
We compare parameters of well-observed type II SN1999em derived by M.Hamuy
and D.Nadyozhin based on Litvinova-Nadyozhin (1985) analytic fits with those
found from the simulations with our radiative hydro code Stella. The difference
of SN parameters is quite large for the long distance scale. The same code
applied to models of SN1993J allows us to estimate systematic errors of
extracting foreground extinction toward SN1993J suggested by Clocchiatti et al.
(1995). A new implicit two-temperature hydro code code Supremna is introduced
which self-consistently takes into account the kinetics of ionization, electron
thermal conduction, and radiative losses for predicting X-ray spectra of young
supernova remnants such as Tycho and Kepler.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9902378 [pdf] - 105397
GRBs: when do blackbody spectra look like non-thermal ones?
Submitted: 1999-02-26
We argue that a nonthermally looking spectrum of a gamma-ray burst (GRB) can
be formed as a superposition of a set of thermal blackbody spectra. This
superposition may be done by time integration which is present even in `time
resolved' GRB spectroscopy. A nonthermal spectrum can be obtained also by the
space integration which should take place unless all the emission comes from a
plane front moving exactly towards the observer. We propose a model of the
gamma-ray burst spectrum formation based on this idea. This model allows the
GRB radiation to be optically thick and to have higher values of baryon load.
Thus the latter is limited by the energy considerations only, and not by the
condition of a small optical depth.