Normalized to: Kovaltsov, G.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.10597 [pdf] - 2099354
Revisited reference solar proton event of 23-Feb-1956: Assessment of the
cosmogenic-isotope method sensitivity to extreme solar events
Submitted: 2020-05-21
Our direct knowledge of solar eruptive events is limited to several decades
and does not include extreme events, which can only be studied by the indirect
proxy method over millennia, or by a large number of sun-like stars. There is a
gap, spanning 1--2 orders of magnitude, in the strength of events between
directly observed and reconstructed ones. Here, we study the proxy-method
sensitivity to identify extreme solar particle events (SPEs). First, the
strongest directly observed SPE (23-Feb-1956), used as a reference for
proxy-based reconstructions, was revisited using the newly developed method.
Next, the sensitivity of the cosmogenic-isotope method to detect a reference
SPE was assessed against the precision and number of individual isotopic
records, showing that it is too weak by a factor $\approx$30 to be reliably
identified in a single record. Uncertainties of 10Be and 14C data are shown to
be dominated by local/regional patterns and measurement errors, respectively.
By combining several proxy records, an SPE 4--5 times stronger than the
reference one can be potentially detected, increasing the present-day
sensitivity by an order of magnitude. This will allow filling the observational
gap in SPE strength distribution, thus enriching statistics of extreme events
from 3--4 presently known ones to several tens. This will provide a solid basis
for research in the field of extreme events, both for fundamental science, viz.
solar and stellar physics, and practical applications, such as the risk
assessments of severe space-based hazards for the modern technological society.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.01929 [pdf] - 1885609
Validation of the neutron monitor yield function using data from AMS-02
experiment, 2011--2017
Submitted: 2019-04-03
The newly published spectra of protons and helium over time directly measured
in space by the AMS-02 experiment for the period 2011--2017 provide a unique
opportunity to calibrate ground-based neutron monitors (NMs). Here, calibration
of several stable sealevel NMs (Inuvik, Apatity, Oulu, Newark, Moscow,
Hermanus, Athens) was performed using these spectra. Four modern NM yield
functions were verified: Mi13 (Mishev et al., 2013), Ma16 (Mangeard et al.,
2016), CM12 (Caballero-Lopez & Moraal, 2012) and CD00 (Clem & Dorman, 2000), on
the basis of the cosmic-ray spectra measured by AMS-02. The Mi13 yield function
was found to realistically represent the NM response to galactic cosmic rays.
CM12 yield function leads to a small skew in the solar cycle dependence of the
scaling factor. In contrast, Ma16 and CD00 yield functions tend to overestimate
the NM sensitivity to low-rigidity (<10 GV) cosmic rays. This effect may be
important for an analysis of ground level enhancements, leading to a potential
underestimate of fluxes of solar energetic particles as based on NM data. The
Mi13 yield function is recommended for quantitative analyses of NM data,
especially for ground-level enhancements. The validity the force-field
approximation was studied, and it was found that it fits well the directly
measured proton spectra, within a few % for periods of low to moderate activity
and up to ~10% for active periods. The results of this work strengthen and
validate the method of the cosmic-ray variability analysis based on the NM data
and yield-function formalism, and improves its accuracy.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.10153 [pdf] - 1775609
Solar energetic particles and galactic cosmic rays over millions of
years as inferred from data on cosmogenic $^{26}$Al in lunar samples
Submitted: 2018-07-26
Aims. Lunar soil and rocks are not protected by a magnetic field or an
atmosphere and are continuously irradiated by energetic particles that can
produce cosmogenic radioisotopes directly inside rocks at different depths
depending on the particle's energy. This allows the mean fluxes of solar and
galactic cosmic rays to be assessed on the very long timescales of millions of
years. Methods. Here we show that lunar rocks can serve as a very good particle
integral spectrometer in the energy range 20-80 MeV. We have developed a new
method based on precise modeling, that is applied to measurements of $^{26}$Al
(half-life ~0.7 megayears) in lunar samples from the Apollo mission, and
present the first direct reconstruction (i.e., without any a priori
assumptions) of the mean energy spectrum of solar and galactic energetic
particles over a million of years. Results. We show that the reconstructed
spectrum of solar energetic particles is totally consistent with that over the
last decades, despite the very different levels of solar modulation of galactic
cosmic rays ($\phi=496\pm 40$ MV over a million years versus $\phi= 660\pm 20$
MV for the modern epoch). We also estimated the occurrence probability of
extreme solar events and argue that no events with the F(>30 MeV) fluence
exceeding $5*10^{10}$ and $10^{11}$ cm$^2$ are expected on timescales of a
thousand and million years, respectively. Conclusions. We conclude that the
mean flux of solar energetic particles hardly depends on the level of solar
activity, in contrast to the solar modulation of galactic cosmic rays. This
puts new observational constraints on solar physics and becomes important for
assessing radiation hazards for the planned space missions.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.01302 [pdf] - 1721066
Solar activity over nine millennia: A consistent multi-proxy
reconstruction
Submitted: 2018-04-04
Solar activity in the past millennia can only be reconstructed from
cosmogenic radionuclide records in terrestrial archives. However, because of
the diversity of the proxy archives, it is difficult to build a homogeneous
reconstruction. Here we provide a new consistent multiproxy reconstruction of
the solar activity over the last 9000 years, using available long-span datasets
of 10Be and 14C in terrestrial archives. A new method, based on a Bayesian
approach, was applied for the first time to solar activity reconstruction. A
Monte Carlo search for the most probable value of the modulation potential was
performed to match data from different datasets for a given time. We used six
10Be series from Greenland and Antarctica, and the global 14C production
series. The 10Be series were resampled to match wiggles related to the grand
minima in the 14C reference dataset. The GRIP and the EDML 10Be series diverge
from each other during the second half of the Holocene, while the 14C series
lies between them. A likely reason for this is the insufficiently precise
beryllium transport and deposition model for Greenland. A slow 6-millennia
variability with lows at ca. 5500 BC and 1500 AD of solar activity is found.
Two components of solar activity can be statistically distinguished: the main
'normal' component and a component corresponding to grand minima. A possible
existence of a component representing grand maxima is indicated, but it cannot
be separated from the main component in a statistically significant manner. A
new consistent reconstruction of solar activity over the last nine millennia is
presented with the most probable values of decadal sunspot numbers and their
realistic uncertainties. Independent components of solar activity corresponding
to the main moderate activity and the grand-minimum state are identified; they
may be related to different operation modes of the dynamo.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.10501 [pdf] - 1674991
A Test of the Active Day Fraction Method of Sunspot Group Number
Calibration: Dependence on the Level of Solar Activity
Submitted: 2018-03-28
The method of active day fraction (ADF) was proposed recently to calibrate
different solar observers to the standard observational conditions. The result
of the calibration may depend on the overall level of solar activity during the
observational period. This dependency is studied quantitatively using data of
the Royal Greenwich Observatory, by formally calibrating synthetic
pseudo-observers to the full reference dataset. It is shown that the sunspot
group number is precisely estimated by the ADF method for periods of moderate
activity, may be slightly underestimated by 0.5\,--\,1.5 groups ($\leq$10\,\%)
for strong and very strong activity, and is strongly overestimated by up to 2.5
groups ($\leq$30\,\%) for weak--moderate activity. The ADF method becomes
unapplicable for the periods of grand minima of activity. In general, the ADF
method tends to overestimate the overall level of activity and to reduce the
long-term trends.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.05109 [pdf] - 1577600
Updated sunspot group number reconstruction for 1749-1996 using the
active day fraction method
Submitted: 2017-05-15
Sunspot number series are composed from observations of hundreds of different
observers that requires careful normalization of the observers to the standard
conditions. Here we present a new normalized series of the number of sunspot
groups for the period 1749-1996. The reconstruction is based on the active day
fraction (ADF) method, which is slightly updated with respect to the previous
works, and a revised database of sunspot group observations. Stability of some
key solar observers has been evaluated against the composite series. The Royal
Greenwich Observatory dataset appears fairly stable since the 1890s but is
about 10% too low before that. A declining trend of 10-15% in the quality of
Wolfer's observation is found between the 1880s and 1920s, suggesting that
using him as the reference observer may lead to additional uncertainties. Wolf
(small telescope) appears fairly stable between the 1860s and 1890s, without
any obvious trend. The new reconstruction reflects the centennial variability
of solar activity as evaluated using the singular spectrum analysis method. It
depicts a highly significant feature of the Modern grand maximum of solar
activity in the second half of the 20th century, being a factor 1.33-1.77
higher than during the 18-19th centuries. The new series of the sunspot group
numbers with monthly and annual resolution, available also in the electronic
format, is provided forming a basis for new studies of the solar variability
and solar dynamo for the last 250 years.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.06183 [pdf] - 1581567
New reconstruction of the sunspot group number since 1739 using the
direct calibration and "backbone" methods
Submitted: 2017-02-20, last modified: 2017-02-27
Group sunspot number (GSN) series constitute the longest instrumental
astronomical database providing information on solar activity. It is a
compilation of observations by many individual observers, and their
inter-calibration has usually been performed using linear rescaling. There are
multiple published series that show different long-term trends for solar
activity. We aim at producing a GSN series, with a non-linear non-parametric
calibration. The only underlying assumptions are that the differences between
the various series are due to different acuity thresholds of the observers, and
that the threshold of each observer remains constant throughout the observing
period. We use a daisy chain process with backbone (BB) observers and calibrate
all overlapping observers to them. The calibration of each individual observer
is performed with a probability distribution function (PDF) matrix, constructed
considering all daily values for the overlapping period with the BB. The
calibration of the BBs is done in a similar manner. Propagation of errors is
modelled with Monte Carlo simulations. The final series extends back to 1739
and includes data from 314 observers. It suggests moderate activity during the
18th and 19th century, which is significantly lower than the high level of
solar activity predicted by other recent reconstructions applying linear
regressions. The new series provides a robust reconstruction, based on modern
and non-parametric methods, of sunspot group numbers since 1739, and it
confirms the existence of the Modern grand maximum of solar activity in the
second half of the 20th century.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.00705 [pdf] - 1532971
An Optical Atmospheric Phenomenon Observed in 1670 over the City of
Astrakhan Was not a Mid-Latitude Aurora
Submitted: 2016-11-28
It has been recently claimed (Zolotova and Ponyavin, Solar Phys., 291, 2869,
2016, ZP16 henceforth) that a mid-latitude optical phenomenon, which took place
over the city of Astrakhan in July 1670, according to Russian chronicles, was a
strong aurora borealis. If this was true, it would imply a very strong or even
severe geomagnetic storm during the quietest part of the Maunder minimum.
However, as we argue in this article, this conclusion is erroneous and caused
by a misinterpretation of the chronicle record. As a result of a thorough
analysis of the chronicle text, we show that the described phenomenon occurred
during the daylight period of the day ("the last morning hour"), in the south
direction ("towards noon"), and its description does not match that of an
aurora. The date of the event was also incorrectly interpreted. We conclude
that this phenomenon was not a mid-latitude aurora but an atmospheric
phenomenon, the so-called sundog (or parhelion) which is a particular type of
solar halo. Accordingly, the claim about a strong mid-latitude aurora during
the deep Maunder minimum is not correct and should be dismissed.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.01498 [pdf] - 1527313
Neutron Monitor Yield Function: New Improved computations
Submitted: 2016-10-25
A ground-based neutron monitor is a standard tool to measure cosmic ray
variability near Earth, and it is crucially important to know its yield
function for primary cosmic rays. Although there are several earlier
theoretically calculated yield functions, none of them agrees with experimental
data of latitude surveys of sea-level neutron monitors, thus suggesting for an
inconsistency. A newly computed yield function of the standard sea-level 6NM64
neutron monitor is presented here separately for primary cosmic ray protons and
$\alpha-$particles, the latter representing also heavier species of cosmic
rays. The computations have been done using the GEANT-4 Planetocosmics
Monte-Carlo tool and a realistic curved atmospheric model. For the first time,
an effect of the geometrical correction of the neutron monitor effective area,
related to the finite lateral expansion of the cosmic ray induced atmospheric
cascade, is considered, that was neglected in the previous studies. This
correction slightly enhances the relative impact of higher-energy cosmic rays
(energy above 5--10 GeV/nucleon) in neutron monitor count rate. The new
computation finally resolves the long-standing problem of disagreement between
the theoretically calculated spatial variability of cosmic rays over the globe
and experimental latitude surveys. The newly calculated yield function,
corrected for this geometrical factor, appears fully consistent with the
experimental latitude surveys of neutron monitors performed during three
consecutive solar minima in 1976--77, 1986--87 and 1996--97. Thus, we provide a
new yield function of the standard sea-level neutron monitor 6NM64 that is
validated against experimental data.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.02446 [pdf] - 1533100
Analysis of Ground Level Enhancements (GLE): Extreme solar energetic
particle events have hard spectra
Submitted: 2016-09-18
Nearly 70 Ground Level Enhancements (GLEs) of cosmic rays have been recorded
by the worldwide neutron monitor network since the 1950s depicting a big
variety of energy spectra of solar energetic particles (SEP). Here we studied a
statistical relation between the event-integrated intensity of GLEs (calculated
as count-rate relative excess, averaged over all available polar neutron
monitors, and expressed in percent-hours) and the hardness of the solar
particle energy spectra. For each event the integral omnidirectional
event-integrated fluences of particles with energy above 30 MeV ($F_{30}$) and
above 200 MeV ($F_{200}$) were computed using the reconstructed spectra, and
the ratio between the two fluences was considered as a simple index of the
event's hardness. We also provided a justification of the spectrum estimate in
the form of the Band-function, using direct PAMELA data for GLE 71
(17-May-2012). We found that, while there is no clear relation between the
intensity and the hardness for weak events, all strong events with the
intensity greater 100 \%*hr are characterized by a very hard spectrum. This
implies that a hard spectrum can be securely assumed for all extreme GLE
events, e.g., those studied using cosmogenic isotope data in the past.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.00569 [pdf] - 1521324
Dependence of the Sunspot-group Size on the Level of Solar Activity and
its Influence on the Calibration of Solar Observers
Submitted: 2016-09-02
The distribution of the sunspot group size (area) and its dependence on the
level of solar activity is studied. It is shown that the fraction of small
groups is not constant but decreases with the level of solar activity so that
high solar activity is largely defined by big groups. We study the possible
influence of solar activity on the ability of a realistic observer to see and
report the daily number of sunspot groups. It is shown that the relation
between the number of sunspot groups as seen by different observers with
different observational acuity thresholds is strongly non-linear and cannot be
approximated by the traditionally used linear scaling ($k-$factors). The
observational acuity threshold [$A_{\rm th}$] is considered to quantify the
quality of each observer, instead of the traditional relative $k-$factor. A
nonlinear $c-$factor based on $A_{\rm th}$ is proposed, which can be used to
correct each observer to the reference conditions. The method is tested on a
pair of principal solar observers, Wolf and Wolfer, and it is shown that the
traditional linear correction, with the constant $k-$factor of 1.66 to scale
Wolf to Wolfer, leads to an overestimate of solar activity around solar maxima.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.05899 [pdf] - 1425578
Production of cosmogenic isotopes 7Be, 10Be, 14C, 22Na and 36Cl in the
atmosphere: Altitudinal profiles of yield functions
Submitted: 2016-06-19
New consistent and precise computations of the production of five cosmogenic
radio-isotopes, 7Be, 10Be, 14C, 22Na and 36Cl, in the Earth's atmosphere by
cosmic rays are presented in the form of tabulated yield functions. For the
first time, a detailed set of the the altitude profiles of the production
functions is provided which makes it possible to apply the results directly as
input for atmospheric transport models. Good agreement with most of the earlier
published works for columnar and global isotopic production rates is shown.
Altitude profiles of the production are important, in particular for such tasks
as studies of strong solar particle events in the past, precise reconstructions
of solar activity on long-term scale, tracing air-mass dynamics using
cosmogenic radio-isotopes, etc. As an example, computations of the $^{10}$Be
deposition flux in the polar region are shown for the last decades and also for
a period around 780 AD and confronted with the actual measurements in Greenland
and Antarctic ice cores.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.02483 [pdf] - 1368733
Solar activity during the Holocene: the Hallstatt cycle and its
consequence for grand minima and maxim
Submitted: 2016-02-08
Cosmogenic isotopes provide the only quantitative proxy for analyzing the
long-term solar variability over a centennial timescale. While essential
progress has been achieved in both measurements and modeling of the cosmogenic
proxy, uncertainties still remain in the determination of the geomagnetic
dipole moment evolution. Here we improve the reconstruction of solar activity
over the past nine millennia using a multi-proxy approach. We used records of
the 14C and 10Be cosmogenic isotopes, current numerical models of the isotope
production and transport in Earth's atmosphere, and available geomagnetic field
reconstructions, including a new reconstruction relying on an updated
archeo-/paleointensity database. The obtained series were analyzed using the
singular spectrum analysis (SSA) method to study the millennial-scale trends. A
new reconstruction of the geomagnetic dipole field moment, GMAG.9k, is built
for the last nine millennia. New reconstructions of solar activity covering the
last nine millennia, quantified in sunspot numbers, are presented and analyzed.
A conservative list of grand minima and maxima is provided. The primary
components of the reconstructed solar activity, as determined using the SSA
method, are different for the series based on 14C and 10Be. These primary
components can only be ascribed to long-term changes in the terrestrial system
and not to the Sun. They have been removed from the reconstructed series. In
contrast, the secondary SSA components of the reconstructed solar activity are
found to be dominated by a common ~2400-yr quasi-periodicity, the so-called
Hallstatt cycle, in both the 14C and 10Be based series. This Hallstatt cycle
thus appears to be related to solar activity. Finally, we show that the grand
minima and maxima occurred intermittently over the studied period, with
clustering near highs and lows of the Hallstatt cycle, respectively.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.06421 [pdf] - 1351656
A New Calibrated Sunspot Group Series Since 1749: Statistics of Active
Day Fractions
Submitted: 2015-12-20
Although the sunspot-number series have existed since the mid-19th century,
they are still the subject of intense debate, with the largest uncertainty
being related to the "calibration" of the visual acuity of individual observers
in the past. Daisy-chain regression methods are applied to inter-calibrate the
observers which may lead to significant bias and error accumulation. Here we
present a novel method to calibrate the visual acuity of the key observers to
the reference data set of Royal Greenwich Observatory sunspot groups for the
period 1900-1976, using the statistics of the active-day fraction. For each
observer we independently evaluate their observational thresholds [S_S] defined
such that the observer is assumed to miss all of the groups with an area
smaller than S_S and report all the groups larger than S_S. Next, using a
Monte-Carlo method we construct, from the reference data set, a correction
matrix for each observer. The correction matrices are significantly non-linear
and cannot be approximated by a linear regression or proportionality. We
emphasize that corrections based on a linear proportionality between annually
averaged data lead to serious biases and distortions of the data. The
correction matrices are applied to the original sunspot group records for each
day, and finally the composite corrected series is produced for the period
since 1748. The corrected series displays secular minima around 1800 (Dalton
minimum) and 1900 (Gleissberg minimum), as well as the Modern grand maximum of
activity in the second half of the 20th century. The uniqueness of the grand
maximum is confirmed for the last 250 years. It is shown that the adoption of a
linear relationship between the data of Wolf and Wolfer results in grossly
inflated group numbers in the 18th and 19th centuries in some reconstructions.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.05516 [pdf] - 1329320
A two-wave dynamo model by Zharkova et al. (2015) disagrees with data on
long-term solar variability
Submitted: 2015-12-17
A two-wave dynamo model was recently proposed by Zharkova et al. (2015, Zh15
henceforth), which aims at long-term predictions of solar activity for
millennia ahead and backwards. Here we confront the backward model predictions
for the last 800 years with known variability of solar activity, using both
direct sunspot observations since 1610 and reconstructions based on cosmogenic
radionuclide data. We show that the Zh15 model fails to reproduce the
well-established features of the solar activity evolution during the last
millennium. This means that the predictive part for the future is not reliable
either.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.05191 [pdf] - 1328798
The Maunder minimum (1645--1715) was indeed a Grand minimum: A
reassessment of multiple datasets
Usoskin, Ilya G.;
Arlt, Rainer;
Asvestari, Eleanna;
Hawkins, Ed;
Käpylä, Maarit;
Kovaltsov, Gennady A.;
Krivova, Natalie;
Lockwood, Michael;
Mursula, Kalevi;
O'Reilly, Jezebel;
Owens, Matthew;
Scott, Chris J.;
Sokoloff, Dmitry D.;
Solanki, Sami K.;
Soon, Willie;
Vaquero, José M.
Submitted: 2015-07-18
Aims: Although the time of the Maunder minimum (1645--1715) is widely known
as a period of extremely low solar activity, claims are still debated that
solar activity during that period might still have been moderate, even higher
than the current solar cycle #24. We have revisited all the existing pieces of
evidence and datasets, both direct and indirect, to assess the level of solar
activity during the Maunder minimum.
Methods: We discuss the East Asian naked-eye sunspot observations, the
telescopic solar observations, the fraction of sunspot active days, the
latitudinal extent of sunspot positions, auroral sightings at high latitudes,
cosmogenic radionuclide data as well as solar eclipse observations for that
period. We also consider peculiar features of the Sun (very strong hemispheric
asymmetry of sunspot location, unusual differential rotation and the lack of
the K-corona) that imply a special mode of solar activity during the Maunder
minimum.
Results: The level of solar activity during the Maunder minimum is reassessed
on the basis of all available data sets.
Conclusions: We conclude that solar activity was indeed at an exceptionally
low level during the Maunder minimum. Although the exact level is still
unclear, it was definitely below that during the Dalton minimum around 1800 and
significantly below that of the current solar cycle #24. Claims of a
moderate-to-high level of solar activity during the Maunder minimum are
rejected at a high confidence level.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.07664 [pdf] - 991690
Level and length of cyclic solar activity during the Maunder minimum as
deduced from the active day statistics
Submitted: 2015-03-26
The Maunder minimum (MM) of greatly reduced solar activity took place in
1645-1715, but the exact level of sunspot activity is uncertain as based, to a
large extent, on historical generic statements of the absence of spots on the
Sun. Here we aim, using a conservative approach, to assess the level and length
of solar cycle during the Maunder minimum, on the basis of direct historical
records by astronomers of that time. A database of the active and inactive days
(days with and without recorded sunspots on the solar disc respectively) is
constructed for three models of different levels of conservatism (loose ML,
optimum MO and strict MS models) regarding generic no-spot records. We have
used the active day fraction to estimate the group sunspot number during the
MM. A clear cyclic variability is found throughout the MM with peaks at around
1655--1657, 1675, 1684 and 1705, and possibly 1666, with the active day
fraction not exceeding 0.2, 0.3 or 0.4 during the core MM, for the three
models. Estimated sunspot numbers are found very low in accordance with a grand
minimum of solar activity.
We have found, for the core MM (1650-1700), that: (1) A large fraction of
no-spot records, corresponding to the solar meridian observations, may be
unreliable in the conventional database. (2) The active day fraction remained
low (below 0.3-0.4) throughout the MM, indicating the low level of sunspot
activity. (3) The solar cycle appears clearly during the core MM. (4) The
length of the solar cycle during the core MM appears $9\pm 1$ years, but there
is an uncertainty in that. (5) The magnitude of the sunspot cycle during MM is
assessed to be below 5-10 in sunspot numbers;
A hypothesis of the high solar cycles during the MM is not confirmed.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.5141 [pdf] - 1055667
Has the Earth been exposed to numerous supernovae within the last 300
kyr?
Submitted: 2014-06-19, last modified: 2014-09-25
Firestone (2014) asserted evidence for numerous (23) nearby (d<300 pc)
supernovae within the Middle and Late Pleistocene. If true, this would have
strong implications for the irradiation of the Earth; at this rate, mass
extinction level events due to supernovae would be more frequent than 100 Myr.
However, there are numerous errors in the application of past research. The
paper overestimates likely nitrate and 14C production from moderately nearby
supernovae by about four orders of magnitude. Moreover, the results are based
on wrongly selected (obsolete) nitrate and 14C datasets. The use of correct and
up-to-date datasets does not confirm the claimed results. The claims in the
paper are invalidated.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.5945 [pdf] - 1579501
A comet could not produce the carbon-14 spike in the 8th century
Submitted: 2014-01-23, last modified: 2014-06-13
A mysterious increase of radiocarbon 14C ca. 775 AD in the Earth's atmosphere
has been recently found by Miyake et al. (Nature, 486, 240, 2012). A possible
source of this event has been discussed widely, the most likely being an
extreme solar energetic particle event. A new exotic hypothesis has been
presented recently by Liu et al. (Nature Sci. Rep., 4, 3728, 2014) who proposed
that the event was caused by a comet bringing additional 14C to Earth. Here we
calculated a realistic mass and size of such a comet to show that it would have
been huge (~100 km across and 10^{14}-10^{15} ton of mass) and would have
produced a disastrous impact on Earth. Such an impact could not remain
unnoticed in the geological records and chronicles. The absence of an evidence
for such a dramatic event makes this hypothesis invalid.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.4720 [pdf] - 787307
Evidence for distinct modes of solar activity
Submitted: 2014-02-19
Aims. The Sun shows strong variability in its magnetic activity, from Grand
minima to Grand maxima, but the nature of the variability is not fully
understood, mostly because of the insufficient length of the directly observed
solar activity records and of uncertainties related to long-term
reconstructions. Here we present a new adjustment-free reconstruction of solar
activity over three millennia and study its different modes. Methods. We
present a new adjustment-free, physical reconstruction of solar activity over
the past three millennia, using the latest verified carbon cycle, 14C
production, and archeomagnetic field models. This great improvement allowed us
to study different modes of solar activity at an unprecedented level of
details. Results. The distribution of solar activity is clearly bi-modal,
implying the existence of distinct modes of activity. The main regular activity
mode corresponds to moderate activity that varies in a relatively narrow band
between sunspot numbers about 20 and 67. The existence of a separate Grand
minimum mode with reduced solar activity, which cannot be explained by random
fluctuations of the regular mode, is confirmed at a high confidence level. The
possible existence of a separate Grand maximum mode is also suggested, but the
statistics is too low to reach a confident conclusion. Conclusions. The Sun is
shown to operate in distinct modes - a main general mode, a Grand minimum mode
corresponding to an inactive Sun, and a possible Grand maximum mode
corresponding to an unusually active Sun. These results provide important
constraints for both dynamo models of Sun-like stars and investigations of
possible solar influence on Earth's climate.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1302.6897 [pdf] - 666713
The AD775 cosmic event revisited: the Sun is to blame
Submitted: 2013-02-27, last modified: 2013-05-22
Miyake et al. (henceforth M12) recently reported, based on 14C data, an
extreme cosmic event ca. AD775. Using a simple model, M12 claimed that the
event was too strong to be caused by a solar flare within the standard theory.
This implied a new paradigm of either an impossibly strong solar flare or a
very strong cosmic ray event of unknown origin occurred ca. AD775. We show that
the strength of the event was significantly overestimated by M12. Several
subsequent works have attempted to find a possible exotic source for such an
event, but they are all based on incorrect estimates by M12. We revisit this
event with analysis of new datasets and consistent theoretical modelling. We
verified the experimental result for the AD775 event using independent datasets
including 10Be series and newly measured 14C annual data. We surveyed available
historical chronicles for astronomical observations for the AD770s to identify
potential sightings of aurorae or supernovae. We interpreted the 14C
measurements using an appropriate carbon cycle model. We show that: (1) The
reality of the AD775 event is confirmed by new measurements of 14C; (2) by
using an inappropriate carbon cycle model, M12 strongly overestimated the
event's strength; (3) The revised magnitude of the event is consistent with
different independent datasets (14C, 10Be, 36Cl) and can be associated with a
strong, but not inexplicably strong, SEP event (or a sequence of events), and
provides the first evidence for an event of this magnitude (the fluence >30 MeV
was about 4.5*10^{10} /cm2) in multiple datasets; (4) This is in agreement with
increased auroral activity identified in historical chronicles. This point to
the likely solar origin of the event, which is the greatest solar event on a
multi-millennial time scale, placing a strong observational constraint on the
theory of explosive energy releases on the Sun and cool stars.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.5088 [pdf] - 771849
Occurrence Probability of Large Solar Energetic Particle Events:
Assessment from Data on Cosmogenic Radionuclides in Lunar Rocks
Submitted: 2013-05-22
We revisited assessments of the occurrence probability distribution of large
events in solar energetic particles (SEP), based on measurements of cosmogenic
radionuclides in lunar rocks. We present a combined cumulative occurrence
probability distribution of SEP events based on three time scales: directly
measured SEP fluences for the last 60 years; estimates based on terrestrial
cosmogenic radionuclides 10Be and 14C for the multi-millennial (Holocene) time
scale; and cosmogenic radionuclides measured in lunar rocks on the time scale
of up to 1 Myr. All the three time scales yield a consistent distribution. The
data suggest a strong rollover of the occurrence probability so that SEP events
with the fluence of protons with energy >30 MeV greater than 10^{11} (protons
/cm2/yr) are not expected at the Myr time scale.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.5932 [pdf] - 666686
Occurrence of extreme solar particle events: Assessment from historical
proxy data
Submitted: 2012-07-25
The probability of occurrence of extreme solar particle events (SPEs) with
the fluence of (>30 MeV) protons F30>10^{10} cm^{-2} is evaluated based on data
of cosmogenic isotopes 14C and 10Be in terrestrial archives
centennial-millennial time scales. Four potential candidates with
F30=(1-1.5)x10^{10} cm^{-2} and no events with F30>2x10^{10} cm^{-2} are
identified since 1400 AD in the annually resolved 10Be data. A strong SPE
related to the Carrington flare of 1859 AD is not supported by the data. For
the last 11400 years, 19 SPE candidates with F30=(1-3)x10^{10} cm^{-2} are
found and clearly no event with F30>5x10^{10} cm^{-2} (50-fold the SPE of
23-Feb-1956) occurring. This values serve as an observational upper limit for
the strength of SPE on the time scale of tens of millennia. Two events, ca. 780
and 1460 AD, appear in different data series making them strong candidates to
extreme SPEs. We built a distribution of the occurrence probability of extreme
SPEs, providing a new strict observational constraint. Practical limits can be
set as F30~1x, 2-3x, and 5x10^{10} cm^{-2} for the occurrence probability
~10^{-2}, 10^{-3} and 10^{-4} year^{-1}, respectively. Because of
uncertainties, our results should be interpreted as a conservative upper limit
of the SPE occurrence near Earth. The mean SEP flux is evaluated as ~40 (cm2
sec)^{-1} in agreement with estimates from the lunar rocks. On average, extreme
SPEs contribute about 10% to the total SEP fluence.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.6974 [pdf] - 666683
A new model of cosmogenic production of radiocarbon 14C in the
atmosphere
Submitted: 2012-06-29
We present the results of full new calculation of radiocarbon 14C production
in the Earth atmosphere, using a numerical Monte-Carlo model. We provide, for
the first time, a tabulated 14C yield function for the energy of primary cosmic
ray particles ranging from 0.1 to 1000 GeV/nucleon. We have calculated the
global production rate of 14C, which is 1.64 and 1.88 atoms/cm2/s for the
modern time and for the pre-industrial epoch, respectively. This is close to
the values obtained from the carbon cycle reservoir inventory. We argue that
earlier models overestimated the global 14C production rate because of outdated
spectra of cosmic ray heavier nuclei. The mean contribution of solar energetic
particles to the global 14C is calculated as about 0.25% for the modern epoch.
Our model provides a new tool to calculate the 14C production in the Earth's
atmosphere, which can be applied, e.g., to reconstructions of solar activity in
the past.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.1520 [pdf] - 1052560
Revisited sunspot data: A new scenario for the onset of the Maunder
minimum
Submitted: 2011-03-08
Maunder Minimum forms an archetype for the Grand minima, and detailed
knowledge of its temporal development has important consequences for the solar
dynamo theory dealing with long-term solar activity evolution. Here we
reconsider the current paradigm of the Grand minimum general scenario by using
newly recovered sunspot observations by G. Marcgraf and revising some earlier
uncertain data for the period 1636--1642, i.e., one solar cycle before the
beginning of the Maunder Minimum. The new and revised data dramatically change
the magnitude of the sunspot cycle just before the Maunder Minimum, from 60--70
down to about 20, implying a possibly gradual onset of the Minimum with reduced
activity started two cycles before it. This revised scenario of the Maunder
Minimum changes, through the paradigm for Grand solar/stellar activity minima,
the observational constraint on the solar/stellar dynamo theories focused on
long-term studies and occurrence of Grand minima.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:0907.0063 [pdf] - 25845
A solar cycle lost in 1793--1800: Early sunspot observations resolve the
old mystery
Submitted: 2009-07-01, last modified: 2009-07-19
Because of the lack of reliable sunspot observation, the quality of sunspot
number series is poor in the late 18th century, leading to the abnormally long
solar cycle (1784--1799) before the Dalton minimum. Using the newly recovered
solar drawings by the 18--19th century observers Staudacher and Hamilton, we
construct the solar butterfly diagram, i.e. the latitudinal distribution of
sunspots in the 1790's. The sudden, systematic occurrence of sunspots at high
solar latitudes in 1793--1796 unambiguously shows that a new cycle started in
1793, which was lost in traditional Wolf's sunspot series. This finally
confirms the existence of the lost cycle that has been proposed earlier, thus
resolving an old mystery. This letter brings the attention of the scientific
community to the need of revising the sunspot series in the 18th century. The
presence of a new short, asymmetric cycle implies changes and constraints to
sunspot cycle statistics, solar activity predictions, solar dynamo theories as
well as for solar-terrestrial relations.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:0706.0385 [pdf] - 900170
Grand minima and maxima of solar activity: New observational constraints
Submitted: 2007-06-04
Using a reconstruction of sunspot numbers stretching over multiple millennia,
we analyze the statistics of the occurrence of grand minima and maxima and set
new observational constraints on long-term solar and stellar dynamo models.
We present an updated reconstruction of sunspot number over multiple
millennia, from $^{14}$C data by means of a physics-based model, using an
updated model of the evolution of the solar open magnetic flux. A list of grand
minima and maxima of solar activity is presented for the Holocene (since 9500
BC) and the statistics of both the length of individual events as well as the
waiting time between them are analyzed.
The occurrence of grand minima/maxima is driven not by long-term cyclic
variability, but by a stochastic/chaotic process. The waiting time distribution
of the occurrence of grand minima/maxima deviates from an exponential
distribution, implying that these events tend to cluster together with long
event-free periods between the clusters. Two different types of grand minima
are observed: short (30--90 years) minima of Maunder type and long ($>$110
years) minima of Sp\"orer type, implying that a deterministic behaviour of the
dynamo during a grand minimum defines its length. The duration of grand maxima
follows an exponential distribution, suggesting that the duration of a grand
maximum is determined by a random process.
These results set new observational constraints upon the long-term behaviour
of the solar dynamo.