Normalized to: Kennefick, D.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.02307 [pdf] - 2115187
Determining the Co-Rotation Radii of Spiral Galaxies Using Spiral Arm
Pitch Angle Measurements at Multiple Wavelengths
Submitted: 2020-02-06
The spiral arms spanning disk galaxies are believed to be created by density
waves that propagate through galactic disks. We present a novel method of
finding the co-rotation radius where the spiral arm pattern speed matches the
velocities of the stars within the disk. Our method uses an image-overlay
technique, which involves tracing the arms of spiral galaxies on images
observed in different wavelengths. Density wave theory predicts that spiral
arms observed from different wavelengths show a phase crossing at the
co-rotation radius. For the purpose of this study, 20 nearby galaxies were
analyzed in four different wavelengths with pitch angle measurements performed
by two independent methods. We used optical wavelength images ($B$-band 440nm),
two infrared wavelength images provided by Spitzer (3.6$\mu$m and 8$\mu$m) and
ultraviolet images from GALEX (1350\AA, 1750\AA). The results were compared and
verified with other records found in the literature. We then found rotation
curve data for six of our galaxies and used our co-rotation radii estimates to
measure the time that would elapse between star formation and moving to their
observed positions in the $B$-band spirals. The average time lapse for this
motion was found to be $\sim$ 50 Myr. The success of this new method of finding
the co-rotation radius confirms density wave theory in a very direct way.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.10687 [pdf] - 1925173
100 years of the first experimental test of General Relativity
Submitted: 2019-07-24
Einsteins general theory of relativity is one of the most important
accomplishments in the history of science. Its experimental verification a
century ago is therefore an essential milestone that is worth celebrating in
full. We reassess the importance of one of the two expeditions that made these
measurements possible, a story that involves a sense of adventure and
scientific ingenuity in equal measure.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.09390 [pdf] - 1920241
Investigating the Origins of Spiral Structure in Disk Galaxies through a
Multiwavelength Study
Submitted: 2019-07-16
The density-wave theory of spiral structure proposes that star formation
occurs in or near a spiral-shaped region of higher density that rotates rigidly
within the galactic disk at a fixed pattern speed. In most interpretations of
this theory, newborn stars move downstream of this position as they come into
view, forming a downstream spiral which is tighter, with a smaller pitch angle
than that of the density wave itself. Rival theories, including theories which
see spiral arms as essentially transient structures, may demand that pitch
angle should not depend on wavelength. We measure the pitch angle of a large
sample of galaxies at several wavelengths associated with star formation or
very young stars (8.0 {\mu}m, H-{\alpha} line and 151 nm in the far-UV) and
show that they all have the same pitch angle, which is larger than the pitch
angle measured for the same galaxies at optical and near-infrared wavelengths.
Our measurements in the B band and at 3.6 {\mu}m have unambiguously tighter
spirals than the starforming wavelengths. In addition, we have measured in the
u-band, which seems to fall midway between these two extremes. Thus, our
results are consistent with a region of enhanced stellar light situated
downstream of a starforming region.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.5876 [pdf] - 1618252
The Black Hole Mass Function Derived from Local Spiral Galaxies
Submitted: 2014-05-22, last modified: 2018-01-15
We present our determination of the nuclear supermassive black hole (SMBH)
mass function for spiral galaxies in the Local Universe, established from a
volume-limited sample consisting of a statistically complete collection of the
brightest spiral galaxies in the Southern Hemisphere. Our SMBH mass function
agrees well at the high-mass end with previous values given in the literature.
At the low-mass end, inconsistencies exist in previous works that still need to
be resolved, but our work is more in line with expectations based on modeling
of SMBH evolution. This low-mass end of the spectrum is critical to our
understanding of the mass function and evolution of SMBHs since the epoch of
maximum quasar activity. A luminosity distance $\leq$ 25.4 $Mpc$ and an
absolute B-band magnitude $\leq$ -19.12 define the sample. These limits define
a sample of 140 spiral galaxies, with 128 measurable pitch angles to establish
the pitch angle distribution for this sample. This pitch angle distribution
function may be useful in the study of the morphology of late-type galaxies. We
then use an established relationship between the pitch angle and the mass of
the central SMBH in a host galaxy in order to estimate the mass of the 128
respective SMBHs in this sample. This result effectively gives us the
distribution of mass for SMBHs residing in spiral galaxies over a lookback time
$\leq$ 82.1 $h_{67.77}^{-1}$ $Myr$ and contained within a comoving volume of
3.37 $\times$ $10^4$ $h_{67.77}^{-3}$ $Mpc^3$. We estimate the density of SMBHs
residing in spiral galaxies in the Local Universe is $5.54_{-2.73}^{+6.55}$
$\times$ $10^4$ $h_{67.77}^3$ $M_{\odot}$ $Mpc^{-3}$. Thus, our derived
cosmological SMBH mass density for spiral galaxies is $\Omega_{BH} =
4.35_{-2.15}^{+5.14}$ $\times$ $10^{-7}$ $h_{67.77}$.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.03070 [pdf] - 1530237
A Fundamental Plane of Spiral Structure in Disk Galaxies
Davis, Benjamin L.;
Kennefick, Daniel;
Kennefick, Julia;
Westfall, Kyle B.;
Shields, Douglas W.;
Flatman, Russell;
Hartley, Matthew T.;
Berrier, Joel C.;
Martinsson, Thomas P. K.;
Swaters, Rob A.
Submitted: 2015-03-10, last modified: 2017-01-16
Spiral structure is the most distinctive feature of disk galaxies and yet
debate persists about which theory of spiral structure is the correct one. Many
versions of the density wave theory demand that the pitch angle is uniquely
determined by the distribution of mass in the bulge and disk of the galaxy. We
present evidence that the tangent of the pitch angle of logarithmic spiral arms
in disk galaxies correlates strongly with the density of neutral atomic
hydrogen in the disk and with the central stellar bulge mass of the galaxy.
These three quantities, when plotted against each other, form a planar
relationship which, we argue should be fundamental to our understanding of
spiral structure in disk galaxies. We further argue that any successful theory
of spiral structure must be able to explain this relationship.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.00969 [pdf] - 1449298
Strong Evidence for the Density-wave Theory of Spiral Structure in Disk
Galaxies
Submitted: 2016-08-02
The density-wave theory of galactic spiral-arm structure makes a striking
prediction that the pitch angle of spiral arms should vary with the wavelength
of the galaxy's image. The reason is that stars are born in the density wave
but move out of it as they age. They move ahead of the density wave inside the
co-rotation radius, and fall behind outside of it, resulting in a tighter pitch
angle at wavelengths that image stars (optical and near-infrared) than those
that are associated with star formation (far-infrared and ultraviolet). In this
study we combined large sample size with wide range of wavelengths, from the
ultraviolet to the infrared to investigate this issue. For each galaxy we used
an optical wavelength image (B-band: 445 nm) and images from the Spitzer Space
Telescope at two infrared wavelengths (infrared: 3.6 and 8.0 {\mu}m) and we
measured the pitch angle with the 2DFFT and Spirality codes. We find that the
B-band and 3.6 {\mu}m images have smaller pitch angles than the infrared 8.0
{\mu}m image in all cases, in agreement with the prediction of density-wave
theory. We also used images in the ultraviolet from Galaxy Evolution Explorer,
whose pitch angles agreed with the measurements made at 8 {\mu}m.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.06365 [pdf] - 1408807
Spirality: A Novel Way to Measure Spiral Arm Pitch Angle
Submitted: 2015-11-19, last modified: 2016-05-19
We present the MATLAB code Spirality, a novel method for measuring spiral arm
pitch angles by fitting galaxy images to spiral templates of known pitch.
Computation time is typically on the order of 2 minutes per galaxy, assuming at
least 8 GB of working memory. We tested the code using 117 synthetic spiral
images with known pitches, varying both the spiral properties and the input
parameters. The code yielded correct results for all synthetic spirals with
galaxy-like properties. We also compared the code's results to two-dimensional
Fast Fourier Transform (2DFFT) measurements for the sample of nearby galaxies
defined by DMS PPak. Spirality's error bars overlapped 2DFFT's error bars for
26 of the 30 galaxies. The two methods' agreement correlates strongly with
galaxy radius in pixels and also with i-band magnitude, but not with redshift,
a result that is consistent with at least some galaxies' spiral structure being
fully formed by z=1.2, beyond which there are few galaxies in our sample. The
Spirality code package also includes GenSpiral, which produces FITS images of
synthetic spirals, and SpiralArmCount, which uses a one-dimensional Fast
Fourier Transform to count the spiral arms of a galaxy after its pitch is
determined. The code package is freely available online; see Comments for URL.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.6667 [pdf] - 1222195
Constraining dark matter halo profiles and galaxy formation models using
spiral arm morphology. II. Dark and stellar mass concentrations for 13 nearby
face-on galaxies
Submitted: 2014-09-23
We investigate the use of spiral arm pitch angles as a probe of disk galaxy
mass profiles. We confirm our previous result that spiral arm pitch angles (P)
are well correlated with the rate of shear (S) in disk galaxy rotation curves.
We use this correlation to argue that imaging data alone can provide a powerful
probe of galactic mass distributions out to large look-back times. We then use
a sample of 13 galaxies, with Spitzer 3.6-$\mu$m imaging data and observed
H$\alpha$ rotation curves, to demonstrate how an inferred shear rate coupled
with a bulge-disk decomposition model and a Tully-Fisher-derived velocity
normalization can be used to place constraints on a galaxy's baryon fraction
and dark matter halo profile. Finally we show that there appears to be a trend
(albeit a weak correlation) between spiral arm pitch angle and halo
concentration. We discuss implications for the suggested link between
supermassive black hole (SMBH) mass and dark halo concentration, using pitch
angle as a proxy for SMBH mass.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.1912 [pdf] - 1202099
On the superradiance-tidal friction correspondence
Submitted: 2013-12-06, last modified: 2013-12-18
Since the work of Hartle in the 1970s, and the subsequent development of the
the Membrane Paradigm approach to black hole physics it has been widely
accepted that superradiant scattering of gravitational waves bears strong
similarities with the phenomenon of ``tidal friction'' (well-known from
Newtonian gravity) operating in binary systems of viscous material bodies. In
this paper we revisit the superradiance-tidal friction analogy within the
context of ultracompact relativistic bodies. We advocate that as long as these
bodies have non-zero viscosity they should undergo tidal friction that can be
construed as a kind of superradiant scattering from the point of view of the
dynamics of an orbiting test-body. In addition we consider the presence of
anisotropic matter, which is required for at least some ultracompact bodies, if
they are to sustain a radius very close to the gravitational radius. We find
that the tidal friction/superradiance output is enhanced with increasing
anisotropy and that strongly anisotropic systems exhibit an unconventional
response to tidal and centrifugal forces. Finally, we make contact with the
artificial system comprising a black hole with its horizon replaced by a mirror
(sometimes used as a proxy for ultracompact material bodies) and discuss
superradiance and tidal friction in relation to it.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.4937 [pdf] - 691221
Further Evidence for a Supermassive Black Hole Mass - Pitch Angle
Relation
Berrier, Joel C.;
Davis, Benjamin L.;
Kennefick, Daniel;
Kennefick, Julia D.;
Seigar, Marc S.;
Barrows, R. Scott;
Hartley, Matthew;
Shields, Doug;
Bentz, Misty C.;
Lacy, Claud H. S.
Submitted: 2013-04-17, last modified: 2013-07-09
We present new and stronger evidence for a previously reported relationship
between galactic spiral arm pitch angle P (a measure of the tightness of spiral
structure) and the mass M_BH of a disk galaxy's nuclear supermassive black hole
(SMBH). We use an improved method to accurately measure the spiral arm pitch
angle in disk galaxies to generate quantitative data on this morphological
feature for 34 galaxies with directly measured black hole masses. We find a
relation of log(M/M_sun) = (8.21 +/- 0.16) - (0.062 +/- 0.009)P. This method is
compared with other means of estimating black hole mass to determine its
effectiveness and usefulness relative to other existing relations. We argue
that such a relationship is predicted by leading theories of spiral structure
in disk galaxies, including the density wave theory. We propose this
relationship as a tool for estimating SMBH masses in disk galaxies. This tool
is potentially superior when compared to other methods for this class of galaxy
and has the advantage of being unambiguously measurable from imaging data
alone.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.3587 [pdf] - 1165266
Identification of Outflows and Candidate Dual Active Galactic Nuclei in
SDSS Quasars at z=0.8-1.6
Submitted: 2013-03-14
We present a sample of 131 quasars from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey at
redshifts 0.8<z<1.6 with double peaks in either of the high-ionization narrow
emission lines [NeV]3426 or [NeIII]3869. These sources were selected with the
intention of identifying high-redshift analogs of the z<0.8 active galactic
nuclei (AGN) with double-peaked [OIII]5007 lines, which might represent AGN
outflows or dual AGN. Lines of high-ionization potential are believed to
originate in the inner, highly photoionized portion of the narrow line region
(NLR), and we exploit this assumption to investigate the possible kinematic
origins of the double-peaked lines. For comparison, we measure the [NeV]3426
and [NeIII]3869 double peaks in low-redshift (z<0.8) [OIII]-selected sources.
We find that [NeV]3426 and [NeIII]3869 show a correlation between
line-splitting and line-width similar to that of [OIII]5007 in other studies;
and the velocity-splittings are correlated with the quasar Eddington ratio.
These results suggest an outflow origin for at least a subset of the
double-peaks, allowing us to study the high-ionization gas kinematics around
quasars. However, we find that a non-neligible fraction of our sample show no
evidence for an ionization stratification. For these sources, the outflow
scenario is less compelling, leaving the dual AGN scenario as a viable
possibility. Finally, we find that our sample shows an anti-correlation between
the velocity-offset ratio and luminosity ratio of the components, which is a
potential dynamical argument for the presence of dual AGN. Therefore, this
study serves as a first attempt at extending the selection of candidate dual
AGN to higher redshifts.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1202.4780 [pdf] - 517719
Measurement of Galactic Logarithmic Spiral Arm Pitch Angle Using
Two-Dimensional Fast Fourier Transform Decomposition
Submitted: 2012-02-21, last modified: 2012-05-29
A logarithmic spiral is a prominent feature appearing in a majority of
observed galaxies. This feature has long been associated with the traditional
Hubble classification scheme, but historical quotes of pitch angle of spiral
galaxies have been almost exclusively qualitative. We have developed a
methodology, utilizing two-dimensional fast Fourier transformations of images
of spiral galaxies, in order to isolate and measure the pitch angles of their
spiral arms. Our technique provides a quantitative way to measure this
morphological feature. This will allow comparison of spiral galaxy pitch angle
to other galactic parameters and test spiral arm genesis theories. In this
work, we detail our image processing and analysis of spiral galaxy images and
discuss the robustness of our analysis techniques.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.4210 [pdf] - 1118104
On the Link Between Central Black Holes, Bar Dynamics, and Dark Matter
Halos in Spiral Galaxies
Submitted: 2012-04-18
The discovery of a relationship between supermassive black hole (SMBH) mass
and spiral arm pitch angle (P) is evidence that SMBHs are tied to the overall
secular evolution of a galaxy. The discovery of SMBHs in late-type galaxies
with little or no bulge suggests that an underlying correlation between the
dark matter halo concentration and SMBH mass (MBH) exists, rather than between
the bulge mass and MBH. In this paper we measure P using a two-dimensional fast
fourier transform and estimate the bar pattern speeds of 40 barred spiral
galaxies from the Carnegie-Irvine Galaxy Survey. The pattern speeds were
derived by estimating the gravitational potentials of our galaxies from Ks-band
images and using them to produce dynamical simulation models. The pattern
speeds allow us to identify those galaxies with low central dark halo
densities, or fast rotating bars, while P provides an estimate of MBH. We find
that a wide range of MBH exists in galaxies with low central dark matter halo
densities, which appears to support other theoretical results. We also find
that galaxies with low central dark halo densities appear to follow more
predictable trends in P versus de Vaucouleurs morphological type (T) and bar
strength versus T than barred galaxies in general. The empirical relationship
between MBH and total gravitational mass of a galaxy (Mtot) allows us to
predict the minimum Mtot that will be observationally measured of our fast bar
galaxies. These predictions will be investigated in a subsequent paper.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.2221 [pdf] - 1034255
Unusual Double-peaked Emission in the SDSS Quasar J093201.60+031858.7
Submitted: 2010-08-12, last modified: 2010-08-16
We examine spectral properties of the SDSS quasar J093201.60+031858.7, in
particular the presence of strong blue peaks in the Balmer emission lines
offset from the narrow lines by approximately 4200 km/s. Asymmetry in the broad
central component of the Hbeta line indicates the presence of a double-peaked
emitter. However, the strength and sharpness of the blue Hbeta and blue Hgamma
peaks make this quasar spectrum unique amongst double-peaked emitters
identified from SDSS spectra. We fit a disk model to the Hbeta line and compare
this object with other unusual double-peaked quasar spectra, particularly
candidate binary supermassive black holes (SMBHs). Under the binary SMBH
scenario, we test the applicability of a model in which a second SMBH may
produce the strong blue peak in the Balmer lines of a double-peaked emitter. If
there were only one SMBH, a circular, Keplerian disk model fit would be
insufficient, indicating some sort of asymmetry is required to produce the
strength of the blue peak. In either case, understanding the nature of the
complex line emission in this object will aid in further discrimination between
a single SMBH with a complex accretion disk and the actual case of a binary
SMBH.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.0773 [pdf] - 11497
Discovery of a relationship between spiral arm morphology and
supermassive black hole mass in disk galaxies
Submitted: 2008-04-04, last modified: 2008-09-04
We present a relationship between spiral arm pitch angle (a measure of the
tightness of spiral structure) and the mass of supermassive black holes (BHs)
in the nuclei of disk galaxies. We argue that this relationship is expected
through a combination of other relationships, whose existence has already been
demonstrated. The recent discovery of AGN in bulgeless disk galaxies suggests
that halo concentration or virial mass may be one of the determining factors in
BH mass. Taken together with the result that mass concentration seems to
determine spiral arm pitch angle, one would expect a relation to exist between
spiral arm pitch angle and supermassive BH mass in disk galaxies, and we find
that this is indeed the case. We conclude that this relationship may be
important for estimating evolution in BH masses in disk galaxies out to
intermediate redshifts, since regular spiral arm structure can be seen in
galaxies out to z~1.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.0685 [pdf] - 603986
Not Only Because of Theory: Dyson, Eddington and the Competing Myths of
the 1919 Eclipse Expedition
Submitted: 2007-09-05
The 1919 Eclipse Expedition to test the light-bending prediction of General
Relativity remains one of the most famous physics experiments of the 20th
century. However, in recent decades it has been increasingly often alleged that
the data-analysis of the expedition's leaders was faulty and biased in favor of
Einstein's theory. Arthur Stanley Eddington is particularly alleged to have
been prejudiced in favor of general relativity. Specifically it is claimed that
some of the data, which would have favored the so-called Newtonian prediction,
was thrown out on dubious grounds. This paper argues that a close examination
of the views of the expedition's organizers, and of their data analysis,
suggests that they had good grounds for acting as they did, and that the key
people involved, in particular the astronomer Frank Watson Dyson, were not
biased in favor of Einstein. It also draws attention to a modern re-analysis of
the most important eclipse plates which, though overlooked until now, tends to
strongly support the thesis of this paper.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0508275 [pdf] - 260636
Gravitational radiation timescales for extreme mass ratio inspirals
Submitted: 2005-08-11, last modified: 2005-11-17
The capture and inspiral of compact stellar masses into massive black holes
is an important source of low-frequency gravitational waves (with frequencies
of ~1-100mHz), such as those that might be detected by the planned Laser
Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). Simulations of stellar clusters designed
to study this problem typically rely on simple treatments of the black hole
encounter which neglect some important features of orbits around black holes,
such as the minimum radii of stable, non-plunging orbits. Incorporating an
accurate representation of the orbital dynamics near a black hole has been
avoided due to the large computational overhead. This paper provides new, more
accurate, expressions for the energy and angular momentum lost by a compact
object during a parabolic encounter with a non-spinning black hole, and the
subsequent inspiral lifetime. These results improve on the Keplerian
expressions which are now commonly used and will allow efficient computational
simulations to be performed that account for the relativistic nature of the
spacetime around the central black hole in the system.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0205033 [pdf] - 110982
Approximating the inspiral of test bodies into Kerr black holes
Submitted: 2002-05-08
We present a new approximate method for constructing gravitational radiation
driven inspirals of test-bodies orbiting Kerr black holes. Such orbits can be
fully described by a semi-latus rectum $p$, an eccentricity $e$, and an
inclination angle $\iota$; or, by an energy $E$, an angular momentum component
$L_z$, and a third constant $Q$. Our scheme uses expressions that are exact
(within an adiabatic approximation) for the rates of change ($\dot{p}$,
$\dot{e}$, $\dot{\iota}$) as linear combinations of the fluxes ($\dot{E}$,
$\dot{L_z}$, $\dot{Q}$), but uses quadrupole-order formulae for these fluxes.
This scheme thus encodes the exact orbital dynamics, augmenting it with
approximate radiation reaction. Comparing inspiral trajectories, we find that
this approximation agrees well with numerical results for the special cases of
eccentric equatorial and circular inclined orbits, far more accurate than
corresponding weak-field formulae for ($\dot{p}$, $\dot{e}$, $\dot{\iota}$). We
use this technique to study the inspiral of a test-body in inclined, eccentric
Kerr orbits. Our results should be useful tools for constructing approximate
waveforms that can be used to study data analysis problems for the future LISA
gravitational-wave observatory, in lieu of waveforms from more rigorous
techniques that are currently under development.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0203086 [pdf] - 110954
Zoom & Whirl: Eccentric equatorial orbits around spinning black holes
and their evolution under gravitational radiation reaction
Submitted: 2002-03-25
We study eccentric equatorial orbits of a test-body around a Kerr black hole
under the influence of gravitational radiation reaction. We have adopted a well
established two-step approach: assuming that the particle is moving along a
geodesic (justifiable as long as the orbital evolution is adiabatic) we
calculate numerically the fluxes of energy and angular momentum radiated to
infinity and to the black hole horizon, via the Teukolsky-Sasaki-Nakamura
formalism. We can then infer the rate of change of orbital energy and angular
momentum and thus the evolution of the orbit. The orbits are fully described by
a semi-latus rectum $p$ and an eccentricity $e$. We find that while, during the
inspiral, $e$ decreases until shortly before the orbit reaches the separatrix
of stable bound orbits (which is defined by $p_{s}(e)$), in many
astrophysically relevant cases the eccentricity will still be significant in
the last stages of the inspiral. In addition, when a critical value
$p_{crit}(e)$ is reached, the eccentricity begins to increase as a result of
continued radiation induced inspiral. The two values $p_{s}$, $p_{crit}$ (for
given $e$) move closer to each other, in coordinate terms, as the black hole
spin is increased, as they do also for fixed spin and increasing eccentricity.
Of particular interest are moderate and high eccentricity orbits around rapidly
spinning black holes, with $p(e) \approx p_{s}(e)$. We call these
``zoom-whirl'' orbits, because of their characteristic behaviour involving
several revolutions around the central body near periastron. Gravitational
waveforms produced by such orbits are calculated and shown to have a very
particular signature. Such signals may well prove of considerable astrophysical
importance for the future LISA detector.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9208005 [pdf] - 90643
The Last Three Minutes: Issues in Gravitational Wave Measurements of
Coalescing Compact Binaries
Cutler, Curt;
Apostolatos, Theocharis A.;
Bildsten, Lars;
Finn, Lee Samuel;
Flanagan, Eanna E.;
Kennefick, Daniel;
Markovic, Dragoljubov M.;
Ori, Amos;
Poisson, Eric;
Sussman, Gerald Jay;
Thorne, Kip S.
Submitted: 1992-08-25
Gravitational-wave interferometers are expected to monitor the last three
minutes of inspiral and final coalescence of neutron star and black hole
binaries at distances approaching cosmological, where the event rate may be
many per year. Because the binary's accumulated orbital phase can be measured
to a fractional accuracy $\ll 10^{-3}$ and relativistic effects are large, the
waveforms will be far more complex, carry more information, and be far harder
to model theoretically than has been expected. Theorists must begin now to lay
a foundation for extracting the waves' information.