Normalized to: Kee, N.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.13739 [pdf] - 2115299
A Detailed View of the Circumstellar Environment and Disk of the Forming
O-star AFGL 4176
Submitted: 2020-04-28, last modified: 2020-05-23
We present a detailed analysis of the disk and circumstellar environment of
the forming O-type star AFGL 4176 mm1, placing results from the Atacama Large
Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) into context with multiwavelength data.
With ALMA, we detect seventeen 1.2 mm continuum sources within 5$''$ (21,000
au) of AFGL 4176 mm1. We find that mm1 has a spectral index of 3.4$\pm$0.2
across the ALMA band, with $>$87% of its 1.2 mm continuum emission from dust.
The source mm2, projected 4200 au from mm1, may be a companion or a blueshifted
knot in a jet. We also explore the morphological differences between the
molecular lines detected with ALMA, finding 203 lines from 25 molecules, which
we categorize into several morphological types. Our results show that AFGL 4176
mm1 provides an example of a forming O-star with a large and chemically complex
disk, which is mainly traced by nitrogen-bearing molecules. Lines that show
strong emission on the blueshifted side of the disk are predominantly
oxygen-bearing, which we suggest are tracing a disk accretion shock. The
molecules C$^{34}$S, H$_2$CS and CH$_{3}$CCN trace a slow wide-angle wind or
dense structures in the outflow cavity walls. With the Australia Telescope
Compact Array (ATCA), we detect a compact continuum source ($<$2000 $\times$
760 au) at 1.2 cm, associated with mm1, of which $>$96% is from ionized gas.
The ATCA NH$_3$(1,1) and (2,2) emission traces a large-scale (r$\sim$0.5 pc)
rotating toroid with the disk source mm1 in the blueshifted part of this
structure offset to the northwest.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.09692 [pdf] - 2050270
Spiral arms and instability within the AFGL 4176 mm1 disc
Johnston, K. G.;
Hoare, M. G.;
Beuther, H.;
Kuiper, R.;
Kee, N. D.;
Linz, H.;
Boley, P.;
Maud, L. T.;
Ahmadi, A.;
Robitaille, T. P.
Submitted: 2019-11-21, last modified: 2020-02-18
We present high-resolution (30 mas or 130 au at 4.2 kpc) Atacama Large
Millimeter/submillimeter Array observations at 1.2 mm of the disc around the
forming O-type star AFGL 4176 mm1. The disc (AFGL 4176 mm1-main) has a radius
of ~1000 au and contains significant structure, most notably a spiral arm on
its redshifted side. We fitted the observed spiral with logarithmic and
Archimedean spiral models. We find that both models can describe its structure,
but the Archimedean spiral with a varying pitch angle fits its morphology
marginally better. As well as signatures of rotation across the disc, we
observe gas arcs in CH$_3$CN that connect to other millimetre continuum sources
in the field, supporting the picture of interactions within a small cluster
around AFGL 4176 mm1-main. Using local thermodynamic equilibrium modelling of
the CH$_3$CN K-ladder, we determine the temperature and velocity field across
the disc, and thus produce a map of the Toomre stability parameter. Our results
indicate that the outer disc is gravitationally unstable and has already
fragmented or is likely to fragment in the future, possibly producing further
companions. These observations provide evidence that disc fragmentation is one
possible pathway towards explaining the high fraction of multiple systems
around high-mass stars.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.13379 [pdf] - 2020580
A 3D short-characteristics method for continuum and line scattering
problems in the winds of hot stars
Submitted: 2019-10-29
Context: Knowledge about hot, massive stars is usually inferred from
quantitative spectroscopy. To analyse non-spherical phenomena, the existing 1D
codes must be extended to higher dimensions, and corresponding tools need to be
developed. Aims: We present a 3D radiative transfer code that is capable of
calculating continuum and line scattering problems in the winds of hot stars.
By considering spherically symmetric test models, we discuss potential error
sources, and indicate advantages and disadvantages by comparing different
solution methods. Further, we analyse the UV resonance line formation in the
winds of rapidly rotating O stars. Methods: We consider both a (simplified)
continuum model including scattering and thermal sources, and a UV resonance
line transition approximated by a two-level-atom. We applied the
short-characteristics (SC) method, using linear or monotonic B\'ezier
interpolations, to solve the equation of radiative transfer on a non-uniform
Cartesian grid. To calculate scattering dominated problems, our solution method
is supplemented by an accelerated $\Lambda$-iteration scheme. Results: For the
spherical test models, the mean relative error of the source function is on the
$5-20\,\%$ level, depending on the applied interpolation technique and the
complexity of the considered model. All calculated line profiles are in
excellent agreement with corresponding 1D solutions. The predicted line
profiles from fast rotating stars show a distinct behaviour as a function of
rotational speed and inclination. This behaviour is tightly coupled to the wind
structure and the description of gravity darkening and stellar surface
distortion. Conclusions: Our SC methods are ready to be used for quantitative
analyses of UV resonance line profiles. When calculating optically thick
continua, both SC methods give reliable results, in contrast to the alternative
finite-volume method.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.10475 [pdf] - 2000284
Theoretical wind clumping predictions of OB supergiants from line-driven
instability simulations across the bi-stability jump
Submitted: 2019-10-23
(Abridged) The behaviour of mass loss across bi-stability jump is a key
uncertainty in models of massive stars. While an increase in mass loss is
theoretically predicted, this has so far not been observationally confirmed.
However, radiation-driven winds of massive stars are known to exhibit clumpy
structures triggered by the line-deshadowing instability (LDI). Wind clumping
affects empirical mass-loss rates inferred from density square-dependent
spectral diagnostics. If clumping properties differ significantly for O and B
supergiants across the bi-stability jump, this may help alleviate discrepancies
between theory and observations. We investigate with analytical and numerical
tools how the onset of clumpy structures behaves in the winds of O supergiants
(OSG) and B supergiants (BSG) across the bi-stability jump. We derive a scaling
relation for the linear growth rate of the LDI for a single optically thick
line and apply it in both regimes. We run 1D time-dependent line-driven
instability simulations to study the non-linear evolution of the LDI in clumpy
OSG and BSG winds. Linear perturbation analysis for a single line shows that
the LDI linear growth rate scales strongly with stellar effective temperature
and terminal wind speed. This implies significantly lower growth rates for
(cooler, slower) BSG winds than for OSG winds. This is confirmed by the
non-linear simulations, which show significant differences in OSG and BSG wind
structure formation, with the latter characterized by significantly weaker
clumping factors and lower velocity dispersions. This suggests that lower
correction factors due to clumping should be employed when deriving empirical
mass-loss rates for BSGs on the cool side of the bi-stability jump. Moreover,
the non-linear simulations provide a theoretical background toward explaining
the general lack of observed intrinsic X-ray emission in (single) B star winds.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.10521 [pdf] - 1806238
Line-driven ablation of circumstellar discs: IV. The role of disc
ablation in massive star formation and its contribution to the stellar upper
mass limit
Submitted: 2018-11-26
Radiative feedback from luminous, massive stars during their formation is a
key process in moderating accretion onto the stellar object. In the prior
papers in this series, we showed that one form such feedback takes is UV
line-driven disc ablation. Extending on this study, we now constrain the
strength of this effect in the parameter range of star and disc properties
appropriate to forming massive stars. Simulations show that ablation rate
depends strongly on stellar parameters, but that this dependence can be
parameterized as a nearly constant, fixed enhancement over the wind mass loss
rate, allowing us to predict the rate of disc ablation for massive (proto)stars
as a function of stellar mass and metallicity. By comparing this to predicted
accretion rates, we conclude that ablation is a strong feedback effect for very
massive (proto)stars which should be considered in future studies of massive
star formation.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.08753 [pdf] - 1713031
Line-driven ablation of circumstellar discs: III. Accounting for and
analyzing the effects of continuum optical depth
Submitted: 2018-06-22
In studying the formation of massive stars, it is essential to consider the
strong radiative feedback on the stars' natal environments from their high
luminosities ($10^4 \sim 10^6 L_\odot$). Given that massive stars contract to
main-sequence-like radii before accretion finishes, one form this feedback
takes is UV line-acceleration, resulting in outflows much like those expected
from main-sequence massive stars. As shown by the prior papers in this series,
in addition to driving stellar winds, such line forces also ablate the surface
layers off of circumstellar discs within a few stellar radii of the stellar
photosphere. This removal of material from an accretion disc in turn results in
a decreased accretion rate onto the forming star. Quantifying this, however,
requires accounting for the continuum optical depth of the disc along the
non-radial rays required for the three-dimensional line-acceleration
prescription used in this paper series. We introduce the "thin disc
approximation", allowing these continuum optical depths arising from an
optically thick but geometrically thin disc to be dynamically treated in the
context of radiation-hydrodynamics simulations. Using this approximation in
full dynamical simulations, we show that such continuum optical depth effects
only reduce the disc ablation by 30 percent or less relative to previous
simulations that ignored continuum absorption.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.08155 [pdf] - 1747964
3D radiative transfer: Continuum and line scattering in non-spherical
winds from OB stars
Submitted: 2018-06-21
Context: State of the art quantitative spectroscopy of OB-stars compares
synthetic spectra (calculated by means of 1D, spherically symmetric computer
codes) with observations. Certain stellar atmospheres, however, show strong
deviations from spherical symmetry, and need to be treated in 3D. Aims: We
present a newly developed 3D radiative transfer code, tailored to the solution
of the radiation field in rapidly expanding stellar atmospheres. We apply our
code to the continuum transfer in wind-ablation models, and to the UV resonance
line formation in magnetic winds. Methods: We have used a 3D finite-volume
method for the solution of the equation of radiative transfer, to study
continuum- and line-scattering problems. Convergence has been accelerated by a
non-local approximate Lambda-iteration scheme. Particular emphasis has been put
on careful (spherically symmetric) test cases. Results: Typical errors of the
source functions, when compared to 1D solutions, are of the order of 10-20 %,
and increase for optically thick continua. In circumstellar discs, the
radiation temperatures in the (optically thin) transition region from wind to
disc are quite similar to corresponding values in the wind. For MHD simulations
of dynamical magnetospheres, the line profiles, calculated with our 3D code,
agree well with previous solutions using a 3D-SEI method. When compared with
profiles resulting from the `analytic dynamical magnetosphere' (ADM) model,
significant differences become apparent. Conclusions: Due to similar radiation
temperatures in the wind and the transition region to the disc, the same
line-strength distribution can be applied within radiation hydrodynamic
calculations for circumstellar discs in `accreting high-mass stars'. To
properly describe the UV line formation in dynamical magnetospheres, the ADM
model needs to be further developed, at least in a large part of the outer
wind.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.03001 [pdf] - 1686898
Disruption of circumstellar discs by large-scale stellar magnetic fields
Submitted: 2018-05-08
Spectropolarimetric surveys reveal that 8-10\% of OBA stars harbor
large-scale magnetic fields, but thus far no such fields have been detected in
any classical Be stars. Motivated by this, we present here MHD simulations for
how a pre-existing Keplerian disc -- like that inferred to form from decretion
of material from rapidly rotating Be stars -- can be disrupted by a
rotation-aligned stellar dipole field. For characteristic stellar and disc
parameters of a near-critically rotating B2e star, we find that a polar surface
field strength of just 10 G can significantly disrupt the disc, while a field
of 100 G, near the observational upper limit inferred for most Be stars,
completely destroys the disc over just a few days. Our parameter study shows
that the efficacy of this magnetic disruption of a disc scales with the
characteristic plasma beta {(defined as the ratio between thermal and magnetic
pressure)} in the disc, but is surprisingly insensitive to other variations,
e.g. in stellar rotation speed, or the mass loss rate of the star's radiatively
driven wind. The disc disruption seen here for even a modest field strength
suggests that the presumed formation of such Be discs by decretion of material
from the star would likely be strongly inhibited by such fields; this provides
an attractive explanation for why no large-scale fields are detected from such
Be stars.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.09312 [pdf] - 1590260
Line-driven ablation of circumstellar discs: II. Analyzing the role of
multiple resonances
Submitted: 2017-10-25, last modified: 2017-11-09
We extend our previous study of radiative ablation of circumstellar disks by
line-scattering of the star's radiation, accounting now for the effect of
multiple line resonances off the stellar limb. For an analytic,
three-dimensional model of the velocity structure of an equatorial Keplerian
disk bounded at higher latitudes by a radially accelerating stellar wind
outflow, we use root-finding methods to identify multiple resonances from a
near-disk circumstellar location along starward rays both on and off the
stellar core. Compared to our previous study that accounted only for the effect
of on-core resonances in reducing the radiative driving through the scattering
of radiation away from a near-disk circumstellar location, including off-limb
resonances leads to additional radiative driving from scattering toward this
location. Instead of the up-to-50% reduction in line-acceleration previously
inferred from multiple resonance effects, we now find a more modest 15-20% net
reduction.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.03647 [pdf] - 1824350
Investigating the origin of cyclical wind variability in hot, massive
stars - II. Hydrodynamical simulations of co-rotating interaction regions
using realistic spot parameters for the O giant $\xi$ Persei
Submitted: 2017-06-12
OB stars exhibit various types of spectral variability historically
associated with wind structures, including the apparently ubiquitous discrete
absorption components (DACs). These features have been proposed to be caused
either by magnetic fields or non-radial pulsations. In this second paper of
this series, we revisit the canonical phenomenological hydrodynamical modelling
used to explain the formation of DACs by taking into account modern
observations and more realistic theoretical predictions. Using constraints on
putative bright spots located on the surface of the O giant $\xi$ Persei
derived from high precision space-based broadband optical photometry obtained
with the Microvariability and Oscillations of STars (MOST) space telescope, we
generate two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of co-rotating interaction
regions in its wind. We then compute synthetic ultraviolet (UV) resonance line
profiles using Sobolev Exact Integration and compare them with historical
timeseries obtained by the International Ultraviolet Explorer (IUE) to evaluate
if the observed behaviour of $\xi$ Persei's DACs is reproduced. Testing three
different models of spot size and strength, we find that the classical pattern
of variability can be successfully reproduced for two of them: the model with
the smallest spots yields absorption features that are incompatible with
observations. Furthermore, we test the effect of the radial dependence of
ionization levels on line driving, but cannot conclusively assess the
importance of this factor. In conclusion, this study self-consistently links
optical photometry and UV spectroscopy, paving the way to a better
understanding of cyclical wind variability in massive stars in the context of
the bright spot paradigm.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.07874 [pdf] - 1374375
Line-driven ablation of circumstellar disks: I. Optically thin decretion
disks of classical Oe/Be stars
Submitted: 2016-02-25
The extreme luminosities of hot, massive stars drive strong stellar winds
through UV line-scattering. For OB stars with an orbiting circumstellar disk,
we explore the effect of such line-scattering in ablating disk material,
initially focusing on the marginally optically thin decretion disks of
classical Oe and Be stars. For this we apply a multi-dimensional
radiation-hydrodynamics code, assuming optically thin ray tracing for the
stellar continuum and a multi-ray Sobolev treatment of the line transfer. This
accounts for desaturation of line-absorption by Keplerian shear in the disk,
and associated driving by non-radial photons. Results show dense,
intermediate-speed surface ablation, consistent with the strong, blue-shifted
absorption seen in UV wind lines of Be shell stars. The asymptotic ablation
rate is typically an order-unity factor times the stellar wind mass loss rate,
leading to disk destruction times of order months to years for Be disks,
consistent with observations. The much stronger radiative forces of O stars
reduce this time to order days, making sustaining a disk difficult, and so
providing a natural explanation for the rarity of Galactic Oe stars.
Additionally, the weakened line-driving at lower metallicity implies both a
reduction in the winds that help spin-down stars from near-critical rotation,
and in the ablation of decretion disks, thus providing a natural explanation
for the higher fraction of Classical Be stars, and the presence of Oe stars, in
the Magellanic Clouds. We conclude with a discussion of future extensions to
study line-driven ablation of denser, optically thick, accretion disks around
pre-main-sequence massive stars.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.04002 [pdf] - 1326822
Radiative Ablation of Disks Around Massive Stars
Submitted: 2015-12-13
Hot, massive stars (spectral types O and B) have extreme luminosities ($10^4
-10^6 L_\odot$) that drive strong stellar winds through UV line-scattering.
Some massive stars also have disks, formed by either decretion from the star
(as in the rapidly rotating "Classical Be stars"), or accretion during the
star's formation. This dissertation examines the role of stellar radiation in
driving (ablating) material away from these circumstellar disks.
A key result is that the observed month to year decay of Classical Be disks
can be explained by line-driven ablation without, as previously done, appealing
to anomalously strong viscous diffusion. Moreover, the higher luminosity of O
stars leads to ablation of optically thin disks on dynamical timescales of
order a day, providing a natural explanation for the lack of observed Oe stars.
In addition to the destruction of Be disks, this dissertation also introduces a
model for their formation by coupling observationally inferred non-radial
pulsation modes and rapid stellar rotation to launch material into orbiting
Keplerian disks.
In contrast to such Be decretion disks, star-forming accretion disks are much
denser and so are generally optically thick to continuum processes. To
circumvent the computational challenges associated with radiation hydrodynamics
through optically thick media, we develop an approximate method for treating
continuum absorption in the limit of geometrically thin disks. The comparison
of ablation with and without continuum absorption shows that accounting for
disk optical thickness leads to less than a 50$\%$ reduction in ablation rate,
implying that ablation rate depends mainly on stellar properties like
luminosity.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.8511 [pdf] - 1293564
Pulsational Mass Ejection in Be Star Disks
Submitted: 2014-12-29, last modified: 2015-10-14
This work explores a Pulsationally Driven Orbital Mass Ejection (PDOME) model
for the launching of Classical Be star disks. Under this model, a combination
of rapid rotation and non-radial pulsation modes contribute to placing material
into the circumstellar environment. Several varieties of non-radial pulsation
modes, characterized by their propagation direction and the relative phase of
their velocity and density perturbations, are considered. As well, the orbital
stability of material launched by such a mechanism is investigated.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.2063 [pdf] - 1202653
Suppression of X-rays from radiative shocks by their thin-shell
instability
Submitted: 2014-01-09
We examine X-rays from radiatively cooled shocks, focusing on how their
thin-shell instability reduces X-ray emission. For 2D simulations of collision
between equal expanding winds, we carry out a parameter study of such
instability as a function of the ratio of radiative vs. adiabatic-expansion
cooling lengths. In the adiabatic regime, the extended cooling layer suppresses
instability, leading to planar shock compression with X-ray luminosity that
follows closely the expected (Lx ~ M^2) quadratic scaling with mass-loss rate M
. In the strongly radiative limit, the X-ray emission now follows an expected
linear scaling with mass loss (Lx ~ M), but the instability deforms the shock
compression into extended shear layers with oblique shocks along fingers of
cooled, dense material. The spatial dispersion of shock thermalization limits
strong X-ray emission to the tips and troughs of the fingers, and so reduces
the X-ray emission (here by about a factor 1/50) below what is expected from
analytic radiative-shock models without unstable structure. Between these two
limits, X-ray emission can switch between a high-state associated with extended
shock compression, and a low-state characterized by extensive shear. Further
study is needed to clarify the origin of this "shear mixing reduction factor"
in X-ray emission, and its dependence on parameters like the shock Mach number.