Normalized to: Kammer, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.12509 [pdf] - 2105718
Pluto's Ultraviolet Spectrum, Surface Reflectance, and Airglow Emissions
Steffl, Andrew J.;
Young, Leslie A.;
Strobel, Darrell F.;
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Evans, J. Scott;
Stevens, Michael H.;
Schindhelm, Rebecca N.;
Parker, Joel Wm.;
Stern, S. Alan;
Weaver, Harold A.;
Olkin, Catherine B.;
Ennico, Kimberly;
Cummings, Jay R.;
Gladstone, G. Randall;
Greathouse, Thomas K.;
Hinson, David P.;
Retherford, Kurt D.;
Summers, Michael E.;
Versteeg, Maarten
Submitted: 2020-04-26
During the New Horizons spacecraft's encounter with Pluto, the Alice
ultraviolet spectrograph conducted a series of observations that detected
emissions from both the interplanetary medium (IPM) and Pluto. In the direction
of Pluto, the IPM was found to be 133.4$\pm$0.6R at Lyman $\alpha$,
0.24$\pm$0.02R at Lyman $\beta$, and <0.10R at He I 584{\AA}. We analyzed
3,900s of data obtained shortly before closest approach to Pluto and detect
airglow emissions from H I, N I, N II, N$_2$, and CO above the disk of Pluto.
We find Pluto's brightness at Lyman $\alpha$ to be $29.3\pm1.9$R, in good
agreement with pre-encounter estimates. The detection of the N II multiplet at
1085{\AA} marks the first direct detection of ions in Pluto's atmosphere. We do
not detect any emissions from noble gasses and place a 3$\sigma$ upper limit of
0.14 R on the brightness of the Ar I 1048{\AA} line. We compare pre-encounter
model predictions and predictions from our own airglow model, based on
atmospheric profiles derived from the solar occultation observed by New
Horizons, to the observed brightness of Pluto's airglow. Although completely
opaque at Lyman $\alpha$, Pluto's atmosphere is optically thin at wavelengths
longer than 1425{\AA}. Consequently, a significant amount of solar FUV light
reaches the surface, where it can participate in space weathering processes.
From the brightness of sunlight reflected from Pluto, we find the surface has a
reflectance factor (I/F) of 17% between 1400-1850{\AA}. We also report the
first detection of an C$_3$ hydrocarbon molecule, methylacetylene, in
absorption, at a column density of ~5$\times10^{15}$ cm$^{-2}$, corresponding
to a column-integrated mixing ratio of $1.6\times10^{-6}$.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.00125 [pdf] - 2076806
Size and Shape Constraints of (486958) Arrokoth from Stellar
Occultations
Buie, Marc W.;
Porter, Simon B.;
Tamblyn, Peter;
Terrell, Dirk;
Parker, Alex Harrison;
Baratoux, David;
Kaire, Maram;
Leiva, Rodrigo;
Verbiscer, Anne J.;
Zangari, Amanda M.;
Colas, François;
Diop, Baïdy Demba;
Samaniego, Joseph I.;
Wasserman, Lawrence H.;
Benecchi, Susan D.;
Caspi, Amir;
Gwyn, Stephen;
Kavelaars, J. J.;
Uría, Adriana C. Ocampo;
Rabassa, Jorge;
Skrutskie, M. F.;
Soto, Alejandro;
Tanga, Paolo;
Young, Eliot F.;
Stern, S. Alan;
Andersen, Bridget C.;
Pérez, Mauricio E. Arango;
Arredondo, Anicia;
Artola, Rodolfo Alfredo;
Bâ, Abdoulaye;
Ballet, Romuald;
Blank, Ted;
Bop, Cheikh Tidiane;
Bosh, Amanda S.;
López, Matías Aarón Camino;
Carter, Christian M.;
Castro-Chacón, J. H.;
Desprez, Alfonso Caycedo;
Guerra, Nicolás Caycedo;
Conard, Steven J.;
Dauvergne, Jean-Luc;
Dean, Bryan;
Dean, Michelle;
Desmars, Josselin;
Dieng, Abdou Lahat;
Dieng, Mame Diarra Bousso;
Diouf, Omar;
Dorego, Gualbert Séraphin;
Dunham, David W.;
Dunham, Joan;
Luca, Hugo A. Durantini;
Edwards, Patrick;
Erasmus, Nicolas;
Faye, Gayane;
Faye, Mactar;
Ferrario, Lucas Ezequiel;
Ferrell, Chelsea L.;
Finley, Tiffany J.;
Fraser, Wesley C.;
Friedli, Alison J.;
Serna, Julián Galvez;
Garcia-Migani, Esteban A.;
Genade, Anja;
Getrost, Kai;
Gil-Hutton, Ricardo A.;
Gimeno, German N.;
Golub, Eli Joseph;
Murillo, Giovanni Francisco González;
Grusin, Michael D.;
Gurovich, Sebastian;
Hanna, William H.;
Henn, Santiago M.;
Hinton, P. C.;
Hughes, Paul J.;
Josephs, John David;
Joya, Raul;
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Keeney, Brian A.;
Keller, John M.;
Kramer, Emily A.;
Levine, Stephen E.;
Lisse, Carey M.;
Lovell, Amy J.;
Mackie, Jason A.;
Makarchuk, Stanislav;
Manzano, Luis E.;
Mbaye, Salma Sylla;
Mbaye, Modou;
Melia, Raul Roberto;
Moreno, Freddy;
Moss, Sean K.;
Ndaiye, Diene;
Ndiaye, Mapathe;
Nelson, Matthew J.;
Olkin, Catherine B.;
Olsen, Aart M.;
Moreno, Victor Jonathan Ospina;
Pasachoff, Jay M.;
Pereyra, Mariana Belen;
Person, Michael J.;
Pinzón, Giovanni;
Pulver, Eduardo Alejandro;
Quintero, Edwin A.;
Regester, Jeffrey R.;
Resnick, Aaron Caleb;
Reyes-Ruiz, Mauricio;
Rolfsmeier, Alex D.;
Ruhland, Trina R.;
Salmon, Julien;
Santos-Sanz, Pablo;
Santucho, Marcos Ariel;
Niño, Diana Karina Sepúlveda;
Sickafoose, Amanda A.;
Silva, José S.;
Singer, Kelsi N.;
Skipper, Joy N.;
Slivan, Stephen M.;
Smith, Rose J. C.;
Spagnotto, Julio C.;
Stephens, Andrew W.;
Strabala, Samuel D.;
Tamayo, Francisco J.;
Throop, Henry B.;
Cañas, Andrés David Torres;
Toure, Labaly;
Traore, Alassane;
Tsang, Constantine C. C.;
Turner, Jake D.;
Vanegas, Santiago;
Venable, Roger;
Wilson, John C.;
Zuluaga, Carlos A.;
Zuluaga, Jorge I.
Submitted: 2019-12-31
We present the results from four stellar occultations by (486958) Arrokoth,
the flyby target of the New Horizons extended mission. Three of the four
efforts led to positive detections of the body, and all constrained the
presence of rings and other debris, finding none. Twenty-five mobile stations
were deployed for 2017 June 3 and augmented by fixed telescopes. There were no
positive detections from this effort. The event on 2017 July 10 was observed by
SOFIA with one very short chord. Twenty-four deployed stations on 2017 July 17
resulted in five chords that clearly showed a complicated shape consistent with
a contact binary with rough dimensions of 20 by 30 km for the overall outline.
A visible albedo of 10% was derived from these data. Twenty-two systems were
deployed for the fourth event on 2018 Aug 4 and resulted in two chords. The
combination of the occultation data and the flyby results provides a
significant refinement of the rotation period, now estimated to be 15.9380
$\pm$ 0.0005 hours. The occultation data also provided high-precision
astrometric constraints on the position of the object that were crucial for
supporting the navigation for the New Horizons flyby. This work demonstrates an
effective method for obtaining detailed size and shape information and probing
for rings and dust on distant Kuiper Belt objects as well as being an important
source of positional data that can aid in spacecraft navigation that is
particularly useful for small and distant bodies.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.00014 [pdf] - 2025661
Investigating Trends in Atmospheric Compositions of Cool Gas Giant
Planets Using Spitzer Secondary Eclipses
Wallack, Nicole L.;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Thomas, Nancy H.;
Thorngren, Daniel P.;
Deming, Drake;
Désert, Jean-Michel;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Kammer, Joshua A.
Submitted: 2019-07-31
We present new 3.6 and 4.5 micron secondary eclipse measurements for five
cool (less than approximately 1000 K) transiting gas giant planets: HAT-P-15b,
HAT-P-17b, HAT-P-18b, HAT-P-26b, and WASP-69b. We detect eclipses in at least
one bandpass for all planets except HAT-P-15b. We confirm and refine the
orbital eccentricity of HAT-P-17b, which is also the only planet in our sample
with a known outer companion. We compare our measured eclipse depths in these
two bands, which are sensitive to the relative abundances of methane versus
carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, respectively, to predictions from 1D
atmosphere models for each planet. For planets with hydrogen-dominated
atmospheres and equilibrium temperatures cooler than approximately 1000 K, this
ratio should vary as a function of both atmospheric metallicity and the
carbon-to-oxygen ratio. For HAT-P-26b, our observations are in good agreement
with the low atmospheric metallicity inferred from transmission spectroscopy.
We find that all four of the planets with detected eclipses are best matched by
models with relatively efficient circulation of energy to the nightside. We see
no evidence for a solar-system-like correlation between planet mass and
atmospheric metallicity, but instead identify a potential (1.9 sigma)
correlation between the inferred methane/(carbon monoxide + carbon dioxide)
ratio and stellar metallicity. Our ability to characterize this potential trend
is limited by the relatively large uncertainties in the stellar metallicity
values. Our observations provide a first look at the brightness of these
planets at wavelengths accessible to the James Webb Space Telescope, which will
be able to resolve individual methane, carbon monoxide, and carbon dioxide
bands and provide much stronger constraints on their atmospheric compositions.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.00449 [pdf] - 1908803
A Sub-Neptune Exoplanet with a Low-Metallicity Methane-Depleted
Atmosphere and Mie-Scattering Clouds
Benneke, Björn;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Lothringer, Joshua;
Crossfield, Ian J. M.;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Morley, Caroline;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Fulton, Benjamin J.;
Dragomir, Diana;
Howard, Andrew W.;
Wong, Ian;
Désert, Jean-Michel;
McCullough, Peter R.;
Kempton, Eliza M. -R.;
Fortney, Jonathan;
Gilliland, Ronald;
Deming, Drake;
Kammer, Joshua
Submitted: 2019-06-30
With no analogues in the Solar System, the discovery of thousands of
exoplanets with masses and radii intermediate between Earth and Neptune was one
of the big surprises of exoplanet science. These super-Earths and sub-Neptunes
likely represent the most common outcome of planet formation. Mass and radius
measurements indicate a diversity in bulk composition much wider than for gas
giants; however, direct spectroscopic detections of molecular absorption and
constraints on the gas mixing ratios have largely remained limited to planets
more massive than Neptune. Here, we analyze a combined Hubble/Spitzer Space
Telescope dataset of 12 transits and 20 eclipses of the sub-Neptune GJ 3470 b,
whose mass of 12.6 $M_\oplus$ places it near the half-way point between
previously studied exo-Neptunes (22-23 $M_\oplus$) and exoplanets known to have
rocky densities (7 $M_\oplus$). Obtained over many years, our data set provides
a robust detection of water absorption (>5$\sigma$) and a thermal emission
detection from the lowest irradiated planet to date. We reveal a
low-metallicity, hydrogen-dominated atmosphere similar to a gas giant, but
strongly depleted in methane gas. The low, near-solar metallicity (O/H=0.2-18)
sets important constraints on the potential planet formation processes at low
masses as well as the subsequent accretion of solids. The low methane abundance
indicates that methane is destroyed much more efficiently than previously
predicted, suggesting that the CH$_4$/CO transition curve has to be revisited
for close-in planets. Finally, we also find a sharp drop in the cloud opacity
at 2-3 $\mu$m characteristic of Mie scattering, which enables narrow
constraints on the cloud particle size and makes GJ 3470b a keystone target for
mid-IR characterization with JWST.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.05571 [pdf] - 1848689
Convection in a volatile nitrogen-ice-rich layer drives Pluto's
geological vigor
McKinnon, William B.;
Nimmo, Francis;
Wong, Teresa;
Schenk, Paul M.;
White, Oliver L.;
Roberts, J. H.;
Moore, J. M.;
Spencer, J. R.;
Howard, A. D.;
Umurhan, O. M.;
Stern, S. A.;
Weaver, H. A.;
Olkin, C. B.;
Young, L. A.;
Smith, K. E.;
Beyer, R.;
Binzel, R. P.;
Buie, M.;
Buratti, B.;
Cheng, A.;
Cruikshank, D.;
Ore, C. Dalle;
Earle, A.;
Gladstone, R.;
Grundy, W.;
Lauer, T.;
Linscott, I.;
Parker, J.;
Porter, S.;
Reitsema, H.;
Reuter, D.;
Robbins, S.;
Showalter, M.;
Singer, K.;
Strobel, D.;
Summers, M.;
Tyler, L.;
Weaver, H.;
Banks, M.;
Barnouin, O.;
Bray, V.;
Carcich, B.;
Chaikin, A.;
Chavez, C.;
Conrad, C.;
Hamilton, D.;
Howett, C.;
Hofgartner, J.;
Kammer, J.;
Lisse, C.;
Marcotte, A.;
Parker, A.;
Retherford, K.;
Saina, M.;
Runyon, K.;
Schindhelm, E.;
Stansberry, J.;
Steffl, A.;
Stryk, T.;
Throop, . H.;
Tsang, C.;
Verbiscer, A.;
Winters, H.;
Zangari, A.
Submitted: 2019-03-13
The vast, deep, volatile-ice-filled basin informally named Sputnik Planum is
central to Pluto's geological activity[1,2]. Composed of molecular nitrogen,
methane, and carbon monoxide ices[3], but dominated by N2-ice, this ice layer
is organized into cells or polygons, typically ~10-40 km across, that resemble
the surface manifestation of solid state convection[1,2]. Here we report, based
on available rheological measurements[4], that solid layers of N2 ice
approximately greater than 1 km thick should convect for estimated present-day
heat flow conditions on Pluto. More importantly, we show numerically that
convective overturn in a several-km-thick layer of solid nitrogen can explain
the great lateral width of the cells. The temperature dependence of N2-ice
viscosity implies that the SP ice layer convects in the so-called sluggish lid
regime[5], a unique convective mode heretofore not definitively observed in the
Solar System. Average surface horizontal velocities of a few cm/yr imply
surface transport or renewal times of ~500,000 years, well under the 10 Myr
upper limit crater retention age for Sputnik Planum[2]. Similar convective
surface renewal may also occur on other dwarf planets in the Kuiper belt, which
may help explain the high albedos of some of them.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.05574 [pdf] - 1848691
Reorientation of Sputnik Planitia implies a Subsurface Ocean on Pluto
Nimmo, F.;
Hamilton, D. P.;
Schenk, W. B. McKinnon P. M.;
Binzel, R. P.;
Bierson, C. J.;
Beyer, R. A.;
Moore, J. M.;
Stern, S. A.;
Weaver, H. A.;
Olkin, C.;
Young, L. A.;
Smith, K. E.;
Spencer, J. R.;
Buie, M.;
Buratti, B.;
Cheng, A.;
Cruikshank, D.;
Ore, C. Dalle;
Earle, A.;
Gladstone, R.;
Grundy, W.;
Howard, A. D.;
Lauer, T.;
Linscott, I.;
Parker, J.;
Porter, S.;
Reitsema, H.;
Reuter, D.;
Roberts, J. H.;
Robbins, S.;
Showalter, M.;
Singer, K.;
Strobel, D.;
Summers, M.;
Tyler, L.;
Weaver, H.;
White, O. L.;
Umurhan, O. M.;
Banks, M.;
Barnouin, O.;
Bray, V.;
Carcich, B.;
Chaikin, A.;
Chavez, C.;
Conrad, C.;
Howett, C.;
Hofgartner, J.;
Kammer, J.;
Lisse, C.;
Marcotte, A.;
Parker, A.;
Retherford, K.;
Saina, M.;
Runyon, K.;
Schindhelm, E.;
Stansberry, J.;
Steffl, A.;
Stryk, T.;
Throop, . H.;
Tsang, C.;
Verbiscer, A.;
Winters, H.;
Zangari, A.
Submitted: 2019-03-13
The deep nitrogen-covered Sputnik Planitia (SP; informal name) basin on Pluto
is located very close to the longitude of Pluto's tidal axis[1] and may be an
impact feature [2], by analogy with other large basins in the solar
system[3,4]. Reorientation[5-7] due to tidal and rotational torques can explain
SP's location, but requires it to be a positive gravity anomaly[7], despite its
negative topography. Here we argue that if SP formed via impact and if Pluto
possesses a subsurface ocean, a positive gravity anomaly would naturally result
because of shell thinning and ocean uplift, followed by later modest N2
deposition. Without a subsurface ocean a positive gravity anomaly requires an
implausibly thick N2 layer (greater than 40 km). A rigid, conductive ice shell
is required to prolong such an ocean's lifetime to the present day[8] and
maintain ocean uplift. Because N2 deposition is latitude-dependent[9], nitrogen
loading and reorientation may have exhibited complex feedbacks[7].
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.03728 [pdf] - 1846000
Pluto's Haze as a Surface Material
Grundy, W. M.;
Bertrand, T.;
Binzel, R. P.;
Buie, M. W.;
Buratti, B. J.;
Cheng, A. F.;
Cook, J. C.;
Cruikshank, D. P.;
Devins, S. L.;
Ore, C. M. Dalle;
Earle, A. M.;
Ennico, K.;
Forget, F.;
Gao, P.;
Gladstone1, G. R.;
Howett, C. J. A.;
Jennings, D. E.;
Kammer, J. A.;
Lauer, T. R.;
Linscott, I. R.;
Lisse, C. M.;
Lunsford, A. W.;
McKinnon, W. B.;
Olkin, C. B.;
Parker, A. H.;
Protopapa, S.;
Quirico, E.;
Reuter, D. C.;
Schmitt, B.;
Singer, K. N.;
Spencer, J. A.;
Stern, S. A.;
Strobel, D. F.;
Summers, M. E.;
Weaver, H. A.;
Weigle, G. E.;
Wong, M. L.;
Young, E. F.;
Young, L. A.;
Zhang, X.
Submitted: 2019-03-08
Pluto's atmospheric haze settles out rapidly compared with geological
timescales. It needs to be accounted for as a surface material, distinct from
Pluto's icy bedrock and from the volatile ices that migrate via sublimation and
condensation on seasonal timescales. This paper explores how a steady supply of
atmospheric haze might affect three distinct provinces on Pluto. We pose the
question of why they each look so different from one another if the same haze
material is settling out onto all of them. Cthulhu is a more ancient region
with comparatively little present-day geological activity, where the haze
appears to simply accumulate over time. Sputnik Planitia is a very active
region where glacial convection, as well as sublimation and condensation
rapidly refresh the surface, hiding recently deposited haze from view. Lowell
Regio is a region of intermediate age featuring very distinct coloration from
the rest of Pluto. Using a simple model haze particle as a colorant, we are not
able to match the colors in both Lowell Regio and Cthulhu. To account for their
distinct colors, we propose that after arrival at Pluto's surface, haze
particles may be less inert than might be supposed from the low surface
temperatures. They must either interact with local materials and environments
to produce distinct products in different regions, or else the supply of haze
must be non-uniform in time and/or location, such that different products are
delivered to different places.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.00400 [pdf] - 1775621
The Lyman-{\alpha} Sky Background as Observed by New Horizons
Gladstone, G. Randall;
Pryor, Wayne R.;
Stern, S. Alan;
Ennico, Kimberly;
Olkin, Catherine B.;
Spencer, John R.;
Weaver, Harold A.;
Young, Leslie A.;
Bagenal, Fran;
Cheng, Andrew F.;
Cunningham, Nathaniel J.;
Elliott, Heather A;
Greathouse, Thomas K.;
Hinson, David P.;
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Linscott, Ivan R.;
Parker, Joel Wm.;
Retherford, Kurt D.;
Steffl, Andrew J.;
Strobel, Darrell F.;
Summers, Michael E.;
Throop, Henry;
Versteeg, Maarten H.;
Davis, Michael W.;
Team, the New Horizons Science
Submitted: 2018-08-01
Recent observations of interplanetary medium (IPM) atomic hydrogen
Lyman-{\alpha} (Ly{\alpha}) emission in the outer solar system, made with the
Alice ultraviolet spectrograph on New Horizons (NH), are presented. The
observations include regularly spaced great-circle scans of the sky and pointed
observations near the downstream and upstream flow directions of interstellar H
atoms. The NH Alice data agree very well with the much earlier Voyager UVS
results, after these are reduced by a factor of 2.4 in brightness, in
accordance with recent re-analyses. In particular, the falloff of IPM
Ly{\alpha} brightness in the upstream-looking direction as a function of
spacecraft distance from the Sun is well-matched by an expected 1/r dependence,
but with an added constant brightness of ~40 Rayleighs. This additional
brightness is a possible signature of the hydrogen wall at the heliopause or of
a more distant background. Ongoing observations are planned at a cadence of
roughly twice per year.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.09684 [pdf] - 1729085
Probing the Hill Sphere of (486958) 2014 MU$_{69}$: HST FGS Observations
During the July 17, 2017 Stellar Occultation
Submitted: 2018-06-25
We observed the July 17, 2017 stellar occultation of HD 168233 by the Kuiper
Belt Object (486958) 2014 MU$_{69}$, the close flyby target of the extended New
Horizons mission. Rather than capture a solid body occultation by the KBO
itself, our program aimed to constrain the opacity of rings, moons, or other
debris in the nearby environment. We used the Hubble Space Telescope Fine
Guidance Sensors (HST FGS) instrument in TRANS F583W mode to collect 40 Hz time
resolution photometry of the stellar occultation star for two HST orbits during
this observation. We present the results of reduction and calibration of the
HST FGS photometry, and set upper limits on rings or other dust opacity within
the Hill sphere of (486958) 2014 MU$_{69}$ at distances ranging from
$\sim$20,000 km to $\sim$75,000 km from the main body.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.04232 [pdf] - 1584644
New Horizons Upper Limits on O$_2$ in Pluto's Present Day Atmosphere
Submitted: 2017-06-13
The surprising discovery by the Rosetta spacecraft of molecular oxygen
(O$_2$) in the coma of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (Bieler et al. 2015)
challenged our understanding of the inventory of this volatile species on and
inside bodies from the Kuiper Belt. That discovery motivated our search for
oxygen in the atmosphere of Kuiper Belt planet Pluto, because O$_2$ is volatile
even at Pluto's surface temperatures. During the New Horizons flyby of Pluto in
July 2015, the spacecraft probed the composition of Pluto's atmosphere using a
variety of observations, including an ultraviolet solar occultation observed by
the Alice UV spectrograph (Stern et al. 2015; Gladstone et al. 2016; Young et
al. 2017). As described in these reports, absorption by molecular species in
Pluto's atmosphere yielded detections of N$_2$, as well as hydrocarbon species
such as CH$_4$, C$_2$H$_2$, C$_2$H$_4$, and C$_2$H$_6$. Our work here further
examines this data to search for UV absorption from molecular oxygen (O$_2$),
which has a signicant cross section in the Alice spectrograph bandpass. We find
no evidence for O$_2$ absorption, and place an upper limit on the total amount
of O$_2$ in Pluto's atmosphere as a function of tangent height up to 700 km. In
most of the atmosphere this upper limit in line of sight abundance units is
~3x10$^{15}$ cm$^{-2}$, which depending on tangent height corresponds to a
mixing ratio of 10$^{-6}$ to 10$^{-4}$, far lower than in comet 67P/CG.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.03389 [pdf] - 1584522
Evidence for Possible Clouds in Pluto's Present Day Atmosphere
Stern, S. A.;
Kammer, J. A.;
Barth, E. L.;
Singer, K. N.;
Lauer, T. R.;
Hofgartner, J. D.;
Weaver, H. A.;
Ennico, K.;
Olkin, C. B.;
Young, L. A.;
Team, the New Horizons LORRI Instrument;
Team, the New Horizons Ralph Instrument;
Team, the New Horizons Atmospheres Investigation
Submitted: 2017-06-11
Several trace constituents can reach saturation vapor pressure in Pluto's
present day atmosphere. As such, we describe a search for discrete could
features in Pluto's atmosphere using New Horizons data obtained on 14-15 July
2015, during the Pluto flyby closest approach. We report that Pluto's present
day atmosphere is at least largely (>99% by surface area) free of discrete
clouds. We also report a handful of features that may plausibly be clouds, all
of which were detected obliquely and at high phase observing geometry. No cloud
candidates were identified away from the terminators or in low phase
(backscattering geometry) images.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.01511 [pdf] - 1582364
Structure and Composition of Pluto's atmosphere from the New Horizons
Solar Ultraviolet Occultation
Young, Leslie A.;
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Steffl, Andrew J.;
Gladstone, G. Randall;
Summers, Michael E.;
Strobel, Darrell F.;
Hinson, David P.;
Stern, S. Alan;
Weaver, Harold A.;
Olkin, Catherine B.;
Ennico, Kimberly;
McComas, David J.;
Cheng, Andrew F.;
Gao, Peter;
Lavvas, Panayotis;
Linscott, Ivan R.;
Wong, Michael L.;
Yung, Yuk L.;
Cunningham, Nathanial;
Davis, Michael;
Parker, Joel Wm.;
Schindhelm, Eric;
Siegmund, Oswald H. W.;
Stone, John;
Retherford, Kurt;
Versteeg, Maarten
Submitted: 2017-04-05
The Alice instrument on NASA's New Horizons spacecraft observed an
ultraviolet solar occultation by Pluto's atmosphere on 2015 July 14. The
transmission vs. altitude was sensitive to the presence of N2, CH4, C2H2, C2H4,
C2H6, and haze. We derived line-of-sight abundances and local number densities
for the 5 molecular species, and line-of-sight optical depth and extinction
coefficients for the haze. We found the following major conclusions: 1) We
confirmed temperatures in Pluto's upper atmosphere that were colder than
expected before the New Horizons flyby, with upper atmospheric temperatures
near 65-68 K. The inferred enhanced Jeans escape rates were (3e22-7e22) N2/s
and (4e25-8e25) CH4/s at the exobase (at a radius of ~2900 km, or an altitude
of ~1710 km). 2) We measured CH4 abundances from 80 to 1200 km above the
surface. A joint analysis of the Alice CH4 and Alice and REX N2 measurements
implied a very stable lower atmosphere with a small eddy diffusion coefficient,
most likely between 550 and 4000 cm2/s. Such a small eddy diffusion coefficient
placed the homopause within 12 km of the surface, giving Pluto a small
planetary boundary layer. The inferred CH4 surface mixing ratio was
~0.28-0.35%. 3) The abundance profiles of the C2Hx hydrocarbons (C2H2, C2H4,
C2H6) were not simply exponential with altitude. We detected local maxima in
line-of-sight abundance near 410 km altitude for C2H4, near 320 km for C2H2,
and an inflection point or the suggestion of a local maximum at 260 km for
C2H6. We also detected local minima near 200 km altitude for C2H4, near 170 km
for C2H2, and an inflection point or minimum near 170-200 km for C2H6. These
compared favorably with models for hydrocarbon production near 300-400 km and
haze condensation near 200 km, especially for C2H2 and C2H4 (Wong et al. 2017).
4) We found haze that had an extinction coefficient approximately proportional
to N2 density.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.07771 [pdf] - 1546402
Haze in Pluto's Atmosphere
Cheng, Andrew F.;
Summers, Michael E.;
Gladstone, G. Randall;
Strobel, Darrell F.;
Young, Leslie A.;
Lavvas, Panayotis;
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Lisse, Carey M.;
Parker, Alex H.;
Young, Eliot F.;
Stern, S. Alan;
Weaver, Harold A.;
Olkin, Cathy B.;
Ennico, Kimberley
Submitted: 2017-02-24, last modified: 2017-02-28
Haze in Pluto's atmosphere was detected in images by both the Long Range
Reconnaissance Imager (LORRI) and the Multispectral Visible Imaging Camera
(MVIC) on New Horizons. LORRI observed haze up to altitudes of at least 200 km
above Pluto's surface at solar phase angles from ~20{\deg} to ~169{\deg}. The
haze is structured with about ~20 layers, and the extinction due to haze is
greater in the northern hemisphere than at equatorial or southern latitudes.
However, more haze layers are discerned at equatorial latitudes. A search for
temporal variations found no evidence for motions of haze layers (temporal
changes in layer altitudes) on time scales of 2 to 5 hours, but did find
evidence of changes in haze scale height above 100 km altitude. An ultraviolet
extinction attributable to the atmospheric haze was also detected by the ALICE
ultraviolet spectrograph on New Horizons. The haze particles are strongly
forward-scattering in the visible, and a microphysical model of haze is
presented which reproduces the visible phase function just above the surface
with 0.5 {\mu}m spherical particles, but also invokes fractal aggregate
particles to fit the visible phase function at 45 km altitude and account for
UV extinction. A model of haze layer generation by orographic excitation of
gravity waves is presented. This model accounts for the observed layer
thickness and distribution with altitude. Haze particles settle out of the
atmosphere and onto Pluto's surface, at a rate sufficient to alter surface
optical properties on seasonal time scales. Pluto's regional scale albedo
contrasts may be preserved in the face of the haze deposition by atmospheric
collapse.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.01679 [pdf] - 1492865
Constraints on the Microphysics of Pluto's Photochemical Haze from New
Horizons Observations
Gao, Peter;
Fan, Siteng;
Wong, Michael L.;
Liang, Mao-Chang;
Shia, Run-Lie;
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Yung, Yuk L.;
Summers, Michael E.;
Gladstone, G. Randall;
Young, Leslie A.;
Olkin, Catherine B.;
Ennico, Kimberly;
Weaver, Harold A.;
Stern, S. Alan;
Team, New Horizons Science
Submitted: 2016-10-05
The New Horizons flyby of Pluto confirmed the existence of hazes in its
atmosphere. Observations of a large high- to low- phase brightness ratio,
combined with the blue color of the haze, suggest that the haze particles are
fractal aggregates, analogous to the photochemical hazes on Titan. Therefore,
studying the Pluto hazes can shed light on the similarities and differences
between the Pluto and Titan atmospheres. We model the haze distribution using
the Community Aerosol and Radiation Model for Atmospheres assuming that the
distribution is shaped by sedimentation and coagulation of particles
originating from photochemistry. Hazes composed of both purely spherical and
purely fractal aggregate particles are considered. Agreement between model
results and occultation observations is obtained with aggregate particles when
the downward flux of photochemical products is equal to the column-integrated
methane destruction rate ~1.2 $\times$ 10$^{-14}$ g cm$^{-2}$ s$^{-1}$, while
for spherical particles the mass flux must be 2-3 times greater. This flux is
nearly identical to the haze production flux of Titan previously obtained by
comparing microphysical model results to Cassini observations. The aggregate
particle radius is sensitive to particle charging, and a particle charge to
radius ratio of 30 e-/{\mu}m is necessary to produce ~0.1-0.2 {\mu}m aggregates
near Pluto's surface, in accordance with forward scattering measurements. Such
a particle charge to radius ratio is 2-4 times higher than those previously
obtained for Titan. Hazes composed of spheres with the same particle charge to
radius ratio have particles that are 4 times smaller. These results further
suggest that the haze particles are fractal aggregates. We also consider the
effect of condensation of HCN, and C$_{2}$-hydrocarbons on the haze particles,
which may play an important role in shaping their distributions.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.06955 [pdf] - 1542709
New Horizons Constraints on Charon's Present Day Atmosphere
Stern, S. A.;
Kammer, J. A.;
Gladstone, G. R.;
Steffl, A. J.;
Cheng, A. F.;
Young, L. A.;
Weaver, H. A.;
Olkin, C. B.;
Ennico, K.;
Parker, J. W.;
Parker, A. H.;
Lauer, T. R.;
Zangari, A.;
Summers, M.;
Team, the New Horizons Atmospheres
Submitted: 2016-08-24
We report on a variety of standard techniques used by New Horizons including
a solar ultraviolet occultation, ultraviolet airglow observations, and
high-phase look-back particulate search imaging to search for an atmosphere
around Pluto's large moon Charon during its flyby in July 2015. Analyzing these
datasets, no evidence for a present day atmosphere has been found for 14
potential atomic and molecular species, all of which are now constrained to
have pressures below 0.3 nanobar, as we describe below, these are much more
stringent upper limits than the previously available 15-110 nanobar constraints
(e.g., Sicardy et al. 2006); for example, we find a 3$\sigma$ upper limit for
an N$_2$ atmosphere on Charon is 4.2 picobars and a 3$\sigma$ upper limit for
the brightness of any atmospheric haze on Charon of I/F=2.6x10$^{-5}$. A radio
occultation search for an atmosphere around Charon was also conducted by New
Horizons but will be published separately by other authors.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.00821 [pdf] - 1542656
Mean radius and shape of Pluto and Charon from New Horizons images
Nimmo, Francis;
Umurhan, Orkan M;
Lisse, Carey M;
Bierson, Carver J;
Lauer, Tod R;
Buie, Marc W;
Throop, Henry B;
Kammer, Josh A;
Roberts, James H;
McKinnon, William B;
Zangari, Amanda M;
Moore, Jeffrey M;
Stern, S Alan;
Young, Leslie A;
Weaver, Harold A;
Olkin, Cathy B;
Ennico, Kim;
team, the New Horizons GGI
Submitted: 2016-03-02, last modified: 2016-06-22
Approach images taken by the LORRI imaging system during the New Horizons
spacecraft encounter have been used to determine the mean radii and shapes of
Pluto and Charon. The primary observations are limb locations derived using
three independent approaches. The resulting mean radii of Pluto and Charon are
1188.3 +/- 1.6 km and 606.0 +/- 1.0 km, respectively (2-sigma). The
corresponding densities are 1854 +/- 11 kg m-3 and 1701 +/- 33 kg m-3
(2-sigma). The Charon radius value is consistent with previous Earth-based
occultation estimates. The Pluto radius estimate is consistent with solar
occultation measurements performed by the ALICE and Fine Sun Sensor instruments
on New Horizons. Neither Pluto nor Charon show any evidence for
tidal/rotational distortions; upper bounds on the oblateness are <0.6% and
<0.5%, respectively.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.04154 [pdf] - 1414038
Searching for Charon's Atmosphere: Predictions for the New Horizons
Approach
Submitted: 2015-06-12, last modified: 2016-05-30
Observations of Pluto's companion planet Charon have so far yielded no
compelling evidence for a persistent atmosphere. However, with the upcoming
encounter of New Horizons at the Pluto-Charon system, sensitivity to detection
of a possible Charon atmosphere will increase by orders of magnitude. In
particular, it has long been planned for New Horizons to use its Alice
ultraviolet spectrograph during solar occultation observations of Charon on
July 14, 2015, for this purpose. But in the days before closest encounter, the
Alice instrument will also acquire spectra of reflected sunlight from Charon's
surface. We examine the effect of absorption by several possible atmospheres
around Charon composed of N$_2$, CH$_4$, and CO, with plausible surface
pressures of 0.1, 1, and 10 nanobar (nbar). We show that this reflectance
technique is sensitive to surface pressures on Charon down to the 0.1 nbar
level, and should provide significant evidence of a possible atmosphere on
Charon before closest encounter. It may also be the only way to detect a local
atmosphere domed over the subsolar region on Charon.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.05356 [pdf] - 1393040
The Atmosphere of Pluto as Observed by New Horizons
Gladstone, G. Randall;
Stern, S. Alan;
Ennico, Kimberly;
Olkin, Catherine B.;
Weaver, Harold A.;
Young, Leslie A.;
Summers, Michael E.;
Strobel, Darrell F.;
Hinson, David P.;
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Parker, Alex H.;
Steffl, Andrew J.;
Linscott, Ivan R.;
Parker, Joel Wm.;
Cheng, Andrew F.;
Slater, David C.;
Versteeg, Maarten H.;
Greathouse, Thomas K.;
Retherford, Kurt D.;
Throop, Henry;
Cunningham, Nathaniel J.;
Woods, William W.;
Singer, Kelsi N.;
Tsang, Constantine C. C.;
Schindhelm, Eric;
Lisse, Carey M.;
Wong, Michael L.;
Yung, Yuk L.;
Zhu, Xun;
Curdt, Werner;
Lavvas, Panayotis;
Young, Eliot F.;
Tyler, G. Leonard;
Team, the New Horizons Science
Submitted: 2016-04-18
Observations made during the New Horizons flyby provide a detailed snapshot
of the current state of Pluto's atmosphere. While the lower atmosphere (at
altitudes <200 km) is consistent with ground-based stellar occultations, the
upper atmosphere is much colder and more compact than indicated by
pre-encounter models. Molecular nitrogen (N$_2$) dominates the atmosphere (at
altitudes <1800 km or so), while methane (CH$_4$), acetylene (C$_2$H$_2$),
ethylene (C$_2$H$_4$), and ethane (C$_2$H$_6$) are abundant minor species, and
likely feed the production of an extensive haze which encompasses Pluto. The
cold upper atmosphere shuts off the anticipated enhanced-Jeans,
hydrodynamic-like escape of Pluto's atmosphere to space. It is unclear whether
the current state of Pluto's atmosphere is representative of its average
state--over seasonal or geologic time scales.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.07704 [pdf] - 1300465
The Pluto system: Initial results from its exploration by New Horizons
Stern, S. A.;
Bagenal, F.;
Ennico, K.;
Gladstone, G. R.;
Grundy, W. M.;
McKinnon, W. B.;
Moore, J. M.;
Olkin, C. B.;
Spencer, J. R.;
Weaver, H. A.;
Young, L. A.;
Andert, T.;
Andrews, J.;
Banks, M.;
Bauer, B.;
Bauman, J.;
Barnouin, O. S.;
Bedini, P.;
Beisser, K.;
Beyer, R. A.;
Bhaskaran, S.;
Binzel, R. P.;
Birath, E.;
Bird, M.;
Bogan, D. J.;
Bowman, A.;
Bray, V. J.;
Brozovic, M.;
Bryan, C.;
Buckley, M. R.;
Buie, M. W.;
Buratti, B. J.;
Bushman, S. S.;
Calloway, A.;
Carcich, B.;
Cheng, A. F.;
Conard, S.;
Conrad, C. A.;
Cook, J. C.;
Cruikshank, D. P.;
Custodio, O. S.;
Ore, C. M. Dalle;
Deboy, C.;
Dischner, Z. J. B.;
Dumont, P.;
Earle, A. M.;
Elliott, H. A.;
Ercol, J.;
Ernst, C. M.;
Finley, T.;
Flanigan, S. H.;
Fountain, G.;
Freeze, M. J.;
Greathouse, T.;
Green, J. L.;
Guo, Y.;
Hahn, M.;
Hamilton, D. P.;
Hamilton, S. A.;
Hanley, J.;
Harch, A.;
Hart, H. M.;
Hersman, C. B.;
Hill, A.;
Hill, M. E.;
Hinson, D. P.;
Holdridge, M. E.;
Horanyi, M.;
Howard, A. D.;
Howett, C. J. A.;
Jackman, C.;
Jacobson, R. A.;
Jennings, D. E.;
Kammer, J. A.;
Kang, H. K.;
Kaufmann, D. E.;
Kollmann, P.;
Krimigis, S. M.;
Kusnierkiewicz, D.;
Lauer, T. R.;
Lee, J. E.;
Lindstrom, K. L.;
Linscott, I. R.;
Lisse, C. M.;
Lunsford, A. W.;
Mallder, V. A.;
Martin, N.;
McComas, D. J.;
McNutt, R. L.;
Mehoke, D.;
Mehoke, T.;
Melin, E. D.;
Mutchler, M.;
Nelson, D.;
Nimmo, F.;
Nunez, J. I.;
Ocampo, A.;
Owen, W. M.;
Paetzold, M.;
Page, B.;
Parker, A. H.;
Parker, J. W.;
Pelletier, F.;
Peterson, J.;
Pinkine, N.;
Piquette, M.;
Porter, S. B.;
Protopapa, S.;
Redfern, J.;
Reitsema, H. J.;
Reuter, D. C.;
Roberts, J. H.;
Robbins, S. J.;
Rogers, G.;
Rose, D.;
Runyon, K.;
Retherford, K. D.;
Ryschkewitsch, M. G.;
Schenk, P.;
Schindhelm, E.;
Sepan, B.;
Showalter, M. R.;
Singer, K. N.;
Soluri, M.;
Stanbridge, D.;
Steffl, A. J.;
Strobel, D. F.;
Stryk, T.;
Summers, M. E.;
Szalay, J. R.;
Tapley, M.;
Taylor, A.;
Taylor, H.;
Throop, H. B.;
Tsang, C. C. C.;
Tyler, G. L.;
Umurhan, O. M.;
Verbiscer, A. J.;
Versteeg, M. H.;
Vincent, M.;
Webbert, R.;
Weidner, S.;
Weigle, G. E.;
White, O. L.;
Whittenburg, K.;
Williams, B. G.;
Williams, K.;
Williams, S.;
Woods, W. W.;
Zangari, A. M.;
Zirnstein, E.
Submitted: 2015-10-26
The Pluto system was recently explored by NASA's New Horizons spacecraft,
making closest approach on 14 July 2015. Pluto's surface displays diverse
landforms, terrain ages, albedos, colors, and composition gradients. Evidence
is found for a water-ice crust, geologically young surface units, surface ice
convection, wind streaks, volatile transport, and glacial flow. Pluto's
atmosphere is highly extended, with trace hydrocarbons, a global haze layer,
and a surface pressure near 10 microbars. Pluto's diverse surface geology and
long-term activity raise fundamental questions about how small planets remain
active many billions of years after formation. Pluto's large moon Charon
displays tectonics and evidence for a heterogeneous crustal composition, its
north pole displays puzzling dark terrain. Small satellites Hydra and Nix have
higher albedos than expected.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.00902 [pdf] - 1280962
Spitzer Secondary Eclipse Observations of Five Cool Gas Giant Planets
and Empirical Trends in Cool Planet Emission Spectra
Kammer, Joshua A.;
Knutson, Heather A.;
Line, Michael R.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Deming, Drake;
Burrows, Adam;
Cowan, Nicolas B.;
Triaud, Amaury H. M. J.;
Agol, Eric;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Fulton, Benjamin J.;
Howard, Andrew W.;
Laughlin, Gregory P.;
Lewis, Nikole K.;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Moses, Julianne I.;
Showman, Adam P.;
Todorov, Kamen O.
Submitted: 2015-08-04
In this work we present Spitzer 3.6 and 4.5 micron secondary eclipse
observations of five new cool (<1200 K) transiting gas giant planets:
HAT-P-19b, WASP-6b, WASP-10b, WASP-39b, and WASP-67b. We compare our measured
eclipse depths to the predictions of a suite of atmosphere models and to
eclipse depths for planets with previously published observations in order to
constrain the temperature- and mass-dependent properties of gas giant planet
atmospheres. We find that the dayside emission spectra of planets less massive
than Jupiter require models with efficient circulation of energy to the night
side and/or increased albedos, while those with masses greater than that of
Jupiter are consistently best-matched by models with inefficient circulation
and low albedos. At these relatively low temperatures we expect the atmospheric
methane to CO ratio to vary as a function of metallicity, and we therefore use
our observations of these planets to constrain their atmospheric metallicities.
We find that the most massive planets have dayside emission spectra that are
best-matched by solar metallicity atmosphere models, but we are not able to
place strong constraints on metallicities of the smaller planets in our sample.
Interestingly, we find that the ratio of the 3.6 and 4.5 micron brightness
temperatures for these cool transiting planets is independent of planet
temperature, and instead exhibits a tentative correlation with planet mass. If
this trend can be confirmed, it would suggest that the shape of these planets'
emission spectra depends primarily on their masses, consistent with the
hypothesis that lower-mass planets are more likely to have metal-rich
atmospheres.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.7404 [pdf] - 1120563
Spitzer Secondary Eclipses of the Dense, Modestly-irradiated, Giant
Exoplanet HAT-P-20b Using Pixel-Level Decorrelation
Deming, Drake;
Knutson, Heather;
Kammer, Joshua;
Fulton, Benjamin J.;
Ingalls, James;
Carey, Sean;
Burrows, Adam;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Todorov, Kamen;
Agol, Eric;
Cowan, Nicolas;
Desert, Jean-Michel;
Fraine, Jonathan;
Langton, Jonathan;
Morley, Caroline;
Showman, Adam P.
Submitted: 2014-11-26, last modified: 2015-06-03
HAT-P-20b is a giant exoplanet that orbits a metal-rich star. The planet
itself has a high total density, suggesting that it may also have a high
metallicity in its atmosphere. We analyze two eclipses of the planet in each of
the 3.6- and 4.5 micron bands of Warm Spitzer. These data exhibit intra-pixel
detector sensitivity fluctuations that were resistant to traditional
decorrelation methods. We have developed a simple, powerful, and radically
different method to correct the intra-pixel effect for Warm Spitzer data, which
we call pixel-level decorrelation (PLD). PLD corrects the intra-pixel effect
very effectively, but without explicitly using - or even measuring - the
fluctuations in the apparent position of the stellar image. We illustrate and
validate PLD using synthetic and real data, and comparing the results to
previous analyses. PLD can significantly reduce or eliminate red noise in
Spitzer secondary eclipse photometry, even for eclipses that have proven to be
intractable using other methods. Our successful PLD analysis of four HAT-P-20b
eclipses shows a best-fit blackbody temperature of 1134 +/-29K, indicating
inefficient longitudinal transfer of heat, but lacking evidence for strong
molecular absorption. We find sufficient evidence for variability in the 4.5
micron band that the eclipses should be monitored at that wavelength by
Spitzer, and this planet should be a high priority for JWST spectroscopy. All
four eclipses occur about 35 minutes after orbital phase 0.5, indicating a
slightly eccentric orbit. A joint fit of the eclipse and transit times with
extant RV data yields e(cos{omega}) = 0.01352 (+0.00054, -0.00057), and
establishes the small eccentricity of the orbit to high statistical confidence.
Given the existence of a bound stellar companion, HAT-P-20b is another
excellent candidate for orbital evolution via Kozai migration or other
three-body mechanism.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.7952 [pdf] - 1180344
A Spitzer Search for Transits of Radial Velocity Detected Super-Earths
Kammer, J. A.;
Knutson, H. A.;
Howard, A. W.;
Laughlin, G. P.;
Deming, D.;
Todorov, K. O.;
Desert, J. -M.;
Agol, E.;
Burrows, A.;
Fortney, J. J.;
Showman, A. P.;
Lewis, N. K.
Submitted: 2013-10-29, last modified: 2014-01-05
Unlike hot Jupiters or other gas giants, super-Earths are expected to have a
wide variety of compositions, ranging from terrestrial bodies like our own to
more gaseous planets like Neptune. Observations of transiting systems, which
allow us to directly measure planet masses and radii and constrain atmospheric
properties, are key to understanding the compositional diversity of the planets
in this mass range. Although Kepler has discovered hundreds of transiting
super-Earth candidates over the past four years, the majority of these planets
orbit stars that are too far away and too faint to allow for detailed
atmospheric characterization and reliable mass estimates. Ground-based transit
surveys focus on much brighter stars, but most lack the sensitivity to detect
planets in this size range. One way to get around the difficulty of finding
these smaller planets in transit is to start by choosing targets that are
already known to contain super-Earth sized bodies detected using the radial
velocity technique. Here we present results from a Spitzer program to observe
six of the most favorable RV detected super-Earth systems, including HD 1461,
HD 7924, HD 156668, HIP 57274, and GJ 876. We find no evidence for transits in
any of their 4.5 micron flux light curves, and place limits on the allowed
transit depths and corresponding planet radii that rule out even the most dense
and iron-rich compositions for these objects. We also observed HD 97658, but
the observation window was based on a possible ground-based transit detection
(Henry et al. 2011) that was later ruled out; thus the window did not include
the predicted time for the transit detection recently made by MOST (Dragomir et
al. 2013).
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.5561 [pdf] - 1166123
A Systematic Retrieval Analysis of Secondary Eclipse Spectra I: A
Comparison of Atmospheric Retrieval Techniques
Submitted: 2013-04-19, last modified: 2013-08-22
Spectra of exoplanet atmospheres provide us the opportunity to improve our
understanding of these objects just as remote sensing in our own solar system
has increased our understanding of the solar system bodies. The challenge is to
quantitatively determine the range of temperatures and species abundances
allowed by the data. This challenge is often difficult given the low
information content of most exoplanet spectra which commonly leads to
degeneracies in the interpretation. A variety of temperature and abundance
retrieval approaches have been applied to exoplanet spectra, but no previous
investigations have sought to compare these approaches. In this investigation
we compare three different retrieval methods: Optimal Estimation, Differential
Evolution Markov Chain Monte Carlo, and Bootstrap Monte Carlo. We call our
suite of retrieval algorithms the Caltech Inverse Modeling and Retrieval
Algorithms (CHIMERA). We discuss what we can expect in terms of uncertainties
in abundances and temperatures given current observations as well as potential
future observations and what conclusions can be drawn given those
uncertainties. In general we find that the three approaches agree for high
quality spectra expected to come from potential future spaceborne missions, but
disagree for low quality spectra representative of current observations. We
also show that the Gaussian posterior probability distribution assumption made
in the Optimal Estimation approach is valid for high quality spectral data. We
also discuss the implications of our models for the inferred C to O ratios of
exoplanetary atmospheres, which of course are important for understanding
formation environments. More specifically we show that in the observational
limit of a few photometric points, the retrieved C/O is biased towards values
near solar and near one simply due to the assumption of uninformative priors.