Normalized to: Kakkad, D.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.02837 [pdf] - 2124578
The BAT AGN Spectroscopic Survey -- XVIII. Searching for Supermassive
Black Hole Binaries in the X-rays
Liu, Tingting;
Koss, Michael;
Blecha, Laura;
Ricci, Claudio;
Trakhtenbrot, Benny;
Mushotzky, Richard;
Harrison, Fiona;
Ichikawa, Kohei;
Kakkad, Darshan;
Oh, Kyuseok;
Powell, Meredith;
Privon, George C.;
Schawinski, Kevin;
Shimizu, T. Taro;
Smith, Krista Lynne;
Stern, Daniel;
Treister, Ezequiel;
Urry, C. Megan
Submitted: 2019-12-05, last modified: 2020-05-22
Theory predicts that a supermassive black hole binary (SMBHB) could be
observed as a luminous active galactic nucleus (AGN) that periodically varies
on the order of its orbital timescale. In X-rays, periodic variations could be
caused by mechanisms including relativistic Doppler boosting and shocks. Here
we present the first systematic search for periodic AGNs using $941$ hard X-ray
light curves (14-195 keV) from the first 105 months of the Swift Burst Alert
Telescope (BAT) survey (2004-2013). We do not find evidence for periodic AGNs
in Swift-BAT, including the previously reported SMBHB candidate
MCG+11$-$11$-$032. We find that the null detection is consistent with the
combination of the upper-limit binary population in AGNs in our adopted model,
their expected periodic variability amplitudes, and the BAT survey
characteristics. We have also investigated the detectability of SMBHBs against
normal AGN X-ray variability in the context of the eROSITA survey. Under our
assumptions of a binary population and the periodic signals they produce which
have long periods of hundreds of days, up to $13$% true periodic binaries can
be robustly distinguished from normal variable AGNs with the ideal uniform
sampling. However, we demonstrate that realistic eROSITA sampling is likely to
be insensitive to long-period binaries because longer observing gaps reduce
their detectability. In contrast, large observing gaps do not diminish the
prospect of detecting binaries of short, few-day periods, as 19% can be
successfully recovered, the vast majority of which can be identified by the
first half of the survey.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.02242 [pdf] - 2030731
KASHz: No evidence for ionised outflows instantaneously suppressing star
formation in moderate luminosity AGN at $z$$\sim$$1.4$-$2.6$
Scholtz, J.;
Harrison, C. M.;
Rosario, D. J.;
Alexander, D. M.;
Chen, C-C.;
Kakkad, D.;
Mainieri, V.;
Tiley, A. L.;
Turner, O.;
Cirasuolo, M.;
Sharples, R. M.;
Stach, S.
Submitted: 2020-01-07, last modified: 2020-01-14
As part of our KMOS AGN Survey at High-redshift (KASHz), we present
spatially-resolved VLT/KMOS and VLT/SINFONI spectroscopic data and ALMA
870$\mu$m continuum imaging of eight $z$=1.4--2.6 moderate AGN ($L_{\rm 2-10
\rm kev}$ = $10^{42} - 10^{45}$ ergs s$^{-1}$). We map [OIII], H$\alpha$ and
rest-frame FIR emission to search for any spatial anti-correlation between
ionised outflows (traced by the [OIII] line) and star formation (SF; traced by
H$\alpha$ and FIR), that has previously been claimed for some high-z AGN and
used as evidence for negative and/or positive AGN feedback. Firstly, we
conclude that H$\alpha$ is unreliable to map SF inside our AGN host galaxies
based on: (i) SF rates inferred from attenuation-corrected H$\alpha$ can lie
below those inferred from FIR; (ii) the FIR continuum is more compact than the
H$\alpha$ emission by a factor of $\sim 2$ on average; (iii) in half of our
sample, we observe significant spatial offsets between the FIR and H$\alpha$
emission, with an average offset of $1.4\pm0.6$ kpc. Secondly, for the five
targets with outflows we find no evidence for a spatial anti-correlation
between outflows and SF using either H$\alpha$ or FIR as a tracer. This holds
for our re-analysis of a famous $z$=1.6 X-ray AGN (`XID 2028') where positive
and negative feedback has been previously claimed. Based on our results, any
impact on SF by ionised outflows must be subtle, either occurring on scales
below our resolution, or on long timescales.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.12395 [pdf] - 2026453
BAT AGN Spectroscopic Survey -- XIX: Type 1 versus Type 2 AGN dichotomy
from the point of view of ionized outflows
Rojas, A. F.;
Sani, E.;
Gavignaud, I.;
Ricci, C.;
Lamperti, I.;
Koss, M.;
Trakhtenbrot, B.;
Schawinski, K.;
Oh, K.;
Bauer, F. E.;
Bischetti, M.;
Boissay-Malaquin, R.;
Bongiorno, A.;
Harrison, F.;
Kakkad, D.;
Masetti, N.;
Ricci, F.;
Shimizu, T.;
Stalevski, M.;
Stern, D.;
Vietri, G.
Submitted: 2019-11-27
We present a detailed study of ionized outflows in a large sample of ~650
hard X-ray detected AGN. Using optical spectroscopy from the BAT AGN
Spectroscopic Survey (BASS) we are able to reveal the faint wings of the [OIII]
emission lines associated with outflows covering, for the first time, an
unexplored range of low AGN bolometric luminosity at low redshift (z~0.05). We
test if and how the incidence and velocity of ionized outflow is related to AGN
physical parameters: black hole mass, gas column density, Eddington Ratio,
[OIII], X-ray, and bolometric luminosities. We find a higher occurrence of
ionized outflows in type 1.9 (55%) and type 1 AGN (46%) with respect to type 2
AGN (24%). While outflows in type 2 AGN are evenly balanced between blue and
red velocity offsets with respect to the [OIII] narrow component, they are
almost exclusively blueshifted in type 1 and type 1.9 AGN. We observe a
significant dependence between the outflow occurrence and accretion rate, which
becomes relevant at high Eddington ratios (> -1.7). We interpret such behaviour
in the framework of covering factor-Eddington ratio dependence. We don't find
strong trends of the outflow maximum velocity with AGN physical parameters, as
an increase with bolometric luminosity can be only identified when including
samples of AGN at high luminosity and high redshift taken from literature.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.04858 [pdf] - 1791007
SUPER I. Toward an unbiased study of ionized outflows in z~2 active
galactic nuclei: survey overview and sample characterization
Circosta, C.;
Mainieri, V.;
Padovani, P.;
Lanzuisi, G.;
Salvato, M.;
Harrison, C. M.;
Kakkad, D.;
Puglisi, A.;
Vietri, G.;
Zamorani, G.;
Cicone, C.;
Husemann, B.;
Vignali, C.;
Balmaverde, B.;
Bischetti, M.;
Brusa, M.;
Bongiorno, A.;
Carniani, S.;
Civano, F.;
Comastri, A.;
Cresci, G.;
Feruglio, C.;
Fiore, F.;
Fotopoulou, S.;
Karim, A.;
Lamastra, A.;
Magnelli, B.;
Mannucci, F.;
Marconi, A.;
Merloni, A.;
Netzer, H.;
Perna, M.;
Piconcelli, E.;
Rodighiero, G.;
Schinnerer, E.;
Schramm, M.;
Schulze, A.;
Silverman, J.;
Zappacosta, L.
Submitted: 2018-09-13
Theoretical models of galaxy formation suggest that the presence of an active
galactic nucleus (AGN) is required to regulate the growth of its host galaxy
through feedback mechanisms, produced by e.g. AGN-driven outflows. Although
such outflows are common both at low and high redshift, a comprehensive picture
is still missing. The peak epoch of galaxy assembly (1<z<3) has been poorly
explored so far, and current observations in this redshift range are mostly
limited to targets with high chances to be in an outflowing phase. This paper
introduces SUPER (a SINFONI Survey for Unveiling the Physics and Effect of
Radiative feedback), an ongoing ESO's VLT/SINFONI Large Programme. SUPER will
perform the first systematic investigation of ionized outflows in a sizeable
and blindly-selected sample of 39 X-ray AGN at z~2, which reaches high spatial
resolutions (~2 kpc) thanks to the adaptive optics-assisted IFU observations.
The outflow morphology and star formation in the host galaxy will be mapped
through the broad component of [OIII] and the narrow component of Ha emission
lines. The main aim of our survey is to infer the impact of outflows on the
on-going star formation and to link the outflow properties to a number of AGN
and host galaxy properties. We describe here the survey characteristics and
goals, as well as the selection of the target sample. Moreover, we present a
full characterization of its multi-wavelength properties: we measure, via
spectral energy distribution fitting of UV-to-FIR photometry, stellar masses
(4x10^9-2x10^11 Msun), star formation rates (25-680 Msun yr^-1) and AGN
bolometric luminosities (2x10^44-8x10^47 erg s^-1), along with obscuring column
densities (<2x10^24 cm^-2) and 2-10 keV luminosities (2x10^43-6x10^45 erg s^-1)
derived through X-ray spectral analysis. Finally, we classify our AGN as jetted
or non-jetted according to their radio and FIR emission.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.02839 [pdf] - 1759315
Spatially resolved electron density in the Narrow Line Region of z<0.02
radio AGNs
Kakkad, D.;
Groves, B.;
Dopita, M.;
Thomas, Adam D.;
Davies, Rebecca L.;
Mainieri, V.;
Kharb, Preeti;
Scharwächter, J.;
Hampton, E. J.;
Ho, I-Ting
Submitted: 2018-06-07
Although studying outflows in the host galaxies of AGN have become the
forefront of extra-galactic astronomy in recent years, estimating the energy
associated with these outflows have been a major challenge. Determination of
the energy associated with an outflow often involves an assumption of uniform
density in the NLR, which span a wide range in literature leading to large
systematic uncertainties in energy estimation. In this paper, we present
electron density maps for a sample of outflowing and non-outflowing Seyfert
galaxies at z<0.02 drawn from the S7 survey and understand the origin and
values of the observed density structures to reduce the systematic
uncertainties in outflow energy estimation. We use the ratio of the
[SII]6716,6731 emission lines to derive spatially resolved electron densities
(<50-2000 cm$^{-3}$). Using optical IFU observations, we are able to measure
densities across the central 2-5 kpc of the selected AGN host galaxies. We
compare the density maps with the positions of the HII regions derived from the
narrow H$\alpha$ component, ionization maps from [OIII], and spatially resolved
BPT diagrams, to infer the origin of the observed density structures. We also
use the electron density maps to construct density profiles as a function of
distance from the central AGN. We find a spatial correlation between the sites
of high star formation and high electron density for targets without an active
ionized outflow. The non-outflowing targets also show an exponential drop in
the electron density as a function of distance from the center, with a mean
exponential index of ~0.15. The correlation between the star forming sites and
electron density ceases for targets with an outflow. The density within the
outflowing medium is not uniform and shows both low and high density sites,
most likely due to the presence of shocks and highly turbulent medium.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.10306 [pdf] - 1642771
AGN outflows and feedback twenty years on
Submitted: 2018-02-28
It is the twentieth anniversary of the publication of the seminal papers by
Magorrian et al. and Silk & Rees which, along with other related work, ignited
an explosion of publications connecting active galactic nuclei (AGN)-driven
outflows to galaxy evolution. With a surge in observations of AGN outflows,
studies are attempting to directly test AGN feedback models using the outflow
properties. With a focus on outflows traced by optical and CO emission lines,
we discuss significant challenges which greatly complicate this task from both
an observational and theoretical perspective. We highlight observational
uncertainties involved, and the assumptions required, when deriving kinetic
coupling efficiencies (i.e., outflow kinetic power as a fraction of AGN
luminosity) from typical observations. Based on recent models we demonstrate
that extreme caution should taken when comparing observationally-derived
kinetic coupling efficiencies to coupling efficiencies from fiducial feedback
models.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.08183 [pdf] - 1552495
ALMA observations of cold molecular gas in AGN hosts at z~1.5 - Evidence
of AGN feedback?
Kakkad, D.;
Mainieri, V.;
Brusa, M.;
Padovani, P.;
Carniani, S.;
Feruglio, C.;
Sargent, M.;
Husemann, B.;
Bongiorno, A.;
Bonzini, M.;
Piconcelli, E.;
Silverman, J. D.;
Rujopakarn, W.
Submitted: 2017-03-23
Similarly to the cosmic star formation history, the black hole accretion rate
density of the Universe peaked at 1<z<3. This cosmic epoch is hence best suited
for investigating the effects of radiative feedback from AGN. Observational
efforts are underway to quantify the impact of AGN feedback, if any, on their
host galaxies. Here we present a study of the molecular gas content of AGN
hosts at z~1.5 using CO[2-1] line emission observed with ALMA for a sample of
10 AGNs. We compare this with a sample of galaxies without an AGN matched in
redshift, stellar mass, and star formation rate. We detect CO in 3 AGNs with
$\mathrm{L_{CO} \sim 6.3-25.1\times 10^{9} L_{\odot}}$ which translates to a
molecular hydrogen gas mass of $\mathrm{2.5-10\times 10^{10} M_{\odot}}$
assuming conventional conversion factor of $\mathrm{\alpha_{CO}}\sim3.6$. Our
results indicate a >99% probability of lower depletion time scales and lower
molecular gas fractions in AGN hosts with respect to the non-AGN comparison
sample. We discuss the implications of these observations on the impact that
AGN feedback may have on star formation efficiency of z>1 galaxies.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.05595 [pdf] - 1494644
Large-scale outflows in luminous QSOs revisited: The impact of beam
smearing on AGN feedback efficiencies
Submitted: 2015-12-17, last modified: 2016-05-27
[Abridged] Enormous observational efforts have been made to constrain the
energetics of AGN feedback by mapping the kinematics of the ionized gas on kpc
scale. We study how the observed kinematics and inferred energetics are
affected by beam smearing of a bright unresolved NLR due to seeing. We analyse
IFU spectroscopy of a sample of twelve QSOs initially presented by Liu et al.
(2014). The PSF for the observations is directly obtained from the light
distribution of the broad Hb line component. We are able to compare the ionized
gas kinematics and derived energetics of the total, spatially extended, and
unresolved [OIII] emission. We find that the spatially resolved [OIII] line
width on kpc scales is significantly narrower than the one before PSF
deblending. The ENLRs appear offset from the QSO position or more elongated
which can be interpreted in favour of a conical outflow on large scales while a
spherical geometry cannot be excluded for the unresolved NLR. We find that the
kinetic power at 5kpc distance from the spherical model by Liu et al. (2013) is
reduced by two magnitudes for a conical outflow and one magnitude for the
unresolved NLR after PSF deblending. This reduced kinetic power corresponds to
0.01-0.1% of the bolometric AGN luminosity. This is smaller than the 5-10%
feedback efficiency required by some simulations to reproduce the massive
galaxy population. The injected momentum fluxes are close or below the simple
radiation-pressure limit Lbol/c for the conical outflow model for the NLR and
ENLR when beam smearing is considered. IFU spectroscopy is a powerful tool to
investigate the energetics of AGN outflows, but the impact of beam smearing has
to be taken into account. For the majority of observations in the literature,
this has not been addressed carefully so that the incidence and energetics of
presumed kpc-scale AGN-driven outflows still remain an unsolved issue.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.08631 [pdf] - 1460900
Tracing outflows in the AGN forbidden region with SINFONI
Kakkad, D.;
Mainieri, V.;
Padovani, P.;
Cresci, G.;
Husemann, B.;
Carniani, S.;
Brusa, M.;
Lamastra, A.;
Lanzuisi, G.;
Piconcelli, E.;
Schramm, M.
Submitted: 2016-05-27
AGN driven outflows are invoked in numerical simulations to reproduce several
observed properties of local galaxies. The z > 1 epoch is of particular
interest as it was during this time that the volume averaged star formation and
the accretion rate of black holes were maximum. Radiatively driven outflows are
therefore believed to be common during this epoch. We aim to trace and
characterize outflows in AGN hosts with high mass accretion rates at z > 1
using integral field spectroscopy. We obtain spatially-resolved kinematics of
the [OIII]5007 line in two targets which reveal the morphology and spatial
extension of the outflows. We present J and H+K band SINFONI observations of 5
AGNs at 1.2 < z < 2.2. To maximize the chance of observing radiatively driven
outflows, our sample was pre-selected based on peculiar values of the Eddington
ratio and the hydrogen column density of the surrounding interstellar medium.
We observe high velocity (~600-1900 km/s) and kiloparsec scale extended ionized
outflows in at least 3 of our targets, using [OIII]5007 line kinematics tracing
the AGN narrow line region. We estimate the total mass of the outflow, the mass
outflow rate, and the kinetic power of the outflows based on theoretical models
and report on the uncertainties associated with them. We find mass outflow
rates of ~1-10 M_sun/yr for the sample presented in this paper. Based on the
high star formation rates of the host galaxies, the observed outflow kinetic
power and the expected power due to the AGN, we infer that both star formation
and AGN radiation could be the dominant source for the outflows. The outflow
models suffer from large uncertainties, hence we call for further detailed
observations for an accurate determination of the outflow properties to confirm
the exact source of these outflows.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.03181 [pdf] - 1378921
A fast ionised wind in a Star Forming-Quasar system at z~1.5 resolved
through Adaptive Optics assisted near-infrared data
Brusa, M.;
Perna, M.;
Cresci, G.;
Schramm, M.;
Delvecchio, I.;
Lanzuisi, G.;
Mainieri, V.;
Mignoli, M.;
Zamorani, G.;
Berta, S.;
Bongiorno, A.;
Comastri, A.;
Fiore, F.;
Kakkad, D.;
Marconi, A.;
Rosario, D.;
Contini, T.;
Lamareille, F.
Submitted: 2016-02-09, last modified: 2016-02-16
Outflows are invoked in co-evolutionary models to link the growth of SMBH and
galaxies through feedback phenomena, and from the analysis of both galaxies and
Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) samples at z$\sim1-3$, it is becoming clear that
powerful winds are quite common in AGN hosts. High-resolution and high S/N
observations are needed in order to uncover the physical properties of the wind
through kinematics analysis. We exploited VIMOS, SINFONI and Subaru/IRCS
Adaptive Optics data to study the kinematics properties on the scale the host
galaxy of XID5395, a luminous, X-ray obscured Starburst/Quasar merging system
at z$\sim1.5$ detected in the XMM-COSMOS field, and associated with an extreme
[O II] emitter (EW$\sim200$ \AA). We mapped, for the first time, at high
resolution the kinematics of the [O III] and H$\alpha$ line complexes and
linked them with the [O II] emission. The high spatial resolution achieved
allowed us to resolve all the components of the SB-QSO system. Our analysis
with a resolution of few kpc reveals complexities and asymmetries in and around
the nucleus of XID5395. The velocity field measured via non parametric analysis
reveals different kinematic components, with maximum blueshifted and redshifted
velocities up to $\simeq1300$ km s$^{-1}$, not spatially coincident with the
nuclear core. These extreme values of the observed velocities and the spatial
location can be explained by the presence of fast moving material. We also
spectroscopically confirm the presence of a merging system at the same redshift
of the AGN host. We propose that EW as large as $>150$ \AA\ in X-ray selected
AGN may be an efficient criterion to isolate objects associated to the short,
transition phase of "feedback" in the AGN-galaxy co-evolutionary path, which
will subsequently evolve in an unobscured QSO, as suggested from the different
observational evidences we accumulated for XID5395.