Normalized to: Justham, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.05077 [pdf] - 2117003
Predictions for the hydrogen-free ejecta of pulsational pair-instability
supernovae
Submitted: 2020-02-12, last modified: 2020-06-16
Present time-domain astronomy efforts will unveil a variety of rare
transients. We focus here on pulsational pair-instability evolution, which can
result in signatures observable with electromagnetic and gravitational waves.
We simulate grids of bare helium stars to characterize the resulting black hole
(BH) masses and ejecta composition, velocity, and thermal state. The stars do
not react "elastically" to the thermonuclear explosion: there is not a
one-to-one correspondence between pair-instability driven ignition and mass
ejections, causing ambiguity in what is an observable pulse. In agreement with
previous studies, we find that for carbon-oxygen core masses 28Msun<
M_CO<30.5Msun the explosions are not strong enough to affect the surface. With
increasing mass, they first cause large radial expansion
(30.5Msun<M_CO<31.4Msun), and finally, also mass ejection episodes
(M_CO>31.4Msun). The lowest mass to be fully disrupted in a pair-instability
supernova is M_CO=57Msun. Models with M_CO>121Msun reach the
photodisintegration regime, resulting in BHs with M_BH>125Msun. If the
pulsating models produce BHs via (weak) explosions, the previously-ejected
material might be hit by the blast wave. We characterize the H-free
circumstellar material from the pulsational pair-instability of helium cores
assuming simply that the ejecta maintain a constant velocity after ejection.
Our models produce He-rich ejecta with mass 10^{-3}Msun<M_CSM<40Msun. These
ejecta are typically launched at a few thousand \kms and reach distances of
~10^{12}-10^{15} cm before core-collapse. The delays between mass ejection
events and the final collapse span a wide and mass-dependent range (from
sub-hour to 10^4 years), and the shells ejected can also collide with each
other. The range of properties we find suggests a possible connection with
(some) type Ibn supernovae.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.08317 [pdf] - 2114373
Non-interacting black hole binaries with Gaia and LAMOST
Submitted: 2020-06-15
Until recently, black holes (BHs) could be discovered only through accretion
from other stars in X-ray binaries, or in merging double compact objects.
Improvements in astrometric and spectroscopic measurements have made it
possible to detect BHs also in non-interacting BH binaries (nBHB) through a
precise analysis of the companion's motion. In this study, using an updated
version of the \startrack\ binary-star population modelling code and a detailed
model of the Milky Way (MW) galaxy we calculate the expected number of
detections for \gaia\ and \lamost\ surveys. We develop a formalism to convolve
the binary population synthesis output with a realistic stellar density
distribution, star-formation history (SFH), and chemical evolution for the MW,
which produces a probability distribution function of the predicted
compact-binary population over the MW. This avoids the additional statistical
uncertainty which is introduced by methods which Monte Carlo sample from binary
population synthesis output to produce one potential specific realisation of
the MW compact-binary distribution, and our method is also comparatively fast
to such Monte Carlo realisations. Specifically, we predict $\sim41$--$340$
nBHBs to be observed by \gaia, although the numbers may drop to $\sim10$--$70$
if the recent ($\lesssim100\;$ Myr) star formation is low ($\sim1\;M_\odot$/yr
). For \lamost\ we predict $\lesssim14$ detectable nBHBs, which is lower
partially because its field-of-view covers just $\sim6\%$ of the Galaxy.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.06678 [pdf] - 2113381
Constraints from gravitational wave detections of binary black hole
mergers on the $^{12}\rm{C}\left(\alpha,\gamma\right)^{16}\!\rm{O}$ rate
Submitted: 2020-06-11
Gravitational wave detections are starting to allow us to probe the physical
processes in the evolution of very massive stars through the imprints they
leave on their final remnants. Stellar evolution theory predicts the existence
of a gap in the black hole mass distribution at high mass due to the effects of
pair-instability. Previously, we showed that the location of the gap is robust
against model uncertainties, but it does depend sensitively on the uncertain
$^{12}\rm{C}\left(\alpha,\gamma\right)^{16}\!\rm{O}$ rate. This rate is of
great astrophysical significance and governs the production of oxygen at the
expense of carbon. We use the open source MESA stellar evolution code to evolve
massive helium stars to probe the location of the mass gap. We find that the
maximum black hole mass below the gap varies between $40\rm{M}_\odot$ to
$90\rm{M}_\odot$, depending on the strength of the uncertain
$^{12}\rm{C}\left(\alpha,\gamma\right)^{16}\!\rm{O}$ reaction rate. With the
first ten gravitational-wave detections of black holes, we constrain the
astrophysical S-factor for
$^{12}\rm{C}\left(\alpha,\gamma\right)^{16}\!\rm{O}$, at $300\rm{keV}$, to
$S_{300}>175\rm{\,keV\, barns}$ at 68% confidence. With $\mathcal{O}(50)$
detected binary black hole mergers, we expect to constrain the S-factor to
within $\pm10$-$30\rm{\,keV\, barns}$. We also highlight a role for independent
constraints from electromagnetic transient surveys. The unambiguous detection
of pulsational pair instability supernovae would imply that
$S_{300}>79\rm{\,keV\, barns}$. Degeneracies with other model uncertainties
need to be investigated further, but probing nuclear stellar astrophysics poses
a promising science case for the future gravitational wave detectors.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.05187 [pdf] - 2104753
Polluting the pair-instability mass gap for binary black holes through
super-Eddington accretion in isolated binaries
Submitted: 2020-04-10, last modified: 2020-06-01
The theory for single stellar evolution predicts a gap in the mass
distribution of black holes (BHs) between approximately 45-130M$_{\odot}$, the
so-called "pair-instability mass gap". We examine whether BHs can pollute the
gap after accreting from a stellar companion. To this end, we simulate the
evolution of isolated binaries using a population synthesis code, where we
allow for super-Eddington accretion. Under our most extreme assumptions, we
find that at most about 2% of all merging binary BH systems contains a BH with
a mass in the pair-instability mass gap, and we find that less than 0.5% of the
merging systems has a total mass larger than 90M$_{\odot}$. We find no merging
binary BH systems with a total mass exceeding 100M$_{\odot}$. We compare our
results to predictions from several dynamical pathways to pair-instability mass
gap events and discuss the distinguishable features. We conclude that the
classical isolated binary formation scenario will not significantly contribute
to the pollution of the pair-instability mass gap. The robustness of the
predicted mass gap for the isolated binary channel is promising for the
prospective of placing constraints on (i) the relative contribution of
different formation channels, (ii) the physics of the progenitors including
nuclear reaction rates, and (iii), tentatively, the Hubble parameter.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.05335 [pdf] - 2082324
Looks can be deceiving: underestimating the age of single white dwarfs
due to binary mergers
Submitted: 2019-10-11, last modified: 2020-04-21
Context: White dwarfs (WDs) are important and abundant tools to study the
structure and evolution of the Galactic environment. However, the multiplicity
of WD progenitors is generally neglected. Specifically, a merger in a binary
system can lead to a single WD, which could result in wrongly inferred
quantities if only single stellar evolution (SSE) is considered. These mergers
are linked to transients such as luminous red novae and Type Ia supernovae.
Aims: We investigate the impact of binary evolution (BE) upon observable single
WDs, and compare their properties to WDs formed through SSE. We assess the
evolutionary channels and the age and mass distributions of the resulting
single Wds. Methods: We employed \texttt{SeBa} to model the evolution of single
star and binary populations. We synthesised the observable single WD population
within $100$ pc, including cooling and observational selection effects.
Additionally, we constructed models with different evolution and primordial
population properties to study the effects on the properties of the resulting
single WDs.
Results: White dwarfs from binary mergers make up about $10-30\%$ of all
observable single WDs and $30-50\%$ of massive WDs. On average, individual WDs
take
$3.1-5$ times longer to form through BE than SE, and so appear ${\sim} 1$ Gyr
younger than they are if BE is ignored. In all models, the effect of mergers on
the age distribution is clearly noticeable. The median age typically increases
by $85-430$ Myr and $200-390$ Myr for massive WDs. Although abundant, we do not
find evidence that WDs from mergers significantly alter the shape of the WD
mass distribution. Conclusions: Assuming SSE for inferring properties of single
WDs gives rise to intrinsic errors as single WDs can also be formed following a
binary merger. Strategies for mitigating the effect of mergers on the WD age
distributions are discussed.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.01120 [pdf] - 2089128
The expansion of stripped-envelope stars: consequences for supernovae
and gravitational-wave progenitors
Submitted: 2020-03-02
Massive binaries that merge as compact objects are the progenitors of
gravitational-wave sources. Most of these binaries experience one or more
phases of mass transfer, during which one of the stars loses part or all of its
outer envelope and becomes a stripped-envelope star. The evolution of the size
of these stripped stars is crucial in determining whether they experience
further interactions and their final fate. We present new calculations of
stripped-envelope stars based on binary evolution models computed with MESA. We
use these to investigate their radius evolution as a function of mass and
metallicity. We further discuss their pre-supernova observable characteristics
and potential consequences of their evolution on the properties of supernovae
from stripped stars. At high metallicity we find that practically all of the
hydrogen-rich envelope is removed, in agreement with earlier findings. Only
progenitors with initial masses below 10\Msun expand to large radii (up to
100\Rsun), while more massive progenitors stay compact. At low metallicity, a
substantial amount of hydrogen remains and the progenitors can, in principle,
expand to giant sizes (> 400\Rsun), for all masses we consider. This implies
that they can fill their Roche lobe anew. We show that the prescriptions
commonly used in population synthesis models underestimate the stellar radii by
up to two orders of magnitude. We expect that this has consequences for the
predictions for gravitational-wave sources from double neutron star mergers, in
particular for their metallicity dependence.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.08200 [pdf] - 2061748
Sensitivity of the lower-edge of the pair instability black hole mass
gap to the treatment of time dependent convection
Submitted: 2020-02-19
Gravitational-wave detections are now probing the black hole (BH) mass
distribution, including the predicted pair-instability mass gap. These data
require robust quantitative predictions, which are challenging to obtain. The
most massive BH progenitors experience episodic mass ejections on timescales
shorter than the convective turn-over timescale. This invalidates the
steady-state assumption on which the classic mixing-length theory relies. We
compare the final BH masses computed with two different versions of the stellar
evolutionary code \texttt{MESA}: (i) using the default implementation of
\cite{paxton:18} and (ii) solving an additional equation accounting for the
timescale for convective deceleration. In the second grid, where stronger
convection develops during the pulses and carries part of the energy, we find
weaker pulses. This leads to lower amounts of mass being ejected and thus
higher final BH masses of up to $\sim$\,$5\,M_\odot$. The differences are much
smaller for the progenitors which determine the maximum mass of BHs below the
gap. This prediction is robust at $M_{\rm BH, max}\simeq 48\,M_\odot$, at least
within the idealized context of this study. This is an encouraging indication
that current models are robust enough for comparison with the present-day
gravitational-wave detections. However, the large differences between
individual models emphasize the importance of improving the treatment of
convection in stellar models, especially in the light of the data anticipated
from the third generation of gravitational wave detectors.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.07230 [pdf] - 2050493
How binarity affects the observed initial and final core masses of
hydrogen-rich, Type II supernova progenitors
Submitted: 2020-02-17
The majority of massive stars, the progenitors of core-collapse supernovae
(SNe), are found in close binary systems. Zapartas et al. (2019) modeled the
fraction of hydrogen-rich, Type II SN progenitors which have their evolution
affected by mass exchange with their companion, finding this to be between 1/3
and 1/2 for most assumptions. Here we study in more depth the impact of this
binary history of Type II SN progenitors on their final pre-SN core mass
distribution, using population synthesis simulations. We find that binary star
progenitors of Type II SNe typically end their life with a larger core mass
than they would have had if they had lived in isolation, because they gained
mass or merged with a companion before explosion. The combination of the
diverse binary evolutionary paths typically lead to a marginally shallower
final core mass distribution. Discussing our results in the context of the red
supergiant problem, i.e., the reported lack of detected high luminosity
progenitors, we conclude that binary evolution does not seem to significantly
affect the issue. This conclusion is quite robust against our variations in the
assumptions of binary physics. We also predict that inferring the initial
masses of Type II SN progenitors from "age-dating" its surrounding environment
systematically yields lower masses compared to methods that probe the pre-SN
core mass or luminosity. A robust discrepancy between the inferred initial
masses of a SN progenitor from those different techniques could indicate an
evolutionary history of binary mass accretion or merging.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.09829 [pdf] - 2041500
Common-Envelope Episodes that lead to Double Neutron Star formation
Submitted: 2020-01-27, last modified: 2020-02-03
Close Double Neutron Stars (DNSs) have been observed as Galactic radio
pulsars, while their mergers have been detected as gamma-ray bursts and
gravitational-wave sources. They are believed to have experienced at least one
common-envelope episode (CEE) during their evolution prior to DNS formation. In
the last decades there have been numerous efforts to understand the details of
the common-envelope phase, but its computational modelling remains challenging.
We present and discuss the properties of the donor and the binary at the onset
of the Roche-lobe overflow (RLOF) leading to these CEEs as predicted by rapid
binary population synthesis models. These properties can be used as initial
conditions for detailed simulations of the common-envelope phase. There are
three distinctive populations, classified by the evolutionary stage of the
donor at the moment of the onset of the RLOF: giant donors with
fully-convective envelopes, cool donors with partially-convective envelopes,
and hot donors with radiative envelopes. We also estimate that, for standard
assumptions, tides would not circularise a large fraction of these systems by
the onset of RLOF. This makes the study and understanding of eccentric mass
transferring systems relevant for DNS populations.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.07771 [pdf] - 2032883
Luminous Red Novae: population models and future prospects
Submitted: 2019-12-16, last modified: 2020-01-17
A class of optical transients known as Luminous Red Novae (LRNe) have
recently been associated with mass ejections from binary stars undergoing
common-envelope evolution. We use the population synthesis code COMPAS to
explore the impact of a range of assumptions about the physics of
common-envelope evolution on the properties of LRNe. In particular, we
investigate the influence of various models for the energetics of LRNe on the
expected event rate and light curve characteristics, and compare with the
existing sample. We find that the Galactic rate of LRNe is $\sim 0.2$
yr$^{-1}$, in agreement with the observed rate. In our models, the luminosity
function of Galactic LRNe covers multiple decades in luminosity and is
dominated by signals from stellar mergers, consistent with observational
constraints from iPTF and the Galactic sample of LRNe. We discuss how
observations of the brightest LRNe may provide indirect evidence for the
existence of massive ($> 40$ M$_\odot$) red supergiants. Such LRNe could be
markers along the evolutionary pathway leading to the formation of double
compact objects. We make predictions for the population of LRNe observable in
future transient surveys with the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope and the
Zwicky Transient Facility. In all plausible circumstances, we predict a
selection-limited observable population dominated by bright, long-duration
events caused by common envelope ejections. We show that the Large Synoptic
Survey Telescope will observe $20$--$750$ LRNe per year, quickly constraining
the luminosity function of LRNe and probing the physics of common-envelope
events.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.12357 [pdf] - 2054086
The Formation of a 70 Msun Black Hole at High Metallicity
Belczynski, K.;
Hirschi, R.;
Kaiser, E. A.;
Liu, Jifeng;
Casares, J.;
Lu, Youjun;
O'Shaughnessy, R.;
Heger, A.;
Justham, S.;
Soria, R.
Submitted: 2019-11-27, last modified: 2020-01-11
A 70Msun BH was discovered in Milky Way disk in a long period and almost
circular detached binary system (LB-1) with a high metallicity 8Msun B star
companion. Current consensus on the formation of BHs from high metallicity
stars limits the black hole mass to be below 20Msun. Using simple evolutionary
model, we show that the formation of a 70Msun BH in high metallicity
environment is possible if stellar wind mass loss rates are reduced by factor
of 5. As observations indicate, a fraction of massive stars have surface
magnetic fields which may quench the wind mass-loss, independently of stellar
mass and metallicity. We also computed detailed stellar evolution models and we
confirm such a scenario. A non-rotating 85Msun model at Z=0.014 with decreased
winds ends up as a 71Msun star prior core-collapse with a 32Msun helium core
and a 28Msun CO core. Such star avoids pair-instability pulsation supernova
mass loss and may form a 70Msun BH in the direct collapse. Stars that can form
such BHs expand to significant size with radius of R>600Rsun, exceeding the
size of LB-1 orbit. Therefore, we can explain the formation of BHs upto 70Msun
at high metallicity and this result is independent from LB-1. However, if LB-1
hosts a massive BH we are unable to explain how such a binary star system could
have formed without invoking some exotic scenarios.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.11989 [pdf] - 2007368
A wide star-black-hole binary system from radial-velocity measurements
Liu, Jifeng;
Zhang, Haotong;
Howard, Andrew W.;
Bai, Zhongrui;
Lu, Youjun;
Soria, Roberto;
Justham, Stephen;
Li, Xiangdong;
Zheng, Zheng;
Wang, Tinggui;
Belczynski, Krzysztof;
Casares, Jorge;
Zhang, Wei;
Yuan, Hailong;
Dong, Yiqiao;
Lei, Yajuan;
Isaacson, Howard;
Wang, Song;
Bai, Yu;
Shao, Yong;
Gao, Qing;
Wang, Yilun;
Niu, Zexi;
Cui, Kaiming;
Zheng, Chuanjie;
Mu, Xiaoyong;
Zhang, Lan;
Wang, Wei;
Heger, Alexander;
Qi, Zhaoxiang;
Liao, Shilong;
Lattanzi, Mario;
Gu, Wei-Min;
Wang, Junfeng;
Wu, Jianfeng;
Shao, Lijing;
Shen, Rongfeng;
Wang, Xiaofeng;
Bregman, Joel;
Di Stefano, Rosanne;
Liu, Qingzhong;
Han, Zhanwen;
Zhang, Tianmeng;
Wang, Huijuan;
Ren, Juanjuan;
Zhang, Junbo;
Zhang, Jujia;
Wang, Xiaoli;
Cabrera-Lavers, Antonio;
Corradi, Romano;
Rebolo, Rafael;
Zhao, Yongheng;
Zhao, Gang;
Chu, Yaoquan;
Cui, Xiangqun
Submitted: 2019-11-27
All stellar mass black holes have hitherto been identified by X-rays emitted
by gas that is accreting onto the black hole from a companion star. These
systems are all binaries with black holes below 30 M$_{\odot}$$^{1-4}$. Theory
predicts, however, that X-ray emitting systems form a minority of the total
population of star-black hole binaries$^{5,6}$. When the black hole is not
accreting gas, it can be found through radial velocity measurements of the
motion of the companion star. Here we report radial velocity measurements of a
Galactic star, LB-1, which is a B-type star, taken over two years. We find that
the motion of the B-star and an accompanying H$\alpha$ emission line require
the presence of a dark companion with a mass of $68^{+11}_{-13}$ M$_{\odot}$,
which can only be a black hole. The long orbital period of 78.9 days shows that
this is a wide binary system. The gravitational wave experiments have detected
similarly massive black holes$^{7,8}$, but forming such massive ones in a
high-metallicity environment would be extremely challenging to current stellar
evolution theories$^{9-11}$.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.12874 [pdf] - 2026162
Mind the gap: The location of the lower edge of the pair instability
supernovae black hole mass gap
Submitted: 2019-10-28
Gravitational-wave detections are now starting to probe the mass distribution
of stellar-mass black holes (BHs). Robust predictions from stellar models are
needed to interpret these. Theory predicts the existence of a gap in the BH
mass distribution because of pair-instability supernova. The maximum BH mass
below the gap is the result of pulsational mass loss. We evolve massive helium
stars through their late hydrodynamical phases of evolution using the
open-source MESA stellar evolution code. We find that the location of the lower
edge of the mass gap at 45$M_\odot$ is remarkably robust against variations in
the metallicity ($\approx 3M_\odot$), the treatment of internal mixing
($\approx 1M_\odot$), stellar wind mass loss ($\approx 4M_\odot$), making it
the most robust predictions for the final stages of massive star evolution. The
reason is that the onset of the instability is dictated by the near-final core
mass, which in turn sets the resulting BH mass. However, varying
$^{12}C\left(\alpha,\gamma\right)^{16}O$ reaction rate within its $1\sigma$
uncertainties shifts the location of the gap between $40M_\odot$ and
$56M_\odot$. We provide updated analytic fits for population synthesis
simulations. Our results imply that the detection of merging BHs can provide
constraints on nuclear astrophysics. Furthermore, the robustness against
metallicity suggests that there is a universal maximum for the location of the
lower edge of the gap, which is insensitive to the formation environment and
redshift for first-generation BHs. This is promising for the possibility to use
the location of the gap as a "standard siren" across the Universe.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.00910 [pdf] - 1975255
STROOPWAFEL: Simulating rare outcomes from astrophysical populations,
with application to gravitational-wave sources
Submitted: 2019-05-02, last modified: 2019-09-10
Gravitational-wave observations of double compact object (DCO) mergers are
providing new insights into the physics of massive stars and the evolution of
binary systems. Making the most of expected near-future observations for
understanding stellar physics will rely on comparisons with binary population
synthesis models. However, the vast majority of simulated binaries never
produce DCOs, which makes calculating such populations computationally
inefficient. We present an importance sampling algorithm, STROOPWAFEL, that
improves the computational efficiency of population studies of rare events, by
focusing the simulation around regions of the initial parameter space found to
produce outputs of interest. We implement the algorithm in the binary
population synthesis code COMPAS, and compare the efficiency of our
implementation to the standard method of Monte Carlo sampling from the birth
probability distributions. STROOPWAFEL finds $\sim$25-200 times more DCO
mergers than the standard sampling method with the same simulation size, and so
speeds up simulations by up to two orders of magnitude. Finding more DCO
mergers automatically maps the parameter space with far higher resolution than
when using the traditional sampling. This increase in efficiency also leads to
a decrease of a factor $\sim$3-10 in statistical sampling uncertainty for the
predictions from the simulations. This is particularly notable for the
distribution functions of observable quantities such as the black hole and
neutron star chirp mass distribution, including in the tails of the
distribution functions where predictions using standard sampling can be
dominated by sampling noise.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.06687 [pdf] - 1979640
The diverse lives of progenitors of hydrogen-rich core-collapse
supernovae: the role of binary interaction
Zapartas, Emmanouil;
de Mink, Selma E.;
Justham, Stephen;
Smith, Nathan;
de Koter, Alex;
Renzo, Mathieu;
Arcavi, Iair;
Farmer, Rob;
Götberg, Ylva;
Toonen, Silvia
Submitted: 2019-07-15
Hydrogen-rich supernovae, known as Type II (SNe II), are the most common
class of explosions observed following the collapse of the core of massive
stars. We use analytical estimates and population synthesis simulations to
assess the fraction of SNe II progenitors that are expected to have exchanged
mass with a companion prior to explosion. We estimate that 1/3 to 1/2 of SN II
progenitors have a history of mass exchange with a binary companion before
exploding. The dominant binary channels leading to SN II progenitors involve
the merger of binary stars. Mergers are expected to produce a diversity of SN
II progenitor characteristics, depending on the evolutionary timing and
properties of the merger. Alternatively, SN II progenitors from interacting
binaries may have accreted mass from their companion, and subsequently been
ejected from the binary system after their companion exploded. We show that the
overall fraction of SN II progenitors that are predicted to have experienced
binary interaction is robust against the main physical uncertainties in our
models. However, the relative importance of different binary evolutionary
channels is affected by changing physical assumptions. We further discuss ways
in which binarity might contribute to the observed diversity of SNe II by
considering potential observational signatures arising from each binary
channel. For supernovae which have a substantial H-rich envelope at explosion
(i.e., excluding Type IIb SNe), a surviving non-compact companion would
typically indicate that the supernova progenitor star was in a wide,
non-interacting binary. We argue that a significant fraction of even Type II-P
SNe are expected to have gained mass from a companion prior to explosion.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.01066 [pdf] - 1929814
Clues on the Origin and Evolution of Massive Contact Binaries:
Atmosphere Analysis of VFTS 352
Abdul-Masih, Michael;
Sana, Hugues;
Sundqvist, Jon;
Mahy, Laurent;
Menon, Athira;
Almeida, Leonardo A.;
De Koter, Alex;
de Mink, Selma E.;
Justham, Stephen;
Langer, Norbert;
Puls, Joachim;
Shenar, Tomer;
Tramper, Frank
Submitted: 2019-06-03
The massive O4.5 V + O5.5 V binary VFTS 352 in the Tarantula nebula is one of
the shortest-period and most massive overcontact binaries known. Recent
theoretical studies indicate that some of these systems could ultimately lead
to the formation of gravitational waves via black hole binary mergers through
the chemically homogeneous evolution pathway. By analyzing ultraviolet-optical
phase-resolved spectroscopic data, we aim to constrain atmospheric and wind
properties that could be later used to confront theoretical predictions from
binary evolution. In particular, surface abundances are powerful diagnostics of
the evolutionary status, mass transfer and the internal mixing processes. From
a set of 32 VLT/FLAMES visual and 8 HST/COS ultraviolet spectra, we used
spectral disentangling to separate the primary and secondary components. Using
a genetic algorithm wrapped around the NLTE model atmosphere and spectral
synthesis code FASTWIND, we perform an 11-parameter optimization to derive the
atmospheric and wind parameters of both components, including the surface
abundances of He, C, N, O and Si. We find that both components are hotter than
expected compared to single-star evolutionary models indicating that additional
mixing processes may be at play. However the derived chemical abundances do not
show significant indications of mixing when adopting baseline values typical
for the system environment.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.02135 [pdf] - 1882557
Massive Stellar Mergers as Precursors of Hydrogen-rich Pulsational Pair
Instability Supernovae
Submitted: 2019-03-05, last modified: 2019-04-24
Interactions between massive stars in binaries are thought to be responsible
for much of the observed diversity of supernovae. As surveys probe rarer
populations of events, we should expect to see supernovae arising from
increasingly uncommon progenitor channels. Here we examine a scenario in which
massive stars merge after they have both formed a hydrogen-exhausted core. We
suggest this could produce stars which explode as pair-instability supernovae
(PISNe) with significantly more hydrogen, at a given metallicity, than in
single-star models with the same pre-explosion oxygen-rich core mass. We
investigate the subset of those stellar mergers which later produce pulsational
PISNe, and estimate that the rate of such post-merger, hydrogen-rich
pulsational PISNe could approach a few in a thousand of all core-collapse
supernovae. The nature and predicted rate of such hydrogen-rich pulsational
PISNe are reminiscent of the very unusual supernova iPTF14hls. For plausible
assumptions, PISNe from similar mergers might dominate the rate of PISNe in the
local Universe.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.09220 [pdf] - 1854201
Deeper, Wider, Sharper: Next-Generation Ground-Based Gravitational-Wave
Observations of Binary Black Holes
Kalogera, Vassiliki;
Berry, Christopher P L;
Colpi, Monica;
Fairhurst, Steve;
Justham, Stephen;
Mandel, Ilya;
Mangiagli, Alberto;
Mapelli, Michela;
Mills, Cameron;
Sathyaprakash, B. S.;
Schneider, Raffaella;
Tauris, Thomas;
Valiante, Rosa
Submitted: 2019-03-21
Next-generation observations will revolutionize our understanding of binary
black holes and will detect new sources, such as intermediate-mass black holes.
Primary science goals include: Discover binary black holes throughout the
observable Universe; Reveal the fundamental properties of black holes; Uncover
the seeds of supermassive black holes.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.09164 [pdf] - 1867947
Massive runaways and walkaway stars
Submitted: 2018-04-24, last modified: 2019-03-04
Anticipating the kinematic constraints from the Gaia mission, we perform an
extensive numerical study of the evolution of massive binary systems to predict
the peculiar velocities that stars obtain when their companion collapses and
disrupts the system. Our aim is to (1) identify which predictions are robust
against model uncertainties and assess their implications, (2) investigate
which physical processes leave a clear imprint and may therefore be constrained
observationally and (3) provide a suite of publicly available model
predictions. We find that $22_{-8}^{+26}$% of all massive binary systems merge
prior to the first core collapse in the system. Of the remainder,
$86_{-9}^{+11}$% become unbound because of the core-collapse. Remarkably, this
rarely produce runaway stars (i.e., stars with velocities above 30 km/s). These
are outnumbered by more than an order of magnitude by slower unbound
companions, or "walkaway stars". This is a robust outcome of our simulations
and is due to the reversal of the mass ratio prior to the explosion and
widening of the orbit, as we show analytically and numerically. We estimate a
$10^{+5}_{-8}$% of massive stars to be walkaways and only $0.5^{+1.0}_{-0.4}$%
to be runaways, nearly all of which have accreted mass from their companion.
Our findings are consistent with earlier studies, however the low runaway
fraction we find is in tension with observed fractions 10%. If Gaia confirms
these high fractions of massive runaway stars resulting from binaries, it would
imply that we are currently missing physics in the binary models. Finally, we
show that high end of the mass distributions of runaway stars is very sensitive
to the assumed black hole natal kicks and propose this as a potentially
stringent test for the explosion mechanism. We discuss companions remaining
bound which can evolve into X-ray and gravitational wave sources.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.00055 [pdf] - 1838115
No surviving stellar companion for Cassiopeia A
Kerzendorf, Wolfgang E.;
Do, Tuan;
de Mink, Selma E.;
Götberg, Ylva;
Millisaljevic, Dan;
Zapartas, Emmanouil;
Renzo, Mathieu;
Justham, Stephen;
Podsiadlowski, Philipp;
Fesen, Robert A.
Submitted: 2017-10-31, last modified: 2018-12-05
Massive stars in binaries can give rise to extreme phenomena such as X-ray
binaries and gravitational wave sources after one or both stars end their lives
as core-collapse supernovae. Stars in close orbit around a stellar or compact
companion are expected to explode as "stripped-envelope supernovae", showing no
(Type Ib/c) or little (Type IIb) signs of hydrogen in the spectra, because
hydrogen-rich progenitors are too large to fit. The physical processes
responsible for the stripping process and the fate of the companion are still
very poorly understood.
Aiming to find new clues, we investigate Cas~A, which is a very young
($\sim$340 \,yr) and near ($\sim$3.4\,kpc) remnant of a core collapse
supernova. Cas~A has been subject to several searches for possible companions,
all unsuccessfully. We present new measurements of the proper motions and
photometry of stars in the vicinity based on deep HST ACS/WFC and WFC3-IR data.
We identify stellar sources that are close enough in projection, but using
their proper motions we show that none are compatible with being at the
location of center at the time of explosion, in agreement with earlier
findings.
Our photometric measurements allow us to place much deeper (order of
magnitude) upper limits on the brightness of possible undetected companions. We
systematically compare them with model predictions for a wide variety of
scenarios. We can confidently rule out the presence of any stellar companion of
any reasonable mass and age (main sequence, pre main sequence or stripped).
Although this finding is not in direct conflict with model predictions, it does
rule out what many considered to be the most likely evolutionary scenario for
type IIb supernova. (abstract abbreviated)
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.05650 [pdf] - 1779707
Gaia and HST astrometry of the very massive $\sim$150 $M_\odot$
candidate runaway star VFTS682
Renzo, M.;
de Mink, S. E.;
Lennon, D. J.;
Platais, I.;
van der Marel, R. P.;
Laplace, E.;
Bestenlehner, J. M.;
Evans, C. J.;
Hénault-Brunet, V.;
Justham, S.;
de Koter, A.;
Langer, N.;
Najarro, F.;
Schneider, F. R. N.;
Vink, J. S.
Submitted: 2018-10-12
How very massive stars form is still an open question in astrophysics.
VFTS682 is among the most massive stars known, with an inferred initial mass of
$\sim$150 $M_\odot$ . It is located in 30 Doradus at a projected distance of 29
pc from the central cluster R136. Its apparent isolation led to two hypotheses:
either it formed in relative isolation or it was ejected dynamically from the
cluster. We investigate the kinematics of VFTS682 as obtained by Gaia and
Hubble Space Telescope astrometry. We derive a projected velocity relative to
the cluster of $38 \pm 17 \mathrm{km \ s^{-1}}$ (1$\sigma$ confidence
interval). Although the error bars are substantial, two independent measures
suggest that VFTS682 is a runaway ejected from the central cluster. This
hypothesis is further supported by a variety of circumstantial clues. The
central cluster is known to harbor other stars more massive than 150 $M_\odot$
of similar spectral type and recent astrometric studies on VFTS16 and VFTS72
provide direct evidence that the cluster can eject some of its most massive
members, in agreement with theoretical predictions. If future data confirm the
runaway nature, this would make VFTS682 the most massive runaway star known to
date.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.07974 [pdf] - 1751831
On the formation history of Galactic double neutron stars
Vigna-Gómez, Alejandro;
Neijssel, Coenraad J.;
Stevenson, Simon;
Barrett, Jim W.;
Belczynski, Krzysztof;
Justham, Stephen;
de Mink, Selma E.;
Müller, Bernhard;
Podsiadlowski, Philipp;
Renzo, Mathieu;
Szécsi, Dorottya;
Mandel, Ilya
Submitted: 2018-05-21, last modified: 2018-09-06
Double neutron stars (DNSs) have been observed as Galactic radio pulsars, and
the recent discovery of gravitational waves from the DNS merger GW170817 adds
to the known DNS population. We perform rapid population synthesis of massive
binary stars and discuss model predictions, including formation rates, mass
distributions, and delay time distributions. We vary assumptions and parameters
of physical processes such as mass transfer stability criteria, supernova kick
distributions, remnant mass distributions and common-envelope energetics. We
compute the likelihood of observing the orbital period-eccentricity
distribution of the Galactic DNS population under each of our population
synthesis models, allowing us to quantitatively compare the models. We find
that mass transfer from a stripped post-helium-burning secondary (case BB) onto
a neutron star is most likely dynamically stable. We also find that a natal
kick distribution composed of both low (Maxwellian $\sigma=30\rm~km~s^{-1}$)
and high ($\sigma=265\rm~km~s^{-1}$) components is preferred over a single
high-kick component. We find that the observed DNS mass distribution can place
strong constraints on model assumptions.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.08457 [pdf] - 1583794
Episodic mass ejections from common-envelope objects
Submitted: 2017-05-23
After the initial fast spiral-in phase experienced by a common-envelope
binary, the system may enter a slow, self-regulated phase, possibly lasting
100s of years, in which all the energy released by orbital decay can be
efficiently transported to the surface, where it is radiated away. If the
remaining envelope is to be removed during this phase, this removal must occur
through some as-yet-undetermined mechanism. We carried out 1-d hydrodynamic
simulations of a low-mass red giant undergoing a synthetic common-envelope
event in such a slow spiral-in phase, using the stellar evolutionary code MESA.
We simulated the heating of the envelope due to frictional dissipation from a
binary companion's orbit in multiple configurations and investigated the
response of the giant's envelope. We find that our model envelopes become
dynamically unstable and develop large-amplitude pulsations, with periods in
the range 3-20 years and very short growth time-scales of similar order. The
shocks and associated rebounds that emerge as these pulsations grow are in some
cases strong enough to dynamically eject shells of matter of up to 0.1
$\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$, $\sim 10$ % of the mass of the envelope, from the stellar
surface at above escape velocity. These ejections are seen to repeat within a
few decades, leading to a time-averaged mass-loss rate of order $10^{-3}$
$\mathrm{M}_{\odot} \: \mathrm{yr}^{-1}$ which is sufficiently high to
represent a candidate mechanism for removing the entire envelope over the
duration of the slow spiral-in phase.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.04464 [pdf] - 1475487
Time-Variable Aluminum Absorption in the Polar AR Ursae Majoris, and an
Updated Estimate for the Mass of the White Dwarf
Submitted: 2016-08-15
We present spectra of the extreme polar AR Ursae Majoris (AR UMa) which
display a clear Al I absorption doublet, alongside spectra taken less than a
year earlier in which that feature is not present. Re-examination of earlier
SDSS spectra indicates that the Al I absorption doublet was also present
$\approx$8 years before our first non-detection. We conclude that this
absorbing material is unlikely to be on the surface of either the white dwarf
(WD) or the donor star. We suggest that this Al I absorption feature arises in
circumstellar material, perhaps produced by the evaporation of asteroids as
they approach the hot WD. The presence of any remaining reservoir of rocky
material in AR UMa might help to constrain the prior evolution of this unusual
binary system. We also apply spectral decomposition to find the stellar
parameters of the M dwarf companion, and attempt to dynamically measure the
mass of the WD in AR UMa by considering both the radial velocity curves of the
H$_\beta$ emission line and the Na I absorption line. Thereby we infer a mass
range for the WD in AR UMa of 0.91 $M_{\odot}$ $<$ $M_{\mathrm{WD}}$ $<$ 1.24
$M_{\odot}$.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.09200 [pdf] - 1323639
Relativistic baryonic jets from an ultraluminous supersoft X-ray source
Liu, Ji-Feng;
Bai, Yu;
Wang, Song;
Justham, Stephen;
Lu, You-Jun;
Gu, Wei-Min;
Liu, Qing-Zhong;
Di Stefano, Rosanne;
Guo, Jin-Cheng;
Cabrera-Lavers, Antonio;
Alvarez, Pedro;
Cao, Yi;
Kulkarni, Shri
Submitted: 2015-11-30, last modified: 2015-12-07
The formation of relativistic jets by an accreting compact object is one of
the fundamental mysteries of astrophysics. While the theory is poorly
understood, observations of relativistic jets from systems known as
microquasars have led to a well-established phenomenology. Relativistic jets
are not expected from sources with soft or supersoft X-ray spectra, although
two such systems are known to produce relatively low-velocity bipolar outflows.
Here we report optical spectra of an ultraluminous supersoft X-ray source (ULS)
in the nearby galaxy M81 (M81 ULS-1) showing blueshifted broad H\alpha\
emission lines, characteristic of baryonic jets with relativistic speeds. The
time variable jets have projected velocities ~17 per cent of the speed of
light, and seem similar to those in the prototype microquasar SS 433. Such
relativistic jets are not expected to be launched from white dwarfs, but an
origin from a black hole or neutron star in M81 ULS-1 is hard to reconcile with
its constant soft X-rays. The completely unexpected presence of relativistic
jets in a ULS challenges the canonical theories for jet formation, but may
possibly be explained by a long speculated super-critically accreting black
hole with optically thick outflows
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.06046 [pdf] - 1265834
Globular cluster formation efficiencies from black-hole X-ray binary
feedback
Submitted: 2015-08-25
We investigate a scenario in which feedback from black-hole X-ray binaries
(BHXBs) sometimes begins inside young star clusters before strong supernova
feedback. Those BHXBs could reduce the gas fraction inside embedded young
clusters whilst maintaining virial equilibrium, which may help globular
clusters (GCs) to stay bound when supernova-driven gas ejection subsequently
occurs. Adopting a simple toy model with parameters guided by BHXB population
models, we produce GC formation efficiencies consistent with
empirically-inferred values. The metallicity dependence of BHXB formation could
naturally explain why GC formation efficiency is higher at lower metallicity.
For reasonable assumptions about that metallicity dependence, our toy model can
produce a GC metallicity bimodality in some galaxies without a bimodality in
the field-star metallicity distribution.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.6847 [pdf] - 1264576
Another thread in the tapestry of stellar feedback: X-ray binaries
Submitted: 2012-03-30, last modified: 2015-08-24
We consider X-ray binaries (XBs) as potential sources of stellar feedback.
XBs observationally appear able to deposit a high fraction of their power
output into their local interstellar medium, which may make them a
non-negligible source of energy input. The formation rate of the most luminous
XBs rises with decreasing metallicity, which should increase their significance
during galaxy formation in the early universe. We also argue that stochastic
effects are important to XB feedback (XBF) and may dominate the systematic
changes due to metallicity in many cases. Large stochastic variation in the
magnitude of XBF at low absolute star formation rates provides a natural reason
for diversity in the evolution of dwarf galaxies which were initially almost
identical, with several percent of such halos experiencing energy input from
XBs roughly two orders of magnitude above the most likely value. These
probability distributions suggest that the effect of XBF is most commonly
significant for total stellar masses between ~10^7 and 10^8 Msun, which might
resolve a current problem with modelling populations of such galaxies. We
explain how XBs might inject energy before luminous supernovae (SNe) contribute
significantly to feedback and how XBs can assist in keeping gas hot long after
the last core-collapse SN has exploded. [...] XBF could be especially important
to some dwarf galaxies, potentially heating gas without expelling it; the
properties of XBF also match those previously derived as allowing episodic star
formation. We also argue that the efficiency of SN feedback (SNF) might be
reduced when XBF has had the opportunity to act first. In addition, we note
that the effect of SNF is unlikely to be scale-free; galaxies smaller than ~100
pc might well experience less effective SNF. (Slightly abbreviated to fit arXiv
size limit.)
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.2426 [pdf] - 1222487
Luminous Blue Variables and superluminous supernovae from binary mergers
Submitted: 2014-10-09
Evidence suggests that the direct progenitor stars of some core-collapse
supernovae (CCSNe) are luminous blue variables (LBVs), perhaps including some
`superluminous supernovae' (SLSNe). We examine models in which massive stars
gain mass soon after the end of core hydrogen burning. These are mainly
intended to represent mergers following a brief contact phase during early Case
B mass transfer, but may also represent stars which gain mass in the
Hertzsprung Gap or extremely late during the main-sequence phase for other
reasons. The post-accretion stars spend their core helium-burning phase as blue
supergiants (BSGs), and many examples are consistent with being LBVs at the
time of core collapse. Other examples are yellow supergiants at explosion. We
also investigate whether such post-accretion stars may explode successfully
after core collapse. The final core properties of post-accretion models are
broadly similar to those of single stars with the same initial mass as the
pre-merger primary star. More surprisingly, when early Case B accretion does
affect the final core properties, the effect appears likely to favour a
successful SN explosion, i.e., to make the core properties more like those of a
lower-mass single star. However, the detailed structures of these cores
sometimes display qualitative differences to any single-star model we have
calculated. The rate of appropriate binary mergers may match the rate of SNe
with immediate LBV progenitors; for moderately optimistic assumptions we
estimate that the progenitor birthrate is ~1% of the CCSN rate.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.3260 [pdf] - 1216880
On the role of recombination in common-envelope ejections
Submitted: 2014-09-10
The energy budget in common-envelope events (CEEs) is not well understood,
with substantial uncertainty even over to what extent the recombination energy
stored in ionised hydrogen and helium might be used to help envelope ejection.
We investigate the reaction of a red-giant envelope to heating which mimics
limiting cases of energy input provided by the orbital decay of a binary during
a CEE, specifically during the post-plunge-in phase during which the spiral-in
has been argued to occur on a time-scale longer than dynamical. We show that
the outcome of such a CEE depends less on the total amount of energy by which
the envelope is heated than on how rapidly the energy was transferred to the
envelope and on where the envelope was heated. The envelope always becomes
dynamically unstable before receiving net heat energy equal to the envelope's
initial binding energy. We find two types of outcome, both of which likely lead
to at least partial envelope ejection: "runaway" solutions in which the
expansion of the radius becomes undeniably dynamical, and superficially
"self-regulated" solutions, in which the expansion of the stellar radius stops
but a significant fraction of the envelope becomes formally dynamically
unstable. Almost the entire reservoir of initial helium recombination energy is
used for envelope expansion. Hydrogen recombination is less energetically
useful, but is nonetheless important for the development of the dynamical
instabilities. However, this result requires the companion to have already
plunged deep into the envelope; therefore this release of recombination energy
does not help to explain wide post-common-envelope orbits.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.2896 [pdf] - 884566
On the evolution of rotating accreting white dwarfs and type Ia
supernovae
Submitted: 2014-09-09
The potential importance of the angular momentum which is gained by accreting
white dwarfs (WDs) has been increasingly recognized in the context of type Ia
supernova (SN Ia) single-degenerate model. The expectation that the spin of the
WD can delay the explosion should help the single-degenerate model to be
consistent with the observed properties of most SNe Ia, in particular by
avoiding hydrogen contamination. In this article, we attempt to study the most
prominent single-degenerate supersoft (WD + MS) channel when the rotation of
accreting WDs is considered. We present a detailed binary population synthesis
study to examine the predicted population of SNe Ia for this channel. For our
standard model, we find that 77% of these SNe Ia explode with WD masses which
are low enough to be supported by solid-body rotation (1.378-1.5Msun); this is
a substantially higher proportion than found by previous work. Only 2% have WD
explosion masses >2.0Msun; these require the initial WD mass to be larger than
1.0 Msun. We further discuss the possible origin of the diversity of SNe Ia
from the pre- and post- accretion properties of the WDs in this population. We
also suggest that some SN Ia progenitors with substantial circumstellar
hydrogen, including some apparent type IIn SNe, might be related to WDs which
required support from differential rotation to avoid explosion, since these can
still be accreting from hydrogen-rich donors with a relatively high
mass-transfer rate at the time of the SN explosion.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.7105 [pdf] - 1209781
The binarity of Milky Way F,G,K stars as a function of effective
temperature and metallicity
Submitted: 2014-05-27, last modified: 2014-06-08
We estimate the fraction of F,G,K stars with close binary companions by
analysing multi-epoch stellar spectra from SDSS and LAMOST for radial velocity
(RV) variations. We employ a Bayesian method to infer the maximum likelihood of
the fraction of binary stars with orbital periods of 1000 days or shorter,
assuming a simple model distribution for a binary population with circular
orbits. The overall inferred fraction of stars with such a close binary
companion is 43.0% \pm 2.0% for a sample of F, G, K stars from SDSS SEGUE, and
30% \pm 8.0% in a similar sample from LAMOST. The apparent close binary
fraction decreases with the stellar effective temperature. We divide the SEGUE
and LEGUE data into three subsamples with different metallicity ([Fe/H] < -1.1;
-1.1 < [Fe/H] < -0.6; -0.6 < [Fe/H]), for which the inferred close binary
fractions are 56% \pm 5.0%, 56.0% \pm 3%, and 30% \pm 5.7%. The metal-rich
stars from our sample are therefore substantially less likely to possess a
close binary companion than otherwise similar stars drawn from metal-poor
populations. The different ages and formation environments of the Milky Way's
thin disk, thick disk and halo may contribute to explaining these observations.
Alternatively metallicity may have a significant effect on the formation and/or
evolution of binary stars.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.0553 [pdf] - 1209899
SDSSJ001153.08-064739.2, a cataclysmic variable with an evolved donor in
the period gap
Submitted: 2014-06-02
Secondary stars in cataclysmic variables (CVs) follow a well defined
period-density relation. Thus, canonical donor stars in CVs are generally
low-mass stars of spectral type M. However, several CVs have been observed
containing secondary stars which are too hot for their inferred masses. This
particular configuration can be explained if the donor stars in these systems
underwent significant nuclear evolution before they reached contact. In this
paper we present SDSSJ001153.08-064739.2 as an additional example belonging to
this peculiar type of CV and discuss in detail its evolutionary history. We
perform spectroscopic and photometric observations and make use of available
Catalina Real-Time Transient Survey photometry to measure the orbital period of
SDSSJ001153.08-064739.2 as 2.4 hours and estimate the white dwarf
(Mwd>0.65Msun) and donor star (0.21Msun<Mdon<0.45Msun) masses, the mass ratio
(q = 0.32 +- 0.08), the orbital inclination (47 degrees < i < 70 degrees),
derive an accurate orbital ephemeris (T0 = 2453383.578 + E x 0.10028081), and
report the detection of an outburst. We show that SDSSJ001153.08-064739.2 is
one of the most extreme cases in which the donor star is clearly too hot for
its mass. SDSSJ001153.08-064739.2 is therefore not only a peculiar CV
containing an evolved donor star but also an accreting CV within the period
gap. Intriguingly, approximately half of the total currently-observed sample of
these peculiar CVs are located in the period gap with nearly the same orbital
period.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.0337 [pdf] - 753534
Puzzling accretion onto a black hole in the ultraluminous X-ray source
M101 ULX-1
Submitted: 2013-12-02
There are two proposed explanations for ultraluminous X-ray sources (ULXs)
with luminosities in excess of $10^{39}$ erg s$^{-1}$. They could be
intermediate-mass black holes (more than 100-1,000, solar masses, $M_\odot$)
radiating at sub-maximal (sub-Eddington) rates, as in Galactic black-hole X-ray
binaries but with larger, cooler accretion disks. Alternatively, they could be
stellar-mass black holes radiating at Eddington or super-Eddington rates. On
its discovery, M101 ULX-1 had a luminosity of $3\times10^{39}$ erg s$^{-1}$ and
a supersoft thermal disk spectrum with an exceptionally low temperature --
uncomplicated by photons energized by a corona of hot electrons -- more
consistent with the expected appearance of an accreting intermediate-mass black
hole. Here we report optical spectroscopic monitoring of M101 ULX-1. We confirm
the previous suggestion that the system contains a Wolf-Rayet star, and reveal
that the orbital period is 8.2 days. The black hole has a minimum mass of
$5M_\odot$, and more probably a mass of $20-30M_\odot$, but we argue that it is
very unlikely to be an intermediate-mass black hole. Therefore its
exceptionally soft spectra at high Eddinton ratios violate the expectations for
accretion onto stellar-mass black holes. Accretion must occur from captured
stellar wind, which has hitherto been thought to be so inefficient that it
could not power an ultraluminous source.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.2297 [pdf] - 750256
Producing type Iax supernovae from a specific class of helium-ignited WD
explosions?
Submitted: 2013-10-08
It has recently been proposed that one sub-class of type Ia supernovae (SNe
Ia) is sufficiently both distinct and common to be classified separately from
the bulk of SNe Ia, with a suggested class name of "type Iax supernovae" (SNe
Iax), after SN 2002cx. However, their progenitors are still uncertain. We study
whether the population properties of this class might be understood if the
events originate from a subset of sub-Chandrasekhar mass explosions. In this
potential progenitor population, a carbon--oxygen white dwarf (CO WD)
accumulates a helium layer from a non-degenerate helium star; ignition of that
helium layer then leads to ignition of the CO WD. We incorporated detailed
binary evolution calculations for the progenitor systems into a binary
population synthesis model to obtain rates and delay times for such events. The
predicted Galactic event rate of these explosions is ~1.5\times10^{-3}{yr}^{-1}
according to our standard model, in good agreement with the measured rates of
SNe Iax. In addition, predicted delay times are ~70Myr-800Myr, consistent with
the fact that most of SNe Iax have been discovered in late-type galaxies. If
the explosions are assumed to be double-detonations -- following current model
expectations -- then based on the CO WD masses at explosion we also estimate
the distribution of resulting SN brightness (-13 \gtrsim M_{bol} \gtrsim
-19mag), which can reproduce the empirical diversity of SNe Iax. We speculate
on why binaries with non-degenerate donor stars might lead to SNe Iax if
similar systems with degenerate donors do not. We suggest that the high mass of
the helium layer necessary for ignition at the lower accretion rates typically
delivered from non-degenerate donors might be necessary to produce SN
2002cx-like characteristics, perhaps even by changing the nature of the CO
ignition.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.1047 [pdf] - 1158845
Double-detonation explosions as progenitors of type Iax supernovae
Submitted: 2013-01-06, last modified: 2013-07-11
It has recently been proposed that one sub-class of type Ia supernovae (SNe
Ia) is sufficiently both distinct and common to be classified separately from
the bulk of SNe Ia, with a suggested class name of "type Iax supernovae" (SNe
Iax), after SN 2002cx. We show that the population properties of this class can
be understood if the events originate from helium double-detonation
sub-Chandrasekhar mass explosions, in which a carbon--oxygen white dwarf (CO
WD) accumulates a helium layer from a non-degenerate helium star. We have
incorporated detailed binary evolution calculations for the progenitor systems
into a binary population synthesis model to obtain birthrates and delay times
for such events. The predicted Galactic event rate is $\sim$$0.6-1.8\times
10^{-3}\,{\rm yr}^{-1}$, in good agreement with the measured rates of SNe Iax.
In addition, predicted delay times are $\sim$70\,Myr$-$710\,Myr, consistent
with the fact that SNe Iax have so far only been discovered in late-type
galaxies. Based on the CO WD mass at explosion and previous detonation models,
we also estimate the distribution of resulting SN brightness ($-13 \gtrsim
M_{\rm bol} \gtrsim -19$ mag), which can reproduce the empirical diversity of
SNe Iax. We speculate on why binaries with non-degenerate donor stars might
lead to SNe Iax if similar systems with degenerate donors do not and suggest
that the higher mass of the helium layer necessary for ignition at the lower
accretion rates typically delivered from non-degenerate donors might provide
the explanation.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.5897 [pdf] - 951760
Identification of the Long-Sought Common-Envelope Events
Submitted: 2013-01-24
Common-envelope events (CEEs), during which two stars temporarily orbit
within a shared envelope, are believed to be vital for the formation of a wide
range of close binaries. For decades, the only evidence that CEEs actually
occur has been indirect, based on the existence of systems that could not be
otherwise explained. Here we propose a direct observational signature of CEE
arising from a physical model where emission from matter ejected in a CEE is
controlled by a recombination front as the matter cools. The natural range of
timescales and energies from this model, as well the expected colors,
light-curve shapes, ejection velocities and event rate, match those of a
recently-recognized class of red transient outbursts.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.4302 [pdf] - 1151501
Common Envelope Evolution: Where we stand and how we can move forward
Ivanova, N.;
Justham, S.;
Chen, X.;
De Marco, O.;
Fryer, C. L.;
Gaburov, E.;
Ge, H.;
Glebbeek, E.;
Han, Z.;
Li, X. -D.;
Lu, G.;
Marsh, T.;
Podsiadlowski, Ph.;
Potter, A.;
Soker, N.;
Taam, R.;
Tauris, T. M.;
Heuvel, E. P. J. van den;
Webbink, R. F.
Submitted: 2012-09-19, last modified: 2012-12-06
This work aims to present our current best physical understanding of
common-envelope evolution (CEE). We highlight areas of consensus and
disagreement, and stress ideas which should point the way forward for progress
in this important but long-standing and largely unconquered problem. Unusually
for CEE-related work, we mostly try to avoid relying on results from population
synthesis or observations, in order to avoid potentially being misled by
previous misunderstandings. As far as possible we debate all the relevant
issues starting from physics alone, all the way from the evolution of the
binary system immediately before CEE begins to the processes which might occur
just after the ejection of the envelope. In particular, we include extensive
discussion about the energy sources and sinks operating in CEE, and hence
examine the foundations of the standard energy formalism. Special attention is
also given to comparing the results of hydrodynamic simulations from different
groups and to discussing the potential effect of initial conditions on the
differences in the outcomes. We compare current numerical techniques for the
problem of CEE and also whether more appropriate tools could and should be
produced (including new formulations of computational hydrodynamics, and
attempts to include 3D processes within 1D codes). Finally we explore new ways
to link CEE with observations. We compare previous simulations of CEE to the
recent outburst from V1309 Sco, and discuss to what extent post-common-envelope
binaries and nebulae can provide information, e.g. from binary eccentricities,
which is not currently being fully exploited.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.4913 [pdf] - 1052318
Single-degenerate type Ia supernovae without hydrogen contamination
Submitted: 2011-02-24, last modified: 2011-02-28
The lack of hydrogen in spectra of type Ia supernovae (SN Ia) is often seen
as troublesome for single-degenerate (SD) progenitor models. We argue that,
since continued accretion of angular momentum can prevent explosion of the
white dwarf, it may be natural for the donor stars in SD progenitors of SN Ia
to exhaust their envelopes and shrink rapidly before the explosion. This
outcome seems most likely for SD SN Ia progenitors where mass-transfer begins
from a giant donor star, and might extend to other SD systems. Not only is the
amount of hydrogen left in such a system below the current detection limit, but
the donor star is typically orders of magnitude smaller than its Roche lobe by
the point when a SD SN Ia occurs, in which case attempts to observe collisions
between SN shocks and giant donor stars seem unlikely to succeed. We consider
the constraints on this model from the circumstellar structures seen in spectra
of SN 2006X and suggest a novel explanation for the origin of this material.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.4391 [pdf] - 1033256
Sub-Chandrasekhar White Dwarf Mergers as the Progenitors of Type Ia
Supernovae
Submitted: 2010-06-22, last modified: 2010-09-10
Type Ia supernovae are generally thought to be due to the thermonuclear
explosions of carbon-oxygen white dwarfs with masses near the Chandrasekhar
mass. This scenario, however, has two long-standing problems. First, the
explosions do not naturally produce the correct mix of elements, but have to be
finely tuned to proceed from sub-sonic deflagration to super-sonic detonation.
Second, population models and observations give formation rates of
near-Chandrasekhar white dwarfs that are far too small. Here, we suggest that
type Ia supernovae instead result from mergers of roughly equal-mass
carbon-oxygen white dwarfs, including those that produce sub-Chandrasekhar mass
remnants. Numerical studies of such mergers have shown that the remnants
consist of rapidly rotating cores that contain most of the mass and are hottest
in the center, surrounded by dense, small disks. We argue that the disks
accrete quickly, and that the resulting compressional heating likely leads to
central carbon ignition. This ignition occurs at densities for which pure
detonations lead to events similar to type Ia supernovae. With this merger
scenario, we can understand the type Ia rates, and have plausible reasons for
the observed range in luminosity and for the bias of more luminous supernovae
towards younger populations. We speculate that explosions of white dwarfs
slowly brought to the Chandrasekhar limit---which should also occur---are
responsible for some of the "atypical" type Ia supernovae.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.1584 [pdf] - 1034191
On the formation of single and binary helium-rich sdO stars
Submitted: 2010-08-09
We propose a formation channel for the previously unexplained helium-rich
subdwarf O (He-rich sdO) stars in which post-subdwarf B (sdB) stars (i.e.
hybrid COHe white dwarfs) reignite helium burning in a shell after gaining
matter from their helium white-dwarf (WD) companions. Such short-period
binaries containing post-sdB WDs and helium WDs are predicted by one of the
major binary formation channels for sdB stars. In the majority of cases, mass
transfer is expected to lead to a dynamically unstable merger event, leaving a
single-star remnant. Calculations of the evolution of these stars show that
their properties are consistent with the observed He-rich sdO stars. The
luminosity of these stars is about an order of magnitude higher than that of
canonical sdB stars. We also suggest that binary systems such as PG 1544+488
(Ahmad et al. 2004) and HE 0301-3039 (Lisker et al. 2004), which each contain
two hot subdwarfs, could be the outcome of a double-core common-envelope phase.
Since this favours intermediate-mass progenitors, this may also explain why the
subdwarfs in these systems are He-rich.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.4539 [pdf] - 155129
Observations of Doppler Boosting in Kepler Lightcurves
Submitted: 2010-01-26, last modified: 2010-04-26
Among the initial results from Kepler were two striking lightcurves, for KOI
74 and KOI 81, in which the relative depths of the primary and secondary
eclipses showed that the more compact, less luminous object was hotter than its
stellar host. That result became particularly intriguing because a substellar
mass had been derived for the secondary in KOI 74, which would make the high
temperature challenging to explain; in KOI 81, the mass range for the companion
was also reported to be consistent with a substellar object. We re-analyze the
Kepler data and demonstrate that both companions are likely to be white dwarfs.
We also find that the photometric data for KOI 74 show a modulation in
brightness as the more luminous star orbits, due to Doppler boosting. The
magnitude of the effect is sufficiently large that we can use it to infer a
radial velocity amplitude accurate to 1 km/s. As far as we are aware, this is
the first time a radial-velocity curve has been measured photometrically.
Combining our velocity amplitude with the inclination and primary mass derived
from the eclipses and primary spectral type, we infer a secondary mass of
0.22+/-0.03 Msun. We use our estimates to consider the likely evolutionary
paths and mass-transfer episodes of these binary systems.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.0249 [pdf] - 1026076
Explosive Common-Envelope Ejection: Implications for Gamma-Ray Bursts
and Low-Mass Black-Hole Binaries
Submitted: 2010-04-01
We present a new mechanism for the ejection of a common envelope in a massive
binary, where the energy source is nuclear energy rather than orbital energy.
This can occur during the slow merger of a massive primary with a secondary of
1-3 Msun when the primary has already completed helium core burning. We show
that, in the final merging phase, hydrogen-rich material from the secondary can
be injected into the helium-burning shell of the primary. This leads to a
nuclear runaway and the explosive ejection of both the hydrogen and the helium
layer, producing a close binary containing a CO star and a low-mass companion.
We argue that this presents a viable scenario to produce short-period
black-hole binaries and long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs). We estimate a
LGRB rate of about 1.e-6 per year at solar metallicity, which implies that this
may account for a significant fraction of all LGRBs, and that this rate should
be higher at lower metallicity.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.0003 [pdf] - 902257
Heavily Obscured AGN in Star-Forming Galaxies at z~2
Treister, E.;
Cardamone, C.;
Schawinski, K.;
Urry, C. M.;
Gawiser, E.;
Virani, S.;
Lira, P.;
Kartaltepe, J.;
Damen, M;
Taylor, E. N.;
Floc'h, E. Le;
Justham, Stephen;
Koekemoer, A.
Submitted: 2009-10-30
We study the properties of a sample of 211 heavily-obscured Active Galactic
Nucleus (AGN) candidates in the Extended Chandra Deep Field-South selecting
objects with f_24/f_R>1000 and R-K>4.5. Of these, 18 were detected in X-rays
and found to be obscured AGN with neutral hydrogen column densities of ~10^23
cm^-2. In the X-ray undetected sample, the following evidence suggests a large
fraction of heavily-obscured (Compton Thick) AGN: (i) The stacked X-ray signal
of the sample is strong, with an observed ratio of soft to hard X-ray counts
consistent with a population of ~90% heavily obscured AGN combined with 10%
star-forming galaxies. (ii) The X-ray to mid-IR ratios for these sources are
significantly larger than that of star-forming galaxies and ~2 orders of
magnitude smaller than for the general AGN population, suggesting column
densities of N_H>5x10^24 cm^-2. (iii) The Spitzer near- and mid-IR colors of
these sources are consistent with those of the X-ray-detected sample if the
effects of dust self-absorption are considered. Spectral fitting to the
rest-frame UV/optical light (dominated by the host galaxy) returns stellar
masses of ~10^11 M_sun and <E(B-V)> =0.5, and reveals evidence for a
significant young stellar population, indicating that these sources are
experiencing considerable star-formation. This sample of heavily-obscured AGN
candidates implies a space density at z~2 of ~10^-5 Mpc^-3, finding a strong
evolution in the number of L_X>10^44 erg/s sources from z=1.5 to 2.5, possibly
consistent with a short-lived heavily-obscured phase before an unobscured
quasar is visible.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:0811.2633 [pdf] - 18596
On type Ia supernovae and the formation of single low-mass white dwarfs
Submitted: 2008-11-17
There is still considerable debate over the progenitors of type Ia supernovae
(SNe Ia). Likewise, it is not agreed how single white dwarfs with masses less
than ~0.5 Msun can be formed in the field, even though they are known to exist.
We consider whether single low-mass white dwarfs (LMWDs) could have been formed
in binary systems where their companions have exploded as a SN Ia. In this
model, the observed single LMWDs are the remnants of giant-branch donor stars
whose envelopes have been stripped off by the supernova explosion. We
investigate the likely remnants of SNe Ia, including the effects of the
explosion on the envelope of the donor star. We also use evolutionary arguments
to examine alternative formation channels for single LMWDs. In addition, we
calculate the expected kinematics of the potential remnants of SNe Ia. SN Ia in
systems with giant-branch donor stars can naturally explain the production of
single LMWDs. It seems difficult for any other formation mechanism to account
for the observations, especially for those single LMWDs with masses less than
~0.4 Msun. Independent of those results, we find that the kinematics of one
potentially useful population containing single LMWDs is consistent with our
model. Studying remnant white-dwarf kinematics seems to be a promising way to
investigate SN Ia progenitors. The existence of single LMWDs appears to
constitute evidence for the production of SNe Ia in binary systems with a
red-giant donor star. Other single white dwarfs with higher space velocities
support a second, probably dominant, population of SN Ia progenitors which
contained main-sequence or subgiant donor stars at the time of explosion. The
runaway stars LP400-22 and US 708 suggest the possibility of a third formation
channnel for some SNe Ia in systems where the donor stars are hot subdwarfs.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:0803.3596 [pdf] - 11196
Supernova Shock Breakout from a Red Supergiant
Schawinski, Kevin;
Justham, Stephen;
Wolf, Christian;
Podsiadlowski, Philipp;
Sullivan, Mark;
Steenbrugge, Katrien C.;
Bell, Tony;
Roeser, Hermann-Josef;
Walker, Emma;
Astier, Pierre;
Balam, Dave;
Balland, Christophe;
Carlberg, Ray;
Conley, Alex;
Fouchez, Dominque;
Guy, Julien;
Hardin, Delphine;
Hook, Isobel;
Howell, Andy;
Pain, Reynald;
Perrett, Kathy;
Pritchet, Chris;
Regnault, Nicolas;
Yi, Sukyoung K.
Submitted: 2008-03-25, last modified: 2008-07-10
Massive stars undergo a violent death when the supply of nuclear fuel in
their cores is exhausted, resulting in a catastrophic "core-collapse"
supernova. Such events are usually only detected at least a few days after the
star has exploded. Observations of the supernova SNLS-04D2dc with the Galaxy
Evolution Explorer space telescope reveal a radiative precursor from the
supernova shock before the shock reached the surface of the star and show the
initial expansion of the star at the beginning of the explosion. Theoretical
models of the ultraviolet light curve confirm that the progenitor was a red
supergiant, as expected for this type of supernova. These observations provide
a way to probe the physics of core-collapse supernovae and the internal
structures of their progenitor stars
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:0708.3698 [pdf] - 4310
Upper limit for circumstellar gas around the Type Ia SN 2000cx
Patat, F.;
Benetti, S.;
Justham, S.;
Mazzali, P. A.;
Pasquini, L.;
Cappellaro, E.;
Della Valle, M.;
Podsiadlowski, Ph.;
Turatto, M.;
Gal-Yam, A.;
Simon, J. D.
Submitted: 2007-08-27
The nature of the companion stars in Type Ia Supernova (SNe) progenitor
systems remains unclear. One possible way to discriminate between different
scenarios is the presence (or absence) of circumstellar material, the left
overs from the progenitor evolution that may be revealed by their interaction
with the SN. A new method to probe the circumstellar environment has been
exploited for the normal Type Ia SN 2006X, leading for the first time to the
direct detection of material which escaped the progenitor system. In this paper
we apply the same analysis to the peculiar Type Ia SN 2000cx, with the aim of
constraining the properties of its progenitor system. Using multi-epoch,
high-resolution spectroscopy we have studied the spectral region where narrow,
time-variable NaID absorption features are expected in case circumstellar
material is present along the line of sight. No NaID absorption is detected in
the rest-frame of the host galaxy to a level of a few mA, setting a stringent
upper limit to the column density of the absorbing material (N(NaI)<=2 x 10^10
cm-2). In this respect the peculiar Type Ia SN 2000cx is different from the
normal Ia SN 2006X. Whether this is to be attributed to a different progenitor
system, to viewing-angle effects or to a low metallicity remains to be
clarified.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:0707.2793 [pdf] - 900183
Detection of circumstellar material in a normal Type Ia Supernova
Patat, F.;
Chandra, P.;
Chevalier, R.;
Justham, S.;
Podsiadlowski, Ph.;
Wolf, C.;
Gal-Yam, A.;
Pasquini, L.;
Crawford, I. A.;
Mazzali, P. A.;
Pauldrach, A. W. A.;
Nomoto, K.;
Benetti, S.;
Cappellaro, E.;
Elias-Rosa, N.;
Hillebrandt, W.;
Leonard, D. C.;
Pastorello, A.;
Renzini, A.;
Sabbadin, F.;
Simon, J. D.;
Turatto, M.
Submitted: 2007-07-18
Type Ia supernovae are thought to be thermonuclear explosions of accreting
white dwarfs that reach a critical mass limit. Despite their importance as
cosmological distance indicators, the nature of their progenitors has remained
controversial. Here we report the detection of circumstellar material in a
normal Type Ia supernova. The expansion velocities, densities and dimensions of
the circumstellar envelope indicate that this material was ejected from the
progenitor system. The relatively low expansion velocities appear to favor a
progenitor system where a white dwarf accretes material from a companion star
which is in the red-giant phase at the time of explosion.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0601128 [pdf] - 78986
Eclipsing binaries in extrasolar planet transit surveys: the case of
SuperWASP
Submitted: 2006-01-06
Using a comprehensive binary population synthesis scheme, we investigate the
statistical properties of a sample of eclipsing binaries that is detectable by
an idealised extrasolar planet transit survey with specifications broadly
similar to those of the SuperWASP (Wide Angle Search for Planets) project. In
this idealised survey the total number of detectable single stars in the
Galactic disc is of the order of 10^6-10^7, while, for a flat initial mass
ratio distribution, the total number of detectable eclipsing binaries is of the
order of 10^4-10^5. The majority of the population of detectable single stars
is made up of main-sequence stars (60%), horizontal-branch stars (20%), and
giant-branch stars (10%). The largest contributions to the population of
detectable eclipsing binaries stem from detached double main-sequence star
binaries (60%), detached giant-branch main-sequence star binaries (20%), and
detached horizontal-branch main-sequence star binaries (10%). The ratio of the
number of eclipsing binaries to the number of single stars detectable by the
idealised SuperWASP survey varies by less than a factor of 2.5 across the sky,
and decreases with increasing Galactic latitude. It is found to be largest in
the direction of the Galactic longitude l=-7.5deg and the Galactic latitude
b=-22.5deg. We also show that the fractions of systems in different subgroups
of eclipsing binaries are sensitive to the adopted initial mass ratio
distribution, which is one of the poorest constrained input parameters in
present-day binary population synthesis calculations. This suggests that once
statistically meaningful results from transit surveys are available, they will
be able to significantly improve the predictive power of population synthesis
studies of interacting binaries and related objects. (abridged)
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511760 [pdf] - 78118
Magnetic Braking of Ap/Bp Stars: Application to Compact Black-Hole X-Ray
Binaries
Submitted: 2005-11-28
We examine the proposal that the subset of neutron-star and black-hole X-ray
binaries that form with Ap or Bp star companions will experience systemic
angular-momentum losses due to magnetic braking, not otherwise operative with
intermediate-mass companion stars. We suggest that for donor stars possessing
the anomalously high magnetic fields associated with Ap and Bp stars, a
magnetically coupled, irradiation-driven stellar wind can lead to substantial
systemic loss of angular-momentum. In this paper we apply this mechanism to a
specific astrophysics problem involving the formation of compact black-hole
binaries with low-mass donor stars. At present, it is not understood how these
systems form, given that low-mass companion stars are not likely to provide
sufficient gravitational potential to unbind the envelope of the massive
progenitor of the black hole during a prior `common-envelope' phase. However,
in the absence of magnetic braking, such systems tend to evolve to long orbital
periods. We show that, with the proposed magnetic braking properties afforded
by Ap and Bp companions, such a scenario can lead to the formation of compact
black-hole binaries with orbital periods, donor masses, lifetimes, and
production rates that are in accord with the observations. In spite of these
successes, our models reveal a significant discrepancy between the calculated
effective temperatures and the observed spectral types of the donor stars.
Finally, we show that this temperature discrepancy would still exist for other
scenarios invoking initially intermediate-mass donor stars, and this presents a
substantial unresolved mystery.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511393 [pdf] - 77751
Models of Ultraluminous X-Ray Sources with Intermediate-Mass Black Holes
Submitted: 2005-11-14
We have computed models for ultraluminous X-ray sources ("ULXs") consisting
of a black-hole accretor of intermediate mass ("IMBH"; e.g., ~1000 Msun) and a
captured donor star. For each of four different sets of initial donor masses
and orbital separations, we computed 30,000 binary evolution models using a
full Henyey stellar evolution code. To our knowledge this is the first time
that a population of X-ray binaries this large has been carried out with other
than approximation methods, and it serves to demonstrate the feasibility of
this approach to large-scale population studies of mass-transfer binaries. In
the present study, we find that in order to have a plausible efficiency for
producing active ULX systems with IMBHs having luminosities > 10^{40} ergs/sec,
there are two basic requirements for the capture of companion/donor stars.
First, the donor stars should be massive, i.e., > 8 Msun. Second, the initial
orbital separations, after circularization, should be close, i.e., < 6-30 times
the radius of the donor star when on the main sequence. Even under these
optimistic conditions, we show that the production rate of IMBH-ULX systems may
fall short of the observed values by factors of 10-100.