Normalized to: Ineson, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.01028 [pdf] - 2026478
Investigating the spectral age problem with powerful radio galaxies
Submitted: 2019-12-02
The 'spectral age problem' is our systematic inability to reconcile the
maximum cooling time of radiating electrons in the lobes of a radio galaxy with
its age as modelled by the dynamical evolution of the lobes. While there are
known uncertainties in the models that produce both age estimates, `spectral'
ages are commonly underestimated relative to dynamical ages, consequently
leading to unreliable estimates of the time-averaged kinetic feedback of a
powerful radio galaxy. In this work we attempt to solve the spectral age
problem by observing two cluster-centre powerful radio galaxies; 3C320 and
3C444. With high-resolution broad-band Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array
observations of the radio sources and deep XMM-Newton and Chandra observations
of their hot intra-cluster media, coupled with the use of an analytic model, we
robustly determine their spectral and dynamical ages. After finding
self-consistent dynamical models that agree with our observational constraints,
and accounting for sub-equipartition magnetic fields, we find that our spectral
ages are still underestimated by a factor of two at least. Equipartition
magnetic fields will underestimate the spectral age by factors of up to ~20.
The turbulent mixing of electron populations in the radio lobes is likely to be
the main remaining factor in the spectral age/dynamical age discrepancy, and
must be accounted for in the study of large samples of powerful radio galaxies.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.03726 [pdf] - 1916031
Revisiting the Fanaroff-Riley dichotomy and radio-galaxy morphology with
the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS)
Mingo, B.;
Croston, J. H.;
Hardcastle, M. J.;
Best, P. N.;
Duncan, K. J.;
Morganti, R.;
Rottgering, H. J. A.;
Sabater, J.;
Shimwell, T. W.;
Williams, W. L.;
Brienza, M.;
Gurkan, G.;
Mahatma, V. H.;
Morabito, L. K.;
Prandoni, I.;
Bondi, M.;
Ineson, J.;
Mooney, S.
Submitted: 2019-07-08
The relative positions of the high and low surface brightness regions of
radio-loud active galaxies in the 3CR sample were found by Fanaroff and Riley
to be correlated with their luminosity. We revisit this canonical relationship
with a sample of 5805 extended radio-loud AGN from the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky
Survey (LoTSS), compiling the most complete dataset of radio-galaxy
morphological information obtained to date. We demonstrate that, for this
sample, radio luminosity does *not* reliably predict whether a source is
edge-brightened (FRII) or centre-brightened (FRI). We highlight a large
population of low-luminosity FRIIs, extending three orders of magnitude below
the traditional FR break, and demonstrate that their host galaxies are on
average systematically fainter than those of high-luminosity FRIIs and of FRIs
matched in luminosity. This result supports the jet power/environment paradigm
for the FR break: low-power jets may remain undisrupted and form hotspots in
lower mass hosts. We also find substantial populations that appear physically
distinct from the traditional FR classes, including candidate restarting
sources and ``hybrids''. We identify 459 bent-tailed sources, which we find to
have a significantly higher SDSS cluster association fraction (at $z<0.4$) than
the general radio-galaxy population, similar to the results of previous work.
The complexity of the LoTSS faint, extended radio sources demonstrates the need
for caution in the automated classification and interpretation of extended
sources in modern radio surveys, but also reveals the wealth of morphological
information such surveys will provide and its value for advancing our physical
understanding of radio-loud AGN.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.10259 [pdf] - 1878849
Unveiling the 100 pc scale nuclear radio structure of NGC 6217 with
e-MERLIN and the VLA
Williams, David R. A.;
McHardy, Ian M.;
Baldi, Ranieri D.;
Beswick, Robert J.;
Pahari, Mayukh;
Argo, Megan K.;
Beri, Aru;
Boorman, Peter;
Brinks, Elias;
Dullo, Bililign T.;
Fenech, Danielle M.;
Ineson, Judith;
Kharb, Preeti;
Knapen, Johan H.;
Muxlow, Tom W. B.;
Westcott, Jonathan
Submitted: 2019-04-23
We present high-sensitivity 1.51 GHz e-MERLIN radio images of the nearby
galaxy NGC 6217. We resolve the compact radio source at the centre of NGC 6217
for the first time, finding a twin-lobed structure with a total linear size of
~4 arcsec (~400pc). The radio source does not have a compact central core but
there is an unresolved hot spot near the outer edge of the southern lobe.
Combining our e-MERLIN data with new VLA A-Array data and archival
multi-wavelength data, we explore possible scenarios which might explain this
complex radio morphology. We conclude that this radio source is most likely
powered by a low-luminosity AGN (LLAGN) but with a possible important
contribution from nuclear star formation. We also investigate the origin of a
putative X-ray jet in NGC 6217, previously suggested in the literature. This
`jet' consists of three X-ray `knots' in a line, pointed away from the nucleus,
with a total size of ~3 arcmin (~15 kpc). We find no extended radio emission
coincident with the `jet'. An additional compact radio source, aligned with the
knots but without an X-ray counterpart is detected. We detect IR/optical
sources falling within the X-ray extraction regions of the `knots', but note
that these sources could be chance associations due to high source density
around the target field and we estimate the probability of three randomly
aligned X-ray sources to be 0.3 per cent in this field.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.07949 [pdf] - 1838254
The environments of radio-loud AGN from the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey
(LoTSS)
Croston, J. H.;
Hardcastle, M. J.;
Mingo, B.;
Best, P. N.;
Sabater, J.;
Shimwell, T. W.;
Williams, W. L.;
Duncan, K. J.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Brienza, M.;
Gürkan, G.;
Ineson, J.;
Morabito, L. M.;
Miley, G. K.;
O'Sullivan, S. P.;
Prandoni, I.
Submitted: 2018-11-19
An understanding of the relationship between radio-loud active galaxies and
their large-scale environments is essential for realistic modelling of
radio-galaxy evolution and environmental impact, for understanding AGN
triggering and life cycles, and for calibrating galaxy feedback in cosmological
models. We use the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS) Data Release 1 catalogues
to investigate this relationship. We cross-matched 8,745 radio-loud AGN with
0.08<z<0.4, selected from LoTSS, with two Sloan Digital Sky Survey cluster
catalogues, and find that only 10 percent of LoTSS AGN in this redshift range
have an association, so that the majority of low-redshift AGN (including a
substantial fraction of the most radio-luminous objects) must inhabit haloes
with M < 10^14 M_sun. We find that the probability of a cluster association,
and the richness of the associated cluster, is correlated with AGN radio
luminosity, and for the cluster population, the number of associated AGN and
the radio luminosity of the brightest associated AGN is richness-dependent. We
demonstrate that these relations are not driven solely by host-galaxy stellar
mass, supporting models in which large-scale environment is influential in
driving AGN jet activity. At the lowest radio luminosities we find that the
minority of objects with a cluster association are located at larger mean
cluster-centre distances than more luminous AGN, which appears to be driven
primarily by host-galaxy mass. Finally, we also find that FRI radio galaxies
inhabit systematically richer environments than FRIIs. The work presented here
demonstrates the potential of LoTSS for AGN environmental studies. In future,
the full northern-sky LoTSS catalogue, together with the use of deeper
optical/IR imaging data and spectroscopic follow-up with WEAVE-LOFAR, will
provide opportunities to extend this type of work to much larger samples and
higher redshifts.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.10172 [pdf] - 1637689
Particle content, radio-galaxy morphology and jet power: all radio-loud
AGN are not equal
Submitted: 2018-01-30
Ongoing and future radio surveys aim to trace the evolution of black hole
growth and feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGN) throughout cosmic time;
however, there remain major uncertainties in translating radio luminosity
functions into a reliable assessment of the energy input as a function of
galaxy and/or dark matter halo mass. A crucial and long-standing problem is the
composition of the radio-lobe plasma that traces AGN jet activity. In this
paper, we carry out a systematic comparison of the plasma conditions in
Fanaroff & Riley class I and II radio galaxies to demonstrate conclusively that
their internal composition is systematically different. This difference is best
explained by the presence of an energetically dominant proton population in the
FRI, but not the FRII radio galaxies. We show that, as expected from this
systematic difference in particle content, radio morphology also affects the
jet-power/radio-luminosity relationship, with FRII radio galaxies having a
significantly lower ratio of jet power to radio luminosity than the FRI cluster
radio sources used to derive jet-power scaling relations via X-ray cavity
measurements. Finally we also demonstrate conclusively that lobe composition is
unconnected to accretion mode (optical excitation class): the internal
conditions of low- and high-excitation FRII radio lobes are indistinguishable.
We conclude that inferences of population-wide AGN impact require careful
assessment of the contribution of different jet sub-classes, particularly given
the increased diversity of jet evolutionary states expected to be present in
deep, low-frequency radio surveys such as the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.09578 [pdf] - 1583924
An X-ray survey of the 2Jy sample. II: X-ray emission from extended
structures
Submitted: 2017-05-26
The 2Jy sample is a survey of radio galaxies with flux densities above 2 Jy
at 2.7 GHz. As part of our ongoing work on the southern subset of 2Jy sources,
in paper I of this series we analysed the X-ray cores of the complete 2Jy
sample with redshifts 0.05<z<0.7. For this work we focus on the X-ray emission
associated with the extended structures (jets, lobes, and environments) of the
complete subset of 2Jy sources with 0.05<z<0.2, that we have observed with
Chandra. We find that hotspots and jet knots are ubiquitous in FRII sources,
which also inhabit systematically poorer environments than the FRI sources in
our sample. Spectral fits of the hotspots with good X-ray statistics invariably
show properties consistent with synchrotron emission, and we show that
inverse-Compton mechanisms under-predict the X-ray emission we observe by 1-2
orders of magnitude. Inverse-Compton emission is detected from many of the
lobes in our sample, and we find that the lobes of the FRII sources show
magnetic fields lower by up to an order of magnitude than expected from
equipartition extrapolations. This is consistent with previous results, which
show that most FRII sources have electron energy densities higher than minimum
energy requirements.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.09510 [pdf] - 1583920
A new method for finding and characterizing galaxy groups via
low-frequency radio surveys
Submitted: 2017-05-26
We describe a new method for identifying and characterizing the thermodynamic
state of large samples of evolved galaxy groups at high redshifts using
high-resolution, low-frequency radio surveys, such as those that will be
carried out with LOFAR and the Square Kilometre Array (SKA). We identify a
sub-population of morphologically regular powerful (FRII) radio galaxies and
demonstrate that, for this sub-population, the internal pressure of the radio
lobes is a reliable tracer of the external intragroup/intracluster medium (ICM)
pressure, and that the assumption of a universal pressure profile for relaxed
groups enables the total mass and X-ray luminosity to be estimated. Using a
sample of well-studied FRII radio galaxies, we demonstrate that our method
enables the estimation of group/cluster X-ray luminosities over three orders of
magnitude in luminosity to within a factor of ~2 from low-frequency radio
properties alone. Our method could provide a powerful new tool for building
samples of thousands of evolved galaxy groups at z>1 and characterizing their
ICM.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.05612 [pdf] - 1534779
A representative survey of the dynamics and energetics of FRII radio
galaxies
Submitted: 2017-01-19
We report the first large, systematic study of the dynamics and energetics of
a representative sample of FRII radio galaxies with well-characterized
group/cluster environments. We used X-ray inverse-Compton and radio synchrotron
measurements to determine the internal radio-lobe conditions, and these were
compared with external pressures acting on the lobes, determined from
measurements of the thermal X-ray emission of the group/cluster. Consistent
with previous work, we found that FRII radio lobes are typically
electron-dominated by a small factor relative to equipartition, and are
over-pressured relative to the external medium in their outer parts. These
results suggest that there is typically no energetically significant proton
population in the lobes of FRII radio galaxies (unlike for FRIs), and so for
this population, inverse-Compton modelling provides an accurate way of
measuring total energy content and estimating jet power. We estimated the
distribution of Mach numbers for the population of expanding radio lobes,
finding that at least half of the radio galaxies are currently driving strong
shocks into their group/cluster environments. Finally, we determined a jet
power--radio luminosity relation for FRII radio galaxies based on our estimates
of lobe internal energy and Mach number. The slope and normalisation of this
relation are consistent with theoretical expectations, given the departure from
equipartition and environmental distribution for our sample.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.04438 [pdf] - 1390672
FR II radio galaxies at low frequencies I: morphology, magnetic field
strength and energetics
Harwood, Jeremy J.;
Croston, Judith H.;
Intema, Huib T.;
Stewart, Adam J.;
Ineson, Judith;
Hardcastle, Martin J.;
Godfrey, Leith;
Best, Philip;
Brienza, Marisa;
Heesen, Volker;
Mahony, Elizabeth K.;
Morganti, Raffaella;
Murgia, Matteo;
Orrú, Emanuela;
Röttgering, Huub;
Shulevski, Aleksandar;
Wise, Michael W.
Submitted: 2016-03-14
Due to their steep spectra, low-frequency observations of FR II radio
galaxies potentially provide key insights in to the morphology, energetics and
spectrum of these powerful radio sources. However, limitations imposed by the
previous generation of radio interferometers at metre wavelengths has meant
that this region of parameter space remains largely unexplored. In this paper,
the first in a series examining FR IIs at low frequencies, we use LOFAR
observations between 50 and 160 MHz, along with complementary archival radio
and X-ray data, to explore the properties of two FR II sources, 3C452 and
3C223. We find that the morphology of 3C452 is that of a standard FR II rather
than of a double-double radio galaxy as had previously been suggested, with no
remnant emission being observed beyond the active lobes. We find that the
low-frequency integrated spectra of both sources are much steeper than expected
based on traditional assumptions and, using synchrotron/inverse-Compton model
fitting, show that the total energy content of the lobes is greater than
previous estimates by a factor of around 5 for 3C452 and 2 for 3C223. We go on
to discuss possible causes of these steeper than expected spectra and provide
revised estimates of the internal pressures and magnetic field strengths for
the intrinsically steep case. We find that the ratio between the equipartition
magnetic field strengths and those derived through synchrotron/inverse-Compton
model fitting remains consistent with previous findings and show that the
observed departure from equipartition may in some cases provide a solution to
the spectral versus dynamical age disparity.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.01033 [pdf] - 1277159
The link between accretion mode and environment in radio-loud active
galaxies
Submitted: 2015-08-05, last modified: 2015-08-21
The interactions between radio-loud AGN and their environments play an
important role in galaxy and cluster evolution. Recent work has demonstrated
fundamental differences between High and Low Excitation Radio Galaxies (HERGs
and LERGs), and shown that they may have different relationships with their
environments. In the Chandra Large Project ERA (Environments of Radio-loud
AGN), we made the first systematic X-ray environmental study of the cluster
environments of radio galaxies at a single epoch (z~0.5), and found tentative
evidence for a correlation between radio luminosity and cluster X-ray
luminosity. We also found that this relationship appeared to be driven by the
LERG sub-population (Ineson et al. 2013).
We have now repeated the analysis with a low redshift sample (z~0.1), and
found strong correlations between radio luminosity and environment richness and
between radio luminosity and central density for the LERGs but not for the
HERGs. These results are consistent with models in which the HERGs are fuelled
from accretion discs maintained from local reservoirs of gas, while LERGs are
fuelled more directly by gas ingested from the intra-cluster medium.
Comparing the samples, we found that although the maximum environment
richness of the HERG environments is similar in both samples, there are poorer
HERG environments in the z~0.1 sample than in the z~0.5 sample. We have
therefore tentative evidence of evolution of the HERG environments. We found no
differences between the LERG sub-samples for the two epochs, as would be
expected if radio and cluster luminosity are related.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.7995 [pdf] - 1222867
The cluster environments of radio-loud AGN
Submitted: 2014-10-29
Radio-loud AGN play an important r\^ole in galaxy evolution. We need to
understand their properties, and the processes that affect their behaviour in
order to model galaxy formation and development. We here present preliminary
results of an investigation into the cluster environments of radio galaxies. We
have found evidence of a strong correlation between radio luminosity and
environment richness for low excitation radio galaxies, and no evidence of
evolution of the environment with redshift. Conversely, for high excitation
radio galaxies, we found no correlation with environment richness, and
tentative evidence of evolution of the cluster environment.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.1050 [pdf] - 1166426
Radio-loud AGN: is there a link between luminosity and cluster
environment?
Submitted: 2013-05-05
We present here the first results from the Chandra ERA (Environments of
Radio-loud AGN) Large Project, characterizing the cluster environments of a
sample of 26 radio-loud AGN at z ~ 0.5 that covers three decades of radio
luminosity. This is the first systematic X-ray environmental study at a single
epoch, and has allowed us to examine the relationship between radio luminosity
and cluster environment without the problems of Malmquist bias. We have found a
weak correlation between radio luminosity and host cluster X-ray luminosity, as
well as tentative evidence that this correlation is driven by the subpopulation
of low-excitation radio galaxies, with high-excitation radio galaxies showing
no significant correlation. The considerable scatter in the environments may be
indicative of complex relationships not currently included in feedback models.