Normalized to: Hubbard, W.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.03695 [pdf] - 2061654
Equilibrium Tidal Response of Jupiter: Detectability by Juno
Submitted: 2020-01-10
An observation of Jupiter's tidal response is anticipated for the on-going
Juno spacecraft mission. We combine self-consistent, numerical models of
Jupiter's equilibrium tidal response with observed Doppler shifts from the Juno
gravity science experiment to test the sensitivity of the spacecraft to tides
raised by the Galilean satellites and the Sun. The concentric Maclaurin
spheroid (CMS) method finds the equilibrium shape and gravity field of a
rotating, liquid planet with the tide raised by a satellite, expanded in Love
numbers ($k_{nm}$). We present improvements to CMS theory that eliminate an
unphysical center of mass offset and study in detail the convergence behavior
of the CMS approach. We demonstrate that the dependence of $k_{nm}$ with
orbital distance is important when considering the combined tidal response for
Jupiter. Conversely, the details of the interior structure have a negligible
influence on $k_{nm}$, for models that match the zonal harmonics $J_2$, $J_4$
and $J_6$, already measured to high precision by Juno. As the mission
continues, improved coverage of Jupiter's gravity field at different phases of
Io's orbit is expected to yield an observed value for the degree-2 Love number
($k_{22}$) and potentially select higher--degree $k_{nm}$. We present a test of
the sensitivity of the Juno Doppler signal to the calculated $k_{nm}$, which
suggests the detectability of $k_{33}$, $k_{42}$ and $k_{31}$, in addition to
$k_{22}$. A mismatch of a robust Juno observation with the remarkably small
range in calculated Io equilibrium $k_{22}=0.58976\pm0.0001$, would indicate a
heretofore uncharacterized dynamic contribution to the tides.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.08907 [pdf] - 1916914
Models of Saturn's Interior Constructed with Accelerated Concentric
Maclaurin Spheroid Method
Submitted: 2019-05-21
The Cassini spacecraft's Grand Finale orbits provided a unique opportunity to
probe Saturn's gravity field and interior structure. Doppler measurements
yielded unexpectedly large values for the gravity harmonics J_6, J_8, and J_10
that cannot be matched with planetary interior models that assume uniform
rotation. Instead we present a suite of models that assume the planet's
interior rotates on cylinders, which allows us to match all the observed even
gravity harmonics. For every interior model, the gravity field is calculated
self-consistently with high precision using the Concentric Maclaurin Spheroid
(CMS) method. We present an acceleration technique for this method, which
drastically reduces the computational cost, allows us to efficiently optimize
model parameters, map out allowed parameter regions with Monte Carlo sampling,
and increases the precision of the calculated J_2n gravity harmonics to match
the error bars of the observations, which would be difficult without
acceleration. Based on our models, Saturn is predicted to have a dense central
core of 15-18 Earth masses and an additional 1.5-5 Earth masses of heavy
elements in the envelope. Finally, we vary the rotation period in the planet's
deep interior and determine the resulting oblateness, which we compare with the
value from radio occultation measurements by the Voyager spacecraft. We predict
a rotation period of 10:33:34 h +- 55s, which is in agreement with recent
estimates derived from ring seismology.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.01278 [pdf] - 1602763
Analytic Scattering and Refraction Models for Exoplanet Transit Spectra
Submitted: 2017-11-03
Observations of exoplanet transit spectra are essential to understanding the
physics and chemistry of distant worlds. The effects of opacity sources and
many physical processes combine to set the shape of a transit spectrum. Two
such key processes - refraction and cloud and/or haze forward scattering - have
seen substantial recent study. However, models of these processes are typically
complex, which prevents their incorporation into observational analyses and
standard transit spectrum tools. In this work, we develop analytic expressions
that allow for the efficient parameterization of forward scattering and
refraction effects in transit spectra. We derive an effective slant optical
depth that includes a correction for forward scattered light, and present an
analytic form of this correction. We validate our correction against a
full-physics transit spectrum model that includes scattering, and we explore
the extent to which the omission of forward scattering effects may bias models.
Also, we verify a common analytic expression for the location of a refractive
boundary, which we express in terms of the maximum pressure probed in a transit
spectrum. This expression is designed to be easily incorporated into existing
tools, and we discuss how the detection of a refractive boundary could help
indicate the background atmospheric composition by constraining the bulk
refractivity of the atmosphere. Finally, we show that opacity from Rayleigh
scattering and collision induced absorption will outweigh the effects of
refraction for Jupiter-like atmospheres whose equilibrium temperatures are
above 400-500 K.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.01997 [pdf] - 1585624
Comparing Jupiter interior structure models to Juno gravity measurements
and the role of a dilute core
Wahl, S. M.;
Hubbard, W. B.;
Militzer, B.;
Guillot, T.;
Miguel, Y.;
Movshovitz, N.;
Kaspi, Y.;
Helled, R.;
Reese, D.;
Galanti, E.;
Levin, S.;
Connerney, J. E.;
Bolton, S. J.
Submitted: 2017-07-06
The Juno spacecraft has measured Jupiter's low-order, even gravitational
moments, $J_2$--$J_8$, to an unprecedented precision, providing important
constraints on the density profile and core mass of the planet. Here we report
on a selection of interior models based on ab initio computer simulations of
hydrogen-helium mixtures. We demonstrate that a dilute core, expanded to a
significant fraction of the planet's radius, is helpful in reconciling the
calculated $J_n$ with Juno's observations. Although model predictions are
strongly affected by the chosen equation of state, the prediction of an
enrichment of $Z$ in the deep, metallic envelope over that in the shallow,
molecular envelope holds. We estimate Jupiter's core to contain an 7--25 Earth
mass of heavy elements. We discuss the current difficulties in reconciling
measured $J_n$ with the equations of state, and with theory for formation and
evolution of the planet.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.06324 [pdf] - 1484756
The Interior of Saturn
Submitted: 2016-09-20
We review our current understanding of the interior structure and thermal
evolution of Saturn, with a focus on recent results in the Cassini era. There
has been important progress in understanding physical inputs, including
equations of state of planetary materials and their mixtures, physical
parameters like the gravity field and rotation rate, and constraints on
Saturnian free oscillations. At the same time, new methods of calculation,
including work on the gravity field of rotating fluid bodies, and the role of
interior composition gradients, should help to better constrain the state of
Saturn's interior, now and earlier in its history. However, a better
appreciation of modeling uncertainties and degeneracies, along with a greater
exploration of modeling phase space, still leave great uncertainties in our
understanding of Saturn's interior. Further analysis of Cassini data sets, as
well as precise gravity field measurements from the Cassini Grand Finale
orbits, will further revolutionize our understanding of Saturn's interior over
the next few years.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.02685 [pdf] - 1498399
Understanding Jupiter's Interior
Submitted: 2016-08-08
This article provides an overview of how models of giant planet interiors are
constructed. We review measurements from past space missions that provide
constraints for the interior structure of Jupiter. We discuss typical
three-layer interior models that consist of a dense central core and an inner
metallic and an outer molecular hydrogen-helium layer. These models rely
heavily on experiments, analytical theory, and first-principle computer
simulations of hydrogen and helium to understand their behavior up to the
extreme pressures ~10 Mbar and temperatures ~10,000 K. We review the various
equations of state used in Jupiter models and compare them with shock wave
experiments. We discuss the possibility of helium rain, core erosion and double
diffusive convection may have important consequences for the structure and
evolution of giant planets. In July 2016 the Juno spacecraft entered orbit
around Jupiter, promising high-precision measurements of the gravitational
field that will allow us to test our understanding of gas giant interiors
better than ever before.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.08559 [pdf] - 1445865
Tidal Response of Preliminary Jupiter Model
Submitted: 2016-07-28
In anticipation of improved observational data for Jupiter's gravitational
field from the Juno spacecraft, we predict the static tidal response for a
variety of Jupiter interior models based on ab initio computer simulations of
hydrogen-helium mixtures. We calculate hydrostatic-equilibrium gravity terms
using the non-perturbative concentric Maclaurin Spheroid (CMS) method that
eliminates lengthy expansions used in the theory of figures. Our method
captures terms arising from the coupled tidal and rotational perturbations,
which we find to be important for a rapidly-rotating planet like Jupiter. Our
predicted static tidal Love number $k_2 = 0.5900$ is $\sim$10\% larger than
previous estimates. The value is, as expected, highly correlated with the zonal
harmonic coefficient $J_2$, and is thus nearly constant when plausible changes
are made to interior structure while holding $J_2$ fixed at the observed value.
We note that the predicted static $k_2$ might change due to Jupiter's dynamical
response to the Galilean moons, and find reasons to argue that the change may
be detectable, although we do not present here a theory of dynamical tides for
highly oblate Jovian planets. An accurate model of Jupiter's tidal response
will be essential for interpreting Juno observations and identifying tidal
signals from effects of other interior dynamics in Jupiter's gravitational
field.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.07350 [pdf] - 1513501
The Concentric Maclaurin Spheroid method with tides and a rotational
enhancement of Saturn's tidal response
Submitted: 2016-02-23
We extend to three dimensions the Concentric Maclaurin Spheroid method for
obtaining the self-consistent shape and gravitational field of a rotating
liquid planet, to include a tidal potential from a satellite. We exhibit, for
the first time, the important effect of the planetary rotation rate on tidal
response of gas giants. Simulations of planets with fast rotation rates like
those of Jupiter and Saturn, exhibit significant changes in calculated tidal
love numbers $k_{nm}$ when compared with non-rotating bodies. A test model of
Saturn fitted to observed zonal gravitational multipole harmonics yields
$k_2=0.413$, consistent with a recent observational determination from Cassini
astrometry data (Lainey et al., 2016). The calculated love number is robust
under reasonable assumptions of interior rotation rate, satellite parameters,
and details of Saturn's interior structure. The method is benchmarked against
several published test cases.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.05143 [pdf] - 1385494
A Preliminary Jupiter Model
Submitted: 2016-02-16
In anticipation of new observational results for Jupiter's axial moment of
inertia and gravitational zonal harmonic coefficients from the forthcoming Juno
orbiter, we present a number of preliminary Jupiter interior models. We combine
results from ab initio computer simulations of hydrogen-helium mixtures,
including immiscibility calculations, with a new nonperturbative calculation of
Jupiter's zonal harmonic coefficients, to derive a self-consistent model for
the planet's external gravity and moment of inertia. We assume helium rain
modified the interior temperature and composition profiles. Our calculation
predicts zonal harmonic values to which measurements can be compared. Although
some models fit the observed (pre-Juno) second- and fourth-order zonal
harmonics to within their error bars, our preferred reference model predicts a
fourth-order zonal harmonic whose absolute value lies above the pre-Juno error
bars. This model has a dense core of about 12 Earth masses, and a
hydrogen-helium-rich envelope with approximately 3 times solar metallicity.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.0803 [pdf] - 659589
Concentric Maclaurin spheroid models of rotating liquid planets
Submitted: 2013-05-03
I present exact expressions for the interior gravitational potential V of a
system of N concentric constant-density (Maclaurin) spheroids. I demonstrate an
iteration procedure to find a self-consistent solution for the shapes of the
interfaces between spheroids, and for the interior gravitational potential. The
external free-space potential, expressed as a multipole expansion, emerges as
part of the self-consistent solution. The procedure is both simpler and more
precise than perturbation methods. One can choose the distribution and mass
densities of the concentric spheroids so as to reproduce a prescribed barotrope
to a specified accuracy. I demonstrate the method's efficacy by comparing its
results with several published test cases.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1302.4691 [pdf] - 1164724
Ab Initio Equation of State for Hydrogen-Helium Mixtures with
Recalibration of the Giant-Planet Mass-Radius Relation
Submitted: 2013-02-19
Using density functional molecular dynamics simulations, we determine the
equation of state for hydrogen-helium mixtures spanning density-temperature
conditions typical of giant planet interiors, ~0.2-9 g/cc and 1000-80000 K for
a typical helium mass fraction of 0.245. In addition to computing internal
energy and pressure, we determine the entropy using an ab initio thermodynamic
integration technique. A comprehensive equation of state (EOS) table with 391
density-temperature points is constructed and the results are presented in form
of two-dimensional free energy fit for interpolation. Deviations between our ab
initio EOS and the semi-analytical EOS model by Saumon and Chabrier are
analyzed in detail, and we use the results for initial revision of the inferred
thermal state of giant planets with known values for mass and radius. Changes
are most pronounced for planets in the Jupiter mass range and below. We present
a revision to the mass-radius relationship which makes the hottest exoplanets
increase in radius by ~0.2 Jupiter radii at fixed entropy and for masses
greater than ~0.5 Jupiter mass. This change is large enough to have possible
implications for some discrepant "inflated giant exoplanets".
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.3699 [pdf] - 30824
Planetary Formation and Evolution Revealed with a Saturn Entry Probe:
The Importance of Noble Gases
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Zahnle, Kevin;
Baraffe, Isabelle;
Burrows, Adam;
Dodson-Robinson, Sarah E.;
Chabrier, Gilles;
Guillot, Tristan;
Helled, Ravit;
Hersant, Franck;
Hubbard, William B.;
Lissauer, Jack J.;
Marley, Mark S.
Submitted: 2009-11-18
The determination of Saturn's atmospheric noble gas abundances are critical
to understanding the formation and evolution of Saturn, and giant planets in
general. These measurements can only be performed with an entry probe. A Saturn
probe will address whether enhancement in heavy noble gases, as was found in
Jupiter, are a general feature of giant planets, and their ratios will be a
powerful constraint on how they form. The helium abundance will show the extent
to which helium has phase separated from hydrogen in the planet's deep
interior. Jupiter's striking neon depletion may also be tied to its helium
depletion, and must be confirmed or refuted in Saturn. Together with Jupiter's
measured atmospheric helium abundance, a consistent evolutionary theory for
both planets, including "helium rain" will be possible. We will then be able to
calibrate the theory of the evolution of all giant planets, including
exoplanets. In addition, high pressure H/He mixtures under giant planet
conditions are an important area of condensed matter physics that are beyond
the realm of experiment.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.3717 [pdf] - 902131
Detecting the Wind-Driven Shapes of Extrasolar Giant Planets from
Transit Photometry
Submitted: 2009-10-19
Several processes can cause the shape of an extrasolar giant planet's shadow,
as viewed in transit, to depart from circular. In addition to rotational
effects, cloud formation, non-homogenous haze production and movement, and
dynamical effects (winds) could also be important. When such a planet transits
its host star as seen from Earth, the asphericity will introduce a deviation in
the transit lightcurve relative to the transit of a perfectly spherical (or
perfectly oblate) planet. We develop a theoretical framework to interpret
planet shapes. We then generate predictions for transiting planet shapes based
on a published theoretical dynamical model of HD189733b. Using these shape
models we show that planet shapes are unlikely to introduce detectable
lightcurve deviations (those >~1e-5 of the host star), but that the shapes may
lead to astrophysical sources of systematic error when measuring planetary
oblateness, transit time, and impact parameter.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.4141 [pdf] - 1002652
Buoyancy waves in Pluto's high atmosphere: Implications for stellar
occultations
Submitted: 2009-06-22
We apply scintillation theory to stellar signal fluctuations in the
high-resolution, high signal/noise, dual-wavelength data from the MMT
observation of the 2007 March 18 occultation of P445.3 by Pluto. A well-defined
high wavenumber cutoff in the fluctuations is consistent with viscous-thermal
dissipation of buoyancy waves (internal gravity waves) in Pluto's high
atmosphere, and provides strong evidence that the underlying density
fluctuations are governed by the gravity-wave dispersion relation.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.4266 [pdf] - 14895
Comparison of Jupiter Interior Models Derived from First-Principles
Simulations
Submitted: 2008-07-26
Recently two groups used first-principles computer simulations to model
Jupiter's interior. While both studies relied on the same simulation technique,
density functional molecular dynamics, the groups derived very different
conclusions. In particular estimates for the size of Jupiter's core and the
metallicity of its hydrogen-helium mantle differed substantially. In this
paper, we discuss the differences of the approaches and give an explanation for
the differing conclusions.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.4264 [pdf] - 14894
A Massive Core in Jupiter Predicted From First-Principles Simulations
Submitted: 2008-07-26
Hydrogen-helium mixtures at conditions of Jupiter's interior are studied with
first-principles computer simulations. The resulting equation of state (EOS)
implies that Jupiter possesses a central core of 14-18 Earth masses of heavier
elements, a result that supports core accretion as standard model for the
formation of hydrogen-rich giant planets. Our nominal model has about 2 Earth
masses of planetary ices in the H-He-rich mantle, a result that is, within
modeling errors, consistent with abundances measured by the 1995 Galileo Entry
Probe mission (equivalent to about 5 Earth masses of planetary ices when
extrapolated to the mantle), suggesting that the composition found by the probe
may be representative of the entire planet. Interior models derived from this
first-principles EOS do not give a match to Jupiter's gravity moment J4 unless
one invokes interior differential rotation, implying that jovian interior
dynamics has an observable effect on the measured gravity field.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0612703 [pdf] - 316684
Possible Solutions to the Radius Anomalies of Transiting Giant Planets
Submitted: 2006-12-22, last modified: 2007-04-20
We calculate the theoretical evolution of the radii of all fourteen of the
known transiting extrasolar giant planets (EGPs) for a variety of assumptions
concerning atmospheric opacity, dense inner core masses, and possible internal
power sources. We incorporate the effects of stellar irradiation and customize
such effects for each EGP and star. Looking collectively at the family as a
whole, we find that there are in fact two radius anomalies to be explained. Not
only are the radii of a subset of the known transiting EGPs larger than
expected from previous theory, but many of the other objects are smaller than
the default theory would allow. We suggest that the larger EGPs can be
explained by invoking enhanced atmospheric opacities that naturally retain
internal heat. This explanation might obviate the necessity for an extra
internal power source. We explain the smaller radii by the presence in perhaps
all the known transiting EGPs of dense cores, such as have been inferred for
Saturn and Jupiter. Importantly, we derive a rough correlation between the
masses of our "best-fit" cores and the stellar metallicity that seems to
buttress the core-accretion model of their formation. Though many caveats and
uncertainties remain, the resulting comprehensive theory that incorporates
enhanced-opacity atmospheres and dense cores is in reasonable accord with all
the current structural data for the known transiting giant planets.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702276 [pdf] - 260869
A Mass Function Constraint on Extrasolar Giant Planet Evaporation Rates
Submitted: 2007-02-09
The observed mass function for all known extrasolar giant planets (EGPs)
varies approximately as M^{-1} for mass M between 0.2 Jupiter masses (M_J) and
5 M_J. In order to study evaporation effects for highly-irradiated EGPs in this
mass range, we have constructed an observational mass function for a subset of
EGPs in the same mass range but with orbital radii <0.07 AU. Surprisingly, the
mass function for such highly-irradiated EGPs agrees quantitatively with the
M^{-1} law, implying that the mass function for EGPs is preserved despite
migration to small orbital radii. Unless there is a remarkable compensation of
mass-dependent orbital migration for mass-dependent evaporation, this result
places a constraint on orbital migration models and rules out the most extreme
mass loss rates in the literature. A theory that predicts more moderate mass
loss gives a mass function that is closer to observed statistics but still
disagrees for M < 1 M_J.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0508591 [pdf] - 75480
Effects of mass loss for highly-irradiated giant planets
Submitted: 2005-08-26, last modified: 2006-10-27
We present calculations for the evolution and surviving mass of
highly-irradiated extrasolar giant planets (EGPs) at orbital semimajor axes
ranging from 0.023 to 0.057 AU using a generalized scaled theory for mass loss,
together with new surface-condition grids for hot EGPs and a consistent
treatment of tidal truncation. Theoretical estimates for the rate of
energy-limited hydrogen escape from giant-planet atmospheres differ by two
orders of magnitude, when one holds planetary mass, composition, and
irradiation constant. Baraffe et al. (2004, A&A 419, L13-L16) predict the
highest rate, based on the theory of Lammer et al. (2003, Astrophys. J. 598,
L121-L124). Scaling the theory of Watson et al. (1981, Icarus 48, 150-166) to
parameters for a highly-irradiated exoplanet, we find an escape rate ~102 lower
than Baraffe's. With the scaled Watson theory we find modest mass loss,
occurring early in the history of a hot EGP. In this theory, mass loss
including the effect of Roche-lobe overflow becomes significant primarily for
masses below a Saturn mass, for semimajor axes = 0.023 AU. This contrasts with
the Baraffe model, where hot EGPs are claimed to be remnants of much more
massive bodies, originally several times Jupiter and still losing substantial
mass fractions at present.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0405264 [pdf] - 64784
Theoretical Radii of Transiting Giant Planets: The Case of OGLE-TR-56b
Submitted: 2004-05-13
We calculate radius versus age trajectories for the photometrically-selected
transiting extrasolar giant planet, OGLE-TR-56b, and find agreement between
theory and observation, without introducing an ad hoc extra source of heat in
its core. The fact that the radius of HD209458b seems larger than the radii of
the recently discovered OGLE family of extremely close-in transiting planets
suggests that HD209458b is anomalous. Nevertheless, our good fit to OGLE-TR-56b
bolsters the notion that the generic dependence of transit radii on stellar
irradiation, mass, and age is, to within error bars, now quantitatively
understood.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0402620 [pdf] - 63134
Effects of Helium Phase Separation on the Evolution of Extrasolar Giant
Planets
Submitted: 2004-02-25
We build on recent new evolutionary models of Jupiter and Saturn and here
extend our calculations to investigate the evolution of extrasolar giant
planets of mass 0.15 to 3.0 M_J. Our inhomogeneous thermal history models show
that the possible phase separation of helium from liquid metallic hydrogen in
the deep interiors of these planets can lead to luminosities ~2 times greater
than have been predicted by homogeneous models. For our chosen phase diagram
this phase separation will begin to affect the planets' evolution at ~700 Myr
for a 0.15 M_J object and ~10 Gyr for a 3.0 M_J object. We show how phase
separation affects the luminosity, effective temperature, radii, and
atmospheric helium mass fraction as a function of age for planets of various
masses, with and without heavy element cores, and with and without the effect
of modest stellar irradiation. This phase separation process will likely not
affect giant planets within a few AU of their parent star, as these planets
will cool to their equilibrium temperatures, determined by stellar heating,
before the onset of phase separation. We discuss the detectability of these
objects and the likelihood that the energy provided by helium phase separation
can change the timescales for formation and settling of ammonia clouds by
several Gyr. We discuss how correctly incorporating stellar irradiation into
giant planet atmosphere and albedo modeling may lead to a consistent
evolutionary history for Jupiter and Saturn.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0312386 [pdf] - 61599
Effects of Helium Phase Separation on the Evolution of Giant Planets
Submitted: 2003-12-15
We present the first models of Saturn and Jupiter to couple their evolution
to both a radiative-atmosphere grid and to high-pressure phase diagrams of
hydrogen with helium. The purpose of these models is to quantify the
evolutionary effects of helium phase separation in Saturn's deep interior. We
find that prior calculated phase diagrams in which Saturn's interior reaches a
region of predicted helium immiscibility do not allow enough energy release to
prolong Saturn's cooling to its known age and effective temperature. We explore
modifications to published phase diagrams that would lead to greater energy
release, and find a modified H-He phase diagram that is physically reasonable,
leads to the correct extension of Saturn's cooling, and predicts an atmospheric
helium mass fraction Y_atmos in agreement with recent estimates. We then expand
our inhomogeneous evolutionary models to show that hypothetical extrasolar
giant planets in the 0.15 to 3.0 Jupiter mass range may have T_effs 10-15 K
greater than one would predict with models that do not incorporate helium phase
separation.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0305277 [pdf] - 56750
A Theory for the Radius of the Transiting Giant Planet HD 209458b
Submitted: 2003-05-15
Using a full frequency-dependent atmosphere code that can incorporate
irradiation by a central primary star, we calculate self-consistent boundary
conditions for the evolution of the radius of the transiting planet HD 209458b.
Using a well-tested extrasolar giant planet evolutionary code, we then
calculate the behavior of this planet's radius with age. The measured radius is
in fact a transit radius that resides high in HD 209458b's inflated atmosphere.
Using our derived atmospheric and interior structures, we find that irradiation
plus the proper interpretation of the transit radius can yield a theoretical
radius that is within the measured error bars. We conclude that if HD 209458b's
true transit radius is at the lower end of the measured range, an extra source
of core heating power is not necessary to explain the transit observations.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0305031 [pdf] - 56504
Phase Separation in Giant Planets: Inhomogeneous Evolution of Saturn
Submitted: 2003-05-01
We present the first models of Jupiter and Saturn to couple their evolution
to both a radiative-atmosphere grid and to high-pressure phase diagrams of
hydrogen with helium and other admixtures. We find that prior calculated phase
diagrams in which Saturn's interior reaches a region of predicted helium
immiscibility do not allow enough energy release to prolong Saturn's cooling to
its known age and effective temperature. We explore modifications to published
phase diagrams that would lead to greater energy release, and propose a
modified H-He phase diagram that is physically reasonable, leads to the correct
extension of Saturn's cooling, and predicts an atmospheric helium mass fraction
Y_atmos = 0.185, in agreement with recent estimates. We also explore the
possibility of internal separation of elements heavier than helium, and find
that, alternatively, such separation could prolong Saturn's cooling to its
known age and effective temperature under a realistic phase diagram and heavy
element abundance (in which case Saturn's Y_atmos would be solar but heavier
elements would be depleted). In none of these scenarios does Jupiter's interior
evolve to any region of helium or heavy-element immiscibility: Jupiter evolves
homogeneously to the present day. We discuss the implications of our
calculations for Saturn's primordial core mass.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0208263 [pdf] - 51079
On the Indirect Detection of Sodium in the Atmosphere of the Planetary
Companion to HD 209458
Submitted: 2002-08-13, last modified: 2003-01-29
Using a self-consistent atmosphere code, we construct a new model of the
atmosphere of the transiting extrasolar giant planet HD 209458b to investigate
the disparity between the observed strength of the sodium absorption feature at
589 nm and the predictions of previous models. For the atmospheric
temperature-pressure profile we derive, silicate and iron clouds reside at a
pressure of several mbar in the planet's atmosphere. These clouds have
significant vertical extent and optical depth due to our slant viewing geometry
and lead to increased absorption in bands directly adjacent to the sodium line
core. Using a non-LTE sodium ionization model that includes photoionization by
stellar UV flux, collisional processes with H_2, and radiative recombination,
we show that the ionization depth in the planet's atmosphere reaches ~1/2 mbar
at the day/night terminator. Ionization leads to a slight weakening of the
sodium feature. We present our baseline model, including ionization and clouds,
which falls near the observational error bars. The sensitivity of our
conclusions to the derived atmospheric temperature-pressure profile is
discussed.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0101024 [pdf] - 40162
Theory of Extrasolar Giant Planet Transits
Submitted: 2001-01-02, last modified: 2001-06-09
We present a synthesis of physical effects influencing the observed
lightcurve of an extrasolar giant planet (EGP) transiting its host star. The
synthesis includes a treatment of Rayleigh scattering, cloud scattering,
refraction, and molecular absorption of starlight in the EGP atmosphere. Of
these effects, molecular absorption dominates in determining the
transit-derived radius $R$. Using a generic model for the atmosphere of EGP
HD209458b, we perform a fit to the best available transit lightcurve data, and
infer that this planet has a radius at a pressure of 1 bar, $R_1$, equal to
94430 km. We predict that $R$ will be a function of wavelength of observation,
with a robust prediction of variations of $\pm 1$% at infrared wavelengths
where H$_2$O opacity in the high EGP atmosphere dominates.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0103383 [pdf] - 41600
The Theory of Brown Dwarfs and Extrasolar Giant Planets
Submitted: 2001-03-22
Straddling the traditional realms of the planets and the stars, objects below
the edge of the main sequence have such unique properties, and are being
discovered in such quantities, that one can rightly claim that a new field at
the interface of planetary science and and astronomy is being born. In this
review, we explore the essential elements of the theory of brown dwarfs and
giant planets, as well as of the new spectroscopic classes L and T. To this
end, we describe their evolution, spectra, atmospheric compositions, chemistry,
physics, and nuclear phases and explain the basic systematics of
substellar-mass objects across three orders of magnitude in both mass and age
and a factor of 30 in effective temperature. Moreover, we discuss the
distinctive features of those extrasolar giant planets that are irradiated by a
central primary, in particular their reflection spectra, albedos, and transits.
Aspects of the latest theory of Jupiter and Saturn are also presented.
Throughout, we highlight the effects of condensates, clouds, molecular
abundances, and molecular/atomic opacities in brown dwarf and giant planet
atmospheres and summarize the resulting spectral diagnostics. Where possible,
the theory is put in its current observational context.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0003185 [pdf] - 35059
On the Radii of Close-in Giant Planets
Submitted: 2000-03-13
The recent discovery that the close-in extrasolar giant planet, HD209458b,
transits its star has provided a first-of-its-kind measurement of the planet's
radius and mass. In addition, there is a provocative detection of the light
reflected off of the giant planet, $\tau$ Boo b. Including the effects of
stellar irradiation, we estimate the general behavior of radius/age
trajectories for such planets and interpret the large measured radii of
HD209458b and $\tau$ Boo b in that context. We find that HD209458b must be a
hydrogen-rich gas giant. Furthermore, the large radius of close-in gas giant is
not due to the thermal expansion of its atmosphere, but to the high residual
entropy that remains throughout its bulk by dint of its early proximity to a
luminous primary. The large stellar flux does not inflate the planet, but
retards its otherwise inexorable contraction from a more extended configuration
at birth. This implies either that such a planet was formed near its current
orbital distance or that it migrated in from larger distances ($\geq$0.5 A.U.),
no later than a few times $10^7$ years of birth.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9812192 [pdf] - 104299
Comparative Evolution of Jupiter and Saturn
Submitted: 1998-12-09
We present evolutionary sequences for Jupiter and Saturn, based on new
nongray model atmospheres, which take into account the evolution of the solar
luminosity and partitioning of dense components to deeper layers. The results
are used to set limits on the extent to which possible interior phase
separation of hydrogen and helium may have progressed in the two planets. When
combined with static models constrained by the gravity field, our evolutionary
calculations constrain the helium mass fraction in Jupiter to be between 0.20
and 0.27, relative to total hydrogen and helium. This is in agreement with the
Galileo determination. The helium mass fraction in Saturn's atmosphere lies
between 0.11 and 0.25, higher than the Voyager determination. Based on the
discrepancy between the Galileo and Voyager results for Jupiter, and our
models, we predict that Cassini measurements will yield a higher atmospheric
helium mass fraction for Saturn relative to the Voyager value.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9809084 [pdf] - 102788
New Ideas in the Theory of Extrasolar Giant Planets and Brown Dwarfs
Submitted: 1998-09-07
We summarize and extend recent work on the theory of extrasolar giant planets
(EGPs) and brown dwarfs, paying particular attention to Gliese 229 B, the
albedos of EGPs, the compositions of substellar atmospheres, the connections
with the giant planets in the solar system, cloud physics, and non-gray
spectral synthesis. The role of condensates in altering the optical spectrum of
Gliese 229 B is explored, as are the systematics of the reflection spectra from
extrasolar giant planets near their primaries. In addition, we discuss the role
of convection and disequilibrium chemistry in explaining the anomalous
detection of CO in Gliese 229 B. Throughout, we highlight the distinctive
chemistry that defines this new class of objects and set goals for future
study.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9801292 [pdf] - 100141
Orbital Evolution and Migration of Giant Planets: Modeling Extrasolar
Planets
Submitted: 1998-01-28
Giant planets in circumstellar disks can migrate inward from their initial
(formation) positions. Radial migration is caused by inward torques between the
planet and the disk; by outward torques between the planet and the spinning
star; and by outward torques due to Roche lobe overflow and consequent mass
loss from the planet. We present self-consistent numerical considerations of
the problem of migrating giant planets. Summing torques on planets for various
physical parameters, we find that Jupiter-mass planets can stably arrive and
survive at small heliocentric distances, thus reproducing observed properties
of some of the recently discovered extra-solar planets. Inward migration
timescales can be approximately equal to or less than disk lifetimes and star
spindown timescales. Therefore, the range of fates of massive planets is broad,
and generally comprises three classes: (I) planets which migrate inward too
rapidly and lose all their mass; (II) planets which migrate inward, lose some
but not all of their mass, and survive in very small orbits; and (III) planets
which do not lose any mass. Some planets in Class III do not migrate very far
from their formation locations. Our results show that there is a wide range of
possible fates for Jupiter-mass planets for both final heliocentric distance
and final mass.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9709278 [pdf] - 98731
The Spectral Character of Giant Planets and Brown Dwarfs
Submitted: 1997-09-26
Since October of 1995, employing Doppler spectroscopy astronomers have
discovered as many as 20 giant planets and brown dwarfs, including companions
to $\tau$ Boo, 51 Peg, $\upsilon$ And, 55 Cnc, $\rho$ CrB, 70 Vir, 16 Cyg B,
and 47 UMa. These discoveries have excited the planetary science community,
astronomers, and the public at large. Within hours of the announcement of the
planet 51 Peg b, the first direct detection of an unimpeachable brown dwarf,
Gl229 B, was also announced. Gl229 B is a watershed since it has methane
spectral features and a surface temperature below 1000 Kelvin, characteristics
unique to objects with substellar masses.
During the last two years, building upon our previous experience in the
modeling of brown dwarfs and M stars, we published theoretical studies of the
evolution and spectra of extrasolar giant planets. We have recently upgraded
our capabilities and now generate non-gray spectral and color models of both
giant planets and brown dwarfs. This theory will soon encompass objects whose
effective temperatures range from 100 K to 4000 K and whose masses span three
orders of magnitude. The evolutionary, spectral, and color calculations upon
which we have embarked are in direct support of the searches now being planned
in earnest with the HST (WFPC2, NICMOS), the IRTF, the MMT 6.5-meter upgrade,
the LBT, Keck's I and II, ISO, UKIRT, NGST, the VLT, COROT, DENIS, 2MASS, and
SIRTF.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9707210 [pdf] - 98034
New Constraints on the Composition of Jupiter from Galileo Measurements
and Interior Models
Submitted: 1997-07-17
Using the helium abundance measured by Galileo in the atmosphere of Jupiter
and interior models reproducing the observed external gravitational field, we
derive new constraints on the composition and structure of the planet. We
conclude that, except for helium which must be more abundant in the metallic
interior than in the molecular envelope, Jupiter could be homogeneous (no core)
or could have a central dense core up to 12 Earth masses. The mass fraction of
heavy elements is less than 7.5 times the solar value in the metallic envelope
and between 1 and 7.2 times solar in the molecular envelope. The total amount
of elements other than hydrogen and helium in the planet is between 11 and 45
Earth masses.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9706080 [pdf] - 97601
Advances in the Theory of Extrasolar Giant Planets and Brown Dwarfs
Submitted: 1997-06-09
We have developed a new non-gray theory of the evolution, spectra, and colors
of extrasolar giant planets (EGPs) and brown dwarfs that reveals their exotic
nature and uniqueness. We have discovered that the fluxes of such objects for
T$_{eff}$s from 1300 K to 100 K can be spectacularly higher in the near
infrared bands than black body values and that their infrared colors are
anomalously blue. As a consequence, EGPs and brown dwarfs reside in hitherto
unoccupied realms of the H--R diagram and may be more easily found with current
and planned telescopes than previously imagined.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9705201 [pdf] - 97463
A Non-Gray Theory of Extrasolar Giant Planets and Brown Dwarfs
Submitted: 1997-05-24
We present the results of a new series of non-gray calculations of the
atmospheres, spectra, colors, and evolution of extrasolar giant planets (EGPs)
and brown dwarfs for effective temperatures below 1300 K. This theory
encompasses most of the mass/age parameter space occupied by substellar objects
and is the first spectral study down to 100 K. These calculations are in aid of
the multitude of searches being conducted or planned around the world for giant
planets and brown dwarfs and reveal the exotic nature of the class.
Generically, absorption by H_2 at longer wavelengths and H_2O opacity windows
at shorter wavelengths conspire to redistribute flux blueward. Below 1200 K,
methane is the dominant carbon bearing molecule and is a universal diagnostic
feature of EGP and brown dwarf spectra. We find that the primary bands in which
to search are $Z$ (\sim 1.05 \mic), $J$ (\sim 1.2 \mic), $H$ (\sim 1.6 \mic),
$K$ (\sim 2.2 \mic), $M$ (\sim 5 \mic), and $N$ (\sim 10 \mic), that
enhancements of the emergent flux over blackbody values, in particular in the
near infrared, can be by many orders of magnitude, and that the infrared colors
of EGPs and brown dwarfs are much bluer than previously believed. In
particular, relative to $J$ and $H$, the $K$ band flux is reduced by CH_4 and
H_2 absorption. Furthermore, we derive that for T_{eff}s below 1200 K most or
all true metals are sequestered below the photosphere, that an interior
radiative zone is a generic feature of substellar objects, and that clouds of
H_2O and NH_3 are formed for T_{eff}s below \sim 400 K and \sim 200 K,
respectively. This study is done for solar-metallicity objects in isolation and
does not include the effects of stellar insolation. Nevertheless, it is an
attempt to bridge the gap between the planetary and stellar realms and to
develop a non-gray theory of objects from 0.3 \mj (``saturn'') to 70 \mj
($\sim$0.07 \mo). We find that the detection ranges for brown dwarf/EGP
discovery of both ground-- and space-based telescopes are larger than
previously estimated.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9705027 [pdf] - 1469520
Extrasolar Giant Planet and Brown Dwarf Models
Submitted: 1997-05-05
With the discovery of the companions of 51 Peg, 55 Cnc, $\tau$ Boo,
$\upsilon$ And, 70 Vir, 47 UMa, and Gl229, evolutionary and spectral models of
gas giants and/or brown dwarfs with masses from 0.3 through 60 times that of
Jupiter assume a new and central role in the emerging field of extrasolar
planetary studies. In this contribution, we describe the structural, spectral,
and evolutionary characteristics of such exotic objects, as determined by our
recent theoretical calculations. These calculations can be used to establish
direct search strategies via SIRTF, ISO, and HST (NICMOS), and via various
ground-based adaptive optics and interferometric platforms planned for the near
future.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9703007 [pdf] - 96768
Liquid metallic hydrogen and the structure of brown dwarfs and giant
planets
Submitted: 1997-03-02
Electron-degenerate, pressure-ionized hydrogen (usually referred to as
metallic hydrogen) is the principal constituent of brown dwarfs, the
long-sought objects which lie in the mass range between the lowest-mass stars
(about eighty times the mass of Jupiter) and the giant planets. The
thermodynamics and transport properties of metallic hydrogen are important for
understanding the properties of these objects, which, unlike stars, continually
and slowly cool from initial nondegenerate (gaseous) states. Within the last
year, a brown dwarf (Gliese 229 B) has been detected and its spectrum observed
and analyzed, and several examples of extrasolar giant planets have been
discovered. The brown dwarf appears to have a mass of about forty to fifty
Jupiter masses and is now too cool to be fusing hydrogen or deuterium, although
we predict that it will have consumed all of its primordial deuterium. This
paper reviews the current understanding of the interrelationship between its
interior properties and its observed spectrum, and also discusses the current
status of research on the structure of giant planets, both in our solar system
and elsewhere.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9608178 [pdf] - 95296
Theortetical Models of Extrasolar Giant Planets
Submitted: 1996-08-27
The recent discoveries of giant planets around nearby stars have galvanized
the planetary science community, astronomers, and the public at large. Since
{\it direct} detection is now feasible, and is suggested by the recent
acquisition of Gl229 B, it is crucial for the future of extrasolar planet
searches that the fluxes, evolution, and physical structure of objects from
Saturn's mass to 15 Juipter masses be theoretically investigated. We discuss
our first attempts to explore the characteristics of extrasolar giant planets
(EGPs), in aid of both NASA's and ESA's recent plans to search for such planets
around nearby stars.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9606036 [pdf] - 94796
Atmospheric, Evolutionary, and Spectral Models of the Brown Dwarf Gliese
229 B
Submitted: 1996-06-05
Theoretical spectra and evolutionary models that span the giant planet--brown
dwarf continuum have been computed based on the recent discovery of the brown
dwarf, Gliese 229 B. A flux enhancement in the 4--5 micron window is a
universal feature from Jovian planets to brown dwarfs. We confirm the existence
of methane and water in Gl 229 B's spectrum and find its mass to be 30 to 55
Jovian masses. Although these calculations focus on Gliese 229 B, they are also
meant to guide future searches for extra-solar giant planets and brown dwarfs.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9511109 [pdf] - 142704
Giant Planets at Small Orbital Distances
Submitted: 1995-11-22
Using Doppler spectroscopy to detect the reflex motion of the nearby star, 51
Pegasi, Mayor \& Queloz (1995) claim to have discovered a giant planet in a
0.05-A.U., 4.23-day orbit. They estimate its mass to be in the range 0.5 \mj to
2 \mj, but are not able to determine its nature or origin. Including the
effects of the severe stellar insolation implied, we extend the theory of giant
planets we have recently developed to encompass those at very small orbital
distances. Our calculations can be used to help formulate search strategies for
luminous planets in tight orbits around other nearby stars. We calculate the
radii and luminosities of such giants for a variety of compositions (H/He, He,
H$_2$O, and olivine), evolutionary tracks for solar- composition gas giants,
and the geometry of the Hayashi forbidden zone in the gas-giant mass regime. We
show that such planets are stable and estimate the magnitude of classical Jeans
evaporation and of photodissociation and loss due to EUV radiation. Even over
the lifetime of the primary, the present companion would not have lost a large
fraction of its mass. In addition, we demonstrate that for the mass range
quoted, such planets are well within their Roche lobes. We show that the strong
composition-dependence of the model radii and distinctive spectral signatures
provide clear diagnostics that might reveal 51 Peg B's nature, should
interferometric or adaptive-optics techniques ever succeed in photometrically
separating planet from star.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9510046 [pdf] - 93419
A Theory of Extrasolar Giant Planets
Submitted: 1995-10-08
We present a broad suite of models of extrasolar giant planets (EGP's),
ranging in mass from 0.3 to 15 Jupiter masses. The models predict luminosity
(both reflected and emitted) as a function of age, mass, deuterium abundance
and distance from parent stars of various spectral type. We also explore the
effects of helium mass fraction, rotation rate and the presence of a rock-ice
core. The models incorporate the most accurate available equation of state for
the interior, including a new theory for the enhancement of deuterium fusion by
electron screening which is potentially important in these low mass objects.
The results of our calculations reveal the enormous sensitivity of EGP's to the
presence of the parent star, particularly for G and earlier spectral types.
They also show a strong sensitivity of the flux contrast in the mid-infrared
between parent star and EGP to the mass and age of the EGP's. We interpret our
results in terms of search strategies for ground- and space-based observatories
in place or anticipated in the near future.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9506055 [pdf] - 92845
Prospects for Detection of Extra-Solar Giant Planets by Next-Generation
Telescopes
Submitted: 1995-06-07
Interest among astronomers in the detection of extra-solar planets is
accelerating with the growing realization that it may soon be technically
feasible. The ongoing renaissance in telescope construction and the anticipated
launches of new space platforms are encouraging many scientists to review and
improve the means by which planets can be discovered. The direct detection of
the light from a distant planet would be the most compelling means of discovery
and to gauge the feasibility of various search strategies, astronomers have
traditionally used the current Jupiter as a benchmark planet. However, in
principle, extra-solar giant planets (EGPs) can have a wide range of masses
and, hence, can be significantly brighter than Jupiter. Furthermore, the
maximum mass a planet can have is not known a priori, and observations will be
needed to determine it. We predict the optical and infrared fluxes of EGPs with
masses from 0.3 through 15 Jupiter masses and ages from 10$^7$ through $5
\times 10^{9}$ years that searches in the next few years may reveal.