Normalized to: Howes, G.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.02563 [pdf] - 2107926
Diagnosing collisionless energy transfer using field-particle
correlations: Alfven-Ion Cyclotron Turbulence
Submitted: 2020-06-03
We apply field-particle correlations -- a technique that tracks the
time-averaged velocity-space structure of the energy density transfer rate
between electromagnetic fields and plasma particles -- to data drawn from a
hybrid Vlasov-Maxwell simulation of Alfv\'en Ion-Cyclotron turbulence. Energy
transfer in this system is expected to include both Landau and cyclotron
wave-particle resonances, unlike previous systems to which the field-particle
correlation technique has been applied. In this simulation, the energy transfer
rate mediated by the parallel electric field $E_\parallel$ comprises
approximately $60\%$ of the total rate, with the remainder mediated by the
perpendicular electric field $E_\perp$. The parallel electric field resonantly
couples to protons, with the canonical bipolar velocity-space signature of
Landau damping identified at many points throughout the simulation. The energy
transfer mediated by $E_\perp$ preferentially couples to particles with $v_{tp}
\lesssim v_\perp \lesssim 3 v_{tp}$ in agreement with the expected formation of
a cyclotron diffusion plateau. Our results demonstrate clearly that the
field-particle correlation technique can distinguish distinct channels of
energy transfer using single-point measurements, even at points in which
multiple channels act simultaneously, and can be used to determine
quantitatively the rates of particle energization in each channel.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.06793 [pdf] - 2046404
Plasma Waves near the Electron Cyclotron Frequency in the near-Sun Solar
Wind
Malaspina, David M.;
Halekas, Jasper;
Bercic, Laura;
Larson, Davin;
Whittlesey, Phyllis;
Bale, Stuart D.;
Bonnell, John W.;
de Wit, Thierry Dudok;
Ergun, Robert E.;
Howes, Gregory;
Goetz, Keith;
Goodrich, Katherine;
Harvey, Peter R.;
MacDowall, Robert J.;
Pulupa, Marc;
Case, Anthony W.;
Kasper, Justin C.;
Korreck, Kelly E.;
Livi, Roberto;
Stevens, Michael L.
Submitted: 2019-12-14
Data from the first two orbits of the Sun by Parker Solar Probe reveal that
the solar wind sunward of 50 solar radii is replete with plasma waves and
instabilities. One of the most prominent plasma wave power enhancements in this
region appears near the electron cyclotron frequency (f_ce). Most of this wave
power is concentrated in electric field fluctuations near 0.7 f_ce and f_ce,
with strong harmonics of both frequencies extending above f_ce. At least two
distinct, often concurrent, wave modes are observed, preliminarily identified
as electrostatic whistler-mode waves and electron Bernstein waves. Wave
intervals range in duration from a few seconds to hours. Both the amplitudes
and number of detections of these near-f_ce waves increase significantly with
decreasing distance to the Sun, suggesting that they play an important role in
the evolution of electron populations in the near-Sun solar wind. Correlations
are found between the detection of these waves and properties of solar wind
electron populations, including electron core drift, implying that these waves
play a role in regulating the heat flux carried by solar wind electrons.
Observation of these near-f_ce waves is found to be strongly correlated with
near-radial solar wind magnetic field configurations with low levels of
magnetic turbulence. A scenario for the growth of these waves is presented
which implies that regions of low-turbulence near-radial magnetic field are a
prominent feature of solar wind structure near the Sun.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.02361 [pdf] - 2050283
Ion Scale Electromagnetic Waves in the Inner Heliosphere
Bowen, Trevor;
Mallet, Alfred;
Huang, Jia;
Klein, Kristopher G.;
Malaspina, David M.;
Stevens, Michael L.;
Bale, Stuart D.;
Bonnell, John W.;
Case, Anthony W.;
Chandran, Benjamin D.;
Chaston, Christopher;
Chen, Christopher H.;
de Wit, Thierry Dudok;
Goetz, Keith;
Harvey, Peter R.;
Howes, Gregory G.;
Kasper, Justin C.;
Korreck, Kelly;
Larson, Davin E.;
Livi, Roberto;
MacDowall, Robert J.;
McManus, Michael;
Pulupa, Marc;
Verniero, J;
Whittlesey, Phyllis
Submitted: 2019-12-04
Understanding the physical processes in the solar wind and corona which
actively contribute to heating, acceleration, and dissipation is a primary
objective of NASA's Parker Solar Probe (PSP) mission. Observations of coherent
electromagnetic waves at ion scales suggests that linear cyclotron resonance
and non-linear processes are dynamically relevant in the inner heliosphere. A
wavelet-based statistical study of coherent waves in the first perihelion
encounter of PSP demonstrates the presence of transverse electromagnetic waves
at ion resonant scales which are observed in 30-50\% of radial field intervals.
Average wave amplitudes of approximately 4 nT are measured, while the mean
duration of wave events is of order 20 seconds; however long duration wave
events can exist without interruption on hour-long timescales. Though ion scale
waves are preferentially observed during intervals with a radial mean magnetic
field, we show that measurement constraints, associated with single spacecraft
sampling of quasi-parallel waves superposed with anisotropic turbulence, render
the measured quasi-parallel ion-wave spectrum unobservable when the mean
magnetic field is oblique to the solar wind flow; these results imply that the
occurrence of coherent ion-scale waves is not limited to a radial field
configuration. The lack of strong radial scaling of characteristic wave
amplitudes and duration suggests that the waves are generated {\em{in-situ}}
through plasma instabilities. Additionally, observations of proton distribution
functions indicate that temperature anisotropy may drive the observed ion-scale
waves.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.09334 [pdf] - 1955888
Collisionless energy transfer in kinetic turbulence: field-particle
correlations in Fourier space
Submitted: 2019-04-18, last modified: 2019-09-05
Turbulence is ubiquitously observed in nearly collisionless heliospheric
plasmas, including the solar wind and corona and the Earth's magnetosphere.
Understanding the collisionless mechanisms responsible for the energy transfer
from the turbulent fluctuations to the particles is a frontier in kinetic
turbulence research. Collisionless energy transfer from the turbulence to the
particles can take place reversibly, resulting in non-thermal energy in the
particle velocity distribution functions (VDFs) before eventual collisional
thermalization is realized. Exploiting the information contained in the
fluctuations in the VDFs is valuable. Here we apply a recently developed method
based on VDFs, the field-particle correlation technique, to a $\beta=1$,
solar-wind-like, low-frequency Alfv\'enic turbulence simulation with well
resolved phase space to identify the field-particle energy transfer in velocity
space. The field-particle correlations reveal that the energy transfer,
mediated by the parallel electric field, results in significant structuring of
the ion and electron VDFs in the direction parallel to the magnetic field.
Fourier modes representing the length scales between the ion and electron
gyroradii show that energy transfer is resonant in nature, localized in
velocity space to the Landau resonances for each Fourier mode. The energy
transfer closely follows the Landau resonant velocities with varying
perpendicular wavenumber $k_\perp$ and plasma $\beta$. This resonant signature,
consistent with Landau damping, is observed in all diagnosed Fourier modes that
cover the dissipation range of the simulation.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.05710 [pdf] - 1849281
[Plasma 2020 Decadal] Disentangling the Spatiotemporal Structure of
Turbulence Using Multi-Spacecraft Data
TenBarge, J. M.;
Alexandrova, O.;
Boldyrev, S.;
Califano, F.;
Cerri, S. S.;
Chen, C. H. K.;
Howes, G. G.;
Horbury, T.;
Isenberg, P. A.;
Ji, H.;
Klein, K. G.;
Krafft, C.;
Kunz, M.;
Loureiro, N. F.;
Mallet, A.;
Maruca, B. A.;
Matthaeus, W. H.;
Meyrand, R.;
Quataert, E.;
Perez, J. C.;
Roberts, O. W.;
Sahraoui, F.;
Salem, C. S.;
Schekochihin, A. A.;
Spence, H.;
Squire, J.;
Told, D.;
Verscharen, D.;
Wicks, R. T.
Submitted: 2019-03-13
This white paper submitted for 2020 Decadal Assessment of Plasma Science
concerns the importance of multi-spacecraft missions to address fundamental
questions concerning plasma turbulence. Plasma turbulence is ubiquitous in the
universe, and it is responsible for the transport of mass, momentum, and energy
in such diverse systems as the solar corona and wind, accretion discs, planet
formation, and laboratory fusion devices. Turbulence is an inherently
multi-scale and multi-process phenomenon, coupling the largest scales of a
system to sub-electron scales via a cascade of energy, while simultaneously
generating reconnecting current layers, shocks, and a myriad of instabilities
and waves. The solar wind is humankind's best resource for studying the
naturally occurring turbulent plasmas that permeate the universe. Since
launching our first major scientific spacecraft mission, Explorer 1, in 1958,
we have made significant progress characterizing solar wind turbulence. Yet,
due to the severe limitations imposed by single point measurements, we are
unable to characterize sufficiently the spatial and temporal properties of the
solar wind, leaving many fundamental questions about plasma turbulence
unanswered. Therefore, the time has now come wherein making significant
additional progress to determine the dynamical nature of solar wind turbulence
requires multi-spacecraft missions spanning a wide range of scales
simultaneously. A dedicated multi-spacecraft mission concurrently covering a
wide range of scales in the solar wind would not only allow us to directly
determine the spatial and temporal structure of plasma turbulence, but it would
also mitigate the limitations that current multi-spacecraft missions face, such
as non-ideal orbits for observing solar wind turbulence. Some of the
fundamentally important questions that can only be addressed by in situ
multipoint measurements are discussed.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.05785 [pdf] - 1832682
Evidence for Electron Landau Damping in Space Plasma Turbulence
Submitted: 2019-02-15
How turbulent energy is dissipated in weakly collisional space and
astrophysical plasmas is a major open question. Here, we present the
application of a field-particle correlation technique to directly measure the
transfer of energy between the turbulent electromagnetic field and electrons in
the Earth's magnetosheath, the region of solar wind downstream of the Earth's
bow shock. The measurement of the secular energy transfer from the parallel
electric field as a function of electron velocity shows a signature consistent
with Landau damping. This signature is coherent over time, close to the
predicted resonant velocity, similar to that seen in kinetic Alfv\'en
turbulence simulations, and disappears under phase randomisation. This suggests
that electron Landau damping could play a significant role in turbulent plasma
heating, and that the technique is a valuable tool for determining the particle
energisation processes operating in space and astrophysical plasmas.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.04154 [pdf] - 1678550
Laboratory Space Physics: Investigating the Physics of Space Plasmas in
the Laboratory
Submitted: 2018-02-09
Laboratory experiments provide a valuable complement to explore the
fundamental physics of space plasmas without the limitations inherent to
spacecraft measurements. Specifically, experiments overcome the restriction
that spacecraft measurements are made at only one (or a few) points in space,
enable greater control of the plasma conditions and applied perturbations, can
be reproducible, and are orders of magnitude less expensive than launching
spacecraft. Here I highlight key open questions about the physics of space
plasmas and identify the aspects of these problems that can potentially be
tackled in laboratory experiments. Several past successes in laboratory space
physics provide concrete examples of how complementary experiments can
contribute to our understanding of physical processes at play in the solar
corona, solar wind, planetary magnetospheres, and outer boundary of the
heliosphere. I present developments on the horizon of laboratory space physics,
identifying velocity space as a key new frontier, highlighting new and enhanced
experimental facilities, and showcasing anticipated developments to produce
improved diagnostics and innovative analysis methods. A strategy for future
laboratory space physics investigations will be outlined, with explicit
connections to specific fundamental plasma phenomena of interest.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.00757 [pdf] - 1648603
Spatially Localized Particle Energization by Landau Damping in Current
Sheets Produced by Strong Alfven Wave Collisions
Submitted: 2017-07-21
Understanding the removal of energy from turbulent fluctuations in a
magnetized plasma and the consequent energization of the constituent plasma
particles is a major goal of heliophysics and astrophysics. Previous work has
shown that nonlinear interactions among counterpropagating Alfven waves---or
Alfven wave collisions---are the fundamental building block of astrophysical
plasma turbulence and naturally generate current sheets in the strongly
nonlinear limit. A nonlinear gyrokinetic simulation of a strong Alfven wave
collision is used to examine the damping of the electromagnetic fluctuations
and the associated energization of particles that occurs in self-consistently
generated current sheets. A simple model explains the flow of energy due to the
collisionless damping and the associated particle energization, as well as the
subsequent thermalization of the particle energy by collisions. The net
particle energization by the parallel electric field is shown to be spatially
intermittent, and the nonlinear evolution is essential in enabling that spatial
non-uniformity. Using the recently developed field-particle correlation
technique, we show that particles resonant with the Alfven waves in the
simulation dominate the energy transfer, demonstrating conclusively that Landau
damping plays a key role in the spatially intermittent damping of the
electromagnetic fluctuations and consequent energization of the particles in
this strongly nonlinear simulation.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.06230 [pdf] - 1641254
The Development of Magnetic Field Line Wander by Plasma Turbulence
Submitted: 2017-07-19
Plasma turbulence occurs ubiquitously in space and astrophysical plasmas,
mediating the nonlinear transfer of energy from large-scale electromagnetic
fields and plasma flows to small scales at which the energy may be ultimately
converted to plasma heat. But plasma turbulence also generically leads to a
tangling of the magnetic field that threads through the plasma. The resulting
wander of the magnetic field lines may significantly impact a number of
important physical processes, including the propagation of cosmic rays and
energetic particles, confinement in magnetic fusion devices, and the
fundamental processes of turbulence, magnetic reconnection, and particle
acceleration. The various potential impacts of magnetic field line wander are
reviewed in detail, and a number of important theoretical considerations are
identified that may influence the development and saturation of magnetic field
line wander in astrophysical plasma turbulence. The results of nonlinear
gyrokinetic simulations of kinetic Alfven wave turbulence of sub-ion length
scales are evaluated to understand the development and saturation of the
turbulent magnetic energy spectrum and of the magnetic field line wander. It is
found that turbulent space and astrophysical plasmas are generally expected to
contain a stochastic magnetic field due to the tangling of the field by strong
plasma turbulence. Future work will explore how the saturated magnetic field
line wander varies as a function of the amplitude of the plasma turbulence and
the ratio of the thermal to magnetic pressure, known as the plasma beta.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.07840 [pdf] - 1583716
A Prospectus on Kinetic Heliophysics
Submitted: 2017-05-18
Under the low density and high temperature conditions typical of heliospheric
plasmas, the macroscopic evolution of the heliosphere is strongly affected by
the kinetic plasma physics governing fundamental microphysical mechanisms.
Kinetic turbulence, collision less magnetic reconnection, particle
acceleration, and kinetic instabilities are four poorly understood,
grand-challenge problems that lie at the new frontier of kinetic heliophysics.
The increasing availability of high cadence and high phase-space resolution
measurements of particle velocity distributions by current and upcoming
spacecraft missions and of massively parallel nonlinear kinetic simulations of
weakly collisional heliospheric plasmas provides the opportunity to transform
our understanding of these kinetic mechanisms through the full utilization of
the information contained in the particle velocity distributions. Several major
considerations for future investigations of kinetic heliophysics are examined.
Turbulent dissipation followed by particle heating is highlighted as an
inherently two-step process in weakly collisional plasmas, distinct from the
more familiar case in fluid theory. Concerted efforts must be made to tackle
the big-data challenge of visualizing the high-dimensional (3D-3V) phase space
of kinetic plasma theory through physics-based reductions. Furthermore, the
development of innovative analysis methods that utilize full velocity-space
measurements, such as the field-particle correlation technique, will enable us
to gain deeper insight into these four grand-challenge problems of kinetic
heliophysics. A systems approach to tackle the multi-scale problem of
heliophysics through a rigorous connection between the kinetic physics at
microscales and the self-consistent evolution of the heliosphere at macro
scales will propel the field of kinetic heliophysics into the future.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.06385 [pdf] - 1583566
Diagnosing collisionless energy transfer using field-particle
correlations: gyrokinetic turbulence
Submitted: 2017-05-17
Determining the physical mechanisms that extract energy from turbulent
fluctuations in weakly collisional magnetized plasmas is necessary for a more
complete characterization of the behavior of a variety of space and
astrophysical plasmas. Such a determination is complicated by the complex
nature of the turbulence as well as observational constraints, chiefly that in
situ measurements of such plasmas are typically only available at a single
point in space. Recent work has shown that correlations between electric fields
and particle velocity distributions constructed from single-point measurements
produce a velocity-dependent signature of the collisionless damping mechanism.
We extend this work by constructing field-particle correlations using data sets
drawn from single points in strongly driven, turbulent, electromagnetic
gyrokinetic simulations to demonstrate that this technique can identify the
collisionless mechanisms operating in such systems. The correlation's
velocity-space structure agrees with expectations of resonant mechanisms
transferring energy collisionlessly in turbulent systems. This work motivates
the eventual application of field-particle correlations to spacecraft
measurements in the solar wind, with the ultimate goal to determine the
physical mechanisms that dissipate magnetized plasma turbulence.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.02842 [pdf] - 1526821
Energy Dissipation and Landau Damping in Two- and Three-Dimensional
Plasma Turbulence
Submitted: 2015-10-09, last modified: 2016-12-04
Plasma turbulence is ubiquitous in space and astrophysical plasmas, playing
an important role in plasma energization, but the physical mechanisms leading
to dissipation of the turbulent energy remain to be definitively identified.
Kinetic simulations in two dimensions (2D) have been extensively used to study
the dissipation process. How the limitation to 2D affects energy dissipation
remains unclear. This work provides a model of comparison between two- and
three-dimensional (3D) plasma turbulence using gyrokinetic simulations; it also
explores the dynamics of distribution functions during the dissipation process.
It is found that both 2D and 3D nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations of a low-beta
plasma generate electron velocity-space structures with the same
characteristics as that of linear Landau damping of Alfv\'en waves in a 3D
linear simulation. The continual occurrence of the velocity-space structures
throughout the turbulence simulations suggests that the action of Landau
damping may be responsible for the turbulent energy transfer to electrons in
both 2D and 3D, and makes possible the subsequent irreversible heating of the
plasma through collisional smoothing of the velocity-space fluctuations.
Although, in the 2D case where variation along the equilibrium magnetic field
is absent, it may be expected that Landau damping is not possible, a common
trigonometric factor appears in the 2D resonant denominator, leaving the
resonance condition unchanged from the 3D case. The evolution of the 2D and 3D
cases is qualitatively similar. However, quantitatively the nonlinear energy
cascade and subsequent dissipation is significantly slower in the 2D case.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.07465 [pdf] - 1460970
The Dynamical Generation of Current Sheets in Astrophysical Plasma
Turbulence
Submitted: 2016-07-25
Turbulence profoundly affects particle transport and plasma heating in many
astrophysical plasma environments, from galaxy clusters to the solar corona and
solar wind to Earth's magnetosphere. Both fluid and kinetic simulations of
plasma turbulence ubiquitously generate coherent structures, in the form of
current sheets, at small scales, and the locations of these current sheets
appear to be associated with enhanced rates of dissipation of the turbulent
energy. Therefore, illuminating the origin and nature of these current sheets
is critical to identifying the dominant physical mechanisms of dissipation, a
primary aim at the forefront of plasma turbulence research. Here we present
evidence from nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations that strong nonlinear
interactions between counterpropagating Alfven waves, or strong Alfven wave
collisions, are a natural mechanism for the generation of current sheets in
plasma turbulence. Furthermore, we conceptually explain this current sheet
development in terms of the nonlinear dynamics of Alfven wave collisions,
showing that these current sheets arise through constructive interference among
the initial Alfven waves and nonlinearly generated modes. The properties of
current sheets generated by a strong Alfven wave collisions are compared to
published observations of current sheets in the Earth's magnetosheath and the
solar wind, and the nature of these current sheets leads to the expectation
that Landau damping of the constituent Alfven waves plays a dominant role in
the damping of turbulently generated current sheets.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.01738 [pdf] - 1457465
Measuring Collisionless Damping in Heliospheric Plasmas using
Field-Particle Correlations
Submitted: 2016-07-06
An innovative field-particle correlation technique is proposed that uses
single-point measurements of the electromagnetic fields and particle velocity
distribution functions to investigate the net transfer of energy from fields to
particles associated with the collisionless damping of turbulent fluctuations
in weakly collisional plasmas, such as the solar wind. In addition to providing
a direct estimate of the local rate of energy transfer between fields and
particles, it provides vital new information about the distribution of that
energy transfer in velocity space. This velocity-space signature can
potentially be used to identify the dominant collisionless mechanism
responsible for the damping of turbulent fluctuations in the solar wind. The
application of this novel field-particle correlation technique is illustrated
using the simplified case of the Landau damping of Langmuir waves in an
electrostatic 1D-1V Vlasov-Poisson plasma, showing that the procedure both
estimates the local rate of energy transfer from the electrostatic field to the
electrons and indicates the resonant nature of this interaction. Modifications
of the technique to enable single-point spacecraft measurements of fields and
particles to diagnose the collisionless damping of turbulent fluctuations in
the solar wind are discussed, yielding a method with the potential to transform
our ability to maximize the scientific return from current and upcoming
spacecraft missions, such as the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) and Solar
Probe Plus missions.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.00695 [pdf] - 953672
Predicted Impacts of Proton Temperature Anisotropy on Solar Wind
Turbulence
Submitted: 2015-03-02, last modified: 2015-03-13
Particle velocity distributions measured in the weakly collisional solar wind
are frequently found to be non-Maxwellian, but how these non-Maxwellian
distributions impact the physics of plasma turbulence in the solar wind remains
unanswered. Using numerical solutions of the linear dispersion relation for a
collisionless plasma with a bi-Maxwellian proton velocity distribution, we
present a unified framework for the four proton temperature anisotropy
instabilities, identifying the associated stable eigenmodes, highlighting the
unstable region of wavevector space, and presenting the properties of the
growing eigenfunctions. Based on physical intuition gained from this framework,
we address how the proton temperature anisotropy impacts the nonlinear dynamics
of the \Alfvenic fluctuations underlying the dominant cascade of energy from
large to small scales and how the fluctuations driven by proton temperature
anisotropy instabilities interact nonlinearly with each other and with the
fluctuations of the large-scale cascade. We find that the nonlinear dynamics of
the large-scale cascade is insensitive to the proton temperature anisotropy,
and that the instability-driven fluctuations are unlikely to cause significant
nonlinear evolution of either the instability-driven fluctuations or the
turbulent fluctuations of the large-scale cascade.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.04109 [pdf] - 1263905
A Dynamical Model of Plasma Turbulence in the Solar Wind
Submitted: 2015-02-13
A dynamical approach, rather than the usual statistical approach, is taken to
explore the physical mechanisms underlying the nonlinear transfer of energy,
the damping of the turbulent fluctuations, and the development of coherent
structures in kinetic plasma turbulence. It is argued that the linear and
nonlinear dynamics of Alfven waves are responsible, at a very fundamental
level, for some of the key qualitative features of plasma turbulence that
distinguish it from hydrodynamic turbulence, including the anisotropic cascade
of energy and the development of current sheets at small scales. The first
dynamical model of kinetic turbulence in the weakly collisional solar wind
plasma that combines self-consistently the physics of Alfven waves with the
development of small-scale current sheets is presented and its physical
implications are discussed. This model leads to a simplified perspective on the
nature of turbulence in a weakly collisional plasma: the nonlinear interactions
responsible for the turbulent cascade of energy and the formation of current
sheets are essentially fluid in nature, while the collisionless damping of the
turbulent fluctuations and the energy injection by kinetic instabilities are
essentially kinetic in nature.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.04130 [pdf] - 935870
Kinetic Turbulence
Submitted: 2015-02-13
The weak collisionality typical of turbulence in many diffuse astrophysical
plasmas invalidates an MHD description of the turbulent dynamics, motivating
the development of a more comprehensive theory of kinetic turbulence. In
particular, a kinetic approach is essential for the investigation of the
physical mechanisms responsible for the dissipation of astrophysical turbulence
and the resulting heating of the plasma. This chapter reviews the limitations
of MHD turbulence theory and explains how kinetic considerations may be
incorporated to obtain a kinetic theory for astrophysical plasma turbulence.
Key questions about the nature of kinetic turbulence that drive current
research efforts are identified. A comprehensive model of the kinetic turbulent
cascade is presented, with a detailed discussion of each component of the model
and a review of supporting and conflicting theoretical, numerical, and
observational evidence.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.5470 [pdf] - 1215114
The Violation of the Taylor Hypothesis in Measurements of Solar Wind
Turbulence
Submitted: 2014-06-20
Motivated by the upcoming Solar Orbiter and Solar Probe Plus missions,
qualitative and quantitative predictions are made for the effects of the
violation of the Taylor hypothesis on the magnetic energy frequency spectrum
measured in the near-Sun environment. The synthetic spacecraft data method is
used to predict observational signatures of the violation for critically
balanced Alfv\'enic turbulence or parallel fast/whistler turbulence. The
violation of the Taylor hypothesis can occur in the slow flow regime, leading
to a shift of the entire spectrum to higher frequencies, or in the dispersive
regime, in which the dissipation range spectrum flattens at high frequencies.
It is found that Alfv\'enic turbulence will not significantly violate the
Taylor hypothesis, but whistler turbulence will. The flattening of the
frequency spectrum is therefore a key observational signature for fast/whistler
turbulence.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.3357 [pdf] - 893672
Analysis of Magnetic Fields in Inertial Alfven Wave Collisions
Submitted: 2014-06-12
Turbulence in astrophysical and space plasmas is dominated by the nonlinear
interaction of counterpropagating Alfven waves. Most Alfven wave turbulence
theories have been based on ideal plasma models, such as incompressible MHD,
for Alfven waves at large scales. However, in the inertial Alfven wave regime
(vA > vthe), relevant to magnetospheric plasmas, how the turbulent nonlinear
interactions are modified by the dispersive nature of the waves remains to be
explored. Here we present the first laboratory evidence of the nonlinear
interaction in the inertial regime. A comparison is made with the theory for
MHD Alfven waves.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.4589 [pdf] - 1833950
The Inherently Three-Dimensional Nature of Magnetized Plasma Turbulence
Submitted: 2013-06-19, last modified: 2014-06-02
It is often asserted or implicitly assumed, without justification, that the
results of two-dimensional investigations of plasma turbulence are applicable
to the three-dimensional plasma environments of interest. A projection method
is applied to derive two scalar equations that govern the nonlinear evolution
of the Alfvenic and pseudo-Alfvenic components of ideal incompressible
magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) plasma turbulence. The mathematical form of these
equations makes clear the inherently three-dimensional nature of plasma
turbulence, enabling an analysis of the nonlinear properties of two-dimensional
limits often used to study plasma turbulence. In the anisotropic limit k_perp
>>k_parallel that naturally arises in magnetized plasma systems, the
perpendicular 2D limit retains the dominant nonlinearities that are mediated
only by the Alfvenic fluctuations but lacks the wave physics associated with
the linear term that is necessary to capture the anisotropic cascade of
turbulent energy. In the in-plane 2D limit, the nonlinear energy transfer is
controlled instead by the pseudo-Alfven waves, with the Alfven waves relegated
to a passive role. In the oblique 2D limit, an unavoidable azimuthal dependence
connecting the wavevector components will likely cause artificial azimuthal
asymmetries in the resulting turbulent dynamics. Therefore, none of these 2D
limits is sufficient to capture fully the rich three-dimensional nonlinear
dynamics critical to the evolution of plasma turbulence.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.5460 [pdf] - 1209660
Validity of the Taylor Hypothesis for Linear Kinetic Waves in the Weakly
Collisional Solar Wind
Submitted: 2014-05-21
The interpretation of single-point spacecraft measurements of solar wind
turbulence is complicated by the fact that the measurements are made in a frame
of reference in relative motion with respect to the turbulent plasma. The
Taylor hypothesis---that temporal fluctuations measured by a stationary probe
in a rapidly flowing fluid are dominated by the advection of spatial structures
in the fluid rest frame---is often assumed to simplify the analysis. But
measurements of turbulence in upcoming missions, such as Solar Probe Plus,
threaten to violate the Taylor hypothesis, either due to slow flow of the
plasma with respect to the spacecraft or to the dispersive nature of the plasma
fluctuations at small scales. Assuming that the frequency of the turbulent
fluctuations is characterized by the frequency of the linear waves supported by
the plasma, we evaluate the validity of the Taylor hypothesis for the linear
kinetic wave modes in the weakly collisional solar wind. The analysis predicts
that a dissipation range of solar wind turbulence supported by whistler waves
is likely to violate the Taylor hypothesis, while one supported by kinetic
Alfven waves is not.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.2913 [pdf] - 809006
The Quasilinear Premise for the Modeling of Plasma Turbulence
Submitted: 2014-04-10
The quasilinear premise is a hypothesis for the modeling of plasma turbulence
in which the turbulent fluctuations are represented by a superposition of
randomly-phased linear wave modes, and energy is transferred among these wave
modes via nonlinear interactions. We define specifically what constitutes the
quasilinear premise, and present a range of theoretical arguments in support of
the relevance of linear wave properties even in a strongly turbulent plasma. We
review evidence both in support of and in conflict with the quasilinear premise
from numerical simulations and measurements of plasma turbulence in the solar
wind. Although the question of the validity of the quasilinear premise remains
to be settled, we suggest that the evidence largely supports the value of the
quasilinear premise in modeling plasma turbulence and that its usefulness may
also be judged by the insights gained from such an approach, with the ultimate
goal to develop the capability to predict the evolution of any turbulent plasma
system, including the spectrum of turbulent fluctuations, their dissipation,
and the resulting plasma heating.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.2306 [pdf] - 1208285
Physical Interpretation of the Angle Dependent Magnetic Helicity
Spectrum in the Solar Wind: The Nature of Turbulent Fluctuations near the
Proton Gyroradius Scale
Submitted: 2014-03-10
Motivated by recent observations of distinct parallel and perpendicular
signatures in magnetic helicity measurements segregated by wave period and
angle between the local magnetic field and the solar wind velocity, this paper
undertakes a comparison of three intervals of \emph{Ulysses} data with
synthetic time series generated from a physically motivated turbulence model.
From these comparisons, it is hypothesized that the observed signatures result
from a perpendicular cascade of \Alfvenic fluctuations and a local,
non-turbulent population of ion cyclotron or whistler waves generated by
temperature anisotropy instabilities. By constraining the model's free
parameters through comparison to \emph{in situ} data, it is found that, on
average, $ \sim 95\%$ of the power near dissipative scales is contained in a
perpendicular \Alfvenic cascade and that the parallel fluctuations are
propagating nearly unidirectionally. The effects of aliasing on magnetic
helicity measurements are considered and shown to be significant near the
Nyquist frequency.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.5166 [pdf] - 1202343
Collisionless Reconnection in the Large Guide Field Regime: Gyrokinetic
Versus Particle-in-Cell Simulations
Submitted: 2013-12-18, last modified: 2014-02-18
Results of the first validation of large guide field, $B_g / \delta B_0 \gg
1$, gyrokinetic simulations of magnetic reconnection at a fusion and solar
corona relevant $\beta_i = 0.01$ and solar wind relevant $\beta_i = 1$ are
presented, where $\delta B_0$ is the reconnecting field. Particle-in-cell (PIC)
simulations scan a wide range of guide magnetic field strength to test for
convergence to the gyrokinetic limit. The gyrokinetic simulations display a
high degree of morphological symmetry, to which the PIC simulations converge
when $\beta_i B_g / \delta B_0 \gtrsim 1$ and $B_g / \delta B_0 \gg 1$. In the
regime of convergence, the reconnection rate, relative energy conversion, and
overall magnitudes are found to match well between the PIC and gyrokinetic
simulations, implying that gyrokinetics is capable of making accurate
predictions well outside its regime of formal applicability. These results
imply that in the large guide field limit many quantities resulting from the
nonlinear evolution of reconnection scale linearly with the guide field.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.2212 [pdf] - 1166533
An Oscillating Langevin Antenna for Driving Plasma Turbulence
Simulations
Submitted: 2013-05-09, last modified: 2013-10-21
A unique method of driving Alfvenic turbulence via an oscillating Langevin
antenna is presented. This method of driving is motivated by a desire to inject
energy into a finite domain numerical simulation in a manner that models the
nonlinear transfer of energy from fluctuations in the turbulent cascade at
scales larger than the simulation domain.. The oscillating Langevin antenna is
shown to capture the essential features of the larger scale turbulence and
efficiently couple to the plasma, generating steady-state turbulence within one
characteristic turnaround time. The antenna is also sufficiently flexible to
explore both strong and weak regimes of Alfvenic plasma turbulence.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.1460 [pdf] - 1171857
Alfven Wave Collisions, The Fundamental Building Block of Plasma
Turbulence III: Theory for Experimental Design
Submitted: 2013-06-06, last modified: 2013-06-11
Turbulence in space and astrophysical plasmas is governed by the nonlinear
interactions between counterpropagating Alfven waves. Here we present the
theoretical considerations behind the design of the first laboratory
measurement of an Alfven wave collision, the fundamental interaction underlying
Alfvenic turbulence. By interacting a relatively large-amplitude, low-frequency
Alfven wave with a counterpropagating, smaller-amplitude, higher-frequency
Alfven wave, the experiment accomplishes the secular nonlinear transfer of
energy to a propagating daughter Alfven wave. The predicted properties of the
nonlinearly generated daughter Alfven wave are outlined, providing a suite of
tests that can be used to confirm the successful measurement of the nonlinear
interaction between counterpropagating Alfven waves in the laboratory.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.2958 [pdf] - 1165873
Current Sheets and Collisionless Damping in Kinetic Plasma Turbulence
Submitted: 2013-04-10, last modified: 2013-06-07
We present the first study of the formation and dissipation of current sheets
at electron scales in a wave-driven, weakly collisional, 3D kinetic turbulence
simulation. We investigate the relative importance of dissipation associated
with collisionless damping via resonant wave-particle interactions versus
dissipation in small-scale current sheets in weakly collisional plasma
turbulence. Current sheets form self-consistently from the wave-driven
turbulence, and their filling fraction is well correlated to the electron
heating rate. However, the weakly collisional nature of the simulation
necessarily implies that the current sheets are not significantly dissipated
via Ohmic dissipation. Rather, collisionless damping via the Landau resonance
with the electrons is sufficient to account for the measured heating as a
function of scale in the simulation, without the need for significant Ohmic
dissipation. This finding suggests the possibility that the dissipation of the
current sheets is governed by resonant wave-particle interactions and that the
locations of current sheets correspond spatially to regions of enhanced
heating.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.1455 [pdf] - 1171855
Alfven Wave Collisions, The Fundamental Building Block of Plasma
Turbulence I: Asymptotic Solution
Submitted: 2013-06-06
The nonlinear interaction between counterpropagating Alfven waves is the
physical mechanism underlying the cascade of energy to small scales in
astrophysical plasma turbulence. Beginning with the equations for
incompressible MHD, an asymptotic analytical solution for the nonlinear
evolution of these Alfven wave collisions is derived in the weakly nonlinear
limit. The resulting qualitative picture of nonlinear energy transfer due to
this mechanism involves two steps: first, the primary counterpropagating Alfven
waves interact to generate an inherently nonlinear, purely magnetic secondary
fluctuation with no parallel variation; second, the two primary waves each
interact with this secondary fluctuation to transfer energy secularly to two
tertiary Alfven waves. These tertiary modes are linear Alfven waves with the
same parallel wavenumber as the primary waves, indicating the lack of a
parallel cascade. The amplitude of these tertiary modes increases linearly with
time due to the coherent nature of the resonant four-wave interaction
responsible for the nonlinear energy transfer. The implications of this
analytical solution for turbulence in astrophysical plasmas is discussed. The
solution presented here provides valuable intuition about the nonlinear
interactions underlying magnetized plasma turbulence, in support of an
experimental program to verify in the laboratory the nature of this fundamental
building block of astrophysical plasma turbulence.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.1456 [pdf] - 1171856
Alfven Wave Collisions, The Fundamental Building Block of Plasma
Turbulence II: Numerical Solution
Submitted: 2013-06-06
This paper presents the numerical verification of an asymptotic analytical
solution for the nonlinear interaction between counterpropagating Alfven waves,
the fundamental building block of astrophysical plasma turbulence. The
analytical solution, derived in the weak turbulence limit using the equations
of incompressible MHD, is compared to a nonlinear gyrokinetic simulation of an
Alfven wave collision. The agreement between these methods signifies that the
incompressible solution satisfactorily describes the essential dynamics of the
nonlinear energy transfer, even under the weakly collisional plasma conditions
relevant to many astrophysical environments.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.1130 [pdf] - 1171830
Alfven Wave Collisions, The Fundamental Building Block of Plasma
Turbulence IV: Laboratory Experiment
Submitted: 2013-06-05
Turbulence is a phenomenon found throughout space and astrophysical plasmas.
It plays an important role in solar coronal heating, acceleration of the solar
wind, and heating of the interstellar medium. Turbulence in these regimes is
dominated by Alfven waves. Most turbulence theories have been established using
ideal plasma models, such as incompressible MHD. However, there has been no
experimental evidence to support the use of such models for weakly to
moderately collisional plasmas which are relevant to various space and
astrophysical plasma environments. We present the first experiment to measure
the nonlinear interaction between two counterpropagating Alfven waves, which is
the building block for astrophysical turbulence theories. We present here four
distinct tests that demonstrate conclusively that we have indeed measured the
daughter Alfven wave generated nonlinearly by a collision between
counterpropagating Alfven waves.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.4568 [pdf] - 1152199
Toward Astrophysical Turbulence in the Laboratory
Submitted: 2012-10-16
Turbulence is a ubiquitous phenomenon in space and astrophysical plasmas,
driving a cascade of energy from large to small scales and strongly influencing
the plasma heating resulting from the dissipation of the turbulence. Modern
theories of plasma turbulence are based on the fundamental concept that the
turbulent cascade of energy is caused by the nonlinear interaction between
counterpropagating Alfven waves, yet this interaction has never been
observationally or experimentally verified. We present here the first
experimental measurement in a laboratory plasma of the nonlinear interaction
between counterpropagating Alfven waves, the fundamental building block of
astrophysical plasma turbulence. This measurement establishes a firm basis for
the application of theoretical ideas developed in idealized models to
turbulence in realistic space and astrophysical plasma systems.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.0127 [pdf] - 683852
Kinetic Scale Density Fluctuations in the Solar Wind
Submitted: 2012-09-29
We motivate the importance of studying kinetic scale turbulence for
understanding the macroscopic properties of the heliosphere, such as the
heating of the solar wind. We then discuss the technique by which kinetic scale
density fluctuations can be measured using the spacecraft potential, including
a calculation of the timescale for the spacecraft potential to react to the
density changes. Finally, we compare the shape of the density spectrum at ion
scales to theoretical predictions based on a cascade model for kinetic
turbulence. We conclude that the shape of the spectrum, including the ion scale
flattening, can be captured by the sum of passive density fluctuations at large
scales and kinetic Alfven wave turbulence at small scales.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.6564 [pdf] - 1124456
Using Synthetic Spacecraft Data to Interpret Compressible Fluctuations
in Solar Wind Turbulence
Submitted: 2012-06-28
Kinetic plasma theory is used to generate synthetic spacecraft data to
analyze and interpret the compressible fluctuations in the inertial range of
solar wind turbulence. The kinetic counterparts of the three familiar linear
MHD wave modes---the fast, Alfven, and slow waves---are identified and the
properties of the density-parallel magnetic field correlation for these kinetic
wave modes is presented. The construction of synthetic spacecraft data, based
on the quasi-linear premise---that some characteristics of magnetized plasma
turbulence can be usefully modeled as a collection of randomly phased, linear
wave modes---is described in detail. Theoretical predictions of the
density-parallel magnetic field correlation based on MHD and Vlasov-Maxwell
linear eigenfunctions are presented and compared to the observational
determination of this correlation based on 10 years of Wind spacecraft data. It
is demonstrated that MHD theory is inadequate to describe the compressible
turbulent fluctuations and that the observed density-parallel magnetic field
correlation is consistent with a statistically negligible kinetic fast wave
energy contribution for the large sample used in this study. A model of the
solar wind inertial range fluctuations is proposed comprised of a mixture of a
critically balanced distribution of incompressible Alfvenic fluctuations and a
critically balanced or more anisotropic than critical balance distribution of
compressible slow wave fluctuations. These results imply that there is little
or no transfer of large scale turbulent energy through the inertial range down
to whistler waves at small scales.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.0749 [pdf] - 1123140
Interpreting Magnetic Variance Anisotropy Measurements in the Solar Wind
Submitted: 2012-05-03
The magnetic variance anisotropy ($\mathcal{A}_m$) of the solar wind has been
used widely as a method to identify the nature of solar wind turbulent
fluctuations; however, a thorough discussion of the meaning and interpretation
of the $\mathcal{A}_m$ has not appeared in the literature. This paper explores
the implications and limitations of using the $\mathcal{A}_m$ as a method for
constraining the solar wind fluctuation mode composition and presents a more
informative method for interpreting spacecraft data. The paper also compares
predictions of the $\mathcal{A}_m$ from linear theory to nonlinear turbulence
simulations and solar wind measurements. In both cases, linear theory compares
well and suggests the solar wind for the interval studied is dominantly
Alfv\'{e}nic in the inertial and dissipation ranges to scales $k \rho_i \simeq
5$.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.0056 [pdf] - 1092654
Evidence of Critical Balance in Kinetic Alfven Wave Turbulence
Simulations
Submitted: 2011-12-29
A numerical simulation of kinetic plasma turbulence is performed to assess
the applicability of critical balance to kinetic, dissipation scale turbulence.
The analysis is performed in the frequency domain to obviate complications
inherent in performing a local analysis of turbulence. A theoretical model of
dissipation scale critical balance is constructed and compared to simulation
results, and excellent agreement is found. This result constitutes the first
evidence of critical balance in a kinetic turbulence simulation and provides
evidence of an anisotropic turbulence cascade extending into the dissipation
range. We also perform an Eulerian frequency analysis of the simulation data
and compare it to the results of a previous study of magnetohydrodynamic
turbulence simulations.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.4158 [pdf] - 1084227
A Weakened Cascade Model for Turbulence in Astrophysical Plasmas
Submitted: 2011-09-19
A refined cascade model for kinetic turbulence in weakly collisional
astrophysical plasmas is presented that includes both the transition between
weak and strong turbulence and the effect of nonlocal interactions on the
nonlinear transfer of energy. The model describes the transition between weak
and strong MHD turbulence and the complementary transition from strong kinetic
Alfven wave (KAW) turbulence to weak dissipating KAW turbulence, a new regime
of weak turbulence in which the effects of shearing by large scale motions and
kinetic dissipation play an important role. The inclusion of the effect of
nonlocal motions on the nonlinear energy cascade rate in the dissipation range,
specifically the shearing by large-scale motions, is proposed to explain the
nearly power-law energy spectra observed in the dissipation range of both
kinetic numerical simulations and solar wind observations.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.4327 [pdf] - 1077459
The slow-mode nature of compressible wave power in solar wind turbulence
Submitted: 2011-06-21
We use a large, statistical set of measurements from the Wind spacecraft at 1
AU, and supporting synthetic spacecraft data based on kinetic plasma theory, to
show that the compressible component of inertial range solar wind turbulence is
primarily in the kinetic slow mode. The zero-lag cross correlation C(delta n,
delta B_parallel) between proton density fluctuations delta n and the
field-aligned (compressible) component of the magnetic field delta B_parallel
is negative and close to -1. The typical dependence of C(delta n,delta
B_parallel) on the ion plasma beta_i is consistent with a spectrum of
compressible wave energy that is almost entirely in the kinetic slow mode. This
has important implications for both the nature of the density fluctuation
spectrum and for the cascade of kinetic turbulence to short wavelengths,
favoring evolution to the kinetic Alfven wave mode rather than the (fast)
whistler mode.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.4328 [pdf] - 1077460
Prediction of the Proton-to-Total Turbulent Heating in the Solar Wind
Submitted: 2011-06-21
This paper employs a recent turbulent heating prescription to predict the
ratio of proton-to-total heating due to the kinetic dissipation of Alfvenic
turbulence as a function of heliocentric distance. Comparing to a recent
empirical estimate for this turbulent heating ratio in the high-speed solar
wind, the prediction shows good agreement with the empirical estimate for R >~
0.8 AU, but predicts less ion heating than the empirical estimate at smaller
heliocentric radii. At these smaller radii, the turbulent heating prescription,
calculated in the gyrokinetic limit, fails because the turbulent cascade is
predicted to reach the proton cyclotron frequency before Landau damping
terminates the cascade. These findings suggest that the turbulent cascade can
reach the proton cyclotron frequency at R <~ 0.8 AU, leading to a higher level
of proton heating than predicted by the turbulent heating prescription in the
gyrokinetic limit. At larger heliocentric radii, R >~ 0.8 AU, this turbulent
heating prescription contains all of the necessary physical mechanisms needed
to reproduce the empirically estimated proton-to-total heating ratio.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1104.0877 [pdf] - 1053174
Gyrokinetic Simulations of Solar Wind Turbulence from Ion to Electron
Scales
Submitted: 2011-04-05
The first three-dimensional, nonlinear gyrokinetic simulation of plasma
turbulence resolving scales from the ion to electron gyroradius with a
realistic mass ratio is presented, where all damping is provided by resolved
physical mechanisms. The resulting energy spectra are quantitatively consistent
with a magnetic power spectrum scaling of $k^{-2.8}$ as observed in \emph{in
situ} spacecraft measurements of the "dissipation range" of solar wind
turbulence. Despite the strongly nonlinear nature of the turbulence, the linear
kinetic \Alfven wave mode quantitatively describes the polarization of the
turbulent fluctuations. The collisional ion heating is measured at
sub-ion-Larmor radius scales, which provides the first evidence of the ion
entropy cascade in an electromagnetic turbulence simulation.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.0279 [pdf] - 903036
AstroGK: Astrophysical Gyrokinetics Code
Submitted: 2010-04-01, last modified: 2010-10-15
The gyrokinetic simulation code AstroGK is developed to study fundamental
aspects of kinetic plasmas and for applications mainly to astrophysical
problems. AstroGK is an Eulerian slab code that solves the electromagnetic
Gyrokinetic-Maxwell equations in five-dimensional phase space, and is derived
from the existing gyrokinetics code GS2 by removing magnetic geometry effects.
Algorithms used in the code are described. The code is benchmarked using linear
and nonlinear problems. Serial and parallel performance scalings are also
presented.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1009.4212 [pdf] - 1040748
A prescription for the turbulent heating of astrophysical plasmas
Submitted: 2010-09-21
The ratio of ion to electron heating due to the dissipation of Alfvenic
turbulence in astrophysical plasmas is calculated based on a cascade model for
turbulence in weakly collisional plasmas. Conditions for validity of this model
are discussed, a prescription for the turbulent heating is presented, and it is
applied to predict turbulent heating in accretion disks and the interstellar
medium.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.3933 [pdf] - 214364
Gyrokinetic simulation of entropy cascade in two-dimensional
electrostatic turbulence
Submitted: 2010-03-20, last modified: 2010-08-16
Two-dimensional electrostatic turbulence in magnetized weakly-collisional
plasmas exhibits a cascade of entropy in phase space [Phys. Rev. Lett. 103,
015003 (2009)]. At scales smaller than the gyroradius, this cascade is
characterized by the dimensionless ratio D of the collision time to the eddy
turnover time measured at the scale of the thermal Larmor radius. When D >> 1,
a broad spectrum of fluctuations at sub-Larmor scales is found in both position
and velocity space. The distribution function develops structure as a function
of v_{perp}, the velocity coordinate perpendicular to the local magnetic field.
The cascade shows a local-scale nonlinear interaction in both position and
velocity spaces, and Kolmogorov's scaling theory can be extended into phase
space.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.5023 [pdf] - 1018105
On the Interpretation of Magnetic Helicity Signatures in the Dissipation
Range of Solar Wind Turbulence
Submitted: 2009-10-26
Measurements of small-scale turbulent fluctuations in the solar wind find a
non-zero right-handed magnetic helicity. This has been interpreted as evidence
for ion cyclotron damping. However, theoretical and empirical evidence suggests
that the majority of the energy in solar wind turbulence resides in low
frequency anisotropic kinetic Alfven wave fluctuations that are not subject to
ion cyclotron damping. We demonstrate that a dissipation range comprised of
kinetic Alfven waves also produces a net right-handed fluctuating magnetic
helicity signature consistent with observations. Thus, the observed magnetic
helicity signature does not necessarily imply that ion cyclotron damping is
energetically important in the solar wind.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:0908.1274 [pdf] - 1003354
Magnetic fluctuation power near proton temperature anisotropy
instability thresholds in the solar wind
Submitted: 2009-08-10
The proton temperature anisotropy in the solar wind is known to be
constrained by the theoretical thresholds for pressure anisotropy-driven
instabilities. Here we use approximately 1 million independent measurements of
gyroscale magnetic fluctuations in the solar wind to show for the first time
that these fluctuations are enhanced along the temperature anisotropy
thresholds of the mirror, proton oblique firehose, and ion cyclotron
instabilities. In addition, the measured magnetic compressibility is enhanced
at high plasma beta ($\beta_\parallel \gtrsim 1$) along the mirror instability
threshold but small elsewhere, consistent with expectations of the mirror mode.
The power in this frequency (the 'dissipation') range is often considered to be
driven by the solar wind turbulent cascade, an interpretation which should be
qualified in light of the present results. In particular, we show that the
short wavelength magnetic fluctuation power is a strong function of
collisionality, which relaxes the temperature anisotropy away from the
instability conditions and reduces correspondingly the fluctuation power.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:0908.0757 [pdf] - 1003306
Constraining Low-Frequency Alfvenic Turbulence in the Solar Wind Using
Density Fluctuation Measurements
Submitted: 2009-08-05
One proposed mechanism for heating the solar wind, from close to the sun to
beyond 10 AU, invokes low-frequency, oblique, Alfven-wave turbulence. Because
small-scale oblique Alfven waves (kinetic Alfven waves) are compressive, the
measured density fluctuations in the solar wind place an upper limit on the
amplitude of kinetic Alfven waves and hence an upper limit on the rate at which
the solar wind can be heated by low-frequency, Alfvenic turbulence. We evaluate
this upper limit for both coronal holes at 5 solar radii and in the near-Earth
solar wind. At both radii, the upper limit we find is consistent with models in
which the solar wind is heated by low-frequency Alfvenic turbulence. At 1 AU,
the upper limit on the turbulent heating rate derived from the measured density
fluctuations is within a factor of 2 of the measured solar wind heating rate.
Thus if low-frequency Alfvenic turbulence contributes to heating the near-Earth
solar wind, kinetic Alfven waves must be one of the dominant sources of solar
wind density fluctuations at frequencies of order 1 Hz. We also present a
simple argument for why density fluctuation measurements do appear to rule out
models in which the solar wind is heated by non-turbulent high-frequency waves
``sweeping'' through the ion-cyclotron resonance, but are compatible with
heating by low-frequency Alfvenic turbulence.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:0905.3382 [pdf] - 24472
The Turbulent Heating Rate in Strong MHD Turbulence with Nonzero Cross
Helicity
Submitted: 2009-05-20
Different results for the cascade power in strong, incompressible MHD
turbulence with nonzero cross helicity appear in the literature. In this paper,
we discuss the conditions under which these different results are valid. We
define z+ to be the rms amplitude of Alfven waves propagating parallel to the
background magnetic field, and z- to be the rms amplitude of Alfven waves
propagating anti-parallel to the background magnetic field. Nonzero cross
helicity implies that z+ and z- differ, and we take z- to be less than z+. We
find that the mechanism that generates the z- fluctuations strongly affects the
cascade power, because it controls the coherence time for interactions between
oppositely directed wave packets at the outer scale. In particular, for fixed
values of z+ and z-, the cascade power is in many cases larger when the z-
fluctuations are generated by the reflection of z+ fluctuations than when the
z- fluctuations are generated by forcing that is only weakly correlated with
the z+ fluctuations.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:0704.0044 [pdf] - 1000352
Astrophysical gyrokinetics: kinetic and fluid turbulent cascades in
magnetized weakly collisional plasmas
Submitted: 2007-03-31, last modified: 2009-05-09
We present a theoretical framework for plasma turbulence in astrophysical
plasmas (solar wind, interstellar medium, galaxy clusters, accretion disks).
The key assumptions are that the turbulence is anisotropic with respect to the
mean magnetic field and frequencies are low compared to the ion cyclotron
frequency. The energy injected at the outer scale scale has to be converted
into heat, which ultimately cannot be done without collisions. A KINETIC
CASCADE develops that brings the energy to collisional scales both in space and
velocity. Its nature depends on the physics of plasma fluctuations. In each of
the physically distinct scale ranges, the kinetic problem is systematically
reduced to a more tractable set of equations. In the "inertial range" above the
ion gyroscale, the kinetic cascade splits into a cascade of Alfvenic
fluctuations, which are governed by the RMHD equations at both the collisional
and collisionless scales, and a passive cascade of compressive fluctuations,
which obey a linear kinetic equation along the moving field lines associated
with the Alfvenic component. In the "dissipation range" between the ion and
electron gyroscales, there are again two cascades: the kinetic-Alfven-wave
(KAW) cascade governed by two fluid-like Electron RMHD equations and a passive
phase-space cascade of ion entropy fluctuations. The latter cascade brings the
energy of the inertial-range fluctuations that was damped by collisionless
wave-particle interaction at the ion gyroscale to collisional scales in the
phase space and leads to ion heating. The KAW energy is similarly damped at the
electron gyroscale and converted into electron heat. Kolmogorov-style scaling
relations are derived for these cascades. Astrophysical and space-physical
applications are discussed in detail.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:0903.4111 [pdf] - 2038169
Limitations of Hall MHD as a model for turbulence in weakly collisional
plasmas
Submitted: 2009-03-24
The limitations of Hall MHD as a model for turbulence in weakly collisional
plasmas are explored using quantitative comparisons to Vlasov-Maxwell kinetic
theory over a wide range of parameter space. The validity of Hall MHD in the
cold ion limit is shown, but spurious undamped wave modes exist in Hall MHD
when the ion temperature is finite. It is argued that turbulence in the
dissipation range of the solar wind must be one, or a mixture, of three
electromagnetic wave modes: the parallel whistler, oblique whistler, or kinetic
Alfven waves. These modes are generally well described by Hall MHD. Determining
the applicability of linear kinetic damping rates in turbulent plasmas requires
a suite of fluid and kinetic nonlinear numerical simulations. Contrasting fluid
and kinetic simulations will also shed light on whether the presence of
spurious wave modes alters the nonlinear couplings inherent in turbulence and
will illuminate the turbulent dynamics and energy transfer in the regime of the
characteristic ion kinetic scales.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.2493 [pdf] - 1720930
Howes et al. Reply
Submitted: 2008-12-12
Howes et al. Reply to Comment on "Kinetic Simulations of Magnetized
Turbulence in Astrophysical Plasmas" arXiv:0711.4355
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:0707.3147 [pdf] - 1000443
A Model of Turbulence in Magnetized Plasmas: Implications for the
Dissipation Range in the Solar Wind
Submitted: 2007-07-20, last modified: 2008-12-12
This paper studies the turbulent cascade of magnetic energy in weakly
collisional magnetized plasmas. A cascade model is presented, based on the
assumptions of local nonlinear energy transfer in wavenumber space, critical
balance between linear propagation and nonlinear interaction times, and the
applicability of linear dissipation rates for the nonlinearly turbulent plasma.
The model follows the nonlinear cascade of energy from the driving scale in the
MHD regime, through the transition at the ion Larmor radius into the kinetic
Alfven wave regime, in which the turbulence is dissipated by kinetic processes.
The turbulent fluctuations remain at frequencies below the ion cyclotron
frequency due to the strong anisotropy of the turbulent fluctuations,
k_parallel << k_perp (implied by critical balance). In this limit, the
turbulence is optimally described by gyrokinetics; it is shown that the
gyrokinetic approximation is well satisfied for typical slow solar wind
parameters. Wave phase velocity measurements are consistent with a kinetic
Alfven wave cascade and not the onset of ion cyclotron damping. The conditions
under which the gyrokinetic cascade reaches the ion cyclotron frequency are
established. Cascade model solutions imply that collisionless damping provides
a natural explanation for the observed range of spectral indices in the
dissipation range of the solar wind. The dissipation range spectrum is
predicted to be an exponential fall off; the power-law behavior apparent in
observations may be an artifact of limited instrumental sensitivity. The
cascade model is motivated by a programme of gyrokinetic simulations of
turbulence and particle heating in the solar wind.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:0806.1069 [pdf] - 13307
Gyrokinetic turbulence: a nonlinear route to dissipation through phase
space
Submitted: 2008-06-05, last modified: 2008-11-04
This paper describes a conceptual framework for understanding kinetic plasma
turbulence as a generalized form of energy cascade in phase space. It is
emphasized that conversion of turbulent energy into thermodynamic heat is only
achievable in the presence of some (however small) degree of collisionality.
The smallness of the collision rate is compensated by the emergence of
small-scale structure in the velocity space. For gyrokinetic turbulence, a
nonlinear perpendicular phase mixing mechanism is identified and described as a
turbulent cascade of entropy fluctuations simultaneously occurring at spatial
scales smaller than the ion gyroscale and in velocity space. Scaling relations
for the resulting fluctuation spectra are derived. An estimate for the
collisional cutoff is provided. The importance of adequately modeling and
resolving collisions in gyrokinetic simulations is biefly discussed, as well as
the relevance of these results to understanding the dissipation-range
turbulence in the solar wind and the electrostatic microturbulence in fusion
plasmas.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:0711.4355 [pdf] - 7451
Kinetic Simulations of Magnetized Turbulence in Astrophysical Plasmas
Submitted: 2007-11-27
This letter presents the first ab initio, fully electromagnetic, kinetic
simulations of magnetized turbulence in a homogeneous, weakly collisional
plasma at the scale of the ion Larmor radius (ion gyroscale). Magnetic and
electric-field energy spectra show a break at the ion gyroscale; the spectral
slopes are consistent with scaling predictions for critically balanced
turbulence of Alfven waves above the ion gyroscale (spectral index -5/3) and of
kinetic Alfven waves below the ion gyroscale (spectral indices of -7/3 for
magnetic and -1/3 for electric fluctuations). This behavior is also
qualitatively consistent with in situ measurements of turbulence in the solar
wind. Our findings support the hypothesis that the frequencies of turbulent
fluctuations in the solar wind remain well below the ion cyclotron frequency
both above and below the ion gyroscale.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:0711.4358 [pdf] - 7453
Inertial range turbulence in kinetic plasmas
Submitted: 2007-11-27
The transfer of turbulent energy through an inertial range from the driving
scale to dissipative scales in a kinetic plasma followed by the conversion of
this energy into heat is a fundamental plasma physics process. A theoretical
foundation for the study of this process is constructed, but the details of the
kinetic cascade are not well understood. Several important properties are
identified: (a) the conservation of a generalized energy by the cascade; (b)
the need for collisions to increase entropy and realize irreversible plasma
heating; and (c) the key role played by the entropy cascade--a dual cascade of
energy to small scales in both physical and velocity space--to convert
ultimately the turbulent energy into heat. A strategy for nonlinear numerical
simulations of kinetic turbulence is outlined. Initial numerical results are
consistent with the operation of the entropy cascade. Inertial range turbulence
arises in a broad range of space and astrophysical plasmas and may play an
important role in the thermalization of fusion energy in burning plasmas.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:0707.3149 [pdf] - 3302
Dissipation-Scale Turbulence in the Solar Wind
Submitted: 2007-07-20
We present a cascade model for turbulence in weakly collisional plasmas that
follows the nonlinear cascade of energy from the large scales of driving in the
MHD regime to the small scales of the kinetic Alfven wave regime where the
turbulence is dissipated by kinetic processes. Steady-state solutions of the
model for the slow solar wind yield three conclusions: (1) beyond the observed
break in the magnetic energy spectrum, one expects an exponential cut-off; (2)
the widely held interpretation that this dissipation range obeys power-law
behavior is an artifact of instrumental sensitivity limitations; and, (3) over
the range of parameters relevant to the solar wind, the observed variation of
dissipation range spectral indices from -2 to -4 is naturally explained by the
varying effectiveness of Landau damping, from an undamped prediction of -7/3 to
a strongly damped index around -4.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511812 [pdf] - 78170
Astrophysical Gyrokinetics: Basic Equations and Linear Theory
Submitted: 2005-11-29, last modified: 2006-05-04
Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence is encountered in a wide variety of
astrophysical plasmas, including accretion disks, the solar wind, and the
interstellar and intracluster medium. On small scales, this turbulence is often
expected to consist of highly anisotropic fluctuations with frequencies small
compared to the ion cyclotron frequency. For a number of applications, the
small scales are also collisionless, so a kinetic treatment of the turbulence
is necessary. We show that this anisotropic turbulence is well described by a
low frequency expansion of the kinetic theory called gyrokinetics. This paper
is the first in a series to examine turbulent astrophysical plasmas in the
gyrokinetic limit. We derive and explain the nonlinear gyrokinetic equations
and explore the linear properties of gyrokinetics as a prelude to nonlinear
simulations. The linear dispersion relation for gyrokinetics is obtained and
its solutions are compared to those of hot-plasma kinetic theory. These results
are used to validate the performance of the gyrokinetic simulation code {\tt
GS2} in the parameter regimes relevant for astrophysical plasmas. New results
on global energy conservation in gyrokinetics are also derived. We briefly
outline several of the problems to be addressed by future nonlinear
simulations, including particle heating by turbulence in hot accretion flows
and in the solar wind, the magnetic and electric field power spectra in the
solar wind, and the origin of small-scale density fluctuations in the
interstellar medium.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0107454 [pdf] - 43825
Gradient Particle Magnetohydrodynamics
Submitted: 2001-07-24
We introduce Gradient Particle Magnetohydrodynamics (GPM), a new Lagrangian
method for magnetohydrodynamics based on gradients corrected for the locally
disordered particle distribution. The development of a numerical code for MHD
simulation using the GPM algorithm is outlined. Validation tests simulating
linear and nonlinear sound waves, linear MHD waves, advection of magnetic
fields in a magnetized vortex, hydrodynamical shocks, and three-dimensional
collapse are presented, demonstrating the viability of an MHD code using GPM.
The characteristics of a GPM code are discussed and possible avenues for
further development and refinement are mentioned. We conclude with a view of
how GPM may complement other methods currently in development for the next
generation of computational astrophysics.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0102394 [pdf] - 41105
Local Gravitational Instability of Magnetized Shear Flows
Submitted: 2001-02-22
The effect of magnetic shear and shear flow on local gravitationally induced
instabilities is investigated. A simple model is constructed allowing for an
arbitrary entropy gradient and a shear plasma flow in the Boussinesq
approximation. A transformation to shearing magnetic coordinates achieves a
model with plasma flow along the magnetic field lines where the coordinate
lines are coincident with the field lines. The solution for the normal modes of
the system depends on two parameters: the Alfven Mach number of the plasma flow
and the entropy gradient. The behavior of the unstable normal modes of this
system is summarized by a stability diagram. Important characteristics of this
stability diagram are the following: magnetic shear is stabilizing and the
entropy gradient must exceed a threshold value for unstable mode growth to
occur; flow acts to suppress mode growth in a substantially unstable regime as
expected, yet near marginal stability it can lessen the stabilizing effect of
magnetic shear and enhance the growth rates of the instability; and, as the
Alfven Mach number approaches one, the instability is completely stabilized.
Analytical work is presented supporting the characteristics of the stability
diagram and illuminating the physical mechanisms controlling the behavior of
the model. The implications of this work for astrophysical and fusion
applications and the potential for future research extending the results to
include compressibility are discussed.