Normalized to: Horenstein, D.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.06345 [pdf] - 1582748
Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project. VII.
Understanding the UV anomaly in NGC 5548 with X-Ray Spectroscopy
Mathur, S.;
Gupta, A.;
Page, K.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Krongold, Y.;
Goad, M. R.;
Adams, S. M.;
Anderson, M. D.;
Arevalo, P.;
Barth, A. J.;
Bazhaw, C.;
Beatty, T. G.;
Bentz, M. C.;
Bigley, A.;
Bisogni, S.;
Borman, G. A.;
Boroson, T. A.;
Bottorff, M. C.;
Brandt, W. N.;
Breeveld, A. A.;
Brown, J. E.;
Brown, J. S.;
Cackett, E. M.;
Canalizo, G.;
Carini, M. T.;
Clubb, K. I.;
Comerford, J. M.;
Coker, C. T.;
Corsini, E. M.;
Crenshaw, D. M.;
Croft, S.;
Croxall, K. V.;
Bonta, E. Dalla;
Deason, A. J.;
Denney, K. D.;
De Lorenzo-Caceres, A.;
De Rosa, G.;
Dietrich, M.;
Edelson, R.;
Ely, J.;
Eracleous, M.;
Evans, P. A.;
Fausnaugh, M. M.;
Ferland, G. J.;
Filippenko, A. V.;
Flatland, K.;
Fox, O. D.;
Gates, E. L.;
Gehrels, N.;
Geier, S.;
Gelbord, J. M.;
Gorjian, V.;
Greene, J. E.;
Grier, C. J.;
Grupe, D.;
Hall, P. B.;
Henderson, C. B.;
Hicks, S.;
Holmbeck, E.;
Holoien, T. W. -S.;
Horenstein, D.;
Horne, Keith;
Hutchison, T.;
Im, M.;
Jensen, J. J.;
Johnson, C. A.;
Joner, M. D.;
Jones, J.;
Kaastra, J.;
Kaspi, S.;
Kelly, B. C.;
Kelly, P. L.;
Kennea, J. A.;
Kim, M.;
Kim, S.;
Kim, S. C.;
King, A.;
Klimanov, S. A.;
Kochanek, C. S.;
Korista, K. T.;
Kriss, G. A.;
Lau, M. W.;
Lee, J. C.;
Leonard, D. C.;
Li, M.;
Lira, P.;
Ma, Z.;
MacInnis, F.;
Manne-Nicholas, E. R.;
Malkan, M. A.;
Mauerhan, J. C.;
McGurk, R.;
McHardy, I. M.;
Montouri, C.;
Morelli, L.;
Mosquera, A.;
Mudd, D.;
Muller-Sanchez, F.;
Musso, R.;
Nazarov, S. V.;
Netzer, H.;
Nguyen, M. L.;
Norris, R. P.;
Nousek, J. A.;
Ochner, P.;
Okhmat, D. N.;
Ou-Yang, B.;
Pancoast, A.;
Papadakis, I.;
Parks, J. R.;
Pei, L.;
Peterson, B. M.;
Pizzella, A.;
Poleski, R.;
Pott, J. -U.;
Rafter, S. E.;
Rix, H. -W.;
Runnoe, J.;
Saylor, D. A.;
Schimoia, J. S.;
Schnülle, K.;
Sergeev, S. G.;
Shappee, B. J.;
Shivvers, I.;
Siegel, M.;
Simonian, G. V.;
Siviero, A.;
Skielboe, A.;
Somers, G.;
Spencer, M.;
Starkey, D.;
Stevens, D. J.;
Sung, H. -I.;
Tayar, J.;
Tejos, N.;
Turner, C. S.;
Uttley, P.;
Van Saders, J.;
Vestergaard, M.;
Vican, L.;
VillanuevaJr., S.;
Villforth, C.;
Weiss, Y.;
Woo, J. -H.;
Yan, H.;
Young, S.;
Yuk, H.;
Zheng, W.;
Zhu, W.;
Zu, Y.
Submitted: 2017-04-20, last modified: 2017-08-01
During the Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project (STORM)
observations of NGC 5548, the continuum and emission-line variability became
de-correlated during the second half of the 6-month long observing campaign.
Here we present Swift and Chandra X-ray spectra of NGC 5548 obtained as a part
of the campaign. The Swift spectra show that excess flux (relative to a
power-law continuum) in the soft X-ray band appears before the start of the
anomalous emission-line behavior, peaks during the period of the anomaly, and
then declines. This is a model-independent result suggesting that the soft
excess is related to the anomaly. We divide the Swift data into on- and
off-anomaly spectra to characterize the soft excess via spectral fitting. The
cause of the spectral differences is likely due to a change in the intrinsic
spectrum rather than being due to variable obscuration or partial covering. The
Chandra spectra have lower signal-to-noise ratios, but are consistent with
Swift data. Our preferred model of the soft excess is emission from an
optically thick, warm Comptonizing corona, the effective optical depth of which
increases during the anomaly. This model simultaneously explains all the three
observations: the UV emission line flux decrease, the soft-excess increase, and
the emission line anomaly.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.01177 [pdf] - 1550468
Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project. V. Optical
Spectroscopic Campaign and Emission-Line Analysis for NGC 5548
Pei, L.;
Fausnaugh, M. M.;
Barth, A. J.;
Peterson, B. M.;
Bentz, M. C.;
De Rosa, G.;
Denney, K. D.;
Goad, M. R.;
Kochanek, C. S.;
Korista, K. T.;
Kriss, G. A.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Bennert, V. N.;
Brotherton, M.;
Clubb, K. I.;
Bontà, E. Dalla;
Filippenko, A. V.;
Greene, J. E.;
Grier, C. J.;
Vestergaard, M.;
Zheng, W.;
Adams, Scott M.;
Beatty, Thomas G.;
Bigley, A.;
Brown, Jacob E.;
Brown, Jonathan S.;
Canalizo, G.;
Comerford, J. M.;
Coker, Carl T.;
Corsini, E. M.;
Croft, S.;
Croxall, K. V.;
Deason, A. J.;
Eracleous, Michael;
Fox, O. D.;
Gates, E. L.;
Henderson, C. B.;
Holmbeck, E.;
Holoien, T. W. -S.;
Jensen, J. J.;
Johnson, C. A.;
Kelly, P. L.;
Kim, S.;
King, A.;
Lau, M. W.;
Li, Miao;
Lochhaas, Cassandra;
Ma, Zhiyuan;
Manne-Nicholas, E. R.;
Mauerhan, J. C.;
Malkan, M. A.;
McGurk, R.;
Morelli, L.;
Mosquera, Ana;
Mudd, Dale;
Sanchez, F. Muller;
Nguyen, M. L.;
Ochner, P.;
Ou-Yang, B.;
Pancoast, A.;
Penny, Matthew T.;
Pizzella, A.;
Poleski, Radosław;
Runnoe, Jessie;
Scott, B.;
Schimoia, Jaderson S.;
Shappee, B. J.;
Shivvers, I.;
Simonian, Gregory V.;
Siviero, A.;
Somers, Garrett;
Stevens, Daniel J.;
Strauss, M. A.;
Tayar, Jamie;
Tejos, N.;
Treu, T.;
Van Saders, J.;
Vican, L.;
Villanueva, S.;
Yuk, H.;
Zakamska, N. L.;
Zhu, W.;
Anderson, M. D.;
Arévalo, P.;
Bazhaw, C.;
Bisogni, S.;
Borman, G. A.;
Bottorff, M. C.;
Brandt, W. N.;
Breeveld, A. A.;
Cackett, E. M.;
Carini, M. T.;
Crenshaw, D. M.;
De Lorenzo-Cáceres, A.;
Dietrich, M.;
Edelson, R.;
Efimova, N. V.;
Ely, J.;
Evans, P. A.;
Ferland, G. J.;
Flatland, K.;
Gehrels, N.;
Geier, S.;
Gelbord, J. M.;
Grupe, D.;
Gupta, A.;
Hall, P. B.;
Hicks, S.;
Horenstein, D.;
Horne, Keith;
Hutchison, T.;
Im, M.;
Joner, M. D.;
Jones, J.;
Kaastra, J.;
Kaspi, S.;
Kelly, B. C.;
Kennea, J. A.;
Kim, M.;
Kim, S. C.;
Klimanov, S. A.;
Lee, J. C.;
Leonard, D. C.;
Lira, P.;
MacInnis, F.;
Mathur, S.;
McHardy, I. M.;
Montouri, C.;
Musso, R.;
Nazarov, S. V.;
Netzer, H.;
Norris, R. P.;
Nousek, J. A.;
Okhmat, D. N.;
Papadakis, I.;
Parks, J. R.;
Pott, J. -U.;
Rafter, S. E.;
Rix, H. -W.;
Saylor, D. A.;
Schnülle, K.;
Sergeev, S. G.;
Siegel, M.;
Skielboe, A.;
Spencer, M.;
Starkey, D.;
Sung, H. -I.;
Teems, K. G.;
Turner, C. S.;
Uttley, P.;
Villforth, C.;
Weiss, Y.;
Woo, J. -H.;
Yan, H.;
Young, S.;
Zu, Y.
Submitted: 2017-02-03
We present the results of an optical spectroscopic monitoring program
targeting NGC 5548 as part of a larger multi-wavelength reverberation mapping
campaign. The campaign spanned six months and achieved an almost daily cadence
with observations from five ground-based telescopes. The H$\beta$ and He II
$\lambda$4686 broad emission-line light curves lag that of the 5100 $\AA$
optical continuum by $4.17^{+0.36}_{-0.36}$ days and $0.79^{+0.35}_{-0.34}$
days, respectively. The H$\beta$ lag relative to the 1158 $\AA$ ultraviolet
continuum light curve measured by the Hubble Space Telescope is roughly
$\sim$50% longer than that measured against the optical continuum, and the lag
difference is consistent with the observed lag between the optical and
ultraviolet continua. This suggests that the characteristic radius of the
broad-line region is $\sim$50% larger than the value inferred from optical data
alone. We also measured velocity-resolved emission-line lags for H$\beta$ and
found a complex velocity-lag structure with shorter lags in the line wings,
indicative of a broad-line region dominated by Keplerian motion. The responses
of both the H$\beta$ and He II $\lambda$4686 emission lines to the driving
continuum changed significantly halfway through the campaign, a phenomenon also
observed for C IV, Ly $\alpha$, He II(+O III]), and Si IV(+O IV]) during the
same monitoring period. Finally, given the optical luminosity of NGC 5548
during our campaign, the measured H$\beta$ lag is a factor of five shorter than
the expected value implied by the $R_\mathrm{BLR} - L_\mathrm{AGN}$ relation
based on the past behavior of NGC 5548.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.06051 [pdf] - 1532705
Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project VI:
reverberating Disk Models for NGC 5548
Starkey, D.;
Horne, Keith;
Fausnaugh, M. M.;
Peterson, B. M.;
Bentz, M. C.;
Kochanek, C. S.;
Denney, K. D.;
Edelson, R.;
Goad, M. R.;
De Rosa, G.;
Anderson, M. D.;
Arevalo, P.;
Barth, A. J.;
Bazhaw, C.;
Borman, G. A.;
Boroson, T. A.;
Bottorff, M. C.;
Brandt, W. N.;
Breeveld, A. A.;
Cackett, E. M.;
Carini, M. T.;
Croxall, K. V.;
Crenshaw, D. M.;
Bonta, E. Dalla;
De Lorenzo-Caceres, A.;
Dietrich, M.;
Efimova, N. V.;
Ely, J.;
Evans, P. A.;
Filippenko, A. V.;
Flatland, K.;
Gehrels, N.;
Geier, S.;
Gelbord, J. M.;
Gonzalez, L.;
Gorjian, V.;
Grier, C. J.;
Grupe, D.;
Hall, P. B.;
Hicks, S.;
Horenstein, D.;
Hutchison, T.;
Im, M.;
Jensen, J. J.;
Joner, M. D.;
Jones, J.;
Kaastra, J.;
Kaspi, S.;
Kelly, B. C.;
Kennea, J. A.;
Kim, S. C.;
Kim, M.;
Klimanov, S. A.;
Korista, K. T.;
Kriss, G. A.;
Lee, J. C.;
Leonard, D. C.;
Lira, P.;
MacInnis, F.;
Manne-Nicholas, E. R.;
Mathur, S.;
McHardy, I. M.;
Montouri, C.;
Musso, R.;
Nazarov, S. V.;
Norris, R. P.;
Nousek, J. A.;
Okhmat, D. N.;
Pancoast, A.;
Parks, J. R.;
Pei, L.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Pott, J. -U.;
Rafter, S. E.;
Rix, H. W.;
Saylor, D. A.;
Schimoia, J. S.;
Schnulle, K.;
Sergeev, S. G.;
Siegel, M. H.;
Spencer, M.;
Sung, H. -I.;
Teems, K. G.;
Turner, C. S.;
Uttley, P.;
Vestergaard, M.;
Villforth, C.;
Weiss, Y.;
Woo, J. -H.;
Yan, H.;
Young, S.;
Zheng, W.;
Zu, Y.
Submitted: 2016-11-18, last modified: 2016-11-24
We conduct a multiwavelength continuum variability study of the Seyfert 1
galaxy NGC 5548 to investigate the temperature structure of its accretion disk.
The 19 overlapping continuum light curves (1158 to 9157 angstroms) combine
simultaneous HST , Swift , and ground-based observations over a 180 day period
from 2014 January to July. Light-curve variability is interpreted as the
reverberation response of the accretion disk to irradiation by a central
time-varying point source. Our model yields the disk inclination, i,
temperature T1 at 1 light day from the black hole, and a temperature-radius
slope, alpha. We also infer the driving light curve and find that it correlates
poorly with both the hard and soft X-ray light curves, suggesting that the
X-rays alone may not drive the ultraviolet and optical variability over the
observing period. We also decompose the light curves into bright, faint, and
mean accretion-disk spectra. These spectra lie below that expected for a
standard blackbody accretion disk accreting at L/LEdd = 0.1
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.08741 [pdf] - 1422270
Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project. IV. Anomalous
behavior of the broad ultraviolet emission lines in NGC 5548
Goad, M. R.;
Korista, K. T.;
De Rosa, G.;
Kriss, G. A.;
Edelson, R.;
Barth, A. J.;
Ferland, G. J.;
Kochanek, C. S.;
Netzer, H.;
Peterson, B. M.;
Bentz, M. C.;
Bisogni, S.;
Crenshaw, D. M.;
Denney, K. D.;
Ely, J.;
Fausnaugh, M. M.;
Grier, C. J.;
Gupta, A.;
Horne, K. D.;
Kaastra, J.;
Pancoast, A.;
Pei, L.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Skielboe, A.;
Starkey, D.;
Vestergaard, M.;
Zu, Y.;
Anderson, M. D.;
Arevalo, P.;
Bazhaw, C.;
Borman, G. A.;
Boroson, T. A.;
Bottorff, M. C.;
Brandt, W. N.;
Breeveld, A. A.;
Brewer, B. J.;
Cackett, E. M.;
Carini, M. T.;
Croxall, K. V.;
Bonta, E. Dalla;
de Lorenzo-Caceres, A.;
Dietrich, M.;
Efimova, N. V.;
Evans, P. A.;
Filippenko, A. V.;
Flatland, K.;
Gehrels, N.;
Geier, S.;
Gelbord, G. M.;
Gonzalez, L.;
Gorjian, V.;
Grupe, D.;
Hall, P. B.;
Hicks, S.;
Horenstein, D.;
Hutchison, T.;
Im, M.;
Jensen, J. J.;
Joner, M. D.;
Jones, J.;
Kaspi, S.;
Kelly, B. C.;
Kennea, J. A.;
Kim, M.;
Kim, S. C.;
Klimanov, S. A.;
Larionov, V. M.;
Lee, J. C.;
Leonard, D. C.;
Lira, P.;
MacInnis, F.;
Manne-Nicholas, E. R.;
Mathur, S.;
McHardy, I. M.;
Montouri, C.;
Musso, R.;
Nazarov, S. V.;
Norris, R. P.;
Nousek, J. A.;
Okhmat, D. N.;
Papadakis, I.;
Parks, J. R.;
Pott, J. -U.;
Rafter, S. E.;
Rix, H. -W.;
Saylor, D. A.;
Schimoia, J. S.;
Schnulle, K.;
Sergeev, S. G.;
Siegel, M.;
Spencer, M.;
Sung, H. -I.;
Teems, K. G.;
Treu, T.;
Turner, C. S.;
Uttley, P.;
Villforth, C.;
Weiss, Y.;
Woo, J. -H.;
Yan, H.;
Young, S.;
Zheng, W. -K.
Submitted: 2016-03-29
During an intensive Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Cosmic Origins Spectrograph
(COS) UV monitoring campaign of the Seyfert~1 galaxy NGC 5548 performed from
2014 February to July, the normally highly correlated far-UV continuum and
broad emission-line variations decorrelated for ~60 to 70 days, starting ~75
days after the first HST/COS observation. Following this anomalous state, the
flux and variability of the broad emission lines returned to a more normal
state. This transient behavior, characterised by significant deficits in flux
and equivalent width of the strong broad UV emission lines, is the first of its
kind to be unambiguously identified in an active galactic nucleus reverberation
mapping campaign. The largest corresponding emission-line flux deficits
occurred for the high-ionization collisionally excited lines, C IV and Si IV(+O
IV]), and also He II(+O III]), while the anomaly in Ly-alpha was substantially
smaller. This pattern of behavior indicates a depletion in the flux of photons
with E_{\rm ph} > 54 eV, relative to those near 13.6 eV. We suggest two
plausible mechanisms for the observed behavior: (i) temporary obscuration of
the ionizing continuum incident upon BLR clouds by a moving veil of material
lying between the inner accretion disk and inner BLR, perhaps resulting from an
episodic ejection of material from the disk, or (ii) a temporary change in the
intrinsic ionizing continuum spectral energy distribution resulting in a
deficit of ionizing photons with energies > 54 eV, possibly due to a transient
restructuring of the Comptonizing atmosphere above the disk. Current evidence
appears to favor the latter explanation.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.05648 [pdf] - 1396732
Space Telescope and Optical Reverberation Mapping Project. III. Optical
Continuum Emission and Broad-Band Time Delays in NGC 5548
Fausnaugh, M. M.;
Denney, K. D.;
Barth, A. J.;
Bentz, M. C.;
Bottorff, M. C.;
Carini, M. T.;
Croxall, K. V.;
De Rosa, G.;
Goad, M. R.;
Horne, Keith;
Joner, M. D.;
Kaspi, S.;
Kim, M.;
Klimanov, S. A.;
Kochanek, C. S.;
Leonard, D. C.;
Netzer, H.;
Peterson, B. M.;
Schnulle, K.;
Sergeev, S. G.;
Vestergaard, M.;
Zheng, W. -K.;
Zu, Y.;
Anderson, M. D.;
Arevalo, P.;
Bazhaw, C.;
Borman, G. A.;
Boroson, T. A.;
Brandt, W. N.;
Breeveld, A. A.;
Brewer, B. J.;
Cackett, E. M.;
Crenshaw, D. M.;
Bonta, E. Dalla;
De Lorenzo-Caceres, A.;
Dietrich, M.;
Edelson, R.;
Efimova, N. V.;
Ely, J.;
Evans, P. A.;
Filippenko, A. V.;
Flatland, K.;
Gehrels, N.;
Geier, S.;
Gelbord, J. M.;
Gonzalez, L.;
Gorjian, V.;
Grier, C. J.;
Grupe, D.;
Hall, P. B.;
Hicks, S.;
Horenstein, D.;
Hutchison, T.;
Im, M.;
Jensen, J. J.;
Jones, J.;
Kaastra, J.;
Kelly, B. C.;
Kennea, J. A.;
Kim, S. C.;
Korista, K. T.;
Kriss, G. A.;
Lee, J. C.;
Lira, P.;
MacInnis, F.;
Manne-Nicholas, E. R.;
Mathur, S.;
McHardy, I. M.;
Montouri, C.;
Musso, R.;
Nazarov, S. V.;
Norris, R. P.;
Nousek, J. A.;
Okhmat, D. N.;
Pancoast, A.;
Papadakis, I.;
Parks, J. R.;
Pei, L.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Pott, J. -U.;
Rafter, S. E.;
Rix, H. -W.;
Saylor, D. A.;
Schimoia, J. S.;
Siegel, M.;
Spencer, M.;
Starkey, D.;
Sung, H. -I.;
Teems, K. G.;
Treu, T.;
Turner, C. S.;
Uttley, P.;
Villforth, C.;
Weiss, Y.;
Woo, J. -H.;
Yan, H.;
Young, S.
Submitted: 2015-10-19, last modified: 2016-02-29
We present ground-based optical photometric monitoring data for NGC 5548,
part of an extended multi-wavelength reverberation mapping campaign. The light
curves have nearly daily cadence from 2014 January to July in nine filters
(\emph{BVRI} and \emph{ugriz}). Combined with ultraviolet data from the
\emph{Hubble Space Telescope} and \emph{Swift}, we confirm significant time
delays between the continuum bands as a function of wavelength, extending the
wavelength coverage from 1158\,\AA\ to the $z$ band ($\sim\!9160$\,\AA). We
find that the lags at wavelengths longer than the {\it V} band are equal to or
greater than the lags of high-ionization-state emission lines (such as He\,{\sc
ii}\,$\lambda 1640$ and $\lambda 4686$), suggesting that the continuum-emitting
source is of a physical size comparable to the inner broad-line region (BLR).
The trend of lag with wavelength is broadly consistent with the prediction for
continuum reprocessing by an accretion disk with $\tau \propto \lambda^{4/3}$.
However, the lags also imply a disk radius that is 3 times larger than the
prediction from standard thin-disk theory, assuming that the bolometric
luminosity is 10\% of the Eddington luminosity ($L = 0.1L_{\rm Edd}$). Using
optical spectra from the Large Binocular Telescope, we estimate the bias of the
interband continuum lags due to BLR emission observed in the filters. We find
that the bias for filters with high levels of BLR contamination ($\sim\! 20\%$)
can be important for the shortest continuum lags, and likely has a significant
impact on the {\it u} and {\it U} bands owing to Balmer continuum emission.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.5794 [pdf] - 1217066
The Mass of the Central Black Hole in the Nearby Seyfert Galaxy NGC5273
Bentz, Misty C.;
Horenstein, Daniel;
Bazhaw, Craig;
Manne-Nicholas, Emily R.;
Ou-Yang, Benjamin J.;
Anderson, Matthew;
Jones, Jeremy;
Norris, Ryan P.;
Parks, J. Robert;
Saylor, Dicy;
Teems, Katherine G.;
Turner, Clay
Submitted: 2014-09-19
We present the results of a reverberation-mapping program targeting NGC5273,
a nearby early-type galaxy with a broad-lined active galactic nucleus. Over the
course of the monitoring program, NGC5273 showed strong variability that
allowed us to measure time delays in the responses of the broad optical
recombination lines to changes in the continuum flux. A weighted average of
these measurements results in a black hole mass determination of $M_{\rm BH} =
(4.7 \pm 1.6) \times 10^6$ M$_{\odot}$. An estimate of the size of the black
hole sphere of influence in NGC5273 puts it just at the limit of the resolution
achievable with current ground-based large aperture telescopes. NGC5273 is
therefore an important future target for a black hole mass determination from
stellar dynamical modeling, especially because it is the only nearby early-type
galaxy hosting an AGN with a reverberation-based mass, allowing the best
comparison for the masses determined from these two techniques.