Normalized to: Holzreuter, R.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.07007 [pdf] - 2038407
The influence of NLTE effects in Fe I lines on an inverted atmosphere I.
6301 A and 6302 A lines formed in 1D NLTE
Submitted: 2019-12-15, last modified: 2020-01-28
Ultraviolet over-ionisation of iron atoms in the solar atmosphere leads to
deviations in their level populations from the Saha-Boltzmann statistics. This
causes their line profiles to form in Non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium
(NLTE) conditions. While inverting such profiles to determine atmospheric
parameters, the NLTE effects are often neglected and deviations from LTE are
compensated for by tweaking other quantities. We investigate how the routinely
employed LTE inversion of iron lines formed in NLTE under- or over-estimates
atmospheric quantities such as temperature (T), line-of-sight velocity (v_LOS),
magnetic field strength (B) and inclination (gamma) while the previous papers
have focused mainly on T. We synthesize the Stokes profiles of Fe I 6301.5 A
and 6302.5 A lines in both LTE and NLTE using a snapshot of a 3D MHD
simulation. The profiles are then inverted in LTE. By considering the
atmosphere inferred from inversion of LTE profiles to be the fiducial model, we
compare atmosphere from the inversion of NLTE profiles with it. Any differences
observed are attributed to NLTE effects. Neglecting the NLTE effects introduces
errors in the inverted atmosphere. While the errors in T can go up to 13%, in
v_LOS and B the errors can be as high as 50% or more. We find these errors to
be present at all three inversion nodes. Importantly, they survive degradation
from spatial averaging of the profiles. We give an overview of how the neglect
of NLTE effects influences the values of T, v_LOS, B and gamma determined by
inverting Fe I 6300 A line pair, as observed, e.g., by Hinode. Errors are found
at the sites of granules, intergranular lanes, magnetic elements, basically in
every region susceptible to NLTE effects. For an accurate determination of
atmospheric quantities and their stratification, it is therefore important to
take account of NLTE effects.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.04224 [pdf] - 1296211
3-D non-LTE radiative transfer effects in Fe I lines: III. Line
formation in magneto-hydrodynamic atmospheres
Submitted: 2015-07-15
Non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) effects in diagnostically
important solar Fe I lines are important due to the strong sensitivity of Fe I
to ionizing UV radiation, which may lead to a considerable under-population of
the Fe I levels in the solar atmosphere and, therefore, to a sizeable weakening
of Fe I lines. Such NLTE effects may be intensified or weakened by horizontal
radiative transfer (RT) in a three-dimensionally (3-D) structured atmosphere.
We analyze the influence of horizontal RT on commonly used Fe I lines in a
snapshot of a 3-D radiation magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulation of a plage
region. NLTE- and horizontal RT effects occur with considerable strength (up to
50% in line depth or equivalent width) in the analyzed snapshot. As they may
have either sign and both signs occur with approximately the same frequency and
strength, the net effects are small when considering spatially averaged
quantities. The situation in the plage atmosphere turns out to be rather
complex. Horizontal transfer leads to line-weakening relative to 1-D NLTE
transfer near the boundaries of kG magnetic elements. Around the centers of
these elements, however, we find an often significant line-strengthening. This
behavior is in contrast to that expected from previous 3-D RT computations in
idealized flux-tube models, which display only a line weakening. The origin of
this unexpected behavior lies in the fact that magnetic elements are surrounded
by dense and relatively cool down-flowing gas, which forms the walls of the
magnetic elements. The continuum in these dense walls is often formed in colder
gas than in the central part of the magnetic elements. Consequently, the
central parts of the magnetic element experience a sub-average UV-irradiation
leading to the observed 3-D NLTE line strengthening.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.2490 [pdf] - 1173332
3-D non-LTE radiative transfer effects in Fe I lines: II. Line formation
in 3-D radiation hydrodynamic simulations
Submitted: 2013-08-12
We investigate the effects of horizontal radiative transfer (RT) a NLTE on
important diagnostic iron lines in a realistic 3-D HD simulation. Using a
multi-level atom we compute and compare widely used Fe I line profiles at 3
different levels of approximation (3-D NLTE, 1-D NLTE, LTE). We find that the
influence of horizontal RT is of the same order of magnitude as that of NLTE,
although spatially more localized. Also, depending on the temperature of the
surroundings, horizontal RT is found to weaken or strengthen spectral lines.
Line depths and equivalent width may differ by up to 20% against the
corresponding LTE value if 3-D RT is applied. Residual intensity contrasts in
LTE are found to be larger than those in 3-D NLTE by up to a factor of two.
When compared to 1-D NLTE, we find that horizontal RT weakens the contrast by
up to 30% almost independently of the angle of line of sight. While the CLV of
the 1-D and 3-D NLTE contrasts are of similar form, the LTE contrast CLV shows
a different run. The determination of temperatures by 1-D NLTE inversions of
spatially resolved observations may produce errors of up to 200 K if one
neglects 3-D RT. We find a linear correlation between the intensity difference
of 1-D and 3-D NLTE and a simple estimate of the temperature in the horizontal
environment of the line formation region. This correlation could be used to
coarsely correct for the effects of horizontal RT in inversions done in 1-D
NLTE. Horizontal RT is less important if one considers spatially averaged line
profiles because local line strengthening and weakening occur with similar
frequency in our HD atmosphere. Thus, the iron abundance is underestimated by
0.012 dex if calculated using 1-D NLTE RT. Since effects of horizontal RT are
largest for spatially resolved quantities, the use of 3-D RT is particularly
important for the interpretation of high spatial resolution observations.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.0559 [pdf] - 1151091
Three-dimensional non-LTE radiative transfer effects in Fe I lines I.
Flux sheet and flux tube geometries
Submitted: 2012-09-04
In network and active region plages, the magnetic field is concentrated into
structures often described as flux tubes (FTs) and sheets (FSs). 3-D radiative
transfer (RT) is important for energy transport in these concentrations. It is
also expected to be important for diagnostic purposes but has rarely been
applied for that purpose. Using true 3-D, non-LTE (NLTE) RT in FT/FS models, we
compute Fe line profiles commonly used to diagnose the Sun's magnetic field by
comparing the results with those obtained from LTE/1-D (1.5-D) NLTE
calculations. Employing a multilevel iron atom, we study the influence of basic
parameters such as Wilson depression, wall thickness, radius/width, thermal
stratification or magnetic field strength on all Stokes $I$ parameters in the
thin-tube approximation. The use of different levels of approximations of RT
may lead to considerable differences in profile shapes, intensity contrasts,
equivalent widths, and the determination of magnetic field strengths. In
particular, LTE, which often provides a good approach in planar 1-D
atmospheres, is a poor approximation in our flux sheet model for some of the
most important diagnostic Fe I lines (524.7nm, 525.0nm, 630.1nm, and 630.2nm).
The observed effects depend on parameters such as the height of line formation,
field strength, and internal temperature stratification. Differences between
the profile shapes may lead to errors in the determination of magnetic fields
on the order of 10 to 20%, while errors in the determined temperature can reach
300-400K. The empirical FT models NET and PLA turn out to minimize the effects
of 3D RT, so that results obtained with these models by applying LTE may also
remain valid for 3-D NLTE calculations. Finally, horizontal RT is found to only
insignificantly smear out structures such as the optically thick walls of FTs
and FSs, allowing features as narrow as 10km to remain visible.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.2157 [pdf] - 1076547
Observations of the forward scattering Hanle effect in the Ca i 4227
{\AA} line
Submitted: 2011-05-11
Chromospheric magnetic fields are notoriously diffcult to measure. The
chromospheric lines are broad, while the fields are producing a minuscule
Zeeman-effect polarization. A promising diagnostic alternative is provided by
the forward-scattering Hanle effect, which can be recorded in chromospheric
lines such as the He i 10830 {\AA} and the Ca i 4227 {\AA} lines. We present a
set of spectropolarimetric observations of the full Stokes vector obtained near
the center of the solar disk in the Ca i 4227 {\AA} line with the ZIMPOL
polarimeter at the IRSOL observatory.We detect a number of interesting
forward-scattering Hanle effect signatures, which we model successfully using
polarized radiative transfer. Here we focus on the observational aspects, while
a separate companion paper deals with the theoretical modeling.