Normalized to: Hollyhead, K.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.02297 [pdf] - 1830712
Spectroscopic detection of multiple populations in the ~2 Gyr old
cluster Hodge 6 in the LMC
Hollyhead, K.;
Martocchia, S.;
Lardo, C.;
Bastian, N.;
Kacharov, N.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Salaris, M.;
Usher, C.
Submitted: 2019-02-06
We report the spectroscopic discovery of abundance spreads (i.e. multiple
populations) in the ~2 Gyr old cluster in the LMC, Hodge 6. We use low
resolution VLT FORS2 spectra of 15 member stars in the cluster to measure their
CN and CH band strengths at ~3883 and 4300 A, respectively, as well as [C/Fe]
and [N/Fe] abundances. We find a sub-population of 2 stars that are enriched in
nitrogen, and we conclude that this sub-population is evidence of multiple
populations in Hodge 6. This is the second ~2 Gyr old cluster (the first being
NGC 1978 in the LMC) to show multiple populations and the first spectroscopic
detection of MPs in a cluster of this age. This result is interesting as it
hints at a possible relationship between the disappearance of extended main
sequence turn-offs in clusters younger than ~2 Gyr and the onset of multiple
populations at ~2 Gyr, which should be explored further.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.04141 [pdf] - 1675021
The search for multiple populations in Magellanic Cloud Clusters IV:
Coeval multiple stellar populations in the young star cluster NGC 1978
Martocchia, S.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Bastian, N.;
Kacharov, N.;
Usher, C.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Lardo, C.;
Cassisi, S.;
Geisler, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Larsen, S.;
Mackey, D.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Platais, I.;
Salaris, M.
Submitted: 2018-04-11
We have recently shown that the $\sim2$ Gyr old Large Magellanic Cloud star
cluster NGC 1978 hosts multiple populations in terms of star-to-star abundance
variations in [N/Fe]. These can be seen as a splitting or spread in the
sub-giant and red giant branches (SGB and RGB) when certain photometric filter
combinations are used. Due to its relative youth, NGC 1978 can be used to place
stringent limits on whether multiple bursts of star-formation have taken place
within the cluster, as predicted by some models for the origin of multiple
populations. We carry out two distinct analyses to test whether multiple
star-formation epochs have occurred within NGC 1978. First, we use UV CMDs to
select stars from the first and second population along the SGB, and then
compare their positions in optical CMDs, where the morphology is dominantly
controlled by age as opposed to multiple population effects. We find that the
two populations are indistinguishable, with age differences of $1\pm20$ Myr
between them. This is in tension with predictions from the AGB scenario for the
origin of multiple populations. Second, we estimate the broadness of the main
sequence turnoff (MSTO) of NGC 1978 and we report that it is consistent with
the observational errors. We find an upper limit of $\sim$65 Myr on the age
spread in the MSTO of NGC 1978. This finding is in conflict with the age spread
scenario as origin of the extended MSTO in intermediate age clusters, while it
fully supports predictions from the stellar rotation model.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.09670 [pdf] - 1634365
Kron 3: a fourth intermediate age cluster in the SMC with evidence of
multiple populations
Submitted: 2018-01-29
We present the results of a spectroscopic study of the intermediate age
(approximately 6.5 Gyr) massive cluster Kron 3 in the Small Magellanic Cloud.
We measure CN and CH band strengths (at 3839 and 4300 Angstroms respectively)
using VLT FORS2 spectra of 16 cluster members and find a sub-population of 5
stars enriched in nitrogen. We conclude that this is evidence for multiple
populations in Kron 3, the fourth intermediate age cluster, after Lindsay 1,
NGC 416 and NGC 339 (ages 6-8 Gyr), to display this phenomenon originally
thought to be a unique characteristic of old globular clusters. At 6.5 Gyr this
is one of the youngest clusters with multiple populations, indicating that the
mechanism responsible for their onset must operate until a redshift of at least
0.75, much later than the peak of globular cluster formation at redshift ~3.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.01121 [pdf] - 1590689
Interpreting the complex CMDs of the Magellanic Clouds clusters
Submitted: 2017-11-03
The Magellanic Clouds host a large population of massive (> 10^4 Msun) star
clusters with ages ranging from a few Myr to 12 Gyr. In nearly all cases, close
inspection of their CMDs reveals features that deviate from expectations of a
classic isochrone. Young (< 2 Gyr) clusters show extended main sequence
turnoffs and in some cases split/dual main sequences. Clusters older than ~ 2
Gyr show splitting in the red giant branches when viewed in UV filters that are
sensitive to abundance variations (in particular nitrogen). A distribution of
stellar rotation rates appears to be the cause of the complex features observed
in the young and intermediate age clusters, while above ~ 2 Gyr the features
seem to be the same light-element abundance variations as observed in the
ancient Galactic globular clusters, a.k.a. "multiple populations". Here, we
provide an overview of current observations and their interpretations and
summarise possible links between all the classes of complexities, regardless of
age.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.00831 [pdf] - 1593666
Age as a Major Factor in the Onset of Multiple Populations in Stellar
Clusters
Martocchia, S.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Lardo, C.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Bastian, N.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Usher, C.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Cordero, M.;
Geisler, D.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Kacharov, N.;
Larsen, S.;
Li, C.;
Mackey, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Platais, I.;
Salaris, M.
Submitted: 2017-10-02
It is now well established that globular clusters (GCs) exhibit star-to-star
light-element abundance variations (known as multiple stellar populations,
MPs). Such chemical anomalies have been found in (nearly) all the ancient GCs
(more than 10 Gyr old) of our Galaxy and its close companions, but so far no
model for the origin of MPs is able to reproduce all the relevant observations.
To gain new insights into this phenomenon, we have undertaken a photometric
Hubble Space Telescope survey to study clusters with masses comparable to that
of old GCs, where MPs have been identified, but with significantly younger
ages. Nine clusters in the Magellanic Clouds with ages between $\sim$ 1.5-11
Gyr have been targeted in this survey. We confirm the presence of multiple
populations in all clusters older than 6 Gyr and we add NGC 1978 to the group
of clusters for which MPs have been identified. With an age of $\sim$ 2 Gyr,
NGC 1978 is the youngest cluster known to host chemical abundance spreads found
to date. We do not detect evident star-to-star variations for slightly younger
massive clusters ($\sim$ 1.7 Gyr), thus pointing towards an unexpected age
dependence for the onset of multiple populations. This discovery suggests that
the formation of MPs is not restricted to the early Universe and that GCs and
young massive clusters share common formation and evolutionary processes.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.04631 [pdf] - 1571039
The Search for Multiple Populations in Magellanic Cloud Clusters III: No
evidence for Multiple Populations in the SMC cluster NGC 419
Martocchia, S.;
Bastian, N.;
Usher, C.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Kacharov, N.;
Lardo, C.;
Larsen, S.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Platais, I.;
Salaris, M.;
Cordero, M.;
Geisler, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Li, C.;
Mackey, D.
Submitted: 2017-03-14
We present the third paper about our ongoing HST survey for the search for
multiple stellar populations (MPs) within Magellanic Cloud clusters. We report
here the analysis of NGC 419, a $\sim 1.5$ Gyr old, massive ($\gtrsim 2 \times
10^5 \, {\rm M_{\odot}}$) star cluster in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). By
comparing our photometric data with stellar isochrones, we set a limit on
[N/Fe] enhancement of $\lesssim$+0.5 dex and hence we find that no MPs are
detected in this cluster. This is surprising because, in the first two papers
of this series, we found evidence for MPs in 4 other SMC clusters (NGC 121;
Lindsay 1, NGC 339, NGC 416), aged from 6 Gyr up to $\sim 10-11$ Gyr. This
finding raises the question whether age could play a major role in the MPs
phenomenon. Additionally, our results appear to exclude mass or environment as
the only key factors regulating the existence of a chemical enrichment, since
all clusters studied so far in this survey are equally massive ($\sim 1-2
\times 10^5 \, {\rm M_{\odot}}$) and no particular patterns are found when
looking at their spatial distribution in the SMC.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.00400 [pdf] - 1532948
The Search for Multiple Populations in Magellanic Cloud Clusters II: The
Detection of Multiple Populations in Three Intermediate-Age SMC Clusters
Niederhofer, F.;
Bastian, N.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Larsen, S.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Lardo, C.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Kacharov, N.;
Platais, I.;
Salaris, M.;
Cordero, M.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Geisler, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Li, C.;
Mackey, D.;
Mucciarelli, A.
Submitted: 2016-12-01
This is the second paper in our series about the search for multiple
populations in Magellanic Cloud star clusters using the Hubble Space Telescope.
Here we report the detection of multiple stellar populations in the
colour-magnitude diagrams of the intermediate-age clusters Lindsay 1, NGC 416
and NGC 339. With ages between 6.0 and 7.5 Gyr, these clusters are the youngest
ones in which chemical abundance spreads have been detected so far. This
confirms that the appearance of multiple populations is not restricted to only
ancient globular clusters, but may also be a common feature in clusters as
young as 6 Gyr. Our results are in agreement with a recent spectroscopic study
of Lindsay 1. We found that the fraction of enriched stars in NGC 416 is ~45%
whereas it is ~25% in NGC 339 and ~36% in Lindsay 1. Similar to NGC 121, these
fractions are lower than the average value for globular clusters in the Milky
Way.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.01595 [pdf] - 1483532
The Search for Multiple Populations in Magellanic Cloud Clusters I: Two
Stellar Populations in the Small Magellanic Cloud Globular Cluster NGC 121
Niederhofer, F.;
Bastian, N.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Larsen, S.;
Salaris, M.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Cordero, M.;
Geisler, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Kacharov, N.;
Lardo, C.;
Li, C.;
Mackey, D.;
Platais, I.
Submitted: 2016-09-06
We started a photometric survey using the WFC3/UVIS instrument onboard the
Hubble Space Telescope to search for multiple populations within Magellanic
Cloud star clusters at various ages. In this paper, we introduce this survey.
As first results of this programme, we also present multi-band photometric
observations of NGC 121 in different filters taken with the WFC3/UVIS and
ACS/WFC instruments. We analyze the colour-magnitude diagram (CMD) of NGC 121,
which is the only "classical" globular cluster within the Small Magellanic
Cloud. Thereby, we use the pseudo-colour
C_(F336W,F438W,F343N)=(F336W-F438W)-(F438W-F343N) to separate populations with
different C and N abundances. We show that the red giant branch splits up in
two distinct populations when using this colour combination. NGC 121 thus
appears to be similar to Galactic globular clusters in hosting multiple
populations. The fraction of enriched stars (N rich, C poor) in NGC 121 is
about 32% +/- 3%, which is lower than the median fraction found in Milky Way
globular clusters. The enriched population seems to be more centrally
concentrated compared to the primordial one. These results are consistent with
the recent results by Dalessandro et al. (2016). The morphology of the
Horizontal Branch in a CMD using the optical filters F555W and F814W is best
produced by a population with a spread in Helium of Delta(Y) =0.025+/-0.005.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.01302 [pdf] - 1521332
Evidence for multiple populations in the intermediate age cluster
Lindsay 1 in the SMC
Submitted: 2016-09-05
Lindsay 1 is an intermediate age (approx 8 Gyr) massive cluster in the Small
Magellanic Cloud (SMC). Using VLT FORS2 spectra of 16 probable cluster members
on the lower RGB of the cluster, we measure CN and CH band strengths (at 3883
and 4300 Angstroms respectively), along with carbon and nitrogen abundances and
find that a sub-population of stars has significant nitrogen enrichment. A lack
of spread in carbon abundances excludes evolutionary mixing as the source of
this enrichment, so we conclude that this is evidence of multiple populations.
Therefore, L1 is the youngest cluster to show such variations, implying that
the process triggering the onset of multiple populations must operate until at
least redshift ~1.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.03451 [pdf] - 1422345
Properties of the cluster population of NGC 1566 and their implications
Submitted: 2016-05-11
We present results of a photometric study into the cluster population of NGC
1566, a nearby grand design spiral galaxy, sampled out to a Galactocentric
radius of $\approx 5.5$ kpc. The shape of the mass-limited age distribution
shows negligible variation with radial distance from the centre of the galaxy,
and demonstrates three separate sections, with a steep beginning, flat middle
and steep end. The luminosity function can be approximated by a power law at
lower luminosities with evidence of a truncation at higher luminosity. The
power law section of the luminosity function of the galaxy is best fitted by an
index $\approx -2$, in agreement with other studies, and is found to agree with
a model luminosity function, which uses an underlying Schechter mass function.
The recovered power law slope of the mass distribution shows a slight
steepening as a function of galactocentric distance, but this is within error
estimates. It also displays a possible truncation at the high mass end.
Additionally, the cluster formation efficiency ($\Gamma$) and the specific
U-band luminosity of clusters ($T_L(U)$) are calculated for NGC 1566 and are
consistent with values for similar galaxies. A difference in NGC 1566, however,
is that the fairly high star formation rate is in contrast with a low
$\Sigma_{SFR}$ and $\Gamma$, indicating that $\Gamma$ can only be said to
depend strongly on $\Sigma_{SFR}$, not the star formation rate.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.02042 [pdf] - 1245852
Sizes and Shapes of Young Star Cluster Light Profiles in M83
Submitted: 2015-06-05
We measure the radii and two-dimensional light profiles of a large sample of
young, massive star clusters in M83 using archival HST/WFC3 imaging of seven
adjacent fields. We use GALFIT to fit the two-dimensional light profiles of the
clusters, from which we find effective (half-light) radii, core radii, and
slopes of the power-law (EFF) profile ($\eta$). We find lognormal distributions
of effective radius and core radius, with medians of $\approx$2.5 pc and
$\approx$1.3 pc, respectively. Our results provide strong evidence for a
characteristic size of young, massive clusters. The average effective radius
and core radius increase somewhat with cluster age. Little to no change in
effective radius is observed with increasing galactocentric distance, except
perhaps for clusters younger than 100 Myr. We find a shallow correlation
between effective radius and mass for the full cluster sample, but a stronger
correlation is present for clusters 200-300 Myr in age. Finally, the majority
of the clusters are best fit by an EFF model with index $\eta\leq3.0$. There is
no strong evidence for change in $\eta$ with cluster age, mass, or
galactocentric distance. Our results suggest that clusters emerge from early
evolution with similar radii and are not strongly affected by the tidal field
of M83. Mass loss due to stellar evolution and/or GMC interactions appear to
dominate cluster expansion in the age range we study.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.03823 [pdf] - 1224423
Studying the YMC population of M83: how long clusters remain embedded,
their interaction with the ISM and implications for GC formation theories
Submitted: 2015-02-12
The study of young massive clusters can provide key information for the
formation of globular clusters, as they are often considered analogues. A
currently unanswered question in this field is how long these massive clusters
remain embedded in their natal gas, with important implications for the
formation of multiple populations that have been used to explain phenomena
observed in globular clusters. We present an analysis of ages and masses of the
young massive cluster population of M83. Through visual inspection of the
clusters, and comparison of their SEDs and position in colour-colour space, the
clusters are all exposed (no longer embedded) by < 4 Myr, most likely less,
indicating that current proposed age spreads within older clusters are
unlikely. We also present several methods of constraining the ages of very
young massive clusters. This can often be difficult using SED fitting due to a
lack of information to disentangle age-extinction degeneracies and possible
inaccurate assumptions in the models used for the fitting. The individual
morphology of the Halpha around each cluster has a significant effect on the
measured fluxes, which contributes to inaccuracies in the age estimates for
clusters younger than 10 Myr using SED fitting. This is due to model
uncertainties and aperture effects. Our methods to help constrain ages of young
clusters include using the near-infrared and spectral features, such as
Wolf-Rayet stars.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.05657 [pdf] - 1224143
Constraining globular cluster formation through studies of young massive
clusters - V. ALMA observations of clusters in the Antennae
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Bastian, N.;
Longmore, S. N.;
Brogan, C.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Larsen, S. S.;
Whitmore, B.;
Johnson, K.;
Chandar, R.;
Henshaw, J. D.;
Davies, B.;
Hibbard, J. E.
Submitted: 2015-01-22
Some formation scenarios that have been put forward to explain multiple
populations within Globular Clusters (GCs) require that the young massive
cluster have large reservoirs of cold gas within them, which is necessary to
form future generations of stars. In this paper we use deep observations taken
with Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA) to assess the amount
of molecular gas within 3 young (50-200 Myr) massive (~10^6 Msun) clusters in
the Antennae galaxies. No significant CO(3--2) emission was found associated
with any of the three clusters. We place upper limits for the molecular gas
within these clusters of ~1x10^5 Msun (or <9 % of the current stellar mass). We
briefly review different scenarios that propose multiple episodes of star
formation and discuss some of their assumptions and implications. Our results
are in tension with the predictions of GC formation scenarios that expect large
reservoirs of cool gas within young massive clusters at these ages.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.6650 [pdf] - 1216556
Constraining Globular Cluster Formation Through Studies of Young Massive
Clusters - IV. Testing the Fast Rotating Massive Star Scenario
Submitted: 2014-08-28
One of the leading models for the formation of multiple stellar populations
within globular clusters is the "Fast Rotating Massive Star" (FRMS) scenario,
where the ejecta of rapidly rotating massive stars is mixed with primordial
material left over from the star-formation process, to form a second generation
of stars within the decretion discs of the high mass stars. A requirement of
this model, at least in its current form, is that young massive (i.e.
proto-globular) clusters are not able to eject the unused gas and dust from the
star-formation process from the cluster for 20-30 Myr after the formation of
the first generation of stars, i.e. the cluster remains embedded within the gas
cloud in which it forms. Here, we test this prediction by performing a
literature search for young massive clusters in nearby galaxies, which have
ages less than 20 Myr that are not embedded. We report that a number of such
clusters exist, with masses near, or significantly above 10^6 Msun, with ages
between a few Myr and ~15 Myr, suggesting that even high mass clusters are able
to clear any natal gas within them within a few Myr after formation.
Additionally, one cluster, Cluster 23 in ESO~338-IG04, has a metallicity below
that of some Galactic globular clusters that have been found to host multiple
stellar populations, mitigating any potential effect of differences in
metallicity in the comparison. The clusters reported here are in contradiction
to the expectations of the FRMS scenario, at least in its current form.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.4163 [pdf] - 1216375
The effect of spatial resolution on optical and near-IR studies of
stellar clusters: Implications for the origin of the red excess
Submitted: 2014-08-18
Recent ground based near-IR studies of stellar clusters in nearby galaxies
have suggested that young clusters remain embedded for 7-10Myr in their
progenitor molecular cloud, in conflict with optical based studies which find
that clusters are exposed after 1-3Myr. Here, we investigate the role that
spatial resolution plays in this apparent conflict. We use a recent catalogue
of young ($<10$~Myr) massive ($>5000$~\msun) clusters in the nearby spiral
galaxy, M83, along with Hubble Space Telescope (HST) imaging in the optical and
near-IR, and ground based near-IR imaging, to see how the colours (and hence
estimated properties such as age and extinction) are affected by the aperture
size employed, in order to simulate studies of differing resolution. We find
that the near-IR is heavily affected by the resolution, and when aperture sizes
$>40$~pc are used, all young/blue clusters move red-ward in colour space, which
results in their appearance as heavily extincted clusters. However, this is due
to contamination from nearby sources and nebular emission, and is not an
extinction effect. Optical colours are much less affected by resolution. Due to
the larger affect of contamination in the near-IR, we find that, in some cases,
clusters will appear to show near-IR excess when large ($>20$~pc) apertures are
used. Our results explain why few young ($<6$~Myr), low extinction ($\av <
1$~mag) clusters have been found in recent ground based near-IR studies of
cluster populations, while many such clusters have been found in higher
resolution HST based studies. Additionally, resolution effects appear to (at
least partially) explain the origin of the near-IR excess that has been found
in a number of extragalactic YMCs.