Normalized to: Hogan, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01306 [pdf] - 2127546
On the relation between mini-halos and AGN feedback in clusters of
galaxies
Richard-Laferrière, A.;
Hlavacek-Larrondo, J.;
Nemmen, R. S.;
Rhea, C. L.;
Taylor, G. B.;
Prasow-Émond, M.;
Gendron-Marsolais, M.;
Latulippe, M.;
Edge, A. C.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Sanders, J. S.;
Hogan, M. T.;
Demontigny, G.
Submitted: 2020-07-02
A variety of large-scale diffuse radio structures have been identified in
many clusters with the advent of new state-of-the-art facilities in radio
astronomy. Among these diffuse radio structures, radio mini-halos are found in
the central regions of cool core clusters. Their origin is still unknown and
they are challenging to discover; less than thirty have been published to date.
Based on new VLA observations, we confirmed the mini-halo in the massive strong
cool core cluster PKS 0745$-$191 ($z=0.1028$) and discovered one in the massive
cool core cluster MACS J1447.4+0827 ($z=0.3755$). Furthermore, using a detailed
analysis of all known mini-halos, we explore the relation between mini-halos
and AGN feedback processes from the central galaxy. We find evidence of strong,
previously unknown correlations between mini-halo radio power and X-ray cavity
power, and between mini-halo and the central galaxy radio power related to the
relativistic jets when spectrally decomposing the AGN radio emission into a
component for past outbursts and one for on-going accretion. Overall, our study
indicates that mini-halos are directly connected to the central AGN in
clusters, following previous suppositions. We hypothesize that AGN feedback may
be one of the dominant mechanisms giving rise to mini-halos by injecting energy
into the intra-cluster medium and reaccelerating an old population of
particles, while sloshing motion may drive the overall shape of mini-halos
inside cold fronts. AGN feedback may therefore not only play a vital role in
offsetting cooling in cool core clusters, but may also play a fundamental role
in re-energizing non-thermal particles in clusters.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.11104 [pdf] - 2102930
Thermally Unstable Cooling Stimulated by Uplift: The Spoiler Clusters
Martz, C. G.;
McNamara, B. R.;
Nulsen, P. E. J.;
Vantyghem, A. N.;
Gingras, M-J.;
Babyk, Iu. V.;
Russell, H. R.;
Edge, A. C.;
McDonald, M.;
Tamhane, P. D.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Hogan, M. T.
Submitted: 2020-03-24, last modified: 2020-05-27
We analyzed Chandra X-ray observations of five galaxy clusters whose
atmospheric cooling times, entropy parameters, and cooling time to free-fall
time ratios within the central galaxies lie below 1 Gyr, below 30 keV cm^2, and
between 20 < tcool/tff < 50, respectively. These thermodynamic properties are
commonly associated with molecular clouds, bright H-alpha emission, and star
formation in central galaxies. However, none of these clusters have detectable
H-alpha indicated in the ACCEPT database, nor do they have significant star
formation rates or detectable molecular gas. Among these, only RBS0533 has a
detectable radio/X-ray bubble which are commonly observed in cooling
atmospheres. Signatures of uplifted, high metallicity atmospheric gas are
absent. Despite its prominent X-ray bubble, RBS0533 lacks significant levels of
molecular gas. Cold gas is absent at appreciable levels in these systems
perhaps because their radio sources have failed to lift low entropy atmospheric
gas to an altitude where the ratio of the cooling time to the free-fall time
falls below unity.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.09164 [pdf] - 1983820
Ubiquitous cold and massive filaments in cool core clusters
Olivares, V.;
Salomé, P.;
Combes, F.;
Hamer, S.;
Guillard, P.;
Lehnert, M. D.;
Polles, F.;
Beckmann, R. S.;
Dubois, Y.;
Donahue, M.;
Edge, A.;
Fabian, A. C.;
McNamara, B.;
Rose, T.;
Russell, H.;
Tremblay, G.;
Vantyghem, A.;
Canning, R. E. A.;
Ferland, G.;
Godard, B.;
Hogan, M.;
Peirani, S.;
Forets, G. Pineau des
Submitted: 2019-02-25
Multi-phase filamentary structures around Brightest Cluster Galaxies are
likely a key step of AGN-feedback. We observed molecular gas in 3 cool cluster
cores: Centaurus, Abell S1101, and RXJ1539.5 and gathered ALMA and MUSE data
for 12 other clusters. Those observations show clumpy, massive and long, 3--25
kpc, molecular filaments, preferentially located around the radio bubbles
inflated by the AGN (Active Galactic Nucleus). Two objects show nuclear
molecular disks. The optical nebula is certainly tracing the warm envelopes of
cold molecular filaments. Surprisingly, the radial profile of the H$\alpha$/CO
flux ratio is roughly constant for most of the objects, suggesting that (i)
between 1.2 to 7 times more cold gas could be present and (ii) local processes
must be responsible for the excitation. Projected velocities are between
100--400 km s$^{-1}$, with disturbed kinematics and sometimes coherent
gradients. This is likely due to the mixing in projection of several thin
unresolved filaments. The velocity fields may be stirred by turbulence induced
by bubbles, jets or merger-induced sloshing. Velocity and dispersions are low,
below the escape velocity. Cold clouds should eventually fall back and fuel the
AGN. We compare the filament's radial extent, r$_{fil}$, with the region where
the X-ray gas can become thermally unstable. The filaments are always inside
the low-entropy and short cooling time region, where t$_{cool}$/t$_{ff}$<20 (9
of 13 sources). The range t$_{cool}$/t$_{ff}$, 8-23 at r$_{fil}$, is likely due
to (i) a more complex gravitational potential affecting the free-fall time
(e.g., sloshing, mergers); (ii) the presence of inhomogeneities or uplifted gas
in the ICM, affecting the cooling time. For some of the sources, r$_{fil}$ lies
where the ratio of the cooling time to the eddy-turnover time,
t$_{cool}$/t$_{eddy}$, is approximately unity.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.02589 [pdf] - 1728870
A Universal Entropy Profile for the Hot Atmospheres of Galaxies and
Clusters within $R_{2500}$
Submitted: 2018-02-07, last modified: 2018-06-13
We present atmospheric gas entropy profiles for 40 early type galaxies and
110 clusters spanning several decades of halo mass, atmospheric gas mass, radio
jet power, and galaxy type. We show that within $\sim 0.1R_{2500}$ the entropy
profiles of low-mass systems, including ellipticals, brightest cluster
galaxies, and spiral galaxies, scale approximately as $K\propto R^{2/3}$.
Beyond $\sim 0.1R_{2500}$ entropy profiles are slightly shallower than the $K
\propto R^{1.1}$ profile expected from gravitational collapse alone, indicating
that heating by AGN feedback extends well beyond the central galaxy. We show
that the $K\propto R^{2/3}$ entropy profile shape indicates that thermally
unstable cooling is balanced by heating where the inner cooling and free-fall
timescales approach a constant ratio. Hot atmospheres of elliptical galaxies
have a higher rate of heating per gas particle compared to central cluster
galaxies. This excess heating may explain why some central cluster galaxies are
forming stars while most early-type galaxies have experienced no significant
star formation for billions of years. We show that the entropy profiles of six
lenticular and spiral galaxies follow the $R^{2/3}$ form. The continuity
between central galaxies in clusters, giant ellipticals, and spirals suggests
perhaps that processes heating the atmospheres of elliptical and brightest
cluster galaxies are also active in spiral galaxies.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.00020 [pdf] - 1670624
X-ray scaling relations of early-type galaxies
Submitted: 2018-02-28
X-ray luminosity, temperature, gas mass, total mass, and their scaling
relations are derived for 94 early-type galaxies using archival $Chandra$ X-ray
Observatory observations. Consistent with earlier studies, the scaling
relations, $L_X \propto T^{4.5\pm0.2}$, $M \propto T^{2.4\pm0.2}$, and $L_X
\propto M^{2.8\pm0.3}$, are significantly steeper than expected from self
similarity. This steepening indicates that their atmospheres are heated above
the level expected from gravitational infall alone. Energetic feedback from
nuclear black holes and supernova explosions are likely heating agents. The
tight $L_X - T$ correlation for low-luminosities systems (i.e., below 10$^{40}$
erg/s) are at variance with hydrodynamical simulations which generally predict
higher temperatures for low luminosity galaxies. We also investigate the
relationship between total mass and pressure, $Y_X = M_g \times T$, finding $M
\propto Y_{X}^{0.45\pm0.04}$. We explore the gas mass to total mass fraction in
early-type galaxies and find a range of $0.1-1.0\%$. We find no correlation
between the gas-to-total mass fraction with temperature or total mass. Higher
stellar velocity dispersions and higher metallicities are found in hotter,
brighter, and more massive atmospheres. X-ray core radii derived from
$\beta$-model fitting are used to characterize the degree of core and cuspiness
of hot atmospheres.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.06564 [pdf] - 1648629
Shaken Snow Globes: Kinematic Tracers of the Multiphase Condensation
Cascade in Massive Galaxies, Groups, and Clusters
Gaspari, M.;
McDonald, M.;
Hamer, S. L.;
Brighenti, F.;
Temi, P.;
Gendron-Marsolais, M.;
Hlavacek-Larrondo, J.;
Edge, A. C.;
Werner, N.;
Tozzi, P.;
Sun, M.;
Stone, J. M.;
Tremblay, G. R.;
Hogan, M. T.;
Eckert, D.;
Ettori, S.;
Yu, H.;
Biffi, V.;
Planelles, S.
Submitted: 2017-09-19, last modified: 2018-02-09
We propose a novel method to constrain turbulence and bulk motions in massive
galaxies, groups and clusters, exploring both simulations and observations. As
emerged in the recent picture of the top-down multiphase condensation, the hot
gaseous halos are tightly linked to all other phases in terms of cospatiality
and thermodynamics. While hot halos (10^7 K) are perturbed by subsonic
turbulence, warm (10^4 K) ionized and neutral filaments condense out of the
turbulent eddies. The peaks condense into cold molecular clouds (< 100 K)
raining in the core via chaotic cold accretion (CCA). We show all phases are
tightly linked via the ensemble (wide-aperture) velocity dispersion along the
line of sight. The correlation arises in complementary long-term AGN feedback
simulations and high-resolution CCA runs, and is corroborated by the combined
Hitomi and new IFU measurements in Perseus cluster. The ensemble multiphase gas
distributions are characterized by substantial spectral line broadening
(100-200 km/s) with mild line shift. On the other hand, pencil-beam detections
sample the small-scale clouds displaying smaller broadening and significant
line shift up to several 100 km/s, with increased scatter due to the turbulence
intermittency. We present new ensemble sigma_v of the warm Halpha+[NII] gas in
72 observed cluster/group cores: the constraints are consistent with the
simulations and can be used as robust proxies for the turbulent velocities, in
particular for the challenging hot plasma (otherwise requiring extremely long
X-ray exposures). We show the physically motivated criterion C = t_cool/t_eddy
~ 1 best traces the condensation extent region and presence of multiphase gas
in observed clusters/groups. The ensemble method can be applied to many
available datasets and can substantially advance our understanding of
multiphase halos in light of the next-generation multiwavelength missions.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.03641 [pdf] - 1637505
Mystery solved: discovery of extended radio emission in the merging
galaxy cluster Abell 2146
Hlavacek-Larrondo, J.;
Gendron-Marsolais, M. -L.;
Fecteau-Beaucage, D.;
van Weeren, R. J.;
Russell, H. R.;
Edge, A.;
Olamaie, M.;
Rumsey, C.;
King, L.;
Fabian, A. C.;
McNamara, B.;
Hogan, M.;
Mezcua, M.;
Taylor, G.
Submitted: 2017-08-11, last modified: 2017-12-01
Abell 2146 ($z=0.232$) is a massive galaxy cluster currently undergoing a
spectacular merger in the plane of the sky with a bullet-like morphology. It
was the first system in which both the bow and upstream shock fronts were
detected at X-ray wavelengths (Mach$\sim2$), yet deep GMRT 325 MHz observations
failed to detect extended radio emission associated with the cluster as is
typically seen in such systems. We present new, multi-configuration $1-2$ GHz
Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) observations of Abell 2146 totalling 16
hours of observations. These data reveal for the first time the presence of an
extended ($\approx850$ kpc), faint radio structure associated with Abell 2146.
The structure appears to harbour multiple components, one associated with the
upstream shock which we classify as a radio relic and one associated with the
subcluster core which is consisted as being a radio halo bounded by the bow
shock. The newly detected structures have some of the lowest radio powers
detected thus far in any cluster ($P_{\rm 1.4 GHz,
halo}=2.4\pm0.2\times10^{23}$ W Hz$^{-1}$ and $P_{\rm 1.4 GHz,
relic}=2.2\pm0.2\times10^{23}$ W Hz$^{-1}$). The flux measurement of the halo,
as well as its morphology, also suggest that the halo was recently created
($\approx0.3$ Gyr after core passage), consistent with the dynamical state of
the cluster. These observations demonstrate the capacity of the upgraded VLA to
detect extremely faint and extended radio structures. Based on these
observations, we predict that many more radio relics and radio halos in merging
clusters should be detected by future radio facilities such as the Square
Kilometre Array (SKA).
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.10268 [pdf] - 1590388
The most massive black holes on the Fundamental Plane of Black Hole
Accretion
Submitted: 2017-10-27, last modified: 2017-11-06
We perform a detailed study of the location of brightest cluster galaxies
(BCGs) on the fundamental plane of black hole (BH) accretion, which is an
empirical correlation between a BH X-ray and radio luminosity and mass
supported by theoretical models of accretion. The sample comprises 72 BCGs out
to $z\sim0.3$ and with reliable nuclear X-ray and radio luminosities. These are
found to correlate as $L_\mathrm{X} \propto L_\mathrm{R}^{0.75 \pm 0.08}$,
favoring an advection-dominated accretion flow as the origin of the X-ray
emission. BCGs are found to be on average offset from the fundamental plane
such that their BH masses seem to be underestimated by the
$M_\mathrm{BH}-M_\mathrm{K}$ relation a factor $\sim$10. The offset is not
explained by jet synchrotron cooling and is independent of emission process or
amount of cluster gas cooling. Those core-dominated BCGs are found to be more
significantly offset than those with weak core radio emission. For BCGs to on
average follow the fundamental plane, a large fraction ($\sim40\%$) should have
BH masses $> 10^{10}$ M$_{\odot}$ and thus host ultramassive BHs. The local
BH-galaxy scaling relations would not hold for these extreme objects. The
possible explanations for their formation, either via a two-phase process (the
BH formed first, the galaxy grows later) or as descendants of high-z seed BHs,
challenge the current paradigm of a synchronized galaxy-BH growth.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.04664 [pdf] - 1637542
The Origin of Molecular Clouds In Central Galaxies
Submitted: 2017-10-12
We present an analysis of 55 central galaxies in clusters and groups with
molecular gas masses and star formation rates lying between $10^{8}-10^{11}\
M_{\odot}$ and $0.5-270$ $M_{\odot}\ yr^{-1}$, respectively. We have used
Chandra observations to derive profiles of total mass and various thermodynamic
variables. Molecular gas is detected only when the central cooling time or
entropy index of the hot atmosphere falls below $\sim$1 Gyr or $\sim$35 keV
cm$^2$, respectively, at a (resolved) radius of 10 kpc. This indicates that the
molecular gas condensed from hot atmospheres surrounding the central galaxies.
The depletion timescale of molecular gas due to star formation approaches 1 Gyr
in most systems. Yet ALMA images of roughly a half dozen systems drawn from
this sample suggest the molecular gas formed recently. We explore the origins
of thermally unstable cooling by evaluating whether molecular gas becomes
prevalent when the minimum of the cooling to free-fall time ratio ($t_{\rm
cool}/t_{\rm ff}$) falls below $\sim10$. We find: 1) molecular gas-rich systems
instead lie between $10 < min(t_{\rm cool}/t_{\rm ff}) < 25$, where $t_{\rm
cool}/t_{\rm ff}=25$ corresponds approximately to cooling time and entropy
thresholds $t_{\rm cool} \lesssim 1$ Gyr and 35 keV~cm$^2$, respectively, 2)
$min(t_{\rm cool}/t_{\rm ff}$) is uncorrelated with molecular gas mass and jet
power, and 3) the narrow range $10 < min(t_{\rm cool}/t_{\rm ff}) < 25$ can be
explained by an observational selection effect. These results and the absence
of isentropic cores in cluster atmospheres are in tension with "precipitation"
models, particularly those that assume thermal instability ensues from linear
density perturbations in hot atmospheres. Some and possibly all of the
molecular gas may instead have condensed from atmospheric gas lifted outward
either by buoyantly-rising X-ray bubbles or merger-induced gas motions.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.09679 [pdf] - 1588994
A $^{13}$CO Detection in a Brightest Cluster Galaxy
Vantyghem, A. N.;
McNamara, B. R.;
Edge, A. C.;
Combes, F.;
Russell, H. R.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Hogan, M. T.;
McDonald, M.;
Nulsen, P. E. J.;
Salomé, P.
Submitted: 2017-09-27
We present ALMA Cycle 4 observations of CO(1-0), CO(3-2), and $^{13}$CO(3-2)
line emission in the brightest cluster galaxy of RXJ0821+0752. This is one of
the first detections of $^{13}$CO line emission in a galaxy cluster. Half of
the CO(3-2) line emission originates from two clumps of molecular gas that are
spatially offset from the galactic center. These clumps are surrounded by
diffuse emission that extends $8~{\rm kpc}$ in length. The detected $^{13}$CO
emission is confined entirely to the two bright clumps, with any emission
outside of this region lying below our detection threshold. Two distinct
velocity components with similar integrated fluxes are detected in the
$^{12}$CO spectra. The narrower component ($60~{\rm km}~{\rm s}^{-1}$ FWHM) is
consistent in both velocity centroid and linewidth with $^{13}$CO(3-2)
emission, while the broader ($130-160~{\rm km}~{\rm s}^{-1}$), slightly
blueshifted wing has no associated $^{13}$CO(3-2) emission. A simple local
thermodynamic model indicates that the $^{13}$CO emission traces $2.1\times
10^{9}~{\rm M}_\odot$ of molecular gas. Isolating the $^{12}$CO velocity
component that accompanies the $^{13}$CO emission yields a CO-to-H$_2$
conversion factor of $\alpha_{\rm CO}=2.3~{\rm M}_{\odot}~({\rm
K~km~s^{-1}})^{-1}$, which is a factor of two lower than the Galactic value.
Adopting the Galactic CO-to-H$_2$ conversion factor in brightest cluster
galaxies may therefore overestimate their molecular gas masses by a factor of
two. This is within the object-to-object scatter from extragalactic sources, so
calibrations in a larger sample of clusters are necessary in order to confirm a
sub-Galactic conversion factor.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.08935 [pdf] - 1587646
Close entrainment of massive molecular gas flows by radio bubbles in the
central galaxy of Abell 1795
Russell, H. R.;
McNamara, B. R.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Nulsen, P. E. J.;
Combes, F.;
Edge, A. C.;
Hogan, M. T.;
McDonald, M.;
Salome, P.;
Tremblay, G.;
Vantyghem, A. N.
Submitted: 2017-08-29
We present new ALMA observations tracing the morphology and velocity
structure of the molecular gas in the central galaxy of the cluster Abell 1795.
The molecular gas lies in two filaments that extend 5 - 7 kpc to the N and S
from the nucleus and project exclusively around the outer edges of two inner
radio bubbles. Radio jets launched by the central AGN have inflated bubbles
filled with relativistic plasma into the hot atmosphere surrounding the central
galaxy. The N filament has a smoothly increasing velocity gradient along its
length from the central galaxy's systemic velocity at the nucleus to -370 km/s,
the average velocity of the surrounding galaxies, at the furthest extent. The S
filament has a similarly smooth but shallower velocity gradient and appears to
have partially collapsed in a burst of star formation. The close spatial
association with the radio lobes, together with the ordered velocity gradients
and narrow velocity dispersions, show that the molecular filaments are gas
flows entrained by the expanding radio bubbles. Assuming a Galactic
$X_{\mathrm{CO}}$ factor, the total molecular gas mass is
$3.2\pm0.2\times10^{9}$M$_{\odot}$. More than half lies above the N radio
bubble. Lifting the molecular clouds appears to require an infeasibly efficient
coupling between the molecular gas and the radio bubble. The energy required
also exceeds the mechanical power of the N radio bubble by a factor of two.
Stimulated feedback, where the radio bubbles lift low entropy X-ray gas that
becomes thermally unstable and rapidly cools in situ, provides a plausible
model. Multiple generations of radio bubbles are required to lift this
substantial gas mass. The close morphological association then indicates that
the cold gas either moulds the newly expanding bubbles or is itself pushed
aside and shaped as they inflate.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.00011 [pdf] - 1608348
The Onset of Thermally Unstable Cooling from the Hot Atmospheres of
Giant Galaxies in Clusters - Constraints on Feedback Models
Hogan, M. T.;
McNamara, B. R.;
Pulido, F.;
Nulsen, P. E. J.;
Vantyghem, A. N.;
Russell, H. R.;
Edge, A. C.;
Babyk, Iu.;
Main, R. A.;
McDonald, M.
Submitted: 2017-03-31
We present accurate mass and thermodynamic profiles for a sample of 56 galaxy
clusters observed with the Chandra X-ray Observatory. We investigate the
effects of local gravitational acceleration in central cluster galaxies, and we
explore the role of the local free-fall time (t$_{\rm ff}$) in thermally
unstable cooling. We find that the local cooling time (t$_{\rm cool}$) is as
effective an indicator of cold gas, traced through its nebular emission, as the
ratio of t$_{\rm cool}$/t$_{\rm ff}$. Therefore, t$_{\rm cool}$ alone
apparently governs the onset of thermally unstable cooling in hot atmospheres.
The location of the minimum t$_{\rm cool}$/t$_{\rm ff}$, a thermodynamic
parameter that simulations suggest may be key in driving thermal instability,
is unresolved in most systems. As a consequence, selection effects bias the
value and reduce the observed range in measured t$_{\rm cool}$/t$_{\rm ff}$
minima. The entropy profiles of cool-core clusters are characterized by broken
power-laws down to our resolution limit, with no indication of isentropic
cores. We show, for the first time, that mass isothermality and the $K \propto
r^{2/3}$ entropy profile slope imply a floor in t$_{\rm cool}$/t$_{\rm ff}$
profiles within central galaxies. No significant departures of t$_{\rm
cool}$/t$_{\rm ff}$ below 10 are found, which is inconsistent with many recent
feedback models. The inner densities and cooling times of cluster atmospheres
are resilient to change in response to powerful AGN activity, suggesting that
the energy coupling between AGN heating and atmospheric gas is gentler than
most models predict.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.04617 [pdf] - 1542754
Mass Distribution in Galaxy Cluster Cores
Submitted: 2016-10-14
Many processes within galaxy clusters, such as those believed to govern the
onset of thermally unstable cooling and AGN feedback, are dependent upon local
dynamical timescales. However, accurately mapping the mass distribution within
individual clusters is challenging, particularly towards cluster centres where
the total mass budget has substantial radially-dependent contributions from the
stellar, gas, and dark matter components. In this paper we use a small sample
of galaxy clusters with deep Chandra observations and good ancillary tracers of
their gravitating mass at both large and small radii to develop a method for
determining mass profiles that span a wide radial range and extend down into
the central galaxy. We also consider potential observational pitfalls in
understanding cooling in hot cluster atmospheres, and find tentative evidence
for a relationship between the radial extent of cooling X-ray gas and nebular
H-alpha emission in cool core clusters. Amongst this small sample we find no
support for the existence of a central 'entropy floor', with the entropy
profiles following a power-law profile down to our resolution limit.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.00716 [pdf] - 1531849
Molecular Gas Along a Bright H-alpha Filament in 2A 0335+096 Revealed by
ALMA
Vantyghem, A. N.;
McNamara, B. R.;
Russell, H. R.;
Hogan, M. T.;
Edge, A. C.;
Nulsen, P. E. J.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Combes, F.;
Salome, P.;
Baum, S. A.;
Donahue, M.;
Main, R. A.;
Murray, N. W.;
O'Connell, R. W.;
O'Dea, C. P.;
Oonk, J. B. R.;
Parrish, I. J;
Sanders, J. S.;
Tremblay, G.;
Voit, G. M.
Submitted: 2016-10-03, last modified: 2016-10-07
We present ALMA CO(1-0) and CO(3-2) observations of the brightest cluster
galaxy (BCG) in the 2A 0335+096 galaxy cluster (z = 0.0346). The total
molecular gas mass of (1.13+/-0.15) x 10^9 M_sun is divided into two
components: a nuclear region and a 7 kpc long dusty filament. The central
molecular gas component accounts for (3.2+/-0.4) x 10^8 M_sun of the total
supply of cold gas. Instead of forming a rotationally-supported ring or disk,
it is composed of two distinct, blueshifted clumps south of the nucleus and a
series of low-significance redshifted clumps extending toward a nearby
companion galaxy. The velocity of the redshifted clouds increases with radius
to a value consistent with the companion galaxy, suggesting that an interaction
between these galaxies <20 Myr ago disrupted a pre-existing molecular gas
reservoir within the BCG. Most of the molecular gas, (7.8+/-0.9) x 10^8 M_sun,
is located in the filament. The CO emission is co-spatial with a 10^4 K
emission-line nebula and soft X-rays from 0.5 keV gas, indicating that the
molecular gas has cooled out of the intracluster medium over a period of 25-100
Myr. The filament trails an X-ray cavity, suggesting that the gas has cooled
from low entropy gas that has been lifted out of the cluster core and become
thermally unstable. We are unable to distinguish between inflow and outflow
along the filament with the present data. Cloud velocities along the filament
are consistent with gravitational free-fall near the plane of the sky, although
their increasing blueshifts with radius are consistent with outflow.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.07818 [pdf] - 1513560
Chandra X-ray observations of the hyper-luminous infrared galaxy IRAS
F15307+3252
Submitted: 2016-06-24, last modified: 2016-09-23
Hyper-luminous infrared galaxies (HyLIRGs) lie at the extreme luminosity end
of the IR galaxy population with $L_{\rm IR}>10^{13}$L$_\odot$. They are
thought to be closer counterparts of the more distant sub-mm galaxies, and
should therefore be optimal targets to study the most massive systems in
formation. We present deep $Chandra$ observations of IRAS~F15307+3252 (100ks),
a classical HyLIRG located at $z=$0.93 and hosting a radio-loud AGN ($L_{\rm
1.4 GHz}\sim3.5\times10^{25}$ W/Hz). The $Chandra$ images reveal the presence
of extended ($r=160$ kpc), asymmetric X-ray emission in the soft 0.3-2.0 keV
band that has no radio counterpart. We therefore argue that the emission is of
thermal origin originating from a hot intragroup or intracluster medium
virializing in the potential. We find that the temperature ($\sim2$ keV) and
bolometric X-ray luminosity ($\sim3\times10^{43}$ erg s$^{-1}$) of the gas
follow the expected $L_{\rm X-ray}-T$ correlation for groups and clusters, and
that the gas has a remarkably short cooling time of $1.2$ Gyrs. In addition,
VLA radio observations reveal that the galaxy hosts an unresolved compact
steep-spectrum (CSS) source, most likely indicating the presence of a young
radio source similar to 3C186. We also confirm that the nucleus is dominated by
a redshifted 6.4 keV Fe K$\alpha$ line, strongly suggesting that the AGN is
Compton-thick. Finally, Hubble images reveal an over-density of galaxies and
sub-structure in the galaxy that correlates with soft X-ray emission. This
could be a snapshot view of on-going groupings expected in a growing cluster
environment. IRAS~F15307+3252 might therefore be a rare example of a group in
the process of transforming into a cluster.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.04629 [pdf] - 1498273
A Mechanism for Stimulating AGN Feedback by Lifting Gas in Massive
Galaxies
Submitted: 2016-04-15, last modified: 2016-08-17
Observation shows that nebular emission, molecular gas, and young stars in
giant galaxies are associated with rising X-ray bubbles inflated by radio jets
launched from nuclear black holes. We propose a model where molecular clouds
condense from low entropy gas caught in the updraft of rising X-ray bubbles.
The low entropy gas becomes thermally unstable when it is lifted to an altitude
where its cooling time is shorter than the time required to fall to its
equilibrium location in the galaxy i.e., t_c/t_I < 1. The infall speed of a
cloud is bounded by the lesser of its free-fall and terminal speeds, so that
the infall time here can exceed the the free-fall time by a significant factor.
This mechanism is motivated by ALMA observations revealing molecular clouds
lying in the wakes of rising X-ray bubbles with velocities well below their
free-fall speeds. Our mechanism would provide cold gas needed to fuel a
feedback loop while stabilizing the atmosphere on larger scales. The observed
cooling time threshold of ~ 5x 10^8 yr --- the clear-cut signature of thermal
instability and the onset of nebular emission and star formation--- may result
from the limited ability of radio bubbles to lift low entropy gas to altitudes
where thermal instabilities can ensue. Outflowing molecular clouds are unlikely
to escape, but instead return to the central galaxy in a circulating flow. We
contrast our mechanism to precipitation models where the minimum value of
t_c/t_ff < 10 triggers thermal instability, which we find to be inconsistent
with observation.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.03022 [pdf] - 1273206
High Radio Frequency Properties and Variability of Brightest Cluster
Galaxies
Hogan, M. T.;
Edge, A. C.;
Geach, J. E.;
Grainge, K. J. B.;
Hlavacek-Larrondo, J.;
Hovatta, T.;
Karim, A.;
McNamara, B. R.;
Rumsey, C.;
Russell, H. R.;
Salomé, P.;
Aller, H. D.;
Aller, M. F.;
Benford, D. J.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Readhead, A. C. S.;
Sadler, E. M.;
Saunders, R. D. E.
Submitted: 2015-07-10
We consider the high radio frequency (15 GHz - 353 GHz) properties and
variability of 35 Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs). These are the most
core-dominated sources drawn from a parent sample of more than 700 X-ray
selected clusters, thus allowing us to relate our results to the general
population. We find that >6.0% of our parent sample (>15.1% if only cool-core
clusters are considered) contain a radio-source at 150 GHz of at least 3mJy
(~1x10^23 W/Hz at our median redshift of z~0.13). Furthermore, >3.4% of the
BCGs in our parent sample contain a peaked component (Gigahertz Peaked
Spectrum, GPS) in their spectra that peaks above 2 GHz, increasing to >8.5% if
only cool-core clusters are considered. We see little evidence for strong
variability at 15 GHz on short (week-month) time-scales although we see
variations greater than 20% at 150 GHz over 6-month times-frames for 4 of the
23 sources with multi-epoch observations. Much more prevalent is long-term
(year-decade time-scale) variability, with average annual amplitude variations
greater than 1% at 15 GHz being commonplace. There is a weak trend towards
higher variability as the peak of the GPS-like component occurs at higher
frequency. We demonstrate the complexity that is seen in the radio spectra of
BCGs and discuss the potentially significant implications of these high-peaking
components for Sunyaev-Zel'dovich cluster searches.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.03019 [pdf] - 1273205
A Comprehensive Study of the Radio Properties of Brightest Cluster
Galaxies
Hogan, M. T.;
Edge, A. C.;
Hlavacek-Larrondo, J.;
Grainge, K. J. B.;
Hamer, S. L.;
Mahony, E. K.;
Russell, H. R.;
Fabian, A. C.;
McNamara, B. R.;
Wilman, R. J.
Submitted: 2015-07-10
We examine the radio properties of the Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs) in a
large sample of X-ray selected galaxy clusters comprising the Brightest Cluster
Sample (BCS), the extended BCS (eBCS) and ROSAT-ESO Flux Limited X-ray (REFLEX)
cluster catalogues. We have multi-frequency radio observations of the BCG using
a variety of data from the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA), Jansky
Very Large Array (VLA) and Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) telescopes. The
radio spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of these objects are decomposed into
a component attributed to on-going accretion by the active galactic nuclei
(AGN) that we refer to as the 'core', and a more diffuse, ageing component we
refer to as the 'non-core'. These BCGs are matched to previous studies to
determine whether they exhibit emission lines (principally H-alpha), indicative
of the presence of a strong cooling cluster core. We consider how the radio
properties of the BCGs vary with cluster environmental factors. Line emitting
BCGs are shown to generally host more powerful radio sources, exhibiting the
presence of a strong, distinguishable core component in about 60% of cases.
This core component more strongly correlates with the BCG's [OIII]5007A line
emission. For BCGs in line-emitting clusters, the X-ray cavity power correlates
with both the extended and core radio emission, suggestive of steady fuelling
of the AGN over bubble-rise time-scales in these clusters.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.03533 [pdf] - 1021971
Far Ultraviolet Morphology of Star Forming Filaments in Cool Core
Brightest Cluster Galaxies
Tremblay, Grant R.;
O'Dea, Christopher P.;
Baum, Stefi A.;
Mittal, Rupal;
McDonald, Michael;
Combes, Françoise;
Li, Yuan;
McNamara, Brian;
Bremer, Malcolm N.;
Clarke, Tracy E.;
Donahue, Megan;
Edge, Alastair C.;
Fabian, Andrew C.;
Hamer, Stephen L.;
Hogan, Michael T.;
Oonk, Raymond;
Quillen, Alice C.;
Sanders, Jeremy S.;
Salomé, Philippe;
Voit, G. Mark
Submitted: 2015-05-13
We present a multiwavelength morphological analysis of star forming clouds
and filaments in the central ($< 50$ kpc) regions of 16 low redshift ($z<0.3$)
cool core brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs). New Hubble Space Telescope (HST)
imaging of far ultraviolet continuum emission from young ($\sim 10$ Myr),
massive ($> 5$ \Msol) stars reveals filamentary and clumpy morphologies, which
we quantify by means of structural indices. The FUV data are compared with
X-ray, Ly$\alpha$, narrowband H$\alpha$, broadband optical/IR, and radio maps,
providing a high spatial resolution atlas of star formation locales relative to
the ambient hot ($\sim10^{7-8}$ K) and warm ionised ($\sim 10^4$ K) gas phases,
as well as the old stellar population and radio-bright AGN outflows. Nearly
half of the sample possesses kpc-scale filaments that, in projection, extend
toward and around radio lobes and/or X-ray cavities. These filaments may have
been uplifted by the propagating jet or buoyant X-ray bubble, or may have
formed {\it in situ} by cloud collapse at the interface of a radio lobe or
rapid cooling in a cavity's compressed shell. The morphological diversity of
nearly the entire FUV sample is reproduced by recent hydrodynamical simulations
in which the AGN powers a self-regulating rain of thermally unstable star
forming clouds that precipitate from the hot atmosphere. In this model,
precipitation triggers where the cooling-to- freefall time ratio is
$t_{\mathrm{cool}}/t_{\mathrm{ff}}\sim 10$. This condition is roughly met at
the maxmial projected FUV radius for more than half of our sample, and
clustering about this ratio is stronger for sources with higher star formation
rates.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.4198 [pdf] - 1222591
Storm in a "Teacup": a radio-quiet quasar with ~10kpc radio-emitting
bubbles and extreme gas kinematics
Submitted: 2014-10-15, last modified: 2015-01-30
We present multi-frequency (1-8 GHz) VLA data, combined with VIMOS IFU data
and HST imaging, of a z=0.085 radio-quiet type 2 quasar (with L(1.4GHz)~5e23
W/Hz and L(AGN)~2e45 erg/s). Due to the morphology of its emission-line region,
the target (J1430+1339) has been referred to as the Teacup AGN in the
literature. We identify "bubbles" of radio emission that are extended ~10-12
kpc to both the east and west of the nucleus. The edge of the brighter eastern
bubble is co-spatial with an arc of luminous ionized gas. We also show that the
Teacup AGN hosts a compact radio structure, located ~0.8 kpc from the core
position, at the base of the eastern bubble. This radio structure is co-spatial
with an ionized outflow with an observed velocity of v=-740 km/s. This is
likely to correspond to a jet, or possibly a quasar wind, interacting with the
interstellar medium at this position. The large-scale radio bubbles appear to
be inflated by the central AGN, which indicates that the AGN can also interact
with the gas on >~10 kpc scales. Our study highlights that even when a quasar
is formally "radio-quiet" the radio emission can be extremely effective for
observing the effects of AGN feedback.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.5664 [pdf] - 910649
The SKA view of cool-core clusters: evolution of radio mini-halos and
AGN feedback
Gitti, Myriam;
Tozzi, Paolo;
Brunetti, Gianfranco;
Cassano, Rossella;
Dallacasa, Daniele;
Edge, Alastair;
Ettori, Stefano;
Feretti, Luigina;
Ferrari, Chiara;
Giacintucci, Simona;
Giovannini, Gabriele;
Hogan, Michael;
Venturi, Tiziana
Submitted: 2014-12-17
In about 70% of the population of relaxed, cool-core galaxy clusters, the
brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) is radio loud, showing non-thermal radio jets
and lobes ejected by the central active galactic nucleus (AGN). In recent years
such relativistic plasma has been unambiguously shown to interact with the
surrounding thermal intra-cluster medium (ICM) thanks to spectacular images
where the lobe radio emission is observed to fill the cavities in the
X-ray-emitting gas. This `radio feedback' phenomenon is widespread and is
critical to understand the physics of the inner regions of galaxy clusters and
the properties of the central BCG. At the same time, mechanically-powerful AGN
are likely to drive turbulence in the central ICM which may also play a role
for the origin of non-thermal emission on cluster-scales. Diffuse non-thermal
emission has been observed in a number of cool-core clusters in the form of a
radio mini-halo surrounding the radio-loud BCG on scales comparable to that of
the cooling region. Large mini-halo samples are necessary to establish their
origin and connection with the cluster thermal properties and dynamics,
especially in light of future X-ray characterization of the cluster cores as it
is expected by Athena-XIFU. We show that All-Sky reference survey at Band 2
with SKA1 at confusion limit (rms ~2 {\mu}Jy per beam) has the potential to
detect up to ~620 mini-halos at redshift z<0.6, whereas Deep Tier reference
surveys at Band 1/2 with SKA1 at sub-arcsec resolution (rms ~0.2 {\mu}Jy per
beam) will allow a complete census of the radio-loud BCGs at any redshift down
to a 1.4 GHz power of 10^{22} W/Hz. We further anticipate that SKA2 might
detect up to ~1900 new mini-halos at redshift z<0.6 and characterize the
radio-mode AGN feedback in every cluster and group up to redshift z ~1.7 (the
highest-z where virialized clusters are currently detected).
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.3647 [pdf] - 1209546
A Non-thermal Study of the Brightest Cluster Galaxy NGC 1275 - The
Gamma-Radio Connection Over Four Decades
Submitted: 2014-05-14
Emission from the active nucleus in the core of the brightest cluster galaxy
of the Perseus cluster, NGC 1275, has varied dramatically over the past four
decades. Prompted by the Fermi detection of flaring in the gamma-ray band, we
present the recent increased activity of this source in the context of its past
radio and gamma-ray output. The broad correspondence between the high-frequency
radio data and the high-energy (HE) emission is striking. However, on short
timescales this correlation breaks down and the 1.3 mm Submillimeter Array flux
is apparently unaffected during Fermi-detected flaring activity. The fact that
NGC 1275 is also detected at TeV energies during the periods of HE gamma-ray
flaring suggests that the short-timescale variation might be primarily related
to changes in the inverse Compton scattering of photons by the electron
population in the jet. The longer-timescale changes suggest a 30--40 year
variation in the fuelling of the black hole, that affects the power of the
inner jet. NCG 1275 is a laboratory for the class of brightest cluster
galaxies, and its variability on these timescales has implications for our
understanding of massive galaxies in cooling-core clusters. The case of NGC
1275 highlights the need for wide coverage across the radio band to correctly
account for the contribution to emission from a synchrotron self-absorbed core
(for example when considering contamination of Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect
observations), and the danger of variability biases in radio surveys of
galaxies.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.0867 [pdf] - 1180469
The State of the Warm and Cold Gas in the Extreme Starburst at the Core
of the Phoenix Galaxy Cluster (SPT-CLJ2344-4243)
McDonald, Michael;
Swinbank, A. M.;
Edge, Alastair C.;
Wilner, David J.;
Veilleux, Sylvain;
Benson, Bradford A.;
Hogan, Michael T.;
Marrone, Daniel P.;
McNamara, Brian R.;
Wei, Lisa H.;
Bayliss, Matthew B.;
Bautz, Marshall W.
Submitted: 2013-11-04, last modified: 2014-02-20
[Abridged] We present new optical integral field spectroscopy (Gemini South)
and submillimeter spectroscopy (Submillimeter Array) of the central galaxy in
the Phoenix cluster (SPT-CLJ2344-4243). This cluster was previously reported to
have a massive starburst (~800 Msun/yr) in the central, brightest cluster
galaxy, most likely fueled by the rapidly-cooling intracluster medium. These
new data reveal a complex emission-line nebula, extending for >30 kpc from the
central galaxy. The total Halpha luminosity, assuming Halpha/Hbeta = 2.85, is
L_Ha = 7.6 +/- 0.4 x10^43 erg/s, making this the most luminous emission line
nebula detected in the center of a cool core cluster. Overall, the relative
fluxes of the low-ionization lines (e.g., [O II], Hbeta) to the UV continuum
are consistent with photoionization by young stars. In both the center of the
galaxy and in a newly-discovered highly-ionized plume to the north of the
galaxy, the ionization ratios are consistent with both shocks and AGN
photoionization. We speculate that this extended plume may be a galactic wind,
driven and partially photoionized by both the starburst and central AGN. We
find evidence for shocks throughout the ISM of the central galaxy, most likely
driven by a combination of stellar winds from massive young stars,
core-collapse supernovae, and the central AGN. In addition to the warm, ionized
gas, we detect a substantial amount of cold, molecular gas via the CO(3-2)
transition, coincident in position with the galaxy center. We infer a molecular
gas mass of M_H2 = 2.2 +/- 0.6 x10^10 Msun, which implies that the starburst
will consume its fuel in ~30 Myr if it is not replenished. The combination of
the high level of turbulence in the warm phase and the high L_IR/M_H2 ratio
suggests that this violent starburst may be in the process of quenching itself.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.6344 [pdf] - 1158085
A Stacked Analysis of Brightest Cluster Galaxies Observed with the Fermi
Large Area Telescope
Submitted: 2012-11-27
We present the results of a search for high-energy gamma-ray emission from a
large sample of galaxy clusters sharing the properties of three existing
Fermi-LAT detections (in Perseus, Virgo and Abell 3392), namely a powerful
radio source within their brightest cluster galaxy (BCG). From a parent, X-ray
flux-limited sample of clusters, we select 114 systems with a core-dominated
BCG radio flux above 50 or 75 mJy, stacking data from the first 45 months of
the Fermi mission, to determine statistical limits on the gamma-ray fluxes of
the ensemble of candidate sources. For a >300 MeV selection, the distribution
of detection significance across the sample is consistent with that across
control samples for significances <3 sigma, but has a tail extending to higher
values, including three >4 sigma signals which are not associated with
previously identified gamma-ray emission. Modelling of the data in these fields
results in the detection of four non-2FGL Fermi sources, though none appear to
be unambiguously associated with the BCG candidate. A search at energies >3 GeV
hints at emission from the BCG in A 2055, which hosts a BL Lac object. There is
no evidence for a signal in the stacked data, and the upper limit derived on
the gamma-ray flux of an average radio-bright BCG in the sample is an
order-of-magnitude more constraining than that calculated for individual
objects. F(1 GeV)/F(1.4 GHz) <15, compared with ~120 for NGC 1275 in Perseus,
which might indicate a special case for those objects detected at high
energies; that beamed emission from member galaxies comprise the dominant
bright gamma-ray sources in clusters.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.5604 [pdf] - 1158006
Radiative efficiency, variability and Bondi accretion onto massive black
holes: from mechanical to quasar feedback in brightest cluster galaxies
Submitted: 2012-11-23
We examine unresolved nuclear X-ray sources in 57 brightest cluster galaxies
to study the relationship between nuclear X-ray emission and accretion onto
supermassive black holes (SMBHs). The majority of the clusters in our sample
have prominent X-ray cavities embedded in the surrounding hot atmospheres,
which we use to estimate mean jet power and average accretion rate onto the
SMBHs over the past several hundred Myr. We find that ~50% of the sample have
detectable nuclear X-ray emission. The nuclear X-ray luminosity is correlated
with average accretion rate determined using X-ray cavities, which is
consistent with the hypothesis that nuclear X-ray emission traces ongoing
accretion. The results imply that jets in systems that have experienced recent
AGN outbursts, in the last ~10^7yr, are `on' at least half of the time. Nuclear
X-ray sources become more luminous with respect to the mechanical jet power as
the mean accretion rate rises. We show that nuclear radiation exceeds the jet
power when the mean accretion rate rises above a few percent of the Eddington
rate, where the AGN apparently transitions to a quasar. The nuclear X-ray
emission from three objects (A2052, Hydra A, M84) varies by factors of 2-10 on
timescales of 6 months to 10 years. If variability at this level is a common
phenomenon, it can account for much of the scatter in the relationship between
mean accretion rate and nuclear X-ray luminosity. We find no significant change
in the spectral energy distribution as a function of luminosity in the variable
objects. The relationship between accretion and nuclear X-ray luminosity is
consistent with emission from either a jet, an ADAF, or a combination of the
two, although other origins are possible. We also consider the longstanding
problem of whether jets are powered by the accretion of cold circumnuclear gas
or nearly spherical inflows of hot keV gas.[abridged]
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.6206 [pdf] - 1123714
A search of CO emission lines in blazars: the low molecular gas content
of BL Lac objects compared to quasars
Submitted: 2012-05-28
BL Lacertae (Lac) objects that are detected at very-high energies (VHE) are
of fundamental importance to study multiple astrophysical processes, including
the physics of jets, the properties of the extragalactic background light and
the strength of the intergalactic magnetic field. Unfortunately, since most
blazars have featureless optical spectra that preclude a redshift
determination, a substantial fraction of these VHE extragalactic sources cannot
be used for cosmological studies. To assess whether molecular lines are a
viable way to establish distances, we have undertaken a pilot program at the
IRAM 30m telescope to search for CO lines in three BL Lac objects with known
redshifts. We report a positive detection of M_H2 ~ 3x10^8 Msun toward 1ES
1959+650, but due to the poor quality of the baseline, this value is affected
by a large systematic uncertainty. For the remaining two sources, W Comae and
RGB J0710+591, we derive 3sigma upper limits at, respectively, M_H2 < 8.0x10^8
Msun and M_H2 < 1.6x10^9 Msun, assuming a line width of 150 km/s and a standard
conversion factor alpha=4 M_sun/(K km/s pc^2). If these low molecular gas
masses are typical for blazars, blind redshift searches in molecular lines are
currently unfeasible. However, deep observations are still a promising way to
obtain precise redshifts for sources whose approximate distances are known via
indirect methods. Our observations further reveal a deficiency of molecular gas
in BL Lac objects compared to quasars, suggesting that the host galaxies of
these two types of active galactic nuclei (AGN) are not drawn from the same
parent population. Future observations are needed to assess whether this
discrepancy is statistically significant, but our pilot program shows how
studies of the interstellar medium in AGN can provide key information to
explore the connection between the active nuclei and the host galaxies.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.5759 [pdf] - 1118279
On the hunt for ultramassive black holes in brightest cluster galaxies
Submitted: 2012-04-25, last modified: 2012-05-22
We investigate where brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) sit on the fundamental
plane of black hole (BH) activity, an established relation between the X-ray
luminosity, the radio luminosity and the mass of a BH. Our sample mostly
consists of BCGs that lie at the centres of massive, strong cooling flow
clusters, therefore requiring extreme mechanical feedback from their central
active galactic nucleus (AGN) to offset cooling of the intracluster plasma
(L_mech>10^44-45 erg/s). Based on the BH masses derived from the M_BH-sigma and
M_BH-M_K correlations, we find that all of our objects are offset from the
plane such that they appear to be less massive than predicted from their X-ray
and radio luminosities (to more than a 99 per cent confidence level). For these
objects to be consistent with the fundamental plane, the M_BH-sigma and
M_BH-M_K correlations therefore seem to underestimate the BH masses of BCGs, on
average by a factor of 10. Our results suggest that the standard relationships
between BH mass and host galaxy properties no longer hold for these extreme
galaxies. Furthermore, our results imply that if these BHs follow the
fundamental plane, then many of those that lie in massive, strong cool core
clusters must be ultramassive with M_BH>10^10M_sun. This rivals the largest BH
masses known and has important ramifications for our understanding of the
formation and evolution of BHs.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.0489 [pdf] - 1084598
Extreme AGN feedback in the Massive Cluster Survey (MACS): a detailed
study of X-ray cavities at z > 0.3
Submitted: 2011-10-03, last modified: 2011-12-17
We present the first statistical study of X-ray cavities in distant clusters
of galaxies (z > 0.3). With the aim of providing further insight into how AGN
feedback operates at higher redshift, we have analysed the Chandra X-ray
observations of the Massive Cluster Survey (MACS) and searched for
surface-brightness depressions associated with the Brightest Cluster Galaxy
(BCG). The MACS sample consists of the most X-ray luminous clusters within 0.3
< z < 0.7 (median L_(X,RASS) = 7*10^44 erg/s), and out of 76 clusters, we find
13 with "clear" cavities and 7 with "potential" cavities (detection rate ~25
per cent). Most of the clusters in which we find cavities have a short central
cooling time below 3 - 5 Gyrs, consistent with the idea that cavities sit
predominantly in cool core clusters. We also find no evidence for evolution in
any of the cavity properties with redshift, up to z~0.6. The cavities of
powerful outbursts are not larger (or smaller) at higher redshift, and are not
able to rise to further (or lesser) distances from the nucleus. The energetics
of these outbursts also remain the same. This suggests that extreme "radio
mode" feedback (L_(mech) > 10^44 erg/s) starts to operate as early as 7 - 8
Gyrs after the Big Bang and shows no sign of evolution since then. In other
words, AGNs lying at the centre of clusters are able to operate at early times
with extreme mechanical powers, and have been operating in such a way for at
least the past 5 Gyrs.