Normalized to: Hippke, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.02123 [pdf] - 2107405
Transit least-squares survey -- III. A $1.9\,R_\oplus$ transit candidate
in the habitable zone of Kepler-160 and a nontransiting planet characterized
by transit-timing variations
Submitted: 2020-06-03
The Sun-like star Kepler-160 (KOI-456) has been known to host two transiting
planets, Kepler-160 b and c, of which planet c shows substantial transit-timing
variations (TTVs). We used the archival Kepler photometry of Kepler-160 to
search for additional transiting planets using a combination of our Wotan
detrending algorithm and our transit least-squares (TLS) detection algorithm.
We also used the Mercury N-body gravity code to study the orbital dynamics of
the system. First, we recovered the known transit series of planets Kepler-160
b and c. Then we found a new transiting candidate with a radius of 1.91 (+0.17,
-0.14) Earth radii (R_ear), an orbital period of 378.417 (+0.028, -0.025) d,
and Earth-like insolation. The vespa software predicts that this signal has an
astrophysical false-positive probability of FPP_3 = 1.8e-3 when the
multiplicity of the system is taken into account. Kepler vetting diagnostics
yield a multiple event statistic of MES = 10.7, which corresponds to an ~85 %
reliability against false alarms due to instrumental artifacts such as rolling
bands. We are also able to explain the observed TTVs of planet c with the
presence of a previously unknown planet. The period and mass of this new
planet, however, do not match the period and mass of the new transit candidate.
Our Markov chain Monte Carlo simulations of the TTVs of Kepler-160 c can be
conclusively explained by a new nontransiting planet with a mass between about
1 and 100 Earth masses and an orbital period between about 7 and 50 d. We
conclude that Kepler-160 has at least three planets, one of which is the
nontransiting planet Kepler-160 d. The expected stellar radial velocity
amplitude caused by this new planet ranges between about 1 and 20 m/s. We also
find the super-Earth-sized transiting planet candidate KOI-456.04 in the
habitable zone of this system, which could be the fourth planet.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.02616 [pdf] - 2050284
Interstellar communication network. I. Overview and assumptions
Submitted: 2019-12-02, last modified: 2020-02-13
It has recently been suggested in this journal by Benford (2019) that
"Lurkers" in the form of interstellar exploration probes could be present in
the solar system. Similarly, extraterrestrial intelligence could send
long-lived probes to many other stellar systems, to report back science and
surveillance. If probes and planets with technological species exist in more
than a handful of systems in our galaxy, it is beneficial to use a coordinated
communication scheme. Due to the inverse square law, data rates decrease
strongly for direct connections over long distances. The network bandwidth
could be increased by orders of magnitude if repeater stations (nodes) are used
in an optimized fashion. This introduction to a series of papers makes the
assumptions of the communication scheme explicit. Subsequent papers will
discuss technical aspects such as transmitters, repeaters, wavelengths, and
power levels. The overall purpose is to gain insight into the physical
characteristics of an interstellar communication network, allowing us to
describe the most likely sizes and locations of nodes and probes.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.00966 [pdf] - 1971259
Wotan: Comprehensive time-series de-trending in Python
Submitted: 2019-06-03, last modified: 2019-08-07
The detection of transiting exoplanets in time-series photometry requires the
removal or modeling of instrumental and stellar noise. While instrumental
systematics can be reduced using methods such as pixel level decorrelation,
removing stellar trends while preserving transit signals proves challenging.
Due to vast archives of light curves from recent transit surveys, there is a
strong need for accurate automatic detrending, without human intervention. A
large variety of detrending algorithms are in active use, but their comparative
performance for transit discovery is unexplored. We benchmark all commonly used
detrending methods against hundreds of Kepler, K2, and TESS planets, selected
to represent the most difficult cases for systems with small planet-to-star
radius ratios. The full parameter range is explored for each method to
determine the best choices for planet discovery. We conclude that the ideal
method is a time-windowed slider with an iterative robust location estimator
based on Tukey's biweight. This method recovers 99% and 94% of the shallowest
Kepler and K2 planets, respectively. We include an additional analysis for
young stars with extreme variability and conclude they are best treated using a
spline-based method with a robust Huber estimator. All stellar detrending
methods explored are available for public use in wotan, an open-source Python
package on GitHub (see https://github.com/hippke/wotan).
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.09038 [pdf] - 1915201
Transit least-squares survey -- II. Discovery and validation of 17 new
sub- to super-Earth-sized planets in multi-planet systems from K2
Submitted: 2019-05-22, last modified: 2019-07-12
The extended Kepler mission (K2) has revealed more than 500 transiting
planets in roughly 500,000 stellar light curves. All of these were found either
with the box least-squares algorithm or by visual inspection. Here we use our
new transit least-squares (TLS) algorithm to search for additional planets
around all K2 stars that are currently known to host at least one planet. We
discover and statistically validate 17 new planets with radii ranging from
about 0.7 Earth radii to roughly 2.2 Earth radii and a median radius of 1.18
Earth radii. EPIC201497682.03, with a radius of 0.692 (-0.048, +0.059) Earth
radii, is the second smallest planet ever discovered with K2. The transit
signatures of these 17 planets are typically 200 ppm deep (ranging from 100 ppm
to 2000 ppm), and their orbital periods extend from about 0.7 d to 34 d with a
median value of about 4 d. Fourteen of these 17 systems only had one known
planet before, and they now join the growing number of multi-planet systems.
Most stars in our sample have subsolar masses and radii. The small planetary
radii in our sample are a direct result of the higher signal detection
efficiency that TLS has compared to box-fitting algorithms in the
shallow-transit regime. Our findings help in populating the period-radius
diagram with small planets. Our discovery rate of about 3.7 % within the group
of previously known K2 systems suggests that TLS can find over 100 additional
Earth-sized planets in the data of the Kepler primary mission.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.00651 [pdf] - 1887880
Transit least-squares survey - I. Discovery and validation of an
Earth-sized planet in the four-planet system K2-32 near the 1:2:5:7 resonance
Submitted: 2019-04-01, last modified: 2019-05-22
We apply, for the first time, the Transit Least Squares (TLS) algorithm to
search for new transiting exoplanets. TLS is a successor to the Box Least
Squares (BLS) algorithm, which has served as a standard tool for the detection
of periodic transits. In this proof-of-concept paper, we demonstrate how TLS
finds small planets that have previously been missed. We showcase TLS'
capabilities using the K2 EVEREST-detrended light curve of the star K2-32
(EPIC205071984) that was known to have three transiting planets. TLS detects
these known Neptune-sized planets K2-32b, d, and c in an iterative search and
finds an additional transit signal with a high signal detection efficiency
(SDE_TLS) of 26.1 at a period of 4.34882 (-0.00075, +0.00069) d. We show that
this signal remains detectable (SDE_TLS = 13.2) with TLS in the K2SFF light
curve of K2-32, which includes a less optimal detrending of the systematic
trends. The signal is below common detection thresholds, however, if searched
with BLS in the K2SFF light curve (SDE_BLS = 8.9) as in previous searches.
Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling shows that the radius of this candidate is
1.01 (-0.09, +0.10) Earth radii. We analyze its phase-folded transit light
curve using the vespa software and calculate a false positive probability FPP =
3.1e-3, formally validating K2-32e as a planet. Taking into account the
multiplicity boost of the system, FPP < 3.1e-4. K2-32 now hosts at least four
planets that are very close to a 1:2:5:7 mean motion resonance chain. The
offset of the orbital periods of K2-32e and b from a 1:2 mean motion resonance
is in very good agreement with the sample of transiting multi-planet systems
from Kepler, lending further credence to the planetary nature of K2-32e. We
expect that TLS can find many more transits of Earth-sized and smaller planets
in the Kepler data that have hitherto remained undetected with BLS and similar
algorithms.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.02015 [pdf] - 1842465
Transit Least Squares: Optimized transit detection algorithm to search
for periodic transits of small planets
Submitted: 2019-01-07, last modified: 2019-01-27
We present a new method to detect planetary transits from time-series
photometry, the Transit Least Squares (TLS) algorithm. TLS searches for
transit-like features while taking the stellar limb darkening and planetary
ingress and egress into account. We have optimized TLS for both signal
detection efficiency (SDE) of small planets and computational speed. TLS
analyses the entire, unbinned phase-folded light curve. We compensate for the
higher computational load by (i.) using algorithms like "Mergesort" (for the
trial orbital phases) and by (ii.) restricting the trial transit durations to a
smaller range that encompasses all known planets, and using stellar density
priors where available. A typical K2 light curve, including 80d of observations
at a cadence of 30min, can be searched with TLS in ~10s real time on a standard
laptop computer, as fast as the widely used Box Least Squares (BLS) algorithm.
We perform a transit injection-retrieval experiment of Earth-sized planets
around sun-like stars using synthetic light curves with 110ppm white noise per
30min cadence, corresponding to a photometrically quiet KP=12 star observed
with Kepler. We determine the SDE thresholds for both BLS and TLS to reach a
false positive rate of 1% to be SDE~7 in both cases. The resulting true
positive (or recovery) rates are ~93% for TLS and ~76% for BLS, implying more
reliable detections with TLS. We also test TLS with the K2 light curve of the
TRAPPIST-1 system and find six of seven Earth-sized planets using an iterative
search for increasingly lower signal detection efficiency, the phase-folded
transit of the seventh planet being affected by a stellar flare. TLS is more
reliable than BLS in finding any kind of transiting planet but it is
particularly suited for the detection of small planets in long time series from
Kepler, TESS, and PLATO. We make our Python implementation of TLS publicly
available.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.07981 [pdf] - 1846888
The PDS 110 observing campaign - photometric and spectroscopic
observations reveal eclipses are aperiodic
Osborn, Hugh P.;
Kenworthy, Matthew;
Rodriguez, Joseph E.;
de Mooij, Ernst J. W.;
Kennedy, Grant M.;
Relles, Howard;
Gomez, Edward;
Hippke, Michael;
Banfi, Massimo;
Barbieri, Lorenzo;
Becker, Igor;
Benni, Paul;
Berlind, Perry;
Bieryla, Allyson;
Bonnoli, Giacomo;
Boussier, Hubert;
Brincat, Stephen;
Briol, John;
Burleigh, Matthew;
Butterley, Tim;
Calkins, Michael L.;
Chote, Paul;
Ciceri, Simona;
Deldem, Marc;
Dhillon, Vik S.;
Dose, Eric;
Dubois, Frank;
Dvorak, Shawn;
Esquerdo, Gilbert A.;
Evans, Daniel;
Berangez, Stephane Ferratfiat Dagot;
Fossey, Stephen;
Güenther, Maximilian N.;
Hall, John;
Hambsch, Josch;
Casas, Enrique Herrero;
Hills, Kevin;
James, Robert;
Kafka, Stella;
Killestein, Thomas L.;
Kotnik, Clifford;
Latham, David W.;
Lemay, Damien;
Lewin, Pablo;
Littlefair, Stuart;
Lopresti, Claudio;
Mallonn, Matthias;
Mancini, Luigi;
Marchini, Alessandro;
McCormac, James J.;
Murawski, Gabriel;
Myers, Gordon;
Papini, Ricardo;
Popov, Velimir;
Quadri, Ulisse;
Quinn, Samuel N.;
Raynard, Liam;
Rizzuti, Luca;
Roa, James;
Robertson, Jeff;
Salvaggio, Fabio;
Scholz, Alexander;
Sfair, Rafael;
Smith, Alexis M. S.;
Southworth, John;
Tan, TG;
Vanaverbeke, Sigfried;
Waagen, Elizabeth O.;
Watson, Christopher;
West, Richard;
Wheatley, P. J.;
Wilson, Richard W.;
Winter, Othon C.;
Zhou, George
Submitted: 2019-01-23
PDS 110 is a young disk-hosting star in the Orion OB1A association. Two
dimming events of similar depth and duration were seen in 2008 (WASP) and 2011
(KELT), consistent with an object in a closed periodic orbit. In this paper we
present data from a ground-based observing campaign designed to measure the
star both photometrically and spectroscopically during the time of predicted
eclipse in September 2017. Despite high-quality photometry, the predicted
eclipse did not occur, although coherent structure is present suggesting
variable amounts of stellar flux or dust obscuration. We also searched for RV
oscillations caused by any hypothetical companion and can rule out close
binaries to 0.1 $M_\odot$. A search of Sonneberg plate archive data also
enabled us to extend the photometric baseline of this star back more than 50
years, and similarly does not re-detect any deep eclipses. Taken together, they
suggest that the eclipses seen in WASP and KELT photometry were due to
aperiodic events. It would seem that PDS 110 undergoes stochastic dimmings that
are shallower and shorter-duration than those of UX Ori variables, but may have
a similar mechanism.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.00523 [pdf] - 1830614
Periodic Spectral Modulations Arise from Non-random Spacing of Spectral
Absorption Lines
Submitted: 2019-01-02
In recent publications, Borra (2013); Borra & Trottier (2016); Borra (2017)
claimed the discovery of ultra-short ($10^{-12}\,$s) optical pulses originating
from stars and galaxies, asserted to be sent by extraterrestrial intelligence.
I show that these signals are not astrophysical or instrumental in nature, but
originate from the non-random spacings of spectral absorption lines. They can
be shown to arise in their clearest form in synthetic solar spectra, as these
do not suffer from noise.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.06084 [pdf] - 1791177
The spectral Petersen diagram as a new tool to map pulsation modes in
variable stars
Submitted: 2018-10-14
Additional pulsation modes have been discovered in many Cepheids, RR Lyrae,
and other variable stars. Fourier transforms are used to find, fit and subtract
the main pulsation period and its harmonics to reveal additional modes.
Commonly, for every star, the strongest of these modes is presented in a
"Petersen diagram", where the shorter-to-longer period ratio is plotted against
the longer period. This diagram discards the information about temporal
variations, multiple pulsation modes, and signals which are below some chosen
signal to noise threshold. I here present a new tool to map pulsation modes in
variable stars, dubbed the "spectral Petersen diagram". It shows all signals,
irrespective of their multiplicity or significance. Many (thousands) of light
curves can be stacked to improve the signal to noise ratio and reveal
unprecedented detail about the pulsation mode space. This tool is useful to
constraint the parameters of variable star models.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.04672 [pdf] - 1747949
Revisiting the exomoon candidate signal around Kepler-1625b
Submitted: 2018-06-12, last modified: 2018-06-26
Transit photometry of the exoplanet candidate Kepler-1625b has recently been
interpreted to show hints of a moon. We aim to clarify whether the exomoon-like
signal is really caused by a large object in orbit around Kepler-1625b. We
explore several detrending procedures, i.e. polynomials and the Cosine
Filtering with Autocorrelation Minimization (CoFiAM). We then supply a light
curve simulator with the co-planar orbital dynamics of the system and fit the
resulting planet-moon transit light curves to the Kepler data. We employ the
Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) to assess whether a single planet or a
planet-moon system is a more likely interpretation of the light curve
variations. We carry out a blind hare-and-hounds exercise using many noise
realizations by injecting simulated transits into different out-of-transit
parts of the original Kepler-1625 data: 100 sequences with 3 synthetic transits
of a Kepler-1625b-like planet and 100 sequences with 3 synthetic transits of
this planet with a Neptune-sized moon. The statistical significance and
characteristics of the exomoon-like signal strongly depend on the detrending
method, and the data chosen for detrending, and on the treatment of gaps in the
light curve. Our injection-retrieval experiment shows evidence for moons in
about 10% of those light curves that do not contain an injected moon.
Strikingly, many of these false-positive moons resemble the exomoon candidate.
We recover up to about half of the injected moons, depending on the detrending
method, with radii and orbital distances broadly corresponding to the injected
values. A $\Delta$BIC of -4.9 for the CoFiAM-based detrending indicates an
exomoon around Kepler-1625b. This solution, however, is only one out of many
and we find very different solutions depending on the details of the detrending
method. It is worrying that the detrending is key to the interpretation of the
data.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1712.10262 [pdf] - 1685688
Interstellar communication. VII. Benchmarking inscribed matter probes
Submitted: 2017-12-29, last modified: 2018-05-18
We have explored the optimal frequency of interstellar photon communications
and benchmarked other particles as information carriers in previous papers of
this series. We now compare the latency and bandwidth of sending probes with
inscribed matter. Durability requirements such as shields against dust and
radiation, as well as data duplication, add negligible weight overhead at
velocities <0.2c. Probes may arrive in full, while most of a photon beam is
lost to diffraction. Probes can be more energy efficient per bit, and can have
higher bandwidth, compared to classical communication, unless a photon receiver
is placed in a stellar gravitational lens. The probe's advantage dominates by
order of magnitude for long distances (kpc) and low velocities (<0.1c) at the
cost of higher latency.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.04727 [pdf] - 1942046
Spaceflight from Super-Earths is difficult
Submitted: 2018-04-12, last modified: 2018-05-18
Many rocky exoplanets are heavier and larger than the Earth, and have higher
surface gravity. This makes space-flight on these worlds very challenging,
because the required fuel mass for a given payload is an exponential function
of planetary surface gravity. We find that chemical rockets still allow for
escape velocities on Super-Earths up to 10x Earth mass. More massive rocky
worlds, if they exist, would require other means to leave the planet, such as
nuclear propulsion.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.07962 [pdf] - 1685651
Interstellar communication. IV. Benchmarking information carriers
Submitted: 2017-11-21, last modified: 2018-05-18
The search for extraterrestrial communication has mainly focused on microwave
photons since the 1950s. We compare other high speed information carriers to
photons, such as electrons, protons, and neutrinos, gravitational waves,
inscribed matter, and artificial megastructures such as occulters. The
performance card includes the speed of exchange, information per energy and
machine sizes, lensing performance, cost, and complexity. In fast
point-to-point communications, photons are superior to other carriers by orders
of magnitude. Sending probes with inscribed matter requires less energy, but
has higher latency. For isotropic beacons with low data rates, our current
technological level is insufficient to determine the best choice. We discuss
cases where our initial assumptions do not apply, and describe the required
properties of hypothetical particles to win over photons.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.11384 [pdf] - 1660866
Super-Earths in need for Extremly Big Rockets
Submitted: 2018-03-30, last modified: 2018-04-04
Many rocky exoplanets are heavier and larger than Earth, so-called
"Super-Earths". Some of these may be habitable, and a few may be inhabited by
Super-Earthlings. Due to the higher surface gravity on these worlds,
space-flight is much more challenging. We find that chemical rockets still
allow for escape velocities on Super-Earths up to 10x Earth mass. Much heavier
rocky worlds, if they exist, will require using up most of the planet as
chemical fuel for the (one) launch, a rather risky undertaking. We also briefly
discuss launching rockets from water worlds, which requires Alien
megastructures.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.01251 [pdf] - 1795691
Interstellar communication. XI. Short pulse duration limits of optical
SETI
Submitted: 2018-04-04
Previous and ongoing searches for extraterrestrial optical and infrared
nanosecond laser pulses and narrow line-width continuous emissions have so far
returned null results. At the commonly used observation cadence of $\sim
10^{-9}\,$s, sky-integrated starlight is a relevant noise source for large
field-of-view surveys. This can be reduced with narrow bandwidth filters,
multipixel detectors, or a shorter observation cadence. We examine the limits
of short pulses set by the uncertainty principle, interstellar scattering,
atmospheric scintillation, refraction, dispersion and receiver technology. We
find that optimal laser pulses are time-bandwidth limited Gaussians with a
duration of $\Delta t \approx\,10^{-12}\,$s at a wavelength
$\lambda_{0}\approx1\,\mu$m, and a spectral width of $\Delta \lambda \approx
1.5\,$nm. Shorter pulses are too strongly affected through Earth's atmosphere.
Given certain technological advances, survey speed can be increased by three
orders of magnitude when moving from ns to ps pulses. Faster (and/or parallel)
signal processing would allow for an all-sky-at-once survey of lasers targeted
at Earth.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.01249 [pdf] - 1795690
Interstellar communication. X. The colors of optical SETI
Submitted: 2018-04-04
It has recently been argued from a laser engineering point of view that there
are only a few magic colors for optical SETI. These are primarily the Nd:YAG
line at 1064 nm and its second harmonic 532.1 nm. Next best choices would be
the sum frequency and/or second harmonic generation of Nd:YAG and Nd:YLF laser
lines, 393.8 nm (near Fraunhofer CaK), 656.5 nm (H$\alpha$) and 589.1 nm
(NaD2). In this paper, we examine the interstellar extinction, atmospheric
transparency and scintillation, as well as noise conditions for these laser
lines. For strong signals, we find that optical wavelengths are optimal for
distances $d\lesssim\,$kpc. Nd:YAG at $\lambda=1{,}064\,$nm is a similarly good
choice, within a factor of two, under most conditions and out to
$d\lesssim3\,$kpc. For weaker transmitters, where the signal-to-noise ratio
with respect to the blended host star is relevant, the optimal wavelength
depends on the background source, such as the stellar type. Fraunhofer spectral
lines, while providing lower stellar background noise, are irrelevant in most
use cases, as they are overpowered by other factors. Laser-pushed spaceflight
concepts, such as "Breakthrough Starshot", would produce brighter and tighter
beams than ever assumed for OSETI. Such beamers would appear as naked eye stars
out to kpc distances. If laser physics has already matured and converged on the
most efficient technology, the laser line of choice for a given scenario (e.g.,
Nd:YAG for strong signals) can be observed with a narrow filter to dramatically
reduce background noise, allowing for large field-of-view observations in fast
surveys.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.02180 [pdf] - 1631510
Interstellar communication. IX. Message decontamination is impossible
Submitted: 2018-02-06
A complex message from space may require the use of computers to display,
analyze and understand. Such a message cannot be decontaminated with certainty,
and technical risks remain which can pose an existential threat. Complex
messages would need to be destroyed in the risk averse case.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.05000 [pdf] - 1637543
The year-long flux variations in Boyajian's star are asymmetric or
aperiodic
Submitted: 2017-10-13, last modified: 2018-01-30
We combine and calibrate publicly available data for Boyajian's star
including photometry from ASAS (SN, V, I), Kepler, Gaia, SuperWASP, and citizen
scientist observations (AAVSO, HAO and Burke-Gaffney). Precise (mmag)
photometry covers the years 2006-2017. We show that the year-long flux
variations with an amplitude of ~4% can not be explained with cyclical
symmetric or asymmetric models with periods shorter than ten years. If the dips
are transits, their period must exceed ten years, or their structure must
evolve significantly during each 4-year long cycle.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.06218 [pdf] - 1620788
Interstellar Communication. VIII. Hard limits on the number of bits per
photon
Submitted: 2018-01-18
A photon can encode several bits of information based on an alphabet of its
time of arrival, energy, and polarization. Heisenberg's uncertainty principle
places a limit on measuring pairs of physical properties of a particle,
limiting the maximal information efficiency to <59 bits per photon in practice,
and <171 bits per photon at Planck energy, at a data rate of one photon per
second.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1712.06639 [pdf] - 1605413
Interstellar communication. VI. Searching X-ray spectra for narrowband
communication
Submitted: 2017-12-18
We have previously argued that targeted interstellar communication has a
physical optimum at narrowband X-ray wavelengths $\lambda\approx1\,$nm, limited
by the surface roughness of focusing devices at the atomic level
(arXiv:1711.05761). We search 24,247 archival X-ray spectra (of 6,454 unique
objects) for such features and present 19 sources with monochromatic signals.
Close examination reveals that these are most likely of natural origin. The
ratio of artificial to natural sources must be <0.01%. This first limit can be
improved in future X-ray surveys.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1712.05682 [pdf] - 1605285
Interstellar communication. V. Introduction to photon information
efficiency (in bits per photon)
Submitted: 2017-12-14
How many bits of information can a single photon carry? Intuition says "one",
but this is incorrect. With an alphabet based on the photon's time of arrival,
energy, and polarization, several bits can be encoded. In this introduction to
photon information efficiency, we explain how to calculate the maximum number
of bits per photon depending on the number of encoding modes, noise, and
losses.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.03795 [pdf] - 1584579
Interstellar communication. I. Maximized data rate for lightweight
space-probes
Submitted: 2017-06-12, last modified: 2017-11-15
Recent technological advances could make interstellar travel possible, using
ultra-lightweight sails pushed by lasers or solar photon pressure, at speeds of
a few percent the speed of light. Obtaining remote observational data from such
probes is not trivial because of their minimal instrumentation (gram scale) and
large distances (pc). We derive the optimal communication scheme to maximize
the data rate between a remote probe and home-base. he framework requires
coronagraphic suppression of the stellar background at the level of $10^{-9}$
within a few tenths of an arcsecond of the bright star. Our work includes
models for the loss of photons from diffraction, technological limitations,
interstellar extinction, and atmospheric transmission. Major noise sources are
atmospheric, zodiacal, stellar and instrumental. We examine the maximum
capacity using the "Holevo bound" which gives an upper limit to the amount of
information (bits) that can be encoded through a quantum state (photons), which
is a few bits per photon for optimistic signal and noise levels. This allows
for data rates of order bits per second per Watt from a transmitter of size 1 m
at a distance of $\alpha\,$Centauri (1.3 pc) to an earth-based large receiving
telescope (E-ELT, 39 m). The optimal wavelength for this distance is 300 nm
(space-based receiver) to 400 nm (earth-based) and increases with distance, due
to extinction, to a maximum of $\approx3\,\mu$m to the center of the galaxy at
8 kpc.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.05761 [pdf] - 1591286
Interstellar communication. III. Optimal frequency to maximize data rate
Submitted: 2017-11-15
The optimal frequency for interstellar communication, using "Earth 2017"
technology, was derived in papers I and II of this series (arXiv:1706.03795,
arXiv:1706.05570). The framework included models for the loss of photons from
diffraction (free space), interstellar extinction, and atmospheric
transmission. A major limit of current technology is the focusing of
wavelengths $\lambda<300\,$nm (UV). When this technological constraint is
dropped, a physical bound is found at $\lambda\approx1\,$nm ($E\approx\,$keV)
for distances out to kpc. While shorter wavelengths may produce tighter beams
and thus higher data rates, the physical limit comes from surface roughness of
focusing devices at the atomic level. This limit can be surpassed by
beam-forming with electromagnetic fields, e.g. using a free electron laser, but
such methods are not energetically competitive. Current lasers are not yet cost
efficient at nm wavelengths, with a gap of two orders of magnitude, but future
technological progress may converge on the physical optimum. We recommend
expanding SETI efforts towards targeted (at us) monochromatic (or narrow band)
X-ray emission at 0.5-2 keV energies.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.05856 [pdf] - 1608648
Photogravimagnetic assists of light sails: a mixed blessing for
Breakthrough Starshot?
Submitted: 2017-10-30
Upon entering a star system, light sails are subject to both gravitational
forces and radiation pressure, and can use both in concert to modify their
trajectory. Moreover, stars possess significant magnetic fields, and if the
sail is in any way charged, it will feel the Lorentz force also.
We investigate the dynamics of so-called "photogravimagnetic assists" of
sailcraft around $\alpha$ Centauri A, a potential first destination en route to
Proxima Centauri (the goal of the Breakthrough Starshot program). We find that
a 10m$^2$ sail with a charge-to-mass-ratio of around 10 $\mu$C/g or higher will
need to take account of magnetic field effects during orbital maneouvres. The
magnetic field can provide an extra source of deceleration and deflection, and
allow capture onto closer orbits around a target star.
However, flipping the sign of the sailcraft's charge can radically change
resulting trajectories, resulting in complex loop-de-loops around magnetic
field lines and essentially random ejection from the star system. Even on
well-behaved trajectories, the field can generate off-axis deflections at
$\alpha$ Centauri that, while minor, can result in very poor targetting of the
final destination (Proxima) post-assist.
Fortunately for Breakthrough Starshot, nanosails are less prone to charging
en route than their heavier counterparts, but can still accrue relatively high
charge at both the origin and destination, when travelling at low speeds.
Photogravimagnetic assists are highly non-trivial, and require careful course
correction to mitigate against unwanted changes in trajectory.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.05570 [pdf] - 1584831
Interstellar communication. II. Application to the solar gravitational
lens
Submitted: 2017-06-17, last modified: 2017-10-18
We have shown in paper I of this series (arXiv:1706.03795) that interstellar
communication to nearby (pc) stars is possible at data rates of bits per second
per Watt between a 1 m sized probe and a large receiving telescope (E-ELT, 39
m), when optimizing all parameters such as frequency at 300-400 nm. We now
apply our framework of interstellar extinction and quantum state calculations
for photon encoding to the solar gravitational lens (SGL), which enlarges the
aperture (and thus the photon flux) of the receiving telescope by a factor of
$>10^9$. For the first time, we show that the use of the SGL for communication
purposes is possible. This was previously unclear because the Einstein ring is
placed inside the solar coronal noise, and contributing factors are difficult
to determine. We calculate point-spread functions, aperture sizes, heliocentric
distance, and optimum communication frequency. The best wavelength for nearby
(<100 pc) interstellar communication is limited by current technology to the UV
and optical band. To suppress coronal noise, an advanced coronograph is
required, alternatively an occulter could be used which would require a second
spacecraft in formation flight 78 km from the receiver, and ~10 m in size. Data
rates scale approximately linear with the SGL telescope size and with
heliocentric distance. Achievable (receiving) data rates from Alpha Cen are
1-10 Mbits per second per Watt for a pair of meter-sized telescopes, an
improvement of $10^6$ compared to using the same receiving telescope without
the SGL. A 1 m telescope in the SGL can receive data at rates comparable to a
km-class "normal" telescope.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.03871 [pdf] - 1582528
Optimized trajectories to the nearest stars using lightweight
high-velocity photon sails
Submitted: 2017-04-11, last modified: 2017-08-30
New means of interstellar travel are now being considered by various research
teams, assuming lightweight spaceships to be accelerated via either laser or
solar radiation to a significant fraction of the speed of light (c). We
recently showed that gravitational assists can be combined with the stellar
photon pressure to decelerate an incoming lightsail from Earth and fling it
around a star or bring it to rest. Here, we demonstrate that photogravitational
assists are more effective when the star is used as a bumper (i.e. the sail
passes "in front of" the star) rather than as a catapult (i.e. the sail passes
"behind" or "around" the star). This increases the maximum deceleration at
$\alpha$ Cen A and B and reduces the travel time of a nominal graphene-class
sail (mass-to-surface ratio 8.6e-4 gram m$^{-2}$) from 95 to 75 yr. The maximum
possible velocity reduction upon arrival depends on the required deflection
angle from $\alpha$ Cen A to B and therefore on the binary's orbital phase.
Here, we calculate the variation of the minimum travel times from Earth into a
bound orbit around Proxima for the next 300 yr and then extend our calculations
to roughly 22,000 stars within about 300 ly. Although $\alpha$ Cen is the most
nearby star system, we find that Sirius A offers the shortest possible travel
times into a bound orbit: 69 yr assuming 12.5% c can be obtained at departure
from the solar system. Sirius A thus offers the opportunity of flyby
exploration plus deceleration into a bound orbit of the companion white dwarf
after relatively short times of interstellar travel.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.03985 [pdf] - 1579934
Dippers and Dusty Disks Edges: A Unified Model
Submitted: 2016-05-12, last modified: 2017-02-21
We revisit the nature of large dips in flux from extinction by dusty
circumstellar material that is observed by Kepler for many young stars in the
Upper Sco and $\rho$ Oph star formation regions. These young, low-mass "dipper"
stars are known to have low accretion rates and primarily host moderately
evolved dusty circumstellar disks. Young low mass stars often exhibit rotating
star spots that cause quasi-periodic photometric variations. We found no
evidence for periods associated with the dips that are different from the star
spot rotation period in spectrograms constructed from the light curves. The
material causing the dips in most of these light curves must be approximately
corotating with the star. We find that disk temperatures computed at the disk
corotation radius are cool enough that dust should not sublime. Crude estimates
for stellar magnetic field strengths and accretion rates are consistent with
magnetospheric truncation near the corotation radius. Magnetospheric truncation
models can explain why the dips are associated with material near corotation
and how dusty material is lifted out of the midplane to obscure the star which
would account for the large fraction of young low mass stars that are dippers.
We propose that variations in disk orientation angle, stellar magnetic field
dipole tilt axis, and disk accretion rate are underlying parameters accounting
for differences in the dipper light curves.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.09290 [pdf] - 1542737
Sonneberg plate photometry for Boyajian's Star in two passbands
Hippke, Michael;
Kroll, Peter;
Matthei, Frank;
Angerhausen, Daniel;
Tuvikene, Taavi;
Stassun, Keivan G.;
Roshchina, Elena;
Vasileva, Tatyana;
Izmailov, Igor;
Samus, Nikolay N.;
Pastukhova, Elena N.;
Bryukhanov, Ivan;
Lund, Michael B.
Submitted: 2016-09-29, last modified: 2017-02-14
The F3 main sequence star KIC 8462852 (Boyajian's Star) showed deep (up to
20%) day-long brightness dips of unknown cause during the 4 years of the Kepler
mission. A 0.164 mag (16%) dimming between 1890 and 1990 was claimed, based on
the analysis of photographic plates from the Harvard Observatory. We have
gathered an independent set of historic plates from Sonneberg Observatory,
Germany, covering the years 1934-1995. With 861 magnitudes in B, and 397
magnitudes in V, we find the star to be of constant brightness within 0.03 mag
per century (3%). Consistent outcomes are found using by-eye estimates of the
best 119 plates. Results are supported by data from Sternberg Observatory,
Moscow, which show the star as constant between 1895 and 1995. The previously
claimed century-long dimming is inconsistent with our results at the 5-sigma
level, however the recently reported modest dimming of 3% in the Kepler data is
not inconsistent with our data. We find no periodicities or shorter trends
within our limits of 5% per 5-year bin, but note a possible dimming event on 24
Oct 1978.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.08803 [pdf] - 1535190
Deceleration of high-velocity interstellar photon sails into bound
orbits at $\alpha$ Centauri
Submitted: 2017-01-30
At a distance of about 4.22 lightyears, it would take about 100,000 years for
humans to visit our closest stellar neighbor Proxima Centauri using modern
chemical thrusters. New technologies are now being developed that involve
high-power lasers firing at 1 gram solar sails in near-Earth orbits,
accelerating them to 20% the speed of light (c) within minutes. Although such
an interstellar probe could reach Proxima 20 years after launch, without
propellant to slow it down it would traverse the system within hours. Here we
demonstrate how the stellar photon pressures of the stellar triple $\alpha$ Cen
A, B, and C (Proxima) can be used together with gravity assists to decelerate
incoming solar sails from Earth. The maximum injection speed at $\alpha$ Cen A
to park a sail with a mass-to-surface ratio ($\sigma$) similar to graphene
(7.6e-4 gram/m$^{-2}$) in orbit around Proxima is about 13,800 km/s (4.6% c),
implying travel times from Earth to $\alpha$ Cen A and B of about 95 years and
another 46 years (with a residual velocity of 1280 km/s) to Proxima. The size
of such a low-$\sigma$ sail required to carry a payload of 10 grams is about
10$^5$ m$^2$ = (316 m)$^2$. Such a sail could use solar photons instead of an
expensive laser system to gain interstellar velocities at departure.
Photogravitational assists allow visits of three stellar systems and an
Earth-sized potentially habitable planet in one shot, promising extremely high
scientific yields.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.05492 [pdf] - 1482529
A first view with GAIA on KIC 8462852 - distance estimates and a
comparison to other F stars
Submitted: 2016-09-18
Distance estimates from Gaia parallax and expected luminosities are compared
for KIC 8462852. Gaia DR1 yields a parallax of $2.55\pm0.31$mas, that is a
distance of $391.4\substack{+53.6 \\ -42.0}$pc, or $391.4\substack{+122.1 \\
-75.2}$pc including systematic uncertainty. The distance estimate based on the
absolute magnitude of an F3V star and measured reddening is $\sim454\pm35$pc.
Both estimates agree within $<1\sigma$, which only excludes some of the most
extreme theorized scenarios for KIC 8462852. Future Gaia data releases will
determine the distance to within 1% and thus allow for the determination a
precise absolute luminosity.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.05094 [pdf] - 1526870
Predictable patterns in planetary transit timing variations and transit
duration variations due to exomoons
Submitted: 2016-04-18, last modified: 2016-06-20
We present new ways to identify single and multiple moons around extrasolar
planets using planetary transit timing variations (TTVs) and transit duration
variations (TDVs). For planets with one moon, measurements from successive
transits exhibit a hitherto undescribed pattern in the TTV-TDV diagram,
originating from the stroboscopic sampling of the planet's orbit around the
planet-moon barycenter. This pattern is fully determined and analytically
predictable after three consecutive transits. The more measurements become
available, the more the TTV-TDV diagram approaches an ellipse. For planets with
multiple moons in orbital mean motion resonance (MMR), like the Galilean moons,
the pattern is much more complex and addressed numerically in this report.
Exomoons in MMR can also form closed, predictable TTV-TDV figures if the drift
of the moons' pericenters is sufficiently slow. We find that MMR exomoons
produce loops in the TTV-TDV diagram and that the number of these loops is
equal to the order of the MMR, or the largest integer in the MMR ratio. We use
a Bayesian model and Monte Carlo simulations to test the discoverability of
exomoons using TTV-TDV diagrams with current and near-future technology. In a
blind test, two of us (BP, DA) successfully retrieved a large moon from
simulated TTV-TDV by co-authors MH and RH, which resembled data from a known
Kepler planet candidate. Single exomoons with a 10% moon-to-planet mass ratio,
like to Pluto-Charon binary, can be detectable in the archival data of the
Kepler primary mission. Multi-exomoon systems, however, require either larger
telescopes or brighter target stars. Complementary detection methods invoking a
moon's own photometric transit or its orbital sampling effect can be used for
validation or falsification. A combination of TESS, CHEOPS, and PLATO data
would offer a compelling opportunity for exomoon discoveries around bright
stars.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.02760 [pdf] - 1451898
The Stability of F-star Brightness on Century Timescales
Submitted: 2016-05-09
The century-long photometric record of the DASCH project provides a unique
window into the variability of stars normally considered to be photometrically
inactive. In this paper, we look for long-term trends in the brightness of F
stars, with particular attention to KIC 8462852,an F3 main sequence star that
has been identified as significant short-term variability according to Kepler
observations. Although a simple search for variability suggests long-term
dimming of a number of F stars, we find that such trends are artifacts of the
'Menzel Gap' in the DASCH data. That includes the behavior of KIC 8462852,
which we believe is consistent with constant flux over the full duration of
observations. We do, however, present a selection of F stars that do have
significant photometric trends, even after systematics are taken into account.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.07314 [pdf] - 1432943
A statistical analysis of the accuracy of the digitized magnitudes of
photometric plates on the time scale of decades with an application to the
century-long light curve of KIC 8462852
Submitted: 2016-01-27, last modified: 2016-04-28
We present a statistical analysis of the accuracy of the digitized magnitudes
of photometric plates on the time scale of decades. In our examination of
archival Johnson B photometry from the Harvard DASCH archive, we find a median
RMS scatter of lightcurves of order 0.15mag over the range B~9-17 for all
calibrations. Slight underlying systematics (trends or flux discontinuities)
are on a level of ~<=0.2mag per century (1889-1990) for the majority of
constant stars. These historic data can be unambiguously used for processes
that happen on scales of magnitudes, and need to be carefully examined in cases
approaching the noise floor. The characterization of these limits in
photometric stability may guide future studies in their use of plate archives.
We explain these limitations for the example case of KIC8462852, which has been
claimed to dim by 0.16mag per century, and show that this trend cannot be
considered as significant.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.07112 [pdf] - 1380340
Modeling the Orbital Sampling Effect of Extrasolar Moons
Submitted: 2016-03-23
The orbital sampling effect (OSE) appears in phase-folded transit light
curves of extrasolar planets with moons. Analytical OSE models have hitherto
neglected stellar limb darkening and non-zero transit impact parameters and
assumed that the moon is on a circular, co-planar orbit around the planet.
Here, we present an analytical OSE model for eccentric moon orbits, which we
implement in a numerical simulator with stellar limb darkening that allows for
arbitrary transit impact parameters. We also describe and publicly release a
fully numerical OSE simulator (PyOSE) that can model arbitrary inclinations of
the transiting moon orbit. Both our analytical solution for the OSE and PyOSE
can be used to search for exomoons in long-term stellar light curves such as
those by Kepler and the upcoming PLATO mission. Our updated OSE model offers an
independent method for the verification of possible future exomoon claims via
transit timing variations and transit duration variations. Photometrically
quiet K and M dwarf stars are particularly promising targets for an exomoon
discovery using the OSE.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.04719 [pdf] - 1447642
Simple nonlinear models suggest variable star universality
Submitted: 2015-10-15
Dramatically improved data from observatories like the CoRoT and Kepler
spacecraft have recently facilitated nonlinear time series analysis and
phenomenological modeling of variable stars, including the search for strange
(aka fractal) or chaotic dynamics. We recently argued [Lindner et al., Phys.
Rev. Lett. 114 (2015) 054101] that the Kepler data includes "golden" stars,
whose luminosities vary quasiperiodically with two frequencies nearly in the
golden ratio, and whose secondary frequencies exhibit power-law scaling with
exponent near -1.5, suggesting strange nonchaotic dynamics and singular
spectra. Here we use a series of phenomenological models to make plausible the
connection between golden stars and fractal spectra. We thereby suggest that at
least some features of variable star dynamics reflect universal nonlinear
phenomena common to even simple systems.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.00427 [pdf] - 1280956
A statistical search for a population of Exo-Trojans in the Kepler
dataset
Submitted: 2015-08-03
Trojans are small bodies in planetary Lagrangian points. In our solar system,
Jupiter has the largest number of such companions. Their existence is assumed
for exoplanetary systems as well, but none has been found so far. We present an
analysis by super-stacking $\sim4\times10^4$ Kepler planets with a total of
$\sim9\times10^5$ transits, searching for an average trojan transit dip. Our
result gives an upper limit to the average Trojan transiting area (per planet)
corresponding to one body of radius $<460$km at $2\sigma$ confidence. We find a
significant Trojan-like signal in a sub-sample for planets with more (or
larger) Trojans for periods $>$60 days. Our tentative results can and should be
checked with improved data from future missions like PLATO2.0, and can guide
planetary formation theories.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.03251 [pdf] - 1273076
Photometry's bright future: Detecting Solar System analogues with future
space telescopes
Submitted: 2015-03-11, last modified: 2015-07-08
Time-series transit photometry from the Kepler space telescope has allowed
for the discovery of thousands of exoplanets. We explore the potential of yet
improved future missions such as PLATO 2.0 in detecting solar system analogues.
We use real-world solar data and end-to-end simulations to explore the stellar
and instrumental noise properties. By injecting and retrieving planets, rings
and moons of our own solar system, we show that the discovery of Venus- and
Earth-analogues transiting G-dwarfs like our Sun is feasible at high S/N after
collecting 6yrs of data, but Mars and Mercury will be difficult to detect due
to stellar noise. In the best cases, Saturn's rings and Jupiter's moons will be
detectable even in single transit observations. Through the high number (>1 bn)
of observed stars by PLATO 2.0, it will become possible to detect thousands of
single-transit events by cold gas giants, analogue to our Jupiter, Saturn,
Uranus and Neptune. Our own solar system aside, we also show, through signal
injection and retrieval, that PLATO 2.0-class photometry will allow for the
secure detection of exomoons transiting quiet M-dwarfs. This is the first study
analyzing in-depth the potential of future missions, and the ultimate limits of
photometry, using realistic case examples.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.05033 [pdf] - 1126229
On the detection of Exomoons: A search in Kepler data for the orbital
sampling effect and the scatter peak
Submitted: 2015-02-17, last modified: 2015-04-16
Despite the discovery of thousands of exoplanets, no exomoons have been
detected so far. We test a recently developed method for exomoon search, the
orbital sampling effect (OSE), using the full exoplanet photometry from the
Kepler Space Telescope. The OSE is applied to phase-folded transits, for which
we present a framework to detect false positives, and discuss four candidates
which pass several of our tests. Using numerical simulations, we inject exomoon
signals into real Kepler data and retrieve them, showing that under favorable
conditions, exomoons can be found with Kepler and the OSE method. In addition,
we super-stack a large sample of Kepler planets to search for the average
exomoon OSE and the accompanying increase in noise, the scatter peak. We find a
significant OSE-like signal, which might indicate the presence of moons, for
planets with 35d<P<80d, having an average dip per planet of 6+-2ppm,
corresponding to a moon radius of 2120 +330 -370km for the average star radius
of 1.24R_Sun in this sample.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.05245 [pdf] - 972619
Discrete steps in dispersion measures of Fast Radio Bursts
Submitted: 2015-03-17, last modified: 2015-03-30
Fast Radios Bursts (FRBs) show large dispersion measures (DMs), suggesting an
extragalactic location. We analyze the DMs of the 11 known FRBs in detail and
identify steps as integer multiples of half the lowest DM found, 187.5cm$^{-3}$
pc, so that DMs occur in groups centered at 375, 562, 750, 937, 1125cm$^{-3}$
pc, with errors observed <5%. We estimate the likelhood of a coincidence as
5:10,000. We speculate that this could originate from a Galaxy population of
FRBs, with Milky Way DM contribution as model deviations, and an underlying
generator process that produces FRBs with DMs in discrete steps. However, we
find that FRBs tend to arrive at close to the full integer second, like
man-made perytons. If this holds, FRBs would also be man-made. This can be
verified, or refuted, with new FRBs to be detected.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.01747 [pdf] - 930978
Strange nonchaotic stars
Submitted: 2015-01-08, last modified: 2015-02-04
The unprecedented light curves of the Kepler space telescope document how the
brightness of some stars pulsates at primary and secondary frequencies whose
ratios are near the golden mean, the most irrational number. A nonlinear
dynamical system driven by an irrational ratio of frequencies generically
exhibits a strange but nonchaotic attractor. For Kepler's "golden" stars, we
present evidence of the first observation of strange nonchaotic dynamics in
nature outside the laboratory. This discovery could aid the classification and
detailed modeling of variable stars.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.1265 [pdf] - 911076
Pulsation period variations in the RRc Lyrae star KIC 5520878
Submitted: 2014-09-03, last modified: 2014-10-23
Learned et. al. proposed that a sufficiently advanced extra-terrestrial
civilization may tickle Cepheid and RR Lyrae variable stars with a neutrino
beam at the right time, thus causing them to trigger early and jogging the
otherwise very regular phase of their expansion and contraction. This would
turn these stars into beacons to transmit information throughout the galaxy and
beyond. The idea is to search for signs of phase modulation (in the regime of
short pulse duration) and patterns, which could be indicative of intentional,
omnidirectional signaling.
We have performed such a search among variable stars using photometric data
from the Kepler space telescope. In the RRc Lyrae star KIC 5520878, we have
found two such regimes of long and short pulse durations. The sequence of
period lengths, expressed as time series data, is strongly auto correlated,
with correlation coefficients of prime numbers being significantly higher
($p=99.8$\%). Our analysis of this candidate star shows that the prime number
oddity originates from two simultaneous pulsation periods and is likely of
natural origin.
Simple physical models elucidate the frequency content and asymmetries of the
KIC 5520878 light curve.
Despite this SETI null result, we encourage testing other archival and future
time-series photometry for signs of modulated stars. This can be done as a
by-product to the standard analysis, and even partly automated.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.3442 [pdf] - 867653
Square root two period ratios in Cepheid and RR Lyrae variable stars
Submitted: 2014-07-13, last modified: 2014-09-16
We document the presence of a few Cepheid and RR Lyrae variable stars with
previously unrecognized characteristics. These stars exhibit the property of a
period ratio of main pulsation divided by secondary pulsation P1/P2 very close
to sqrt(2). Other stars of these types have period ratios which do not show
clustering with a close association and a single remarkable non-harmonic
number. Close examination reveals a deviation of multiples of a few times
~0.06% for these stars. This deviation seems to be present in discrete steps on
the order of ~0.000390(4), indicating the possible presence of a sort of fine
structure in this oscillation.