Normalized to: Hillman, L.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0301184 [pdf] - 54155
The phase coherence of light from extragalactic sources - direct
evidence against first order Planck scale fluctuations in time and space
Submitted: 2003-01-10, last modified: 2003-01-27
We present a method of directly testing whether time continues to have its
usual meaning on scales of <= t_P = sqrt(hbar G/c^5) ~ 5.4E-44 s, the Planck
time. According to quantum gravity, the time t of an event cannot be determined
more accurately than a standard deviation of the form sigma_t/t = a_o
(t_P/t)^a, where a_o and a are positive constants ~1; likewise distances are
subject to an ultimate uncertainty c \sigma_t, where c is the speed of light.
As a consequence, the period and wavelength of light cannot be specified
precisely; rather, they are independently subject to the same intrinsic
limitations in our knowledge of time and space, so that even the most
monochromatic plane wave must in reality be a superposition of waves with
varying omega and {\bf k}, each having a different phase velcocity omega/k. For
the entire accessible range of the electromagnetic spectrum this effect is
extremely small, but can cumulatively lead to a complete loss of phase
information if the emitted radiation propagated a sufficiently large distance.
Since, at optical frequencies, the phase coherence of light from a distant
point source is a necessary condition for the presence of diffraction patterns
when the source is viewed through a telescope, such observations offer by far
the most sensitive and uncontroversial test. We show that the HST detection of
Airy rings from the active galaxy PKS1413+135, located at a distance of 1.2
Gpc, secures the exclusion of all first order (a=1) quantum gravity
fluctuations with an amplitude a_o > 0.003. The same result may be used to
deduce that the speed of light in vacuo is exact to a few parts in 10^32.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0211402 [pdf] - 53137
Stringent limits on the existence of Planck time from stellar
interferometry
Submitted: 2002-11-18
We present a method of directly testing whether time is `grainy' on scales of
<= t_P = (hbar G/c^5)^0.5 ~ 5.4E-44 s, the Planck time. If the phenomenon
exists, the energy and momentum of a photon (quantities which are independently
measured) will be subject to ultimate uncertainties of the form dE/E ~ dp/p ~
(E/E_P)^a, where E=h/t_P and a~1, because surpassing these will lead to
`super-clocks' and `super-rulers'. A well-known consequence is random
perturbation of the photon dispersion equation by a correction term which to
lowest order modifies the equation to the form p^2 = E^2[1 +/- a_o(E/E_P)^a],
where a_o ~ 1 and c=1. As a result, the two wave velocities will fluctuate by
different amounts, so that after propagating a sufficiently large distance the
phase of the radiation will no longer be well-defined. Now, at optical
frequencies, the technique of stellar interferometry readily ascertains whether
light from an astronomical object retains is phase information upon arrival.
Currently the furthest star from which interference fringes were seen, S Ser,
is at ~ 1 kpc, implying that all models with a <= 13/15 are to be rejected. The
decisive step, of course, is to test the presence or not of the first order
term E/E_P itself (i.e. a=1); for this one must await the imminent observations
of extra-galactic sources at > 1 Mpc by the Very Large Telescope Interferometer
(the VLTI). Based upon the S Ser result, nonetheless, it is already possible to
conclude that there is no first order departure from exactness in time over
intervals ~ 4.2E-40 s (~10^4 times longer than the Planck time).