Normalized to: Hatch, N.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.03706 [pdf] - 2131041
Massive molecular gas reservoir around the central AGN in the CARLA
J1103+3449 cluster at z=1.44
Markov, Vladan;
Mei, Simona;
Salomé, Philippe;
Combes, Francoise;
Stern, Daniel;
Galametz, Audrey;
De Breuck, Carlos;
Wylezalek, Dominika;
Amodeo, Stefania;
Cooke, Elizabeth A.;
Gonzalez, Anthony H.;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Noirot, Gaël;
Rettura, Alessandro;
Seymour, Nick;
Stanford, Spencer A.;
Vernet, Joël
Submitted: 2020-07-07
Passive early-type galaxies dominate cluster cores at z $\lesssim$1.5. At
higher redshift, cluster core galaxies are observed to have still on-going
star-formation, fuelled by cold molecular gas. We measure the molecular gas
reservoir of the central region around the radio-loud AGN in the cluster CARLA
J1103+3449 at z=1.44 with NOEMA. The AGN synchrotron emission dominates the
continuum emission at 94.48 GHz, and we measure its flux at the AGN position
and at the position of two radio jets. Combining our measurements with
published results over the range 4.71 GHz-94.5 GHz, we obtain a flat spectral
index $\alpha = 0.14 \pm 0.03$ for the AGN core emission, and a steeper index
$\alpha = 1.43 \pm 0.04$ and $\alpha = 1.15 \pm 0.04$ at positions close to the
western and eastern lobe, respectively. The total spectral index is $\alpha =
0.92 \pm 0.02$ over the range 73.8 MHz-94.5 GHz. We detect two CO(2-1) emission
lines, both blue-shifted with respect to the AGN. Their emission corresponds to
two regions, ~17 kpc south-east and ~14 kpc south-west of the AGN, not
associated with galaxies. In these two regions, we find a total massive
molecular gas reservoir of $M_{gas}$ = 3.9 $\pm$ 0.4 $10^{10} M_{\odot}$, which
dominates (~ 60%) the central total molecular gas reservoir. These results can
be explained by massive cool gas flows in the center of the cluster. The AGN
early-type host is not yet quenched; its star formation rate is consistent with
being on the main sequence of star-forming galaxies in the field (SFR~30-140
$M_{\odot}$/yr), and the cluster core molecular gas reservoir is expected to
feed the AGN and the host star-formation before quiescence. The other cluster
confirmed members show star formation rates at ~2 $\sigma$ below the field main
sequence at similar redshifts and do not have molecular gas masses larger than
galaxies of similar stellar mass in the field.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.10461 [pdf] - 2072767
The clustering of X-ray AGN at 0.5 < z < 4.5: host galaxies dictate dark
matter halo mass
Submitted: 2020-03-23
We present evidence that AGN do not reside in ``special'' environments, but
instead show large-scale clustering determined by the properties of their host
galaxies. Our study is based on an angular cross-correlation analysis applied
to X-ray selected AGN in the COSMOS and UDS fields, spanning redshifts from
$z\sim4.5$ to $z\sim0.5$. Consistent with previous studies, we find that AGN at
all epochs are on average hosted by galaxies in dark matter halos of
$10^{12}-10^{13}$ M$_{\odot}$, intermediate between star-forming and passive
galaxies. We find, however, that the same clustering signal can be produced by
inactive (i.e. non-AGN) galaxies closely matched to the AGN in spectral class,
stellar mass and redshift. We therefore argue that the inferred bias for AGN
lies in between the star-forming and passive galaxy populations because AGN
host galaxies are comprised of a mixture of the two populations. Although AGN
hosted by higher mass galaxies are more clustered than lower mass galaxies,
this stellar mass dependence disappears when passive host galaxies are removed.
The strength of clustering is also largely independent of AGN X-ray luminosity.
We conclude that the most important property that determines the clustering in
a given AGN population is the fraction of passive host galaxies. We also infer
that AGN luminosity is likely not driven by environmental triggering, and
further hypothesise that AGN may be a stochastic phenomenon without a strong
dependence on environment.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.08273 [pdf] - 2026386
VLT/SINFONI study of black hole growth in high redshift radio-loud
quasars from the CARLA survey
Marinello, M.;
Overzier, R. A.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Kurk, J. D.;
De Breuck, C.;
Vernet, J.;
Wylezalek, D.;
Stern, D.;
Duncan, K. J.;
Hatch, N.;
Kashikawa, N.;
Lin, Y. -T.;
Nemmen, R. S.;
Saxena, A.
Submitted: 2019-11-19
We present VLT/SINFONI observations of 35 quasars at 2.1 < z < 3.2, the
majority of which were selected from the Clusters Around Radio-Loud AGN (CARLA)
survey. CARLA quasars have large CIV-based black hole (BH) masses (M(BH) > 10^9
Msun) and powerful radio emission (P(500MHz) > 27.5 W/Hz). We estimate Ha-based
M(BH), finding a scatter of 0.35 dex compared to CIV. We evaluate several
recipes for correcting CIV-based masses, which reduce the scatter to 0.24 dex.
The radio power of the radio-loud quasars is at most weakly correlated with the
interconnected quantities Ha-width, L(5100A) and M(BH), suggesting that it is
governed by different physical processes. However, we do find a strong inverse
correlation between CIV blueshift and radio power linked to higher Eddington
ratios and L(5100A). Under standard assumptions, the BH growth time is longer
than the cosmic age for many CARLA quasars, suggesting that they must have
experienced more efficient growth in the past. If these BHs were growing from
seeds since the epoch of reionization, it is possible that they grew at the
Eddington limit like the quasars at z ~ 6-7, and then continued to grow at the
reduced rates observed until z ~ 2-3. Finally, we study the relation between
M(BH) and environment, finding a weak positive correlation between M(BH) and
galaxy density measured by CARLA.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.02513 [pdf] - 1960375
Searching for the shadows of giants: characterising protoclusters with
line of sight Lyman-{\alpha} absorption
Submitted: 2019-09-05, last modified: 2019-09-12
We use state of the art hydrodyamical simulations from the Sherwood, EAGLE
and Illustris projects to examine the signature of $M_{\rm z=0}\simeq
10^{14}M_{\odot}$ protoclusters observed in Ly-$\alpha$ absorption at $z\simeq
2.4$. We find there is a weak correlation between the mass overdensity,
$\delta_{\rm m}$, and the Ly-$\alpha$ effective optical depth relative to the
mean, $\delta_{\tau_\textrm{eff}}$, averaged over $15~h^{-1}\rm\,cMpc$ scales,
although scatter in the $\delta_{\rm m}$--$\delta_{\tau_\textrm{eff}}$ plane
means it is not possible to uniquely identify large scale overdensities with
strong Ly-$\alpha$ absorption. Although all protoclusters are associated with
large scale mass overdensities, most sight lines through protoclusters in a
$\sim 10^{6}$ $\rm cMpc^{3}$ volume probe the low column density Ly-$\alpha$
forest. A small subset of sight lines that pass through protoclusters exhibit
coherent, strong Ly-$\alpha$ absorption on $15h^{-1}\rm\,cMpc$ scales, although
these correspond to a wide range in mass overdensity. Assuming perfect removal
of contamination by Ly-$\alpha$ absorbers with damping wings, more than half of
the remaining sight lines with $\delta_{\tau_{\rm eff}}>3.5$ trace
protoclusters. It is furthermore possible to identify a model dependent
$\delta_{\tau_{\rm eff}}$ threshold that selects only protoclusters. However,
such regions are rare: excluding absorption caused by damped systems, less than
0.1 per cent of sight lines that pass through a protocluster have
$\delta_{\tau_{\rm eff}}>3.5$, meaning that any protocluster sample selected in
this manner will also be highly incomplete. On the other hand, coherent regions
of Ly-$\alpha$ absorption also provide a promising route for identifying and
studying filamentary environments at high redshift.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.02766 [pdf] - 1945892
High-velocity outflows in massive post-starburst galaxies at z > 1
Maltby, David T.;
Almaini, Omar;
McLure, Ross J.;
Wild, Vivienne;
Dunlop, James;
Rowlands, Kate;
Hartley, William G.;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Socolovsky, Miguel;
Wilkinson, Aaron;
Amorin, Ricardo;
Bradshaw, Emma J.;
Carnall, Adam C.;
Castellano, Marco;
Cimatti, Andrea;
Cresci, Giovanni;
Cullen, Fergus;
De Barros, Stephane;
Fontanot, Fabio;
Garilli, Bianca;
Koekemoer, Anton M.;
McLeod, Derek J.;
Pentericci, Laura;
Talia, Margherita
Submitted: 2019-08-07
We investigate the prevalence of galactic-scale outflows in post-starburst
(PSB) galaxies at high redshift ($1 < z < 1.4$), using the deep optical spectra
available in the UKIDSS Ultra Deep Survey (UDS). We use a sample of $\sim40$
spectroscopically confirmed PSBs, recently identified in the UDS field, and
perform a stacking analysis in order to analyse the structure of strong
interstellar absorption features such as Mg ii ($\lambda2800$ Ang.). We find
that for massive ($M_* > 10^{10}\rm\,M_{\odot}$) PSBs at $z > 1$, there is
clear evidence for a strong blue-shifted component to the Mg ii absorption
feature, indicative of high-velocity outflows ($v_{\rm
out}\sim1150\pm160\rm\,km\,s^{-1}$) in the interstellar medium. We conclude
that such outflows are typical in massive PSBs at this epoch, and potentially
represent the residual signature of a feedback process that quenched these
galaxies. Using full spectral fitting, we also obtain a typical stellar
velocity dispersion $\sigma_*$ for these PSBs of $\sim200\rm\,km\,s^{-1}$,
which confirms they are intrinsically massive in nature (dynamical mass $M_{\rm
d}\sim10^{11}\rm\,M_{\odot}$). Given that these high-$z$ PSBs are also
exceptionally compact ($r_{\rm e}\sim1$--$2\rm\,kpc$) and spheroidal (Sersic
index $n\sim3$), we propose that the outflowing winds may have been launched
during a recent compaction event (e.g. major merger or disc collapse) that
triggered either a centralised starburst or active galactic nuclei (AGN)
activity. Finally, we find no evidence for AGN signatures in the optical
spectra of these PSBs, suggesting they were either quenched by stellar feedback
from the starburst itself, or that if AGN feedback is responsible, the AGN
episode that triggered quenching does not linger into the post-starburst phase.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.06818 [pdf] - 1795888
The Environments of Luminous Radio - WISE Selected Infrared Galaxies
Penney, J. I.;
Blain, A. W.;
Wylezalek, D.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Lonsdale, C.;
Kimball, A.;
Assef, R. J.;
Condon, J. J.;
Eisenhardt, P. R. M.;
Jones, S. F.;
Kim, M.;
Lacy, M.;
Muldrew, S. I.;
Petty, S.;
Sajina, A.;
Silva, A.;
Stern, D.;
Diaz-Santos, T.;
Tsai, C-W.;
Wu, J.
Submitted: 2018-11-16
We have observed the environments of a population of 33 heavily dust
obscured, ultra-luminous, high-redshift galaxies, selected using WISE and NVSS
at $z>$1.3 with the Infra-Red Array Camera on the $Spitzer$ Space Telescope
over $\rm5.12\,'\times5.12\,'$ fields. Colour selections are used to quantify
any potential overdensities of companion galaxies in these fields. We find no
significant excess of galaxies with the standard colour selection for IRAC
colours of $\rm[3.6]-[4.5]>-0.1$ consistent with galaxies at $z>$1.3 across the
whole fields with respect to wide-area $Spitzer$ comparison fields, but there
is a $\rm>2\sigma$ statistical excess within $\rm0.25\,'$ of the central
radio-WISE galaxy. Using a colour selection of $\rm[3.6]-[4.5]>0.4$, 0.5
magnitudes redder than the standard method of selecting galaxies at $z>$1.3, we
find a significant overdensity, in which $\rm76\%$ ($\rm33\%$) of the 33 fields
have a surface density greater than the $\rm3\sigma$ ($\rm5\sigma$) level.
There is a statistical excess of these redder galaxies within $\rm0.5\,'$,
rising to a central peak $\rm\sim2$--4 times the average density. This implies
that these galaxies are statistically linked to the radio-WISE selected galaxy,
indicating similar structures to those traced by red galaxies around radio-loud
AGN.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.10023 [pdf] - 1773120
Compact star-forming galaxies preferentially quenched to become PSBs in
$z<1$ clusters
Submitted: 2018-10-23
We analyse the structure of galaxies with high specific star formation rate
(SSFR) in cluster and field environments in the redshift range $0.5<z<1.0$.
Recent studies have shown that these galaxies are strongly depleted in dense
environments due to rapid environmental quenching, giving rise to
post-starburst galaxies (PSBs). We use effective radii and S\'ersic indices as
tracers of galaxy structure, determined using imaging from the UKIDSS Ultra
Deep Survey (UDS). We find that the high-SSFR galaxies that survive into the
cluster environment have, on average, larger effective radii than those in the
field. We suggest that this trend is likely to be driven by the most compact
star-forming galaxies being preferentially quenched in dense environments. We
also show that the PSBs in clusters have stellar masses and effective radii
that are similar to the missing compact star-forming population, suggesting
that these PSBs are the result of size-dependent quenching. We propose that
both strong stellar feedback and the stripping of the extended halo act
together to preferentially and rapidly quench the compact and low-mass
star-forming systems in clusters to produce PSBs. We test this scenario using
the stacked spectra of 124 high-SSFR galaxies, showing that more compact
galaxies are more likely to host outflows. We conclude that a combination of
environmental and secular processes is the most likely explanation for the
appearance of PSBs in galaxy clusters.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.08755 [pdf] - 1763121
MAHALO Deep Cluster Survey II. Characterizing massive forming galaxies
in the Spiderweb protocluster at z=2.2
Shimakawa, Rhythm;
Koyama, Yusei;
Rottgering, Huub J. A.;
Kodama, Tadayuki;
Hayashi, Masao;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Dannerbauer, Helmut;
Tanaka, Ichi;
Tadaki, Ken-ichi;
Suzuki, Tomoko L.;
Fukagawa, Nao;
Cai, Zheng;
Kurk, Jaron D.
Submitted: 2018-09-24
This paper is the second in a series presenting the results of our deep
H$\alpha$-line survey towards protoclusters at $z>2$, based on narrow-band
imaging with the Subaru Telescope. This work investigates massive galaxies in a
protocluster region associated with a radio galaxy (PKS 1138$-$262), the
Spiderweb galaxy, at $z=2.2$. Our 0.5 mag deeper narrow-band imaging than
previous surveys collects a total of 68 H$\alpha$ emitters (HAE). 17 out of the
68 are newly discovered protocluster members. First, a very high characteristic
stellar mass of M$_\star^\ast=10^{11.73}$ M$_\odot$ is measured from a
Schechter function fit to the mass distribution of HAEs. Together with the
Chandra X-ray data, we find that four out of six massive HAEs
(M$_\star>10^{11}$ M$_\odot$) show bright X-ray emission, suggesting that they
host active galactic nuclei (AGNs). Their mass estimates, therefore, would be
affected by the nuclear emission from AGNs. Notably, the X-ray detected HAEs
are likely positioned near the boundary between star-forming and quiescent
populations in the rest-frame $UVJ$ plane. Moreover, our deep narrow-band data
succeed in probing the bright H$\alpha$ (+[Nii]) line nebula of the Spiderweb
galaxy extending over $\sim100$ physical kpc. These results suggest that the
massive galaxies in the Spiderweb protocluster are on the way to becoming the
bright red sequence objects seen in local galaxy clusters, where AGNs might
play an essential role in their quenching processes. Though a more statistical
database is needed to build a general picture.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.01325 [pdf] - 1717237
The structure of post-starburst galaxies at $0.5 < z < 2$: evidence for
two distinct quenching routes at different epochs
Maltby, David T.;
Almaini, Omar;
Wild, Vivienne;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Hartley, William G.;
Simpson, Chris;
Rowlands, Kate;
Socolovsky, Miguel;
[;
Nottingham;
Andrews, St;
UCL;
Gemini;
Hopkins], Johns
Submitted: 2018-07-03
We present an analysis of the structure of post-starburst (PSB) galaxies in
the redshift range $0.5 < z < 2$, using a photometrically-selected sample
identified in the Ultra Deep Survey (UDS) field. We examine the structure of
$\sim80$ of these transient galaxies using radial light $\mu(r)$ profiles
obtained from CANDELS $\textit{Hubble Space Telescope}$ near-infrared/optical
imaging, and compare to a large sample of $\sim2000$ passive and star-forming
galaxies. For each population, we determine their typical structural properties
(effective radius $r_{\rm e}$, S\'ersic index $n$) and find significant
differences in PSB structure at different epochs. At high redshift ($z > 1$),
PSBs are typically massive ($M_* > 10^{10}\rm\,M_{\odot}$), very compact and
exhibit high S\'ersic indices, with structures that differ significantly from
their star-forming progenitors but are similar to massive passive galaxies. In
contrast, at lower redshift ($0.5 < z < 1$), PSBs are generally of low mass
($M_* < 10^{10}\rm\,M_{\odot}$) and exhibit compact but less concentrated
profiles (i.e. lower S\'ersic indices), with structures similar to low-mass
passive discs. Furthermore, for both epochs we find remarkably consistent PSB
structure across the optical/near-infrared wavebands (which largely trace
different stellar populations), suggesting that any preceding starburst and/or
quenching in PSBs was not strongly centralized. Taken together, these results
imply that PSBs at $z > 1$ have been recently quenched during a major
disruptive event (e.g. merger or protogalactic collapse) which formed a compact
remnant, while at $z < 1$ an alternative less disruptive process is primarily
responsible. Our results suggest that high-$z$ PSBs are an intrinsically
different population to those at lower redshifts, and indicate different
quenching routes are active at different epochs.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.01500 [pdf] - 1694079
$HST$ Grism Confirmation of $16$ Structures at $1.4 < z < 2.8$ from the
Clusters Around Radio-Loud AGN (CARLA) Survey
Noirot, Gaël;
Stern, Daniel;
Mei, Simona;
Wylezalek, Dominika;
Cooke, Elizabeth A.;
De Breuck, Carlos;
Galametz, Audrey;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Vernet, Joël;
Brodwin, Mark;
Eisenhardt, Peter;
Gonzalez, Anthony H.;
Jarvis, Matt;
Rettura, Alessandro;
Seymour, Nick;
Stanford, S. A.
Submitted: 2018-04-04
We report spectroscopic results from our 40-orbit $Hubble~Space~Telescope$
slitless grism spectroscopy program observing the 20 densest CARLA candidate
galaxy clusters at $1.4 < z < 2.8$. These candidate rich structures, among the
richest and most distant known, were identified on the basis of $[3.6]-[4.5]$
color from a $408~$hr multi-cycle $Spitzer$ program targeting $420$ distant
radio-loud AGN. We report the spectroscopic confirmation of $16$ distant
structures at $1.4 < z < 2.8$ associated with the targeted powerful
high-redshift radio-loud AGN. We also report the serendipitous discovery and
spectroscopic confirmation of seven additional structures at $0.87 < z < 2.12$
not associated with the targeted radio-loud AGN. We find that $10^{10} -
10^{11}\,M_{\odot}$ member galaxies of our confirmed CARLA structures form
significantly fewer stars than their field counterparts at all redshifts within
$1.4\leq z\leq 2$. We also observe higher star-forming activity in the
structure cores up to $z = 2$, finding similar trends as cluster surveys at
slightly lower redshifts ($1.0 < z < 1.5$). By design, our efficient strategy
of obtaining just two grism orbits per field only obtains spectroscopic
confirmation of emission-line galaxies. Deeper spectroscopy will be required to
study the population of evolved, massive galaxies in these (forming) clusters.
Lacking multi-band coverage of the fields, we adopt a very conservative
approach of calling all confirmations "structures", although we note that a
number of features are consistent with some of them being bona fide galaxy
clusters. Together, this survey represents a unique and large homogenous sample
of spectroscopically confirmed structures at high redshifts, potentially more
than doubling the census of confirmed, massive clusters at $z > 1.4$.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.08742 [pdf] - 1652503
Giant galaxy growing from recycled gas: ALMA maps the circumgalactic
molecular medium of the Spiderweb in [CI]
Emonts, B. H. C.;
Lehnert, M. D.;
Dannerbauer, H.;
De Breuck, C.;
Villar-Martin, M.;
Miley, G. K.;
Allison, J. R.;
Gullberg, B.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Guillard, P.;
Mao, M. Y.;
Norris, R. P.
Submitted: 2018-02-23
The circumgalactic medium (CGM) of the massive Spiderweb Galaxy, a
conglomerate of merging proto-cluster galaxies at z=2.2, forms an enriched
interface where feedback and recycling act on accreted gas. This is shown by
observations of [CI], CO(1-0) and CO(4-3) performed with the Atacama Large
Millimeter Array (ALMA) and Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA). [CI] and
CO(4-3) are detected across ~50 kpc, following the distribution of previously
detected low-surface-brightness CO(1-0) across the CGM. This confirms our
previous results on the presence of a cold molecular halo. The central radio
galaxy MRC1138-262 shows a very high global $L'_{\rm CO(4-3)}$/$L'_{\rm
CO(1-0)}$ ~ 1, suggesting that mechanisms other than FUV-heating by star
formation prevail at the heart of the Spiderweb Galaxy. Contrary, the CGM has
$L'_{\rm CO(4-3)}$/$L'_{\rm CO(1-0)}$ and $L'_{\rm [CI]}$/$L'_{\rm CO(1-0)}$
similar to the ISM of five galaxies in the wider proto-cluster, and its carbon
abundance, $X_{\rm [CI]}$/$X_{\rm H2}$, resembles that of the Milky Way and
starforming galaxies. The molecular CGM is thus metal-rich and not diffuse,
confirming a link between the cold gas and in-situ star formation. Thus, the
Spiderweb Galaxy grows not directly through accretion of gas from the cosmic
web, but from recycled gas in the GCM.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.00005 [pdf] - 1629287
Massive post-starburst galaxies at z > 1 are compact proto-spheroids
Submitted: 2017-07-31, last modified: 2018-02-05
We investigate the relationship between the quenching of star formation and
the structural transformation of massive galaxies, using a large sample of
photometrically-selected post-starburst galaxies in the UKIDSS UDS field. We
find that post-starburst galaxies at high-redshift ($z>1$) show high S\'ersic
indices, significantly higher than those of active star-forming galaxies, but
with a distribution that is indistinguishable from the old quiescent
population. We conclude that the morphological transformation occurs before (or
during) the quenching of star formation. Recently quenched galaxies are also
the most compact; we find evidence that massive post-starburst galaxies
(M$_{\ast}> 10^{10.5} ~$M$_{\odot}$) at high redshift ($z>1$) are on average
smaller than comparable quiescent galaxies at the same epoch. Our findings are
consistent with a scenario in which massive passive galaxies are formed from
three distinct phases: (1) gas-rich dissipative collapse to very high
densities, forming the proto-spheroid; (2) rapid quenching of star formation,
to create the "red nugget" with post-starburst features; (3) a gradual growth
in size as the population ages, perhaps as a result of minor mergers.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.01593 [pdf] - 1630404
The enhancement of rapidly quenched galaxies in distant clusters at
0.5<z<1.0
Submitted: 2018-02-05
We investigate the relationship between environment and galaxy evolution in
the redshift range $0.5 < z < 1.0$. Galaxy overdensities are selected using a
Friends-of-Friends algorithm, applied to deep photometric data in the
Ultra-Deep Survey (UDS) field. A study of the resulting stellar mass functions
reveals clear differences between cluster and field environments, with a strong
excess of low-mass rapidly quenched galaxies in cluster environments compared
to the field. Cluster environments also show a corresponding deficit of young,
low-mass star-forming galaxies, which show a sharp radial decline towards
cluster centres. By comparing mass functions and radial distributions, we
conclude that young star-forming galaxies are rapidly quenched as they enter
overdense environments, becoming post-starburst galaxies before joining the red
sequence. Our results also point to the existence of two environmental
quenching pathways operating in galaxy clusters, operating on different
timescales. Fast quenching acts on galaxies with high specific star-formation
rates, operating on timescales shorter than the cluster dynamical time ($ < 1$
Gyr). In contrast, slow quenching affects galaxies with moderate specific
star-formation rates, regardless of their stellar mass, and acts on longer
timescales ($\gtrsim 1$ Gyr). Of the cluster galaxies in the stellar mass range
$9.0 < \log(M_{*}/M_{\odot}) < 10.5$ quenched during this epoch, we find that
73% were transformed through fast quenching, while the remaining 27% followed
the slow quenching route.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.08489 [pdf] - 1605025
Scientific Synergy Between LSST and Euclid
Rhodes, Jason;
Nichol, Robert C.;
Aubourg, Éric;
Bean, Rachel;
Boutigny, Dominique;
Bremer, Malcolm N.;
Capak, Peter;
Cardone, Vincenzo;
Carry, Benoît;
Conselice, Christopher J.;
Connolly, Andrew J.;
Cuillandre, Jean-Charles;
Hatch, N. A.;
Helou, George;
Hemmati, Shoubaneh;
Hildebrandt, Hendrik;
Hložek, Renée;
Jones, Lynne;
Kahn, Steven;
Kiessling, Alina;
Kitching, Thomas;
Lupton, Robert;
Mandelbaum, Rachel;
Markovic, Katarina;
Marshall, Phil;
Massey, Richard;
Maughan, Ben J.;
Melchior, Peter;
Mellier, Yannick;
Newman, Jeffrey A.;
Robertson, Brant;
Sauvage, Marc;
Schrabback, Tim;
Smith, Graham P.;
Strauss, Michael A.;
Taylor, Andy;
Von Der Linden, Anja
Submitted: 2017-10-23, last modified: 2017-11-29
Euclid and the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) are poised to
dramatically change the astronomy landscape early in the next decade. The
combination of high cadence, deep, wide-field optical photometry from LSST with
high resolution, wide-field optical photometry and near-infrared photometry and
spectroscopy from Euclid will be powerful for addressing a wide range of
astrophysical questions. We explore Euclid/LSST synergy, ignoring the political
issues associated with data access to focus on the scientific, technical, and
financial benefits of coordination. We focus primarily on dark energy
cosmology, but also discuss galaxy evolution, transient objects, solar system
science, and galaxy cluster studies. We concentrate on synergies that require
coordination in cadence or survey overlap, or would benefit from pixel-level
co-processing that is beyond the scope of what is currently planned, rather
than scientific programs that could be accomplished only at the catalog level
without coordination in data processing or survey strategies. We provide two
quantitative examples of scientific synergies: the decrease in photo-z errors
(benefitting many science cases) when high resolution Euclid data are used for
LSST photo-z determination, and the resulting increase in weak lensing
signal-to-noise ratio from smaller photo-z errors. We briefly discuss other
areas of coordination, including high performance computing resources and
calibration data. Finally, we address concerns about the loss of independence
and potential cross-checks between the two missions and potential consequences
of not collaborating.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.07009 [pdf] - 1588629
Galaxy evolution in protoclusters
Submitted: 2017-09-20
We investigate galaxy evolution in protoclusters using a semi-analytic model
applied to the Millennium Simulation, scaled to a Planck cosmology. We show
that the model reproduces the observed behaviour of the star formation history
(SFH) both in protoclusters and the field. The rate of star formation peaks
$\sim0.7\,{\rm Gyr}$ earlier in protoclusters than in the field and declines
more rapidly afterwards. This results in protocluster galaxies forming
significantly earlier: 80% of their stellar mass is already formed by $z=1.4$,
but only 45% of the field stellar mass has formed by this time. The model
predicts that field and protocluster galaxies have similar average specific
star-formation rates (sSFR) at $z>3$, and we find evidence of an enhancement of
star formation in the dense protoclusters at early times. At $z<3$,
protoclusters have lower sSFRs, resulting in the disparity between the SFHs. We
show that the stellar mass functions of protoclusters are top-heavy compared
with the field due to the early formation of massive galaxies, and the
disruption and merging of low-mass satellite galaxies in the main haloes. The
fundamental cause of the different SFHs and mass functions is that dark matter
haloes are biased tracers of the dark matter density field: the high density of
haloes and the top-heavy halo mass function in protoclusters result in the
early formation then rapid merging and quenching of galaxies. We compare our
results with observations from the literature, and highlight which observables
provide the most informative tests of galaxy formation.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.05250 [pdf] - 1598002
The implications of the surprising existence of a large, massive CO disk
in a distant protocluster
Dannerbauer, H.;
Lehnert, M. D.;
Emonts, B. H. C.;
Ziegler, B.;
Altieri, B.;
De Breuck, C.;
Hatch, N.;
Kodama, T.;
Koyama, Y.;
Kurk, J. D.;
Matiz, T.;
Miley, G.;
Narayanan, D.;
Norris, R.;
Overzier, R.;
Roettgering, H. J. A.;
Sargent, M.;
Seymour, N.;
Tanaka, M.;
Valtchanov, I.;
Wylezalek, D.
Submitted: 2017-01-18, last modified: 2017-07-09
It is not yet known if the properties of molecular gas in distant
protocluster galaxies are significantly affected by their environment as
galaxies are in local clusters. Through a deep, 64 hours of effective on-source
integration with the Australian Telescope Compact Array (ATCA), we discovered a
massive, M_mol=2.0+-0.2x10^11 M_sun, extended, ~40 kpc, CO(1-0)-emitting disk
in the protocluster surrounding the radio galaxy, MRC1138-262. The galaxy, at
z_CO=2.1478, is a clumpy, massive disk galaxy, M_star~5x10^11 M_sun, which lies
250 kpc in projection from MRC1138-262 and is a known H-alpha emitter, HAE229.
HAE229 has a molecular gas fraction of ~30%. The CO emission has a kinematic
gradient along its major axis, centered on the highest surface brightness
rest-frame optical emission, consistent with HAE229 being a rotating disk.
Surprisingly, a significant fraction of the CO emission lies outside of the
UV/optical emission. In spite of this, HAE229 follows the same relation between
star-formation rate and molecular gas mass as normal field galaxies. HAE229 is
the first CO(1-0) detection of an ordinary, star-forming galaxy in a
protocluster. We compare a sample of cluster members at z>0.4 that are detected
in low-order CO transitions with a similar sample of sources drawn from the
field. We confirm findings that the CO-luminosity and FWHM are correlated in
starbursts and show that this relation is valid for normal high-z galaxies as
well as those in overdensities. We do not find a clear dichotomy in the
integrated Schmidt-Kennicutt relation for protocluster and field galaxies. Not
finding any environmental dependence in the "star-formation efficiency" or the
molecular gas content, especially for such an extended CO disk, suggests that
environmentally-specific processes such as ram pressure stripping are not
operating efficiently in (proto)clusters. (abridged)
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.10799 [pdf] - 1584054
Enhancement of AGN in a protocluster at z=1.6
Krishnan, Charutha;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Almaini, Omar;
Kocevski, Dale;
Cooke, Elizabeth A.;
Hartley, William G.;
Hasinger, Guenther;
Maltby, David T.;
Muldrew, Stuart I.;
Simpson, Chris
Submitted: 2017-05-30
We investigate the prevalence of AGN in the high-redshift protocluster
$\rm{Cl}\,0218.3$-$0510$ at $z=1.62$. Using imaging from the Chandra X-ray
Telescope, we find a large overdensity of AGN in the protocluster; a factor of
$23\pm9$ times the field density of AGN. Only half of this AGN overdensity is
due to the overdensity of massive galaxies in the protocluster (a factor of
$11\pm2$), as we find that $17^{+6}_{-5}\%$ of massive galaxies ($M_* >
10^{10}\,\rm{M}_{\odot}$) in the protocluster host an X-ray luminous AGN,
compared to $8\pm1\%$ in the field. This corresponds to an enhancement of AGN
activity in massive protocluster galaxies by a factor of $2.1\pm0.7$ at
$1.6\sigma$ significance. We also find that the AGN overdensity is centrally
concentrated, located within 3 arcmin and most pronounced within 1 arcmin of
the centre of the protocluster. Our results confirm that there is a reversal in
the local anti-correlation between galaxy density and AGN activity, so there is
an enhancement of AGN in high-redshift protoclusters. We compare the properties
of AGN in the protocluster to the field and find no significant differences in
the distributions of their stellar mass, X-ray luminosity, or hardness ratio.
We therefore suggest that triggering mechanisms are similar in both
environments, and that the mechanisms simply occur more frequently in denser
environments.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.02706 [pdf] - 1511464
The WEAVE-LOFAR Survey
Smith, D. J. B.;
Best, P. N.;
Duncan, K. J.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Jarvis, M. J.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Simpson, C. J.;
Stott, J. P.;
Cochrane, R. K.;
Coppin, K. E.;
Dannerbauer, H.;
Davis, T. A.;
Geach, J. E.;
Hale, C. L.;
Hardcastle, M. J.;
Hatfield, P. W.;
Houghton, R. C. W.;
Maddox, N.;
McGee, S. L.;
Morabito, L.;
Nisbet, D.;
Pandey-Pommier, M.;
Prandoni, I.;
Saxena, A.;
Shimwell, T. W.;
Tarr, M.;
van Bemmel, I.;
Verma, A.;
White, G. J.;
Williams, W. L.
Submitted: 2016-11-08
In these proceedings we highlight the primary scientific goals and design of
the WEAVE-LOFAR survey, which will use the new WEAVE spectrograph on the 4.2m
William Herschel Telescope to provide the primary source of spectroscopic
information for the LOFAR Surveys Key Science Project. Beginning in 2018,
WEAVE-LOFAR will generate more than 10$^6$ R=5000 365-960 nm spectra of
low-frequency selected radio sources, across three tiers designed to
efficiently sample the redshift-luminosity plane, and produce a data set of
enormous legacy value. The radio frequency selection, combined with the high
multiplex and throughput of the WEAVE spectrograph, make obtaining redshifts in
this way very efficient, and we expect that the redshift success rate will
approach 100 per cent at $z < 1$. This unprecedented spectroscopic sample -
which will be complemented by an integral field component - will be
transformational in key areas, including studying the star formation history of
the Universe, the role of accretion and AGN-driven feedback, properties of the
epoch of reionisation, cosmology, cluster haloes and relics, as well as the
nature of radio galaxies and protoclusters. Each topic will be addressed in
unprecedented detail, and with the most reliable source classifications and
redshift information in existence.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.08629 [pdf] - 1488455
The impact of protocluster environments at z = 1.6
Submitted: 2016-09-27
We investigate the effects of dense environments on galaxy evolution by
examining how the properties of galaxies in the z = 1.6 protocluster Cl
0218.3-0510 depend on their location. We determine galaxy properties using
spectral energy distribution fitting to 14-band photometry, including data at
three wavelengths that tightly bracket the Balmer and 4000A breaks of the
protocluster galaxies. We find that two-thirds of the protocluster galaxies,
which lie between several compact groups, are indistinguishable from field
galaxies. The other third, which reside within the groups, differ significantly
from the intergroup galaxies in both colour and specific star formation rate.
We find that the fraction of red galaxies within the massive protocluster
groups is twice that of the intergroup region. These excess red galaxies are
due to enhanced fractions of both passive galaxies (1.7 times that of the
intergroup region) and dusty star-forming galaxies (3 times that of the
intergroup region). We infer that some protocluster galaxies are processed in
the groups before the cluster collapses. These processes act to suppress star
formation and change the mode of star formation from unobscured to obscured.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.04162 [pdf] - 1502127
HST Grism Confirmation of Two $z \sim 2$ Structures from the Clusters
Around Radio-Loud AGN (CARLA) Survey
Noirot, Gaël;
Vernet, Joël;
De Breuck, Carlos;
Wylezalek, Dominika;
Galametz, Audrey;
Stern, Daniel;
Mei, Simona;
Brodwin, Mark;
Cooke, Elizabeth A.;
Gonzalez, Anthony H.;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Rettura, Alessandro;
Stanford, Spencer Adam
Submitted: 2016-09-14
Using HST slitless grism data, we report the spectroscopic confirmation of
two distant structures at $z \sim 2$ associated with powerful high-redshift
radio-loud AGN. These rich structures, likely (forming) clusters, are among the
most distant currently known and were identified on the basis of Spitzer/IRAC
[3.6] - [4.5] color. We spectroscopically confirm 9 members in the field of MRC
2036-254, comprising eight star-forming galaxies and the targeted radio galaxy.
The median redshift is $z = 2.000$. We spectroscopically confirm 10 members in
the field of B3 0756+406, comprising eight star-forming galaxies and two AGN,
including the targeted radio-loud quasar. The median redshift is $z = 1.986$.
All confirmed members are within 500 kpc (1 arcmin) of the targeted AGN. We
derive median (mean) star-formation rates of $\sim 35~M_{\odot}\rm ~ yr^{-1}$
($\sim 50~M_{\odot}\rm ~ yr^{-1}$) for the confirmed star-forming members of
both structures based on their [OIII]$\lambda5007$ luminosities, and estimate
average galaxy stellar masses $\lesssim 1 \times 10^{11} ~M_{\odot}$ based on
mid-infrared fluxes and SED modeling. Most of our confirmed members are located
above the star-forming main-sequence towards starburst galaxies, consistent
with clusters at these early epochs being the sites of significant levels of
star formation. The structure around MRC 2036-254 shows an overdensity of
IRAC-selected candidate galaxy cluster members consistent with being quiescent
galaxies, while the structure around B3 0756+406 shows field values, albeit
with many lower limits to colors that could allow an overdensity of faint red
quiescent galaxies. The structure around MRC 2036-254 shows a red sequence of
passive galaxy candidates.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.02436 [pdf] - 1422401
HST imaging of the dusty filaments and nucleus swirl in NGC4696 at the
centre of the Centaurus Cluster
Fabian, A. C.;
Walker, S. A.;
Russell, H. R.;
Pinto, C.;
Canning, R. E. A.;
Salome, P.;
Sanders, J. S.;
Taylor, G. B.;
Zweibel, E. G.;
Conselice, C. J.;
Combes, F.;
Crawford, C. S.;
Ferland, G. J.;
Gallagher, J. S.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Johnstone, R. M.;
Reynolds, C. S.
Submitted: 2016-06-08
Narrow-band HST imaging has resolved the detailed internal structure of the
10 kpc diameter H alpha+[NII] emission line nebulosity in NGC4696, the central
galaxy in the nearby Centaurus cluster, showing that the dusty, molecular,
filaments have a width of about 60pc. Optical morphology and velocity
measurements indicate that the filaments are dragged out by the bubbling action
of the radio source as part of the AGN feedback cycle. Using the drag force we
find that the magnetic field in the filaments is in approximate pressure
equipartition with the hot gas. The filamentary nature of the cold gas
continues inward, swirling around and within the Bondi accretion radius of the
central black hole, revealing the magnetic nature of the gas flows in massive
elliptical galaxies. HST imaging resolves the magnetic, dusty, molecular
filaments at the centre of the Centaurus cluster to a swirl around and within
the Bondi radius.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.08941 [pdf] - 1426311
The identification of post-starburst galaxies at z~1 using
multiwavelength photometry: a spectroscopic verification
Maltby, David T.;
Almaini, Omar;
Wild, Vivienne;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Hartley, William G.;
Simpson, Chris;
McLure, Ross J.;
Dunlop, James;
Rowlands, Kate;
Cirasuolo, Michele
Submitted: 2016-03-29
Despite decades of study, we still do not fully understand why some massive
galaxies abruptly switch off their star formation in the early Universe, and
what causes their rapid transition to the red sequence. Post-starburst galaxies
provide a rare opportunity to study this transition phase, but few have
currently been spectroscopically identified at high redshift ($z>1$). In this
paper we present the spectroscopic verification of a new photometric technique
to identify post-starbursts in high-redshift surveys. The method classifies the
broad-band optical-near--infrared spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of
galaxies using three spectral shape parameters (super-colours), derived from a
principal component analysis of model SEDs. When applied to the multiwavelength
photometric data in the UKIDSS Ultra Deep Survey (UDS), this technique
identified over 900 candidate post-starbursts at redshifts $0.5<z<2.0$. In this
study we present deep optical spectroscopy for a subset of these galaxies, in
order to confirm their post-starburst nature. Where a spectroscopic assessment
was possible, we find the majority (19/24 galaxies; ~80 per cent) exhibit the
strong Balmer absorption (H $\delta$ equivalent width $W_{\lambda}$ >5 Ang.)
and Balmer break, characteristic of post-starburst galaxies. We conclude that
photometric methods can be used to select large samples of recently-quenched
galaxies in the distant Universe.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.03774 [pdf] - 1379076
The structure and evolution of a forming galaxy cluster at z = 1.62
Submitted: 2016-03-11
We present a comprehensive picture of the Cl0218.3-0510 protocluster at
$z=1.623$ across 10 co-moving Mpc. Using filters that tightly bracket the
Balmer and 4000 Angstrom breaks of the protocluster galaxies we obtain precise
photometric redshifts resulting in a protocluster galaxy sample that is 89+/-5%
complete and has a contamination of only 12+/-5%. Both star forming and
quiescent protocluster galaxies are located allowing us to map the structure of
the forming cluster for the first time. The protocluster contains 6 galaxy
groups, the largest of which is the nascent cluster. Only a small minority of
the protocluster galaxies are in the nascent cluster (11%) or in the other
galaxy groups (22%), as most protocluster galaxies reside between the groups.
Unobscured star forming galaxies predominantly reside between the
protocluster's groups, whereas red galaxies make up a large fraction of the
groups' galactic content, so observing the protocluster through only one of
these types of galaxies results in a biased view of the protocluster's
structure. The structure of the protocluster reveals how much mass is available
for the future growth of the cluster and we use the Millennium Simulation,
scaled to a Planck cosmology, to predict that Cl0218.3-0510 will evolve into a
2.7x 10^14 Msun cluster by the present day.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.04823 [pdf] - 1429431
ALMA Finds Dew Drops in the Dusty Spider's Web
Gullberg, B.;
Lehnert, M. D.;
De Breuck, C.;
Branchu, S.;
Dannerbauer, H.;
Drouant, G.;
Emonts, B.;
Guillard, P.;
Hatch, N.;
Nesvadba, N. P. H.;
Omont, A.;
Seymour, N.;
Vernet, J.
Submitted: 2016-02-15
We present 0."5 resolution ALMA detections of the observed 246GHz continuum,
[CI]^3P_2-^3P_1 fine structure line ([CI]2-1), CO(7-6) and H2O lines in the
z=2.161 radio galaxy MRC1138-262, the 'Spiderweb Galaxy'. We detect strong
[CI]2-1 emission both at the position of the radio core, and in a second
component ~4kpc away from it. The 1100km/s broad [CI]2-1 line in this latter
component, combined with its H2 mass of 1.6x10^10Msun implies this emission
must come from a compact region <60pc, possibly containing a second AGN. The
combined H2 mass derived for both objects using the [CI]2-1 emission is
3.3x10^10Msun. The total CO(7-6)/[CI]2-1 line flux ratio of 0.2 suggests a low
excitation molecular gas reservoir and/or enhanced atomic carbon in cosmic-ray
dominated regions. We detect spatially-resolved H2O 2_{11}-2_{02} emission -
for the first time in a high-z un-lensed galaxy - near the outer radio lobe to
the east, and near the bend of the radio jet to the west of the radio galaxy.
No underlying 246GHz continuum emission is seen at either position. We suggest
that the H2O emission is excited in the cooling region behind slow (10-40km/s)
shocks in dense molecular gas (10^{3-5} cm^-3). The extended water emission is
likely evidence of the radio jet's impact in cooling and forming molecules in
the post-shocked gas in the halo and inter-cluster gas similar to what is seen
in low-z clusters and other high-z radio galaxies. These observations imply
that the passage of the radio jet in the interstellar and inter-cluster medium
not only heats gas to high temperatures as is commonly assumed or found in
simulations, but also induces cooling and dissipation which can lead to
substantial amounts of cold dense molecular gas. The formation of molecules and
strong dissipation in the halo gas of MRC1138-262 may explain both the extended
diffuse molecular gas and young stars observed around MRC1138-262.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.01561 [pdf] - 1341300
Semi-Analytic Model Predictions of the Galaxy Population in
Proto-clusters
Submitted: 2015-12-04
We investigate the galaxy population in simulated proto-cluster regions using
a semi-analytic model of galaxy formation, coupled to merger trees extracted
from N-body simulations. We select the most massive clusters at redshift $z=0$
from our set of simulations, and follow their main progenitors back in time.
The analysis shows that proto-cluster regions are dominated by central galaxies
and their number decreases with time as many become satellites, clustering
around the central object. In agreement with observations, we find an
increasing velocity dispersion with cosmic time, the increase being faster for
satellites. The analysis shows that proto-clusters are very extended regions,
$\gtrsim 20 \, Mpc$ at $z \gtrsim 1$. The fraction of galaxies in proto-cluster
regions that are not progenitor of cluster galaxies varies with redshift,
stellar mass and area considered. It is about 20-30 per cent for galaxies with
stellar mass $\sim 10^9\,{\rm M}_{\sun}$, while negligible for the most massive
galaxies considered. Nevertheless, these objects have properties similar to
those of progenitors. We investigate the building-up of the passive-sequence in
clusters, and find that their progenitors are on average always active at any
redshift of interest of proto-clusters. The main mechanism which quenches their
star formation is the removal of the hot gas reservoir at the time of
accretion. The later galaxies are accreted (become satellite), and the more the
cold gas available, the longer the time spent as active. Central galaxies are
active over all redshift range considered, although a non-negligible fraction
of them become passive at redshift $z<1$, due to strong feedback from Active
Galactic Nuclei.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.05150 [pdf] - 1347629
A mature galaxy cluster at z=1.58 around the radio galaxy 7C1753+6311
Cooke, E. A.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Stern, D.;
Rettura, A.;
Brodwin, M.;
Galametz, A.;
Wylezalek, D.;
Bridge, C.;
Conselice, C. J.;
De Breuck, C.;
Gonzalez, A. H.;
Jarvis, M.
Submitted: 2015-11-16
We report on the discovery of a z=1.58 mature cluster around the
high-redshift radio galaxy 7C1753+6311, first identified in the Clusters Around
Radio-Loud AGN survey. Two-thirds of the excess galaxies within the central
1Mpc lie on a red sequence with a colour that is consistent with an average
formation redshift of zf~3. We show that 80+/-6% of the red sequence galaxies
in the cluster core are quiescent, while the remaining 20% are red due to dusty
star formation. We demonstrate that the cluster has an enhanced quiescent
galaxy fraction that is three times that of the control field. We also show
that this enhancement is mass dependent: 91+/-9% of the M* >10^{10.5}Msun
cluster galaxies are quiescent, compared to only 36+/-2% of field galaxies,
whereas the fraction of quiescent galaxies with lower masses is the same in the
cluster and field environments. The presence of a dense core and a well-formed,
quiescent red sequence suggest that this is a mature cluster. This means that
distant radio galaxies do not solely reside in young, uncollapsed
protoclusters, rather they can be found in clusters in a wide range of
evolutionary states.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.00350 [pdf] - 1259119
The formation history of massive cluster galaxies as revealed by CARLA
Cooke, E. A.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Rettura, A.;
Wylezalek, D.;
Galametz, A.;
Stern, D.;
Brodwin, M.;
Muldrew, S. I.;
Almaini, O.;
Conselice, C. J.;
Eisenhardt, P. R.;
Hartley, W. G.;
Jarvis, M.;
Seymour, N.;
Stanford, S. A.
Submitted: 2015-07-01
We use a sample of 37 of the densest clusters and protoclusters across $1.3
\le z \le 3.2$ from the Clusters Around Radio-Loud AGN (CARLA) survey to study
the formation of massive cluster galaxies. We use optical $i'$-band and
infrared 3.6$\mu$m and 4.5$\mu$m images to statistically select sources within
these protoclusters and measure their median observed colours; $\langle
i'-[3.6] \rangle$. We find the abundance of massive galaxies within the
protoclusters increases with decreasing redshift, suggesting these objects may
form an evolutionary sequence, with the lower redshift clusters in the sample
having similar properties to the descendants of the high redshift
protoclusters. We find that the protocluster galaxies have an approximately
unevolving observed-frame $i'-[3.6]$ colour across the examined redshift range.
We compare the evolution of the $\langle i'-[3.6] \rangle$ colour of massive
cluster galaxies with simplistic galaxy formation models. Taking the full
cluster population into account, we show that the formation of stars within the
majority of massive cluster galaxies occurs over at least 2Gyr, and peaks at $z
\sim 2$-3. From the median $i'-[3.6]$ colours we cannot determine the star
formation histories of individual galaxies, but their star formation must have
been rapidly terminated to produce the observed red colours. Finally, we show
that massive galaxies at $z>2$ must have assembled within 0.5Gyr of them
forming a significant fraction of their stars. This means that few massive
galaxies in $z>2$ protoclusters could have formed via dry mergers.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.08835 [pdf] - 1259103
What are Protoclusters? -- Defining High Redshift Galaxy Clusters and
Protoclusters
Submitted: 2015-06-29
We explore the structures of protoclusters and their relationship with high
redshift clusters using the Millennium Simulation combined with a semi-analytic
model. We find that protoclusters are very extended, with 90 per cent of their
mass spread across $\sim35\,h^{-1}{\rm Mpc}$ comoving at $z=2$ ($\sim30\,
\rm{arcmin}$). The `main halo', which can manifest as a high redshift cluster
or group, is only a minor feature of the protocluster, containing less than 20
per cent of all protocluster galaxies at $z=2$. Furthermore, many protoclusters
do not contain a main halo that is massive enough to be identified as a high
redshift cluster. Protoclusters exist in a range of evolutionary states at high
redshift, independent of the mass they will evolve to at $z=0$. We show that
the evolutionary state of a protocluster can be approximated by the mass ratio
of the first and second most massive haloes within the protocluster, and the
$z=0$ mass of a protocluster can be estimated to within 0.2 dex accuracy if
both the mass of the main halo and the evolutionary state is known. We also
investigate the biases introduced by only observing star-forming protocluster
members within small fields. The star formation rate required for line-emitting
galaxies to be detected is typically high, which leads to the artificial loss
of low mass galaxies from the protocluster sample. This effect is stronger for
observations of the centre of the protocluster, where the quenched galaxy
fraction is higher. This loss of low mass galaxies, relative to the field,
distorts the size of the galaxy overdensity, which in turn can contribute to
errors in predicting the $z=0$ evolved mass.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.3730 [pdf] - 882044
An excess of dusty starbursts related to the Spiderweb galaxy
Dannerbauer, H.;
Kurk, J. D.;
De Breuck, C.;
Wylezalek, D.;
Santos, J. S.;
Koyama, Y.;
Seymour, N.;
Tanaka, M.;
Hatch, N.;
Altieri, B.;
Coia, D.;
Galametz, A.;
Kodama, T.;
Miley, G.;
Röttgering, H.;
Sanchez-Portal, M.;
Valtchanov, I.;
Venemans, B.;
Ziegler, B.
Submitted: 2014-10-14
We present APEX LABOCA 870 micron observations of the field around the
high-redshift radio galaxy MRC1138-262 at z=2.16. We detect 16 submillimeter
galaxies in this ~140 square arcmin bolometer map with flux densities in the
range 3-11 mJy. The raw number counts indicate a density of submillimeter
galaxies (SMGs) that is up to four times that of blank field surveys. Based on
an exquisite multiwavelength database, including VLA 1.4 GHz radio and infrared
observations, we investigate whether these sources are members of the
protocluster structure at z=2.2. Using Herschel PACS+SPIRE and Spitzer MIPS
photometry, we derive reliable far-infrared photometric redshifts for all
sources. Follow-up VLT ISAAC and SINFONI near-infrared spectra confirm that
four of these SMGs have redshifts of z=2.2. We also present evidence that
another SMG in this field, detected earlier at 850 micron, has a counterpart
that exhibits Halpha and CO(1-0) emission at z=2.15. Including the radio galaxy
and two SMGs with far-IR photometric redshifts at z=2.2, we conclude that at
least eight submm sources are part of the protocluster at z=2.16 associated
with the radio galaxy MRC1138-262. We measure a star formation rate density
SFRD ~1500 Msun yr^-1 Mpc^-3, four magnitudes higher than the global SFRD of
blank fields at this redshift. Strikingly, these eight sources are concentrated
within a region of 2 Mpc (the typical size of clusters in the local universe)
and are distributed within the filaments traced by the Halpha emitters at
z=2.2. This concentration of massive, dusty starbursts is not centered on the
submillimeter-bright radio galaxy which could support the infalling of these
sources into the cluster center. Approximately half (6/11) of the SMGs that are
covered by the Halpha imaging data are associated with Halpha emitters,
demonstrating the potential of tracing SMG counterparts with this population
(abridged).
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.1218 [pdf] - 1216676
Why z > 1 radio-loud galaxies are commonly located in proto-clusters
Hatch, N. A.;
Wylezalek, D.;
Kurk, J. D.;
Stern, D.;
De Breuck, C.;
Jarvis, M. J.;
Galametz, A.;
Gonzalez, A. H.;
Hartley, W. G.;
Mortlock, A.;
Seymour, N.;
Stevens, J. A.
Submitted: 2014-09-03
Distant powerful radio-loud active galactic nuclei (RLAGN) tend to reside in
dense environments and are commonly found in proto-clusters at z > 1.3. We
examine whether this occurs because RLAGN are hosted by massive galaxies, which
preferentially reside in rich environments. We compare the environments of
powerful RLAGN at 1.3 < z < 3.2 from the CARLA survey to a sample of
radio-quiet galaxies matched in mass and redshift. We find the environments of
RLAGN are significantly denser than those of radio-quiet galaxies, implying
that not more than 50% of massive galaxies in this epoch can host powerful
radio-loud jets. This is not an observational selection effect as we find no
evidence to suggest it is easier to observe the radio emission when the galaxy
resides in a dense environment. We therefore suggest that the dense Mpc-scale
environment fosters the formation of a radio-jet from an AGN. We show that the
number density of potential RLAGN host galaxies is consistent with every >
10^14 solar mass cluster having experienced powerful radio-loud feedback of
duration ~60 Myr during 1.3 < z < 3.2. This feedback could heat the
intracluster medium to the extent of 0.5-1 keV per gas particle, which could
limit the amount of gas available for further star formation in the
proto-cluster galaxies.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.3114 [pdf] - 862776
A Trio of GRB-SNe: GRB 120729A, GRB 130215A / SN 2013ez and GRB 130831A
/ SN 2013fu
Cano, Z.;
Postigo, A. de Ugarte;
Pozanenko, A.;
Butler, N.;
Thone, C. C.;
Guidorzi, C.;
Kruhler, T.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Leloudas, G.;
Malesani, D.;
Hjorth, J.;
Melandri, A.;
Mundell, C.;
Wiersema, K.;
D'Avanzo, P.;
Schulze, S.;
Gomboc, A.;
Johansson, A.;
Zheng, W.;
Kann, D. A.;
Knust, F.;
Varela, K.;
Akerlof, C. W.;
Bloom, J.;
Burkhonov, O.;
Cooke, E.;
de Diego, J. A.;
Dhungana, G.;
Farina, C.;
Ferrante, F. V.;
Flewelling, H. A.;
Fox, O. D.;
Fynbo, J.;
Gehrels, N.;
Georgiev, L.;
Gonzalez, J. J.;
Greiner, J.;
Guver, T.;
Hartoog, O.;
Hatch, N.;
Jelinek, M;
Kehoe, R.;
Klose, S.;
Klunko, E.;
Kopac, D.;
Kutyrev, A.;
Krugl, Y.;
Lee, W. H.;
Levan, A.;
Linkov, V.;
Matkin, A.;
Minikulov, N.;
Molotov, I.;
Prochaska, J. Xavier;
Richer, M. G.;
Roman-Zuniga, C. G.;
Rumyantsev, V.;
Sanchez-Ramirez, R.;
Steele, I.;
Tanvir, N. R.;
Volnova, A.;
Watson, A. M.;
Xu, D.;
Yuan, F.
Submitted: 2014-05-13
We present optical and near-infrared (NIR) photometry for three gamma-ray
burst supernovae (GRB-SNe): GRB 120729A, GRB 130215A / SN 2013ez and GRB
130831A / SN 2013fu. In the case of GRB 130215A / SN 2013ez, we also present
optical spectroscopy at t-t0=16.1 d, which covers rest-frame 3000-6250
Angstroms. Based on Fe II (5169) and Si (II) (6355), our spectrum indicates an
unusually low expansion velocity of 4000-6350 km/s, the lowest ever measured
for a GRB-SN. Additionally, we determined the brightness and shape of each
accompanying SN relative to a template supernova (SN 1998bw), which were used
to estimate the amount of nickel produced via nucleosynthesis during each
explosion. We find that our derived nickel masses are typical of other GRB-SNe,
and greater than those of SNe Ibc that are not associated with GRBs. For GRB
130831A / SN 2013fu, we use our well-sampled R-band light curve (LC) to
estimate the amount of ejecta mass and the kinetic energy of the SN, finding
that these too are similar to other GRB-SNe. For GRB 130215A, we take advantage
of contemporaneous optical/NIR observations to construct an optical/NIR
bolometric LC of the afterglow. We fit the bolometric LC with the millisecond
magnetar model of Zhang & Meszaros (2001), which considers dipole radiation as
a source of energy injection to the forward shock powering the optical/NIR
afterglow. Using this model we derive an initial spin period of P=12 ms and a
magnetic field of B=1.1 x 10^15 G, which are commensurate with those found for
proposed magnetar central engines of other long-duration GRBs.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.1080 [pdf] - 1208796
Rapidly growing black holes and host galaxies in the distant Universe
from the Herschel Radio Galaxy Evolution Project
Drouart, G.;
De Breuck, C.;
Vernet, J.;
Seymour, N.;
Lehnert, M.;
Barthel, P.;
Bauer, F. E.;
Ibar, E.;
Galametz, A.;
Haas, M.;
Hatch, N.;
Mullaney, J. R.;
Nesvadba, N.;
Rocca-Volmerange, B.;
Rottgering, H. J. A.;
Stern, D.;
Wylezalek, D.
Submitted: 2014-04-03
We present results from a survey of 70 radio galaxies (RGs) at redshifts
1<z<5.2 using the PACS and SPIRE on-board Herschel. Combined with existing
mid-IR photometry from Spitzer and observations obtained with LABOCA, the SEDs
of galaxies in our sample are continuously covered across 3.6-870um. The total
infrared luminosities of these RGs are such that they almost all are either
ultra-or hyper-luminous infrared galaxies. We fit the infrared SEDs with a set
of empirical templates which represent dust heated (1) by a variety of SB and
(2) by a AGN. We find that the SEDs of RGs require the dust to be heated by
both AGN and SB, but the luminosities of these two components are not strongly
correlated. Assuming empirical relations and simple physical assumptions, we
calculate the SFR, the black hole mass accretion rate (MdotBH), and the black
hole mass (MBH) for each RG. We find that the host galaxies and their BHs are
growing extremely rapidly, having SFR~100-5000 Msun/yr and MdotBH~1-100
Msun/yr. The mean sSFR of RGs at z>2.5 are higher than the sSFR of typical
star-forming galaxies over the same redshift range but are similar or perhaps
lower than the galaxy population for RGs at z<2.5. By comparing the sSFR and
the specific black hole mass accretion rate, we conclude that BHs in radio loud
AGN are already, or soon will be, overly massive compared to their host
galaxies in terms of expectations from the local MBH-MGal relation. In order to
``catch up'' with the BH, the galaxies require about an order-of magnitude more
time to grow in mass, at the observed SFRs, compared to the time the BH is
actively accreting. However, during the current cycle of activity, we argue
that this catching-up is likely to be difficult due to the short gas depletion
times. Finally, we speculate on how the host galaxies might grow sufficiently
in stellar mass to ultimately fall onto the local MBH-MGal relation.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.4259 [pdf] - 1208433
A z=2.5 protocluster associated with the radio galaxy MRC 2104-242: star
formation and differing mass functions in dense environments
Submitted: 2014-03-17
We present results from a narrow-band survey of the field around the high
redshift radio galaxy MRC 2104-242. We have selected Halpha emitters in a
7sq.arcmin field and compared the measured number density with that of a field
sample at similar redshift. We find that MRC 2104-242 lies in an overdensity of
galaxies that is 8.0 +/- 0.8 times the average density of a blank field,
suggesting it resides in a large-scale structure that may eventually collapse
to form a massive cluster. We find that there is more dust obscured star
formation in the protocluster galaxies than in similarly selected control field
galaxies and there is tentative evidence of a higher fraction of starbursting
galaxies in the denser environment. However, on average we do not find a
difference between the star formation rate (SFR)-mass relations of the
protocluster and field galaxies and so conclude that the SFR of these galaxies
at z~2.5 is governed predominantly by galaxy mass and not the host environment.
We also find that the stellar mass distribution of the protocluster galaxies is
skewed towards higher masses and there is a significant lack of galaxies at M <
10^10Msun within our small field of view. Based on the level of overdensity we
expect to find ~22 star forming galaxies below 10^10Msun in the protocluster
and do not detect any. This lack of low mass galaxies affects the level of
overdensity which we detect. If we only consider high mass (M > 10^10.5Msun)
galaxies, the density of the protocluster field increases to ~55 times the
control field density.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.2390 [pdf] - 1208292
The Galaxy Cluster Mid-Infrared Luminosity Function at 1.3<z<3.2
Wylezalek, Dominika;
Vernet, Joël;
De Breuck, Carlos;
Stern, Daniel;
Brodwin, Mark;
Galametz, Audrey;
Gonzalez, Anthony H.;
Jarvis, Matt;
Hatch, Nina;
Seymour, Nick;
Stanford, Spencer A.
Submitted: 2014-03-10
We present 4.5 {\mu}m luminosity functions for galaxies identified in 178
candidate galaxy clusters at 1.3 < z < 3.2. The clusters were identified as
Spitzer/IRAC color-selected overdensities in the Clusters Around Radio-Loud AGN
(CARLA) project, which imaged 421 powerful radio-loud AGN at z > 1.3. The
luminosity functions are derived for different redshift and richness bins, and
the IRAC imaging reaches depths of m*+2, allowing us to measure the faint end
slopes of the luminosity functions. We find that {\alpha} = -1 describes the
luminosity function very well in all redshifts bins and does not evolve
significantly. This provides evidence that the rate at which the low mass
galaxy population grows through star formation, gets quenched and is
replenished by in-falling field galaxies does not have a major net effect on
the shape of the luminosity function. Our measurements for m* are consistent
with passive evolution models and high formation redshifts z_f ~ 3. We find a
slight trend towards fainter m* for the richest clusters, implying that the
most massive clusters in our sample could contain older stellar populations,
yet another example of cosmic downsizing. Modelling shows that a contribution
of a star-forming population of up to 40% cannot be ruled out. This value,
found from our targeted survey, is significantly lower than the values found
for slightly lower redshift, z ~ 1, clusters found in wide-field surveys. The
results are consistent with cosmic downsizing, as the clusters studied here
were all found in the vicinity of radio-loud AGNs -- which have proven to be
preferentially located in massive dark matter halos in the richest environments
at high redshift -- they may therefore be older and more evolved systems than
the general protocluster population.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.5710 [pdf] - 1180115
Searching for large-scale structures around high-redshift radio galaxies
with Herschel
Rigby, E. E.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Sibthorpe, B.;
Chiang, Y. K.;
Overzier, R.;
Herbonnet, R.;
Borgani, S.;
Clements, D. L.;
Dannerbauer, H.;
De Breuck, C.;
De Lucia, G.;
Kurk, J.;
Maschietto, F.;
Miley, G.;
Saro, A.;
Seymour, N.;
Venemans, B.
Submitted: 2013-10-21
This paper presents the first results of a far-infrared search for
protocluster-associated galaxy overdensities using the SPIRE instrument
on-board the {\it Herschel} Space Observatory. Large ($\sim$400 arcmin$^{2}$)
fields surrounding 26 powerful high-redshift radio galaxies ($2.0 < z < 4.1$;
$L_{\rm 500 MHz} > 10^{28.5}$ WHz$^{-1}$) are mapped at 250, 350 and 500\mic to
give a unique wide-field sample.
On average the fields have a higher than expected, compared to blank fields,
surface density of 500\mic sources within 6 comoving Mpc of the radio galaxy.
The analysis is then restricted to potential protocluster members only, which
are identified using a far-infrared colour selection; this reveals significant
overdensities of galaxies in 2 fields, neither of which are previously known
protoclusters. The probability of finding 2 overdensities of this size by
chance, given the number of fields observed is $5 \times 10^{-4}$.
Overdensities here exist around radio galaxies with $L_{\rm 500 MHz} \gtrsim
10^{29}$ WHz$^{-1}$ and $z < 3$. The radial extent of the average far-infrared
overdensity is found to be $\sim$6 comoving Mpc.
Comparison with predictions from numerical simulations shows that the
overdensities are consistent with having masses $> 10^{14}$Msolar. However, the
large uncertainty in the redshift estimation means that it is possible that
these far-infrared overdensities consist of several structures across the
redshift range searched.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.6645 [pdf] - 1179498
A large-scale galaxy structure at z = 2.02 associated with the radio
galaxy MRC0156-252
Galametz, Audrey;
Stern, Daniel;
Pentericci, Laura;
De Breuck, Carlos;
Vernet, Joel;
Wylezalek, Dominika;
Fassbender, Rene;
Hatch, Nina;
Kurk, Jaron;
Overzier, Roderik;
Rettura, Alessandro;
Seymour, Nick
Submitted: 2013-09-25, last modified: 2013-10-01
We present the spectroscopic confirmation of a structure of galaxies
surrounding the radio galaxy MRC0156-252 at z = 2.02. The structure was
initially discovered as an overdensity of both near-infrared selected z > 1.6
and mid-infrared selected z > 1.2 galaxy candidates. We used the VLT/FORS2
multi-object spectrograph to target ~80 high-redshift galaxy candidates, and
obtain robust spectroscopic redshifts for more than half the targets. The
majority of the confirmed sources are star-forming galaxies at z > 1.5. In
addition to the radio galaxy, two of its close-by companions (< 6'') also show
AGN signatures. Ten sources, including the radio galaxy, lie within |z - 2.020
| < 0.015 (i.e., velocity offsets < 1500 km/s) and within projected 2 Mpc
comoving of the radio galaxy. Additional evidence suggests not only that the
galaxy structure associated with MRC0156-252 is a forming galaxy cluster but
also that this structure is most probably embedded in a larger scale structure.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.5954 [pdf] - 1179435
The host galaxy of the z=2.4 radio-loud AGN MRC 0406-244 as seen by HST
Hatch, N. A.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Miley, G. K.;
Rigby, E.;
De Breuck, C.;
Ford, H.;
Kuiper, E.;
Kurk, J. D.;
Overzier, R. A.;
Pentericci, L.
Submitted: 2013-09-23
We present multicolour Hubble Space Telescope images of the powerful z=2.4
radio galaxy MRC 0406-244 and model its complex morphology with several
components including a host galaxy, a point source, and extended nebular and
continuum emission. We suggest that the main progenitor of this radio galaxy
was a normal, albeit massive (M ~10^{11} solar masses), star-forming galaxy.
The optical stellar disc of the host galaxy is smooth and well described by a
S\'ersic profile, which argues against a recent major merger, however there is
also a point-source component which may be the remnant of a minor merger. The
half-light radius of the optical disc is constrained to lie in the range 3.5 to
8.2kpc, which is of similar size to coeval star forming galaxies.
Biconical shells of nebular emission and UV-bright continuum extend out from
the host galaxy along the radio jet axis, which is also the minor axis of the
host galaxy. The origin of the continuum emission is uncertain, but it is most
likely to be young stars or dust-scattered light from the AGN, and it is
possible that stars are forming from this material at a rate of
200^{+1420}_{-110} solar masses per year.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.2926 [pdf] - 1166596
Resolving the optical emission lines of Lya blob 'B1' at z=2.38: another
hidden quasar
Submitted: 2013-05-13
We have used the SINFONI near-infrared integral field unit on the VLT to
resolve the optical emission line structure of one of the brightest (L~1e44
erg/s) and nearest (z=2.38) of all Lya blobs (LABs). The target, known in the
literature as object 'B1' (Francis et al. 1996), lies at a redshift where the
main optical emission lines are accessible in the observed near-infrared. We
detect luminous [OIII]4959,5007A and Ha emission with a spatial extent of at
least 32x40 kpc (4"x5"). The dominant optical emission line component shows
relatively broad lines (600-800 km/s, FWHM) and line ratios consistent with
AGN-photoionization. The new evidence for AGN photoionization, combined with
previously detected CIV and luminous, warm infrared emission, suggest that B1
is the site of a hidden quasar. This is confirmed by the fact that [OII] is
relatively weak compared to [OIII] (extinction-corrected [OIII]/[OII] of about
3.8), which is indicative of a high, Seyfert-like ionization parameter. From
the [OIII] luminosity we infer a bolometric AGN luminosity of ~3e46 erg/s, and
further conclude that the obscured AGN may be Compton-thick given existing
X-ray limits. The large line widths observed are consistent with clouds moving
within the narrow line region of a luminous QSO. The AGN scenario is capable of
producing sufficient ionizing photons to power the Lya, even in the presence of
dust. By performing a census of similar objects in the literature, we find that
virtually all luminous LABs harbor obscured quasars. Based on simple duty-cycle
arguments, we conclude that AGN are the main drivers of the Lya in LABs rather
than the gravitational heating and subsequent cooling suggested by cold stream
models. We also conclude that the empirical relation between LABs and overdense
environments at high redshift must be due to a more fundamental correlation
between AGN (or massive galaxies) and environment.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.0770 [pdf] - 1165689
Galaxy Clusters around radio-loud AGN at 1.3 < z < 3.2 as seen by
Spitzer
Wylezalek, D.;
Galametz, A.;
Stern, D.;
Vernet, J.;
De Breuck, C.;
Seymour, N.;
Brodwin, M.;
Eisenhardt, P. M.;
Gonzalez, A. H.;
Hatch, N.;
Jarvis, M.;
Rettura, A.;
Stanford, S. A.;
Stevens, J. A.
Submitted: 2013-04-02
We report the first results from the Clusters Around Radio-Loud AGN (CARLA)
program, a Cycle 7 and 8 Spitzer Space Telescope snapshot program to
investigate the environments of a large sample of obscured and unobscured
luminous radio-loud AGN at 1.2 < z < 3.2. These data, obtained for 387 fields,
reach 3.6 and 4.5 um depths of [3.6] (AB) = 22.6 and [4.5] (AB) = 22.9 at the
95% completeness level, which is two to three times fainter than L* in this
redshift range. By using the color cut [3.6]-[4.5] > -0.1 (AB), which
efficiently selects high-redshift (z > 1.3) galaxies of all types, we identify
galaxy cluster member candidates in the fields of the radio-loud AGN. The local
density of these IRAC-selected sources is compared to the density of similarly
selected sources in blank fields. We find that 92% of the radio-loud AGN reside
in environments richer than average. The majority (55%) of the radio-loud AGN
fields are found to be overdense at a > 2 {\sigma} level; 10% are overdense at
a > 5 {\sigma} level. A clear rise in surface density of IRAC-selected sources
towards the position of the radio-loud AGN strongly supports an association of
the majority of the IRAC-selected sources with the radio-loud AGN. Our results
provide solid statistical evidence that radio-loud AGN are likely beacons for
finding high-redshift galaxy (proto-)clusters. We investigate how environment
depends on AGN type (unobscured radio-loud quasars vs. obscured radio
galaxies), radio luminosity and redshift, finding no correlation with either
AGN type or radio luminosity. We find a decrease in density with redshift,
consistent with galaxy evolution for this uniform, flux-limited survey. These
results are consistent with expectations from the orientation-driven AGN
unification model, at least for the high radio luminosity regimes considered in
this sample.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.6361 [pdf] - 1152390
The Herschel view of the environment of the radio galaxy 4C+41.17 at z =
3.8
Wylezalek, D.;
Vernet, J.;
De Breuck, C.;
Stern, D.;
Galametz, A.;
Seymour, N.;
Jarvis, M.;
Barthel, P.;
Drouart, G.;
Greve, T. R.;
Haas, M.;
Hatch, N.;
Ivison, R.;
Lehnert, M.;
Meisenheimer, K.;
Miley, G.;
Nesvadba, N.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Stevens, J. A.
Submitted: 2012-10-23
We present Herschel observations at 70, 160, 250, 350 and 500 micron of the
environment of the radio galaxy 4C+41.17 at z = 3.792. About 65% of the
extracted sources are securely identified with mid-IR sources observed with the
Spitzer Space Telescope at 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, 8 and 24 micron. We derive simple
photometric redshifts, also including existing 850 micron and 1200 micron data,
using templates of AGN, starburst-dominated systems and evolved stellar
populations. We find that most of the Herschel sources are foreground to the
radio galaxy and therefore do not belong to a structure associated with
4C+41.17. We do, however, find that the SED of the closest (~ 25" offset)
source to the radio galaxy is fully consistent with being at the same redshift
as 4C+41.17. We show that finding such a bright source that close to the radio
galaxy at the same redshift is a very unlikely event, making the environment of
4C+41.17 a special case. We demonstrate that multi-wavelength data, in
particular on the Rayleigh-Jeans side of the spectral energy distribution,
allow us to confirm or rule out the presence of protocluster candidates that
were previously selected by single wavelength data sets.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.5821 [pdf] - 1124380
Rapid Coeval Black Hole and Host Galaxy Growth in MRC 1138-262: The
Hungry Spider
Seymour, N.;
Altieri, B.;
De Breuck, C.;
Barthel, P.;
Coia, D.;
Conversi, L.;
Dannerbauer, H.;
Dey, A.;
Dickinson, M.;
Drouart, G.;
Galametz, A.;
Greve, T. R.;
Haas, M.;
Hatch, N.;
Ibar, E.;
Ivison, R.;
Jarvis, M.;
Kovacs, A.;
Kurk, J.;
Lehnert, M.;
Miley, G.;
Nesvadba, N.;
Rawlings, J. I.;
Rettura, A.;
Rottgering, H.;
Rocca-Volmerange, B.;
Sanchez-Portal, M.;
Santos, J. S.;
Stern, D.;
Stevens, J.;
Valtchanov, I.;
Vernet, J.;
Wylezalek, D.
Submitted: 2012-06-25
We present a detailed study of the infrared spectral energy distribution of
the high-redshift radio galaxy MRC 1138-26 at z = 2.156, also known as the
Spiderweb Galaxy. By combining photometry from Spitzer, Herschel and LABOCA we
fit the rest-frame 5-300 um emission using a two component, starburst and
active galactic nucleus (AGN), model. The total infrared (8 - 1000 um)
luminosity of this galaxy is (1.97+/-0.28)x10^13 Lsun with (1.17+/-0.27) and
(0.79+/-0.09)x10^13 Lsun due to the AGN and starburst components respectively.
The high derived AGN accretion rate of \sim20% Eddington, and the measured star
formation rate (SFR) of 1390pm150 Msun/yr, suggest that this massive system is
in a special phase of rapid central black hole and host galaxy growth, likely
caused by a gas rich merger in a dense environment. The accretion rate is
sufficient to power both the jets and the previously observed large outflow.
The high SFR and strong outflow suggest this galaxy could potentially exhaust
its fuel for stellar growth in a few tens of Myr, although the likely merger of
the radio galaxy with nearby satellites suggest bursts of star formation may
recur again on time scales of several hundreds of Myr. The age of the radio
lobes implies the jet started after the current burst of star formation, and
therefore we are possibly witnessing the transition from a merger-induced
starburst phase to a radio-loud AGN phase. We also note tentative evidence for
[CII]158um emission. This paper marks the first results from the Herschel
Galaxy Evolution Project (Project HeRGE), a systematic study of the
evolutionary state of 71 high redshift, 1 < z < 5.2, radio galaxies.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.2196 [pdf] - 1117204
A z~3 radio galaxy and its protocluster: evidence for a superstructure?
Submitted: 2012-03-09
We present spectroscopic follow-up observations of Lyman Break Galaxies
(LBGs) selected in the field surrounding the radio galaxy MRC0316-257 at z~3.13
(0316). Robust spectroscopic redshifts are determined for 20 out of 24 objects.
Three of the spectroscopically confirmed galaxies have 3.12<z<3.13 indicating
that these objects reside in a protocluster structure previously found around
the radio galaxy. An additional 5 objects are found 1600 km/s blue-shifted with
respect to the main protocluster structure. This is in addition to three [OIII]
emitters found at this redshift in a previous study. This is further evidence
that a structure exists directly in front of the 0316 protocluster. We estimate
that the foreground structure is responsible for half of the surface
overdensity of LBGs found in the field as a whole. The foreground structure is
associated with a strong surface density peak 1.4 Mpc to the North-West of the
radio galaxy and a 2D Kolmogorov-Smirnov test indicates that the spatial
distributions of the 0316 and foreground galaxies differ at the 3 sigma level.
In addition, we compare the properties of protocluster, foreground structure
and field galaxies, but we find no significant differences. In terms of the
nature of the two structures, a merger scenario is a possible option. Simple
merger dynamics indicates that the observed relative velocity of 1600 km/s can
be reproduced if the two structures have masses of ~5x10^14 Msun and have
starting separations of around 2.5 to 3 Mpc. It is also possible that the
foreground structure is unrelated to the 0316 protocluster in which case the
two structures will not interact before z=0.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1202.4489 [pdf] - 1116772
The Mid-Infrared Environments of High-Redshift Radio Galaxies
Galametz, Audrey;
Stern, Daniel;
De Breuck, Carlos;
Hatch, Nina;
Mayo, Jack;
Miley, George;
Rettura, Alessandro;
Seymour, Nick;
Stanford, S. Adam;
Vernet, Joel
Submitted: 2012-02-20
Taking advantage of the impressive sensitivity of Spitzer to detect massive
galaxies at high redshift, we study the mid-infrared environments of powerful,
high-redshift radio galaxies at 1.2<z<3. Galaxy cluster member candidates were
isolated using a single Spitzer/IRAC mid-infrared color criterion,
[3.6]-[4.5]>-0.1 (AB), in the fields of 48 radio galaxies at 1.2<z<3. This
simple IRAC color selection is effective at identifying galaxies at z>1.2.
Using a counts-in-cell analysis, we identify a field as overdense when 15 or
more red IRAC sources are found within 1arcmin (i.e.,~0.5Mpc at 1.2<z<3) of the
radio galaxy to the 5sigma flux density limits of our IRAC data (f3.6=11.0uJy,
f4.5=13.4uJy). We find that radio galaxies lie preferentially in medium to
dense regions, with 73% of the targeted fields denser than average. Our
(shallow) 120s data permit the rediscovery of previously known clusters and
protoclusters associated with radio galaxies as well as the discovery of new
promising galaxy cluster candidates at z>1.2.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.0452 [pdf] - 1091353
Riding the wake of a merging galaxy cluster
Canning, R. E. A.;
Russell, H. R.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Zabludoff, A. I.;
Crawford, C. S.;
King, L. J.;
McNamara, B. R.;
Okamoto, S.;
Raimundo, S. I.
Submitted: 2011-11-02
Using WHT OASIS integral field unit observations, we report the discovery of
a thin plume of ionised gas extending from the brightest cluster galaxy in
Abell 2146 to the sub-cluster X-ray cool core which is offset from the BCG by
~37 kpc. The plume is greater than 15 kpc long and less than 3 kpc wide. This
plume is unique in that the cluster it is situated in is currently undergoing a
major galaxy cluster merger. The brightest cluster galaxy is unusually located
behind the X-ray shock front and in the wake of the ram pressure stripped X-ray
cool core and evidence for recent disruption to the BCG is observed. We examine
the gas and stellar morphology, the gas kinematics of the BCG and their
relation to the X-ray gas. We propose that a causal link between the ionised
gas plume and the offset X-ray cool core provides the simplest explanation for
the formation of the plume. An interaction or merger between the BCG and
another cluster galaxy is probably the cause of the offset.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.2757 [pdf] - 1083385
Herschel observations of the Centaurus cluster - the dynamics of cold
gas in a cool core
Mittal, Rupal;
O'Dea, Christopher P.;
Ferland, Gary;
Oonk, Raymond;
Edge, Alastair C.;
Canning, Rebecca E. A.;
Russell, Helen;
Baum, Stefi A.;
Böhringer, Hans;
Combes, Francoise;
Donahue, Megan;
Fabian, Andy C.;
Hatch, Nina A.;
Hoffer, Aaron;
Johnstone, Roderick;
McNamara, Brian R.;
Salomé, Philippe;
Tremblay, Grant
Submitted: 2011-08-13
Brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) in the cores of galaxy clusters have
distinctly different properties from other low redshift massive ellipticals.
The majority of the BCGs in cool-core clusters show signs of active star
formation. We present observations of NGC 4696, the BCG of the Centaurus galaxy
cluster, at far-infrared (FIR) wavelengths with the Herschel space telescope.
Using the PACS spectrometer, we detect the two strongest coolants of the
interstellar medium, CII at 157.74 micron and OI at 63.18 micron, and in
addition NII at 121.90 micron. The CII emission is extended over a region of 7
kpc with a similar spatial morphology and kinematics to the optical H-alpha
emission. This has the profound implication that the optical hydrogen
recombination line, H-alpha, the optical forbidden lines, NII 6583 Angstrom,
the soft X-ray filaments and the far-infrared CII line all have the same energy
source. We also detect dust emission using the PACS and SPIRE photometers at
all six wavebands. We perform a detailed spectral energy distribution fitting
using a two-component modified black-body function and find a cold 19 K dust
component with mass 1.6x10^6 solar mass and a warm 46 K dust component with
mass 4.0x10^3 solar mass. The total FIR luminosity between 8 micron and 1000
micron is 7.5x10^8 solar luminosity, which using Kennicutt relation yields a
low star formation rate of 0.13 solar mass per yr. This value is consistent
with values derived from other tracers, such as ultraviolet emission. Combining
the spectroscopic and photometric results together with optical H-alpha, we
model emitting clouds consisting of photodissociation regions (PDRs) adjacent
to ionized regions. We show that in addition to old and young stellar
populations, there is another source of energy, such as cosmic rays, shocks or
reconnection diffusion, required to excite the H-alpha and CII filaments.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1107.4011 [pdf] - 1078102
A deep spectroscopic study of the filamentary nebulosity in NGC4696, the
brightest cluster galaxy in the Centaurus cluster
Submitted: 2011-07-20
We present results of deep integral field spectroscopy observations using
high resolution optical (4150-7200 A) VIMOS VLT spectra, of NGC 4696, the
dominant galaxy in the Centaurus cluster (Abell 3526). After the Virgo cluster,
this is the second nearest (z=0.0104) example of a cool core cluster. NGC 4696
is surrounded by a vast, luminous H alpha emission line nebula (L = 2.2 \times
10^40 ergs per second). We explore the origin and excitation of the
emission-line filaments and find their origin consistent with being drawn out,
under rising radio bubbles, into the intracluster medium as in other similar
systems. Contrary to previous observations we do not observe evidence for shock
excitation of the outer filaments. Our optical spectra are consistent with the
recent particle heating excitation mechanism of Ferland et al.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.5495 [pdf] - 1077583
Discovery of a high-z protocluster with tunable filters: the case of
6C0140+326 at z=4.4
Kuiper, E.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Venemans, B. P.;
Miley, G. K.;
Rottgering, H. J. A.;
Kurk, J. D.;
Overzier, R. A.;
Pentericci, L.;
Bland-Hawthorn, J.;
Cepa, J.
Submitted: 2011-06-27
We present the first results obtained using a tunable narrowband filter in
the search for high-z protoclusters. Using the recently commissioned red
tunable filter on the Gran Telescopio Canarias we have searched for Lya
emitters in a 75 arcmin^2 field centered on the z=4.413 radio galaxy
6C0140+326. With three different wavelength tunings we find a total of 27
unique candidate Lya emitters. The availability of three different wavelength
tunings allows us to make estimates of the redshifts for each of the objects.
It also allows us to separate a possible protocluster from structure in the
immediate foreground. This division shows that the foreground region contains
significantly fewer Lya emitters. Also, the spatial distribution of the objects
in the protocluster field deviates from a random distribution at the 2.5 sigma
level. The observed redshift distribution of the emitters is different from the
expected distribution of a blank field at the ~3 sigma level, with the Lya
emitters concentrated near the radio galaxy at z>4.38. The 6C0140+326 field is
denser by a factor of 9+/-5 than a blank field, and the number density of Lya
emitters close to the radio galaxy is similar to that of the z~4.1 protocluster
around TNJ1338-1942. We thus conclude that there is an overdensity of Lya
emitters around the radio galaxy 6C0140+326. This is one of few known
overdensities at such a high redshift.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1104.1176 [pdf] - 1053217
A SINFONI view of flies in the Spiderweb: a galaxy cluster in the making
Kuiper, E.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Miley, G. K.;
Nesvadba, N. P. H.;
Rottgering, H. J. A.;
Kurk, J. D.;
Lehnert, M. D.;
Overzier, R. A.;
Pentericci, L.;
Schaye, J.;
Venemans, B. P.
Submitted: 2011-04-06
The environment of the high-z radio galaxy PKS 1138-262 at z~2.2 is a prime
example of a forming galaxy cluster. We use deep SINFONI data to perform a
detailed study of the kinematics of the galaxies within 60 kpc of the radio
core and we link this to the kinematics of the protocluster on the megaparsec
scale. Identification of optical emission lines shows that 11 galaxies are at
the redshift of the protocluster. The density of line emitters is more than an
order of magnitude higher in the core of the protocluster than the larger scale
environment. This implies a matter overdensity in the core of delta_m~70 which
is similar to the outskirts of local galaxy clusters. The velocity distribution
of the confirmed satellite galaxies shows a broad, double-peaked velocity
structure with sigma=1360+/-206 km/s. A similar broad, double-peaked
distribution was found in a previous study targeting the large scale
protocluster structure, indicating that a common process is acting on both
small and large scales. Including all spectroscopically confirmed protocluster
galaxies, a velocity dispersion of 1013+/-87 km/s is found. We show that the
protocluster has likely decoupled from the Hubble flow and is a dynamically
evolved structure. Comparison to the Millenium simulation indicates that the
protocluster velocity distribution is consistent with that of the most massive
haloes at z~2, but we rule out that the protocluster is a fully virialized
structure based on dynamical arguments and its X-ray luminosity. Comparison to
merging haloes in the Millennium simulation shows that the structure as
observed in and around the Spiderweb galaxy is best interpreted as being the
result of a merger between two massive haloes. We propose that this merger can
result in an increase in star formation and AGN activity in the protocluster
core and is possibly an important stage in the evolution of massive cD
galaxies.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.4364 [pdf] - 1052891
H-alpha emitters in z~2 proto-clusters: evidence for faster evolution in
dense environments
Submitted: 2011-03-22
This is a study of H-alpha emitters in two dense galaxy proto-clusters
surrounding radio galaxies at z~2. We show that the proto-cluster surrounding
MRC 1138-262 contains 14+/-2 times more H-alpha candidates than the average
field (9 sigma significance), and the z=2.35 radio galaxy 4C+10.48 is
surrounded by 12+/-2 times more emitters than the field (5 sigma), so it is
also likely to reside in a dense proto-cluster environment. We compared these
H-alpha emitters, situated in dense environments, to a control field sample
selected from 3 separate fields forming a total area of 172 arcmin^2. We
constructed and compared H-alpha and rest-frame R continuum luminosity
functions of the emitters in both environments. The star formation density is
on average 13 times greater in the proto-clusters than the field at z~2, so the
total star formation rate within the central 1.5Mpc of the proto-clusters
exceeds 3000Msun/yr. However, we found no significant difference in the shape
of the H-alpha luminosity functions, implying that environment does not
substantially affect the strength of the H-alpha line from strongly star
forming galaxies. The proto-cluster emitters are typically 0.8mag brighter in
rest-frame R continuum than field emitters, implying they are twice as massive
as their field counterparts at the same redshift. We also show the
proto-cluster galaxies have lower specific star formation rates than field
galaxies, meaning the emitters in the dense environments formed more of their
stars earlier than the field galaxies. We conclude that galaxy growth in the
early Universe was accelerated in dense environments, and that cluster galaxies
differed from field galaxies even before the cluster had fully formed.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.1765 [pdf] - 1052598
Far Ultraviolet Emission in the A2597 and A2204 Brightest Cluster
Galaxies
Submitted: 2011-03-09
We use the Hubble Space Telescope ACS/SBC and Very Large Telescope FORS
cameras to observe the Brightest Cluster Galaxies in Abell 2597 and Abell 2204
in the far-ultraviolet (FUV) F150LP and optical U, B, V, R, I Bessel filters.
The FUV and U band emission is enhanced in bright, filamentary structures
surrounding the BCG nuclei. These filaments can be traced out to 20 kpc from
the nuclei in the FUV. Excess FUV and U band light is determined by removing
emission due to the underlying old stellar population and mapped with 1 arcsec
spatial resolution over the central 20 kpc regions of both galaxies. We find
the FUV and U excess emission to be spatially coincident and a stellar
interpretation requires the existence of a significant amount of 10000-50000 K
stars. Correcting for nebular continuum emission and dust intrinsic to the BCG
further increases the FUV to U band emission ratio and implies that stars alone
may not suffice to explain the observations. However, lack of detailed
information on the gas and dust distribution and extinction law in these
systems prevents us from ruling out a purely stellar origin. Non-stellar
processes, such as the central AGN, Scattering, Synchrotron and Bremsstrahlung
emission are investigated and found to not be able to explain the FUV and U
band measurements in A2597. Contributions from non-thermal processes not
treated here should be investigated. Comparing the FUV emission to the optical
H-alpha line emitting nebula shows good agreement on kpc-scales in both A2597
and A2204. In concordance with an earlier investigation by O'Dea et al. (2004)
we find that O-stars can account for the ionising photons necessary to explain
the observed H-alpha line emission.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:1009.2581 [pdf] - 1034942
Detection of optical coronal emission from 10^6 K gas in the core of the
Centaurus cluster
Submitted: 2010-09-14
We report a detection (3.5x10^37 \pm 5.6x10^36 ergps) of the optical coronal
emission line [Fe X]6374 and upper limits of four other coronal lines using
high resolution VIMOS spectra centred on NGC 4696, the brightest cluster galaxy
in the Centaurus cluster. Emission from these lines is indicative of gas at
temperatures between 1 and 5 million K so traces the interstellar gas in NGC
4696. The rate of cooling derived from the upper limits is consistent with the
cooling rate from X-ray observations (~10 solar masses per year) however we
detect twice the luminosity expected for [Fe X]6374 emission, at 1 million K,
our lowest temperature probe. We suggest this emission is due to the gas being
heated rather than cooling out of the intracluster medium. We detect no coronal
lines from [Ca XV], which are expected from the 5 million K gas seen near the
centre in X-rays with Chandra. Calcium is however likely to be depleted from
the gas phase onto dust grains in the central regions of NGC 4696.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.4588 [pdf] - 1034521
Galaxy protocluster candidates around z ~ 2.4 radio galaxies
Hatch, N. A.;
De Breuck, C.;
Galametz, A.;
Miley, G. K.;
Overzier, R. A.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Doherty, M.;
Kodama, T.;
Kurk, J. D.;
Seymour, N.;
Venemans, B. P.;
Vernet, J.;
Zirm, A. W.
Submitted: 2010-08-26
We study the environments of 6 radio galaxies at 2.2 < z < 2.6 using
wide-field near-infrared images. We use colour cuts to identify galaxies in
this redshift range, and find that three of the radio galaxies are surrounded
by significant surface overdensities of such galaxies. The excess galaxies that
comprise these overdensities are strongly clustered, suggesting they are
physically associated. The colour distribution of the galaxies responsible for
the overdensity are consistent with those of galaxies that lie within a narrow
redshift range at z ~ 2.4. Thus the excess galaxies are consistent with being
companions of the radio galaxies. The overdensities have estimated masses in
excess of 10^14 solar masses, and are dense enough to collapse into virizalised
structures by the present day: these structures may evolve into groups or
clusters of galaxies. A flux-limited sample of protocluster galaxies with K <
20.6 mag is derived by statistically subtracting the fore- and background
galaxies. The colour distribution of the protocluster galaxies is bimodal,
consisting of a dominant blue sequence, comprising 77 +/- 10% of the galaxies,
and a poorly populated red sequence. The blue protocluster galaxies have
similar colours to local star-forming irregular galaxies (U -V ~ 0.6),
suggesting most protocluster galaxies are still forming stars at the observed
epoch. The blue colours and lack of a dominant protocluster red sequence
implies that these cluster galaxies form the bulk of their stars at z < 3.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.1094 [pdf] - 1034142
Galaxy protocluster candidates at 1.6<z<2
Galametz, Audrey;
Vernet, Joel;
De Breuck, Carlos;
Hatch, Nina;
Miley, George;
Kodama, Tadayuki;
Kurk, Jaron;
Overzier, Roderik;
Rettura, Alessandro;
Rottgering, Huub;
Seymour, Nick;
Venemans, Bram;
Zirm, Andrew
Submitted: 2010-08-05
We present a study of protoclusters associated with high redshift radio
galaxies. We imaged MRC1017-220 (z=1.77) and MRC0156-252 (z=2.02) using the
near-infrared wide-field (7.5'x7.5') imager VLT/HAWK-I in the Y, H and Ks
bands. We present the first deep Y-band galaxy number counts within a large
area (200 arcmin2). We then develop a purely near-infrared colour selection
technique to isolate galaxies at 1.6<z<3 that may be associated with the two
targets, dividing them into (i) red passively evolving or dusty star-forming
galaxies or (ii) blue/star-formation dominated galaxies with little or no dust.
Both targeted fields show an excess of star-forming galaxies with respect to
control fields. No clear overdensity of red galaxies is detected in the
surroundings of MRC1017-220 although the spatial distribution of the red
galaxies resembles a filament-like structure within which the radio galaxy is
embedded. In contrast, a significant overdensity of red galaxies is detected in
the field of MRC0156-252, ranging from a factor of 2-3 times the field density
at large scales (2.5Mpc, angular distance) up to a factor of 3-4 times the
field density within a 1Mpc radius of the radio galaxy. Half of these red
galaxies have colours consistent with red sequence models at z~2, with a large
fraction being bright (Ks<21.5, i.e. massive). In addition, we also find a
small group of galaxies within 5" of MRC0156-252 suggesting that the radio
galaxy has multiple companions within ~50 kpc. We conclude that the field of
MRC0156-252 shows many remarkable similarities with the well-studied
protocluster surrounding PKS1138-262 (z=2.16) suggesting that MRC0156-252 is
associated with a galaxy protocluster at z~2.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.1211 [pdf] - 1026720
Herschel photometry of brightest cluster galaxies in cooling flow
clusters
Edge, A. C.;
Oonk, J. B. R.;
Mittal, R.;
Allen, S. W.;
Baum, S. A.;
Boehringer, H.;
Bregman, J. N.;
Bremer, M. N.;
Combes, F.;
Crawford, C. S.;
Donahue, M.;
Egami, E.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Ferland, G. J.;
Hamer, S. L.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Jaffe, W.;
Johnstone, R. M.;
McNamara, B. R.;
O'Dea, C. P.;
Popesso, P.;
Quillen, A. C.;
Salome, P.;
Sarazin, C. L.;
Voit, G. M.;
Wilman, R. J.;
Wise, M. W.
Submitted: 2010-05-07, last modified: 2010-05-10
The dust destruction timescales in the cores of clusters of galaxies are
relatively short given their high central gas densities. However, substantial
mid-infrared and sub-mm emission has been detected in many brightest cluster
galaxies. In this letter we present Herschel PACS and SPIRE photometry of the
brightest cluster galaxy in three strong cooling flow clusters, A1068, A2597
and Zw3146. This photometry indicates that a substantial mass of cold dust is
present (>3 x 10^7 Mo) at temperatures significantly lower (20-28K) than
previously thought based on limited MIR and/or sub-mm results. The mass and
temperature of the dust appear to match those of the cold gas traced by CO with
a gas-to-dust ratio of 80-120.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.1207 [pdf] - 1026719
Herschel observations of FIR emission lines in brightest cluster
galaxies
Edge, A. C.;
Oonk, J. B. R.;
Mittal, R.;
Allen, S. W.;
Baum, S. A.;
Boehringer, H.;
Bregman, J. N.;
Bremer, M. N.;
Combes, F.;
Crawford, C. S.;
Donahue, M.;
Egami, E.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Ferland, G. J.;
Hamer, S. L.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Jaffe, W.;
Johnstone, R. M.;
McNamara, B. R.;
O'Dea, C. P.;
Popesso, P.;
Quillen, A. C.;
Salome, P.;
Sarazin, C. L.;
Voit, G. M.;
Wilman, R. J.;
Wise, M. W.
Submitted: 2010-05-07, last modified: 2010-05-10
The question of how much gas cools in the cores of clusters of galaxies has
been the focus of many, multiwavelength studies in the past 30 years. In this
letter we present the first detections of the strongest atomic cooling lines,
[C II], [O I] and [N I] in two strong cooling flow clusters, A1068 and A2597,
using Herschel PACS. These spectra indicate that the substantial mass of cold
molecular gas (>10^9 Mo) known to be present in these systems is being
irradiated by intense UV radiation, most probably from young stars. The line
widths of these FIR lines indicate that they share dynamics similar but not
identical to other ionised and molecular gas traced by optical, near-infrared
and CO lines. The relative brightness of the FIR lines compared to CO and FIR
luminosity is consistent with other star-forming galaxies indicating that the
properties of the molecular gas clouds in cluster cores and the stars they form
are not unusual. These results provide additional evidence for a reservoir of
cold gas that is fed by the cooling of gas in the cores of the most compact
clusters and provide important diagnostics of the temperature and density of
the dense clouds this gas resides in.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.4511 [pdf] - 1025890
Central galaxy growth and feedback in the most massive nearby cool core
cluster
Submitted: 2010-03-23, last modified: 2010-03-25
We present multi-wavelength observations of the centre of RXCJ1504.1-0248 -
the galaxy cluster with the most luminous and relatively nearby cool core at
z~0.2. Although there are several galaxies within 100 kpc of the cluster core,
only the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG), which lies at the peak of the X-ray
emission, has blue colours and strong line-emission. Approximately 80 Msun/yr
of intracluster gas is cooling below X-ray emitting temperatures, similar to
the observed UV star formation rate of ~140 Msun/yr. Most star formation occurs
in the core of the BCG and in a 42 kpc long filament of blue continuum, line
emission, and X-ray emission, that extends southwest of the galaxy. The
surrounding filamentary nebula is the most luminous around any observed BCG.
The number of ionizing stars in the BCG is barely sufficient to ionize and heat
the nebula, and the line ratios indicate an additional heat source is needed.
This heat source can contribute to the H\alpha-deduced star formation rates
(SFRs) in BCGs and therefore the derived SFRs should only be considered upper
limits. AGN feedback can slow down the cooling flow to the observed mass
deposition rate if the black hole accretion rate is of the order of 0.5 Msun/yr
at 10% energy output efficiency. The average turbulent velocity of the nebula
is vturb ~325 km/s which, if shared by the hot gas, limits the ratio of
turbulent to thermal energy of the intracluster medium to less than 6%.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.4198 [pdf] - 1025326
A galaxy populations study of a radio-selected protocluster at z~3.1
Kuiper, E.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Rottgering, H. J. A.;
Miley, G. K.;
Overzier, R. A.;
Venemans, B. P.;
de Breuck, C.;
Croft, S.;
Kajisawa, M.;
Kodama, T.;
Kurk, J. D.;
Pentericci, L.;
Stanford, S. A.;
Tanaka, I.;
Zirm, A. W.
Submitted: 2010-02-22
We present a population study of several types of galaxies within the
protocluster surrounding the radio galaxy MRC0316-257 at z~3.1. In addition to
the known population of Ly_alpha emitters (LAEs) and [OIII] emitters, we use
colour selection techniques to identify protocluster candidates that are Lyman
break galaxies (LBG) and Balmer break galaxies (BBGs). The radio galaxy field
contains an excess of LBG candidates, with a surface density 1.6\pm0.3 times
larger than found for comparable blank fields. This surface overdensity
corresponds to an LBG volume overdensity of ~8\pm4. The BBG photometric
redshift distribution peaks at the protocluster's redshift, but we detect no
significant surface overdensity of BBG. This is not surprising because a volume
overdensity similar to the LBGs would have resulted in a surface density of
~1.2 that found in the blank field. This could not have been detected in our
sample. Masses and star formation rates of the candidate protocluster galaxies
are determined using SED fitting. These properties are not significantly
different from those of field galaxies. The galaxies with the highest masses
and star formation rates are located near the radio galaxy, indicating that the
protocluster environment influences galaxy evolution at z~3. We conclude that
the protocluster around MRC0316-257 is still in the early stages of formation.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:0901.3353 [pdf] - 20564
The growth and assembly of a massive galaxy at z ~ 2
Submitted: 2009-01-22
We study the stellar mass assembly of the Spiderweb Galaxy (MRC 1138-262), a
massive z = 2.2 radio galaxy in a protocluster and the probable progenitor of a
brightest cluster galaxy. Nearby protocluster galaxies are identified and their
properties are determined by fitting stellar population models to their
rest-frame ultraviolet to optical spectral energy distributions. We find that
within 150 kpc of the radio galaxy the stellar mass is centrally concentrated
in the radio galaxy, yet most of the dust-uncorrected, instantaneous star
formation occurs in the surrounding low-mass satellite galaxies. We predict
that most of the galaxies within 150 kpc of the radio galaxy will merge with
the central radio galaxy by z = 0, increasing its stellar mass by up to a
factor of ~ 2. However, it will take several hundred Myr for the first mergers
to occur, by which time the large star formation rates are likely to have
exhausted the gas reservoirs in the satellite galaxies. The tidal radii of the
satellite galaxies are small, suggesting that stars and gas are being stripped
and deposited at distances of tens of kpc from the central radio galaxy. These
stripped stars may become intracluster stars or form an extended stellar halo
around the radio galaxy, such as those observed around cD galaxies in cluster
cores.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:0810.5372 [pdf] - 17992
Collisional heating as the origin of filament emission in galaxy
clusters
Submitted: 2008-10-29
[Abridged] Photoionization, whether by starlight or other sources, has
difficulty in accounting for the observed spectra of the optical filaments that
often surround central galaxies in large clusters. Our first paper examined
whether heating by energetic particles or dissipative MHD wave can account for
the observations. Here we include atomic and low-ionization regions. The model
of the hydrogen atom, along with all elements of the H-like iso-electronic
sequence, is now fully nl-resolved. We show how the predicted HI spectrum
differs from the pure recombination case. The second update is to the rates for
H^0 - H2 inelastic collisions. We now use the values computed by Wrathmall et
al. The rates are often much larger.
We calculate the chemistry, ionization, temperature, gas pressure, and
emission-line spectrum for a wide range of gas densities and collisional
heating rates. We assume that the filaments are magnetically confined and free
to move along field lines so that the gas pressure is equal to that of the
surrounding hot gas. A mix of clouds, some being dense and cold and others hot
and tenuous, can exist. The observed spectrum will be the integrated emission
from clouds with different densities and temperatures but the same pressure. We
assume that the gas filling factor is given by a power law in density. The
power-law index is set by matching the observed intensities of IR H2 lines
relative to optical HI lines. We conclude that the filaments are heated by
ionizing particles, either conducted in from surrounding regions or produced in
situ by processes related to MHD waves.
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.0152 [pdf] - 14087
[OIII] emitters in the field of the MRC 0316-257 protocluster
Maschietto, F.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Venemans, B. P.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Miley, G. K.;
Overzier, R. A.;
Dopita, M. A.;
Eisenhardt, P. R.;
Kurk, J. D.;
Meurer, G. R.;
Pentericci, L.;
Rosati, P.;
Stanford, S. A.;
van Breugel, W.;
Zirm, A. W.
Submitted: 2008-07-01
Venemans et al. (2005) found evidence for an overdensity of Ly-alpha emission
line galaxies associated with the radio galaxy MRC 0316-257 at z=3.13
indicating the presence of a massive protocluster. Here, we present the results
of a search for additional star-forming galaxies and AGN within the
protocluster. Narrow-band infrared imaging was used to select candidate [O III]
emitters in a 1.1 x 1.1 Mpc^2 region around the radio galaxy. Thirteen
candidates have been detected. Four of these are among the previously confirmed
sample of Ly-alpha galaxies, and an additional three have been confirmed
through follow-up infrared spectroscopy. The three newly confirmed objects lie
within a few hundred km/s of each other, but are blueshifted with respect to
the radio galaxy and Ly-alpha emitters by ~2100 km/s. Although the sample is
currently small, our results indicate that the radio-selected protocluster is
forming at the centre of a larger, ~60 co-moving Mpc super-structure. On the
basis of an HST/ACS imaging study we calculate dust-corrected star-formation
rates and investigate morphologies and sizes of the [O III] candidate emitters.
From a comparison of the star formation rate derived from UV-continuum and [O
III] emission, we conclude that at least two of the [O III] galaxies harbour an
AGN which ionized the O+ gas.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.2113 [pdf] - 11731
Cold gas in the Perseus cluster core: Excitation of molecular gas in
filaments
Submitted: 2008-04-14
We have recently detected CO lines in the well-known filaments around NGC
1275, the galaxy at the centre of the Perseus cluster of galaxies. These
previous observations, with the HERA multi-beam array at the IRAM 30m telescope
enabled us to make a large map of the CO(2-1) line and to see hints of
molecular gas far away from the cluster centre. To confirm the presence of CO
emission lines in the outer filaments and to study the CO(2-1)/CO(1-0) line
ratio, we observed seven regions of interest again with the 30m telescope in
both CO(1-0) and CO(2-1). The regions we observed were: the eastern filament,
the horseshoe, the northern filament and a southern extension, all selected
from Halpha emission line mapping. Molecular gas is detected in all the
observed regions. This result confirms the large extent of the cold molecular
gas filaments. We discuss the CO(2-1)/CO(1-0) ratios in the filaments. The
eastern filament has optically thick gas, whereas further away, the line ratio
increases close to values expected for a warmer optically thin medium. We also
show CO(1-0) and CO(2-1) lines in 9 regions closer to the centre. The
kinematics of the CO is studied here in more detail and confirms that it
follows the motions of the warm H_2 gas found in the near-infrared. Finally, we
searched for dense gas tracers around 3C84 and claim here the first detection
of HCN(3-2).
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:0802.2535 [pdf] - 10198
The origin of molecular hydrogen emission in cooling-flow filaments
Submitted: 2008-02-18
The optical filaments found in many cooling flows in galaxy clusters consist
of low density ($\sim 10^3 \pcc$) cool ($\sim 10^3$ K) gas surrounded by
significant amounts of cosmic-ray and magnetic-field energy. Their spectra show
anomalously strong low-ionization and molecular emission lines when compared
with galactic molecular clouds exposed to ionizing radiation such as the Orion
complex. Previous studies have shown that the spectra cannot be produced by
O-star photoionization. Here we calculate the physical conditions in dusty gas
that is well shielded from external sources of ionizing photons and is
energized either by cosmic rays or dissipative MHD waves. Strong molecular
hydrogen lines, with relative intensities similar to those observed, are
produced. Selection effects introduced by the microphysics produce a
correlation between the \htwo line upper level energy and the population
temperature. These selection effects allow a purely collisional gas to produce
\htwo emission that masquerades as starlight-pumped \htwo but with intensities
that are far stronger. This physics may find application to any environment
where a broad range of gas densities or heating rates occur.
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:0710.4553 [pdf] - 6363
Diffuse UV light associated with the Spiderweb Galaxy: evidence for
in-situ star formation outside galaxies
Submitted: 2007-10-25
We present detailed images of diffuse UV intergalactic light (IGL), situated
in a 60kpc halo that surrounds the radio galaxy MRC 1138-262 at z=2. We discuss
the nature of the IGL and rule out faint cluster galaxies, nebular continuum
emission, synchrotron, inverse Compton emission and scattering of galactic
stellar light as possible sources of the IGL. Dust scattered quasar light is an
unlikely possibility that cannot be ruled out entirely. We conclude that the
source of the IGL is most likely to be a young stellar population distributed
in a halo encompassing the radio and satellite galaxies, undergoing star
formation at a rate greater than 57 Msun/yr. Within 70kpc of the radio core,
approximately 44% of the star formation that is traced by UV light occurs in
this diffuse mode. The average UV colour of the IGL is bluer than the average
galaxy colour, and there is a trend for the IGL to become bluer with increasing
radius from the radio galaxy. Both the galaxies and the IGL show a UV
colour--surface brightness relation which can be obtained by variations in
either stellar population age or extinction. These observations show a
different, but potentially important mode of star formation, that is diffuse in
nature. Star formation, as traced by UV light, occurs in two modes in the high
redshift universe: one in the usual Lyman break galaxy clump-like mode on kpc
scales, and the other in a diffuse mode over a large region surrounding massive
growing galaxies. Such a mode of star formation can easily be missed by high
angular resolution observations that are well suited for detecting high surface
brightness compact galaxies. Extrapolating from these results, it is possible
that a significant amount of star formation occurs in large extended regions
within the halos of the most massive galaxies forming at high redshift.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702431 [pdf] - 89485
Discovery of atomic and molecular mid infra-red emission lines in
off-nuclear regions of NGC 1275 and NGC 4696 with the Spitzer Space Telescope
Submitted: 2007-02-16, last modified: 2007-09-12
We present Spitzer high-resolution spectra of off-nuclear regions in the
central cluster galaxies NGC 1275 and NGC 4696 in the Perseus and Centaurus
clusters, respectively. Both objects are surrounded by extensive optical
emission-line filamentary nebulae, bright outer parts of which are the targets
of our observations. The 10-37um spectra show strong pure rotational lines from
molecular hydrogen revealing a molecular component to the filaments which has
an excitation temperature of ~300-400K. The flux in the 0-0S(1) molecular
hydrogen line correlates well with the strength of the optical lines, having
about 3 per cent of the Halpha+[NII] emission. The 11.3um PAH feature is seen
in some spectra. Emission is also seen from both low and high ionization fine
structure lines. Molecular hydrogen cooler than ~400K dominates the mass of the
outer filaments; the nebulae are predominantly molecular.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:0706.0661 [pdf] - 1907
Ionized nebulae surrounding brightest cluster galaxies
Submitted: 2007-06-05
We present IFU observations of six emission-line nebulae that surround the
central galaxy of cool core clusters. Qualitatively similar nebulae are
observed in cool core clusters even when the dynamics and possibly formation
and excitation source are different. Evidence for a nearby secondary galaxy
disturbing a nebula, as well as AGN and starburst driven outflows are presented
as possible formation mechanisms. One nebula has a rotation velocity of the
same amplitude as the underlying molecular reservoir, which implies that the
excitation or formation of a nebula does not require any disturbance of the
molecular reservoir within the central galaxy. Bulk flows and velocity shears
of a few hundred km/s are seen across all nebulae. The majority lack any
ordered rotation, their configurations are not stable so the nebulae must be
constantly reshaping, dispersing and reforming. The dimmer nebulae are
co-spatial with dust features whilst the more luminous are not. Significant
variation in the ionization state of the gas is seen in all nebulae through the
non-uniform [NII]/H_alpha ratio. There is no correlation between the line ratio
and H_alpha surface brightness, but regions with excess blue or UV light have
lower line ratios. This implies that UV from massive, young stars act in
combination with an underlying heating source that produces the observed
low-ionization spectra.
[66]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0603350 [pdf] - 80559
Cold molecular gas in the Perseus cluster core - Association with X-ray
cavity, Halpha filaments and cooling flow -
Salome, P.;
Combes, F.;
Edge, A. C.;
Crawford, C.;
Erlund, M.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Hatch, N. A.;
Johnstone, R. M.;
Sanders, J. S.;
Wilman, R. J.
Submitted: 2006-03-14
Cold molecular gas has been recently detected in several cooling flow
clusters of galaxies where huge optical nebulosities often stand. These optical
filaments are tightly linked to the cooling flow and to the related phenomena,
like the rising bubbles of relativistic plasma, fed by the radio jets. We
present here a map in the CO(2-1) rotational line of the cold molecular gas
associated with some Halpha filaments surrounding the central galaxy of the
Perseus cluster: NGC 1275. The map, extending to about 50 kpc (135 arcsec) from
the center of the galaxy, has been made with the 18-receiver array HERA, at the
focus of the IRAM 30m telescope. Although most of the cold gas is concentrated
to the center of the galaxy, the CO emission is also clearly associated to the
extended filaments conspicuous in ionised gas and could trace a possible
reservoir fueling the star formation there. Some of the CO emission is also
found where the X-ray gas could cool down more efficiently: at the rims of the
central X-ray cavity (where the hot gas is thought to have been pushed out and
compressed by the central AGN expanding radio lobes). The CO global kinematics
does not show any rotation in NGC 1275. The cold gas is probably a mixture of
gas falling down on the central galaxy and of uplifted gas dragged out by a
rising bubble in the intracluster medium. As recenlty suggested in other
cluster cores, the cold gas peculiar morphology and kinematics argue for the
picture of an intermittent cooling flow scenario where the central AGN plays an
important role.
[67]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0512331 [pdf] - 78531
On the origin and excitation of the extended nebula surrounding NGC 1275
Submitted: 2005-12-13
We use line-of-sight velocity information on the filamentary emission-line
nebula of NGC 1275 to infer a dynamical model of the nebula's flow through the
surrounding intracluster gas. We detect outflowing gas and flow patterns that
match simulations of buoyantly rising bubbles from which we deduce that some of
the nebula filaments have been drawn out of NGC 1275. We find a radial gradient
of the ratio [NII]6584/H-alpha which may be due to a variation in metallicity,
interactions with the surrounding intracluster medium or a hardening of the
excitation mechanism. We find no preferred spatial correlation of stellar
clusters within the filaments and there is a notable lack of [OIII]5007
emission, therefore it is unlikely that the filaments are ionized by stellar
UV.
[68]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0507627 [pdf] - 74796
The extended H-alpha emitting filaments surrounding NGC4696, the central
galaxy of the Centaurus cluster
Submitted: 2005-07-27
We present images of NGC4696, the central galaxy in the Centaurus cluster,
showing the large extent of cool filaments which are bright in H-alpha line
emission. These filaments share the detailed structure of both the central dust
lane and the inner regions of the arc-like plumes seen in soft X-ray emission.
The X-ray gas is at its coolest, and most absorbed in this same region. The
smoothness of the features implies that the local environment is not strongly
turbulent. We suggest that these filaments are either shaped by confinement due
to a strong magnetic field, or by bulk flows within the intracluster medium. We
propose that like similar filamentary systems in the core of clusters, these
cooler components have been drawn out of the central galaxy behind buoyant gas
bubbles from previous episodes of radio activity. We find a spur of
low-frequency radio emission leading to a region of low X-ray pressure within
the intracluster medium supporting this interpretation.
[69]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0411446 [pdf] - 69045
Detections of Molecular Hydrogen in the Outer Filaments of NGC 1275
Submitted: 2004-11-16
We present clear spectroscopic detections of molecular hydrogen in the outer
filaments of the H-alpha nebula surrounding the central galaxy of the Perseus
cluster, NGC 1275. This implies the presence of warm molecular gas clouds at
projected distances up to 24 kpc from the nucleus of the host galaxy, embedded
in the hot intracluster medium. The emission-line intensity ratios reveal that
the molecular hydrogen is predominately thermally excited with excitation
temperatures of 1600-2200K, suggesting a lack of pressure balance between the
molecular component and its surrounding medium. Excitation by stellar UV or by
the central AGN is shown to be unlikely, whilst thermal excitation by X-rays or
conduction from the ICM or shocks are all possibilities. Evidence for a
non-thermal component is found in the spectra of some regions based on a low
ortho-to-para ratio.