Normalized to: Hartman, R.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:0808.1740 [pdf] - 15348
Gamma-Ray Emission from the Broad-Line Radio Galaxy 3C111
Submitted: 2008-08-12
The broad-line radio galaxy 3C111 has been suggested as the counterpart of
the gamma-ray source 3EGJ0416+3650. While 3C111 meets most of the criteria for
a high-probability identification, like a bright flat-spectrum radio core and a
blazar-like broadband SED, in the Third EGRET Catalog, the large positional
offset of about 1.5 degrees put 3C111 outside the 99% probability region for
3EGJ0416+3650, making this association questionable. We present a re-analysis
of all available data for 3C111 from the EGRET archives, resulting in probable
detection of high-energy gamma-ray emission above 1000MeV from a position close
to the nominal position of 3C111, in two separate viewing periods (VPs), at a
3-sigma level in each. A new source, GROJ0426+3747, appears to be present
nearby. For >100MeV, one source seems to account for most of the EGRET-detected
emission of 3EGJ0416+3650. A follow-up Swift UVOT/XRT observation reveals one
moderately bright X-ray source in the error box of 3EGJ0416+3650, but because
of the large EGRET position uncertainty, it is not certain that the X-ray and
gamma-ray sources are associated. Another Swift observation, of GROJ0426+3747,
detected no X-ray source nearby.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:0704.0939 [pdf] - 190
Does the Blazar Gamma-Ray Spectrum Harden with Increasing Flux? Analysis
of 9 Years of EGRET Data
Submitted: 2007-04-06
The Energetic Gamma-Ray Experiment Telescope (EGRET) on the Compton Gamma-Ray
Observatory (CGRO) discovered gamma-ray emission from more than 67 blazars
during its 9 yr lifetime. We conducted an exhaustive search of the EGRET
archives and selected all the blazars that were observed multiple times and
were bright enough to enable a spectral analysis using standard power-law
models. The sample consists of 18 flat-spectrum radio quasars(FSRQs), 6
low-frequency peaked BL Lac objects (LBLs) and 2 high-frequency peaked BL Lac
objects (HBLs). We do not detect any clear pattern in the variation of spectral
index with flux. Some of the blazars do not show any statistical evidence for
spectral variability. The spectrum hardens with increasing flux in a few cases.
There is also evidence for a flux-hardness anticorrelation at low fluxes in
five blazars. The well-observed blazars (3C 279, 3C 273, PKS 0528+134, PKS
1622-297 PKS 0208-512) do not show any overall trend in the long-term spectral
dependence on flux, but the sample shows a mixture of hard and soft states. We
observed a previously unreported spectral hysteresis at weekly timescales in
all three FSRQs for which data from flares lasting for ~(3-4) weeks were
available. All three sources show a counterclockwise rotation, despite the
widely different flux profiles. We analyze the observed spectral behavior in
the context of various inverse Compton mechanisms believed to be responsible
for emission in the EGRET energy range. Our analysis uses the EGRET skymaps
that were regenerated to include the changes in performance during the mission.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702581 [pdf] - 89635
The Anti-Coincidence Detector for the GLAST Large Area Telescope
Submitted: 2007-02-21
This paper describes the design, fabrication and testing of the
Anti-Coincidence Detector (ACD) for the Gamma-ray Large Area Space Telescope
(GLAST) Large Area Telescope (LAT). The ACD is LAT first-level defense against
the charged cosmic ray background that outnumbers the gamma rays by 3-5 orders
of magnitude. The ACD covers the top and 4 sides of the LAT tracking detector,
requiring a total active area of ~8.3 square meters. The ACD detector utilizes
plastic scintillator tiles with wave-length shifting fiber readout. In order to
suppress self-veto by shower particles at high gamma-ray energies, the ACD is
segmented into 89 tiles of different sizes. The overall ACD efficiency for
detection of singly charged relativistic particles entering the tracking
detector from the top or sides of the LAT exceeds the required 0.9997.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0209595 [pdf] - 1938836
Gamma Ray Large Area Space Telescope (GLAST) Balloon Flight Data
Handling Overview
Burnett, T. H.;
Chekhtman, A.;
Silva, E. do Couto e;
Dubois, R.;
Flath, D.;
Gable, I.;
Grove, J. E.;
Hartman, R.;
Kamae, T.;
Kavelaars, A.;
Kelly, H.;
Kotani, T.;
Kuss, M.;
Lauben, D.;
Lindner, T.;
Lumb, N.;
Mizuno, T.;
Moiseev, A.;
Ozaki, M.;
Rochester, L. S.;
Schaefer, R.;
Spandre, G.;
Thompson, D. J.;
Usher, T.;
Young, K.
Submitted: 2002-09-27
The GLAST Balloon Flight Engineering Model (BFEM) represents one of 16 towers
that constitute the Large Area Telescope (LAT), a high-energy (>20 MeV)
gamma-ray pair-production telescope being built by an international partnership
of astrophysicists and particle physicists for a satellite launch in 2006. The
prototype tower consists of a Pb/Si pair-conversion tracker (TKR), a CsI
hodoscopic calorimeter (CAL), an anti-coincidence detector (ACD) and an
autonomous data acquisition system (DAQ). The self-triggering capabilities and
performance of the detector elements have been previously characterized using
positron, photon and hadron beams. External target scintillators were placed
above the instrument to act as sources of hadronic showers. This paper provides
a comprehensive description of the BFEM data-reduction process, from receipt of
the flight data from telemetry through event reconstruction and background
rejection cuts. The goals of the ground analysis presented here are to verify
the functioning of the instrument and to validate the reconstruction software
and the background-rejection scheme.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0207355 [pdf] - 50498
Broad-band continuum and line emission of the gamma-ray blazar PKS
0537-441
Pian, E.;
Falomo, R.;
Hartman, R. C.;
Maraschi, L.;
Tavecchio, F.;
Tornikoski, M.;
Treves, A.;
Urry, C. M.;
Ballo, L.;
Mukherjee, R.;
Scarpa, R.;
Thompson, D. J.;
Pesce, J. E.
Submitted: 2002-07-17
PKS 0537-441, a bright gamma-ray emitting blazar, was observed at radio,
optical, UV and X-ray frequencies during various EGRET pointings, often
quasi-simultaneously. In 1995 the object was found in an intense emission state
at all wavelengths. BeppoSAX observations made in 1998, non-simultaneously with
exposures at other frequencies, allow us to characterize precisely the spectral
shape of the high energy blazar component, which we attribute to inverse
Compton scattering. The optical-to-gamma-ray spectral energy distributions at
the different epochs show that the gamma-ray luminosity dominates the
bolometric output. This, together with the presence of optical and UV line
emission, suggests that, besides the synchrotron self-Compton mechanism, the
Compton upscattering of photons external to the jet (e.g., in the broad line
region) may have a significant role for high energy radiation. The
multiwavelength variability can be reproduced by changes of the plasma bulk
Lorentz factor. The spectrum secured by IUE in 1995 appears to be partially
absorbed shortward of ~1700 A. However, this signature is not detected in the
HST spectrum taken during a lower state of the source. The presence of
intervening absorbers is not supported by optical imaging and spectroscopy of
the field.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0202479 [pdf] - 47973
XMM-Newton and Wide Field Optical Imaging to crack the mystery of
unidentified gamma-ray sources
Submitted: 2002-02-26
The limited angular resolution of gamma-ray telescopes prevents the straight
identification of the majority of the sources detected so far. While the only
certified galactic gamma-ray emitters are associated with pulsars, more than
90% of the nearly 100 low latitude sources detected by EGRET on the GRO lack an
identification. The best identification strategy devised over the years relies
on the use of X-ray and optical data to single out possible counterparts,
rating them on the basis of their extreme F_x/F_opt. Here we describe our
multiwavelength programme based on the EPIC mapping of selected EGRET sources
complemented by the optical coverage of the same fields obtained through the
Wide Field Imager (WFI) of the ESO 2.2 m telescope. The field of view of the
WFI, comparable to that of EPIC, will allow to directly cross-correlate X and
optical data speeding up significantly the selection of interesting candidates
worth follow-up optical (and X-ray) studies.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0105247 [pdf] - 42476
Day-Scale Variability of 3C 279 and Searches for Correlations in
Gamma-Ray, X-Ray, and Optical Bands
Hartman, R. C.;
Villata, M.;
Balonek, T. J.;
Bertsch, D. L.;
Bock, H.;
Boettcher, M.;
Carini, M. T.;
Collmar, W.;
De Francesco, G.;
Ferrara, E. C.;
Heidt, J.;
Kanbach, G.;
Katajainen, S.;
Koskimies, M.;
Kurtanidze, O. M.;
Lanteri, L.;
Lawson, A.;
Lin, Y. C.;
Marscher, A. P.;
McFarland, J. P.;
McHardy, I. M.;
Miller, H. R.;
Nikolashvili, M.;
Nilsson, K.;
Noble, J. C.;
Nucciarelli, G.;
Ostorero, L.;
Pursimo, T.;
Raiteri, C. M.;
Rekola, R.;
Savolainen, T.;
Sillanpaa, A.;
Smale, A.;
Sobrito, G.;
Takalo, L. O.;
Thompson, D. J.;
Tosti, G.;
Wagner, S. J.;
Wilson, J. W.
Submitted: 2001-05-15
Light curves of 3C 279 are presented in optical (R-band), X-rays (RXTE/PCA),
and gamma rays (CGRO/EGRET) for 1999 Jan-Feb and 2000 Jan-Mar. During both of
those epochs the gamma-ray levels were high, and all three observed bands
demonstrated substantial variation, on time scales as short as one day.
Correlation analyses provided no consistent pattern, although a rather
significant optical/gamma-ray correlation was seen in 1999, with a gamma-ray
lag of ~2.5 days, and there are other suggestions of correlations in the light
curves. For comparison, correlation analysis is also presented for the
gamma-ray and X-ray light curves during the large gamma ray flare in 1996 Feb
and the two gamma-bright weeks leading up to it; the correlation at that time
was strong, with a gamma-ray/X-ray offset of no more than 1 day.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0102127 [pdf] - 40838
Multi-Epoch Multiwavelength Spectra and Models for Blazar 3C~279
Submitted: 2001-02-07
Of the blazars detected by EGRET in GeV gamma rays, 3C 279 is not only the
best-observed by EGRET, but also one of the best-monitored at lower
frequencies. We have assembled eleven spectra, from GHz radio through GeV gamma
rays, from the time intervals of EGRET observations. Although some of the data
have appeared in previous publications, most are new, including data taken
during the high states in early 1999 and early 2000. All of the spectra show
substantial gamma-ray contribution to the total luminosity of the object; in a
high state, the gamma-ray luminosity dominates over that at all other
frequencies by a factor of more than 10. There is no clear pattern of time
correlation; different bands do not always rise and fall together, even in the
optical, X-ray, and gamma-ray bands.
The spectra are modeled using a leptonic jet, with combined synchrotron
self-Compton + external Compton gamma-ray production. Spectral variability of
3C 279 is consistent with variations of the bulk Lorentz factor of the jet,
accompanied by changes in the spectral shape of the electron distribution. Our
modeling results are consistent with the UV spectrum of 3C 279 being dominated
by accretion disk radiation during times of low gamma-ray intensity.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0004252 [pdf] - 35611
A Systematic Search for Short-term Variability of EGRET Sources
Submitted: 2000-04-18
The 3rd EGRET Catalog of High-energy Gamma-ray Sources contains 170
unidentified sources, and there is great interest in the nature of these
sources. One means of determining source class is the study of flux variability
on time scales of days; pulsars are believed to be stable on these time scales
while blazars are known to be highly variable. In addition, previous work has
demonstrated that 3EG J0241-6103 and 3EG J1837-0606 are candidates for a new
gamma-ray source class. These sources near the Galactic plane display transient
behavior but cannot be associated with any known blazars. Although many
instances of flaring AGN have been reported, the EGRET database has not been
systematically searched for occurrences of short-timescale ($\sim1$ day)
variability. These considerations have led us to conduct a systematic search
for short-term variability in EGRET data, covering all viewing periods through
proposal cycle 4. Six 3EG catalog sources are reported here to display
variability on short time scales; four of them are unidentified. In addition,
three non-catalog variable sources are discussed.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0004061 [pdf] - 35420
Multifrequency Observations of the Virgo Blazars 3C 273 and 3C 279 in
CGRO Cycle 8
Collmar, W.;
Benlloch, S.;
Grove, J. E.;
Hartman, R. C.;
Heindl, W. A.;
Kraus, A.;
Teraesranta, H.;
Villata, M.;
Bennett, K.;
Bloemen, H.;
Johnson, W. N.;
Krichbaum, T. P.;
Raiteri, C. M.;
Ryan, J.;
Sobrito, G.;
Schoenfelder, V.;
Williams, O. R.;
Wilms, J.
Submitted: 2000-04-05
We report first observational results of multifrequency campaigns on the
prominent Virgo blazars 3C 273 and 3C 279 which were carried out in January and
February 1999. Both blazars are detected from radio to gamma-ray energies. We
present the measured X- to gamma-ray spectra of both sources, and for 3C 279 we
compare the 1999 broad-band (radio to gamma-ray) spectrum to measured previous
ones.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9901106 [pdf] - 104700
Broadband Spectral Analysis of PKS 0528+134: A Report on Six Years of
EGRET Observations
Submitted: 1999-01-10, last modified: 1999-06-25
The multiwavelength spectra of PKS 0528+134 during six years of observations
by EGRET have been analyzed using synchrotron self-Compton (SSC) and external
radiation Compton (ERC) models. We find that a two-component model, in which
the target photons are produced externally to the gamma-ray emitting region,
but also including an SSC component, is required to suitably reproduce the
spectral energy distributions of the source. Our analysis indicates that there
is a trend in the observed properties of PKS 0528+134, as the source goes from
a gamma-ray low state to a flaring state. We observe that during the higher
gamma-ray states, the bulk Lorentz factor of the jet increases and the ERC
component dominates the high-energy emission. Our model calculations indicate
the trend that the energies of the electrons giving rise to the synchrotron
peak decreases, and the power-ratio of the gamma-ray and low energy spectral
components increases, as the source goes from a low to a high gamma-ray state.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9906326 [pdf] - 107047
Ultraviolet and Multiwavelength Variability of the Blazar 3C 279:
Evidence for Thermal Emission
Pian, E.;
Urry, C. M.;
Maraschi, L.;
Madejski, G.;
McHardy, I. M.;
Koratkar, A.;
Treves, A.;
Chiappetti, L.;
Grandi, P.;
Hartman, R. C.;
Kubo, H.;
Leach, C. M.;
Pesce, J. E.;
Imhoff, C.;
Thompson, R.;
Wehrle, A. E.
Submitted: 1999-06-21
The gamma-ray blazar 3C 279 was monitored on a nearly daily basis with IUE,
ROSAT and EGRET for three weeks between December 1992 and January 1993. During
this period, the blazar was at a historical minimum at all wavelengths. Here we
present the UV data obtained during the above multiwavelength campaign. A
maximum UV variation of ~50% is detected, while during the same period the
X-ray flux varied by no more than 13%. At the lowest UV flux level the average
spectrum in the 1230-2700 A interval is unusually flat for this object
(<alpha_UV>~1). The flattening could represent the lowest energy tail of the
inverse Compton component responsible for the X-ray emission, or could be due
to the presence of a thermal component at ~20000 K possibly associated with an
accretion disk. The presence of an accretion disk in this blazar object, likely
observable only in very low states and otherwise hidden by the beamed, variable
synchrotron component, would be consistent with the scenario in which the seed
photons for the inverse Compton mechanism producing the gamma-rays are external
to the relativistic jet. We further discuss the long term correlation of the UV
flux with the X-ray and gamma-ray fluxes obtained at various epochs. All UV
archival data are included in the analysis. Both the X- and gamma-ray fluxes
are generally well correlated with the UV flux, approximately with square root
and quadratic dependences, respectively.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9901277 [pdf] - 272399
GeV emission from the nearby radio galaxy Centaurus A
Submitted: 1999-01-20
EGRET has detected 67 sources associated with active galactic nuclei. With
the exception of radio galaxy Cen A, all are classified as belonging to the
blazar class of active galactic nuclei. The cumulative exposure from multiple
EGRET observations has provided the first clear detection of Centaurus A.
Unlike the \gr blazars seen by EGRET which are believed to exhibit
near-alignment of the central jet along the line-of-sight, Cen A provides the
first evidence for $>$100 MeV emission from a source with a confirmed
large-inclination jet. Although the high-energy emission represents a lower
luminosity than most EGRET blazars, with the advent of new more sensitive
instruments such as GLAST and VERITAS, the detection of off-axis high-energy
emission from more distant radio galaxies is an exciting possibility.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9811014 [pdf] - 103640
A Study of High Energy Emission from the TeV blazar Mrk 501 during
Multiwavelength Observations in 1996
Kataoka, J.;
Mattox, J. R.;
Quinn, J.;
Kubo, H.;
Makino, F.;
Takahashi, T.;
Inoue, S.;
Hartman, R. C.;
Madejski, G. M.;
Sreekumar, P.;
Wagner, S. J.
Submitted: 1998-11-02
We present the results of a multiwavelength campaign for Mrk 501 performed in
March 1996 with ASCA, EGRET, Whipple, and optical telescopes. In the X-ray
band, a spectral break was observed around 2 keV. We report here for the first
time the detection of high-energy gamma-ray flux from Mrk 501 with EGRET with
3.5 sigma significance (E>100 MeV). Higher flux was also observed in April/May
1996, with 4.0 sigma significance for E>100 MeV, and 5.2 sigma significance for
E>500 MeV. The gamma-ray spectrum was measured to be flatter than most of the
gamma-ray blazars. We find that the multiband spectrum in 1996 is consistent
with that calculated from a one-zone SSC model in a homogeneous region. In the
context of this model, we investigate the values of the magnetic field strength
and the beaming factor allowed by the observational results. We compare the
March 1996 multiwavelength spectrum with that in the flare state in April 1997.
Between these two epochs, the TeV flux increase is well correlated with that
observed in keV range. The keV and TeV amplitudes during the April 1997 flare
are accurately reproduced, assuming that the population of synchrotron photons
in 1996 are scattered by the newly injected relativistic electrons, having
maximum energies of G_max = 6.0e6. However, the TeV spectrum observed during
March 1996 campaign is flatter than predicted by our models. We find that this
cannot be explained by either higher order Comptonization or the contribution
of the `seed' IR photons from the host galaxy for the first-order external
radiation Comptonization.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9711243 [pdf] - 99376
Multiwavelength Observations of a Dramatic High Energy Flare in the
Blazar 3C 279
Submitted: 1997-11-20
The blazar 3C 279, one of the brightest identified extragalactic objects in
the gamma-ray sky, underwent a flare of a factor 10 amplitude in gamma-rays
towards the end of a 3-week pointing by CGRO, in 1996 January-February. The
flare peak represents the highest gamma-ray intensity ever recorded for this
object. During the high state, extremely rapid gamma-ray variability was seen.
Coordinated multifrequency observations were carried out with RXTE, ASCA, ROSAT
and IUE and from many ground-based observatories, covering most accessible
wavelengths. The well-sampled, simultaneous RXTE light curve shows an outburst
of lower amplitude (factor of ~3) well correlated with the gamma-ray flare
without any apparent lag. The optical-UV light curves, which are not well
sampled during the high energy flare, exhibit more modest variations (factor of
~2) and a lower degree of correlation. The flux at millimetric wavelengths was
near an historical maximum during the gamma-ray flare peak, with suggestion of
a correlated decay. We present simultaneous spectral energy distributions of 3C
279 prior to and near to the flare peak. The gamma-rays vary by more than the
square of the observed IR-optical flux change, which poses some problems for
specific blazar emission models. The synchrotron-self Compton model would
require that the largest synchrotron variability occurred in the mostly
unobserved sub-mm/far-infrared region. Alternatively, a large variation in the
external photon field could occur over a time scale of few days. This occurs
naturally in the ``mirror'' model, wherein the flaring region in the jet
photoionizes nearby broad-emission-line clouds, which in turn provide soft
photons that are Comptonized to gamma-ray energies.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9709305 [pdf] - 98758
Short Time-scale Gamma-Ray Variability of Blazars and EGRET Unidentified
Sources
Submitted: 1997-09-30
We have begun to examine the EGRET database for short term variations in the
fluxes of blazars and unidentified sources at high Galactic latitude. We find
that several AGN show previously unreported variability. Such variations are
consistent with inverse Compton scattering processes in a shock propagating
through a relativistic jet.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9709279 [pdf] - 98732
Possible New Identifications for EGRET Sources
Submitted: 1997-09-26
We have conducted a multiwavelength study of several radio sources within or
near the error boxes of EGRET unidentified sources at mid to high Galactic
latitude, under the hypothesis that the radio sources are blazars and are thus
the best identification candidates for the EGRET objects. We show that one of
these radio sources, PMN 0850-12, has a flux of 1.5 Jy at 22 GHz and a nearly
flat spectrum up to 230 GHz and is thus very likely to be the correct
identification for for the EGRET source 2EG J0852-1237.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9703147 [pdf] - 96908
A spectral study of gamma-ray emitting AGN
Submitted: 1997-03-24
In this paper we present a statistical analysis of the gamma-ray spectra of
flat-spectrum radio quasars (FSRQ) compared to those of BL Lacs. The average
spectra and possible systematic deviations from power-law behaviour are
investigated by summing up the intensity and the power-law fit statistic for
both classes of objects. We also compare the time-averaged spectrum to that at
the time of gamma-ray outbursts. The spectrum of the average AGN is softer than
that of the extragalactic gamma-ray background. It may be that BL Lacs, which
on average have a harder spectrum than FSRQs, make up the bulk of the
extragalactic background. We also find apparent cut-offs at both low and high
energies in the spectra of FSRQs at the time of gamma-ray outbursts. While the
cut-off at high energies may have something to do with opacity, the cut-off at
low energies may be taken as indication that the gamma-ray emission of FSRQs is
not a one component spectrum.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9612187 [pdf] - 96215
The Identification of EGRET Sources with Flat-Spectrum Radio Sources
Submitted: 1996-12-18
We present a method to assess the reliability of the identification of EGRET
sources with extragalactic radio sources. We verify that EGRET is detecting the
blazar class of AGN. However, many published identifications are found to be
questionable. We provide a table of 42 blazars which we expect to be robust
identifications of EGRET sources. This includes one previously unidentified
EGRET source, the lensed AGN PKS 1830-210 near the direction of the Galactic
center. We provide the best available positions for 16 more radio sources which
are also potential identifications for previously unidentified EGRET sources.
All high Galactic latitude EGRET sources (b>3 degrees) which demonstrate
significant variability can be identified with flat spectrum radio sources.
This suggests that EGRET is not detecting any type of AGN other than blazars.
This identification method has been used to establish with 99.998% confidence
that the peak gamma-ray flux of a blazar is correlated with its average 5 GHz
radio flux. An even better correlation is seen between gamma-ray flux and the
2.29 GHz flux density measured with VLBI at the base of the radio jet. Also,
using high confidence identifications, we find that the radio sources
identified with EGRET sources have larger correlated VLBI flux densities than
the parent population of flat radio spectrum sources.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9602113 [pdf] - 94165
Is there a correlation between radio and gamma ray luminosities of AGN ?
Mücke, A.;
Pohl, M.;
Reich, P.;
Reich, W.;
Schlickeiser, R.;
Fichtel, C. E.;
Hartman, R. C.;
Kanbach, G.;
Kniffen, D. A.;
Hasselwander, H. A. Mayer-;
Merck, M.;
Michelson, P. F.;
von Montigny, C.;
Willis, T. D.
Submitted: 1996-02-22
The possibility of a correlation between the radio (cm)- and $\gamma$-ray
luminosity of variable AGN seen by EGRET is investigated. We performed
Monte-Carlo simulations of typical data sets and applied different correlation
techniques (partial correlation analysis, $\chi^2$-test applied on flux-flux
relations) in view of a truncation bias caused by sensitivity limits of the
surveys. For K-corrected flux densities, we find that with the least squares
method only a linear correlation can be recovered. Partial correlation analysis
on the other side provides a robust tool to detect correlations even in
flux-limited samples if intrinsic scatter does not exceed $\sim 40$ \% of the
original $\gamma$-ray luminosity. The analysis presented in this paper takes
into account redshift bias and truncation effects simultaneously which was
never considered in earlier papers.
Applying this analysis to simultaneously observed radio- and $\gamma$-ray
data, no correlation is found. However, an artificial correlation appears when
using the mean flux. This is probably due to the reduction of the dynamical
range in the flux-flux relation. Furthermore, we show that comparing the
emission in both spectral bands at a high activity state leads to no convincing
correlation.
In conclusion, we can not confirm a correlation between radio and
$\gamma$-ray luminosities of AGN which is claimed in previous works.