Normalized to: Hanasoge, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.05825 [pdf] - 2112137
Solar wind prediction using deep learning
Submitted: 2020-06-10
Emanating from the base of the Sun's corona, the solar wind fills the
interplanetary medium with a magnetized stream of charged particles whose
interaction with the Earth's magnetosphere has space-weather consequences such
as geomagnetic storms. Accurately predicting the solar wind through
measurements of the spatio-temporally evolving conditions in the solar
atmosphere is important but remains an unsolved problem in heliophysics and
space-weather research.
In this work, we use deep learning for prediction of solar wind (SW)
properties. We use Extreme Ultraviolet images of the solar corona from space
based observations to predict the SW speed from the NASA OMNIWEB dataset,
measured at Lagragian point 1. We evaluate our model against autoregressive and
naive models, and find that our model outperforms the benchmark models,
obtaining a best-fit correlation of 0.55 $\pm$ 0.03 with the observed data.
Upon visualization and investigation of how the model uses data to make
predictions, we find higher activation at the coronal holes for fast wind
prediction ($\approx$ 3 to 4 days prior to prediction), and at the active
regions for slow wind prediction. These trends bear an uncanny similarity to
the influence of regions potentially being the sources of fast and slow wind,
as reported in literature. This suggests that our model was able to learn some
of the salient associations between coronal and solar wind structure without
built-in physics knowledge. Such an approach may help us discover hitherto
unknown relationships in heliophysics datasets.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.13333 [pdf] - 2103011
Supervised convolutional neural networks for classification of flaring
and nonflaring active regions using line-of-sight magnetograms
Submitted: 2020-05-27
Solar flares are explosions in the solar atmosphere that release intense
bursts of short-wavelength radiation and are capable of producing severe
space-weather consequences. Flares release free energy built up in coronal
fields, which are rooted in active regions (ARs) on the photosphere, via
magnetic reconnection. The exact processes that lead to reconnection are not
fully known and therefore reliable forecasting of flares is challenging.
Recently, photospheric magnetic-field data has been extensively analysed using
machine learning (ML) and these studies suggest that flare-forecasting accuracy
does not strongly depend on how long in advance flares are predicted (Bobra &
Couvidat 2015; Raboonik et al. 2017; Huang et al. 2018). Here, we use ML to
understand the evolution of AR magnetic fields before and after flares. We
explicitly train convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to classify SDO/HMI
line-of-sight magnetograms into ARs producing at least one M- or X-class flare
or as nonflaring. We find that flaring ARs remain in flare-productive states --
marked by recall >60% with a peak of ~ 80% -- days before and after flares. We
use occlusion maps and statistical analysis to show that the CNN pays attention
to regions between the opposite polarities from ARs and the CNN output is
dominantly decided by the total unsigned line-of-sight flux of ARs. Using
synthetic bipole magnetograms, we find spurious dependencies of the CNN output
on magnetogram dimensions for a given bipole size. Our results suggest that it
is important to use CNN designs that eliminate such artifacts in CNN
applications for processing magnetograms and, in general, solar image data.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.14536 [pdf] - 2126793
Sensitivity kernels for inferring Lorentz stresses from normal-mode
frequency splittings in the Sun
Submitted: 2020-04-29
Departures from standard spherically symmetric solar models, in the form of
perturbations such as global and local-scale flows and structural
asphericities, result in the splitting of eigenfrequencies in the observed
spectrum of solar oscillations. Drawing from prevalent ideas in normal-mode
coupling theory in geophysical literature, we devise a procedure that enables
the computation of sensitivity kernels for general Lorentz stress fields in the
Sun. Mode coupling due to any perturbation requires careful consideration of
self- and cross-coupling of multiplets. Invoking the isolated-multiplet
approximation allows for limiting the treatment to purely self-coupling,
requiring significantly less computational resources. We identify the presence
of such isolated multiplets under the effect of Lorentz stresses in the Sun.
Currently, solar missions allow precise measurements of self-coupling of
multiplets via "$a$-coefficients" and the cross-spectral correlation signal
which enables the estimation of the "structure coefficients". We demonstrate
the forward problem for both self-coupling ($a$-coefficients) and
cross-coupling (structure coefficients). In doing so, we plot the self-coupling
kernels and estimate $a$-coefficients arising from a combination of
deep-toroidal and surface-dipolar axisymmetric fields. We also compute the
structure coefficients for an arbitrary general magnetic field (real and
solenoidal) and plot the corresponding "splitting function", a convenient way
to visualize the splitting of multiplets under 3D internal perturbations. The
results discussed in this paper pave the way to formally pose an inverse
problem, and infer solar internal magnetic fields.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.05890 [pdf] - 2065226
Properties of solar Rossby waves from normal mode coupling and
characterizing its systematics
Submitted: 2019-08-16, last modified: 2020-02-05
Rossby waves play an important role in mediating the angular momentum of
rotating spherical fluids, creating weather on Earth and tuning exoplanet
orbits in distant stellar systems (Ogilvie 2014). Their recent discovery in the
solar convection zone provides an exciting opportunity to appreciate the
detailed astrophysics of Rossby waves. Large-scale Rossby waves create subtle
drifts in acoustic oscillations in the convection zone, which we measure using
helioseismology to image properties of Rossby waves in the interior. We analyze
20 years of space-based observations, from 1999 to 2018, to measure Rossby-mode
frequencies, line-widths, and amplitudes. Spatial leakage affects the
measurements of normal model coupling and complicates the analysis of
separating out specific harmonic degree and the azimuthal number of features on
the Sun. Here we demonstrate a novel approach to overcome this difficulty and
test it by performing synthetic tests. We find that the root-mean-square
velocity of the modes is of the order of 0.5 m/s at the surface.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.08456 [pdf] - 1975406
Validating time-distance helioseismic inversions for non-separable
subsurface profiles of an average supergranule
Submitted: 2019-08-22
Supergranules are divergent 30-Mm sized cellular flows observed everywhere at
the solar photosphere. Their place in the hierarchy of convective structures
and their origin remain poorly understood (Rincon et al., 2018). Estimating
supergranular depth is of particular interest since this may help point to the
underlying physics. However, their subsurface velocity profiles have proven
difficult to ascertain. Birch et al. (2006) had suggested that helioseismic
inferences would benefit from an ensemble average over multiple realizations of
supergranules due to the reduction in realization noise. Bhattacharya et al.
(2017) used synthetic forward-modelled seismic wave travel times and
demonstrated the potential of helioseismic inversions at recovering the flow
profile of an average supergranule that is separable in the horizontal and
vertical directions, although the premise of this calculation has since been
challenged by Ferret (2019). In this work we avoid this assumption and carry
out a validation test of helioseismic travel-time inversions starting from
plausible synthetic non-separable profiles of an average supergranule. We
compute seismic wave travel times and sensitivity kernels by simulating wave
propagation through this background. We find that, while the ability to recover
the exact profile degrades based on the number of parameters involved, we are
nevertheless able to recover the peak depth of our models in a few iterations
where the measurements are presumably above the noise cutoff. This represents
an important step towards unraveling the physics behind supergranules, as we
start appreciating the parameters that we may reliably infer from a
time-distance helioseismic inversion.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.10167 [pdf] - 1888938
Machine learning reveals systematic accumulation of electric current in
lead-up to solar flares
Submitted: 2019-05-24
Solar flares - bursts of high-energy radiation responsible for severe
space-weather effects - are a consequence of the occasional destabilization of
magnetic fields rooted in active regions (ARs). The complexity of AR evolution
is a barrier to a comprehensive understanding of flaring processes and accurate
prediction. Though machine learning (ML) has been used to improve flare
predictions, the potential for revealing precursors and associated physics has
been underexploited. Here, we train ML algorithms to classify between
vector-magnetic-field observations from flaring ARs, producing at least one
M-/X-class flare, and non-flaring ARs. Analysis of magnetic-field observations
accurately classified by the machine presents statistical evidence for (1) ARs
persisting in flare-productive states --- characterized by AR area --- for
days, before and after M- and X-class flare events, (2) systematic pre-flare
build-up of free energy in the form of electric currents, suggesting that
associated subsurface magnetic field is twisted, (3) intensification of Maxwell
stresses in the corona above newly emerging ARs, days before first flares.
These results provide new insights into flare physics and improving flare
forecasting.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.01676 [pdf] - 1855735
Latitudinal differential rotation in the solar analogues 16 Cyg A and B
Submitted: 2019-02-05, last modified: 2019-02-09
Asteroseismology has undergone a profound transformation as a scientific
field following the CoRoT and Kepler space missions. The latter is now yielding
the first measurements of latitudinal differential rotation obtained directly
from oscillation frequencies. Differential rotation is a fundamental mechanism
of the stellar dynamo effect. Our goal is to measure the amount of differential
rotation in the solar analogues 16 Cyg A and B, which are the components of a
binary system. These stars are the brightest observed by Kepler and have
therefore been extensively observed, with exquisite precision on their
oscillation frequencies. We modelled the acoustic power spectrum of 16 Cyg A
and B using a model that takes into account the contribution of differential
rotation to the rotational frequency splitting. The estimation was carried out
in a Bayesian setting. We then inverted these results to obtain the rotation
profile of both stars under the assumption of a solar-like functional form. We
observe that the magnitude of latitudinal differential rotation has a strong
chance of being solar-like for both stars, their rotation rates being higher at
the equator than at the pole. The measured latitudinal differential rotation,
defined as the difference of rotation rate between the equator and the pole, is
$320\pm269$ nHz and $440^{+363}_{-383}$ nHz for 16 Cyg A and B, respectively,
confirming that the rotation rates of these stars are almost solar-like. Their
equatorial rotation rates are $535\pm75$ nHz and $565_{-129}^{+150}$ nHz. Our
results are in good agreement with measurements obtained from
spectropolarimetry, spectroscopy, and photometry. We present the first
conclusive measurement of latitudinal differential rotation for solar
analogues. Their rotational profiles are very close to those of the Sun. These
results depend weakly on the uncertainties of the stellar parameters.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.06479 [pdf] - 1818923
Detection of Rossby waves in the Sun using normal-mode coupling
Submitted: 2019-01-19
Rossby waves play a fundamental role in angular momentum processes in
rotating fluids. In addition to the potential to shed light on physical
mechanisms operating in the solar convection zone, the recent detection of
Rossby waves in the Sun (L\"optien et al. 2018; Liang et al. 2018) also serves
as a means of comparison between different helioseismic methods. Time-distance
helioseismology, ring-diagram analysis and other techniques have all proven
successful in recovering the Rossby-wave dispersion relation from analyses of
Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager data (HMI; Schou et al. 2012). In this
article, we demonstrate that analyses of two years of HMI
global-mode-oscillation data using the technique of normal-mode coupling also
show signatures of Rossby waves. In addition to providing an independent means
of inferring Rossby waves, this detection lends credence to the methodology of
mode coupling and encourages a more complete exploration of its possibilities.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.01505 [pdf] - 1826888
Supervised Neural Networks for Helioseismic Ring-Diagram Inversions
Submitted: 2019-01-06
The inversion of ring fit parameters to obtain subsurface flow maps in
ring-diagram analysis for 8 years of SDO observations is computationally
expensive, requiring ~3200 CPU hours. In this paper we apply machine learning
techniques to the inversion in order to speed up calculations. Specifically, we
train a predictor for subsurface flows using the mode fit parameters and the
previous inversion results, to replace future inversion requirements. We
utilize Artificial Neural Networks as a supervised learning method for
predicting the flows in 15 degree ring tiles. To demonstrate that the machine
learning results still contain the subtle signatures key to local helioseismic
studies, we use the machine learning results to study the recently discovered
solar equatorial Rossby waves. The Artificial Neural Network is computationally
efficient, able to make future flow predictions of an entire Carrington
rotation in a matter of seconds, which is much faster than the current ~31 CPU
hours. Initial training of the networks requires ~3 CPU hours. The trained
Artificial Neural Network can achieve a root mean-square error equal to
approximately half that reported for the velocity inversions, demonstrating the
accuracy of the machine learning (and perhaps the overestimation of the
original errors from the ring-diagram pipeline). We find the signature of
equatorial Rossby waves in the machine learning flows covering six years of
data, demonstrating that small-amplitude signals are maintained. The recovery
of Rossby waves in the machine learning flow maps can be achieved with only one
Carrington rotation (27.275 days) of training data. We have shown that machine
learning can be applied to, and perform more efficiently than the current
ring-diagram inversion. The computation burden of the machine learning includes
3 CPU hours for initial training, then around 0.0001 CPU hours for future
predictions.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.07938 [pdf] - 1754384
Asteroseismic detection of latitudinal differential rotation in 13
Sun-like stars
Benomar, O.;
Bazot, M.;
Nielsen, M. B.;
Gizon, L.;
Sekii, T.;
Takata, M.;
Hotta, H.;
Hanasoge, S.;
Sreenivasan, K. R.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.
Submitted: 2018-09-21
The differentially rotating outer layers of stars are thought to play a role
in driving their magnetic activity, but the underlying mechanisms that generate
and sustain differential rotation are poorly understood. We report the
measurement of latitudinal differential rotation in the convection zones of 40
Sun-like stars using asteroseismology. For the most significant detections, the
stars' equators rotate approximately twice as fast as their mid-latitudes. The
latitudinal shear inferred from asteroseismology is much larger than
predictions from numerical simulations.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.00314 [pdf] - 1732774
Helioseismic inversion to infer depth profile of solar meridional flow
using spherical Born kernels
Submitted: 2018-07-01
Accurate inference of solar meridional flow is of crucial importance for the
understanding of solar dynamo process. Wave travel times, as measured on the
surface, will change if the waves encounter perturbations e.g. in the sound
speed or flows, as they propagate through the solar interior. Using functions
called sensitivity kernels, we may image the underlying anomalies that cause
measured shifts in travel times. The inference of large-scale structures e.g
meridional circulation requires computing sensitivity kernels in spherical
geometry. Mandal et al. (2017) have computed such spherical kernels in the
limit of the first-Born approximation. In this work, we perform an inversion
for meridional circulation using travel-time measurements obtained from 6 years
of SDO/HMI data and those sensitivity kernels. We enforce mass conservation by
inverting for a stream function. The number of free parameters is reduced by
projecting the solution on to cubic B-splines in radius and derivatives of the
Legendre-polynomial basis in latitude, thereby improving the condition number
of the inverse problem. We validate our approach for synthetic observations
before performing the actual inversion. The inversion suggests a single-cell
profile with the return-flow occurring at depths below 0.78 $R_\odot$.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.02776 [pdf] - 1717004
Measurement process and inversions using helioseismic normal-mode
coupling
Submitted: 2018-02-08, last modified: 2018-05-08
Normal modes are coupled by the presence of perturbations in the Sun,
providing a novel and under-appreciated helioseismic technique with which to
image the solar interior. The process of measuring coupling between normal
modes is straightforward, much more so when compared with other prevalent
helioseismic techniques. The theoretical framework to interpret these
measurements is well developed with the caveat that it applies only in the case
where the entire surface of the Sun is observed. In practice however, the
limited visibility of the Sun and line-of-sight related effects diminish the
resolution of the technique. Here, we compute realistic sensitivities of
normal-mode coupling measurements to flows in the solar interior and describe
how to mitigate the sometimes-overwhelming effect of leakage. The importance of
being able to isolate individual spherical harmonics and observe the full Sun,
to which future solar observatories may aspire, is thus highlighted in our
results. In the latter part of the article, we describe the noise model for the
variance of coupling coefficients, a critical component to the process of
inference.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.06117 [pdf] - 1675054
Asymmetry of line profiles of stellar oscillations measured by Kepler
for ensembles of solar-like oscillators: impact on mode frequencies and
dependence on effective temperature
Benomar, O.;
Goupil, Mjo.;
Belkacem, K.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Nielsen, M. B.;
Bazot, M.;
Gizon, L.;
Hanasoge, S.;
Sreenivasan, K. R.;
Marchand, B.
Submitted: 2018-04-17
Oscillation properties are usually measured by fitting symmetric Lorentzian
profiles to the power spectra of Sun-like stars. However the line profiles of
solar oscillations have been observed to be asymmetrical for the Sun. The
physical origin of this line asymmetry is not fully understood, although it
should depend on the depth dependence of the source of wave excitation
(convective turbulence) and details of the observable (velocity or intensity).
For oscillations of the Sun, it has been shown that neglecting the asymmetry
leads to systematic errors in the frequency determination. This could
subsequently affects the results of seismic inferences of the solar internal
structure. Using light curves from the {\it Kepler} spacecraft we have measured
mode asymmetries in 43 stars. We confirm that neglecting the asymmetry leads to
systematic errors that can exceed the $1\sigma$ confidence intervals for
seismic observations longer than one year. Therefore, the application of an
asymmetric Lorentzian profile is to be favoured to improve the accuracy of the
internal stellar structure and stellar fundamental parameters. We also show
that the asymmetry changes sign between cool Sun-like stars and hotter stars.
This provides the best constraints to date on the location of the excitation
sources across the Hertzsprung-Russel diagram.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.03464 [pdf] - 1593584
Iterative inversion of synthetic travel times successful at recovering
sub-surface profiles of supergranular flows
Submitted: 2017-08-11
We develop a helioseismic inversion algorithm that can be used to recover
sub-surface vertical profiles of 2-dimensional supergranular flows from surface
measurements of synthetic wave travel times. We carry out seismic
wave-propagation simulations through a 2-dimensional section of a flow profile
that resembles an averaged supergranule, and a starting model that has flows
only at the surface. We assume that the wave measurements are entirely without
realization noise for the purpose of our test. We expand the vertical profile
of the supergranule stream function on a basis of B-splines. We iteratively
update the B-spline coefficients of the supergranule model to reduce the
travel-times differences observed between the two simulations. We carry out the
exercise for four different vertical profiles peaking at different depths below
the solar surface. We are able to accurately recover depth profiles of four
supergranule models at depths up to $8-10\,\text{Mm}$ below the solar surface
using $f-p_4$ modes, under the assumption that there is no realization noise.
We are able to obtain the peak depth and the depth of the return flow for each
model. A basis-resolved inversion performs significantly better than one where
the flow field is inverted for at each point in the radial grid. This is an
encouraging result and might act as a guide in developing more realistic
inversion strategies that can be applied to supergranular flows in the Sun.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.09431 [pdf] - 1583916
Seismic sensitivity of Normal-mode Coupling to Lorentz stresses in the
Sun
Submitted: 2017-05-26, last modified: 2017-07-28
Understanding the governing mechanism of solar magnetism remains an
outstanding challenge in astrophysics. Seismology is the most compelling
technique with which to infer the internal properties of the Sun and stars.
Waves in the Sun, nominally acoustic, are sensitive to the emergence and
cyclical strengthening of magnetic field, evidenced by measured changes in
resonant oscillation frequencies that are correlated with the solar cycle. The
inference of internal Lorentz stresses from these measurements has the
potential to significantly advance our appreciation of the dynamo. Indeed,
seismological inverse theory for the Sun is well understood for perturbations
in composition, thermal structure and flows but, is not fully developed for
magnetism, owing to the complexity of the ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD)
equation. Invoking first-Born perturbation theory to characterize departures
from spherically symmetric hydrostatic models of the Sun and applying the
notation of generalized spherical harmonics, we calculate sensitivity functions
of seismic measurements to the general time-varying Lorentz stress tensor. We
find that eigenstates of isotropic (i.e. acoustic only) background models are
dominantly sensitive to isotropic deviations in the stress tensor and much more
weakly so to anisotropic stresses (and therefore challenging to infer). The
apple cannot fall far from the tree.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.08204 [pdf] - 1583769
Sensitivity of Helioseismic Measurements of Normal-mode Coupling to
Flows and Sound-speed Perturbations
Submitted: 2017-05-23
In this article, we derive and compute the sensitivity of measurements of
coupling between normal modes of oscillation in the Sun to underlying flows.
The theory is based on first-Born perturbation theory, and the analysis is
carried out using the formalism described by \citet{lavely92}. Albeit tedious,
we detail the derivation and compute the sensitivity of specific pairs of
coupled normal modes to anomalies in the interior. Indeed, these kernels are
critical for the accurate inference of convective flow amplitudes and
large-scale circulations in the solar interior. We resolve some inconsistencies
in the derivation of \citet{lavely92} and reformulate the fluid-continuity
condition. We also derive and compute sound-speed kernels, paving the way for
inverting for thermal anomalies alongside flows.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.04020 [pdf] - 1583325
Finite-frequency sensitivity kernels in spherical geometry for
time-distance helioseismology
Submitted: 2017-05-11
The inference of internal properties of the Sun from surface measurements of
wave travel times is the goal of time-distance helioseismology. A critical step
toward the accurate interpretation of travel-time shifts is the computation of
sensitivity functions linking seismic measurements to internal structure. Here
we calculate finite-frequency sensitivity kernels in spherical geometry for
two-point travel-time measurements. We numerically build Green's function by
solving for it at each frequency and spherical-harmonic degree and summing over
all these pieces. These computations are performed in parallel
("embarrassingly"), thereby achieving significant speedup in wall-clock time.
Kernels are calculated by invoking the first-order Born approximation
connecting deviations in the wavefield to perturbations in the operator.
Validated flow kernels are shown to produce travel times within 0.47% of the
true value for uniform flows up to 750 m/s. We find that travel-time can be
obtained with errors of 1 millisecond or less for flows having magnitudes
similar to meridional circulation. Alongside flows, we also compute and
validate sensitivity kernel for sound-speed perturbations. These accurate
sensitivity kernels might improve the current inferences of sub-surface flows
significantly.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.00902 [pdf] - 1475280
Asteroseismic determination of fundamental parameters of sun-like stars
using multi-layered neural networks
Submitted: 2016-02-02, last modified: 2016-07-01
The advent of space-based observatories such as CoRoT and Kepler has enabled
the testing of our understanding of stellar evolution on thousands of stars.
Evolutionary models typically require five input parameters, the mass, initial
Helium abundance, initial metallicity, mixing- length (assumed to be constant
over time), and the age to which the star must be evolved. Some of these
parameters are also very useful in characterizing the associated planets and in
studying galactic archaeology. How to obtain these parameters from observations
rapidly and accurately, specifically in the context of surveys of thousands of
stars, is an outstanding ques- tion, one that has eluded straightforward
resolution. For a given star, we typically measure the effective temperature
and surface metallicity spectroscopically and low-degree oscillation
frequencies through space observatories. Here we demonstrate that statistical
learning, using artificial neural networks, is successful in determining the
evolutionary parameters based on spectroscopic and seismic measurements. Our
trained networks show robustness over a broad range of parameter space, and
critically, are entirely computationally inexpensive and fully automated. We
analyze the observations of a few stars using this method and the results com-
pare well to inferences obtained using other techniques. This method is both
computationally cheap and inferentially accurate, paving the way for analyzing
the vast quantities of stellar observations from past, current, and future
missions.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.09315 [pdf] - 1447780
Strategies in seismic inference of supergranular flows on the Sun
Submitted: 2016-05-30
Observations of the solar surface reveal the presence of flows with length
scales of around $35$ Mm, commonly referred to as supergranules. Inferring the
sub-surface flow profile of supergranules from measurements of the surface and
photospheric wavefield is an important challenge faced by helioseismology.
Traditionally, the inverse problem has been approached by studying the linear
response of seismic waves in a horizontally translationally invariant
background to the presence of the supergranule; following an iterative approach
that does not depend on horizontal translational invariance might perform
better, since the misfit can be analyzed post iterations. In this work, we
construct synthetic observations using a reference supergranule, and invert for
the flow profile using surface measurements of travel-times of waves belonging
to modal ridges $f$ (surface-gravity) and $p_{1}$ through $p_{7}$ (acoustic).
We study the extent to which individual modes and their combinations contribute
to infer the flow. We show that this method of non-linear iterative inversion
tends to underestimate the flow velocities as well as inferring a shallower
flow profile, with significant deviations from the reference supergranule near
the surface. We carry out a similar analysis for a sound-speed perturbation and
find that analogous near-surface deviations persist, although the iterations
converge faster and more accurately. We conclude that a better approach to
inversion would be to expand the supergranule profile in an appropriate basis,
thereby reducing the number of parameters being inverted for and appropriately
regularizing them.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.04048 [pdf] - 1029528
Frequency shifts of resonant modes of the Sun due to near-surface
convective scattering
Submitted: 2015-05-15
Measurements of oscillation frequencies of the Sun and stars can provide
important independent constraints on their internal structure and dynamics.
Seismic models of these oscillations are used to connect structure and rotation
of the star to its resonant frequencies, which are then compared with
observations, the goal being that of minimizing the difference between the two.
Even in the case of the Sun, for which structure models are highly tuned,
observed frequencies show systematic deviations from modeled frequencies, a
phenomenon referred to as the "surface term." The dominant source of this
systematic effect is thought to be vigorous near-surface convection, which is
not well accounted for in both stellar modeling and mode-oscillation physics.
Here we bring to bear the method of homogenization, applicable in the
asymptotic limit of large wavelengths (in comparison to the correlation scale
of convection), to characterize the effect of small-scale surface convection on
resonant-mode frequencies in the Sun. We show that the full oscillation
equations, in the presence of temporally stationary 3-D flows, can be reduced
to an effective "quiet-Sun" wave equation with altered sound speed,
Br\"{u}nt--V\"{a}is\"{a}la frequency and Lamb frequency. We derive the modified
equation and relations for the appropriate averaging of three dimensional flows
and thermal quantities to obtain the properties of this effective medium. Using
flows obtained from three dimensional numerical simulations of near-surface
convection, we quantify their effect on solar oscillation frequencies, and find
that they are shifted systematically and substantially. We argue therefore that
consistent interpretations of resonant frequencies must include modifications
to the wave equation that effectively capture the impact of vigorous
hydrodynamic convection.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.06032 [pdf] - 1043172
Simulating acoustic waves in spotted stars
Submitted: 2015-03-20, last modified: 2015-04-13
Acoustic modes of oscillation are affected by stellar activity, however it is
unclear how starspots contribute to these changes. Here we investigate the
nonmagnetic effects of starspots on global modes with angular degree $\ell \leq
2$ in highly active stars, and characterize the spot seismic signature on
synthetic light curves. We perform 3D time-domain simulations of linear
acoustic waves to study their interaction with a model starspot. We model the
spot as a 3D change in the sound speed stratification with respect to a
convectively stable stellar background, built from solar Model S. We perform a
parametric study by considering different depths and perturbation amplitudes.
Exact numerical simulations allow the investigation of the wavefield-spot
interaction beyond first order perturbation theory. The interaction of the
axisymmetric modes with the starspot is strongly nonlinear. As mode frequency
increases, the frequency shifts for radial modes exceed the value predicted by
linear theory, while the shifts for the $\ell=2, m=0$ modes are smaller than
predicted by linear theory, with avoided-crossing-like patterns forming between
the $m=0$ and $m=1$ mode frequencies. The nonlinear behavior increases with
increasing spot amplitude and/or decreasing depth. Linear theory still
reproduces the correct shifts for nonaxisymmetric modes. In the nonlinear
regime the mode eigenfunctions are not pure spherical harmonics, but rather a
mixture of different spherical harmonics. This mode mixing, together with the
frequency changes, may lead to misidentification of the modes in the observed
acoustic power spectra.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.08539 [pdf] - 972680
Solar Dynamics, Rotation, Convection and Overshoot
Submitted: 2015-03-30
We discuss recent observational, theoretical and modeling progress made in
understanding the Sun's internal dynamics, including its rotation, meridional
flow, convection and overshoot. Over the past few decades, substantial
theoretical and observational effort has gone into appreciating these aspects
of solar dynamics. A review of these observations, related helioseismic
methodology and inference and computational results in relation to these
problems is undertaken here.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.07961 [pdf] - 1342738
Seismic Sounding of Convection in the Sun
Submitted: 2015-03-27
Our Sun, primarily composed of ionized hydrogen and helium, has a surface
temperature of 5777~K and a radius $R_\odot \approx 696,000$ km. In the outer
$R_\odot/3$, energy transport is accomplished primarily by convection. Using
typical convective velocities $u\sim100\,\rm{m\,s^{-1}}$ and kinematic
viscosities of order $10^{-4}$ m$^{2}$s$^{-1}$, we obtain a Reynolds number $Re
\sim 10^{14}$. Convection is thus turbulent, causing a vast range of scales to
be excited. The Prandtl number, $Pr$, of the convecting fluid is very low, of
order $10^{-7}$\,--\,$10^{-4}$, so that the Rayleigh number ($\sim Re^2 Pr$) is
on the order of $10^{21}\,-\,10^{24}$. Solar convection thus lies in
extraordinary regime of dynamical parameters, highly untypical of fluid flows
on Earth. Convective processes in the Sun drive global fluid circulations and
magnetic fields, which in turn affect its visible outer layers ("solar
activity") and, more broadly, the heliosphere ("space weather"). The precise
determination of the depth of solar convection zone, departures from
adiabaticity of the temperature gradient, and the internal rotation rate as a
function of latitude and depth are among the seminal contributions of
helioseismology towards understanding convection in the Sun. Contemporary
helioseismology, which is focused on inferring the properties of
three-dimensional convective features, suggests that transport velocities are
substantially smaller than theoretical predictions. Furthermore,
helioseismology provides important constraints on the anisotropic Reynolds
stresses that control the global dynamics of the solar convection zone. This
review discusses the state of our understanding of convection in the Sun, with
a focus on helioseismic diagnostics. We present our considerations with the
interests of fluid dynamicists in mind.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.1981 [pdf] - 1222458
Full Waveform Inversion of Solar Interior Flows
Submitted: 2014-10-08
The inference of flows of material in the interior of the Sun is a subject of
major interest in helioseismology. Here we apply techniques of Full Waveform
Inversion (FWI) to synthetic data to test flow inversions. In this idealized
setup, we do not model seismic realization noise, training the focus entirely
on the problem of whether a chosen supergranulation flow model can be
seismically recovered. We define the misfit functional as a sum of L_2 norm
deviations in travel times between prediction and observation, as measured
using short-distance f and p_1 filtered and large-distance unfiltered $p$
modes. FWI allows for the introduction of measurements of choice and
iteratively improving the background model, while monitoring the evolution of
the misfit in all desired categories. Although the misfit is seen to uniformly
reduce in all categories, convergence to the true model is very slow, possibly
because it is trapped in a local minimum. The primary source of error is
inaccurate depth localization, which, owing to density stratification, leads to
wrong ratios of horizontal and vertical flow velocities (`cross talk'). In the
present formulation, the lack of sufficient temporal frequency and spatial
resolution makes it difficult to accurately localise flow profiles at depth. We
therefore suggest that the most efficient way to discover the global minimum is
to perform a probabilistic forward search, involving calculating the misfit
associated with a broad range of models (generated, for instance, by a
Monte-Carlo algorithm) and locating the deepest minimum. Such techniques
possess the added advantage of being able to quantify model uncertainty as well
as realization noise (data uncertainty).
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.2533 [pdf] - 1208896
Additional Evidence Supporting a Model of Shallow, High-Speed
Supergranulation
Submitted: 2014-04-09
Recently, Duvall and Hanasoge ({\it Solar Phys.} {\bf 287}, 71-83, 2013)
found that large distance $[\Delta]$ separation travel-time differences from a
center to an annulus $[\delta t_{\rm{oi}}]$ implied a model of the average
supergranular cell that has a peak upflow of $240\rm{ms^{-1}}$ at a depth of
$2.3\rm{Mm}$ and a corresponding peak outward horizontal flow of
$700\rm{ms^{-1}}$ at a depth of $1.6\rm{Mm}$. In the present work, this effect
is further studied by measuring and modeling center-to-quadrant travel-time
differences $[\delta t_{\rm{qu}}]$, which roughly agree with this model.
Simulations are analyzed that show that such a model flow would lead to the
expected travel-time differences. As a check for possible systematic errors,
the center-to-annulus travel-time differences $[\delta t_{\rm{oi}}]$ are found
not to vary with heliocentric angle. A consistency check finds an increase of
$\delta t_{\rm{oi}}$ with the temporal frequency $[\nu]$ by a factor of two,
which is not predicted by the ray theory.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.7603 [pdf] - 1203058
Full Waveform Inversion for Time-Distance Helioseismology
Submitted: 2014-01-29
Inferring interior properties of the Sun from photospheric measurements of
the seismic wavefield constitutes the helioseismic inverse problem. Deviations
in seismic measurements (such as wave travel times) from their fiducial values
estimated for a given model of the solar interior imply that the model is
inaccurate. Contemporary inversions in local helioseismology assume that
properties of the solar interior are linearly related to measured travel-time
deviations. It is widely known, however, that this assumption is invalid for
sunspots and active regions, and likely for supergranular flows as well. Here,
we introduce nonlinear optimization, executed iteratively, as a means of
inverting for the sub-surface structure of large-amplitude perturbations.
Defining the penalty functional as the $L_2$ norm of wave travel-time
deviations, we compute the the total misfit gradient of this functional with
respect to the relevant model parameters %(only sound speed in this case) at
each iteration around the corresponding model. The model is successively
improved using either steepest descent, conjugate gradient, or quasi-Newton
limited-memory BFGS. Performing nonlinear iterations requires privileging
pixels (such as those in the near-field of the scatterer), a practice not
compliant with the standard assumption of translational invariance.
Measurements for these inversions, although similar in principle to those used
in time-distance helioseismology, require some retooling. For the sake of
simplicity in illustrating the method, we consider a 2-D inverse problem with
only a sound-speed perturbation.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.0110 [pdf] - 1202491
The Quest to Understand Supergranulation and Large-Scale Convection in
the Sun
Submitted: 2013-12-31
Surface granulation of the Sun is primarily a consequence of thermal
transport in the outer 1 % of the radius. Its typical scale of about 1 - 2 Mm
is set by the balance between convection, free-streaming radiation, and the
strong density stratification in the surface layers.
The physics of granulation is well understood, as demonstrated by the close
agreement between numerical simulation, theory, and observation. Superimposed
on the energetic granular structure comprising high-speed flows, are larger
scale long-lived flow systems (~ 300 m/s) called supergranules.
Supergranulation has a typical scale of 24 - 36 Mm. It is not clear if
supergranulation results from the interaction of granules or is causally linked
to deep convection or a consequence of magneto-convection. Other outstanding
questions remain: how deep are supergranules? How do they participate in global
dynamics of the Sun? Further challenges are posed by our lack of insight into
the dynamics of larger scales in the deep convection region. Recent
helioseismic constraints have suggested that convective velocity amplitudes on
large scales may be overestimated by an order of magnitude or more, implying
that Reynolds stresses associated with large-scale convection, thought to play
a significant role in the sustenance of differential rotation and meridional
circulation, might be two orders of magnitude weaker than theory and
computation predict. While basic understanding on the nature of convection on
global scales and the maintenance of global circulations is incomplete,
progress is imminent, given substantial improvements in computation, theory and
helioseismic inferences.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.0857 [pdf] - 1179688
Measurements and Kernels for Source-Structure Inversions in Noise
Tomography
Submitted: 2013-10-02
Seismic noise cross correlations are used to image crustal structure and
heterogeneity. Typically, seismic networks are only anisotropically illuminated
by seismic noise, a consequence of the non-uniform distribution of sources.
Here, we study the sensitivity of such a seismic network to structural
heterogeneity in a 2-D setting. We compute finite-frequency cross-correlation
sensitivity kernels for travel-time, waveform-energy and waveform-difference
measurements. In line with expectation, wavespeed anomalies are best imaged
using travel times and the source distribution using cross-correlation
energies. Perturbations in attenuation and impedance are very difficult to
image and reliable inferences require a high degree of certainty in the
knowledge of the source distribution and wavespeed model (at least in the case
of transmission tomography studied here). We perform single-step Gauss-Newton
inversions for the source distribution and the wavespeed, in that order, and
quantify the associated Cram\'{e}r-Rao lower bound. The inversion and
uncertainty estimate are robust to errors in the source model but are sensitive
to the theory used to interpret of measurements. We find that when classical
source-receiver kernels are used instead of cross-correlation kernels, errors
appear in the both the inversion and uncertainty estimate, systematically
biasing the results. We outline a computationally tractable algorithm to
account for distant sources when performing inversions.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.4352 [pdf] - 708554
Seismic constraints on rotation of Sun-like star and mass of exoplanet
Gizon, Laurent;
Ballot, Jérome;
Michel, Eric;
Stahn, Thorsten;
Vauclair, Gérard;
Bruntt, Hans;
Quirion, Pierre-Olivier;
Benomar, Othman;
Vauclair, Sylvie;
Appourchaux, Thierry;
Auvergne, Michel;
Baglin, Annie;
Barban, Caroline;
Baudin, Fréderic;
Bazot, Michaël;
Campante, Tiago;
Catala, Claude;
Chaplin, William;
Creevey, Orlagh;
Deheuvels, Sébastien;
Dolez, Noël;
Elsworth, Yvonne;
García, Rafael;
Gaulme, Patrick;
Mathis, Stéphane;
Mathur, Savita;
Mosser, Benoît;
Régulo, Clara;
Roxburgh, Ian;
Salabert, David;
Samadi, Réza;
Sato, Kumiko;
Verner, Graham;
Hanasoge, Shravan;
Sreenivasan, Katepalli R.
Submitted: 2013-08-20
Rotation is thought to drive cyclic magnetic activity in the Sun and Sun-like
stars. Stellar dynamos, however, are poorly understood owing to the scarcity of
observations of rotation and magnetic fields in stars. Here, inferences are
drawn on the internal rotation of a distant Sun-like star by studying its
global modes of oscillation. We report asteroseismic constraints imposed on the
rotation rate and the inclination of the spin axis of the Sun-like star HD
52265, a principal target observed by the CoRoT satellite that is known to host
a planetary companion. These seismic inferences are remarkably consistent with
an independent spectroscopic observation (rotational line broadening) and with
the observed rotation period of star spots. Furthermore, asteroseismology
constrains the mass of exoplanet HD 52265b. Under the standard assumption that
the stellar spin axis and the axis of the planetary orbit coincide, the minimum
spectroscopic mass of the planet can be converted into a true mass of 1.85
(+0.52,-0.42) M_Jupiter, which implies that it is a planet, not a brown dwarf.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.3646 [pdf] - 1173442
Interpreting Cross-correlations of One-bit Filtered Seismic Noise
Submitted: 2013-08-16
Seismic noise, generated by oceanic microseisms and other sources,
illuminates the crust in a manner different from tectonic sources, and
therefore provides independent information. The primary measurable is the
two-point cross-correlation, evaluated using traces recorded at a pair of
seismometers over a finite-time interval. However, raw seismic traces contain
intermittent large-amplitude perturbations arising from tectonic activity and
instrumental errors, which may corrupt the estimated cross-correlations of
microseismic fluctuations. In order to diminish the impact of these
perturbations, the recorded traces are filtered using the nonlinear one-bit
digitizer, which replaces the measurement by its sign. Previous theory shows
that for stationary Gaussian-distributed seismic noise fluctuations one-bit and
raw correlation functions are related by a simple invertible transformation.
Here we extend this to show that the simple correspondence between these two
correlation techniques remains valid for {\it non-stationary} Gaussian and a
very broad range of {\it non-Gaussian} processes as well. For a limited range
of stationary and non-stationary Gaussian fluctuations, we find that one-bit
filtering performs at least as well as spectral whitening. We therefore
recommend using one-bit filtering when processing terrestrial seismic noise,
with the substantial benefit that the measurements are fully compatible with
current theoretical interpretation (e.g., adjoint theory). Given that seismic
records are non-stationary and comprise small-amplitude fluctuations and
intermittent, large-amplitude tectonic/other perturbations, we outline an
algorithm to accurately retrieve the correlation function of the
small-amplitude signals.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.3620 [pdf] - 1172067
Propagation of seismic waves through a spatio-temporally fluctuating
medium: Homogenization
Submitted: 2013-06-15
Measurements of seismic wave travel times at the photosphere of the Sun have
enabled inferences of its interior structure and dynamics. In interpreting
these measurements, the simplifying assumption that waves propagate through a
temporally stationary medium is almost universally invoked. However, the Sun is
in a constant state of evolution, on a broad range of spatio-temporal scales.
At the zero wavelength limit, i.e., when the wavelength is much shorter than
the scale over which the medium varies, the WKBJ (ray) approximation may be
applied. Here, we address the other asymptotic end of the spectrum, the
infinite wavelength limit, using the technique of homogenization. We apply
homogenization to scenarios where waves are propagating through rapidly varying
media (spatially and temporally), and derive effective models for the media.
One consequence is that a scalar sound speed becomes a tensorial wavespeed in
the effective model and anisotropies can be induced depending on the nature of
the perturbation. The second term in this asymptotic two-scale expansion, the
so-called corrector, contains contributions due to higher-order scattering,
leading to the decoherence of the wavefield. This decoherence may be causally
linked to the observed wave attenuation in the Sun. Although the examples we
consider here consist of periodic arrays of perturbations to the background,
homogenization may be extended to ergodic and stationary random media. This
method may have broad implications for the manner in which we interpret seismic
measurements in the Sun and for modeling the effects of granulation on the
scattering of waves and distortion of normal-mode eigenfunctions.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.6886 [pdf] - 1158155
Testing Helioseismic-Holography Inversions for Supergranular Flows Using
Synthetic Data
Submitted: 2012-11-29
Supergranulation is one of the most visible length scales of solar convection
and has been studied extensively by local helioseismology. We use synthetic
data computed with the Seismic Propagation through Active Regions and
Convection (SPARC) code to test regularized-least squares (RLS) inversions of
helioseismic holography measurements for a supergranulation-like flow. The code
simulates the acoustic wavefield by solving the linearized three-dimensional
Euler equations in Cartesian geometry. We model a single supergranulation cell
with a simple, axisymmetric, mass-conserving flow.
The use of simulated data provides an opportunity for direct evaluation of
the accuracy of measurement and inversion techniques. The RLS technique applied
to helioseismic-holography measurements is generally successful in reproducing
the structure of the horizontal flow field of the model supergranule cell. The
errors are significant in horizontal-flow inversions near the top and bottom of
the computational domain as well as in vertical-flow inversions throughout the
domain. We show that the errors in the vertical velocity are due largely to
cross talk from the horizontal velocity.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.2313 [pdf] - 1151944
The influence of noise sources on cross-correlation amplitudes
Submitted: 2012-10-08
We use analytical examples and asymptotic forms to examine the mathematical
structure and physical meaning of the seismic cross correlation measurement. We
show that in general, cross correlations are not Green's functions of medium,
and may be very different depending on the source distribution. The modeling of
noise sources using spatial distributions as opposed to discrete collections of
sources is emphasized. When stations are illuminated by spatially complex
source distributions, cross correlations show arrivals at a variety of time
lags, from zero to the maximum surface-wave arrival time. Here, we demonstrate
the possibility of inverting for the source distribution using the energy of
the full cross-correlation waveform. The interplay between the source
distribution and wave attenuation in determining the functional dependence of
cross correlation energies on station-pair distance is quantified. Without
question, energies contain information about wave attenuation. However, the
accurate interpretation of such measurements is tightly connected to the
knowledge of the source distribution.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.6075 [pdf] - 1125093
Subsurface Supergranular Vertical Flows as Measured Using Large Distance
Separations in Time-Distance Helioseismology
Submitted: 2012-07-25
As large--distance rays (say, 10\,-\,$24 ^\circ$) approach the solar surface
approximately vertically, travel times measured from surface pairs for these
large separations are mostly sensitive to vertical flows, at least for shallow
flows within a few Mm of the solar surface. All previous analyses of
supergranulation have used smaller separations and have been hampered by the
difficulty of separating the horizontal and vertical flow components. We find
that the large separation travel times associated with supergranulation cannot
be studied using the standard phase-speed filters of time-distance
helioseismology. These filters, whose use is based upon a refractive model of
the perturbations, reduce the resultant travel time signal by at least an order
of magnitude at some distances. More effective filters are derived. Modeling
suggests that the center--annulus travel time difference $[\delta t_{\rm{oi}}]$
in the separation range $\Delta=10$\,-\,$24 ^\circ$ is insensitive to the
horizontally diverging flow from the centers of the supergranules and should
lead to a constant signal from the vertical flow. Our measurement of this
quantity, $5.1 \pm 0.1\secs$, is constant over the distance range. This
magnitude of signal cannot be caused by the level of upflow at cell centers
seen at the photosphere of $10\ms$ extended in depth. It requires the vertical
flow to increase with depth. A simple Gaussian model of the increase with depth
implies a peak upward flow of $240\ms$ at a depth of $2.3\Mm$ and a peak
horizontal flow of $700\ms$ at a depth of $1.6\Mm$.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.4352 [pdf] - 1124924
Seismic probes of solar interior magnetic structure
Submitted: 2012-07-18
Sunspots are prominent manifestations of solar magnetoconvection and imaging
their subsurface structure is an outstanding problem of wide physical
importance. Travel times of seismic waves that propagate through these
structures are typically used as inputs to inversions. Despite the presence of
strongly anisotropic magnetic waveguides, these measurements have always been
interpreted in terms of changes to isotropic wavespeeds and flow-advection
related Doppler shifts. Here, we employ PDE-constrained optimization to
determine the appropriate parameterization of the structural properties of the
magnetic interior. Seven different wavespeeds fully characterize helioseismic
wave propagation: the isotropic sound speed, a Doppler-shifting flow-advection
velocity and an anisotropic magnetic velocity. The structure of magnetic media
is sensed by magnetoacoustic slow and fast modes and Alfv\'{e}n waves, each of
which propagates at a different wavespeed. We show that even in the case of
weak magnetic fields, significant errors may be incurred if these anisotropies
are not accounted for in inversions. Translation invariance is demonstrably
lost. These developments render plausible the accurate seismic imaging of
magnetoconvection in the Sun.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.3173 [pdf] - 1124117
Anomalously Weak Solar Convection
Submitted: 2012-06-14
Convection in the solar interior is thought to comprise structures on a
spectrum of scales. This conclusion emerges from phenomenological studies and
numerical simulations, though neither covers the proper range of dynamical
parameters of solar convection. Here, we analyze observations of the wavefield
in the solar photosphere using techniques of time-distance helioseismology to
image flows in the solar interior. We downsample and synthesize 900 billion
wavefield observations to produce 3 billion cross-correlations, which we
average and fit, measuring 5 million wave travel times. Using these travel
times, we deduce the underlying flow systems and study their statistics to
bound convective velocity magnitudes in the solar interior, as a function of
depth and spherical-harmonic degree $\ell$. Within the wavenumber band
$\ell<60$, Convective velocities are 20-100 times weaker than current
theoretical estimates. This suggests the prevalence of a different paradigm of
turbulence from that predicted by existing models, prompting the question: what
mechanism transports the heat flux of a solar luminosity outwards? Advection is
dominated by Coriolis forces for wavenumbers $\ell<60$, with Rossby numbers
smaller than $\sim10^{-2}$ at $r/R_\odot=0.96$, suggesting that the Sun may be
a much faster rotator than previously thought, and that large-scale convection
may be quasi-geostrophic. The fact that iso-rotation contours in the Sun are
not co-aligned with the axis of rotation suggests the presence of a latitudinal
entropy gradient.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.3806 [pdf] - 1117365
Detectable seismic consequences of the interaction of a primordial black
hole with Earth
Submitted: 2012-03-16
Galaxies observed today are likely to have evolved from density perturbations
in the early universe. Perturbations that exceeded some critical threshold are
conjectured to have undergone gravitational collapse to form primordial black
holes (PBHs) at a range of masses. Such PBHs serve as candidates for cold dark
matter and their detection would shed light on conditions in the early
universe. Here we propose a mechanism to search for transits of PBHs
through/nearby Earth by studying the associated seismic waves. Using a
spectral-element method, we simulate and visualize this seismic wave field in
Earth's interior. We predict the emergence of two unique signatures, namely, a
wave that would arrive almost simultaneously everywhere on Earth's free surface
and the excitation of unusual spheroidal modes with a characteristic
frequency-spacing in free oscillation spectra. These qualitative
characteristics are unaffected by the speed or proximity of the PBH trajectory.
The seismic energy deposited by a proximal ${M^{PBH} = 10^{15}}$ g PBH is
comparable to a magnitude $M_w=4$ earthquake. The non-seismic collateral damage
due to the actual impact of such small PBHs with Earth would be negligible.
Unfortunately, the expected collision rate is very low even if PBHs constituted
all of dark matter, at ${\sim 10^{-7} {yr}^{-1}}$, and since the rate scales as
${1/M^{PBH}}$, fortunately encounters with larger, Earth-threatening PBHs are
exceedingly unlikely. However, the rate at which non-colliding close encounters
of PBHs could be detected by seismic activity alone is roughly two orders of
magnitude larger --- that is once every hundred thousand years --- than the
direct collision rate.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.0011 [pdf] - 416254
Transient solar oscillations driven by primordial black holes
Submitted: 2011-05-31, last modified: 2011-09-25
Stars are transparent to the passage of primordial black holes (PBHs) and
serve as seismic detectors for such objects. The gravitational field of a PBH
squeezes a star and causes it to ring acoustically. We calculate the seismic
signature of a PBH passing through the Sun. The background for this signal is
the observed spectrum of solar oscillations excited by supersonic turbulence.
We predict that PBHs more massive than 10^21 g (comparable in mass to an
asteroid) are detectable by existing solar observatories. The oscillations
excited by PBHs peak at large scales and high frequencies, making them
potentially detectable in other stars. The discovery of PBHs would have
profound implications for cosmology and high-energy physics.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.2712 [pdf] - 973044
Multi-Channel Three-Dimensional SOLA Inversion for Local Helioseismology
Submitted: 2011-09-13
Inversions for local helioseismology are an important and necessary step for
obtaining three-dimensional maps of various physical quantities in the solar
interior. Frequently, the full inverse problems that one would like to solve
prove intractable because of computational constraints. Due to the enormous
seismic data sets that already exist and those forthcoming, this is a problem
that needs to be addressed. To this end, we present a very efficient linear
inversion algorithm for local helioseismology. It is based on a subtractive
optimally localized averaging (SOLA) scheme in the Fourier domain, utilizing
the horizontal-translation invariance of the sensitivity kernels. In Fourier
space the problem decouples into many small problems, one for each horizontal
wave vector. This multi-channel SOLA method is demonstrated for an example
problem in time-distance helioseismology that is small enough to be solved both
in real and Fourier space. We find that both approaches are successful in
solving the inverse problem. However, the multi-channel SOLA algorithm is much
faster and can easily be parallelized.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.2651 [pdf] - 1083375
Lattice Boltzmann Method for Electromagnetic Wave Propagation
Submitted: 2011-08-12
We present a new Lattice Boltzmann (LB) formulation to solve the Maxwell
equations for electromagnetic (EM) waves propagating in a heterogeneous medium.
By using a pseudo-vector discrete Boltzmann distribution, the scheme is shown
to reproduce the continuum Maxwell equations. The technique compares well with
a pseudo-spectral method at solving for two-dimensional wave propagation in a
heterogeneous medium, which by design contains substantial contrasts in the
refractive index. The extension to three dimensions follows naturally and,
owing to the recognized efficiency of LB schemes for parallel computation in
irregular geometries, it gives a powerful method to numerically simulate a wide
range of problems involving EM wave propagation in complex media.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.4263 [pdf] - 1076782
The Adjoint Method Applied to Time-Distance Helioseismology
Submitted: 2011-05-21
For a given {\it misfit function}, a specified optimality measure of a model,
its gradient describes the manner in which one may alter properties of the
system to march towards a stationary point. The adjoint method, arising from
partial-differential-equation-constrained optimization, describes a means of
extracting derivatives of a misfit function with respect to model parameters
through finite computation. It relies on the accurate calculation of wavefields
that are driven by two types of sources, namely the average wave-excitation
spectrum, resulting in the {\it forward wavefield}, and differences between
predictions and observations, resulting in an {\it adjoint wavefield}. All
sensitivity kernels relevant to a given measurement emerge directly from the
evaluation of an interaction integral involving these wavefields. The technique
facilitates computation of sensitivity kernels (Fr\'{e}chet derivatives)
relative to three-dimensional heterogeneous background models, thereby paving
the way for non-linear iterative inversions. An algorithm to perform such
inversions using as many observations as desired is discussed.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1104.4083 [pdf] - 1053494
Validated helioseismic inversions for 3-D vector flows
Submitted: 2011-04-20
According to time-distance helioseismology, information about internal fluid
motions is encoded in the travel times of solar waves. The inverse problem
consists of inferring 3-D vector flows from a set of travel-time measurements.
Here we investigate the potential of time-distance helioseismology to infer 3-D
convective velocities in the near-surface layers of the Sun. We developed a new
Subtractive Optimally Localised Averaging (SOLA) code suitable for pipeline
pseudo-automatic processing. Compared to its predecessor, the code was improved
by accounting for additional constraints in order to get the right answer
within a given noise level. The main aim of this study is to validate results
obtained by our inversion code. We simulate travel-time maps using a snapshot
from a numerical simulation of solar convective flows, realistic Born
travel-time sensitivity kernels, and a realistic model of travel-time noise.
These synthetic travel times are inverted for flows and the results compared
with the known input flow field. Additional constraints are implemented in the
inversion: cross-talk minimization between flow components and spatial
localization of inversion coefficients. Using modes f, p1 through p4, we show
that horizontal convective flow velocities can be inferred without bias, at a
signal-to-noise ratio greater than one in the top 3.5 Mm, provided that
observations span at least four days. The vertical component of velocity (v_z),
if it were to be weak, is more difficult to infer and is seriously affected by
cross-talk from horizontal velocity components. We emphasise that this
cross-talk must be explicitly minimised in order to retrieve v_z in the top 1
Mm. We also show that statistical averaging over many different areas of the
Sun allows for reliably measuring of average properties of all three flow
components in the top 5.5 Mm of the convection zone.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.0125 [pdf] - 285928
Deep-Focus Diagnostics of Sunspot Structure
Submitted: 2010-12-30
In sequel to Moradi et al. [2009, ApJ, 690, L72], we employ two established
numerical forward models (a 3D ideal MHD solver and MHD ray theory) in
conjunction with time-distance helioseismology to probe the lateral extent of
wave-speed perturbations produced in regions of strong, near-surface magnetic
fields. We continue our comparisons of forward modeling approaches by extending
our previous surface-focused travel-time measurements with a common midpoint
deep-focusing scheme that avoids the use of oscillation signals within the
sunspot region. The idea is to also test MHD ray theory for possible
application in future inverse methods.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.4982 [pdf] - 1018908
Modeling the Subsurface Structure of Sunspots
Moradi, H.;
Baldner, C.;
Birch, A. C.;
Braun, D.;
Cameron, R.;
Duvall, T. L.;
Gizon, L.;
Haber, D.;
Hanasoge, S.;
Hindman, B. W.;
Jackiewicz, J.;
Khomenko, E.;
Komm, R.;
Rajaguru, P.;
Rempel, M.;
Roth, M.;
Schlichenmaier, R.;
Schunker, H.;
Spruit, H.;
Strassmeier, K.;
Thompson, M. J.;
Zharkov, S.
Submitted: 2009-12-25, last modified: 2010-08-23
While sunspots are easily observed at the solar surface, determining their
subsurface structure is not trivial. There are two main hypotheses for the
subsurface structure of sunspots: the monolithic model and the cluster model.
Local helioseismology is the only means by which we can investigate
subphotospheric structure. However, as current linear inversion techniques do
not yet allow helioseismology to probe the internal structure with sufficient
confidence to distinguish between the monolith and cluster models, the
development of physically realistic sunspot models are a priority for
helioseismologists. This is because they are not only important indicators of
the variety of physical effects that may influence helioseismic inferences in
active regions, but they also enable detailed assessments of the validity of
helioseismic interpretations through numerical forward modeling. In this paper,
we provide a critical review of the existing sunspot models and an overview of
numerical methods employed to model wave propagation through model sunspots. We
then carry out an helioseismic analysis of the sunspot in Active Region 9787
and address the serious inconsistencies uncovered by
\citeauthor{gizonetal2009}~(\citeyear{gizonetal2009,gizonetal2009a}). We find
that this sunspot is most probably associated with a shallow, positive
wave-speed perturbation (unlike the traditional two-layer model) and that
travel-time measurements are consistent with a horizontal outflow in the
surrounding moat.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.0725 [pdf] - 1025500
An absorbing boundary formulation for the stratified, linearized, ideal
MHD equations based on an unsplit, convolutional perfectly matched layer
Submitted: 2010-03-02, last modified: 2010-07-31
Perfectly matched layers are a very efficient and accurate way to absorb
waves in media. We present a stable convolutional unsplit perfectly matched
formulation designed for the linearized stratified Euler equations. However,
the technique as applied to the Magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) equations requires
the use of a sponge, which, despite placing the perfectly matched status in
question, is still highly efficient at absorbing outgoing waves. We study
solutions of the equations in the backdrop of models of linearized wave
propagation in the Sun. We test the numerical stability of the schemes by
integrating the equations over a large number of wave periods.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.2369 [pdf] - 1477098
Helioseismology of Sunspots: A Case Study of NOAA Region 9787
Gizon, L.;
Schunker, H.;
Baldner, C. S.;
Basu, S.;
Birch, A. C.;
Bogart, R. S.;
Braun, D. C.;
Cameron, R.;
Duvall, T. L.;
Hanasoge, S. M.;
Jackiewicz, J.;
Roth, M.;
Stahn, T.;
Thompson, M. J.;
Zharkov, S.
Submitted: 2010-02-11
Various methods of helioseismology are used to study the subsurface
properties of the sunspot in NOAA Active Region 9787. This sunspot was chosen
because it is axisymmetric, shows little evolution during 20-28 January 2002,
and was observed continuously by the MDI/SOHO instrument. (...) Wave travel
times and mode frequencies are affected by the sunspot. In most cases, wave
packets that propagate through the sunspot have reduced travel times. At short
travel distances, however, the sign of the travel-time shifts appears to depend
sensitively on how the data are processed and, in particular, on filtering in
frequency-wavenumber space. We carry out two linear inversions for wave speed:
one using travel-times and phase-speed filters and the other one using mode
frequencies from ring analysis. These two inversions give subsurface wave-speed
profiles with opposite signs and different amplitudes. (...) From this study of
AR9787, we conclude that we are currently unable to provide a unified
description of the subsurface structure and dynamics of the sunspot.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.4508 [pdf] - 1024802
Seismic Constraints on Interior Solar Convection
Submitted: 2010-01-25
We constrain the velocity spectral distribution of global-scale solar
convective cells at depth using techniques of local helioseismology. We
calibrate the sensitivity of helioseismic waves to large-scale convective cells
in the interior by analyzing simulations of waves propagating through a
velocity snapshot of global solar convection via methods of time-distance
helioseismology. Applying identical analysis techniques to observations of the
Sun, we are able to bound from above the magnitudes of solar convective cells
as a function of spatial convective scale. We find that convection at a depth
of $r/R_\odot = 0.95$ with spatial extent $\ell <20$, where $\ell$ is the
spherical harmonic degree, comprise weak flow systems, on the order of 15 m/s
or less. Convective features deeper than $r/R_\odot = 0.95$ are more difficult
to image due to the rapidly decreasing sensitivity of helioseismic waves.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.4671 [pdf] - 1002688
A Wave Scattering Theory of Solar Seismic Power Haloes
Submitted: 2009-06-25
Spatial maps of the high-pass frequency filtered time-averaged
root-mean-squared (RMS) Doppler velocities tend to show substantial decrements
within regions of strong field and curiously, randomly distributed patches of
enhancement in the vicinity. We propose that these haloes or enhancements are a
consequence of magnetic-field-induced mode mixing (scattering), resulting in
the preferential powering of waves that possess strong surface velocity
signatures (i.e. scattering from low to high wavenumbers). Evidently, this
process can occur in the reverse, and therefore in order to determine if the
haloes are indeed caused by mode mixing, we must answer the question: {\it how
are acoustic waves scattered by magnetic fields?} Through simulations of the
interactions between waves and sunspots and models of plage, we demonstrate
that the high to low modal order scattering channels are favoured. With
increasing frequency and consequently, decreasing wavelength, a growing number
of modes are scattered by the sunspot, thereby rendering the enhancements most
visible around the high-frequency parts of the spectrum. The haloes obtained
from the simulations are on the same order of magnitude but weaker than those
observed. We also present observational evidence to support this theory:
observations of active region AR9787 are firstly frequency filtered to isolate
the 5-6 mHz signals and secondly, decomposed into three wavenumber bandpasses,
$l - [0,400], [400,800], [800,2222]$. With increasing wavenumber, the extent of
the halo effect is seen increase dramatically, in line with theoretical
expectation.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:0905.3132 [pdf] - 554094
Measuring Meridional Circulation in the Sun
Submitted: 2009-05-19
Measuring the depth variation of the meridional flows is important for
understanding the solar cycle, at least according to a number of dynamo models.
While attempting to extend the early observations of \citet{giles_thesis} of
time-distance measurements of flow, we have stumbled upon some systematic
errors that can affect these measurements: 1) the additional distance traveled
by radiation coming from points away from disk center causes an apparent
`shrinking' Sun, that is an apparent flow towards the disk center and 2) in
measurements away from the central longitude, the rotation signal can leak into
meridional flow signals. Attempts to understand and overcome these systematic
problems will be presented. Forward models based on ray theory have been
applied in order to test the sensitivity of travel times to various models.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.1284 [pdf] - 315374
Multiple scattering of waves by a pair of gravitationally stratified
flux tubes
Submitted: 2008-12-06, last modified: 2008-12-09
We study the near-field coupling of a pair of flux tubes embedded in a
gravitationally stratified environment. The mutual induction of the near-field
{\it jackets} of the two flux tubes can considerably alter the scattering
properties of the system, resulting in sizable changes in the magnitudes of
scattering coefficients and bizarre trends in the phases. The dominant length
scale governing the induction zone turns out to be approximately half the
horizontal wave length of the incident mode, a result that fits in quite
pleasantly with extant theories of scattering. Higher-$\beta$ flux tubes are
more strongly coupled than weaker ones, a consequence of the greater role that
the near-field jacket modes play in the such tubes. We also comment on the
importance of incorporating the effects of multiple scattering when studying
the effects of mode absorption in plage and interpreting related scattering
measurements. That the near-field plays such an important role in the
scattering process lends encouragement to the eventual goal of observationally
resolving sub-wavelength features of flux tubes using techniques of
helioseismology.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.0119 [pdf] - 315359
Sub-Wavelength Resolution Imaging of the Solar Deep Interior
Submitted: 2008-11-29
We derive expectations for signatures in the measured travel times of waves
that interact with thermal anomalies and jets. A series of numerical
experiments that involve the dynamic linear evolution of an acoustic wave field
in a solar-like stratified spherical shell in the presence of fully 3D
time-stationary perturbations are performed. The imprints of these interactions
are observed as shifts in wave travel times, which are extracted from these
data through methods of time-distance helioseismology \citep{duvall}. In
situations where at least one of the spatial dimensions of the scatterer was
smaller than a wavelength, oscillatory time shift signals were recovered from
the analyses, pointing directly to a means of resolving sub-wavelength
features. As evidence for this claim, we present analyses of simulations with
spatially localized jets and sound-speed perturbations. We analyze 1 years'
worth solar observations to estimate the noise level associated with the time
differences. Based on theoretical estimates, Fresnel zone time shifts
associated with the (possible) sharp rotation gradient at the base of the
convection zone are of the order 0.01 - 0.1 s, well below the noise level that
could be reached with the currently available amount of data ($\sim 0.15-0.2$ s
with 10 yrs of data).
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:0808.3628 [pdf] - 15703
Numerical Models of Travel-Time Inhomogeneities in Sunspots
Submitted: 2008-08-27, last modified: 2008-11-09
We investigate the direct contribution of strong, sunspot-like magnetic
fields to helioseismic wave travel-time shifts via two numerical forward
models, a 3D ideal MHD solver and MHD ray theory. The simulated data cubes are
analyzed using the traditional time-distance center-to-annulus measurement
technique. We also isolate and analyze the direct contribution from purely
thermal perturbations to the observed travel-time shifts, confirming some
existing ideas and bring forth new ones: (i) that the observed travel-time
shifts in the vicinity of sunspots are largely governed by MHD physics, (ii)
the travel-time shifts are sensitively dependent on frequency and phase-speed
filter parameters and the background power below the $p_1$ ridge, and finally,
(iii) despite its seeming limitations, ray theory succeeds in capturing the
essence of the travel-time variations as derived from the MHD simulations.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:0803.3839 [pdf] - 11247
Scattering of acoustic waves by a magnetic cylinder
Submitted: 2008-03-26
With the aim of studying magnetic effects in time-distance helioseismology,
we use the first-order Born approximation to compute the scattering of acoustic
plane waves by a magnetic cylinder embedded in a uniform medium. We show, by
comparison with the exact solution, that the travel-time shifts computed in the
Born approximation are everywhere valid to first order in the ratio of the
magnetic to the gas pressures. We also show that, for arbitrary magnetic field
strength, the Born approximation is not valid in the limit where the radius of
the magnetic cylinder tends to zero.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:0707.1369 [pdf] - 2947
Impact of Locally Suppressed Wave sources on helioseismic travel times
Submitted: 2007-07-10, last modified: 2008-03-13
Wave travel-time shifts in the vicinity of sunspots are typically interpreted
as arising predominantly from magnetic fields, flows, and local changes in
sound speed. We show here that the suppression of granulation related wave
sources in a sunspot can also contribute significantly to these travel-time
shifts, and in some cases, an asymmetry between in and outgoing wave travel
times. The tight connection between the physical interpretation of travel times
and source-distribution homogeneity is confirmed. Statistically significant
travel-time shifts are recovered upon numerically simulating wave propagation
in the presence of a localized decrease in source strength. We also demonstrate
that these time shifts are relatively sensitive to the modal damping rates;
thus we are only able to place bounds on the magnitude of this effect. We see a
systematic reduction of 10-15 seconds in $p$-mode mean travel times at short
distances ($\sim 6.2$ Mm) that could be misinterpreted as arising from a
shallow (thickness of 1.5 Mm) increase ($\sim$ 4%) in the sound speed. At
larger travel distances ($\sim 24$ Mm) a 6-13 s difference between the ingoing
and outgoing wave travel times is observed; this could mistakenly be
interpreted as being caused by flows.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.3578 [pdf] - 8394
Seismic Halos Around Active Regions: An MHD Theory
Submitted: 2007-12-20, last modified: 2008-02-27
Comprehending the manner in which magnetic fields affect propagating waves is
a first step toward constructing accurate helioseismic models of active region
sub-surface structure and dynamics. Here, we present a numerical method to
compute the linear interaction of waves with magnetic fields embedded in a
solar-like stratified background. The ideal Magneto-Hydrodynamic (MHD)
equations are solved in a 3-dimensional box that straddles the solar
photosphere, extending from 35 Mm within to 1.2 Mm into the atmosphere. One of
the challenges in performing these simulations involves generating a
Magneto-Hydro-Static (MHS) state wherein the stratification assumes horizontal
inhomogeneity in addition to the strong vertical stratification associated with
the near-surface layers. Keeping in mind that the aim of this effort is to
understand and characterize linear MHD interactions, we discuss a means of
computing statically consistent background states. Power maps computed from
simulations of waves interacting with thick flux tubes of peak photospheric
field strengths 600 G and 3000 G are presented. Strong modal power reduction in
the `umbral' regions of the flux tube enveloped by a halo of increased wave
power are seen in the simulations with the thick flux tubes. These enhancements
are also seen in Doppler velocity power maps of active regions observed in the
Sun, leading us to propose that the halo has MHD underpinnings.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:0711.2076 [pdf] - 6995
{\it f}-mode interactions with thin flux tubes: the scattering matrix
Submitted: 2007-11-13, last modified: 2008-02-27
We calculate the scattering effects associated with the interaction of a
surface gravity or {\it f} mode with a thin magnetic flux tube embedded in a
realistically stratified medium. We find that the dominant scattered wave is an
$f$ mode with amplitude and phase of 1.17% and around $49^\circ$ relative to
the incident wave, compared to the values of 0.13% and $40^\circ$ estimated
from observations. The extent of scattering into high-order acoustic $p$ modes
is too weak to be accurately characterized. We recover the result that the
degree of scattering is enhanced as (a) the frequency of the incident wave
increases and (b) the flux tube becomes magnetically dominated.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:0711.1877 [pdf] - 6950
Global effects of local sound-speed perturbations in the Sun: A
theoretical study
Submitted: 2007-11-12
We study the effect of localized sound-speed perturbations on global mode
frequencies by applying techniques of global helioseismology on numerical
simulations of the solar acoustic wave field. Extending the method of
realization noise subtraction (e.g. Hanasoge et al. 2007) to global modes and
exploiting the luxury of full spherical coverage, we are able to achieve very
highly resolved frequency differences that are used to study sensitivities and
the signatures of the thermal asphericities. We find that (1) global modes are
almost twice as sensitive to sound-speed perturbations at the bottom of the
convection zone as in comparison to anomalies well in the radiative interior
($r\lesssim0.55 R_\odot$), (2) the $m$-degeneracy is lifted ever so slightly,
as seen in the $a$ coefficients, and (3) modes that propagate in the vicinity
of the perturbations show small amplitude shifts ($\sim 0.5%$).