Normalized to: Greenhouse, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.05904 [pdf] - 1916060
Astro2020: Astrophotonics White Paper
Gatkine, Pradip;
Veilleux, Sylvain;
Mather, John;
Betters, Christopher;
Bland-Hawthorn, Jonathan;
Bryant, Julia;
Cenko, S. Bradley;
Dagenais, Mario;
Deming, Drake;
Ellis, Simon;
Greenhouse, Matthew;
Harris, Andrew;
Jovanovic, Nemanja;
Kuhlmann, Steve;
Kutyrev, Alexander;
Leon-Saval, Sergio;
Madhav, Kalaga;
Moseley, Samuel;
Norris, Barnaby;
Rauscher, Bernard;
Roth, Martin;
Vogel, Stuart
Submitted: 2019-07-12
Astrophotonics is the application of versatile photonic technologies to
channel, manipulate, and disperse guided light from one or more telescopes to
achieve scientific objectives in astronomy in an efficient and cost-effective
way. The developments and demands from the telecommunication industry have
driven a major boost in photonic technology and vice versa in the last 40
years. The photonic platform of guided light in fibers and waveguides has
opened the doors to next-generation instrumentation for both ground- and
space-based telescopes in optical and near/mid-IR bands, particularly for the
upcoming extremely large telescopes (ELTs). The large telescopes are pushing
the limits of adaptive optics to reach close to a near-diffraction-limited
performance. The photonic devices are ideally suited for capturing this
AO-corrected light and enabling new and exciting science such as characterizing
exoplanet atmospheres. The purpose of this white paper is to summarize the
current landscape of astrophotonic devices and their scientific impact,
highlight the key issues, and outline specific technological and organizational
approaches to address these issues in the coming decade and thereby enable new
discoveries as we embark on the era of extremely large telescopes.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.11313 [pdf] - 1791684
SOFIA - HIRMES: Looking forward to the HIgh-Resolution Mid-infrarEd
Spectrometer
Richards, Samuel N.;
Moseley, Samuel H.;
Stacey, Gordon;
Greenhouse, Matthew;
Kutyrev, Alexander;
Arendt, Richard;
Atanasoff, Hristo;
Banks, Stuart;
Brekosky, Regis P.;
Brown, Ari-David;
Bulcha, Berhanu;
Cazeau, Tony;
Choi, Michael;
Colazo, Felipe;
Engler, Chuck;
Hadjimichael, Theodore;
Hays-Wehle, James;
Henderson, Chuck;
Hsieh, Wen-Ting;
Huang, Jeffrey;
Jenstrom, Iver;
Kellogg, Jim;
Kimball, Mark;
Kovacs, Attila;
Leiter, Steve;
Maher, Steve;
McMurray, Robert;
Melnick, Gary J.;
Mentzell, Eric;
Mikula, Vilem;
Miller, Timothy M.;
Nagler, Peter;
Nikola, Thomas;
Oxborrow, Joseph;
Pontoppidan, Klaus M.;
Rangwala, Naseem;
Rhodes, Alan;
Roberge, Aki;
Rosner, Stefan;
Rostem, Karwan;
Rustemeyer, Nancy;
Sharp, Elmer;
Sparr, Leroy;
Stevanovic, Dejan;
Taraschi, Peter;
Temi, Pasquale;
Vacca, William D.;
de Lorenzo, Jordi Vila Hernandez;
Wohler, Bill;
Wollack, Edward J.;
Wilks, Shannon
Submitted: 2018-11-27
The HIgh-Resolution Mid-infrarEd Spectrometer (HIRMES) is the 3rd Generation
Instrument for the Stratospheric Observatory For Infrared Astronomy (SOFIA),
currently in development at the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC), and
due for commissioning in 2019. By combining direct-detection Transition Edge
Sensor (TES) bolometer arrays, grating-dispersive spectroscopy, and a host of
Fabry-Perot tunable filters, HIRMES will provide the ability for High
Resolution (R~100,000), Mid-Resolution (R~10,000), and Low-Resolution (R~600)
slit-spectroscopy, and 2D Spectral Imaging (R~2000 at selected wavelengths)
over the 25 - 122 {\mu}m mid-far infrared waveband. The driving science
application is the evolution of proto-planetary systems via measurements of
water-vapor, water-ice, deuterated hydrogen (HD), and neutral oxygen lines.
However, HIRMES has been designed to be as flexible as possible to cover a wide
range of science cases that fall within its phase-space, all whilst reaching
sensitivities and observing powers not yet seen thus far on SOFIA, providing
unique observing capabilities which will remain unmatched for decades.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.09387 [pdf] - 1586532
Improved Reference Sampling and Subtraction: A Technique for Reducing
the Read Noise of Near-infrared Detector Systems
Rauscher, Bernard J.;
Arendt, Richard G.;
Fixsen, D. J.;
Greenhouse, Matthew A.;
Lander, Matthew;
Lindler, Don;
Loose, Markus;
Moseley, S. H.;
Mott, D. Brent;
Went, Yiting;
Wilson, Donna V.;
Xenophontos, Christos
Submitted: 2017-07-28
Near-infrared array detectors, like the \JWST NIRSpec's Teledyne's H2RGs,
often provide reference pixels and a reference output. These are used to remove
correlated noise. Improved Reference Sampling and Subtraction (\IRSSquare,
pronounced "IRS-square") is a statistical technique for using this reference
information optimally in a least squares sense. Compared to "traditional" H2RG
readout, \IRSSquare uses a different clocking pattern to interleave many more
reference pixels into the data than is otherwise possible. Compared to standard
reference correction techniques, \IRSSquare subtracts the reference pixels and
reference output using a statistically optimized set of frequency dependent
weights. The benefits include somewhat lower noise variance and much less
obvious correlated noise. NIRSpec's \IRSSquare images are cosmetically clean,
with less $1/f$ banding than in traditional data from the same system. This
article describes the \IRSSquare clocking pattern and presents the equations
that are needed to use \IRSSquare in systems other than NIRSpec. For NIRSpec,
applying these equations is already an option in the calibration pipeline. As
an aid to instrument builders, we provide our prototype \IRSSquare calibration
software and sample \JWST NIRSpec data. The same techniques are applicable to
other detector systems, including those based on Teledyne's H4RG arrays. The
H4RG's "interleaved reference pixel readout" mode is effectively one \IRSSquare
pattern.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.1754 [pdf] - 894232
Observations of Transiting Exoplanets with the James Webb Space
Telescope (JWST), Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific
(PASP), December 2014
Beichman, Charles;
Benneke, Bjoern;
Knutson, Heather;
Smith, Roger;
Dressing, Courtney;
Latham, David;
Deming, Drake;
Lunine, Jonathan;
Lagage, Pierre-Olivier;
Sozzetti, Alessandro;
Beichman, Charles;
Sing, David;
Kempton, Eliza;
Ricker, George;
Bean, Jacob;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Bouwman, Jeroen;
Crossfield, Ian;
Christiansen, Jessie;
Ciardi, David;
Fortney, Jonathan;
Albert, Loïc;
Doyon, René;
Rieke, Marcia;
Rieke, George;
Clampin, Mark;
Greenhouse, Matt;
Goudfrooij, Paul;
Hines, Dean;
Keyes, Tony;
Lee, Janice;
McCullough, Peter;
Robberto, Massimo;
Stansberry, John;
Valenti, Jeff;
Deroo, Pieter D.;
Mandell, Avi;
Ressler, Michael E.;
Shporer, Avi;
Swain, Mark;
Vasisht, Gautam;
Carey, Sean;
Krick, Jessica;
Birkmann, Stephan;
Ferruit, Pierre;
Giardino, Giovanna;
Greene, Tom;
Howell, Steve
Submitted: 2014-11-06
This article summarizes a workshop held on March, 2014, on the potential of
the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to revolutionize our knowledge of the
physical properties of exoplanets through transit observations. JWST's unique
combination of high sensitivity and broad wavelength coverage will enable the
accurate measurement of transits with high signal-to-noise. Most importantly,
JWST spectroscopy will investigate planetary atmospheres to determine atomic
and molecular compositions, to probe vertical and horizontal structure, and to
follow dynamical evolution, i.e. exoplanet weather. JWST will sample a diverse
population of planets of varying masses and densities in a wide variety of
environments characterized by a range of host star masses and metallicities,
orbital semi-major axes and eccentricities. A broad program of exoplanet
science could use a substantial fraction of the overall JWST mission.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.1886 [pdf] - 1123997
Breakthrough capability for the NASA Astrophysics Explorer Program:
Reaching the darkest sky
Submitted: 2012-06-08
We describe a mission architecture designed to substantially increase the
science capability of the NASA Science Mission Directorate (SMD) Astrophysics
Explorer Program for all AO proposers working within the near-UV to
far-infrared spectrum. We have demonstrated that augmentation of Falcon 9
Explorer launch services with a 13 kW Solar Electric Propulsion (SEP) stage can
deliver a 700 kg science observatory payload to extra-Zodiacal orbit. This new
capability enables up to ~13X increased photometric sensitivity and ~160X
increased observing speed relative to a Sun-Earth L2, Earth-trailing, or Earth
orbit with no increase in telescope aperture. All enabling SEP stage
technologies for this launch service augmentation have reached sufficient
readiness (TRL-6) for Explorer Program application in conjunction with the
Falcon 9. We demonstrate that enabling Astrophysics Explorers to reach
extra-zodiacal orbit will allow this small payload program to rival the science
performance of much larger long development time systems; thus, providing a
means to realize major science objectives while increasing the SMD Astrophysics
portfolio diversity and resiliency to external budget pressure. The SEP
technology employed in this study has strong applicability to SMD Planetary
Science community-proposed missions. SEP is a stated flight demonstration
priority for NASA's Office of the Chief Technologist (OCT). This new mission
architecture for astrophysics Explorers enables an attractive realization of
joint goals for OCT and SMD with wide applicability across SMD science
disciplines.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:0903.4240 [pdf] - 22723
Training of Instrumentalists and Development of New Technologies on
SOFIA
Erickson, Edwin F.;
Allamandola, Louis J.;
Baluteau, Jean-Paul;
Becklin, Eric E.;
Bjoraker, Gordon;
Burton, Michael;
Caroff, Lawrence J.;
Ceccarelli, Cecilia;
Churchwell, Edward B.;
Clemens, Dan P.;
Cohen, Martin;
Cruikshank, Dale P.;
Dinerstein, Harriet L.;
Dunham, Edward W.;
Fazio, Giovanni G.;
Gatley, Ian;
Gehrz, Robert D.;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Graf, Paul;
Greenhouse, Matthew A.;
Harper, Doyal A.;
Harvey, Paul M.;
Harwit, Martin;
Hildebrand, Roger H.;
Hollenbach, David J.;
Lane, Adair P.;
Larson, Harold P.;
Lord, Steven D.;
Madden, Suzanne;
Melnick, Gary J.;
Neufeld, David A.;
Olkin, Catherine B.;
Packham, Christopher C.;
Roellig, Thomas L.;
Roeser, Hans-Peter;
Sandford, Scott A.;
Sellgren, Kristen;
Simpson, Janet P.;
Storey, John W. V.;
Telesco, Charles M.;
Tielens, Alexander G. G. M.;
Tokunaga, Alan T.;
Townes, Charles H.;
Walker, Christopher K.;
Werner, Michael W.;
Whitcomb, Stanley E.;
Wolf, Juergen;
Woodward, Charles E.;
Young, Erick T.;
Zmuidzinas, Jonas
Submitted: 2009-03-25
This white paper is submitted to the Astronomy and Astrophysics 2010 Decadal
Survey (Astro2010)1 Committee on the State of the Profession to emphasize the
potential of the Stratospheric Observatory for Infrared Astronomy (SOFIA) to
contribute to the training of instrumentalists and observers, and to related
technology developments. This potential goes beyond the primary mission of
SOFIA, which is to carry out unique, high priority astronomical research.
SOFIA is a Boeing 747SP aircraft with a 2.5 meter telescope. It will enable
astronomical observations anywhere, any time, and at most wavelengths between
0.3 microns and 1.6 mm not accessible from ground-based observatories. These
attributes, accruing from the mobility and flight altitude of SOFIA, guarantee
a wealth of scientific return. Its instrument teams (nine in the first
generation) and guest investigators will do suborbital astronomy in a
shirt-sleeve environment. The project will invest $10M per year in science
instrument development over a lifetime of 20 years. This, frequent flight
opportunities, and operation that enables rapid changes of science instruments
and hands-on in-flight access to the instruments, assure a unique and extensive
potential - both for training young instrumentalists and for encouraging and
deploying nascent technologies. Novel instruments covering optical, infrared,
and submillimeter bands can be developed for and tested on SOFIA by their
developers (including apprentices) for their own observations and for those of
guest observers, to validate technologies and maximize observational
effectiveness.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.4165 [pdf] - 9433
Milliarcsecond N-Band Observations of the Nova RS Ophiuchi: First
Science with the Keck Interferometer Nuller
Barry, R. K.;
Danchi, W. C.;
Traub, W. A.;
Sokoloski, J. L.;
Wisniewski, J. P.;
Serabyn, E.;
Kuchner, M. J.;
Akeson, R.;
Appleby, E.;
Bell, J.;
Booth, A.;
Brandenburg, H.;
Colavita, M.;
Crawford, S.;
Creech-Eakman, M.;
Dahl, W.;
Felizardo, C.;
Garcia, J.;
Gathright, J.;
Greenhouse, M. A.;
Herstein, J.;
Hovland, E.;
Hrynevych, M.;
Koresko, C.;
Ligon, R.;
Mennesson, B.;
Millan-Gabet, R.;
Morrison, D.;
Palmer, D.;
Panteleeva, T.;
Ragland, S.;
Shao, M.;
Smythe, R.;
Summers, K.;
Swain, M.;
Tsubota, K.;
Tyau, C.;
Vasisht, G.;
Wetherell, E.;
Wizinowich, P.;
Woillez, J.
Submitted: 2008-01-27
We report observations of the nova RS Ophiuchi (RS Oph) using the Keck
Interferometer Nuller (KIN), approximately 3.8 days following the most recent
outburst that occurred on 2006 February 12. These observations represent the
first scientific results from the KIN, which operates in N-band from 8 to 12.5
microns in a nulling mode. By fitting the unique KIN data, we have obtained an
angular size of the mid-infrared continuum of 6.2, 4.0, or 5.4 mas for a disk
profile, gaussian profile (FWHM), and shell profile respectively. The data show
evidence of enhanced neutral atomic hydrogen emission and atomic metals
including silicon located in the inner spatial regime near the white dwarf (WD)
relative to the outer regime. There are also nebular emission lines and
evidence of hot silicate dust in the outer spatial region, centered at ! 17 AU
from the WD, that are not found in the inner regime. Our evidence suggests that
these features have been excited by the nova flash in the outer spatial regime
before the blast wave reached these regions. These identifications support a
model in which the dust appears to be present between outbursts and is not
created during the outburst event. We further discuss the present results in
terms of a unifying model of the system that includes an increase in density in
the plane of the orbit of the two stars created by a spiral shock wave caused
by the motion of the stars through the cool wind of the red giant star. These
data show the power and potential of the nulling technique which has been
developed for the detection of Earth-like planets around nearby stars for the
Terrestrial Planet Finder Mission and Darwin missions.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:0705.0701 [pdf] - 1018
The Early Spectrophotometric Evolution of V1186 Scorpii (Nova Scorpii
2004 #1)
Schwarz, G. J.;
Woodward, C. E.;
Bode, M. F.;
Evans, A.;
Eyres, S. P.;
Geballe, T. R.;
Gehrz, R. D.;
Greenhouse, M. A.;
Hauschildt, P. H.;
Helton, L. A.;
Lynch, D. K.;
Lyke, J. E.;
O'Brien, T. J.;
Russell, R. W.;
Rudy, R. J.;
Shore, S. N.;
Starrfield, S. G.;
Temim, T.;
Truran, J. W.;
Venturini, C. C.;
Williams, R. E.;
Zamanov, R.
Submitted: 2007-05-04
We report optical photometry and optical through mid-infrared spectroscopy of
the classical nova V1186 Sco. This slowly developing nova had an complex light
curve with multiple secondary peaks similar to those seen in PW Vul. The time
to decline 2 magnitudes, t$_2$, was 20 days but the erratic nature of the light
curve makes determination of intrinsic properties based on the decline time
(e.g., luminosity) problematic, and the often cited MMRD relationship of Della
Valle and Livio (1995) fails to yield a plausible distance. Spectra covering
0.35 to 35 $\mu$m were obtained in two separate epochs during the first year of
outburst. The first set of spectra, taken about 2 months after visible maximum,
are typical of a CO-type nova with narrow line emission from \ion{H}{1},
\ion{Fe}{2}, \ion{O}{1} and \ion{He}{1}. Later data, obtained between 260 and
380 days after maximum, reveal an emerging nebular spectrum. \textit{Spitzer}
spectra show weakening hydrogen recombination emission with the emergence of
[\ion{Ne}{2}] (12.81 $\mu$m) as the strongest line. Strong emission from
[\ion{Ne}{3}] (15.56 $\mu$m) is also detected. Photoionization models with low
effective temperature sources and only marginal neon enhancement (Ne $\sim$ 1.3
Ne$_{\odot}$) are consistent with these IR fine-structure neon lines indicating
that V1186 Sco did not occur on a ONeMg white dwarf. In contrast, the slow and
erratic light curve evolution, spectral development, and photoionization
analysis of the ejecta imply the outburst occurred on a low mass CO white
dwarf. We note that this is the first time strong [\ion{Ne}{2}] lines have been
detected so early in the outburst of a CO nova and suggests that the presence
of mid-infrared neon lines is not directly indicative of a ONeMg nova event.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0606175 [pdf] - 82615
The James Webb Space Telescope
Gardner, Jonathan P.;
Mather, John C.;
Clampin, Mark;
Doyon, Rene;
Greenhouse, Matthew A.;
Hammel, Heidi B.;
Hutchings, John B.;
Jakobsen, Peter;
Lilly, Simon J.;
Long, Knox S.;
Lunine, Jonathan I.;
McCaughrean, Mark J.;
Mountain, Matt;
Nella, John;
Rieke, George H.;
Rieke, Marcia J.;
Rix, Hans-Walter;
Smith, Eric P.;
Sonneborn, George;
Stiavelli, Massimo;
Stockman, H. S.;
Windhorst, Rogier A.;
Wright, Gillian S.
Submitted: 2006-06-07
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) is a large (6.6m), cold (50K),
infrared-optimized space observatory that will be launched early in the next
decade. The observatory will have four instruments: a near-infrared camera, a
near-infrared multi-object spectrograph, and a tunable filter imager will cover
the wavelength range, 0.6 to 5.0 microns, while the mid-infrared instrument
will do both imaging and spectroscopy from 5.0 to 29 microns. The JWST science
goals are divided into four themes. The End of the Dark Ages: First Light and
Reionization theme seeks to identify the first luminous sources to form and to
determine the ionization history of the early universe. The Assembly of
Galaxies theme seeks to determine how galaxies and the dark matter, gas, stars,
metals, morphological structures, and active nuclei within them evolved from
the epoch of reionization to the present day. The Birth of Stars and
Protoplanetary Systems theme seeks to unravel the birth and early evolution of
stars, from infall on to dust-enshrouded protostars to the genesis of planetary
systems. The Planetary Systems and the Origins of Life theme seeks to determine
the physical and chemical properties of planetary systems including our own,
and investigate the potential for the origins of life in those systems. To
enable these observations, JWST consists of a telescope, an instrument package,
a spacecraft and a sunshield. The telescope consists of 18 beryllium segments,
some of which are deployed. The segments will be brought into optical alignment
on-orbit through a process of periodic wavefront sensing and control. The JWST
operations plan is based on that used for previous space observatories, and the
majority of JWST observing time will be allocated to the international
astronomical community through annual peer-reviewed proposal opportunities.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409218 [pdf] - 67299
The Microlensing Planet Finder: Completing the Census of Extrasolar
Planets in the Milky Way
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I.;
Cheng, E.;
Friedman, S.;
Garnavich, P.;
Gaudi, B.;
Gilliland, R.;
Gould, A.;
Greenhouse, M.;
Griest, K.;
Kimble, R.;
Lunine, J.;
Mather, J.;
Minniti, D.;
Niedner, M.;
Paczynski, B.;
Peale, S.;
Rauscher, B.;
Rich, M.;
Sahu, K.;
Tenerelli, D.;
Udalski, A.;
Woolf, N.;
Yock, P.
Submitted: 2004-09-09
The Microlensing Planet Finder (MPF) is a proposed Discovery mission that
will complete the first census of extrasolar planets with sensitivity to
planets like those in our own solar system. MPF will employ a 1.1m aperture
telescope, which images a 1.3 sq. deg. field-of-view in the near-IR, in order
to detect extrasolar planets with the gravitational microlensing effect. MPF's
sensitivity extends down to planets of 0.1 Earth masses, and MPF can detect
Earth-like planets at all separations from 0.7AU to infinity. MPF's extrasolar
planet census will provide critical information needed to understand the
formation and frequency of extra solar planetary systems similar to our own.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0002024 [pdf] - 34367
ISO-LWS spectroscopy of Centaurus A: extended star formation
Unger, S. J.;
Clegg, P. E.;
Stacey, G. J.;
Cox, P.;
Fischer, J.;
Greenhouse, M.;
Lord, S. D.;
Luhman, M. L.;
Satyapal, S.;
Smith, H. A.;
Spinoglio, L.;
Wolfire, M.
Submitted: 2000-02-01
We present the first full FIR spectrum of Centaurus A (NGC 5128) from 43 -
196.7 um. The data was obtained with the ISO Long Wavelength Spectrometer
(LWS). We conclude that the FIR emission in a 70 arcsec beam centred on the
nucleus is dominated by star formation rather than AGN activity. The flux in
the far-infrared lines is ~ 1 % of the total FIR: the [CII] line flux is ~ 0.4
% FIR and the [OI] line is ~ 0.2 %, with the remainder arising from [OIII],
[NII] and [NIII] lines. These are typical values for starburst galaxies.
The ratio of the [NIII]/[NII] line intensities from the HII regions in the
dust lane can be modelled as a ~ 6 million year old starburst. This suggests
that the galaxy underwent either a recent merger or a merger which triggered a
series of bursts.
We estimate that < 5 % of the observed [CII] arises in the cold neutral
medium (CNM) and that ~ 10 % arises in the warm ionized medium (WIM). The main
contributors to the [CII] emission are the PDRs, which are located throughout
the dust lane and in regions beyond where the bulk of the molecular material
lies. On scales of ~ 1 kpc the average physical properties of the PDRs are
modelled with a gas density, n ~ 1000 cm^-3, an incident far-UV field, G ~ 100
times the local Galactic field, and a gas temperature of ~ 250 K.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9911310 [pdf] - 109438
ISO Far-IR Spectroscopy of IR-Bright Galaxies and ULIRGs
Fischer, J.;
Luhman, M. L.;
Satyapal, S.;
Greenhouse, M. A.;
Stacey, G. J.;
Bradford, C. M.;
Lord, S. D.;
Brauher, J. R.;
Unger, S. J.;
Clegg, P. E.;
Smith, H. A.;
Melnick, G.;
Colbert, J. W.;
Malkan, M. A.;
Spinoglio, L.;
Cox, P.;
Harvey, V.;
Suter, J. -P.;
Strelnitski, V.
Submitted: 1999-11-16
Based on far-infrared spectroscopy of a small sample of nearby
infrared-bright and ultraluminous infrared galaxies (ULIRGs) with the ISO Long
Wavelength Spectrometer, we find a dramatic progression in ionic/atomic
fine-structure emission line and molecular/atomic absorption line
characteristics in these galaxies extending from strong [O III]52,88 and [N
III]57 micron line emission to detection of only faint [C II]158 micron line
emission from gas in photodissociation regions in the ULIRGs. The molecular
absorption spectra show varying excitation as well, extending from galaxies in
which the molecular population mainly occupies the ground state to galaxies in
which there is significant population in higher levels. In the case of the
prototypical ULIRG, the merger galaxy Arp 220, the spectrum is dominated by
absorption lines of OH, H2O, CH, and [O I]. Low [O III]88 micron line flux
relative to the integrated far-infrared flux correlates with low excitation and
does not appear to be due to far-infrared extinction or to density effects. A
progression toward soft radiation fields or very dusty HII regions may explain
these effects.