Normalized to: Grappin, R.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.04118 [pdf] - 1871572
Three-dimensional local anisotropy of velocity fluctuations in the solar
wind
Submitted: 2019-04-08
We analyse velocity fluctuations in the solar wind at magneto-fluid scales in
two datasets, extracted from Wind data in the period 2005-2015, that are
characterised by strong or weak expansion. Expansion affects measurements of
anisotropy because it breaks axisymmetry around the mean magnetic field.
Indeed, the small-scale three-dimensional local anisotropy of magnetic
fluctuations ({\delta}B) as measured by structure functions (SF_B) is
consistent with tube-like structures for strong expansion. When passing to weak
expansion, structures become ribbon-like because of the flattening of SFB along
one of the two perpendicular directions. The power-law index that is consistent
with a spectral slope -5/3 for strong expansion now becomes closer to -3/2.
This index is also characteristic of velocity fluctuations in the solar wind.
We study velocity fluctuations ({\delta}V) to understand if the anisotropy of
their structure functions (SF_V ) also changes with the strength of expansion
and if the difference with the magnetic spectral index is washed out once
anisotropy is accounted for. We find that SF_V is generally flatter than SF_B.
When expansion passes from strong to weak, a further flattening of the
perpendicular SF_V occurs and the small-scale anisotropy switches from
tube-like to ribbon-like structures. These two types of anisotropy, common to
SF_V and SF_B, are associated to distinct large-scale variance anisotropies of
{\delta}B in the strong- and weak-expansion datasets. We conclude that SF_V
shows anisotropic three-dimensional scaling similar to SF_B, with however
systematic flatter scalings, reflecting the difference between global spectral
slopes.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.09837 [pdf] - 1824364
3D Anisotropy of Solar Wind Turbulence, Tubes, or Ribbons?
Submitted: 2018-02-27, last modified: 2019-01-30
We study the anisotropy with respect to the local magnetic field of turbulent
magnetic fluctuations at magnetofluid scales in the solar wind. Previous
measurements in the fast solar wind obtained axisymmetric anisotropy, despite
that the analysis method allows nonaxisymmetric structures. These results are
probably contaminated by the wind expansion that introduces another symmetry
axis, namely, the radial direction, as indicated by recent numerical
simulations. These simulations also show that while the expansion is strong,
the principal fluctuations are in the plane perpendicular to the radial
direction. Using this property, we separate 11 yr of Wind spacecraft data into
two subsets characterized by strong and weak expansion and determine the
corresponding turbulence anisotropy. Under strong expansion, the small-scale
anisotropy is consistent with the Goldreich & Sridhar critical balance. As in
previous works, when the radial symmetry axis is not eliminated, the turbulent
structures are field-aligned tubes. Under weak expansion, we find 3D anisotropy
predicted by the Boldyrev model, that is, turbulent structures are ribbons and
not tubes. However, the very basis of the Boldyrev phenomenology, namely, a
cross-helicity increasing at small scales, is not observed in the solar wind:
the origin of the ribbon formation is unknown.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.09094 [pdf] - 1513723
Beyond the Maltese cross: geometry of turbulence between 0.2 and 1 AU
Submitted: 2016-09-28
The spectral anisotropy of turbulent structures has been measured in the
solar wind since 1990, relying on the assumption of axisymmetry about the mean
magnetic field, B0. However, several works indicate that this hypothesis might
be partially wrong, thus raising two questions: (i) is it correct to interpret
measurements at 1 AU (the so-called Maltese cross) in term of a sum of slab and
2D turbulence? (ii) what information is really contained in the Maltese cross?
We solve direct numerical simulations of the MHD equations including the
transverse stretching exerted by the solar wind flow and study the genuine 3D
anisotropy of turbulence as well as that one resulting from the assumption of
axisymmetry about B0. We show that the evolution of the turbulent spectrum from
0.2 to 1 AU depends strongly on its initial anisotropy. An axisymmetric
spectrum with respect to B0 keeps its axisymmetry, i.e., resists stretching
perpendicular to radial, while an isotropic spectrum becomes essentially
axisymmetric with respect to the radial direction.
We conclude that close to the Sun, slow-wind turbulence has a spectrum that
is axisymmetric around B0 and the measured 2D component at 1 AU describes the
real shape of turbulent structures. On the contrary, fast-wind turbulence has a
more isotropic spectrum at the source and becomes radially symmetric at 1 AU.
Such structure is hidden by the symmetrization applied to the data that instead
returns a slab geometry.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.03559 [pdf] - 1396940
Alfv\'en-dynamo balance and magnetic excess in MHD turbulence
Submitted: 2016-03-11
3D Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulent flows with initially magnetic and
kinetic energies at equipartition spontaneously develop a magnetic excess (or
residual energy), as well in numerical simulations and in the solar wind.
Closure equations obtained in 1983 describe the residual spectrum as being
produced by a dynamo source proportional to the total energy spectrum, balanced
by a linear Alfv\'en damping term. A good agreement was found in 2005 with
incompressible simulations; however, recent solar wind measurements disagree
with these results. The previous dynamo-Alfv\'en theory is generalized to a
family of models, leading to simple relations between residual and total energy
spectra. We want to assess these models in detail against MHD simulations and
solar wind data. The family of models is tested against compressible decaying
MHD simulations with low Mach number, low cross-helicity, zero mean magnetic
field, without or with expansion terms (EBM or expanding box model). A single
dynamo-Alfv\'en model is found to describe correctly both solar wind scalings
and compressible simulations without or with expansion. It is equivalent to the
1983-2005 closure equation but with critical balance of nonlinear turnover and
linear Alfv\'en times, while the dynamo source term remains unchanged. The
discrepancy with previous incompressible simulations is elucidated. The model
predicts a linear relation between the spectral slopes of total and residual
energies $m_R = -1/2 + 3/2 m_T$. Examining the solar wind data as in
\cite{2013ApJ...770..125C}, our relation is found to be valid whatever the
cross-helicity, even better so at high cross-helicity, with the total energy
slope varying from $1.7$ to $1.55$.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.03450 [pdf] - 1258995
Imprints of expansion onto the local anisotropy of solar wind turbulence
Submitted: 2015-06-10
We study the anisotropy of II-order structure functions defined in a frame
attached to the local mean field in three-dimensional (3D) direct numerical
simulations of magnetohydrodynamic turbulence, including or not the solar wind
expansion. We simulate spacecraft flybys through the numerical domain by taking
increments along the radial (wind) direction that forms an angle of $45^o$ with
the ambient magnetic field. We find that only when expansion is taken into
account, do the synthetic observations match the 3D anisotropy observed in the
solar wind, including the change of anisotropy with scales. Our simulations
also show that the anisotropy changes dramatically when considering increments
oblique to the radial directions. Both results can be understood by noting that
expansion reduces the radial component of the magnetic field at all scales,
thus confining fluctuations in the plane perpendicular to the radial. Expansion
is thus shown to affect not only the (global) spectral anisotropy, but also the
local anisotropy of second-order structure functions by influencing the
distribution of the local mean field, which enters this higher-order
statistics.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.04705 [pdf] - 1055789
Anisotropy of third-order structure functions in MHD turbulence
Submitted: 2015-02-16, last modified: 2015-04-02
The measure of the third-order structure function, Y, is employed in the
solar wind to compute the cascade rate of turbulence. In the absence of a mean
field B0=0, Y is expected to be isotropic (radial) and independent of the
direction of increments, so its measure yields directly the cascade rate. For
turbulence with mean field, as in the solar wind, Y is expected to become more
two dimensional (2D), that is, to have larger perpendicular components, loosing
the above simple symmetry. To get the cascade rate one should compute the flux
of Y, which is not feasible with single-spacecraft data, thus measurements rely
upon assumptions about the unknown symmetry. We use direct numerical
simulations (DNS) of magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence to characterize the
anisotropy of Y. We find that for strong guide field B0=5 the degree of
two-dimensionalization depends on the relative importance of shear and pseudo
polarizations (the two components of an Alfv\'en mode in incompressible MHD).
The anisotropy also shows up in the inertial range. The more Y is 2D, the more
the inertial range extent differs along parallel and perpendicular directions.
We finally test the two methods employed in observations and find that the
so-obtained cascade rate may depend on the angle between B0 and the direction
of increments. Both methods yield a vanishing cascade rate along the parallel
direction, contrary to observations, suggesting a weaker anisotropy of solar
wind turbulence compared to our DNS. This could be due to a weaker mean field
and/or to solar wind expansion.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.3459 [pdf] - 907911
Three-dimensional Iroshnikov-Kraichnan turbulence in a mean magnetic
field
Submitted: 2013-12-12, last modified: 2014-12-13
Forced, weak MHD turbulence with guide field is shown to adopt different
regimes, depending on the magnetic excess of the large forced scales. When the
magnetic excess is large enough, the classical perpendicular cascade with $5/3$
scaling is obtained, while when equipartition is imposed, an isotropic $3/2$
scaling appears in all directions with respect to the mean field
(\cite{2010PhRvE..82b6406G} or GM10). We show here that the $3/2$ scaling of
the GM10 regime is not ruled by a small-scale cross-helicity cascade, and
propose that it is a 3D extension of a perpendicular weak Iroshnikov-Kraichnan
(IK) cascade. We analyze in detail the structure functions in real space and
show that they closely follow the critical balance relation both in the local
frame and the global frame: we show that there is no contradiction between this
and the isotropic $3/2$ scaling of the spectra. We propose a scenario
explaining the spectral structure of the GM10 regime, that starts with a
perpendicular weak IK cascade and extends to 3D by using quasi-resonant
couplings. The quasi-resonance condition happens to reduce the energy flux in
the same way as is done in the weak perpendicular cascade, so leading to a
$3/2$ scaling in all directions. We discuss the possible applications of these
findings to solar wind turbulence.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.0018 [pdf] - 1216589
Evolution of turbulence in the expanding solar wind, a numerical study
Submitted: 2014-08-29
We study the evolution of turbulence in the solar wind by solving numerically
the full 3D magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) equations embedded in a radial mean
wind. The corresponding equations (expanding box model or EBM) have been
considered earlier but never integrated in 3D simulations. Here, we follow the
development of turbulence from 0.2 AU up to about 1.5 AU. Starting with
isotropic spectra scaling as $k^{-1}$, we observe a steepening toward a
$k^{-5/3}$ scaling in the middle of the wavenumber range and formation of
spectral anisotropies. The advection of a plasma volume by the expanding solar
wind causes a non-trivial stretching of the volume in directions transverse to
radial and the selective decay of the components of velocity and magnetic
fluctuations. These two effects combine to yield the following results. (i)
Spectral anisotropy: gyrotropy is broken, and the radial wavevectors have most
of the power. (ii) Coherent structures: radial streams emerge that resemble the
observed microjets. (iii) Energy spectra per component: they show an ordering
in good agreement with the one observed in the solar wind at 1 AU. The latter
point includes a global dominance of the magnetic energy over kinetic energy in
the inertial and $f^{-1}$ range and a dominance of the
perpendicular-to-the-radial components over the radial components in the
inertial range. We conclude that many of the above properties are the result of
evolution during transport in the heliosphere, and not just the remnant of the
initial turbulence close to the Sun.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.1412 [pdf] - 1165743
Rotational/ Compressional nature of the Magnetopause: application of the
BV technique on a magnetopause case study
Submitted: 2013-04-04
The magnetopause boundary implies two kinds of variations: a density/
temperature gradient and a magnetic field rotation. These two kinds are always
observed in a close vicinity of each other, if not inseparably mixed. We
present a case study from the Cluster data where the two are clearly separated
and investigate the natures of both layers. We evidence that the first one is a
slow shock while the second is a rotational discontinuity. The interaction
between these two kinds of discontinuities is then studied with the help of
1,5-D magnetohydrodynamics simulations. The comparison with the data is quite
positive and leads to think that most of the generic properties of the
magnetopause may be interpreted in this sense.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.0341 [pdf] - 1158787
Coupling the solar surface and the corona: coronal rotation, Alfv\'en
wave-driven polar plumes
Submitted: 2013-01-02
The dynamical response of the solar corona to surface and sub-surface
perturbations depends on the chromospheric stratification, and specifically on
how efficiently these layers reflect or transmit incoming Alfv\'en waves. While
it would be desirable to include the chromospheric layers in the numerical
simulations used to study such phenomena, that is most often not feasible. We
defined and tested a simple approximation allowing the study of coronal
phenomena while taking into account a parametrised chromospheric reflectivity.
We addressed the problems of the transmission of the surface rotation to the
corona and that of the generation of polar plumes by Alfv\'en waves (Pinto et
al., 2010, 2011). We found that a high (yet partial) effective chromospheric
reflectivity is required to properly describe the angular momentum balance in
the corona and the way the surface differential rotation is transmitted
upwards. Alfv\'en wave-driven polar plumes maintain their properties for a wide
range of values for the reflectivity, but they become bursty (and eventually
disrupt) when the limit of total reflection is attained.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.0412 [pdf] - 597804
Solar wind turbulent spectrum at plasma kinetic scales
Submitted: 2012-12-03
The description of the turbulent spectrum of magnetic fluctuations in the
solar wind in the kinetic range of scales is not yet completely established.
Here, we perform a statistical study of 100 spectra measured by the STAFF
instrument on the Cluster mission, which allows to resolve turbulent
fluctuations from ion scales down to a fraction of electron scales, i.e. from
$\sim 10^2$ km to $\sim 300$ m. We show that for $k_{\perp}\rho_e \in[0.03,3]$
(that corresponds approximately to the frequency in the spacecraft frame $f\in
[3,300]$ Hz), all the observed spectra can be described by a general law
$E(k_\perp)\propto k_\perp^{-8/3}\exp{(-k_\perp \rho_e)}$, where $k_{\perp}$ is
the wave-vector component normal to the background magnetic field and $\rho_e$
the electron Larmor radius. This exponential tail found in the solar wind seems
compatible with the Landau damping of magnetic fluctuations onto electrons.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.4450 [pdf] - 565749
Quasi-isotropic cascade in MHD turbulence with mean field
Submitted: 2012-09-20
We propose a phenomenological theory of incompressible magnetohydrodynamic
turbulence in the presence of a strong large-scale magnetic field, which
establishes a link between the known anisotropic models of strong and weak MHD
turbulence We argue that the Iroshnikov-Kraichnan isotropic cascade develops
naturally within the plane perpendicular to the mean field, while
oblique-parallel cascades with weaker amplitudes can develop, triggered by the
perpendicular cascade, with a reduced flux resulting from a quasi-resonance
condition. The resulting energy spectrum $E(k_\parallel,k_\bot)$ has the same
slope in all directions. The ratio between the extents of the inertial range in
the parallel and perpendicular directions is equal to $b_{rms}/B_0$. These
properties match those found in recent 3D MHD simulations with isotropic
forcing reported in [R. Grappin and W.-C. M\"uller, Phys. Rev. E \textbf{82},
26406 (2010)].
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.2094 [pdf] - 1117867
Transition from weak to strong cascade in MHD turbulence
Submitted: 2012-04-10, last modified: 2012-06-29
The transition from weak to strong turbulence when passing from large to
small scales in magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence with guide field is a
cornerstone of anisotropic turbulence theory. We present the first check of
this transition, using the Shell-RMHD which combines a shell model of
perpendicular nonlinear coupling and linear propagation along the guide field.
This model allows us to reach Reynolds numbers around $10^6$. We obtain
surprisingly good agreement with the theoretical predictions, with a reduced
perpendicular energy spectrum scaling as $k^{-2}$ at large scales and as
$k^{-5/3}$ at small scales, where critical balance between nonlinear and
propagation time is reached. However, even in the strong regime, a high level
of excitation is found in the weak coupling region of Fourier space, which is
due to the rich frequency spectrum of large eddies. A corollary is that the
reduced parallel spectral slope is not a definite test of the spectral
anisotropy, contrary to standard belief.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.6219 [pdf] - 1117607
On the origin of the 1/f spectrum in the solar wind magnetic field
Submitted: 2012-03-28, last modified: 2012-04-09
We present a mechanism for the formation of the low frequency 1/f magnetic
spectrum based on numerical solutions of a shell reduced-MHD model of the
turbulent dynamics inside the sub-Alfv\'enic solar wind. We assign reasonably
realistic profiles to the wind speed and the density along the radial
direction, and a radial magnetic field. Alfv\'en waves of short periodicity
(600 s) are injected at the base of the chromosphere, penetrate into the corona
and are partially reflected, thus triggering a turbulent cascade. The cascade
is strong for the reflected wave while it is weak for the outward propagating
waves. Reflection at the transition region recycles the strong turbulent
spectrum into the outward weak spectrum, which is advected beyond the
Alfv\'enic critical point without substantial evolution. There, the magnetic
field has a perpendicular power-law spectrum with slope close to the Kolmogorov
-5/3. The parallel spectrum is inherited from the frequency spectrum of large
(perpendicular) eddies. The shape is a double power-law with slopes of -1 and
-2 at low and high frequencies respectively, the position of the break
depending on the injected spectrum. We suggest that the double power-law
spectrum measured by Helios at 0.3 AU, where the average magnetic field is not
aligned with the radial (contrary to our assumptions) results from the
combination of such different spectral slopes. At low frequency the parallel
spectrum dominates with its characteristic 1/f shape, while at higher
frequencies its steep spectral slope (-2) is masked by the more energetic
perpendicular spectrum (slope -5/3).
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.5649 [pdf] - 443215
Fluid-like dissipation of magnetic turbulence at electron scales in the
solar wind
Submitted: 2011-11-23
The turbulent spectrum of magnetic fluctuations in the solar wind displays a
spectral break at ion characteristic scales. At electron scales the spectral
shape is not yet completely established. Here, we perform a statistical study
of 102 spectra at plasma kinetic scales, measured by the Cluster/STAFF
instrument in the free solar wind. We show that the magnetic spectrum in the
high frequency range, [1,400] Hz, has a form similar to what is found in
hydrodynamics in the dissipation range ~Ak^(-\alpha)exp(-kl_d). The dissipation
scale l_d is found to be correlated with the electron Larmor radius \rho_e. The
spectral index \alpha varies in the range [2.2,2.9] and is anti-correlated with
l_d, as expected in the case of the balance between the energy injection and
the energy dissipation. The coefficient A is found to be proportional to the
ion temperature anisotropy, suggesting that local ion instabilities may play
some role for the solar wind turbulence at plasma kinetic scales. The
exponential spectral shape found here indicates that the effective dissipation
of magnetic fluctuations in the solar wind has a wave number dependence similar
to that of the resistive term in collisional fluids ~k^2\delta B.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.5359 [pdf] - 1091855
Coronal heating in coupled photosphere-chromosphere-coronal systems:
turbulence and leakage
Submitted: 2011-11-22
Coronal loops act as resonant cavities for low frequency fluctuations that
are transmitted from the deeper layers of the solar atmosphere and are
amplified in the corona, triggering nonlinear interactions. However trapping is
not perfect, some energy leaks down to the chromosphere, thus limiting the
turbulence development and the associated heating. We consider the combined
effects of turbulence and leakage in determining the energy level and
associated heating rate in models of coronal loops which include the
chromosphere and transition region. We use a piece-wise constant model for the
Alfven speed and a Reduced MHD - Shell model to describe the interplay between
turbulent dynamics in the direction perpendicular to the mean field and
propagation along the field. Turbulence is sustained by incoming fluctuations
which are equivalent, in the line-tied case, to forcing by the photospheric
shear flows. While varying the turbulence strength, we compare systematically
the average coronal energy level (E) and dissipation rate (D) in three models
with increasing complexity: the classical closed model, the semi-open corona
model, and the corona-chromosphere (or 3-layer) model, the latter two models
allowing energy leakage. We find that:
(i) Leakage always plays a role (even for strong turbulence), E and D are
systematically lower than in the line-tied model. (ii) E is close to the
resonant prediction, i.e., assuming effective turbulent correlation time longer
than the Alfven coronal crossing time (Ta). (iii) D is close to the value given
by the ratio of photospheric energy divided by Ta (iv) The coronal spectra
exibits an inertial range with 5/3 spectral slope, and a large scale peak of
trapped resonant modes that inhibit nonlinear couplings. (v) In the realistic
3-layer model, the two-component spectrum leads to a damping time equal to the
Kolmogorov time reduced by a factor u_rms/Va_corona
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.0882 [pdf] - 1077082
Coupling the solar dynamo and the corona: wind properties, mass and
momentum losses during an activity cycle
Submitted: 2011-06-05
We study the connections between the sun's convection zone and the evolution
of the solar wind and corona. We let the magnetic fields generated by a 2.5D
axisymmetric kinematic dynamo code (STELEM) evolve in a 2.5D axisymmetric
coronal isothermal MHD code (DIP). The computations cover an 11 year activity
cycle. The solar wind's asymptotic velocity varies in latitude and in time in
good agreement with the available observations. The magnetic polarity reversal
happens at different paces at different coronal heights. Overall sun's mass
loss rate, momentum flux and magnetic braking torque vary considerably
throughout the cycle. This cyclic modulation is determined by the latitudinal
distribution of the sources of open flux and solar wind and the geometry of the
Alfv\'en surface. Wind sources and braking torque application zones also vary
accordingly.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.3226 [pdf] - 902775
Coronal Inflows and Giant Polar Plumes
Submitted: 2009-12-16
We present the first results of simulations of giant polar plumes and coronal
flows. We use a 2.5D axisymmetric MHD numerical model of an isothermal corona
and slow solar wind. A plume is generated just above asmall magnetic bipole
embedded in an unipolar flux region which is perturbed by Alfv\'en waves
injected from the coronal base. The boundary conditions are transparent. The
results are compared to those obtained previously with a 1D wind model in which
plumes are generated as a consequence of variations of the heating and
flux-tube expansion parameters.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.1497 [pdf] - 902672
Coupling Photosphere and Corona: Linear and Turbulent Regimes
Submitted: 2009-12-08
In a recent work Grappin et al. [1] have shown that low- frequency movements
can be transmitted from one footpoint to the other along a magnetic loop, thus
mimicking a friction effect of the corona on the photosphere, and invalidating
the line-tying approximation. We consider here successively the effect of high
frequencies and turbulent damping on the process. We use a very simple
atmospheric model which allows to study analytically the laminar case, and to
study the turbulent case both using simple phenomenological arguments and a
more sophisticated turbulence model [2]. We find that, except when turbulent
damping is such that all turbulence is damped during loop traversal, coupling
still occurs between distant footpoints, and moreover the coronal field induced
by photospheric movements saturates at finite values.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:0710.0899 [pdf] - 5663
Instability of P-waves just below the transition region in a global
solar wind simulation
Submitted: 2007-10-03
We investigate how wave propagation is modified by the presence of heat
sources and sinks, in the simple 1D, hydrodynamical case, including
chromosphere and solar wind. We integrate the time-dependent hydrodynamic
equations of the solar wind with spherical symmetry, including conduction,
radiative cooling and a prescribed mechanical heat flux. Once a
quasi-stationary wind is established, we study the response of the system to
pressure oscillations at the photospheric boundary. We use transparent boundary
conditions. We find that wavepackets with high enough amplitude propagating
upward from the photosphere implode just below the transition region. This
implosion is due to the radiative cooling term generating pressure holes close
to the wave crests of the wave, which make the wave collapse. In the case where
heat sources and sinks are not present in the equations, the wave remains
stable whatever the initial wave amplitude, which is compatible with published
work. Instability should be observable when and where the TR is high enough
above the optically thick regions.