Normalized to: Ghizzardi, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01084 [pdf] - 2126902
Iron in X-COP: tracing enrichment in cluster outskirts with high
accuracy abundance profiles
Ghizzardi, Simona;
Molendi, Silvano;
van der Burg, Remco;
De Grandi, Sabrina;
Bartalucci, Iacopo;
Gastaldello, Fabio;
Rossetti, Mariachiara;
Biffi, Veronica;
Borgani, Stefano;
Eckert, Dominique;
Ettori, Stefano;
Gaspari, Massimo;
Ghirardini, Vittorio;
Rasia, Elena
Submitted: 2020-07-02
We present the first metal abundance profiles for a representative sample of
massive clusters. Our measures extend to $R_{500}$ and are corrected for a
systematic error plaguing previous outskirt estimates. Our profiles flatten out
at large radii, admittedly not a new result, however the radial range and
representative nature of our sample extends its import well beyond previous
findings. We find no evidence of segregation between cool-core and
non-cool-core systems beyond $\sim 0.3 R_{500}$, implying that, as was found
for thermodynamic properties (Ghirardini et al, 2019), the physical state of
the core does not affect global cluster properties. Our mean abundance within
$R_{500}$ shows a very modest scatter, $< $15%, suggesting the enrichment
process must be quite similar in all these massive systems. This is a new
finding and has significant implications on feedback processes. Together with
results from thermodynamic properties presented in a previous X-COP paper, it
affords a coherent picture where feedback effects do not vary significantly
from one system to another. By combing ICM with stellar measurements we have
found the amount of Fe diffused in the ICM to be about ten times higher than
that locked in stars. Although our estimates suggest, with some strength, that
the measured iron mass in clusters is well in excess of the predicted one,
systematic errors prevent us from making a definitive statement. Further
advancements will only be possible when systematic uncertainties, principally
those associated to stellar masses, both within and beyond $R_{500}$, can be
reduced.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.10838 [pdf] - 2099824
Chandra and XMM-Newton observations of A2256: cold fronts, merger
shocks, and constraint on the IC emission
Ge, Chong;
Liu, Ruo-Yu;
Sun, Ming;
Yu, Heng;
Rudnick, Lawrence;
Eilek, Jean;
Owen, Frazer;
Dasadia, Sarthak;
Rossetti, Mariachiara;
Markevitch, Maxim;
Clarke, Tracy E.;
Jones, Thomas W.;
Ghizzardi, Simona;
Venturi, Tiziana;
Finoguenov, Alexis;
Eckert, Dominique
Submitted: 2020-05-21
We present the results of deep Chandra and XMM-Newton observations of a
complex merging galaxy cluster Abell 2256 (A2256) that hosts a spectacular
radio relic. The temperature and metallicity maps show clear evidence of a
merger between the western subcluster and the primary cluster. We detect five
X-ray surface brightness edges. Three of them near the cluster center are cold
fronts (CFs): CF1 is associated with the infalling subcluster; CF2 is located
in the east of the primary cluster and CF3 is to the west of the primary
cluster core. The other two edges at cluster outskirts are shock fronts (SFs):
SF1 near the radio relic in the NW has Mach numbers derived from the
temperature and the density jumps respectively of $M_T=1.62\pm0.12$ and
$M_\rho=1.23\pm0.06$; SF2 in the SE has $M_T=1.54\pm0.05$ and
$M_\rho=1.16\pm0.13$. In the region of the radio relic there is no evidence for
the correlation between X-ray and radio substructures, from which we estimate
an upper limit for the inverse Compton emission, and therefore set a lower
limit on the magnetic field ($\sim$ 450 kpc from primary cluster center) of
$B>1.0\ \mu$G for a single power-law electron spectrum or $B>0.4\ \mu$G for a
broken power-law electron spectrum. We propose a merger scenario including a
primary cluster, a subcluster, and a group. Our merger scenario accounts for
the X-ray edges, diffuse radio features, and galaxy kinematics, as well as
projection effects.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.02277 [pdf] - 2034384
The velocity field of the Lyra complex
Girardi, M.;
Boschin, W.;
De Grandi, S.;
Longhetti, M.;
Clavico, S.;
Eckert, D.;
Gastaldello, F.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Nonino, M.;
Rossetti, M.
Submitted: 2019-08-06, last modified: 2019-10-21
The formation of cosmic structure culminates with the assembly of galaxy
clusters, a process quite different from cluster to cluster. We present the
study of the structure and dynamics of the Lyra complex formed of the two
clusters RXC J1825.3+3026 and CIZA J1824.1+3029, very recently studied using
both X-ray and radio data. This is the first analysis based on kinematics of
member galaxies. New spectroscopic data for 285 galaxies were acquired at the
Italian Telescopio Nazionale Galileo and used in combination with PanSTARRS
photometry. The result of our member selection is a sample of 198 galaxies. For
RXCJ1825 and CIZAJ1824 we report the redshifts, z=0.0645 and z=0.0708, the
first estimates of velocity dispersion, sigmav=995 and 700 km/s, and dynamical
mass, M200=1.1E15 and 4E14 Msun. The past assembly of RXCJ1825 is traced by the
two dominant galaxies, both aligned with the major axis of the galaxy
distribution along the East-West direction, and by a minor North-East
substructure. We also detect a quite peculiar high velocity field in the
South-West region of the Lyra complex. This feature is likely related to a high
velocity, very luminous galaxy, suggested to be the central galaxy of a group
in interaction with RXCJ1825 by very recent studies based on X-ray and radio
data. The redshift of the whole Lyra complex is z=0.067. Assuming that the
redshift difference between RXCJ1825 and CIZAJ1824 is due to the relative
kinematics, the projected distance between the cluster centers is 1.3 Mpc and
the los velocity difference is 1750 km/s. A dynamical analysis of the system
shows that the two clusters are likely to be gravitationally bound, in a
pre-merger phase, with CIZAJ1824 in front of RXCJ1825 and going toward it. Our
results corroborate a picture where the Lyra region is the place of a very
complex scenario of cluster assembly.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.02276 [pdf] - 2005459
Growth and disruption in the Lyra complex
Clavico, S.;
De Grandi, S.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Rossetti, M.;
Molendi, S.;
Gastaldello, F.;
Girardi, M.;
Boschin, W.;
Botteon, A.;
Cassano, R.;
Bruggen, M.;
Brunetti, G.;
Dallacasa, D.;
Eckert, D.;
Ettori, S.;
Gaspari, M.;
Sereno, M.;
Shimwell, T.;
van Weeren, R. J.
Submitted: 2019-08-06, last modified: 2019-10-08
Nearby clusters of galaxies, z<0.1, are cosmic structures still under
formation. Understanding the thermodynamic properties of merging clusters can
provide crucial information on how they grow in the local universe. A detailed
study of the intra-cluster medium (ICM) properties of un-relaxed systems is
essential to understand the fate of in-falling structures and, more generally,
the virialization process. We analyzed a mosaic of XMM-Newton observations (240
ks) of the Lyra system (z=0.067) that shows a complex dynamical state. We find
the main cluster RXC J1825.3+3026 to be in a late merger phase, whereas its
companion CIZA J1824.1+3029 is a relaxed cool-core cluster. We estimate a mass
ratio of ~1:2 for the pair. No diffuse X-ray emission is found in the region
between them, indicating that these clusters are in a pre-merger phase. We
found evidence of a galaxy group infalling on RXC J1825.3+3026 in an advanced
state of disruption. The Southern Galaxy, one of the brightest galaxies in the
Lyra complex, was very likely at the center of the infalling group. This galaxy
has a gaseous corona indicating that it was able to retain some of its gas
after the ram-pressure stripping of the intra-group medium. In this scenario
the diffuse emission excess observed southwest of RXC J1825.3+3026 could be due
to gas once belonging to the group and/or to cluster ICM dislocated by the
passage of the group. Finally, we identified three high-velocity galaxies
aligned between RXC J1825.3+3026 and the SG, two of these showing evidence of
gas stripped from them during infall. We estimate them to be currently falling
onto the main cluster at an infall velocity of ~ 3000 km/s. Our study of the
Lyra complex provides important clues about the processes presiding over the
virialization of massive clusters in the local Universe.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.07527 [pdf] - 1966974
Particle acceleration in a nearby galaxy cluster pair: the role of
cluster dynamics
Botteon, A.;
Cassano, R.;
Eckert, D.;
Brunetti, G.;
Dallacasa, D.;
Shimwell, T. W.;
van Weeren, R. J.;
Gastaldello, F.;
Bonafede, A.;
Brüggen, M.;
Bîrzan, L.;
Clavico, S.;
Cuciti, V.;
de Gasperin, F.;
De Grandi, S.;
Ettori, S.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Rossetti, M.;
Röttgering, H. J. A.;
Sereno, M.
Submitted: 2019-08-20
Diffuse radio emission associated with the intra-cluster medium (ICM) is
observed in a number of merging galaxy clusters. It is currently believed that
in mergers a fraction of the kinetic energy is channeled into non-thermal
components, such as turbulence, cosmic rays and magnetic fields, that may lead
to the formation of giant synchrotron sources in the ICM. Studying merging
galaxy clusters in different evolutionary phases is fundamental to
understanding the origin of radio emission in the ICM. We observed the nearby
galaxy cluster pair RXC J1825.3+3026 ($z\sim0.065$) and CIZA J1824.1+3029
($z\sim0.071$) at 120-168 MHz with the LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR) and made use
of a deep (240 ks) XMM-Newton dataset to study the non-thermal and thermal
properties of the system. RXC J1825.3+3026 is in a complex dynamical state,
with a primary on-going merger in the E-W direction and a secondary later stage
merger with a group of galaxies in the SW, while CIZA J1824.1+3029 is
dynamically relaxed. These two clusters are in a pre-merger phase. We report
the discovery of a Mpc-scale radio halo with a low surface brightness extension
in RXC J1825.3+3026 that follows the X-ray emission from the cluster center to
the remnant of a galaxy group in the SW. This is among the least massive
systems and the faintest giant radio halo known to date. Contrary to this, no
diffuse radio emission is observed in CIZA J1824.1+3029 nor in the region
between the pre-merger cluster pair. The power spectra of the X-ray surface
brightness fluctuations of RXC J1825.3+3026 and CIZA J1824.1+3029 are in
agreement with the findings for clusters exhibiting a radio halo and the ones
where no radio emission has been detected, respectively. We provide
quantitative support to the idea that cluster mergers play a crucial role in
the generation of non-thermal components in the ICM.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.07730 [pdf] - 1949382
A joint XMM-NuSTAR observation of the galaxy cluster Abell 523:
constraints on Inverse Compton emission
Cova, F.;
Gastaldello, F.;
Wik, D. R.;
Boschin, W.;
Botteon, A.;
Brunetti, G.;
Buote, D. A.;
De Grandi, S.;
Eckert, D.;
Ettori, S.;
Feretti, L.;
Gaspari, M.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Giovannini, G.;
Ghirardi, M.;
Govoni, F.;
Molendi, S.;
Murgia, M.;
Rossetti, M.;
Vacca, V.
Submitted: 2019-06-18
We present the results of a joint XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observation (200 ks)
of the galaxy cluster Abell 523 at $z=0.104$. The peculiar morphology of the
cluster radio halo and its outlier position in the radio power P(1.4 GHz) -
X-ray luminosity plane make it an ideal candidate for the study of radio-X-ray
correlations and for the search of inverse Compton (IC) emission. We
constructed thermodynamic maps derived from the XMM observations to describe in
detail the physical and dynamical state of the ICM. We performed a
point-to-point comparison in terms of surface brightness between the X-ray and
radio emissions, to quantify their morphological discrepancies. Making use of
NuSTAR's hard X-ray focusing capability, we looked for IC emission both
globally and locally, after modeling the purely thermal component with a
multi-temperature description. The thermodynamic maps suggest the presence of a
secondary merging process that could be responsible for the peculiar radio halo
morphology. This hypothesis is supported by the comparison between the X-ray
and radio surface brightnesses, which shows a broad intrinsic scatter and a
series of outliers. The global NuSTAR spectrum can be explained by purely
thermal gas emission, and there is no convincing evidence that an IC component
is needed. The $3\sigma$ upper limit on the IC flux in the 20-80 keV band is in
the range $\left[2.2 - 4.0\right] \times 10^{-13} \, \mathrm{erg} \,
\mathrm{s}^{-1} \, \mathrm{cm}^{-2}$, implying a lower limit on the magnetic
field strength in the range $B > [0.23 - 0.31] \, \mu G$. Locally, we looked
for IC emission in the central region of the cluster radio halo finding a
$3\sigma$ upper limit on the 20-80 keV non-thermal flux of $3.17 \times
10^{-14} \, \mathrm{erg} \, \mathrm{s}^{-1} \, \mathrm{cm}^{-2}$, corresponding
to a lower limit on the magnetic field strength of $B \gtrsim 0.81 \, \mu G$.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.00035 [pdf] - 1811045
Hydrostatic mass profiles in X-COP galaxy clusters
Ettori, S.;
Ghirardini, V.;
Eckert, D.;
Pointecouteau, E.;
Gastaldello, F.;
Sereno, M.;
Gaspari, M.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Roncarelli, M.;
Rossetti, M.
Submitted: 2018-04-30, last modified: 2018-10-31
We present the reconstruction of hydrostatic mass profiles in 13 X-ray
luminous galaxy clusters that have been mapped in their X-ray and SZ signal out
to $R_{200}$ for the XMM-Newton Cluster Outskirts Project (X-COP). Using
profiles of the gas temperature, density and pressure that have been spatially
resolved out to (median value) 0.9 $R_{500}$, 1.8 $R_{500}$, and 2.3 $R_{500}$,
respectively, we are able to recover the hydrostatic gravitating mass profile
with several methods and using different mass models. The hydrostatic masses
are recovered with a relative (statistical) median error of 3% at $R_{500}$ and
6% at $R_{200}$. By using several different methods to solve the equation of
the hydrostatic equilibrium, we evaluate some of the systematic uncertainties
to be of the order of 5% at both $R_{500}$ and $R_{200}$. A Navarro-Frenk-White
profile provides the best-fit in nine cases out of 13, with the remaining four
cases that do not show a statistically significant tension with it. The
distribution of the mass concentration follows the correlations with the total
mass predicted from numerical simulations with a scatter of 0.18 dex, with an
intrinsic scatter on the hydrostatic masses of 0.15 dex. We compare them with
the estimates of the total gravitational mass obtained through X-ray scaling
relations applied to $Y_X$, gas fraction and $Y_{SZ}$, and from weak lensing
and galaxy dynamics techniques, and measure a substantial agreement with the
results from scaling laws, from WL at both $R_{500}$ and $R_{200}$ (with
differences below 15%), from cluster velocity dispersions, but a significant
tension with the caustic masses that tend to underestimate the hydrostatic
masses by 40% at $R_{200}$. We also compare these measurements with predictions
from alternative models to the Cold Dark Matter, like the "Emergent Gravity"
and MOND scenarios.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.00034 [pdf] - 1811044
Non-thermal pressure support in X-COP galaxy clusters
Eckert, D.;
Ghirardini, V.;
Ettori, S.;
Rasia, E.;
Biffi, V.;
Pointecouteau, E.;
Rossetti, M.;
Molendi, S.;
Vazza, F.;
Gastaldello, F.;
Gaspari, M.;
De Grandi, S.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Bourdin, H.;
Tchernin, C.;
Roncarelli, M.
Submitted: 2018-04-30, last modified: 2018-10-04
Galaxy clusters are the endpoints of structure formation and are continuously
growing through the merging and accretion of smaller structures. Numerical
simulations predict that a fraction of their energy content is not yet
thermalized, mainly in the form of kinetic motions (turbulence, bulk motions).
Measuring the level of non-thermal pressure support is necessary to understand
the processes leading to the virialization of the gas within the potential well
of the main halo and to calibrate the biases in hydrostatic mass estimates. We
present high-quality measurements of hydrostatic masses and intracluster gas
fraction out to the virial radius for a sample of 12 nearby clusters with
available XMM-Newton and Planck data. We compare our hydrostatic gas fractions
with the expected universal gas fraction to constrain the level of non-thermal
pressure support. We find that hydrostatic masses require little correction and
infer a median non-thermal pressure fraction of $\sim6\%$ and $\sim10\%$ at
$R_{500}$ and $R_{200}$, respectively. Our values are lower than the
expectations of hydrodynamical simulations, possibly implying a faster
thermalization of the gas. If instead we use the mass calibration adopted by
the Planck team, we find that the gas fraction of massive local systems implies
a mass bias $1-b=0.85\pm0.05$ for SZ-derived masses, with some evidence for a
mass-dependent bias. Conversely, the high bias required to match Planck CMB and
cluster count cosmology is excluded by the data at high significance, unless
the most massive halos are missing a substantial fraction of their baryons.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.04174 [pdf] - 1583338
A systematic analysis of the XMM-Newton background: IV. Origin of the
unfocused and focused components
Submitted: 2017-05-11
We show the results obtained in the FP7 European program EXTraS and in the
ESA R&D ATHENA activity AREMBES aimed at a deeper understanding of the
XMM-Newton background to better design the ATHENA mission. Thanks to an
analysis of the full EPIC archive coupled to the information obtained by the
Radiation Monitor we show the cosmic ray origin of the unfocused particle
background and its anti-correlation with the solar activity. We show the first
results of the effort to obtain informations about the particle component of
the soft proton focused background.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.04173 [pdf] - 1583337
A systematic analysis of the XMM-Newton background: III. Impact of the
magnetospheric environment
Submitted: 2017-05-11
A detailed characterization of the particle induced background is fundamental
for many of the scientific objectives of the Athena X-ray telescope, thus an
adequate knowledge of the background that will be encountered by Athena is
desirable. Current X-ray telescopes have shown that the intensity of the
particle induced background can be highly variable. Different regions of the
magnetosphere can have very different environmental conditions, which can, in
principle, differently affect the particle induced background detected by the
instruments. We present results concerning the influence of the magnetospheric
environment on the background detected by EPIC instrument onboard XMM-Newton
through the estimate of the variation of the in-Field-of-View background excess
along the XMM-Newton orbit. An important contribution to the XMM background,
which may affect the Athena background as well, comes from soft proton flares.
Along with the flaring component a low-intensity component is also present. We
find that both show modest variations in the different magnetozones and that
the soft proton component shows a strong trend with the distance from Earth.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.04171 [pdf] - 1583336
A Systematic Analysis of the XMM-Newton Background: I. Dataset and
Extraction Procedures
Submitted: 2017-05-11
XMM-Newton is the direct precursor of the future ESA ATHENA mission. A study
of its particle-induced background provides therefore significant insight for
the ATHENA mission design. We make use of about 12 years of data, products from
the third XMM-Newton catalog as well as FP7 EXTraS project to avoid celestial
sources contamination and to disentangle the different components of the
XMM-Newton particle-induced background. Within the ESA R&D AREMBES
collaboration, we built new analysis pipelines to study the different
components of this background: this covers time behavior as well as spectral
and spatial characteristics.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.04172 [pdf] - 1634069
A Systematic Analysis of the XMM-Newton Background: II. Properties of
the in-Field-Of-View Excess Component
Submitted: 2017-05-11
We present an accurate characterization of the particle background behaviour
on XMM-Newton based on the entire EPIC archive. This corresponds to the largest
EPIC data set ever examined. Our results have been obtained thanks to the
collaboration between the FP7 European program EXTraS and the ESA R&D ATHENA
activity AREMBES. We used as a diagnostic an improved version of the diagnostic
which compares the data collected in unexposed region of the detector with the
region of the field of view in the EPIC-MOS. We will show that the in
Field-of-View excess background is made up of two different components, one
associated to flares produced by soft protons and the other one to a
low-intensity background. Its origin needs to be further investigated.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.05549 [pdf] - 1521306
Where does the gas fueling star formation in BCGs originate?
Submitted: 2016-08-19
We investigate the relationship between X-ray cooling and star formation in
brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs). We present an X-ray spectral analysis of the
inner regions, 10-40 kpc, of six nearby cool core clusters (z<0.35) observed
with Chandra ACIS. This sample is selected on the basis of the high star
formation rate (SFR) observed in the BCGs. We restrict our search for cooling
gas to regions that are roughly cospatial with the starburst. We fit single-
and multi-temperature mkcflow models to constrain the amount of isobarically
cooling intracluster medium (ICM). We find that in all clusters, below a
threshold temperature ranging between 0.9 and 3 keV, only upper limits can be
obtained. In four out of six objects, the upper limits are significantly below
the SFR and in two, namely A1835 and A1068, they are less than a tenth of the
SFR. Our results suggests that a number of mechanisms conspire to hide the
cooling signature in our spectra. In a few systems the lack of a cooling
signature may be attributed to a relatively long delay time between the X-ray
cooling and the star burst. However, for A1835 and A1068, where the X-ray
cooling time is shorter than the timescale of the starburst, a possible
explanation is that the region where gas cools out of the X-ray phase extends
to very large radii, likely beyond the core of these systems.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.07148 [pdf] - 1460828
A textbook example of ram-pressure stripping in the Hydra A/A780 cluster
De Grandi, S.;
Eckert, D.;
Molendi, S.;
Girardi, M.;
Roediger, E.;
Gaspari, M.;
Gastaldello, F.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Nonino, M.;
Rossetti, M.
Submitted: 2016-02-23
In the current epoch, one of the main mechanisms driving the growth of galaxy
clusters is the continuous accretion of group-scale halos. In this process, the
ram pressure applied by the hot intracluster medium on the gas content of the
infalling group is responsible for stripping the gas from its dark-matter halo,
which gradually leads to the virialization of the infalling gas in the
potential well of the main cluster. Using deep wide-field observations of the
poor cluster Hydra A/A780 with XMM-Newton and Suzaku, we report the discovery
of an infalling galaxy group 1.1 Mpc south of the cluster core. The presence of
a substructure is confirmed by a dynamical study of the galaxies in this
region. A wake of stripped gas is trailing behind the group over a projected
scale of 760 kpc. The temperature of the gas along the wake is constant at kT ~
1.3 keV, which is about a factor of two less than the temperature of the
surrounding plasma. We observe a cold front pointing westwards compared to the
peak of the group, which indicates that the group is currently not moving in
the direction of the main cluster, but is moving along an almost circular
orbit. The overall morphology of the group bears remarkable similarities with
high-resolution numerical simulations of such structures, which greatly
strengthens our understanding of the ram-pressure stripping process.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.00410 [pdf] - 1359011
Measuring the dynamical state of Planck SZ-selected clusters: X-ray peak
- BCG offset
Submitted: 2015-12-01
We want to characterize the dynamical state of galaxy clusters detected with
the Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) effect by Planck and compare them with the dynamical
state of clusters selected in X-rays survey. We analyzed a representative
subsample of the Planck SZ catalogue, containing the 132 clusters with the
highest signal to noise ratio and characterize their dynamical state using as
indicator the projected offset between the peak of the X-ray emission and the
position of the Brightest cluster galaxy. We study the distribution of our
indicator in our sample and compare it to its distribution in X-ray selected
samples (HIFLUGCS, MACS and REXCESS). The distributions are significantly
different and the fraction of relaxed objects is smaller in the Planck sample
($52 \pm 4 \%$) than in X-ray samples ($\simeq 74\%$) We interpret this result
as an indication of different selection effects affecting X-rays (e.g. "cool
core bias") and SZ surveys of galaxy clusters.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.05428 [pdf] - 1347632
A critical assessment of the metal content of the ICM
Submitted: 2015-11-17
Our goal is to provide a robust estimate of the metal content of the ICM in
massive clusters. We make use of published abundance profiles for a sample of
~60 nearby systems, we include in our estimate uncertainties associated to the
measurement process and to the almost total lack of measures in cluster
outskirts. We perform a first, albeit rough, census of metals finding that the
mean abundance of the ICM within r_180 is very poorly constrained, 0.06Z_sol <
Z < 0.26Z_sol, and presents no tension with expectations. Similarly, the
question of if and how the bulk of the metal content in clusters varies with
cosmic time, is very much an open one. A solid estimate of abundances in
cluster outskirts could be achieved by combining observations of the two
experiments which will operate on board Athena, the XIFU and the WFI, provided
they do not fall victim to the de-scoping process that has afflicted several
space observatories over the last decade.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.6814 [pdf] - 1215907
Metal distribution in sloshing galaxy clusters: the case of A496
Submitted: 2014-07-25
We report results from a detailed study of the sloshing gas in the core of
A496. We detect the low temperature/entropy spiral feature found in several
cores, we also find that conduction between the gas in the spiral and the
ambient medium must be suppressed by more than one order of magnitude with
respect to Spitzer conductivity. Intriguingly, while the gas in the spiral
features a higher metal abundance than the surrounding medium, it follows the
entropy vs metal abundance relation defined by gas lying outside the spiral.
The most plausible explanation for this behavior is that the low entropy metal
rich plasma uplifted through the cluster atmosphere by sloshing, suffers little
heating or mixing with the ambient medium. While sloshing appears to be capable
of uplifting significant amounts of gas, the limited heat exchange and mixing
between gas in and outside the spiral implies that this mechanism is not at all
effective in: 1) permanently redistributing metals within the core region and
2) heating up the coolest and densest gas, thereby providing little or no
contribution to staving of catastrophic cooling in cool cores.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.5633 [pdf] - 893658
Dark matter-baryons separation at the lowest mass scale: the Bullet
Group
Gastaldello, F.;
Limousin, M.;
Foëx, G.;
Muñoz, R. P.;
Verdugo, T.;
Motta, V.;
More, A.;
Cabanac, R.;
Buote, D. A.;
Eckert, D.;
Ettori, S.;
Fritz, A.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Humphrey, P. J.;
Meneghetti, M.;
Rossetti, M.
Submitted: 2014-04-22, last modified: 2014-05-05
We report on the X-ray observation of a strong lensing selected group, SL2S
J08544-0121, with a total mass of $2.4 \pm 0.6 \times 10^{14}$ $\rm{M_\odot}$
which revealed a separation of $124\pm20$ kpc between the X-ray emitting
collisional gas and the collisionless galaxies and dark matter (DM), traced by
strong lensing. This source allows to put an order of magnitude estimate to the
upper limit to the interaction cross section of DM of 10 cm$^2$ g$^{-1}$. It is
the lowest mass object found to date showing a DM-baryons separation and it
reveals that the detection of bullet-like objects is not rare and confined to
mergers of massive objects opening the possibility of a statistical detection
of DM-baryons separation with future surveys.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.1241 [pdf] - 1171845
Metal jumps across sloshing cold fronts: the case of A496
Submitted: 2013-06-05
Cold-fronts in cool-core clusters are thought to be induced by minor mergers
and to develop through a sloshing mechanism. While temperature and
surface-brightness jumps have been detected and measured in many systems, a
detailed characterization of the metal abundance across the discontinuity is
only available for a handful of objects. Within the sloshing scenario, we
expect the central cool and metal rich gas to be displaced outwards into lower
abundance regions, thus generating a metal discontinuity across the front. We
analyzed a long (120 ksec) XMM-Newton observation of A496 to study the metal
distribution and its correlation with the cold-fronts. We find Fe
discontinuities across the two main cold-fronts located ~60 kpc NNW and ~160
kpc South of the peak and a metal excess in the South direction.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.2420 [pdf] - 1166558
Abell 2142 at large scales: An extreme case for sloshing?
Submitted: 2013-05-10, last modified: 2013-06-03
We present results obtained with a new XMM-Newton observation of A2142, a
famous textbook example of cluster with multiple cold fronts, which has been
studied in detail with Chandra but whose large scale properties are presented
here for the first time. We report the discovery of a a new cold front, the
most distant one ever detected in a galaxy cluster, at about one Mpc from the
center to the SE. Residual images, thermodynamics and metal abundance maps are
qualitatively in agreement with predictions from numerical simulations of the
sloshing phenomenon. However, the scales involved are much larger, similarly to
what recently observed in the Perseus cluster. These results show that sloshing
is a cluster-wide phenomenon, not confined in the cores, which extends well
beyond the cooling region involving a large fraction of the ICM up to almost
half of the virial radius. The absence of a cool core and a newly discovered
giant radio halo in A2142, in spite of its relaxed X-ray morphology, suggest
that large scale sloshing, or the intermediate merger which caused it, may
trigger Mpc-scale radio emission and may lead to the disruption of the cluster
cool core
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.5478 [pdf] - 1166110
Sloshing cold fronts in galaxy groups and their perturbing disk
galaxies: an X-ray, Optical and Radio Case Study
Gastaldello, F.;
Di Gesu, L.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Giacintucci, S.;
Girardi, M.;
Roediger, E.;
Rossetti, M.;
Brighenti, F.;
Buote, D. A.;
Eckert, D.;
Ettori, S.;
Humphrey, P. J.;
Mathews, W. G.
Submitted: 2013-04-19, last modified: 2013-04-22
We present a combined X-ray, optical, and radio analysis of the galaxy group
IC 1860 using the currently available Chandra and XMM data, literature
multi-object spectroscopy data and GMRT data. The Chandra and XMM imaging and
spectroscopy reveal two surface brightness discontinuities at 45 and 76 kpc
shown to be consistent with a pair of cold fronts. These features are
interpreted as due to sloshing of the central gas induced by an off-axis minor
merger with a perturber. This scenario is further supported by the presence of
a peculiar velocity of the central galaxy IC 1860 and the identification of a
possible perturber in the optically disturbed spiral galaxy IC 1859. The
identification of the perturber is consistent with the comparison with
numerical simulations of sloshing. The GMRT observation at 325 MHz shows faint,
extended radio emission contained within the inner cold front, as seen in some
galaxy clusters hosting diffuse radio mini-halos. However, unlike mini-halos,
no particle reacceleration is needed to explain the extended radio emission,
which is consistent with aged radio plasma redistributed by the sloshing. There
is strong analogy of the X-ray and optical phenomenology of the IC 1860 group
with two other groups, NGC 5044 and NGC 5846, showing cold fronts. The evidence
presented in this paper is among the strongest supporting the currently favored
model of cold-front formation in relaxed objects and establishes the group
scale as a chief environment to study this phenomenon.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.1407 [pdf] - 1092190
Gas sloshing, cold fronts, Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities and the merger
history of the cluster of galaxies Abell 496
Submitted: 2011-12-06
We investigate the origin and nature of the multiple sloshing cold fronts in
the core of Abell 496 by direct comparison between observations and dedicated
hydrodynamical simulations. Our simulations model a minor merger with a
4{\times}10^13M{\circ} subcluster crossing A496 from the south-west to the
north-north-east, passing the cluster core in the south-east at a pericentre
distance 100 to a few 100 kpc about 0.6 to 0.8 Gyr ago. The gas sloshing
triggered by the merger can reproduce almost all observed features, e.g. the
characteristic spiral-like brightness residual distribution in the cluster
centre and its asymmetry out to 500 kpc, also the positions of and contrasts
across the cold fronts. If the subcluster passes close (100 kpc) to the cluster
core, the resulting shear flows are strong enough to trigger Kelvin-Helmholtz
instabilities that in projection resemble the peculiar kinks in the cold fronts
of Abell 496. Finally, we show that sloshing does not lead to a significant
modification of the global ICM profiles but a mild oscillation around the
initial profiles.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.4563 [pdf] - 1077485
Back and forth from cool core to non-cool core: clues from radio-halos
Submitted: 2011-06-22
X-ray astronomers often divide galaxy clusters into two classes: "cool core"
(CC) and "non-cool core" (NCC) objects. The origin of this dichotomy has been
the subject of debate in recent years, between "evolutionary" models (where
clusters can evolve from CC to NCC, mainly through mergers) and "primordial"
models (where the state of the cluster is fixed "ab initio" by early mergers or
pre-heating). We found that in a well-defined sample (clusters in the GMRT
Radio halo survey with available Chandra or XMM-Newton data), none of the
objects hosting a giant radio halo can be classified as a cool core. This
result suggests that the main mechanisms which can start a large scale
synchrotron emission (most likely mergers) are the same that can destroy CC and
therefore strongly supports "evolutionary" models of the CC-NCC dichotomy.
Moreover combining the number of objects in the CC and NCC state with the
number of objects with and without a radio-halo, we estimated that the time
scale over which a NCC cluster relaxes to the CC state, should be larger than
the typical life-time of radio-halos and likely shorter than about 3 Gyr. This
suggests that NCC transform into CC more rapidly than predicted from the
cooling time, which is about 10 Gyr in NCC systems, allowing the possibility of
a cyclical evolution between the CC and NCC states.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.4183 [pdf] - 294369
A radio approach to the cool core -- non cool core dichotomy
Submitted: 2011-01-21
From the point of view of X-ray astronomers, galaxy clusters are usually
divided into two classes: "cool core"(CC) and "non-cool core" (NCC) objects.
The origin of this dichotomy has been subject of debate in recent years,
between "evolutionary" models (where clusters can evolve from CC to NCC, mainly
through mergers) and "primordial" models (where the state of the cluster is
fixed "ab initio" by early mergers or pre-heating). We found that in a
representative sample (clusters in the GMRT Radio halo survey with available
X-ray data), none of the objects hosting a giant radio halo can be classified
as a cool core. This result suggests that the main mechanisms which can produce
the ingredients to start a large scale synchrotron emission (most likely
mergers) are the same that can destroy CC and therefore strongly supports
"evolutionary" models of the CC-NCC dichotomy.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.3255 [pdf] - 249407
Apparent high metallicity in 3-4 keV galaxy clusters: the inverse
iron-bias in action in the case of the merging cluster Abell 2028
Submitted: 2010-06-16, last modified: 2010-10-28
Recent work based on a global measurement of the ICM properties find evidence
for an increase of the iron abundance in galaxy clusters with temperature
around 2-4 keV up to a value about 3 times larger than that typical of very hot
clusters. We have started a study of the metal distribution in these objects
from the sample of Baumgartner et al. (2005), aiming at resolving spatially the
metal content of the ICM. We report here on a 42ks XMM observation of the first
object of the sample, the cluster Abell 2028. The XMM observation reveals a
complex structure of the cluster over scale of 300 kpc, showing an interaction
between two sub-clusters in cometary-like configurations. At the leading edges
of the two substructures cold fronts have been detected. The core of the main
subcluster is likely hosting a cool corona. We show that a one-component fit
for this region returns a biased high metallicity. This inverse iron bias is
due to the behavior of the fitting code in shaping the Fe-L complex. In
presence of a multi-temperature structure of the ICM, the best-fit metallicity
is artificially higher when the projected spectrum is modeled with a single
temperature component and it is not related to the presence of both Fe-L and
Fe-K emission lines in the spectrum. After accounting for the bias, the overall
abundance of the cluster is consistent with the one typical of hotter, more
massive clusters. We caution the interpretation of high abundances inferred
when fitting a single thermal component to spectra derived from relatively
large apertures in 3-4 keV clusters, because the inverse iron bias can be
present. Most of the inferences trying to relate high abundances in 3-4 keV
clusters to fundamental physical processes will likely have to be revised.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.1051 [pdf] - 1025536
Cold fronts in galaxy clusters
Submitted: 2010-03-04
Cold fronts have been observed in a large number of galaxy clusters.
Understanding their nature and origin is of primary importance for the
investigation of the internal dynamics of clusters. To gain insight on the
nature of these features, we carry out a statistical investigation of their
occurrence in a sample of galaxy clusters observed with XMM-Newton and we
correlate their presence with different cluster properties. We have selected a
sample of 45 clusters starting from the B55 flux limited sample by Edge et al.
(1990) and performed a systematic search of cold fronts. We find that a large
fraction of clusters host at least one cold front. Cold fronts are easily
detected in all systems that are manifestly undergoing a merger event in the
plane of the sky while the presence of such features in the remaining clusters
is related to the presence of a steep entropy gradient, in agreement with
theoretical expectations. Assuming that cold fronts in cool core clusters are
triggered by minor merger events, we estimate a minimum of 1/3 merging events
per halo per Gyr.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0611390 [pdf] - 1233978
Cold fronts in cool core clusters
Submitted: 2006-11-13
Cold fronts have been detected both in merging and in cool core clusters,
where little or no sign of a merging event is present. A systematic search of
sharp surface brightness discontinuities performed on a sample of 62 galaxy
clusters observed with XMM-Newton shows that cold fronts are a common feature
in galaxy clusters. Indeed most (if not all) of the nearby clusters (z < 0.04)
host a cold front. Understanding the origin and the nature of a such frequent
phenomenon is clearly important. To gain insight on the nature of cold fronts
in cool core clusters we have undertaken a systematic study of all contact
discontinuities detected in our sample, measuring surface brightness,
temperature and when possible abundance profiles across the fronts. We measure
the Mach numbers for the cold fronts finding values which range from 0.2 to
0.9; we also detect a discontinuities in the metal profile of some clusters.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0611056 [pdf] - 86442
A cluster in a crowded environment: XMM-Newton and Chandra observations
of A3558
Submitted: 2006-11-02, last modified: 2006-11-03
Combining XMM-Newton and Chandra data, we have performed a detailed study of
Abell 3558. Our analysis shows that its dynamical history is more complicated
than previously thought. We have found some traits typical of cool core
clusters (surface brightness peaked at the center, peaked metal abundance
profile) and others that are more common in merging clusters, like deviations
from spherical symmetry in the thermodynamic quantities of the ICM. This last
result has been achieved with a new technique for deriving temperature maps
from images. We have also detected a cold front and, with the combined use of
XMM-Newton and Chandra, we have characterized its properties, such as the speed
and the metal abundance profile across the edge. This cold front is probably
due to the sloshing of the core, induced by the perturbation of the
gravitational potential associated with a past merger. The hydrodynamic
processes related to this perturbation have presumably produced a tail of lower
entropy, higher pressure and metal rich ICM, which extends behind the cold
front for about 500 kpc. The unique characteristics of A3558 are probably due
to the very peculiar environment in which it is located: the core of the
Shapley supercluster.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511445 [pdf] - 77803
Searching for Sharp Surface Brightness Discontinuities: a Systematic
Study of Cold Fronts in Galaxy Clusters
Submitted: 2005-11-15
We perform a systematic search of cold fronts in a sample of 62 clusters
observed with XMM-Newton with redshift ranging from 0.01 to 0.3. We detect one
or more cold fronts in 21 (34%) of our objects. A large fraction (87.5%) of
nearby clusters 0.01 < z < 0.04 host a cold front while only 20% of the distant
clusters, mostly merging clusters, do so. The absence of sharp surface
brightness discontinuites in distant cool cores is most likely a consequence of
the insufficent spatial resolution of our images. Some nearby cool core
clusters show a dislocation between the surface brightness and the pressure
peak. This implies that the cool central gas is displaced from the bottom of
the gravitational potential well and likely sloshing.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0404060 [pdf] - 63968
Radiative cooling, heating and thermal conduction in M87
Submitted: 2004-04-05
The crisis of the standard cooling flow model brought about by Chandra and
XMM-Newton observations of galaxy clusters, has led to the development of
several models which explore different heating processes in order to assess if
they can quench the cooling flow. Among the most appealing mechanisms are
thermal conduction and heating through buoyant gas deposited in the ICM by
AGNs. We combine Virgo/M87 observations of three satellites (Chandra,
XMM-Newton and Beppo-SAX) to inspect the dynamics of the ICM in the center of
the cluster. Using the spectral deprojection technique, we derive the physical
quantities describing the ICM and determine the extra-heating needed to balance
the cooling flow assuming that thermal conduction operates at a fixed fraction
of the Spitzer value. We assume that the extra-heating is due to buoyant gas
and we fit the data using the model developed by Ruszkowski and Begelman
(2002). We derive a scale radius for the model of $\sim 5$ kpc, which is
comparable with the M87 AGN jet extension, and a required luminosity of the AGN
of a $few \times 10^{42}$ erg s$^{-1}$, which is comparable to the observed AGN
luminosity. We discuss a scenario where the buoyant bubbles are filled of
relativistic particles and magnetic field responsible for the radio emission in
M87. The AGN is supposed to be intermittent and to inject populations of
buoyant bubbles through a succession of outbursts. We also study the X-ray cool
component detected in the radio lobes and suggest that it is structured in
blobs which are tied to the radio buoyant bubbles.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0304016 [pdf] - 55924
SMAUG: a new technique for the deprojection of galaxy clusters
Submitted: 2003-04-01
This paper presents a new technique for reconstructing the spatial
distributions of hydrogen, temperature and metal abundance of a galaxy cluster.
These quantities are worked out from the X-ray spectrum, modeled starting from
few analytical functions describing their spatial distributions. These
functions depend upon some parameters, determined by fitting the model to the
observed spectrum. We have implemented this technique as a new model in the
XSPEC software analysis package. We describe the details of the method, and
apply it to work out the structure of the cluster A1795. We combine the
observation of three satellites, exploiting the high spatial resolution of
Chandra for the cluster core, the wide collecting area of XMM-Newton for the
intermediate regions and the large field of view of Beppo-SAX for the outer
regions. We also test the validity and precision of our method by i) comparing
its results with those from a geometrical deprojection, ii) examining the
spectral residuals at different radii of the cluster and iii) reprojecting the
unfolded profiles and comparing them directly to the measured quantities. Our
analytical method yields the parameters defining the spatial functions directly
from the spectra. Their explicit knowledge allows a straightforward derivation
of other indirect physical quantities like the gravitating mass, as well as a
fast and easy estimate of the profiles uncertainties.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0202372 [pdf] - 47866
Status of the EPIC/MOS calibration
Ferrando, P.;
Abbey, A. F.;
Altieri, B.;
Arnaud, M.;
Bennie, P.;
Dadina, M.;
Denby, M.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Griffiths, R. G.;
La Palombara, N.;
de Luca, A.;
Lumb, D.;
Molendi, S.;
Neumann, D.;
Sauvageot, J. L.;
Saxton, R. D.;
Sembay, S.;
Tiengo, A.;
Turner, M. J. L.
Submitted: 2002-02-20
The XMM-Newton observatory has the largest collecting area flown so far for
an X-ray imaging system, resulting in a very high sensitivity over a broad
spectral range. In order to exploit fully these performances, a very accurate
calibration of the XMM-Newton instruments is required, and has led to an
extensive ground and flight calibration program. We report here on the current
status of the EPIC/MOS cameras calibrations, highlighting areas for which a
reasonably good accuracy has been achieved, and noting points where further
work is needed.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0011086 [pdf] - 39093
XMM- Newton Observation of the Coma Galaxy Cluster: The temperature
structure in the central region
Arnaud, M.;
Aghanim, N.;
Gastaud, R.;
Neumann, D. M.;
Lumb, D.;
Briel, U.;
Altieri, B.;
Ghizzardi, S.;
Mittaz, J.;
Sasseen, T. P.;
Vestrand, W. T.
Submitted: 2000-11-03
We present a temperature map and a temperature profile of the central part (r
< 20' or 1/4 virial radius) of the Coma cluster. We combined 5 overlapping
pointings made with XMM/EPIC/MOS and extracted spectra in boxes of 3.5' X 3.5'.
The temperature distribution around the two central galaxies is remarkably
homogeneous (r<10'), contrary to previous ASCA results, suggesting that the
core is actually in a relaxed state. At larger distance from the cluster center
we do see evidence for recent matter accretion. We confirm the cool area in the
direction of NGC 4921, probably due to gas stripped from an infalling group. We
find indications of a hot front in the South West, in the direction of NGC4839,
probably due to an adiabatic compression.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0001038 [pdf] - 33835
Morphological evolution of X-ray clusters using hydrodynamical
simulations
Submitted: 2000-01-04
A large set of TREESPH simulations is used to test the global morphology of
galaxy clusters and its evolution against X-ray data. A powerful method to
investigate substructures in galaxy clusters are the power ratios introduced by
Buote & Tsai. We consider three flat cosmological models: CDM,
LCDM($\Omega_\Lambda = 0.7$) and CHDM($\Omega_h = 0.2$, 1 massive $\nu$), all
normalized so to fit the observed number of clusters. For each model we built
40 clusters, using a TREESPH code, and performed a statistical comparison with
a data sample including nearby clusters observed with ROSAT PSPC instrument.
The comparison disfavors the LCDM model, as clusters appear too relaxed, while
CDM and CHDM clusters, in which a higher degree of complexity occurs, seem to
be closer to observations. A better fit of data can be expected for some
different DM mix. If DM distributions are used instead of baryons, we find
substructures more pronounced than in gas and models have a different score.
Using hydrodynamical simulations is therefore essential to our aims.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9901151 [pdf] - 104745
Global cluster morphology and its evolution: X-ray data vs CDM, LCDM and
mixed models
Submitted: 1999-01-12
The global structure of galaxy clusters and its evolution are tested within a
large set of TREESPH simulations, so to allow a fair statistical comparison
with available X-ray data. Structure tests are based on the "power ratios",
introduced by Buote & Tsai. Cosmological models considered are CDM, LCDM
(Omega_L=0.7) and CHDM (1 mass.neu., Omega_h = 0.2). All models are normalized
to provide a fair number density of clusters. For each model we run a P3M
simulation in a large box, where we select the most massive 40 clusters. Going
back to the initial redshift we run a hydro-TREESPH simulation for each of
them. In this way we perform a statistical comparison of the global morphology
of clusters, for each cosmological model, with ROSAT data, using Student
t-test, F-test and K-S test. The last test and its generalization to 2--D
distributions are also used to compare the joint distributions of 2 or 3 power
ratios. We find that, using DM distribution, instead of gas, as done by some
authors, leads to biased results, as baryons are distributed in a less
structured way than DM. We also find that the cosmological models considered
have different behaviours in these tests: LCDM has the worst performance. CDM
and our CHDM have similar scores. The general trend of power ratio
distributions is already fit by these models, but a further improvement is
expected either from a different DM mix or a non-flat CDM model.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9802302 [pdf] - 100473
Evolution of Cluster Morphology: X-ray data vs. CDM models
Submitted: 1998-02-24
We compare the evolution of morphology in X-ray cluster data and in clusters
obtained in a simulation of flat CDM, normalized to the observed cluster
abundance. We find that the evolution rate in model clusters is significantly
higher than in data clusters. The results is stricking, as our cluster data are
all just for $z \simlt 0.2$, but is not contrary to expectations, as is known
that the CDM spectrum is too flat, around the cluster scale, and therefore
induces the presence of too many substructures. The cluster simulations were
run using a TREESPH code and therefore include hydrodynamical effects. The test
we performed, which turns out to be very sensitive, starts from the so--called
power ratios introduced by Buote and Tsai, and makes use of the 2--dimensional
generalization of the Kolmogorov--Smirnov test. The discrepancy between data
and model is however directly visible through linear regression techniques and
using simpler statistical tests.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9505076 [pdf] - 363114
Phase--space Distribution of Volatile Dark Matter
Submitted: 1995-05-17
We discuss the phase--space distribution of $\mu$ neutrinos if $\tau$
neutrinos are unstable and decay into $\nu_\mu + scalar$. If this scalar is a
familon or a Majoron, in the generic case the $\nu_\mu$ background is NOT the
straightforward overlap of neutrinos of thermal and decay origins. A delay in
$\nu_\tau$ decay, due to the Pauli exclusion principle, can modify it in a
significant way. We provide the equations to calculate the $\nu_\mu$
distribution and show that, in some cases, there exists a good approximate
solution to them. However, even when such solution is not admitted, the
equations can be numerically solved following a precise pattern. We give such a
solution for a number of typical cases. If $\nu_\mu$ has a mass $\sim 2$ eV and
the see--saw argument holds, $\nu_\tau$ must be unstable and the decay into
$\nu_\mu + scalar$ is a reasonable possibility. The picture leads to a delayed
equivalence redshift, which could allow to reconcile COBE data with a bias
parameter $b\ge 1$.