Normalized to: Fraix-Burnet, D.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.12753 [pdf] - 1966909
A Maximum Parsimony analysis of the effect of the environment on the
evolution of galaxies
Submitted: 2019-07-30
Context. Galaxy evolution and the effect of environment are most often
studied using scaling relations or some regression analyses around some given
property. These approaches however do not take into account the complexity of
the physics of the galaxies and their diversification. Aims. We here
investigate the effect of cluster environment on the evolution of galaxies
through multivariate unsupervised classification and phylogenetic analyses
applied to two relatively large samples from the WINGS survey, one of cluster
members and one of field galaxies (2624 and 1476 objects respectively).
Methods. These samples are the largest ones ever analysed with a phylogenetic
approach in astrophysics. To be able to use the Maximum Parsimony (cladistics)
method, we first performed a pre-clustering in 300 clusters with a hierarchical
clustering technique, before applying it to these pre-clusters. All these
computations used seven parameters: B-V, log(Re), nV , $\mu$e , H$\beta$ ,
D4000 , log(M *). Results. We have obtained a tree for the combined samples and
do not find different evolutionary paths for cluster and field galaxies.
However, the cluster galaxies seem to have accelerated evolution in the sense
they are statistically more diversified from a primitive common ancestor. The
separate analyses show a hint for a slightly more regular evolution of the
variables for the cluster galaxies, which may indicate they are more
homogeneous as compared to field galaxies in the sense that the groups of the
latter appear to have more specific properties. On the tree for the cluster
galaxies, there is a separate branch which gathers rejunevated or stripped-off
groups of galaxies. This branch is clearly visible on the colour-magnitude
diagram, going back from the red sequence towards the blue one. On this
diagram, the distribution and the evolutionary paths of galaxies are strikingly
different for the two samples. Globally, we do not find any dominant variable
able to explain either the groups or the tree structures. Rather, co-evolution
appears everywhere, and could depend itself on environment or mass.
Conclusions. This study is another demonstration that unsupervised machine
learning is able to go beyond the simple scaling relations by taking into
account several properties together. The phylogenetic approach is invaluable to
trace the evolutionary scenarii and project them onto any biavariate diagram
without any a priori modelling. Our WINGS galaxies are all at low redshift, and
we now need to go to higher redshfits to find more primitve galaxies and
complete the map of the evolutionary paths of present day galaxies.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.02856 [pdf] - 1975176
Unsupervised Classification of Galaxies. I. ICA feature selection
Submitted: 2018-02-08, last modified: 2018-12-19
Subjective classification of galaxies can mislead us in the quest of the
origin regarding formation and evolution of galaxies since this is necessarily
limited to a few features. The human mind is not able to apprehend the complex
correlations in a manyfold parameter space, and multivariate analyses are the
best tools to understand the differences among various kinds of objects. In
this series of papers, an objective classification of 362,923 galaxies from the
Value Added Galaxy Catalogue (VAGC) is carried out with the help of two methods
of multivariate analysis. First, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) is used
to determine a set of derived independent components that are linear
combinations of 47 observed features (viz. ionized lines, Lick indices,
photometric and morphological properties, star formation rates etc.) of the
galaxies. Subsequently, a K-means cluster analysis is applied on the nine
independent components to obtain ten distinct and homogeneous groups. In this
first paper, we describe the methods and the main results. It appears that the
nine Independent Components represent a complete physical description of
galaxies (velocity dispersion, ionisation, metallicity, surface brightness and
structure). We find that our ten groups can be essentially placed into
traditional and empirical classes (from colour-magnitude and emission-line
diagnostic diagrams, early- vs late-types) despite the classical corresponding
features (colour, line ratios and morphology) being not significantly
correlated with the nine Independent Components. More detailed physical
interpretation of the groups will be performed in subsequent papers.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.03787 [pdf] - 1767512
A phylogenetic approach to chemical tagging. Reassembling open cluster
stars
Submitted: 2018-07-10
Context. The chemical tagging technique is a promising approach to
reconstruct the history of the Galaxy by only using stellar chemical
abundances. Different studies have undertaken this analysis and they raised
several challenges.
Aims. Using a sample of open clusters stars, we wish to address two issues:
minimize chemical abundance differences which origin is linked to the
evolutionary stage of the stars and not their original composition; evaluate a
phylogenetic approach to group stars based on their chemical composition.
Methods. We derived differential chemical abundances for 207 stars (belonging
to 34 open clusters) using the Sun as reference star (classical approach) and a
dwarf plus a giant star from the open cluster M67 as reference (new approach).
These abundances were then used to perform two phylogenetic analyses,
cladistics (Maximum Parsimony) and Neighbour-Joining, together with a
partitioning unsupervised classification analysis with k-means. The resulting
groupings were finally confronted to the true open cluster memberships of the
stars.
Results. We successfully reconstruct most of the original open clusters when
carefully selecting a subset of the abundances derived differentially with
respect to M67. We find a set of eight chemical elements that yields the best
result, and discuss the possible reasons for them to be good tracers of the
history of the Galaxy.
Conclusions. Our study shows that unraveling the history of the Galaxy by
only using stellar chemical abundances is greatly improved provided that i) we
perform a differential spectroscopic analysis with respect to an open cluster
instead of the Sun, ii) select the chemical elements that are good tracers of
the history of the Galaxy, and iii) use tools that are adapted to detect
evolutionary tracks such as phylogenetic approaches.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.09213 [pdf] - 1590256
Phylogenetic Analyses of Quasars and Galaxies
Submitted: 2017-10-25
Phylogenetic approaches have proven to be useful in astrophysics. We have
recently published a Maximum Parsimony (or cladistics) analysis on two samples
of 215 and 85 low-z quasars (z < 0.7) which offer a satisfactory coverage of
the Eigenvector 1-derived main sequence. Cladistics is not only able to group
sources radiating at higher Eddington ratios, to separate radio-quiet (RQ) and
radio-loud (RL) quasars and properly distinguishes core-dominated and
lobe-dominated quasars, but it suggests a black hole mass threshold for
powerful radio emission as already proposed elsewhere. An interesting
interpretation from this work is that the phylogeny of quasars may be
represented by the ontogeny of their central black hole, i.e. the increase of
the black hole mass. However these exciting results are based on a small sample
of low-z quasars, so that the work must be extended. We are here faced with two
difficulties. The first one is the current lack of a larger sample with similar
observables. The second one is the prohibitive computation time to perform a
cladistic analysis on more that about one thousand objects. We show in this
paper an experimental strategy on about 1500 galaxies to get around this
difficulty. Even if it not related to the quasar study, it is interesting by
itself and opens new pathways to generalize the quasar findings.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.00286 [pdf] - 1540208
Phylogenetic Tools in Astrophysics
Submitted: 2017-03-01
Multivariate clustering in astrophysics is a recent development justified by
the bigger and bigger surveys of the sky. The phylogenetic approach is probably
the most unexpected technique that has appeared for the unsupervised
classification of galaxies, stellar populations or globular clusters. On one
side, this is a somewhat natural way of classifying astrophysical entities
which are all evolving objects. On the other side, several conceptual and
practical difficulties arize, such as the hierarchical representation of the
astrophysical diversity, the continuous nature of the parameters, and the
adequation of the result to the usual practice for the physical interpretation.
Most of these have now been solved through the studies of limited samples of
stellar clusters and galaxies. Up to now, only the Maximum Parsimony
(cladistics) has been used since it is the simplest and most general
phylogenetic technique. Probabilistic and network approaches are obvious
extensions that should be explored in the future.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.02468 [pdf] - 1535579
The phylogeny of quasars and the ontogeny of their central black holes
Submitted: 2017-02-08
The connection between multifrequency quasar observational and physical
parameters related to accretion processes is still open to debate. In the last
20 year, Eigenvector 1-based approaches developed since the early papers by
Boroson and Green (1992) and Sulentic et al. (2000b) have been proven to be a
remarkably powerful tool to investigate this issue, and have led to the
definition of a quasar "main sequence". In this paper we perform a cladistic
analysis on two samples of 215 and 85 low-z quasars (z 0.7) which were studied
in several previous works and which offer a satisfactory coverage of the
Eigenvector 1-derived main sequence. The data encompass accurate measurements
of observational parameters which represent key aspects associated with the
structural diversity of quasars. Cladistics is able to group sources radiating
at higher Eddington ratios, as well as to separate radio-quiet (RQ) and
radio-loud (RL) quasars. The analysis suggests a black hole mass threshold for
powerful radio emission and also properly distinguishes core-dominated and
lobe-dominated quasars, in accordance with the basic tenet of RL unification
schemes. Considering that black hole mass provides a sort of "arrow of time" of
nuclear activity, a phylogenetic interpretation becomes possible if cladistic
trees are rooted on black hole mass: the ontogeny of black holes is represented
by their monotonic increase in mass. More massive radio-quiet Population B
sources at low-z become a more evolved counterpart of Population A i.e., wind
dominated sources to which the "local" Narrow-Line Seyfert 1s belong.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.01631 [pdf] - 1418073
Concepts of Classification and Taxonomy. Phylogenetic Classification
Submitted: 2016-06-06
Phylogenetic approaches to classification have been heavily developed in
biology by bioinformaticians. But these techniques have applications in other
fields, in particular in linguistics. Their main characteristics is to search
for relationships between the objects or species in study, instead of grouping
them by similarity. They are thus rather well suited for any kind of
evolutionary objects. For nearly fifteen years, astrocladistics has explored
the use of Maximum Parsimony (or cladistics) for astronomical objects like
galaxies or globular clusters. In this lesson we will learn how it works. 1 Why
phylogenetic tools in astrophysics? 1.1 History of classification The need for
classifying living organisms is very ancient, and the first classification
system can be dated back to the Greeks. The goal was very practical since it
was intended to distinguish between eatable and toxic aliments, or kind and
dangerous animals. Simple resemblance was used and has been used for centuries.
Basically, until the XVIIIth century, every naturalist chose his own criterion
to build a classification. At the end, hundreds of classifications were
available, most often incompatible to each other. The criteria for this
traditional way of classifying is the subjective appearance of the living
organisms. During the XVIIIth a revolution occurred. Scientists like Adanson
and Linn{\'e} devised new ways of classifying the objects and naming the
classes. Adanson realised that all the observable traits should be used, giving
birth to the mutivariate clustering and classification activity (Adanson,
1763). Linn{\'e} based his binomial nomenclature on neutral names unrelated
whatsoever to any property of the classes. We can realise the success of these
two ideas more than two centuries and a half later!
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.00235 [pdf] - 1416450
Clustering with phylogenetic tools in astrophysics
Submitted: 2016-06-01
Phylogenetic approaches are finding more and more applications outside the
field of biology. Astrophysics is no exception since an overwhelming amount of
multivariate data has appeared in the last twenty years or so. In particular,
the diversification of galaxies throughout the evolution of the Universe quite
naturally invokes phylogenetic approaches. We have demonstrated that Maximum
Parsimony brings useful astrophysical results, and we now proceed toward the
analyses of large datasets for galaxies. In this talk I present how we solve
the major difficulties for this goal: the choice of the parameters, their
discretization, and the analysis of a high number of objects with an
unsupervised NP-hard classification technique like cladistics. 1. Introduction
How do the galaxy form, and when? How did the galaxy evolve and transform
themselves to create the diversity we observe? What are the progenitors to
present-day galaxies? To answer these big questions, observations throughout
the Universe and the physical modelisation are obvious tools. But between
these, there is a key process, without which it would be impossible to extract
some digestible information from the complexity of these systems. This is
classification. One century ago, galaxies were discovered by Hubble. From
images obtained in the visible range of wavelengths, he synthetised his
observations through the usual process: classification. With only one parameter
(the shape) that is qualitative and determined with the eye, he found four
categories: ellipticals, spirals, barred spirals and irregulars. This is the
famous Hubble classification. He later hypothetized relationships between these
classes, building the Hubble Tuning Fork. The Hubble classification has been
refined, notably by de Vaucouleurs, and is still used as the only global
classification of galaxies. Even though the physical relationships proposed by
Hubble are not retained any more, the Hubble Tuning Fork is nearly always used
to represent the classification of the galaxy diversity under its new name the
Hubble sequence (e.g. Delgado-Serrano, 2012). Its success is impressive and can
be understood by its simplicity, even its beauty, and by the many correlations
found between the morphology of galaxies and their other properties. And one
must admit that there is no alternative up to now, even though both the Hubble
classification and diagram have been recognised to be unsatisfactory. Among the
most obvious flaws of this classification, one must mention its monovariate,
qualitative, subjective and old-fashioned nature, as well as the difficulty to
characterise the morphology of distant galaxies. The first two most significant
multivariate studies were by Watanabe et al. (1985) and Whitmore (1984). Since
the year 2005, the number of studies attempting to go beyond the Hubble
classification has increased largely. Why, despite of this, the Hubble
classification and its sequence are still alive and no alternative have yet
emerged (Sandage, 2005)? My feeling is that the results of the multivariate
analyses are not easily integrated into a one-century old practice of modeling
the observations. In addition, extragalactic objects like galaxies, stellar
clusters or stars do evolve. Astronomy now provides data on very distant
objects, raising the question of the relationships between those and our
present day nearby galaxies. Clearly, this is a phylogenetic problem.
Astrocladistics 1 aims at exploring the use of phylogenetic tools in
astrophysics (Fraix-Burnet et al., 2006a,b). We have proved that Maximum
Parsimony (or cladistics) can be applied in astrophysics and provides a new
exploration tool of the data (Fraix-Burnet et al., 2009, 2012, Cardone \&
Fraix-Burnet, 2013). As far as the classification of galaxies is concerned, a
larger number of objects must now be analysed. In this paper, I
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.06756 [pdf] - 1267442
Multivariate Approaches to Classification in Extragalactic Astronomy
Submitted: 2015-08-27
Clustering objects into synthetic groups is a natural activity of any
science. Astrophysics is not an exception and is now facing a deluge of data.
For galaxies, the one-century old Hubble classification and the Hubble tuning
fork are still largely in use, together with numerous mono-or bivariate
classifications most often made by eye. However, a classification must be
driven by the data, and sophisticated multivariate statistical tools are used
more and more often. In this paper we review these different approaches in
order to situate them in the general context of unsupervised and supervised
learning. We insist on the astrophysical outcomes of these studies to show that
multivariate analyses provide an obvious path toward a renewal of our
classification of galaxies and are invaluable tools to investigate the physics
and evolution of galaxies.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.07324 [pdf] - 1080569
Stellar populations in $\omega$ Centauri: a multivariate analysis
Submitted: 2015-05-27
We have performed multivariate statistical analyses of photometric and
chemical abundance parameters of three large samples of stars in the globular
cluster $\omega$ Centauri. The statistical analysis of a sample of 735 stars
based on seven chemical abundances with the method of Maximum Parsimony
(cladistics) yields the most promising results: seven groups are found,
distributed along three branches with distinct chemical, spatial and
kinematical properties. A progressive chemical evolution can be traced from one
group to the next, but also within groups, suggestive of an inhomogeneous
chemical enrichment of the initial interstellar matter. The adjustment of
stellar evolution models shows that the groups with metallicities
[Fe/H]\textgreater{}-1.5 are Helium-enriched, thus presumably of second
generation. The spatial concentration of the groups increases with chemical
evolution, except for two groups, which stand out in their other properties as
well. The amplitude of rotation decreases with chemical evolution, except for
two of the three metal-rich groups, which rotate fastest, as predicted by
recent hydrodynamical simulations. The properties of the groups are interpreted
in terms of star formation in gas clouds of different origins. In conclusion,
our multivariate analysis has shown that metallicity alone cannot segregate the
different populations of $\omega$ Centauri.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.3729 [pdf] - 719505
Clustering large number of extragalactic spectra of galaxies and quasars
through canopies
Submitted: 2013-09-15
Cluster analysis is the distribution of objects into different groups or more
precisely the partitioning of a data set into subsets (clusters) so that the
data in subsets share some common trait according to some distance measure.
Unlike classi cation, in clustering one has to rst decide the optimum number of
clusters and then assign the objects into different clusters. Solution of such
problems for a large number of high dimensional data points is quite
complicated and most of the existing algorithms will not perform properly. In
the present work a new clustering technique applicable to large data set has
been used to cluster the spectra of 702248 galaxies and quasars having 1540
points in wavelength range imposed by the instrument. The proposed technique
has successfully discovered ve clusters from this 702248X1540 data matrix.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.3690 [pdf] - 1124165
A six-parameter space to describe galaxy diversification
Submitted: 2012-06-16, last modified: 2012-07-04
Galaxy diversification proceeds by transforming events like accretion,
interaction or mergers. These explain the formation and evolution of galaxies
that can now be described with many observables. Multivariate analyses are the
obvious tools to tackle the datasets and understand the differences between
different kinds of objects. However, depending on the method used,
redundancies, incompatibilities or subjective choices of the parameters can
void the usefulness of such analyses. The behaviour of the available parameters
should be analysed before an objective reduction of dimensionality and
subsequent clustering analyses can be undertaken, especially in an evolutionary
context. We study a sample of 424 early-type galaxies described by 25
parameters, ten of which are Lick indices, to identify the most structuring
parameters and determine an evolutionary classification of these objects. Four
independent statistical methods are used to investigate the discriminant
properties of the observables and the partitioning of the 424 galaxies:
Principal Component Analysis, K-means cluster analysis, Minimum Contradiction
Analysis and Cladistics. (abridged)
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.6122 [pdf] - 1118322
VLTI/AMBER observations of the Seyfert nucleus of NGC 3783
Weigelt, G.;
Hofmann, K. -H.;
Kishimoto, M.;
Hönig, S.;
Schertl, D.;
Marconi, A.;
Millour, F.;
Petrov, R.;
Fraix-Burnet, D.;
Malbet, F.;
Tristram, K.;
Vannier, M.
Submitted: 2012-04-27
Context. The putative tori surrounding the accretion disks of active galactic
nuclei (AGNs) play a fundamental role in the unification scheme of AGNs.
Infrared long-baseline interferometry allows us to study the inner dust
distribution in AGNs with unprecedented spatial resolution over a wide infrared
wavelength range.
Aims. Near- and mid-infrared interferometry is used to investigate the
milli-arcsecond-scale dust distribution in the type 1.5 Seyfert nucleus of NGC
3783.
Methods. We observed NGC 3783 with the VLTI/AMBER instrument in the K-band
and compared our observations with models.
Results. From the K-band observations, we derive a ring-fit torus radius of
0.74 +/- 0.23 mas or 0.16 +/- 0.05 pc. We compare this size with infrared
interferometric observations of other AGNs and UV/optical-infrared
reverberation measurements. For the interpretation of our observations, we
simultaneously model our near- and mid-infrared visibilities and the SED with a
temperature/density-gradient model including an additional inner hot 1400 K
ring component.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.3709 [pdf] - 375541
Multivariate Evolutionary Analyses in Astrophysics
Submitted: 2011-06-19
The large amount of data on galaxies, up to higher and higher redshifts, asks
for sophisticated statistical approaches to build adequate classifications.
Multivariate cluster analyses, that compare objects for their global
similarities, are still confidential in astrophysics, probably because their
results are somewhat difficult to interpret. We believe that the missing key is
the unavoidable characteristics in our Universe: evolution. Our approach, known
as Astrocladistics, is based on the evolutionary nature of both galaxies and
their properties. It gathers objects according to their "histories" and
establishes an evolutionary scenario among groups of objects. In this
presentation, I show two recent results on globular clusters and earlytype
galaxies to illustrate how the evolutionary concepts of Astrocladistics can
also be useful for multivariate analyses such as K-means Cluster Analysis.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.3154 [pdf] - 397802
The Fundamental Plane of Early-Type Galaxies as a Confounding
Correlation
Submitted: 2011-06-16
Early-type galaxies are characterized by many scaling relations. One of them,
the so-called fundamental plane is a relatively tight correlation between three
variables, and has resisted a clear physical understanding despite many years
of intensive research. Here, we show that the correlation between the three
variables of the fundamental plane can be the artifact of the effect of another
parameter influencing all, so that the fundamental plane may be understood as a
confounding correlation. Indeed, the complexity of the physics of galaxies and
of their evolution suggests that the main confounding parameter must be related
to the level of diversification reached by the galaxies. Consequently, many
scaling relations for galaxies are probably evolutionary correlations.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.5636 [pdf] - 176508
Astrocladistics: Multivariate Evolutionary Analysis in Astrophysics
Submitted: 2010-05-31
The Hubble tuning fork diagram, based on morphology and established in the
1930s, has always been the preferred scheme for classification of galaxies.
However, the current large amount of data up to higher and higher redshifts
asks for more sophisticated statistical approaches like multivariate analyses.
Clustering analyses are still very confidential, and do not take into account
the unavoidable characteristics in our Universe: evolution. Assuming branching
evolution of galaxies as a 'transmission with modification', we have shown that
the concepts and tools of phylogenetic systematics (cladistics) can be
heuristically transposed to the case of galaxies. This approach that we call
"astrocladistics", has now successfully been applied on several samples of
galaxies and globular clusters. Maximum parsimony and distance-based approaches
are the most popular methods to produce phylogenetic trees and, like most other
studies, we had to discretize our variables. However, since astrophysical data
are intrinsically continuous, we are contributing to the growing need for
applying phylogenetic methods to continuous characters.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.5645 [pdf] - 242131
Structures in the fundamental plane of early-type galaxies
Submitted: 2010-05-31
The fundamental plane of early-type galaxies is a rather tight
three-parameter correlation discovered more than twenty years ago. It has
resisted a both global and precise physical interpretation despite a consequent
number of works, observational, theoretical or using numerical simulations. It
appears that its precise properties depend on the population of galaxies in
study. Instead of selecting a priori these populations, we propose to
objectively construct homologous populations from multivariate analyses. We
have undertaken multivariate cluster and cladistic analyses of a sample of 56
low-redshift galaxy clusters containing 699 early-type galaxies, using four
parameters: effective radius, velocity dispersion, surface brightness averaged
over effective radius, and Mg2 index. All our analyses are consistent with
seven groups that define separate regions on the global fundamental plane, not
across its thickness. In fact, each group shows its own fundamental plane,
which is more loosely defined for less diversified groups. We conclude that the
global fundamental plane is not a bent surface, but made of a collection of
several groups characterizing several fundamental planes with different
thicknesses and orientations in the parameter space. Our diversification
scenario probably indicates that the level of diversity is linked to the number
and the nature of transforming events and that the fundamental plane is the
result of several transforming events. We also show that our classification,
not the fundamental planes, is universal within our redshift range (0.007 -
0.053). We find that the three groups with the thinnest fundamental planes
presumably formed through dissipative (wet) mergers. In one of them, this(ese)
merger(s) must have been quite ancient because of the relatively low
metallicity of its galaxies, Two of these groups have subsequently undergone
dry mergers to increase their masses. In the k-space, the third one clearly
occupies the region where bulges (of lenticular or spiral galaxies) lie and
might also have formed through minor mergers and accretions. The two least
diversified groups probably did not form by major mergers and must have been
strongly affected by interactions, some of the gas in the objects of one of
these groups having possibly been swept out. The interpretation, based on
specific assembly histories of galaxies of our seven groups, shows that they
are truly homologous. They were obtained directly from several observables,
thus independently of any a priori classification. The diversification scenario
relating these groups does not depend on models or numerical simulations, but
is objectively provided by the cladistic analysis. Consequently, our
classification is more easily compared to models and numerical simulations, and
our work can be readily repeated with additional observables.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.4164 [pdf] - 28691
Galaxies and Cladistics
Submitted: 2009-09-23
The Hubble tuning fork diagram, based on morphology and established in the
1930s, has always been the preferred scheme for classification of galaxies.
However, the current large amount of multiwavelength data, most often spectra,
for objects up to very high distances, asks for more sophisticated statistical
approaches. Interpreting formation and evolution of galaxies as a ?transmission
with modification' process, we have shown that the concepts and tools of
phylogenetic systematics can be heuristically transposed to the case of
galaxies. This approach, which we call ?astrocladistics', has successfully been
applied on several samples. Many difficulties still remain, some of them being
specific to the nature of both galaxies and their diversification processes,
some others being classical in cladistics, like the pertinence of the
descriptors in conveying any useful evolutionary information.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.3458 [pdf] - 25420
The environment of formation as a second parameter for globular cluster
classification
Submitted: 2009-06-18
We perform an evolutionary multivariate analysis of a sample of 54 Galactic
globular clusters with high-quality colour-magnitude diagrams and
well-determined ages. The four parameters adopted for the analysis are:
metallicity, age, maximum temperature on the horizontal branch, and absolute V
magnitude. Our cladistic analysis breaks the sample into three novel groups. An
a posteriori kinematical analysis puts groups 1 and 2 in the halo, and group 3
in the thick disc. The halo and disc clusters separately follow a
luminosity-metallicity relation of much weaker slope than galaxies. This
property is used to propose a new criterion for distinguishing halo and disc
clusters. A comparison of the distinct properties of the two halo groups with
those of Galactic halo field stars indicates that the clusters of group 1
originated in the inner halo, while those of group 2 formed in the outer halo
of the Galaxy. The inner halo clusters were presumably initially the most
massive one, which allowed the formation of more strongly helium-enriched
second generation stars, thus explaining the presence of Cepheids and of very
hot horizontal-branch stars exclusively in this group. We thus conclude that
the "second parameter" is linked to the environment in which globular clusters
form, the inner halo favouring the formation of the most massive clusters which
subsequently become more strongly self-enriched than their counterparts of the
galactic outer halo and disc.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:0905.2481 [pdf] - 24302
Phylogenetic Applications of the Minimum Contradiction Approach on
Continuous Characters
Submitted: 2009-05-15
We describe the conditions under which a set of continuous variables or
characters can be described as an X-tree or a split network. A distance matrix
corresponds exactly to a split network or a valued X-tree if, after ordering of
the taxa, the variables values can be embedded into a function with at most a
local maxima and a local minima, and crossing any horizontal line at most
twice. In real applications, the order of the taxa best satisfying the above
conditions can be obtained using the Minimum Contradiction method. This
approach is applied to 2 sets of continuous characters. The first set
corresponds to craniofacial landmarks in Hominids. The contradiction matrix is
used to identify possible tree structures and some alternatives when they
exist. We explain how to discover the main structuring characters in a tree.
The second set consists of a sample of 100 galaxies. In that second example one
shows how to discretize the continuous variables describing physical properties
of the galaxies without disrupting the underlying tree structure.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.3475 [pdf] - 8371
Extragalactic Objects and Next Generation Interferometers
Submitted: 2007-12-20
The most obvious extragalactic targets for optical/infrared interferometers
are Active Galactic Nuclei. In this document, I try to overview other topics
that could be of interest to studies of galaxies and whether they could be
adequate for a next generation interferometer. The very high spatial resolution
would be profitable for extragalactic supernovae, globular clusters, star
forming regions, gravitational lenses and some stellar studies in very close
galaxies. However, sensitivity is the main concern since the interesting
magnitude limit would have to be of the order of 25 or more for these studies
not to remain marginal.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610936 [pdf] - 86360
Direct constraint on the distance of y2 Velorum from AMBER/VLTI
observations
Millour, F.;
Petrov, R. G.;
Chesneau, O.;
Bonneau, D.;
Dessart, L.;
Bechet, C.;
Tallon-Bosc, I.;
Tallon, M.;
Thiébaut, E.;
Vakili, F.;
Malbet, F.;
Mourard, D.;
Zins, G.;
Roussel, A.;
Robbe-Dubois, S.;
Puget, P.;
Perraut, K.;
Lisi, F.;
Coarer, E. Le;
Lagarde, S.;
Kern, P.;
Glück, L.;
Duvert, G.;
Chelli, A.;
Bresson, Y.;
Beckmann, U.;
Antonelli, P.;
Weigelt, G.;
Ventura, N.;
Vannier, M.;
Valtier, J. -C.;
Testi, L.;
Tatulli, E.;
Tasso, D.;
Stefanini, P.;
Stee, P.;
Solscheid, W.;
Schertl, D.;
Salinari, P.;
Sacchettini, M.;
Richichi, A.;
Reynaud, F.;
Rebattu, S.;
Rabbia, Y.;
Preibisch, T.;
Perrier, C.;
Pacini, F.;
Ohnaka, K.;
Nussbaum, E.;
Mouillet, D.;
Monin, J. -L.;
Mège, P.;
Mathias, P.;
Martinot-Lagarde, G.;
Mars, G.;
Marconi, A.;
Magnard, Y.;
Lopez, B.;
Contel, D. Le;
Contel, J. -M. Le;
Kraus, S.;
Kamm, D.;
Hofmann, K. -H.;
Utrera, O. Hernandez;
Heininger, M.;
Heiden, M.;
Gil, C.;
Giani, E.;
Glentzlin, A.;
Gennari, S.;
Gallardo, A.;
Fraix-Burnet, D.;
Foy, R.;
Fossat, E.;
Forveille, T.;
Ferruzzi, D.;
Feautrier, P.;
Dugué, M.;
Driebe, T.;
De Souza, A. Domiciano;
Delboulbé, A.;
Connot, C.;
Colin, J.;
Clausse, J. -M.;
Cassaing, F.;
Busoni, S.;
Bonhomme, S.;
Blöcker, T.;
Behrend, J.;
Baffa, C.;
Aristidi, E.;
Arezki, B.;
Agabi, K.;
Acke, B.;
Accardo, M.;
Kiekebusch, M.;
Rantakyrö, F.;
Schoeller, Markus
Submitted: 2006-10-31
In this work, we present the first AMBER observations, of the Wolf-Rayet and
O (WR+O) star binary system y2 Velorum. The AMBER instrument was used with the
telescopes UT2, UT3, and UT4 on baselines ranging from 46m to 85m. It delivered
spectrally dispersed visibilities, as well as differential and closure phases,
with a resolution R = 1500 in the spectral band 1.95-2.17 micron. We interpret
these data in the context of a binary system with unresolved components,
neglecting in a first approximation the wind-wind collision zone flux
contribution. We show that the AMBER observables result primarily from the
contribution of the individual components of the WR+O binary system. We discuss
several interpretations of the residuals, and speculate on the detection of an
additional continuum component, originating from the free-free emission
associated with the wind-wind collision zone (WWCZ), and contributing at most
to the observed K-band flux at the 5% level. The expected absolute separation
and position angle at the time of observations were 5.1±0.9mas and
66±15° respectively. However, we infer a separation of
3.62+0.11-0.30 mas and a position angle of 73+9-11°. Our analysis thus
implies that the binary system lies at a distance of 368+38-13 pc, in agreement
with recent spectrophotometric estimates, but significantly larger than the
Hipparcos value of 258+41-31 pc.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610190 [pdf] - 85614
Determining the evolutionary history of galaxies by astrocladistics :
some results on close galaxies
Submitted: 2006-10-06
Astrocladistics, a methodology borrowed from biology, is an objective way of
understanding galaxy diversity through evolutionary relationships. It is based
on the evolution of all the available parameters describing galaxies and thus
integrates the complexity of these objects. Through the formalization of the
concepts around galaxy formation and evolution, and the identification of the
processes of diversification (build up, secular evolution, interaction,
merging/accretion, sweeping/ejection), galaxy diversity can be expected to
organize itself in a hierarchy. About 500 galaxies described by about 40
observables have now been analysed and several robust trees found. For
instance, we show that the Dwarf Galaxies of the Local Group all derive from a
common ancestral kind of objects. We identify three evolutionary groups, each
one having its own characteristics and own evolution. The Virgo galaxies
present a relatively regular diversification, with rather few violent events
such as major mergers. Diversification in another sample made of gas-poor
galaxies in different environments appears to be slightly more complicated with
several diverging evolutionary groups. Work on a large sample of galaxies at
non-zero redshifts is in progress and is pioneering a brand new approach to
exploit data from the big extragalactic surveys.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0605221 [pdf] - 81909
Towards a Phylogenetic Analysis of Galaxy Evolution : a Case Study with
the Dwarf Galaxies of the Local Group
Submitted: 2006-05-09
Context: The Hubble tuning fork diagram has always been the preferred scheme
for classification of galaxies. It is based on morphology only. At the
opposite, biologists have long taken into account the genealogical relatedness
of living entities for classification purposes. Aims: Assuming branching
evolution of galaxies as a 'descent with modification', we show here that the
concepts and tools of phylogenetic systematics widely used in biology can be
heuristically transposed to the case of galaxies. Methods: This approach that
we call "astrocladistics" is applied to Dwarf Galaxies of the Local Group and
provides the first evolutionary tree for real galaxies. Results: The trees that
we present here are sufficiently solid to support the existence of a
hierarchical organization in the diversity of dwarf galaxies of the Local
Group. This also shows that these galaxies all derive from a common ancestral
kind of objects. We find that some kinds of dIrrs are progenitors of both dSphs
and other kinds of dIrrs.We also identify three evolutionary groups, each one
having its own characteristics and own evolution. Conclusions: The present work
opens a new way to analyze galaxy evolution and a path towards a new
systematics of galaxies. Work on other galaxies in the Universe is in progress.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602581 [pdf] - 80157
Astrocladistics: a phylogenetic analysis of galaxy evolution I.
Character evolutions and galaxy histories
Submitted: 2006-02-27
This series of papers is intended to present astrocladistics in some detail
and evaluate this methodology in reconstructing phylogenies of galaxies. Being
based on the evolution of all the characters describing galaxies, it is an
objective way of understanding galaxy diversity through evolutionary
relationships. In this first paper, we present the basic steps of a cladistic
analysis and show both theoretically and practically that it can be applied to
galaxies. For illustration, we use a sample of 50 simulated galaxies taken from
the GALICS database, which are described by 91 observables (dynamics, masses
and luminosities). These 50 simulated galaxies are indeed 10 different galaxies
taken at 5 cosmological epochs, and they are free of merger events. The
astrocladistic analysis easily reconstructs the true chronology of evolution
relationships within this sample. It also demonstrates that burst characters
are not relevant for galaxy evolution as a whole. A companion paper is devoted
to the formalization of the concepts of formation and diversification in galaxy
evolution.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602580 [pdf] - 80156
Astrocladistics: a phylogenetic analysis of galaxy evolution II.
Formation and diversification of galaxies
Submitted: 2006-02-27
This series of papers is intended to evaluate astrocladistics in
reconstructing phylogenies of galaxies. The objective of this second paper is
to formalize the concept of galaxy formation and to identify the processes of
diversification. We show that galaxy diversity can be expected to organize
itself in a hierarchy. In order to better understand the role of mergers, we
have selected a sample of 43 galaxies from the GALICS database built from
simulations with a hybrid model for galaxy formation studies. These simulated
galaxies, described by 119 characters and considered as representing still
undefined classes, have experienced different numbers of merger events during
evolution. Our cladistic analysis yields a robust tree that proves the
existence of a hierarchy. Mergers, like interactions (not taken into account in
the GALICS simulations), are probably a strong driver for galaxy
diversification. Our result shows that mergers participate in a branching type
of evolution, but do not seem to play the role of an evolutionary clock.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0509208 [pdf] - 1456440
First AMBER/VLTI observations of hot massive stars
Petrov, R. G.;
Millour, F.;
Chesneau, O.;
Weigelt, G.;
Bonneau, D.;
Stee, Ph.;
Kraus, S.;
Mourard, D.;
Meilland, A.;
Malbet, F.;
Lisi, F.;
Kern, P.;
Beckmann, U.;
Lagarde, S.;
Gennari, S.;
Lecoarer, E.;
Driebe, Th.;
Accardo, M.;
Robbe-Dubois, S.;
Ohnaka, K.;
Busoni, S.;
Roussel, A.;
Zins, G.;
Behrend, J.;
Ferruzi, D.;
Bresson, Y.;
Duvert, G.;
Nussbaum, E.;
Marconi, A.;
Feautrier, Ph.;
Dugué, M.;
Chelli, A.;
Tatulli, E.;
Heininger, M.;
Delboulbé, A.;
Bonhomme, S.;
Schertl, D.;
Testi, L.;
Mathias, Ph.;
Monin, J. -L.;
Gluck, L.;
Hofmann, K. H.;
Salinari, P.;
Puget, P.;
Clausse, J. -M.;
Fraix-Burnet, D.;
Foy, R.;
Isella, A.
Submitted: 2005-09-08
AMBER is the first near infrared focal instrument of the VLTI. It combines
three telescopes and produces spectrally resolved interferometric measures.
This paper discusses some preliminary results of the first scientific
observations of AMBER with three Unit Telescopes at medium (1500) and high
(12000) spectral resolution. We derive a first set of constraints on the
structure of the circumstellar material around the Wolf Rayet Gamma2 Velorum
and the LBV Eta Carinae.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0406512 [pdf] - 1348142
First phylogenetic analyses of galaxy evolution
Submitted: 2004-06-23, last modified: 2005-01-03
The Hubble tuning fork diagram, based on morphology, has always been the
preferred scheme for classification of galaxies and is still the only one
originally built from historical/evolutionary relationships. At the opposite,
biologists have long taken into account the parenthood links of living entities
for classification purposes. Assuming branching evolution of galaxies as a
"descent with modification", we show that the concepts and tools of
phylogenetic systematics widely used in biology can be heuristically transposed
to the case of galaxies. This approach that we call "astrocladistics" has been
first applied to Dwarf Galaxies of the Local Group and provides the first
evolutionary galaxy tree. The cladogram is sufficiently solid to support the
existence of a hierarchical organization in the diversity of galaxies, making
it possible to track ancestral types of galaxies. We also find that morphology
is a summary of more fundamental properties. Astrocladistics applied to
cosmology simulated galaxies can, unsurprisingly, reconstruct the correct
"genealogy". It reveals evolutionary lineages, divergences from common
ancestors, character evolution behaviours and shows how mergers organize galaxy
diversity. Application to real normal galaxies is in progress. Astrocladistics
opens a new way to analyse galaxy evolution and a path towards a new
systematics of galaxies.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0303410 [pdf] - 55649
What can biologists say about galaxy evolution ?
Submitted: 2003-03-18
It is possible to borrow from a topic of biology called phylogenetic
systematics, concepts and tools for a logical and objective classification of
galaxies. It is based on observable properties of objects - characters - either
qualitative (like morphology) or quantitative (like luminosity, mass or
spectrum). Distance analysis can readily be performed using a method called
phenetics and based on characters. But the most promising approach is
cladistics. It makes use of characters that can exist in at least two states,
one being ancestral and the other one derived. Objects are gathered depending
on the derived states they share. We illustrate a first application of this
method to astrophysics, that we name astrocladistics, with dwarf galaxies from
the Local Group.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0201174 [pdf] - 1468356
Linear polarization and composition of VLBI jets
Submitted: 2002-01-11
It is shown that linear polarization data can be used to constrain the
composition (normal or pair plasma) of pc-scale extragalactic jets.
A simple criterion, based on synchrotron and Faraday depolarization
properties, is established. It does not depend on the particle density and the
length of the emitting region along the line of sight, thus eliminating two
physical unknowns.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9610259 [pdf] - 1234816
An optical counterjet in 3C66B?
Submitted: 1996-10-31
Long exposure observations at the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope of 3C66B in
the I filter are presented. After subtraction of the galactic background,
optical emission on the counterjet side is detected in 10 knots coincident with
the radio counterjet. Their radio-to-optical spectral indices (0.5--0.6) are
typical of synchrotron emission in extragalactic jets, so that these knots
possibly are the optical counterparts of the radio counterjet. If this is
confirmed, 3C66B would be the first double-sided extragalactic optical jet. The
optical counterjet would also be brighter than what is predicted from the
relativistic beaming interpretation of brightness asymmetry between the two
jets. This would thus prove that the radiation properties are intrinsically
different in the two jets. Alternatively, these knots could have nothing to do
with the counterjet. But it seems that in this case, the optical counterjet
would be fainter than expected from the relativistic beaming interpretation,
favouring intrinsic asymmetry as well. In addition, two new optical components
are found in the jet.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9610260 [pdf] - 95784
Two-fluid model for VLBI jets. I. Homogeneous and stationary synchrotron
emission simulations
Submitted: 1996-10-31
In this series of papers, we develop a two-fluid model for VLBI jets. The
idea is that the jet itself is non- or mildly-relativistic (electrons and
protons), while the radiating blobs are relativistic electron-positron `clouds'
moving on helical paths wrapped around the jet. In this work, the emphasis is
on the physical description of the clouds, and not on the structure or origin
of the trajectory. In the simple case where the magnetic field is uniform and
homogeneous accross the cloud, and the properties of the cloud are constant,
the present paper shows synthetic maps of VLBI jets in different
configurations, as well as the variation of different observational parameters
along the trajectory.