Normalized to: Fournier, D.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.00402 [pdf] - 1795796
Signal and noise in helioseismic holography
Submitted: 2018-09-30
Helioseismic holography is an imaging technique used to study heterogeneities
and flows in the solar interior from observations of solar oscillations at the
surface. Holograms contain noise due to the stochastic nature of solar
oscillations. We provide a theoretical framework for modeling signal and noise
in Porter-Bojarski helioseismic holography. The wave equation may be recast
into a Helmholtz-like equation, so as to connect with the acoustics literature
and define the holography Green's function in a meaningful way. Sources of wave
excitation are assumed to be stationary, horizontally homogeneous, and
spatially uncorrelated. Using the first Born approximation we calculate
holograms in the presence of perturbations in sound-speed, density, flows, and
source covariance, as well as the noise level as a function of position. This
work is a direct extension of the methods used in time-distance helioseismology
to model signal and noise. To illustrate the theory, we compute the hologram
intensity numerically for a buried sound-speed perturbation at different depths
in the solar interior. The reference Green's function is obtained for a
spherically-symmetric solar model using a finite-element solver in the
frequency domain. Below the pupil area on the surface, we find that the spatial
resolution of the hologram intensity is very close to half the local
wavelength. For a sound-speed perturbation of size comparable to the local
spatial resolution, the signal-to-noise ratio is approximately constant with
depth. Averaging the hologram intensity over a number $N$ of frequencies above
3 mHz increases the signal-to-noise ratio by a factor nearly equal to the
square root of $N$. This may not be the case at lower frequencies, where large
variations in the holographic signal are due to the individual contributions of
the long-lived modes of oscillation.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.06141 [pdf] - 1747918
Sensitivity kernels for time-distance helioseismology: efficient
computation for spherically-symmetric solar models
Submitted: 2018-05-16
The interpretation of helioseismic measurements, such as wave travel-time, is
based on the computation of kernels that give the sensitivity of the
measurements to localized changes in the solar interior. These are computed
using the ray or the Born approximation. The Born approximation is preferable
as it takes finite-wavelength effects into account, but can be computationally
expensive. We propose a fast algorithm to compute travel-time sensitivity
kernels under the assumption that the background solar medium is spherically
symmetric. Kernels are typically expressed as products of Green's functions
that depend upon depth, latitude and longitude. Here, we compute the spherical
harmonic decomposition of the kernels and show that the integrals in latitude
and longitude can be performed analytically. In particular, the integrals of
the product of three associated Legendre polynomials can be computed thanks to
the algorithm of Dong and Lemus (2002). The computations are fast and accurate
and only require the knowledge of the Green's function where the source is at
the pole. The computation time is reduced by two orders of magnitude compared
to other recent computational frameworks. This new method allows for flexible
and computationally efficient calculations of a large number of kernels,
required in addressing key helioseismic problems. For example, the computation
of all the kernels required for meridional flow inversion takes less than two
hours on 100 cores.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.02311 [pdf] - 1661876
Comparison of Travel-Time and Amplitude Measurements for Deep-Focusing
Time--Distance Helioseismology
Submitted: 2018-03-22
The purpose of deep-focusing time--distance helioseismology is to construct
seismic measurements that have a high sensitivity to the physical conditions at
a desired target point in the solar interior. With this technique, pairs of
points on the solar surface are chosen such that acoustic ray paths intersect
at this target (focus) point. Considering acoustic waves in a homogeneous
medium, we compare travel-time and amplitude measurements extracted from the
deep-focusing cross-covariance functions. Using a single-scattering
approximation, we find that the spatial sensitivity of deep-focusing travel
times to sound-speed perturbations is zero at the target location and maximum
in a surrounding shell. This is unlike the deep-focusing amplitude
measurements, which have maximum sensitivity at the target point. We compare
the signal-to-noise ratio for travel-time and amplitude measurements for
different types of sound-speed perturbations, under the assumption that noise
is solely due to the random excitation of the waves. We find that, for highly
localized perturbations in sound speed, the signal-to-noise ratio is higher for
amplitude measurements than for travel-time measurements. We conclude that
amplitude measurements are a useful complement to travel-time measurements in
time--distance helioseismology.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.02156 [pdf] - 1602621
Atmospheric radiation boundary conditions for high frequency waves in
time-distance helioseismology
Submitted: 2017-09-07
The temporal covariance between seismic waves measured at two locations on
the solar surface is the fundamental observable in time-distance
helioseismology. Above the acoustic cut-off frequency ($\sim$5.3~mHz), waves
are not trapped in the solar interior and the covariance function can be used
to probe the upper atmosphere. We wish to implement appropriate radiative
boundary conditions for computing the propagation of high-frequency waves in
the solar atmosphere. We consider the radiative boundary conditions recently
developed by Barucq et al. (2017) for atmospheres in which sound-speed is
constant and density decreases exponentially with radius. We compute the
cross-covariance function using a finite element method in spherical geometry
and in the frequency domain. The ratio between first- and second-skip
amplitudes in the time-distance diagram is used as a diagnostic to compare
boundary conditions and to compare with observations. We find that a boundary
condition applied 500 km above the photosphere and derived under the
approximation of small angles of incidence accurately reproduces the `infinite
atmosphere' solution for high-frequency waves. When the radiative boundary
condition is applied 2 Mm above the photosphere, we find that the choice of
atmospheric model affects the time-distance diagram. In particular, the
time-distance diagram exhibits double-ridge structure when using a VAL
atmospheric model.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.08566 [pdf] - 1586421
Problems in computational helioseismology
Submitted: 2017-07-25
We discuss current advances in forward and inverse modeling for local
helioseismology. We report theoretical uniqueness results, in particular the
Novikov-Agaltsov reconstruction algorithm, which is relevant to solving the
non-linear inverse problem of time-distance helioseismology (finite amplitude
pertubations to the medium). Numerical experiments were conducted to determine
the number of frequencies required to reconstruct density and sound speed in
the solar interior.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.08991 [pdf] - 1542868
The amplitude of the cross-covariance function of solar oscillations as
a diagnostic tool for wave attenuation and geometrical spreading
Submitted: 2016-12-28
Context. In time-distance helioseismology, wave travel times are measured
from the two-point cross-covariance function of solar oscillations and are used
to image the solar convection zone in three dimensions. There is, however, also
information in the amplitude of the cross-covariance function, for example
about seismic wave attenuation. Aims. Here we develop a convenient procedure to
measure the amplitude of the cross-covariance function of solar oscillations.
Methods. In this procedure, the amplitude of the cross-covariance function is
linearly related to the cross-covariance function and can be measured even for
high levels of noise. Results. As an example application, we measure the
amplitude perturbations of the seismic waves that propagate through the sunspot
in active region NOAA 9787. We can recover the amplitude variations due to the
scattering and attenuation of the waves by the sunspot and associated
finite-wavelength effects. Conclusions. The proposed definition of
cross-covariance amplitude is robust to noise, can be used to relate measured
amplitudes to 3D perturbations in the solar interior under the Born
approximation, and will provide independent information from the travel times.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.01666 [pdf] - 1553924
Computational helioseismology in the frequency domain: acoustic waves in
axisymmetric solar models with flows
Gizon, Laurent;
Barucq, Hélène;
Duruflé, Marc;
Hanson, Chris S.;
Leguèbe, Michael;
Birch, Aaron C.;
Chabassier, Juliette;
Fournier, Damien;
Hohage, Thorsten;
Papini, Emanuele
Submitted: 2016-11-05
Local helioseismology has so far relied on semi-analytical methods to compute
the spatial sensitivity of wave travel times to perturbations in the solar
interior. These methods are cumbersome and lack flexibility. Here we propose a
convenient framework for numerically solving the forward problem of
time-distance helioseismology in the frequency domain. The fundamental quantity
to be computed is the cross-covariance of the seismic wavefield. We choose
sources of wave excitation that enable us to relate the cross-covariance of the
oscillations to the Green's function in a straightforward manner. We illustrate
the method by considering the 3D acoustic wave equation in an axisymmetric
reference solar model, ignoring the effects of gravity on the waves. The
symmetry of the background model around the rotation axis implies that the
Green's function can be written as a sum of longitudinal Fourier modes, leading
to a set of independent 2D problems. We use a high-order finite-element method
to solve the 2D wave equation in frequency space. The computation is
`embarrassingly parallel', with each frequency and each azimuthal order solved
independently on a computer cluster. We compute travel-time sensitivity kernels
in spherical geometry for flows, sound speed, and density perturbations under
the first Born approximation. Convergence tests show that travel times can be
computed with a numerical precision better than one millisecond, as required by
the most precise travel-time measurements. The method presented here is
computationally efficient and will be used to interpret travel-time
measurements in order to infer, e.g., the large-scale meridional flow in the
solar convection zone. It allows the implementation of (full-waveform)
iterative inversions, whereby the axisymmetric background model is updated at
each iteration.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.5335 [pdf] - 862974
Generalization of the noise model for time-distance helioseismology
Submitted: 2014-06-20
In time-distance helioseismology, information about the solar interior is
encoded in measurements of travel times between pairs of points on the solar
surface. Travel times are deduced from the cross-covariance of the random wave
field. Here we consider travel times and also products of travel times as
observables. They contain information about e.g. the statistical properties of
convection in the Sun. The basic assumption of the model is that noise is the
result of the stochastic excitation of solar waves, a random process which is
stationary and Gaussian. We generalize the existing noise model (Gizon and
Birch 2004) by dropping the assumption of horizontal spatial homogeneity. Using
a recurrence relation, we calculate the noise covariance matrices for the
moments of order 4, 6, and 8 of the observed wave field, for the moments of
order 2, 3 and 4 of the cross-covariance, and for the moments of order 2, 3 and
4 of the travel times. All noise covariance matrices depend only on the
expectation value of the cross-covariance of the observed wave field. For
products of travel times, the noise covariance matrix consists of three terms
proportional to $1/T$, $1/T^2$, and $1/T^3$, where $T$ is the duration of the
observations. For typical observation times of a few hours, the term
proportional to $1/T^2$ dominates and $Cov[\tau_1 \tau_2, \tau_3 \tau_4]
\approx Cov[\tau_1, \tau_3] Cov[\tau_2, \tau_4] + Cov[\tau_1, \tau_4]
Cov[\tau_2, \tau_3]$, where the $\tau_i$ are arbitrary travel times. This
result is confirmed for $p_1$ travel times by Monte Carlo simulations and
comparisons with SDO/HMI observations. General and accurate formulae have been
derived to model the noise covariance matrix of helioseismic travel times and
products of travel times. These results could easily be generalized to other
methods of local helioseismology, such as helioseismic holography and ring
diagram analysis.