Normalized to: Foglizzo, T.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.06966 [pdf] - 2057705
Acoustic wave generation in collapsing massive stars with convective
shells
Submitted: 2019-07-16, last modified: 2020-02-21
The convection that takes place in the innermost shells of massive stars
plays an important role in the formation of core-collapse supernova explosions.
Upon encountering the supernova shock, additional turbulence is generated,
amplifying the explosion. In this work, we study how the convective
perturbations evolve during the stellar collapse. Our main aim is to establish
their physical properties right before they reach the supernova shock. To this
end, we solve the linearized hydrodynamics equations perturbed on a stationary
background flow. The latter is approximated by the spherical transonic Bondi
accretion, while the convective perturbations are modeled as a combination of
entropy and vorticity waves. We follow their evolution from large radii, where
convective shells are initially located, down to small radii, where they are
expected to encounter the accretion shock above the proto-neutron star.
Considering typical vorticity perturbations with a Mach number $\sim 0.1$ and
entropy perturbations with magnitude $\sim 0.05 k_\mathrm{b}/\mathrm{baryon}$,
we find that the advection of these perturbations down to the shock generates
acoustic waves with a relative amplitude $\delta p/\gamma p \lesssim 10\%$, in
agreement with published numerical simulations. The velocity perturbations
consist of contributions from acoustic and vorticity waves with values reaching
$\sim 10\%$ of the sound speed ahead of the shock. The perturbation amplitudes
decrease with increasing $\ell$ and initial radii of the convective shells.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.08125 [pdf] - 1717018
The non-linear onset of neutrino-driven convection in two and
three-dimensional core-collapse supernovae
Submitted: 2018-02-22, last modified: 2018-06-29
A toy model of the post-shock region of core-collapse supernovae is used to
study the non-linear development of turbulent motions driven by convection in
the presence of advection. Our numerical simulations indicate that buoyant
perturbations of density are able to trigger self-sustained convection only
when the instability is not linearly stabilized by advection. Large amplitude
perturbations produced by strong shock oscillations or combustion
inhomogeneities before the collapse of the progenitor are efficiently shredded
through phase mixing and generate a turbulent cascade. Our model enables us to
investigate several physical arguments that had been proposed to explain the
impact of the dimensionality on the onset of explosions in global simulations
of core-collapse supernovae. Three-dimensional (3D) simulations are found to
lead to higher entropy values than two-dimensional (2D) ones. We attribute this
to greater turbulent mixing and dissipation of the kinetic energy into heat in
3D. Our results show that the increase of entropy is enhanced with finer
numerical resolution and larger perturbation amplitude.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.07029 [pdf] - 1581260
Are pulsars spun up or down by SASI spiral modes?
Submitted: 2017-01-24, last modified: 2017-06-29
Pulsars may either be spun up or down by hydrodynamic instabilities during
the supernova explosion of massive stars. Besides rapidly-rotating cases
related to bipolar explosions, stellar rotation may affect the explosion of
massive stars in the more common situations where the centrifugal force is
minor. Using 2D simulations of a simplified setup in cylindrical geometry, we
examine the impact of rotation on the Standing Accretion Shock Instability
(SASI) and the corotation instability, also known as low-T/|W|. The influence
of rotation on the saturation amplitude of these instabilities depends on the
specific angular momentum in the accretion flow and the ratio of the shock to
the neutron star radii. The spiral mode of SASI becomes more vigorous with
faster rotation only if this ratio is large enough. A corotation instability
develops at large rotation rates and impacts the dynamics more dramatically,
leading to a strong one-armed spiral wave. Non-axisymmetric instabilities are
able to redistribute angular momentum radially and affect the pulsar spin at
birth. A systematic study of the relationship between the core rotation period
of the progenitor and the initial pulsar spin is performed. Stellar rotation
rates for which pulsars are spun up or down by SASI are estimated. Rapidly
spinning progenitors are modestly spun down by spiral modes, less than $\sim
30\%$, when a corotation instability develops. Given the observational
constraints on pulsar spin periods at birth, this suggests that rapid rotation
might not play a significant hydrodynamic role in most core-collapse
supernovae.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.06892 [pdf] - 1500539
The Deep and Transient Universe in the SVOM Era: New Challenges and
Opportunities - Scientific prospects of the SVOM mission
Wei, J.;
Cordier, B.;
Antier, S.;
Antilogus, P.;
Atteia, J. -L.;
Bajat, A.;
Basa, S.;
Beckmann, V.;
Bernardini, M. G.;
Boissier, S.;
Bouchet, L.;
Burwitz, V.;
Claret, A.;
Dai, Z. -G.;
Daigne, F.;
Deng, J.;
Dornic, D.;
Feng, H.;
Foglizzo, T.;
Gao, H.;
Gehrels, N.;
Godet, O.;
Goldwurm, A.;
Gonzalez, F.;
Gosset, L.;
Götz, D.;
Gouiffes, C.;
Grise, F.;
Gros, A.;
Guilet, J.;
Han, X.;
Huang, M.;
Huang, Y. -F.;
Jouret, M.;
Klotz, A.;
La Marle, O.;
Lachaud, C.;
Floch, E. Le;
Lee, W.;
Leroy, N.;
Li, L. -X.;
Li, S. C.;
Li, Z.;
Liang, E. -W.;
Lyu, H.;
Mercier, K.;
Migliori, G.;
Mochkovitch, R.;
O'Brien, P.;
Osborne, J.;
Paul, J.;
Perinati, E.;
Petitjean, P.;
Piron, F.;
Qiu, Y.;
Rau, A.;
Rodriguez, J.;
Schanne, S.;
Tanvir, N.;
Vangioni, E.;
Vergani, S.;
Wang, F. -Y.;
Wang, J.;
Wang, X. -G.;
Wang, X. -Y.;
Watson, A.;
Webb, N.;
Wei, J. J.;
Willingale, R.;
Wu, C.;
Wu, X. -F.;
Xin, L. -P.;
Xu, D.;
Yu, S.;
Yu, W. -F.;
Yu, Y. -W.;
Zhang, B.;
Zhang, S. -N.;
Zhang, Y.;
Zhou, X. L.
Submitted: 2016-10-21
To take advantage of the astrophysical potential of Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs),
Chinese and French astrophysicists have engaged the SVOM mission (Space-based
multi-band astronomical Variable Objects Monitor). Major advances in GRB
studies resulting from the synergy between space and ground observations, the
SVOM mission implements space and ground instrumentation. The scientific
objectives of the mission put a special emphasis on two categories of GRBs:
very distant GRBs at z$>$5 which constitute exceptional cosmological probes,
and faint/soft nearby GRBs which allow probing the nature of the progenitors
and the physics at work in the explosion. These goals have a major impact on
the design of the mission: the on-board hard X-ray imager is sensitive down to
4 keV and computes on line image and rate triggers, and the follow-up
telescopes on the ground are sensitive in the NIR. At the beginning of the next
decade, SVOM will be the main provider of GRB positions and spectral parameters
on very short time scale. The SVOM instruments will operate simultaneously with
a wide range of powerful astronomical devices. This rare instrumental
conjunction, combined with the relevance of the scientific topics connected
with GRB studies, warrants a remarkable scientific return for SVOM. In
addition, the SVOM instrumentation, primarily designed for GRB studies,
composes a unique multi-wavelength observatory with rapid slew capability that
will find multiple applications for the whole astronomy community beyond the
specific objectives linked to GRBs. This report lists the scientific themes
that will benefit from observations made with SVOM, whether they are specific
GRB topics, or more generally all the issues that can take advantage of the
multi-wavelength capabilities of SVOM.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.02828 [pdf] - 1309575
New insights on the spin-up of a neutron star during core-collapse
Submitted: 2015-09-08, last modified: 2015-11-11
The spin of a neutron star at birth may be impacted by the asymmetric
character of the explosion of its massive progenitor. During the first second
after bounce, the spiral mode of the Standing Accretion Shock Instability
(SASI) is able to redistribute angular momentum and spin-up a neutron star born
from a non-rotating progenitor. Our aim is to assess the robustness of this
process. We perform 2D numerical simulations of a simplified setup in
cylindrical geometry to investigate the timescale over which the dynamics is
dominated by a spiral or a sloshing mode. We observe that the spiral mode
prevails only if the ratio of the initial shock radius to the neutron star
radius exceeds a critical value. In that regime, both the degree of asymmetry
and the average expansion of the shock induced by the spiral mode increase
monotonously with this ratio, exceeding the values obtained when a sloshing
mode is artificially imposed. With a timescale of 2-3 SASI oscillations, the
dynamics of SASI takes place fast enough to affect the spin of the neutron star
before the explosion. The spin periods deduced from the simulations are
compared favorably to analytical estimates evaluated from the measured
saturation amplitude of the SASI wave. Despite the simplicity of our setup,
numerical simulations revealed unexpected stochastic variations, including a
reversal of the direction of rotation of the shock. Our results show that the
spin up of neutron stars by SASI spiral modes is a viable mechanism even though
it is not systematic.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.01334 [pdf] - 1223893
The explosion mechanism of core-collapse supernovae: progress in
supernova theory and experiments
Foglizzo, Thierry;
Kazeroni, Rémi;
Guilet, Jérôme;
Masset, Frédéric;
González, Matthias;
Krueger, Brendan K.;
Novak, Jérôme;
Oertel, Micaela;
Margueron, Jérôme;
Faure, Julien;
Martin, Noël;
Blottiau, Patrick;
Peres, Bruno;
Durand, Gilles
Submitted: 2015-01-06, last modified: 2015-02-06
The explosion of core-collapse supernova depends on a sequence of events
taking place in less than a second in a region of a few hundred kilometers at
the center of a supergiant star, after the stellar core approaches the
Chandrasekhar mass and collapses into a proto-neutron star, and before a shock
wave is launched across the stellar envelope. Theoretical efforts to understand
stellar death focus on the mechanism which transforms the collapse into an
explosion. Progress in understanding this mechanism is reviewed with particular
attention to its asymmetric character. We highlight a series of successful
studies connecting observations of supernova remnants and pulsars properties to
the theory of core-collapse using numerical simulations. The encouraging
results from first principles models in axisymmetric simulations is tempered by
new puzzles in 3D. The diversity of explosion paths and the dependence on the
pre-collapse stellar structure is stressed, as well as the need to gain a
better understanding of hydrodynamical and MHD instabilities such as SASI and
neutrino-driven convection. The shallow water analogy of shock dynamics is
presented as a comparative system where buoyancy effects are absent. This
dynamical system can be studied numerically and also experimentally with a
water fountain. The potential of this complementary research tool for supernova
theory is analyzed. We also review its potential for public outreach in science
museums.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.0469 [pdf] - 1179645
Characterizing SASI- and Convection-Dominated Core-Collapse Supernova
Explosions in Two Dimensions
Submitted: 2013-10-01, last modified: 2014-02-28
The success of the neutrino mechanism of core-collapse supernovae relies on
the supporting action of two hydrodynamic instabilities: neutrino-driven
convection and the Standing Accretion Shock Instability (SASI). Depending on
the structure of the stellar progenitor, each of these instabilities can
dominate the evolution of the gain region prior to the onset of explosion, with
implications for the ensuing asymmetries. Here we examine the flow dynamics in
the neighborhood of explosion by means of parametric two-dimensional,
time-dependent hydrodynamic simulations for which the linear stability
properties are well understood. We find that systems for which the convection
parameter is sub-critical (SASI-dominated) develop explosions once large-scale,
high-entropy bubbles are able to survive for several SASI oscillation cycles.
These long-lived structures are seeded by the SASI during shock expansions.
Finite-amplitude initial perturbations do not alter this outcome qualitatively,
though they can lead to significant differences in explosion times.
Supercritical systems (convection-dominated) also explode by developing
large-scale bubbles, though the formation of these structures is due to buoyant
activity. Non-exploding systems achieve a quasi-steady state in which the
time-averaged flow adjusts itself to be convectively sub-critical. We
characterize the turbulent flow using a spherical Fourier-Bessel decomposition,
identifying the relevant scalings and connecting temporal and spatial
components. Finally, we verify the applicability of these principles on the
general relativistic, radiation-hydrodynamic simulations of Mueller, Janka, &
Heger (2012), and discuss implications for the three-dimensional case.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.3448 [pdf] - 469885
A Shallow Water Analogue of the Standing Accretion Shock Instability:
Experimental Demonstration and Two-Dimensional Model
Submitted: 2011-12-15
Despite the sphericity of the collapsing stellar core, the birth conditions
of neutron stars can be highly non spherical due to a hydrodynamical
instability of the shocked accretion flow. Here we report the first laboratory
experiment of a shallow water analogue, based on the physics of hydraulic
jumps. Both the experiment and its shallow water modeling demonstrate a robust
linear instability and nonlinear properties of symmetry breaking, in a system
which is one million times smaller and about hundred times slower than its
astrophysical analogue.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.1427 [pdf] - 1092202
On the linear growth mechanism driving the stationary accretion shock
instability
Submitted: 2011-12-06
During stellar core collapse, which eventually leads to a supernovae
explosion, the stalled shock is unstable due to the standing accretion shock
instability (SASI). This instability induces large-scale non spherical
oscillations of the shock, which have crucial consequences on the dynamics and
the geometry of the explosion. While the existence of this instability has been
firmly established, its physical origin remains somewhat uncertain. Two
mechanisms have indeed been proposed to explain its linear growth. The first is
an advective-acoustic cycle, where the instability results from the interplay
between advected perturbations (entropy and vorticity) and an acoustic wave.
The second mechanism is purely acoustic and assumes that the shock is able to
amplify trapped acoustic waves. Several arguments favouring the
advective-acoustic cycle have already been proposed, however none was entirely
conclusive for realistic flow parameters. In this article we give two new
arguments which unambiguously show that the instability is not purely acoustic,
and should be attributed to the advective-acoustic cycle. First, we extract a
radial propagation timescale by comparing the frequencies of several unstable
harmonics that differ only by their radial structure. The extracted time
matches the advective-acoustic time but strongly disagrees with a purely
acoustic interpretation. Second, we present a method to compute purely acoustic
modes, by artificially removing advected perturbations below the shock. All
these purely acoustic modes are found to be stable, showing that the advected
wave is essential to the instability mechanism.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.4697 [pdf] - 1033294
Dynamics of an Alfven surface in core collapse supernovae
Submitted: 2010-06-24, last modified: 2011-01-07
We investigate the dynamics of an Alfven surface (where the Alfven speed
equals the advection velocity) in the context of core collapse supernovae
during the phase of accretion on the proto-neutron star. Such a surface should
exist even for weak magnetic fields because the advection velocity decreases to
zero at the center of the collapsing core. In this decelerated flow, Alfven
waves created by the standing accretion shock instability (SASI) or convection
accumulate and amplify while approaching the Alfven surface. We study this
amplification using one dimensional MHD simulations with explicit physical
dissipation. In the linear regime, the amplification continues until the Alfven
wavelength becomes as small as the dissipative scale. A pressure feedback that
increases the pressure in the upstream flow is created via a non linear
coupling. We derive analytic formulae for the maximum amplification and the non
linear coupling and check them with numerical simulations to a very good
accuracy. We also characterize the non linear saturation of this amplification
when compression effects become important, leading to either a change of the
velocity gradient, or a steepening of the Alfven wave. Applying these results
to core collapse supernovae shows that the amplification can be fast enough to
affect the dynamics, if the magnetic field is strong enough for the Alfven
surface to lie in the region of strong velocity gradient just above the
neutrinosphere. This requires the presence of a strong magnetic field in the
progenitor star, which would correspond to the formation of a magnetar under
the assumption of magnetic flux conservation. An extrapolation of our analytic
formula (taking into account the nonlinear saturation) suggests that the Alfven
wave could reach an amplitude of B ~ 10^15 G, and that the pressure feedback
could significantly contribute to the pressure below the shock.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.2795 [pdf] - 902432
Toward a magnetohydrodynamic theory of the stationary accretion shock:
toy model of the advective-acoustic cycle in a magnetized flow
Submitted: 2009-11-16, last modified: 2010-04-02
The effect of a magnetic field on the linear phase of the advective-acoustic
instability is investigated, as a first step toward a magnetohydrodynamic (MHD)
theory of the stationary accretion shock instability taking place during
stellar core collapse. We study a toy model where the flow behind a planar
stationary accretion shock is adiabatically decelerated by an external
potential. Two magnetic field geometries are considered: parallel or
perpendicular to the shock. The entropy-vorticity wave, which is simply
advected in the unmagnetized limit, separates into five different waves: the
entropy perturbations are advected, while the vorticity can propagate along the
field lines through two Alfven waves and two slow magnetosonic waves. The two
cycles existing in the unmagnetized limit, advective-acoustic and purely
acoustic, are replaced by up to six distinct MHD cycles. The phase differences
among the cycles play an important role in determining the total cycle
efficiency and hence the growth rate. Oscillations in the growth rate as a
function of the magnetic field strength are due to this varying phase shift. A
vertical magnetic field hardly affects the cycle efficiency in the regime of
super-Alfvenic accretion that is considered. In contrast, we find that a
horizontal magnetic field strongly increases the efficiencies of the vorticity
cycles that bend the field lines, resulting in a significant increase of the
growth rate if the different cycles are in phase. These magnetic effects are
significant for large-scale modes if the Alfven velocity is a sizable fraction
of the flow velocity.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.3953 [pdf] - 902152
The saturation of SASI by parasitic instabilities
Submitted: 2009-10-20, last modified: 2010-04-02
The Standing Accretion Shock Instability (SASI) is commonly believed to be
responsible for large amplitude dipolar oscillations of the stalled shock
during core collapse, potentially leading to an asymmetric supernovae
explosion. The degree of asymmetry depends on the amplitude of SASI, which
nonlinear saturation mechanism has never been elucidated. We investigate the
role of parasitic instabilities as a possible cause of nonlinear SASI
saturation. As the shock oscillations create both vorticity and entropy
gradients, we show that both Kelvin-Helmholtz and Rayleigh-Taylor types of
instabilities are able to grow on a SASI mode if its amplitude is large enough.
We obtain simple estimates of their growth rates, taking into account the
effects of advection and entropy stratification. In the context of the
advective-acoustic cycle, we use numerical simulations to demonstrate how the
acoustic feedback can be decreased if a parasitic instability distorts the
advected structure. The amplitude of the shock deformation is estimated
analytically in this scenario. When applied to the set up of Fernandez &
Thompson (2009a), this saturation mechanism is able to explain the dramatic
decrease of the SASI power when both the nuclear dissociation energy and the
cooling rate are varied. Our results open new perspectives for anticipating the
effect, on the SASI amplitude, of the physical ingredients involved in the
modeling of the collapsing star.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:0809.2302 [pdf] - 315082
A simple toy model of the advective-acoustic instability I. Perturbative
approach
Submitted: 2008-09-12, last modified: 2008-12-14
Some general properties of the advective-acoustic instability are described
and understood using a toy model which is simple enough to allow for analytical
estimates of the eigenfrequencies. The essential ingredients of this model, in
the unperturbed regime, are a stationary shock and a subsonic region of
deceleration. For the sake of analytical simplicity, the 2D unperturbed flow is
parallel and the deceleration is produced adiabatically by an external
potential. The instability mechanism is determined unambiguously as the
consequence of a cycle between advected and acoustic perturbations. The purely
acoustic cycle, considered alone, is proven to be stable in this flow. Its
contribution to the instability can be either constructive or destructive. A
frequency cut-off is associated to the advection time through the region of
deceleration. This cut-off frequency explains why the instability favours
eigenmodes with a low frequency and a large horizontal wavelength. The relation
between the instability occurring in this highly simplified toy model and the
properties of SASI observed in the numerical simulations of stellar
core-collapse is discussed. This simple set up is proposed as a benchmark test
to evaluate the accuracy, in the linear regime, of numerical simulations
involving this instability. We illustrate such benchmark simulations in a
companion paper.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0809.2303 [pdf] - 315083
A simple toy model of the advective-acoustic instability. II. Numerical
simulations
Submitted: 2008-09-12, last modified: 2008-12-14
The physical processes involved in the advective-acoustic instability are
investigated with 2D numerical simulations. Simple toy models, developped in a
companion paper, are used to describe the coupling between acoustic and
entropy/vorticity waves, produced either by a stationary shock or by the
deceleration of the flow. Using two Eulerian codes based on different second
order upwind schemes, we confirm the results of the perturbative analysis. The
numerical convergence with respect to the computation mesh size is studied with
1D simulations. We demonstrate that the numerical accuracy of the quantities
which depend on the physics of the shock is limited to a linear convergence. We
argue that this property is likely to be true for most current numerical
schemes dealing with SASI in the core-collapse problem, and could be solved by
the use of advanced techniques for the numerical treatment of the shock. We
propose a strategy to choose the mesh size for an accurate treatment of the
advective-acoustic coupling in future numerical simulations.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0710.3041 [pdf] - 6073
Effect of Rotation on the Stability of a Stalled Cylindrical Shock and
its Consequences for Core-Collapse Supernovae
Submitted: 2007-10-16, last modified: 2008-02-20
A perturbative analysis is used to investigate the effect of rotation on the
instability of a steady accretion shock (SASI) in a simple toy-model, in view
of better understanding supernova explosions in which the collapsing core
contains angular momentum. A cylindrical geometry is chosen for the sake of
simplicity. Even when the centrifugal force is very small, rotation can have a
strong effect on the non axisymmetric modes of SASI by increasing the growth
rate of the spiral modes rotating in the same direction as the steady flow.
Counter-rotating spiral modes are significantly damped, while axisymmetric
modes are hardly affected by rotation. The growth rates of spiral modes have a
nearly linear dependence on the specific angular momentum of the flow. The
fundamental one-armed spiral mode (m=1) is favoured for small rotation rates,
whereas stronger rotation rates favour the mode m=2. A WKB analysis of higher
harmonics indicates that the efficiency of the advective-acoustic cycles
associated to spiral modes is strongly affected by rotation in the same manner
as low frequency modes, whereas the purely acoustic cycles are stable. These
results suggest that the linear phase of SASI in rotating core-collapse
supernovae naturally selects a spiral mode rotating in the same direction of
the flow, as observed in the 3D numerical simulations of Blondin & Mezzacappa
(2007). This emphasizes the need for a 3D approach of rotating core-collapse,
before conclusions on the explosion mechanisms and pulsar kicks can be drawn.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:0704.3001 [pdf] - 662
Multidimensional supernova simulations with approximative neutrino
transport. II. Convection and the advective-acoustic cycle in the supernova
core
Submitted: 2007-04-23, last modified: 2007-11-20
By 2D hydrodynamic simulations including a detailed equation of state and
neutrino transport, we investigate the interplay between different non-radial
hydrodynamic instabilities that play a role during the postbounce accretion
phase of collapsing stellar cores. The convective mode of instability, which is
driven by negative entropy gradients caused by neutrino heating or by time
variations of the shock strength, can be identified clearly by the development
of typical Rayleigh-Taylor mushrooms. However, in cases where the gas in the
postshock region is rapidly advected towards the gain radius, the growth of
such a buoyancy instability can be suppressed. In such a situation the shocked
flow nevertheless can develop non-radial asymmetry with an oscillatory growth
of the amplitude. This phenomenon has been termed ``standing accretion shock
instability'' (SASI). It is shown here that the SASI oscillations can trigger
convective instability and like the latter they lead to an increase of the
average shock radius and of the mass in the gain layer. Both hydrodynamic
instabilities in combination stretch the advection time of matter through the
neutrino-heating layer and thus enhance the neutrino energy deposition in
support of the neutrino-driven explosion mechanism. A rapidly contracting and
more compact nascent NS turns out to be favorable for explosions, because the
accretion luminosity and neutrino heating are larger and the growth rate of the
SASI is higher. Moreover, we show that the oscillation period of the SASI and a
variety of other features in our simulations agree with estimates for the
advective-acoustic cycle (AAC), in which perturbations are carried by the
accretion flow from the shock to the neutron star and pressure waves close an
amplifying global feedback loop. (abridged)
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0606640 [pdf] - 83080
Instability of a stalled accretion shock: evidence for the
advective-acoustic cycle
Submitted: 2006-06-26, last modified: 2006-09-21
We analyze the linear stability of a stalled accretion shock in a perfect gas
with a parametrized cooling function L ~ rho^{beta-alpha} P^alpha. The
instability is dominated by the l=1 mode if the shock radius exceeds 2-3 times
the accretor radius, depending on the parameters of the cooling function. The
growth rate and oscillation period are comparable to those observed in the
numerical simulations of Blondin & Mezzacappa (2006). The instability mechanism
is analyzed by separately measuring the efficiencies of the purely acoustic
cycle and the advective-acoustic cycle. These efficiencies are estimated
directly from the eigenspectrum, and also through a WKB analysis in the high
frequency limit. Both methods prove that the advective-acoustic cycle is
unstable, and that the purely acoustic cycle is stable. Extrapolating these
results to low frequency leads us to interpret the dominant mode as an
advective-acoustic instability, different from the purely acoustic
interpretation of Blondin & Mezzacappa (2006). A simplified characterization of
the instability is proposed, based on an advective-acoustic cycle between the
shock and the radius r_nabla where the velocity gradients of the stationary
flow are strongest. The importance of the coupling region in this mechanism
calls for a better understanding of the conditions for an efficient
advective-acoustic coupling in a decelerated, nonadiabatic flow, in order to
extend these results to core-collapse supernovae.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0507636 [pdf] - 74805
Neutrino-driven convection versus advection in core collapse supernovae
Submitted: 2005-07-27, last modified: 2006-08-24
A toy model is analyzed in order to evaluate the linear stability of the gain
region immediately behind a stalled accretion shock, after core bounce. This
model demonstrates that a negative entropy gradient is not sufficient to
warrant linear instability. The stability criterion is governed by the ratio
\chi of the advection time through the gain region divided by the local
timescale of buoyancy. The gain region is linearly stable if \chi< 3. The
classical convective instability is recovered in the limit \chi\gg 3. For
\chi>3, perturbations are unstable in a limited range of horizontal wavelengths
centered around twice the vertical size H of the gain region. The threshold
horizontal wavenumbers k_{min} and k_{max} follow simple scaling laws such that
Hk_{min}\propto 1/{\chi} and Hk_{max}\propto \chi. The convective stability of
the l=1 mode in spherical accretion is discussed, in relation with the
asymmetric explosion of core collapse supernovae. The advective stabilization
of long wavelength perturbations weakens the possible influence of convection
alone on a global l=1 mode.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0509635 [pdf] - 76216
The Advective-Acoustic instability in type II Supernovae
Submitted: 2005-09-21, last modified: 2005-09-26
The puzzle of birth velocities of pulsars (pulsar kicks) could be solved by
an asymmetric explosion of type II Supernovae. We propose a simple
hydrodynamical mechanism in order to explain this asymmetry, through the
advective-acoustic cycle (Foglizzo 2002) : during the phase of stalled shock,
an instability based on the cycle between advected perturbations (entropy /
vorticity) and acoustic perturbations can develop between the shock and the
surface of the nascent neutron star. Eigenfrequencies are computed numerically,
improving the calculation of Houck & Chevalier (1992). The linear instability
is dominated by a mode l=1, as observed in the numerical simulations of Blondin
et al. (2003) and Scheck et al. (2004). The frequency dependence of the growth
rate reveals the presence of the advective-acoustic cycle.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0502168 [pdf] - 70959
A fresh look at the unstable simulations of Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton
accretion
Submitted: 2005-02-08
The instability of Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton accretion, observed in numerical
simulations, is analyzed through known physical mechanisms and possible
numerical artefacts. The mechanisms of the longitudinal and transverse
instabilities, established within the accretion line model, are clarified. They
cannot account for the instability of BHL accretion at moderate Mach number
when the pressure forces within the shock cone are taken into account. The
advective-acoustic instability is considered in the context of BHL accretion
when the shock is detached from the accretor. This mechanism naturally explains
the stability of the flow when the shock is weak, and the instability when the
accretor is small. In particular, it is a robust proof of the instability of 3D
accretion when gamma=5/3 if the accretor is small enough, even for moderate
shock strength (M sim 3). The numerical artefacts that may be present in
existing numerical simulations are reviewed, with particular attention paid to
the advection of entropy/vorticity perturbations and the artificial acoustic
feedback from the accretor boundary condition. Several numerical tests are
proposed to test these mechanisms.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0308534 [pdf] - 58813
Non-radial instability of stalled accretion shocks: advective-acoustic
cycle
Submitted: 2003-08-29
The linear stability of stalled accretion shocks is investigated in the
context of core collapse of type II supernovae. We focus on a particular
instability mechanism based on the coupling of acoustic perturbations with
advected ones (vorticity, entropy). This advective-acoustic cycle takes place
between the shock and the nascent neutron star. Both adiabatic and
non-adiabatic processes may contribute to this coupling, but only adiabatic
ones are considered in this first approach. The growth time of the adiabatic
instability scales like the advection time, and is dominated by low degree
modes l=0,1,2. Non radial modes (l=1,2) found unstable by Blondin et al. (2003)
can be related to this mechanism.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0307047 [pdf] - 57760
Non-axisymmetric instabilities in shocked accretion flows with
differential rotation
Submitted: 2003-07-02
The linear stability of a shocked isothermal accretion flow onto a black hole
is investigated in the inviscid limit. The outer shock solution, which was
previously found to be stable with respect to axisymmetric perturbations, is,
however, generally unstable to non-axisymmetric ones. Eigenmodes and growth
rates are obtained by numerical integration of the linearized equations. The
mechanism of this instability is based on the cycle of acoustic waves between
their corotation radius and the shock. It is a form of the Papaloizou-Pringle
instability, modified by advection and the presence of the shock. As such it
can be generalized to non isothermal shocked accretion flows. Blobs and
vortices are generated by the shock as a by-product of the instability.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0206274 [pdf] - 49905
Non-radial instabilities of isothermal Bondi accretion with a shock:
vortical-acoustic cycle vs post-shock acceleration
Submitted: 2002-06-17
The linear stability of isothermal Bondi accretion with a shock is studied
analytically in the asymptotic limit of high incident Mach number M_1. The flow
is unstable with respect to radial perturbations as expected by Nakayama
(1993), due to post-shock acceleration. Its growth time scales like the
advection time from the shock r_sh to the sonic point r_son. The growth rate of
non-radial perturbations l=1 is higher by a factor M_1^{2/3}, and is therefore
intermediate between the advection and acoustic frequencies. Besides these
instabilities based on post-shock acceleration, our study revealed another
generic mechanism based on the cycle of acoustic and vortical perturbations
between the shock and the sonic radius, independently of the sign of post-shock
acceleration. The vortical-acoustic instability is fundamentally non-radial. It
is fed by the efficient excitation of vorticity waves by the isothermal shock
perturbed by acoustic waves. The growth rate exceeds the advection rate by a
factor log M_1. Unstable modes cover a wide range of frequencies from the
fundamental acoustic frequency ~c/r_sh up to a cut-off ~c/r_son associated with
the sonic radius. The highest growth rate is reached for l=1 modes near the
cut-off. The additional cycle of acoustic waves between the shock and the sonic
radius is responsible for variations of the growth rate by a factor up to 3
depending on its phase relative to the vortical-acoustic cycle. The instability
also exists, with a similar growth rate, below the fundamental acoustic
frequency down to the advection frequency, as vorticity waves are efficiently
coupled to the region of pseudosound. These results open new perspectives to
address the stability of shocked accretion flows.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0101056 [pdf] - 40194
Entropic-acoustic instability of shocked Bondi accretion I. What does
perturbed Bondi accretion sound like ?
Submitted: 2001-01-04
In the radial flow of gas into a black hole (i.e. Bondi accretion), the
infall of any entropy or vorticity perturbation produces acoustic waves
propagating outward. The dependence of this acoustic flux on the shape of the
perturbation is investigated in detail. This is the key process in the
mechanism of the entropic-acoustic instability proposed by Foglizzo & Tagger
(2000) to explain the instability of Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton accretion. These
acoustic waves create new entropy and vorticity perturbations when they reach
the shock, thus closing the entropic-acoustic cycle. With an adiabatic index
1<gamma<=5/3, the linearized equations describing the perturbations of the
Bondi flow are studied analytically and solved numerically. The fundamental
frequency of this problem is the cut-off frequency of acoustic refraction,
below which ingoing acoustic waves are refracted out. This cut-off is
significantly smaller than the Keplerian frequency at the sonic radius and
depends on the latitudinal number l of the perturbations. When advected
adiabatically inward, entropy and vorticity perturbations trigger acoustic
waves propagating outward, with an efficiency which is highest for non radial
perturbations l=1. The outgoing acoustic flux produced by the advection of
vorticity perturbations is always moderate and peaks at rather low frequency.
By contrast, the acoustic flux produced by an entropy wave is highest close to
the refraction cut-off. It can be very large if gamma is close to 5/3. These
results suggest that the shocked Bondi flow with gamma=5/3 is strongly unstable
with respect to the entropic-acoustic mechanism.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0009193 [pdf] - 38035
Entropic-Acoustic instability in shocked accretion flows
Submitted: 2000-09-13
A new instability mechanism is described in accretion flows where the gas is
accelerated from a stationary shock to a sonic surface. The instability is
based on a cycle of acoustic and entropic waves in this subsonic region of the
flow. When advected adiabatically inward, entropy perturbations trigger
acoustic waves propagating outward. If a shock is present at the outer
boundary, acoustic waves reaching the shock produce new entropy perturbations,
thus creating an entropic-acoustic cycle between the shock and the sonic
surface. The interplay of acoustic and entropy perturbations is estimated
analytically using a simplified model based on the compact nozzle
approximation. According to this model, the entropic-acoustic cycle is unstable
if the sound speed at the sonic surface significantly exceeds the sound speed
immediately after the shock. The growth rate scales like the inverse of the
advection time from the outer shock to the sonic point. The frequency of the
most unstable perturbations is comparable to the refraction cutoff, defined as
the frequency below which acoustic waves propagating inward are significantly
refracted outward. This generic mechanism should occur in Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton
accretion, and also in shocked accretion discs.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9905226 [pdf] - 106552
An analytic study of Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton accretion
Submitted: 1999-05-18
The adiabatic shock produced by a compact object moving supersonically
relative to a gas with uniform entropy and no vorticity is a source of entropy
gradients and vorticity. We investigate these analytically. The
non-axisymmetric Rayleigh-Taylor and axisymmetric Kelvin-Helmholtz linear
instabilities are potential sources of destabilization of the subsonic
accretion flow after the shock. A local Lagrangian approach is used in order to
evaluate the efficiency of these linear instabilities. However, the conditions
required for such a WKB type approximation are fulfilled only marginally: a
quantitative estimate of their local growth rate integrated along a flow line
shows that their growth time is at best comparable to the time needed for
advection onto the accretor, even at high Mach number and for a small accretor
size. Despite this apparently low efficiency, several features of these
mechanisms qualitatively match those observed in numerical simulations: in a
gas with uniform entropy, the instability occurs only for supersonic accretors.
It is nonaxisymmetric, and begins close to the accretor in the equatorial
region perpendicular to the symmetry axis. The mechanism is more efficient for
a small, highly supersonic accretor, and also if the shock is detached. We also
show by a 3-D numerical simulation an example of unstable accretion of a
subsonic flow with non-uniform entropy at infinity. This instability is
qualitatively similar to the one observed in 3-D simulations of the
Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton flow, although it involves neither a bow shock nor an
accretion line.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9808318 [pdf] - 102662
Are solar granules the only source of acoustic oscillations ?
Submitted: 1998-08-27
The excitation mechanism of low degree acoustic modes is investigated through
the analysis of the stochastic time variations of their energy. The correlation
between the energies of two different modes is interpreted as the signature of
the occurrence rate of their excitation source. The different correlations
determined by Foglizzo et al. (1998) constrain the physical properties of an
hypothetical source of excitation, which would act in addition to the classical
excitation by the turbulent convection. Particular attention is drawn to the
effect of coronal mass ejections. The variability of their occurrence rate with
the solar cycle could account for the variation of the correlation between
IPHIR and GOLF data. Such an interpretation would suggest that the mean
correlation between low degree acoustic modes is at least 0.2 % at solar
minimum.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9709095 [pdf] - 98548
Are Solar Acoustic Modes Correlated ?
Foglizzo, T.;
Garcia, R. A.;
Boumier, P.;
Charra, J.;
Gabriel, A. H.;
Grec, G.;
Robillot, J. M.;
Cortes, T. Roca;
Turck-Chieze, S.;
Ulrich, R. K.
Submitted: 1997-09-10
We have studied the statistical properties of the energy of individual
acoustic modes, extracted from 310 days of GOLF data near the solar minimum.
The exponential distribution of the energy of each mode is clearly seen. The
modes are found to be uncorrelated with a +-0.6 % accuracy, thus supporting the
hypothesis of stochastic excitation by the solar convection. Nevertheless, the
same analysis performed on the same modes just before the solar maximum, using
IPHIR data, rejects the hypothesis of no correlation at a 99.3 % confidence
level. A simple model suggests that 31.3 +-9.4 % of the energy of each mode is
coherent among the modes studied in IPHIR data, correponding to a mean
correlation of 10.7 +-5.9 %.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9604160 [pdf] - 94531
An analytical study of Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton accretion I. Stationary
flows
Submitted: 1996-04-26
We prove that the sonic surface of axisymmetric meridional stationary flows
is always attached to the accretor, however small, if the adiabatic index of
the gas is gamma=5/3. Using local expansions near a point-like accretor, we
extend Bondi's classification of spherically symmetric flows to axisymmetric
flows, introducing the possibility of angular sectors reached by no flow lines,
and singular directions of infinite mass flux, in addition to the angular
regions of subsonic and supersonic accretion. For gamma<5/3, we show the
impossibility of subsonic accretion onto a point-like accretor when the entropy
of the flow is not uniform. The special case gamma=5/3 is treated separately.
We analyse the influence of the adiabatic index and Mach number of the flow at
infinity on the mass accretion rate of shocked spherical flows. We propose an
interpolation formula for the mass accretion rate of axisymmetric flows as a
function of the Mach number and the adiabatic index, in the range
9/7<gamma<5/3.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9502049 [pdf] - 1469176
The Parker-Shearing instability in azimuthaly magnetized discs
Submitted: 1995-02-08
We describe the effects of both magnetic buoyancy and differential rotation
on a disc of isothermal gas embedded in a purely azimuthal magnetic field, in
order to study the evolution and interplay of Parker and shearing
instabilities. Both instabilities occur on the slow MHD branch of the
dispersion relation, and can affect the same waves. We put a stress on the
natural polarization properties of the slow MHD waves to get a better
understanding of the physics involved. The mechanism of the shearing
instability is described in details. Waves with a vertical wavelength shorter
than the scale height of the disc are subject to both the Parker and the
transient shearing instabilities. They occur in different ranges of radial
wavenumbers, \ie at different times in the shearing evolution ; these ranges
can overlap or, on the contrary, be separated by a phase of wave-like
oscillations, depending on the strength of differential rotation. Our results
can be applied to both galactic and accretion discs.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9403019 [pdf] - 91308
The Parker instability in disks with differential rotation
Submitted: 1994-03-10
We present a detailed study of the growth of the Parker instability in a
differentially rotating disk embedded in an azimuthal equilibrium magnetic
field, such as the interstellar gas or an accretion disk. Basic properties of
the instability without shear are first recalled. Differential rotation is
modeled in the shearing sheet approximation, classical in the theory of spiral
density waves. The action of differential rotation is reduced to two different
effects, (i) a linear time-dependence of the radial wavenumber, and (ii) a
radial differential force. We present both exact numerical solutions, and
approximate analytical ones based on the WKB approximation in the limit of weak
differential rotation. Most important are (i) a transient natural stabilization
of the Parker mode due to the radial differential force (ii) the generation of
magnetosonic and Alfvenic waves, and (iii) in a certain parameter range a
possible ``turn-over'' of the perturbation whereby, quite surprisingly, matter
which had started being elevated by the instability may end up dropping towards
the disk midplane. A simplified model shows the possible observable effects of
this turn-over.