Frank and Sigwarth (2001,JGRSP,106,A3,3665; FS) report on an optical search for small comets in which they report detection of nine faint trails. FS claim that these trails are produced by low-mass, low-albedo ob-jects whose inferred number density is consistent with that predicted by the small comet hypothesis. The images used for the search were the same as those obtained in a previous unsuccessful optical search for small comets reported by Mutel and Fix (2000, JGRSP,105,24907; MF). The results of these two independent analyses of the same image dataset are not formally in disagreement, since all detections reported by FS are fainter than the minimum detectable magnitude limit (16.5) determined by MF. However, since the conclusions are quite different, we have independently re-analyzed the original search images for evidence of the faint detections reported by FS. In particular, we have carefully examined whether the three putative trails whose positions are available satisfy several necessary criteria for a candidate grouping of excess-count pixels to be caused by a celestial object. While we have not evaluated the formal statistical significance of faint detections, all three claimed detections fail one or more independent criteria required for a valid detection. In addition, both the level and shape of the claimed integral detection rate versus magnitude are in strong disagreement with the inte-gral number density of the small comets hypothesis. We conclude that unless the remaining claimed detections can prove otherwise, the lack of detections after "careful examination" of the 1,500 search images described in FS provides the most compelling evidence yet published against the small comet hypothesis.

Arecibo spectra of the mainline OH maser emission from U Her over more than a decade show variations of the OH emission over these time scales. These observations are combined with high spatial resolution VLBA maps to investigate the causes of the variations in the velocities of the maser components. Global properties of the dust shell, such as accelerations, variations in the pump and shell-wide magnetic field changes are examined as possibilities, and eliminated. A possible solution to the problem involving plasma turbulence and the local magnetic field is introduced, and the relevant time scales of the turbulence are calculated. The turbulent velocity field yields time scales of the turbulence are calculated. The turbulent velocity field yields time scales that are too long (of order centuries), while the turbulent magnetic field produces variations on appropriate time scales of a few years. A line-of-sight model of the turbulence is developed and investigated. The complete exploration of this solution requires extensive theoretical and observational work. Possible avenues of investigation of the plasma turbulence model are presented.