Normalized to: Fisher, G.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.14579 [pdf] - 2122166
The Coronal Global Evolutionary Model: Using HMI Vector Magnetogram and
Doppler Data to Determine Coronal Magnetic Field Evolution
Hoeksema, J. Todd;
Abbett, William P.;
Bercik, David J.;
Cheung, Mark C. M.;
DeRosa, Marc L.;
Fisher, George H.;
Hayashi, Keiji;
Kazachenko, Maria D.;
Liu, Yang;
Lumme, Erkka;
Lynch, Benjamine J.;
Sun, Xudong;
Welsch, Brian T.
Submitted: 2020-06-25
The Coronal Global Evolutionary Model (CGEM) provides data-driven simulations
of the magnetic field in the solar corona to better understand the build-up of
magnetic energy that leads to eruptive events. The CGEM project has developed
six capabilities. CGEM modules (1) prepare time series of full-disk vector
magnetic field observations to (2) derive the changing electric field in the
solar photosphere over active-region scales. This local electric field is (3)
incorporated into a surface flux transport model that reconstructs a global
electric field that evolves magnetic flux in a consistent way. These electric
fields drive a (4) 3D spherical magneto-frictional (SMF) model, either at
high-resolution over a restricted range of solid angle or at lower resolution
over a global domain, to determine the magnetic field and current density in
the low corona. An SMF-generated initial field above an active region and the
evolving electric field at the photosphere are used to drive (5) detailed
magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of active regions in the low corona. SMF
or MHD solutions are then used to compute emissivity proxies that can be
compared with coronal observations. Finally, a lower-resolution SMF magnetic
field is used to initialize (6) a global MHD model that is driven by an SMF
electric-field time series to simulate the outer corona and heliosphere,
ultimately connecting Sun to Earth. As a demonstration, this report features
results of CGEM applied to observations of the evolution of NOAA Active Region
11158 in February 2011.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.08301 [pdf] - 2084121
The PDFI_SS Electric Field Inversion Software
Submitted: 2019-12-17, last modified: 2020-04-24
We describe the PDFI_SS software library, which is designed to find the
electric field at the Sun's photosphere from a sequence of vector magnetogram
and Doppler velocity measurements, and estimates of horizontal velocities
obtained from local correlation tracking using the recently upgraded FLCT code.
The library, a collection of Fortran subroutines, uses the "PDFI" technique
described by Kazachenko et al. (2014), but modified for use in spherical,
Plate-Carr\'ee geometry on a staggered grid. The domain over which solutions
are found is a subset of the global spherical surface, defined by
user-specified limits of colatitude and longitude. Our staggered-grid approach,
based on that of Yee (1966), is more conservative and self-consistent compared
to the centered, Cartesian grid used by Kazachenko et al. (2014). The library
can be used to compute an end-to-end solution for electric fields from data
taken by the HMI instrument aboard NASA's SDO Mission. This capability has been
incorporated into the HMI pipeline processing system operating at SDO's JSOC.
The library is written in a general and modular way so that the calculations
can be customized to modify or delete electric field contributions, or used
with other data sets. Other applications include "nudging" numerical models of
the solar atmosphere to facilitate assimilative simulations. The library
includes an ability to compute "global" (whole-Sun) electric field solutions.
The library also includes an ability to compute Potential Magnetic Field
solutions in spherical coordinates. This distribution includes a number of test
programs which allow the user to test the software.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.00367 [pdf] - 1908796
Probing the effect of cadence on the estimates of photospheric energy
and helicity injections in eruptive active region NOAA AR 11158
Submitted: 2019-06-30
In this work we study how the input data cadence affects the photospheric
energy and helicity injection estimates in eruptive NOAA active region 11158.
We sample the novel 2.25-minute vector magnetogram and Dopplergram data from
the \emph{Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager} (HMI) instrument onboard the
\emph{Solar Dynamics Observatory} (SDO) spacecraft to create input datasets of
variable cadences ranging from 2.25 minutes to 24 hours. We employ
state-of-the-art data processing, velocity and electric field inversion methods
for deriving estimates of the energy and helicity injections from these
datasets. We find that the electric field inversion methods that reproduce the
observed magnetic field evolution through the use of Faraday's law are more
stable against variable cadence: the PDFI (PTD-Doppler-FLCT-Ideal) electric
field inversion method produces consistent injection estimates for cadences
from 2.25 minutes up to 2 hours, implying that the photospheric processes
acting on time scales below 2 hours contribute little to the injections, or
that they are below the sensitivity of the input data and the PDFI method. On
other hand, the electric field estimate derived from the output of DAVE4VM
(Differential Affine Velocity Estimator for Vector Magnetograms), which does
not fulfil Faraday's law exactly, produces significant variations in the energy
and helicity injection estimates in the 2.25-minute to 2-hour cadence range. We
present also a third, novel DAVE4VM-based electric field estimate, which
corrects the poor inductivity of the raw DAVE4VM estimate. This method is less
sensitive to the changes of cadence, but still faces significant issues for the
lowest of considered cadences ($\geq$2 hours). We find several potential
problems in both PDFI- and DAVE4VM-based injection estimates and conclude that
the quality of both should be surveyed further in controlled environments.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.08323 [pdf] - 1533852
A model for stealth coronal mass ejections
Submitted: 2016-12-25
Stealth coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are events in which there are almost no
observable signatures of the CME eruption in the low corona but often a
well-resolved slow flux rope CME observed in the coronagraph data. We present
results from a three-dimensional numerical magnetohydrodynamics (MHD)
simulation of the 1--2 June 2008 slow streamer blowout CME that Robbrecht et
al. (2009) called "the CME from nowhere." We model the global coronal structure
using a 1.4 MK isothermal solar wind and a low-order potential field source
surface representation of the Carrington Rotation 2070 magnetogram synoptic
map. The bipolar streamer belt arcade is energized by simple shearing flows
applied in the vicinity of the helmet streamer's polarity inversion line. The
flows are large scale and impart a shear typical of that expected from the
differential rotation. The slow expansion of the energized helmet streamer
arcade results in the formation of a radial current sheet. The subsequent onset
of expansion-induced flare reconnection initiates the stealth CME while
gradually releasing the stored magnetic energy. We present favorable
comparisons between our simulation results and the multiviewpoint SOHO-LASCO
(Large Angle and Spectrometric Coronagraph) and STEREO-SECCHI (Sun Earth
Connection Coronal and Heliospheric Investigation) coronagraph observations of
the preeruption streamer structure and the initiation and evolution of the
stealth streamer blowout CME.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.08754 [pdf] - 1424645
Deriving Potential Coronal Magnetic Fields from Vector Magnetograms
Submitted: 2015-03-30, last modified: 2016-06-16
The minimum-energy configuration for the magnetic field above the solar
photosphere is curl-free (hence, by Ampere's law, also current-free), so can be
represented as the gradient of a scalar potential. Since magnetic fields are
divergence free, this scalar potential obeys Laplace's equation, given an
appropriate boundary condition (BC). With measurements of the full magnetic
vector at the photosphere, it is possible to employ either Neumann or Dirichlet
BCs there. Historically, the Neumann BC was used with available line-of-sight
magnetic field measurements, which approximate the radial field needed for the
Neumann BC. Since each BC fully determines the 3D vector magnetic field, either
choice will, in general, be inconsistent with some aspect of the observed field
on the boundary, due to the presence of both currents and noise in the observed
field. We present a method to combine solutions from both Dirichlet and Neumann
BCs to determine a hybrid, "least-squares" potential field, which minimizes the
integrated square of the residual between the potential and actual fields. This
has advantages in both not overfitting the radial field used for the Neumann
BC, and maximizing consistency with the observations. We demonstrate our
methods with SDO/HMI vector magnetic field observations of AR 11158, and find
that residual discrepancies between the observed and potential fields are
significant, and are consistent with nonzero horizontal photospheric currents.
We also analyze potential fields for two other active regions observed with two
different vector magnetographs, and find that hybrid potential fields have
significantly less energy than the Neumann fields in every case --- by more
than 10^(32) erg in some cases. This has major implications for estimates of
free magnetic energy in coronal field models, e.g., non-linear force-free field
extrapolations.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.05974 [pdf] - 1280865
Photospheric Electric Fields and Energy Fluxes in the Eruptive Active
Region NOAA 11158
Submitted: 2015-05-22, last modified: 2015-08-11
How much electromagnetic energy crosses the photosphere in evolving solar
active regions? With the advent of high-cadence vector magnetic field
observations, addressing this fundamental question has become tractable. In
this paper, we apply the "PTD-Doppler-FLCT-Ideal" (PDFI) electric field
inversion technique of Kazachenko et al. (2014) to a 6-day HMI/SDO vector
magnetogram and Doppler velocity sequence, to find the electric field and
Poynting flux evolution in active region NOAA 11158, which produced an X2.2
flare early on 2011 February 15. We find photospheric electric fields ranging
up to $2$ V/cm. The Poynting fluxes range from $[-0.6$ to $2.3]\times10^{10}$
ergs$\cdot$cm$^{-2}$s$^{-1}$, mostly positive, with the largest contribution to
the energy budget in the range of $[10^9$-$10^{10}]$
ergs$\cdot$cm$^{-2}$s$^{-1}$. Integrating the instantaneous energy flux over
space and time, we find that the total magnetic energy accumulated above the
photosphere from the initial emergence to the moment before the X2.2 flare to
be $E=10.6\times10^{32}$ ergs, which is partitioned as $2.0$ and
$8.6\times10^{32}$ ergs, respectively, between free and potential energies.
Those estimates are consistent with estimates from preflare non-linear
force-free field (NLFFF) extrapolations and the Minimum Current Corona
estimates (MCC), in spite of our very different approach. This study of
photospheric electric fields demonstrates the potential of the PDFI approach
for estimating Poynting fluxes and opens the door to more quantitative studies
of the solar photosphere and more realistic data-driven simulations of coronal
magnetic field evolution.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.06018 [pdf] - 1244280
The Coronal Global Evolutionary Model: Using HMI Vector Magnetogram and
Doppler Data to Model the Buildup of Free Magnetic Energy in the Solar Corona
Fisher, George H.;
Abbett, William. P.;
Bercik, David J.;
Kazachenko, Maria D.;
Lynch, Benjamin J.;
Welsch, Brian T.;
Hoeksema, J. Todd;
Hayashi, Keiji;
Liu, Yang;
Norton, Aimee A.;
Dalda, Alberto Sainz;
Sun, Xudong;
DeRosa, Marc L.;
Cheung, Mark C. M.
Submitted: 2015-05-22, last modified: 2015-07-09
The most violent space weather events (eruptive solar flares and coronal mass
ejections) are driven by the release of free magnetic energy stored in the
solar corona. Energy can build up on timescales of hours to days, and then may
be suddenly released in the form of a magnetic eruption, which then propagates
through interplanetary space, possibly impacting the Earth's space environment.
Can we use the observed evolution of the magnetic and velocity fields in the
solar photosphere to model the evolution of the overlying solar coronal field,
including the storage and release of magnetic energy in such eruptions? The
objective of CGEM, the Coronal Global Evolutionary Model, funded by the
NASA/NSF Space Weather Modeling program, is to develop and evaluate such a
model for the evolution of the coronal magnetic field. The evolving coronal
magnetic field can then be used as a starting point for magnetohydrodynamic
(MHD) models of the corona, which can then be used to drive models of
heliospheric evolution and predictions of magnetic field and plasma density
conditions at 1AU.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.0135 [pdf] - 1085716
Emergence of Anchored Flux Tubes Through the Convection Zone
Submitted: 2010-05-02, last modified: 2015-05-28
We model the evolution of buoyant magnetic flux tubes in the Sun's convection
zone. A flux tube is assumed to lie initially near the top of the stably
stratified radiative core below the convection zone, but a segment of it is
perturbed into the convection zone by gradual heating and convective overshoot
motions. The ends ("footpoints") of the segment remain anchored at the base of
the convection zone, and if the segment is sufficiently long, it may be
buoyantly unstable, rising through the convection zone in a short time. The
length of the flux tube determines the ratio of buoyancy to magnetic tension:
short loops of flux are arrested before reaching the top of the convection
zone, while longer loops emerge to erupt through the photosphere. Using
Spruit's convection zone model, we compute the minimum footpoint separation
$L_c$ required for erupting flux tubes. We explore the dependence of $L_c$ on
the initial thermal state of the perturbed flux tube segment and on its initial
magnetic field strength. Following an investigation of thermal diffusion time
scales and the dynamic rise times of unstable flux tube segments, we conclude
that the most likely origin for magnetic flux which erupts to the surface is
from short length scale perturbations ($L < L_c$) which are initially stable,
but which are subsequently destabilized either by diffusion of heat into the
tube or by stretching of the anchor points until $L$ just exceeds $L_c$. In
either case, the separation of the anchor points of the emergent tube should
lie between the critical distance for a tube in mechanical equilibrium and one
in thermal equilibrium. Finally, after comparing the dispersion of dynamic rise
times with the much shorter observed active region formation time scales, we
conclude that active regions form from the emergence of a single flux tube
segment.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.06950 [pdf] - 988354
Why Is the Great Solar Active Region 12192 Flare-Rich But CME-Poor?
Submitted: 2015-02-24, last modified: 2015-05-05
Solar active region (AR) 12192 of October 2014 hosts the largest sunspot
group in 24 years. It is the most prolific flaring site of Cycle 24, but
surprisingly produced no coronal mass ejection (CME) from the core region
during its disk passage. Here, we study the magnetic conditions that prevented
eruption and the consequences that ensued. We find AR 12192 to be "big but
mild"; its core region exhibits weaker non-potentiality, stronger overlying
field, and smaller flare-related field changes compared to two other major
flare-CME-productive ARs (11429 and 11158). These differences are present in
the intensive-type indices (e.g., means) but generally not the extensive ones
(e.g., totals). AR 12192's large amount of magnetic free energy does not
translate into CME productivity. The unexpected behavior suggests that AR
eruptiveness is limited by some relative measure of magnetic non-potentiality
over the restriction of background field, and that confined flares may leave
weaker photospheric and coronal imprints compared to their eruptive
counterparts.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.04279 [pdf] - 1224064
Sign singularity and flares in solar active region NOAA 11158
Sorriso-Valvo, Luca;
De Vita, Gaetano;
Kazachenko, Maria D.;
Krucker, Sam;
Primavera, Leonardo;
Servidio, Sergio;
Vecchio, Antonio;
Welsch, Brian T.;
Fisher, George H.;
Lepreti, Fabio;
Carbone, Vincenzo
Submitted: 2015-01-18
Solar Active Region NOAA 11158 has hosted a number of strong flares,
including one X2.2 event. The complexity of current density and current
helicity are studied through cancellation analysis of their sign-singular
measure, which features power-law scaling. Spectral analysis is also performed,
revealing the presence of two separate scaling ranges with different spectral
index. The time evolution of parameters is discussed. Sudden changes of the
cancellation exponents at the time of large flares, and the presence of
correlation with EUV and X-ray flux, suggest that eruption of large flares can
be linked to the small scale properties of the current structures.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.4027 [pdf] - 880189
A Comprehensive Method of Estimating Electric Fields from Vector
Magnetic Field and Doppler Measurements
Submitted: 2014-04-15, last modified: 2014-09-10
Photospheric electric fields, estimated from sequences of vector magnetic
field and Doppler measurements, can be used to estimate the flux of magnetic
energy (the Poynting flux) into the corona and as time-dependent boundary
conditions for dynamic models of the coronal magnetic field. We have modified
and extended an existing method to estimate photospheric electric fields that
combines a poloidal-toroidal (PTD) decomposition of the evolving magnetic field
vector with Doppler and horizontal plasma velocities. Our current, more
comprehensive method, which we dub the "{\bf P}TD-{\bf D}oppler-{\bf F}LCT {\bf
I}deal" (PDFI) technique, can now incorporate Doppler velocities from
non-normal viewing angles. It uses the \texttt{FISHPACK} software package to
solve several two-dimensional Poisson equations, a faster and more robust
approach than our previous implementations. Here, we describe systematic,
quantitative tests of the accuracy and robustness of the PDFI technique using
synthetic data from anelastic MHD (\texttt{ANMHD}) simulations, which have been
used in similar tests in the past. We find that the PDFI method has less than
$1%$ error in the total Poynting flux and a $10%$ error in the helicity flux
rate at a normal viewing angle $(\theta=0$) and less than $25%$ and $10%$
errors respectively at large viewing angles ($\theta<60^\circ$). We compare our
results with other inversion methods at zero viewing angle, and find that our
method's estimates of the fluxes of magnetic energy and helicity are comparable
to or more accurate than other methods. We also discuss the limitations of the
PDFI method and its uncertainties.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.2451 [pdf] - 1092902
A Magnetic Calibration of Photospheric Doppler Velocities
Submitted: 2012-01-11, last modified: 2013-02-13
The zero point of measured photospheric Doppler shifts is uncertain for at
least two reasons: instrumental variations (from, e.g., thermal drifts), and
the convective blueshift, a known correlation between intensity and upflows.
Calibrated Doppler velocities would be useful for (i) improving estimates of
the Poynting flux of magnetic energy across the photosphere, and (ii)
constraining processes underlying flux cancellation, the mutual apparent loss
of magnetic flux in closely spaced, opposite-polarity magnetogram features. We
present a method to absolutely calibrate line-of-sight (LOS) velocities in
solar active regions (ARs) near disk center using three successive vector
magnetograms and one Dopplergram coincident with the central magnetogram. It
exploits the fact that Doppler shifts measured along polarity inversion lines
(PILs) of the LOS magnetic field determine one component of the velocity
perpendicular to the magnetic field, and optimizes consistency between changes
in LOS flux near PILs and the transport of transverse magnetic flux by LOS
velocities, assuming ideal electric fields govern the magnetic evolution. We
apply our method to vector magnetograms of AR 11158, observed by the
Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) aboard the Solar Dynamics Observatory,
and find clear evidence of offsets in the Doppler zero point, in the range of
50 -- 550 m s$^{-1}$. In addition, we note that a simpler calibration can be
determined from an LOS magnetogram and Dopplergram pair from the median Doppler
velocity among all near-disk-center PIL pixels. We briefly discuss shortcomings
in our initial implementation, and suggest ways to address these. In addition,
as a step in our data reduction, we discuss use of temporal continuity in the
transverse magnetic field direction to correct apparently spurious fluctuations
in resolution of the 180$^\circ$ ambiguity.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.5247 [pdf] - 447093
Global Forces in Eruptive Solar Flares: The Lorentz force Acting on the
Solar Atmosphere and the Solar Interior
Submitted: 2010-06-27, last modified: 2011-12-04
We compute the change in the Lorentz force integrated over the outer solar
atmosphere implied by observed changes in vector magnetograms that occur during
large, eruptive solar flares. This force perturbation should be balanced by an
equal and opposite force perturbation acting on the solar photosphere and solar
interior. The resulting expression for the estimated force change in the solar
interior generalizes the earlier expression presented by Hudson, Fisher and
Welsch (CS-383, ASP, 221, 2008), providing horizontal as well as vertical force
components, and provides a more accurate result for the vertical component of
the perturbed force. We show that magnetic eruptions should result in the
magnetic field at the photosphere becoming more horizontal, and hence should
result in a downward (towards the solar interior) force change acting on the
photosphere and solar interior, as recently argued from an analysis of
magnetogram data by Wang and Liu (Astrophys. J. Lett. 716, L195, 2010). We
suggest the existence of an observational relationship between the force change
computed from changes in the vector magnetograms, the outward momentum carried
by the ejecta from the flare, and the properties of the helioseismic
disturbance driven by the downward force change. We use the impulse driven by
the Lorentz-force change in the outer solar atmosphere to derive an upper limit
to the mass of erupting plasma that can escape from the Sun. Finally, we
compare the expected Lorentz-force change at the photosphere with simple
estimates from flare-driven gasdynamic disturbances and from an estimate of the
perturbed pressure from radiative backwarming of the photosphere in flaring
conditions.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.1035 [pdf] - 1051911
Radiative Cooling in MHD Models of the Quiet Sun Convection Zone and
Corona
Submitted: 2011-02-04, last modified: 2011-06-10
We present a series of numerical simulations of the quiet Sun plasma threaded
by magnetic fields that extend from the upper convection zone into the low
corona. We discuss an efficient, simplified approximation to the physics of
optically thick radiative transport through the surface layers, and investigate
the effects of convective turbulence on the magnetic structure of the Sun's
atmosphere in an initially unipolar (open field) region. We find that the net
Poynting flux below the surface is on average directed toward the interior,
while in the photosphere and chromosphere the net flow of electromagnetic
energy is outward into the solar corona. Overturning convective motions between
these layers driven by rapid radiative cooling appears to be the source of
energy for the oppositely directed fluxes of electromagnetic energy.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.4086 [pdf] - 1051590
Can we Determine Electric Fields and Poynting Fluxes from Vector
Magnetograms and Doppler Measurements?
Submitted: 2011-01-21, last modified: 2011-03-16
The availability of vector magnetogram sequences with sufficient accuracy and
cadence to estimate the time derivative of the magnetic field allows us to use
Faraday's law to find an approximate solution for the electric field in the
photosphere, using a Poloidal-Toroidal Decomposition (PTD) of the magnetic
field and its partial time derivative. Without additional information, however,
the electric field found from this technique is under-determined -- Faraday's
law provides no information about the electric field that can be derived the
gradient of a scalar potential. Here, we show how additional information in the
form of line-of-sight Doppler flow measurements, and motions transverse to the
line-of-sight determined with ad-hoc methods such as local correlation
tracking, can be combined with the PTD solutions to provide much more accurate
solutions for the solar electric field, and therefore the Poynting flux of
electromagnetic energy in the solar photosphere. Reliable, accurate maps of the
Poynting flux are essential for quantitative studies of the buildup of magnetic
energy before flares and coronal mass ejections.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.2722 [pdf] - 166183
Radiation Hydrodynamics in Solar Flares
Submitted: 2010-05-16
Solar flares are currently understood as the explosive release of energy
stored in the form of stressed magnetic fields. In many cases, the released
energy seems to take the form of large numbers of electrons accelerated to high
energies or alternatively plasma heated to very high temperatures. The
transport of this energy into the remaining portion of the atmosphere results
in violent mass motion and strong emission across the electromagnetic spectrum.
One important phenomenon observed during flares is the appearance in coronal
magnetic loops of large amounts of upflowing, soft X-ray emitting plasma. It is
believed that this is due to chromospheric evaporation, the process of heating
cool chromospheric material beyond its ability to radiate. The pressure
increase in the evaporated plasma leads to a number of interesting phenomena in
the flare chromosphere. The sudden pressure increase initiates a downward
moving "chromospheric condensation", an overdense region which gradually
decelerates as it accretes material and propagates into the gravitationally
stratified chromosphere. Solutions to an equation of motion for this
condensation shows that its motion decays after about one minute of propagation
into the chromosphere. When the front of this downflowing region is supersonic
relative to the atmosphere ahead of it, a radiating shock will form. If the
downflow is rapid enough, the shock strength should be sufficient to excite UV
radiation normally associated with the transition region, and furthermore, the
radiating shock will be brighter than the transition region. These results lead
to a number of observationally testable relationships between the optical and
ultraviolet spectra from the condensation and radiating shock.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.4916 [pdf] - 902857
Estimating Electric Fields from Vector Magnetogram Sequences
Submitted: 2009-12-24, last modified: 2010-05-06
Determining the electric field (E-field) distribution on the Sun's
photosphere is essential for quantitative studies of how energy flows from the
Sun's photosphere, through the corona, and into the heliosphere. This E-field
also provides valuable input for data-driven models of the solar atmosphere and
the Sun-Earth system. We show how Faraday's Law can be used with observed
vector magnetogram time series to estimate the photospheric E-field, an
ill-posed inversion problem. Our method uses a "poloidal-toroidal
decomposition" (PTD) of the time derivative of the vector magnetic field. The
PTD solutions are not unique; the gradient of a scalar potential can be added
to the PTD E-field without affecting consistency with Faraday's Law. We present
an iterative technique to determine a potential function consistent with ideal
MHD evolution; but this E-field is also not a unique solution to Faraday's Law.
Finally, we explore a variational approach that minimizes an energy functional
to determine a unique E-field, similar to Longcope's "Minimum Energy Fit". The
PTD technique, the iterative technique, and the variational technique are used
to estimate E-fields from a pair of synthetic vector magnetograms taken from an
MHD simulation; and these E-fields are compared with the simulation's known
electric fields. These three techniques are then applied to a pair of vector
magnetograms of solar active region NOAA AR8210, to demonstrate the methods
with real data.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.0641 [pdf] - 160393
Improving Large-scale Convection Zone-to-Corona Models
Submitted: 2010-05-04
We introduce two new methods that are designed to improve the realism and
utility of large, active region-scale 3D MHD models of the solar atmosphere. We
apply these methods to RADMHD, a code capable of modeling the Sun's upper
convection zone, photosphere, chromosphere, transition region, and corona
within a single computational volume. We first present a way to approximate the
physics of optically-thick radiative transfer without having to take the
computationally expensive step of solving the radiative transfer equation in
detail. We then briefly describe a rudimentary assimilative technique that
allows a time series of vector magnetograms to be directly incorporated into
the MHD system.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.5318 [pdf] - 1026587
On the Mechanical Energy Available to Drive Solar Flares
Submitted: 2010-04-29
Where does solar flare energy come from? More specifically, assuming that the
ultimate source of flare energy is mechanical energy in the convection zone,
how is this translated into energy dissipated or stored in the corona? This
question appears to have been given relatively little thought, as attention has
been focussed predominantly on mechanisms for the rapid dissipation of coronal
magnetic energy by way of MHD instabilities and plasma micro instabilities. We
consider three types of flare theory: the steady state "photospheric dynamo"
model in which flare power represents coronal dissipation of currents generated
simultaneously by sub-photospheric flows; the "magnetic energy storage" model
where sub-photospheric flows again induce coronal currents but which in this
case are built up over a longer period before being released suddenly; and
"emerging flux" models, in which new magnetic flux rising to the photosphere
already contains free energy, and does not require subsequent stressing by
photospheric motions. We conclude that photospheric dynamos can power only very
minor flares; that coronal energy storage can in principle meet the
requirements of a major flare, although perhaps not the very largest flares,
but that difficulties in coupling efficiently to the energy source may limit
this mechanism to moderate sized flares; and that emerging magnetic flux tubes,
generated in the solar interior, can carry sufficient free energy to power even
the largest flares ever observed.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:0905.0529 [pdf] - 23932
What is the relationship between photospheric flow fields and solar
flares?
Submitted: 2009-05-05, last modified: 2009-10-14
We estimated photospheric velocities by separately applying the Fourier Local
Correlation Tracking (FLCT) and Differential Affine Velocity Estimator (DAVE)
methods to 2708 co-registered pairs of SOHO/MDI magnetograms, with nominal
96-minute cadence and ~2" pixels, from 46 active regions (ARs) from 1996-1998
over the time interval t45 when each AR was within 45^o of disk center. For
each magnetogram pair, we computed the average estimated radial magnetic field,
B; and each tracking method produced an independently estimated flow field, u.
We then quantitatively characterized these magnetic and flow fields by
computing several extensive and intensive properties of each; extensive
properties scale with AR size, while intensive properties do not depend
directly on AR size. Intensive flow properties included moments of speeds,
horizontal divergences, and radial curls; extensive flow properties included
sums of these properties over each AR, and a crude proxy for the ideal Poynting
flux, the total |u| B^2. Several magnetic quantities were also computed,
including: total unsigned flux; a measure of the amount of unsigned flux near
strong-field polarity inversion lines, R; and the total B^2. Next, using
correlation and discriminant analysis, we investigated the associations between
these properties and flares from the GOES flare catalog, when averaged over
both t45 and shorter time windows, of 6 and 24 hours. We found R and total |u|
B^2 to be most strongly associated with flares; no intensive flow properties
were strongly associated with flares.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.4289 [pdf] - 8506
FLCT: A Fast, Efficient Method for Performing Local Correlation Tracking
Submitted: 2007-12-28
We describe the computational techniques employed in the recently updated
Fourier local correlation tracking (FLCT) method. The FLCT code is then
evaluated using a series of simple, 2D, known flow patterns that test its
accuracy and characterize its errors.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:0710.0546 [pdf] - 5579
Surface Flows From Magnetograms
Submitted: 2007-10-02
Estimates of velocities from time series of photospheric and/or chromospheric
vector magnetograms can be used to determine fluxes of magnetic energy (the
Poynting flux) and helicity across the magnetogram layer, and to provide
time-dependent boundary conditions for data-driven simulations of the solar
atmosphere above this layer. Velocity components perpendicular to the magnetic
field are necessary both to compute these transport rates and to derive model
boundary conditions. Here, we discuss some possible approaches to estimating
perpendicular flows from magnetograms. Since Doppler shifts contain
contributions from flows parallel to the magnetic field, perpendicular
velocities are not generally recoverable from Doppler shifts alone. The
induction equation's vertical component relates evolution in $B_z$ to the
perpendicular flow field, but has a finite null space, meaning some ``null''
flows, e.g., motions along contours of normal field, do not affect $B_z$.
Consequently, additional information is required to accurately specify the
perpendicular flow field. Tracking methods, which analyze $\partial_t B_z$ in a
neighborhood, have a long heritage, but other approaches have recently been
developed. In a recent paper, several such techniques were tested using
synthetic magnetograms from MHD simulations. Here, we use the same test data to
characterize: 1) the ability of the induction equation's normal component, by
itself, to estimate flows; and 2) a tracking method's ability to recover flow
components that are perpendicular to $\mathbf{B}$ and parallel to contours of
$B_z$. This work has been supported by NASA Heliophysics Theory grant
NNG05G144G.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0506027 [pdf] - 73427
Convective Dynamos and the Minimum X-ray Flux in Main Sequence Stars
Submitted: 2005-06-01
The objective of this paper is to investigate whether a convective dynamo can
account quantitatively for the observed lower limit of X-ray surface flux in
solar-type main sequence stars. Our approach is to use 3D numerical simulations
of a turbulent dynamo driven by convection to characterize the dynamic
behavior, magnetic field strengths, and filling factors in a non-rotating
stratified medium, and to predict these magnetic properties at the surface of
cool stars. We use simple applications of stellar structure theory for the
convective envelopes of main-sequence stars to scale our simulations to the
outer layers of stars in the F0--M0 spectral range, which allows us to estimate
the unsigned magnetic flux on the surface of non-rotating reference stars. With
these estimates we use the recent results of \citet{Pevtsov03} to predict the
level of X-ray emission from such a turbulent dynamo, and find that our results
compare well with observed lower limits of surface X-ray flux. If we scale our
predicted X-ray fluxes to \ion{Mg}{2} fluxes we also find good agreement with
the observed lower limit of chromospheric emission in K dwarfs. This suggests
that dynamo action from a convecting, non-rotating plasma is a viable
alternative to acoustic heating models as an explanation for the basal emission
level seen in chromospheric, transition region, and coronal diagnostics from
late-type stars.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0008501 [pdf] - 37817
The Effects of Rotation on the Evolution of Rising Omega-loops in a
Stratified Model Convection Zone
Submitted: 2000-08-30
We present three-dimensional MHD simulations of buoyant magnetic flux tubes
that rise through a stratified model convection zone in the presence of solar
rotation. The equations of MHD are solved in the anelastic approximation, and
the results are used to determine the effects of solar rotation on the dynamic
evolution an Omega-loop. We find that the Coriolis force significantly
suppresses the degree of fragmentation at the apex of the loop during its
ascent toward the photosphere. If the initial axial field strength of the tube
is reduced, then, in the absence of forces due to convective motions, the
degree of apex fragmentation is also reduced. We show that the Coriolis force
slows the rise of the tube, and induces a retrograde flow in both the
magnetized and unmagnetized plasma of an emerging active region.
Observationally, we predict that this flow will appear to originate at the
leading polarity, and will terminate at the trailing polarity.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0004031 [pdf] - 35391
The Three-dimensional Evolution of Rising, Twisted Magnetic Flux Tubes
in a Gravitationally Stratified Model Convection Zone
Submitted: 2000-04-03
We present three-dimensional numerical simulations of the rise and
fragmentation of twisted, initially horizontal magnetic flux tubes which evolve
into emerging Omega-loops. The flux tubes rise buoyantly through an
adiabatically stratified plasma that represents the solar convection zone. The
MHD equations are solved in the anelastic approximation, and the results are
compared with studies of flux tube fragmentation in two dimensions. We find
that if the initial amount of field line twist is below a critical value, the
degree of fragmentation at the apex of a rising Omega-loop depends on its
three-dimensional geometry: the greater the apex curvature of a given
Omega-loop, the lesser the degree of fragmentation of the loop as it approaches
the photosphere. Thus, the amount of initial twist necessary for the loop to
retain its cohesion can be reduced substantially from the two-dimensional
limit. The simulations also suggest that as a fragmented flux tube emerges
through a relatively quiet portion of the solar disk, extended crescent-shaped
magnetic features of opposite polarity should form and steadily recede from one
another. These features eventually coalesce after the fragmented portion of the
Omega-loop emerges through the photosphere.