sort results by

Use logical operators AND, OR, NOT and round brackets to construct complex queries. Whitespace-separated words are treated as ANDed.

Show articles per page in mode

Fenner, Yeshe

Normalized to: Fenner, Y.

21 article(s) in total. 50 co-authors, from 1 to 17 common article(s). Median position in authors list is 2,0.

[1]  oai:arXiv.org:1912.06305  [pdf] - 2015855
Ground-Based Gravitational-Wave Astronomy in Australia: 2019 White Paper
Comments: 8 pages, 7 figures
Submitted: 2019-12-12, last modified: 2019-12-16
The past four years have seen a scientific revolution through the birth of a new field: gravitational-wave astronomy. The first detection of gravitational waves---recognised by the 2017 Nobel Prize in Physics---provided unprecedented tests of general relativity while unveiling a previously unknown class of massive black holes, thirty times more massive than the Sun. The subsequent detection of gravitational waves from a merging binary neutron star confirmed the hypothesised connection between binary neutron stars and short gamma-ray bursts while providing an independent measurement of the expansion of the Universe. The discovery enabled precision measurement of the speed of gravity while shedding light on the origin of heavy elements. At the time of writing, the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO) and its European partner, Virgo, have published the detection of eleven gravitational-wave events. New, not-yet-published detections are announced on a nearly weekly basis. This fast-growing catalogue of gravitational-wave transients is expected to yield insights into a number of topics, from the equation of state of matter at supra-nuclear densities to the fate of massive stars. The science potential of 3G observatories is enormous, enabling measurements of gravitational waves from the edge of the Universe and precise determination of the neutron star equation of state. Australia is well-positioned to help develop the required technology. The Mid-term Review for the Decadal plan for Australian astronomy 2016-2025 should consider investment in a scoping study for an Australian Gravitational-Wave Pathfinder that develops and validates core technologies required for the global 3G detector network.
[2]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610860  [pdf] - 86284
An Evolutionary Model For Submillimeter Galaxies
Comments: 19 pages, 27 figures, Submitted to ApJ, higher resolution figures can be found at http://www.cfa.harvard.edu/~schakrab/smg.ps
Submitted: 2006-10-29
[abridged]We calculate multi-wavelength spectral energy distributions (SEDs) (spanning optical to millimeter wavelengths) from simulations of major galaxy mergers with black hole feedback which produce submillimeter bright galaxies (SMGs), using a self-consistent three-dimensional radiative transfer code. We reproduce correlations for local AGN observed in Spitzer Space Telescope's IRAC bands, and make definitive predictions for infrared X-ray correlations that should be testable by combining observations by Spitzer and the upcoming Herschel mission with X-ray surveys. Our dynamical approach allows us to directly correlate observed clustering in the data as seen in IRAC color-color plots with the relative amount of time the system spends in a region of color-color space. We also find that this clustering is positively correlated with the stars dominating in their contribution to the total bolometric luminosity. We present photo albums spanning the lifetime of SMGs, from their infancy in the pre-merger phase to the final stage as an elliptical galaxy, as seen in the observed $3.6 \micron$ and $450 \micron$ band to visually illustrate some of the morphological differences between mergers of differing orbital inclination and progenitor redshift. We find that SMGs are a broader class of systems than starbursts or quasars. We introduce a simple, heuristic classification scheme on the basis of the $L_{\rm IR}/L_{\rm x}$ ratios of these galaxies, which may be interpreted qualitatively as an evolutionary scheme, as these galaxies evolve in $L_{\rm IR}/L_{\rm x}$ while transiting from the pre-merger stage, through the quasar phase, to a merger remnant.
[3]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0608366  [pdf] - 84243
The Chemical Evolution of Helium in Globular Clusters: Implications for the Self-Pollution Scenario
Comments: accepted for publication in ApJ
Submitted: 2006-08-17
We investigate the suggestion that there are stellar populations in some globular clusters with enhanced helium (Y from 0.28 to 0.40) compared to the primordial value. We assume that a previous generation of massive Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars have polluted the cluster. Two independent sets of AGB yields are used to follow the evolution of helium and CNO using a Salpeter initial mass function (IMF) and two top-heavy IMFs. In no case are we able to produce the postulated large Y ~ 0.35 without violating the observational constraint that the CNO content is nearly constant.
[4]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0605540  [pdf] - 82227
Helium enhancements in globular cluster stars from Asymptotic Giant Branch star pollution
Comments: To appear in Proceedings of The VIII Torino Workshop on Nucleosynthesis in AGB stars: Constraints on AGB Nucleosynthesis from Observations, edited by C. Abia and I. Dominguez
Submitted: 2006-05-21
Using a chemical evolution model we investigate the intriguing suggestion that there are populations of stars in some globular clusters (e.g. NGC 2808, omega Centauri) with enhanced levels of helium (Y from about 0.28 to 0.40) compared to the majority of the population that presumably have a primordial helium abundance. We assume that a previous generation of massive low-metallicity Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars has polluted the cluster gas via a slow stellar wind. We use two independent sets of AGB yields computed from detailed models to follow the evolution of helium, carbon, nitrogen and oxygen in the cluster gas using a Salpeter initial mass function (IMF) and a number of top-heavy IMFs. In no case were we able to fit the observational constraints, Y > 0.30 and C+N+O approximately constant. Depending on the shape of the IMF and the yields, we either obtained Y approximately greater than 0.30 and large increases in C+N+O or Y < 0.30 and C+N+O approximately constant. These results suggest that either AGB stars alone are not responsible for the large helium enrichment or that any dredge-up from this generation of stars was less than predicted by standard models.
[5]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602489  [pdf] - 80065
Cosmological implications of dwarf spheroidal chemical evolution
Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures. Accepted for publication in ApJ. Minor changes following referee report
Submitted: 2006-02-22, last modified: 2006-04-10
The chemical properties of dwarf spheroidals in the local group are shown to be inconsistent with star formation being truncated after the reionization epoch (z~8). Enhanced levels of [Ba/Y] in stars in dwarf spheroidals like Sculptor indicate strong s-process production from low-mass stars whose lifetimes are comparable with the duration of the pre-reionization epoch. The chemical evolution of Sculptor is followed using a model with SNeII and SNeIa feedback and mass- and metallicity-dependent nucleosynthetic yields for elements from H to Pb. We are unable to reproduce the Ba/Y ratio unless stars formed over an interval long enough for the low-mass stars to pollute the interstellar medium with s-elements. This robust result challenges the suggestion that most of the local group dwarf spheroidals are fossils of reionization and supports the case for large initial dark matter halos.
[6]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0505378  [pdf] - 73148
Abundance Anomalies in NGC6752 - Do AGB Stars Have a Role?
Comments: To be published in: Nuclear Physics, Section A. 4 pages, 2 figures. Conference: "The Eighth International Symposium on Nuclei in the Cosmos", Canada, July 2004
Submitted: 2005-05-18
We are in the process of testing a popular theory that the observed abundance anomalies in the Globular Cluster NGC 6752 are due to `internal pollution' from intermediate mass asymptotic giant branch stars. To this end we are using a chemical evolution model incorporating custom-made stellar evolution yields calculated using a detailed stellar evolution code. By tracing the chemical evolution of the intracluster gas, which is polluted by two generations of stars, we are able to test the internal pollution scenario in which the Na- and Al-enhanced ejecta from intermediate mass stars is either accreted onto the surfaces of other stars, or goes toward forming new stars. In this paper we focus mainly on the nucleosynthetic yields of the AGB stars and discuss whether these stars are the source of the observed Na-O anticorrelation. Comparing our preliminary results with observational data suggests that the qualitative theory is not supported by this quantitative study.
[7]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0501168  [pdf] - 70280
On variations in the fine-structure constant and stellar pollution of quasar absorption systems
Comments: Accepted by MNRAS. 13 pages, 14 ps figures
Submitted: 2005-01-10, last modified: 2005-03-30
At redshifts z_abs < 2, quasar absorption-line constraints on space-time variations in the fine-structure constant, alpha, rely on the comparison of MgII and FeII transition wavelengths. One potentially important uncertainty is the relative abundance of Mg isotopes in the absorbers which, if different from solar, can cause spurious shifts in the measured wavelengths and, therefore, alpha. Here we explore chemical evolution models with enhanced populations of intermediate-mass (IM) stars which, in their asymptotic giant branch (AGB) phase, are thought to be the dominant factories for heavy Mg isotopes at the low metallicities typical of quasar absorption systems. By design, these models partially explain recent Keck/HIRES evidence for a smaller alpha in z_abs < 2 absorption clouds than on Earth. However, such models also over-produce N, violating observed abundance trends in high-z_abs damped Lyman-alpha systems (DLAs). Our results do not support the recent claim of Ashenfelter, Mathews & Olive (2004b) that similar models of IM-enhanced initial mass functions (IMFs) may simultaneously explain the HIRES varying-alpha data and DLA N abundances. We explore the effect of the IM-enhanced model on Si, Al and P abundances, finding it to be much-less pronounced than for N. We also show that the 13C/12C ratio, as measured in absorption systems, could constitute a future diagnostic of non-standard models of the high-redshift IMF.
[8]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0502280  [pdf] - 71071
Galactic Chemical Evolution Redux: Atomic Numbers 6 < Z < 15
Comments: 4 pages, Accepted for publication in Nuclear Physics A (2005); Proceedings of Nuclei in the Cosmic VIII
Submitted: 2005-02-14
Motivated by the inability of Galactic chemical evolution models to reproduce some of the observed solar neighbourhood distribution of elements (and isotopes) with atomic numbers 6 < Z < 15, we have revisited the relevant stellar and Galactic models as part of an ambitious new program aimed at resolving these long-standing discrepancies. Avoiding the use of (traditional) parametric models for low- and intermediate-mass stellar evolution, we have generated a new, physically self-consistent, suite of stellar models and integrated the nucleosynthetic outputs into GEtool, our semi-analytical galactic chemical evolution software package. The predicted temporal evolution of several light- and intermediate-mass elements (and their isotopes) in the solar neighbourhood - from carbon to phosphorus - demonstrate the efficacy of the new yields in reconciling theory and observation.
[9]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0501355  [pdf] - 329100
Stellar abundance gradients in galactic disks. I. Method and spectral line gradients
Comments: Accepted by MNRAS. 16 pages
Submitted: 2005-01-17
We describe the technique of absorption line imaging of galaxy disks using the Taurus Tunable Filter on the Anglo-Australian Telescope and demonstrate its sensitivity to the behaviour of spectral features associated with Mg and Fe. Radial profiles of Mg2 and Fe5270 line-strengths are presented for a sample of eight face-on spiral galaxies spanning a range of Hubble types. Signatures of phenomena including merger-induced star formation, HII rings and galactic bars are also reported. This study demonstrates the capacity of tunable filters to measure Mg and Fe line-strengths across the face of spiral galaxies, which can ultimately reveal clues about the star formation history and chemical evolution.
[10]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0410579  [pdf] - 68428
Contrasting the chemical evolution of the Milky Way and Andromeda galaxies
Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures. MNRAS in press
Submitted: 2004-10-24
The chemical evolution history of a galaxy hides clues about how it formed and has been changing through time. We have studied the chemical evolution history of the Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31) to find which are common features in the chemical evolution of disc galaxies as well as which are galaxy-dependent. We use a semi-analytic multi-zone chemical evolution model. Such models have succeeded in explaining the mean trends of the observed chemical properties in these two Local Group spiral galaxies with similar mass and morphology. Our results suggest that while the evolution of the MW and M31 shares general similarities, differences in the formation history are required to explain the observations in detail. In particular, we found that the observed higher metallicity in the M31 halo can be explained by either a) a higher halo star formation efficiency or b) a larger reservoir of infalling halo gas with a longer halo formation phase. These two different pictures would lead to a) a higher [O/Fe] at low metallicities or b) younger stellar populations in the M31 halo, respectively. Both pictures result in a more massive stellar halo in M31, which suggests a possible correlation between the halo metallicity and its stellar mass.
[11]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0410580  [pdf] - 68429
On the origin of fluorine in the Milky Way
Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures. MNRAS in press
Submitted: 2004-10-24
The main astrophysical factories of fluorine (19F) are thought to be Type II supernovae, Wolf-Rayet stars, and the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) of intermediate mass stars. We present a model for the chemical evolution of fluorine in the Milky Way using a semi-analytic multi-zone chemical evolution model. For the first time, we demonstrate quantitatively the impact of fluorine nucleosynthesis in Wolf-Rayet and AGB stars. The inclusion of these latter two fluorine production sites provides a possible solution to the long-standing discrepancy between model predictions and the fluorine abundances observed in Milky Way giants. Finally, fluorine is discussed as a possible probe of the role of supernovae and intermediate mass stars in the chemical evolution history of the globular cluster omega Centauri.
[12]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0406360  [pdf] - 65517
Modelling self-pollution of globular clusters from AGB stars
Comments: 7 pages. Accepted for publication in MNRAS
Submitted: 2004-06-15
A self-consistent model of the chemical evolution of the globular cluster NGC 6752 is presented to test a popular theory that observed abundance anomalies are due to ``internal pollution'' from intermediate mass asymptotic giant branch stars. We simulated the chemical evolution of the intracluster medium under the assumption that the products of Type II SNe are completely expelled from the globular cluster, whereas material ejected from stars with m < 7 M_sun is retained, due to their weak stellar winds. By tracing the chemical evolution of the intracluster gas, we tested an internal pollution scenario in which the Na- and Al-enhanced ejecta from intermediate mass stars is either accreted onto the surfaces of other stars, or goes toward forming new stars. The observed spread in Na and Al was reproduced, but not the O-Na and Mg-Al anticorrelations. In particular, neither O nor Mg are sufficiently depleted to account for the observations. We predict that the Mg content of Na-rich cluster stars should be overwhelmingly dominated by the 25,26Mg isotopes, whereas the latest data shows only a mild 26Mg enhancement and no correlation with 25Mg. Furthermore, stars bearing the imprint of intermediate mass stellar ejecta are predicted to be strongly enhanced in both C and N, in conflict with the empirical data. We find that while standard AGB stellar models do show the hot H burning that seems required to explain the observations, this is accompanied by He burning, producing primary C, N, Mg and Na (via HBB) which do not match the observations. (Abridged)
[13]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0401413  [pdf] - 62283
Constraints on Early Nucleosynthesis from the Abundance Pattern of a Damped Ly-alpha System at z = 2.626
Comments: 12 pages, 7 figs. Accepted for publication in ApJ (The Astrophysical Journal)
Submitted: 2004-01-21
We have investigated chemical evolution in the young universe by analysing the detailed chemical enrichment pattern of a metal-rich galaxy at high redshift. The recent detection of over 20 elements in the gas-phase of a damped Lyman-alpha absorber (DLA) at z = 2.626 represents an exciting new avenue for exploring early nucleosynthesis. Given a strict upper age of ~2.5 Gyr and a gas-phase metallicity about one third solar, we have shown the DLA abundance pattern to be consistent with the predictions of a chemical evolution model in which the interstellar enrichment is dominated by massive stars with a small contribution from Type Ia supernovae. Discrepancies between the empirical data and the models are used to highlight outstanding issues in nucleosynthesis theory, including a tendency for Type II supernovae models to overestimate the magnitude of the "odd-even" effect at subsolar metallicities. Our results suggest a possible need for supplemental sources of magnesium and zinc, beyond that provided by massive stars.
[14]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0401282  [pdf] - 62152
Photometric Properties of White Dwarf Dominated Halos
Comments: 4 pages, Refereed contribution to the 5th Galactic Chemodynamics conference held in Swinburne, July 2003. Accepted for publication in PASA
Submitted: 2004-01-14
Using stellar population synthesis techniques, we explore the photometric signatures of white dwarf progenitor dominated galactic halos, in order to constrain the fraction of halo mass that may be locked-up in white dwarf stellar remnants. We first construct a 10^9 M_sun stellar halo using the canonical Salpeter initial stellar mass distribution, and then allow for an additional component of low- and intermediate-mass stars, which ultimately give rise to white dwarf remnants. Microlensing observations towards the Large Magellanic Cloud, coupled with several ground-based proper motion surveys, have led to claims that in excess of 20% of the dynamical mass of the halo (10^12 M_sun) might be found in white dwarfs. Our results indicate that (1) even if only 1% of the dynamical mass of the dark halo today could be attributed to white dwarfs, their main sequence progenitors at high redshift (z ~ 3) would have resulted in halos more than 100 times more luminous than those expected from conventional initial mass functions alone, and (2) any putative halo white dwarf progenitor dominated initial mass function component, regardless of its dynamical importance, would be virtually impossible to detect at the present-day, due to its extremely faint surface brightness.
[15]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0401024  [pdf] - 61894
The Galactic Habitable Zone and the Age Distribution of Complex Life in the Milky Way
Comments: 9 pages, 4 figs. Published in Science, 2 January 2004
Submitted: 2004-01-05
We modeled the evolution of the Milky Way to trace the distribution in space and time of four prerequisites for complex life: the presence of a host star, enough heavy elements to form terrestrial planets, sufficient time for biological evolution and an environment free of life-extinguishing supernovae. We identified the Galactic habitable zone (GHZ) as an annular region between 7 and 9 kiloparsecs from the Galactic center that widens with time and is composed of stars that formed between 8 and 4 billion years ago. This GHZ yields an age distribution for the complex life that may inhabit our Galaxy. We found that 75% of the stars in the GHZ are older than the Sun.
[16]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0312255  [pdf] - 61468
Galactic Chemical Evolution
Comments: 16 pages, 9 figures, 1 table, LaTeX (emulatepasa.sty). Invited Review, accepted for publication in the Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia, Vol 20, Num 4 (2003)
Submitted: 2003-12-10
The primary present-day observables upon which theories of galaxy evolution are based are a system's morphology, dynamics, colour, and chemistry. Individually, each provides an important constraint to any given model; in concert, the four represent a fundamental (intractable) boundary condition for chemodynamical simulations. We review the current state-of-the-art semi-analytical and chemodynamical models for the Milky Way, emphasising the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches.
[17]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0307445  [pdf] - 58158
The Chemical Evolution of Magnesium Isotopic Abundances in the Solar Neighbourhood
Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures, to appear in Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia (PASA) in 2003, vol. 20, No. 4
Submitted: 2003-07-25
The abundance of the neutron-rich magnesium isotopes observed in metal-poor stars is explained quantitatively with a chemical evolution model of the local Galaxy that considers - for the first time - the metallicity-dependent contribution from intermediate mass stars. Previous models that simulate the variation of Mg isotopic ratios with metallicity in the solar neighbourhood have attributed the production of Mg25 and Mg26 exclusively to hydrostatic burning in massive stars. These models match the data well for [Fe/H]>-1.0 but severely underestimate Mg25/Mg24 and Mg26/Mg24 at lower metallicities. Earlier studies have noted that this discrepancy may indicate a significant role played by intermediate-mass stars. Only recently have detailed calculations of intermediate-mass stellar yields of Mg25 and Mg26 become available with which to test this hypothesis. In an extension of previous work, we present a model that successfully matches the Mg isotopic abundances in nearby Galactic disk stars through the incorporation of nucleosynthesis predictions of Mg isotopic production in asymptotic giant branch stars.
[18]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0304320  [pdf] - 56228
Deriving the Metallicity Distribution Function of Galactic Systems
Comments: 16 pages, 5 figures, accepted for publication in PASA (Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia)
Submitted: 2003-04-17
The chemical evolution of the Milky Way is investigated using a dual-phase metal-enriched infall model in which primordial gas fuels the earliest epoch of star formation, followed by the ongoing formation of stars from newly accreted gas. The latest metallicity distribution of local K-dwarfs is reproduced by this model, which allows the Galactic thin disk to form from slightly metal-enriched gas with alpha-element enhancement. Our model predicts ages for the stellar halo and thin disk of 12.5 and 7.4 Gyr, respectively, in agreement with empirically determined values. The model presented in this paper is compared with a similar dual-phase infall model from Chiappini et al. (2001). We discuss a degeneracy that enables both models to recover the K-dwarf metallicity distribution while yielding different star formation histories. The metallicity distribution function (MDF) of K-dwarfs is proposed to be more directly comparable to chemical evolution model results than the G-dwarf distribution because lower mass K-dwarfs are less susceptible to stellar evolutionary effects. The K-dwarf MDF should consequently be a better probe of star formation history and provide a stronger constraint to chemical evolution models than the widely used G-dwarf MDF. The corrections that should be applied to a G-dwarf MDF are quantified for the case of the outer halo of NGC 5128.
[19]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0205249  [pdf] - 49323
Galaxy Evolution tool: Construction and Applications
Comments: 2 pages, 4 figures, to appear in "The Evolution of Galaxies II: Basic Building Blocks", (2002) ed. M. Sauvage et al. (Kluwer)
Submitted: 2002-05-15
We present a dual-infall galactic chemical evolution model which uses a new set of stellar yields calculated by Limongi et al (2001) to constrain the amount of iron-peak elements ejected by massive stars. The age-metallicity relation, G-dwarf distribution and evolution of abundance ratios are predicted using Galaxy Evolution tool (GEtool), a software package currently being developed to self-consistenly model the chemical and spectral evolution of disk galaxies. A comparison with results obtained using the Woosley & Weaver (1995) core-collapse supernova models suggests that the observed behaviour of key abundance patterns cannot be reproduced if the iron yield of massive stars increases with initial mass.
[20]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0203217  [pdf] - 48238
A Limit on the Metallicity of Compact High Velocity Clouds
Comments: 15 pages, 3 postscript figures + 1 JPEG figure (reduced from postscript for size considerations), accepted for publication in ApJ (June 2002)
Submitted: 2002-03-13
There is a fortuitous coincidence in the positions of the quasar TonS210 and the compact H I high velocity cloud CHVC224.0-83.4-197 on the sky. Using Far Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer observations of the metal-line absorption in this cloud and sensitive H I 21cm emission observations obtained with the multibeam system at Parkes Observatory, we determine a metallicity of (O/H) <0.46 solar at a confidence of 3 sigma. The metallicity of the high velocity gas is consistent with either an extragalactic or Magellanic Cloud origin, but is not consistent with a location inside the Milky Way unless the chemical history of the gas is considerably different from that of the interstellar medium in the Galactic disk and halo. Combined with measurements of highly ionized species (C III and O VI) at high velocities, this metallicity limit indicates that the cloud has a substantial halo of ionized gas; there is as much ionized gas as neutral gas directly along the Ton S210 sight line. We suggest several observational tests that would improve the metallicity determination substantially and help to distinguish between possible origins for the high velocity gas. Additional observations of this sight line would be valuable since the number of compact HVCs positioned in front of background sources bright enough for high resolution absorption-line studies is extremely limited.
[21]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0107496  [pdf] - 43867
Are High-Velocity Clouds the Building Blocks of the Local Group?
Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures, LaTeX (newpasp), also available at http://astronomy.swin.edu.au/bgibson/publications.html, to appear in Extragalactic Gas at Low Redshift, ed. J.S. Mulchaey & J.T. Stocke, ASP Conference Series, in press (2002). Corrected a few minor typos. No content revisions, though
Submitted: 2001-07-26, last modified: 2001-08-04
Motivated by the apparent order-of-magnitude discrepancy between the observed number of Local Group satellite galaxies, and that predicted by Lambda-CDM hierarchical clustering cosmologies, we explore an alternate suggestion - perhaps the missing satellites are not actually ``missing'', but are instead ``in disguise''. The disguise we consider here is that of the classical HI High-Velocity Clouds. Is it possible that what have been thought of traditionally as a ``Galactic'' phenomenon, are actually the building blocks of the Local Group? We discuss the strengths and weaknesses of this hypothesis, and highlight avenues of future research which may provide an unequivocal resolution to this contentious issue.