Normalized to: Edmonds, I.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.10703 [pdf] - 1791611
Assessment of a planetary model to predict Rieger periodicity in
sunspots and flares
Submitted: 2018-11-26
This paper develops a planetary model to predict the occurrence of
intermediate range periodicity in solar activity, in particular the ~155 day
Rieger periodicity in flare activity. It is shown that periodicity at half
integer multiples of the period of Mercury occurs consistently in indices of
solar activity. For this reason the planetary model is based on the triggering
of sunspot emergence when planetary tides peak at times of conjunction of
Mercury with Venus, Earth and/or Jupiter. The periodicity of components in the
planetary model match reasonably well the observed intermediate periodicity in
sunspot and flare activity with the strongest model component occurring at 155
day period. A comparison of filtered versions of the model and the N.O.A.A.
flare index at 155 day periodicity demonstrates the potential for both short
term, (within a solar cycle), and longer term, (over several solar cycles),
predictive capability of the model. However, this assessment finds that
prediction of 155 day periodicity in flare activity is effective only when the
north and south hemispheric components of flare activity are in-phase.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.04240 [pdf] - 1513818
Revisiting 154-day periodicity in the occurrence of hard flares. A
planetary influence?
Submitted: 2016-11-13
Rieger et al (1984) reported observations of a 154 day periodicity in flares
during solar cycle 21. This paper discusses the observations in the light of a
simple empirical planetary model of sunspot emergence. The planetary model
predicts sunspot emergence when Mercury and Earth approach conjunction and
Mercury approaches the Sun. We show that the reported times of flare activity
are coherent with the planetary model. While the base period of the model is
170 days, the average model period, over the interval of flare recordings, is
157 days due to a 180 degree phase change in the planetary forcing near the
middle of the record interval. We conclude that the periodicity at 154 days
arises when the phase change in planetary forcing and the resulting progressive
phase change in total sunspot area emergence and flare occurrence shifts the
major peak in the flare spectrum from the planetary forcing period, 170 days,
to 154 days.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.02632 [pdf] - 1494104
Planetary model of sunspot emergence: A spectral and autocorrelation
analysis
Submitted: 2016-10-09
This paper is concerned with intermediate range periodicity in the sunspot
area spectrum. An empirical model of sunspot area emergence based on Mercury
planet conjunctions was developed and the spectra of the model variation and
the sunspot area variation compared. By including solar cycle amplitude
modulation and the effect of solar magnetic field reversal the model was able
to predict fine detail in the sunspot area spectrum. As Mercury planet
conjunctions occur predictably it was possible to compare the time variation of
band limited components of sunspot area with the corresponding component
variations in the model. When the model component variation was stable
corresponding components of sunspot area lagged the model variation by a few
tens of days. When a 180 degree phase change occurred in the model variation
the corresponding component of sunspot area followed the change over an
interval of a few hundred days, first by decreasing to zero and then emerging
in phase with the model variation. Where periodicities in sunspot area did not
match periods of Fourier components of the model the autocorrelation function
of the model variation provided an indirect numerical link to these
periodicities. Included in these indirect periodicities were components at
periods of about 138, 235, 355, 472, 530, 605, 833, 1190 and 2020 days. Direct
periodicities in the model, those linked directly to Fourier components of
sunspot area, included components at about 88, 116, 176, 200, 292 and 405 days.
The model was developed without allowing for a variable threshold for sunspot
emergence. However, it was found that with a variable threshold above which the
model variation is effective in triggering sunspots, weak Fourier components at
the indirect periods were generated. The model with threshold then encompasses
all of the significant intermediate range periodicities in sunspot area.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.05028 [pdf] - 1493873
Are intermediate range periodicities in sunspot area associated with
planetary motion?
Submitted: 2016-05-17, last modified: 2016-10-09
In this paper we examine the possibility that intermediate range
periodicities in sunspot area can be linked to Mercury or to Mercury-planet
conjunction periods. We show that peaks at the 45 day Mercury-Jupiter
conjunction period, the 116 day first harmonic period of the Mercury-Earth
conjunction and the 289 day period of the sub harmonic
Mercury-Venus/Mercury-Earth conjunctions are prominent in spectra of sunspot
area. We observe two prominent peaks close to the 88 day Mercury periodicity
and two prominent peaks close to the 176 day first sub harmonic of Mercury
periodicity. To confirm that the peaks arise as sidebands we band pass filter
the sunspot area record to isolate the 88 and 176 day components of sunspot
area. The components occur in episodes of duration from 1.5 to 4 years, with
successive episodes usually overlapping in time but, for significant intervals
in the record, the episodes were discrete, i.e. not overlapping. The time
variation of the components was compared with the time variation of the tidal
effect of Mercury. We were able to show that whenever episodes were discrete
the component of sunspot area during the episode was either in-phase or in
anti-phase with the Mercury tidal effect. We interpret this as indicating a
connection between planetary motion and sunspot emergence. When several
discrete episodes of the components occurred during a solar cycle the spectrum
of sunspot area during that solar cycle exhibited periodicities at sidebands to
the 88 day or 176 day periods, the periodicity of the sidebands depending on
the duration of the episodes. A simple model based on amplitude modulation of
88 day and 176 day period sinusoids was able to consistently reproduce the
spectral peaks, or Rieger quasi-periodicities, observed in the spectra of
sunspot area.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.02524 [pdf] - 1290850
Evidence of a planetary influence on solar activity: Phase coherence of
the variation in sunspot area with the tidal effect of Mercury
Submitted: 2015-10-08
There have been numerous reports of quasiperiodicities in solar activity in
the intermediate period range. However, no accepted explanation for the
episodic occurrence of quasiperiodicities has emerged. This paper examines the
possibility that the periodicities are associated with a Mercury Sun
interaction of base period 88 days. To test this idea we band pass filter the
140 year long daily sunspot area data to obtain the 88 day period and 176 day
sub harmonic period components of the data and compare the time variation of
the components with the time variation of the orbital radius of Mercury, or
more specifically with the time variation of the tidal effect of Mercury. We
were able to show that, when successive episodes of the occurrence of the 88
day period component were discrete and not overlapping in time, the time
variation of this component of sunspot area was either exactly in-phase or
exactly in anti-phase with the time variation of tidal effect. A similar result
was obtained for the 176 day period component. When several discrete episodes
of the components occurred during a solar cycle the spectrum of the sunspot
area data exhibited strong sidebands with periods dependent on the duration of
the episodes. A simple model based on episode modulation and solar cycle
modulation of 88 day and sub harmonic period sinusoids reproduced most of the
spectral peaks observed in the intermediate range of sunspot area periodicity.
This is compelling evidence of a link between the motion of Mercury and the
periodic emergence of sunspots. It is proposed that the link involves magnetic
surface waves with mode periods close to the sub harmonic periods associated
with Mercury and the triggering of sunspot emergence by the waves.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.3326 [pdf] - 809868
Sensitivity of sunspot area to the tidal effect of planet Mercury during
solar cycle 23
Submitted: 2014-04-12
We present evidence that the allowed periods of equatorially trapped Rossby
wave modes on the Sun coincide closely with the 88 day period and 176 day sub
harmonic period of Mercury and evidence of Rossby waves on the Sun at the same
periods. To test the hypothesis that Rossby waves trigger the emergence of
sunspots we use band pass filtering to obtain the 88 day period and 176 day
period components of hemispherical sunspot area and compare the variations to
the tidal height variation on the surface of the Sun due to Mercury. We find
that the two components of hemispherical sunspot area occur in several episodes
or activations of duration 2 to 6 years during each solar cycle. When the
activations are discrete the variation of the 88 day and 176 day period
components are phase coherent with the tidal height variation and a 180 degree
phase change is evident between successive activations. We use this result to
demonstrate that Rieger type quasi-periodicities in sunspot activity are, in
most reported cases, periodicities associated with sidebands of the 88 day and
176 day period variation. We find that, in variables that arise from activity
in both solar hemispheres, phase coherence with the Mercury tidal effect occurs
at infrequent intervals but, when it does occur, it is possible to observe
phase coherence of variables such as sunspot number, solar flares, solar wind
speed and cosmic ray flux with the Mercury tidal effect. Sensitivity of a range
of variables to the tidal effect is calculated for such intervals in solar
cycle 23.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.6007 [pdf] - 775108
Evidence of two different types of short term solar modulation of
regional surface temperature and cloud
Submitted: 2014-01-22
Recent work indicates that 27 day variations in cosmic ray flux during 2007
2009 are phase locked to 27 day variations in cloud and surface temperature at
Shetland. Here we extend the study to other regions including Central England,
US and Australia and to several other annual intervals that exhibit strong 27
day variation in cosmic ray flux and sunspot area. Band pass filtering was used
to obtain 27 day components of daily maximum temperature in each region and 27
day components of cloud variation were determined, in Australia only, from
solar exposure records. When cosmic ray flux is the dominant influence phase
locked variations in surface temperature occur in each of the regions with,
however, in phase or anti phase variation in different regions. Similar phase
locking of 27 day variation in surface temperature to sunspot area variation
occurs when sunspot activity is the dominant influence with indications that
changes from in phase to anti phase variation are linked to flipping of sunspot
activity from one active longitude to another. The 27 day component of cloud in
Australia was phase locked to the 27 day component of temperature in Central
England in two of the intervals studied, 1997 and 2005, indicating the global
nature of the connection between solar disturbance and the lower atmosphere. It
was observed that very large swings in 27 day temperature components are often
correlated with 27 day variation in solar activity.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.2712 [pdf] - 769875
Association of a planetary tidal effect with the time variation of the
~13.5 day component of geomagnetic activity
Submitted: 2014-01-13
We show that there is a previously unreported quad-annual variation in the
~13.5 day component of the aa index of geomagnetic activity. We derive a model
based on the planetary tidal effect at the solar surface due to Mercury and
Jupiter that, when combined with an equinoctial response of the magnetosphere,
predicts the times of occurrence of predominantly quad-annual variation or
predominantly semi-annual variation in the ~13.5 day component of the aa index.
In support of the model we show that, during years when the quad-annual
variation in the ~13.5 day component of aa index is predominant there is a
large component at the 88 day periodicity of Mercury in the ~13.5 day component
of solar wind speed. As further support for the model we establish that
significant peaks in the aa index spectrum are due to an 88 day modulation of
27 day period solar activity. The model also predicts the occurrence of
planetary tidal effect maximum in anti-phase with solar cycle maximums around
1970 and we show this is consistent with prior observations of higher solar
emissions during the 1975 solar cycle minimum than in the following solar cycle
maximum. This effect offers a possible explanation of the reduced solar cycle
maximums around 1970 and during the Dalton Minimum.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.0704 [pdf] - 754016
On the semi-annual, 27 day, variation in geomagnetic activity, cloud
cover and surface temperature
Submitted: 2013-12-03
We develop a basic model of the time variation of geomagnetic activity and
show that the model predicts, with decreasing levels of exactitude, the time
variation of the ~27 day period components of geomagnetic aa index, cloud cover
and surface temperature during several years near solar cycle minima. We
interpret this as indicating that there is a connection between the ~27 day
variation of geomagnetic activity and the ~27 day variations of cloud cover and
surface temperature with the decreasing correlations between model variation
and aa index, cloud cover and surface temperature variation due to delays and
phase shifts between the three variables some of which are obvious, such as the
180 degree seasonal phase shift between cloud cover and surface temperature,
and others less certain. We find that, while the components of cloud cover and
surface temperature influenced by geomagnetic activity amount to, on average,
about 20% of the overall variations, the influence may be several times higher
during the semi-annual maxima in geomagnetic activity that occur around the
equinoxes.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.0921 [pdf] - 688286
The correlation of 27 day period solar activity and daily maximum
temperature in continental Australia
Submitted: 2013-07-03
We report the first observation of a 27 day period component in daily maximum
temperature recorded at widely spaced locations in Australia. The 27 day
component, extracted by band pass filtering, is correlated with the variation
of daily solar radio flux during years close to solar minimum. We demonstrate
that the correlation is related to the emergence of regions of solar activity
on the Sun separated, temporally, from the emergence of other active regions.
In this situation, which occurs only near solar minimum, the observed 27 day
variation of temperature can be in phase or out of phase with the 27 day
variation of solar activity. During solar maximum correlation of temperature
and solar activity is much less defined. The amplitude of the 27 day
temperature response to solar activity is large, at times as high as 6 degrees
C, and much larger than the well documented temperature response to the 11 year
cycle of solar activity. We demonstrate that the 27 day temperature response is
localised to the Australian continent and increases towards the centre of the
continent. Several aspects of the 27 day temperature response are consistent
with a 27 day period solar input to the Earth continents generating large scale
planetary waves.