Normalized to: Dormy, E.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.00165 [pdf] - 1361301
Dipolar dynamos in stratified systems
Submitted: 2015-02-28, last modified: 2015-03-03
Observations of low-mass stars reveal a variety of magnetic field topologies
ranging from large-scale, axial dipoles to more complex magnetic fields. At the
same time, three-dimensional spherical simulations of convectively driven
dynamos reproduce a similar diversity, which is commonly obtained either with
Boussinesq models or with more realistic models based on the anelastic
approximation, which take into account the variation of the density with depth
throughout the convection zone. Nevertheless, a conclusion from different
anelastic studies is that dipolar solutions seem more difficult to obtain as
soon as substantial stratifications are considered. In this paper, we aim at
clarifying this point by investigating in more detail the influence of the
density stratification on dipolar dynamos. To that end, we rely on a systematic
parameter study that allows us to clearly follow the evolution of the stability
domain of the dipolar branch as the density stratification is increased. The
impact of the density stratification both on the dynamo onset and the dipole
collapse is discussed and compared to previous Boussinesq results. Furthermore,
our study indicates that the loss of the dipolar branch does not ensue from a
specific modification of the dynamo mechanisms related to the background
stratification, but could instead result from a bias as our observations
naturally favour a certain domain in the parameter space characterized by
moderate values of the Ekman number, owing to current computational
limitations. Moreover, we also show that the critical magnetic Reynolds number
of the dipolar branch is scarcely modified by the increase of the density
stratification, which provides an important insight into the global
understanding of the impact of the density stratification on the stability
domain of the dipolar dynamo branch.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.7364 [pdf] - 1361279
Topology and field strength in spherical, anelastic dynamo simulations
Submitted: 2013-12-27, last modified: 2015-03-02
Numerical modelling of convection driven dynamos in the Boussinesq
approximation revealed fundamental characteristics of the dynamo-generated
magnetic fields and the fluid flow. Because these results were obtained for an
incompressible fluid, their validity for gas planets and stars remains to be
assessed. A common approach is to take some density stratification into account
with the so-called anelastic approximation. The validity of previous results
obtained in the Boussinesq approximation is tested for anelastic models. We
point out and explain specific differences between both types of models, in
particular with respect to the field geometry and the field strength, but we
also compare scaling laws for the velocity amplitude, the magnetic dissipation
time, and the convective heat flux. Our investigation is based on a systematic
parameter study of spherical dynamo models in the anelastic approximation. We
make use of a recently developed numerical solver and provide results for the
test cases of the anelastic dynamo benchmark. The dichotomy of dipolar and
multipolar dynamos identified in Boussinesq simulations is also present in our
sample of anelastic models. Dipolar models require that the typical length
scale of convection is an order of magnitude larger than the Rossby radius.
However, the distinction between both classes of models is somewhat less
explicit than in previous studies. This is mainly due to two reasons: we found
a number of models with a considerable equatorial dipole contribution and an
intermediate overall dipole field strength. Furthermore, a large density
stratification may hamper the generation of dipole dominated magnetic fields.
Previously proposed scaling laws, such as those for the field strength, are
similarly applicable to anelastic models. It is not clear, however, if this
consistency necessarily implies similar dynamo processes in both settings.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.4743 [pdf] - 862960
Influence of the mass distribution on the magnetic field topology
Submitted: 2014-06-18, last modified: 2014-07-08
Context. Three-dimensional spherical dynamo simulations carried out within
the framework of the anelastic approximation have revealed that the established
distinction between dipolar and multipolar dynamos tends to be less clear than
it was in Boussinesq studies. This result was first interpreted as a direct
consequence of the existence of a larger number of models with a high
equatorial dipole contribution, together with an intermediate dipole field
strength. However, this finding has not been clearly related to specific
changes that would have been introduced by the use of the anelastic
approximation. Aims. In this paper, we primarily focus on the effects of
choosing of a different mass distribution. Indeed, it is likely to have as
large consequences as would taking a stratified reference state into account,
especially when comparing our results to previous Boussinesq studies. Methods.
Our investigation is based on a systematic parameter study of weakly stratified
anelastic dynamo models. Results. We show that the tendencies highlighted in
previous anelastic dynamo simulations are already present in the Boussinesq
limit. Thus they cannot be systematically related to anelastic effects.
Actually, a central mass distribution can result in changes in the magnetic
field topology that are mainly due to the concentration of convective cells
close to the inner sphere.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.3341 [pdf] - 749230
Evidence for dynamo bistability among very low mass stars
Submitted: 2012-08-16, last modified: 2013-11-20
Dynamo action in fully convective stars is a debated issue that also
questions our understanding of magnetic field generation in partly convective
Sun-like stars. During the past few years, spectropolari- metric observations
have demonstrated that fully convective objects are able to trigger strong
large-scale and long-lived magnetic fields. We present here the first
spectropolarimetric study of a sample of active late M dwarfs (M5-M8) carried
out with ESPaDOnS@CFHT. It reveals the co-existence of two distinct types of
magnetism among stars having similar masses and rotation rates. A possible
explanation for this unexpected discovery is the existence of two dynamo
branches in this parameter regime, we discuss here the possible identification
with the weak vs strong field bistability predicted for the geodynamo.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.2402 [pdf] - 1158422
Mechanisms of Planetary and Stellar Dynamos
Submitted: 2012-12-11
We review some of the recent progress on modeling planetary and stellar
dynamos. Particular attention is given to the dynamo mechanisms and the
resulting properties of the field. We present direct numerical simulations
using a simple Boussinesq model. These simulations are interpreted using the
classical mean-field formalism. We investigate the transition from steady
dipolar to multipolar dynamo waves solutions varying different control
parameters, and discuss the relevance to stellar magnetic fields. We show that
owing to the role of the strong zonal flow, this transition is hysteretic. In
the presence of stress-free boundary conditions, the bistability extends over a
wide range of parameters.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1202.4666 [pdf] - 1116792
Dipole Collapse and Dynamo Waves in Global Direct Numerical Simulations
Submitted: 2012-02-21
Magnetic fields of low-mass stars and planets are thought to originate from
self-excited dynamo action in their convective interiors. Observations reveal a
variety of field topologies ranging from large-scale, axial dipole to more
structured magnetic fields. In this article, we investigate more than 70
three-dimensional, self-consistent dynamo models obtained by direct numerical
simulations. The control parameters, the aspect ratio and the mechanical
boundary conditions have been varied to build up this sample of models. Both,
strongly dipolar and multipolar models have been obtained. We show that these
dynamo regimes can in general be distinguished by the ratio of a typical
convective length scale to the Rossby radius. Models with a predominantly
dipolar magnetic field were obtained, if the convective length scale is at
least an order of magnitude larger than the Rossby radius. Moreover, we
highlight the role of the strong shear associated with the geostrophic zonal
flow for models with stress-free boundary conditions. In this case, the above
transition disappears and is replaced by a region of bistability for which
dipolar and multipolar dynamos co-exist. We interpret our results in terms of
dynamo eigenmodes using the so-called test-field method. We can thus show that
models in the dipolar regime are characterized by an isolated 'single mode'.
Competing overtones become significant as the boundary to multipolar dynamos is
approached. We discuss how these findings relate to previous models and to
observations.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.4263 [pdf] - 1077446
Weak and Strong Field Dynamos: from the Earth to the stars
Submitted: 2011-06-21, last modified: 2011-09-14
Observations of magnetism in very low mass stars recently made important
progress, revealing characteristics that are now to be understood in the
framework of dynamo theory. In parallel, there is growing evidence that dynamo
processes in these stars share many similarities with planetary dynamos. We
investigate the extent to which the weak \emph{vs} strong field bistability
predicted for the geodynamo can apply to recent observations of two groups of
very low mass fully-convective stars sharing similar stellar parameters but
generating radically different types of magnetic fields. Our analysis is based
on previously published spectropolarimetric and spectroscopic data. We argue
that these can be interpreted in the framework of weak and strong field
dynamos.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.1837 [pdf] - 1051285
Oscillatory dynamos and their induction mechanisms
Submitted: 2011-01-10
Context: Large-scale magnetic fields resulting from hydromagnetic dynamo
action may differ substantially in their time dependence. Cyclic field
variations, characteristic for the solar magnetic field, are often explained by
an important omega-effect, i.e. by the stretching of field lines due to strong
differential rotation. Aims: The dynamo mechanism of a convective, oscillatory
dynamo model is investigated. Methods: We solve the MHD-equations for a
conducting Boussinesq fluid in a rotating spherical shell. For a resulting
oscillatory model, dynamo coefficients have been computed with the help of the
so-called test-field method. Subsequently, these coefficients have been used in
a mean-field calculation in order to explore the underlying dynamo mechanism.
Results: Although the rather strong differential rotation present in this model
influences the magnetic field, the omega-effect alone is not responsible for
its cyclic time variation. If the omega-effect is suppressed, the resulting
alpha^2-dynamo remains oscillatory. Surprisingly, the corresponding alpha-omega
dynamo leads to a non-oscillatory magnetic field. Conclusions: The assumption
of an alpha-omega mechanism does not explain the occurrence of magnetic cycles
satisfactorily.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.1144 [pdf] - 903195
The dynamo bifurcation in rotating spherical shells
Submitted: 2010-06-06
We investigate the nature of the dynamo bifurcation in a configuration
applicable to the Earth's liquid outer core, i.e. in a rotating spherical shell
with thermally driven motions. We show that the nature of the bifurcation,
which can be either supercritical or subcritical or even take the form of isola
(or detached lobes) strongly depends on the parameters. This dependence is
described in a range of parameters numerically accessible (which unfortunately
remains remote from geophysical application), and we show how the magnetic
Prandtl number and the Ekman number control these transitions.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:0901.1217 [pdf] - 1001288
Magnetostrophic MRI in the Earth's Outer Core
Submitted: 2009-01-09
We show that a simple, modified version of the Magnetorotational Instability
(MRI) can develop in the outer liquid core of the Earth, in the presence of a
background shear. It requires either thermal wind, or a primary instability,
such as convection, to drive a weak differential rotation within the core. The
force balance in the Earth's core is very unlike classical astrophysical
applications of the MRI (such as gaseous disks around stars). Here, the weak
differential rotation in the Earth core yields an instability by its
constructive interaction with the planet's much larger rotation rate. The
resulting destabilising mechanism is just strong enough to counteract
stabilizing resistive effects, and produce growth on geophysically interesting
timescales. We give a simple physical explanation of the instability, and show
that it relies on a force balance appropriate to the Earth's core, known as
magnetostrophic balance.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:0901.0828 [pdf] - 20052
Relations between dynamo-region geometry and the magnetic behavior of
stars and planets
Submitted: 2009-01-07
The geo and solar magnetic fields have long been thought to be very different
objects both in terms of spatial structure and temporal behavior. The recently
discovered field structure of a fully convective star is more reminiscent of
planetary magnetic fields than the Sun's magnetic field (Donati J.-F. et al.,
Science, 311 (2006) 633), despite the fact that the physical and chemical
properties of these objects clearly differ. This observation suggests that a
simple controlling parameter could be responsible for these different
behaviors. We report here the results of three-dimensional simulations which
show that varying the aspect ratio of the active dynamo region can yield sharp
transition from Earth-like steady dynamos to Sun-like dynamo waves.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:0901.0403 [pdf] - 19956
Direct numerical simulations of the galactic dynamo in the kinematic
growing phase
Submitted: 2009-01-04
We present kinematic simulations of a galactic dynamo model based on the
large scale differential rotation and the small scale helical fluctuations due
to supernova explosions. We report for the first time direct numerical
simulations of the full galactic dynamo using an unparameterized global
approach. We argue that the scale of helicity injection is large enough to be
directly resolved rather than parameterized. While the actual superbubble
characteristics can only be approached, we show that numerical simulations
yield magnetic structures which are close both to the observations and to the
previous parameterized mean field models. In particular, the quadrupolar
symmetry and the spiraling properties of the field are reproduced. Moreover,
our simulations show that the presence of a vertical inflow plays an essential
role to increase the magnetic growth rate. This observation could indicate an
important role of the downward flow (possibly linked with galactic fountains)
in sustaining galactic magnetic fields.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.0115 [pdf] - 11384
Time scales separation for dynamo action
Submitted: 2008-04-01, last modified: 2008-04-02
The study of dynamo action in astrophysical objects classically involves two
timescales: the slow diffusive one and the fast advective one. We investigate
the possibility of field amplification on an intermediate timescale associated
with time dependent modulations of the flow. We consider a simple steady
configuration for which dynamo action is not realised. We study the effect of
time dependent perturbations of the flow. We show that some vanishing low
frequency perturbations can yield exponential growth of the magnetic field on
the typical time scale of oscillation. The dynamo mechanism relies here on a
parametric instability associated with transient amplification by shear flows.
Consequences on natural dynamos are discussed.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0601715 [pdf] - 79573
Kinematic Dynamos using Constrained Transport with High Order Godunov
Schemes and Adaptive Mesh Refinement
Submitted: 2006-01-31
We propose to extend the well-known MUSCL-Hancock scheme for Euler equations
to the induction equation modeling the magnetic field evolution in kinematic
dynamo problems. The scheme is based on an integral form of the underlying
conservation law which, in our formulation, results in a ``finite-surface''
scheme for the induction equation. This naturally leads to the well-known
``constrained transport'' method, with additional continuity requirement on the
magnetic field representation. The second ingredient in the MUSCL scheme is the
predictor step that ensures second order accuracy both in space and time. We
explore specific constraints that the mathematical properties of the induction
equations place on this predictor step, showing that three possible variants
can be considered. We show that the most aggressive formulations (referred to
as C-MUSCL and U-MUSCL) reach the same level of accuracy as the other one
(referred to as Runge-Kutta), at a lower computational cost. More
interestingly, these two schemes are compatible with the Adaptive Mesh
Refinement (AMR) framework. It has been implemented in the AMR code RAMSES. It
offers a novel and efficient implementation of a second order scheme for the
induction equation. We have tested it by solving two kinematic dynamo problems
in the low diffusion limit. The construction of this scheme for the induction
equation constitutes a step towards solving the full MHD set of equations using
an extension of our current methodology.