Normalized to: Dirkx, D.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.01060 [pdf] - 1860119
The gravitational redshift monitored with RadioAstron from near Earth up
to 350,000 km
Submitted: 2019-04-01
We report on our efforts to test the Einstein Equivalence Principle by
measuring the gravitational redshift with the VLBI spacecraft RadioAstron, in
an eccentric orbit around Earth with geocentric distances as small as $\sim$
7,000 km and up to 350,000 km. The spacecraft and its ground stations are each
equipped with stable hydrogen maser frequency standards, and measurements of
the redshifted downlink carrier frequencies were obtained at both 8.4 and 15
GHz between 2012 and 2017. Over the course of the $\sim$ 9 d orbit, the
gravitational redshift between the spacecraft and the ground stations varies
between $6.8 \times 10^{-10}$ and $0.6 \times 10^{-10}$. Since the clock offset
between the masers is difficult to estimate independently of the gravitational
redshift, only the variation of the gravitational redshift is considered for
this analysis. We obtain a preliminary estimate of the fractional deviation of
the gravitational redshift from prediction of $\epsilon = -0.016 \pm 0.003_{\rm
stat} \pm 0.030_{\rm syst}$ with the systematic uncertainty likely being
dominated by unmodelled effects including the error in accounting for the
non-relativistic Doppler shift. This result is consistent with zero within the
uncertainties. For the first time, the gravitational redshift has been probed
over such large distances in the vicinity of Earth. About three orders of
magnitude more accurate estimates may be possible with RadioAstron using
existing data from dedicated interleaved observations combining uplink and
downlink modes of operation.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.01582 [pdf] - 1864022
Venus Express radio occultation observed by PRIDE
Bocanegra-Bahamon, T. M.;
Calves, G. Molera;
Gurvits, L. I.;
Cimo, G.;
Dirkx, D.;
Duev, D. A.;
Pogrebenko, S. V.;
Rosenblatt, P.;
Limaye, S.;
Cui, L.;
Li, P.;
Kondo, T.;
Sekido, M.;
Mikhailov, A. G.;
Kharinov, M. A.;
Ipatov, A. V.;
Wang, W.;
Zheng, W.;
Ma, M.;
Lovell, J. E. J.;
McCallum, J. N.
Submitted: 2019-03-04
Context. Radio occultation is a technique used to study planetary atmospheres
by means of the refraction and absorption of a spacecraft carrier signal
through the atmosphere of the celestial body of interest, as detected from a
ground station on Earth. This technique is usually employed by the deep space
tracking and communication facilities (e.g., NASA's Deep Space Network (DSN),
ESA's Estrack). Aims. We want to characterize the capabilities of the Planetary
Radio Interferometry and Doppler Experiment (PRIDE) technique for radio
occultation experiments, using radio telescopes equipped with Very Long
Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) instrumentation. Methods. We conducted a test
with ESA's Venus Express (VEX), to evaluate the performance of the PRIDE
technique for this particular application. We explain in detail the data
processing pipeline of radio occultation experiments with PRIDE, based on the
collection of so-called open-loop Doppler data with VLBI stations, and perform
an error propagation analysis of the technique. Results. With the VEX test case
and the corresponding error analysis, we have demonstrated that the PRIDE setup
and processing pipeline is suited for radio occultation experiments of
planetary bodies. The noise budget of the open-loop Doppler data collected with
PRIDE indicated that the uncertainties in the derived density and temperature
profiles remain within the range of uncertainties reported in previous Venus'
studies. Open-loop Doppler data can probe deeper layers of thick atmospheres,
such as that of Venus, when compared to closed-loop Doppler data. Furthermore,
PRIDE through the VLBI networks around the world, provides a wide coverage and
range of large antenna dishes, that can be used for this type of experiments.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.09195 [pdf] - 1837484
Propagation and Estimation of the Dynamical Behaviour of Gravitationally
Interacting Rigid Bodies
Submitted: 2019-02-25
Next-generation planetary tracking methods, such as interplanetary laser
ranging (ILR) and same-beam interferometry (SBI) promise an orders-of-magnitude
increase in the accuracy of measurements of solar system dynamics. This
requires a reconsideration of modelling strategies for the translational and
rotational dynamics of natural bodies, to ensure that model errors are well
below the measurement uncertainties.
The influence of the gravitational interaction of the full mass distributions
of celestial bodies, the so-called figure-figure effects, will need to be
included for selected future missions. The mathematical formulation of this
problem to arbitrary degree is often provided in an elegant and compact manner
that is not trivially relatable to the formulation used in space geodesy and
ephemeris generation. This complicates the robust implementation of such a
model in operational software packages. We formulate the problem in a manner
that is directly compatible with the implementation used in typical dynamical
modelling codes: in terms of spherical harmonic coefficients and Legendre
polynomials. An analytical formulation for the associated variational equations
for both translational and rotational motion is derived.
We apply our methodology to both Phobos and the KW4 binary asteroid system,
to analyze the influence of figure-figure effects during estimation from
next-generation tracking data. For the case of Phobos, omitting these effects
during estimation results in relative errors of $0.42\%$ and $0.065\%$ for the
$\bar{C}_{20}$ and $\bar{C}_{22}$ spherical harmonic gravity field
coefficients, respectively. These values are below current uncertainties, but
orders of magnitude larger than those obtained from past simulations for
accurate tracking of a future Phobos lander.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.08932 [pdf] - 1721260
Laser and Radio Tracking for Planetary Science Missions - A Comparison
Submitted: 2018-07-24
At present, tracking data for planetary missions largely consists of radio
observables: range-rate range and angular position. Future planetary missions
may use Interplanetary Laser Ranging (ILR) as a tracking observable. Two-way
ILR will provide range data that are about 2 orders of magnitude more accurate
than radio-based range data. ILR does not produce Doppler data, however. In
this article, we compare the relative strength of radio Doppler and laser range
data for the retrieval of parameters of interest in planetary missions, to
clarify and quantify the science case of ILR, with a focus on geodetic
observables.
We first provide an overview of the near-term attainable quality of ILR, in
terms of both the realization of the observable and the models used to process
the measurements. Subsequently, we analyze the sensitivity of radio-Doppler and
laser-range measurements in representative mission scenarios. We use both an
analytical approximation and numerical analyses of the relative sensitivity of
ILR and radio Doppler observables for more general cases.
We show that mm-precise range normal points are feasible for ILR, but
mm-level accuracy and stability is unlikely to be attained, due to a
combination of instrumental and model errors. ILR has the potential for
superior performance in observing signatures in the data with a characteristic
period of greater than 0.33-1.65 hours This indicates that Doppler tracking
will typically remain the method of choice for gravity field determination and
spacecraft orbit determination in planetary missions. Laser ranging data,
however, are shown to have a significant advantage for the retrieval of
rotational and tidal characteristics from landers. Similarly, laser ranging
data will be superior for the construction of planetary ephemerides and the
improvement of solar system tests of gravitation.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.11506 [pdf] - 1590527
On the contribution of PRIDE-JUICE to Jovian system ephemerides
Submitted: 2017-10-31
The JUICE mission will perform detailed measurements of the properties of the
Galilean moons, with a nominal in-system science-mission duration of about 3.5
years. Using both the radio tracking data, and (Earth- and JUICE-based) optical
astrometry, the dynamics of the Galilean moons will be measured to
unprecedented accuracy. This will provide crucial input to the determination of
the ephemerides and physical properties of the system, most notably the
dissipation in Io and Jupiter.
The data from Planetary Radio Interferometry and Doppler Experiment (PRIDE)
will provide the lateral position of the spacecraft in the ICRF. In this
article, we analyze the relative quantitative influence of the JUICE-PRIDE
observables to the determination of the ephemerides of the Jovian system and
the associated physical parameters.
We perform a covariance analysis for a broad range of mission and system
characteristics. We analyze the influence of VLBI data quality, observation
planning, as well as the influence of JUICE orbit determination quality. This
provides key input for the further development of the PRIDE observational
planning and ground segment development.
Our analysis indicates that the VLBI data are especially important for
constraining the dynamics of Ganymede and Callisto perpendicular to their
orbital planes. Also, the use of the VLBI data makes the uncertainty in the
ephemerides less dependent on the error in the orbit determination of the JUICE
spacecraft itself. Furthermore, we find that optical astrometry data of
especially Io using the JANUS instrument will be crucial for stabilizing the
solution of the normal equations. Knowledge of the dissipation in the Jupiter
system cannot be improved using satellite dynamics obtained from JUICE data
alone, the uncertainty in Io's dissipation obtained from our simulations is
similar to the present level of uncertainty.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.10074 [pdf] - 1724841
Probing the gravitational redshift with an Earth-orbiting satellite
Litvinov, D. A.;
Rudenko, V. N.;
Alakoz, A. V.;
Bach, U.;
Bartel, N.;
Belonenko, A. V.;
Belousov, K. G.;
Bietenholz, M.;
Biriukov, A. V.;
Carman, R.;
Cimó, G.;
Courde, C.;
Dirkx, D.;
Duev, D. A.;
Filetkin, A. I.;
Granato, G.;
Gurvits, L. I.;
Gusev, A. V.;
Haas, R.;
Herold, G.;
Kahlon, A.;
Kanevsky, B. Z.;
Kauts, V. L.;
Kopelyansky, G. D.;
Kovalenko, A. V.;
Kronschnabl, G.;
Kulagin, V. V.;
Kutkin, A. M.;
indqvist, M. L;
Lovell, J. E. J.;
Mariey, H.;
McCallum, J.;
Molera-Calvés, G.;
Moore, C.;
Moore, K.;
Neidhardt, A.;
Plötz, C.;
Pogrebenko, S. V.;
Pollard, A.;
Porayko, N. K.;
Quick, J.;
Smirnov, A. I.;
Sokolovsky, K. V.;
Stepanyants, V. A.;
Torre, J. -M.;
de Vicente, P.;
Yang, J.;
Zakhvatkin, M. V.
Submitted: 2017-10-27
We present an approach to testing the gravitational redshift effect using the
RadioAstron satellite. The experiment is based on a modification of the Gravity
Probe A scheme of nonrelativistic Doppler compensation and benefits from the
highly eccentric orbit and ultra-stable atomic hydrogen maser frequency
standard of the RadioAstron satellite. Using the presented techniques we expect
to reach an accuracy of the gravitational redshift test of order $10^{-5}$, a
magnitude better than that of Gravity Probe A. Data processing is ongoing, our
preliminary results agree with the validity of the Einstein Equivalence
Principle.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.03419 [pdf] - 1614803
Planetary Radio Interferometry and Doppler Experiment (PRIDE) Technique:
a Test Case of the Mars Express Phobos Fly-by. 2. Doppler tracking:
Formulation of observed and computed values, and noise budget
Submitted: 2017-09-11
Context. Closed-loop Doppler data obtained by deep space tracking networks
(e.g., NASA's DSN and ESA's Estrack) are routinely used for navigation and
science applications. By "shadow tracking" the spacecraft signal, Earth-based
radio telescopes involved in Planetary Radio Interferometry and Doppler
Experiment (PRIDE) can provide open-loop Doppler tracking data when the
dedicated deep space tracking facilities are operating in closed-loop mode
only. Aims. We explain in detail the data processing pipeline, discuss the
capabilities of the technique and its potential applications in planetary
science. Methods. We provide the formulation of the observed and computed
values of the Doppler data in PRIDE tracking of spacecraft, and demonstrate the
quality of the results using as a test case an experiment with ESA's Mars
Express spacecraft. Results. We find that the Doppler residuals and the
corresponding noise budget of the open-loop Doppler detections obtained with
the PRIDE stations are comparable to the closed-loop Doppler detections
obtained with the dedicated deep space tracking facilities.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.06685 [pdf] - 1378760
Space-time Dynamics Estimation from Space Mission Tracking Data
Submitted: 2015-12-21
Many physical parameters that can be estimated from space mission tracking
data influence both the translational dynamics and proper time rates of
observers. These different proper time rates cause a variability of the time
transfer observable beyond that caused by their translational (and rotational)
dynamics. With the near-future implementation of (interplanetary) transponder
laser ranging, these effects will become increasingly important, requiring a
re-evaluation of the common data analysis practice of using a priori time
ephemerides, which is the goal of this paper.
We develop a framework for the simultaneous estimation of the initial
translational state and the initial proper time of an observer, with the goal
of facilitating robust tracking data analysis from next-generation space
missions carrying highly accurate clocks and tracking equipment. Using our
approach, the influence of physical parameters on both translational and time
dynamics are considered at the same level in the analysis, and mutual
correlations between the signatures of the two are automatically identified. We
perform a covariance analysis using our proposed method with simulated laser
data from Earth-based stations to both a Mars and Mercury lander.
Using four years of tracking data for the Mars lander simulations, we find a
difference between our results using the simultaneous space-time dynamics
estimation and the classical analysis technique (with an ta priori time
ephemeris) of around 0.1 % in formal errors and correlation coefficients. For a
Mercury lander this rises to around 1% for a 1-month mission and 10 % for a
4-year mission. By means of Monte Carlo simulation, we find that using an a
priori time ephemeris of representative accuracy will result in estimation
errors that are orders of magnitude above the formal error when processing
highly accurate laser time transfer data.