Normalized to: Diaz-Gimenez, E.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.12888 [pdf] - 2026460
Compact groups from semi-analytical models of galaxy formation -- I: a
comparative study of frequency and nature
Submitted: 2019-11-28
Compact groups (CGs) of galaxies are defined as isolated and dense galaxy
systems that appear to be a unique site of multiple galaxy interactions.
Semi-analytical models of galaxy formation (SAMs) are a prime tool to
understand CGs. We investigate how the frequency and the three-dimensional
nature of CGs depends on the SAM and its underlying cosmological parameters.
Extracting 9 lightcones of galaxies from 5 different SAMs and selecting CGs as
in observed samples, we find that the frequency and nature of CGs depends
strongly on the cosmological parameters. Moving from the WMAP1 to the WMAP7 and
Planck cosmologies (increasing density of the Universe and decreasing
normalisation of the power spectrum), the space density of CGs is decreased by
a factor 2.5, while the fraction of CGs that are physically dense falls from 50
to 35 percent. The lower $\sigma_8$ leads to fewer dense groups, while the
higher $\Omega_{\rm m}$ causes more chance alignments. However, with increased
mass and spatial resolution, the fraction of CGs that are physically dense is
pushed back up to 50 percent. The intrinsic differences in the SAM recipes also
lead to differences in the frequency and nature of CGs, particularly those
related to how SAMs treat orphan galaxies. We find no dependence of CG
properties on the flux limit of the mock catalogues nor on the waveband in
which galaxies are selected. One should thus be cautious when interpreting a
particular SAM for the frequency and nature of CGs.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.10051 [pdf] - 1775659
Improving Hickson-like compact group finders in redshift surveys: an
implementation in the SDSS
Submitted: 2018-08-29
In this work we present an algorithm to identify compact groups (CGs) that
closely follows Hickson's original aim and that improves the completeness of
the samples of compact groups obtained from redshift surveys. Instead of
identifying CGs in projection first and then checking a velocity concordance
criterion, we identify them directly in redshift space using Hickson-like
criteria. The methodology was tested on a mock lightcone of galaxies built from
the outputs of a recent semi-analytic model of galaxy formation run on top of
the Millennium Simulation I after scaling to represent the first-year Planck
cosmology. The new algorithm identifies nearly twice as many CGs, no longer
missing CGs that failed the isolation criterion because of velocity outliers
lying in the isolation annulus. The new CG sample picks up lower surface
brightness groups, which are both looser and with fainter brightest galaxies,
missed by the classic method. A new catalogue of compact groups from the Sloan
Digital Sky Survey is the natural corollary of this study. The publicly
available sample comprises $462$ observational groups with four or more galaxy
members, of which $406$ clearly fulfil all the compact group requirements:
compactness, isolation, and velocity concordance of all of their members. The
remaining $56$ groups need further redshift information of potentially
contaminating sources. This constitutes the largest sample of groups that
strictly satisfy all the Hickson's criteria in a survey with available
spectroscopic information.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.01184 [pdf] - 1422383
On the properties of compact groups identified in different photometric
bands
Submitted: 2016-06-03
Historically, compact group catalogues vary not only in their identification
algorithms and selection functions, but also in their photometric bands.
Differences between compact group catalogues have been reported. However, it is
difficult to assess the impact of the photometric band in these differences
given the variety of identification algorithms. We used the mock lightcone
built by Henriques et al. (2012) to identify and compare compact groups in
three different photometric bands: $K$, $r$, and $u$. We applied the same
selection functions in the three bands, and found that compact groups in the
u-band look the smallest in projection, the difference between the two
brightest galaxies is the largest in the K-band, while compact groups in the
r-band present the lowest compactness. We also investigated the differences
between samples when galaxies are selected only in one particular band (pure
compact groups) and those that exist regardless the band in which galaxies were
observed (common compact groups). We found that the differences between the
total samples are magnified, but also some others arise: pure-r compact groups
are the largest in projection; pure-u compact groups have the brightest first
ranked galaxies, and the most similar two first ranked galaxies; pure-K compact
groups have the highest compactness and the most different two first ranked
galaxies; and common compact groups show the largest percentage of physically
dense groups. Therefore, without a careful selection and identification of the
samples, the characteristic features of group properties in a particular
photometric band could be overshadowed.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.05978 [pdf] - 1347647
Fossil groups in the Millennium simulation. From the brightest to the
faintest galaxies during the past 8 Gyr
Submitted: 2015-11-18
We investigate the evolution of bright and faint galaxies in fossil and
non-fossil groups. We used mock galaxies constructed based on the Millennium
run simulation II. We identified fossil groups at redshift zero according to
two different selection criteria, and then built reliable control samples of
non-fossil groups that reproduce the fossil virial mass and assembly time
distributions. The faint galaxies were defined as having r-band absolute
magnitudes in the range [-16,-11]. We analysed the properties of the bright and
faint galaxies in fossil and non-fossil groups during the past 8 Gyr. We
observed that the brightest galaxy in fossil groups is typically brighter and
more massive than their counterparts in control groups. Fossil groups developed
their large magnitude gap between the brightest galaxies around 3.5 Gyr ago.
The brightest galaxy stellar masses of all groups show a notorious increment at
that time. By analysing the behaviour of the magnitude gap between the first
and the second, third, and fourth ranked galaxies, we found that at earlier
times, fossil groups comprised two large brightest galaxies with similar
magnitudes surrounded by much fainter galaxies, while in control groups these
magnitude gaps were never as large as in fossils. At early times, fossil groups
in the faint population were denser than non-fossil groups, then this trend
reversed, and finally they became similar at the present day. The mean number
of faint galaxies in non-fossil systems increases in an almost constant rate
towards later times, while this number in fossil groups reaches a plateau at
$z\sim0.6$ that lasts $\sim 2$ Gyr, and then starts growing again more rapidly.
The formation of fossil groups is defined at the very beginning of the groups
according to their galaxy luminosity sampling, which could be determined by
their merging rate at early times.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.02447 [pdf] - 1129086
Where are compact groups in the local Universe?
Submitted: 2015-04-09
The purpose of this work is to perform a statistical analysis of the location
of compact groups in the Universe from observational and semi-analytical points
of view. We used the velocity-filtered compact group sample extracted from the
Two Micron All Sky Survey for our analysis. We also used a new sample of galaxy
groups identified in the 2M++ galaxy redshift catalogue as tracers of the
large-scale structure. We defined a procedure to search in redshift space for
compact groups that can be considered embedded in other overdense systems and
applied this criterion to several possible combinations of different compact
and galaxy group subsamples. We also performed similar analyses for simulated
compact and galaxy groups identified in a 2M++ mock galaxy catalogue
constructed from the Millennium Run Simulation I plus a semi-analytical model
of galaxy formation. We observed that only $\sim27\%$ of the compact groups can
be considered to be embedded in larger overdense systems, that is, most of the
compact groups are more likely to be isolated systems. The embedded compact
groups show statistically smaller sizes and brighter surface brightnesses than
non-embedded systems. No evidence was found that embedded compact groups are
more likely to inhabit galaxy groups with a given virial mass or with a
particular dynamical state. We found very similar results when the analysis was
performed using mock compact and galaxy groups. Based on the semi-analytical
studies, we predict that $70\%$ of the embedded compact groups probably are 3D
physically dense systems. Finally, real space information allowed us to reveal
the bimodal behaviour of the distribution of 3D minimum distances between
compact and galaxy groups. The location of compact groups should be carefully
taken into account when comparing properties of galaxies in environments that
are a priori different.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.6740 [pdf] - 903775
Are compact groups hostile towards faint galaxies?
Submitted: 2014-09-23
The goal of this work is to understand whether the extreme environment of
compact groups can affect the distribution and abundance of faint galaxies
around them. We performed an analysis of the faint galaxy population in the
vicinity of compact groups and normal groups. We built a light-cone mock galaxy
catalogue constructed from the Millennium Run Simulation II plus a
semi-analytical model of galaxy formation. We identified a sample of compact
groups in the mock catalogue as well as a control sample of normal galaxy
groups and computed the projected number density profiles of faint galaxies
around the first- and the second-ranked galaxies. We also compared the profiles
obtained from the semi-analytical galaxies in compact groups with those
obtained from observational data. In addition, we investigated whether the
ranking or the luminosity of a galaxy is the most important parameter in the
determination of the centre around which the clustering of faint galaxies
occurs. There is no particular influence of the extreme compact group
environment on the number of faint galaxies in such groups compared to control
groups. When selecting normal groups with separations between the 1st and 2nd
ranked galaxies similar to what is observed in compact groups, the faint galaxy
projected number density profiles in compact groups and normal groups are
similar in shape and height. We observed a similar behaviour of the population
of faint galaxies in observations and simulations in the regions closer to the
1st and 2nd ranked galaxies. Finally, we find that the projected density of
faint galaxies is higher around luminous galaxies,regardless of the ranking in
the compact group. The semi-analytical approach shows that compact groups and
their surroundings do not represent a hostile enough environment to make faint
galaxies to behave differently than in normal groups.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.2196 [pdf] - 570216
Compact Groups of Galaxies selected by stellar mass: The 2MASS Compact
Group Catalogue
Submitted: 2012-07-09
We present a photometric catalogue of compact groups of galaxies (p2MCGs)
automatically extracted from the 2MASS extended source catalogue. A total of
262 p2MCGs are identified, following the criteria of Hickson (1982), of which
230 survive visual inspection. Only 1/4 of these groups were previously known
compact groups (CGs). Among the 144 p2MCGs that have all their galaxies with
known redshifts, 85 have 4 or more accordant galaxies. This v2MCG sample of
velocity-filtered p2MCGs constitutes the largest sample of CGs catalogued to
date, with both well-defined selection criteria and velocity filtering, and is
the first CG sample selected by stellar mass. We compared the properties of the
78 v2MCGs with <v> > 3000 km/s with the properties of other CG samples, as well
as those (mvCGs) extracted from the semi-analytical model of Guo et al. (2011)
run on the high-resolution Millennium-II simulation. In this mvCG sample, 2/3
of the groups are physically dense. The space density of v2MCGs within 6000
km/s is 4 times that of the Hickson sample up to the same distance and with the
same criteria used here, but still 40% less than that of mvCGs. The v2MCG
constitutes the first group catalogue showing statistically significant signs
of wide magnitude gaps (according to Tremaine-Richstone statistics) and
centrally located 1st-ranked galaxies, both consistent with the predictions
obtained from mvCGs. By virtue of its automatic selection with the popular
Hickson criteria, its size, its selection on stellar mass, and its statistical
signs of mergers and centrally located brightest galaxies, the v2MCG catalogue
appears to be the laboratory of choice to study compact groups of 4 or more
galaxies of comparable luminosity. [Abridged]
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1012.5831 [pdf] - 955806
Fossil Groups in the Millennium Simulation: Their environment and its
evolution
Submitted: 2010-12-28, last modified: 2011-02-09
Fossil systems are defined to be X-ray bright galaxy groups with a
2-magnitude difference between their two brightest galaxies within half the
projected virial radius,and represent an interesting extreme of the population
of galaxy agglomerations.However,the physical conditions and processes leading
to their formation are still poorly constrained.We compare the outskirts of
fossil systems with that of normal groups to understand whether environmental
conditions play a significant role in their formation.We study galaxy groups in
both,numerical simulations and observations.We use a variety of statistical
tools including the spatial cross-correlation function and the local density
parameter \Delta_5 to probe differences in the density and structure of the
environments of normal and fossil systems in the Millennium simulation.We find
that the number density of galaxies surrounding fossil systems evolves from
greater than that observed around normal systems at z=0.69, to lower than the
normal systems by z=0.Both fossil and normal systems exhibit an increment in
their otherwise radially declining local density measure (\Delta_5) at
distances of order 2.5r_{vir} from the system centre.We show that this
increment is more noticeable for fossil systems than normal systems and
demonstrate that this difference is linked to the earlier formation epoch of
fossil groups.Despite the importance of the assembly time, we show that the
environment is different for fossil and non-fossil systems with similar masses
and formation times along their evolution.We also confirm that the physical
characteristics identified in the Millennium simulation can also be detected in
SDSS observations.Our results confirm the commonly held belief that fossil
systems assembled earlier than normal systems but also show that the
surroundings of fossil groups could be responsible for the formation of their
large magnitude gap.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:0809.3483 [pdf] - 1944095
Compact groups from the Millennium Simulations: I. Their Nature and the
completeness of the Hickson sample
Submitted: 2008-09-22, last modified: 2010-07-22
We identify compact groups of galaxies (CGs) within mock galaxy catalogues
from the Millennium Simulation at z=0 with three semi-analytic models (SAMs) of
galaxy formation. CGs are identified using the same 2D criteria as those
visually applied by Hickson (1982) to his CGs (HCGs), but with a brightest
galaxy magnitude limit, and the blending of close projected pairs. Half of the
mock CGs identified in projection contain at least 4 accordant velocities
(mvCGs), versus 70% for HCGs. In comparison to mvCGs, the HCGs are only 8%
complete at distances < 9000 km/s, missing the CGs with small angular sizes, a
strongly dominant galaxy, and (for one SAM) the CGs that are fainter and those
with lower surface brightness. We explore different ways to determine the
fraction of physically dense groups. Binding energy criteria turn out to be
inapplicable given the segregation between galaxies and dark matter particles.
We rely instead on the combination of the 3D length of the CGs (maximum real
space galaxy separation) and their elongation along the line-of-sight (ratio of
maximum line-of-sight to maximum projected separations), restricting ourselves
in both cases to smallest quartets within the CGs. We find that between 64% and
80% (depending on the SAM) of the mvCGs have 3D lengths shorter than 200 kpc/h,
between 71% and 80% have line-of-sight elongations less than 2, while between
59% and 76% have either 3D lengths shorter than 100 kpc/h or both lengths
shorter than 200 kpc/h and elongations smaller than 2. Therefore, chance
alignments (CAs) of galaxies concern at most 40% of the mvCGs. These CAs are
mostly produced from larger host groups, but a few have galaxies extending a
few Mpc beyond the host group. The mvCGs built with the Hickson selection with
(without) the close projected pair blending criterion have 10% higher (lower)
fractions of physically dense systems.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.3953 [pdf] - 901806
The nature of compact groups of galaxies from cosmological simulations
Submitted: 2009-09-22, last modified: 2009-11-16
The nature of compact groups (CGs) of galaxies, apparently so dense that the
galaxies often overlap, is still a subject of debate: Are CGs roughly as dense
in 3D as they appear in projection? Or are they caused by chance alignments of
galaxies along the line-of-sight, within larger virialized groups or even
longer filamentary structures? The nature of CGs is re-appraised using the z=0
outputs of three galaxy formation models, applied to the dissipationless
Millennium Simulation. The same selection criteria are applied to mock galaxy
catalogs from these models as have been applied by Hickson and co-workers in
redshift space. We find 20 times as many mock CGs as the `HCGs' found by
Hickson within a distance corresponding to 9000 km/s. This very low (5%) HCG
completeness is caused by Hickson missing groups that were either faint, near
the surface brightness threshold, of small angular size, or with a dominant
brightest galaxy. We find that most velocity-filtered CGs are physically dense,
regardless of the precise threshold used in 3D group size and line-of-sight
elongation, and of the galaxy formation model used. This result also holds for
mock CGs with the same selection biases as was found for the HCGs.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:0809.2290 [pdf] - 280252
Fossil Groups in the Millennium Simulation. Evolution of the Brightest
Galaxies
Submitted: 2008-09-12
We create a catalogue of simulated fossil groups and study their properties,
in particular the merging histories of their first-ranked galaxies. We compare
the simulated fossil group properties with those of both simulated non-fossil
and observed fossil groups. Using simulations and a mock galaxy catalogue, we
searched for massive ($>$ 5 $\times$ 10$^{13} h^{-1} {\cal M}_\odot$) fossil
groups in the Millennium Simulation Galaxy Catalogue. In addition, attempted to
identify observed fossil groups in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 6
using identical selection criteria. Our predictions on the basis of the
simulation data are:(a) fossil groups comprise about 5.5% of the total
population of groups/clusters with masses larger than 5 x 10$^{13} h^{-1} {\cal
M}_\odot$. This fraction is consistent with the fraction of fossil groups
identified in the SDSS, after all observational biases have been taken into
account; (b) about 88% of the dominant central objects in fossil groups are
elliptical galaxies that have a median R-band absolute magnitude of $\sim
-23.5-5 log h$, which is typical of the observed fossil groups known in the
literature; (c)first-ranked galaxies of systems with $ {\cal M} >$ 5 x 10$^{13}
h^{-1} {\cal M}_\odot$, regardless of whether they are either fossil or
non-fossil, are mainly formed by gas-poor mergers; (d) although fossil groups,
in general, assembled most of their virial masses at higher redshifts in
comparison with non-fossil groups, first-ranked galaxies in fossil groups
merged later, i.e. at lower redshifts, compared with their non-fossil-group
counterparts. We therefore expect to observe a number of luminous galaxies in
the centres of fossil groups that show signs of a recent major merger.