Normalized to: Debras, F.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.06546 [pdf] - 2015825
Idealised simulations of the deep atmosphere of hot jupiters: Deep, hot,
adiabats as a robust solution to the radius inflation problem
Sainsbury-Martinez, F.;
Wang, P.;
Fromang, S.;
Tremblin, P.;
Dubos, T.;
Meurdesoif, Y.;
Spiga, A.;
Leconte, J.;
Baraffe, I.;
Chabrier, G.;
Mayne, N.;
Drummond, B.;
Debras, F.
Submitted: 2019-11-15
Context: The anomalously large radii of hot Jupiters has long been a mystery.
However, by combining both theoretical arguments and 2D models, a recent study
has suggested that the vertical advection of potential temperature leads to an
adiabatic temperature profile in the deep atmosphere hotter than the profile
obtained with standard 1D models. Aims: In order to confirm the viability of
that scenario, we extend this investigation to three dimensional,
time-dependent, models. Methods: We use a 3D GCM, DYNAMICO to perform a series
of calculations designed to explore the formation and structure of the driving
atmospheric circulations, and detail how it responds to changes in both upper
and deep atmospheric forcing. Results: In agreement with the previous, 2D,
study, we find that a hot adiabat is the natural outcome of the long-term
evolution of the deep atmosphere. Integration times of order $1500$ years are
needed for that adiabat to emerge from an isothermal atmosphere, explaining why
it has not been found in previous hot Jupiter studies. Models initialised from
a hotter deep atmosphere tend to evolve faster toward the same final state. We
also find that the deep adiabat is stable against low-levels of deep heating
and cooling, as long as the Newtonian cooling time-scale is longer than $\sim
3000$ years at $200$ bar. Conclusions: We conclude that the steady-state
vertical advection of potential temperature by deep atmospheric circulations
constitutes a robust mechanism to explain hot Jupiter inflated radii. We
suggest that future studies of hot Jupiters are evolved for a longer time than
currently done, and, when possible, include models initialised with a hot deep
adiabat. We stress that this mechanism stems from the advection of entropy by
irradiation induced mass flows and does not require (finely tuned) dissipative
process, in contrast with most previously suggested scenarios.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.03182 [pdf] - 2026281
The Acceleration of Superrotation in Simulated Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
Submitted: 2019-11-08
Context. Atmospheric superrotating flows at the equator are an almost
ubiquitous result of simulations of hot Jupiters, and a theory explaining how
this zonally coherent flow reaches an equilibrium has been developed in the
literature. However, this understanding relies on the existence of either an
initial superrotating or a sheared flow, coupled with a slow evolution such
that a linear steady state can be reached. Aims. A consistent physical
understanding of superrotation is needed for arbitrary drag and radiative
timescales, and the relevance of considering linear steady states needs to be
assessed. Methods. We obtain an analytical expression for the structure,
frequency and decay rate of propagating waves in hot Jupiter atmospheres around
a state at rest in the 2D shallow water beta plane limit. We solve this
expression numerically and confirm the robustness of our results with a 3D
linear wave algorithm. We then compare with 3D simulations of hot Jupiter
atmospheres and study the non linear momentum fluxes. Results. We show that
under strong day night heating the dynamics does not transit through a linear
steady state when starting from an initial atmosphere in solid body rotation.
We further show that non linear effects favour the initial spin up of
superrotation and that the acceleration due to the vertical component of the
eddy momentum flux is critical to the initial development of superrotation.
Conclusions. Overall, we describe the initial phases of the acceleration of
superrotation, including consideration of differing radiative and drag
timescales, and conclude that eddy-momentum driven superrotating equatorial
jets are robust, physical phenomena in simulations of hot Jupiter atmospheres.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.03722 [pdf] - 1979729
Eigenvectors, Circulation and Linear Instabilities for Planetary Science
in 3 Dimensions (ECLIPS3D)
Submitted: 2019-09-09
Context. The study of linear waves and instabilities is necessary to
understand the physical evolution of an atmosphere, and can provide physical
interpretation of the complex flows found in simulations performed using Global
Circulation Models (GCM). In particular, the acceleration of superrotating flow
at the equator of hot Jupiters has mostly been studied under several
simplifying assumptions, the relaxing of which may impact final results. Aims.
We develop and benchmark a publicly available algorithm to identify the
eigenmodes of an atmosphere around any initial steady state. We also solve for
linear steady states. Methods. We linearise the hydrodynamical equations of a
planetary atmosphere in a steady state with arbitrary velocities and thermal
profile. We then discretise the linearised equations on an appropriate
staggered grid, and solve for eigenvectors and linear steady solutions with the
use of a parallel library for linear algebra: ScaLAPACK. We also implement a
posteriori calculation of an energy equation in order to obtain more
information on the underlying physics of the mode. Results. Our code is
benchmarked against classical wave and instability test cases in multiple
geometries. The steady linear circulation calculations also reproduce expected
results for the atmosphere of hot Jupiters. We finally show the robustness of
our energy equation, and its power to obtain physical insight into the modes.
Conclusions. We have developed and benchmarked a code for the study of linear
processes in planetary atmospheres, with an arbitrary steady state. The
calculation of an a posteriori energy equation provides both increased
robustness and physical meaning to the obtained eigenmodes. This code can be
applied to various problems, and notably to further study the initial spin up
of superrotation of GCM simulations of hot Jupiter.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.06537 [pdf] - 1855812
Dust traps in the protoplanetary disc MWC 758: two vortices produced by
two giant planets?
Baruteau, Clément;
Barraza, Marcelo;
Pérez, Sebastián;
Casassus, Simon;
Dong, Ruobing;
Lyra, Wladimir;
Marino, Sebastián;
Christiaens, Valentin;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Carmona, Andrés;
Debras, Florian;
Alarcon, Felipe
Submitted: 2019-03-15
Resolved ALMA and VLA observations indicate the existence of two dust traps
in the protoplanetary disc MWC 758. By means of 2D gas+dust hydrodynamical
simulations post-processed with 3D dust radiative transfer calculations, we
show that the spirals in scattered light, the eccentric, asymmetric ring and
the crescent-shaped structure in the (sub)millimetre can all be caused by two
giant planets: a 1.5-Jupiter mass planet at 35 au (inside the spirals) and a
5-Jupiter mass planet at 140 au (outside the spirals). The outer planet forms a
dust-trapping vortex at the inner edge of its gap (at ~85 au), and the
continuum emission of this dust trap reproduces the ALMA and VLA observations
well. The outer planet triggers several spiral arms which are similar to those
observed in polarised scattered light. The inner planet also forms a vortex at
the outer edge of its gap (at ~50 au), but it decays faster than the vortex
induced by the outer planet, as a result of the disc's turbulent viscosity. The
vortex decay can explain the eccentric inner ring seen with ALMA as well as the
low signal and larger azimuthal spread of this dust trap in VLA observations.
Finding the thermal and kinematic signatures of both giant planets could verify
the proposed scenario.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.05697 [pdf] - 1838352
New models of Jupiter in the context of Juno and Galileo
Submitted: 2019-01-17
Observations of Jupiter's gravity field by Juno have revealed surprisingly
small values for the high order gravitational moments, considering the
abundances of heavy elements measured by Galileo 20 years ago. The derivation
of recent equations of state for hydrogen and helium, much denser in the Mbar
region, worsen the conflict between these two observations. In order to
circumvent this puzzle, current Jupiter model studies either ignore the
constraint from Galileo or invoke an ad hoc modification of the equations of
state. In this paper, we derive Jupiter models which satisfy both Juno and
Galileo constraints. We confirm that Jupiter's structure must encompass at
least four different regions: an outer convective envelope, a region of
compositional, thus entropy change, an inner convective envelope and an
extended diluted core enriched in heavy elements, and potentially a central
compact core. We show that, in order to reproduce Juno and Galileo
observations, one needs a significant entropy increase between the outer and
inner envelopes and a smaller density than for an isentropic profile,
associated with some external differential rotation. The best way to fulfill
this latter condition is an inward decreasing abundance of heavy elements in
this region. We examine in details the three physical mechanisms able to yield
such a change of entropy and composition: a first order molecular-metallic
hydrogen transition, immiscibility between hydrogen and helium or a region of
layered convection. Given our present knowledge of hydrogen pressure
ionization, combination of the two latter mechanisms seems to be the most
favoured solution.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.02451 [pdf] - 1823008
The Limits of the Primitive Equations of Dynamics for Warm, Slowly
Rotating Small Neptunes and Super Earths
Submitted: 2018-12-06
We present significant differences in the simulated atmospheric flow for
warm, tidally-locked small Neptunes and super Earths (based on a nominal GJ
1214b) when solving the simplified, and commonly used, primitive dynamical
equations or the full Navier-Stokes equations. The dominant prograde,
superrotating zonal jet is markedly different between the simulations which are
performed using practically identical numerical setups, within the same model.
The differences arise due to the breakdown of the so-called `shallow-fluid' and
traditional approximations, which worsens when rotation rates are slowed, and
day-night temperature contrasts are increased. The changes in the zonal
advection between simulations solving the full and simplified equations, give
rise to significant differences in the atmospheric redistribution of heat,
altering the position of the hottest part of the atmosphere and temperature
contrast between the day and night sides. The implications for the atmospheric
chemistry and, therefore, observations need to be studied with a model
including a more detailed treatment of the radiative transfer and chemistry.
Small Neptunes and super Earths are extremely abundant and important,
potentially bridging the structural properties (mass, radius, composition) of
terrestrial and gas giant planets. Our results indicate care is required when
interpreting the output of models solving the primitive equations of motion for
such planets.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.03969 [pdf] - 1622289
A complete study of the precision of the concentric MacLaurin spheroid
method to calculate Jupiter's gravitational moments
Submitted: 2017-10-11
A few years ago, Hubbard (2012, 2013) presented an elegant, non-perturbative
method, called concentric MacLaurin spheroid (CMS), to calculate with very high
accuracy the gravitational moments of a rotating fluid body following a
barotropic pressure-density relationship. Having such an accurate method is of
great importance for taking full advantage of the Juno mission, and its
extremely precise determination of Jupiter gravitational moments, to better
constrain the internal structure of the planet. Recently, several authors have
applied this method to the Juno mission with 512 spheroids linearly spaced in
altitude. We demonstrate in this paper that such calculations lead to errors
larger than Juno's error bars, invalidating the aforederived Jupiter models at
the level required by Juno's precision. We show that, in order to fulfill
Juno's observational constraints, at least 1500 spheroids must be used with a
cubic, square or exponential repartition, the most reliable solutions. When
using a realistic equation of state instead of a polytrope, we highlight the
necessity to properly describe the outermost layers to derive an accurate
boundary condition, excluding in particular a zero pressure outer condition.
Providing all these constraints are fulfilled, the CMS method can indeed be
used to derive Jupiter models within Juno's present observational constraints.
However, we show that the treatment of the outermost layers leads to
irreducible errors in the calculation of the gravitational moments and thus on
the inferred physical quantities for the planet. We have quantified these
errors and evaluated the maximum precision that can be reached with the CMS
method in the present and future exploitation of Juno's data.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.05440 [pdf] - 1582637
Advection of potential temperature in the atmosphere of irradiated
exoplanets: a robust mechanism to explain radius inflation
Submitted: 2017-04-18
The anomalously large radii of strongly irradiated exoplanets have remained a
major puzzle in astronomy. Based on a 2D steady state atmospheric circulation
model, the validity of which is assessed by comparison to 3D calculations, we
reveal a new mechanism, namely the advection of the potential temperature due
to mass and longitudinal momentum conservation, a process occuring in the
Earth's atmosphere or oceans. At depth, the vanishing heating flux forces the
atmospheric structure to converge to a hotter adiabat than the one obtained
with 1D calculations, implying a larger radius for the planet. Not only do the
calculations reproduce the observed radius of HD209458b, but also the observed
correlation between radius inflation and irradiation for transiting planets.
Vertical advection of potential temperature induced by non uniform atmospheric
heating thus provides a robust mechanism explaining the inflated radii of
irradiated hot Jupiters.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.00539 [pdf] - 1582308
Results from a set of three-dimensional numerical experiments of a hot
Jupiter atmosphere
Mayne, N. J.;
Debras, F.;
Baraffe, I.;
Thuburn, John;
Amundsen, David S.;
Acreman, David M.;
Smith, Chris;
Browning, Matthew K.;
Manners, James;
Wood, Nigel
Submitted: 2017-04-03
We present highlights from a large set of simulations of a hot Jupiter
atmosphere, nominally based on HD 209458b, aimed at exploring both the
evolution of the deep atmosphere, and the acceleration of the zonal flow or
jet. We find the occurrence of a super-rotating equatorial jet is robust to
changes in various parameters, and over long timescales, even in the absence of
strong inner or bottom boundary drag. This jet is diminished in one simulation
only, where we strongly force the deep atmosphere equator-to-pole temperature
gradient over long timescales. Finally, although the eddy momentum fluxes in
our atmosphere show similarities with the proposed mechanism for accelerating
jets on tidally-locked planets, the picture appears more complex. We present
tentative evidence for a jet driven by a combination of eddy momentum transport
and mean flow.