Normalized to: De Marco, D.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.4423 [pdf] - 876865
Antarctic Radio Frequency Albedo and Implications for Cosmic Ray
Reconstruction
Besson, D. Z.;
Stockham, J.;
Sullivan, M.;
Allison, P.;
Barwick, S. W.;
Baughman, B. M.;
Beatty, J. J.;
Belov, K.;
Bevan, S.;
Binns, W. R.;
Chen, C.;
Chen, P.;
Clem, J. M.;
Connolly, A.;
De Marco, D.;
Dowkontt, P. F.;
DuVernois, M.;
Goldstein, D.;
Gorham, P. W.;
Grashorn, E. W.;
Hill, B.;
Hoover, S.;
Huang, M.;
Israel, M. H.;
Javaid, A.;
Kowalski, J.;
Learned, J.;
Liewer, K. M.;
Matsuno, S.;
Mercurio, B. C.;
Miki, C.;
Mottram, M.;
Nam, J.;
Naudet, C. J.;
Nichol, R. J.;
Palladino, K.;
Romero-Wolf, A.;
Ruckman, L.;
Saltzberg, D.;
Seckel, D.;
Shang, R. Y.;
Stockham, M.;
Varner, G. S.;
Vieregg, A. G.;
Wang, Y.
Submitted: 2013-01-18, last modified: 2014-10-06
From an elevation of ~38 km, the balloon-borne ANtarctic Impulsive Transient
Antenna (ANITA) is designed to detect the up-coming radio frequency (RF) signal
resulting from a sub-surface neutrino-nucleon collision. Although no neutrinos
have been discovered thus far, ANITA is nevertheless the only experiment to
self-trigger on radio frequency emissions from cosmic-ray induced atmospheric
air showers. In the majority of those cases, down-coming RF signals are
observed via their reflection from the Antarctic ice sheet and back up to the
ANITA interferometer. Estimating the energy scale of the incident cosmic rays
therefore requires an estimate of the fractional power reflected at the air-ice
interface. Similarly, inferring the energy of neutrinos interacting in-ice from
observations of the upwards-directed signal refracting out to ANITA also
requires consideration of signal coherence across the interface. By comparing
the direct Solar RF signal intensity measured with ANITA to the
surface-reflected Solar signal intensity, as a function of incident elevation
angle relative to the surface {\Theta}, we estimate the power reflection
coefficients R({\Theta}). We find general consistency between our average
measurements and the values of R({\Theta}) expected from the Fresnel equations,
separately for horizontal- vs. vertical-polarizations.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.3206 [pdf] - 1405023
The First Limits on the Ultra-high Energy Neutrino Fluence from
Gamma-ray Bursts
Vieregg, A. G.;
Palladino, K.;
Allison, P.;
Baughman, B. M.;
Beatty, J. J.;
Belov, K.;
Besson, D. Z.;
Bevan, S.;
Binns, W. R.;
Chen, C.;
Chen, P.;
Clem, J. M.;
Connolly, A.;
Detrixhe, M.;
De Marco, D.;
Dowkontt, P. F.;
DuVernois, M.;
Gorham, P. W.;
Grashorn, E. W.;
Hill, B.;
Hoover, S.;
Huang, M.;
Israel, M. H.;
Javaid, A.;
Liewer, K. M.;
Matsuno, S.;
Mercurio, B. C.;
Miki, C.;
Mottram, M.;
Nam, J.;
Nichol, R. J.;
Romero-Wolf, A.;
Ruckman, L.;
Saltzberg, D.;
Seckel, D.;
Varner, G. S.;
Wang, Y.
Submitted: 2011-02-15
We set the first limits on the ultra-high energy (UHE) neutrino fluence at
energies greater than 10^9 GeV from gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) based on data from
the second flight of the ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna (ANITA). During
the 31 day flight of ANITA-II, 26 GRBs were recorded by Swift or Fermi. Of
these, we analyzed the 12 GRBs which occurred during quiet periods when the
payload was away from anthropogenic activity. In a blind analysis, we observe 0
events on a total background of 0.0044 events in the combined prompt window for
all 12 low-background bursts. We also observe 0 events from the remaining 14
bursts. We place a 90% confidence level limit on the E^-4 prompt neutrino
fluence of 2.5x10^17 GeV^3/cm^2 between 10^8 and 10^12 GeV from GRB090107A.
This is the first reported limit on the UHE neutrino fluence from GRBs above
10^9 GeV, and the strongest limit above 10^8 GeV.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.5004 [pdf] - 1042144
Erratum: Observational Constraints on the Ultra-high Energy Cosmic
Neutrino Flux from the Second Flight of the ANITA Experiment
Gorham, P. W.;
Allison, P.;
Baughman, B. M.;
Beatty, J. J.;
Belov, K.;
Besson, D. Z.;
Bevan, S.;
Binns, W. R.;
Chen, C.;
Chen, P.;
Clem, J. M.;
Connolly, A.;
Detrixhe, M.;
De Marco, D.;
Dowkontt, P. F.;
DuVernois, M.;
Grashorn, E. W.;
Hill, B.;
Hoover, S.;
Huang, M.;
Israel, M. H.;
Javaid, A.;
Liewer, K. M.;
Matsuno, S.;
Mercurio, B. C.;
Miki, C.;
Mottram, M.;
Nam, J.;
Nichol, R. J.;
Palladino, K.;
Romero-Wolf, A.;
Ruckman, L.;
Saltzberg, D.;
Seckel, D.;
Shang, R. Y.;
Varner, G. S.;
Vieregg, A. G.;
Wang, Y.
Submitted: 2010-11-22
This is an erratum to our paper in Physical Review D82:022004,2010,
corresponding to preprint: arXiv:1003.2961 .
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.2961 [pdf] - 270035
Observational Constraints on the Ultra-high Energy Cosmic Neutrino Flux
from the Second Flight of the ANITA Experiment
The ANITA Collaboration;
Gorham, P. W.;
Allison, P.;
Baughman, B. M.;
Beatty, J. J.;
Belov, K.;
Besson, D. Z.;
Bevan, S.;
Binns, W. R.;
Chen, C.;
Chen, P.;
Clem, J. M.;
Connolly, A.;
Detrixhe, M.;
De Marco, D.;
Dowkontt, P. F.;
DuVernois, M.;
Grashorn, E. W.;
Hill, B.;
Hoover, S.;
Huang, M.;
Israel, M. H.;
Javaid, A.;
Liewer, K. M.;
Matsuno, S.;
Mercurio, B. C.;
Miki, C.;
Mottram, M.;
Nam, J.;
Nichol, R. J.;
Palladino, K.;
Romero-Wolf, A.;
Ruckman, L.;
Saltzberg, D.;
Seckel, D.;
Varner, G. S.;
Vieregg, A. G.;
Wang, Y.
Submitted: 2010-03-15, last modified: 2010-05-18
The Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna (ANITA) completed its second
long-duration balloon flight in January 2009, with 31 days aloft (28.5 live
days) over Antarctica. ANITA searches for impulsive coherent radio Cherenkov
emission from 200 to 1200 MHz, arising from the Askaryan charge excess in
ultra-high energy neutrino-induced cascades within Antarctic ice. This flight
included significant improvements over the first flight in the payload
sensitivity, efficiency, and a flight trajectory over deeper ice. Analysis of
in-flight calibration pulses from surface and sub-surface locations verifies
the expected sensitivity. In a blind analysis, we find 2 surviving events on a
background, mostly anthropogenic, of 0.97+-0.42 events. We set the strongest
limit to date for 1-1000 EeV cosmic neutrinos, excluding several current
cosmogenic neutrino models.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:0907.5275 [pdf] - 148512
ESAF: Full Simulation of Space-Based Extensive Air Showers Detectors
Berat, C.;
Bottai, S.;
De Marco, D.;
Moreggia, S.;
Naumov, D.;
Pallavicini, M.;
Pesce, R.;
Petrolini, A.;
Stutz, A.;
Taddei, E.;
Thea, A.
Submitted: 2009-07-30, last modified: 2010-02-18
Future detection of Extensive Air Showers (EAS) produced by Ultra High Energy
Cosmic Particles (UHECP) by means of space based fluorescence telescopes will
open a new window on the universe and allow cosmic ray and neutrino astronomy
at a level that is virtually impossible for ground based detectors. In this
paper we summarize the results obtained in the context of the EUSO project by
means of a detailed Monte Carlo simulation of all the physical processes
involved in the fluorescence technique, from the Extensive Air Shower
development to the instrument response. Particular emphasis is given to
modeling the light propagation in the atmosphere and the effect of clouds. Main
results on energy threshold and resolution, direction resolution and Xmax
determination are reported. Results are based on EUSO telescope design, but are
also extended to larger and more sensitive detectors.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:0705.3184 [pdf] - 1504
Numerical Propagation of Cosmic Rays in the Galaxy
Submitted: 2007-05-22
We present a Monte-Carlo (MC) calculation of the propagation of cosmic ray
protons in the Galaxy for energies above 1 PeV. We discuss the relative
strengths of competing effects such as parallel/perpendicular diffusion and
drifts in toy models of the Galaxy. We compare our estimates with the results
of the MC calculation for the toy models and then we apply the MC calculation
to a few more realistic models of the Galactic magnetic field. We study the
containment times in different models of the magnetic field in order to
understand which one may be consistent with the low energy data.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:0705.1972 [pdf] - 1251
Numerical propagation of high energy cosmic rays in the Galaxy I:
technical issues
Submitted: 2007-05-14
We present the results of a numerical simulation of propagation of cosmic
rays with energy above $10^{15}$ eV in a complex magnetic field, made in
general of a large scale component and a turbulent component. Several
configurations are investigated that may represent specific aspects of a
realistic magnetic field of the Galaxy, though the main purpose of this
investigation is not to achieve a realistic description of the propagation in
the Galaxy, but rather to assess the role of several effects that define the
complex problem of propagation. Our simulations of Cosmic Rays in the Galaxy
will be presented in Paper II. We identified several effects that are difficult
to interpret in a purely diffusive approach and that play a crucial role in the
propagation of cosmic rays in the complex magnetic field of the Galaxy. We
discuss at length the problem of the extrapolation of our results to much lower
energies where data are available on the confinement time of cosmic rays in the
Galaxy. The confinement time and its dependence on particles' rigidity are
crucial ingredients for 1) relating the source spectrum to the observed cosmic
ray spectrum; 2) quantifying the production of light elements by spallation; 3)
predicting the anisotropy as a function of energy.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0609118 [pdf] - 84710
Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays: Observations and Theoretical Aspects
Submitted: 2006-09-05
We present a brief introduction to the physics of Ultra High Energy Cosmic
Rays (UHECRs), concentrating on the experimental results obtained so far and on
what, from these results, can be inferred about the sources of UHECRs.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0603615 [pdf] - 80824
Small Scale Anisotropy Predictions for the Auger Observatory
Submitted: 2006-03-22
We study the small scale anisotropy signal expected at the Pierre Auger
Observatory in the next 1, 5, 10, and 15 years of operation, from sources of
ultra-high energy (UHE) protons. We numerically propagate UHE protons over
cosmological distances using an injection spectrum and normalization that fits
current data up to $\sim 10^{20}\eV$. We characterize possible sources of
ultra-high energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) by their mean density in the local
Universe, $\bar{\rho} = 10^{-r}$ Mpc$^{-3}$, with $r$ between 3 and 6.
These densities span a wide range of extragalactic sites for UHECR sources,
from common to rare galaxies or even clusters of galaxies. We simulate 100
realizations for each model and calculate the two point correlation function
for events with energies above $4 \times 10^{19}\eV$ and above $10^{20}\eV$, as
specialized to the case of the Auger telescope. We find that for $r\ga 4$,
Auger should be able to detect small scale anisotropies in the near future.
Distinguishing between different source densities based on cosmic ray data
alone will be more challenging than detecting a departure from isotropy and is
likely to require larger statistics of events. Combining the angular
distribution studies with the spectral shape around the GZK feature will also
help distinguish between different source scenarios.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0512479 [pdf] - 358306
Cosmogenic Neutrinos from Cosmic Ray Interactions with Extragalactic
Infrared Photons
Submitted: 2005-12-19
We discuss the production of cosmogenic neutrinos on extragalactic infrared
photons in a model of its cosmological evolution. The relative importance of
these infrared photons as a target for proton interactions is significant,
especially in the case of steep injection spectra of the ultrahigh energy
cosmic rays. For an E$^{-2.5}$ cosmic ray injection spectrum, for example, the
event rate of neutrinos of energy above 1 PeV is more than doubled.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511535 [pdf] - 77893
High Energy Neutrinos from Cosmic Ray Interactions in Clusters of
Galaxies
Submitted: 2005-11-17
The spatial clustering of galaxies in galaxy clusters implies that the
background of infrared (IR) light in the intracluster medium (ICM) may exceed
the universal background. Cosmic rays injected within the ICM propagate
diffusively and at low enough energies are trapped there for cosmological
times. The photopion production interactions of cosmic rays with the IR photons
are responsible for the generation of neutrinos whose detection may shed some
light on the origin and propagation of high energy cosmic rays in the universe.
Here we discuss our calculations of the flux of neutrinos from single clusters
as well as the contribution of photopion production in clusters of galaxies to
the diffuse neutrino background.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0506318 [pdf] - 358301
On the shape of the UHE cosmic ray spectrum
Submitted: 2005-06-14, last modified: 2005-09-28
We fit the ultra high energy cosmic ray spectra above 10$^{19}$ eV with
different injection spectra at cosmic ray sources that are uniformly and
homogeneously distributed in the Universe. We conclude that the current UHE
spectra are consistent with power laws of index $\alpha$ between 2.4 and 2.7.
There is a slow dependence of these indices on the cosmological evolution of
the cosmic ray sources, which in this model determines the end of the galactic
cosmic rays spectrum.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0507324 [pdf] - 74493
A closer look at the spectrum and small scale anisotropies of UHECRs
Submitted: 2005-07-13
We present results of numerical simulations of the propagation of ultra high
energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) over cosmological distances, aimed at quantifying
the statistical significance of the highest energy data on the spectrum and
small scale anisotropies as detected by the AGASA experiment. We assess the
significance of the lack of a GZK feature and its compatibility with the
reported small scale anisotropies.
Assuming that UHECRs are protons from extragalactic sources, we find that the
small scale anisotropies are incompatible with the reported spectrum at a
probability level of $2 \times 10^{-5}$. Our analysis of the AGASA results
shows the power of combining spectrum and small scale anisotropy data in future
high statistics experiments, such as Auger.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0506412 [pdf] - 73812
Propagation of UHECRs
Submitted: 2005-06-17, last modified: 2005-06-21
In this general introduction to Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays (UHECRs) we
discuss the propagation of UHE protons and the GZK feature that is expected
approaching $10^{20}\eV$ for homogeneously distributed sources. We also briefly
present the effects of the propagation on other particles that can play the
role of UHECRs. With the help of numerical simulations for the propgation of
UHECRs, we show that the GZK feature cannot be accurately determined with the
small sample of events with energies $\sim10^{20}\eV$ detected thus far by the
largest two experiments, AGASA and HiRes.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0404352 [pdf] - 64260
High energy gamma ray counterparts of astrophysical sources of
ultra-high energy cosmic rays
Submitted: 2004-04-19
If ultra-high energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) are accelerated at astrophysical
point sources, the identification of such sources can be achieved if there is
some kind of radiation at observable wavelengths that may be associated with
the acceleration and/or propagation processes. No radiation of this type has so
far been detected or at least no such connection has been claimed. The process
of photopion production during the propagation of UHECRs from the sources to
the Earth results in the generation of charged and neutral pions. The neutral
(charged) pions in turn decay to gamma quanta and electrons that initiate an
electromagnetic cascade in the universal photon background. We calculate the
flux of this gamma radiation in the GeV-TeV energy range and find that for
source luminosities compatible with those expected from small scale
anisotropies in the directions of arrival of UHECRs, the fluxes can be
detectable by future Cerenkov gamma ray telescopes, such as VERITAS and HESS,
provided the intergalactic magnetic field is not larger than $\sim 10^{-10}$
Gauss and for source distances comparable with the loss length for photopion
production.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0308365 [pdf] - 58644
The GZK Feature in the Spectrum of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays
Submitted: 2003-08-21
The detection of the GZK feature in the cosmic ray spectrum, resultingfrom
the production of pions by ultra-high energy protons scattering off the cosmic
microwave background (CMB), can shed light on the mysterious sources of these
high energy particles. Using numerical simulations we developed for the
propagation of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays (UHECR) in the CMB we determine
the statistical significance of the GZK feature in the spectrum of UHECR
measured by AGASA and HiRes and we show that, with the small sample of events
with energies of the order of 10^20 eV detected thus far, an accurate and
statistically significant determination of the GZK feature is not possible. The
data from these two experiments are best fit by two different injection spectra
in the region below 10^20 eV, and a comparison of the spectra suggests the
resence of about a 30% systematic errors in the relative energy determination.
Correcting for these systematics, the two experiments are best fit by the same
injection spectrum in the region below 10^20 eV, while above this threshold
they maintain their disagreement, but only at the 2 sigma level. These results
clearly show the need for much larger experiments such as Auger, EUSO and OWL,
that can increase the number of detected events by one or two orders of
magnitude making the determination of the GZK feature feasible.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0307067 [pdf] - 57780
The Small Scale Anisotropies, the Spectrum and the Sources of Ultra High
Energy Cosmic Rays
Submitted: 2003-07-03
We calculate the number density and luminosity of the sources of ultra high
energy cosmic rays (UHECRs), using the information about the small scale
anisotropies and the observed spectra. We find that the number of doublets and
triplets observed by AGASA can be best reproduced for a source density of $\sim
10^{-5} Mpc^{-3}$, with large uncertainties. The spectrum of UHECRs implies an
energy input of $\sim 6\times 10^{44} erg yr^{-1} Mpc^{-3}$ above $10^{19}$ eV
and an injection spectrum $\propto E^{-2.6}$. A flatter injection spectrum,
$E^{-2.4}$, can be adopted if the sources have luminosity evolution $\propto
(1+z)^4$. The combination of these two pieces of information suggests that the
single sources should on average have a cosmic ray luminosity above $10^{19}$
eV of $L_{source}\approx 2\times 10^{42} erg s^{-1}$, weakly dependent upon the
injection spectrum. Unfortunately, with the limited statistics of events
available at present, there are approximately one-two orders of magnitude
uncertainty in the source density provided above. We make predictions on the
expected performances of the Auger and EUSO experiments, with particular
attention for the expected improvements in our understanding of the nature of
the sources of UHECRs. We find that a critical experimental exposure $\Sigma_c$
exists, such that experiments with exposure larger than $\Sigma_c$ can detect
at least one event from each source at energies above $10^{20}$ eV. This
represents a unique opportunity to directly count and identify the sources of
UHECRs.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0305336 [pdf] - 56809
The GZK Feature in the Spectrum of UHECRs: What is it Telling Us?
Submitted: 2003-05-19
We developed a numerical simulation of the propagation of UHECR in the Cosmic
Microwave Background (CMB) and we used it to determine the significance of the
GZK feature in the spectrum of UHECR measured by AGASA and HiRes. We find that
these two experiments are best fit by two different injection spectra in the
region below 10^20 eV and that the error bars around the GZK feature are
dominated by fluctuations which leave a determination of the GZK feature not
attainable at present. In addition the comparison of the spectra of AGASA and
HiRes suggests the presence of about a 30% systematic errors in the relative
energy determination of the two experiments. Correcting for these systematics,
the two experiments are brought in agreement at energies below 10^20 eV and, in
this region, are best fit by an injection spectrum with spectral index 2.5-2.6.
In the high energy region (above 10^20 eV) the two experiments maintain their
disagreement, but only at the 2sigma level. Our results clearly show the need
for much larger experiments such as Auger, EUSO, and OWL, that can increase the
number of detected events by one or two orders of magnitude.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0302144 [pdf] - 880637
On the generation of UHECRs in GRBs: a reappraisal
Submitted: 2003-02-07, last modified: 2003-04-07
We re-examine critically the arguments raised against the theory that Ultra
High Energy Cosmic Rays observed at Earth are produced in Gamma Ray Bursts.
These include the limitations to the highest energy attainable by protons
around the bursts' shocks, the spectral slope at the highest energies, the
total energy released in non--thermal particles, the occurrence of doublets and
triplets in the data reported by AGASA. We show that, to within the
uncertainties in our current knowledge of GRBs, none of these objections is
really fatal to the scenario. In particular, we show that the total energy
budget of GRBs easily accounts for the energy injection rate necessary to
account for UHECRs as observed at Earth. We also compute the expected particle
spectrum at Earth, showing that it fits the HiRes and AGASA data to within
statistical uncertainties. We consider the existence of multiplets in AGASA'
data. To this end, we present a Langevin--like treatment for the motion of a
charged particle in the IGM magnetic field, which allows us to estimate both
the average and the rms timedelay for particles of given energy; we discuss
when particles of identical energies reach the Earth in bunches, or spread over
the rms timedelay, showing that multiplets pose no problem for an explosive
model for the sources of UHECRs. We compare our model with a scenario where the
particles are accelerated at internal shocks, underlining differences and
advantages of particle acceleration at external shocks.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0301497 [pdf] - 54468
On the statistical significance of the GZK feature in the spectrum of
ultra high energy cosmic rays
Submitted: 2003-01-24, last modified: 2003-03-17
The nature of the unknown sources of ultra-high energy cosmic rays can be
revealed through the detection of the GZK feature in the cosmic ray spectrum,
resulting from the production of pions by ultra-high energy protons scattering
off the cosmic microwave background. Here we show that the GZK feature cannot
be accurately determined with the small sample of events with energies $\sim
10^{20}$ eV detected thus far by the largest two experiments, AGASA and HiRes.
With the help of numerical simulations for the propagation of cosmic rays, we
find the error bars around the GZK feature are dominated by fluctuations which
leave a determination of the GZK feature unattainable at present. In addition,
differing results from AGASA and HiRes suggest the presence of $\sim 30%$
systematic errors that may be due to discrepancies in the relative energy
determination of the two experiments. Correcting for these systematics, the two
experiments are brought into agreement at energies below $\sim 10^{20}$ eV.
After simulating the GZK feature for many realizations and different injection
spectra, we determine the best fit injection spectrum required to explain the
observed spectra at energies above $10^{18.5}$ eV. We show that the discrepancy
between the two experiments at the highest energies has low statistical
significance (at the 2 $\sigma$ level) and that the corrected spectra are best
fit by an injection spectrum with spectral index $\sim 2.6$. Our results
clearly show the need for much larger experiments such as Auger, EUSO, and OWL,
that can increase the number of detected events by 2 orders of magnitude. Only
large statistics experiments can finally prove or disprove the existence of the
GZK feature in the cosmic ray spectrum.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0303177 [pdf] - 55416
Low Statistics of EHECRs
Submitted: 2003-03-07
The nature of the unknown sources of ultra-high energy cosmic rays can be
revealed through the detection of the GZK feature in the cosmic ray spectrum.
The only two experiments that have probed this energy range, AGASA and HiRes,
have apparently conflicting results. HiRes measured a flux consistent with the
GZK feature while AGASA reported a larger than expected flux of so-called
Super-GZK particles. Here we emphasize that neither experiment has gathered the
statistics necessary for making a definitive measurement of the GZK cutoff. The
photo-pion production responsible for the GZK feature is stochastic for
energies around the cutoff leading to large fluctuations of the spectrum for
low statistics measurements. We show that the results from AGASA and HiRes
results are within about $ 2 \sigma$ of one another by simulating 400 spectra
for a range of input spectral indices normalized to the number of events above
$10^{19}$ eV for each experiment. If a 15% systematic correction in energy is
applied to both experiments, the agreement between the experiments improves
considerably and the best fit input spectral index becomes $\sim 2.6$ for both
data sets. Our results clearly show the need for much larger experiments such
as Auger and EUSO, that can increase the number of detected events by 2 orders
of magnitude. Only large statistics experiments can finally prove or disprove
the existence of the GZK feature in the cosmic ray spectrum.