Normalized to: Cridland, A.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01066 [pdf] - 2126900
Tracing bulk elemental ratios in exoplanetary atmospheres with TiO
chemistry
Submitted: 2020-07-02
Knowing the bulk elemental abundances of an exoplanetary atmosphere is not an
easy task, but it is crucial to understand the formation history of planets.
The purpose of this work is to show that the observability of TiO features at
optical wavelengths in the transmission spectra of hot Jupiter atmospheres is
sensitive to the bulk chemical properties of the atmosphere. For that, we run a
grid of chemical models which include TiO formation and destruction, for the
ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-19b and an ultra-hot version of HD~209458b. We take into
account non-equilibrium chemistry and changes in the temperature and pressure
structure of these atmospheres caused by different C/O ratios. We calculate
synthetic transmission spectra for these models, and study the relative
strengths of TiO and \ce{H2O} features quantitatively. To compare with
observations, we use a model independent metric for molecular abundances,
$\Delta Z_{\rm TiO-H_2O}/H_{\rm eq}$ that has been previously used in
observational studies of exoplanetary atmospheres. We find that with this
metric we can differentiate between different chemical models and place
constraints on the atmosphere's bulk carbon and oxygen abundance. From chemical
considerations we expected that the TiO abundance would depend on the bulk
nitrogen, however found that any change to N/H did not result in changes to the
resulting TiO. We apply our method to a set of known exoplanets that have been
observed in the relevant optical wavelengths and find good agreement between
low resolution observations and our model for WASP-121b, marginally good
agreement with WASP-79b, WASP-76b, and WASP-19b, and poorer agreement with HD
209458b. Our method can be particularly helpful for indirect studies of the
bulk abundances of carbon and oxygen.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.02812 [pdf] - 2109225
Dust masses of young disks: constraining the initial solid reservoir for
planet formation
Tychoniec, Łukasz;
Manara, Carlo F.;
Rosotti, Giovanni P.;
van Dishoeck, Ewine F.;
Cridland, Alexander J.;
Hsieh, Tien-Hao;
Murillo, Nadia M.;
Segura-Cox, Dominique;
van Terwisga, Sierk E.;
Tobin, John J.
Submitted: 2020-06-04, last modified: 2020-06-05
In recent years evidence has been building that planet formation starts
early, in the first $\sim$ 0.5 Myr. Studying the dust masses available in young
disks enables understanding the origin of planetary systems since mature disks
are lacking the solid material necessary to reproduce the observed exoplanetary
systems, especially the massive ones. We aim to determine if disks in the
embedded stage of star formation contain enough dust to explain the solid
content of the most massive exoplanets. We use Atacama Large
Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) Band 6 observations of embedded disks in
the Perseus star-forming region together with Very Large Array (VLA) Ka-band (9
mm) data to provide a robust estimate of dust disk masses from the flux
densities. Using the DIANA opacity model including large grains, with a dust
opacity value of $\kappa_{\rm 9\ mm}$ = 0.28 cm$^{2}$ g$^{-1}$, the median dust
masses of the embedded disks in Perseus are 158 M$_\oplus$ for Class 0 and 52
M$_\oplus$ for Class I from the VLA fluxes. The lower limits on the median
masses from ALMA fluxes are 47 M$_\oplus$ and 12 M$_\oplus$ for Class 0 and
Class I, respectively, obtained using the maximum dust opacity value
$\kappa_{\rm 1.3mm}$ = 2.3 cm$^{2}$ g$^{-1}$. The dust masses of young Class 0
and I disks are larger by at least a factor of 10 and 3, respectively, compared
with dust masses inferred for Class II disks in Lupus and other regions. The
dust masses of Class 0 and I disks in Perseus derived from the VLA data are
high enough to produce the observed exoplanet systems with efficiencies
acceptable by planet formation models: the solid content in observed giant
exoplanets can be explained if planet formation starts in Class 0 phase with an
efficiency of $\sim$ 15%. Higher efficiency of $\sim$ 30% is necessary if the
planet formation is set to start in Class I disks.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.10588 [pdf] - 2046511
Formation of Planetary Populations II: Effects of Initial Disk Size &
Radial Dust Drift
Submitted: 2020-01-28
Recent ALMA observations indicate that while a range of disk sizes exist,
typical disk radii are small, and that radial dust drift affects the
distribution of solids in disks. Here we explore the consequences of these
features in planet population synthesis models. A key feature of our model is
planet traps - barriers to otherwise rapid type-I migration of forming planets
- for which we include the ice line, heat transition, and outer edge of the
dead zone. We find that the ice line plays a fundamental role in the formation
of warm Jupiters. In particular, the ratio of super Earths to warm Jupiters
formed at the ice line depend sensitively on the initial disk radius. Initial
gas disk radii of $\sim$50 AU results in the largest super Earth populations,
while both larger and smaller disk sizes result in the ice line producing more
gas giants near 1 AU. This transition between typical planet class formed at
the ice line at various disk radii confirms that planet formation is
fundamentally linked to disk properties (in this case, disk size), and is a
result that is only seen when dust evolution effects are included in our
models. Additionally, we find that including radial dust drift results in the
formation of more super Earths between 0.1 - 1 AU, having shorter orbital radii
than those produced in models where dust evolution effects are not included.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.05808 [pdf] - 2061659
Vertical gas accretion impacts the carbon-to-oxygen ratio of gas giant
atmospheres
Submitted: 2020-01-16
Recent theoretical, numerical, and observational work have suggested that
when a growing planet opens a gap in its disk the flow of gas into the gap is
dominated by gas falling vertically from a height of at least one gas scale
height. Our primary objective is to include, for the first time, the chemical
impact that accreting gas above the midplane will have on the resulting C/O. We
compute the accretion of gas onto planetary cores beginning at different disk
radii and track the chemical composition of the gas and small icy grains to
predict the resulting carbon-to-oxygen ratio (C/O) in their atmospheres. In our
model, all of the planets which began their evolution inward of 60 AU open a
gap in the gas disk, and hence are chemically affected by the vertically
accreting gas. Two important conclusions follow from this vertical flow: (1)
more oxygen rich icy dust grains become available for accretion onto the
planetary atmosphere. (2) The chemical composition of the gas dominates the
final C/O of planets in the inner ($<$ 20 AU) part of the disk. This implies
that with the launch of the James Webb Space Telescope we can trace the disk
material that sets the chemical composition of exoplanetary atmospheres.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.12320 [pdf] - 2020556
Diverse outcomes of planet formation and composition around low-mass
stars and brown dwarfs
Submitted: 2019-09-26, last modified: 2019-12-18
The detection of Earth-size exoplanets around low-mass stars -- in stars such
as Proxima Centauri and TRAPPIST-1 -- provide an exceptional chance to improve
our understanding of the formation of planets around M stars and brown dwarfs.
We explore the formation of such planets with a population synthesis code based
on a planetesimal-driven model previously used to study the formation of the
Jovian satellites. Because the discs have low mass and the stars are cool, the
formation is an inefficient process that happens at short periods, generating
compact planetary systems. Planets can be trapped in resonances and we follow
the evolution of the planets after the gas has dissipated and they undergo
orbit crossings and possible mergers. We find that formation of planets above
Mars mass and in the planetesimal accretion scenario, is only possible around
stars with masses $M_{\star} \ge 0.07 M_{sun}$ and discs of $M_{disc} \ge
10^{-2}~M_{sun} $. We find that planets above Earth-mass form around stars with
masses larger than $0.15 M_{\oplus}$ while planets larger than $5 M_{\oplus}$do
not form in our model, even not under the most optimal conditions (massive
disc), showing that planets such as GJ 3512b form with another, more efficient
mechanism. Our results show that the majority of planets form with a
significant water fraction; that most of our synthetic planetary systems have
1, 2, or 3 planets, but those with 4, 5, 6, and 7 planets are also common,
confirming that compact planetary systems with many planets should be a
relatively common outcome of planet formation around small stars.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.11154 [pdf] - 2011995
Jupiter formed as a pebble pile around the N$_2$ ice line
Submitted: 2019-11-25
The region around the H$_2$O ice line, due to its higher surface density,
seems to be the ideal location to form planets. The core of Jupiter, as well as
the cores of close in gas giants are thus thought to form in this region of the
disk. Actually constraining the formation location of individual planets has
proven to be difficult, however. We aim to use the Nitrogen abundance in
Jupiter, which is around 4 times solar, in combination with \textit{Juno}
constraints on the total mass of heavy elements in Jupiter, to narrow down its
formation scenario. Different pathways of enrichment of Jupiter's atmosphere,
such as the accretion of enriched gas, pebbles or planetesimals are considered
and their implications for the oxygen abundance of Jupiter is discussed. The
super solar Nitrogen abundance in Jupiter necessitates the accretion of extra
N$_2$ from the proto-solar nebula. The only location of the disk that this can
happen is outside, or just inside the N$_2$ ice line. These constraints favor a
pebble accretion origin of Jupiter, both from the composition as well as from a
planet formation perspective. We predict that Jupiter's oxygen abundance is
between 3.6 and 4.5 times solar.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.13171 [pdf] - 2008022
Connecting planet formation and astrochemistry: A main sequence for C/O
in hot-exoplanetary atmospheres
Submitted: 2019-10-29
To understand the role that planet formation history has on the observable
atmospheric carbon-to-oxygen ratio (C/O) we have produced a population of
astrochemically evolving protoplanetary disks. Based on the parameters used in
a pre-computed population of growing planets their combination allows us to
trace the molecular abundances of the gas that is being collected into
planetary atmospheres. We include atmospheric pollution of incoming (icy)
planetesimals as well as the effect of refractory carbon erosion noted to exist
in our own solar system. We find that the carbon and oxygen content of
Neptune-mass planets are determined primarily through solid accretion and
result in more oxygen-rich (by roughly two orders of magnitude) atmospheres
than Hot-Jupiters, whose C/O are primarily determined by gas accretion.
Generally we find a `main-sequence' between the fraction of planetary mass
accreted through solid accretion and the resulting atmospheric C/O - with
planets of higher solid accretion fraction having lower C/O. Hot-Jupiters whose
atmospheres have been chemically characterized agree well with our population
of planets, and our results suggest that Hot Jupiter formation typically begins
near the water ice line. Lower mass hot-Neptunes are observed to be much more
carbon-rich (with 0.33 $\lesssim$ C/O $\lesssim$ 1) than is found in our models
(C/O $\sim 10^{-2}$), and suggest that some form of chemical processing may
affect their observed C/O over the few Gyrs between formation and observation.
Our population reproduces the general mass-metallicity trend of the solar
system and qualitatively reproduces the C/O-metallicity anti-correlation that
has been inferred for the population of characterized exoplanetary atmospheres.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.08896 [pdf] - 1916803
Connecting planet formation and astrochemistry: Refractory carbon
depletion leading to super-stellar C/O in giant planetary atmospheres
Submitted: 2019-01-25
[Abridged] Combining a time-dependent astrochemical model with a model of
planet formation and migration, we compute the carbon-to-oxygen ratio (C/O) of
a range of planetary embryos starting their formation in the inner solar system
(1-3 AU). The volatile and ice abundance of relevant carbon and oxygen bearing
molecular species are determined through a complex chemical kinetic code which
includes both gas and grain surface chemistry. This is combined with a model
for the abundance of the refractory dust grains to compute the total carbon and
oxygen abundance in the protoplanetary disk available for incorporation into a
planetary atmosphere. We include the effects of the refractory carbon depletion
that has been observed in our solar system, and posit two models that would put
this missing carbon back into the gas phase. This excess gaseous carbon then
becomes important in determining the final planetary C/O because the gas disk
now becomes more carbon rich relative to oxygen (high gaseous C/O). One model,
where the carbon excess is maintained throughout the lifetime of the disk
results in Hot Jupiters that have super-stellar C/O. The other model deposits
the excess carbon early in the disk life and allows it to advect with the bulk
gas. In this model the excess carbon disappears into the host star within 0.8
Myr, returning the gas disk to its original (sub-stellar) C/O, so the Hot
Jupiters all exclusively have sub-stellar C/O. This shows that while the solids
will tend to be oxygen rich, Hot Jupiters can have super-stellar C/O if a
carbon excess can be maintained by some chemical processing of the dust grains.
Whether the carbon and oxygen content of the atmosphere was accreted primarily
by gas or solid accretion is heavily dependent on the mass of the atmosphere
and where in the disk the growing planet accreted.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.00778 [pdf] - 1815159
Physics of Planet Trapping with Applications to HL Tau
Submitted: 2019-01-03
We explore planet formation in the HL Tau disk and possible origins of the
prominent gaps and rings observed by ALMA. We investigate whether dust gaps are
caused by dynamically trapped planetary embryos at the ice lines of abundant
volatiles. The global properties of the HL Tau disk (total mass, size) at its
current age are used to constrain an evolving analytic disk model describing
its temperature and density profiles. By performing a detailed analysis of the
planet-disk interaction for a planet near the water ice line including a
rigorous treatment of the dust opacity, we confirm that water is sufficiently
abundant (1.5x10^-4 molecules per H) to trap planets at its ice line due to an
opacity transition. When the abundance of water is reduced by 50% planet
trapping disappears. We extend our analysis to other planet traps: the heat
transition, dead zone edge, and the CO_2 ice line and find similar trapping.
The formation of planets via planetesimal accretion is computed for dynamically
trapped embryos at the water ice line, dead zone, and heat transition. The end
products orbit in the inner disk (R < 3 AU), unresolved by ALMA, with masses
that range between sub-Earth to 5 Jupiter masses. While we find that the dust
gaps correspond well with the radial positions of the CO_2 , CH_4 , and CO ice
lines, the planetesimal accretion rates at these radii are too small to build
large embryos within 1 Myr.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.04657 [pdf] - 1789511
Magnetically induced termination of giant planet formation
Submitted: 2018-09-12, last modified: 2018-09-20
Here a physical model for terminating giant planet formation is outlined and
compared to other methods of late-stage giant planet formation. As has been
pointed out before, gas accreting into a gap and onto the planet will encounter
the planetary dynamo-generated magnetic field. The planetary magnetic field
produces an effective cross section through which gas is accreted. Gas outside
this cross section is recycled into the protoplanetary disk, hence only a
fraction of mass that is accreted into the gap remains bound to the planet.
This cross section inversely scales with the planetary mass, which naturally
leads to stalled planetary growth late in the formation process. We show that
this method naturally leads to Jupiter-mass planets and does not invoke any
artificial truncation of gas accretion, as has been done in some previous
population synthesis models. The mass accretion rate depends on the radius of
the growing planet after the gap has opened, and we show that so-called
hot-start planets tend to become more massive than cold-start planets. When
this result is combined with population synthesis models, it might show
observable signatures of cold-start versus hot-start planets in the exoplanet
population.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.04070 [pdf] - 1790672
Connecting Planetary Composition with Formation
Submitted: 2018-04-11
The rapid advances in observations of the different populations of
exoplanets, the characterization of their host stars and the links to the
properties of their planetary systems, the detailed studies of protoplanetary
disks, and the experimental study of the interiors and composition of the
massive planets in our solar system provide a firm basis for the next big
question in planet formation theory. How do the elemental and chemical
compositions of planets connect with their formation? The answer to this
requires that the various pieces of planet formation theory be linked together
in an end-to-end picture that is capable of addressing these large data sets.
In this review, we discuss the critical elements of such a picture and how they
affect the chemical and elemental make up of forming planets. Important issues
here include the initial state of forming and evolving disks, chemical and dust
processes within them, the migration of planets and the importance of planet
traps, the nature of angular momentum transport processes involving turbulence
and/or MHD disk winds, planet formation theory, and advanced treatments of disk
astrochemistry. All of these issues affect, and are affected by the chemistry
of disks which is driven by X-ray ionization of the host stars. We discuss how
these processes lead to a coherent end-to-end model and how this may address
the basic question.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.02381 [pdf] - 1573966
Composition of Early Planetary Atmospheres II: Coupled Dust and Chemical
Evolution in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2017-05-05
We present the next step in a series of papers devoted to connecting the
composition of the atmospheres of forming planets with the chemistry of their
natal evolving protoplanetary disks. The model presented here computes the
coupled chemical and dust evolution of the disk and the formation of three
planets per disk model. Our three canonical planet traps produce a Jupiter near
1 AU, a Hot Jupiter and a Super-Earth. We study the dependency of the final
orbital radius, mass, and atmospheric chemistry of planets forming in disk
models with initial disk masses that vary by 0.02 $M_\odot$ above and below our
fiducial model ($M_{disk,0} = 0.1 ~M_\odot$). We compute C/O and C/N for the
atmospheres formed in our 3 models and find that C/O$_{\rm planet}\sim$
C/O$_{\rm disk}$, which does not vary strongly between different planets formed
in our model. The nitrogen content of atmospheres can vary in planets that grow
in different disk models. These differences are related to the formation
history of the planet, the time and location that the planet accretes its
atmosphere, and are encoded in the bulk abundance of NH$_3$. These results
suggest that future observations of atmospheric NH$_3$ and an estimation of the
planetary C/O and C/N can inform the formation history of particular planetary
systems.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.02718 [pdf] - 1511474
Radial Drift of Dust in Protoplanetary Disks: The Evolution of Ice lines
and Dead zones
Submitted: 2016-11-08
We have developed a new model for the astrochemical structure of a viscously
evolving protoplanetary disk that couples an analytic description of the disk's
temperature and density profile, chemical evolution, and an evolving dust
distribution. We compute evolving radial distributions for a range of dust
grain sizes, which depend on coagulation, fragmentation and radial drift
processes. In particular we find that the water ice line plays an important
role in shaping the radial distribution of the maximum grain size because ice
coated grains are significantly less susceptible to fragmentation than their
dry counterparts. This in turn has important effects on disk ionization and
therefore on the location of dead zones. In comparison to a simple constant
gas-to-dust ratio model for the dust as an example, we find that the new model
predicts an outer dead zone edge that moves in by a factor of about 3 at 1 Myr
(to 5 AU) and by a factor of about 14 by 3 Myr (to 0.5 AU). We show that the
changing position of the dead zone and heat transition traps have important
implications for the formation and trapping of planets in protoplanetary disks.
Finally, we consider our results in light of recent ALMA observations of HL Tau
and TW Hya.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.09174 [pdf] - 1483411
On the Formation and Chemical Composition of Super Earths
Submitted: 2016-06-29, last modified: 2016-09-13
Super Earths are the largest population of exoplanets and are seen to exhibit
a rich diversity of compositions as inferred through their mean densities. Here
we present a model that combines equilibrium chemistry in evolving disks with
core accretion that tracks materials accreted onto planets during their
formation. In doing so, we aim to explain why super Earths form so frequently
and how they acquire such a diverse range of compositions. A key feature of our
model is disk inhomogeneities, or planet traps, that act as barriers to rapid
type-I migration. The traps we include are the dead zone, which can be caused
by either cosmic ray or X-ray ionization, the ice line, and the heat
transition. We find that in disks with sufficiently long lifetimes ($\gtrsim$ 4
Myr), all traps produce Jovian planets. In these disks, planet formation in the
heat transition and X-ray dead zone produces hot Jupiters while the ice line
and cosmic ray dead zones produce Jupiters at roughly 1 AU. Super Earth
formation takes place within short-lived disks ($\lesssim$ 2 Myr), whereby the
disks are photoevaporated while planets are in a slow phase of gas accretion.
We find that super Earth compositions range from dry and rocky ($<$ 6 % ice by
mass) to those with substantial water contents ($>$ 30 % ice by mass). The
traps play a crucial role in our results, as they dictate where in the disk
particular planets can accrete from, and what compositions they are able to
acquire.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.09407 [pdf] - 1530765
Composition of Early Planetary Atmospheres I: Connecting Disk
Astrochemistry to the Formation of Planetary Atmospheres
Submitted: 2016-05-30, last modified: 2016-06-21
We present a model of the early chemical composition and elemental abundances
of planetary atmospheres based on the cumulative gaseous chemical species that
are accreted onto planets forming by core accretion from evolving
protoplanetary disks. The astrochemistry of the host disk is computed using an
ionization driven, non-equilibrium chemistry network within viscously evolving
disk models. We accrete gas giant planets whose orbital evolution is controlled
by planet traps using the standard core accretion model and track the chemical
composition of the material that is accreted onto the protoplanet. We choose a
fiducial disk model and evolve planets in 3 traps - water ice line, dead zone
and heat transition. For a disk with a lifetime of 4.1 Myr we produce two Hot
Jupiters (M = 1.43, 2.67 M$_{\rm Jupiter}$, r = 0.15, 0.11 AU) in the heat
transition and ice line trap and one failed core (M = 0.003 M$_{\rm Jupiter}$,
r =3.7 AU) in the dead zone. These planets are found with mixing ratios for CO
and H$_2$O of $1.99\times 10^{-4}$, $5.0\times 10^{-4}$ respectively for both
Hot Jupiters. Additionally for these planets we find CO$_2$ and CH$_4$, with
mixing ratios of $1.8\times 10^{-6}\rightarrow 9.8\times 10^{-10}$ and
$1.1\times 10^{-8}\rightarrow 2.3\times 10^{-10}$ respectively. These ranges
correspond well with the mixing ratio ranges that have been inferred through
the detection of emission spectra from Hot Jupiters by multiple authors. We
compute a carbon-to-oxygen ratio of 0.227 for the ice line planet and 0.279 for
the heat transition planet. These planets accreted their gas inside the ice
line, hence the sub-solar C/O.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.6338 [pdf] - 1179468
Cold dust but warm gas in the unusual elliptical galaxy NGC 4125
Wilson, C. D.;
Cridland, A.;
Foyle, K.;
Parkin, T. J.;
Cooper, E. Mentuch;
Roussel, H.;
Sauvage, M.;
Smith, M. W. L.;
Baes, M.;
Bendo, G.;
Boquien, M.;
Boselli, A.;
Ciesla, L.;
Clements, D. L.;
Cooray, A.;
De Looze, I.;
Galametz, M.;
Gear, W.;
Lebouteiller, V.;
Madden, S.;
Pereira-Santaella, M.;
Remy-Ruyer, A.
Submitted: 2013-09-24
Data from the Herschel Space Observatory have revealed an unusual elliptical
galaxy, NGC 4125, which has strong and extended submillimeter emission from
cold dust but only very strict upper limits to its CO and HI emission.
Depending on the dust emissivity, the total dust mass is 2-5x10^6 Msun. While
the neutral gas-to-dust mass ratio is extremely low (< 12-30), including the
ionized gas traced by [CII] emission raises this limit to < 39-100. The dust
emission follows a similar r^{1/4} profile to the stellar light and the dust to
stellar mass ratio is towards the high end of what is found in nearby
elliptical galaxies. We suggest that NGC 4125 is currently in an unusual phase
where evolved stars produced in a merger-triggered burst of star formation are
pumping large amounts of gas and dust into the interstellar medium. In this
scenario, the low neutral gas-to-dust mass ratio is explained by the gas being
heated to temperatures >= 10^4 K faster than the dust is evaporated. If
galaxies like NGC 4125, where the far-infrared emission does not trace neutral
gas in the usual manner, are common at higher redshift, this could have
significant implications for our understanding of high redshift galaxies and
galaxy evolution.