From four independent calculations using three different theoretical approaches, rate coefficients for the formation of HeH$^+$ via the radiative association of He$^+$ and H were computed. Good agreement is found between our new calculations and prior results obtained two decades ago for kinetic temperatures between $\sim$800 and 20,000 K. This finding is inconsistent with a recent claim in the literature of a wide variation in published values and establishes the robustness of our knowledge of this process for the formation of HeH$^+$. The implications of the current results to the first detection of HeH$^+$ and its modeled abundance in the planetary nebula NGC 7027 are discussed.