Normalized to: Commercon, B.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.11194 [pdf] - 2034491
The dynamically young outflow of the Class 0 protostar Cha-MMS1
Submitted: 2019-11-25
On the basis of its low luminosity, its chemical composition, and the absence
of a large-scale outflow, the dense core Cha-MMS1 located in the Chamaeleon I
molecular cloud was proposed as a first hydrostatic core (FHSC) candidate a
decade ago. Our goal is to test this hypothesis by searching for a slow,
compact outflow driven by Cha-MMS1 that would match the predictions of MHD
simulations for this short phase of star formation. We use the Atacama Large
Millimetre/submillimetre Array (ALMA) to map Cha-MMS1 at high angular
resolution in CO 3-2 and 13CO 3-2 as well as in continuum emission. We report
the detection of a bipolar outflow emanating from the central core, along a
(projected) direction roughly parallel to the filament in which Cha-MMS1 is
embedded and perpendicular to the large-scale magnetic field. The morphology of
the outflow indicates that its axis lies close to the plane of the sky. We
measure velocities corrected for inclination of more than 90km/s which is
clearly incompatible with the expected properties of a FHSC outflow. Several
properties of the outflow are determined and compared to previous studies of
Class 0 and Class I protostars. The outflow of Cha-MMS1 has a much smaller
momentum force than the outflows of other Class 0 protostars. In addition, we
find a dynamical age of 200-3000yr indicating that Cha-MMS1 might be one of the
youngest ever observed Class 0 protostars. While the existence of the outflow
suggests the presence of a disk, no disk is detected in continuum emission and
we derive an upper limit of 55au to its radius. We conclude that Cha-MMS1 has
already gone through the FHSC phase and is a young Class 0 protostar, but it
has not brought its outflow to full power yet.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.02591 [pdf] - 1994180
Dust Polarization Toward Embedded Protostars in Ophiuchus with ALMA.
III. Survey Overview
Sadavoy, Sarah I.;
Stephens, Ian W.;
Myers, Philip C.;
Looney, Leslie;
Tobin, John;
Kwon, Woojin;
Commercon, Benoit;
Segura-Cox, Dominique;
Henning, Thomas;
Hennebelle, Patrick
Submitted: 2019-09-05
We present 0.25 arcsec resolution (35 au) ALMA 1.3 mm dust polarization
observations for 37 young stellar objects (YSOs) in the Ophiuchus cloud. These
data encompass all the embedded protostars in the cloud and several Flat and
Class II objects to produce the largest, homogeneous study of dust polarization
on disk scales to date. The goal of this study is to study dust polarization
down to disk scales. We find that 14/37 (38%) of the YSOs are detected in
polarization. Nine of these sources have uniform polarization angles and four
sources have azimuthal polarization. The sources with uniform polarization tend
to have steeper inclinations (> 60 degree) than those with azimuthal
polarization (< 60 degree). The majority (9/14) of the detected sources have
polarization morphologies and disk properties consistent with dust
self-scattering in optically thick disks. The remaining sources may be instead
tracing magnetic fields. Their inferred field directions from rotating the
polarization vectors by 90 degree are mainly poloidal or hourglass shaped. We
find no evidence of a strong toroidal field component toward any of our disks.
For the 23 YSOs that are undetected in polarization, roughly half of them have
3-sigma upper limits of < 2%. These sources also tend to have inclinations < 60
degree and they are generally compact. Since lower inclination sources tend to
have azimuthal polarization, these YSOs may be undetected in polarization due
to unresolved polarization structure within our beam. We propose that disks
with inclinations > 60 degree are the best candidates for future polarization
studies of dust self-scattering as these systems will generally show uniform
polarization vectors that do not require very high resolution to resolve. We
release the continuum and polarization images for all the sources with this
publication. Data from the entire survey can be obtained from Dataverse.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.08542 [pdf] - 1919508
Numerical Methods for Simulating Star Formation
Submitted: 2019-07-19
We review the numerical techniques for ideal and non-ideal
magneto-hydrodynamics (MHD) used in the context of star formation simulations.
We outline the specific challenges offered by modeling star forming
environments, which are dominated by supersonic and super-Alfvenic turbulence
in a radiative, self-gravitating fluid. These conditions are rather unique in
physics and engineering and pose particularly severe restrictions on the
robustness and accuracy of numerical codes. One striking aspect is the
formation of collapsing fluid elements leading to the formation of
singularities that represent point-like objects, namely the proto-stars.
Although a few studies have attempted to resolve the formation of the first and
second Larson cores, resolution limitations force us to use sink particle
techniques, with sub-grid models to compute the accretion rates of mass,
momentum and energy, as well as their ejection rate due to radiation and jets
from the proto-stars. We discuss the most popular discretisation techniques
used in the community, namely smoothed particle hydrodynamics, finite
difference and finite volume methods, stressing the importance to maintain a
divergence-free magnetic field. We discuss how to estimate the truncation error
of a given numerical scheme, and its importance in setting the magnitude of the
numerical diffusion. This can have a strong impact on the outcome of these MHD
simulations, where both viscosity and resistivity are implemented at the grid
scale. We then present various numerical techniques to model non-ideal MHD
effects, such as Ohmic and ambipolar diffusion, as well as the Hall effect.
These important physical ingredients are posing strong challenges in term of
resolution and time stepping. For the latter, several strategies are discussed
to overcome the limitations due to prohibitively small time steps (abridged).
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.04978 [pdf] - 1875209
Gas phase Elemental abundances in Molecular cloudS (GEMS) I. The
prototypical dark cloud TMC 1
Fuente, A.;
Navarro, D.;
Caselli, P.;
Gerin, M.;
Kramer, C.;
Roueff, E.;
Alonso-Albi, T.;
Bachiller, R.;
Cazaux, S.;
Commercon, B.;
Friesen, R.;
García-Burillo, S.;
Giuliano, B. M.;
Goicoechea, J. R.;
Gratier, P.;
Hacar, A.;
Jiménez-Serra, I.;
Kirk, J.;
Lattanzi, V.;
Loison, J. C.;
Malinen, P. J.;
Marcelino, N.;
Martín-Doménech, R.;
Muñoz-Caro, G.;
Pineda, J.;
Tafalla, M.;
Tercero, B.;
Ward-Thompson, D.;
Treviño-Morales, S.;
Riviére-Marichalar, P.;
Roncero, O.;
Vidal, T.;
Ballester, Maikel Y.
Submitted: 2018-09-13, last modified: 2019-03-07
GEMS is an IRAM 30m Large Program whose aim is determining the elemental
depletions and the ionization fraction in a set of prototypical star-forming
regions. This paper presents the first results from the prototypical dark cloud
TMC 1. Extensive millimeter observations have been carried out with the IRAM
30m telescope (3mm and 2mm) and the 40m Yebes telescope (1.3cm and 7mm) to
determine the fractional abundances of CO, HCO+, HCN, CS, SO, HCS+, and N2H+ in
three cuts which intersect the dense filament at the well-known positions TMC
1-CP, TMC 1-NH3, and TMC 1-C, covering a visual extinction range from Av~3 to
~20mag. Two phases with differentiated chemistry can be distinguished: i) the
translucent envelope with molecular hydrogen densities of (1-5)x10$^3$
cm$^{-3}$; and ii) the dense phase, located at Av>10mag, with molecular
hydrogen densities >10$^4$ cm$^{-3}$. Observations and modeling show that the
gas phase abundances of C and O progressively decrease along the C+/C/CO
transition zone where C/H~8x10$^{-5}$ and C/O~0.8-1, until the beginning of the
dense phase at Av~10 mag. This is consistent with the grain temperatures being
below the CO evaporation temperature in this region. In the case of sulfur, a
strong depletion should occur before the translucent phase where we estimate a
S/H~(0.4 - 2.2) x10$^{-6}$, an abundance ~7-40 times lower than the solar
value. A second strong depletion must be present during the formation of the
thick icy mantles to achieve the values of S/H measured in the dense cold cores
(S/H~8x10$^{-8}$). Based on our chemical modeling, we constrain the value of
$\zeta_{\rm H_2}$ to ~(0.5 - 1.8) x10$^{-16}$ s$^{-1}$ in the translucent
cloud.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.03104 [pdf] - 1806193
Dust Polarization Toward Embedded Protostars in Ophiuchus with ALMA. II.
IRAS 16293-2422
Submitted: 2018-11-07, last modified: 2018-12-13
We present high-resolution (~ 35 au) ALMA Band 6 1.3 mm dust polarization
observations of IRAS 16293. These observations spatially resolve the dust
polarization across the two protostellar sources and toward the filamentary
structures between them. The dust polarization and inferred magnetic field have
complicated structures throughout the region. In particular, we find that the
magnetic field is aligned parallel to three filamentary structures. We
characterize the physical properties of the filamentary structure that bridges
IRAS 16293A and IRAS 16293B and estimate a magnetic field strength of 23-78 mG
using the Davis-Chandrasekhar-Fermi method. We construct a toy model for the
bridge material assuming that the young stars dominate the mass and
gravitational potential of the system. We find that the expected gas flow to
each star is of comparable order to the Alfven speed, which suggests that the
field may be regulating the gas flow. We also find that the bridging material
should be depleted in ~ 1000 yr. If the bridge is part of the natal filament
that formed the stars, then it must have accreted new material. Alternatively,
the bridge could be a transient structure. Finally, we show that the 1.3 mm
polarization morphology of the optically thick IRAS 16293B system is
qualitatively similar to dust self-scattering. Based on similar polarization
measurements at 6.9 mm, we propose that IRAS 16293B has produced a substantial
population of large dust grains with sizes between 200 and 2000 um.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.05968 [pdf] - 1698152
Dust Polarization Toward Embedded Protostars in Ophiuchus with ALMA. I.
VLA 1623
Sadavoy, Sarah I.;
Myers, Philip C.;
Stephens, Ian W.;
Tobin, John;
Commercon, Benoit;
Henning, Thomas;
Looney, Leslie;
Kwon, Woojin;
Segura-Cox, Dominique;
Harris, Robert
Submitted: 2018-04-16, last modified: 2018-06-05
We present high resolution (~ 30 au) ALMA Band 6 dust polarization
observations of VLA 1623. The VLA 1623 data resolve compact ~ 40 au inner disks
around the two protobinary sources, VLA 1623-A and VLA 1623-B, and also an
extended ~ 180 au ring of dust around VLA 1623-A. This dust ring was previously
identified as a large disk in lower-resolution observations. We detect highly
structured dust polarization toward the inner disks and the extended ring with
typical polarization fractions ~ 1.7% and ~ 2.4%, respectively. The two
components also show distinct polarization morphologies. The inner disks have
uniform polarization angles aligned with their minor axes. This morphology is
consistent with expectations from dust scattering. By contrast, the extended
dust ring has an azimuthal polarization morphology not previously seen in
lower-resolution observations. We find that our observations are well fit by a
static, oblate spheroid model with a flux-frozen, poloidal magnetic field. We
propose that the polarization traces magnetic grain alignment likely from flux
freezing on large scales and magnetic diffusion on small scales. Alternatively,
the azimuthal polarization may be attributed to grain alignment by the
anisotropic radiation field. If the grains are radiatively aligned, then our
observations indicate that large (~ 100 um) dust grains grow quickly at large
angular extents. Finally, we identify significant proper motion of VLA 1623
using our observations and those in the literature. This result indicates that
the proper motion of nearby systems must be corrected for when combining ALMA
data from different epochs.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.04623 [pdf] - 1648578
Thermal Jeans fragmentation within 1000 AU in OMC-1S
Submitted: 2017-06-14, last modified: 2018-02-20
We present subarcsecond 1.3 mm continuum ALMA observations towards the Orion
Molecular Cloud 1 South (OMC-1S) region, down to a spatial resolution of 74 AU,
which reveal a total of 31 continuum sources. We also present subarcsecond 7 mm
continuum VLA observations of the same region, which allow to further study
fragmentation down to a spatial resolution of 40 AU. By applying a Mean Surface
Density of Companions method we find a characteristic spatial scale at ~560 AU,
and we use this spatial scale to define the boundary of 19 `cores' in OMC-1S as
groupings of millimeter sources. We find an additional characteristic spatial
scale at ~2900 AU, which is the typical scale of the filaments in OMC-1S,
suggesting a two-level fragmentation process. We measured the fragmentation
level within each core and find a higher fragmentation towards the southern
filament. In addition, the cores of the southern filament are also the densest
(within 1100 AU) cores in OMC-1S. This is fully consistent with previous
studies of fragmentation at spatial scales one order of magnitude larger, and
suggests that fragmentation down to 40 AU seems to be governed by thermal Jeans
processes in OMC-1S.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.07702 [pdf] - 1588729
Evidence for disks at an early stage in class 0 protostars?
Gerin, M.;
Pety, J.;
Commercon, B.;
Fuente, A.;
Cernicharo, J.;
Marcelino, N.;
Ciardi, A.;
Lis, D. C.;
Roueff, E.;
Wootten, H. A.;
Chapillon, E.
Submitted: 2017-09-22
The formation epoch of protostellar disks is debated because of the competing
roles of rotation, turbulence, and magnetic fields in the early stages of
low-mass star formation. Magnetohydrodynamics simulations of collapsing cores
predict that rotationally supported disks may form in strongly magnetized cores
through ambipolar diffusion or misalignment between the rotation axis and the
magnetic field orientation. Detailed studies of individual sources are needed
to cross check the theoretical predictions. We present 0.06-0.1" resolution
images at 350 GHz toward B1b-N and B1b-S, which are young class 0 protostars,
possibly first hydrostatic cores. The images have been obtained with ALMA, and
we compare these data with magnetohydrodynamics simulations of a collapsing
turbulent and magnetized core. The submillimeter continuum emission is
spatially resolved by ALMA. Compact structures with optically thick 350 GHz
emission are detected toward both B1b-N and B1b-S, with 0.2 and 0.35" radii (46
and 80 au at the Perseus distance of 230 pc), within a more extended envelope.
The flux ratio between the compact structure and the envelope is lower in B1b-N
than in B1b-S, in agreement with its earlier evolutionary status. The size and
orientation of the compact structure are consistent with 0.2" resolution 32 GHz
observations obtained with the Very Large Array as a part of the VANDAM survey,
suggesting that grains have grown through coagulation. The morphology,
temperature, and densities of the compact structures are consistent with those
of disks formed in numerical simulations of collapsing cores. Moreover, the
properties of B1b-N are consistent with those of a very young protostar,
possibly a first hydrostatic core. These observations provide support for the
early formation of disks around low-mass protostars.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.00058 [pdf] - 1587771
Chemical segregation in the young protostars Barnard 1b-N and S:
evidence of pseudo-disk rotation in Barnard 1b-S
Fuente, Asunción;
Gerin, Maryvonne;
Pety, Jerome;
Commercon, Benoit;
Agúndez, Marcelino;
Cernicharo, José;
Marcelino, Nuria;
Roueff, Evelyne;
Lis, Darek C.;
Wootten, H. A.
Submitted: 2017-08-31
The extremely young Class 0 object B1b-S and the first hydrostatic core
(FSHC) candidate, B1b-N, provide a unique opportunity to study the chemical
changes produced in the elusive transition from the prestellar core to the
protostellar phase. We present 40"x70" images of Barnard 1b in the 13CO 1->0,
C18O 1->0, NH2D 1_{1,1}a->1_{0,1}s, and SO 3_2->2_1 lines obtained with the
NOEMA interferometer. The observed chemical segregation allows us to unveil the
physical structure of this young protostellar system down to scales of ~500au.
The two protostellar objects are embedded in an elongated condensation, with a
velocity gradient of ~0.2-0.4 m s^{-1} au^{-1} in the east-west direction,
reminiscent of an axial collapse. The NH2D data reveal cold and dense
pseudo-disks (R~500-1000 au) around each protostar. Moreover, we observe
evidence of pseudo-disk rotation around B1b-S. We do not see any signature of
the bipolar outflows associated with B1b-N and B1b-S, which were previously
detected in H2CO and CH3OH, in any of the imaged species. The non-detection of
SO constrains the SO/CH3OH abundance ratio in the high-velocity gas.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.03273 [pdf] - 1561212
ALMA survey of massive cluster progenitors from ATLASGAL. Limited
fragmentation at the early evolutionary stage of massive clumps
Csengeri, T.;
Bontemps, S.;
Wyrowski, F.;
Motte, F.;
Menten, K. M.;
Beuther, H.;
Bronfman, L.;
Commercon, B.;
Chapillon, E.;
Duarte-Cabral, A.;
Fuller, G. A.;
Henning, Th.;
Leurini, S.;
Longmore, S.;
Palau, A.;
Peretto, N.;
Schuller, F.;
Tan, J. C.;
Testi, L.;
Traficante, A.;
Urquhart, J. S.
Submitted: 2017-03-09
The early evolution of massive cluster progenitors is poorly understood. We
investigate the fragmentation properties from 0.3 pc to 0.06 pc scales of a
homogenous sample of infrared-quiet massive clumps within 4.5 kpc selected from
the ATLASGAL survey. Using the ALMA 7m array we detect compact dust continuum
emission towards all targets, and find that fragmentation, at these scales, is
limited. The mass distribution of the fragments uncovers a large fraction of
cores above 40 $M_\odot$, corresponding to massive dense cores (MDCs) with
masses up to ~400 $M_\odot$. 77 % of the clumps contain at most 3 MDCs per
clump, and we also reveal single clumps/MDCs. The most massive cores are formed
within the more massive clumps, and a high concentration of mass on small
scales reveals a high core formation efficiency. The mass of MDCs highly
exceeds the local thermal Jeans-mass, and observational evidence is lacking for
a sufficiently high level of turbulence or strong enough magnetic fields to
keep the most massive MDCs in equilibrium. If already collapsing, the observed
fragmentation properties with a high core formation efficiency are consistent
with the collapse setting in at parsec scales.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.05688 [pdf] - 1581542
The magnetic diffusivities in 3D radiative chemo-hydrodynamic
simulations of protostellar collapse
Submitted: 2017-02-18
The grand question of star and planet formation is the distribution of
magnetic flux in the protoplanetary disks. To answer it, a detailed
self-consistent chemical evolution is needed to describe the magnetic
dissipation in the collapsing core accurately. We use a chemo-dynamical version
of RAMSES to follow the evolution of collapsing dense cores for a range in the
dust size assumptions. The number density of dust and it's mean size are
affecting the efficiency of the charge capturing and thus the chemistry. The
chemical abundances for the range of dust sizes are produced by RAMSES and
serve as an input to calculations of Ohmic, ambipolar and Hall diffusivity
terms. We find that Ohmic resistivity only plays a role at the late stage of
the collapse where gas density exceeds few times $10^{13}\rm cm^{-3}$.
Ambipolar diffusion is a dominant magnetic diffusivity term in cases where mean
dust size is a typical ISM value or larger. We show that the assumption of a
fixed 'dominant ion' mass can change the ambipolar diffusion up to one order of
magnitude. 'Negative' Hall effect is dominant during the collapse in case of
mean dust size of 0.02 $\mu$m and smaller, the effect which we connect to the
dominance of negatively charged grains. We find that the Hall effect's sign
reversal is depending on relative contribution of negatively charged dust to
the hall conductivity. The dust grain mean size appears to be the parameter
dividing the collapsing clouds in Hall-dominated and ambipolar-dominated
clouds, and thus affecting the size of the new-born disks. We propose to link
the dust properties and the occurance and size of disk structures in Class 0
YSO's. The proper accounting for dust grain growth in the radiative
magneto-hydrodynamical collapse models appear to be be as important as coupling
the dynamics of the collapse with the chemistry.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.02525 [pdf] - 1531221
Magnetically self-regulated formation of early protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2016-08-08
The formation of protoplanetary discs during the collapse of molecular dense
cores is significantly influenced by angular momentum transport, notably by the
magnetic torque. In turn, the evolution of the magnetic field is determined by
dynamical processes and non-ideal MHD effects such as ambipolar diffusion.
Considering simple relations between various timescales characteristic of the
magnetized collapse, we derive an expression for the early disc radius, $ r
\simeq 18 \, {\rm AU} \, \left({\eta_{\rm AD} / 0.1 \, {\rm s}} \right)^{2/9}
\left({B_z / 0.1\, {\rm G}} \right) ^{-4/9} \left({M / 0.1 \msol} \right)
^{1/3},$ where $M$ is the total disc plus protostar mass, $\eta_\mathrm{AD}$ is
the ambipolar diffusion coefficient and $B_z$ is the magnetic field in the
inner part of the core. This is about significantly smaller than the discs that
would form if angular momentum was conserved.
The analytical predictions are confronted against a large sample of 3D,
non-ideal MHD collapse calculations covering variations of a factor 100 in core
mass, a factor 10 in the level of turbulence, a factor 5 in rotation, and
magnetic mass-to-flux over critical mass-to-flux ratios 2 and 5. The disc
radius estimates are found to agree with the numerical simulations within less
than a factor 2.
A striking prediction of our analysis is the weak dependence of circumstellar
disc radii upon the various relevant quantities, suggesting weak variations
among class-0 disc sizes. In some cases, we note the onset of large spiral arms
beyond this radius.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.02529 [pdf] - 1400494
Chemical and physical characterization of collapsing low-mass prestellar
dense cores
Submitted: 2016-03-08
The first hydrostatic core, also called the first Larson core, is one of the
first steps in low-mass star formation, as predicted by theory. With recent and
future high performance telescopes, details of these first phases become
accessible, and observations may confirm theory and even bring new challenges
for theoreticians. In this context, we study from a theoretical point of view
the chemical and physical evolution of the collapse of prestellar cores until
the formation of the first Larson core, in order to better characterize this
early phase in the star formation process. We couple a state-of-the-art
hydrodynamical model with full gas-grain chemistry, using different assumptions
on the magnetic field strength and orientation. We extract the different
components of each collapsing core (i.e., the central core, the outflow, the
disk, the pseudodisk, and the envelope) to highlight their specific physical
and chemical characteristics. Each component often presents a specific physical
history, as well as a specific chemical evolution. From some species, the
components can clearly be differentiated. The different core models can also be
chemically differentiated. Our simulation suggests some chemical species as
tracers of the different components of a collapsing prestellar dense core, and
as tracers of the magnetic field characteristics of the core. From this result,
we pinpoint promising key chemical species to be observed.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.04522 [pdf] - 1415029
The first Galaxy scale hunt for the youngest high-mass protostars
Csengeri, T.;
Bontemps, S.;
Wyrowski, F.;
Menten, K. M.;
Leurini, S.;
Urquhart, J. S.;
Motte, F.;
Schuller, F.;
Testi, L.;
Bronfman, L.;
Beuther, H.;
Longmore, S.;
Commercon, B.;
Henning, Th.;
Palau, A.;
Tan, J. C.;
Fuller, G.;
Peretto, N.;
Duarte-Cabral, A.;
Traficante, A.
Submitted: 2015-12-13
The origin of massive stars is a fundamental open issue in modern
astrophysics. Pre-ALMA interferometric studies reveal precursors to early B to
late O type stars with collapsing envelopes of 15-20 M$_\odot$ on 1000-3000 AU
size-scales. To search for more massive envelopes we selected the most massive
nearby young clumps from the ATLASGAL survey to study their protostellar
content with ALMA. Our first results using the intermediate scales revealed by
the ALMA ACA array providing 3-5" angular resolution, corresponding to
$\sim$0.05-0.1 pc size-scales, reveals a sample of compact objects. These
massive dense cores are on average two-times more massive than previous studies
of similar types of objects. We expect that once the full survey is completed,
it will provide a comprehensive view on the origin of the most massive stars.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.06817 [pdf] - 969876
Cosmic-ray propagation at small scale: a support for protostellar disc
formation
Submitted: 2015-03-23
As long as magnetic fields remain frozen into the gas, the magnetic braking
prevents the formation of protostellar discs. This condition is subordinate to
the ionisation fraction characterising the inmost parts of a collapsing cloud.
The ionisation level is established by the number and the energy of the cosmic
rays able to reach these regions. Adopting the method developed in our previous
studies, we computed how cosmic rays are attenuated as a function of column
density and magnetic field strength. We applied our formalism to low- and
high-mass star formation models obtained by numerical simulations of
gravitational collapse that include rotation and turbulence. In general, we
found that the decoupling between gas and magnetic fields, condition allowing
the collapse to go ahead, occurs only when the cosmic-ray attenuation is taken
into account with respect to a calculation in which the cosmic-ray ionisation
rate is kept constant. We also found that the extent of the decoupling zone
also depends on the dust grain size distribution and is larger if large grains
(of radius about 0.1 microns) are formed by compression and coagulation during
cloud collapse. The decoupling region disappears for the high-mass case due to
magnetic field diffusion that is caused by turbulence and that is not included
in the low-mass models. We infer that a simultaneous study of the cosmic-ray
propagation during the cloud's collapse may lead to values of the gas
resistivity in the innermost few hundred AU around a forming protostar that is
higher than generally assumed.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.8292 [pdf] - 1203112
Fragmentation of massive dense cores down to ~1000 AU: Relation between
fragmentation and density structure
Palau, Aina;
Estalella, R.;
Girart, J. M.;
Fuente, A.;
Fontani, F.;
Commercon, B.;
Busquet, G.;
Bontemps, S.;
Sanchez-Monge, A.;
Zapata, L. A.;
Zhang, Q.;
Hennebelle, P.;
Di Francesco, J.
Submitted: 2014-01-31
In order to shed light on the main physical processes controlling
fragmentation of massive dense cores, we present a uniform study of the density
structure of 19 massive dense cores, selected to be at similar evolutionary
stages, for which their relative fragmentation level was assessed in a previous
work. We inferred the density structure of the 19 cores through a simultaneous
fit of the radial intensity profiles at 450 and 850 micron (or 1.2 mm in two
cases) and the Spectral Energy Distribution, assuming spherical symmetry and
that the density and temperature of the cores decrease with radius following
power-laws. We find a weak (inverse) trend of fragmentation level and density
power-law index, with steeper density profiles tending to show lower
fragmentation, and vice versa. In addition, we find a trend of fragmentation
increasing with density within a given radius, which arises from a combination
of flat density profile and high central density and is consistent with Jeans
fragmentation. We considered the effects of rotational-to-gravitational energy
ratio, non-thermal velocity dispersion, and turbulence mode on the density
structure of the cores, and found that compressive turbulence seems to yield
higher central densities. Finally, a possible explanation for the origin of
cores with concentrated density profiles, which are the cores showing no
fragmentation, could be related with a strong magnetic field, consistent with
the outcome of radiation magnetohydrodynamic simulations.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.1112 [pdf] - 791848
A fast, robust, and simple implicit method for adaptive time-stepping on
adaptive mesh-refinement grids
Submitted: 2014-01-06, last modified: 2014-01-10
Implicit solvers present strong limitations when used on supercomputing
facilities and in particular for adaptive mesh-refinement codes. We present a
new method for implicit adaptive time-stepping on adaptive mesh
refinement-grids. We implement it in the radiation hydrodynamics solver we
designed for the RAMSES code for astrophysical purposes and, more particularly,
for protostellar collapse. We briefly recall the radiation hydrodynamics
equations and the adaptive time-stepping methodology used for hydrodynamical
solvers. We then introduce the different types of boundary conditions
(Dirichlet, Neumann, and Robin) that are used at the interface between levels
and present our implementation of the new method in the RAMSES code. The method
is tested against classical diffusion and radiation hydrodynamics tests, after
which we present an application for protostellar collapse. We show that using
Dirichlet boundary conditions at level interfaces is a good compromise between
robustness and accuracy and that it can be used in structure formation
calculations. The gain in computational time over our former unique time step
method ranges from factors of 5 to 50 depending on the level of adaptive
time-stepping and on the problem. We successfully compare the old and new
methods for protostellar collapse calculations that involve highly nonlinear
physics. We have developed a simple but robust method for adaptive
time-stepping of implicit scheme on adaptive mesh-refinement grids. It can be
applied to a wide variety of physical problems that involve diffusion
processes.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.1010 [pdf] - 1172466
Simulations of protostellar collapse using multigroup radiation
hydrodynamics. II. The second collapse
Submitted: 2013-07-03
Star formation begins with the gravitational collapse of a dense core inside
a molecular cloud. As the collapse progresses, the centre of the core begins to
heat up as it becomes optically thick. The temperature and density in the
centre eventually reach high enough values where fusion reactions can ignite;
the protostar is born. This sequence of events entail many physical processes,
of which radiative transfer is of paramount importance. Many simulations of
protostellar collapse make use of a grey treatment of radiative transfer
coupled to the hydrodynamics. However, interstellar gas and dust opacities
present large variations as a function of frequency. In this paper, we
follow-up on a previous paper on the collapse and formation of Larson's first
core using multigroup radiation hydrodynamics (Paper I) by extending the
calculations to the second phase of the collapse and the formation of Larson's
second core. We have made the use of a non-ideal gas equation of state as well
as an extensive set of spectral opacities in a spherically symmetric fully
implicit Godunov code to model all the phases of the collapse of a 0.1, 1 and
10 solar mass cloud cores. We find that, for a same central density, there are
only small differences between the grey and multigroup simulations. The first
core accretion shock remains supercritical while the shock at the second core
border is found to be strongly subcritical with all the accreted energy being
transfered to the core. The size of the first core was found to vary somewhat
in the different simulations (more unstable clouds form smaller first cores)
while the size, mass and temperature of the second cores are independent of
initial cloud mass, size and temperature. Our simulations support the idea of a
standard (universal) initial second core size of 0.003 AU and mass 0.0014 solar
masses.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.2666 [pdf] - 1157692
Early stages of cluster formation: fragmentation of massive dense cores
down to ~1000 AU
Palau, Aina;
Fuente, Asunción;
Girart, Josep M.;
Estalella, Robert;
Ho, Paul T. P.;
Sánchez-Monge, Álvaro;
Fontani, Francesco;
Busquet, Gemma;
Commercon, Benoît;
Hennebelle, Patrick;
Boissier, Jérémie;
Zhang, Qizhou;
Cesaroni, Riccardo;
Zapata, Luis A.
Submitted: 2012-11-12
In order to study the fragmentation of massive dense cores, which constitute
the cluster cradles, we observed with the PdBI in the most extended
configuration the continuum at 1.3 mm and the CO(2-1) emission of four massive
cores. We detect dust condensations down to ~0.3 Msun and separate millimeter
sources down to 0.4" or ~1000 AU, comparable to the sensitivities and
separations reached in optical/infrared studies of clusters. The CO(2-1) high
angular resolution images reveal high-velocity knots usually aligned with
previously known outflow directions. This, in combination with additional cores
from the literature observed at similar mass sensitivity and spatial
resolution, allowed us to build a sample of 18 protoclusters with luminosities
spanning 3 orders of magnitude. Among the 18 regions, ~30% show no signs of
fragmentation, while 50% split up into ~4 millimeter sources. We compiled a
list of properties for the 18 massive dense cores, such as bolometric
luminosity, total mass, and mean density, and found no correlation of any of
these parameters with the fragmentation level. In order to investigate the
combined effects of magnetic field, radiative feedback and turbulence in the
fragmentation process, we compared our observations to radiation
magneto-hydrodynamic simulations, and found that the low-fragmented regions are
well reproduced in the magnetized core case, while the highly-fragmented
regions are consistent with cores where turbulence dominates over the magnetic
field. Overall, our study suggests that the fragmentation in massive dense
cores could be determined by the initial magnetic field/turbulence balance in
each particular core.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.1786 [pdf] - 560869
Theories of the massive star formation: a (short) review
Submitted: 2012-09-09
We briefly review the recent numerical works that have been performed to
understand the formation of massive stars. After a brief description of the
classical works, we review more specifically $i)$ the problem of building stars
more massive than 20 $M_\odot$ and $ii)$ how to prevent the massive cores to
fragment in many objects. Multi-D simulations succeed in circumventing the
radiative pressure leading to the formation of massive stars although some
questions are still debated regarding how is accretion exactly proceeding.
While the core fragmentation is slightly reduced by the radiative feedback and
the magnetic field when they are treated separately, it is almost entirely
suppressed when both of them are included. This is because, magnetic field by
removing angular momentum focusses the flow in a compact region. This makes the
radiative feedback very efficient leading to a significant increase of the
temperature.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.0656 [pdf] - 1124563
Synthetic observations of first hydrostatic cores in collapsing low-mass
dense cores. I. Spectral energy distributions and evolutionary sequence
Submitted: 2012-07-03, last modified: 2012-07-13
The low-mass star formation evolutionary sequence is relatively well-defined
both from observations and theoretical considerations. The first hydrostatic
core is the first protostellar equilibrium object that is formed during the
star formation process. Using state-of-the-art radiation-magneto-hydrodynamic
3D adaptive mesh refinement calculations, we aim to provide predictions for the
dust continuum emission from first hydrostatic cores. We investigate the
collapse and the fragmentation of magnetized one solar mass prestellar dense
cores and the formation and evolution of first hydrostatic cores using the
RAMSES code. We use three different magnetization levels for the initial
conditions, which cover a large variety of early evolutionary morphology, e.g.,
the formation of a disk or a pseudo-disk, outflow launching, and fragmentation.
We post-process the dynamical calculations using the 3D radiative transfer code
RADMC-3D. We compute spectral energy distributions and usual evolutionary stage
indicators such as bolometric luminosity and temperature. We find that the
first hydrostatic core lifetimes depend strongly on the initial magnetization
level of the parent dense core. We derive, for the first time, spectral energy
distribution evolutionary sequences from high-resolution
radiation-magneto-hydrodynamic calculations. We show that under certain
conditions, first hydrostatic cores can be identified from dust continuum
emission at 24 microns and 70 microns. We also show that single spectral energy
distributions cannot help to distinguish between the formation scenarios of the
first hydrostatic core, i.e., between the magnetized and non-magnetized models.
Spectral energy distributions are a first useful and direct way to target first
hydrostatic core candidates but high-resolution interferometry is definitively
needed to determine the evolutionary stage of the observed sources.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.5143 [pdf] - 1123607
Simulations of protostellar collapse using multigroup radiation
hydrodynamics. I. The first collapse
Submitted: 2012-05-23
Radiative transfer plays a major role in the process of star formation. Many
simulations of gravitational collapse of a cold gas cloud followed by the
formation of a protostellar core use a grey treatment of radiative transfer
coupled to the hydrodynamics. However, dust opacities which dominate extinction
show large variations as a function of frequency. In this paper, we used
frequency-dependent radiative transfer to investigate the influence of the
opacity variations on the properties of Larson's first core. We used a
multigroup M1 moment model in a 1D radiation hydrodynamics code to simulate the
spherically symmetric collapse of a 1 solar mass cloud core. Monochromatic dust
opacities for five different temperature ranges were used to compute Planck and
Rosseland means inside each frequency group. The results are very consistent
with previous studies and only small differences were observed between the grey
and multigroup simulations. For a same central density, the multigroup
simulations tend to produce first cores with a slightly higher radius and
central temperature. We also performed simulations of the collapse of a 10 and
0.1 solar mass cloud, which showed the properties of the first core to be
independent of the initial cloud mass, with again no major differences between
grey and multigroup models. For Larson's first collapse, where temperatures
remain below 2000 K, the vast majority of the radiation energy lies in the IR
regime and the system is optically thick. In this regime, the grey
approximation does a good job reproducing the correct opacities, as long as
there are no large opacity variations on scales much smaller than the width of
the Planck function. The multigroup method is however expected to yield more
important differences in the later stages of the collapse when high energy (UV
and X-ray) radiation is present and matter and radiation are strongly
decoupled.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.2955 [pdf] - 1084854
Collapse of massive magnetized dense cores using
radiation-magneto-hydrodynamics: early fragmentation inhibition
Submitted: 2011-10-13
We report the results of radiation-magneto-hydrodynamics calculations in the
context of high mass star formation, using for the first time a self-consistent
model for photon emission (i.e. via thermal emission and in radiative shocks)
and with the high resolution necessary to resolve properly magnetic braking
effects and radiative shocks on scales <100 AU. We investigate the combined
effects of magnetic field, turbulence, and radiative transfer on the early
phases of the collapse and the fragmentation of massive dense cores. We
identify a new mechanism that inhibits initial fragmentation of massive dense
cores, where magnetic field and radiative transfer interplay. We show that this
interplay becomes stronger as the magnetic field strength increases. Magnetic
braking is transporting angular momentum outwards and is lowering the
rotational support and is thus increasing the infall velocity. This enhances
the radiative feedback owing to the accretion shock on the first core. We
speculate that highly magnetized massive dense cores are good candidates for
isolated massive star formation, while moderately magnetized massive dense
cores are more appropriate to form OB associations or small star clusters.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.1216 [pdf] - 1051928
Radiation hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement and application to
prestellar core collapse. I Methods
Submitted: 2011-02-06, last modified: 2011-02-23
Radiative transfer has a strong impact on the collapse and the fragmentation
of prestellar dense cores. We present the radiation-hydrodynamics solver we
designed for the RAMSES code. The method is designed for astrophysical
purposes, and in particular for protostellar collapse. We present the solver,
using the co-moving frame to evaluate the radiative quantities. We use the
popular flux limited diffusion approximation, under the grey approximation (one
group of photon). The solver is based on the second-order Godunov scheme of
RAMSES for its hyperbolic part, and on an implicit scheme for the radiation
diffusion and the coupling between radiation and matter. We report in details
our methodology to integrate the RHD solver into RAMSES. We test successfully
the method against several conventional tests. For validation in 3D, we perform
calculations of the collapse of an isolated 1 M_sun prestellar dense core,
without rotation. We compare successfully the results with previous studies
using different models for radiation and hydrodynamics. We have developed a
full radiation hydrodynamics solver in the RAMSES code, that handles adaptive
mesh refinement grids. The method is a combination of an explicit scheme and an
implicit scheme, accurate to the second-order in space. Our method is well
suited for star formation purposes. Results of multidimensional dense core
collapse calculations with rotation are presented in a companion paper.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.1574 [pdf] - 1051262
Collapse, outflows and fragmentation of massive, turbulent and
magnetized prestellar barotropic cores
Submitted: 2011-01-08, last modified: 2011-02-21
Stars and more particularly massive stars, have a drastic impact on galaxy
evolution. Yet the conditions in which they form and collapse are still not
fully understood. In particular, the influence of the magnetic field on the
collapse of massive clumps is relatively unexplored, it is thus of great
relevance in the context of the formation of massive stars to investigate its
impact. We perform high resolution, MHD simulations of the collapse of hundred
solar masses, turbulent and magnetized clouds, using the adaptive mesh
refinement code RAMSES. We compute various quantities such as mass
distribution, magnetic field and angular momentum within the collapsing core
and study the episodic outflows and the fragmentation that occurs during the
collapse. The magnetic field has a drastic impact on the cloud evolution. We
find that magnetic braking is able to substantially reduce the angular momentum
in the inner part of the collapsing cloud. Fast and episodic outflows are being
launched with typical velocities of the order of 3-5 km s$^{-1}$ although the
highest velocities can be as high as 30-40 km s$^{-1}$. The fragmentation in
several objects, is reduced in substantially magnetized clouds with respect to
hydrodynamical ones by a factor of the order of 1.5-2. We conclude that
magnetic fields have a significant impact on the evolution of massive clumps.
In combination with radiation, magnetic fields largely determine the outcome of
massive core collapse. We stress that numerical convergence of MHD collapse is
a challenging issue. In particular, numerical diffusion appears to be important
at high density therefore possibly leading to an over-estimation of the number
of fragments.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.5651 [pdf] - 1042192
Radiative, magnetic and numerical feedbacks on small-scale fragmentation
Submitted: 2010-11-25
Radiative feedback and magnetic field are understood to have a strong impact
on the protostellar collapse. We present high resolution numerical calculations
of the collapse of a 1 solar mass dense core in solid body rotation, including
both radiative transfer and magnetic field. Using typical parameters for
low-mass cores, we study thoroughly the effect of radiative transfer and
magnetic field on the first core formation and fragmentation. We show that
including the two aforementioned physical processes does not correspond to the
simple picture of adding them separately. The interplay between the two is
extremely strong, via the magnetic braking and the radiation from the accretion
shock.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.3138 [pdf] - 1018805
Protostellar collapse: radiative and magnetic feedbacks on small scale
fragmentation
Submitted: 2009-12-16, last modified: 2009-12-17
It is established that both radiative transfer and magnetic field have a
strong impact on the collapse and the fragmentation of prestellar dense cores,
but no consistent calculation exists yet at such scales. We present original
AMR calculations including magnetic field (in the ideal MHD limit) and
radiative transfer, within the Flux Limited Diffusion approximation, of the
collapse of a 1 solar mass dense core. We compare the results with calculations
performed with a barotropic EOS. We show that radiative transfer has an
important impact on the collapse and the fragmentation, through the cooling or
heating of the gas, and is complementary of the magnetic field. A larger field
yields a stronger magnetic braking, increasing the accretion rate and thus the
effect of the radiative feedback. Even for a strongly magnetized core, where
the dynamics of the collapse is dominated by the magnetic field, radiative
transfer is crucial to determine the temperature and optical depth
distributions, two potentially accessible observational diagnostics. A
barotropic EOS cannot account for realistic fragmentation. The diffusivity of
the numerical scheme, however, is found to strongly affect the output of the
collapse, leading eventually to spurious fragmentation. Both radiative transfer
and magnetic field must be included in numerical calculations of star formation
to obtain realistic collapse configurations and observable signatures.
Nevertheless, the numerical resolution and the robustness of the solver are of
prime importance to obtain reliable results. When using an accurate solver, the
fragmentation is found to always remain inhibited by the magnetic field, at
least in the ideal MHD limit, even when radiative transfer is included.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.3092 [pdf] - 9204
Protostellar collapse: A comparison between SPH and AMR calculations
Submitted: 2008-01-20
The development of parallel supercomputers allows today the detailed study of
the collapse and the fragmentation of prestellar cores with increasingly
accurate numerical simulations. Thanks to the advances in sub-millimeter
observations, a wide range of observed initial conditions enable us to study
the different modes of low-mass star formation. The challenge for the
simulations is to reproduce the observational results. Two main numerical
methods, namely AMR and SPH, are widely used to simulate the collapse and the
fragmentation of prestellar cores. We compare thoroughly these two methods
within their standard framework. We use the AMR code RAMSES and the SPH code
DRAGON. Our physical model is as simple as possible and consists of an
isothermal sphere rotating around the z-axis. We first study the conservation
of angular momentum as a function of the resolution. Then, we explore a wide
range of simulation parameters to study the fragmentation of prestellar cores.
There seems to be a convergence between the two methods, provided resolution in
each case is sufficient. Resolution criteria adapted to our physical cases, in
terms of resolution per Jeans mass, for an accurate description of the
formation of protostellar cores are deduced from the present study. This
convergence is encouraging for future work in simulations of low-mass star
formation, providing the aforementioned criteria are fulfilled.
Higher resolution figures can be downloaded at
http://www-dapnia.cea.fr/Projets/COAST/paper_amrvssph.pdf
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.2450 [pdf] - 4999
Numerical methods comparison for protostellar collapse calculations
Submitted: 2007-09-15
The development of parallel supercomputers allows today the detailed study of
the collapse and the fragmentation of prestellar cores with increasingly
accurate numerical simulations. Thanks to the advances in sub-millimeter
observations, a wide range of observed initial conditions enable us to study
the different modes of low-mass star formation. The challenge for the
simulations is to reproduce the observational results. Two main numerical
methods, namely AMR and SPH, are widely used to simulate the collapse and the
fragmentation of prestellar cores. We compare here thoroughly these two methods
with numerical resolution requirements deduced from previous studies. Our
physical model is as simple as possible, and consists of an isothermal sphere
rotating around the z-axis. We first study the conservation of angular momentum
as a function of the resolution. Then, we explore a wide range of simulation
parameters to study the fragmentation of prestellar cores. There seems to be a
convergence between the two methods, provided resolution in each case is
sufficient. Resolution criteria adapted to our physical cases, in terms of
resolution per Jeans mass, for an accurate description of the formation of
protostellar cores are deduced from the present study. This convergence is
encouraging for future work in simulations of low-mass star formation,
providing the aforementioned criteria are fulfilled.