Normalized to: Clarkson, C.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.04879 [pdf] - 2131662
Null tests of the concordance model in the era of Euclid and the SKA
Submitted: 2020-07-09
We perform null tests of the concordance model, using $H(z)$ measurements
that mimic next-generation surveys such as Euclid and the SKA. To this end, we
deploy a non-parametric method, so that we make minimal assumptions about the
fiducial cosmology as well as the statistical analysis. We produce simulations
assuming different cosmological models in order to verify how well we can
distinguish between their signatures. We find that SKA- and Euclid-like surveys
should be able to discriminate sharply between the concordance and alternative
dark energy models that are compatible with the Planck CMB data. We conclude
that SKA and Euclid will be able to falsify the concordance model in a
statistically significant way, if one of the benchmarks models represents the
true Universe, without making assumptions about the underlying cosmology.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.04619 [pdf] - 2104616
The Hubble constant tension with next-generation galaxy surveys
Submitted: 2019-08-13, last modified: 2020-05-01
The rate at which the universe is expanding today is a fundamental parameter
in cosmology which governs our understanding of structure formation and dark
energy. However, current measurements of the Hubble constant, $H_0$, show a
significant tension ($\sim 4-6\sigma$) between early- and late-Universe
observations. There are ongoing efforts to check the diverse observational
results and also to investigate possible theoretical ways to resolve the
tension~-- which could point to radical extensions of the standard model. Here
we demonstrate the potential of next-generation spectroscopic galaxy surveys to
shed light on the Hubble constant tension. Surveys such as those with Euclid
and the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) are expected to reach sub-percent
precision on Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) measurements of the Hubble
parameter, with a combined redshift coverage of $0.1<z<3$. This wide redshift
range, together with the high precision and low level of systematics in BAO
measurements, mean that these surveys will provide independent and tight
constraints on $H(z)$. These $H(z)$ measurements can be extrapolated to $z = 0$
to provide constraints on $H_0$ using a non-parametric regression. To this end
we deploy Gaussian processes and we find that Euclid-like surveys can reach
$\sim$3\% precision on $H_0$, with SKA-like intensity mapping surveys reaching
$\sim$2\%. When we combine the low-redshift SKA-like Band 2 survey with either
its high-redshift Band 1 counterpart, or with the non-overlapping Euclid-like
survey, the precision is predicted to be close to 1\% with 40 $H(z)$ data
points. This would be sufficient to rule out the current early- or
late-Universe measurements at a $\sim$5$\sigma$ level.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.11016 [pdf] - 2093151
Multipoles of the relativistic galaxy bispectrum
Submitted: 2019-12-23, last modified: 2020-04-14
Above the equality scale the galaxy bispectrum will be a key probe for
measuring primordial non-Gaussianity which can help differentiate between
different inflationary models and other theories of the early universe. On
these scales a variety of relativistic effects come into play once the galaxy
number-count fluctuation is projected onto our past lightcone. By decomposing
the Fourier-space bispectrum into invariant multipoles about the observer's
line of sight we examine in detail how the relativistic effects contribute to
these. We show how to perform this decomposition analytically, which is
significantly faster for subsequent computations. While all multipoles receive
a contribution from the relativistic part, odd multipoles arising from the
imaginary part of the bispectrum have no Newtonian contribution, making the odd
multipoles a smoking gun for a relativistic signature in the bispectrum for
single tracers. The dipole and the octopole are significant on equality scales
and above where the Newtonian approximation breaks down. This breakdown is
further signified by the fact that the even multipoles receive a significant
correction on very large scales.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.04471 [pdf] - 2072533
Recursion relations for gravitational lensing
Submitted: 2019-04-09, last modified: 2020-03-31
The weak gravitational lensing formalism can be extended to the strong
lensing regime by integrating a nonlinear version of the geodesic deviation
equation. The resulting "roulette" expansion generalises the notion of
convergence, shear and flexion to arbitrary order. The independent coefficients
of this expansion are screen space gradients of the optical tidal tensor which
approximates to the usual lensing potential in the weak field limit. From
lensed images, knowledge of the roulette coefficients can in principle be
inverted to reconstruct the mass distribution of a lens. In this paper, we
simplify the roulette expansion and derive a family of recursion relations
between the various coefficients, generalising the Kaiser-Squires relations
beyond the weak-lensing regime.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.02398 [pdf] - 2075627
Detecting the relativistic galaxy bispectrum
Submitted: 2019-11-06, last modified: 2020-03-16
The Fourier-space galaxy bispectrum is complex, with the imaginary part
arising from leading-order relativistic corrections, due to Doppler,
gravitational redshift and related line-of-sight effects in redshift space. The
detection of the imaginary part of the bispectrum is potentially a smoking gun
signal of relativistic contributions. We investigate whether next-generation
spectroscopic surveys could make such a detection. For a Stage IV spectroscopic
$H\alpha$ survey similar to Euclid, we find that the cumulative signal to noise
of this relativistic signature is $\mathcal{O}(10)$. Long-mode relativistic
effects couple to short-mode Newtonian effects in the galaxy bispectrum, but
not in the galaxy power spectrum. This is the basis for detectability of
relativistic effects in the bispectrum of a single galaxy survey, whereas the
power spectrum requires multiple galaxy surveys to detect the corresponding
signal.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.04024 [pdf] - 2045604
Weak-lensing observables in relativistic N-body simulations
Submitted: 2020-02-10
We investigate for the first time weak lensing in a high-resolution
relativistic N-body simulation, which includes all relevant effects from
general relativity. We integrate the photon geodesics backwards from the
observer to the emitters. Our analysis is fully relativistic and
non-perturbative for the scalar part of the gravitational potential and
first-order in the vector part, frame dragging. We solve the Sachs optical
equations and study in detail the weak-lensing convergence, ellipticity and
rotation. We present the angular power spectra and one-point probability
distribution functions for the weak-lensing variables, which we find are
broadly in agreement with comparable Newtonian simulations. Our geometric
approach, however, is more robust and flexible, and can therefore be applied
consistently to non-standard cosmologies and modified theories of gravity.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.02217 [pdf] - 2028896
A null test to probe the scale-dependence of the growth of structure as
a test of General Relativity
Submitted: 2019-06-05, last modified: 2020-01-10
The main science driver for the coming generation of cosmological surveys is
understanding dark energy which relies on testing General Relativity on the
largest scales. Once we move beyond the simplest explanation for dark energy of
a cosmological constant, the space of possible theories becomes both vast and
extremely hard to compute realistic observables. A key discriminator of a
cosmological constant, however, is that the growth of structure is
scale-invariant on large scales. By carefully weighting observables derived
from distributions of galaxies and a dipole pattern in their apparent sizes, we
construct a null test which vanishes for any model of gravity or dark energy
where the growth of structure is scale-independent. It relies only on very few
assumptions about cosmology, and does not require any modelling of the growth
of structure. We show that with a survey like DESI a scale-dependence of the
order of 10-20 percent can be detected at 3 sigma with the null test, which
will drop by a factor of 2 for a survey like the Square Kilometre Array. We
also show that the null test is very insensitive to typical uncertainties in
other cosmological parameters including massive neutrinos and scale-dependent
bias, making this a key null test for dark energy.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.04894 [pdf] - 2065281
Multi-Scale Perturbation Theory I: Methodology and Leading-Order
Bispectrum Corrections in the Matter-Dominated Era
Submitted: 2019-10-10, last modified: 2020-01-08
Two-parameter perturbation theory is a scheme tailor-made to consistently
include nonlinear density contrasts on small scales ($<100\; \mathrm{Mpc}$),
whilst retaining a traditional approach to cosmological perturbations in the
long-wavelength universe. In this paper we study the solutions that arise from
this theory in a spatially-flat dust-filled cosmology, and what these imply for
the bispectrum of matter. This is achieved by using Newtonian perturbation
theory to model the gravitational fields of nonlinear structures in the
quasi-linear regime, and then using the resulting solutions as source terms for
the cosmological equations. We find that our approach results in the
leading-order part of the cosmological gravitational potentials being identical
to those that result from standard cosmological perturbation theory at
second-order, while the dark matter bispectrum itself yields some differences
on Hubble scales. This demonstrates that our approach is sufficient to capture
most leading-order relativistic effects, but within a framework that is far
easier to generalize. We expect this latter property to be particularly useful
for calculating leading-order relativistic corrections to the matter power
spectrum, as well as for deriving predictions for relativistic effects in
alternative theories of gravity.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.09919 [pdf] - 2030445
Probing beyond-Horndeski gravity on ultra-large scales
Submitted: 2019-02-26, last modified: 2019-12-21
The beyond-Horndeski gravity has recently been reformulated in the dark
energy paradigm - which has been dubbed, Unified Dark Energy (UDE). The
evolution equations for the given UDE appear to correspond to a
non-conservative dark energy scenario, in which the total energy-momentum
tensor is not conserved. We investigate both the background cosmology and, the
large-scale imprint of the UDE by probing the angular power spectrum of galaxy
number counts, on ultra-large scales; taking care to include the full
relativistic corrections in the observed overdensity. The background evolution
shows that only an effective mass smaller than the Planck mass is needed in the
early universe in order for predictions in the given theory to match current
observational constraints. We found that the effective mass-evolution-rate
parameter, which drives the evolution of the UDE, acts to enhance the observed
power spectrum and, hence, relativistic effects (on ultra-large scales) by
enlarging the UDE sound horizon. Conversely, both the (beyond) Horndeski
parameter and the kineticity act to diminish the observed power spectrum, by
decreasing the UDE sound horizon. Our results show that, in a universe with
UDE, a multi-tracer analysis will be needed to detect the relativistic effects
in the large-scale structure. In the light of a multi-tracer analysis, the
various relativistic effects hold the potential to distinguish different
gravity models. Moreover, while the Doppler effect will remain significant at
all epochs and, thus can not be ignored, the integrated Sachs-Wolfe, the
time-delay and the potential (difference) effects, respectively, will only
become significant at epochs near z=3 and beyond, and may be neglected at late
epochs. In the same vein, the Doppler effect alone can serve as an effective
cosmological probe for the large-scale structure or gravity models, in the
angular power spectrum - at all z.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.02680 [pdf] - 2050117
Fundamental Physics with the Square Kilometre Array
Weltman, A.;
Bull, P.;
Camera, S.;
Kelley, K.;
Padmanabhan, H.;
Pritchard, J.;
Raccanelli, A.;
Riemer-Sørensen, S.;
Shao, L.;
Andrianomena, S.;
Athanassoula, E.;
Bacon, D.;
Barkana, R.;
Bertone, G.;
Bonvin, C.;
Bosma, A.;
Brüggen, M.;
Burigana, C.;
Bœhm, C.;
Calore, F.;
Cembranos, J. A. R.;
Clarkson, C.;
Connors, R. M. T.;
de la Cruz-Dombriz, Á.;
Dunsby, P. K. S.;
Fonseca, J.;
Fornengo, N.;
Gaggero, D.;
Harrison, I.;
Larena, J.;
Ma, Y. -Z.;
Maartens, R.;
Méndez-Isla, M.;
Mohanty, S. D.;
Murray, S. G.;
Parkinson, D.;
Pourtsidou, A.;
Quinn, P. J.;
Regis, M.;
Saha, P.;
Sahlén, M.;
Sakellariadou, M.;
Silk, J.;
Trombetti, T.;
Vazza, F.;
Venumadhav, T.;
Vidotto, F.;
Villaescusa-Navarro, F.;
Wang, Y.;
Weniger, C.;
Wolz, L.;
Zhang, F.;
Gaensler, B. M.
Submitted: 2018-10-05, last modified: 2019-10-22
The Square Kilometre Array (SKA) is a planned large radio interferometer
designed to operate over a wide range of frequencies, and with an order of
magnitude greater sensitivity and survey speed than any current radio
telescope. The SKA will address many important topics in astronomy, ranging
from planet formation to distant galaxies. However, in this work, we consider
the perspective of the SKA as a facility for studying physics. We review four
areas in which the SKA is expected to make major contributions to our
understanding of fundamental physics: cosmic dawn and reionisation; gravity and
gravitational radiation; cosmology and dark energy; and dark matter and
astroparticle physics. These discussions demonstrate that the SKA will be a
spectacular physics machine, which will provide many new breakthroughs and
novel insights on matter, energy and spacetime.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04336 [pdf] - 1919367
Bias and scatter in the Hubble diagram from cosmological large-scale
structure
Submitted: 2018-12-11, last modified: 2019-07-19
An important part of cosmological model fitting relies on correlating
distance indicators of objects (for example type Ia supernovae) with their
redshift, often illustrated on a Hubble diagram. Comparing the observed
correlation with a homogeneous model is one of the key pieces of evidence for
dark energy. The presence of cosmic structures introduces a bias and scatter,
mainly due to gravitational lensing and peculiar velocities, but also due to
smaller non-linear relativistic contributions which are more difficult to
account for. For the first time we perform ray tracing onto halos in a
relativistic N-body simulation. Our simulation is the largest that takes into
account all leading-order corrections from general relativity in the evolution
of structure, and we present a novel methodology for working out the non-linear
projection of that structure onto the observer's past light cone. We show that
the mean of the bias in the Hubble diagram is indeed as small as expected from
perturbation theory. However, the distribution of sources is significantly
skewed with a very long tail of highly magnified objects and we illustrate that
the bias of cosmological parameters strongly depends on the function of
distance which we consider.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.12793 [pdf] - 1931402
Testing General Relativity with the Doppler magnification effect
Submitted: 2018-10-30, last modified: 2019-07-09
The apparent sizes and brightnesses of galaxies are correlated in a dipolar
pattern around matter overdensities in redshift space, appearing larger on
their near side and smaller on their far side. The opposite effect occurs for
galaxies around an underdense region. These patterns of apparent magnification
induce dipole and higher multipole terms in the cross-correlation of galaxy
number density fluctuations with galaxy size/brightness (which is sensitive to
the convergence field). This provides a means of directly measuring peculiar
velocity statistics at low and intermediate redshift, with several advantages
for performing cosmological tests of GR. In particular, it does not depend on
empirically-calibrated scaling relations like the Tully-Fisher and Fundamental
Plane methods. We show that the next generation of spectroscopic galaxy
redshift surveys will be able to measure the Doppler magnification effect with
sufficient signal-to-noise to test GR on large scales. We illustrate this with
forecasts for the constraints that can be achieved on parametrised deviations
from GR for forthcoming low-redshift galaxy surveys with DESI and SKA2.
Although the cross-correlation statistic considered has a lower signal to noise
than RSD, it will be a useful probe of GR since it is sensitive to different
systematics.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.00861 [pdf] - 1877887
Accurately computing weak lensing convergence
Submitted: 2018-12-03, last modified: 2019-05-06
Weak lensing will play an important role in future cosmological surveys,
including e.g. Euclid and SKA. Sufficiently accurate theoretical predictions
are important for correctly interpreting these surveys and hence for extracting
correct cosmological parameter estimations. We quantify for the first time in a
relativistic setting how many post-Born and lens-lens coupling corrections are
required for sub-percent accuracy of the theoretical weak lensing convergence
for $z\le 2$ (the primary weak lensing range for Euclid and SKA). We do this by
ray-tracing through a fully relativistic exact solution of the Einstein Field
Equations which consists of randomly packed mass-compensated underdensities of
realistic amplitudes. We find that including lens-lens coupling terms and
post-Born corrections up to second and third order respectively is sufficient
for sub-percent accuracy of the convergence along $94\%$ of the studied light
rays. We also find that a significant percentage of the studied rays have
post-Born corrections of size over $10\%$ of the usual gravitational
convergence, $\kappa^{(1)}$, and several rays even have post-Born corrections
several times the size of $\kappa^{(1)}$ at $z = 2$.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.07460 [pdf] - 1884383
General relativistic effects in the galaxy bias at second order
Submitted: 2019-01-22, last modified: 2019-05-01
The local galaxy bias formalism relies on the energy constraint equation at
the formation time to relate the metric perturbation to the matter density
contrast. In the Newtonian approximation, this relationship is linear, which
allows us to specify the initial galaxy density as a function of local physical
operators. In general relativity however, the relationship is intrinsically
nonlinear and a modulation of the short-wavelength mode by the long-wavelength
mode might be expected. We describe in detail how to obtain local coordinates
where the coupling of the long- to the short-wavelength modes is removed
through a change of coordinates (in the absence of the primordial
non-Gaussianity). We derive the general-relativistic correction to the galaxy
bias expansion at second order. The correction does not come from the
modulation of small-scale clustering by the long-wavelength mode; instead, it
arises from distortions of the volume element by the long-wavelength mode and
it does not lead to new bias parameters.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.09512 [pdf] - 1914635
The dipole of the galaxy bispectrum
Submitted: 2018-12-22, last modified: 2019-05-01
The bispectrum will play an important role in future galaxy surveys. On large
scales it is a key probe for measuring primordial non-Gaussianity which can
help differentiate between different inflationary models and other theories of
the early universe. On these scales a variety of relativistic effects come into
play once the galaxy number-count fluctuation is projected onto our past
lightcone. We show for the first time that the leading relativistic correction
from these distortions in the galaxy bispectrum generates a significant dipole,
mainly from relativistic redshift space distortions. The amplitude of the
dipole can be more than 10% of the monopole even on equality scales. Such a
dipole is absent in the Newtonian approximation to the redshift space
bispectrum, so it offers a clear signature of relativistic effects on
cosmological scales in large scale structure.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.05458 [pdf] - 1840730
Imprints of local lightcone projection effects on the galaxy bispectrum
IV: Second-order vector and tensor contributions
Submitted: 2018-11-13, last modified: 2019-02-19
The galaxy bispectrum on scales around and above the equality scale receives
contributions from relativistic effects. Some of these arise from lightcone
deformation effects, which come from local and line-of-sight integrated
contributions. Here we calculate the local contributions from the generated
vector and tensor background which is formed as scalar modes couple and enter
the horizon. We show that these modes are sub-dominant when compared with other
relativistic contributions.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.09309 [pdf] - 1793519
Safely smoothing spacetime: backreaction in relativistic cosmological
simulations
Submitted: 2017-06-28, last modified: 2018-12-06
A persistent theme in the study of dark energy is the question of whether it
really exists or not. It is often claimed hat we are mis-calculating the
cosmological model by neglecting the effects associated with averaging over
large-scale structures. In the Newtonian approximation this is clear: there is
no effect. Within the full relativistic picture this remains an important open
question however, owing to the complex mathematics involved. We study this
issue using particle numerical simulations which account for all relevant
relativistic effects without any problems from shell crossing. In this context
we show for the first time that the backreaction from structure can differ by
many orders of magnitude depending upon the slicing of spacetime one chooses to
average over. In the worst case, where smoothing is carried out in synchronous
spatial surfaces, the corrections can reach ten percent and more. However, when
smoothing on the constant time hypersurface of the Newtonian gauge,
backreaction contributions remain 3-5 orders of magnitude smaller.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.4350 [pdf] - 1731535
Non-linear relativistic contributions to the cosmological weak-lensing
convergence
Submitted: 2014-02-18, last modified: 2018-08-13
Relativistic contributions to the dynamics of structure formation come in a
variety of forms, and can potentially give corrections to the standard picture
on typical scales of 100 Mpc. These corrections cannot be obtained by Newtonian
numerical simulations, so it is important to accurately estimate the magnitude
of these relativistic effects. Density fluctuations couple to produce a
background of gravitational waves, which is larger than any primordial
background. A similar interaction produces a much larger spectrum of vector
modes which represent the frame-dragging rotation of spacetime. These can
change the metric at the percent level in the concordance model at scales below
the equality scale. Vector modes modify the lensing of background galaxies by
large-scale structure. This gives in principle the exciting possibility of
measuring relativistic frame dragging effects on cosmological scales. The
effects of the non-linear tensor and vector modes on the cosmic convergence are
computed and compared to first-order lensing contributions from density
fluctuations, Doppler lensing, and smaller Sachs-Wolfe effects. The lensing
from gravitational waves is negligible so we concentrate on the vector modes.
We show the relative importance of this for future surveys such as Euclid and
SKA. We find that these non-linear effects only marginally affect the overall
weak lensing signal so they can safely be neglected in most analyses, though
are still much larger than the linear Sachs-Wolfe terms. The second-order
vector contribution can dominate the first-order Doppler lensing term at
moderate redshifts and are actually more important for survey geometries like
the SKA.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.01812 [pdf] - 1656168
Imprints of local lightcone projection effects on the galaxy bispectrum.
III Relativistic corrections from nonlinear dynamical evolution on
large-scales
Submitted: 2017-11-06, last modified: 2018-03-26
The galaxy bispectrum is affected on equality scales and above by
relativistic observational effects, at linear and nonlinear order. These
lightcone effects include local contributions from Doppler and gravitational
potential terms, as well as integrated contributions like lensing, together
with all the couplings at nonlinear order. We recently presented the correction
to the galaxy bispectrum from all local lightcone effects up to second order in
perturbations, using a plane-parallel approximation. Here we update our
previous result by including the effects from relativistic nonlinear dynamical
evolution. We show that these dynamical effects make a significant contribution
to the projection effects.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.02179 [pdf] - 1674750
Model-independent curvature determination with 21cm intensity mapping
experiments
Submitted: 2017-11-06, last modified: 2018-01-17
Recent precision cosmological parameter constraints imply that the spatial
curvature of the Universe is essentially dynamically negligible - but only if
relatively strong assumptions are made about the equation of state of dark
energy (DE). When these assumptions are relaxed, strong degeneracies arise that
make it hard to disentangle DE and curvature, degrading the constraints. We
show that forthcoming 21cm intensity mapping experiments such as HIRAX are
ideally designed to carry out model-independent curvature measurements, as they
can measure the clustering signal at high redshift with sufficient precision to
break many of the degeneracies. We consider two different model-independent
methods, based on `avoiding' the DE-dominated regime and non-parametric
modelling of the DE equation of state respectively. Our forecasts show that
HIRAX will be able to improve upon current model-independent constraints by
around an order of magnitude, reaching percent-level accuracy even when an
arbitrary DE equation of state is assumed. In the same model-independent
analysis, the sample variance limit for a similar survey is another order of
magnitude better.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.04165 [pdf] - 1620094
The kinematic dipole in galaxy redshift surveys
Submitted: 2017-09-13, last modified: 2017-12-11
In the concordance model of the Universe, the matter distribution - as
observed in galaxy number counts or the intensity of line emission (such as the
21cm line of neutral hydrogen) - should have a kinematic dipole due to the
Sun's motion relative to the CMB rest-frame. This dipole should be aligned with
the kinematic dipole in the CMB temperature. Accurate measurement of the
direction of the matter dipole will become possible with future galaxy surveys,
and this will be a critical test of the foundations of the concordance model.
The amplitude of the matter dipole is also a potential cosmological probe. We
derive formulas for the amplitude of the kinematic dipole in galaxy redshift
and intensity mapping surveys, taking into account the Doppler, aberration and
other relativistic effects. The amplitude of the matter dipole can be
significantly larger than that of the CMB dipole. Its redshift dependence
encodes information on the evolution of the Universe and on the tracers, and we
discuss possible ways to determine the amplitude.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.09630 [pdf] - 1582181
Imprints of local lightcone projection effects on the galaxy bispectrum.
II
Submitted: 2017-03-28, last modified: 2017-09-29
General relativistic imprints on the galaxy bispectrum arise from
observational (or projection) effects. The lightcone projection effects include
local contributions from Doppler and gravitational potential terms, as well as
lensing and other integrated contributions. We recently presented for the first
time, the correction to the galaxy bispectrum from all local lightcone
projection effects up to second order in perturbations. Here we provide the
details underlying this correction, together with further results and
illustrations. For moderately squeezed shapes, the correction to the Newtonian
prediction is ~30% on equality scales at z ~ 1. We generalise our recent
results to include the contribution, up to second order, of magnification bias
(which affects some of the local terms) and evolution bias.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.05946 [pdf] - 1580430
Dipolar modulation in the size of galaxies: The effect of Doppler
magnification
Submitted: 2016-10-19, last modified: 2017-08-10
Objects falling into an overdensity appear larger on its near side and
smaller on its far side than other objects at the same redshift. This produces
a dipolar pattern of magnification, primarily as a consequence of the Doppler
effect. At low redshift this Doppler magnification completely dominates the
usual integrated gravitational lensing contribution to the lensing
magnification. We show that one can optimally observe this pattern by
extracting the dipole in the cross-correlation of number counts and galaxy
sizes. This dipole allows us to almost completely remove the contribution from
gravitational lensing up to redshift 0.5, and even at high redshift z~1 the
dipole picks up the Doppler magnification predominantly. Doppler magnification
should be easily detectable in current and upcoming optical and radio surveys;
by forecasting for telescopes such as the SKA, we show that this technique is
competitive with using peculiar velocities via redshift-space distortions to
constrain dark energy. It produces similar yet complementary constraints on the
cosmological model to those found using measurements of the cosmic shear.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.03726 [pdf] - 1557785
How does the cosmic large-scale structure bias the Hubble diagram?
Submitted: 2016-12-12, last modified: 2017-04-01
The Hubble diagram is one of the cornerstones of observational cosmology. It
is usually analysed assuming that, on average, the underlying relation between
magnitude and redshift matches the prediction of a
Friedmann-Lema\^itre-Robertson-Walker model. However, the inhomogeneity of the
Universe generically biases these observables, mainly due to peculiar
velocities and gravitational lensing, in a way that depends on the notion of
average used in theoretical calculations. In this article, we carefully derive
the notion of average which corresponds to the observation of the Hubble
diagram. We then calculate its bias at second-order in cosmological
perturbations, and estimate the consequences on the inference of cosmological
parameters, for various current and future surveys. We find that this bias
deeply affects direct estimations of the evolution of the dark-energy equation
of state. However, errors in the standard inference of cosmological parameters
remain smaller than observational uncertainties, even though they reach percent
level on some parameters; they reduce to sub-percent level if an optimal
distance indicator is used.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.03351 [pdf] - 1550342
A general relativistic signature in the galaxy bispectrum: the local
effects of observing on the lightcone
Submitted: 2016-10-11, last modified: 2017-03-15
Next-generation galaxy surveys will increasingly rely on the galaxy
bispectrum to improve cosmological constraints, especially on primordial
non-Gaussianity. A key theoretical requirement that remains to be developed is
the analysis of general relativistic effects on the bispectrum, which arise
from observing galaxies on the past lightcone, {as well as from relativistic
corrections to the dynamics}. {As an initial step towards a fully relativistic
analysis of the galaxy bispectrum, we compute for the first time the local
relativistic lightcone effects on the bispectrum,} which come from Doppler and
gravitational potential contributions. For the galaxy bispectrum, the problem
is much more complex than for the power spectrum, since we need the lightcone
corrections at second order. Mode-coupling contributions at second order mean
that relativistic corrections can be non-negligible at smaller scales than in
the case of the power spectrum. In a primordial Gaussian universe, we show that
the local lightcone corrections for squeezed shapes at $z\sim1$ mean that the
bispectrum can differ from the Newtonian prediction by $\gtrsim 10\%$ when the
short modes are $k\lesssim (50\,{\rm Mpc})^{-1}$. These relativistic projection
effects, if ignored in the analysis of observations, could be mistaken for
primordial non-Gaussianity. For upcoming surveys which probe equality scales
and beyond, {all relativistic lightcone effects and relativistic dynamical
corrections should be included} for an accurate measurement of primordial
non-Gaussianity.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.04652 [pdf] - 1513507
Roulettes: A weak lensing formalism for strong lensing - II. Derivation
and analysis
Submitted: 2016-03-15, last modified: 2016-11-14
We present a new extension of the weak lensing formalism capable of
describing strongly lensed images. This paper accompanies Paper I,
arXiv:1603.04698 where we provided a condensed overview of the approach and
illustrated how it works. Here we give all the necessary details, together with
some more explicit examples. We solve the non-linear geodesic deviation
equation order-by-order, keeping the leading derivatives of the optical tidal
matrix, giving rise to a series of maps from which a complete strongly lensed
image is formed. The family of maps are decomposed by separating the trace and
trace-free parts of each map. Each trace-free tensor represents an independent
spin mode, which distort circles into a variety of roulettes in the
screen-space. It is shown how summing this series expansion allows us to create
large strongly lensed images in regions where convergence, shear and flexion
are not sufficient. This paper is a detailed exposition of Paper I which
presents the key elements of the subject matter in a wider context.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.04698 [pdf] - 1443846
Roulettes: A weak lensing formalism for strong lensing - I. Overview
Submitted: 2016-03-15, last modified: 2016-07-26
We present a new perspective on gravitational lensing. We describe a new
extension of the weak lensing formalism capable of describing strongly lensed
images. By integrating the non-linear geodesic deviation equation, the
amplification matrix of weak lensing is generalised to a sum over independent
amplification tensors of increasing rank. We show how an image distorted by a
generic lens may be constructed as a sum over `roulettes', which are the
natural curves associated with the independent spin modes of the amplification
tensors. Highly distorted images can be constructed even for large sources
observed near or within the Einstein radius of a lens where the shear and
convergence are large. The amplitude of each roulette is formed from a sum over
appropriate derivatives of the lensing potential. Consequently, measuring these
individual roulettes for images around a lens gives a new way to reconstruct a
strong lens mass distribution without requiring a lens model. This formalism
generalises the convergence, shear and flexion of weak lensing to arbitrary
order, and provides a unified bridge between the strong and weak lensing
regimes.
This overview paper is accompanied by a much more detailed Paper II,
arXiv:1603.04652
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.02059 [pdf] - 1482321
HIRAX: A Probe of Dark Energy and Radio Transients
Newburgh, L. B.;
Bandura, K.;
Bucher, M. A.;
Chang, T. -C.;
Chiang, H. C.;
Cliche, J. F.;
Dave, R.;
Dobbs, M.;
Clarkson, C.;
Ganga, K. M.;
Gogo, T.;
Gumba, A.;
Gupta, N.;
Hilton, M.;
Johnstone, B.;
Karastergiou, A.;
Kunz, M.;
Lokhorst, D.;
Maartens, R.;
Macpherson, S.;
Mdlalose, M.;
Moodley, K.;
Ngwenya, L.;
Parra, J. M.;
Peterson, J.;
Recnik, O.;
Saliwanchik, B.;
Santos, M. G.;
Sievers, J. L.;
Smirnov, O.;
Stronkhorst, P.;
Taylor, R.;
Vanderlinde, K.;
Van Vuuren, G.;
Weltman, A.;
Witzemann, A.
Submitted: 2016-07-07
The Hydrogen Intensity and Real-time Analysis eXperiment (HIRAX) is a new
400-800MHz radio interferometer under development for deployment in South
Africa. HIRAX will comprise 1024 six meter parabolic dishes on a compact grid
and will map most of the southern sky over the course of four years. HIRAX has
two primary science goals: to constrain Dark Energy and measure structure at
high redshift, and to study radio transients and pulsars. HIRAX will observe
unresolved sources of neutral hydrogen via their redshifted 21-cm emission line
(`hydrogen intensity mapping'). The resulting maps of large-scale structure at
redshifts 0.8-2.5 will be used to measure Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO).
HIRAX will improve upon current BAO measurements from galaxy surveys by
observing a larger cosmological volume (larger in both survey area and redshift
range) and by measuring BAO at higher redshift when the expansion of the
universe transitioned to Dark Energy domination. HIRAX will complement CHIME, a
hydrogen intensity mapping experiment in the Northern Hemisphere, by completing
the sky coverage in the same redshift range. HIRAX's location in the Southern
Hemisphere also allows a variety of cross-correlation measurements with
large-scale structure surveys at many wavelengths. Daily maps of a few thousand
square degrees of the Southern Hemisphere, encompassing much of the Milky Way
galaxy, will also open new opportunities for discovering and monitoring radio
transients. The HIRAX correlator will have the ability to rapidly and
eXperimentciently detect transient events. This new data will shed light on the
poorly understood nature of fast radio bursts (FRBs), enable pulsar monitoring
to enhance long-wavelength gravitational wave searches, and provide a rich data
set for new radio transient phenomena searches. This paper discusses the HIRAX
instrument, science goals, and current status.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.0319 [pdf] - 1428636
Observed galaxy number counts on the lightcone up to second order: II.
Derivation
Submitted: 2014-06-02, last modified: 2016-06-26
We present a detailed derivation of the observed galaxy number over-density
on cosmological scales up to second order in perturbation theory. We include
all relativistic effects that arise from observing on the past lightcone. The
derivation is in a general gauge, and applies to all dark energy models
(including interacting dark energy) and many modified gravity models. The
result will be important for accurate cosmological parameter estimation,
including non-Gaussianity, since all projection effects need to be taken into
account. It also offers the potential for new probes of General Relativity,
dark energy and modified gravity. This paper accompanies Paper I which presents
the key results for the concordance model in Poisson gauge.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.4403 [pdf] - 1428635
Observed galaxy number counts on the lightcone up to second order: I.
Main result
Submitted: 2014-05-17, last modified: 2016-06-26
We present the galaxy number overdensity up to second order in redshift space
on cosmological scales for a concordance model. The result contains all general
relativistic effects up to second order that arise from observing on the past
light cone, including all redshift effects, lensing distortions from
convergence and shear, and contributions from velocities, Sachs-Wolfe,
integrated SW and time-delay terms. This result will be important for accurate
calculation of the bias on estimates of non-Gaussianity and on precision
parameter estimates, introduced by nonlinear projection effects.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.6813 [pdf] - 1418690
Lensing and time-delay contributions to galaxy correlations
Submitted: 2013-11-26, last modified: 2016-06-07
Galaxy clustering on very large scales can be probed via the 2-point
correlation function in the general case of wide and deep separations,
including all the lightcone and relativistic effects. Using our recently
developed formalism, we analyze the behavior of the local and integrated
contributions and how these depend on redshift range, linear and angular
separations and luminosity function. Relativistic corrections to the local part
of the correlation can be non-negligible but they remain generally
sub-dominant. On the other hand, the additional correlations arising from
lensing convergence and time-delay effects can become very important and even
dominate the observed total correlation function. We investigate different
configurations formed by the observer and the pair of galaxies, and we find
that the case of near-radial large-scale separations is where these effects
will be the most important.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.01821 [pdf] - 1409297
Dodging the dark matter degeneracy while determining the dynamics of
dark energy
Submitted: 2015-05-07, last modified: 2016-05-19
One of the key issues in cosmology is to establish the nature of dark energy,
and to determine whether the equation of state evolves with time. When
estimating this from distance measurements there is a degeneracy with the
matter density. We show that there exists a simple function of the dark energy
equation of state and its first derivative which is independent of this
degeneracy at all redshifts, and so is a much more robust determinant of the
evolution of dark energy than just its derivative. We show that this function
can be well determined at low redshift from supernovae using Gaussian
Processes, and that this method is far superior to a variety of
parameterisations which are also subject to priors on the matter density. This
shows that parametrised models give very biased constraints on the evolution of
dark energy.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.5221 [pdf] - 1278318
Beyond the plane-parallel and Newtonian approach: Wide-angle redshift
distortions and convergence in general relativity
Submitted: 2012-05-23, last modified: 2015-09-16
We extend previous analyses of wide-angle correlations in the galaxy power
spectrum in redshift space to include all general relativistic effects. These
general relativistic corrections to the standard approach become important on
large scales and at high redshifts, and they lead to new terms in the
wide-angle correlations. We show that in principle the new terms can produce
corrections of nearly 10 % on Gpc scales over the usual Newtonian
approximation. General relativistic corrections will be important for future
large-volume surveys such as SKA and Euclid, although the problem of cosmic
variance will present a challenge in observing this.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.04906 [pdf] - 1280778
Cosmological evolution of the gravitational entropy of the large-scale
structure
Submitted: 2015-01-20, last modified: 2015-09-01
We consider the entropy associated with the large-scale structure of the
Universe in the linear regime, where the Universe can be described by a
perturbed Friedmann-Lema\^itre spacetime. In particular, we compare two
different definitions proposed in the literature for the entropy using a
spatial averaging prescription. For one definition, the entropy of the
large-scale structure for a given comoving volume always grows with time, both
for a CDM and a $\Lambda$CDM model. In particular, while it diverges for a CDM
model, it saturates to a constant value in the presence of a cosmological
constant. The use of a light-cone averaging prescription in the context of the
evaluation of the entropy is also discussed.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.01676 [pdf] - 1262535
Cosmological ensemble and directional averages of observables
Submitted: 2015-04-07, last modified: 2015-08-14
We show that at second order, ensemble averages of observables and
directional averages do not commute due to gravitational lensing -- observing
the same thing in many directions over the sky is not the same as taking an
ensemble average. In principle this non-commutativity is significant for a
variety of quantities that we often use as observables and can lead to a bias
in parameter estimation. We derive the relation between the ensemble average
and the directional average of an observable, at second order in perturbation
theory. We discuss the relevance of these two types of averages for making
predictions of cosmological observables, focusing on observables related to
distances and magnitudes. In particular, we show that the ensemble average of
the distance in a given observed direction is increased by gravitational
lensing, whereas the directional average of the distance is decreased. For a
generic observable, there exists a particular function of the observable that
is not affected by second-order lensing perturbations. We also show that
standard areas have an advantage over standard rulers, and we discuss the
subtleties involved in averaging in the case of supernova observations.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.07831 [pdf] - 1262529
Do we care about the distance to the CMB? Clarifying the impact of
second-order lensing
Submitted: 2015-03-26, last modified: 2015-08-14
It has recently been shown that second-order corrections to the background
distance-redshift relation can build up significantly at large redshifts, due
to an aggregation of gravitational lensing events. This shifts the expectation
value of the distance to the CMB by 1%. In this paper we show that this shift
is already properly accounted for in standard CMB analyses. We clarify the role
that the area distance to the CMB plays in the presence of second-order lensing
corrections.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.08660 [pdf] - 1319530
The general theory of secondary weak gravitational lensing
Submitted: 2015-03-30
Weak gravitational lensing is normally assumed to have only two principle
effects: a magnification of a source and a distortion of the sources shape in
the form of a shear. However, further distortions are actually present owing to
changes in the gravitational field across the scale of the ray bundle of light
propagating to us, resulting in the familiar arcs in lensed images. This is
normally called the flexion, and is approximated by Taylor expanding the shear
and magnification across the image plane. However, the physical origin of this
effect arises from higher-order corrections in the geodesic deviation equation
governing the gravitational force between neighbouring geodesics - so involves
derivatives of the Riemann tensor. We show that integrating the second-order
geodesic deviation equation results in a 'Hessian map' for gravitational
lensing, which is a higher-order addition to the Jacobi map. We derive the
general form of the Hessian map in an arbitrary spacetime paying particular
attention to the separate effects of local Ricci versus non-local Weyl
curvature. We then specialise to the case of a perturbed FLRW model, and give
the general form of the Hessian for the first time. This has a host of new
contributions which could in principle be used as tests for modified gravity.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.2741 [pdf] - 943747
Does small scale structure significantly affect cosmological dynamics?
Submitted: 2014-08-12, last modified: 2015-02-06
The large-scale homogeneity and isotropy of the universe is generally thought
to imply a well defined background cosmological model. It may not. Smoothing
over structure adds in an extra contribution, transferring power from small
scales up to large. Second-order perturbation theory implies that the effect is
small, but suggests that formally the perturbation series may not converge. The
amplitude of the effect is actually determined by the ratio of the Hubble
scales at matter-radiation equality and today - which are entirely unrelated.
This implies that a universe with significantly lower temperature today could
have significant backreaction from more power on small scales, and so provides
the ideal testing ground for understanding backreaction. We investigate this
using two different N-body numerical simulations - a 3D Newtonian and a 1D
simulation which includes all relevant relativistic effects. We show that while
perturbation theory predicts an increasing backreaction as more initial
small-scale power is added, in fact the virialisation of structure saturates
the backreaction effect at the same level independently of the equality scale.
This implies that backreaction is a small effect independently of initial
conditions. Nevertheless, it may still contribute at the percent level to
certain cosmological observables and therefore it cannot be neglected in
precision cosmology.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.03820 [pdf] - 922493
Testing foundations of modern cosmology with SKA all-sky surveys
Schwarz, Dominik J.;
Bacon, David;
Chen, Song;
Clarkson, Chris;
Huterer, Dragan;
Kunz, Martin;
Maartens, Roy;
Raccanelli, Alvise;
Rubart, Matthias;
Starck, Jean-Luc
Submitted: 2015-01-15
Continuum and HI surveys with the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) will allow us
to probe some of the most fundamental assumptions of modern cosmology,
including the Cosmological Principle. SKA all-sky surveys will map an enormous
slice of space-time and reveal cosmology at superhorizon scales and redshifts
of order unity. We illustrate the potential of these surveys and discuss the
prospects to measure the cosmic radio dipole at high fidelity. We outline
several potentially transformational tests of cosmology to be carried out by
means of SKA all-sky surveys.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.7860 [pdf] - 1222175
What is the distance to the CMB?
Submitted: 2014-05-30, last modified: 2014-10-31
The success of precision cosmology depends not only on accurate observations,
but also on the theoretical model - which must be understood to at least the
same level of precision. Subtle relativistic effects can lead to biased
measurements if they are neglected. One such effect gives a systematic shift in
the distance-redshift relation away from its background value, due to the non-
linear relativistic conservation of total photon flux. We also show directly
how this shift follows from a fully relativistic analysis of the geodesic
deviation equation. We derive the expectation value of the shift using
second-order perturbations about a concordance background, and show that the
distance to last scattering is increased by 1%. We argue that neglecting this
shift could lead to a significant bias in the background cosmological
parameters, because it alters the meaning of the background model. A naive
adjustment of CMB parameter estimation if this shift is really a correction to
the background would raise the H0 value inferred from the CMB by 5%,
potentially removing the tension with local measurements of H0. Other CMB
parameters which depend on the distance would also be shifted by ~1sigma when
combined with local H0 data. While our estimations rely on a simplistic
analysis, they nevertheless illustrate that accurately defining the background
model in terms of the expectation values of observables is critical when we aim
to determine the model parameters at the sub-percent level.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.2109 [pdf] - 1222163
Nonlinear relativistic corrections to cosmological distances, redshift
and gravitational lensing magnification. I - Key results
Submitted: 2012-07-09, last modified: 2014-09-22
The next generation of telescopes will usher in an era of precision
cosmology, capable of determining the cosmological model to beyond the percent
level. For this to be effective, the theoretical model must be understood to at
least the same level of precision. A range of subtle relativistic effects
remain to be explored theoretically, and offer the potential for probing
general relativity in this new regime. We present the distance-redshift
relation to second order in cosmological perturbation theory for a general dark
energy model. This relation determines the magnification of sources at high
precision, as well as redshift space distortions in the mildly non-linear
regime. We identify a range of new lensing effects, including:
double-integrated and nonlinear integrated Sach-Wolfe contributions, transverse
Doppler effects, lensing from the induced vector mode and gravitational wave
backgrounds, in addition to lensing from the second-order potential.
Modifications to Doppler lensing from redshift-space distortions are
identified. Finally, we find a new double-coupling between the density
fluctuations integrated along the line of sight, and gradients in the density
fluctuations coupled to transverse velocities along the line of sight. These
can be large and thus offer important new probes of gravitational lensing and
general relativity. This paper accompanies arXiv:1402.1933, where a
comprehensive derivation is given.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.1933 [pdf] - 1222174
Nonlinear relativistic corrections to cosmological distances, redshift
and gravitational lensing magnification. II - Derivation
Submitted: 2014-02-09, last modified: 2014-09-22
We present a derivation of the cosmological distance-redshift relation up to
second order in perturbation theory. In addition, we find the observed redshift
and the lensing magnification to second order. We do not require that the
density contrast is small, we only that the metric potentials and peculiar
velocities are small. Thus our results apply into the nonlinear regime, and can
be used for most dark energy models. We present the results in a form which can
be readily computed in an N-body simulation. This paper accompanies
arXiv:1207.2109, where the key results are summarised in a physically
transparent form and applications are discussed.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.5241 [pdf] - 862434
Evolution of linear perturbations in spherically symmetric dust
spacetimes
Submitted: 2013-11-20, last modified: 2014-08-11
We present results from a numerical code implementing a new method to solve
the master equations describing the evolution of linear perturbations in a
spherically symmetric but inhomogeneous background. This method can be used to
simulate several configurations of physical interest, such as relativistic
corrections to structure formation, the lensing of gravitational waves and the
evolution of perturbations in a cosmological void model. This paper focuses on
the latter problem, i.e. structure formation in a Hubble scale void in the
linear regime. This is considerably more complicated than linear perturbations
of a homogeneous and isotropic background because the inhomogeneous background
leads to coupling between density perturbations and rotational modes of the
spacetime geometry, as well as gravitational waves. Previous analyses of this
problem ignored this coupling in the hope that the approximation does not
affect the overall dynamics of structure formation in such models. We show that
for a giga-parsec void, the evolution of the density contrast is well
approximated by the previously studied decoupled evolution only for very
large-scale modes. However, the evolution of the gravitational potentials
within the void is inaccurate at more than the $10\%$ level, and is even worse
on small scales.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.2214 [pdf] - 1091526
Observational Constraints on the Averaged Universe
Submitted: 2011-11-09, last modified: 2014-07-22
Averaging in general relativity is a complicated operation, due to the
general covariance of the theory and the non-linearity of Einstein's equations.
The latter of these ensures that smoothing spacetime over cosmological scales
does not yield the same result as solving Einstein's equations with a smooth
matter distribution, and that the smooth models we fit to observations need not
be simply related to the actual geometry of spacetime. One specific consequence
of this is a decoupling of the geometrical spatial curvature term in the metric
from the dynamical spatial curvature in the Friedmann equation. Here we
investigate the consequences of this decoupling by fitting to a combination of
HST, CMB, SNIa and BAO data sets. We find that only the geometrical spatial
curvature is tightly constrained, and that our ability to constrain dark energy
dynamics will be severely impaired until we gain a thorough understanding of
the averaging problem in cosmology.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.5227 [pdf] - 854188
The Value of $H_0$ from Gaussian Processes
Submitted: 2014-07-19
A new non-parametric method based on Gaussian Processes was proposed recently
to measure the Hubble constant $H_0$. The freedom in this approach comes in the
chosen covariance function, which determines how smooth the process is and how
nearby points are correlated. We perform coverage tests with a thousand mock
samples within the LCDM model in order to determine what covariance function
provides the least biased results. The function Matern(5/2) is the best with
sligthly higher errors than other covariance functions, although much more
stable when compared to standard parametric analyses.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.3694 [pdf] - 903389
Cosmology with Doppler Lensing
Submitted: 2014-01-15, last modified: 2014-07-08
Doppler lensing is the apparent change in object size and magnitude due to
peculiar velocities. Objects falling into an overdensity appear larger on its
near side, and smaller on its far side, than typical objects at the same
redshifts. This effect dominates over the usual gravitational lensing
magnification at low redshift. Doppler lensing is a promising new probe of
cosmology, and we explore in detail how to utilize the effect with forthcoming
surveys. We present cosmological simulations of the Doppler and gravitational
lensing effects based on the Millennium simulation. We show that Doppler
lensing can be detected around stacked voids or unvirialised over-densities.
New power spectra and correlation functions are proposed which are designed to
be sensitive to Doppler lensing. We consider the impact of gravitational
lensing and intrinsic size correlations on these quantities. We compute the
correlation functions and forecast the errors for realistic forthcoming
surveys, providing predictions for constraints on cosmological parameters.
Finally, we demonstrate how we can make 3-D potential maps of large volumes of
the Universe using Doppler lensing.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.0902 [pdf] - 796480
Spherically symmetric cosmological spacetimes with dust and radiation -
numerical implementation
Submitted: 2013-08-05, last modified: 2014-03-13
We present new numerical cosmological solutions of the Einstein Field
Equations. The spacetime is spherically symmetric with a source of dust and
radiation approximated as a perfect fluid. The dust and radiation are
necessarily non-comoving due to the inhomogeneity of the spacetime. Such a
model can be used to investigate non-linear general relativistic effects
present during decoupling or big-bang nucleosynthesis, as well as for
investigating void models of dark energy with isocurvature degrees of freedom.
We describe the full evolution of the spacetime as well as the redshift and
luminosity distance for a central observer. After demonstrating accuracy of the
code, we consider a few example models, and demonstrate the sensitivity of the
late time model to the degree of inhomogeneity of the initial radiation
contrast.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.5429 [pdf] - 1203499
Evidence for a Lower Value for $H_0$ from Cosmic Chronometers Data?
Submitted: 2014-02-21
An intriguing discrepancy emerging in the concordance model of cosmology is
the tension between the locally measured value of the Hubble rate, and the
'global' value inferred from the cosmic microwave background (CMB). This could
be due to systematic uncertainties when measuring $H_0$ locally, or it could be
that we live in a highly unlikely Hubble bubble, or other exotic scenarios. We
point out that the global $H_0$ can be found by extrapolating $H(z)$ data
points at high-$z$ down to $z=0$. By doing this in a Bayesian non-parametric
way we can find a model-independent value for $H_0$. We apply this to 19
measurements based on differential age of passively evolving galaxies as cosmic
chronometers. Using Gaussian processes, we find $H_0=64.9 \pm 4.2$ km s$^{-1}$
Mpc$^{-1}$ $(1\sigma)$, in agreement with the CMB value, but reinforcing the
tension with the local value. An analysis of possible sources of systematic
errors shows that the stellar population synthesis model adopted may change the
results significantly, being the main concern for subsequent studies. Forecasts
for future data show that distant $H(z)$ measurements can be a robust method to
determine $H_0$, where a focus in precision and a careful assessment of
systematic errors are required.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.2566 [pdf] - 787665
The Effect of Weak Lensing on Distance Estimates from Supernovae
Smith, Mathew;
Bacon, David J.;
Nichol, Robert C.;
Campbell, Heather;
Clarkson, Chris;
Maartens, Roy;
D'Andrea, Chris B.;
Bassett, Bruce A.;
Cinabro, David;
Finley, David A.;
Frieman, Joshua A.;
Galbany, Lluis;
Garnavich, Peter M.;
Olmstead, Matthew D.;
Schneider, Donald P.;
Shapiro, Charles;
Sollerman, Jesper
Submitted: 2013-07-09, last modified: 2013-12-09
Using a sample of 608 Type Ia supernovae from the SDSS-II and BOSS surveys,
combined with a sample of foreground galaxies from SDSS-II, we estimate the
weak lensing convergence for each supernova line-of-sight. We find that the
correlation between this measurement and the Hubble residuals is consistent
with the prediction from lensing (at a significance of 1.7sigma. Strong
correlations are also found between the residuals and supernova nuisance
parameters after a linear correction is applied. When these other correlations
are taken into account, the lensing signal is detected at 1.4sigma. We show for
the first time that distance estimates from supernovae can be improved when
lensing is incorporated by including a new parameter in the SALT2 methodology
for determining distance moduli. The recovered value of the new parameter is
consistent with the lensing prediction. Using CMB data from WMAP7, H0 data from
HST and SDSS BAO measurements, we find the best-fit value of the new lensing
parameter and show that the central values and uncertainties on Omega_m and w
are unaffected. The lensing of supernovae, while only seen at marginal
significance in this low redshift sample, will be of vital importance for the
next generation of surveys, such as DES and LSST, which will be systematics
dominated.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.4099 [pdf] - 1173476
Null tests of the cosmological constant using supernovae
Submitted: 2013-08-19, last modified: 2013-12-05
The standard concordance model of the Universe is based on the cosmological
constant as the driver of accelerating expansion. This concordance model is
being subjected to a growing range of inter-locking observations. In addition
to using generic observational tests, one can also design tests that target the
specific properties of the cosmological constant. These null tests do not rely
on parametrisations of observables, but focus on quantities that are constant
only if dark energy is a cosmological constant. We use supernova data in null
tests that are based on the luminosity distance. In order to extract
derivatives of the distance in a model-independent way, we use Gaussian
Processes. We find that the concordance model is compatible with the Union 2.1
data, but the error bars are fairly large. Simulated datasets are generated for
the DES supernova survey and we show that this survey will allow for a sharper
null test of the cosmological constant if we assume the Universe is flat.
Allowing for spatial curvature degrades the power of the null test.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.6678 [pdf] - 752112
Optimising Gaussian processes for reconstructing dark energy dynamics
from supernovae
Submitted: 2013-11-26
Gaussian processes are a fully Bayesian smoothing technique that allows for
the reconstruction of a function and its derivatives directly from
observational data, without assuming a specific model or choosing a
parameterization. This is ideal for constraining dark energy because physical
models are generally phenomenological and poorly motivated. Model-independent
constraints on dark energy are an especially important alternative to
parameterized models, as the priors involved have an entirely different source
so can be used to check constraints formulated from models or
parameterizations. A critical prior for Gaussian process reconstruction lies in
the choice of covariance function. We show how the choice of covariance
function affects the result of the reconstruction, and present a choice which
leads to reliable results for present day supernovae data. We also introduce a
method to quantify deviations of a model from the Gaussian process
reconstructions.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.4078 [pdf] - 781938
Testing the Copernican principle by constraining spatial homogeneity
Submitted: 2012-09-18, last modified: 2013-11-22
We present a new programme for placing constraints on radial inhomogeneity in
a dark-energy dominated universe. We introduce a new measure to quantify
violations of the Copernican principle. Any violation of this principle would
interfere with our interpretation of any dark-energy evolution. In particular,
we find that current observations place reasonably tight constraints on
possible late-time violations of the Copernican principle: the allowed area in
the parameter space of amplitude and scale of a spherical inhomogeneity around
the observer has to be reduced by a factor of three so as to confirm the
Copernican principle. Then, by marginalizing over possible radial inhomogeneity
we provide the first constraints on the cosmological constant which are free of
the homogeneity prior prevalent in cosmology.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.6540 [pdf] - 749763
Supernovae as probes of cosmic parameters: estimating the bias from
under-dense lines of sight
Submitted: 2013-09-25, last modified: 2013-11-21
Correctly interpreting observations of sources such as type Ia supernovae
(SNe Ia) require knowledge of the power spectrum of matter on AU scales - which
is very hard to model accurately. Because under-dense regions account for much
of the volume of the universe, light from a typical source probes a mean
density significantly below the cosmic mean. The relative sparsity of sources
implies that there could be a significant bias when inferring distances of SNe
Ia, and consequently a bias in cosmological parameter estimation. While the
weak lensing approximation should in principle give the correct prediction for
this, linear perturbation theory predicts an effectively infinite variance in
the convergence for ultra-narrow beams. We attempt to quantify the effect
typically under-dense lines of sight might have in parameter estimation by
considering three alternative methods for estimating distances, in addition to
the usual weak lensing approximation. We find in each case this not only
increases the errors in the inferred density parameters, but also introduces a
bias in the posterior value.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.1602 [pdf] - 642679
Galaxy correlations and the BAO in a void universe: structure formation
as a test of the Copernican Principle
Submitted: 2012-06-07, last modified: 2013-03-21
A suggested solution to the dark energy problem is the void model, where
accelerated expansion is replaced by Hubble-scale inhomogeneity. In these
models, density perturbations grow on a radially inhomogeneous background. This
large scale inhomogeneity distorts the spherical Baryon Acoustic Oscillation
feature into an ellipsoid which implies that the bump in the galaxy correlation
function occurs at different scales in the radial and transverse correlation
functions. We compute these for the first time, under the approximation that
curvature gradients do not couple the scalar modes to vector and tensor modes.
The radial and transverse correlation functions are very different from those
of the concordance model, even when the models have the same average BAO scale.
This implies that if void models are fine-tuned to satisfy average BAO data,
there is enough extra information in the correlation functions to distinguish a
void model from the concordance model. We expect these new features to remain
when the full perturbation equations are solved, which means that the radial
and transverse galaxy correlation functions can be used as a powerful test of
the Copernican Principle.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.3142 [pdf] - 615870
Anti-lensing: the bright side of voids
Submitted: 2012-09-14, last modified: 2013-01-17
More than half of the volume of our Universe is occupied by cosmic voids. The
lensing magnification effect from those under-dense regions is generally
thought to give a small dimming contribution: objects on the far side of a void
are supposed to be observed as slightly smaller than if the void were not
there, which together with conservation of surface brightness implies net
reduction in photons received. This is predicted by the usual weak lensing
integral of the density contrast along the line of sight. We show that this
standard effect is swamped at low redshifts by a relativistic Doppler term that
is typically neglected. Contrary to the usual expectation, objects on the far
side of a void are brighter than they would be otherwise. Thus the local
dynamics of matter in and near the void is crucial and is only captured by the
full relativistic lensing convergence. There are also significant nonlinear
corrections to the relativistic linear theory, which we show actually
under-predicts the effect. We use exact solutions to estimate that these can be
more than 20% for deep voids. This remains an important source of systematic
errors for weak lensing density reconstruction in galaxy surveys and for
supernovae observations, and may be the cause of the reported extra scatter of
field supernovae located on the edge of voids compared to those in clusters.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.6181 [pdf] - 1151690
Testing Homogeneity with Galaxy Star Formation Histories
Submitted: 2012-09-27, last modified: 2012-11-26
Observationally confirming spatial homogeneity on sufficiently large
cosmological scales is of importance to test one of the underpinning
assumptions of cosmology, and is also imperative for correctly interpreting
dark energy. A challenging aspect of this is that homogeneity must be probed
inside our past lightcone, while observations take place on the lightcone. The
star formation history (SFH) in the galaxy fossil record provides a novel way
to do this. We calculate the SFH of stacked Luminous Red Galaxy (LRG) spectra
obtained from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. We divide the LRG sample into 12
equal area contiguous sky patches and 10 redshift slices (0.2 < z < 0.5), which
correspond to 120 blocks of volume 0.04Gpc3. Using the SFH in a time period
which samples the history of the Universe between look-back times 11.5 to 13.4
Gyrs as a proxy for homogeneity, we calculate the posterior distribution for
the excess large-scale variance due to inhomogeneity, and find that the most
likely solution is no extra variance at all. At 95% credibility, there is no
evidence of deviations larger than 5.8%.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.3794 [pdf] - 1091696
The isotropic blackbody CMB as evidence for a homogeneous universe
Submitted: 2011-11-16, last modified: 2012-08-03
The question of whether the Universe is spatially homogeneous and isotropic
on the largest scales is of fundamental importance to cosmology, but has not
yet been answered decisively. Surprisingly, neither an isotropic primary CMB
nor combined observations of luminosity distances and galaxy number counts are
sufficient to establish such a result. The inclusion of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich
effect in CMB observations, however, dramatically improves this situation. We
show that even a solitary observer who sees an isotropic blackbody CMB can
conclude that the universe is homogeneous and isotropic in their causal past
when the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect is present. Critically, however, the CMB
must either be viewed for an extended period of time, or CMB photons that have
scattered more than once must be detected. This result provides a theoretical
underpinning for testing the Cosmological Principle with observations of the
CMB alone.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.3431 [pdf] - 581396
Using H(z) data as a probe of the concordance model
Submitted: 2012-05-15, last modified: 2012-07-12
Direct observations of the Hubble rate, from cosmic chronometers and the
radial baryon acoustic oscillation scale, can out-perform supernovae
observations in understanding the expansion history, because supernovae
observations need to be differentiated to extract H(z). We use existing H(z)
data and smooth the data using a new Gaussian Processes package, GaPP, from
which we can also estimate derivatives. The obtained Hubble rate and its
derivatives are used to reconstruct the equation of state of dark energy and to
perform consistency tests of the LCDM model, some of which are newly devised
here. Current data is consistent with the concordance model, but is rather
sparse. Future observations will provide a dramatic improvement in our ability
to constrain or refute the concordance model of cosmology. We produce simulated
data to illustrate how effective H(z) data will be in combination with Gaussian
Processes.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.2832 [pdf] - 1117940
Reconstruction of dark energy and expansion dynamics using Gaussian
processes
Submitted: 2012-04-12, last modified: 2012-05-31
An important issue in cosmology is reconstructing the effective dark energy
equation of state directly from observations. With few physically motivated
models, future dark energy studies cannot only be based on constraining a dark
energy parameter space, as the errors found depend strongly on the
parameterisation considered. We present a new non-parametric approach to
reconstructing the history of the expansion rate and dark energy using Gaussian
Processes, which is a fully Bayesian approach for smoothing data. We present a
pedagogical introduction to Gaussian Processes, and discuss how it can be used
to robustly differentiate data in a suitable way. Using this method we show
that the Dark Energy Survey - Supernova Survey (DES) can accurately recover a
slowly evolving equation of state to sigma_w = +-0.04 (95% CL) at z=0 and +-0.2
at z=0.7, with a minimum error of +-0.015 at the sweet-spot at z~0.14, provided
the other parameters of the model are known. Errors on the expansion history
are an order of magnitude smaller, yet make no assumptions about dark energy
whatsoever. A code for calculating functions and their first three derivatives
using Gaussian processes has been developed and is available for download at
http://www.acgc.uct.ac.za/~seikel/GAPP/index.html .
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.2484 [pdf] - 1084000
(Mis-)Interpreting supernovae observations in a lumpy universe
Submitted: 2011-09-12, last modified: 2012-05-22
Light from `point sources' such as supernovae is observed with a beam width
of order of the sources' size - typically less than 1 AU. Such a beam probes
matter and curvature distributions that are very different from coarse-grained
representations in N-body simulations or perturbation theory, which are
smoothed on scales much larger than 1 AU. The beam typically travels through
unclustered dark matter and hydrogen with a mean density much less than the
cosmic mean, and through dark matter halos and hydrogen clouds. Using N-body
simulations, as well as a Press-Schechter approach, we quantify the density
probability distribution as a function of beam width and show that, even for
Gpc-length beams of 500 kpc diameter, most lines of sight are significantly
under-dense. From this we argue that modelling the probability distribution for
AU-diameter beams is absolutely critical. Standard analyses predict a huge
variance for such tiny beam sizes, and nonlinear corrections appear to be
non-trivial. It is not even clear whether under-dense regions lead to dimming
or brightening of sources, owing to the uncertainty in modelling the expansion
rate which we show is the dominant contribution. By considering different
reasonable approximations which yield very different cosmologies we argue that
modelling ultra-narrow beams accurately remains a critical problem for
precision cosmology. This could appear as a discordance between angular
diameter and luminosity distances when comparing SN observations to BAO or CMB
distances.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.5505 [pdf] - 1118249
Establishing homogeneity of the universe in the shadow of dark energy
Submitted: 2012-04-24
Assuming the universe is spatially homogeneous on the largest scales lays the
foundation for almost all cosmology. This idea is based on the Copernican
principle, that we are not at a particularly special place in the universe.
Surprisingly, this philosophical assumption has yet to be rigorously
demonstrated independently of the standard paradigm. This issue has been
brought to light by cosmological models which can potentially explain apparent
acceleration by spatial inhomogeneity rather than dark energy. These models
replace the temporal fine tuning associated with Lambda with a spatial fine
tuning, and so violate the Copernican assumption. While is seems unlikely that
such models can really give a realistic solution to the dark energy problem,
they do reveal how poorly constrained radial inhomogeneity actually is. So the
bigger issue remains: How do we robustly test the Copernican principle
independently of dark energy or theory of gravity?
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.4265 [pdf] - 1052234
Locally extracting scalar, vector and tensor modes in cosmological
perturbation theory
Submitted: 2011-02-21, last modified: 2011-10-03
Cosmological perturbation theory relies on the decomposition of perturbations
into so-called scalar, vector and tensor modes. This decomposition is non-local
and depends on unknowable boundary conditions. The non-locality is particularly
important at second- and higher-order because perturbative modes are sourced by
products of lower-oder modes, which must be integrated over all space in order
to isolate each mode. However, given a trace-free rank-2 tensor, a locally
defined scalar mode may be trivially derived by taking two divergences, which
knocks out the vector and tensor degrees of freedom. A similar local
differential operation will return a pure vector mode. This means that scalar
and vector degrees of freedom have local descriptions. The corresponding local
extraction of the tensor mode is unknown however. We give it here. The
operators we define are useful for defining gauge-invariant quantities at
second-order. We perform much of our analysis using an index-free
`vector-calculus' approach which makes manipulating tensor equations
considerably simpler.
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.2314 [pdf] - 1841269
Does the growth of structure affect our dynamical models of the
universe? The averaging, backreaction and fitting problems in cosmology
Submitted: 2011-09-11
Structure occurs over a vast range of scales in the universe. Our large-scale
cosmological models are coarse-grained representations of what exists, which
have much less structure than there really is. An important problem for
cosmology is determining the influence the small-scale structure in the
universe has on its large-scale dynamics and observations. Is there a
significant, general relativistic, backreaction effect from averaging over
structure? One issue is whether the process of smoothing over structure can
contribute to an acceleration term and so alter the apparent value of the
cosmological constant. If this is not the case, are there other aspects of
concordance cosmology that are affected by backreaction effects? Despite much
progress, this 'averaging problem' is still unanswered, but it cannot be
ignored in an era of precision cosmology.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.4513 [pdf] - 401458
Local gauge-invariance at any order in cosmological perturbation theory
Submitted: 2011-08-23
The relativistic theory of structure formation in cosmology is based mainly
on linear perturbations about a homogeneous background. But we are now driven
to understand the theory of higher-order perturbations in full detail, both
from observational and theoretical points of view. An important aspect of this
lies in defining gauge-invariant perturbations at any order. We present a new
covariant approach to this based on a local separation of tensors into their
scalar, vector and tensor parts. Such a local decomposition necessarily
requires a trio of mutually annihilating differential operators which form the
basis for defining gauge-invariant objects. It makes no use of non-local
Green's functions or pre-defined gauges, and can be used to define families of
scalar, vector and tensor modes at any order one chooses.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.1886 [pdf] - 1076510
Is backreaction really small within concordance cosmology?
Submitted: 2011-05-10
Smoothing over structures in general relativity leads to a renormalisation of
the background, and potentially many other effects which are poorly understood.
Observables such as the distance-redshift relation when averaged on the sky do
not necessarily yield the same smooth model which arises when performing
spatial averages. These issues are thought to be of technical interest only in
the standard model of cosmology, giving only tiny corrections. However, when we
try to calculate observable quantities such as the all-sky average of the
distance-redshift relation, we find that perturbation theory delivers divergent
answers in the UV and corrections to the background of order unity. There are
further problems. Second-order perturbations are the same size as first-order,
and fourth-order at least the same as second, and possibly much larger, owing
to the divergences. Much hinges on a coincidental balance of 2 numbers: the
primordial power, and the ratio between the comoving Hubble scales at
matter-radiation equality and today. Consequently, it is far from obvious that
backreaction is irrelevant even in the concordance model, however natural it
intuitively seems.
[66]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.3959 [pdf] - 1042022
The Hubble rate in averaged cosmology
Submitted: 2010-11-17, last modified: 2011-02-28
The calculation of the averaged Hubble expansion rate in an averaged
perturbed Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker cosmology leads to small
corrections to the background value of the expansion rate, which could be
important for measuring the Hubble constant from local observations. It also
predicts an intrinsic variance associated with the finite scale of any
measurement of H_0, the Hubble rate today. Both the mean Hubble rate and its
variance depend on both the definition of the Hubble rate and the spatial
surface on which the average is performed. We quantitatively study different
definitions of the averaged Hubble rate encountered in the literature by
consistently calculating the backreaction effect at second order in
perturbation theory, and compare the results. We employ for the first time a
recently developed gauge-invariant definition of an averaged scalar. We also
discuss the variance of the Hubble rate for the different definitions.
[67]
oai:arXiv.org:1007.3443 [pdf] - 320747
The Cosmic Microwave Background in an Inhomogeneous Universe - why void
models of dark energy are only weakly constrained by the CMB
Submitted: 2010-07-20, last modified: 2011-02-21
The dimming of Type Ia supernovae could be the result of Hubble-scale
inhomogeneity in the matter and spatial curvature, rather than signaling the
presence of a dark energy component. A key challenge for such models is to fit
the detailed spectrum of the cosmic microwave background (CMB). We present a
detailed discussion of the small-scale CMB in an inhomogeneous universe,
focusing on spherically symmetric `void' models. We allow for the dynamical
effects of radiation while analyzing the problem, in contrast to other work
which inadvertently fine tunes its spatial profile. This is a surprisingly
important effect and we reach substantially different conclusions. Models which
are open at CMB distances fit the CMB power spectrum without fine tuning; these
models also fit the supernovae and local Hubble rate data which favours a high
expansion rate. Asymptotically flat models may fit the CMB, but require some
extra assumptions. We argue that a full treatment of the radiation in these
models is necessary if we are to understand the correct constraints from the
CMB, as well as other observations which rely on it, such as spectral
distortions of the black body spectrum, the kinematic Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect
or the Baryon Acoustic Oscillations.
[68]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.1043 [pdf] - 478051
Do primordial Lithium abundances imply there's no Dark Energy?
Submitted: 2010-03-04, last modified: 2010-08-19
Explaining the well established observation that the expansion rate of the
universe is apparently accelerating is one of the defining scientific problems
of our age. Within the standard model of cosmology, the repulsive 'dark energy'
supposedly responsible has no explanation at a fundamental level, despite many
varied attempts. A further important dilemma in the standard model is the
Lithium problem, which is the substantial mismatch between the theoretical
prediction for 7-Li from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis and the value that we observe
today. This observation is one of the very few we have from along our past
worldline as opposed to our past lightcone. By releasing the untested
assumption that the universe is homogeneous on very large scales, both apparent
acceleration and the Lithium problem can be easily accounted for as different
aspects of cosmic inhomogeneity, without causing problems for other
cosmological phenomena such as the cosmic microwave background. We illustrate
this in the context of a void model.
[69]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.2165 [pdf] - 903148
Inhomogeneity and the foundations of concordance cosmology
Submitted: 2010-05-12, last modified: 2010-06-01
The apparent accelerating expansion of the Universe is forcing us to examine
the foundational aspects of the standard model of cosmology -- in particular,
the fact that dark energy is a direct consequence of the homogeneity
assumption. We discuss the foundations of the assumption of spatial
homogeneity, in the case when the Copernican Principle is adopted. We present
results that show how (almost-) homogeneity follows from (almost-) isotropy of
various observables. The analysis requires the fully nonlinear field equations
-- i.e., it is not possible to use second- or higher-order perturbation theory,
since one cannot assume a homogeneous and isotropic background. Then we
consider what happens if the Copernican Principle is abandoned in our Hubble
volume. The simplest models are inhomogeneous but spherically symmetric
universes which do not require dark energy to fit the distance modulus. Key
problems in these models are to compute the CMB anisotropies and the features
of large-scale structure. We review how to construct perturbation theory on a
non-homogeneous cosmological background, and discuss the complexities that
arise in using this to determine the growth of large-scale structure.
[70]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.1479 [pdf] - 600198
Rendering Dark Energy Void
Submitted: 2009-09-08, last modified: 2010-05-21
Dark energy observations may be explained within general relativity using an
inhomogeneous Hubble-scale depression in the matter density and accompanying
curvature, which evolves naturally out of an Einstein-de Sitter (EdS) model. We
present a simple parameterization of a void which can reproduce concordance
model distances to arbitrary accuracy, but can parameterize away from this to
give a smooth density profile everywhere. We show how the Hubble constant is
not just a nuisance parameter in inhomogeneous models because it affects the
shape of the distance-redshift relation. Independent Hubble-rate data from age
estimates can in principle serve to break the degeneracy between concordance
and void models, but the data is not yet able to achieve this. Using the latest
Constitution supernova dataset we show that robust limits can be placed on the
size of a void which is roughly independent of its shape. However, the
sharpness of the profile at the origin cannot be well constrained due to
supernova being dominated by peculiar velocities in the local Universe. We
illustrate our results using some recently proposed diagnostics for the
Friedmann models.
[71]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.4858 [pdf] - 163171
Model independent tests of the standard cosmological model
Submitted: 2009-11-25, last modified: 2010-05-04
The dark energy problem has led to speculation that not only may LCDM be
wrong, but that the FLRW models themselves may not even provide the correct
family of background models. We discuss how direct measurements of H(z) can be
used to formulate tests of the standard paradigm in cosmology. On their own,
such measurements can be used to test for deviations from flat LCDM. When
combined with supernovae distances, Hubble rate measurements provide a test of
the Copernican principle and the homogeneity assumption of the standard model,
which is independent of dark energy or metric based theory of gravity. A
modification of this test also provides a model independent observable for
flatness which decorrelates curvature determination from dark energy. We
investigate these tests using Hubble rate measurements from age data, as well
as from a Hubble rate inferred from recent measurements of the baryon acoustic
oscillations. While the current data is too weak to say anything significant,
these tests are exciting prospects for the future.
[72]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.5004 [pdf] - 902972
Direct reconstruction of dark energy
Submitted: 2010-02-26, last modified: 2010-05-04
An important issue in cosmology is reconstructing the effective dark energy
equation of state directly from observations. With so few physically motivated
models, future dark energy studies cannot only be based on constraining a dark
energy parameter space. We present a new non-parametric method which can
accurately reconstruct a wide variety of dark energy behaviour with no prior
assumptions about it. It is simple, quick and relatively accurate, and involves
no expensive explorations of parameter space. The technique uses principal
component analysis and a combination of information criteria to identify real
features in the data, and tailors the fitting functions to pick up trends and
smooth over noise. We find that we can constrain a large variety of w(z) models
to within 10-20 % at redshifts z<1 using just SNAP-quality data.
[73]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.2041 [pdf] - 119871
Gravitational Lensing in Spherically Symmetric Spacetimes
Submitted: 2010-02-10
We present a framework for studying gravitational lensing in spherically
symmetric spacetimes using 1+1+2 covariant methods. A general formula for the
deflection angle is derived and we show how this can be used to recover the
standard result for the Schwarzschild spacetime.
[74]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.2601 [pdf] - 902411
On the determination of dark energy
Submitted: 2009-11-13
I consider some of the issues we face in trying to understand dark energy.
Huge fluctuations in the unknown dark energy equation of state can be hidden in
distance data, so I argue that model-independent tests which signal if the
cosmological constant is wrong are valuable. These can be constructed to remove
degeneracies with the cosmological parameters. Gravitational effects can play
an important role. Even small inhomogeneity clouds our ability to say something
definite about dark energy. I discuss how the averaging problem confuses our
potential understanding of dark energy by considering the backreaction from
density perturbations to second-order in the concordance model: this effect
leads to at least a 10% increase in the dynamical value of the deceleration
parameter, and could be significantly higher. Large Hubble-scale inhomogeneity
has not been investigated in detail, and could conceivably be the cause of
apparent cosmic acceleration. I discuss void models which defy the Copernican
principle in our Hubble patch, and describe how we can potentially rule out
these models.
[75]
oai:arXiv.org:0907.3377 [pdf] - 26472
The influence of structure formation on the cosmic expansion
Submitted: 2009-07-20, last modified: 2009-11-02
We investigate the effect that the average backreaction of structure
formation has on the dynamics of the cosmological expansion, within the
concordance model. Our approach in the Poisson gauge is fully consistent up to
second-order in a perturbative expansion about a flat Friedmann background,
including a cosmological constant. We discuss the key length scales which are
inherent in any averaging procedure of this kind. We identify an intrinsic
homogeneity scale that arises from the averaging procedure, beyond which a
residual offset remains in the expansion rate and deceleration parameter. In
the case of the deceleration parameter, this can lead to a quite large increase
in the value - more than 10% - and may therefore have important ramifications
for dark energy measurements, even if the underlying nature of dark energy is a
cosmological constant. We give the intrinsic variance that affects the value of
the effective Hubble rate and deceleration parameter. These considerations
serve to add extra intrinsic errors to our determination of the cosmological
parameters, and, in particular, may render attempts to measure the Hubble
constant to percent precision overly optimistic.
[76]
oai:arXiv.org:0907.2174 [pdf] - 26256
Gravitational waves in the black string braneworld
Submitted: 2009-07-13
We study gravitational waves in the black string Randall-Sundrum braneworld.
We present a reasonably self-contained and complete derivation of the equations
governing the evolution of gravitational perturbations in the presence of a
brane localized source, and then specialize to the case of spherical radiation
from a pointlike body in orbit around the black string. We solve for the
resulting gravitational waveform numerically for a number of different orbital
parameters.
[77]
oai:arXiv.org:0903.5040 [pdf] - 1001798
Perturbation Theory in Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi Cosmology
Submitted: 2009-03-29, last modified: 2009-06-18
The Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi solution has received much attention as a possible
alternative to Dark Energy, as it is able to account for the apparent
acceleration of the Universe without any exotic matter content. However, in
order to make rigorous comparisons between these models and cosmological
observations, such as the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect, baryon acoustic
oscillations and the observed matter power spectrum, it is absolutely necessary
to have a proper understanding of the linear perturbation theory about them.
Here we present this theory in a fully general, and gauge-invariant form. It is
shown that scalar, vector and tensor perturbations interact, and that the
natural gauge invariant variables in Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi cosmology do not
correspond straightforwardly to the usual Bardeen variables, in the limit of
spatial homogeneity. We therefore construct new variables that reduce to pure
scalar, vector and tensor modes in this limit.
[78]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.1349 [pdf] - 1001165
The cosmological background of vector modes
Submitted: 2008-12-07, last modified: 2009-02-19
We investigate the spectrum of vector modes today which is generated at
second order by density perturbations. The vector mode background that is
generated by structure formation is small but in principle it contributes to
the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect, to redshift-space distortions and to weak
lensing. We recover, clarify and extend previous results, and explain carefully
why no vorticity is generated in the fluid at second order. The amplitude of
the induced vector mode in the metric is around 1% that of the first-order
scalars on small scales. We also calculate the power spectrum and the energy
density of the vector part of the shear at second order.
[79]
oai:arXiv.org:0811.0981 [pdf] - 18257
Model independent constraints on the cosmological expansion rate
Submitted: 2008-11-06, last modified: 2009-01-28
We investigate what current cosmological data tells us about the cosmological
expansion rate in a model independent way. Specifically, we study if the
expansion was decelerating at high redshifts and is accelerating now, without
referring to any model for the energy content of the universe, nor to any
specific theory of gravity. This differs from most studies of the expansion
rate which, e.g., assumes some underlying parameterised model for the dark
energy component of the universe. To accomplish this, we have devised a new
method to probe the expansion rate without relying on such assumptions.
Using only supernova data, we conclude that there is little doubt that the
universe has been accelerating at late times. However, contrary to some
previous claims, we can not determine if the universe was previously
decelerating. For a variety of methods used for constraining the expansion
history of the universe, acceleration is detected from supernovae alone at >5
sigma, regardless of the curvature of the universe. Specifically, using a
Taylor expansion of the scale factor, acceleration today is detected at >12
sigma. If we also include the ratio of the scale of the baryon acoustic
oscillations as imprinted in the cosmic microwave background and in the large
scale distribution of galaxies, it is evident from the data that the expansion
decelerated at high redshifts, but only with the assumption of a flat or
negatively curved universe.
[80]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.4304 [pdf] - 14899
A litmus test for Lambda
Submitted: 2008-07-28
The critical issue in cosmology today lies in determining if the cosmological
constant is the underlying ingredient of dark energy. Our profound lack of
understanding of the physics of dark energy places severe constrains on our
ability to say anything about its possible dynamical nature. Quoted errors on
the equation of state, w(z), are so heavily dependent on necessarily
over-simplified parameterisations they are at risk of being rendered
meaningless. Moreover, the existence of degeneracies between the reconstructed
w(z) and the matter and curvature densities weakens any conclusions still
further. We propose consistency tests for the cosmological constant which
provide a direct observational signal if Lambda is wrong, regardless of the
densities of matter and curvature. As an example of its utility, our flat case
test can warn of a small transition from w(z)=-1 of 20% from SNAP quality data
at 4-sigma, even when direct reconstruction techniques see virtually no
evidence for deviation from Lambda. It is shown to successfully rule out a wide
range of non-Lambda dark energy models with no reliance on knowledge of Omega_m
using SNAP-quality data and a large range for using 10^5 supernovae as
forecasted for LSST.
[81]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.0068 [pdf] - 8539
Time drift of cosmological redshifts as a test of the Copernican
principle
Submitted: 2007-12-29, last modified: 2008-07-23
We present the time drift of the cosmological redshift in a general
spherically symmetric spacetime. We demonstrate that its observation would
allow us to test the Copernican principle and so determine if our universe is
radially inhomogeneous, an important issue in our understanding of dark energy.
In particular, when combined with distance data, this extra observable allows
one to fully reconstruct the geometry of a spacetime describing a spherically
symmetric under-dense region around us, purely from background observations.
[82]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.3457 [pdf] - 8367
A general test of the Copernican Principle
Submitted: 2007-12-20, last modified: 2008-03-17
The recent discovery of apparent cosmic acceleration has highlighted the
depth of our ignorance of the fundamental properties of nature. It is commonly
assumed that the explanation for acceleration must come from a new form of
energy dominating the cosmos - dark energy - or a modification of Einstein's
theory of Relativity. It is often overlooked, however, that a currently viable
alternative explanation of the data is radial inhomogeneity which alters the
Hubble diagram without any acceleration. This explanation is often ignored for
two reasons: radial inhomogeneity significantly complicates analysis and
predictions, and so the full details have not been investigated; and it is a
philosophically highly controversial idea, revoking as it does the long-held
Copernican Principle. To date, there has not been a general way of determining
the validity if the Copernican Principle -- that we live at a typical position
in the universe -- significantly weakening the foundations of cosmology as a
scientific endeavour. Here we present an observational test for the Copernican
assumption which can be automatically implemented while we search for dark
energy in the coming decade. Our test is entirely independent of any model for
dark energy or theory of gravity and thereby represents a model-independent
test of the Copernican Principle.
[83]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.1619 [pdf] - 4820
Vector modes generated by primordial density fluctuations
Submitted: 2007-09-11, last modified: 2008-02-08
While vector modes are usually ignored in cosmology since they are not
produced during inflation they are inevitably produced from the interaction of
density fluctuations of differing wavelengths. This effect may be calculated
via a second-order perturbative expansion. We investigate this effect during
the radiation era. We discuss the generation mechanism by investigating two
scalar modes interacting, and we calculate the power of vector modes generated
by a power-law spectrum of density perturbations on all scales.
[84]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.3847 [pdf] - 9376
Non-parametric Dark Energy Degeneracies
Submitted: 2008-01-24
We study the degeneracies between dark energy dynamics, dark matter and
curvature using a non-parametric and non-perturbative approach. This allows us
to examine the knock-on bias induced in the reconstructed dark energy equation
of state, w(z), when there is a bias in the cosmic curvature or dark matter
content, without relying on any specific parameterisation of w. Even assuming
perfect Hubble, distance and volume measurements, we show that for z > 1, the
bias in w(z) is up to two orders of magnitude larger than the corresponding
errors in Omega_k or Omega_m. This highlights the importance of obtaining
unbiased estimators of all cosmic parameters in the hunt for dark energy
dynamics.
[85]
oai:arXiv.org:hep-ph/0609310 [pdf] - 115388
Photon gas dynamics in the early universe
Submitted: 2006-09-29, last modified: 2007-10-19
Quantum electrodynamics predicts that photons undergo one-loop scattering.
The combined effect of this on the behaviour of a photon gas for temperatures
above 10^{10} K results in a softening of the equation of state. We calculate
the effect this has on the effective equation of state in the early universe,
taking into account all the species of the Standard Model. The change to the
dynamics of the early universe is discussed.
[86]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702670 [pdf] - 89724
Dynamical Dark Energy or Simply Cosmic Curvature?
Submitted: 2007-02-26, last modified: 2007-07-27
We show that the assumption of a flat universe induces critically large
errors in reconstructing the dark energy equation of state at z>~0.9 even if
the true cosmic curvature is very small, O(1%) or less. The spuriously
reconstructed w(z) shows a range of unusual behaviour, including crossing of
the phantom divide and mimicking of standard tracking quintessence models. For
1% curvature and LCDM, the error in w grows rapidly above z~0.9 reaching
(50%,100%) by redshifts of (2.5,2.9) respectively, due to the long cosmological
lever arm. Interestingly, the w(z) reconstructed from distance data and Hubble
rate measurements have opposite trends due to the asymmetric influence of the
curved geodesics. These results show that including curvature as a free
parameter is imperative in any future analyses attempting to pin down the
dynamics of dark energy, especially at moderate or high redshifts.
[87]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0612108 [pdf] - 247941
Gravitational waves generated by second order effects during inflation
Submitted: 2006-12-18, last modified: 2007-04-16
The generation of gravitational waves during inflation due to the non-linear
coupling of scalar and tensor modes is discussed. Two methods describing
gravitational wave perturbations are used and compared: a covariant and local
approach, as well as a metric-based analysis based on the Bardeen formalism. An
application to slow-roll inflation is also described.
[88]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0612013 [pdf] - 112391
The cosmological gravitational wave background from primordial density
perturbations
Submitted: 2006-12-01
We discuss the gravitational wave background generated by primordial density
perturbations evolving during the radiation era. At second-order in a
perturbative expansion, density fluctuations produce gravitational waves. We
calculate the power spectra of gravitational waves from this mechanism, and
show that, in principle, future gravitational wave detectors could be used to
constrain the primordial power spectrum on scales vastly different from those
currently being probed by large-scale structure. As examples we compute the
gravitational wave background generated by both a power-law spectrum on all
scales, and a delta-function power spectrum on a single scale.
[89]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610470 [pdf] - 85894
A gravitational wave window on extra dimensions
Submitted: 2006-10-16
We report on the possibility of detecting a submillimetre-sized extra
dimension by observing gravitational waves (GWs) emitted by pointlike objects
orbiting a braneworld black hole. Matter in the `visible' universe can generate
a discrete spectrum of high frequency GWs with amplitudes moderately weaker
than the predictions of general relativity (GR), while GW signals generated by
matter on a `shadow' brane hidden in the bulk are potentially strong enough to
be detected using current technology. We know of no other astrophysical
phenomena that produces GWs with a similar spectrum, which stresses the need to
develop detectors capable of measuring this high-frequency signature of large
extra dimensions.
[90]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0505277 [pdf] - 880850
Gravity-wave detectors as probes of extra dimensions
Submitted: 2005-05-13
If string theory is correct, then our observable Universe may be a
3-dimensional "brane" embedded in a higher-dimensional spacetime. This
theoretical scenario should be tested via the state-of-the-art in gravitational
experiments -- the current and upcoming gravity-wave detectors. Indeed, the
existence of extra dimensions leads to oscillations that leave a spectroscopic
signature in the gravity-wave signal from black holes. The detectors that have
been designed to confirm Einstein's prediction of gravity waves, can in
principle also provide tests and constraints on string theory.
[91]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0408032 [pdf] - 111599
Detecting extra dimensions with gravity wave spectroscopy: the black
string brane-world
Submitted: 2004-08-11, last modified: 2005-02-28
Using the black string between two branes as a model of a brane-world black
hole, we compute the gravity wave perturbations and identify the features
arising from the additional polarizations of the graviton. The standard
four-dimensional gravitational wave signal acquires late-time oscillations due
to massive modes of the graviton. The Fourier transform of these oscillations
shows a series of spikes associated with the masses of the Kaluza-Klein modes,
providing in principle a spectroscopic signature of extra dimensions.
[92]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0411140 [pdf] - 68739
The general relativistic MHD dynamo equation
Submitted: 2004-11-05, last modified: 2005-01-11
The magnetohydrodynamic dynamo equation is derived within general relativity,
using the covariant 1+3 approach, for a plasma with finite electric
conductivity. This formalism allows for a clear division and interpretation of
plasma and gravitational effects, and we have not restricted to a particular
spacetime geometry. The results should be of interest in astrophysics and
cosmology, and the formulation is well suited to gauge invariant perturbation
theory. Moreover, the dynamo equation is presented in some specific limits. In
particular, we consider the interaction of gravitational waves with magnetic
fields, and present results for the evolution of the linearly growing
electromagnetic induction field, as well as the diffusive damping of these
fields.
[93]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0311505 [pdf] - 880685
Cosmological density fluctuations and gravity waves: A covariant
approach to gauge-invariant non-linear perturbation theory
Submitted: 2003-11-21, last modified: 2004-10-18
We present a new approach to gauge-invariant cosmological perturbations at
second order, which is also covariant. We examine two cases in particular for a
dust Friedman-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker model of any curvature: we investigate
gravity waves generated from clustering matter, that is, induced tensor modes
from scalar modes; and we discuss the generation of density fluctuations
induced by gravity waves -- scalar modes from tensor perturbations. We derive a
linear system of evolution equations for second-order gauge-invariant variables
which characterise fully the induced modes of interest, with a source formed
from variables quadratic in first-order quantities; these we transform into
fully-fledged second-order gauge-invariant variables. Both the invariantly
defined variables and the key evolution equations are considerably simpler than
similar gauge-invariant results derived by other methods. By finding analytical
solutions, we demonstrate that non-linear effects can significantly amplify or
dampen modes present in standard linearised cosmological perturbation theory,
thereby providing an important source of potential error in, and refinement of,
the standard model. Moreover, these effects can dominate at late times, and on
super-Hubble scales.
[94]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0310323 [pdf] - 59986
The electromagnetic signature of black hole ringdown
Submitted: 2003-10-12, last modified: 2004-09-07
We investigate generation of electromagnetic radiation by gravitational waves
interacting with a strong magnetic field in the vicinity of a vibrating
Schwarzschild black hole. Such an effect may play an important role in
gamma-ray bursts and supernovae, their afterglows in particular. It may also
provide an electromagnetic counterpart to gravity waves in many situations of
interest, enabling easier extraction and verification of gravity wave waveforms
from gravity wave detection. We set up the Einstein-Maxwell equations for the
case of odd parity gravity waves impinging on a static magnetic field as a
covariant and gauge-invariant system of differential equations which can be
integrated as an initial value problem, or analysed in the frequency domain. We
numerically investigate both of these cases. We find that the black hole
ringdown process can produce substantial amounts of electromagnetic radiation
from a dipolar magnetic field in the vicinity of the photon sphere.
[95]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0209051 [pdf] - 111065
Covariant Perturbations of Schwarzschild Black Holes
Submitted: 2002-09-17, last modified: 2003-06-19
We present a new covariant and gauge-invariant perturbation formalism for
dealing with spacetimes having spherical symmetry (or some preferred spatial
direction) in the background, and apply it to the case of gravitational wave
propagation in a Schwarzschild black hole spacetime. The 1+3 covariant approach
is extended to a `1+1+2 covariant sheet' formalism by introducing a radial unit
vector in addition to the timelike congruence, and decomposing all covariant
quantities with respect to this. The background Schwarzschild solution is
discussed and a covariant characterisation is given. We give the full
first-order system of linearised 1+1+2 covariant equations, and we show how, by
introducing (time and spherical) harmonic functions, these may be reduced to a
system of first-order ordinary differential equations and algebraic constraints
for the 1+1+2 variables which may be solved straightforwardly. We show how both
the odd and even parity perturbations may be unified by the discovery of a
covariant, frame- and gauge-invariant, transverse-traceless tensor describing
gravitational waves, which satisfies a covariant wave equation equivalent to
the Regge-Wheeler equation for both even and odd parity perturbations. We show
how the Zerilli equation may be derived from this tensor, and derive a similar
transverse traceless tensor equivalent to this equation. The so-called
`special' quasinormal modes with purely imaginary frequency emerge naturally.
The significance of the degrees of freedom in the choice of the two frame
vectors is discussed, and we demonstrate that, for a certain frame choice, the
underlying dynamics is governed purely by the Regge-Wheeler tensor. The two
transverse-traceless Weyl tensors which carry the curvature of gravitational
waves are discussed.
[96]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0208364 [pdf] - 1591930
CMB limits on large-scale magnetic fields in an inhomogeneous universe
Submitted: 2002-08-20, last modified: 2003-03-26
We use the cosmic microwave background temperature anisotropy to place limits
on large-scale magnetic fields in an inhomogeneous (perturbed Friedmann)
universe. If no assumptions are made about the spacetime geometry, only a weak
limit can be deduced directly from the CMB. In the special case where spatial
inhomogeneity is neglected to first order, the upper limit is much stronger,
i.e. a few nano-G
[97]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0203081 [pdf] - 110953
On Scaling Solutions with a Dissipative Fluid
Submitted: 2002-03-25
We study the asymptotic behaviour of scaling solutions with a dissipative
fluid and we show that, contrary to recent claims, the existence of stable
accelerating attractor solution which solves the `energy' coincidence problem
depends crucially on the chosen equations of state for the thermodynamical
variables. We discuss two types of equations of state, one which contradicts
this claim, and one which supports it.
[98]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0108268 [pdf] - 44244
Qualitative Properties of Magnetic Fields in Scalar Field Cosmology
Submitted: 2001-08-15
We study the qualitative properties of the class of spatially homogeneous
Bianchi VI_o cosmological models containing a perfect fluid with a linear
equation of state, a scalar field with an exponential potential and a uniform
cosmic magnetic field, using dynamical systems techniques. We find that all
models evolve away from an expanding massless scalar field model in which the
matter and the magnetic field are negligible dynamically. We also find that for
a particular range of parameter values the models evolve towards the usual
power-law inflationary model (with no magnetic field) and, furthermore, we
conclude that inflation is not fundamentally affected by the presence of a
uniform primordial magnetic field. We investigate the physical properties of
the Bianchi I magnetic field models in some detail.
[99]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0102172 [pdf] - 40883
Magnetic Fields and the Cosmic Microwave Background
Submitted: 2001-02-09, last modified: 2001-05-07
Observations of the high degree of isotropy of the cosmic microwave
background are commonly believed to indicate that the Universe is `almost'
Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (at least since the time of last
scattering). Theoretical support for this belief comes from the so-called
Ehlers-Geren-Sachs Theorem. We show that a generalization of this theorem rules
out any strong magnetic fields in the Universe. Our theoretical result is
model-independent and includes the case of inhomogeneous magnetic fields,
complementing previous results. We thus prove that cosmic microwave background
observations severely constrain all types of primordial and protogalactic
magnetic fields in the universe.
[100]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9911235 [pdf] - 109363
Undermining the Cosmological Principle: Almost Isotropic Observations in
Inhomogeneous Cosmologies
Submitted: 1999-11-12, last modified: 2001-03-13
We challenge the widely held belief that the cosmological principle is an
obvious consequence of the observed isotropy of the cosmic microwave background
radiation, combined with the Copernican principle. We perform a detailed
analysis of a class of inhomogeneous perfect fluid cosmologies admitting an
isotropic radiation field, with a view to assessing their viability as models
of the real universe. These spacetimes are distinguished from FLRW universes by
the presence of inhomogeneous pressure, which results in an acceleration of the
fundamental observers. We examine their physical, geometrical and observational
characteristics for all observer positions in the spacetimes. To this end, we
derive exact, analytic expressions for the distance-redshift relations and
anisotropies for any observer, and compare their predictions with available
observational constraints. The isotropy constraints derived from `local'
observations are also considered, qualitatively. A crucial aspect of this work
is the application of the Copernican principle: for a specific model to be
acceptable we demand that it must be consistent with current observational
constraints (especially anisotropy constraints) for all observer locations. The
most important results of the paper are presented as exclusion plots in the 2-D
parameter space of the models. We show that there is a region of parameter
space not ruled out by the constraints we consider and containing models that
are significantly inhomogeneous. It follows immediately from this that the
cosmological principle cannot be assumed to hold on the basis of present
observational constraints.
[101]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0008089 [pdf] - 37405
On the Observational Characteristics of Inhomogeneous Cosmologies:
Undermining the Cosmological Principle
Submitted: 2000-08-04
This thesis concerns the compatibility of inhomogeneous cosmologies with our
present understanding of the universe. It is a problem of some interest to find
the class of all relativistic cosmological models which are capable of
providing a reasonable `fit' to the universe. This thesis, in some respects, is
part of this process. We consider Stephani models, which are a generalisation
of the standard Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) models, which can be
thought of as FLRW models with acceleration and pressure gradients. Thus these
models generalise the `dust' assumption of standard cosmology.
The crucial aspect of this work is the retention of the Copernican principle
-- an assumption regarded by many as crucial to cosmology. It states that we
are not at a special location in the universe. This is a vital aspect of the
original work in this thesis: consideration of an inhomogeneous model, while
retaining the Copernican principle has, as far as the author is aware, not been
considered in detail before.
We start by generalising the Ehlers-Geren-Sachs Theorem to identify the class
of inhomogeneous spacetimes which allow an isotropic radiation field for all
observers in the spacetime. We then investigate observational and physical
aspects of these models from all observer locations. We conclude that there
exist spacetimes which conform to present observational constraints (especially
anisotropy constraints) for any location in the spacetime, while at the same
time being significantly inhomogeneous; ie, not `almost-FLRW'.
[102]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/9906097 [pdf] - 113206
Does the Isotropy of the CMB Imply a Homogeneous Universe? Some
Generalised EGS Theorems
Submitted: 1999-06-23, last modified: 1999-12-14
We demonstrate that the high isotropy of the Cosmic Microwave Background
(CMB), combined with the Copernican principle, is not sufficient to prove
homogeneity of the universe -- in contrast to previous results on this subject.
The crucial additional factor not included in earlier work is the acceleration
of the fundamental observers. We find the complete class of irrotational
perfect fluid spacetimes admitting an exactly isotropic radiation field for
every fundamental observer and show that are FLRW if and only if the
acceleration is zero. While inhomogeneous in general, these spacetimes all
possess three-dimensional symmetry groups, from which it follows that they also
admit a thermodynamic interpretation. In addition to perfect fluids models we
also consider multi-component fluids containing non-interacting radiation, dust
and a quintessential scalar field or cosmological constant in which the
radiation is isotropic for the geodesic (dust) observers. It is shown that the
non-acceleration of the fundamental observers forces these spacetimes to be
FLRW. While it is plausible that fundamental observers (galaxies) in the real
universe follow geodesics, it is strictly necessary to determine this from
local observations for the cosmological principle to be more than an
assumption. We discuss how observations may be used to test this.