Normalized to: Claeys, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.6503 [pdf] - 1201861
PopCORN: Hunting down the differences between binary population
synthesis codes
Submitted: 2013-11-25, last modified: 2014-02-10
Binary population synthesis (BPS) modelling is a very effective tool to study
the evolution and properties of close binary systems. The uncertainty in the
parameters of the model and their effect on a population can be tested in a
statistical way, which then leads to a deeper understanding of the underlying
physical processes involved. To understand the predictive power of BPS codes,
we study the similarities and differences in the predicted populations of four
different BPS codes for low- and intermediate-mass binaries. We investigate
whether the differences are caused by different assumptions made in the BPS
codes or by numerical effects. To simplify the complex problem of comparing BPS
codes, we equalise the inherent assumptions as much as possible. We find that
the simulated populations are similar between the codes. Regarding the
population of binaries with one WD, there is very good agreement between the
physical characteristics, the evolutionary channels that lead to the birth of
these systems, and their birthrates. Regarding the double WD population, there
is a good agreement on which evolutionary channels exist to create double WDs
and a rough agreement on the characteristics of the double WD population.
Regarding which progenitor systems lead to a single and double WD system and
which systems do not, the four codes agree well. Most importantly, we find that
for these two populations, the differences in the predictions from the four
codes are not due to numerical differences, but because of different inherent
assumptions. We identify critical assumptions for BPS studies that need to be
studied in more detail.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.2895 [pdf] - 1202706
Theoretical uncertainties of the type Ia supernova rate
Submitted: 2014-01-13
It is thought that type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) are explosions of
carbon-oxygen white dwarfs (CO WDs). Two main evolutionary channels are
proposed for the WD to reach the critical density required for a thermonuclear
explosion: the single degenerate scenario (SD), in which a CO WD accretes from
a non-degenerate companion, and the double degenerate scenario (DD), in which
two CO WDs merge. However, it remains difficult to reproduce the observed SN Ia
rate with these two scenarios.
With a binary population synthesis code we study the main evolutionary
channels that lead to SNe Ia and we calculate the SN Ia rates and the
associated delay time distributions. We find that the DD channel is the
dominant formation channel for the longest delay times. The SD channel with
helium-rich donors is the dominant channel at the shortest delay times. Our
standard model rate is a factor five lower than the observed rate in galaxy
clusters.
We investigate the influence of ill-constrained aspects of single- and
binary-star evolution and uncertain initial binary distributions on the rate of
type Ia SNe. These distributions, as well as uncertainties in both helium star
evolution and common envelope evolution, have the greatest influence on our
calculated rates. Inefficient common envelope evolution increases the relative
number of SD explosions such that for $\alpha_{\rm ce} = 0.2$ they dominate the
SN Ia rate. Our highest rate is a factor three less than the galaxy-cluster SN
Ia rate, but compatible with the rate determined in a field-galaxy dominated
sample. If we assume unlimited accretion onto WDs, to maximize the number of SD
explosions, our rate is compatible with the observed galaxy-cluster rate.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1302.0495 [pdf] - 622492
Progenitors of Supernovae Type Ia
Submitted: 2013-02-03
Despite the significance of Type Ia supernovae (SNeIa) in many fields in
astrophysics, SNeIa lack a theoretical explanation. The standard scenarios
involve thermonuclear explosions of carbon/oxygen white dwarfs approaching the
Chandrasekhar mass; either by accretion from a companion or by a merger of two
white dwarfs. We investigate the contribution from both channels to the SNIa
rate with the binary population synthesis (BPS) code SeBa in order to constrain
binary processes such as the mass retention efficiency of WD accretion and
common envelope evolution. We determine the theoretical rates and delay time
distribution of SNIa progenitors and in particular study how assumptions affect
the predicted rates.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.1469 [pdf] - 1158880
Population synthesis of triple systems in the context of mergers of
carbon-oxygen white dwarfs
Submitted: 2013-01-08
Hierarchical triple systems are common among field stars yet their long-term
evolution is poorly understood theoretically. In such systems Kozai cycles can
be induced in the inner binary system during which the inner orbit eccentricity
and the inclination between both binary orbits vary periodically. These cycles,
combined with tidal friction and gravitational wave emission, can significantly
affect the inner binary evolution. To investigate these effects quantitatively
we perform a population synthesis study of triple systems and focus on
evolutionary paths that lead to mergers of carbon-oxygen (CO) white dwarfs
(WDs), which constitute an important candidate progenitor channel for type Ia
supernovae (SNe Ia). We approach this problem by Monte Carlo sampling from
observation-based distributions of systems within the primary mass range 1.0 -
6.5 M_Sun and inner orbit semi-major axes a_1 and eccentricities e_1 satisfying
a_1 (1-e_1^2) > 12 AU, i.e. non-interacting in the absence of a tertiary
component. We evolve these systems by means of a newly developed algorithm that
couples secular triple dynamics with an existing binary population synthesis
code. We find that the tertiary significantly alters the inner binary evolution
in about 24% of all sampled systems. In particular, we find several channels
leading to CO WD mergers. Amongst these is a novel channel in which a collision
occurs in wide inner binary systems as a result of extremely high
eccentricities induced by Kozai cycles. With assumptions on which CO WD mergers
lead to a SN Ia explosion we estimate the SNe Ia delay time distribution
resulting from triples and compare to a binary population synthesis study and
to observations. Although we find that our triple rate is low, we have
determined a lower limit of the triple-induced SNe Ia rate and further study is
needed that includes triples with initially tighter inner orbits.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.0809 [pdf] - 585637
POPCORN: A comparison of binary population synthesis codes
Submitted: 2012-11-05
We compare the results of three binary population synthesis codes to
understand the differences in their results. As a first result we find that
when equalizing the assumptions the results are similar. The main differences
arise from deviating physical input.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.4342 [pdf] - 1052251
Spin-Up/Spin-Down models for Type Ia Supernovae
Submitted: 2011-02-21
In the single degenerate scenario for Type Ia supernova (SNeIa), a white
dwarf (WD) must gain a significant amount of matter from a companion star.
Because the accreted mass carries angular momentum, the WD is likely to achieve
fast spin periods, which can increase the critical mass, $M_{crit}$, needed for
explosion. When $M_{crit}$ is higher than the maximum mass achieved by the WD,
the WD must spin down before it can explode. This introduces a delay between
the time at which the WD has completed its epoch of mass gain and the time of
the explosion. Matter ejected from the binary during mass transfer therefore
has a chance to become diffuse, and the explosion occurs in a medium with a
density similar to that of typical regions of the interstellar medium. Also,
either by the end of the WD's mass increase or else by the time of explosion,
the donor may exhaust its stellar envelope and become a WD. This alters,
generally diminishing, explosion signatures related to the donor star.
Nevertheless, the spin-up/spin-down model is highly predictive. Prior to
explosion, progenitors can be super-$M_{Ch}$ WDs in either wide binaries with
WD companions, or else in cataclysmic variables. These systems can be
discovered and studied through wide-field surveys. Post explosion, the
spin-up/spin-down model predicts a population of fast-moving WDs, low-mass
stars, and even brown dwarfs. In addition, the spin-up/spin-down model provides
a paradigm which may be able to explain both the similarities and the diversity
observed among SNeIa.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.1732 [pdf] - 1051988
Binary progenitor models of type IIb supernovae
Submitted: 2011-02-08
Massive stars that lose their hydrogen-rich envelope down to a few tenths of
a solar mass explode as extended type IIb supernovae, an intriguing subtype
that links the hydrogen-rich type II supernovae with the hydrogen-poor type Ib
and Ic. The progenitors may be very massive single stars that lose their
envelope due to their stellar wind, but mass stripping due to interaction with
a companion star in a binary system is currently considered to be the dominant
formation channel. We computed an extensive grid of binary models with the
Eggleton binary evolution code. The predicted rate from our standard models,
which assume conservative mass transfer, is about 6 times smaller than the
current rate indicated by observations. It is larger but still comparable to
the rate expected from single stars. To recover the observed rate we must
generously allow for uncertainties and low accretion efficiencies in
combination with limited angular momentum loss from the system. Motivated by
the claims of detection and non-detection of companions for a few IIb
supernovae, we investigate the properties of the secondary star at the moment
of explosion. We identify three cases: (1) the companion appears as a hot O
star in about 90% of the cases, (2) the companion becomes an over-luminous B
star in about 3% of the cases, or (3) the companion will appear as a K
supergiant. The second case, which applies to the well-studied case of SN 1993J
and possibly to SN 2001ig, is the least common case and requires that the
companion very efficiently accretes the transferred material -in contrast to
what is required to recover the overall IIb rate. The fast increasing number of
type IIb detections may lead to more solid constraints on model uncertainties,
like stellar wind-mass loss and internal mixing.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.5601 [pdf] - 297934
The search for progenitor models of type Ia supernovae
Submitted: 2011-01-28
We show the preliminary results of our search for the progenitor systems of
type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia). We model binary populations our aim being to
compare these models with the observations of detailed element abundances of
the hot Intra-Cluster Medium.