Normalized to: Ciesla, F.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.04233 [pdf] - 2092510
Earths in Other Solar Systems N-body simulations: the Role of Orbital
Damping in Reproducing the Kepler Planetary Systems
Submitted: 2020-05-08
The population of exoplanetary systems detected by Kepler provides
opportunities to refine our understanding of planet formation. Unraveling the
conditions needed to produce the observed exoplanets will sallow us to make
informed predictions as to where habitable worlds exist within the galaxy. In
this paper, we examine using N-body simulations how the properties of planetary
systems are determined during the final stages of assembly. While accretion is
a chaotic process, trends in the ensemble properties of planetary systems
provide a memory of the initial distribution of solid mass around a star prior
to accretion. We also use EPOS, the Exoplanet Population Observation Simulator,
to account for detection biases and show that different accretion scenarios can
be distinguished from observations of the Kepler systems. We show that the
period of the innermost planet, the ratio of orbital periods of adjacent
planets, and masses of the planets are determined by the total mass and radial
distribution of embryos and planetesimals at the beginning of accretion. In
general, some amount of orbital damping, either via planetesimals or gas,
during accretion is needed to match the whole population of exoplanets.
Surprisingly, all simulated planetary systems have planets that are similar in
size, showing that the "peas in a pod" pattern can be consistent with both a
giant impact scenario and a planet migration scenario. The inclusion of
material at distances larger than what Kepler observes has a profound impact on
the observed planetary architectures, and thus on the formation and delivery of
volatiles to possible habitable worlds.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.08804 [pdf] - 2025515
The Exoplanet Population Observation Simulator. II -- Population
Synthesis in the Era of Kepler
Submitted: 2019-05-21, last modified: 2019-12-13
The collection of planetary system properties derived from large surveys such
as Kepler provides critical constraints on planet formation and evolution.
These constraints can only be applied to planet formation models, however, if
the observational biases and selection effects are properly accounted for. Here
we show how epos, the Exoplanet Population Observation Simulator, can be used
to constrain planet formation models by comparing the Bern planet population
synthesis models to the Kepler exoplanetary systems. We compile a series of
diagnostics, based on occurrence rates of different classes of planets and the
architectures of multi-planet systems, that can be used as benchmarks for
future and current modeling efforts. Overall, we find that a model with 100
seed planetary cores per protoplanetary disk provides a reasonable match to
most diagnostics. Based on these diagnostics we identify physical properties
and processes that would result in the Bern model more closely matching the
known planetary systems. These are: moving the planet trap at the inner disk
edge outward; increasing the formation efficiency of mini-Neptunes; and
reducing the fraction of stars that form observable planets. We conclude with
an outlook on the composition of planets in the habitable zone, and highlight
that the majority of simulated planets smaller than 1.7 Earth radii have
substantial hydrogen atmospheres.
The software used in this paper is available online for public scrutiny at
https://github.com/GijsMulders/epos
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.00609 [pdf] - 1995481
Tracking Dust Grains During Transport and Growth in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2019-10-01
Protoplanetary disks are dynamic objects, within which dust grains and gas
are expected to be redistributed over large distances. Evidence for this
redistribution is seen both in other protoplanetary disks and in our own Solar
System, with high-temperature materials thought to originate close to the
central star found in the cold, outer regions of the disks. While models have
shown this redistribution is possible through a variety of mechanisms, these
models have generally ignored the possible growth of solids via grain-grain
collisions that would occur during transit. Here we investigate the interplay
of coagulation and radial and vertical transport of solids in protoplanetary
disks, considering cases where growth is limited by bouncing or by
fragmentation. We find that in all cases, growth effectively limits the ability
for materials to be carried outward or preserved at large distances from the
star. This is due to solids being incorporated into large aggregates which
drift inwards rapidly under the effects of gas drag. We discuss the
implications for mixing in protoplanetary disks, and how the preservation of
high temperature materials in outer disks may require structures or outward
flow patterns to avoid them being lost via radial drift.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.03267 [pdf] - 1971348
Systematic Variations of CO Gas Abundance with Radius in Gas-rich
Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2019-08-08
CO is the most widely used gas tracer of protoplanetary disks. Its abundance
is usually assumed to be an interstellar ratio throughout the warm molecular
layer of the disk. But recent observations of low CO gas abundance in many
protoplanetary disks challenge our understanding of physical and chemical
evolutions in disks. Here we investigate the CO abundance structures in four
well-studied disks and compare their structures with predictions of chemical
processing of CO and transport of CO ice-coated dust grains in disks. We use
spatially resolved CO isotopologue line observations and detailed
thermo-chemical models to derive CO abundance structures. We find that the CO
abundance varies with radius by an order of magnitude in these disks. We show
that although chemical processes can efficiently reduce the total column of CO
gas within 1 Myr under an ISM level of cosmic-ray ionization rate, the
depletion mostly occurs at the deep region of a disk. Without sufficient
vertical mixing, the surface layer is not depleted enough to reproduce weak CO
emissions observed. The radial profiles of CO depletion in three disks are
qualitatively consistent with predictions of pebble formation, settling, and
drifting in disks. But the dust evolution alone cannot fully explain the high
depletion observed in some disks. These results suggest that dust evolution may
play a significant role in transporting volatile materials and a coupled
chemical-dynamical study is necessary to understand what raw materials are
available for planet formation at different distances from the central star.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.04961 [pdf] - 1953641
Dust Transport and Processing in Centrifugally Driven Protoplanetary
Disk Winds
Submitted: 2019-07-10
There is evidence that protoplanetary disks--including the protosolar
one--contain crystalline dust grains on spatial scales where the dust
temperature is lower than the threshold value for their formation through
thermal annealing of amorphous interstellar silicates. We interpret these
observations in terms of an extended, magnetocentrifugally driven disk wind
that transports grains from the inner disk--where they are thermally processed
by the stellar radiation after being uplifted from the disk surfaces--to the
outer disk regions. For any disk radius $r$ there is a maximum grain size
$a_\mathrm{max}(r)$ that can be uplifted from that location: grains of size
$a$$\ll$$a_\mathrm{max}$ are carried away by the wind, whereas those with
$a$$\lesssim$$a_\mathrm{max}$ reenter the disk at larger radii. A significant
portion of the reentering grains converge to--and subsequently accumulate in--a
narrow region just beyond $r_\mathrm{max}(a)$, the maximum radius from which
grains of size $a$ can be uplifted. We show that this model can account for the
inferred crystallinity fractions in classical T Tauri and Herbig Ae disks and
for their indicated near constancy after being established early in the disk
evolution. It is also consistent with the reported radial gradients in the mean
grain size, crystallinity, and crystal composition. In addition, this model
yields the properties of the grains that remain embedded in the outflows from
protoplanetary disks and naturally explains the inferred persistence of small
grains in the surface layers of these disks.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.06056 [pdf] - 1791386
The Efficiency of Noble Gas Trapping in Astrophysical Environments
Submitted: 2018-11-14
Amorphous ice has long been invoked as a means for trapping extreme volatiles
into solids, explaining the abundances of these species in comets and planetary
atmospheres. Experiments have shown that such trapping is possible and have
been used to estimate the abundances of each species in primitive ices after
they formed. However, these experiments have been carried out at deposition
rates which exceed those expected in a molecular cloud or solar nebula by many
orders of magnitude. Here we develop a numerical model which reproduces the
experimental results and apply it to those conditions expected in molecular
clouds and protoplanetary disks. We find that two regimes of ice trapping
exist: `burial trapping' where the ratio of trapped species to water in the ice
reflects that same ratio in the gas and `equilibrium trapping' where the ratio
in the ice depends only on the partial pressure of the trapped species in the
gas. The boundary between these two regimes is set by both the temperature and
rate of ice deposition. Such effects must be accounted for when determining the
source of trapped volatiles during planet formation.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.01840 [pdf] - 1751950
Transport of CO in Protoplanetary Disks: Consequences of Pebble
Formation, Settling, and Radial Drift
Submitted: 2018-08-06
Current models of (exo)planet formation often rely on a large influx of
so-called `pebbles' from the outer disk into the planet formation region. In
this paper, we investigate how the formation of pebbles in the cold outer
regions of protoplanetary disks and their subsequent migration to the inner
disk can alter the gas-phase CO distribution both interior and exterior to the
midplane CO snowline. By simulating the resulting CO abundances in the midplane
as well as the warm surface layer, we identify observable signatures of
large-scale pebble formation and migration that can be used as `smoking guns'
for these important processes. Specifically, we find that after
$1\mathrm{~Myr}$, the formation and settling of icy pebbles results in the
removal of up to $80\%$ of the CO vapor in the warm ($T>22\mathrm{~K}$) disk
layers outside the CO snowline, while the radial migration of pebbles results
in the generation of a plume of CO vapor interior the snowline, increasing the
CO abundance by a factor ${\sim}2{-}6$ depending on the strength of the
turbulence and the sizes of the individual pebbles. The absence of this plume
of CO vapor in young nearby disks could indicate efficient conversion of CO
into a more refractory species, or a reduction in the radial mass flux of
pebbles by, for example, disk inhomogeneities or early planetesimal formation.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.08211 [pdf] - 1712979
The Exoplanet Population Observation Simulator. I - The Inner Edges of
Planetary Systems
Submitted: 2018-05-21
The Kepler survey provides a statistical census of planetary systems out to
the habitable zone. Because most planets are non-transiting, orbital
architectures are best estimated using simulated observations of ensemble
populations. Here, we introduce EPOS, the Exoplanet Population Observation
Simulator, to estimate the prevalence and orbital architectures of multi-planet
systems based on the latest Kepler data release, DR25. We estimate that at
least 42% of sun-like stars have nearly coplanar planetary systems with 7 or
more exoplanets. The fraction of stars with at least one planet within 1 au
could be as high as 100% depending on assumptions about the distribution of
single transiting planets. We estimate an occurrence rate of planets in the
habitable zone around sun-like stars of eta_earth=36+-14%. The innermost
planets in multi-planet systems are clustered around an orbital period of 10
days (0.1 au), reminiscent of the protoplanetary disk inner edge or could be
explained by a planet trap at that location. Only a small fraction of planetary
systems have the innermost planet at long orbital periods, with fewer than ~8%
and ~3% having no planet interior to the orbit of Mercury and Venus,
respectively. These results reinforce the view that the solar system is not a
typical planetary system, but an outlier among the distribution of known
exoplanetary systems. We predict that at least half of the habitable zone
exoplanets are accompanied by (non-transiting) planets at shorter orbital
periods, hence knowledge of a close-in exoplanet could be used as a way to
optimize the search for Earth-size planets in the Habitable Zone with future
direct imaging missions.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.08682 [pdf] - 1654584
A comprehensive understanding of planet formation is required for
assessing planetary habitability and for the search for life
Apai, Dániel;
Ciesla, Fred;
Mulders, Gijs D.;
Pascucci, Ilaria;
Barry, Richard;
Pontoppidan, Klaus;
Bergin, Edwin;
Bixel, Alex;
Brittain, Sean;
Domagal-Goldman, Shawn D.;
Hasegawa, Yasuhiro;
Jang-Condell, Hannah;
Malhotra, Renu;
Meyer, Michael R.;
Youdin, Andrew;
Teske, Johanna;
Turner, Neal
Submitted: 2018-03-23
Dozens of habitable zone, approximately earth-sized exoplanets are known
today. An emerging frontier of exoplanet studies is identifying which of these
habitable zone, small planets are actually habitable (have all necessary
conditions for life) and, of those, which are earth-like. Many parameters and
processes influence habitability, ranging from the orbit through detailed
composition including volatiles and organics, to the presence of geological
activity and plate tectonics. While some properties will soon be directly
observable, others cannot be probed by remote sensing for the foreseeable
future. Thus, statistical understanding of planetary systems' formation and
evolution is a key supplement to the direct measurements of planet properties.
Probabilistically assessing parameters we cannot directly measure is essential
to reliably assess habitability, to prioritizing habitable-zone planets for
follow-up, and for interpreting possible biosignatures.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.03360 [pdf] - 1586983
Disk evolution and the fate of water
Submitted: 2017-08-10
We review the general theoretical concepts and observational constraints on
the distribution and evolution of water vapor and ice in protoplanetary disks,
with a focus on the Solar System. Water is expected to freeze out at distances
greater than 1-3 AU from solar-type central stars; more precise estimates are
difficult to obtain due to uncertainties in the complex processes involved in
disk evolution, including dust growth, settling, and radial drift, and the
level of turbulence and viscous dissipation within disks. Interferometric
observations are now providing constraints on the positions of CO snow lines,
but extrapolation to the unresolved regions where water ice sublimates will
require much better theoretical understanding of mass and angular momentum
transport in disks as well as more refined comparison of observations with
sophisticated disk models.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.08982 [pdf] - 1586476
Destruction of Refractory Carbon in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2017-07-27
The Earth and other rocky bodies in the inner solar system contain
significantly less carbon than the primordial materials that seeded their
formation. These carbon-poor objects include the parent bodies of primitive
meteorites, suggesting that at least one process responsible for solid-phase
carbon depletion was active prior to the early stages of planet formation.
Potential mechanisms include the erosion of carbonaceous materials by photons
or atomic oxygen in the surface layers of the protoplanetary disk. Under
photochemically generated favorable conditions, these reactions can deplete the
near-surface abundance of carbon grains and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons by
several orders of magnitude on short timescales relative to the lifetime of the
disk out to radii of ~20-100+ au from the central star depending on the form of
refractory carbon present. Due to the reliance of destruction mechanisms on a
high influx of photons, the extent of refractory carbon depletion is quite
sensitive to the disk's internal radiation field. Dust transport within the
disk is required to affect the composition of the midplane. In our current
model of a passive, constant-alpha disk, where alpha = 0.01, carbon grains can
be turbulently lofted into the destructive surface layers and depleted out to
radii of ~3-10 au for 0.1-1 um grains. Smaller grains can be cleared out of the
planet-forming region completely. Destruction may be more effective in an
actively accreting disk or when considering individual grain trajectories in
non-idealized disks.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.01411 [pdf] - 1564160
Fast litho-panspermia in the habitable zone of the TRAPPIST-1 system
Submitted: 2017-04-05
With several short-period, Earth-mass planets in the habitable zone, the
TRAPPIST-1 system potentially allows litho-panspermia to take place on very
short timescales. We investigate the efficiency and speed of inter-planetary
material transfer resulting from impacts onto the habitable zone planets. By
simulating trajectories of impact ejecta from their moment of ejection until
(re-)accretion, we find that transport between the habitable zone planets is
fastest for ejection velocities around and just above planetary escape
velocity. At these ejection velocities, ${\sim}10\%$ of the ejected material
reaches another habitable zone planet within $10^2\mathrm{~yr}$, indicating
litho-panspermia can be 4 to 5 orders of magnitude faster in TRAPPIST-1 than in
the Solar System.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.06463 [pdf] - 1532166
Tracing water vapor and ice during dust growth
Submitted: 2016-10-20
The processes that govern the evolution of dust and water (in the form of
vapor or ice) in protoplanetary disks are intimately connected. We have
developed a model that simulates dust coagulation, dust dynamics (settling,
turbulent mixing), vapor diffusion, and condensation/sublimation of volatiles
onto grains in a vertical column of a protoplanetary disk. We employ the model
to study how dust growth and dynamics influence the vertical distribution of
water vapor and water ice in the region just outside the radial snowline. Our
main finding is that coagulation (boosted by the enhanced stickiness of icy
grains) and the ensuing vertical settling of solids results in water vapor
being depleted, but not totally removed, from the region above the snowline on
a timescale commensurate with the vertical turbulent mixing timescale.
Depending on the strength of the turbulence and the temperature, the depletion
can reach factors of up to ${\sim}50$ in the disk atmosphere. In our isothermal
column, this vapor depletion results in the vertical snowline moving closer to
the midplane (by up to 2 gas scale heights) and the gas-phase C/O ratio above
the vertical snowline increasing. Our findings illustrate the importance of
dynamical effects and the need for understanding coevolutionary dynamics of gas
and solids in planet-forming environments.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.03621 [pdf] - 1510323
A Steeper than Linear Disk Mass-Stellar Mass Scaling Relation
Pascucci, I.;
Testi, L.;
Herczeg, G. J.;
Long, F.;
Manara, C. F.;
Hendler, N.;
Mulders, G. D.;
Krijt, S.;
Ciesla, F.;
Henning, Th.;
Mohanty, S.;
Drabek-Maunder, E.;
Apai, D.;
Szucs, L.;
Sacco, G.;
Olofsson, J.
Submitted: 2016-08-11
The disk mass is among the most important input parameter for every planet
formation model to determine the number and masses of the planets that can
form. We present an ALMA 887micron survey of the disk population around objects
from 2 to 0.03Msun in the nearby 2Myr-old Chamaeleon I star-forming region. We
detect thermal dust emission from 66 out of 93 disks, spatially resolve 34 of
them, and identify two disks with large dust cavities of about 45AU in radius.
Assuming isothermal and optically thin emission, we convert the 887micron flux
densities into dust disk masses, hereafter Mdust. We find that the Mdust-Mstar
relation is steeper than linear with power law indices 1.3-1.9, where the range
reflects two extremes of the possible relation between the average dust
temperature and stellar luminosity. By re-analyzing all millimeter data
available for nearby regions in a self-consistent way, we show that the 1-3
Myr-old regions of Taurus, Lupus, and Chamaeleon I share the same Mdust-Mstar
relation, while the 10Myr-old Upper Sco association has a steeper relation.
Theoretical models of grain growth, drift, and fragmentation reproduce this
trend and suggest that disks are in the fragmentation-limited regime. In this
regime millimeter grains will be located closer in around lower-mass stars, a
prediction that can be tested with deeper and higher spatial resolution ALMA
observations.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.02630 [pdf] - 1411382
Dust diffusion and settling in the presence of collisions: Trapping
(sub)micron grains in the midplane
Submitted: 2016-03-08
In protoplanetary disks, the distribution and abundance of small (sub)micron
grains are important for a range of physical and chemical processes. For
example, they dominate the optical depth at short wavelengths and their
surfaces are the sites of many important chemical reactions such as the
formation of water. Based on their aerodynamical properties (i.e., their strong
dynamical coupling with the surrounding gas) it is often assumed that these
small grains are well-mixed with the gas. Our goal is to study the vertical
(re)distribution of grains taking into account settling, turbulent diffusion,
as well as collisions with other dust grains. Assuming a fragmentation-limited
background dust population, we developed a Monte Carlo approach that follows
single monomers as they move through a vertical column of gas and become
incorporated in different aggregates as they undergo sticking and fragmenting
collisions. We find that (sub)micron grains are not necessarily well-mixed
vertically, but can become trapped in a thin layer with a scale-height that is
significantly smaller than that of the gas. This collisional trapping occurs
when the timescale for diffusion is comparable to or longer than the collision
timescale in the midplane and its effect is strongest when the most massive
particles in the size-distribution show significant settling. Based on
simulations and analytical considerations we conclude that for typical
dust-to-gas ratios and turbulence levels, the collisional trapping of small
grains should be a relatively common phenomenon. The absence of trapping could
then indicate a low dust-to-gas ratio, possibly because a large portion of the
dust mass has been removed through radial drift or is locked up in
planetesimals.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.03622 [pdf] - 1351483
Planet Hunters X. KIC 8462852 - Where's the Flux?
Boyajian, T. S.;
LaCourse, D. M.;
Rappaport, S. A.;
Fabrycky, D.;
Fischer, D. A.;
Gandolfi, D.;
Kennedy, G. M.;
Korhonen, H.;
Liu, M. C.;
Moor, A.;
Olah, K.;
Vida, K.;
Wyatt, M. C.;
Best, W. M. J.;
Brewer, J.;
Ciesla, F.;
Csak, B.;
Deeg, H. J.;
Dupuy, T. J.;
Handler, G.;
Heng, K.;
Howell, S. B.;
Ishikawa, S. T.;
Kovacs, J.;
Kozakis, T.;
Kriskovics, L.;
Lehtinen, J.;
Lintott, C.;
Lynn, S.;
Nespral, D.;
Nikbakhsh, S.;
Schawinski, K.;
Schmitt, J. R.;
Smith, A. M.;
Szabo, Gy.;
Szabo, R.;
Viuho, J.;
Wang, J.;
Weiksnar, A.;
Bosch, M.;
Connors, J. L.;
Goodman, S.;
Green, G.;
Hoekstra, A. J.;
Jebson, T.;
Jek, K. J.;
Omohundro, M. R.;
Schwengeler, H. M.;
Szewczyk, A.
Submitted: 2015-09-11, last modified: 2016-01-25
Over the duration of the Kepler mission, KIC8462852 was observed to undergo
irregularly shaped, aperiodic dips in flux of up to $\sim 20$\%. The dipping
activity can last for between 5 and 80 days. We characterize the object with
high-resolution spectroscopy, spectral energy distribution fitting, radial
velocity measurements, high-resolution imaging, and Fourier analyses of the
Kepler light curve. We determine that KIC8462852 is a typical main-sequence F3
V star that exhibits no significant IR excess, and has no very close
interacting companions. In this paper, we describe various scenarios to explain
the dipping events observed in the Kepler light curve. We confirm that the
dipping signals in the data are not caused by any instrumental or data
processing artifact, and thus are astrophysical in origin. We construct
scenario-independent constraints on the size and location of a body in the
system that is needed to reproduce the observations. We deliberate over several
assorted stellar and circumstellar astrophysical scenarios, most of which have
problems explaining the data in hand. By considering the observational
constraints on dust clumps in orbit around a normal main-sequence star, we
conclude that the scenario most consistent with the data in hand is the passage
of a family of exocomet or planetesimal fragments, all of which are associated
with a single previous break-up event, possibly caused by tidal disruption or
thermal processing. The minimum total mass associated with these fragments
likely exceeds $10^{-6}$~\mearth, corresponding to an original rocky body of
$>100$~km in diameter. We discuss the necessity of future observations to help
interpret the system.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.06762 [pdf] - 1327587
Direct imaging of the water snow line at the time of planet formation
using two ALMA continuum bands
Submitted: 2015-11-20
Molecular snow lines in protoplanetary disks have been studied theoretically
for decades because of their importance in shaping planetary architectures and
compositions. The water snow line lies in the planet formation region at < 10
AU, and so far its location has been estimated only indirectly from
spatially-unresolved spectroscopy. This work presents a proof-of-concept method
to directly image the water snow line in protoplanetary disks through its
physical and chemical imprint in the local dust properties. We adopt a physical
disk model that includes dust coagulation, fragmentation, drift, and a change
in fragmentation velocities of a factor 10 between dry silicates and icy grains
as found by laboratory work. We find that the presence of a water snow line
leads to a sharp discontinuity in the radial profile of the dust emission
spectral index {\alpha}_mm, due to replenishment of small grains through
fragmentation. We use the ALMA simulator to demonstrate that this effect can be
observed in protoplanetary disks using spatially-resolved ALMA images in two
continuum bands. We explore the model dependence on the disk viscosity and find
that the spectral index reveals the water snow line for a wide range of
conditions, with opposite trends when the emission is optically thin rather
than thick. If the disk viscosity is low ({\alpha}_visc < 10^-3) the snow line
produces a ring-like structure with a minimum at {\alpha}_mm ~ 2 in the
optically thick regime, possibly similar to what has been measured with ALMA in
the innermost region of the HL Tau disk.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.04756 [pdf] - 1319594
Tracing the Ingredients for a Habitable Earth from Interstellar Space
through Planet Formation
Submitted: 2015-07-16
We use the C/N ratio as a monitor of the delivery of key ingredients of life
to nascent terrestrial worlds. Total elemental C and N contents, and their
ratio, are examined for the interstellar medium, comets, chondritic meteorites
and terrestrial planets; we include an updated estimate for the Bulk Silicate
Earth (C/N = 49.0 +/- 9.3). Using a kinetic model of disk chemistry, and the
sublimation/condensation temperatures of primitive molecules, we suggest that
organic ices and macro-molecular (refractory or carbonaceous dust) organic
material are the likely initial C and N carriers. Chemical reactions in the
disk can produce nebular C/N ratios of ~1-12, comparable to those of comets and
the low end estimated for planetesimals. An increase of the C/N ratio is traced
between volatile-rich pristine bodies and larger volatile-depleted objects
subjected to thermal/accretional metamorphism. The C/N ratios of the dominant
materials accreted to terrestrial planets should therefore be higher than those
seen in carbonaceous chondrites or comets. During planetary formation, we
explore scenarios leading to further volatile loss and associated C/N
variations owing to core formation and atmospheric escape. Key processes
include relative enrichment of nitrogen in the atmosphere and preferential
sequestration of carbon by the core. The high C/N BSE ratio therefore is best
satisfied by accretion of thermally processed objects followed by large-scale
atmospheric loss. These two effects must be more profound if volatile
sequestration in the core is effective. The stochastic nature of these
processes hints that the surface/atmospheric abundances of biosphere-essential
materials will likely be variable.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.03516 [pdf] - 1021961
The snow line in viscous disks around low-mass stars: implications for
water delivery to terrestrial planets in the habitable zone
Submitted: 2015-05-13
The water ice or snow line is one of the key properties of protoplanetary
disks that determines the water content of terrestrial planets in the habitable
zone. Its location is determined by the properties of the star, the mass
accretion rate through the disk, and the size distribution of dust suspended in
the disk. We calculate the snow line location from recent observations of mass
accretion rates and as a function of stellar mass. By taking the observed
dispersion in mass accretion rates as a measure of the dispersion in initial
disk mass, we find that stars of a given mass will exhibit a range of snow line
locations. At a given age and stellar mass, the observed dispersion in mass
accretion rates of 0.4 dex naturally leads to a dispersion in snow line
locations of 0.2 dex. For ISM-like dust sizes, the one-sigma snow line location
among solar mass stars of the same age ranges from 2 to 5 au. For more
realistic dust opacities that include larger grains, the snow line is located
up to two times closer to the star. We use these locations and the outcome of
N-body simulations to predict the amount of water delivered to terrestrial
planets that formed in situ in the habitable zone. We find that the dispersion
in snow line locations leads to a large range in water content. For ISM-like
dust sizes, a significant fraction of habitable-zone terrestrial planets around
sun-like stars remain dry, and no water is delivered to the habitable zones of
low-mass M stars (less than half a solar mass) as in previous works. The
closer-in snow line in disks with larger grains enables water delivery to the
habitable zone for a significant fraction of M stars and all FGK stars.
Considering their larger numbers and higher planet occurrence, M stars may host
most of the water-rich terrestrial planets in the galaxy if these planets are
able to hold on to their water in their subsequent evolution.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.07412 [pdf] - 1231879
Volatile Delivery to Planets from Water-rich Planetesimals around Low
Mass Stars
Submitted: 2015-02-25
Most models of volatile delivery to accreting terrestrial planets assume that
the carriers for water are similar in water content to the carbonaceous
chondrites in our Solar System. Here we suggest that the water content of
primitive bodies in many planetary systems may actually be much higher, as
carbonaceous chondrites have lost some of their original water due to heating
from short-lived radioisotopes that drove parent body alteration. Using N-body
simulations, we explore how planetary accretion would be different if bodies
beyond the water line contained a water mass fraction consistent with chemical
equilibrium calculations, and more similar to comets, as opposed to the more
traditional water-depleted values. We apply this model to consider planet
formation around stars of different masses and identify trends in the
properties of Habitable Zone planets and planetary system architecture which
could be tested by ongoing exoplanet census data collection. Comparison of such
data with the model predicted trends will serve to evaluate how well the N-body
simulations and the initial conditions used in studies of planetary accretion
can be used to understand this stage of planet formation.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.01878 [pdf] - 1223920
Sulfurization of Iron in the Dynamic Solar Nebula and Implications for
Planetary Compositions
Submitted: 2015-01-08
One explanation for the enhanced ratio of volatiles to hydrogen in Jupiter's
atmosphere compared to a a gas of solar composition is that the planet accreted
volatile-bearing clathrates during its formation. Models, however, suggest that
S would be over abundant if clathrates were the primary carrier of Jupiter's
volatiles. This led to the suggestion that S was depleted in the outer nebula
due to the formation troilite (FeS). Here, this depletion is quantitatively
explored by modeling the coupled dynamical and chemical evolution of Fe grains
in the solar nebula. It is found that disks that undergo rapid radial expansion
from an initially compact state may allow sufficient production of FeS and
carry H$_{2}$S-depleted gas outward where ices would form, providing the
conditions needed for S-depleted clathrates to form. However, this expansion
would also carry FeS grains to this region, which could also be incorporated
into planetesimals. Thus for clathrates to be a viable source of volatiles,
models must account for the presence of both H$_{2}$S in FeS in the outer solar
nebula.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.5333 [pdf] - 1203490
The Phases of Water Ice in the Solar Nebula
Submitted: 2014-02-21
Understanding the phases of water ice that were present in the solar nebula
has implications for understanding cometary and planetary compositions as well
as internal evolution of these bodies. Here we show that amorphous ice formed
more readily than previously recognized, with formation at temperatures <70 K
being possible under protoplanetary disk conditions. We further argue that
photodesorption and freeze-out of water molecules near the surface layers of
the solar nebula would have provided the conditions needed for amorphous ice to
form. This processing would be a natural consequence of ice dynamics, and would
allow for the trapping of noble gases and other volatiles in water ice in the
outer solar nebula.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.7549 [pdf] - 717350
The early impact histories of meteorite parent bodies
Submitted: 2013-07-29, last modified: 2013-09-10
We have developed a statistical framework that uses collisional evolution
models, shock physics modeling and scaling laws to determine the range of
plausible collisional histories for individual meteorite parent bodies. It is
likely that those parent bodies that were not catastrophically disrupted
sustained hundreds of impacts on their surfaces - compacting, heating, and
mixing the outer layers; it is highly unlikely that many parent bodies escaped
without any impacts processing the outer few kilometers. The first 10 - 20 Myr
were the most important time for impacts, both in terms of the number of
impacts and the increase of specific internal energy due to impacts. The model
has been applied to evaluate the proposed impact histories of several meteorite
parent bodies: up to 10 parent bodies that were not disrupted in the first 100
Myr experienced a vaporizing collision of the type necessary to produce the
metal inclusions and chondrules on the CB chondrite parent; around 1 - 5% of
bodies that were catastrophically disrupted after 12 Myr sustained impacts at
times that match the heating events recorded on the IAB/winonaite parent body;
more than 75% of 100 km radius parent bodies which survived past 100 Myr
without being disrupted sustained an impact that excavates to the depth
required for mixing in the outer layers of the H chondrite parent body; and to
protect the magnetic field on the CV chondrite parent body, the crust would
have had to have been thick (~ 20 km) in order to prevent it being punctured by
impacts.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.1760 [pdf] - 1150598
Indication of insensitivity of planetary weathering behavior and
habitable zone to surface land fraction
Submitted: 2012-08-08
It is likely that unambiguous habitable zone terrestrial planets of unknown
water content will soon be discovered. Water content helps determine surface
land fraction, which influences planetary weathering behavior. This is
important because the silicate weathering feedback determines the width of the
habitable zone in space and time. Here a low-order model of weathering and
climate, useful for gaining qualitative understanding, is developed to examine
climate evolution for planets of various land-ocean fractions. It is pointed
out that, if seafloor weathering does not depend directly on surface
temperature, there can be no weathering-climate feedback on a waterworld. This
would dramatically narrow the habitable zone of a waterworld. Results from our
model indicate that weathering behavior does not depend strongly on land
fraction for partially ocean-covered planets. This is powerful because it
suggests that previous habitable zone theory is robust to changes in land
fraction, as long as there is some land. Finally, a mechanism is proposed for a
waterworld to prevent complete water loss during a moist greenhouse through
rapid weathering of exposed continents. This process is named a "waterworld
self-arrest," and it implies that waterworlds can go through a moist greenhouse
stage and end up as planets like Earth with partial ocean coverage. This work
stresses the importance of surface and geologic effects, in addition to the
usual incident stellar flux, for habitability.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.3101 [pdf] - 547371
Post-Impact Thermal Evolution of Porous Planetesimals
Submitted: 2012-07-12
Impacts between planetesimals have largely been ruled out as a heat source in
the early Solar System, by calculations that show them to be an inefficient
heat source and unlikely to cause global heating. However, the long-term,
localized thermal effects of impacts on planetesimals have never been fully
quantified. Here, we simulate a range of impact scenarios between planetesimals
to determine the post-impact thermal histories of the parent bodies, and hence
the importance of impact heating in the thermal evolution of planetesimals. We
find on a local scale that heating material to petrologic type 6 is achievable
for a range of impact velocities and initial porosities, and impact melting is
possible in porous material at a velocity of > 4 km/s. Burial of heated
impactor material beneath the impact crater is common, insulating that material
and allowing the parent body to retain the heat for extended periods (~
millions of years). Cooling rates at 773 K are typically 1 - 1000 K/Ma,
matching a wide range of measurements of metallographic cooling rates from
chondritic materials. While the heating presented here is localized to the
impact site, multiple impacts over the lifetime of a parent body are likely to
have occurred. Moreover, as most meteorite samples are on the centimeter to
meter scale, the localized effects of impact heating cannot be ignored.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.4736 [pdf] - 1083594
Residence Times of Particles in Diffusive Protoplanetary Disk
Environments II. Radial Motions and Applications to Dust Annealing
Submitted: 2011-08-23
The origin of crystalline grains in comets and the outer regions of
protoplanetary disks remains a mystery. It has been suggested that such grains
form via annealing of amorphous precursors in the hot, inner region of a
protoplanetary disk, where the temperatures needed for such transformations
were found, and were then transported outward by some dynamical means. Here we
develop a means of tracking the paths that dust grains would have taken through
a diffusive protoplanetary disk and examine the types and ranges of
environments that particles would have seen over a 10$^{6}$ year time period in
the dynamic disk. We then combine this model with three annealing laws to
examine how the dynamic evolution of amorphous grains would have led to their
physical restructuring and their delivery to various regions of the disk. It is
found that "sibling particles"-- those particles that reside at the same
location at a given period of time--take a wide range of unique and independent
paths through the disk to arrive there. While high temperatures can persist in
the disk for very long time periods, we find that those grains which are
delivered to the cold outer regions of the disk are largely annealed in the
first few $\times10^{5}$ yrs of disk history. This suggests that the
crystallinity of grains in the outer disk would be determined early and remain
unchanged for much of disk history, in agreement with recent astronomical
observations.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.2620 [pdf] - 1076610
Heterogeneous distribution of Al-26 at the birth of the Solar System
Submitted: 2011-05-13
It is believed that Al-26, a short-lived (t1/2 = 0.73 Ma) and now extinct
radionuclide, was uniformly distributed in the nascent Solar System with the
initial Al-26/Al-27 ratio of ~5.2\times10-5, suggesting its external stellar
origin. However, the stellar source of Al-26 and the manner in which it was
injected into the solar system remain controversial: the Al-26 could have been
produced by an asymptotic giant branch star, a supernova, or a Wolf-Rayet star
and injected either into the protosolar molecular cloud or protoplanetary disk.
Corundum (Al2O3) is thermodynamically predicted to be the first condensate from
a cooling gas of solar composition. Here we show that micron-sized corundum
condensates from O-16-rich gas (Big Delta O-17 ~ -25%) of solar composition
recorded heterogeneous distribution of Al-26 at the birth of the solar system:
the inferred initial Al-26/Al-27 ratio ranges from ~6.5x10-5 to <2x10-6; ~50%
of the corundum grains measured are Al-26-poor. Other Al-26-poor, O-16-rich
refractory objects include grossite (CaAl4O7)- and hibonite(CaAl12O19)-rich
calcium-aluminum-rich inclusions (CAIs) in CH chondrites, platy hibonite
crystals in CM chondrites, and FUN (fractionation and unidentified nuclear
isotopic anomalies) CAIs in CV, CO, and CR chondrites. Considering the
apparently early and short duration (<0.3 Ma) of condensation of refractory
O-16-rich solids in the solar system, we infer that Al-26 was injected into the
collapsing protosolar molecular cloud and later homogenized in the
protoplanetary disk. The apparent lack of correlation between Al-26 abundance
and O-isotope compositions of corundum grains put important constraints on the
stellar source of Al-26 in the solar system.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1010.1579 [pdf] - 1041153
Residence Times of Particles in Diffusive Protoplanetary Disk
Environments I. Vertical Motions
Submitted: 2010-10-07
The chemical and physical evolution of primitive materials in protoplanetary
disks are determined by the types of environments they are exposed to and their
residence times within each environment. Here a method for calculating
representative paths of materials in diffusive protoplanetary disks is
developed and applied to understanding how the vertical trajectories that
particles take impact their overall evolution. The methods are general enough
to be applied to disks with uniform diffusivity, the so-called
"constant-$\alpha$" cases, and disks with a spatially varying diffusivity, such
as expected in "layered-disks." The average long-term dynamical evolution of
small particles and gaseous molecules is independent of the specific form of
the diffusivity in that they spend comparable fractions of their lifetimes at
different heights in the disk. However, the paths that individual particles and
molecules take depend strongly on the form of the diffusivity leading to a
different range of behavior of particles in terms of deviations from the mean.
As temperatures, gas densities, chemical abundances, and photon fluxes will
vary with height in protoplanetary disks, the different paths taken by
primitive materials will lead to differences in their chemical and physical
evolution. Examples of differences in gas phase chemistry and photochemistry
are explored here. The methods outlined here provide a means of integrating
particle dynamics with chemical models to understand the formation and
evolution of primitive materials in protoplanetary disks over timescales of
$10^5$-$10^6$ years.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.3916 [pdf] - 19718
Two-Dimensional Transport of Solids in Viscous Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2008-12-19, last modified: 2009-01-05
Large-scale radial transport of solids appears to be a fundamental
consequence of protoplanetary disk evolution based on the presence of high
temperature minerals in comets and the outer regions of protoplanetary disks
around other stars. Further, inward transport of solids from the outer regions
of the solar nebula has been postulated to be the manner in which short-lived
radionuclides were introduced to the terrestrial planet region and the cause of
the variations in oxygen isotope ratios seen in primitive materials. Here, both
outward and inward transport of solids are investigated in the context of a
two-dimensional, viscously evolving protoplanetary disk. The dynamics of solids
are investigated to determine how they depend on particle size and the
particular stage of protoplanetary disk evolution, corresponding to different
rates of mass transport. It is found that the outward flows that arise around
the disk midplane of a protoplanetary disk aid in the outward transport of
solids up to the size of CAIs and can increase the crystallinity fraction of
silicate dust at 10 AU around a solar mass star to as much as $\sim$40% in the
case of rapidly evolving disks, decreasing as the accretion rate onto the star
slows. High velocity, inward flows along the disk surface aid in the rapid
transport of solids from the outer disk to the inner disk, particularly for
small dust. Despite the diffusion that occurs throughout the disk, the
large-scale, meridonal flows associated with mass transport prevent complete
homogenization of the disk, allowing compositional gradients to develop that
vary in intensity for a timescale of one million years.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:0809.5051 [pdf] - 16859
Cooling of Dense Gas by H2O Line Emission and an Assessment of its
Effects in Chondrule-Forming Shocks
Submitted: 2008-09-29
We consider gas at densities appropriate to protoplanetary disks and
calculate its ability to cool due to line radiation emitted by H2O molecules
within the gas. Our work follows that of Neufeld & Kaufman (1993; ApJ, 418,
263), expanding on their work in several key aspects, including use of a much
expanded line database, an improved escape probability formulism, and the
inclusion of dust grains, which can absorb line photons. Although the escape
probabilities formally depend on a complicated combination of optical depth in
the lines and in the dust grains, we show that the cooling rate including dust
is well approximated by the dust-free cooling rate multiplied by a simple
function of the dust optical depth. We apply the resultant cooling rate of a
dust-gas mixture to the case of a solar nebula shock pertinent to the formation
of chondrules, millimeter-sized melt droplets found in meteorites. Our aim is
to assess whether line cooling can be neglected in chondrule-forming shocks or
if it must be included. We find that for typical parameters, H2O line cooling
shuts off a few minutes past the shock front; line photons that might otherwise
escape the shocked region and cool the gas will be absorbed by dust grains.
During the first minute or so past the shock, however, line photons will cool
the gas at rates ~ 10,000 K/hr, dropping the temperature of the gas (and most
likely the chondrules within the gas) by several hundred K. Inclusion of H2O
line cooling therefore must be included in models of chondrule formation by
nebular shocks.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702032 [pdf] - 1234087
Radial Transport in the Solar Nebula: Implications for Moderately
Volatile Element Depletions in Chondritic Meteorites
Submitted: 2007-02-01
In this paper, the possibility that the moderately volatile element
depletions observed in chondritic meteorites are the results of planetesimals
accreting in a solar nebula that cooled from an initially hot state
(temperatures > 1350 K out to ~2-4 AU) is explored. A model is developed to
track the chemical inventory of planetesimals that accrete in a viscously
evolving protoplanetary disk, accounting for the redistribution of solids and
vapor by advection, diffusion, and gas drag. It is found that depletion trends
similar to those observed in the chondritic meteorites can be reproduced for a
small range of model parameters. However, the necessary range of parameters is
inconsistent with observations of disks around young stars and other
constraints on meteorite parent body formation. Thus, counter to previous work,
it is concluded that the global scale evolution of the solar nebula is not the
cause for the observed depletion trends.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0611811 [pdf] - 87197
Dust Coagulation and Settling in Layered Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2006-11-27
Previous models of dust growth in protoplanetary disks considered either
uniformly laminar or turbulent disks. This Letter explores how dust growth
occurs in a layered protoplanetary disk in which the magnetorotational
instability generates turbulence only in the surface layers of a disk. Two
cases are considered: a completely laminar dead zone and a dead zone in which
turbulence is ``stirred up'' from the MRI acting above. It is found that dust
is depleted from high altitudes in layered disks faster than in those cases of
a uniformly laminar or turblent disks. This is a result of the accelerated
growth of particles in the turbulent regions and their storage in the lower
levels where they escape energetic collisions which would result in disruption.
Thus the regions of a protoplanetary disk above a dead zone would become
rapidly depleted in small dust grains, whereas the outer regions, where the MRI
is active throughout, will maintain a small dust poplulation at all heights due
to the disruptive collisions and vertical mixing from turbulence. This
structure is similar to that which has been inferred for disks around TW Hydra,
GM Auriga, and CoKu Tau/4, which are depleted in dust close to the star, but
are optically thick at larger heliocentric distances.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511372 [pdf] - 77730
The Evolution of the Water Distribution in a Viscous Protoplanetary Disk
Submitted: 2005-11-11
(Abridged) Astronomical observations have shown that protoplanetary disks are
dynamic objects through which mass is transported and accreted by the central
star. Age dating of meteorite constituents shows that their creation,
evolution, and accumulation occupied several Myr, and over this time disk
properties would evolve significantly. Moreover, on this timescale, solid
particles decouple from the gas in the disk and their evolution follows a
different path. Here we present a model which tracks how the distribution of
water changes in an evolving disk as the water-bearing species experience
condensation, accretion, transport, collisional destruction, and vaporization.
Because solids are transported in a disk at different rates depending on their
sizes, the motions will lead to water being concentrated in some regions of a
disk and depleted in others. These enhancements and depletions are consistent
with the conditions needed to explain some aspects of the chemistry of
chondritic meteorites and formation of giant planets. The levels of
concentration and depletion, as well as their locations, depend strongly on the
combined effects of the gaseous disk evolution, the formation of rapidly
migrating rubble, and the growth of immobile planetesimals. We present examples
of evolution under a range of plausible assumptions and demonstrate how the
chemical evolution of the inner region of a protoplanetary disk is intimately
connected to the physical processes which occur in the outer regions.