Normalized to: Ciambur, B.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.00015 [pdf] - 2057065
Double X/Peanut Structures in Barred Galaxies -- Insights from an
$N$--body Simulation
Submitted: 2020-02-28
Boxy, peanut- or X-shaped "bulges" are observed in a large fraction of barred
galaxies viewed in, or close to, edge-on projection, as well as in the Milky
Way. They are the product of dynamical instabilities occurring in stellar bars,
which cause the latter to buckle and thicken vertically. Recent studies have
found nearby galaxies that harbour two such features arising at different
radial scales, in a nested configuration. In this paper we explore the
formation of such double peanuts, using a collisionless N-body simulation of a
pure disc evolving in isolation within a live dark matter halo, which we
analyse in a completely analogous way to observations of real galaxies. In the
simulation we find a stable double configuration consisting of two X/peanut
structures associated to the same galactic bar - rotating with the same pattern
speed - but with different morphology, formation time, and evolution. The
inner, conventional peanut-shaped structure forms early via the buckling of the
bar, and experiences little evolution once it stabilises. This feature is
consistent in terms of size, strength and morphology, with peanut structures
observed in nearby galaxies. The outer structure, however, displays a strong X,
or "bow-tie", morphology. It forms just after the inner peanut, and gradually
extends in time (within 1 to 1.5 Gyr) to almost the end of the bar, a radial
scale where ansae occur. We conclude that, although both structures form, and
are dynamically coupled to, the same bar, they are supported by inherently
different mechanisms.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.00777 [pdf] - 1924954
The disc origin of the Milky Way bulge: On the necessity of the thick
disc
Submitted: 2019-01-03
In the MW bulge, metal-rich stars form a strong bar and are more
peanut-shaped than metal-poor stars. It has been recently claimed that this
behavior is driven by the initial in-plane radial velocity dispersion of these
populations, rather than by their initial vertical random motions. This has led
to the suggestion that a thick disc is not necessary to explain the
characteristics of the MW bulge. We rediscuss this issue by analyzing two
dissipationless N-body simulations of boxy/peanut (b/p)-shaped bulges formed
from composite stellar discs, made of kinematically cold and hot stellar
populations, and we conclude that initial vertical random motions are as
important as in-plane random motions in determining the relative contribution
of cold and hot disc populations with height above the plane, the metallicity
and age trends. Previous statements emphasizing the dominant role of in-plane
motions in determining these trends are not confirmed. However, differences
exist in the morphology and strength of the resulting b/p-shaped bulges: a
model where disc populations have initially only different in-plane random
motions, but similar thickness, results into a b/p bulge where all populations
have a similar peanut shape, independently on their initial kinematics, or
metallicity. We discuss the reasons behind these differences, and also predict
the signatures that these two extreme initial conditions would leave on the
vertical age and metallicity gradients of disc stars, outside the bulge region.
We conclude that a metal-poor, kinematically (radial and vertical) hot
component, that is a thick disc, is necessary in the MW before bar formation,
supporting the scenario traced in previous works. [abridged]
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.00570 [pdf] - 1712904
Evolution of the anti-truncated stellar profiles of S0 galaxies since
$z=0.6$ in the SHARDS survey: II - Structural and photometric evolution
Borlaff, Alejandro;
Eliche-Moral, M. Carmen;
Beckman, John E.;
Vazdekis, Alexandre;
Lumbreras-Calle, Alejandro;
Ciambur, Bogdan C.;
Pérez-González, Pablo G.;
Cardiel, Nicolás;
Barro, Guillermo;
Cava, Antonio
Submitted: 2018-03-01, last modified: 2018-03-19
Type-III S0 galaxies present tight scaling relations between their surface
brightness photometric and structural parameters. Several evolutionary models
have been proposed for the formation of Type-III S0 galaxies but the
observations of are usually limited to the local Universe.
We study the evolution of the photometric and structural scaling relations
found between the parameters of the surface brightness profiles in the
rest-frame R-band of Type-III S0 galaxies with z and the possible differences
between the rest-frame (B-R) colours of the inner and outer disc profiles.
We make use of a sample of 14 Type-III E/S0--S0 galaxies at 0.2<z<0.6 to
study if the correlations found in local Type-III S0 galaxies were present ~6
Gyr ago. We analyse the distribution of the surface brightness characteristic
parameters as a function of the stellar mass and if there is a significant
change with z. We also derive their rest-frame (B-R) colour profiles and we
compare these results with the predictions from a grid of SSP models.
We find that the inner and outer scale-lengths of Type-III S0 galaxies at
0.4<z<0.6 follow compatible trends and scaling relations with those observed in
local S0 galaxies. We do not detect any significant differences between the
location of Rbreak between z~0.6 and z=0 for a fixed stellar mass of the
object, whereas the surface brightness at the break radius is ~1.5 mag arcsec-2
dimmer in the local Universe than at z~0.6 for a fixed stellar mass.
In contrast to Type-II profiles, the Type-III surface brightness profiles of
S0 galaxies present compatible Rbreak values and scaling relations during the
last 6 Gyr. This result and the similarity of the colours of the inner and
outer discs point to a highly scalable and stable formation process, probably
more related to gravitational and dynamical processes than to the evolution of
stellar populations (abridged).
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.09902 [pdf] - 1585331
Quantifying the (X/peanut)-shaped Structure of the Milky Way - New
Constraints on the Bar Geometry
Submitted: 2017-06-29
The nature, size and orientation of the dominant structural components in the
Milky Way's inner ~4 kpc - specifically the bulge and bar - have been the
subject of conflicting interpretations in the literature. We present a
different approach to inferring the properties of the long bar which extends
beyond the inner bulge, via the information encoded in the Galaxy's X/peanut
(X/P)-shaped structure. We perform a quantitative analysis of the X/P feature
seen in WISE wide-field imaging at 3.4 $\mu$m and 4.6 $\mu$m. We measure the
deviations of the isophotes from pure ellipses, and quantify the X/P structure
via the radial profile of the Fourier n=6 harmonic (cosine term $B_6$). In
addition to the vertical height and integrated `strength' of the X/P
instability, we report an intrinsic radius of $R_{\Pi;{\rm int}} = 1.67\pm0.27$
kpc, and an orientation angle of $\alpha = {37^\circ}^{+7^\circ}_{-10^\circ}$
with respect to our line-of-sight to the Galactic Centre. Based on X/P
structures observed in other galaxies, we make three assumptions: (i) the
peanut is intrinsically symmetric, (ii) the peanut is aligned with the long
Galactic bar, and (iii) their sizes are correlated. Thus the implication for
the Galactic bar is that it is oriented at the same $37^\circ$ angle and has an
expected radius of ~4.2 kpc, but possibly as low as ~3.2 kpc. We further
investigate how the Milky Way's X/P structure compares with other analogues,
and find that the Galaxy is broadly consistent with our recently established
scaling relations, though with a moderately stronger peanut instability than
expected. We additionally perform a photometric decomposition of the Milky
Way's major axis surface brightness profile, accounting for spiral structure,
and determine an average disc scale length of $h = 2.54\pm0.16$ kpc in the WISE
bands, in good agreement with the literature.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.05850 [pdf] - 1583495
Evolution of the anti-truncated stellar profiles of S0 galaxies since
$z=0.6$ in the SHARDS survey: I - Sample and Methods
Submitted: 2017-05-16
The controversy about the origin of the structure of S0--E/S0 galaxies may be
due to the difficulty of comparing surface brightness profiles with different
depths, photometric corrections and PSF effects (almost always ignored). We aim
to quantify the properties of Type-III (anti-truncated) discs in a sample of S0
galaxies at 0.2<z<0.6. In this paper, we present the sample selection and
describe in detail the methods to robustly trace the structure in their
outskirts and correct for PSF effects. We have selected and classified a sample
of 150 quiescent galaxies at 0.2<z<0.6 in the GOODS-N field. We perform a
quantitative structural analysis of 44 S0-E/S0 galaxies. We corrected their
surface brightness profiles for PSF distortions and analysed the biases in the
structural and photometric parameters when the PSF correction is not applied.
Additionally, we have developed Elbow, an automatic statistical method to
determine whether a possible break is significant - or not - and its type and
made it publicly available. We found 14 anti-truncated S0-E/S0 galaxies in the
range 0.2<z<0.6 (~30% of the final sample). This fraction is similar to the
those reported in the local Universe. In our sample, ~25% of the Type-III
breaks observed in PSF-uncorrected profiles are artifacts, and their profiles
turn into a Type I after PSF correction. PSF effects also soften Type-II
profiles. We found that the profiles of Type-I S0 and E/S0 galaxies of our
sample are compatible with the inner profiles of the Type-III, in contrast with
the outer profiles. We have obtained the first robust and reliable sample of 14
anti-truncated S0--E/S0 galaxies beyond the local Universe, in the range
0.2<z<0.6. PSF effects significantly affect the shape of the surface brightness
profiles in galaxy discs even in the case of the narrow PSF of HST/ACS images,
so future studies on the subject should make an effort to correct them.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.03587 [pdf] - 1583282
Implications for the origin of dwarf early-type galaxies: a detailed
look at the isolated rotating dwarf early-type galaxy CG 611, with
ramifications for the Fundamental Plane's (S_K)^2 kinematic scaling and the
spin-ellipticity diagram
Submitted: 2017-05-09
Selected from a sample of nine, isolated, dwarf early-type galaxies (ETGs)
having the same range of kinematic properties as dwarf ETGs in clusters, we use
CG 611 (LEDA 2108986) to address the Nature versus Nurture debate regarding the
formation of dwarf ETGs. The presence of faint disk structures and rotation
within some cluster dwarf ETGs has often been heralded as evidence that they
were once late-type spiral or dwarf irregular galaxies prior to experiencing a
cluster-induced transformation into an ETG. However, CG 611 also contains
significant stellar rotation (~20 km/s) over its inner half light radius,
R_(e,maj)=0.71 kpc, and its stellar structure and kinematics resemble those of
cluster ETGs. In addition to hosting a faint young nuclear spiral within a
possible intermediate-scale stellar disk, CG 611 has accreted an
intermediate-scale, counter-rotating gas disk. It is therefore apparent that
dwarf ETGs can be built by accretion events, as opposed to disk-stripping
scenarios. We go on to discuss how both dwarf and ordinary ETGs with
intermediate-scale disks, whether under (de)construction or not, are not fully
represented by the kinematic scaling S_0.5=sqrt{ 0.5(V_rot)^2 + sigma^2 }, and
we also introduce a modified spin-ellipticity diagram, lambda(R)-epsilon(R),
with the potential to track galaxies with such disks.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.04434 [pdf] - 1582565
Understanding the environment around the intermediate mass black hole
candidate ESO 243-49 HLX-1
Webb, N. A.;
Guérou, A.;
Ciambur, B.;
Detoeuf, A.;
Coriat, M.;
Godet, O.;
Barret, D.;
Combes, F.;
Contini, T.;
Graham, Alister W.;
Maccarone, T. J.;
Mrkalj, M.;
Servillat, M.;
Schroetter, I.;
Wiersema, K.
Submitted: 2017-04-14
Aims. ESO 243-49 HLX-1, otherwise known as HLX-1, is an intermediate mass
black hole (IMBH) candidate located 8" (3.7 Kpc) from the centre of the edge-on
S0 galaxy ESO 243-49. How the black hole came to be associated with this
galaxy, and the nature of the environment in which it resides, are still
unclear. Using multi-wavelength observations we investigate the nature of the
medium surrounding HLX-1, search for evidence of past mergers with ESO 243-49
and constrain parameters of the galaxy. Methods. We reduce and analyse integral
field unit observations of ESO 243-49 that were taken with the MUSE instrument
on the VLT. Using complementary multi-wavelength data, including X-Shooter,
HST, Swift, Chandra and ATCA data, we further examine the vicinity of HLX-1. We
additionally examine the nature of the host galaxy and estimate the mass of the
central supermassive black hole (SMBH) in ESO 243-49. Results. No evidence for
a recent minor-merger that could result in the presence of the IMBH is
discerned, but the data are compatible with a scenario in which minor mergers
may have occurred in the history of ESO 243-49. The MUSE data reveal a rapidly
rotating disc in the centre of the galaxy, around the SMBH. The mass of the
SMBH at the centre of ESO 243-49 is estimated to be 0.5-23 $\times$ 10$^7$
M$_\odot$. Studying the spectra of HLX-1, that were taken in the low/hard
state, we determine H$_\alpha$ flux variability to be at least a factor 6,
compared to observations taken during the high/soft state. This H$_\alpha$ flux
variability over one year indicates that the line originates close to the IMBH,
excluding the possibility that the line emanates from a surrounding nebula or a
star cluster. The large variability associated with the X-ray states of HLX-1
confirms that the H$_\alpha$ line is associated with the object and therefore
validates the distance to HLX-1.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.06794 [pdf] - 1567630
Searching for Intermediate Mass Black Holes in galaxies with Low
Luminosity AGN: A multiple-method approach
Koliopanos, Filippos;
Ciambur, Bogdan C.;
Graham, Alister W.;
Webb, Natalie A.;
Coriat, Mickael;
Mutlu-Pakdil, Burcin;
Davis, Benjamin L.;
Godet, Olivier;
Barret, Didier;
Seigar, Marc S.
Submitted: 2016-12-20, last modified: 2017-01-09
Aims: This work is the first stage of a campaign to search for IMBHs, in low
luminosity AGN (LLAGN) and dwarf galaxies. An additional, and equally
important, aim of this pilot study is to investigate the consistency between
the predictions of several BH scaling relations and the fundamental plane of
black hole activity (FP-BH). Methods: We use X-ray and radio luminosity
relations in accreting BHs, along with the latest scaling relations between the
mass of the central black hole (MBH) and the properties of its host spheroid,
to predict MBH in seven LLAGN, that were previously reported to be in the IMBH
regime. Namely, we use the recently re-evaluated MBH - Msph (Msph : spheroid
absolute magnitude at 3.6 microm) scaling relation for spiral galaxies, the MBH
- nsph (nsph : major axis Sersic index of the bulge) relation, the MBH - PA
(PA: pitch angle) relation and the FP-BH for weakly accreting BHs, to
independently estimate MBH in all seven galaxies. Results: We find that all
LLAGN in our list have low-mass central black holes - with log MBH/Msol~6.5 on
average - but they are, not IMBHs. All 4 methods used predicted consistent BH
masses, in the 1sigma range. Furthermore, we report that, in contrast to
previous classification, galaxy NGC 4470 is bulge-less, and cast doubts on the
AGN classification of NGC 3507. Conclusions: We find that our latest,
state-of-the-art techniques for bulge magnitude & Sersic index computations and
the most recent updates of the MBH - Lsph, MBH - nsph , MBH - PA relations and
the FP-BH produce consistent results in the low mass regime. We establish a
multiple method approach for predicting BH masses in the regime where their
spheres-of- grav. influence cannot be spatially resolved. Our approach
mitigates against outliers from any one relation and provides a more robust
average prediction. We will use our new method to revisit more IMBH candidates
in LLAGN
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.00711 [pdf] - 1510307
Disky elliptical galaxies and the allegedly over-massive black hole in
the compact massive `ES' galaxy NGC 1271
Submitted: 2016-08-02, last modified: 2016-09-13
While spiral and lenticular galaxies have large-scale disks extending beyond
their bulges, and most local early-type galaxies with 10^{10} < M_*/M_Sun <
2x10^{11} contain a disk (e.g., ATLAS^3D), the early-type galaxies do possess a
range of disk sizes. The edge-on, `intermediate-scale' disk in the `disky
elliptical' galaxy NGC 1271 has led to some uncertainty as to what its
spheroidal component is. Walsh et al. reported a directly measured black hole
mass of 3x10^9 M_Sun for this galaxy; which they remarked was an order of
magnitude greater than what they expected based on their derivation of the host
spheroid's luminosity. Our near-infrared image analysis supports a small
embedded disk within a massive spheroidal component with M_{sph,*} =
(0.9+/-0.2)x10^{11} M_Sun (using M_*/L_H = 1.4 from Walsh et al.). This places
NGC 1271 just 1.6-sigma above the near-linear M_bh-M_{sph,*} relation for
early-type galaxies. Therefore, past speculation that there may be a systematic
difference in the black hole scaling relations between compact massive
early-type galaxies with intermediate-scale disks, i.e. ES galaxies such as NGC
1271, and early-type galaxies with either no substantial disk (E) or a
large-scale disk (S0) is not strongly supported by NGC 1271. We additionally
(i) show how ES galaxies fit naturally in the (`bulge'-to-total)-(morphological
type) diagram, while noting a complication with recent revisions to the
Hubble-Jeans tuning-fork diagram, (ii) caution about claims of over-massive
black holes in other ES galaxies if incorrectly modelled as S0 galaxies, and
(iii) reveal that the compact massive spheroid in NGC 1271 has properties
similar to bright bulges in other galaxies which have grown larger-scale disks.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.08620 [pdf] - 1580101
$Profiler$ - A Fast and Versatile New Program for Decomposing Galaxy
Light Profiles
Submitted: 2016-07-28
I introduce $Profiler$, a new, user-friendly program written in $Python$ and
designed to analyse the radial surface brightness profiles of galaxies. With an
intuitive graphical user interface, $Profiler$ can accurately model a wide
range of galaxies and galaxy components, such as elliptical galaxies, the
bulges of spiral and lenticular galaxies, nuclear sources, discs, bars, rings,
spiral arms, etc., with a variety of parametric functions routinely employed in
the field (S\'ersic, core-S\'ersic, exponential, Gaussian, Moffat and Ferrers).
In addition to these, $Profiler$ can employ the broken exponential model
(relevant for disc truncations or antitruncations) and two special cases of the
edge-on disc model: namely along the major axis (in the disc plane) and along
the minor axis (perpendicular to the disc plane). $Profiler$ is optimised to
work with galaxy light profiles obtained from isophotal measurements which
capture radial gradients in the ellipticity, position angle and Fourier
harmonic profiles of the isophotes, and are thus often better at capturing the
total light than two-dimensional image-fitting programs. Additionally, the
one-dimensional approach is generally less computationally expensive and more
stable. In $Profiler$, the convolution of either circular or elliptical models
with the point spread function is performed in two-dimensions, and offers a
choice between Gaussian, Moffat or a user-provided data vector (a table of
intensity values as a function of radius) for the point spread function. I
demonstrate $Profiler$'s features and operation by decomposing three case-study
galaxies: the cored elliptical galaxy NGC 3348, the nucleated dwarf Seyfert I
galaxy Pox 52, and NGC 2549, a structurally complex, double-barred galaxy which
also displays a Type II truncated disc viewed edge-on. $Profiler$ is freely
available at: https://github.com/BogdanCiambur/PROFILER
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.00019 [pdf] - 1392888
Quantifying the (X/Peanut)-Shaped Structure in Edge-on Disc Galaxies:
Length, Strength, and Nested Peanuts
Submitted: 2016-02-29, last modified: 2016-04-03
X-shaped or peanut-shaped (X/P) bulges are observed in more than 40% of
(nearly) edge-on disc galaxies, though to date a robust method to quantify them
is lacking. Using Fourier harmonics to describe the deviation of galaxy
isophotes from ellipses, we demonstrate with a sample of 11 such galaxies
(including NGC 128) that the sixth Fourier component ($B_6$) carries physical
meaning by tracing this X/P structure. We introduce five quantitative
diagnostics based on the radial $B_6$ profile, namely: its `peak' amplitude
($\Pi_{\rm max}$); the (projected major-axis) `length' where this peak occurs
($R_{\Pi,max}$); its vertical `height' above the disc plane ($z_{\Pi,max}$);
the $B_6$ profile's integrated `strength' ($S_{\Pi}$); and the $B_6$ peak
`width' ($W_{\Pi}$). We also introduce different `classes' of $B_6$ profile
shape. Furthermore, we convincingly detect and measure the properties of
multiple (nested) X/P structures in individual galaxies which additionally
display the signatures of multiple bars in their surface brightness profiles,
thus consolidating further the scenario in which peanuts are associated with
bars. We reveal that the peanut parameter space (`length', `strength' and
`height') for real galaxies is not randomly populated, but the 3 metrics are
inter-correlated (both in kpc and disc scale-length $h$). Additionally, the X/P
`length' and `strength' appear to correlate with $v_{rot}/\sigma_*$, lending
further support to the notion that peanuts `know' about the galactic disc in
which they reside. Such constraints are important for simulations, as they
provide a direct link between peanuts and their host disc. Our diagnostics
reveal a spectrum of X/P properties and could provide a means of distinguishing
between different peanut formation scenarios. Moreover, nested peanuts, as
remnants of bar buckling events, can provide insights into the disc and bar
instability history.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.00991 [pdf] - 1370279
Does the intermediate mass black hole in LEDA 87300 (RGG 118) follow the
near-quadratic (M_bh)-(M_spheroid) relation?
Submitted: 2015-12-03, last modified: 2016-01-15
The mass scaling relation between supermassive black holes and their host
spheroids has previously been described by a quadratic or steeper relation at
low masses (10^5 < M_bh/M_sun < 10^7). How this extends into the realm of
intermediate mass black holes (10^2 < M_bh/M_sun < 10^5) is not yet clear,
although for the barred Sm galaxy LEDA 87300, Baldassare et al. have recently
reported a nominal virial mass M_bh=5x10^4 M_sun residing in a `spheroid' of
stellar mass equal to 6.3x10^8 M_sun. We point out, for the first time, that
LEDA 87300 therefore appears to reside on the near-quadratic M_bh-M_{sph,*}
relation. However, Baldassare et al. modelled the bulge _and_ bar as the single
spheroidal component of this galaxy. Here we perform a 3-component
bulge+bar+disk decomposition and find a bulge luminosity which is 7.7 times
fainter than the published `bulge' luminosity. After correcting for dust we
find that M_bulge=0.9x10^8 M_sun, and M_bulge/M_disk=0.04 - which is now in
accord with ratios typically found in Scd-Sm galaxies. We go on to discuss
slight revisions to the stellar velocity dispersion (40+/-11 km/s) and black
hole mass (M_bh=2.9x10^4 M_sun) and show that LEDA 87300 remains consistent
with both the M_bh-sigma relation and the near-quadratic M_bh-M_{sph,*}
relation when using the reduced bulge mass. LEDA 87300 therefore offers the
first support for the rapid but regulated (near-quadratic) growth of black
holes, relative to their host bulge/spheroid, extending into the domain of
intermediate mass black holes.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.02691 [pdf] - 1280920
Beyond Ellipse(s): Accurately Modelling the Isophotal Structure of
Galaxies with $Isofit$ and $Cmodel$
Submitted: 2015-07-09
This work introduces a new fitting formalism for isophotes which enables more
accurate modelling of galaxies with non-elliptical shapes, such as disk
galaxies viewed edge-on or galaxies with X-shaped/peanut bulges. Within this
scheme, the angular parameter which defines quasi-elliptical isophotes is
transformed from the commonly used, but inappropriate, polar co-ordinate to the
`eccentric anomaly'. This provides a superior description of deviations from
ellipticity, better capturing the true isophotal shape. Furthermore, this makes
it possible to accurately recover both the surface brightness profile, using
the correct azimuthally-averaged isophote, and the two-dimensional model of any
galaxy: the hitherto ubiquitous, but artificial, cross-like features in
residual images are completely removed. The formalism has been implemented into
the IRAF tasks $Ellipse$ and $Bmodel$ to create the new tasks `$Isofit$', and
`$Cmodel$'. The new tools are demonstrated here with application to five
galaxies, chosen to be representative case-studies for several areas where this
technique makes it possible to gain new scientific insight. Specifically:
properly quantifying boxy/disky isophotes via the fourth harmonic order in
edge-on galaxies, quantifying X-shaped/peanut bulges, higher-order Fourier
moments for modelling bars in disks, and complex isophote shapes. Higher order
(n > 4) harmonics now become meaningful and may correlate with structural
properties, as boxyness/diskyness is known to do. This work also illustrates
how the accurate construction, and subtraction, of a model from a galaxy image
facilitates the identification and recovery of over-lapping sources such as
globular clusters and the optical counterparts of X-ray sources.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.5025 [pdf] - 1159190
On the Evolution of the Bi-Modal Distribution of Galaxies in the Plane
of Specific Star Formation Rate versus Stellar Mass
Submitted: 2013-01-21
We have compared the observed distribution of galaxies in the plane of
specific star formation rate versus stellar mass with the predictions of the
Garching semi-analytic model at redshifts 0, 1 and 2. The goal is to test
whether the implementation of radio mode AGN feedback, which is responsible for
terminating the formation of stars in high mass galaxies, provides an adequate
match to current high-redshift observations. The fraction of quenched galaxies
as a function of stellar mass in the models is in good agreement with data at
z=0 and z=1. By z=2, there are too few quenched galaxies with low stellar
masses in the models. At z=2, the population of galaxies with no ongoing star
formation is clearly separated from the `main sequence' of star-forming
galaxies in the data. This is not found in the models, because z=2 galaxies
with stellar masses less than 10^11 solar masses are predicted to host black
holes with relatively low masses (less than 10^8 solar masses). The current
implementation of radio mode feedback from such black holes reduces the cooling
rates from the surrounding halo, but does not generate sufficient energy to
stop star formation entirely. We suggest that the models may be brought into
better agreement with the data if black hole growth is triggered by disc
instabilities in addition to major mergers, and if feedback mechanisms
associated with the formation of galactic bulges act to quench star formation
in galaxies.