Numerous theories extending beyond the standard model of particle physics predict the existence of spin-0 bosons that could constitute the dark matter (DM) permeating the universe. In the standard halo model of galactic dark matter the velocity distribution of the bosonic DM field defines a characteristic coherence time $\tau_c$. Until recently, laboratory experiments searching for bosonic DM fields have been in the regime where the measurement time $T$ significantly exceeds $\tau_c$, so null results have been interpreted as constraints on the coupling of bosonic DM to standard model particles with a bosonic DM field amplitude $\Phi_0$ fixed by the average local DM density. However, motivated by new theoretical developments, a number of recent searches probe the regime where $T\ll\tau_c$. Here we show that experiments operating in this regime do not sample the full distribution of bosonic DM field amplitudes so results cannot assume a fixed value of $\Phi_0$. Instead, in order to interpret laboratory measurements (even in the event of a discovery), it is necessary to account for the stochastic nature of such a virialized ultralight field (VULF). Re-examining previous null experiments in the context of stochastic DM fluctuations shows that at least seven published constraints are overestimated by roughly one order of magnitude.