Normalized to: Campbell-Brown, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.08576 [pdf] - 2114399
Activity of the Eta-Aquariid and Orionid meteor showers
Submitted: 2020-06-15
We present a multi-instrumental, multidecadal analysis of the activity of the
Eta-Aquariid and Orionid meteor showers for the purpose of constraining models
of 1P/Halley's meteoroid streams. The interannual variability of the showers'
peak activity and period of duration is investigated through the compilation of
published visual and radar observations prior to 1985 and more recent
measurements reported in the International Meteor Organization (IMO) Visual
Meteor DataBase, by the IMO Video Meteor Network and by the Canadian Meteor
Orbit Radar (CMOR). These techniques probe the range of meteoroid masses from
submilligrams to grams. The Eta-Aquariids and Orionids activity duration,
shape, maximum zenithal hourly rates (ZHR) values, and the solar longitude of
annual peaks since 1985 are analyzed. When available, annual activity profiles
recorded by each detection network were measured and are compared. Observations
from the three detection methods show generally good agreement in the showers'
shape, activity levels, and annual intensity variations. Both showers display
several activity peaks of variable location and strength with time. The
Eta-Aquariids are usually two to three times stronger than the Orionids, but
the two showers display occasional outbursts with peaks two to four times their
usual activity level. CMOR observations since 2002 seem to support the
existence of an ~12 year cycle in Orionids activity variations; however,
additional and longer term radar and optical observations of the shower are
required to confirm such periodicity.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.02979 [pdf] - 2082333
Estimating trajectories of meteors: an observational Monte Carlo
approach -- I. Theory
Submitted: 2019-11-07, last modified: 2020-04-21
It has recently been shown by Egal et al. (2017) that some types of existing
meteor in-atmosphere trajectory estimation methods may be less accurate than
others, particularly when applied to high precision optical measurements. The
comparative performance of trajectory solution methods has previously only been
examined for a small number of cases. Besides the radiant, orbital accuracy
depends on the estimation of pre-atmosphere velocities, which have both random
and systematic biases. Thus it is critical to understand the uncertainty in
velocity measurement inherent to each trajectory estimation method.
In this first of a series of two papers, we introduce a novel meteor
trajectory estimation method which uses the observed dynamics of meteors across
stations as a global optimization function and which does not require either a
theoretical or empirical flight model to solve for velocity. We also develop a
3D observational meteor trajectory simulator that uses a meteor ablation model
to replicate the dynamics of meteoroid flight, as a means to validate different
trajectory solvers.
We both test this new method and compare it to other methods, using synthetic
meteors from three major showers spanning a wide range of velocities and
geometries (Draconids, Geminids, Perseids). We determine which meteor
trajectory solving algorithm performs better for: all-sky, moderate field of
view, and high-precision narrow-field optical meteor detection systems. The
results are presented in the second paper in this series. Finally, we give
detailed equations for estimating meteor trajectories and analytically
computing meteoroid orbits, and provide the Python code of the methodology as
open source software.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.03881 [pdf] - 2072682
A new method for measuring the meteor mass index: application to the
2018 Draconid meteor shower outburst
Submitted: 2020-02-10
Context. Several authors predicted an outburst of the Draconid meteor shower
in 2018, but with an uncertain level of activity. Aims. Optical meteor
observations were used to derive the population and mass indices, flux, and
radiant positions of Draconid meteors. Methods. 90 minutes of multi-station
observations after the predicted peak of activity were performed using highly
sensitive Electron Multiplying Charge Coupled Device (EMCCD) cameras. The data
calibration is discussed in detail. A novel maximum likelihood estimation
method of computing the population and mass index with robust error estimation
was developed. We apply the method to observed Draconids and use the values to
derive the flux. Meteor trajectories are computed and compared to predicted
radiant positions from meteoroid ejection models. Results. We found that the
mass index was $1.74 \pm 0.18$ in the 30 minute bin after the predicted peak,
and $2.32 \pm 0.27$ in the next 60 minutes. The location and the dispersion of
the radiant matches well to modeled values, but there is an offset of
$0.4^{\circ}$ in solar longitude.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.11734 [pdf] - 2026445
Estimating trajectories of meteors: an observational Monte Carlo
approach -- II. Results
Submitted: 2019-11-26
In the first paper of this series we examined existing methods of optical
meteor trajectory estimation and developed a novel method which simultaneously
uses both the geometry and the dynamics of meteors to constrain their
trajectories. We also developed a simulator which uses an ablation model to
generate realistic synthetic meteor trajectories which we use to test meteor
trajectory solvers. In this second paper, we perform simulation validation to
estimate radiant and velocity accuracy which may be achieved by various meteor
observation systems as applied to several meteor showers. For low-resolution
all-sky systems, where the meteor deceleration is generally not measurable, the
multi-parameter fit method assuming a constant velocity better reproduces the
radiant and speed of synthetic meteors. For moderate field of view systems, our
novel method performs the best at all convergence angles, while multi-parameter
fit methods generally produce larger speed errors. For high-resolution, narrow
field of view systems, we find our new method of trajectory estimation
reproduces radiant and speed more accurately than all other methods tested. The
ablation properties of meteoroids are commonly found to be the limiting factor
in velocity accuracy. We show that the true radiant dispersion of meteor
showers can be reliably measured with moderate field of view (or more precise)
systems provided appropriate methods of meteor trajectory estimation are
employed. Finally, we compare estimated and real angular radiant uncertainty
and show that for the solvers tested the real radiant error is on average
underestimated by a factor of two.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.12185 [pdf] - 1886611
Meteor Shower Modeling: Past and Future Draconid Outbursts
Submitted: 2019-04-27
This work presents numerical simulations of meteoroid streams released by
comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner over the period 1850-2030. The initial methodology,
based on Vaubaillon et al. (2005), has been updated and modified to account for
the evolution of the comet's dust production along its orbit. The peak time,
intensity, and duration of the shower were assessed using simulated activity
profiles that are calibrated to match observations of historic Draconid
outbursts. The characteristics of all the main apparitions of the shower are
reproduced, with a peak time accuracy of half an hour and an intensity estimate
correct to within a factor of 2 (visual showers) or 3 (radio outbursts). Our
model also revealed the existence of a previously unreported strong radio
outburst on October 9 1999, that has since been confirmed by archival radar
measurements. The first results of the model, presented in Egal et al. (2018),
provided one of the best predictions of the recent 2018 outburst. Three future
radio outbursts are predicted in the next decade, in 2019, 2025 and 2029. The
strongest activity is expected in 2025 when the Earth encounters the young 2012
trail. Because of the dynamical uncertainties associated with comet 21P's
orbital evolution between the 1959 and 1965 apparitions, observations of the
2019 radio outburst would be particularly helpful to improve the confidence of
subsequent forecasts.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.06572 [pdf] - 1864052
Meteoroid Structure and Fragmentation
Submitted: 2019-03-15
The physical composition and structure of meteoroids gives us insight into
the formation processes of their parent asteroids and comets. The strength of
and fundamental grain sizes in meteoroids tell us about the environment in
which small solar system bodies formed, and the processes which built up these
basic planetary building blocks. The structure of meteorites can be studied
directly, but the set of objects which survive entry through the atmosphere is
biased toward large, strong objects with slow encounter speeds. Fragile
objects, small objects and objects with high relative speeds are very unlikely
to survive impact with the atmosphere. Objects between 100 microns and 1 meter,
which are not strong enough to survive the ablation process, must be studied by
radar or optical methods.
Large meteoroids, which produce bright fireballs, are generally studied by
investigating their compressive strength when they fragment, and their strength
can also be inferred indirectly from their end heights.
Fragmentation in faint meteors can be inferred from interference in radar
observations, or observed directly with high-resolution optical systems. Meteor
light curves, begin heights and time-evolving spectra can also be used to infer
meteoroid structure.
This paper presents a review of the meteor observation methods currently used
to infer the structure and fragmentation of meteoroids in the millimeter to
meter size range, and the current state of understanding these observations
have given us.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.09422 [pdf] - 1851720
Solar cycle variation in meteor rates
Submitted: 2019-02-25
Sixteen years of meteor radar data from the Canadian Meteor Orbit Radar
(CMOR) were used to investigate the link between observed meteor rates and both
solar and geomagnetic activity. Meteor rates were corrected for transmitter
power and receiver noise, and seasonal effects were removed. A strong negative
correlation is seen between solar activity, as measured with the 10.7 cm flux,
and observed meteor rates. This lends support to the idea that heating in the
atmosphere at times of elevated solar activity changes the scale height and
therefore the length and maximum brightness of meteors; a larger scale height
near solar maximum leads to longer, fainter meteors and therefore lower rates.
A weaker negative correlation was observed with geomagnetic activity as
measured with the $K$ index; this correlation was still present when solar
activity effects were removed. Meteor activity at solar maximum is as much as
30\% lower than at solar minimum, strictly due to observing biases; geomagnetic
activity usually affects meteor rates by less than 10 percent.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.05931 [pdf] - 1832697
Properties of meteors with double peaked light curves
Submitted: 2019-02-15
Twenty-one meteors showing double peaked light curves were analysed with
observations collected with the Canadian Automated Meteor Observatory tracking
system. Each event has orbital information, photometry, and at least one
high-resolution observation. Two distinct light curve shapes were found: sudden
double peaked curves, and smooth double peaked curves. The sudden peaked curves
were produced by objects on asteroidal orbits and mostly showed noticeable
fragmentation, while the smooth peaked curves were produced by cometary
meteoroids and predominantly showed little to no visible fragmentation. An
attempt to model these meteors as single bodies with two chemical components
was unsuccessful, implying that fragmentation must be included in meteoroid
ablation models.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.03213 [pdf] - 1725056
Modeling the measurement accuracy of pre-atmosphere velocities of
meteoroids
Submitted: 2018-07-09
Many existing optical meteor trajectory estimation methods use the
approximation that the velocity of the meteor at the beginning of its luminous
phase is equivalent to its velocity before atmospheric entry. Meteoroid kinetic
energy loss prior to the luminous phase cannot be measured, but for some masses
and entry geometries neglecting this loss may lead to non-negligible
deceleration prior to thermal ablation. Using a numerical meteoroid ablation
model, we simulate the kinematics of meteoroids beginning at 180 km with
initial velocities ranging from 11 km/s to 71 km/s, and compare model
velocities at the moment of detection to measurements. We validate the
simulations by comparing the simulated luminous beginning heights with observed
beginning heights of different populations of meteors detected with different
optical systems. We find that most low-velocity meteoroids have a significant
velocity difference of 100 m/s to 750 m/s (depending on meteoroid type, mass,
and observation system). This systematic underestimate of meteoroid speeds also
results in systematically lower semi-major axes for meteoroid orbits.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.06123 [pdf] - 1634331
Luminous efficiency estimates of meteors -II. Application to Canadian
Automated Meteor Observatory meteor events
Submitted: 2018-01-18
Luminous efficiency is a necessary parameter for determining meteoroid mass
from optical emission. Despite this importance, it is very poorly known, with
previous results varying by up to two orders of magnitude for a given speed. We
present the most recent study of luminous efficiency values determined with
modern high-resolution instruments, by directly comparing dynamic and
photometric meteoroid masses. Fifteen non-fragmenting meteoroids were used,
with a further five clearly fragmenting events for comparison. Twelve of the
fifteen non-fragmenting meteoroids had luminous efficiencies less than 1%,
while the fragmenting meteoroids had upper limits of a few tens of percent. No
clear trend with speed was seen, but there was a weak negative trend of
luminous efficiency on meteoroid mass, implying that smaller meteoroids radiate
more efficiently.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.07732 [pdf] - 1585087
Generating realistic synthetic meteoroid orbits
Submitted: 2017-06-23
Context. Generating a synthetic dataset of meteoroid orbits is a crucial step
in analysing the probabilities of random grouping of meteoroid orbits in
automated meteor shower surveys. Recent works have shown the importance of
choosing a low similarity threshold value of meteoroid orbits, some pointing
out that the recent meteor shower surveys produced false positives due to
similarity thresholds which were too high. On the other hand, the methods of
synthetic meteoroid orbit generation introduce additional biases into the data,
thus making the final decision on an appropriate threshold value uncertain.
Aims. As a part of the ongoing effort to determine the nature of meteor
showers and improve automated methods, it was decided to tackle the problem of
synthetic meteoroid orbit generation, the main goal being to reproduce the
underlying structure and the statistics of the observed data in the synthetic
orbits.
Methods. A new method of generating synthetic meteoroid orbits using the
Kernel Density Estimation method is presented. Several types of approaches are
recommended, depending on whether one strives to preserve the data structure,
the data statistics or to have a compromise between the two.
Results. The improvements over the existing methods of synthetic orbit
generation are demonstrated. The comparison between the previous and newly
developed methods are given, as well as the visualization tools one can use to
estimate the influence of different input parameters on the final data.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.08656 [pdf] - 1569398
Luminous Efficiency Estimates of Meteors -I. Uncertainty analysis
Submitted: 2017-04-27
The luminous efficiency of meteors is poorly known, but critical for
determining the meteoroid mass. We present an uncertainty analysis of the
luminous efficiency as determined by the classical ablation equations, and
suggest a possible method for determining the luminous efficiency of real
meteor events. We find that a two-term exponential fit to simulated lag data is
able to reproduce simulated luminous efficiencies reasonably well.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.00560 [pdf] - 1449846
When Comets Get Old: A Synthesis of Comet and Meteor Observations of the
Low Activity Comet 209P/LINEAR
Submitted: 2015-09-02
It is speculated that some weakly active comets may be transitional objects
between active and dormant comets. These objects are at a unique stage of the
evolution of cometary nuclei, as they are still identifiable as active comets,
in contrast to inactive comets that are observationally indistinguishable from
low albedo asteroids. In this paper, we present a synthesis of comet and meteor
observations of Jupiter-family comet 209P/LINEAR, one of the most weakly active
comets recorded to-date. Images taken by the Xingming 0.35-m telescope and the
Gemini Flamingo-2 camera are modeled by a Monte Carlo dust model, which yields
a low dust ejection speed ($1/10$ of that of moderately active comets),
dominance of large dust grains, and a low dust production of $0.4~\mathrm{kg
\cdot s^{-1}}$ at 19~d after the 2014 perihelion passage. We also find a
reddish nucleus of 209P/LINEAR that is similar to D-type asteroids and most
Trojan asteroids. Meteor observations with the Canadian Meteor Orbit Radar
(CMOR), coupled with meteoroid stream modeling, suggest a low dust production
of the parent over the past few hundred orbits, although there are hints of a
some temporary increase in activity in the 18th century. Dynamical simulations
indicate 209P/LINEAR may have resided in a stable near-Earth orbit for $\sim
10^4$~yr, which is significantly longer than typical JFCs. All these lines of
evidence imply that 209P/LINEAR as an aging comet quietly exhausting its
remaining near surface volatiles. We also compare 209P/LINEAR to other low
activity comets, where evidence for a diversity of the origin of low activity
is seen.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.6002 [pdf] - 788225
Meteoroid structure and ablation implications from multiple maxima
meteor light curves
Submitted: 2014-02-24
The Canadian Automated Meteor Observatory (CAMO) detects occasional meteors
with two maxima in the image intensified CCD based light curves. We report
early results from an analysis of 21 of these events. Most of these events show
qualitatively similar light curves, with a rounded luminous peak, followed by
an almost linear sharp rise in the second peak, and a relatively rapid curved
decay of the second peak. While a number of mechanisms could explain two maxima
in the light curves, numerical modelling shows that most of these events can be
matched by a simple dustball model in which some grains have been released well
before intensive ablation begins, followed by a later release of core grains at
a single time. Best fits to observations are obtained with the core grains
being larger than the pre-released outer grains, with the core grains typically
$10^{-6}$ kg while the early release grains are of the order of $10^{-9}$ kg.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.1733 [pdf] - 1180571
The Unexpected 2012 Draconid Meteor Storm
Submitted: 2013-11-07
An unexpected intense outburst of the Draconid meteor shower was detected by
the Canadian Meteor Orbit Radar (CMOR) on October 8, 2012. The peak flux
occurred at ~16:40 UT on October 8 with a maximum of 2.4 +/- 0.3 hr-1 km-2
(appropriate to meteoroid mass larger than 10-7 kg), equivalent to a ZHRmax =
9000 +/- 1000 using 5-minute intervals, using a mass distribution index of s =
1.88 +/- 0.01 as determined from the amplitude distribution of underdense
Draconid echoes. This makes the out- burst among the strongest Draconid returns
since 1946 and the highest flux shower since the 1966 Leonid meteor storm,
assuming a constant power-law distribution holds from radar to visual meteoroid
sizes. The weighted mean geocentric radiant in the time interval of 15-19h UT,
Oct 8, 2012 was {\alpha}g = 262.4 +/- 0.1 deg, {\delta}g = 55.7 +/- 0.1 deg
(epoch J2000.0). Visual observers also reported increased activity around the
peak time, but with a much lower rate (ZHR 200), suggesting that the
magnitude-cumulative num- ber relationship is not a simple power-law. Ablation
modeling of the observed meteors as a population does not yield a unique
solution for the grain size and distribution of Draconid meteoroids, but is
consistent with a typical Draconid meteoroid of mtotal between 10-6 to 10-4 kg
being composed of 10 - 100 grains. Dynamical simulations indicate that the
outburst was caused by dust particles released during the 1966 per- ihelion
passage of the parent comet, 21P/Giacobini-Zinner, although there are dis-
crepancies between the modelled and observed timing of the encounter,
presumably caused by approaches of the comet to Jupiter during 1966-1972. Based
on the results of our dynamical simulation, we predict possible increased
activity of the Draconid meteor shower in 2018, 2019, 2021 and 2025.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.7841 [pdf] - 1166310
Radar Observations of the 2011 October Draconid Outburst
Submitted: 2013-04-29, last modified: 2013-10-01
A strong outburst of the October Draconid meteor shower was predicted for
October 8, 2011. Here we present the observations obtained by the Canadian
Meteor Orbit Radar (CMOR) during the 2011 outburst. CMOR recorded 61
multi-station Draconid echoes and 179 single-station overdense Draconid echoes
(covering the magnitude range of +3 <= MV <= +7) between 16-20h UT on October
8, 2011. The mean radiant for the outburst was determined to be a_g = 261.9o
+/- 0.3o, d_g = +55.3o +/- 0.3o (J2000) from observations of the underdense
multi-station echoes. This radiant location agrees with model predictions to
~1o . The determined geocentric velocity was found to be ~10-15% lower than the
model value (17.0 - 19.1 km s^-1 versus 20.4 km s^-1), a discrepancy we
attribute to undercorrection for atmospheric deceleration of low density
Draconid meteoroids as well as to poor radar radiant geometry during the
outburst peak. The mass index at the time of the outburst was determined to be
~ 1.75 using the amplitude distribution of underdense echoes...
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.4389 [pdf] - 1091772
The distribution of interplanetary dust between 0.96 and 1.04 AU as
inferred from impacts on the STEREO spacecraft observed by the Heliospheric
Imagers
Davis, C. J.;
Davies, J. A.;
Cyr, O. C St;
Campbell-Brown, M.;
Skelt, A.;
Kaiser, M.;
Meyer-Vernet, Nicole;
Crothers, S.;
Lintott, C.;
Smith, A.;
Bamford, S.;
Baeten, E. M. L.
Submitted: 2011-11-18
The distribution of dust in the ecliptic plane between 0.96 and 1.04 AU has
been inferred from impacts on the two STEREO spacecraft through observation of
secondary particle trails and unexpected off-points in the Heliospheric Imager
(HI) cameras. This study made use of analysis carried out by members of a
distributed web-based project, Solar Stormwatch. A comparison between
observations of the brightest particle trails and a survey of fainter trails
shows consistent distributions. While there is no obvious correlation between
this distribution and the occurrence of individual meteor streams at Earth,
there are some broad longitudinal features in these distributions that are also
observed in sources of the sporadic meteor population. The asymmetry in the
number of trails seen by each spacecraft and the fact that there are many more
unexpected off-points in the HI-B than in HI-A, indicates that the majority of
impacts are coming from the apex direction. For impacts causing off-points in
the HI-B camera these dust particles are estimated to have masses in excess of
10-17 kg with radii exceeding 0.1 {\mu}m. For off-points observed in the HI-A
images, which can only have been caused by particles travelling from the
anti-apex direction, the distribution is consistent with that of secondary
'storm' trails observed by HI-B, providing evidence that these trails also
result from impacts with primary particles from an anti-apex source. It is
apparent that the differential mass index of particles from the apex direction
is consistently above 2. This indicates that the majority of the mass is within
the smaller particles of this population. In contrast, the differential mass
index of particles from the anti-apex direction (causing off-points in HI-A) is
consistently below 2, indicating that the majority of the mass is to be found
in larger particles of this distribution.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.5882 [pdf] - 1085163
An Optical Survey for mm-Sized Interstellar Meteoroids
Submitted: 2011-10-26
We report high resolution multi-station observations of meteors by the
Canadian Automated Meteor Observatory (CAMO) recorded from June 2009 to August
2010. Our survey has a limiting detection magnitude of +5 mag in R-band,
equivalent to a limiting meteoroid mass of ~2*E-7 kg. The high metric
trajectory accuracy (of the order of 30 m perpendicular to the solution and 200
m along-track) allows us to determine velocities with average uncertainty of <
1.5% in speed and ~0.4 degr in radiant direction. A total of 1739 meteors had
measured orbits. The data has been searched for meteors in hyperbolic orbits,
which are potentially of interstellar origin. We found 22 potential hyperbolic
meteors among our sample, with only two of them having a speed at least three
sigma above the hyperbolic limit. For our one year survey we find no clear
evidence of interstellar meteoroids at mm-sizes in a weighted time-area product
of ~1*E4 km^2*h. Backward integrations performed for these 22 potentially
hyperbolic meteors to check for close encounters with planets show no
considerable changes in their orbits. Detailed examination leads us to conclude
that our few identified events are most likely the result of measurement error.
We find an upper limit of f_ISP < 2*E-4/(km^2*h) for the flux of interstellar
meteoroids at Earth with a limiting mass of m > 2*E-7 kg.