Normalized to: Byrne, R.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.08463 [pdf] - 2080210
A Unified Calibration Framework for 21 cm Cosmology
Submitted: 2020-04-17
Calibration precision is currently a limiting systematic in 21 cm cosmology
experiments. While there are innumerable calibration approaches, most can be
categorized as either `sky-based,' relying on an extremely accurate model of
astronomical foreground emission, or `redundant,' requiring a precisely regular
array with near-identical antenna response patterns. Both of these classes of
calibration are inflexible to the realities of interferometric measurement. In
practice, errors in the foreground model, antenna position offsets, and beam
response inhomogeneities degrade calibration performance and contaminate the
cosmological signal. Here we show that sky-based and redundant calibration can
be unified into a highly general and physically motivated calibration framework
based on a Bayesian statistical formalism. Our new framework includes sky and
redundant calibration as special cases but can additionally support relaxing
the rigid assumptions implicit in those approaches. Furthermore, we present
novel calibration techniques such as redundant calibration for arrays with no
redundant baselines, representing an alternative calibration method for imaging
arrays such as the MWA Phase I. These new calibration approaches could mitigate
systematics and reduce calibration error, thereby improving the precision of
cosmological measurements.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.07819 [pdf] - 2081131
Quantifying Excess Power from Radio Frequency Interference in Epoch of
Reionization Measurements
Submitted: 2020-04-15
We quantify the effect of radio frequency interference (RFI) on Epoch of
Reionization (EoR) power spectra. Specifically, we investigate how the
frequency structure of source emission generates contamination in higher-order
wave modes that is much more problematic than smooth-spectrum foreground
sources. We find that even a single relatively dim RFI source can overwhelm
typical estimates of the EoR power spectrum signal on cosmological modes of
interest. If total apparent RFI flux density in an integration is kept below 1
mJy, an EoR detection should be feasible given no other systematic. These
results emphasize the need for highly effective RFI mitigation strategies for
telescopes used to search for the EoR.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.02575 [pdf] - 2050429
Deep multi-redshift limits on Epoch of Reionisation 21cm Power Spectra
from Four Seasons of Murchison Widefield Array Observations
Trott, Cathryn M.;
Jordan, C. H.;
Midgley, S.;
Barry, N.;
Greig, B.;
Pindor, B.;
Cook, J. H.;
Sleap, G.;
Tingay, S. J.;
Ung, D.;
Hancock, P.;
Williams, A.;
Bowman, J.;
Byrne, R.;
Chokshi, A.;
Hazelton, B. J.;
Hasegawa, K.;
Jacobs, D.;
Joseph, R. C.;
Li, W.;
Line, J. L. B;
Lynch, C.;
McKinley, B.;
Mitchell, D. A.;
Morales, M. F.;
Ouchi, M.;
Pober, J. C.;
Rahimi, M.;
Takahashi, K.;
Wayth, R. B.;
Webster, R. L.;
Wilensky, M.;
Wyithe, J. S. B.;
Yoshiura, S.;
Zhang, Z.;
Zheng, Q.
Submitted: 2020-02-06
We compute the spherically-averaged power spectrum from four seasons of data
obtained for the Epoch of Reionisation (EoR) project observed with the
Murchison Widefield Array (MWA). We measure the EoR power spectrum over $k=
0.07-3.0~h$Mpc$^{-1}$ at redshifts $z=6.5-8.7$. The largest aggregation of 110
hours on EoR0 high-band (3,340 observations), yields a lowest measurement of
(43~mK)$^2$ = 1.8$\times$10$^3$ mK$^2$ at $k$=0.14~$h$Mpc$^{-1}$ and $z=6.5$
(2$\sigma$ thermal noise plus sample variance). Using the Real-Time System to
calibrate and the CHIPS pipeline to estimate power spectra, we select the best
observations from the central five pointings within the 2013--2016 observing
seasons, observing three independent fields and in two frequency bands. This
yields 13,591 2-minute snapshots (453 hours), based on a quality assurance
metric that measures ionospheric activity. We perform another cut to remove
poorly-calibrated data, based on power in the foreground-dominated and
EoR-dominated regions of the two-dimensional power spectrum, reducing the set
to 12,569 observations (419 hours). These data are processed in groups of 20
observations, to retain the capacity to identify poor data, and used to analyse
the evolution and structure of the data over field, frequency, and data
quality. We subsequently choose the cleanest 8,935 observations (298 hours of
data) to form integrated power spectra over the different fields, pointings and
redshift ranges.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.10216 [pdf] - 2018257
First Season MWA Phase II EoR Power Spectrum Results at Redshift 7
Li, W.;
Pober, J. C.;
Barry, N.;
Hazelton, B. J.;
Morales, M. F.;
Trott, C. M.;
Lanman, A.;
Wilensky, M.;
Sullivan, I.;
Beardsley, A. P.;
Booler, T.;
Bowman, J. D.;
Byrne, R.;
Crosse, B.;
Emrich, D.;
Franzen, T. M. O.;
Hasegawa, K.;
Horsley, L.;
Johnston-Hollitt, M.;
Jacobs, D. C.;
Jordan, C. H.;
Joseph, R. C.;
Kaneuji, T.;
Kaplan, D. L.;
Kenney, D.;
Kubota, K.;
Line, J.;
Lynch, C.;
McKinley, B.;
Mitchell, D. A.;
Murray, S.;
Pallot, D.;
Pindor, B.;
Rahimi, M.;
Riding, J.;
Sleap, G.;
Steele, K.;
Takahashi, K.;
Tingay, S. J.;
Walker, M.;
Wayth, R. B.;
Webster, R. L.;
Williams, A.;
Wu, C.;
Wyithe, J. S. B.;
Yoshiura, S.;
Zheng, Q.
Submitted: 2019-11-22, last modified: 2019-12-20
The compact configuration of Phase II of the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA)
consists of both a redundant subarray and pseudo-random baselines, offering
unique opportunities to perform sky-model and redundant interferometric
calibration. The highly redundant hexagonal cores give improved power spectrum
sensitivity. In this paper, we present the analysis of nearly 40 hours of data
targeting one of the MWA's EoR fields observed in 2016. We use both improved
analysis techniques presented in Barry et al. (2019) as well as several
additional techniques developed for this work, including data quality control
methods and interferometric calibration approaches. We show the EoR power
spectrum limits at redshift 6.5, 6.8 and 7.1 based on our deep analysis on this
40-hour data set. These limits span a range in $k$ space of $0.18$ $h$
$\mathrm{Mpc^{-1}}$ $<k<1.6$ $h$ $\mathrm{Mpc^{-1}}$, with a lowest measurement
of $\Delta^2\leqslant2.39\times 10^3$ $\mathrm{mK}^2$ at $k=0.59$ $h$
$\mathrm{Mpc^{-1}}$ and $z=6.5$.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.01093 [pdf] - 1976826
Absolving the SSINS of Precision Interferometric Radio Data: A New
Technique for Mitigating Faint Radio Frequency Interference
Submitted: 2019-06-03, last modified: 2019-10-09
We introduce a new pipeline for analyzing and mitigating radio frequency
interference (RFI), which we call Sky-Subtracted Incoherent Noise Spectra
(SSINS). SSINS is designed to identify and remove faint RFI below the single
baseline thermal noise by employing a frequency-matched detection algorithm on
baseline-averaged amplitudes of time-differenced visibilities. We demonstrate
the capabilities of SSINS using the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) in Western
Australia. We successfully image aircraft flying over the array via digital
television (DTV) reflection detected using SSINS and summarize an RFI occupancy
survey of MWA Epoch of Reionization data. We describe how to use SSINS with new
data using a documented, publicly available implementation with comprehensive
usage tutorials.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.00561 [pdf] - 1976860
Improving the Epoch of Reionization Power Spectrum Results from
Murchison Widefield Array Season 1 Observations
Barry, N.;
Wilensky, M.;
Trott, C. M.;
Pindor, B.;
Beardsley, A. P.;
Hazelton, B. J.;
Sullivan, I. S.;
Morales, M. F.;
Pober, J. C.;
Line, J.;
Greig, B.;
Byrne, R.;
Lanman, A.;
Li, W.;
Jordan, C. H.;
Joseph, R. C.;
McKinley, B.;
Rahimi, M.;
Yoshiura, S.;
Bowman, J. D.;
Gaensler, B. M.;
Hewitt, J. N.;
Jacobs, D. C.;
Mitchell, D. A.;
Shankar, N. Udaya;
Sethi, S. K.;
Subrahmanyan, R.;
Tingay, S. J.;
Webster, R. L.;
Wyithe, J. S. B.
Submitted: 2019-09-02, last modified: 2019-10-08
Measurements of 21 cm Epoch of Reionization (EoR) structure are subject to
systematics originating from both the analysis and the observation conditions.
Using 2013 data from the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA), we show the
importance of mitigating both sources of contamination. A direct comparison
between results from Beardsley et al. 2016 and our updated analysis
demonstrates new precision techniques, lowering analysis systematics by a
factor of 2.8 in power. We then further lower systematics by excising
observations contaminated by ultra-faint RFI, reducing by an additional factor
of 3.8 in power for the zenith pointing. With this enhanced analysis precision
and newly developed RFI mitigation, we calculate a noise-dominated upper limit
on the EoR structure of $\Delta^2 \leq 3.9 \times 10^3$ mK$^2$ at $k=0.20$
$\textit{h}$ Mpc$^{-1}$ and $z=7$ using 21 hr of data, improving previous MWA
limits by almost an order of magnitude.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.02980 [pdf] - 1920817
The FHD/$\boldsymbol{\varepsilon}$ppsilon Epoch of Reionization Power
Spectrum Pipeline
Submitted: 2019-01-09, last modified: 2019-07-23
Epoch of Reionization data analysis requires unprecedented levels of accuracy
in radio interferometer pipelines. We have developed an imaging power spectrum
analysis to meet these requirements and generate robust 21 cm EoR measurements.
In this work, we build a signal path framework to mathematically describe each
step in the analysis, from data reduction in the FHD package to power spectrum
generation in the $\varepsilon$ppsilon package. In particular, we focus on the
distinguishing characteristics of FHD/$\varepsilon$ppsilon: highly accurate
spectral calibration, extensive data verification products, and end-to-end
error propagation. We present our key data analysis products in detail to
facilitate understanding of the prominent systematics in image-based power
spectrum analyses. As a verification to our analysis, we also highlight a
full-pipeline analysis simulation to demonstrate signal preservation and lack
of signal loss. This careful treatment ensures that the
FHD/$\varepsilon$ppsilon power spectrum pipeline can reduce radio
interferometric data to produce credible 21 cm EoR measurements.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.07161 [pdf] - 1920932
Gridded and direct Epoch of Reionisation bispectrum estimates using the
Murchison Widefield Array
Trott, Cathryn M.;
Watkinson, Catherine A.;
Jordan, Christopher H.;
Yoshiura, Shintaro;
Majumdar, Suman;
Barry, N.;
Byrne, R.;
Hazelton, B. J.;
Hasegawa, K.;
Joseph, R.;
Kaneuji, T.;
Kubota, K.;
Li, W.;
Line, J.;
Lynch, C.;
McKinley, B.;
Mitchell, D. A.;
Morales, M. F.;
Murray, S.;
Pindor, B.;
Pober, J. C.;
Rahimi, M.;
Riding, J.;
Takahashi, K.;
Tingay, S. J.;
Wayth, R. B.;
Webster, R. L.;
Wilensky, M.;
Wyithe, J. S. B.;
Zheng, Q.;
Emrich, David;
Beardsley, A. P.;
Booler, T.;
Crosse, B.;
Franzen, T. M. O.;
Horsley, L.;
Johnston-Hollitt, M.;
Kaplan, D. L.;
Kenney, D.;
Pallot, D.;
Sleap, G.;
Steele, K.;
Walker, M.;
Williams, A.;
Wu, C.
Submitted: 2019-05-17
We apply two methods to estimate the 21~cm bispectrum from data taken within
the Epoch of Reionisation (EoR) project of the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA).
Using data acquired with the Phase II compact array allows a direct bispectrum
estimate to be undertaken on the multiple redundantly-spaced triangles of
antenna tiles, as well as an estimate based on data gridded to the $uv$-plane.
The direct and gridded bispectrum estimators are applied to 21 hours of
high-band (167--197~MHz; $z$=6.2--7.5) data from the 2016 and 2017 observing
seasons. Analytic predictions for the bispectrum bias and variance for point
source foregrounds are derived. We compare the output of these approaches, the
foreground contribution to the signal, and future prospects for measuring the
bispectra with redundant and non-redundant arrays. We find that some triangle
configurations yield bispectrum estimates that are consistent with the expected
noise level after 10 hours, while equilateral configurations are strongly
foreground-dominated. Careful choice of triangle configurations may be made to
reduce foreground bias that hinders power spectrum estimators, and the 21~cm
bispectrum may be accessible in less time than the 21~cm power spectrum for
some wave modes, with detections in hundreds of hours.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.11623 [pdf] - 1882663
Robust statistics toward detection of the 21 cm signal from the Epoch of
Reionisation
Trott, Cathryn M.;
Fu, Shih Ching;
Murray, Steven;
Jordan, Christopher;
Line, Jack;
Barry, N.;
Byrne, R.;
Hazelton, B. J.;
Hasegawa, K.;
Joseph, R.;
Kaneuji, T.;
Kubota, K.;
Li, W.;
Lynch, C.;
McKinley, B.;
Mitchell, D. A.;
Morales, M. F.;
Pindor, B.;
Pober, J. C.;
Rahimi, M.;
Takahashi, K.;
Tingay, S. J.;
Wayth, R. B.;
Webster, R. L.;
Wilensky, M.;
Wyithe, J. S. B.;
Yoshiura, S.;
Zheng, Q.;
Walker, M.
Submitted: 2019-04-25
We explore methods for robust estimation of the 21 cm signal from the Epoch
of Reionisation (EoR). A Kernel Density Estimator (KDE) is introduced for
measuring the spatial temperature fluctuation power spectrum from the EoR. The
KDE estimates the underlying probability distribution function of fluctuations
as a function of spatial scale, and contains different systematic biases and
errors to the typical approach to estimating the fluctuation power spectrum.
Extraction of histograms of visibilities allows moments analysis to be used to
discriminate foregrounds from 21 cm signal and thermal noise. We use the
information available in the histograms, along with the statistical
dis-similarity of foregrounds from two independent observing fields, to
robustly separate foregrounds from cosmological signal, while making no
assumptions about the Gaussianity of the signal. Using two independent
observing fields to robustly discriminate signal from foregrounds is crucial
for the analysis presented in this paper. We apply the techniques to 13 hours
of Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) EoR data over two observing fields. We
compare the output to that obtained with a comparative power spectrum
estimation method, and demonstrate the reduced foreground contamination using
this approach. Using the second moment obtained directly from the KDE
distribution functions yields a factor of 2-3 improvement in power for k <
0.3hMpc^{-1} compared with a matched delay space power estimator, while
weighting data by additional statistics does not offer significant improvement
beyond that available for thermal noise-only weights.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.01378 [pdf] - 1871426
Fundamental Limitations on the Calibration of Redundant 21 cm Cosmology
Instruments and Implications for HERA and the SKA
Byrne, Ruby;
Morales, Miguel F.;
Hazelton, Bryna;
Li, Wenyang;
Barry, Nichole;
Beardsley, Adam P.;
Joseph, Ronniy;
Pober, Jonathan;
Sullivan, Ian;
Trott, Cathryn
Submitted: 2018-11-04, last modified: 2019-03-20
Precise instrument calibration is critical to the success of 21 cm Cosmology
experiments. Unmitigated errors in calibration contaminate the Epoch of
Reionization (EoR) signal, precluding a detection. Barry et al. 2016
characterizes one class of inherent errors that emerge from calibrating to an
incomplete sky model, however it has been unclear if errors in the sky model
affect the calibration of redundant arrays. In this paper, we show that
redundant calibration is vulnerable to errors from sky model incompleteness
even in the limit of perfect antenna positioning and identical beams. These
errors are at a level that can overwhelm the EoR signal and prevent a
detection. Finally, we suggest error mitigation strategies with implications
for the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) and the Square Kilometre
Array (SKA).
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.05312 [pdf] - 1740060
Comparing Redundant and Sky Model Based Interferometric Calibration: A
First Look with Phase II of the MWA
Li, W.;
Pober, J. C.;
Hazelton, B. J.;
Barry, N.;
Morales, M. F.;
Sullivan, I.;
Parsons, A. R.;
Ali, Z. S.;
Dillon, J. S.;
Beardsley, A. P.;
Bowman, J. D.;
Briggs, F.;
Byrne, R.;
Carroll, P.;
Crosse, B.;
Emrich, D.;
Ewall-Wice, A.;
Feng, L.;
Franzen, T. M. O.;
Hewitt, J. N.;
Horsley, L.;
Jacobs, D. C.;
Johnston-Hollitt, M.;
Jordan, C.;
Joseph, R. C.;
Kaplan, D. L.;
Kenney, D.;
Kim, H.;
Kittiwisit, P.;
Lanman, A.;
Line, J.;
McKinley, B.;
Mitchell, D. A.;
Murray, S.;
Neben, A.;
Offringa, A. R.;
Pallot, D.;
Paul, S.;
Pindor, B.;
Procopio, P.;
Rahimi, M.;
Riding, J.;
Sethi, S. K.;
Shankar, N. Udaya;
Steele, K.;
Subrahmanian, R.;
Tegmark, M.;
Thyagarajan, N.;
Tingay, S. J.;
Trott, C.;
Walker, M.;
Wayth, R. B.;
Webster, R. L.;
Williams, A.;
Wu, C.;
Wyithe, S.
Submitted: 2018-07-13
Interferometric arrays seeking to measure the 21 cm signal from the Epoch of
Reionization must contend with overwhelmingly bright emission from foreground
sources. Accurate recovery of the 21 cm signal will require precise calibration
of the array, and several new avenues for calibration have been pursued in
recent years, including methods using redundancy in the antenna configuration.
The newly upgraded Phase II of Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) is the first
interferometer that has large numbers of redundant baselines while retaining
good instantaneous UV-coverage. This array therefore provides a unique
opportunity to compare redundant calibration with sky-model based algorithms.
In this paper, we present the first results from comparing both calibration
approaches with MWA Phase II observations. For redundant calibration, we use
the package OMNICAL, and produce sky-based calibration solutions with the
analysis package Fast Holographic Deconvolution (FHD). There are three
principal results. (1) We report the success of OMNICAL on observations of
ORBComm satellites, showing substantial agreement between redundant visibility
measurements after calibration. (2) We directly compare OMNICAL calibration
solutions with those from FHD, and demonstrate these two different calibration
schemes give extremely similar results. (3) We explore improved calibration by
combining OMNICAL and FHD. We evaluate these combined methods using power
spectrum techniques developed for EoR analysis and find evidence for marginal
improvements mitigating artifacts in the power spectrum. These results are
likely limited by signal-to-noise in the six hours of data used, but suggest
future directions for combining these two calibration schemes.